My Child Keeps Getting Sent Home or Put on a Shortened Day

My Child Keeps Getting Sent Home or Put on a Shortened Day

Last reviewed: November 2026

When a school sends a student with an IEP home early because of behavior, asks the family to keep the student home, or shortens the student’s school day, it is removing the student from school. These removals count toward the 10 school days after which a student with an IEP is entitled to services and, if the removals form a pattern, to a manifestation determination, even when the school never calls them suspensions. (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.530, 300.536.) A shortened school day on an ongoing basis is also a change to the student’s program, and it can be made only by the IEP team, with the parent, based on what the student needs. In Doe v. Maher (9th Cir. 1986), a San Francisco school cut a student’s day in half after repeated misbehavior, and his grandparents went along with it without being told they could challenge the change. The Ninth Circuit held that the cut was a change in placement, and that making it without notice of the family’s right to challenge it violated the student’s rights.

These removals are sometimes called informal removals, because nothing formal happens. No one gives the student a chance to respond or sends a notice. Nothing goes into the discipline record, and no one is counting days. That is what makes them a problem. Every protection the law gives a student with a disability in discipline starts with a count of the number of days they are out of school, and an informal removal is a removal no one is counting.

What Informal Removals Look Like

  • A call from the office asking you to pick your child up because of behavior.
  • A request to keep your child home “until things settle down,” or until a meeting can be scheduled.
  • A school day that ends at lunch, or a start time later than other students’, because of behavior.
  • Hours spent in the office, a hallway, or an empty room without instruction.
  • Being told your child can come to school only if you stay, or only if an aide is available that day.
  • Exclusion from field trips, assemblies, recess, or the bus.
  • A move to “independent study,” online instruction, or home instruction that the IEP team never decided on.
  • Being told that the school will suspend your child, recommend expulsion, or call the police unless you pick your child up, agree to a shorter day, or agree to a transfer.

The federal Office for Civil Rights (OCR) describes most of these practices in its 2022 guidance on discipline under Section 504 as informal exclusions it has seen in its investigations.

Why It Happens

Most of these removals aren’t meant as punishment. If a classroom teacher doesn’t think they have enough staff to support a student’s learning and keep them safe, they may believe that calling to have a parent pick up their child is in their best interest. Often the staff member making the call sincerely believes the child is better off at home that afternoon. Sending a child home also doesn’t require an administrator to fill out a suspension form or add to the school’s reported suspension numbers, so nothing prompts anyone to ask what is going wrong.

That explains the practice, but it doesn’t justify it. A student who is repeatedly sent home is missing instruction and services, is learning that certain behavior ends the school day, and is being treated differently from classmates because of a disability. And the school’s real problem, which is that it doesn’t yet have a plan that works for this student, stays unsolved.

How the Law Treats Informal Removals

They count as removals. The U.S. Department of Education explained, when it issued the discipline regulations, that part of a day counts, and that an in-school suspension counts unless the student keeps working in the general curriculum, keeps receiving IEP services, and keeps spending time with non-disabled classmates as before. (71 Fed. Reg. 46,715 (Aug. 14, 2006).) OCR’s 2022 guidance takes the same position under Section 504: informal exclusions are subject to the same requirements as formal discipline, and a school that doesn’t keep accurate records of when and why it excluded a student can’t tell when the student’s protections begin. (OCR, Supporting Students with Disabilities and Avoiding the Discriminatory Use of Student Discipline under Section 504 (July 2022), pp. 22–23.) The guidance is OCR’s reading of the law and isn’t itself binding, but it follows from the regulations: what matters is that the student was removed, not what the school called it.

The Department’s guidance for students with IEPs, issued the same month, addresses shortened days directly. A shortened day that school staff impose on their own in response to behavior, without a decision by the IEP team, is an informal removal, and when it is used repeatedly the discipline rules generally apply. The only exception is when the student still has the chance to take part in the general curriculum, still receives the services in the IEP, and still spends time with non-disabled classmates as before. (OSERS, Questions and Answers: Addressing the Needs of Children with Disabilities and IDEA’s Discipline Provisions (July 19, 2022), Question C-6.) This document is also guidance, not binding law.

A suspension has to be called a suspension. California law requires a meeting with the student, a call to the parent, and written notice whenever a student is suspended. (Ed. Code § 48911.) A school that sends a student home for behavior without those steps has suspended the student without following the law.

After 10 days, special education services must resume. Once informal and formal removals together pass 10 school days in a school year, the student is entitled to services during any further removal, and a pattern of removals requires a manifestation determination. (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.530(d), 300.536.)

Missed services are a failure to follow the IEP. An IEP states how often and for how long each service will be provided (Los Angeles Unified School District v. A.O., 9th Cir. 2024), so every afternoon a student is sent home can be measured in missed instruction and missed sessions. In Van Duyn v. Baker School District 5J (2007), the Ninth Circuit held that a district violates the law when there is more than a minor discrepancy between the services it provides and the services the IEP requires, and that the family doesn’t have to prove the student was harmed, although a lack of progress is evidence that the shortfall mattered. In that case, a shortfall of about five hours a week of math instruction met the test. The usual remedy is compensatory education, which is services to make up for what was lost.

Related:

When a Shortened Day Is Allowed

A shortened school day can be appropriate for a particular student for a period of time, for example for health reasons, or while a student returns to school after a hospitalization. That is different from shortening the day because of behavior the school hasn’t found a way to support. It is a significant change to the student’s education, and these conditions apply:

  1. The IEP team decides, with the parent. A district can’t change a student’s program on its own. In M.C. v. Antelope Valley Union High School District (2017), the Ninth Circuit held that a district that changed an IEP without telling the parent had denied the parent the chance to take part in the decision.
  2. The reason is the student’s needs, not staffing, scheduling, or the convenience of the school. The first question is what supports would let the student attend for the full day, and whether the school has provided them. The Department’s guidance says that a school day for a student with a disability generally shouldn’t be shorter than the school day for other students, and that shortening the day as a response to behavior can deny the student an appropriate education if the IEP team hasn’t considered added or different services that would let the student stay for the full day. (OSERS Questions and Answers, Question C-6.)
  3. It is written into the IEP, with the reason, the schedule, the services the student will receive, and the data the team will use to decide when to lengthen the day.
  4. It has an end date and a plan to return the student. The IEP should say when the team will meet again and what steps will bring the student back to a full day.
  5. The parent agrees. In California a district can’t put a change to the IEP into effect without the parent’s consent, unless it files for due process and a judge approves the change. (Ed. Code § 56346(e)–(f).)

A shortened day also separates a student from classmates, so the law’s requirement that students with disabilities be educated with their non-disabled peers as much as is appropriate applies to it. The same is true of home instruction, which is among the most restrictive placements there is and isn’t a substitute for behavior support at school. Even when a student has been removed for discipline, the Department’s guidance says the IEP team will likely need to look at options other than home instruction, because the setting has to let the student keep participating in the general curriculum and keep working toward the IEP’s goals. (OSERS Questions and Answers, Question D-5.)

A district policy or habit of shortening the day for students with a particular disability, without individual decisions, can also be disability discrimination under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Related:

What to Do

  1. Keep a log. For every removal, write down the date, the time your child left, who called, and what they said. Save texts and voicemails.
  2. Ask the question in writing. After a call to pick your child up, send a short email the same day: “You asked me to pick up my child at 11:30 today because of behavior. Please confirm whether this is a suspension, and send me the written notice.” A sample letter is linked below.
  3. Think before agreeing to pick up. You can ask what the school has tried, whether the behavior plan was followed, and whether your child can stay with support. If the school says your child has to leave, ask it to say so in writing. Don’t describe a pickup as voluntary if it wasn’t your choice.
  4. Ask for an IEP meeting and a functional behavioral assessment, which is an assessment of what triggers the behavior and what purpose it serves for your child. Ask the team to add or revise a behavior plan, and to consider added support such as an aide or behavior services.
  5. Don’t sign a shortened day you don’t agree with. You can consent to the rest of an IEP and decline that part. If you do agree, ask that the IEP state the schedule, the services, and the date the team will meet to review it.
  6. Tell the school when the count reaches 10 days, and ask for services and a manifestation determination.
  7. Use the complaint options if it continues. A compliance complaint to the California Department of Education (CDE) fits a clear rule violation, such as suspensions without notice or services the IEP requires that weren’t provided. A due process complaint can seek compensatory education and an order for the supports your child needs.

Related:

Is your child being sent home again and again? Request a consultation today.

Legal sources: 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.530, 300.536; 71 Fed. Reg. 46,715 (Aug. 14, 2006); OCR, Supporting Students with Disabilities and Avoiding the Discriminatory Use of Student Discipline under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (July 2022); OSERS, Questions and Answers: Addressing the Needs of Children with Disabilities and IDEA’s Discipline Provisions (July 19, 2022); Ed. Code §§ 48911, 56346; 29 U.S.C. § 794; 42 U.S.C. § 12132; Doe v. Maher, 793 F.2d 1470 (9th Cir. 1986); L.A. Unified Sch. Dist. v. A.O., 92 F.4th 1159 (9th Cir. 2024); M.C. v. Antelope Valley Union High Sch. Dist., 858 F.3d 1189 (9th Cir. 2017); Van Duyn v. Baker Sch. Dist. 5J, 502 F.3d 811 (9th Cir. 2007).