California OAH special education decision · December 7, 2010

Student v. Los Angeles County Office of Education et al.

OAH Case No. 2010090601 · ALJ Charles Marson

Los Angeles County Office of Education and Probation agree to 480 hours of reading, speech, counseling and transition services by settlement.

Decision by settlement

This case was resolved by a decision by settlement under California Code of Regulations, title 5, section 3087. The parties agreed on the terms, and the administrative law judge adopted them after finding they were not contrary to law. The case was not decided after a contested hearing, so the judge made no findings on the disputed issues; any findings come from the parties' own stipulations.

Summary

A 16-year-old eligible for special education because of a learning disability, a speech and language impairment, and emotional disturbance filed for due process, through his mother, against the Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) and the Los Angeles County Probation Department. LACOE operates the schools in the county's juvenile facilities; the student attended its Challenger School in 2009-2010 and its schools at the Nidorf and Eastlake juvenile halls from May 2010. He sought compensatory education, and the parties were also parties to a related federal class action, Casey A. v. Robles.

The parties filed a stipulated final decision, and ALJ Charles Marson entered it as a decision by settlement under California Code of Regulations, title 5, section 3087, after finding the terms not contrary to law. No issue was heard or decided.

LACOE and Probation must provide, through certified nonpublic agencies, 300 hours of intensive one-to-one reading and writing instruction using research-based methods such as Lindamood-Bell or Wilson, 50 hours of one-to-one math instruction, 30 hours of speech-language therapy, 15 hours of assistive technology training, 50 hours of mental health counseling, and 35 hours of transition services. They will provide a bus pass on request, and the services must be used within two years.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

Illustrates the kind of intensive, itemized compensatory services that can be secured by settlement for a student in county juvenile facility schools, including research-based reading intervention, mental health counseling, and transition services.

Issues and holdings

  1. Resolved by settlementFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did LACOE and the Probation Department deny Student a FAPE while he attended LACOE schools in county juvenile facilities, entitling him to compensatory education?

    Resolved by the parties' stipulated decision; OAH heard and decided no issue.

What the decision orders (agreed terms)

  • Compensatory education. 300 hours of intensive one-to-one instruction in reading, decoding, comprehension, and written expression by a certified nonpublic agency using research-based methods such as Lindamood-Bell or Wilson, at least four hours a day.
  • Compensatory education. 50 hours of one-to-one math instruction, 30 hours of one-to-one speech-language therapy, 15 hours of assistive technology training, 50 hours of mental health counseling and services, and 35 hours of transition services.
  • Bus pass on request (renewed only if services are used); services must be used within two years, tolled for delays caused by the agencies or their providers.

Total: 480 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified Sch. Dist.; Rich Vision Centers v. Board of Medical Examiners

People named in the decision

  • Challenger School, LACOE school at a county juvenile facility
  • Barry J. Nidorf Juvenile Hall school, LACOE school
  • Eastlake Juvenile Hall school, LACOE school

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Published text of the OAH decision. Student and family details have been removed and marked in brackets, and page headers and numbers from the original PDF have been dropped.

BEFORE THE

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In the Matter of:

STUDENT

v.

LOS ANGELES COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION AND LOS ANGELES

COUNTY PROBATION DEPARTMENT

CASE NO. 2010090601

DECISION BY SETTLEMENT

(Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3087)

December 7, 2010 Charles Marson, Administrative Law Judge, Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), State of California, enters this Decision by Settlement pursuant to section 3087 of title 5 of the California Code of Regulations.

David B. Sapp, Attorney at Law, represented Student. Vibiana Andrade, Attorney at Law, represented the Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE). Roger Granbo, Attorney at Law, represented the Los Angeles County Probation Department (Probation).

Accessibility Modified

Student filed his request for due process hearing on September 14, 2010. On September 19, 2010, the parties jointly filed a Stipulated Final Decision in Lieu of Due Process Hearing (Stipulated Decision). On October 20, 2010, the ALJ discussed the proposed decision extensively with the parties, and the matter was continued. On November 10, 2010, the parties notified OAH that they had formally settled the matter according to the terms set forth herein.

FACTUAL FINDINGS

1.

The parties stipulate that Student, who is 16 years old, is a resident of Los

Angeles County and is eligible for special education and related services because of a learning disability, speech and language impairment, and emotional disturbance. 2.

The parties stipulate that LACOE is the local education agency that operates the schools inside all Los Angeles County juvenile rehabilitation facilities, and that Student attended Challenger School, one of LACOE’S facilities, from July 2009 to January 2010, and attended schools operated by LACOE at the Barry J. Nidorf and Easlake Juvenile Halls from May 2010 to the present..

3.

The parties stipulate that Probation’s Office of Juvenile Institutions

Bureau operates three juvenile halls and 18 juvenile camps, including the six camps at Challenger School, and is responsible for the care of youth detained in those facilities. 1

Since no party has contested its designation as a party hereto, OAH has had no occasion to rule on the status of any party.

Accessibility Modified

4.

The parties hereto are also parties to Casey A., et al., v. Robles, et al.

(C.D.Cal., No. CV 10-00192), a class action now pending in the Federal District Court for the Central District of California, in which an interim settlement is pending. 4.

The parties’ Stipulated Decision is attached to this Decision by Settlement as Exhibit A and incorporated herein. 2 It contains an Agreement obliging LACOE and Probation to provide to Student certain compensatory education services. The parties have determined that the terms of the Agreement are appropriate, and the compensatory education services agreed to have been incorporated in the Order below. 5.

The Stipulated Decision does not contain any provision that is contrary to the law.

LEGAL CONCLUSIONS

1.

The Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act and related state laws strongly encourage the settlement of special education disputes. (See, e.g., 20 U.S.C. § 1415(f)(1)(B); Ed. Code, § 56501.5, subd. (a) [requirement of resolution session before due process hearing]; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e); Ed. Code, § 56500.3 [availability of mediation before due process hearing]; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(f)(1)(B)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.510(d)(2)(2006);

At the status conference on October 20, 2010, the parties stipulated that, in order to comply with federal laws governing the confidentiality of these proceedings, Student’s proper name could be redacted from Exhibit A and the word “Student” inserted in its place, and that Mother's name could be redacted and the word "Parent" inserted in its place. Exhibit A has been altered by the parties in accordance with that stipulation and not otherwise.

Accessibility Modified

Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 4650, subd. (a)(4); Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 2000) 223 F.3d 1026, 1028-1030 [administrative enforcement of settlements of due process disputes].)

2.

Decision by settlement is authorized by California administrative law.

(Gov. Code, § 11415.60; Rich Vision Centers, Inc. v. Board of Medical Examiners (1983) 144 Cal.App.3d 110.) Government Code section 11415.60 does not apply to special education due process disputes (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3089), but the State Board of Education has adopted a similar regulation. Section 3087 of title 5 of the California Code of Regulations provides:

Notwithstanding Government Code section 11415.60 of the Administrative Procedure Act, a decision by settlement may be issued on terms the parties determine are appropriate so long as the agreed-upon terms are not contrary to the law.

3.

Based on Factual Finding 4 and Legal Conclusion 2, the parties have settled their dispute on terms they have determined are appropriate. 4.

Based on Factual Finding 5 and Legal Conclusion 2, the Stipulated Decision does not contain any agreed-upon term that is contrary to the law.

ORDER

The Los Angeles County Office of Education and the Los Angeles County Probation Department shall provide to Student the following compensatory education services:

Accessibility Modified

1.

300 hours of intensive one-on-one instruction in reading, decoding, reading comprehension, and written expression. This instruction should be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience working with students who have significant language deficits and should utilize research-based interventions and methodologies such as LindaMood Bell or Wilson. This instruction should be provided for, at minimum, four hours per day.

2.

50 hours of intensive one-on-one instruction in mathematics computation and application. This instruction should be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience working with students who have significant language deficits and dyslexia and should utilize research-based interventions and methodologies. 3.

30 hours of intensive one-on-one speech and language therapy. This therapy should be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience remediating language deficits in students with language-based processing disorders. 4.

15 hours of intensive one-on-one training by an assistive technology specialist to help Student learn to use and become proficient with assistive technology to enhance his academic, vocational and personal endeavors.

5.

50 hours of mental health counseling and services. This counseling and services to be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience working with children with emotional disturbance and children who have suffered from significant trauma.

6.

35 hours of transition services, including but not limited to job training, coaching, interviewing skills, and resume preparation.

Accessibility Modified

7.

LACOE and Probation will not be responsible for providing or funding transportation to Student, or otherwise reimbursing Student for any transportation costs associated with accessing the services described in paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 above, except as follows: LACOE and Probation will provide Student with a bus pass to go to attend such services upon request, but if Student does not utilize the services from the contracted non-public agency within the month that he is provided with a bus pass by LACOE and Probation, then the bus pass will not be renewed until such time as he demonstrates that he has made arrangements for such services and has attended at least one session. Student’s counsel and LACOE and Probation will endeavor to identify certified non-public agencies who provide services locally and can provide services in a location accessible to Student.

8.

Student shall have two years from the date of this Order to utilize the compensatory services specified above. Thereafter, any unused balance of hours shall expire, and LACOE and Probation shall not be required to pay for any additional compensatory services. This two-year period shall be tolled for the duration of any delay in provision of services to Student that is solely attributable to LACOE or Probation or the providers with whom they contract, and Student and his counsel shall promptly notify LACOE and Probation of any issues related to interruption in services as soon as they are aware of such issues.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507, subdivision (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. Here, no issue was heard and decided by OAH because the parties have agreed upon the terms of a settlement incorporated into this Decision.

Accessibility Modified

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within 90 days of receipt of this Decision. (Ed. Code, § 56505, subd. (k).)

CHARLES MARSON

Administrative Law Judge Office of Administrative Hearings

Accessibility Modified

EXHIBIT A

MARK D. ROSENBAUM (CA SBN 59940)

(mrosenbaum@aclu-sc.org)

DAVID B. SAPP (CA SBN 264464)

(dsapp@aclu-sc.org)

ACLU FOUNDATION OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA

1313 W. 8th Street Los Angeles, CA 90017 Telephone: 213-977-5220 Facsimile: 213-417-2220

HERNAN VERA (CA SBN 175149)

(hvera@publiccounsel.org)

LAURA FAER (CA SBN 223846)

(lfaer@publiccounsel.org)

BENJAMIN CONWAY (CA SBN 246410)

(bconway@publiccounsel.org )

PUBLIC COUNSEL

610 South Ardmore Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90005 Telephone: 213-385-2977 Facsimile: 213-385-9089

PAULA D. PEARLMAN (CA SBN 109038)

(paula.pearlman@lls.edu)

SHAWNA L. PARKS (CA SBN 208301)

Accessibility Modified (shawna.parks@lls.edu)

SURISA E. RIVERS (CA SBN 250868)

(surisa.rivers@lls.edu)

DISABILITY RIGHTS LEGAL CENTER

919 Albany Street Los Angeles, CA 90015 Telephone: 213-736-8366 Facsimile: 213-487-2106 DENNIS D. PARKER (Not Admitted in CA)

(dparker@aclu.org)

LAURENCE M. SCHWARTZTOL (Not Admitted in CA)

(lschwartztol@aclu.org)

AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION FOUNDATION

NATIONAL LEGAL DEPARTMENT

125 Broad Street, 18th Floor New York, NY 10004 Telephone: 213-549-2682 Facsimile: 213-549-2654 Attorneys for Petitioner

Accessibility Modified

BEFORE THE

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In the Matter of:

STUDENT BY AND THROUGH HIS MOTHER, [PARENT],

STUDENT AND PETITIONER,

vs.

LOS ANGELES COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION AND LOS ANGELES

COUNTY PROBATION DEPARTMENT,

RESPONDENTS.

CASE NO. Not Yet Assigned

STIPULATED FINAL DECISION IN LIEU OF DUE PROCESS HEARING

(Proposed Order Filed Concurrently)

WHEREAS the parties have engaged in settlement negotiations to resolve the class action lawsuit filed by [Student] and two other students against Los Angeles County Office of Education and Los Angeles County Probation Department; WHEREAS the above referenced matter is an inextricable part of [Student]’s class action lawsuit;

Accessibility Modified

WHEREAS the parties have agreed that it is in their best interest to stipulate to findings and a remedial order to be issued by the Office of Administrative Hearings based on those findings;

This Stipulated Final Decision in Lieu of Due Process Hearing is entered into by and between [Student], on the one hand, and Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE) and Los Angeles County Probation Department (together “Respondents”), on the other hand, with reference to the following facts and findings:

RECITALS

1.

[Student] is a sixteen year old student eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability, speech and language impairment, and a student with emotional disturbance. He is a citizen and resident of Los Angeles County.

2.

The Los Angeles County Office of Education (“LACOE”) is the local education agency that operates the schools inside all Los Angeles County juvenile rehabilitation facilities and provides direct instruction to the students enrolled in those schools. Specifically, LACOE operates the school at the Challenger Youth Memorial Center (“Challenger School”) in Lancaster, California. Respondent LACOE has its principal offices in Downey, CA.

3.

From July 2009 to January 2010, [Student] attended the school run by

Respondent LACOE at Camp Challenger (“Challenger School”). Subsequently, from May 2010 through the present, [Student] has attended the schools run by Respondent LACOE at the Barry J. Nidorf and Eastlake Juvenile Halls (“Nidorf School” and “Eastlake School,” respectively). While [Student] attends the Challenger, Nidorf, and Eastlake Schools, LACOE is and has been the local educational agency charged by federal and

Accessibility Modified state law with providing him with a free and appropriate public education. During these periods of time, LACOE was the local educational agency charged by federal and state law with providing him with a free and appropriate public education. 4.

The Los Angeles County Probation Department (“Probation”) is a public agency with headquarters in Downey, California. Probation’s Office of Juvenile Institutions Bureau operates three juvenile halls and 18 juvenile camps, including the six camps at Challenger, and is responsible for the care of youth detained in those facilities. As the caretaker charged with these youth’s wellbeing, Respondent Probation is responsible for, among other things: (1) designing and implementing treatment plans designed to assist youth in their transition back into society; (2) ensuring that LACOE, and any other educational agency that enters the facilities, provides the youth with a FAPE and otherwise complies with federal and state special education laws; and (3) executing their duties as a special education related service provider in compliance with applicable federal and state special education laws.

5.

Along with this Final Decision in Lieu of Due Process Hearing, [Student], by and through his mother [Parent], files a due process request with the Office of Administrative Hearings against Respondents, seeking compensatory education for various violations of his educational rights under federal and state laws. 6.

During his six months of enrollment at the Challenger School, [Student]

alleges that he was not given the proper educational assessments, denied a free and appropriate education, and subjected to discriminatory treatment and unnecessary segregation and deprivation. [Student] further alleges that he continues to suffer emotional and behavioral problems which continue to hamper his academic progress. Since leaving Challenger, he has been assessed by a number of professionals who all agree that [Student] requires a heightened level of emotional and academic supports. Accessibility Modified

WHEREFORE, it is stipulated by and between Student and Respondents as follows:

AGREEMENT

The parties agree to the following compensatory education services: 1.

300 hours of intensive one-on-one instruction in reading, decoding, reading comprehension, and written expression. This instruction should be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience working with students who have significant language deficits and should utilize research-based interventions and methodologies such as LindaMood Bell or Wilson. This instruction should be provided for, at minimum, four hours per day.

2.

50 hours of intensive one-on-one instruction in mathematics computation and application. This instruction should be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience working with students who have significant language deficits and dyslexia and should utilize research-based interventions and methodologies. 3.

30 hours of intensive one-on-one speech and language therapy. This therapy should be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience remediating language deficits in students with language-based processing disorders. 4.

15 hours of intensive one-on-one training by an assistive technology specialist to help [Student] learn to use and become proficient with assistive technology to enhance his academic, vocational and personal endeavors.

5.

50 hours of mental health counseling and services. This counseling and services to be provided by a certified nonpublic agency that has experience working with children with emotional disturbance and children who have suffered from significant trauma.

Accessibility Modified

6.

35 hours of transition services, including but not limited to job training, coaching, interviewing skills, and resume preparation.

7.

Respondents will not be responsible for providing or funding transportation to Petitioner, or otherwise reimbursing Petitioner for any transportation costs associated with accessing the services described in paragraphs 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 above, except as follows: Respondents will provide Petitioner with a bus pass to go to attend such services upon request, but if Petitioner does not utilize the services from the contracted non-public agency within the month that he is provided with a bus pass by Respondents, then the bus pass will not be renewed until such time as he demonstrates that he has made arrangements for such services and has attended at least one session. Petitioner’s Counsel and Respondents will endeavor to identify certified non-public agencies who provide services locally and can provide services in a location accessible to Petitioner.

The parties further agree that Petitioner shall have two years from the date an order adopting this stipulation is entered to utilize the compensatory services specified above. Thereafter, any unused balance of hours shall expire, and Defendants shall not be required to pay for any additional compensatory services under this stipulation. This two-year period shall be tolled for the duration of any delay in provision of services to Petitioner that is solely attributable to Defendants or the Providers with whom they contract, and Petitioner and Class Counsel shall promptly notify Respondents of any issues related to interruption in services as soon as they are aware of such issues. In light of the settlement agreement entered into between Petitioner and Respondents in Casey A. v. Robles, No. CV 10-00192 (C.D. Ca.), and the attorney’s fees

Accessibility Modified specifically provided for therein, the parties stipulate that Petitioner’s counsel will not seek reimbursement for accrued fees and costs from the Office of Administration Hearings.

The parties further stipulate that, upon entry of an order adopting this stipulation, Petitioner will have satisfied the standard for exhaustion of administrative remedies under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the Americans with Disabilities Act. Respondents LACOE and Probation further stipulate that they will not raise any defense of failure to exhaust in connection to any claims brought by petitioner in federal court under the above-referenced statutes or in connection with the settlement agreement entered into between Petitioner and Respondents in Casey A. v. Robles, No. CV 10-00192 (C.D. Ca.).

Dated: [Sept. 14, 2010]

By:________/s___________________ Shawna L. Parks Surisa E. Rivers

DISABILITY RIGHTS LEGAL CENTER

For Student and Petitioner ____________/s________________ Mark Rosenbaum David Sapp ACLU Foundation of Southern California For Student and Petitioner _____________/s________________ Accessibility Modified

Laura Faer Benjamin Conway Public Counsel Law Center For Student and Petitioner

Dated: [Sept. 14, 2010]

___________/s_________________ Roger Granbo Office of the County Counsel, County of Los Angeles For Respondent Los Angeles County Probation Department ____________/s__________________ Vibiana Andrade General Counsel, Los Angeles County Office of Education For Respondent Los Angeles County Office of Education

Accessibility Modified