California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 2, 2004
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 0010-04, SN-0010-04 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Los Angeles Unified conceded denying FAPE through 2001-2002; Hearing Officer orders independent reassessment, behavior plan, and IEP-set compensatory education.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The mother of a 17-year-old eleventh grader filed this case against Los Angeles Unified School District. The student was eligible for special education under other health impairment because of ADHD. The case raised claims going back to first grade. The Hearing Officer found that the mother had received the District's procedural safeguards guide and had used it by May 2000. Because nothing paused the three-year limitations period, claims before January 5, 2001 were barred. Claims for personal injury, damages and harassment were outside the Hearing Office's jurisdiction.
The District conceded that it denied a FAPE from January 5, 2001 through the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer noted that the District had wrongly identified the student as emotionally disturbed. After that, the District dropped its own nonpublic school recommendation and left him at a comprehensive high school, where he repeated ninth grade.
The District did not have to reassess him when he enrolled at North Hills Prep School in September 2003. He moved there because his prior nonpublic school, Clairmont Academy, closed. His triennial review was not due, and he had been doing well. With small classes and a college-prep focus, North Hills offered a FAPE through January 2004. His attendance and work had recently slipped, so the District must add a behavior support plan.
The Hearing Officer ordered a reassessment by an independent psychologist and an IEP review of his transcript. The IEP team must then decide on compensatory education, to be completed in 2004-2005.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the three-year limitations period when a parent had received and actually used the procedural safeguards guide. It also shows a Hearing Officer leaving the type and amount of compensatory education to the IEP team after an independent reassessment, instead of setting hours herself.
Issues and holdings
Issue Procedural ruling (a). Whether Petitioner may raise claims or seek compensatory education for any period before January 5, 2001, three years before the due process request (Ed. Code § 56505(j)).
Mother received and actually used the District's Parent's Guide to procedural rights by May 2000, so no facts tolled the three-year limitations period; claims before January 5, 2001 were barred.
- Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue Procedural ruling (b). Claims for personal injury, monetary and punitive damages, harassment and retaliation, and a written apology.
Personal injury, damages, harassment and retaliation claims are outside the Hearing Office's jurisdiction under Ed. Code § 56501(a) and were not addressed.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I. Did the District deny Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, beginning January 5, 2001, and/or during the 2001-2002 school year?
Based on the District's concession, Student was denied a FAPE from January 5, 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue II. Did the District have an obligation to reassess Student in September 2003 when he enrolled at North Hills Prep School?
The triennial was not due until April 2004, conditions did not warrant reassessment because the move followed the closure of his prior school rather than any decline, and no parent or teacher requested one.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue III. Does the District's offered placement for Student at North Hills Prep School constitute a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
North Hills, with small classes and a college-prep focus, met Student's needs and offered a FAPE through January 2004; due to his recent decline in attendance and work, a BSP must be added, and with it the placement is a FAPE for the rest of the year.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue IV. If the District has denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to a different placement for the current school year or to compensatory education services?
No change of placement was needed; for the conceded 2001-2002 denial of FAPE, an independent psychologist must reassess Student and the IEP team must set the type and amount of compensatory education, to be completed in 2004-2005.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, if not already done, convene an IEP meeting to prepare a Behavior Support Plan (with Student participating) to help him attend class and complete class and homework assignments, and to conduct a comprehensive transcript review of credits earned and needed for graduation and whether a separate class period for study hall and/or compensatory services is feasible.
- Order to provide or change services. Add a Behavior Support Plan to Student's IEP addressing class attendance and completion of class and homework assignments.
- Order to assess. Within 10 calendar days, District to arrange a comprehensive reassessment by an independent licensed psychologist, which will serve as the triennial reassessment, covering current academic strengths and weaknesses, areas needing assistance or remediation, and strategies in light of ADHD and hearing loss. Parental consent not required; mother must make Student reasonably available. Assessment and report to be completed within 30 calendar days of the decision.
- Compensatory education. Within 5 calendar days of receiving the independent report, the IEP team (including mother, Student, and the assessing psychologist) shall determine the type and amount of compensatory education for the denial of FAPE from January 5, 2001 through the end of 2001-2002. Unless Petitioner agrees otherwise, services must begin within 10 calendar days of that meeting and be completed during the 2004-2005 school year. No hours specified.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School District
People named in the decision
- Susan Glickman, coordinating due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Marsee Seegan, coordinating specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Karen Jaster, school psychologist (2001 reassessment), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Julianne Gwin, director of education; behavior intervention case manager; District witness, North Hills Prep School
- Adam Marinus Louderback, advanced physical science teacher; District witness, North Hills Prep School
- Stephen Alan Friedman, licensed marriage and family therapist, clinical program director, DIS counselor; District witness, North Hills Prep School
- Jeane Gennis, English teacher; District witness, North Hills Prep School
- Elin Bradley, executive director, North Hills Prep School
- North Hills Prep School, certified nonpublic school (current placement)
- Clairmont Academy, certified nonpublic school (2002-2003 placement; closed June 2003)
- Montclair College Preparatory School, private school (2003 summer school; not a certified NPS)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Los Angeles, California, on February 24, 25, and 26, 2004. Oral closing arguments were heard by telephone conference on March 1, 2004.
Student (Petitioner or Student) was represented throughout the hearing by his mother, Student’s Mother. On February 26, 2004, Student was present at the hearing to testify. Los Angeles Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney, Peter Sansom. Also present on the District=s behalf was its coordinating due process specialist, Susan Glickman.
Petitioner called his mother to testify on his behalf. Respondent called the following witnesses from Student=s current placement at North Hills Prep School (North Hills) to testify on its behalf: director of education Julianne Gwin, advanced physical science teacher Adam Marinus Louderback, marriage and family therapist Stephen Alan Friedman, and English teacher Jeane Gennis. The District also called Student as a witness.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following the parties= closing arguments on March 1, 2004, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Statute of Limitations
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56505 (j), the appropriate scope of issues for a due process hearing is Athree years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request.@
Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing with the Hearing Office on January 5, 2004, and raised issues that encompassed twelve school years. Specifically, Petitioner asserted that, beginning in the first grade during the 1992-1993 school year and continuing over the next seven years, the District failed to identify him for special education. Petitioner further asserted that for five years after he was identified for special education, including the current school year, the District provided him with inappropriate special educational services.
During the February 9, 2004 prehearing conference, the District requested a ruling that Petitioner could only pursue special education claims for the three-year period prior to the date he filed his request for due process hearing, or from January 5, 2001 to the present. The Hearing Officer declined to rule on this request and advised the parties that an evidentiary hearing was required to determine when Petitioner knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for his request for periods prior to January 5, 2001. In addition, Student’s Mother asserted that the District denied her right to due process by its decision not to file for due process following her refusal to sign Student’s initial March 3, 2000 Individualized Education Program (IEP). The District acknowledged there was a factual issue for hearing regarding whether it had provided Student’s Mother with notice of her procedural rights. See: February 12, 2004 Prehearing Conference Order. After the conclusion of all witness testimony and during its closing argument, the District renewed its motion to dismiss Petitioner’s claims arising before January 5, 2001 and to deny him any compensatory education services for alleged educational losses prior to January 5, 2001.
The evidence produced at hearing firmly established that, as early as March 2000, Student’s Mother believed Student suffered from a disability arising from his attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) that required special education services and that he was not receiving appropriate educational services from the District. (Footnote 1) In addition, the uncontroverted evidence established that Student’s Mother had been provided, and had used, a copy of the District=s AA Parent=s Guide to Special Education Services (Including Procedural Rights and Safeguards)@ (Parent=s Guide, District Exhibit 23) at least by May 2000. (Testimony of Student’s Mother, Petitioner=s Ex. C 16-17). Specifically, the evidence demonstrated that Student’s Mother refused to sign Student=s March 3, 2000 initial IEP in which he was determined eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED). As indicated on that IEP, Student’s Mother Awas provided with Parent=s Rights and these were explained to her.@ On May 15, 2000, District coordinating specialist Marsee Seegan wrote to Student’s Mother that Ain the spirit of cooperation,@ the District did Anot wish to take [her] to due process@ for refusing to sign Student=s IEP. Ms Seegan suggested that Student’s Mother meet with her or with a District due process specialist to discuss her concerns about the IEP. In her May 18, 2000 letter responding to Ms. Seegan, Student’s Mother outlined her strong disagreement with Student=s identification as ED, asserted that procedural violations occurred at the IEP team meeting, raised concerns regarding inaccurate assessment data and interpretation of assessment data, advised the District of a new method of assessing students for ADHD, and requested an independent assessment of Student. (Pet. Exh. C 14- 17). In this letter, Student’s Mother also made several direct references to and quoted from the Parent=s Guide.
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner=s mother was provided with the Parent’s Guide and notice of her right to directly request a due process hearing on her son=s behalf from the Special Education Hearing Office on multiple occasions, including at Student=s initial March 2, 2000 IEP meeting, at the April 23, 2001 IEP meeting when Student=s eligibility was changed from ED to other health impaired, at the April 15, 2002 IEP meeting, and at subsequent IEP team meetings. The Hearing Officer further finds that the Parent=s Guide explains how to request a due process hearing, provides the address for the Special Education Hearing Office, and was actually used by the parent in her communications with the District in May 2000. From this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that there are no facts to toll the running of the three- year statute of limitations. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner cannot now raise claims or seek compensatory education services for any time prior to January 5, 2001, three years from the date he filed his request for due process.
Appropriate Issues for Hearing
In his request for due process hearing, Petitioner included claims for personal injury based on physical and emotional damage allegedly caused by the District, including a hearing loss allegedly incurred in September 2001 during a fight at the District=s Reseda High School. Petitioner requested monetary damages, future medical costs, and punitive damages for these injuries. Petitioner also asserted claims for alleged harassment and retaliation against him for his mother=s actions and complaints, and he requested that the District provide a written apology and unspecified corrective action to prevent such acts in the future.
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56501(a), issues that may be addressed at the due process hearing arise (1) where there is either a proposal or a refusal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education (FAPE), (2) where parent does not consent to an assessment, or (3) where there is a disagreement between a parent and a district regarding the availability of a program appropriate for the child.
As explained to Petitioner at the prehearing conferences and throughout the hearing, because these issues are outside the scope of the Hearing Office=s jurisdiction, they are not addressed in this Decision. (Footnote 2)
Continuance of Hearing and Relevance Objections to Petitioner=s Evidence
On February 24, 2004, Student’s Mother became visibly upset when the District objected to the relevance of some of Petitioner=s evidence, including documents from the early 1990s and documents relating to Student=s alleged personal injuries and harassment by District employees. Student’s Mother stated that Student had been molested while attending a District school in the second grade and asserted that perhaps this should be the focus of the due process hearing. The Hearing Officer advised her that this would not be an issue for the hearing. Student’s Mother stated that she had been Arailroaded@ by the District before and would be Arailroaded@ again in the due process hearing. Student’s Mother requested a continuance of the hearing, and began to leave the hearing before the Hearing Officer could rule on her request. In response to the Hearing Officer=s request that she state the basis for her continuance request, Student’s Mother stated Athe parent=s emotional instability.@ She then left the hearing before any ruling could be made.
After waiting a reasonable time to allow the parent an opportunity to return, the Hearing Officer granted the continuance until 9:30 a.m. on the following day. A minute order was read to Petitioner=s voice mail advising Student’s Mother that the hearing would proceed on February 25, 2004. On February 25, 2004, Student’s Mother returned to the hearing, which proceeded through its conclusion without further interruption.
Thereafter, the Hearing Officer took the District=s evidentiary objections to Petitioner=s Exhibits F 105-108, F 112, 114, 115 under submission. Those documents are now admitted. The Hearing Officer has read, reviewed, and considered all of Petitioner=s documentary evidence in light of Student’s Mother=s testimony in order to understand Student=s background and history, as well as his mother=s concerns. The Hearing Officer has given Petitioner=s evidence weight in relation to its relevance to the appropriate issues for this due process hearing as outlined below and in light of the relevant time period for the hearing as discussed above.
ISSUES FOR HEARING (Footnote 3)
I. Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year, beginning January 5, 2001, and/or during the 2001-2002 school year?
II. Did the District have an obligation to reassess Student in September 2003 when he enrolled at North Hills Prep School?
III. Does the District=s offered placement for Student at North Hills Prep School constitute a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
IV. If the District has denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to a different placement for the current school year or to compensatory education services?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District has denied him a free appropriate public education for many years. In Petitioner=s view, the District has historically (1) failed to address his needs for assistance in organization and study skills, including attending classes and completing class and homework assignments, and (2) failed to address his auditory problems, that have only recently been identified. Petitioner further asserts that while the District changed its initial erroneous identification of him as an emotionally disturbed (ED) student, it has continued to place him with ED student populations to his behavioral detriment. In Petitioner=s view, these historical failings are also present in his current placement at North Hills Prep School. Petitioner asserts that the District should have reassessed him in September 2003, when he enrolled at North Hills, that North Hills is an unsafe campus for him because he is free to leave it and because he is being physically harmed by its staff, and that his current North Hills DIS therapist, Stephen Friedman, is inappropriate. Petitioner=s mother changed her position regarding Student=s current placement during the hearing. By the conclusion of the hearing, after Student testified that he wanted to remain at North Hills, Student’s Mother dropped her request to remove him from this placement. Instead, Petitioner argues that North Hills could be an appropriate placement if Student is provided one hour a day of tutoring to assist him with his organization and study skills.
The District conceded that it did not provide Student a FAPE from January 2001 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year. It argues that compensatory education for this denial of FAPE can only be determined by the IEP team following a comprehensive reassessment of Student to determine his current areas of academic need. In view of the parent=s distrust of previous District assessments, the District agrees to have the reassessment conducted by an independent assessor. Regarding the 2003-2004 school year, the District argues that there is no merit to Petitioner=s assertions that it was required to reassess him on enrollment at North Hills. In the District=s view, North Hills is a certified nonpublic school with a safe environment that was able to successfully implement Student’s IEP, and he has been provided with a qualified therapist, Mr. Friedman, for DIS counseling services. The District asserts that it intends to convene an IEP team meeting to prepare and offer Student a behavior support plan (BSP) to help him attend class and complete his homework. The District argues that North Hills= existing onsite tutoring programs, in conjunction with a BSP, provide Student with sufficient academic support and that North Hills is an appropriate placement with this change to its offered program. Accordingly, the District contends that its placement offer for the 2003-2004 school year provides Student with a FAPE.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Student is a 17-year-old eleventh grade student who is eligible for special education and related services as a student with an Aother health impairment@ (OHI) arising from his ADHD. In fifth grade, Student was identified as intellectually gifted and eligible for the AGifted and Talented Education,@ or GATE, program. Although Student was observed to have difficulty remaining on task during elementary school, his academic performance as reflected in his grades was not affected. Beginning in middle school, however, Student=s behavior and academic performance began to deteriorate and he had multiple school placements.
Student was first assessed for special education in February 2000 while attending eighth grade at the District=s Sutter Middle School. On the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT), Student scored at the 98th percentile in reading, the 92nd percentile in spelling, and the 90th percentile in arithmetic. On the Learning Efficiency Test II (LET-II), Student=s global memory score was at the 99.9th percentile, with a visual standard score of 125 and an auditory standard score of ™145. Behavior scales were completed by Student, Student’s Mother, and Student=s teachers with discrepant results. On March 2, 2000, the IEP team found Student eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) and offered him placement in a nonpublic school (NPS). The team noted that Student had multiple behavioral referrals for refusing to work, disrupting class, using profanity, making threats, demonstrating disrespect, threatening others and fighting. The IEP team concluded that Student had Aan inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships within the school environment, including seeking negative attention such as punishment or ostracism, behavior that is inappropriate or atypical under normal circumstances, and an inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory or health factors.@ This conclusion was strongly disputed by his mother, who refused to sign the IEP.
Following this IEP meeting, Student moved to the District=s Portola Middle School. In May 2000, while still in eighth grade, Student was transferred from Portola to Zane Grey Continuation High School, where Student’s Mother testified he was isolated from the general population.
2000-2001 school year: reassessment and identification as OHI
In September 2000, Student began ninth grade at the District=s Reseda High School, his home school, where he participated in and was removed from the Police Magnet Program. For the majority of the 2000-2001 school year, Student was identified as an ED student with a recommended NPS placement, pursuant to the unsigned March 2000 IEP. In December 2000, Student was transferred back to Zane Grey in the general population where, according to Student’s Mother, he was exposed to negative influences and became involved in acts of vandalism aimed at the family home.
In the spring of 2001, the District agreed to reassess Student due to his mother=s ongoing concerns regarding ADHD and his identification as ED. Student=s performance on standardized tests was described as in the above average to markedly above average range, with classroom achievement markedly below his cognitive level. District psychologist Karen Jaster concluded that Student exhibited a disorder in the area of attention and that his relative processing strengths were in the areas of auditory and visual memory. She concluded that Student Aappears to exhibit attention deficit behaviors associated with ADHD.@ Ms. Jaster also determined that Student did not exhibit ED behaviors, and that behaviors previously noted at school Aappear to be mild to serious conduct problems rather than ED behaviors,@ that Aare often associated with students who have ADHD.@ The psychologist concluded that Student met eligibility criteria as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD).
On April 23, 2001, the IEP team considered the reassessment and determined Student was eligible as a student with an Aother health impairment@ due to his ADHD, rather than as a student with an ED or an SLD. Placement at a nonpublic school was again offered. Student’s Mother consented to this IEP. Student failed the ninth grade.
2001-2002 school year
In early September 2001, Student returned to Reseda High School to repeat the ninth grade. On September 6, 2001, Student sustained a head injury during a fight at school that Student’s Mother believed affected his hearing. On September 12, 2001, in response to the parent=s request, an IEP team meeting was convened to discuss Student=s placement. In an addendum to the April 23, 2001 IEP, the IEP team noted that Student’s Mother did not believe any of the NPS placements offered, including North Hills, were appropriate for Student. The IEP team expressed its current agreement that Student=s Aneeds can best be met at a comprehensive high school with the support of a study skills class in the resource specialist program [RSP], with DIS counseling.@ Student’s Mother consented to this IEP.
Shortly after this IEP, Student transferred to the District=s Cleveland High School, where he repeated the ninth grade, and had a fifth period study hall in the resource room. Student’s Mother testified that Student was successful during the semester at Cleveland. During the second semester of the 2001-2002 school year, however, Student=s grades declined and his absences from class increased. Student was placed on graduation ceremony probation as a result of his attendance problems and truancies. (Footnote 4)
On April 15, 2002, the IEP team convened for Student=s annual review and confirmed his eligibility as OHI. (Footnote 5) Student=s teachers reported that he had difficulty sustaining his performance over time, that his performance fluctuated Adramatically, from positive success to zero,@ that he continued to cut classes, and did not complete assignments or maintain his organizer. Despite Student=s above average cognitive skills, the team determined that he Aneeds very close supervision, small intervals of instruction, scaffolding of skills to lead to completion of work, chunking of information on related topics to encourage integration of new information and consistent presentation.@ The IEP team offered Student placement in the resource specialist (RSP) program, DIS counseling services (declined by Student’s Mother), and a special education assistant Awhen truancies are noted such as returning to class from nutrition and lunch as well as attending assemblies.@ In addition, the IEP contained a Behavior Support Plan (BSP) for Student that targeted his off-task behavior of 0 to 55 minutes per period. It was recommended that his curriculum and teaching strategies be modified to include frequent checking of his on-task behavior, use of outlines and handouts to support lectures, daily checking of agenda, and use of study skills class to follow up on assignments which are incomplete. Student=s goal was to be on-task in study skills class for 45 minutes of the class period. Student’s Mother testified this IEP was not implemented.
On June 6, 2002, the IEP team again convened to determine the need for any modifications to the IEP. The team noted that Student continued to cut classes, failed to maintain his organizer or complete his assignments, was failing most classes, was frequently out of class, and was on-task only ten to twenty percent when he did attend. The team noted that Student did attend his RSP study skills class two to three days a week and was on task approximately forty five minutes during that class. The IEP team noted that Student was able to remain on task more regularly in a smaller setting where he is able to receive individualized instruction. From its review, the IEP team determined that Student required placement in a small structured environment and agreed to place him at Clairmont Academy, a certified NPS, for the following year, as requested by the parent. Student’s Mother consented to this IEP.
2002-2003 School Year: Clairmont Academy NPS
Student enrolled in and completed tenth grade at Clairmont Academy during the 2002-2003 school year. At Clairmont, Student=s grades dramatically improved, with a predominance of A and B grades. Student does not assert a denial of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school or extended school year.
At his June 2, 2003 annual IEP review, Student was characterized as a Agreat reader@ who read at the tenth grade level with 95% accuracy on reading comprehension questions. Student was described as a student with Aa great math foundation@ and math was noted to be another one of his strong academic subjects. In language arts, Student was writing three-paragraph cohesive essays, with a goal to further develop his compound sentences and overall length of essays. Student=s present level of performance on his vocational education/transition goal was described by the team as reflective of great improvement. Student was able to Astay in the classroom for more than one hour on a consistent basis. He participates well in class and completes most of his daily assignments.... has made his behavioral points for almost 3 months and has had minimal incident reports. Student has no problems asking permission to leave the classroom, this is a great improvement for Student.@ The IEP team confirmed Student=s placement at a nonpublic school for the 2003-2004 school year, with one hour a week of DIS counseling services. Student=s counseling goal was to learn to deal with impulsive behaviors and frustrating situations.
In late June 2003, Clairmont Academy suddenly closed and advised its students that it would not renew its contract with the District for the 2003 extended school year (ESY) or the 2003-2004 school year. Student attended summer school at Montclair College Preparatory School. Both Student and Student’s Mother wanted him to continue at Montclair for the 2003-2004 school year; however, on September 10, 2003, the District mailed Student’s Mother a letter in which it offered Student placement at North Hills Prep School, a certified NPS, for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 6)
2003-2004 School Year at North Hills Prep School
In late September 2003, Student enrolled in the eleventh grade at North Hills. Due to his expressed desire to attend a four-year university, Student=s initial class schedule included college prerequisite courses in chemistry and algebra II.
On October 23, 2003, an IEP team meeting convened at North Hills to update Student=s present levels of performance, to review his goals and objectives, and to amend the June 2, 2003 IEP to reflect the District=s placement offer at North Hills for the 2003-2004 school year. Student was present at this IEP meeting; however, Student’s Mother was not. In response to the notice of IEP meeting, Student’s Mother asked the IEP team to ensure that Student=s math placement was proper for his skill level, that his chemistry teacher assigned and enforced any >catch-up= fundamentals Student may need, and that tutoring be promptly assigned for Student Aif required B he will not volunteer.@ Under academics, the IEP team noted that Student had shown a good adjustment to all of his classes since enrollment except chemistry. The team determined that Student would transfer from chemistry to advanced physical science. The team also noted that Student was earning an F in algebra II Awhich he thinks is due to not completing his homework and having had a few absences that are difficult to catch up.@ The team discussed North Hill=s tutoring program with Student and he agreed to participate in tutoring after school or at lunchtime if his grade did not improve. The IEP team determined that all of Student=s goals and objectives from the June 2, 2003 IEP, except his math goal, remained valid and in progress. A new goal was drafted in mathematics.
On October 24, 2003, Student’s Mother indicated her disagreement with parts of the IEP; however, she consented to the implementation of all elements of the IEP pending resolution of the dispute. Specifically, Student’s Mother disagreed with the instructional setting at North Hills and with the assignment of Stephen Friedman as Student=s therapist for DIS counseling services.
Student successfully completed the first semester at North Hills and has expressed his desire to remain at North Hills. Student will turn eighteen on September 11, 2004. He is scheduled to graduate from high school with a diploma in June 2005.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.' 1400; Education Code ' 56000. The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student=s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(8) (1997). ASpecial education@ is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401 (25) (1997). The term Arelated services@ includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22). Education Code ' 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California=s term for related services, shall be provided Awhen the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.@
To determine whether the District provided Student a free appropriate public education, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District=s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student=s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student=s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a Abasic floor of opportunity@ that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s offer must have been designed to meet Student=s unique needs, and must have been reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit. In addition, the services actually provided to him must have comported with his IEP. (Footnote 7)
ISSUE No. I: Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year beginning on January 5, 2001, and/or during the 2001-2002 school year?
On the first day of hearing, the District informed the Hearing Officer and Petitioner that it did not dispute Issue I. Based on this admission by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that Student was denied a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year beginning on January 5, 2001 and for the 2001-2002 school year.
The remedy for this denial of FAPE will be addressed in Issue IV, below.
ISSUE II: Did the District have an obligation to reassess Student in September 2003 when he enrolled at North Hills Prep School?
Petitioner contends that the District had an obligation to reassess him when he enrolled at North Hills in September 2003 to determine his then-current present levels of performance. The District asserts that a formal reassessment was neither requested or required and that North Hills= staff was capable of and did implement Student=s current IEP using informal assessment and observation.
Both the IDEA and state special education law require that a student with a disability be reassessed at least every three years, but more frequently Aif conditions warrant,@ or if requested by the child=s parent or teacher. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(a)(2)(A), Cal. Educ. Code ' 56381. From the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that, when Student enrolled at North Hills in September 2003, his triennial reassessment was not due and conditions did not warrant a reassessment. First, Student=s triennial reassessment IEP is due April 23, 2004, three years from the date the IEP team changed in his eligibility category from emotionally disturbed to other health impairment, based upon his comprehensive reassessment in April 2001. Although Student’s Mother flatly asserted that the April 2004 triennial date is Afraudulent,@ the Hearing Officer finds no basis for this assertion. Second, the evidence presented does not support a finding that conditions warranted a reassessment in September 2003. At the time, Student was transitioning into North Hills from another nonpublic school, Clairmont Academy, where he was academically successful for the 2002-2003 school year. No evidence was presented regarding Student=s academic performance during his brief attendance at Montclair Prep School in the 2003 extended school year to suggest otherwise. In summary, Student=s enrollment at North Hills was not precipitated by any decline in his own performance or behavior that might have suggested a need for reassessment; rather, it was necessitated due to the sudden closure of Clairmont Academy.
The Hearing Officer also finds that there was no request for a formal reassessment of Student in September 2003. First, no evidence was presented that any of Student=s teachers at North Hills requested a reassessment. Second, for the October 23, 2003 IEP, Student’s Mother inquired about placement tests and asked the IEP team to Amake sure [Student=s] math placement is proper for skill level.@ The Hearing Officer finds that this request, on its face, does not constitute a request for a reassessment. North Hills’ director of education, Ms. Gwin, also testified persuasively that Student’s Mother did not request a formal assessment of Student when he initially enrolled at North Hills in late September 2003. According to Ms. Gwin, she discussed informal assessment with Student’s Mother. Ms. Gwin further testified that, in her opinion, there was no need for additional data regarding Student=s academic present levels of performance to implement his existing IEP in the fall of 2003. She based this opinion on the information available from Student=s progress on his recent June 2003 IEP, as well as from North Hill=s informal assessment of his abilities from his class tests, written assignments on coursework and his grades. (Footnote 8) This informal evaluation process led to changes in Student=s math goal on his October 23, 2004 IEP. It also led to class schedule adjustments within a reasonable time after his enrollment at North Hills (i.e., from chemistry to advanced physical science and from algebra II to algebra review) and to Student=s successful completion of these new classes.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not have an obligation to reassess Student in September 2003 when he enrolled at North Hills Prep School.
ISSUE III: Does Student=s current placement at North Hills Prep School provide him with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
As previously discussed, to constitute a FAPE, the District=s placement offer for the 2003-2004 school year must have been designed to meet Student=s unique needs, and must have been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. In addition, the services actually provided to him must have comported with his IEP.
A. Is the placement at North Hills designed to meet Student=s unique needs?
1. Student=s unique needs
Student=s unique educational needs arising from his OHI disability are largely undisputed. To benefit from his education in light of his disability, Student has a unique need for a small learning environment that can provide him with additional time to complete tasks. The evidence established that, because of his ADHD, Student has difficulty in sustaining his attention and remaining on task, and his Aattentional difficulties impact his ability to meet grade level standards.@ The testimony of Ms. Gwin and Student’s physical science teacher, Mr. Louderback, established that, since his enrollment at North Hills, Student has remained on task for periods of ten to fifteen minutes. He then takes a break of up to five minutes, and returns to work. Student is not disruptive during his breaks and he is able to remain in his class for the fifty-two minute period.
Student also has unique behavior needs arising from his disability. The evidence demonstrated that Student had a history of behavior problems while attending public schools. For example, the unsigned March 2, 2000 IEP indicated Student had multiple behavioral referrals for refusing to work, disrupting class, using profanity, making threats, demonstrating disrespect, threatening others and fighting. Once Student began attending nonpublic school, this behavior sharply declined. As indicated in the June 2003 IEP, Student’s behavior at Clairmont was positive. In addition, the testimony of Student=s North Hills teachers clearly established that he does not present behavior problems of this type at this school. Rather, Student was consistently described as a respectful student who follows staff directions and who is well liked by his peers.
As discussed above, much of Student=s behavior has improved. The evidence persuasively established, however, that Student is frequently tardy to and absent from classes at North Hills. The parties do not dispute that Student has a unique need for assistance in organization, and study skills. It is apparent that this need encompasses assistance in attending class as well as in completing class and homework assignments. Mr. Louderback and Ms. Gennis both testified that Student has many strengths and that his primary weakness is his lack of motivation. (Footnote 9) This is manifested in part by his tardiness to or absence from class, which in turn affects his ability to understand and complete his class and homework. For example, Student was academically successful in the majority of his classes for the first semester of the 2003-2004 school year (September 3, 2003 through January 30, 2004). In his Spanish class, however, Student received a D for the semester and his teacher reported that he had multiple tardies and absences. Without regular attendance at class, Student’s organization and study skills cannot be addressed.
In addition, Student has recently been determined to have unique needs relating to his hearing. In Student’s Mother=s view, Student has experienced hearing problems for some years that have not been addressed by the District. On November 3, 2003, an audiometric test was conducted on Student at North Hills. The results of this assessment suggested a possible reduction in hearing acuity. North Hills advised Student’s Mother to have Student assessed by his doctor as soon as possible. On November 24, 2003, Student’s Mother advised North Hills staff that Student’s specialist determined he has a 15 decibel hearing loss in his right ear “due to injury or birth defect,” that makes hearing in a large classroom difficult. Because his left ear is undamaged, it was recommended that Student sit at the right front in his classrooms.
Finally, Student has unique transition needs to achieve his goal of attending college. While he would prefer to attend a four-year university, Student is also considering beginning his post-secondary school education at a two-year community college. Student=s current transition goal is to complete all four academic subjects with ninety percent accuracy.
2. Designed to meet Student’s unique needs?
To determine if Student=s placement is designed to meet his unique needs, the Hearing Officer begins by reviewing the District=s placement offer for Student for the 2003-2004 school year. The District=s offer is contained in Student=s June 2, 2003 annual IEP, as amended by the October 23, 2003 IEP. Pursuant to these documents, Student was offered placement for the 2003-2004 school and extended school year at North Hills Prep nonpublic school, one hour a week of DIS counseling, and supports and instructional accommodations of small group instruction, extended time for tasks, and positive reinforcement for completion of assignments. Student=s IEP includes an individual transition plan (ITP) that requires both NSP staff and Student to facilitate his consistent attendance at school as necessary to earn all the required credits to meet his goal of attending college after graduation.
The evidence established that North Hills is a certified nonpublic school that, by definition, meets California requirements for teaching staff who either hold valid California teaching credentials or who are supervised by staff with such credentials. Cal. Educ. Code § 56366.1(k). North Hills= director of education, Ms. Gwin, testified that North Hills has a current enrollment of approximately 104 seventh- through twelth-grade students. Maximum class size is twelve students with an average of eight to ten students per class. Ms. Gwin testified that North Hills educates students with all types of disabilities including ADHD, emotional disturbance (ED), other health impairment (OHI), and specific learning disabilities (SLDs), but that it does not specialize in any disability area. She testified that North Hills has two programs: one for students with SLDs and another for students, like Student, who have average to above average intelligence but who have experienced problems in the public schools. (Footnote 10) As outlined in its program description on the California certified nonpublic, nonsectarian schools and agencies database [Dist. Ex. 19], North Hills Aemphasizes college preparatory study while supporting our students with special needs to work in that direction.@
The Hearing Officer finds that the small size of the classrooms at North Hills meets Student=s unique need for a small learning environment, as well as his unique hearing needs. First, Ms. Gwin=s testimony regarding North Hill=s small class size was confirmed by Student, who testified that his only larger class was sports. Second, the evidence established that Student has been able to succeed academically since moving from larger general education classroom settings to smaller NPS settings like Clairmont and North Hills. Third, Mr. Louderback testified that multi-sensory teaching methods are used by all teachers at North Hills. Fourth, Ms. Gwin testified that Student would require preferential seating if he were attending large room, general education classes. Because North Hills= classrooms are small, however, he does not need to sit in the front of the class. North Hills teachers generally testified that Student has refused their offers of closer seats and that he prefers to sit in the back of the room near the door. In addition, Student testified that he has no problem hearing the teachers at North Hills from where he sits in his classrooms.
The Hearing Officer also finds that North Hills is designed to meet Student=s unique transition needs. As reflected in both his ITP and his testimony, Student=s goal is to attend college after graduation. As discussed above, North Hills is a nonpublic school that Aemphasizes college preparatory study while supporting our students with special needs to work in that direction.@ Ms. Gwin testified that as part of her previous duties as North Hills= dean of students, she has developed curriculum and programs to help its students enter college. She also testified that, when Student initially enrolled in September 2003, he was placed in algebra II and chemistry classes because these courses are prerequisites to attendance at a four-year university and this was Student=s expressed desire. While these classes were eventually changed, it is evident that North Hills is dedicated to the goal of preparing its students for college and that it has and continues to provide academic instruction and counseling that is designed to meet Student=s unique transition needs.
a. Safety of North Hills Campus and Staff
Petitioner contends that North Hills is an unsafe placement for Student because it is an open campus he can leave and because he is being harmed by North Hills= staff. The District counters that there is no credible evidence that North Hills poses a safety risk to Student. The Hearing Officer finds no merit in Petitioner=s contentions.
Ms. Gwin testified that North Hills is an open campus that students are able to leave. She also acknowledged that there have been some instances where Student has arrived at school and then left the campus. Student himself candidly testified that he has left the campus in the past, primarily to obtain food items with friends. Student also acknowledged that these off campus trips contribute to his tardiness to class. There was no evidence, however, that the fact that North Hills is an open campus poses a safety hazard to Student. Student=s OHI disability is not of a nature to create a risk of harm to himself or to others. Rather, as discussed in subsection (c) below, the appropriate concern is with Student=s tardiness and absence from class occasioned by his involvement in social activities occurring on campus, as well as to trips off campus. Finally, Student testified that he is currently restricted from leaving campus and that he is complying with this restriction.
Student’s Mother testified that North Hills is not appropriate because Student is being hurt by its staff. The evidence established that, in early November 2003, Student=s finger was accidentally closed in the car door of North Hills= executive director, Elin Bradley, by another student. Ms. Gwin, Mr. Louderback, Mr. Friedman, and Ms. Gennis each testified that they had never seen Student being hurt by North Hills’ staff. In fact, these witnesses testified and the Hearing Officer observed that Student is a tall, sturdy, athletic young man who appears capable of defending himself. Furthermore, Student himself testified that he had never been harmed by any of the North Hills staff, that he had no safety concerns, and that he wanted to remain at North Hills. Student also testified that he is not uncomfortable on campus with North Hill students who are identified as emotionally disturbed.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Gwin, Mr. Louderback, Mr. Friedman, and Ms. Gennis regarding the safety of the North Hills campus to be credible and persuasive on this point. In addition, throughout the due process hearing, the Hearing Officer had the opportunity to observe Student’s Mother’s demeanor and to listen to her opinions. From the totality of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds Student’s Mother=s testimony that North Hills is an unsafe campus for Student to be highly questionable and entitled to little credibility. (Footnote 11) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that North Hills does not expose Student to an unsafe environment that is contrary to meeting his unique needs.
b. DIS Therapist
For the current school year, the District has offered Student one hour a week of DIS counseling services without specifying any particular therapist for Student in his IEP. Student’s Mother expressed her strong antipathy for Student=s current therapist, Stephen Friedman, and asserted that he is inappropriate to provide Student=s DIS counseling services. (Footnote 12) The District counters that it has a right to choose qualified personnel to implement IEP services and that there is no credible evidence that Mr. Friedman is not an appropriate therapist for Student.
Mr. Friedman=s undisputed testimony established that he is a licensed marriage, family and child therapist with fourteen years of experience and advanced doctoral level coursework in clinical psychology. Mr. Friedman testified that he is the director of North Hills= clinical program, supervises its four other therapists, and directly counsels students at North Hills. Mr. Friedman testified that he has counseled Student on a weekly basis since October 2003, addressing issues of impulse control, frustration tolerance, oppositional defiance, depression, ability to focus on school work and grades, and pressures from both in and out of school. The Hearing Officer found Mr. Friedman to be a very credible witness and observed his demeanor to be calm, professional, and explanatory in response to frequently hostile questions posed to him by Student’s Mother. Despite their differences, Hearing Officer notes that Student’s Mother and Mr. Friedman agree on one thing B it is very hard for Student to ask for help.
Student testified that he no longer wants Mr. Friedman to be his therapist. The Hearing Officer found Student to be an honest young man who is aware of his own needs and willingness to participate in offered or suggested services. However, in this one area, the Hearing Officer must consider Student=s testimony in light of the fact that he was testifying in front of his mother on a matter regarding which she has a particularly strong opinion. The Hearing Officer also notes that following a meeting between Student’s Mother and Mr. Friedman in October 2003 that escalated into a confrontation, Student told North Hills personnel that he liked Mr. Friedman as his therapist. Dist. Ex. 13. For this reason, the Hearing Officer concludes that Mr. Friedman’s opinion that it is not in Student’s best interest to remove him from their established therapeutic relationship based solely on Student’s Mother’s feelings is entitled to greater weight than Student=s testimony on this point.
The Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Friedman=s role as Student=s DIS therapist in no way renders North Hills inappropriate as a placement to address Student=s unique needs. The Hearing Officer further concludes that it is unnecessary to determine whether Mr. Friedman should continue as Student=s therapist for the following reason. Mr. Friedman testified that North Hills has four other qualified therapists and that, if the parent or Student did not want him to work with Student, he would assign a different therapist. There is no basis for the Hearing Officer to conclude that this internal therapist assignment process will not be followed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that North Hills’ internal process for assigning a particular therapist to provide Student with his DIS therapy is sufficient to address Petitioner’s concern. In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer also takes into consideration that relying on North Hill’s internal assignment process will also allow Student an opportunity to express his wishes outside of the hearing process.
c. Support in Organization and Study Skills, Including Class Attendance And Completion Of Class And Homework Assignments
The primary area of dispute between the parties is whether North Hills provides Student sufficient support in organization and study skills, including class attendance and completion of class and homework assignments. (Footnote 13) In Petitioner=s view, he requires behavior monitoring to ensure class attendance and a study hall period to ensure that he will complete his homework assignments at school. In response, the District asserts that North Hills= existing tutorial programs, in conjunction with a behavior support plan (BSP) to be developed and offered to him by the IEP team, provide Student with appropriate support to meet his needs. The Hearing Officer notes that while a BSP was part of Student=s IEP at public school, such a plan has been unnecessary since he began attending nonpublic schools, due to his marked improvement in grades and behavior.
The weight of the evidence established that tutorial and homework support for students is an integral part of the current academic program at North Hills and was in existence in September 2003. According to North Hill=s staff, this tutoring is offered to students during a lunch time study hall, staffed by the math and English teachers, and an after school tutorial, staffed by senior peers tutors and the algebra teacher, twice a week. North Hills= students voluntarily access these supports. Team notes from the October 23, 2003 IEP meeting indicate that the IEP team discussed the program with Student and that he agreed to participate in it if his chemistry grade did not improve. Ms. Gwin testified that she has told Student that he would be provided with transportation home if he stayed, but that he does not generally participate. Student also testified that he is aware of the study hall but has only gone twice. Thus, the record demonstrates the Student is aware of the tutorial and homework support program but has infrequently used it.
In addition, the evidence established that North Hills has a grading policy designed to ensure that students do not fail classes based solely upon their inability to complete homework. Ms. Gwin testified that North Hills recognizes that, for students like Student with ADHD, getting through the school day is enough, and further academic engagement in homework is unlikely. To ensure that students who do not complete their homework cannot fail, North Hills has a policy of assigning only ten percent of a class grade to homework completion.
Since his enrollment at North Hills, Student=s academic performance has been varied but predominantly successful. Student initially experienced difficulty transitioning to a new campus as shown in his class participation and grades. For example, Student=s first semester English teacher, Ms. Gennis, testified that his academic performance transformed tremendously during her four month class. Student initially had many absences, did not work in class and earned a D grade. She testified that Student later became very motivated to pull up his grade, frequently asked her what he needed to do or complete, and earned a B for the class. With the exception of his Spanish class, Student was successful in his other classes during the first semester. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student substantially succeeded academically at North Hills during the first semester without the necessity of a BSP and even though he rarely used North Hills’ existing support programs. From this, the Hearing Officer concludes that the North Hills placement was designed to meet Student=s unique needs for organizational, attendance, and study skills support through the end of the first semester in late January 2004.
Currently, Student=s academic performance has waned. Mr. Louderback testified that Student=s attendance, class participation, and homework completion in his advanced physical science class have deteriorated within the last two to three weeks and that he has observed Student to be depressed and withdrawn. Student is frequently late to this first period class and will sleep in class or ask to go to the counselor=s office. Mr. Louderback testified that he has heard Student talk about using marijuana and alcohol in social situations.
North Hills staff uniformly testified that Student would benefit from the addition of a behavior support plan to his IEP. Ms. Gwin testified that she has been trained as a behavior intervention case manager (BICM) and has designed and implemented many BSPs for students with attentional and homework difficulties. In her opinion, the goal of Student=s BSP should be to get to class on time, remain there, and complete his daily assignments and homework. Ms. Gwin, Mr. Louderbach, and Mr. Friedman agreed that, because Student loves and is highly motivated by sports, a BSP could effectively use sports as an incentive to accomplish these goals. Mr. Friedman testified that a BSP to this effect (i.e., that provides Student with a reinforcer of his choice, such as playing basketball for the last ten minutes of class) has recently been drafted by North Hills staff, but that an IEP team meeting has not been held to address it. In Mr. Friedman=s opinion, Student could benefit from a BSP if he participates in its development.
The weight of the evidence persuasively established that, at seventeen and a half years old, Student has established priorities. While Student remains focused on his goal to attend college, he has a strong interest in friends and sports. Ms. Gwin testified that Student prefers to be with his friends and to play basketball during non-class time. This observation was confirmed by Student, who set clear parameters during his testimony on the time during which he was willing to work with a tutor. Specifically, Student testified that he was not willing to attend such a program during lunch, at home, or as a pull-out from sports. Student also testified that he is aware of his graduation requirements and when during each quarter he needs to begin focusing on his schoolwork.
As discussed above, Student=s most recent pattern of attendance and class performance is deteriorating. It is difficult to know with certainty if this pattern is a conscious choice by Student, due to insufficient support at North Hills, due to a combination of both, or due to Student=s awareness of the impending due process proceeding. Student acknowledged that he was not doing well in school lately, that he had been sidetracked by outside events, and that he was conscious of the need to catch up. Student impressed the Hearing Officer as a teenager who is academically goal oriented and who has, in the past, been able to concentrate on his studies to achieve good grades. However, because the evidence also supports a finding that Student has great difficulty asking for help, the Hearing Officer finds that Student=s recent change in behavior and attendance necessitates a change in his IEP; specifically, the addition of a BSP as described above. A BSP designed specifically to address Student’s class attendance and assignment completion behavior can meet Student’s unique needs in this area within the context of his existing academic program at North Hills. The finding that Student currently requires a BSP to address these needs does not mandate a conclusion that North Hill placement has been inappropriate for Student since his enrollment. To the contrary, the evidence firmly established that, until early February 2004, North Hills= placement was designed to meet Student unique organizational, study skills and attendance needs, and that with the addition of a BSP, it will be designed to meet his unique needs in this area for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. ***
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student’s placement at North Hills has been designed to meet his unique needs through the end of January 2004 and that, with the addition of the BSP discussed above, will continue to be designed to meet his unique needs for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year.
B. Is Student=s placement at North Hills reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?
The weight of the evidence established that Student=s placement at North Hills has been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Ms. Gennis persuasively testified that Student definitely made academic progress in her English class during his first semester at North Hills because he improved his grade from a D to a B. She also observed that, during this time, Student became very self-motivated, wrote journals and poetry in which he expressed grief for Amessing up his life@ and expressed a desire to stop this negative behavior. In addition, Student=s North Hills report card for the fall 2003-2004 through the end of January 2004, revealed that he was doing average to above average work. For his first semester classes, Student received a final grade of D in Spanish, a C+ in English, a B- in advanced physical science, a B in sports, and a credit in transition planning. At the end of January 2004, Student was noted to be making substantial progress on his math and written language goals and partial progress on his counseling and transition goals.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s North Hills placement was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit through the end of the first semester. As discussed above, a recent change in Student=s behavior mandates the addition of a BSP to his IEP. With this addition, the Hearing Officer finds that Student=s placement at North Hills will continue to be reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
C. Does Student=s Placement at North Hills Comport with his IEP?
Petitioner does not contend that his placement does not comport with his IEP.
* * *
In summary, it is undisputed that Student wants to remain at North Hills, at least for his academic coursework. (Footnote 14) The Hearing Officer finds that the District offered Student a FAPE through the conclusion of the first semester in January 2004. As discussed above, due to a recent change in circumstances, it is clear that a behavior support plan needs to be developed and added to Student=s IEP to further address his organizational and study skills needs arising from his OHI disability. The Hearing Officer concludes that, with this change, Student=s current placement at North Hills Prep School provides him with a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.
ISSUE IV: If the District has denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to a different placement for the current school year and/or, to compensatory education services?
In light of the conclusion reached in Issue III, it is unnecessary to address a change of placement for Student. The only remedy the Hearing Officer must address is for the denial of FAPE from January 5, 2001, through the conclusion of the 2001-2002 school year. There is no doubt that Student suffered from this denial of FAPE. First, Student was erroneously identified as a student with an emotional disturbance and no special education services were provided to him until his reassessment and change in eligibility to OHI in April 2001. Second, Student had to repeat ninth grade during the 2001-2002 school year. Third, in April 2001, after Student was identified as OHI, the District recognized that he required placement in a small nonpublic school (NPA) setting, then failed to locate an appropriate NPS placement, and simply capitulated when Student’s Mother stated she did not believe any of its offered NPS placements were appropriate for Student. Rather than seek an appropriate NPA or pursue due process to ensure that Student received a FAPE, the District altered its recommendation in September 2001, and allowed Student to attend a comprehensive high school where he continued to struggle. Fourth, although the exact date Student developed a hearing loss is unknown, he attended large general education classrooms during this period which current evidence establishes would have been detrimental to him without preferential seating.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is Aappropriate@ in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. ' 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F. 2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. AAppropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.@ Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir.1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1497.
On the first day of hearing, the District outlined its proposal to remedy its conceded denial of FAPE. It proposed that a comprehensive reassessment be conducted to determine Student=s current academic and social emotional needs, and that the IEP team should determine an appropriate amount of compensatory education for Student in light of the reasssessment results. In response to Student’s Mother=s distrust of previous District assessments and her belief that the SAT-9 is the only reliable academic assessment, the District agreed to have the reassessment conducted by an independent assessor and to have the IEP team consider the results of the SAT-9 in determining compensatory education services when they became available.
Petitioner did not agree with the District=s proposed remedy. Rather, he requested compensatory services in the form of in-home tutoring, behavioral counseling, and/or, any other services and assistance that may be required to help him attain scores like those he had previously received on the standardized SAT 9 test. During the hearing, however, Student clearly testified that he did not want and would not use in-home tutoring. (Footnote 15) Petitioner provided no evidence of the type or amount of other compensatory education services that would be appropriate to remedy this denial of FAPE. In fact, Student’s Mother testified that, in her opinion, the harm done by the District to Student was irreparable. Following Student=s testimony, however, Student’s Mother argued that Student requires (1) an academic assessment to determine his current levels of performance and academic IEP goals, that should be considered in conjunction with his SAT 9 scores, (2) a comprehensive transcript review to determine the courses he requires for graduation, and to determine if he has sufficient credits to drop one class and use this school time for a tutorial, and (3) a tutor for one hour each school day to assist him with homework skills, daily projects, and to address his areas of academic weakness, using strategies designed to assist students with ADHD.
In the absence of any other evidence regarding compensatory remedies, the Hearing Officer finds that a comprehensive reassessment of Student must be conducted and that the IEP team shall determine the focus and amount of compensatory education services to be provided to Student for the denial of FAPE from January 5, 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year. The reassessment shall be conducted by an independent, licensed psychologist and this reassessment will constitute Student=s triennial reassessment. In addition to any other tests required for a triennial reassessment, the psychologist shall determine Student=s current areas of academic strength and weakness, and shall identify areas in which he would benefit from academic assistance and/or remediation. The reassessment shall specifically address methods or strategies that should be used to assist Student achieve long-term academic success in light of his ADHD and hearing loss. In light of Petitioner’s agreement to this process for determining a compensatory education remedy, parental consent is not required for this reassessment. Student’s Mother shall make Student reasonably available for this reassessment.
The Hearing Officer also concludes that, in addition to Student’s Mother, both Student and the psychologist who reassesses him shall be part of the IEP team that determines compensatory education. The Hearing Officer further finds that, in determining compensatory education to be awarded, the IEP team shall consider the results of and recommendations in the triennial reassessment, Student=s desires, and other information provided to the IEP team. Because of the time necessary to complete this process as outlined in the Orders below, it is unlikely that compensatory education services will commence during the 2003-2004 school year. Rather, for the remainder of this school year, the parties will be involved in the process of reassessment and determining compensatory education services for Student. Accordingly, the compensatory services shall be completed during the 2004-2005 school year. Finally, the Hearing Officer believes it is reasonable to expect that the IEP team and Petitioner can work together to ensure that Student graduates on time, at the same time that they consider Student’s interests as well as his compensatory education needs.
ORDER
1. Within ten (10) calendar days of the date of this Decision, if they have not already done so, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to do the following:
a. Prepare a Behavior Support Plan for Student to assist him in attending class, and in completing class and homework assignments. Student shall participate in the development of this plan.
b. Conduct a comprehensive review of Student’s transcript for the purpose of identifying credits earned to date, remaining credits and courses required for graduation, and determining whether it is feasible in light of this review to provide him with a separate class period for use in providing a study hall and/or compensatory education services.
2. Within ten (10) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall arrange for a comprehensive reassessment of Student by an independent licensed psychologist that shall constitute Student=s triennial reassessment. In addition to any other tests required for a triennial reassessment, the psychologist shall determine Student=s current areas of academic strength and weakness and shall identify areas in which he would benefit from academic assistance and/or remediation. The reassessment shall specifically address methods or strategies that should be used to assist Student to achieve long-term academic success in light of his ADHD and hearing loss. Parental consent is not required for this reassessment and Student’s Mother shall make Student reasonably available for the assessment.
3. Within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of this Decision, the independent reassessment and the report of the reassessment shall be completed.
4. Within five (5) calendar days of receipt of the independent reassessment report, the IEP team shall meet for the purpose of reviewing the reassessment and determining an appropriate type and amount of compensatory education for Student for the denial of FAPE from January 5, 2001 through the end of the 2001-2002 school year. In addition to Student’s Mother, both the psychologist who conducts the reassessment and Student shall participate in the IEP team=s determination of an appropriate type and amount of compensatory education services. In determining compensatory education to be awarded, the IEP team shall consider the results of and recommendations in the triennial reassessment report, Student=s desires, and other information provided to the IEP team.
5. Unless Petitioner agrees otherwise, compensatory education services recommended by the IEP team shall commence no later than ten (10) calendar days from the date of the IEP team meeting outlined in Order 4 and shall be completed during the 2004-2005 school year.
6. In all other respects, Petitioner=s requests are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code ' 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
On the First Issue: The Student prevailed.
On the Second Issue: The District prevailed.
On the Third Issue: The District substantially prevailed. On thee Fourth issue: Both the Student and the District prevailed in part.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code ' 56505(i).
Dated: April 2, 2004 ____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Petitioner has referred variously to his attention deficit disorder (ADD) and to his attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Because Student=s OHI designation was taken from the findings of ADHD in his February 2001 reassessment, that term will be used throughout the Decision. 2 At the February 9, 2004 prehearing conference, issues for the hearing were clarified to exclude those outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. See: February 12, 2004 Prehearing Conference Order. Throughout the hearing, however, Petitioner had to be reminded that these claims are not within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. Petitioner=s proposed Exhibits G 65-66, a claim against the District for personal injuries from 1992 to present, were excluded as not relevant to the issues for hearing. 3 In light of the ruling on the statute of limitations and for clarity of analysis, the issues have been restructured and reworded 4Student’s Mother challenged the District’s policy regarding student participation in graduation ceremonies and filed complaints with the California Departments of Education and Justice, and the Los Angeles Police Department. Student’s Mother alleged that Student was harassed and suffered retaliation from the District as a result of her complaints. Petitioner=s Ex. F 89-104, a transcript of a meeting regarding this policy, was excluded as irrelevant. 5On February 4, 2002, Student’s Mother signed an IEP form dated February 2, 2002, Aremoving@ Student from special education at her request and noting that Student=s current grade point average did not demonstrate a need for special education. The record does not establish that Student was formally exited from special education and there was no mention of this IEP document at the April 15, 2002 annual review. 6As indicated in prehearing motions, Montclair is not a certified nonpublic school. In July 2003, the District offered Student’s Mother four nonpublic schools, including North Hills, as potential NPS placements for the 2003-2004 school year. 7The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Petitioner did not raise any procedural violations for the current school year 8 In addition, Ms. Gwin testified that North Hills has a policy of assessing each of its students twice a year with the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT) basic skills math test and the Briggance reading test. She testified that North Hills has repeatedly tried to assess Student pursuant to this policy, but that on each of the monthly test dates, Student has been absent from school. 9 Mr. Louderback testified that Student is a good reader who can do his work in advanced physical science quickly and correctly Aif he is in the mood,@ and that he has a better sentence structure than most students. Ms. Gennis testified that Student has an ability to write from the heart, demonstrates maturity in comprehending complex characters and issues, and Aaced@ his vocabulary tests. 10 The testimony was in conflict regarding the percentage of students at North Hill identified as emotionally disturbed (ED). According to Ms. Gwin, fifty percent of the total student body is identified as ED. Mr. Friedman testified that approximately sixty-five percent of its population is identified as ED. 11 It was apparent throughout the hearing that Student’s Mother has a longstanding and passionate dislike of the District that appears to have tainted her perspective of North Hills, once her preferred placement for Student at Montclair was not available. Testimonial and documentary evidence established that Student’s Mother has had agitated encounters with several members of the North Hills staff, including its director Elin Bradley and Student=s therapist Mr. Friedman, and that Student has Aliterally begged@ her to Astay away from his school and to avoid all contact with his teachers, counselors, etc.@ Student’s Mother attributed Student=s request to his fear Athat he will be injured, [and]... continuously hassled...@ by school officials, Ausing the methods of child abusers.@ (Dist ex. 9). 12 In approximately April 2001, Student was placed on Ritalin for a period of several months, but he has not taken any medication for his ADHD since that time. On the October 23, 2003 IEP, Student’s Mother characterized Mr. Friedman as a “pro-drug, anti-behavioral therapist ... inappropriate for a non-medicated child.@ 13 Although Student’s Mother phrased this as a challenge to homework support, from her testimony it is apparent that her broader concern is whether North Hills meets Student=s unique need for assistance in organization, study skills, including class attendance and completion of class and homework assignments 14 Student testified that he would prefer a dual enrollment where he would complete his academic courses at North Hills and participate in sports on a comprehensive campus. Student also testified that he has been advised by the IEP team of the requirements for dual enrollment, which include consistently attending his classes. The decision regarding such an enrollment is one for Student=s IEP team. 15 He also strongly rejected the idea proposed by Ms. Gwin of a full time one-to-one aide.
