California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 3, 2005

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 00476R-03, SN-00476R-03 · Hearing Officer Christian P. Hurley

Los Angeles Unified must serve student as learning disabled from January 2004 and provide 138 compensatory hours plus reading-program reimbursement.

Split decision: student prevailed on 9 of 15 issues (7 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

This decision follows a remand. An earlier SEHO decision (August 14, 2003) found Student not eligible. Student sought review in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, filed November 12, 2003. On July 15, 2004, Judge Audrey B. Collins reversed the findings on severe discrepancy, processing disorder and correctability in general education. The court affirmed the denial of reimbursement for the pre-assessment 2002-2003 IEEs, remanded the case, and ordered new District assessments. The Hearing Officer issued a minute order for those assessments on August 3, 2004.

Summary

A third grader at Los Angeles Unified's Van Gogh Elementary had never been found eligible for special education. A 2003 SEHO decision found him not eligible. A federal district court reversed parts of that decision and sent the case back. The Hearing Officer then ordered new District assessments and held a second hearing. On remand, the Hearing Officer found that in 2002-2003 the student had severe gaps between his superior ability and his achievement in basic reading, reading comprehension and written expression. The gaps came from a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and a language-based reading disability. Because he was improving in general education that year, he was not yet eligible. By January 2004, however, his reading fluency was still below grade level despite a Section 504 plan, extra help and hours of parent tutoring at home. The District should have reassessed him and held an IEP meeting. From then on, he was eligible under specific learning disability. The District conceded speech or language impairment eligibility for 2004-2005. The Hearing Officer found the District's cognitive test inappropriate because it weighted language skills heavily. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 20 days and provide daily specialized reading instruction, twice-weekly 30-minute speech therapy and 2005 extended school year services. It must also provide 46 hours of compensatory speech therapy and 92 hours of compensatory reading instruction, and reimburse the summer 2004 Lindamood-Bell program. Requests for ongoing Lindamood-Bell, counseling and a private school were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied California's three-part test for specific learning disability on remand from federal court. It used the "snapshot" rule to judge each school year separately. A student who was progressing in general education was not yet eligible, but his continued lack of progress triggered child find duties. The decision also rejected a cognitive test that was weighted toward the student's impaired language skills.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Should Student have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

    On remand, severe discrepancies in basic reading, reading comprehension and written expression existed and were caused by a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and a language-based reading disability, but they were being corrected in general education, so Student was not eligible in 2002-2003.

  2. Student prevailed in partEligibility

    Issue 2. Should Student have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2003-2004 school year?

    By January 2004 the District knew or should have known the reading fluency discrepancy was not being corrected despite 504 accommodations and extra help; it should have reassessed and held an IEP meeting, and Student was eligible from January 2004. No attention disorder was found.

  3. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. Should Student have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2004-2005 school year?

    Using the WISC-IV score of 118 rather than the District's lower General Intellectual Ability score, Student had severe discrepancies in oral expression, written expression, basic reading, reading comprehension and fluency, caused by a disorder in expression, that general education was not correcting.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4(1). What programs or services does Student require to receive a FAPE for the remainder of 2004-2005: educational therapy

    Student did not explain or show a need for educational therapy.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4(2). What programs or services does Student require to receive a FAPE: reading specialist services

    Student needs daily specialized reading instruction in a small group with individual instruction by a special education teacher, plus reading support in other subjects. Lindamood-Bell is not required because methodology is left to the District.

  6. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4(3). What programs or services does Student require to receive a FAPE: speech and language therapy

    Student needs two 30-minute speech-language sessions per week, as the District therapist recommended, not two hours per week. The request that a nonpublic agency provide the therapy was denied.

  7. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 4(4). What programs or services does Student require to receive a FAPE: extended school year services

    Student needs 2005 ESY, including daily specialized reading instruction and two 30-minute speech-language sessions per week, to prevent serious regression.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4(5). What programs or services does Student require to receive a FAPE: psychological counseling

    Recent rating scales put anxiety in the average to mildly elevated range, and Student's attitude toward school was improving, so counseling was not needed.

  9. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4(6). What programs or services does Student require to receive a FAPE: placement in a small classroom with typical peers, intensive one-to-one teaching, and a focus on learning-disability strategies

    Under the Rachel H. factors, Student's needs can be met in regular classes with supplementary services and resource support. The specific placement was left to the IEP team, and a nonpublic school was not required.

  10. Issue 5A. Are Student and his parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained Lindamood-Bell programs?

    FAPE was denied from January 2004, so the summer 2004 Lindamood-Bell program and mileage are reimbursable. The summer 2003 and December 2003 programs predate eligibility and are not.

  11. Issue 5B. Are Student and his parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations?

    The December 2003/February 2004 evaluation (April 2004 report) came before the District's 2004 assessments and is not reimbursable. The December 2004 WISC-IV is reimbursable because the District's General Intellectual Ability test was inappropriate for a student with language processing deficits.

  12. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5C(1). Compensatory education in the form of educational therapy

    No evidence was offered about what educational therapy would involve or why it was needed.

  13. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5C(2). Compensatory education in the form of speech and language (language) therapy

    Awarded 46 hours (one hour per week for about 46 school weeks since January 2004) rather than the 200 hours requested.

  14. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5C(3). Compensatory education in the form of reading specialist services

    Awarded 92 hours of specialized reading instruction by a credentialed special education teacher, taking into account the reimbursed 64 hours of summer 2004 Lindamood-Bell. Compensatory Lindamood-Bell services were denied.

  15. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5C(4). Compensatory education in the form of psychological counseling services

    There was no persuasive evidence that counseling was needed at any time since January 2004.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop an IEP for the rest of 2004-2005, with a specific placement offer that considers Student's specific learning disability, speech and language impairment, and deficits in reading, written expression and oral expression. The team must seriously consider keeping Student at Van Gogh Elementary (34 C.F.R. § 300.552(c)).
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include daily specialized reading instruction addressing reading fluency, phonemic awareness and decoding; reading support in other subjects that involve reading; and speech-language therapy twice a week, 30 minutes per session.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include an ESY program (2005) with daily specialized reading instruction and speech-language therapy twice a week, 30 minutes per session.
  • Compensatory education. 46 hours of compensatory speech-language therapy, to be completed by the end of the 2006 ESY. The IEP team decides the delivery method.
  • Compensatory education. 92 hours of compensatory specialized reading instruction by a credentialed special education teacher, addressing reading fluency, phonemic awareness and decoding, to be completed by the end of the 2006 ESY. The IEP team decides how to fit it into Student's schedule.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving proof of payment, the District must reimburse the parents for the summer 2004 Lindamood-Bell program (64 hours), plus mileage at the District rate. No dollar amount is stated.
  • IEE at public expense. The decision's conclusions and prevailing-party section award reimbursement for Dr. Humphrey's December 2004 WISC-IV cognitive assessment. However, this item does not appear in the numbered Order. No amount is stated.

Total: 138 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Todd v. Andrews; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist.; Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B v. Milford Board of Education; Student v. Monterey Peninsula School District (SEHO SN02-02753); Student v. San Dieguito Union High School District (SEHO SN02-01363); Student v. Redlands Unified School District (SEHO SN03-00953)

People named in the decision

  • N. Jane Dubovy, attorney for Student
  • Carrie Watts, advocate for Student
  • Erin Brown, educational advocate for Student
  • Barrett Green, attorney for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Barbara Dixon, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Lorie Humphrey, Ph.D., private neuropsychologist; expert witness for Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute; private practice
  • Michael Pobanz, Ph.D., school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Gail Hallenberg, speech and language therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Pam Flait, third-grade teacher, Van Gogh Elementary School
  • Karen Arsenault, third-grade teacher, Van Gogh Elementary School
  • Niki Jakins, clinical director, nonpublic agency, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center
  • Alnita Rettig Dunn, Ph.D., psychological services coordinator / school psychologist; expert witness for District, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Candace Bowen, second-grade teacher (called by Hearing Officer), Van Gogh Elementary School
  • Virginia Williams, school psychologist (2001 assessment), El Oro Way Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • V. Silver, resource specialist (2001 assessment), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Linda Joslin, school psychologist (2002 assessment), Van Gogh Elementary School
  • Linda Hirsch, resource specialist (2002 achievement testing), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Rita Eichenstein, Ph.D., independent neuropsychological-educational evaluator
  • Trang Nguyen, optometrist; independent functional vision assessment
  • Dave Harbeson, associate clinic director, nonpublic agency, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center
  • Denise Hogrefe, occupational therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Paula Himmelstein, first-grade teacher, Van Gogh Elementary School
  • Hope Watterson, first-grade teacher, Van Gogh Elementary School
  • Lisa Marlow, kindergarten teacher, North Valley Jewish Community Center
  • Audrey B. Collins, U.S. District Judge who issued remand order, U.S. District Court, Central District of California

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Christian Hurley, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. The matter proceeded to hearing in Los Angeles, California, on December 14-16, 2004.

STUDENT (Student) was represented by attorney N. Jane Dubovy and advocate Carrie Watts. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. STUDENT’s father, FATHER, and Erin Brown, educational advocate, also attended portions of the hearing. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Barrett Green. Barbara Dixon, due process specialist for the District, was also present on behalf of the District during portions of the hearing.

The Student called the following witnesses: Lorie Humphrey, Ph.D., private psychologist; STUDENT; MOTHER, his mother; Dr. Michael Pobanz, school psychologist for the District; Gail Hallenberg, District speech and language therapist; Pam Flait and Karen Aresnault, his third-grade teachers; and Niki Jakins, clinical director for Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, a certified nonpublic agency. The District called the following witness: Alnita Rettig Dunn, Ph.D., school psychologist. The Hearing Officer called Candice Bowen, STUDENT’s second-grade teacher.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

2. Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2003-2004 school year?

3. Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2004-2005 school year?

4. If STUDENT is eligible for special education, what programs or services does he require to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year?

5. Are STUDENT and his parents entitled to remedies in the form of reimbursement for privately obtained Lindamood-Bell programs and independent educational evaluations, and compensatory education in the form of educational therapy, language therapy, reading specialist services, and psychological counseling services?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

The first hearing in this case took place on June 19, 20, 24, 25, 26, and 27, 2003. The Hearing Officer issued a written decision on August 14, 2003, in which he found that STUDENT had not been eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year. The Hearing Officer also found that the District failed to assess STUDENT in the areas of language processing and phonological processing and failed to consider independent educational evaluations obtained by STUDENT’s parents at two IEP meetings in February and June 2004. Finally, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT’s parents were entitled to reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) obtained by them in May of 2003 but were not entitled to reimbursement for IEEs obtained in December 2002 and January 2003 because his parents had not yet received the District’s assessment results and therefore could not have disagreed with those assessments prior to obtaining the IEEs.

On November 12, 2003, Student filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the Central District of California, requesting judicial review of the Hearing Officer’s decision. On June 14, 2004, Student and the District filed cross-motions for summary judgment. On July 15, 2004, Judge Audrey B. Collins issued an order reversing portions of the Hearing Officer’s decision and remanding this matter to the Hearing Office for further proceedings.

The Court reversed the Hearing Officer’s determination that severe discrepancies between ability and achievement existed in the areas of reading comprehension, basic reading skills, and written expression. The Court also reversed the Hearing Officer’s determination that the severe discrepancies were not caused by a disorder in a basic psychological process, and the Hearing Officer’s conclusion that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies could be corrected within the regular instructional program. The Court found that the Hearing Officer correctly denied reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents for assessments obtained prior to the receipt of the results of the District’s 2002 assessments.

Finally, the Court remanded this matter for further consideration of STUDENT’s eligibility for special education under the category of specific learning disability and specifically of the three requisite elements to determining eligibility: the existence of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement, the existence of a processing disorder in a basic psychological process that is causing the severe discrepancy, and the inability to correct the discrepancy in the regular education environment. The Court ordered the Hearing Officer to instruct the District to perform new assessments in all areas of suspected disability, including assessments in the areas of reading comprehension, basic reading skills, written expression, language processing, and phonological processing.

On August 3, 2004, the Hearing Officer issued a minute order directing the District to conduct assessments in all areas of suspected disability. In September 2004, the District school psychologist and speech and language therapist completed a psychoeducational assessment and speech and language assessment of STUDENT. On December 13, 2004, a telephonic prehearing conference was held in this matter. During the prehearing conference, Student confirmed that he was adding additional issues concerning his eligibility for special education during the 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 school years, as well as reimbursement and compensatory education claims related to these additional school years.

CONTENTIONS

Student contends that he is currently eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability and was also eligible for special education under this category for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years. He contends that severe discrepancies exist between his ability and achievement in several academic areas, including the following: basic reading skills, reading comprehension, written expression, and oral expression. Student claims that these discrepancies are due to a disorder in the basic psychological process of the cognitive ability of expression, specifically his ability to retrieve information from his memory and convey this information verbally and in writing. (Footnote 1) With regard to the 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 school years, Student contends that the discrepancies are also due to a disorder in the psychological process of attention. Student further contends that these discrepancies cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. Finally, Student seeks remedies in the form of reimbursement for independent psychological assessments and Lindamood-Bell reading remediation programs, an award of compensatory education in the form of educational therapy, language therapy, reading specialist services, and psychological counseling services, and prospective relief in the form of educational therapy, reading specialist services, language therapy, extended school year services, psychological counseling, and prospective placement in a small classroom with typical peers, opportunities for intensive one-to-one teaching, and a focus on strategies for students with learning disorders.

The District contends that STUDENT is not currently eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability but is eligible for special education during the 2004-2005 school year as a student with a speech and language impairment. The District contends that STUDENT was not eligible for special education during the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years. Specifically, the District argues that a severe discrepancy did not exist in any of the academic areas identified in California Education Code section 56337(a), that Student does not have a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes set forth in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(j)(1), and that even if a severe discrepancy existed, it was and is being corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. The District further contends that it appropriately assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and that STUDENT and his parents are not entitled to reimbursement, compensatory education, or prospective relief.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a nine-year-old boy who has never been identified as eligible for special education. He is currently in the third grade at the District’s Van Gogh Elementary School (Van Gogh). STUDENT resides with his parents, MOTHER and FATHER, and an older brother. STUDENT’s medical history is significant for grade one bleeding in the brain at birth, enlarged subdural and ventrical cavities in the brain, and viral meningitis with a high fever at age two and one-half, which required hospitalization.

STUDENT attended the North Valley Jewish Community Center (JCC) from ages two through six. At age three, STUDENT was attending nursery school at the JCC when a gunman entered the building and began to shoot at adults and children. Several people were killed. During the shooting incident, STUDENT hid with his classmates and teacher in a closet in his classroom.

In the fall of 2001, STUDENT’s parents requested that STUDENT be assessed out of concern that he was experiencing difficulty retaining new information he was learning at school. At this time, STUDENT was attending kindergarten at the JCC.

The District’s psychoeducational assessment was conducted in October 2001 by Virginia Williams, school psychologist for El Oro Way Elementary School, and V. Silver, resource specialist. The Matrix Analogies Test (MAT) was used to measure STUDENT’s cognitive ability. It produced a standard score of 96, placing STUDENT in the 39th percentile. The Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R) and the Wide Range Achievement Test-Third Edition (WRAT-III) were administered to measure STUDENT’s levels of achievement. On the WJ-R, STUDENT received the following scores:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 100 49 Oral Expression 96 40 Picture Vocabulary 79 8 Listening Comprehension 102 56 Letter-Word Identification 95 37 Story Recall 109 74 Understanding Directions 109 72 Applied Problems 98 45 Picture Vocabulary 92 30 Oral Comprehension 97 42 Qualitative Concepts 90 25 Passage Comprehension 85 16 Spelling 83 13 Math Reasoning 93 33 Quantitative Concepts 90 25

On the WRAT-III, STUDENT received a standard score of 84 in reading, placing him in the average to low average range; a score of 93 in spelling, placing him in the low average range; and a score of 96 in arithmetic, placing him in the average range. To measure STUDENT’s motor skills, Ms. Williams administered the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test (Bender), a paper and pencil task wherein he was required to copy nine designs. The Bender yielded results in the average range and ranked him at the 50th percentile. To measure STUDENT’s auditory and visual perception, Ms. Williams administered the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R) and the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TVPS-R). STUDENT’s performance on the TAPS-R in auditory memory placed him well above the average range. Overall, his auditory perceptual skills were in the high average range. His fund of general knowledge was low average. On the TVPS-R, a non-motor test of visual perception, STUDENT’s performance fell in the below average range. His visual memory was in the average range. These assessors concluded that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability because he was performing in at least the average range. MOTHER testified at hearing that she did not want an IEP meeting to be held following the assessment by Ms. Williams because she was concerned about the ramifications of STUDENT being labeled as learning disabled.

STUDENT’s kindergarten progress report for the 2001-2002 school year is unremarkable. He received grades of “very good” in all areas, including academic development, oral expression, pre-reading/reading/language skills, science, and social studies, with the exception of “meets new challenges with confidence” on which STUDENT received a mark of “good.”

In the fall of 2002, when STUDENT was beginning the first grade at Van Gogh, FATHER and MOTHER requested a second psychoeducational assessment. On September 13, 2002, the District prepared a Special Education Assessment Plan for STUDENT. On September 19, 2002, MOTHER signed the assessment plan, indicating her consent to assess STUDENT. MOTHER also indicated on the assessment plan that she and her husband were in the process of obtaining an independent assessment. The assessment plan indicates that the District received it on October 7, 2002, and that the last date to hold the individualized education program (IEP) meeting was November 25, 2002.

In October 2002, MOTHER requested an IEP meeting. On October 22, 2002, the IEP team met to review the results of the psychoeducational assessment conducted by Virginia Williams in 2001 and to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. (Footnote 2) The District members of the IEP team concluded, based upon the October 2001 assessment information, that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. Specifically, they concluded that there was no evidence of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement and that there was no evidence of a processing disorder. The IEP team agreed that new assessments would be conducted pursuant to the assessment plan approved by MOTHER in September.

On October 22 and 29, 2002, Linda Joslin, school psychologist for Van Gogh Elementary, conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the assessment plan developed in September. Ms. Joslin administered the Cognitive Assessment System (CAS) to measure his cognitive processing ability. STUDENT obtained a full scale score of 121 on the CAS, which fell within the superior range. To measure STUDENT’s academic achievement, Linda Hirsch, the District’s resource specialist, administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-Third Edition (WJ-III), Form A. On the WJ-III, STUDENT received the following scores:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 105 63 Total Achievement 96 40 Broad Reading 91 28 Broad Math 111 77 Broad Written Language 95 37 Math Calculation Skills 115 85 Written Expression 94 34 Academic Skills 102 56 Academic Fluency 94 34 Academic Applications 93 32 Letter-Word Identification 99 48 Reading Fluency 91 26 Story Recall 107 69 Understanding Directions 104 60 Calculation 116 86 Math Fluency 105 64 Spelling 97 42 Writing Fluency 96 39 Passage Comprehension 86 17 Applied Problems 104 60 Writing Samples 95 37

Ms. Joslin also administered the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R), the Motor-Free Visual Perception Test-Revised (MVPT-R), the Bender, the Sentence Completion Test, and Draw-A-Person. STUDENT’s auditory perceptual skills on the TAPS-R were within normal limits, as were his visual perceptual skills as measured by the MVPT-R and his perceptual motor skills as measured by the Bender. In her report, Ms. Joslin drew the following conclusions:

There is evidence of a severe discrepancy between his ability and his achievement in reading and written expression based upon standardized test scores. However, STUDENT’s total achievement score is within grade level and his teachers state that he is at grade level in all academic areas and they do not note any difficulties in his academic performance.

On December 20, 2002, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent neuropsychological-educational evaluation of STUDENT by Rita Eichenstein, Ph.D. At this time, STUDENT was seven years old. Dr. Eichenstein administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scales for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III) to assess STUDENT’s cognitive ability. STUDENT received the following intelligence quotient (IQ) standard scores on the WISC-III:

Verbal IQ 117 Performance IQ 119 Full Scale IQ 120

Dr. Eichenstein administered the WJ-III, Form A, to assess STUDENT’s academic achievement. (Footnote 3) STUDENT received the following scores on the WJ-III:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 115 85 Basic Reading Skills 114 82 Academic Skills 106 67 Academic Applications 109 72 Phon/Graph Knowledge 106 66 Letter-Word Identification 107 67 Story Recall 114 82 Understanding Directions 112 79 Calculation 125 95 Math Fluency 105 64 Spelling 89 23 Passage Comprehension 104 60 Applied Problems 116 86 Writing Samples 103 59 Word Attack 118 88 Spelling of Sounds 83 13 Sound Awareness 110 75

Dr. Eichenstein also administered the McCarthy Scales of Children’s Abilities (selected subtests), the Bender, the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), the Wide Range Assessment of Visual Motor Abilities (WRAVMA), the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP), the Grey Oral Reading Test-Fourth Edition (GORT-4), Test of Variabilities of Attention-Visual (TOVA-V), Conners’ Parent Rating Scale-Revised, Barkley ADHD Structured Interview, NEPSY: A Developmental Neuropsychological Assessment: Selected Subtests, the Brief Rating Inventory of Executive Function, Wisconsin Card Sorting-64, the Quick Neurological Screening Test, the Test of Visual Perceptual Skills-Revised (TVPS-R), Children’s Apperception Test (CAT), the Children’s Anxiety Test (RCMAS), House-Tree-Person, and the Piers-Harris Children’s Self Concept Scale.

On the Grey Oral Reading Test, which measures reading fluency and comprehension, STUDENT’s reading rate, accuracy, and fluency scores were all at the pre-kindergarten level and his comprehension score was at the kindergarten level. On the CTOPP, STUDENT received the following scores:

Subtest Age Equiv. Percentile Stand. Score

Ellision 14.9 99 18 Blending Words 7.9 63 11 Memory for Digits 14.9 98 16 Rapid Digit Naming 6.6 25 8 Nonword Repetition 7.6 50 10 Rapid Letter Naming 6.9 37 9 Rapid Color Naming 5.6 16 7 Phoneme Reversal 5.9 16 7 Rapid Object Naming 5.6 9 6 Blending Nonwords 8.9 50 10

According to Dr. Eichenstein’s report, STUDENT’s high scores in Ellision, Memory for Digits, and Blending Nonwords demonstrated his “extremely strong skills in auditory to verbal processing.” STUDENT’s much lower scores in the tasks of Rapid Color Naming, Rapid Object Naming, and the Phoneme Reversal Task indicated that he was significantly weaker in visual to verbal processing and his complex working memory for phonemic identification. According to Dr. Eichenstein’s report, STUDENT’s significant weakness in using and organizing language rapidly and his weakness in phonemic reversal suggested a language based reading disability. In other words, his ability to access this information visually and link the visual to verbal processing of phonemic information was impaired.

On the WRAML, STUDENT’s memory function was in the average to above average range with the exceptions of the Picture Memory and Sound Symbol subtests, on which STUDENT scored in the low range. According to Dr. Eichenstein, this suggested a short-term memory deficit involving symbol to sound issues, i.e., the pairing of a visual symbol to an auditory sound. Her report stated that weak sound-symbol issues are linked to reading difficulties. Dr. Eichenstein concluded that this was a visual processing impairment which presented as a memory weakness.

Dr. Eichenstein found that STUDENT scored in the superior range of cognitive abilities. She noted that STUDENT displayed “superior to gifted abilities in his non-verbal problem solving abilities, his ability in complex verbal analytic reasoning and higher order critical thinking skills.” Dr. Eichenstein described STUDENT as “significantly weaker in his visual attention to detail, visual discrimination, visual sequencing.” She noted that these weaknesses can be an underlying component of a reading difficulty. With regard to tests of academic achievement, Dr. Eichenstein found that STUDENT scored significantly above grade level in most areas of academics that were not related to reading, writing, or spelling. By contrast, she noted that STUDENT displayed a relatively weak cluster of reading related skills. She stated that his significantly weak areas were in visual to verbal processing, auditory complex working memory, and verbal fluency for focused access of lexicon. She noted that “[t]hese weak areas are indicative of a visual to language based disability which compromises reading and writing mastery.” Dr. Eichenstein diagnosed STUDENT with a reading disorder and generalized anxiety disorder secondary to posttraumatic stress syndrome. Her recommendations included an intensive and structured reading remediation program such as the Lindamood Bell system to increase his reading fluency. According to Dr. Eichenstein, such a program would assist STUDENT in grapheme phoneme development and would stimulate his visual memory and sight word recognition. In her report, Dr. Eichenstein also recommended further investigation of STUDENT’s visual abilities, specifically visual tracking, visual discrimination, visual matching, visual attending, and all areas of eye movement skills, eye focusing skills, and eye teaming skills. She suggested that STUDENT might benefit from a developmental optometry exam to rule out visual dysfunctions. Finally, she recommended that STUDENT receive psychotherapy to address anxiety caused by the events at the JCC when he was in nursery school.

On January 18, 2003, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent functional visual assessment of STUDENT by optometrist Trang Nguyen. According to Dr. Nguyen’s report, the assessment covered STUDENT’s visual intake skills, visual perception, eye health, eye movement skills, eye teaming skills, visual motor organization skills, visual motor skills, and visual motor integration. He also screened STUDENT for visual dyslexia. In his report dated January 19, 2003, Dr. Nguyen concluded that STUDENT had excellent visual intake skills, good accommodative focusing skills, normal color vision, and good peripheral vision. Dr. Nguyen noted weaknesses in STUDENT’s visual tracking skills and visual perception skills, including reduced tracking speed. Dr. Nguyen went on to state: “As a result, STUDENT may have difficulty completing his classroom assignments on time, difficulty copying from the board efficiently, and difficulty transferring answers from his textbooks onto worksheets.” Dr. Nguyen also noted that STUDENT demonstrated weak visual memory and visual figure ground skills. According to Dr. Nguyen’s report, these visual perception skills can impact overall academic performance: “Because STUDENT has difficulty visually remembering patterns or words, he may have difficulty recognizing words based on visual recall.” Dr. Nguyen recommended home vision therapy activities to improve STUDENT’s speed of tracking to age appropriate levels. Dr. Nguyen also performed a visual dyslexia screening. This testing evaluates one’s ability to visually recognize and decode words. The results of this test revealed that STUDENT had difficulty visually recognizing whole words. According to Dr. Nguyen, STUDENT tended to decode each word, making reading slow and laborious. Dr. Nguyen recommended that STUDENT be assessed by a reading specialist to rule out dyseidetic dyslexia and to provide educational treatment recommendations.

The IEP team reconvened on February 25, 2003, to review the results of the psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT conducted by school psychologist Linda Joslin, the neuropsychological-educational assessment conducted by Dr. Eichenstein, and the functional vision assessment by Dr. Nguyen. (Footnote 4) The District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. Under the section entitled “Reason(s),” the IEP document states as follows: “There is a severe discrepancy between his ability and his achievement. However, his weakness in visual processing do not appear to be adversely impeting [sic] on his academic achievement & classroom performance in meeting standards and accessing the curriculum.” The IEP team indicated its intent to develop a 504 plan, pursuant to section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, with accommodations that would assist STUDENT in continuing to access his reading and language arts program and address his need for additional time for comprehension tasks and test taking situations.

On March 10, 2003, the Hearing Office received a written request for a due process hearing from MOTHER. On March 18, 2003, the matter was taken off calendar at the request of the parties to accommodate their pending mediation.

On May 6, 2003, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent assessment of STUDENT by Lorie Humphrey, Ph.D, a private psychologist. To assess STUDENT’s language functioning, Dr. Humphrey administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Third Edition (CELF-III), the Picture Vocabulary subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement, and the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities. She also administered the Children’s Memory Scale and two measures of visuoconstruction, the Beery Visual Motor Integration (Beery) and the Rey-Osterrieth. Based on the results of this testing and her review of prior assessments, Dr. Humphrey diagnosed STUDENT with a reading disability, learning disorder, expressive language disorder, and posttraumatic stress disorder.

On June 3, 2003, the IEP team reconvened to consider Dr. Humphrey’s report and to discuss STUDENT’s progress in school. The IEP document indicates that District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was still able to access the curriculum. According to the IEP document, the IEP team also discussed STUDENT’s auditory comprehension problems in relation to his reading and phonic skills and stated its intent to request a speech and language assessment to investigate possible central auditory processing disorders. Finally, the IEP team discussed the 504 plan for STUDENT. The 504 plan indicates that STUDENT had a mental disability in retrieval and that this disability impaired his pacing during reading and writing tasks. The 504 plan called for extended time on tests and assignments, preview of text, a quiet room to finish work, a seat close to the teacher, directions to be repeated as needed, and verbal prompts of sound patterns.

The first due process hearing in this case took place on June 19, 20, 24, 25, 26, and 27, 2003.

During July and August 2003, STUDENT’s parents placed him in an eighty-hour Lindamood-Bell program called “Seeing Stars” which focused on strengthening phonemic awareness and symbol imagery to allow STUDENT to use visual imagery to read words in isolation, build his sight word vocabulary, and read a page in context.

On August 14, 2003, the Hearing Officer issued a written decision finding that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. On November 12, 2003, Student filed a complaint in the United States Court for the Central District of California, requesting judicial review of the Hearing Officer’s decision.

In December 2003, STUDENT’s parents obtained an additional forty-eight hours of Lindamood-Bell (LMB) reading remediation services for him. In treatment recommendation memos dated December 22, 2003, Dave Harbeson, associate clinic director of LMB, stated that a diagnostic evaluation indicated a weakness in concept imagery, described as the ability to create a visual whole from oral or written language, which contributed to associated weaknesses in comprehending and expressing oral and written language, problem solving, and following oral directions. He further stated that a diagnostic evaluation indicated a weakness in phonemic awareness/symbol imagery, described as the ability to auditorily perceive and visually image the identity, number, and sequence of sounds and letters within words. According to Mr. Harbeson, this difficulty in sensory-cognitive processing contributed to weaknesses in word attack, word recognition, contextual reading fluency, and spelling. Mr. Harbeson recommended that STUDENT receive intensive sensory-cognitive training (four hours daily) for a minimum of eighty to one hundred hours.

On April 30, 2004, Dr. Humphrey issued her report regarding her second neuropsychological examination of STUDENT, which had been obtained by his parents in December 2003 and February 2004. For this examination, Dr. Humphrey administered the Beery, the Child Behavior Checklist, Connors Continuous Performance Test-Second Edition (CCPT-II), the Conners’ Parent Rating Scale-Revised, the NEPSY, the WJ-III Tests of Achievement and selected tests of cognition, and the WISC-IV Coding and Symbol Search.

Dr. Humphrey found that STUDENT’s scores were lower on tests in which speed was required for academic tasks, especially those with reading and naming components, and that he demonstrated relative difficulties on language tests from the WJ-III, such as Oral Language, Oral Expression, and Listening Comprehension. He also demonstrated lower than expected scores on the Broad Reading cluster and reading subtests such as Meaning of Sentences and Reading Fluency. She also found that he had inattention issues based upon the results of the CCPT-II, the NEPSY, and the Conners’.

On June 28, 2004, STUDENT’s parents obtained for him sixty-four additional hours of LMB reading remediation services which ended on August 24, 2004.

On July 15, 2004, Judge Audrey B. Collins issued an order reversing portions of the Hearing Officer’s decision and remanding this matter to the Hearing Office for further proceedings. Noting that the 2002 assessment results are now significantly out of date, the Court also ordered the Hearing Officer to instruct the District to perform new assessments in all areas of suspected disability, including assessments in the areas of reading comprehension, basic reading skills, written expression, language processing, and phonological processing. On August 3, 2004, the Hearing Officer issued a minute order directing the District to conduct assessments in all areas of suspected disability.

In September 2004, Michael Pobanz, Ph.D., a District school psychologist, conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT pursuant to the orders issued by the Court and the Hearing Officer. Dr. Pobanz administered the following assessments: the Connor’s Parent Rating Scale, the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities and Tests of Achievement, the Test of Memory and Learning (TOMAL), and the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP). In his report, Dr. Pobanz stated that two factors are affecting STUDENT’s learning: (1) his language deficit, including word retrieval from lexicon, multiple meanings, and word associations; and (2) his consequent difficulty in fluency in reading and writing. According to Dr. Pobanz, STUDENT does not exhibit a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the academic areas delineated by Education Code section 56337(a): oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, and mathematics reasoning. Dr. Pobanz found that STUDENT does exhibit a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of broad reading, broad writing, and academic knowledge, which are not areas specifically identified in section 56337(a). He indicates that these discrepancies appear to be due to language processing deficits in retrieval of vocabulary/lexicon and that STUDENT appears to qualify for special education services under the eligibility category of speech and language impairment. He concludes that STUDENT would benefit from instruction that helps him compensate for his word-finding deficits, such as engaging in word association activities, putting words in categories, naming categories for words, and improving his skills in the area of words with multiple meanings. He also recommended that STUDENT be given extra time to process language, read texts, and complete spelling and writing assignments.

Also, in September 2004, Gail Hallenberg, the District’s speech and language therapist, conducted a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT pursuant to the orders issued by the Court and the Hearing Officer. She administered the following assessments: Oral and Written Language Scales (OWLS), the CELF-3, the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT), the Language Processing Test-Revised, and the Language Sample/Informal Assessment. In her report dated October 22, 2004, she notes that STUDENT’s overall performance on formal standardized assessments is inconsistent, with subtest scores ranging from the 5th percentile to the 98th percentile. STUDENT received scores greater than 1.5 standard deviations below the mean on two subtests of the Language Processing Test, and a score that is significantly below average on the Rapid Automatic Naming subtest of the CELF. Ms. Hallenberg also stated that the extended time STUDENT required during testing to complete the required items should be considered. She found that STUDENT meets the requirements for eligibility for special education under the category of speech or language impairment-language disorder and stated that STUDENT may benefit from therapy that focuses on teaching and practicing strategies he can use to compensate for his word-finding deficits and should work to improve his skills in the area of multiple meanings.

In September and October 2004, Denise Hogrefe, the District’s occupational therapist, conducted an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Hogrefe assessed STUDENT in the following areas related to occupational therapy: neuromuscular system, organization of behavior, sensory processing, tactile system, proprioceptive system, vestibular system, praxis, fine motor skills, and visual motor skills. In her report, she found that STUDENT demonstrated many areas of strength, including his neuromuscular system, sensory processing, and praxis skills. She found that STUDENT did not demonstrate any areas of need related to occupational therapy and concluded that he does not require occupational therapy services at this time.

On or about November 23, 2004, counsel for the District sent correspondence to STUDENT’s counsel indicating the District’s desire to convene an IEP meeting to review the assessments and evaluate eligibility and service issues. No evidence was presented at hearing as to the Student’s response to this invitation or whether an IEP meeting was held. On December 4, 2004, Dr. Humphrey administered the WISC-IV. According to Dr. Humphrey’s report, STUDENT received a full scale cognitive score of 118. In her report, Dr. Humphrey states that although this score is 2 points lower than STUDENT’s full scale score on the WISC-III administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002, the 118 score is statistically unchanged from the prior testing because it falls within the potential range of error for the full scale score.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) A child with a disability, including a specific learning disability, is one who by reason of that disability needs instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a), (b).) In this case, Student asserts that he was eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability.

The IDEA defines “specific learning disability” as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, written or spoken, which disorder may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations.” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(26).) California Education Code section 56337 sets forth the following three requirements that must be met to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:

(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas:

(1) Oral expression;

(2) Listening comprehension;

(3) Written expression;

(4) Basic reading skills;

(5) Reading comprehension;

(6) Mathematics calculation;

(7) Mathematics reasoning.

(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.

(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

Pursuant to section 56337(c), the existence of a severe discrepancy alone is not sufficient to qualify a student as eligible for special education due to an SLD. Rather, the local educational agency must also be unable to remediate the student’s severe discrepancy within the regular educational program.

In judging whether the District properly determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability for the 2002-2003 school year, the District can only be held to account for the information it knew or should have known at the time of its determination. (See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)).)

Addressing each subsection of section 56337, the Hearing Officer finds as follows:

(a) Severe Discrepancy Between Intellectual Ability and Achievement

A severe discrepancy can be established either through a formula using standardized tests (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A)), by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(B)), or through a determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(C).)

When standardized tests are considered valid, a severe discrepancy is established by the following:

[F]irst, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A).)

The calculation of this formula has commonly involved interpreting the required difference for a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement standard scores to be at least 22.5 points (1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of 15), plus or minus 4 points, which is one standard error of measurement. The computed difference constitutes a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data, which may include other tests, scales, instruments, and work samples, as appropriate. (Id.)

In the present case, there was no allegation or evidence that standardized tests were invalid in measuring STUDENT’s ability or achievement. Therefore, to determine if a severe discrepancy existed, STUDENT’s scores on standardized intellectual testing could have been compared with his scores on achievement testing.

In his first decision in this case, the Hearing Officer determined that severe discrepancies between ability and achievement existed in the areas of reading comprehension, basic reading skills, and written expression. The Court reversed this determination, finding that the Hearing Officer improperly relied upon the practice effect in concluding that the December 2002 test results did not accurately represent STUDENT’s levels of achievement. The Court further found that the Hearing Officer failed to address the consequences of the District’s incomplete assessment of STUDENT and that this rendered his decision as to STUDENT’s severe discrepancies incomplete. The Court ordered the Hearing Officer to instruct the District to perform new assessments in all areas of suspected disability, including assessments in the areas of reading comprehension, basic reading skills, written expression, language processing, and phonological processing.

Cognitive Ability

In the first decision, the Hearing Officer utilized STUDENT’s full scale score of 121 on the CAS administered by the District in October 2002 to compare his cognitive ability to his academic achievement for purposes of determining the existence of a severe discrepancy for the 2002-2003 school year. Because the use of this score by the Hearing Officer was not disturbed by the Court in its order, the Hearing Officer will again utilize this score as the measure of STUDENT’s cognitive ability.

Academic Achievement

Pursuant to the Court’s order, the Hearing Officer must reexamine the evidence to determine which set of scores on the WJ-III Tests of Achievement represent the best measure of STUDENT’s academic achievement: the scores from the WJ-III administered in October 2002 or the scores from the WJ-III administered in December 2002.

On the WJ-III administered by the District in October 2002, STUDENT received the following scores: Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 105 63 Total Achievement 96 40 Broad Reading 91 28 Broad Math 111 77 Broad Written Language 95 37 Math Calculation Skills 115 85 Written Expression 94 34 Academic Skills 102 56 Academic Fluency 94 34 Academic Applications 93 32 Letter-Word Identification 99 48 Reading Fluency 91 26 Story Recall 107 69 Understanding Directions 104 60 Calculation 116 86 Math Fluency 105 64 Spelling 97 42 Writing Fluency 96 39 Passage Comprehension 86 17 Applied Problems 104 60 Writing Samples 95 37

STUDENT received the following scores on the WJ-III administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 115 85 Basic Reading Skills 114 82 Academic Skills 106 67 Academic Applications 109 72 Phon/Graph Knowledge 106 66 Letter-Word Identification 107 67 Story Recall 114 82 Understanding Directions 112 79 Calculation 125 95 Math Fluency 105 64 Spelling 89 23 Passage Comprehension 104 60 Applied Problems 116 86 Writing Samples 103 59 Word Attack 118 88 Spelling of Sounds 83 13 Sound Awareness 110 75

Dr. Lorie Humphrey and Dr. Alnita Dunn both provided testimony with regard to the validity and reliability of the 2002 achievement scores. Dr. Humphrey is a neuropsychologist at the Neuropsychiatric Institute and Hospital at UCLA, where she has been an assistant clinical professor since 1997. She has also maintained a private practice for the past eight years that includes neuropsychological assessments and psychotherapy. Dr. Alnita Dunn has been the psychological services coordinator for the District since 1999. In that capacity, she supervises all of the District’s school psychologists. From 1981 to 1997, she was a school psychologist with the District and in that capacity administered educational assessments to District students.

Both Dr. Humphrey and Dr. Dunn testified that with some types of assessments, the student can elevate his or her score if he or she takes the test again shortly after the first administration, because the student is familiar with the test. This is referred to as a practice effect. Dr. Humphey testified that the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC), a cognitive ability assessment, is one such test and that this test should not be given more than once a year. Dr. Humphrey testified that certain types of tasks on assessments are vulnerable to practice effects, such as Object Assembly, which is a performance subtest on the WISC, because students remember how the puzzle is put together and can do it faster the second time. Dr. Dunn also testified that practice effects occur more often with cognitive ability tests than with achievment tests. She testified that the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement have fewer problems with practice effect because the student is not provided the answers after testing and does not know if his or her prior answers were correct. Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT has some stress around school and concluded that the improvement in STUDENT’s scores between the October 2002 and December 2002 administrations of the WJ-III may have been the result of the calmer setting and quieter environment in Dr. Eichenstein’s office. She testified that his higher score on the Letter-Word Identification subtest of the December 2002 WJ-III is a better reflection of his abilities. Accordingly, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s higher scores in December 2002 were most likely not the result of a practice effect.

The existence of a severe discrepancy cannot be based solely upon a single score or product of scores, test, or procedure. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(4).) The Hearing Officer must therefore examine both sets of achievement scores in the context of all of the evidence presented to determine whether the October 2002 scores or the December 2002 scores are supported by the other testing and observations of STUDENT.

In the first decision, the Hearing Officer found that a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement existed in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression. The Hearing Officer further found that a severe discrepancy did not exist in the area of oral expression. The Court reversed the Hearing Officer’s finding with respect to the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression, but did not disturb the Hearing Officer’s finding that no severe discrepancy existed in the area of oral expression. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will only address those three academic areas that were reversed by the Court and remanded to the Hearing Office.

Basic Reading Skills

Dr. Humphrey testified that she found a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of basic reading skills. She based her finding on a comparison of STUDENT’s cognitive ability with the following scores obtained on the WJ-III Broad Reading Cluster, Reading Fluency subtest, Passage Comprehension subtest, and Letter Word Identification subtest administered by District resource specialist Linda Hirsch in October 2002: a standard score of 91 on the Broad Reading Cluster, a score of 91 on the Reading Fluency subtest, a score of 86 on the Passage Comprehension subtest and a score of 99 on the Letter-Word Identification subtest. In comparing STUDENT’s scores to his CAS full scale score of 121, the differences are 30 points, 30 points, 35 points, and 22 points, respectively. Thus, utilizing this set of scores, a severe discrepancy was demonstrated between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in the area of basic reading skills.

The District contends that STUDENT’s score of 114 on the Basic Reading Skills cluster administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002 was the appropriate score to utilize in determining whether a severe discrepancy existed in the area of basic reading skills. (Footnote 5) Dr. Dunn relied in part on this score in reaching her conclusion that STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy in the area of basic reading skills. When compared to his CAS full scale score of 121, the difference was 7 points, which would not have constituted a severe discrepancy. She attributed the higher scores that STUDENT received on the WJ-III administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002 to the progress STUDENT as a result of the curriculum at Van Gogh.

The Hearing Officer finds that the October 2002 WJ-III test scores were a more accurate and reliable measurement of STUDENT’s achievement level in the area of basic reading skills and that these scores showed a severe discrepancy in this academic area. Neither Student nor the District presented any persuasive expert testimony as to why one of the two scores would be more appropriate to use than the other. However, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Humphrey’s finding that a severe discrepancy existed in the area of basic reading skills was supported by STUDENT’s scores on other reading assessments, including the Grey Oral Reading Test-Fourth Edition (GORT-4) administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002, which measures reading fluency and comprehension. On the GORT-4, STUDENT’s reading rate, accuracy, and fluency scores were all at the pre-kindergarten level and his comprehension score was at the kindergarten level. In her report, Dr. Eichenstein notes that STUDENT was unable to read the first story, which was at kindergarten level, and was unable to decode any sight words. In addition, the testimony of Paula Himmelstein and Hope Waterson, STUDENT’s first grade teachers, establishes that STUDENT’s reading fluency was below grade level during the 2002-2003 school year. Finally, Dr. Humphrey, Dr. Eichenstein, and STUDENT’s parents and teachers all stated that they observed labored decoding when STUDENT read to them. Because the weight of the evidence corroborates the lower reading scores STUDENT received on the October 2002 WJ-III, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy in the area of basic reading skills.

Reading Comprehension

Student contends that he had a severe discrepancy between cognitive ability and achievement in the area of reading comprehension. In comparing STUDENT’s full scale cognitive ability score of 121 to his score of 86 on the Passage Comprehension subtest of the WJ-III administered by Ms. Hirsch in October 2002, a severe discrepancy of 35 points is apparent. The District contends that STUDENT’s score of 104 on the Passage Comprehension subtest administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002 was the more appropriate score by which to measure his academic achievement in the area of reading comprehension.

The Hearing Officer finds that the October 2002 WJ-III score was a more accurate and reliable measurement of STUDENT’s achievement level in the area of reading comprehension and that these scores showed a severe discrepancy in this academic area. Neither Student nor the District presented any persuasive expert testimony as to why one of the two scores would be more appropriate to use than the other. However, the Hearing Officer notes that the existence of a severe discrepancy in the area of reading comprehension is corroborated by STUDENT’s scores on other reading assessments, such as the GORT-4. The GORT-4 placed him at the kindergarten level for reading comprehension, which was more consistent with the October 2002 Passage Comprehension score. In addition, STUDENT’s standard score of 85 on the Passage Comprehension subtest of the Woodcock-Johnson-Revised administered in October 2001 is more consistent with STUDENT’s score of 86 on the October 2002 WJ-III than it is with the December 2002 WJ-III score of 104. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the October 2002 score was the appropriate score to utilize and that the use of this score showed a severe discrepancy in the area of reading comprehension.

Written Expression

STUDENT received a standard score of 95 on the Broad Written Language cluster of the WJ-III administered in October 2002 and received a standard score of 94 on the Written Expression cluster of that test. These scores led District psychologist Linda Joslin to conclude in her report that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy in the academic area of written expression. Student contends that the October 2002 scores were the appropriate scores to utilize in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy. STUDENT’s score on the Writing Samples subtest of the WJ-III increased from a standard score of 95 in October 2002 to a standard score of 103 in December. The District contends that the December 2002 score was the appropriate score to utilize.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the cluster scores obtained in October 2002 provided a more reliable measure of STUDENT’s achievement level in the area of written expression. Neither Student nor the District presented any persuasive expert testimony as to why one of the two scores would be more appropriate to use than the other. However, the Hearing Officer notes that the lower scores were corroborated by other evidence such as the testimony of STUDENT’s first grade teachers that STUDENT was below grade level in writing at the end of the first reporting period for his first grade class. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in the area of written expression.

The District’s October 2002 Assessment of STUDENT

Next, the Hearing Officer will address the consequences of the District’s incomplete assessment of STUDENT in October 2002 on the issue of whether a severe discrepancy existed during the 2002-2003 school year. The Court found that in the prior decision, the Hearing Officer determined that the District failed to assess STUDENT in the areas of language processing and phonological processing but failed to address the District’s incomplete assessment in rendering findings as to STUDENT’s severe discrepancies. The Hearing Officer did not consider the impact of the District’s failure to assess in these areas on the existence of a severe discrepancy in the prior decision because STUDENT’s parents had obtained independent educational evaluations from Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Humphrey in December 2002 and May 2003. Those evaluations were available to the District and were admitted into evidence during the first hearing, were discussed by the witnesses at hearing, and were considered by the Hearing Officer in his decision. Those evaluations included additional assessments in language processing and phonological processing not administered by the District, including the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP) in December 2002, which assesses phonological processing; the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Third Edition (CELF-III) in May 2003; and the Picture Vocabulary and Rapid Picture Naming subtests of the WJ-III in May of 2003, all of which assess language processing.

While Dr. Humphrey credibly testified during the first hearing that the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT in the areas of language and phonological processing in October 2002, she did not testify that there was insufficient information available to the District during the 2002-2003 school year or at the time of the first hearing in June 2003 for the Hearing Officer to make a determination regarding the existence of a severe discrepancy. Indeed, no witness testified as such. To the contrary, the witnesses for both STUDENT and the District stated their opinions regarding the existence of a severe discrepancy and the basis for those opinions without any qualifications regarding the sufficiency of the assessments. Because the independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Eichenstein and Dr. Humphrey included assessments in the areas the District failed to assess, and because no witness testified that there was insufficient information regarding STUDENT’s language or phonological processing abilities at the time of the hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to assess in those areas in October 2002 did not adversely affect the Hearing Officer’s ability to determine the existence of a severe discrepancy in the prior hearing.

Consideration of New Assessment Data

As set forth above, the Court also ordered the Hearing Officer to instruct the District to perform new assessments in all areas of suspected disability, including assessments in the areas of reading comprehension, basic reading skills, written expression, language processing, and phonological processing. The Court noted that the 2002 assessment results are now significantly out of date. On August 3, 2004, the Hearing Officer issued a minute order directing the District to conduct assessments in all areas of suspected disability. In September 2004, the District administered assessments in these areas to STUDENT and the results of those assessments were admitted into evidence during the second hearing.

The Court did not provide any guidance, however, as to whether or how the new assessment results should be considered with respect to STUDENT’s eligibility for special education during the 2002-2003 school year or the 2003-2004 school year. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has endorsed the “snapshot” rule, which holds that the actions of the school cannot be judged exclusively in hindsight. Rather, a determination must be made as to what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken. (See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)).) In this case, the snapshots would be taken at the time the IEP meetings convened during the 2002-2003 school year at which STUDENT’s eligibility for special education was considered.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the assessment results obtained in September 2004 are not appropriate to consider as a basis for determining the existence of a severe discrepancy during the 2002-2003 school year. As set forth above, a hindsight analysis using assessment data and other information not available to the IEP team is not appropriate, particularly in this case where the District had valid assessment data available to it at the IEP team meetings. Moreover, the evidence establishes that the September 2004 assessments were administered to STUDENT after he had completed the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years at Van Gogh Elementary and after he had completed approximately 192 hours of Lindamood-Bell programs during July and August 2003, December 2003, and July and August of 2004. Thus, the new assessments measure STUDENT’s skills and academic achievement after he received a considerable amount of classroom and individual instruction in academic subjects. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Court intended the results of the new assessments to be utilized in determining STUDENT’s eligibility for the 2004-2005 school year, and that the Hearing Officer should consider the results of the assessments administered during the 2002-2003 school year in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy for that school year.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT exhibited severe discrepancies in the academic areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression. The Hearing Officer will now turn to the issue of whether these discrepancies were caused by a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language.

(b) Disorder in Basic Psychological Processes

The second requirement for eligibility based upon a specific learning disability is that the disability must involve a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(26)(A); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j).) Basic psychological processes include “attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression.” (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j)(1).) In addition, the disorder must not primarily be the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. (34 C.F.R. § 300.541(b)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(b).) The Code of Regulations does not identify a specific methodology to be used in determining whether a psychological processing disorder exists. (See Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j).)

The Court reversed the Hearing Officer’s determination in the first decision that the severe discrepancies were not caused by a disorder in a basic psychological process, finding that the Hearing Officer applied the incorrect standard in determining that the severe discrepancies were not caused by a disorder in a basic psychological process. Specifically, the Court found that the Hearing Officer incorrectly utilized the methodology set forth in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(c)(4) in determining that the severe discrepancies were not caused by a disorder in a basic psychological process. (Footnote 6)) The Court found that section 3030(c)(4) is used to determine whether a student suffers from an expressive or receptive language disorder and that it was inappropriate to use the methodology set forth in that section to determine the existence of a disorder in a basic psychological process in the context of specific learning disabilities. In addition, the Court found that the Hearing Officer erred in making this conclusion because he found that the evidence suggested that STUDENT may have a phonological processing disorder, a subset of a disorder of one of the basic psychological processes. Finally, the Court found that the Hearing Officer failed to address whether the discrepancy was the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage.

The Hearing Officer must thus reexamine the evidence to determine if STUDENT’s difficulties in reading and written expression were due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using written or spoken language. Student contends that he had a disorder in the “cognitive ability of expression,” specifically his ability to retrieve information from his memory and convey this information verbally and in writing. According to Student, his disorder in the cognitive ability of expression was evidenced by the results of several assessments, including the expressive subtests of the CELF-III, his scores on the Rapid Word Retrieval subtest of the WJ-III, and his scores on the Rapid Naming subtests of the CTOPP. The District disputes that Student had a psychological processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. Specifically, the District contends that STUDENT’s expressive language test scores were within the average range, along with his scores on other processing tests such as the TAPS-R, MVPT-R, and the Bender.

Student’s expert, Dr. Humphrey, testified concerning the results of her assessment of STUDENT and her review of prior assessments. According to Dr. Humphrey, by the time of her assessment in May 2003, STUDENT had not previously been assessed in the following areas: language, memory, and visual motor functioning. To assess STUDENT’s language functioning, Dr. Humphrey administered the CELF-III, the Picture Vocabulary subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement, and the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities. On the CELF-III, STUDENT received a standard score of 114 for receptive language, placing him in the 82nd percentile; a score of 94 for expressive language, placing him in the 34th percentile; and a total language score of 104, placing him in the 61st percentile. On the three subtests that measure receptive language, STUDENT’s scores fell above the 90th percentile with the exception of Concepts and Directions, where STUDENT’s score fell in the 25th percentile. On the three subtests that measure expressive language, STUDENT scored as follows: Word Structure (37th percentile), Formulated Sentences (16th percentile), and Recalling Sentences (63rd percentile). On the Picture Vocabulary subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement, STUDENT received a standard score of 101, placing him in the 53rd percentile. On the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities, STUDENT received a standard score of 77, placing him in the 6th percentile. On the Children’s Memory Scale, most of STUDENT’s immediate memory scores were within expected limits, ranging from the 37th to the 75th percentile. STUDENT scored significantly lower on certain subtests, such as the Stories-Delayed Recognition and Stories-Delayed Thematic, Word Pairs-Long Delay, and Faces-Delayed. On the Beery VMI, a test of visual motor integration, STUDENT’s score placed him at the 34th percentile. On the Rey-Osterreith, STUDENT copied a complex design and then drew it again from memory. His scores placed him at the 48th and 59th percentiles.

Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies in reading and written expression were due to a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, specifically his ability to retrieve information from his memory and convey this information verbally and in writing. She diagnosed STUDENT with an expressive language disorder using the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) criteria. She based her diagnosis on STUDENT’s scores on the expressive language portion of the CELF-III administered in May 2003, specifically STUDENT’s total expressive language score and his scores on the Word Structure subtest and the Formulated Sentence subtest. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT’s scores on these tests should have been compared to his cognitive ability, rather than the mean of the test, to determine whether a psychological processing disorder existed. She stated that children with high cognitive abilities such as STUDENT are often able to support their academic difficulties with their intellectual abilities and that this may hide the severity of some his struggles because the effort he is putting into tasks to receive low average or lower average scores is much greater than that expended by other children.

Dr. Humphrey compared STUDENT’s total expressive language score of 94 on the CELF-III with STUDENT’s full scale CAS score of 121 and noted a discrepancy of 27 points, more than 1.5 standard deviations. She also compared STUDENT’s expressive language score to his receptive language score and found that his expressive score was 20 points lower than his receptive language score. Dr. Humphrey also testified that STUDENT exhibited relative weaknesses on some of the expressive language subtests of the CELF-III. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT had difficulty providing irregular plurals, auxiliary verbs plus “-ing,” regular and irregular past tenses, demonstrative pronouns, and future tenses on the Word Structure subtest. STUDENT received a scaled score of 9 which, according to Dr. Humphrey, translated to a standard score of 95 and fell within the 37th percentile. She also testified that STUDENT experienced significant difficulties on the Formulated Sentence subtest, on which STUDENT was required to make up a sentence about a picture he was shown. STUDENT’s scaled score was 7, which translated to a standard score of 90 and placed him in the 16th percentile. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT’s performance on this test revealed significant difficulties with language organization. Specifically, she testified that STUDENT exhibited significant word-finding difficulties. Finally, Dr. Humphrey found that STUDENT also exhibited problems with working memory and organization that supported her finding of a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression related to his ability to retrieve information from his memory and express it. She testified that although STUDENT’s immediate memory scores on the Children’s Memory Scale were within expected limits, his delayed memory scores were significantly lower.

Dr. Humphrey also diagnosed STUDENT with a related reading disability, specifically a deficit in phonological processing. According to Dr. Humphrey, phonological processing is the ability to process the individual sounds, or “phonemes” in words, and has been identified as the core component of quick, efficient reading. She based her diagnosis on STUDENT’s Broad Reading cluster score on the WJ-III administered in October 2002, his scores on the Rapid Naming and Phoneme Reversal subtests of the CTOPP in May 2003, the GORT-4 administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002, and STUDENT’s reading of the Brown Bear book to Dr. Humphrey in May 2003. Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT’s score of 91 on the Broad Reading Cluster of the WJ-III represented a 29-point discrepancy between his ability and achievement in the area of reading. On the CTOPP, which measures phonological processing, STUDENT scored lowest on the “rapid naming tests.” This test was administered by Dr. Eichenstein when STUDENT was 7.0 years old. On Rapid Digit Naming, STUDENT’s score placed him in the 25th percentile with an age equivalent of 6.6 years. On Rapid Letter Naming, STUDENT’s score placed him in the 37th percentile, with an age equivalent of 6.9 years. On Rapid Color Naming, STUDENT’s score placed him in the 16th percentile with an age equivalent of 5.6 years. On Rapid Object Naming, STUDENT’s score placed him in the 9th percentile, with an age equivalent of 5.6 years. Finally, on the Phoneme Reversal subtest, STUDENT’s score placed him in the 16th percentile with an age equivalent of 5.6. According to Dr. Humphrey, children in kindergarten and first grade who experience difficulty with these tests are more likely to have reading problems. Dr. Humphrey also relied upon STUDENT’s scores on the GORT-4, which measures reading fluency and comprehension. According to Dr. Eichenstein’s report, STUDENT’s reading rate, accuracy, and fluency scores were all at the pre-kindergarten level and his comprehension score was at the kindergarten level. Finally, Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT was able to read the Brown Bear book, but demonstrated significant slowing when he needed to decode an unfamiliar word.

In contrast, the District’s expert, Dr. Dunn, testified that STUDENT did not have a processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. Dr. Dunn based her opinion on STUDENT’s expressive language scores on the CELF-III. She testified that in determining whether a child has a psychological disorder, the child’s score on the processing test is compared to the mean for the test, not to the child’s cognitive ability. If the child’s score on the processing test is within the average range, the child does not have a processing disorder. According to Dr. Dunn, the reason for comparing the child’s score to the mean, as opposed to the child’s cognitive ability, is that the tests, including the CELF-III, are normed to the mean. Dr. Dunn compared STUDENT’s CELF-III expressive language score of 94 to the mean of 100 and noted that his score is in the average range, only 6 points below the mean.

Dr. Dunn testified that the Cognitive Fluency cluster of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities also provided a good measure of STUDENT’s cognitive expression ability. Dr. Dunn pointed out that in May 2003 Dr. Humphrey administered the Rapid Picture Naming subtest of the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities, which is one of the three subtests that make up the Cognitive Fluency cluster. She testified that STUDENT’s standard score of 77 on the Rapid Picture Naming subtest, which placed him in the 6th percentile, was not a sufficient basis on which to make a determination as to whether STUDENT had a processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. Rather, she stated that the entire cluster should have been administered to obtain a complete picture of STUDENT’s cognitive expression.

Dr. Dunn also disagreed with Dr. Humphrey’s conclusion that STUDENT has a reading disorder. According to Dr. Dunn, the CTOPP measures phonological processing, which is a component of auditory processing. Dr. Dunn acknowledged that STUDENT exhibited some weakness in the “rapid naming” subtests of the CTOPP, but testified that his total score on the CTOPP was in the average range and would not constitute an area of relative weakness. Dr. Dunn also testified regarding other tests that measure auditory processing skills and specifically phonological processing skills. Specifically, Dr. Dunn testified that the Phoneme/Grapheme Knowledge Cluster and the Word Attack and Sound Awareness subtests of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement all test phonological skills. On the Phoneme/Grapheme Knowledge Cluster, STUDENT received a standard score of 106, placing him in the 66th percentile. On the Word Attack subtest, STUDENT received a standard score of 118, placing him in the 88th percentile. Finally, on the Sound Awareness subtest, STUDENT received a standard score of 110, placing him in the 75th percentile. Dr. Dunn testified that these scores, along with STUDENT’s scores on the CTOPP, established that STUDENT does not have a phonological processing disorder.

In reviewing the transcript from the first hearing, along with all of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer is now persuaded that STUDENT has a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, which is one of the basic psychological processes involved in using written and spoken language. While the Hearing Officer initially found Dr. Dunn’s testimony more persuasive on this issue, that determination was largely based on the Hearing Officer’s finding that the methodology set forth in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(c)(4), which is used to determine eligibility under the category of speech and language impairment, was the correct measure to use in determining the existence of a processing disorder for purposes of eligibility under the category of specific learning disability. In its order, the Court found that the Hearing Officer erred in using this section to determine the existence of a processing disorder.

While the Hearing Officer found both Dr. Humphrey and Dr. Dunn to be well-qualified and credible witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Humphrey to be more persuasive on this issue. Dr. Humphrey personally administered several assessment instruments to STUDENT in May of 2003, and was therefore able to personally observe STUDENT’s performance during the testing. In contrast, Dr. Dunn did not administer any testing to STUDENT and instead relied upon assessment results and reports prepared by others. By personally administering the testing instruments, Dr. Humphrey was able to observe STUDENT’s test taking performance firsthand. She testified that STUDENT displayed significant difficulties in language organization and word finding abilities, particularly when he was required to retrieve words quickly and that he often needed several sentences to get to the answer.

Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Dr. Humphrey’s testimony that in determining a processing disorder, STUDENT’s test scores should have been compared to his cognitive ability, rather than the mean score of 100, because his cognitive ability is in the superior range, 20 points above the mean, and his language ability should correlate with his cognitive ability. As Dr. Humphrey testified, comparing STUDENT’s total expressive language score of 94 on the CELF-III with STUDENT’s full scale CAS score of 121 results in a discrepancy of 27 points and comparing STUDENT’s expressive language score on the CELF to his receptive language score on the CELF reveals that the expressive score was 20 points lower than his receptive language score. Dr. Humphrey also testified that STUDENT exhibited relative weaknesses on some of the expressive language subtests of the CELF-III, including the Word Structure and Formulated Sentences subtests.

For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, which is a basic psychological process involved in understanding or in using written and spoken language. The evidence also supports a finding that STUDENT has a language-based reading disability. Specifically, STUDENT’s scores on the GORT-4 were at the pre-kindergarten and kindergarten level. Moreover, Dr. Humphrey, Dr. Eichenstein, and STUDENT’s parents and teachers noted labored decoding when STUDENT read to them. And, as discussed in the prior section, STUDENT’s scores on the WJ-III Broad Reading Cluster, Passage Comprehension subtest, and Reading Fluency subtest were significantly discrepant from STUDENT’s cognitive ability. In addition, both Dr. Humphrey and Dr. Eichenstein found that STUDENT’s low scores on the Rapid Naming and Phoneme Reversal subtests of the CTOPP demonstrated significant weaknesses in using and organizing language rapidly and suggested a language-based reading disability.

The evidence further establishes that these disorders manifested themselves in an imperfect ability on the part of STUDENT to speak, read, write, and spell and that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression were due to these disorders. Finally, both Dr. Humphrey and Dr. Dunn credibly testified that any processing disorder that existed was not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and his reading disability were not the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage.

(c) Discrepancy Cannot be Corrected Through Other Regular or Categorical Services Offered Within the Regular Instructional Program

The final requirement for eligibility as a child with a specific learning disability is that the severe discrepancy cannot be ameliorated through “other regular or categorical services” offered within the regular instructional program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); see 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6).) The Student contends that his needs could not be accommodated in regular education. Respondent contends that STUDENT’s discrepancy could and was corrected within the regular instructional program.

In the first decision, the Hearing Officer found the testimony of STUDENT’s first grade teachers that STUDENT’s reading fluency and writing skills improved during the course of the school year persuasive. The Hearing Officer concluded that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies could be corrected within the regular instructional program. The Hearing Officer noted that while the evidence showed that STUDENT did not require special education during the 2002-2003 school year, the evidence should put the parties on notice that STUDENT may need special education at some time in the future if modifications and accommodations in the regular education program proved less successful than expected in enabling him to benefit.

The Court reversed the Hearing Officer’s conclusion in the first decision that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies could be corrected within the regular instructional program, finding that the Hearing Officer failed to address whether the improvements in STUDENT’s grades and the accommodations offered by his teachers demonstrated the sufficiency of the regular instructional program for STUDENT if he had a processing disorder. In addition, the Court found that the Hearing Officer could not properly ascertain whether the regular education curriculum was sufficient to remedy those suspected disabilities in light of his finding that the District had conducted an incomplete assessment. Finally, the Court found that the Hearing Officer failed to address the testimony of the Student’s expert, Dr. Humphrey, and recommendations she made with regard to correcting his severe discrepancies. The Hearing Officer will address each of the Court’s concerns below.

Sufficiency of the Regular Education Program

The Hearing Officer will first address whether the improvements in STUDENT’s grades and the accommodations offered by his teachers demonstrated the sufficiency of the regular instructional program for STUDENT if he had a processing disorder.

MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, testified at the first hearing that she and FATHER spent between one and two hours per night working with STUDENT on his academic skills, with a focus on his reading and spelling skills, during the 2002-2003 school year. She testified that STUDENT was a slow reader who had difficulty with letter and word recognition and frequently had trouble remembering a word that he learned to sound out moments before. She also testified that STUDENT had difficulty expressing himself verbally, sometimes using two to three sentences to get a point across to the listener. The Court found that the Hearing Officer did not consider the recommendations made by Dr. Humphrey with regard to correcting STUDENT’s severe discrepancies. During the first hearing, Dr. Humphrey testified that the regular education program available to STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year could not correct STUDENT’s severe discrepancies in the areas of reading and written expression. According to Dr. Humphrey, STUDENT required an intensive reading program over the summer of 2003 that focused on phonological processing, such as a Lindamood-Bell program. She stated that research has shown that such programs can retrain a student’s brain and bring a student’s reading to expected levels. She also recommended that STUDENT receive two hours of language therapy per week to address vocabulary, sequencing, and expressive organization. Finally, she recommended that STUDENT receive short-term cognitive behavioral therapy with a specialist in child trauma to address posttraumatic stress resulting from his involvement in the nursery school shooting incident.

STUDENT’s first grade class was taught by Paula Himmelstein and Hope Watterson. During the first hearing, Ms. Himmelstein and Ms. Watterson both testified that STUDENT’s academic skills were at grade level during the 2002-2003 school year with the exception of reading fluency. With regard to STUDENT’s reading fluency, Ms. Himmelstein testified that she and Ms. Watterson taught STUDENT’s class using the Open Court System, a State standards-based curriculum. Ms. Himmelstein testified that three of the first grade teachers decided to team teach and divided their students into three reading groups based on each student’s skill level: “high,” “middle,” and “low.” Ms. Himmelstein taught the middle group, of which STUDENT was a member. She testified that while STUDENT had good reading comprehension skills, he experienced difficulty sounding out and decoding words. According to Ms. Himmelstein, he could answer questions based on a story he read, demonstrated a lot of insight into the stories, and could make inferences about what he read in the stories. Ms. Himmelstein testified that under the Open Court reading program, she began testing the students in her class in the area of reading fluency in the 24th week of school, which fell approximately in March of 2003. In March 2003, the District recommended that STUDENT be placed in an extended learning program to assist him with his reading. This program took place each Monday for one hour for a total of eight weeks. STUDENT’s progress report for the extended learning program reflects that he attended six of the eight sessions. The report describes STUDENT’s progress as “satisfactory” as opposed to “unsatisfactory.” Under the heading of “Teacher Comments,” the program’s teacher wrote: “[STUDENT] works hard to decode words and is making progress in his oral fluency.” Ms. Himmelstein credibly testified that STUDENT’s reading fluency improved during the course of the year. Moreover, she testified that STUDENT’s reading comprehension skills were at grade level and that he was always able to answer questions about a passage or story he read. She expressed the opinion that STUDENT could improve his reading fluency by continuing the Open Court Reading curriculum. Specifically, she recommended that STUDENT continue to be taught the sounds that make up words so that he learns letter patterns better, which she believed would increase his reading rate and make reading more automatic.

Ms. Himmelstein testified that she provided a few accommodations to STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year due to his difficulties with reading fluency and following directions. Specifically, she placed his desk towards the front of the class, repeated directions for him when needed, and allowed him additional time to complete reading assignments, with the exception of timed reading assignments. She did not modify his curriculum by giving him different or fewer assignments. Ms. Himmelstein expressed the opinion that with these accommodations, STUDENT would be able to continue to access the curriculum. She testified that other strategies or assistance might be necessary if his fluency did not improve and it began to affect his comprehension, his ability to keep up with the class, and/or his grades.

According to Ms. Himmelstein, STUDENT’s writing skills were below grade level at the end of the first reporting period of the 2002-2003 school year. In November 2002, a notice was sent home to STUDENT’s parents advising them that STUDENT was working below grade level in writing. Ms. Himmelstein testified that his writing skills improved during the course of the school year and that he was writing at grade level by the end of the year. In fact, she testified that STUDENT’s writing improved to the point that he was almost above grade level by the end of the school year. (Footnote 7) On his progress reports, STUDENT received grades in the “proficient” range in reading, writing, listening, speaking, mathematics, history/social science, and science. STUDENT received one “partially proficient” mark in writing at the end of the first quarter. However, this mark improved to “proficient” for the second and third quarters. (Footnote 8)

Similarly, during STUDENT’s kindergarten year, he received grades of “very good” in all areas, including academic development, oral expression, pre-reading/reading/language skills, science, and social studies, with the exception of “meets new challenges with confidence” on which STUDENT received a mark of “good.” Lisa Marlow, STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher at the JCC, testified during the first hearing that STUDENT performed at grade level and was able to access the curriculum taught to him, although she was concerned by his difficulty in learning and remembering the letters of the alphabet, words, and days of the week. With regard to his pre-reading and reading skills, however, Ms. Marlow testified that STUDENT received a score of “good” at mid-year which improved to “very good” at the end of the year. According to Ms. Marlow, STUDENT was able to read and blend words together by the end of the school year.

The weight of the evidence available to the District at the time of the February 25, 2003 IEP meeting supports the conclusion that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies were in the process of being corrected within the regular instructional program. While the Hearing Officer found FATHER and MOTHER to be both credible witnesses and devoted parents, it is not unusual for parents to work with their children at home on their school work for an hour or two per night, as they did with STUDENT. Although the Hearing Officer found Dr. Humphrey to be a credible witness as well, she did not address the progress that STUDENT was making in his academic classes during the course of the 2002-2003 school year, as credibly testified to by STUDENT’s teachers. Moreover, the evidence available to the District by the end of the school year, when the June 3, 2003 IEP meeting took place, supports the District’s conclusion that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies were in the process of being corrected within the regular instructional program. According to his teachers, by the end of the school year, STUDENT was at grade level in all academic areas except reading fluency, and he was demonstrating improvement in that area as well following participation in a reading fluency workshop. In addition, STUDENT’s writing skills had improved from a score of “partially proficient” to “proficient” by the end of the year. In light of STUDENT’s improvement in these areas during the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s conclusion that his discrepancies could be corrected with services available within the regular education program was reasonable at the time.

In June of 2003, the District completed a 504 plan for STUDENT. The 504 plan indicates that STUDENT had a mental disability in retrieval and that this disability impaired his pacing during reading and writing tasks. The 504 plan called for extended time on tests and assignments, preview of text, a quiet room to finish work, a seat close to the teacher, directions to be repeated as needed, and verbal prompts of sound patterns. The evidence established that Ms. Himmelstein implemented some of these accommodations earlier in the school year and that STUDENT was placed in an extended learning program to assist him with his reading fluency. STUDENT’s performance in reading fluency and writing improved, although his reading fluency remained below grade level. If his fluency or his writing remained below grade level despite regular education accommodations, modifications, and additional instructional assistance, however, the District would have been obligated to reconvene the IEP team to determine whether STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. At that time, the recommendations made by Dr. Humphrey for a specialized reading program, speech and language therapy, and behavioral counseling should have been revisited.

The Court’s statement that the Hearing Officer did not consider whether improvements in STUDENT’s grades and the accommodations offered by his teachers demonstrated the sufficiency of the regular instructional program for STUDENT if he had a processing disorder is somewhat ambiguous. The law clearly contemplates that it is possible to ameliorate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement caused by a processing disorder through regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56337(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.543(a)(6).) In this Decision, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT had a processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression during the 2002-2003 school year. The Hearing Officer has further found that despite this processing disorder, STUDENT was demonstrating improvement in the areas of reading fluency and writing during the 2002-2003 school year as a result of the additional assistance and accommodations provided to him in the regular education program.

The Hearing Officer must make a determination as to what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken near the end of the 2002-2003 school year. (See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir.1999) (citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)).) The Hearing Officer has found that the evidence available to the District at the time of the IEP meeting in February 2003 supported the conclusion that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies could be corrected through the regular education curriculum. At the same time, the District was obligated under its child find obligations to reevaluate STUDENT’s eligibility for special education if these discrepancies persisted and his performance in these subjects remained below grade level. In any event, however, the evidence available by the end of the 2002-2003 school year demonstrated the reasonableness of the determination that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies, caused by a processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, could be addressed in the regular education setting, as described above. STUDENT was improving in his areas of deficit by the end of the school year, as previously detailed.

The District’s Incomplete Assessment in October 2002

The Court found that in the first decision, the Hearing Officer could not properly ascertain whether the regular education curriculum was sufficient to remedy STUDENT’s suspected disabilities in light of the Hearing Officer’s finding that the District had conducted an incomplete assessment. As previously discussed, although the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to assess STUDENT in the areas of phonological processing and language processing in October 2002, STUDENT’s parents obtained independent educational evaluations from Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002 and from Dr. Humphrey in May 2003, which included the administration of assessments in these areas. This assessment information was presented as evidence at the first hearing and was considered by the Hearing Officer in his first decision. During the first hearing, no witness testified that he or she lacked sufficient information regarding STUDENT’s phonological processing or language processing abilities to present an informed opinion as to whether STUDENT’s severe discrepancies in reading and writing could be corrected within the regular education curriculum. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that sufficient assessment data existed in the record to enable the Hearing Officer to ascertain whether the regular education curriculum was sufficient to remedy STUDENT’s suspected disabilities.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT exhibited a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression. The Hearing Officer further determines that these severe discrepancies were caused by a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and by a reading disability, but that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies were in the process of being corrected through the regular instructional program. Accordingly, STUDENT was not eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability for the 2002-2003 school year.

ISSUE NO. 2: Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2003-2004 school year?

During the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT attended second grade in a regular education classroom at Van Gogh. STUDENT’s mother testified that she received an assessment plan from the District sometime during the 2003-2004 school year, but prior to March 25, 2004. The assessment plan indicated that the District sought to assess STUDENT in the areas of social/emotional development, cognitive development, academic achievement, perceptual development, communication/language, and health. STUDENT’s mother testified that she made numerous handwritten notations on the assessment plan including requests that the District conduct a functional behavior assessment, a mental health assessment under AB3632, and language processing and attention deficit disorder assessments. She testified that she sent the revised assessment plan to the District on March 25, 2004. On or about March 29, 2004, she received another assessment plan from the District. The second assessment plan indicated that the District sought to assess STUDENT in the areas of social/emotional development, cognitive development, academic achievement, perceptual development, communication/language, and health. The second assessment plan further indicated that the District sought to assess STUDENT for a central auditory processing disorder. It did not reflect the specific changes that STUDENT’s mother had made to the initial assessment plan. STUDENT’s mother testified that she did not sign or return the second assessment plan.

The District did not present any witnesses to testify regarding the preparation or purpose of the assessment plans that were sent to STUDENT’s parents during the 2003-2004 school year. The District did not file a request for a due process hearing during the 2003-2004 school year to seek the right to assess STUDENT in the areas specified by the assessment plans and no evidence was presented at hearing that the District conducted any assessments of STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year. No evidence was presented that anyone requested an IEP team meeting regarding STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year.

On April 30, 2004, Dr. Humphrey issued her report regarding her second neuropsychological examination of STUDENT, which had been obtained by his parents in December 2003 and February 2004. For this examination, Dr. Humphrey administered the Beery, the Child Behavior Checklist, Connors Continuous Performance Test-Second Edition (CCPT-II), the Conners’ Parent Rating Scale-Revised, the NEPSY, the WJ-III Tests of Achievement and selected tests of cognition, and the WISC-IV Coding and Symbol Search. There was no evidence that the District was provided with this report at any time during the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 9)

(a) Severe Discrepancy Between Intellectual Ability and Achievement

As previously set forth, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the following academic areas during the 2002-2003 school year: basic reading skills, reading comprehension, reading fluency, and written expression. The evidence establishes that STUDENT continued to perform below grade level in reading, specifically in the area of reading fluency, during the first quarter of the 2003-2004 school year.

In a progress report dated December 9, 2003, Candace Bowen, STUDENT’s second grade teacher for the 2003-2004 school year, stated that STUDENT was struggling in reading and writing despite ample support and assistance. According to Ms. Bowen, this support and assistance included working with STUDENT every morning on his spelling and fluency and assistance from a teacher’s aide in fluency and spelling during recess twice a week. She also suggested that STUDENT’s parents read with him every night, encourage him to keep a journal, and work with him on spelling to help him progress with his reading and writing.

MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, testified that during the 2003-2004 school year, she and her husband worked with STUDENT for approximately four hours per night on his homework and the subject matter covered in class that day, which was a substantial increase from the 2002-2003 school year, when they worked with STUDENT for approximately one to two hours per night. She stated that she frequently felt like she was teaching STUDENT material for the first time at home, even though it had been taught to him at school that day. She also credibly testified that she had numerous communications, both oral and in writing, with Ms. Bowen regarding STUDENT’s academic performance during the 2003-2004 school year.

The District has a continuing obligation to identify, locate, and assess all individuals with disabilities who are in need of special education and related services. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.) A student may be referred for an assessment by the student’s parent or guardian, teacher or other service provider, or foster parent. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56029.) However, as noted previously, under the “snapshot” rule, the actions of the school cannot be judged exclusively in hindsight. Rather, a determination must be made as to what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the District makes its determination regarding a child’s eligibility. (See Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)).)

The evidence supports a finding that by January 2004, the District knew or should have known that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy in the area of reading was not being corrected through the regular instructional program. Despite the accommodations afforded by the 504 plan, the extended reading program provided during the second semester of the 2002-2003 school year, the additional instruction provided by Ms. Bowen and her aide in class and during recess, and the extensive assistance that STUDENT’s parents provided him at home, STUDENT was still performing below grade level in reading fluency by December 2003 as evidenced by his progress report from that period and the testimony of Ms. Bowen. This information, combined with the assessment and academic performance data and observations available to the District during the 2002-2003 school year, should have placed the District on notice that STUDENT’s eligibility for special education needed to be reevaluated at this juncture. An IEP meeting should have been called to reevaluate STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. The District did not call an IEP meeting. While the District did request the opportunity to conduct new assessments on STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year, it was apparently unable to reach agreement with STUDENT’s parents regarding the scope of the assessments. After failing to reach agreement on the proposed assessments, the District did not request a due process hearing on its right to assess STUDENT. There was no evidence that the District undertook to investigate or address STUDENT’s difficulties with reading fluency, other than to continue providing him with the assistance and accommodations that he had previously been provided, following the end of the first half of the school year in December. STUDENT remained below grade level in reading fluency for the entire school year, as evidenced by his progress report and the testimony of Ms. Bowen.

The evidence demonstrates that if the District had reassessed STUDENT’s academic achievement through standardized testing in December of 2003, the results would have confirmed the existence of a severe discrepancy in the area of reading fluency. The only standardized tests of academic achievement administered to STUDENT during the 2003-2004 school year and presented as evidence in this hearing were the WJ-III Tests of Achievement administered by Dr. Humphrey in December 2003. (Footnote 10)

STUDENT scored as follows:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 98 44 Oral Expression 96 38 Listening Comprehension 100 49 Total Achievement 105 63 Broad Reading 106 65 Broad Math 114 82 Broad Written Language 99 48 Basic Reading Skills 116 85 Reading Composition 104 59 Math Calculation Skills 107 67 Written Expression 104 61 Academic Skills 111 77 Academic Fluency 95 37 Academic Applications 112 79 Phoneme/Grapheme Know 113 81 Letter-Word Identification 115 83 Reading Fluency 95 36 Story Recall 107 69 Understanding Directions 103 73 Calculation 112 78 Math Fluency 95 37 Spelling 95 37 Writing Fluency 98 46 Passage Comprehension 102 56 Applied Problems 118 88 Writing Samples 113 81 Word Attack 112 79 Picture Vocabulary 92 29 Oral Comprehension 93 32 Reading Vocabulary 104 60 Spelling of Sounds 115 84 Sound Awareness 97 43

In comparing STUDENT’s scores on the WJ-III Tests of Achievement with his cognitive score of 120 on the WISC-III administered by Dr. Eichenstein in December 2002, his most recent cognitive ability score in existence as of December 2003, there is a difference of more than 1.5 standard deviations in several areas, including oral expression, academic fluency, reading fluency, spelling, picture vocabulary, and oral comprehension. (Footnote 11)

The District maintains that reading fluency is not one of the academic areas specifically enumerated by Education Code section 56337(a) and therefore cannot be considered in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy in the area of basic reading skills. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by this argument. Section 56337(a) does not define the components of basic reading skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must look to other evidence to determine whether reading fluency should be considered a “basic reading skill” for purposes of determining a severe discrepancy. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, including Ms. Himmelstein, Ms. Watterson, and Ms. Bowen, establish that the Open Court reading program utilized by the District, which is based on State content standards, includes instruction and testing on reading fluency and comprehension. In addition, a student’s grade in reading is composed of his scores on both reading fluency and comprehension tests. Because reading fluency is a component of STUDENT’s reading instruction and his overall grade in reading, the Hearing Officer finds it appropriate to consider his score on the Reading Fluency subtest of the WJ-III in determining whether a severe discrepancy existed in the area of basic reading skills.

For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to exhibit a severe discrepancy in the area of basic reading skills (reading fluency).

(b) Disorder in Basic Psychological Processes

As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT has a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression that is not the result of an environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. Student contends that he also exhibited a disorder in the basic psychological process of attention during the 2003-2004 school year. The District maintains that STUDENT does not have a disorder in the area of attention.

Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT has an attention disorder that impacted his academic performance. In her report dated April 30, 2004, she indicates that STUDENT demonstrated slow reaction time, significant vulnerability to the speed of the stimuli, inattention, and poor vigilance on the Connors Continuous Performance Test-Second Edition and that this test indicated there was a 53.9% chance of significant attention problems. Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT also struggled on the NEPSY, an auditory attention test. His scores on this instrument were low average, in the 16th percentile, which is equivalent to a cognitive ability of 85. According to her report, these scores mean that he had trouble responding quickly to an auditory target both in the simple and working memory phases. Her report further states that STUDENT’s parents’ responses on the questionnaires from the Conners’ Parent Rating Scale-Revised yielded mild non-clinical elevations on the cognitive problems/inattention scale.

Dr. Pobanz and Dr. Dunn, the District’s psychologists, testified that STUDENT does not have an attention disorder. Dr. Pobanz provided STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT’s second grade teacher with the Conners’ Parent Rating Scale-Revised (Conners’) and the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC). In his report dated September 27, 2004, he states that both STUDENT’s parents and Candace Bowen, his second grade teacher, rated him in the average range on all of the clinical and adaptive scales of the BASC, which measures several areas of behavior, including attention. On the Conners’, STUDENT’s parents and Ms. Bowen rated STUDENT in the average range for all of the categories, including inattention and the attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) index.

Dr. Dunn testified that STUDENT’s performance on the Connor’s Continuous Performance Test-Second Edition shows a 53.9% chance that STUDENT has an attention disorder. She also testified that STUDENT’s performance on the subtests of the NEPSY did not indicate a problem with attention because if he had an attention disorder, his performance on the Tower subtest of the NEPSY would have been lower. She pointed out that STUDENT’s score on the Tower subtest was in the 98th percentile.

Candace Bowen, STUDENT’s second grade teacher for the 2003-2004 school year, testified that she observed STUDENT daydreaming in class only once or twice per week. She further testified that she did not have to repeat directions to STUDENT any more than for other students in her class and that STUDENT appeared to understand the directions that she gave him.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT had an attention disorder during the 2003-2004 school year. The weight of the evidence, in the form of the assessment results from the BASC, the Conners’ Parent Rating Scale-Revised, the Connors Continuous Performance Test-Second Edition, and observations by STUDENT’s teacher, who credibly testified that STUDENT did not display any significant problems with inattention, establishes that STUDENT did not manifest an attention disorder during the 2003-2004 school year. In addition, there was no persuasive testimony linking any deficit in the area of attention to STUDENT’s severe discrepancy in the area of basic reading skills/reading fluency.

(c) Discrepancy Cannot be Corrected Through Other Regular or Categorical Services Offered Within the Regular Instructional Program

As set forth above, the evidence demonstrates that by the end of the first quarter of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s severe discrepancy in reading was not being corrected through the regular educational curriculum, in spite of accommodations, additional assistance from the classroom teacher and aide, and considerable assistance from STUDENT’s parents at home. Furthermore, STUDENT remained below grade level in the area of reading: he continued to have deficits in reading fluency for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year, as evidenced by his progress reports and the testimony of Ms. Bowen.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy in the area of reading fluency were not being corrected through services offered within the regular education program during the 2003-2004 school year and that this should have been evident to the District by the end of the first half of the 2003-2004 school year.

Several witnesses, including Dr. Humphrey, Dr. Dunn, Dr. Pobanz, and Gail Hallenberg, testified regarding the effectiveness of different special education programs and services in addressing and correcting STUDENT’s reading and language deficits. The Hearing Officer will address the issue of which programs and services STUDENT requires in a separate section of this Decision.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to exhibit a severe discrepancy in the area of reading fluency during the 2003-2004 school year. The evidence demonstrates that this discrepancy was due to a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. Finally, the evidence demonstrates that in light of all of the information in the District’s possession, including assessment data and STUDENT’s classroom performance in reading during the 2002-2003 school year and the first half of the 2003-2004 school year, the District’s child find obligations should have prompted the District to conduct additional assessments, call an IEP team meeting, and reevalaute STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. The evidence supports a finding that by January 2004, the District knew or should have known that STUDENT’s severe discrepancy was not being corrected through the regular education program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services as a student with a specific learning disability by January 2004.

ISSUE NO. 3: Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2004-2005 school year?

STUDENT is currently attending third grade in a regular education class at Van Gogh for the 2004-2005 school year. In September 2004, the District conducted a psychoeducational assessment, a speech and language assessment, and an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT pursuant to orders issued by the Court and the Hearing Officer in July and August 2004. In her written assessment report, Gail Hallenberg, the District’s speech and language therapist, concluded that STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services under the category of speech and language disorder-language impairment.

During the second hearing in this matter, the District conceded that STUDENT is eligible for special education under the category of speech and language disorder-language impairment (SLI) for the 2004-2005 school year, but maintained that STUDENT is not eligible under the category of specific learning disability. Student contends that regardless of his eligibility as SLI, he is still eligible under the category of specific learning disability and has specific educational needs related to that disability, including an intensive reading remediation program. Despite the concession on the part of the District regarding STUDENT’s eligibility as SLI, the Hearing Officer must still address Student’s contention regarding his eligibility under the category of specific learning disability to determine whether STUDENT has unique educational needs related to a specific learning disability.

(a) Severe Discrepancy Between Intellectual Ability and Achievement

Cognitive Testing

To determine if a severe discrepancy exists for the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT’s scores on standardized intellectual testing will again be compared with his scores on achievement testing. The Hearing Officer must first determine which score of intellectual/cognitive ability provides the most accurate measure of STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. STUDENT’s cognitive ability has been measured several times during the past few years. In October 2002, the District administered the Cognitive Assessment System, on which STUDENT received a standard score of 121. In December 2002, Dr. Eichenstein administered the WISC-III, on which STUDENT obtained a standard score of 120. In September 2004, the District administered the General Intelligence Assessment (GIA), on which STUDENT received a standard score of 112. In December 2004, STUDENT received a standard score of 118 on the WISC-IV administered by Dr. Humphrey.

Dr. Humphrey, Student’s psychologist, testified that the cognitive score of 118 on the WISC-IV is the most appropriate score to utilize in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement for the 2004-2005 school year. Dr. Humphrey stated that this score is consistent with all of the other cognitive scores STUDENT received, with the exception of the GIA score of 112, which she described as a statistically lower score. In addition, Dr. Humphrey testified that the GIA score is weighted according to the various areas tested, and the language components of the GIA are weighted more heavily at STUDENT’s age level than they are on other cognitive assessments such as the WISC. Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT’s low scores on the language subtests of the GIA were the result of deficits in the area of language processing and that these low scores resulted in a lower overall cognitive ability score on the GIA. According to Dr. Humphrey, the weighted score on the GIA “washes out” or eliminates the severe discrepancy between ability and achievement that would otherwise be present. Dr. Humphrey testified that, for these reasons, the cognitive ability score of 118 on the WISC-IV is the most appropriate score to utilize in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement.

Dr. Dunn and Dr. Pobanz, the District’s psychologists, testified that the cognitive ability score of 112 on the GIA is the most appropriate score to utilize in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. Dr. Dunn testified that the GIA, which is the Woodcock-Johnson cognitive ability test, is a more reliable measure of STUDENT’s cognitive ability because it is co-normed with the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test. Dr. Dunn explained that co-norming means that the two tests are developed using the same normative sample and that the correlation of the ability and achievement tests is therefore more reliable. In addition, Dr. Dunn testified that the GIA score is a better measure of cognitive ability because it was administered to STUDENT most closely in time to the administration of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement in September 2004 and therefore provides the most accurate estimate of STUDENT’s ability level at that time.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Humphrey to be most persuasive regarding the question of which cognitive ability scores to use. STUDENT’s cognitive ability scores on the CAS, the WISC-III, and the WISC-IV are all consistent over a period of two years, while STUDENT’s standard score on the GIA is statistically lower. In addition, the Hearing Officer found persuasive Dr. Humphrey’s testimony that STUDENT’s low scores on the language subtests of the GIA were the result of deficits in the area of language processing and that these low scores resulted in a lower overall cognitive ability score on the GIA. Dr. Humphrey’s testimony is supported by Education Code section 56320(d), which provides, in pertinent part, that assessments must be selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT’s GIA score may not accurately reflect his cognitive abilities because it afforded greater weight to STUDENT’s language skills, which are impacted by his language processing disorder. Finally, while Dr. Dunn testified that the GIA score would be the best score to use, she also testified that the WISC-III and WISC-IV are appropriate instruments for measuring STUDENT’s cognitive ability. Therefore, for purposes of determining the existence of a severe discrepancy during the 2004-2005 school year, the Hearing Officer will utilize the score of 118 that STUDENT received on the WISC-IV administered by Dr. Humphrey in December 2004, because it represents STUDENT’s most recent cognitive ability score in relation to the 2004-2005 school year, other than the less reliable GIA score obtained in September 2004.

Achievement Testing

The only standardized tests of academic achievement administered to STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year and presented as evidence in this hearing were the WJ-III Tests of Achievement administered by Dr. Pobanz in September 2004. STUDENT received the following scores on the WJ-III:

Standard Score Percentile Ranking

Oral Language 103 57 Oral Expression 94 35 Listening Comprehension 108 71 Total Achievement 91 28 Broad Reading 88 21 Broad Math 106 66 Broad Written Language 88 21 Basic Reading Skills 95 38 Reading Composition 94 34 Math Calculation Skills 97 43 Math Reasoning 109 73 Basic Writing Skills 91 28 Written Expression 89 24 Academic Skills 94 34 Academic Fluency 82 11 Academic Applications 102 55 Academic Knowledge 84 14 Phoneme/Grapheme Know 103 59 Letter-Word Identification 93 33 Reading Fluency 84 14 Story Recall 116 86 Understanding Directions 114 82 Calculation 102 56 Math Fluency 82 82 Spelling 89 24 Writing Fluency 82 11 Passage Comprehension 91 28 Applied Problems 116 85 Writing Samples 103 59 Word Attack 98 45 Picture Vocabulary 88 21 Oral Comprehension 102 56 Reading Vocabulary 100 49 Quantitative Concepts 104 61 Academic Knowledge 84 14 Spelling of Sounds 114 83 Sound Awareness 108 71

In comparing STUDENT’s scores on the WJ-III with his score of 118 on the WISC-IV administered by Dr. Humphrey, there is a difference of more than 1.5 standard deviations in the following academic areas set forth in Education Code section 56337(a): oral expression, written expression, basic reading skills, and reading comprehension. (Footnote 12) In addition, there is a difference of more than 1.5 standard deviations as measured by several WJ-III achievement clusters or subtests including Total Achievement, Broad Reading, Broad Written Language, Basic Writing Skills, and Reading Fluency. These discrepancies are corroborated by STUDENT’s performance in school. Specifically, on his progress report for the first quarter of the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT received scores of “partially proficient” in the following subjects: reading, writing, and speaking, which correspond to the aforementioned academic areas where the discrepancies appear. STUDENT’s third-grade teachers testified that STUDENT requires additional assistance in the areas of reading fluency, writing, and spelling. Specifically, Pamela Flait, one of STUDENT’s third-grade teachers, testified that STUDENT is in a reading fluency workshop and a writing workshop because he is having difficulties in these areas. She also testified that she provides STUDENT with individual attention to work on his spelling, which is also an area of difficulty for him. STUDENT’s other third-grade teacher, Karen Arsenault, testified that STUDENT is one of the slower readers in class and requires extra time to complete individual assignments.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT exhibits a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the academic areas of oral expression, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and reading fluency.

(b) Disorder in Basic Psychological Processes

The Hearing Officer must determine whether STUDENT’s severe discrepancies in the areas of oral expression, written expression, basic reading skills, reading fluency, and reading comprehension continue to be the result of a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. New assessments were administered to STUDENT in 2004 by Dr. Humphrey, Dr. Pobanz, and Gail Hallenberg, the District’s speech and language therapist. Student maintains that he continues to exhibit a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and that he also has a disorder in the area of attention. The District maintains that Student does not have a disorder in any basic psychological process.

Cognitive Ability of Expression

Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT continues to exhibit a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and continues to exhibit a reading disability. She testified that the criteria for a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression is outlined by the DSM-IV as including difficulty in finding words, articulating thoughts, and the efficiency of the communication process. She testified that the more recent results from testing conducted by herself, Gail Hallenberg, and Dr. Pobanz demonstrate that STUDENT still meets these criteria. Specifically, she cited STUDENT’s standard score of 88 on the Picture Vocabulary subtest of the WJ-III achievement tests administered by Dr. Pobanz in September 2004. She also pointed to STUDENT’s performance on the Language Processing Test-Revised (LPT-R), which measures a student’s ability to organize information and make sense of what he or she hears. STUDENT’s scores on the Associations subtest and the Multiple Meanings subtest were both significantly below average and more than 1.5 standard deviations below the mean. Dr. Humphrey also relied upon STUDENT’s score on the Rapid Automatic Naming subtest of the CELF-III, which she stated demonstrates his difficulty with word retrieval. In her report, she states that STUDENT continues to demonstrate difficulties in phonological processing. In her December 2004 report, Dr. Humphrey noted that STUDENT’s performance on the verbal comprehension index of the WISC-IV intelligence tests revealed that he has considerable difficulties expressing his ideas on these tests, which require answering questions requiring reasoning and common sense. She found that STUDENT continues to demonstrate markers of language-based learning disabilities in reading and writing, in spite of intensive reading intervention.

Dr. Dunn testified that STUDENT does not have a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. She based her opinion on STUDENT’s performance on the CELF-III. Specifically, she compared STUDENT’s performance on the CELF-III administered by Dr. Humphrey in May 2003 with his performance on the CELF-III administered by Ms. Hallenberg in September 2004. She testified that STUDENT’s scores from the CELF-III administered by Dr. Humphrey in May 2003 displayed a significant difference between his expressive language score of 94 and his receptive language score of 114. She compared these scores to STUDENT’s scores from the CELF-III administered by Gail Hallenberg in September 2004, on which STUDENT received a score of 108 for receptive language and a score of 116 for expressive language. She pointed out that the gap between the expressive and receptive language scores has narrowed and no longer constitutes a significant difference. In addition, she pointed out that STUDENT’s expressive language score is now higher than his receptive score.

In September 2004, Michael Pobanz, Ph.D., a District school psychologist, conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Pobanz administered the following assessments: the Conner’s Rating Scale, the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), the WJ-III Tests of Cognitive Abilities and Tests of Achievement, the Test of Memory and Learning (TOMAL), and the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP). In his report, Dr. Pobanz stated that two factors are affecting STUDENT’s learning: (1) his language deficit, including word retrieval from lexicon, multiple meanings, and word associations and (2) his consequent difficulty in fluency in reading and writing. According to Dr. Pobanz, STUDENT exhibits a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of broad reading, broad writing, and academic knowledge, as tested on the WJ-III Tests of Achievement. He testified that these discrepancies appear to be due to language processing deficits in retrieval of vocabulary/lexicon and that STUDENT appears to qualify for special education services under the category of speech and language impairment. He did not find that STUDENT exhibits a processing disorder in the cognitive ability of expression.

The evidence supports a finding that STUDENT continues to manifest a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, as well as a related reading disorder. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Dr. Humphrey most persuasive on this issue. Dr. Humphrey has personally administered a variety of assessments to STUDENT on three separate occasions between May of 2003 and December 2004. She has therefore been able to personally observe STUDENT’s performance on the assessments, whereas Dr. Dunn has never administered any assessments to STUDENT and has instead based her opinions on the reports of other psychologists and educational professionals. Moreover, Dr. Humphrey’s findings are corroborated by Dr. Pobanz’s observations that STUDENT’s language deficits contribute to his difficulty in fluency in reading and writing. Finally, STUDENT’s performance in the areas of reading, writing, speaking, and history/social science, in which he received scores of “partially proficient” for the first half of the 2004-2005 school year, all corroborate the existence of a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression. As set forth above, Karen Arsenault, one of STUDENT’s third-grade teachers, testified that STUDENT is one of the slowest readers in her class and requires additional assistance with writing and spelling.

Finally, both Dr. Humphrey and Dr. Dunn credibly testified that any processing disorder that exists is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and his reading disability are not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage.

Attention

Student maintains that he has a disorder in the area of attention. The District contends that STUDENT does not have such a disorder. As previously set forth, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT did not have a disorder in the area of attention during the 2003-2004 school year.

MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, testified that she consulted with three different psychiatrists in 2004, all of whom concurred that STUDENT has attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). According to MOTHER, STUDENT was prescribed a medication called Medidate by one of his psychiatrists in September or October of 2004. She testified that it is easier for him to focus now and that his reading has improved since he was put on the medication.

Pamela Flait and Karen Arsenault are STUDENT’s teachers in third grade for the 2004-2005 school year. Ms. Flait testified that STUDENT does not have any difficulty with attention, “spacing out,” or staying in his seat. Ms. Arsenault testified that STUDENT is focused on classroom activities most of the time and that she has observed him “looking out into space” only approximately four times per week. She also stated that she repeats directions to him in class only two to three times per week.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not currently exhibit a disorder in the area of attention. While MOTHER testified regarding her consultations with psychiatrists and the medication prescription provided by one of them, none of these psychiatrists testified at hearing, nor were any of their records presented as evidence in this hearing to explain the basis of the diagnosis for ADHD and the prescription for medication. Moreover, the testimony of STUDENT’s third grade teachers supports a finding that STUDENT does not display any significant attention problems. This testimony is consistent with that of STUDENT’s teachers in prior school years. Finally, as previously discussed in the section addressing processing disorders for the 2003-2004 school year, the results of assessments measuring STUDENT’s attention do not indicate a significant attention problem.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies continue to be due to a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression and related reading disability. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have a disorder in the area of attention.

(c) Discrepancy Cannot be Corrected Through Other Regular or Categorical Services Offered Within the Regular Instructional Program

Student contends that the regular education services provided to him continue to be an inadequate means for correcting his severe discrepancies. The District contends that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies can and are being corrected through regular education services.

Pam Flait is one of STUDENT’s third-grade teachers for the 2004-2005 school year. Ms. Flait has taught elementary and middle school classes since 1973. She currently teaches STUDENT math and language arts, and Karen Arsenault teaches him social studies and science. STUDENT’s progress report for the first half of the 2004-2005 school year indicates that he received scores of “partially proficient” in the following subjects: reading, writing, speaking, and history/social science. Ms. Flait testified that she uses the Open Court curriculum for reading. According to Ms. Flait, the students are separated into reading workshop groups three days per week based upon their areas of weakness. She testified that STUDENT is in the reading fluency group because this is an area of need for him. Similar groups exist for writing and STUDENT is in a writing workshop. She testified that she pulls STUDENT out for individual attention to work on spelling. According to Ms. Flait, STUDENT also receives accommodations in class that include a seat in the front of the class, extra time to complete assignments and tests, and repeated directions for assignments if needed.

Ms. Arsenault has taught elementary school classes in the District since 1981. She also testified regarding the accommodations provided to STUDENT. She testified that STUDENT sits close to her in class so that she can make sure he understands directions and assignments. She testified that she repeats directions for STUDENT in class two to three times per week. She stated that STUDENT also requires extra time to complete individual assignments. According to Ms. Arsenault, STUDENT has problems with reading fluency and is one of the slower readers in class.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies in reading, writing, and oral expression are still not being corrected by the instruction and accommodations provided to STUDENT in the classroom. Despite the extra help and accommodations, STUDENT is performing below grade level in these areas at school and continues to be one of the slower readers in his class despite his superior cognitive ability. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s severe discrepancies cannot be corrected in the regular education environment. (Footnote 13)

ISSUE NO. 4: If STUDENT is eligible for special education, what programs or services does he require in order to receive a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year?

As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT is currently eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability and has been eligible since the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. In addition, the District has conceded that STUDENT is eligible for special education as an SLI student.

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8).)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id.) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).) A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).) The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.)

Finally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56342(b).) 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must meet the following three substantive requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program. It must: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; and (3) comport with his IEP. Finally, the placement must be in the least restrictive environment.

In this case, an IEP has not yet been developed and the District has not offered STUDENT any special education programs or related services for the 2004-2005 school year. Student contends that the District has denied him a FAPE during the time he has been eligible for special education and maintains that he currently requires the following programs and services: 1) educational therapy, 2) reading specialist services, 3) language therapy, 4) extended school year services, 5) psychological counseling, and 6) prospective placement in a small classroom with typical peers, opportunities for intensive one-to-one teaching, and a focus on strategies for students with learning disorders. (Footnote 14) The District contends that STUDENT is only eligible for special education under the category of speech and language impairment and that STUDENT requires two thirty-minute sessions of speech and language therapy per week to address his language processing issues. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will limit his FAPE analysis to a determination as to whether STUDENT requires the aforementioned programs and services to meet his unique educational need and to provide him a program reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and to a determination as to the least restrictive environment for STUDENT’s education.

STUDENT’s Unique Needs (1) Educational Therapy

In his issue statement, Student asserts that he is entitled to prospective services in the form of educational therapy. However, during the course of the hearing, Student did not clarify what the educational therapy would consist of, nor was any evidence presented that he requires such therapy to meet his unique educational needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require educational therapy to meet his unique needs.

(2) Reading Specialist Services

Dr. Humphrey testified that the remediation provided to STUDENT in his class is not working and that STUDENT requires intensive programs to address his reading and language needs. In her report dated April 30, 2004, she states that STUDENT has shown strong benefit from the LMB program but that the results indicate the ongoing need for work with concept imagery, as well as reading fluency and reading automaticity. She testified that his reading remediation programs must be consistently implemented to remedy his language deficits and that there were gaps in time between STUDENT’s LMB program during the 2003-2004 school year that may have rendered it less effective. She recommends that he continue to receive intensive, individual intervention in the areas of concept imagery, reading fluency, and reading automaticity. In her report, she recommends that STUDENT also receive at least eight hours per week of resource support in reading.

Niki Jakins, the clinical director for LMB, has a master’s degree in educational psychology and has been employed at LMB for six years. She testified that the LMB programs address students’ language processing needs, including reading, spelling, comprehension, and critical thinking, through intensive daily intervention. According to Ms. Jakins, the LMB programs are research based and are designed to teach the students different processing strategies. Ms. Jakins testified that LMB instructors administered fifteen tests to STUDENT in July 2003, before STUDENT’s LMB program began, to determine the level of his language processing skills. In reviewing STUDENT’s scores on these initial tests, she found that STUDENT experienced difficulty in decoding, reading comprehension, and reading fluency and recommended that STUDENT participate in an eighty-hour “Seeing Stars” program, which focused on strengthening phonemic awareness and symbol imagery to allow STUDENT to use visual imagery to read and decode words in isolation, build his sight word vocabulary, and read a page in context. STUDENT attended this program during July and August of 2003.

Ms. Jakins testified that STUDENT was retested after receiving eighty hours of instruction and that he demonstrated improvement on assessments that focus on decoding, which was the focus of the initial eighty hour program that STUDENT attended. She cited the following assessment results as demonstrating improvement in STUDENT’s decoding abilities: the Word Attack subtest on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, where STUDENT moved from a grade level of 3.4 to a grade level of 4.6 and from the 71st percentile to the 84th percentile; the Slosson Oral Reading Test, where STUDENT progressed from a grade level of 1.6 to a grade level of 1.7; and the GORT-4, on which STUDENT’s reading accuracy rate increased from the 16th to the 37th percentile and from a grade level of 1.2 to a grade level of 2.2, his reading fluency increased from the 9th to the 16th percentile and from below a first grade level to a first grade level, and his reading comprehension increased from the 37th percentile to the 63rd percentile and from the second to the third grade level. According to Ms. Jakins, STUDENT attended fifteen more hours of the Seeing Stars program during the summer of 2003 and then discontinued the program when school started.

Ms. Jakins testified that STUDENT received forty-eight more hours of treatment in the Seeing Stars program at LMB during the winter break of the 2003-2004 school year. On December 22, 2003, STUDENT was assessed at the beginning of this 48-hour program. According to Ms. Jakins, LMB did not retest STUDENT after this 48-hour program because LMB usually only retests a student after a program of at least four weeks or eighty hours in duration.

During the summer of 2004, STUDENT received another sixty-four hours of treatment in LMB’s Seeing Stars phonemic awareness/symbol imagery program. STUDENT was pretested on June 28, 2004, and retested on August 24, 2004. The testing report compares STUDENT’s performance on the same assessment tools utilized in the LMB testing during the summer of 2003 both before and after the 64-hour program. On the assessments cited by Ms. Jakins as measuring decoding, STUDENT performed as follows: on the Word Attack subtest on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, STUDENT declined from a grade level of 7.4 to a grade level of 6.4 and from the 93rd percentile to the 83rd percentile; on the Slosson Oral Reading Test, STUDENT progressed from a grade level of 3.4 to a grade level of 3.8; and on the GORT-4, STUDENT’s accuracy increased from 16th to the 50th percentile and from a grade level of 2.2 to a grade level of 3.4. His fluency increased from the 9th to the 16th percentile and from the 1.7 grade level to the 2.2 grade level, and his comprehension decreased from the 63rd percentile to the 25th percentile and from a grade level of 4.2 to a grade level of 2.4.

Ms. Jakins testified that STUDENT requires continued treatment with LMB’s Seeing Stars and Visualizing and Verbalizing programs to strengthen his phonemic awareness and symbol imagery, and allow him to use visual imagery to read and decode words in isolation and build his sight word vocabulary. She testified that imagery is important for reading because it helps one retain information and understand what is being read, and that the LMB programs will strengthen his ability to read independently and automatically at grade level. According to Ms. Jakins, STUDENT’s instruction in these areas must be intensive and daily. She recommends that STUDENT participate in a program four hours per day, five days per week for a total of 180-220 hours. At the end of this period, STUDENT should be retested to determine whether his reading is automatic and independent at grade level, which is the goal of the program.

Dr. Dunn testified that she has not been trained in LMB’s programs, but that she has reviewed LMB assessment reports before and is familiar with the assessment tools used by LMB to measure STUDENT’s progress. She testified that STUDENT’s scores on the majority of the assessments administered by LMB before and after its treatment programs demonstrate that the program has not significantly improved STUDENT’s achievement. She testified that an increase in a standard score of less than one standard deviation, which would be 15 points on a test with a mean of 100, does not represent a significant change. She compared STUDENT’s scores on the “pre-test” administered on June 28, 2004, with the scores on the re-test. According to Dr. Dunn, there were significant increases of more than one standard deviation on only two subtests: Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-2 (Oral Directions) and the GORT-4 (Accuracy). Dr. Dunn also compared STUDENT’s scores on the re-test administered on August 22, 2003, with the scores on the re-test administered August 24, 2004, and found significant increases of more than one standard deviation on only one subtest of the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-2 (Oral Directions).

The Hearing Officer does not find the testimony of Student’s witnesses or the District’s witnesses persuasive on the issue of how to address STUDENT’s severe discrepancy in reading fluency. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the District’s witnesses that STUDENT does not need any specialized reading assistance to address his fluency issues unpersuasive. The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT has deficits in the areas of reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding and that the programs and services available in regular education are not correcting these deficits. At the same time, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that a reading remediation program such as Lindamood-Bell is the appropriate or only means of addressing this area of deficit. STUDENT’s parents provided him with approximately 192 hours of LMB reading remediation programs between June 2003 and August 2004, over one hundred hours more than Dr. Humphrey initially recommended during her testimony in the first hearing. While STUDENT demonstrated at least some improvement in his achievement test scores following the LMB programs, he remained below grade level in reading fluency during the 2003-2004 school year and is currently below grade level in reading, writing, and speaking. Moreover, there was no persuasive evidence that the LMB programs offer the only methodology that can address STUDENT’s reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding deficits. As long as the school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left to the school’s discretion. (Student v. Monterey Peninsula School District, SEHO Case No. SN02-02753, 38 IDELR 223 (2003) (citing Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200, 208).) .

The evidence demonstrates that STUDENT requires daily specialized instruction to address his reading fluency deficits. This instruction should be provided in a small group setting with the opportunity for individual instruction with a special education teacher. The evidence further demonstrates that STUDENT requires support for reading in other subject areas such as science and social science. STUDENT’s reading instruction could be provided through a resource specialist program on a pull out basis, through an after school program at his school, or at another site. The Hearing Officer orders the IEP team to meet and determine the appropriate program and services to provide STUDENT with daily specialized instruction in reading and support for reading in the other subject areas that require reading.

(3) Speech and Language Therapy

Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT requires language therapy to address deficits in his oral and written expression including vocabulary building, word-finding abilities, language organization, and fluidity of expression. She testified that he has difficulty hearing the individual sounds in words, understanding basic word structures, and organizing his expressive language. She recommends two hours of speech and language therapy per week to address these areas.

In September 2004, Gail Hallenberg, the District’s speech and language therapist, conducted a speech and language evaluation of STUDENT pursuant to the orders issued by the Court and the Hearing Officer. In her report, she notes that STUDENT’s overall performance on formal standardized testing measures was inconsistent, with subtest scores ranging from the 5th percentile to the 98th percentile. According to Ms. Hallenberg, STUDENT obtained scores that are greater than 1.5 standard deviations below the mean on two subtests of the Language Processing Test, and a score that is significantly below criteria on the Rapid Automatic Naming subtest of the CELF. Ms. Hallenberg also stated that the extended time STUDENT required during the testing to complete the required items should be considered. She found that STUDENT meets the requirements for eligibility for special education under the category of SLI. At hearing, she recommended that STUDENT receive two thirty-minute sessions of speech and language therapy per week to improve his word retrieval abilities through drilling exercises and to provide him with strategies he can use to compensate for his word-finding deficits.

The evidence supports a finding that STUDENT requires speech and language services to address his language processing deficits. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded, however, that STUDENT requires two hours of therapy per week to address his deficits. Dr. Humphrey, who is not a credentialed speech and language therapist, did not provide any persuasive testimony as to why STUDENT requires such a significant amount of therapy per week. The Hearing Officer found persuasive Ms. Hallenberg’s testimony that STUDENT requires two thirty minute sessions of speech and language therapy per week to meet his educational needs. Ms. Hallenberg is a speech and language therapist with six years of experience providing speech and language therapy and assessing speech and language needs. She personally assessed STUDENT in September 2004 using valid standardized assessments designed to measure STUDENT’s speech and language skills. Dr. Humphrey testified that Ms. Hallenberg administered appropriate language assessments, including the Language Processing Test-Revised. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires two thirty-minute sessions of speech and language therapy to address his deficits in vocabulary building, word-finding abilities, language organization, and fluidity of expression. There was no testimony regarding the appropriate form of delivery for STUDENT’s speech and language services. Different forms of delivery include one-to-one therapy, group therapy, and “push in” therapy in which the entire class participates in the session. Because there is insufficient evidence regarding the available methods of delivering the therapy and the method or methods that would be appropriate for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer leaves the determination as to the form of delivering his speech and language therapy to the IEP team.

Student contends that such language therapy should be provided by a nonpublic agency because the District cannot provide the type of therapy he requires to address his language needs. The Hearing Officer finds, however, that there is no persuasive evidence to even suggest that the District’s language therapists lack the ability to address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of vocabulary building, word-finding abilities, language organization, and fluidity of expression. Accordingly, Student’s request for language therapy through a nonpublic agency is denied.

(4) ESY Services

In his issue statement, Student contends that he requires prospective services in the form of ESY services to meet his unique educational needs and receive a FAPE.

Extended school year programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. (Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).) In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2).) Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii).)

In this case, the evidence established that the nature of STUDENT’s disability is such that the possibility of serious regression exists over the summer months and that he requires special education and related services during this summer. STUDENT received intensive reading remediation programs through LMB during the summer of 2003, in December 2003, and during the summer of 2004. Despite these programs, STUDENT’s reading fluency remained below grade level during the 2003-2004 school year. In this current school year, STUDENT continued to have a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of oral expression, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and reading fluency and is below grade level in reading, writing, and speaking. The number of academic areas in which STUDENT exhibits a severe discrepancy is increasing. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT requires ESY services during the 2005 ESY to address his areas of deficit and to prevent serious regression. The Hearing Officer has insufficient information regarding the nature and extent of the ESY programs available on which to determine the appropriate ESY placement. The evidence supports a finding, however, that STUDENT’s ESY should include daily specialized reading instruction to address his deficits in the areas of reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding and should also include two thirty-minute sessions of speech and language therapy to address his deficits in vocabulary building, word-finding abilities, language organization, and fluidity of expression. Given the lack of evidence regarding the nature and extent of the ESY programs and the methods of service delivery available, the Hearing Officer leaves the determination as to an appropriate ESY program and the appropriate method to deliver the specialized reading instruction and speech and language services to the IEP team.

(5) Psychological Counseling

In his issue statement, Student contends that he requires prospective services in the form of psychological counseling to meet his educational needs.

In December 2002, Dr. Eichenstein administered emotional and personality testing to STUDENT, including House-Tree-Person, the Children’s Anxiety Questionaire-RCMAS, and the Children’s Apperception Test. In her December 2002 report, she found that STUDENT demonstrated elevated levels of anxiety in the category of worry and oversensitivity and that many of his projective stories were reflective of trauma, such as a bad man theme or a house on fire. (Footnote 15) Dr. Eichenstein concluded that STUDENT suffered from a generalized anxiety disorder secondary to posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) related to the school shooting and recommended that STUDENT receive psychotherapy in the form of play therapy. In the first hearing, Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT was struggling with PTSD subsequent to his involvement in the nursery school shooting incident which occurred in 1999, when STUDENT was three years old. She did not administer behavior assessments to STUDENT but relied upon the results of assessments administered by Dr. Eichensten. Dr. Humphrey recommended that STUDENT receive short-term cognitive behavior therapy with a specialist in child trauma to address these symptoms.

In the second hearing, Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT continues to be a sensitive and anxious child. In her report dated April 30, 2004, she states that questionnaires of social/emotional behavior completed by his mother yielded mild elevations on the anxious/depressed scale and the thought problems scale. She recommended that STUDENT’s parents consult with a child psychiatrist to address possible PTSD.

During the second hearing, STUDENT’s mother testified that during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT frequently told her that he did not want to go to school. She testified that during the 2003-2004 school year, he stopped telling her that he did not want to go to school but did tell her that he did not want school to be so hard. STUDENT also testified during the second hearing. He indicated that he likes school but that he finds reading difficult and that it takes him longer to read sometimes.

In September 2004, Dr. Pobanz provided STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT’s second grade teacher with the Conner’s Rating Scale and the Behavior Assessment System for Children. (Footnote 16) In his report dated September 27, 2004, he states that both STUDENT’s parents and Candace Bowen, his second grade teacher, rated him in the average range on all of the clinical and adaptive scales of the BASC, which measures several areas of behavior, including anxiety. On the Conner’s, STUDENT’s parents and Ms. Bowen rated STUDENT in the average range for all of the categories, including oppositional behavior, inattention, hyperactivity, and the attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) index.

Thus, the most recent behavioral assessments and observations indicate that STUDENT is in the average to mildly-elevated range in the area of anxiety and that his attitude towards school is improving. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT does not require the related service of psychological counseling to meet his educational needs.

(6) Educational Placement

Student contends that he requires placement in a small classroom with typical peers, opportunities for intensive one-to-one teaching, and a focus on strategies for students with learning disorders.

As set forth above, Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT requires a specialized reading program to address his reading fluency issues and language therapy to address his vocabulary and word-finding difficulties. She testified that she has not been to Van Gogh, STUDENT’s school, and does not know what the school offers in terms of programs to address these areas of need. She also testified that another alternative would be placement in a nonpublic school for children with language or reading-based disabilities, such as Summit View, Frostig, or Westmark. STUDENT’s mother testified that she would like to have him placed at Frostig, because it incorporates Lindamood Bell reading remediation programs into the curriculum. The Student did not, however, identify any particular school or placement as his requested prospective placement.

The District did not present any evidence regarding the appropriate placement for STUDENT in the event he is found eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability. Instead, the District argued that STUDENT is eligible for special education as a student with SLI and that an IEP meeting should be held to determine appropriate services for him.

In determining the type of placement STUDENT requires, the Hearing Officer notes that special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56342(b).) As noted earlier, 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

In determining whether a placement is the least restrictive environment, the Ninth Circuit has indicated four factors need to be considered. Those factors include: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to educational benefits of a special education classroom, (2) the non-academic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with nonhandicapped children, (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom, and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. (Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 1207, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)

As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT requires specialized reading instruction and speech and language therapy to meet his unique educational needs. The Hearing Officer has insufficient information on which to determine the specific educational placement and appropriate method for delivering services to STUDENT. Based on the information presented at hearing, however, it is clear that the nature of STUDENT’s disability is such that continued education in regular classes with the use of supplementary services and resource specialist programs can meet his needs and provide educational benefit, particularly in a large school district with a variety of programs and services available, such as the District. Given STUDENT’s superior cognitive ability, he would benefit more academically from an educational placement and program which includes regular education classes along with specialized assistance to address his areas of deficit, rather than placement in a special day class. Similarly, STUDENT would benefit from a placement and program which affords him continued opportunities to interact with typically developing peers for the majority of his school day. The evidence also supports a finding that STUDENT’s presence in a regular education classroom would not have an adverse impact on either the teacher or the other students in the classroom. Specifically, all of the teachers who have testified regarding STUDENT have described him as a personable and hard working student. Finally, no evidence was presented regarding the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream STUDENT in a regular classroom setting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot address this fourth component of the LRE analysis. Given the lack of evidence regarding the nature and extent of the placements and the methods of service delivery available in the District, the Hearing Officer leaves the determination as to the specific placement and the appropriate methods to deliver the specialized reading instruction and speech and language services to the IEP team, with consideration of the foregoing findings.

****

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires the following services to receive a FAPE: (1) daily specialized reading instruction to address his deficits in reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding, (2) two thirty-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy to address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of vocabulary building, word-finding abilities, language organization, and fluidity of expression, and (3) an ESY program and services for the 2005 ESY. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require educational therapy, LMB services, two hours per week of speech and language therapy by an NPA, psychological counseling, or placement in a nonpublic school with only disabled children to receive a FAPE during the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year.

ISSUE NO. 5: Are STUDENT and his parents entitled to remedies in the form of reimbursement for privately obtained Lindamood-Bell programs and independent educational evaluations, and compensatory education in the form of educational therapy, language therapy, reading specialist services, and psychological counseling services?

Student contends that his parents are entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained LMB programs that he attended during the summer of 2003, December 2003, and the summer of 2004. He also contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Humphrey in December 2003, February 2004, April 2004, and December 2004. In addition, Student contends that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of speech and language services for the period of time he has been eligible for special education to remedy the lack of such services during that time. The District contends that Student is not entitled to the remedies of reimbursement or compensatory education.

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 131 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. (Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F. 2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).) In Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court expressly exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the State. (Id. at 13-14.) The Court recognized, however, that the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as provide a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provide the student educational benefit. (Id.) In summary, to be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private services, it must be determined that 1) the student was denied a FAPE, and 2) the student’s private placement or program addresses the student’s educational needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him or her with educational benefit.

A. Reimbursement for Lindamood-Bell Programs

STUDENT attended LMB programs in the summer of 2003, December 2003, and the summer of 2004. The Hearing Officer has found that the District knew or should have known that STUDENT’s deficits in the area of reading were not being corrected through the regular education program by January of 2004 and that the evidence supports a finding that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria under the category of specific learning disability by that time. The evidence establishes that the LMB programs obtained by STUDENT’s parents were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit by addressing his deficits in the areas of reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding and that the programs provided him with at least some benefit. Specifically, the evidence established that STUDENT demonstrated some improvement in the area of decoding, which was the primary focus of the LMB programs that STUDENT attended, as evidenced by STUDENT’s scores on the pre-tests and re-tests administered by LMB.

Because STUDENT was eligible for special education beginning in January of 2004 and his needs in the area of reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding were not being met, he has been denied a FAPE from that date to the present. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the LMB program STUDENT attended in the summer of 2004. STUDENT’s parents are also entitled to reimbursement for mileage at the District rate for transporting STUDENT to and from his LMB programs. STUDENT’s parents are not, however, entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s programs during the summer of 2003 and December 2003 because STUDENT was not eligible for special education until January of 2004 and, therefore, no denial of FAPE occurred until January 2004.

B. Reimbursement for Independent Educational Evaluations

Student contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for two independent educational evaluations conducted by Dr. Humphrey in December 2003, February 2004, and December 2004. However, Student does not identify the basis on which he is entitled to reimbursement, other than the assertion that the District utilized an inappropriate assessment to measure his cognitive ability in September 2004. During the prehearing conference, Student’s counsel stated that the only District assessment at issue in this hearing was the GIA cognitive assessment administered by Dr. Pobanz in September 2004.

California Education Code section 56329(b) and (c) provides that a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation.

In this case, Student appears to be seeking reimbursement for two assessments. The assessment that resulted in a written report in April 2004, however, was procured before Student received the District’s reports from the assessments conducted in September 2004 by Gail Hallenberg, the District’s speech and language therapist, and Dr. Pobanz, the District’s school psychologist. Specifically, Dr. Humphrey’s assessment in December 2003 and February 2004, and the resulting written report in April 2004, was obtained well before Dr. Pobanz and Ms. Hallenberg administered their assessments and well before the Court issued its order in July 2004 requiring the District to conduct new assessments. In Student v. San Dieguito Union High School District, SEHO Case No. SN02-01363, the hearing officer denied reimbursement for independent assessments procured before the school district completed its assessments. In Student v. Redlands Unified School District, SEHO Case No. SN03-00953, the hearing officer denied reimbursement for independent assessments procured before the parents received the District’s assessment reports. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s parents could not have disagreed with the District’s September 2004 assessment reports prior to the time they sought the first independent evaluation and the resulting written report by Dr. Humphrey, because the District’s 2004 assessments had not been administered yet. Accordingly, Student is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Humphrey’s assessment in December 2003 and February 2004, and her written report in April 2004.

Student also seeks reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation conducted by Dr. Humphrey on December 4, 2004. On this date, Dr. Humphrey administered the WISC-IV to measure STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. STUDENT’s mother did not testify as to why she had Dr. Humphrey administer the WISC-IV in December. The Hearing Officer must determine whether the District’s cognitive assessment of STUDENT in September 2004 was appropriate.

California Education Code section 56320, subsections (a) through (d), states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; validated for the purposes for which they are used; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; tailored to assess specific areas of need; and selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. Section 56320(g) states that the assessments must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student’s disability. California Education Code section 56322 also requires that the assessments be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments. Additionally, California Education Code section 56324 requires that a credentialed school psychologist perform any psychological assessment.

Dr. Humphrey testified that she disagreed with the District’s decision to administer the GIA, which is the Woodcock-Johnson cognitive ability assessment, as a measure of STUDENT’s cognitive ability. Dr. Humphrey testified that the GIA score is weighted according to the various areas tested, and the language components of the test are weighted more heavily at STUDENT’s age level. Dr. Humphrey testified that STUDENT’s low scores on the language subtests of the GIA were the result of deficits in the area of language processing and that these low scores resulted in a lower overall cognitive ability score on the GIA. According to Dr. Humphrey, the weighted score on the GIA eliminates the severe discrepancy between ability and achievement because the ability score will be lower.

Dr. Dunn testified that the GIA is a more reliable measure of STUDENT’s cognitive ability because it is co-normed with the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test. Dr. Dunn explained that co-norming means that the two tests are developed using the same normative sample and that the correlation of the ability and achievement tests is therefore more reliable. In addition, Dr. Dunn testified that the GIA score is a better measure of cognitive ability because it was administered to STUDENT most closely in time to the administration of the WJ-III Tests of Achievement and, therefore, would provide the most accurate estimate of STUDENT’s ability level at that time.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s use of the GIA to measure STUDENT’s cognitive ability was inappropriate given his language processing deficits. As previously discussed, the Hearing Officer elected to utilize STUDENT’s score on the WISC-IV as the measure of his cognitive ability for the 2004-2005 school year. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Dr. Humphrey persuasive regarding the inappropriateness of the GIA as an assessment tool to measure STUDENT’s cognitive ability, given STUDENT’s suspected impairments in language skills. The GIA produced a statistically lower score and the Hearing Officer utilized the WISC-IV score as the measure of cognitive ability because it is more consistent with STUDENT’s prior cognitive ability scores. Moreover, the evidence establishes that Dr. Pobanz, who administered the GIA to STUDENT, should have been on notice that STUDENT’s cognitive score on the GIA was not reliable and that a different cognitive measure should be administered once he received the results of Ms. Hallenberg’s speech and language assessment, in which she finds STUDENT eligible for special education as speech and language impaired.

As mentioned previously, Education Code section 56320(d) provides, in pertinent part, that assessments must be selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired speaking skills. The evidence demonstrates that the use of the GIA to measure STUDENT’s cognitive ability violated Education Code section 56329(d) because it affords greater weight to STUDENT’s impaired language skills, which are impacted by his language processing disorder, and therefore his score may not accurately reflect his cognitive abilities. (Footnote 17) Because the District’s assessment was inappropriate, Student is entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Humphrey’s cognitive ability assessment administered in December 2004.

C. Compensatory Education

Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. (Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991).) There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated with the meaning of the IDEA.” (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).)

In his issue statement, Student asserted that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of educational therapy, language therapy, reading specialist services, and psychological counseling services. In his closing brief, Student contends that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of speech and language services. Because it is unclear whether Student still contends that he is entitled to the other forms of compensatory education identified in his issue statement, the Hearing Officer will address each of these areas.

1. Educational Therapy

During the course of the hearing, Student did not clarify what he meant by educational therapy or what it would consist of, nor was any evidence presented that he requires such therapy as compensatory education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education in the form of educational therapy.

2. Speech and Language Therapy

Student contends that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of speech and language services for the period of time he has been eligible for special education. The District contends that Student is not entitled to compensatory education.

As set forth above, the evidence establishes that STUDENT requires one hour per week of speech and language therapy per week to address his language deficits. Neither party presented any evidence, however, as to the amount of compensatory speech and language therapy STUDENT requires to ensure that he is appropriately educated with the meaning of the IDEA. In his closing brief, Student contends that he is entitled to two hundred hours of compensatory speech and language therapy. He bases this calculation on two hours of therapy per week for the past two and one half years of school during which he claimed that he has been eligible. As set forth in this Decision, however, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education until January of 2004 and that he requires only one hour per week of speech and language therapy. The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not receive speech and language therapy for approximately forty-six weeks of school between January 2004 and the date of this Decision, which is equivalent to forty-six hours of speech and language therapy. This denial of necessary services was relatively recent and there was no indication during the hearing that it has caused sufficient detriment to require more compensatory time than that actually missed. Based upon the totality of the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of forty-six hours of compensatory speech and language therapy is appropriate. This compensatory speech and language therapy shall be completed by the end of the 2006 ESY.

There was no testimony regarding the appropriate form of delivery for STUDENT’s speech and language services. Different forms of delivery include one-to-one therapy, group therapy, and “push in” therapy in which the entire class participates in the session. Because there is insufficient evidence regarding the available methods of delivering the therapy and the method or methods that would be appropriate for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer leaves the determination as to the form of delivering his compensatory speech and language therapy to the IEP team.

3. Reading Specialist Services

Student contends that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of reading specialist services and Lindamood-Bell services. As previously set forth, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of specific learning disability beginning in January 2004 and that he requires daily specialized instruction in a small group setting with the opportunity for individual instruction to address his reading fluency deficits. The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT does not specifically require the LMB reading remediation programs to receive a FAPE.

The evidence supports a finding that STUDENT required specialized instruction in reading beginning in January 2004, when he became eligible for special education and that he did not receive these services from that date to the date of this Decision. Accordingly, STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education in the form of specialized reading instruction to make up for lost educational opportunity. However, neither party presented any persuasive evidence as to the amount of compensatory reading instruction STUDENT requires to ensure that he is appropriately educated with the meaning of the IDEA. The evidence establishes that STUDENT did not receive specialized reading instruction for approximately forty-six weeks of school between January 2004 and the date of this Decision, other than the LMB programs provided by his parents in the summer of 2004, for which the parents will be reimbursed. Based on the totality of the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of ninety two hours of compensatory specialized reading instruction, provided by a credentialed special education teacher and that addresses his deficits in reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding will provide STUDENT with an appropriate education. This award takes into account the reimbursement awarded to STUDENT and his parents for the sixty-four hours of LMB provided to STUDENT in the summer of 2004. The compensatory reading instruction awarded to STUDENT could be provided to him during his school day, after school, or during the summer. The Hearing Officer is concerned that too much remediation provided too quickly may prove to be overly burdensome to STUDENT and leaves to the IEP team the determination of how to appropriately fold this compensatory reading instruction into his instructional day. This compensatory reading instruction shall be completed by the end of the 2006 ESY.

4. Psychological Services

Student contends that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of psychological counseling services. As previously set forth, however, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT does not currently require psychological services to address anxiety because the most recent assessments and teacher observations indicate that STUDENT has an average to mildly elevated level of anxiety. Similarly, there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required psychological counseling at any time from January 2004, when he first became eligible for special education, to the date of this Decision. Accordingly, Student’s request for compensatory education in the form of psychological counseling services is denied.

**** In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the 2004 LMB program, but not for the 2003 programs. Student is also entitled to reimbursement for the cognitive ability assessment administered by Dr. Humphrey in December 2004, but is not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment and report by Dr. Humphrey in December 2003, February 2004, and April 2004. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is entitled to forty-six hours of compensatory speech and language therapy and ninety-two hours of specialized reading instruction, but is not entitled to compensatory education in the form of educational therapy or psychological counseling services.

ORDER

1. Within twenty calendar days, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to develop an IEP for STUDENT for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year. The IEP shall include a specific offer of placement in an instructional environment appropriate for STUDENT, taking into consideration his specific learning disability, speech and language impairment, and deficits in reading, written expression, and oral expression. STUDENT’s IEP shall also include daily specialized reading instruction which addresses STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding; reading support in STUDENT’s other subjects that involve reading; speech and language therapy two times per week, thirty minutes per session, to address STUDENT’s language processing deficits; and an ESY program which includes daily specialized reading instruction and speech and language therapy two times per week, thirty minutes per session. The IEP team shall also give serious consideration to maintaining STUDENT’s placement at Van Gogh, pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.552, subdivision (c), which states that in determining the placement of a child with a disability, unless the IEP requires some other arrangement, the child shall be educated in the school that he or she would attend if nondisabled.

2. The District shall provide STUDENT forty-six hours of compensatory speech and language therapy. The District shall also provide him with ninety-two hours of compensatory specialized reading instruction by a credentialed special education teacher that addresses his deficits in reading fluency, phonemic awareness, and decoding. All compensatory education shall be completed by the end of the 2006 ESY.

3. Within 30 days of receiving proof of the amounts paid by STUDENT’s parents, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of the Lindamood-Bell program they provided to STUDENT during the summer of 2004, including reimbursement for mileage at the District rate.

4. All of Student’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2002-2003 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2003-2004 school year?

The District prevailed from the beginning of the school year until January 2004. The Student prevailed on this issue from January 2004 until the end of the school year.

3. Should STUDENT have been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability during the 2004-2005 school year?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

4. If STUDENT is eligible for special education, what programs or services does he require to receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year?

The Student prevailed on this issue with respect to the specialized reading instruction and the ESY program. The Student partially prevailed with respect to the speech and language services. The District prevailed with respect to the educational therapy, LMB programs, and psychological counseling.

5. Are STUDENT and his parents entitled to remedies in the form of reimbursement for privately obtained Lindamood-Bell programs and independent educational evaluations, and compensatory education in the form of educational therapy, language therapy, reading specialist services, and psychological counseling services?

The District prevailed with respect to the issue of reimbursement for the 2003 LMB programs and the December 2003 and February 2004 independent assessment that resulted in a written report in April 2004. The Student prevailed with respect to the issue of reimbursement for the 2004 LMB program, the December 2004 independent educational evaluation, and the issue of compensatory education in the form of language therapy and reading specialist services. Student did not prevail with respect to his requests for compensatory education in the form of educational therapy, LMB services, and psychological services.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Date: March 3, 2005 ___________________________________ Christian P. Hurley, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

At the beginning of the first hearing, during the clarification of the issues, Student contended that his severe discrepancies were due to an auditory processing disorder. During the testimony of Student’s expert, Dr. Humphrey, Student dropped this contention and instead alleged that his severe discrepancies were caused by a disorder in the cognitive ability of expression, which is one of the psychological processes enumerated in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3030(j)(1).

2 MOTHER testified at hearing that she was told by District representatives that the assessments conducted in October 2001 would have to be addressed at the October 2002 IEP meeting before additional assessments could be undertaken.

3 Dr. Eichenstein did not administer the same test clusters and subtests on the WJ-III that Linda Hirsch administered in October 2002.

4 The IEP document dated February 25, 2003, reflects that the IEP meeting was originally scheduled for November 26, 2002, but was postponed on numerous occasions at the request of STUDENT’s mother to allow for outside assessments and the attendance of STUDENT’s prior teachers. No evidence was presented at hearing contradicting this statement.

5 In outlining STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the area of reading in the February 25, 2003 IEP, however, the District utilized the October 2002 scores despite having the December 2002 report of Dr. Eichenstein available at that meeting.

6 Under section 3030)(c)(4), an expressive language disorder which qualifies a student for special education services exists if, among other things, a student scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, on two or more standardized tests in at least one of the following areas of language development: morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics.

7 Ms. Himmelstein testified that STUDENT’s writing ability would have been above grade level but for his spelling. She stated that his spelling ability did not correspond with his strong writing ability, but described his spelling as age appropriate. She further testified that STUDENT’s spelling errors demonstrated that he was learning the rules of phonics because he spelled phonetically even when he misspelled a word, i.e., “bruther” instead of brother and “frend” instead of friend.

8 According to STUDENT’s progress report, “proficient” means “meets grade level standards.” The scores are defined as follows: “1” equals “not proficient,” “2” is “partially proficient,” “3” is “proficient,” and “4” is “advanced.”

9 The only evidence presented on this issue was facsimile correspondence purportedly from Student’s counsel to the District’s counsel dated August 18, 2004, which included a copy of Dr. Humphrey’s report.

10 Dr. Humphrey calculated STUDENT’s scores on the WJ-III using norms based on his grade at the time of testing (2.4) and his age at the time of testing (8.1). Dr. Dunn credibly testified that the test scores calculated using the grade-based norms are more appropriate to use because STUDENT spent two years in kindergarten, and using grade-based norms would result in his achievement being compared to students who were one grade ahead of him at the time of testing. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer will utilize the scores calculated with the grade-based norms for purposes of determining the existence of a severe discrepancy. Under either set of scores, a severe discrepancy in the area of reading fluency is apparent.

11 Utilizing STUDENT’s cognitive ability score of 120 and subtracting 22.5 (representing 1.5 standard deviations), any score below 97.5 constitutes a severe discrepancy between ability and achievment.

12 The difference between STUDENT’s cognitive ability score of 118 and his oral expression score of 91 is 27 points; for written expression, the difference is 29 points; for reading comprehension, the difference is 24 points; for reading fluency, the difference is 34 points--all of which constitute more than 1.5 standard deviations. Even if the District’s GIA score is used as the cognitive ability measure, STUDENT would still exhibit a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in several areas including broad reading, reading fluency, broad writing, and academic knowledge.

13 Several witnesses, including Dr. Humphrey, Dr. Dunn, Dr. Pobanz, and Gail Hallenberg, testified regarding the effectiveness of different special education programs and services in addressing and correcting STUDENT’s severe discrepancies. The Hearing Officer will address the issue of which programs and services STUDENT requires in a separate section of this Decision.

14 In his issue statement, Student requested prospective relief in the form of educational therapy services, a reading program, language therapy, extended school year services, and behavioral counseling. In his closing brief, Student requested prospective relief in the form of 220 hours of Lindamood-Bell reading remediation programs and placement in a small classroom with typical peers, opportunities for intensive one-to-one teaching, and a focus on strategies for students with learning disorders. Because it is unclear whether Student is still seeking the same relief as alleged in his issue statement, the Hearing Officer will address all of these proposed remedies.

15 Dr. Eichenstein did not testify at either the first or second hearing.

16 Dr. Pobanz testified that he did not provide these questionnaires to STUDENT’s current teacher because the 2004-2005 school year had just begun and he did not feel the teacher would have sufficient information about STUDENT’s behavior.

17 The District’s use of the GIA as the testing instrument to determine STUDENT’s cognitive ability does not impact the Hearing Officer’s ability to determine the existence of a severe discrepancy because the Hearing Officer has several other cognitive ability scores, including STUDENT’s score of 118 on the WISC-4 administered by Dr. Humphrey in December 2004, to utilize in making this determination.