California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 2, 2002
Student v. Temecula Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1012-02 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Temecula Valley Unified must reclassify a student under autism and provide compensatory pragmatic language services; counseling request denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A fourth-grader's mother filed for due process against Temecula Valley Unified School District. Since preschool, the student had received speech and language services and resource specialist program (RSP) services. His IEP listed speech or language impairment as his eligibility category. He had been diagnosed with a mild form of autism in 1995. In February 2002, a Regional Center evaluator diagnosed autistic disorder using the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS). District staff testified that he showed no signs of autism at school. Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino found the outside evaluators credible and held that the student met federal and state autism criteria. He rejected the District's argument that autism traits other than speech and language must appear at school. On FAPE for 2001-2002, the Hearing Officer found that the District's program met the student's social-interaction needs, including through added Mental Health services and goals. However, testing showed serious deficits in pragmatic (social) language, and the IEPs had no present levels or goals for that area. Because of that gap, the program was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The Hearing Officer ordered the District to change the eligibility category to autism. He also ordered the IEP team to meet at the start of 2002-2003 to design compensatory pragmatic language services that reflect a full year without them. He denied the request for counseling by an independent psychologist.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed outside clinical evaluations against school staff's observations in an eligibility dispute. It held that autism eligibility does not require every trait to appear at school. It also treated the lack of measurable pragmatic language goals as a denial of FAPE, even though staff said they addressed pragmatics informally.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Does the Petitioner qualify for special education under the eligibility category of autism?
The student met federal and state autism criteria based on credible outside evaluations, including an ADOS-based DSM-IV diagnosis. Autism traits beyond speech and language need not appear at school when autism adversely affects educational performance.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District offer a free appropriate public education to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?
The District denied FAPE because its 2001-2002 IEPs had no present levels or goals for the student's pragmatic language deficits. Its program otherwise met his social-interaction needs, so the request for counseling by an independent psychologist was denied.
- Dismissed / withdrawnImplementation
Issue Withdrawn (fn. 3-a). The manner by which 84 make-up speech and language sessions would be provided
The Petitioner withdrew this issue after presenting his case-in-chief.
- Dismissed / withdrawnIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue Withdrawn (fn. 3-b). Whether, upon a finding of autism eligibility, the District should be ordered to provide an independent educational assessment by someone other than District personnel
The Petitioner withdrew this issue over the District's objection. The Hearing Officer allowed the withdrawal because the District had not filed its own hearing request.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The student's eligibility classification shall be changed to autism, as defined in 34 C.F.R. 300.7 and Cal. Educ. Code 56026.
- Compensatory education. Compensatory speech and language services focused on pragmatic language, for the District's failure to address pragmatic language for the entire 2001-2002 school year. The IEP team decides the nature, duration, frequency and timing. Services are in addition to FAPE services, must not overburden the student, and should be integrated into existing school activities where practicable. No hours were specified.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team shall meet at the start of the 2002-2003 school year, and as needed afterward, to decide the compensatory pragmatic language services. It may consider additional assessment.
Key authorities
Rowley; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; 34 C.F.R. 300.7(c)(1)(i); 5 C.C.R. 3030(g); Cal. Educ. Code 56026
People named in the decision
- Amil Alzubaidi, Marriage and family therapy intern; mental health assessor; witness for Student, Riverside County Department of Mental Health
- Gina Robinson, Ph.D., Psychological assistant; Regional Center evaluator; witness for Student, Inland County Regional Center (as stated)
- Mavis Johnson, Private occupational therapist; witness for Student, Private provider
- Joseph Stradley, School psychologist (1998 triennial assessment), Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Fred Fox, Program specialist; District representative and witness, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Melanie Hertig, School psychologist (January 2002 behavioral/psychoeducational evaluation), Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Judy Zuckerman, Resource specialist (RSP) teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Kimberly Robinson, Speech and language pathologist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Cate Hawthorne, Resource specialist (RSP) teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Mr. Prevo, General education classroom teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Charles Martin, Ph.D., Speech-language assessor (May 2002 CASL/SNAL testing) on behalf of District, Temecula Valley Unified School District (contracted or staff; not stated)
- Ira Lott, M.D., Physician who diagnosed mild autism in 1995, University of California Irvine Medical Center
- Cheryl Pfent, Mental health services supervisor, Riverside County Department of Mental Health
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on June 4, 5, and July 2 and 3, 2002, in Temecula, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his advocate, Laura Wiles. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Temecula Valley Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Andrew V. Arczynski from the office of Filarsky and Watt LLP. Also present on behalf of the District was Fred Fox, District program specialist.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Amil Alzubaidi, marriage family and child therapy intern (MFTI) at Riverside County Department of Mental Health (Mental Health); Gina Robinson, Ph.D., psychological assistant at Inland County Regional Center (Regional Center); Mavis Johnson, registered occupational therapist; Joseph Stradley, District school psychologist; Fred Fox; and MOTHER. The District called the following witnesses: Melanie Hertig, District school psychologist; Judy Zuckerman, District resource specialist (RSP) teacher; Kimberly Robinson, District speech and language pathologist; Cate Hawthorne, District RSP teacher; and Fred Fox.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until receipt of the closing briefs on July 18, 2002.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
Issue No. 1 Does the Petitioner qualify for special education under the eligibility category of autism?
Issue No. 2 Did the District offer a free appropriate public education to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner asserts that he is eligible as a student with autism under criteria established by special education law. He seeks to have his eligibility category for special education, as designated on his individualized education program (IEP), changed from speech and language impairment to autism. The Petitioner asserts that the services offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year did not appropriately address his needs arising from autism, and he asserts that the District’s failure to properly state his eligibility category and meet his needs arising from autism resulted in the denial of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year. As a remedy, the Petitioner seeks an order that his eligibility category listed on his IEP be designated as autism. As a further remedy, the Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to provide counseling services by an independent psychologist to address social deficits incurred as a result of the District’s failure to provide intervention services specific to autism. No other contentions pertinent to FAPE were presented for resolution by the Petitioner. The District asserts that the Petitioner has correctly been designated on his IEP as eligible under the category of speech and language and that the Petitioner does not meet the eligibility criteria for autism. The District further asserts that even if the Petitioner is found by the Hearing Officer to be eligible under the category of autism, the program offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year constituted a FAPE.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], completed fourth grade in June 2002. STUDENT has received speech and language services and RSP services from his preschool years through the present. His unique needs, as indicated in his IEPs during that period, relate primarily to delays in speech and language which adversely affect his academic performance.
In November 1995, STUDENT was diagnosed at the University of California Irvine Medical Center as having a “mild form of autism.” The November 1995 report by Ira Lott, M.D., states that the diagnosis was supported by a regression in expressive speech at the age of two years, the loss of good eye contact for at least one year, difficulties with socialization, and a mild tendency toward compulsions. As a preschooler, STUDENT began receiving services at Cottonwood State Preschool pursuant to an IEP from Hemet Unified School District (Hemet). His annual IEP review dated May 1997 states that his eligibility category was “speech/language impaired.” Written IEPs from Hemet in May and September 1997 state that STUDENT’s delays in language skills were “autistic in nature.” A triennial assessment performed by the District in May 1998 notes that STUDENT had a medical diagnosis of mild autism in his background, and the report concludes by recommending eligibility due to “a severe language disorder which adversely affects educational performance.” STUDENT’s May 1998 IEP lists his eligibility category as speech and language, without reference to autism. His first-grade IEP from the District, dated May 6, 1999, lists his eligibility category as “speech or language impairment.” STUDENT’s May 10, 2000 IEP lists his eligibility category as “specific learning disability,” although the text of the IEP refers primarily to impairments in speech and language.
The District conducted a triennial assessment in May 2001. STUDENT’s performance IQ on the WISC III was 89, placing him in the average to low average range. As measured by the WISC III, STUDENT showed average abilities in arithmetic problem solving and recalling information. He showed weaknesses in visual processing speed, verbal conceptualization, abstract thinking, verbal concept formation, and verbal expression. On certain tests, he was easily distracted and had difficulty sustaining attention. On verbal tasks, difficulty was noted in categorical thinking and comprehension of novel questions regarding social situations. He would often start by answering a question correctly, but then had difficulty explaining his answers more fully. He would lose focus of the question and begin to talk about subjects unrelated to the question. According to the May 2001 report, other testing and data showed significant evidence of attention deficit disorder, which was adversely affecting his educational performance. STUDENT’s parents stated that they were concerned about his behaviors. His parents described STUDENT as being very sensitive and worried about how his peers perceived him. His parents said that STUDENT had difficulty making and maintaining friendships. They also stated that he was easily distracted and moody, at times lapsing into daydreaming and at other times becoming argumentative, destructive, and disingenuous. In speech and language testing, STUDENT’s total language score on the CELF:3 was at the fourth percentile. Overall, the assessment team recommended continuation of eligibility due to STUDENT’s speech and language disorder. The assessment team recommended continuation of speech and language services, continuation of RSP services, and further medical investigation by the parents regarding possible attention deficit disorder.
STUDENT’s IEP team met on June 5, 2001, to review the triennial assessment and to formulate an IEP for the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT would be entering the fourth grade. The team recommended continued eligibility under the category of speech/language impairment. Present levels of performance listed on the June 5, 2001 IEP show that in reading STUDENT was above grade level at identifying words, but he was only at the 3.1 grade level in passage comprehension. He was at grade level in math. His overall written language skills were also rated at grade level, but certain writing samples were at the kindergarten level. He had difficulties focusing, varying his sentence structures, and organizing his thoughts. Deficits in receptive and expressive language were also noted. As priorities for enhancing STUDENT’s education in the long term, his parents listed reduction of distractibility, improvement of writing and comprehension, and improvement of social skills. The IEP states that “mild autism, speech/language impairments and attentional difficulties negatively impact written language, and STUDENT’s classroom task completion.” The IEP provided for RSP and speech and language services. Goals and objectives were stated for writing skills, task completion, reading comprehension, comprehension of word associations, understanding of spacial and sequential relationships in text, syntactical skills, expressive language, and following directions in the classroom.
At an IEP meeting held on October 18, 2001, STUDENT’s mother expressed concerns about his social skills, and she also wanted STUDENT to undergo an occupational therapy (OT) screening. She wanted a behavioral evaluation performed due to STUDENT’s history of inappropriate comments, cruelty to animals, lack of empathy for others, and insensitivity to his environment. The speech and language specialist expressed her view that STUDENT’s lack of pragmatic speech and language skills might be responsible for some of these behaviors. The mother thought that counseling would be helpful. The team agreed to have STUDENT tested in the area of pragmatic language. Regarding his behaviors, the team noted that STUDENT had a history of pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) that was affecting his social skills and that further behavioral testing would need to be done. An assessment plan for OT services, pragmatic skills, and behavioral evaluation was discussed and signed.
An OT evaluation was performed by Mavis Johnson in October 2001. Her report states that the evaluation was done primarily from information provided by STUDENT’s mother. Ms. Johnson concluded that STUDENT demonstrated difficulty in the areas of modulating his sensory input and that the modulation difficulties had led to proprioceptive seeking behaviors by STUDENT. According to Ms. Johnson, STUDENT showed tactile and auditory defensiveness and difficulty maintaining a balanced level of alertness. Ms. Johnson commented in her report that a “system that is on high alert may eventually affect a person’s ability to perform tasks and to participate appropriately in school or various social settings.” Examples of proprioceptive seeking behaviors by STUDENT were not indicated in the report.
The Test of Pragmatic Language (TOPL) was administered to STUDENT by Kimberly Robinson on November 2, 2001. Results from the TOPL indicated that STUDENT was performing below average in his pragmatic language skills. His chronological age was 10 years and 1 month, but he scored at the age equivalent of 7 years with a percentile rank of 10.
An IEP meeting was conducted by telephone on November 13, 2001, to discuss the mother’s request that STUDENT be assessed by Mental Health. The meeting notes state that STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Prevo, was concerned with STUDENT’s difficulties in attention, focus, and completing work. The notes state that STUDENT often did not understand his work after it was completed, that he did not feel confident participating in class, that he was often off topic, and that “he does not socialize out on the playground and may withdraw in class.” From the context of the meeting notes, all of these observations appear to have been attributed to Mr. Prevo.
A mental health assessment was performed at Temecula Mental Health on December 19, 2001 by therapist Amil Alzubaidi. The report shows that Mr. Alzubaidi conducted clinical observations of STUDENT, and Mr. Alzubaidi testified that he had also reviewed an extensive packet of written information included with the referral to Mental Health. Mr. Alzubaidi stated in his report that he observed STUDENT’s thought process to be disorganized. STUDENT would move from one topic to another without coming to any points or conclusions. He appeared agitated in the session and “continued to fold his legs together and flap his arms rhythmically.” He had poor insight into his problem areas and demonstrated poor judgment in making choices. His affect appeared dysthymic, and his short term memory was impaired. According to the report, symptoms displayed by STUDENT included inability to attend to details, difficulty sustaining attention, inability to complete instructions, difficulty being organized, avoidance of tasks requiring mental effort, inability to develop peer relationships, delays in expressive language, inability to engage in make-believe play, and dependence on a set routine. Mr. Alzubaidi concluded that STUDENT qualified for Mental Health services and that generalized goals would be to establish peer relationships, learn effective anger management skills, stop impulsive decisions, and engage in thoughtful choices after considering consequences.
A behavioral evaluation was performed by District school psychologist Melanie Hertig in January 2002. Her report notes that evidence of attention deficit disorder, autistic spectrum disorder, and/or PDD had been presented in prior evaluations she had reviewed. Ms. Hertig stated that although STUDENT had been diagnosed in earlier years with autism or PDD, current indications for such a diagnosis were limited. She concluded that at the time of her evaluation, STUDENT presented as a child with language impairment and also with some inattentive behaviors consistent with attention deficit disorder. However, she also concluded that STUDENT was not demonstrating behaviors within the school setting that would be of concern. Furthermore, she stated that he was observed to demonstrate many behaviors in the school setting that were appropriate for the classroom. For example, he engaged in two-way conversation with his peers and teacher when appropriate. He was able to listen to conversations of peers and still maintain his ability to stay on task. He listened to and answered oral questions presented by the teacher and followed the rules of the classroom appropriately. In math class, he frequently raised his hand to volunteer responses to the lesson.
Following receipt of the above-discussed assessments, the IEP team reconvened for a meeting on February 14, 2002. According to the notes, STUDENT’s mother voiced her opinion that STUDENT met the “district criteria” for autism. She also asserted that STUDENT had been incorrectly identified as eligible under speech and language instead of autism and, consequently, that he was not receiving proper services to address his behaviors, lack of organizational skills, and other deficits. Observations of STUDENT by District personnel were discussed. The regular education teacher stated that STUDENT had limited interaction with his peers in large-group settings, but in small groups he was relatively lively and friendly. His speech therapist concurred. STUDENT’s RSP teacher stated that although STUDENT’s social interaction was limited, his attention to task had improved in structured settings and he would engage with others. Other team members stated that STUDENT’s attention, self-confidence, and eye contact had improved over the past year. The mother felt that STUDENT was being tormented by certain classmates, but the classroom teacher stated that she could recall no specific events of significant conflict.
The team agreed at the February 14, 2002 IEP meeting that Mental Health would write goals and objectives and provide services pertinent to STUDENT’s social skills. The goals and objectives would be incorporated into the IEP on District forms. The District’s program specialist felt that the speech and language pathologist could work on some of the Mental Health goals and incorporate them into pragmatic areas. Ms. Hertig’s report was reviewed, and the significant differences were noted between STUDENT’s behaviors at home and at school. Ms. Hertig stated her opinion that STUDENT was not demonstrating behaviors at school that would be of concern, although STUDENT’s propensity for off-task comments was recognized as being “more atypical and off the subject” in comparison with other students. Having heard the mother’s concerns, the team discussed and wrote an assessment plan to determine whether STUDENT should have his eligibility category changed to autism. The plan was given to STUDENT’s mother for her review and consideration, but she did not sign it. Meanwhile, STUDENT’s February 14, 2002 IEP provided for collaborative and pullout RSP services, speech and language services in small-group settings, outpatient Mental Health services, and OT. New goals and objectives were added to those of his prior IEP, addressing organizational skills, handwriting, peer relationships, anger management, and impulsive decision-making.
For the purpose of determining STUDENT’s eligibility for Regional Center services, a psychological assessment was performed at the Regional Center by Gina Robinson, Ph.D., on February 20, 2002. Dr. Robinson administered the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule - Module Three (ADOS) to STUDENT. She interviewed STUDENT’s mother and did the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales by parent interview. She also observed STUDENT in a clinical setting and reviewed his file. She did not interview STUDENT’s teachers or interview STUDENT in the school setting. Dr. Robinson concluded that STUDENT presented with a complex pattern of behaviors. His score on the ADOS fell within the autistic range. The report states that “his behavioral presentation also meets the DSM-IV criteria for autistic disorder considering his limited reciprocal social interactions, language delay, difficulty with change, and encompassing preoccupations.” She recommended a smaller classroom setting to allow for fewer distractions and more individualized attention for STUDENT’s unique learning needs. She also recommended speech and language services, a functional behavioral analysis to address, among other things, his off-task behaviors and poor organizational skills, an in-home behavioral consultation to address his potentially dangerous impulsive behaviors, and a social recreation program to help improve his social interaction skills. Her diagnostic impression was “Axis I: 299.00 Autistic Disorder.”
STUDENT’s IEP team met again on February 27, 2002. The mother still did not sign the proposed assessment plan from the prior IEP meeting. Instead, she requested that the assessment be performed by some entity other than the District, but the District refused. She did, however, sign a plan for an OT assessment to include sensory integration. She also signed her agreement to the Mental Health and OT services offered at the February 14, 2002 IEP meeting. The present due process hearing request was filed by STUDENT’s mother on May 10, 2002.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1 Does the Petitioner qualify for special education under the eligibility category of autism?
The Petitioner asserts that he qualifies for special education as an individual with exceptional needs under the eligibility category of autism. The District asserts that the Petitioner has correctly been designated on his IEP as eligible under the category of speech and language and that the Petitioner does not meet the eligibility criteria for autism. Neither party disputes that the Petitioner’s speech and language impairments are sufficient to qualify him for special education, although the Petitioner asserts that his speech and language deficits arise from autism. For purposes of special education eligibility, the term “child with a disability” is defined by federal law in 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(3)(A)(ii), as meaning a child with at least one of the several conditions listed in that section, including speech and language deficits and “autism,” who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services. The term “autism” is defined in federal regulations as “a developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age 3, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance. Other characteristics often associated with autism are engagement in repetitive activities and stereotyped movements, resistance to environmental change or change in daily routines, and unusual responses to sensory experiences.” Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7(c)(1)(i).
State law incorporates the above-referenced federal definitions of “child with a disability” and “autism.” State law defines an “individual with exceptional needs” as a student who is identified by an IEP team as “a child with a disability,” as that latter phrase is defined by federal statute in 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(3)(A)(ii), and who requires special education because of his or her “impairment.” Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56026.
In addition to incorporating the above-referenced federal definitions of “child with a disability” and “autism,” State special education law contains a provision regarding behaviors related to autism. Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030 includes a list of conditions, referred to in the regulation as “impairments,” that may qualify a pupil as an individual with exceptional needs and thereby entitle the pupil to special education if required by “the degree of the pupil’s impairment.” The “impairment” of “autistic-like behaviors” is described in Sec. 3030(g), which states:
(g) A pupil exhibits any combination of the following autistic-like behaviors, to include but not limited to: (1) An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. (2) A history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. (3) An obsession to maintain sameness.
(4) Extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects or both. (5) Extreme resistance to controls.
(6) Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns. (7) Self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior.
The testimony in this hearing was split on the question of whether STUDENT meets the criteria for eligibility under the category of autism. Each witness who was not employed by the District supported STUDENT’s contention. Each witness who was employed by the District rejected the notion that STUDENT should be found eligible under the category of autism.
Witnesses supporting the Petitioner’s contention
Mr. Alzubaidi testified that when he performed the assessment of STUDENT at Mental Health on December 19, 2001, he noted signs of an autism disorder. Mr. Alzubaidi observed that STUDENT was disorganized in his thought processes. He switched discussion topics without making points or conclusions, became agitated in session and continued to fold his legs together and flap his arms rhythmically, had poor insight into his problem areas, demonstrated poor judgment in making appropriate choices, and exhibited a dysthymic affect. Mr. Alzubaidi testified that before he could make a diagnosis of autism, he would need more time with STUDENT than the one and one-half-hour session in December 2001.
Dr. Robinson testified that when she evaluated STUDENT for the Regional Center in February 2002, her impression was that STUDENT met the DSM-IV criteria for autism, and her diagnosis was autistic disorder. Dr. Robinson was knowledgeable about autism. She testified that she specialized in testing children at the Regional Center and that as many as ninety percent of the children she tested were being evaluated for a possible autism disorder. Although Dr. Robinson’s evaluation was performed in her capacity as a “psychological assistant,” she testified that the staff psychologist at Regional Center concurred with the diagnosis of autism, and the staff psychologist signed the report. Dr. Robinson testified that she is familiar with the term “autistic-like behaviors” as used in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(g). She testified that her diagnosis was made under the standardized DSM-IV criteria used by doctors to diagnose patients with psychological disorders and that it was not her intent to show whether STUDENT qualified for special education under Sec. 3030(g). She testified that an important assessment tool in her evaluation was the ADOS, administered directly to STUDENT. STUDENT’s score on the ADOS was 14. Her report states that a score of 10 or above on the ADOS is suggestive of autism. She testified that STUDENT exhibited poor social interaction and that poor social interaction is a significant trait of autism. He offered a relatively small amount of “back and forth” information during conversation. He showed little change in facial expression, even when asked to demonstrate specific emotions. The tone of his voice and use of language sounded mechanical or scripted. He would maintain eye contact for only a few seconds before looking away.
STUDENT’s private OT provider, Ms. Johnson, has been a registered occupational therapist since 1967. She has extensive experience providing sensory integration therapy to children with autism. She testified regarding her observations of STUDENT’s behaviors in his home setting. At the time of her testimony, she had been providing weekly OT to STUDENT for about 9 months commencing in the fall of 2001. She testified that STUDENT is very tactile-sensitive. Clothing textures are troublesome for him. He is very reactive to life in general. She testified that because his “system” does not properly filter incoming stimuli, his responses may often be overly reactive. This compromises his ability to control himself and to control how his environment affects him. She testified that she has seen many autistic features in STUDENT, including repetitive, self-stimulatory, and/or perseverative behaviors, such as arm flapping when under stress, rocking, an obsession with cars, wagging his head, pressing, banging his wrists or the heels of his feet, climbing inappropriately, grinding his teeth, and biting objects. In her opinion, STUDENT’s social interaction skills were poor. She observed him playing with other children at home on games such as Nintendo, but noted that he did not initiate conversation or engage in conversation that would indicate an interest in her or the other children, such as by saying “How are you?”
STUDENT’s mother testified that she has observed STUDENT extensively in his school setting during her volunteer work at STUDENT’s school. She testified that she has worked at his school for 1 or 2 hours of every week of every school year. According to the mother, STUDENT is deficient in his social skills and social interaction at school. In her estimation, STUDENT seems to be socially lost in elementary school. She has observed that on the playground, STUDENT generally chooses to play games not requiring interaction with other children, including games such as handball, tetherball, or swings. She testified that when STUDENT does attempt to interact with other children, he is either dominated by them or is picked on. She testified that in classroom groups he does not interact with the other children, that nobody wants to associate with him, and that he seems to be lost in trying to understand what he is supposed to do. Consequently, most of his work ranges from incomplete to not done at all. She testified that STUDENT struggles to follow a structured setting at school and then releases his frustrations when he arrives at home. She believes that STUDENT has even been assaulted by other students, but that he does not have the communication skills necessary to articulate his problems to his teachers and he is afraid of retaliation from certain peers. She testified that through third grade, STUDENT regularly displayed anger at school, manifested by tantrums, crying, and yelling. Such manifestations of anger have continued at home during his fourth-grade school year and have actually worsened.
Witnesses supporting the District’s position
Mr. Stradley is a District school psychologist. He wrote a triennial assessment report on STUDENT in May 1998. He testified that STUDENT’s prior medical diagnosis of autism was considered as a factor in determining STUDENT’s eligibility category and program at that time. He testified that autism is characterized by, among other things, impairment in speech and language, impairment in social skills, and behavioral problems related to “cause and effect.” Mr. Stradley testified that STUDENT’s social skills improved significantly during the kindergarten year and that by May 1998, the autistic-like behaviors listed in Sec. 3030(g) were not necessarily a problem for STUDENT, except for the continuing speech and language impairments.
Ms. Hertig is a District school psychologist who testified regarding her January 2002 psychoeducatioal assessment of STUDENT. The assessment was conducted in response to the concerns about STUDENT’s behavior raised by his mother at the October 18, 2001 IEP meeting. Ms. Hertig observed STUDENT’s behavior in the classroom environment. She testified that with respect to the factors listed in Sec. 3030(g), STUDENT displayed speech and languageimpairments, but that none of the other autistic-like behaviors specified in Sec. 3030(g) were observed by her or reported by school personnel as occurring in the school setting during the 2001-2002 school year. Ms. Hertig used the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) as a tool for determining whether STUDENT was autistic. The CARS scores were derived by interviews of STUDENT’s mother and teachers. As rated by the mother, STUDENT fell within the severely autistic range on the CARS. However, as rated by the RSP teacher and the classroom teacher, STUDENT was well within the non-autistic range. Ms. Hertig testified that it would be unlikely for the behaviors reported by the mother on the CARS to be occurring in the home if they are not occurring in the school. She testified that she found nothing in the May 2001 triennial assessment report or in her own observation to suggest that STUDENT was autistic. She testified that the Regional Center report prepared by Dr. Robinson contained no information about how STUDENT performed in the school setting and, consequently, the report did not persuade her that STUDENT meets the Sec. 3030(g) criteria. Ms. Hertig testified that she observed and found STUDENT’s behavior to be well within normal limits at school. He was able to move within the classroom, seeking out other students and interacting and speaking with them in reciprocal conversations. He appeared to be involved in the classroom activities and to follow instructions. His teacher told Ms. Hertig that what Ms. Hertig had observed was typical of STUDENT, and that STUDENT had developed a small group of friends with whom he played and interacted. Nothing was brought to Ms. Hertig’s attention to indicate STUDENT was having problems with his classmates. She saw nothing unusual in STUDENT other than his speech and language deficits and some attention deficit issues.
Ms. Hertig testified that a child with autism is not able to turn his autistic-like behaviors on and off. Instead, an autistic child’s behaviors would be relatively consistent at home and at school. She testified that because of the disparity in reporting on the CARS by STUDENT’s mother compared to the reporting of school personnel, and because STUDENT did not show behaviors in the school setting indicative of autism, his reported behaviors at home caused her to be concerned about STUDENT’s emotional status in his home environment and the stressors affecting him at home.
Ms. Zuckerman testified that she was STUDENT’s RSP teacher in the 2001-2002 school year, assisting him with reading, spelling, and language through a combination of collaborative and pull-out services. She testified that with respect to behaviors, he did not “stand out” from his classmates. Sometimes he was relatively quiet. His eye contact varied. Generally, he got along well with everyone. She never observed children picking on him, and she never had a student complain to her about STUDENT’s behavior. He was attentive in groups. She saw no emotional outbursts, tantrums, or incidents necessitating that he be controlled. He usually completed his work within the time limits in the RSP setting. Ms. Zuckerman completed the CARS scales at the request of Ms. Hertig. She testified that STUDENT’s behavior was very good, and she never had to discipline him by “pulling his card.” She stated that STUDENT sometimes would rock in his seat, but she considered the rocking to be indicative of restlessness, not autism. She thought that STUDENT adapted well to change in schedules, and she had observed no self-stimulatory behaviors. Except for speech and language, Ms. Zuckerman testified that she saw STUDENT display none of the autistic-like behaviors listed in Sec. 3030(g).
Ms. Robinson, a District speech and language pathologist, testified that she provided services to STUDENT throughout the 2001-2002 school year. She testified that she has seen no behavior or transition problems in STUDENT. During the speech and language pull-out sessions, STUDENT was usually very excited to come to class because if he had done his work he would receive a “surprise.” STUDENT interacted well with the other children in the group, and he was welcomed in the group. She saw no maladaptive behaviors or tantrums. STUDENT had no problems following rules that included being attentive, using no mean language, following directions the first time given, and being unafraid to ask questions. STUDENT reported no problem to her concerning his relationships with other children, and he showed no difficulties initiating contact with teachers and peers. She regularly conferred and collaborated with STUDENT’s teachers concerning his program. She stated that STUDENT’s classroom teacher, Mr. Prevo, indicated no problems to her regarding STUDENT in the classroom. When she observed STUDENT in Mr. Prevo’s class, she saw no problems that would distinguish STUDENT from his peers. Ms. Robinson testified that none of the autistic-like behaviors listed in Sec. 3030(g) applied to STUDENT, not even in speech and language. She stated that STUDENT has problems with syntax, morphology, and grammar, but he can still communicate his intended message.
Ms. Hawthorne testified that she provided RSP services in academics to STUDENT in third and fourth grade. She testified that on the basis of her observations, none of the autistic-like behaviors listed in Sec. 3030(g) were applicable to STUDENT.
Discussion
Except for the opinions of some of the District’s employees that STUDENT displayed speech and language deficits within the meaning of Sec. 3030(g), the District’s employees unanimously testified that STUDENT displayed absolutely no characteristics of autism when observed by them in the school setting. In contrast, the testimony and/or reports of Mr. Alzubaidi from Mental Health, Dr. Robinson from the Regional Center, Ms. Johnson the private OT therapist, and STUDENT’s mother, collectively depict STUDENT as a child with serious speech and language deficits and with other characteristics consistent with the definitions of autism in Sec. 300.7 and Sec. 3030(g). Those other characteristics include peculiar motoric mannerisms, repetitive activities, stereotyped movements, self-stimulatory behavior, and/or ritualistic behavior. Those characteristics were manifested by STUDENT continuing to fold his legs together and flap his arms rhythmically when observed by Mr. Alzubaidi; the “encompassing preoccupations” referenced in Dr. Robinson’s report; and the arm flapping, rocking, wagging of his head, pressing, banging of his wrists or the heels of his feet, climbing inappropriately, grinding his teeth, and biting of objects, as observed by Ms. Johnson. Additional characteristics include unusual responses to sensory experiences, as testified to by Ms. Johnson; resistance to environmental change, as reported by Mr. Alzubaidi on the basis of parent report; and impairment in social interaction, as observed by Dr. Robinson, Mr. Alzubaidi, Ms. Johnson, and STUDENT’s mother. Furthermore, STUDENT has a history of being diagnosed with a “mild form of autism” by Dr. Lott at U.C. Irvine in 1995, and he was diagnosed by Dr. Robinson at the Regional Center in February 2002 as meeting the DSM-IV criteria for autistic disorder.
The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Dr. Robinson, Mr. Alzubaidi, and Ms. Johnson to be credible. None of them had any apparent personal or professional reason to be interested in the outcome of this case. Although they interviewed STUDENT’s mother, their conclusions were based on their own personal observations of STUDENT. Dr. Robinson relied on objective clinical testing. She administered the ADOS directly to STUDENT, and the results were not dependent upon reporting by the parent or other persons. By contrast, the CARS data gathered by Ms. Hertig was derived from reporting by the mother, an RSP teacher, and a classroom teacher. Dr. Robinson was asked to explain how STUDENT could be characterized as severely autistic by his mother’s reporting on the CARS, yet be characterized as outside of the autistic range by his teachers on the CARS. Dr. Robinson testified that the CARS results could indicate that STUDENT’s behavior at home was substantially different from his behavior at school. She added, however, that problems in evaluation are often encountered when using the CARS alone. For that reason, she had added the ADOS to the assessment battery.
Furthermore, Dr. Robinson used objective criteria to reach her diagnostic impression of autistic disorder under the DSM-IV. Regarding the disparity between the diagnosis of autistic disorder made by Dr. Robinson using DSM-IV and the absence of Sec. 3030(g) characteristics reported by the District’s employees, Dr. Robinson testified that the criteria in Sec. 3030(g) are relatively broad and are subject to differing interpretations of the persons who apply Sec. 3030(g). For example, she explained that professionals could differ on what is meant in Sec. 3030(g) by the phrases “inability to use appropriate language for oral communication” and “impairment in social interaction” or the broad language regarding mannerisms and behavior. In contrast, a psychological or psychiatric diagnosis under the DSM-IV is the product of the specific application of diagnostic criteria and does not permit the same degree of subjectivity in its application as Sec. 3030(g).
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has speech and language deficits significantly affecting his verbal and nonverbal communication. He displays some peculiar motoric mannerisms, repetitive activities, stereotyped movements, and/or self-stimulatory, ritualistic behavior; unusual responses to sensory experiences; resistance to environmental change; and impairment in social interaction. He also has a history of being diagnosed with a “mild form of autism” by a medical specialist in 1995, and the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Dr. Robinson’s February 2002 diagnosis of autistic disorder under the DSM-IV criteria is valid and consistent with the prior medical diagnosis.
The evidence established a nexus between STUDENT’s diagnosis of autistic disorder and his need for special education services. The evidence showed that STUDENT has been diagnosed with an autistic disorder, that speech and language deficits are consistent with an autistic disorder, that he has significant speech and language deficits, and that his speech and language deficits were instrumental to the diagnosis of autism made by Dr. Robinson and earlier by Dr. Lott. The evidence also showed that STUDENT’s speech and language deficits have adversely affected his educational performance and that special education services are required to address those deficits, including speech and language services and RSP support.
The District asserts that even if STUDENT displays characteristics of autism outside of the school setting, he is not eligible under the category of autism because, except for some speech and language deficits, he does not display other characteristics of autism within the school setting. The District’s assertion is contrary to the law and the facts. The eligibility criteria listed in federal and State law do not require that more than one of the pupil’s characteristics of autism be present in the school setting. If a pupil has autism and the autistic disorder is adversely affecting his educational performance to the extent that special education is required, the pupil meets the eligibility criteria for autism. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401; Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7; Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(g).
In summary, STUDENT has a valid diagnosis of autism, a developmental disability significantly affecting his verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction. STUDENT’s autism, most notably because of the consequent speech and language deficits, has adversely affected his educational performance. This meets the federal definition of “autism” quoted above from Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7(c)(1)(i). Because of his autism, STUDENT needs special education and related services in the area of speech and language. He also needs RSP services to address deficits in his academic performance that have arisen, at least in part, from his speech and language deficits. Therefore, because of his autism and the need for special education arising therefrom, STUDENT is a “child with a disability” within the meaning of 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(3)(A)(ii) and Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7. Because STUDENT is a “child with a disability” and that disability, specifically autism, causes STUDENT to need special education services, he meets the definition of an “individual with exceptional needs under Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56026. Also, consistent with the federal definition of autism, STUDENT exhibits a combination of the “autistic-like behaviors” listed in the State regulations, Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(g), and that “impairment” as described in Sec. 3030(g) requires special education and related services in the form of RSP and speech and language services.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT meets the federal and State eligibility criteria under the category of autism, as set forth in 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(3)(A)(ii); Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7; Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56026; and Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(g).
Issue No. 2 Did the District offer a free appropriate public education to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?
Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.
In determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, the matters to be addressed are: (I) Was the District’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from autism? (II) Was the District’s program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
I. Was the District’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from autism?
The Petitioner asserts that the program offered by the District was not designed to meet his unique needs arising from autism. The Hearing Officer initially notes that although STUDENT has been found herein to meet the criteria for eligibility under the category of autism, this does not compel a further conclusion that the District, having classified STUDENT as eligible under the category of speech and language, failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from autism. Federal and State law describe the types of disabilities that may qualify a child for special education and related services, but the child’s unique needs arising from his or her disability are the fundamental determinant of an appropriate program for the child. As stated in federal law, “the services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a FAPE must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” Title 34, C.F.R Sec. 300.300(a)(3)(ii). Similarly, State law refers to “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
STUDENT’s unique needs
Before determining whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from autism, those unique needs must be identified. The Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT exhibits the following characteristics consistent with autism: speech and language deficits significantly affecting his verbal and nonverbal communication; peculiar motoric mannerisms, repetitive activities, stereotyped movements, and/or self-stimulatory, ritualistic behavior; unusual responses to sensory experiences; resistance to environmental change; and impairment in social interaction. The Hearing Officer must now determine which of those characteristics, if any, give rise to “unique needs” that must be addressed in STUDENT’s educational program.
With respect to speech and language, the Petitioner asserts that his pragmatic language is an area of need and that his needs in pragmatic language were not met. On the Test of Pragmatic Language (TOPL) administered by Ms. Robinson in November 2001, STUDENT’s age-equivalent score was 7 years, or 3 years below his chronological age of 10 years and 1 month. The Petitioner asserts that the TOPL results confirm serious deficits in his pragmatic language skills. On behalf of the District, Ms. Robinson testified that although STUDENT’s pragmatic language scores were poor when measured by the TOPL, she would expect his scores to be poor because STUDENT’s deficits in receptive and expressive language interfered with his ability to respond to test questions on the TOPL, thereby skewing his scores toward a lower ranking.
Although STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language deficits may have affected his performance on the TOPL, the fact remains that his scores on the TOPL were low, indicating that his ability to use pragmatic language is impaired. One would expect that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language deficits are having a similar adverse effect on his use of pragmatic language skills in real-life situations, including the school setting. This was confirmed by oral and documentary evidence regarding STUDENT’s limitations in interactive conversation skills. Furthermore, deficits in the area of pragmatic language were shown by recent additional testing of STUDENT’s semantic and pragmatic language skills performed on behalf of the District by Charles Martin, Ph.D., in May 2002. Dr. Martin administered the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language (CASL) and the Strong Narrative Assessment of Language (SNAL). His report states that the CASL and the SNAL were chosen for the purpose of augmenting the results from the TOPL administered by Ms. Robinson in November 2001. Dr. Martin concluded in his report that the results of his testing showed deficits consistent with the previous testing of semantic-pragmatic language skills performed by Ms. Robinson. Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has unique needs arising from his deficits in the use of pragmatic language.
The Hearing Officer also finds that social interaction is an area of need for STUDENT. After reviewing the results of the May 2001 triennial assessment, including the results of the WISC III, the IEP team acknowledged in the June 5, 2001 IEP that STUDENT needed to improve his social skills. Deficits manifested by STUDENT related to the area of social interaction included difficulty staying on topic during conversations and keeping his thoughts organized; poor judgment in making choices; poor insight into his problem areas; difficulty appropriately demonstrating emotions; avoidance of games that require interaction with other children; and difficulty maintaining appropriate eye contact. Most of those deficits were acknowledged by the District’s staff to be present in the school setting, and the Hearing Officer is persuaded that all those deficits do exist and adversely affect STUDENT’s social interaction in the school setting. Moreover, the adverse effect of those deficits on STUDENT’s social interaction is compounded by his other speech and language deficits.
The Hearing Officer finds that the other characteristics of autism manifested by STUDENT were not at sufficient levels to create additional areas of unique need. The Petitioner asserted that his seeking of proprioceptive input as a device for self-calming was causing his behaviors to be misinterpreted and dealt with in a punitive manner. The Petitioner asserted that he needed sensory integration therapy and a positive behavior intervention plan as interventions at school. The Petitioner also asserted that such interventions would have a calming affect on him and would address his attention deficits. However, although STUDENT was observed to be demonstrating such characteristics outside of the structured school setting, the evidence did not show that those characteristics were adversely affecting STUDENT’s educational performance. Except for some concerns about social interaction, such as those concerns mentioned in the November 13, 2001 IEP meeting notes, behavioral problems in STUDENT were described by the District employees as ranging from typical to nonexistent. With the exception of STUDENT sometimes sitting in his chair at school with his legs folded under him on the seat, all of the District personnel who testified claimed that they saw STUDENT display no peculiar motoric mannerisms, repetitive activities, stereotyped movements, self-stimulatory or ritualistic behavior, unusual responses to sensory experiences, or resistance to environmental change.
In summary, with respect to matters related to STUDENT’s autism, STUDENT needed services in the 2001-2002 school year to address his pragmatic language deficits. He also needed services to address his deficits in social interaction skills, including his difficulty staying on topic during conversations and keeping his thoughts organized, poor judgment in making choices, poor insight into his problem areas, difficulty appropriately demonstrating emotions, difficulty engaging in games that require interaction with other children, and difficulty maintaining appropriate eye contact.
The District’s program
The next task is to examine whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his autism, as identified immediately above.
Pragmatic language. STUDENT’s IEPs for the 2001-2002 school year contained no goals and objectives specific to the area of pragmatic language. STUDENT’s speech and language pathologist, Ms. Robinson, testified that no goals and objectives were needed in pragmatics because pragmatics were ancillary to what she was already teaching STUDENT in the areas of receptive and expressive language, and pragmatics did not need to be a focus of her teaching. Her testimony in that respect was consistent with the notes on that subject from the February 27, 2002 IEP meeting. According to those notes, the consensus of the IEP team was that STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills were being affected by his other language skills, and that all of STUDENT’s teachers and service providers were addressing STUDENT’s pragmatics as needed. The notes also show that the District recommended a more comprehensive speech and language assessment to ascertain how and to what extent STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills were being affected by his other skills. Specific tests to be included in that assessment were identified. STUDENT’s mother rejected the assessment proposal because she wanted the additional assessment to be performed by independent experts.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s approach to meeting STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of pragmatic language was deficient. Although the services being provided to STUDENT may have been addressing pragmatics in an ancillary fashion, the addition of goals and objectives with reference to present levels of performance was required so that STUDENT’s progress in pragmatics could be measured and the program adjusted accordingly. No such goals and objectives or present levels of performance were stated in STUDENT’s IEPs for the 2001-2002 school year.
Social interaction. In the area of social interaction, STUDENT needed services to address his difficulty staying on topic during conversations and keeping his thoughts organized, poor judgment in making choices, poor insight into his problem areas, difficulty appropriately demonstrating emotions, difficulty engaging in games that require interaction with other children, and difficulty maintaining appropriate eye contact.
With regard to STUDENT’s difficulties in staying on topic and keeping his thoughts organized, the June 5, 2001 IEP contained an annual goal and short-term objectives for writing skills. The goal emphasized the writing of paragraphs with focus to topic and the correct sequencing of sentences. A separate goal for reading comprehension emphasized recalling the sequencing of events, predicting outcomes, and stating cause and effect. A goal for syntactical skills involved STUDENT’s learning to combine two simple sentences into compound sentences. An expressive language goal involved correct use of verb tenses and irregular plurals. The February 14, 2002 IEP addendum added a goal for improving organizational skills by maintaining a binder for daily homework and homework assignments. All of these goals were pertinent to helping STUDENT make progress in his areas of need related to staying on topic and keeping his thoughts organized.
With regard to STUDENT’s other needs in the area of social interaction, the June 5, 2001 IEP contained goals and/or objectives related to predicting outcomes and stating cause and effect. Although those provisions had some application to choice-making skills, their overall target area was reading comprehension. However, the IEP team acted promptly and appropriately at the October 18, 2001 IEP meeting when STUDENT’s mother and the rest of the IEP team had a discussion regarding the mother’s observations of STUDENT’s behaviors. A battery of evaluations was arranged, including the December 2001 evaluation of STUDENT by Mental Health. The IEP team then used that new information to directly address STUDENT’s social interaction needs. The February 14, 2002 IEP addendum provided for outpatient Mental Health services and included goals and objectives dealing with peer relationships, anger management, and impulsive decision-making.
In summary, the evidence showed that the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of social interaction, with one significant exception. As shown by the evidence, pragmatic language skills are a part of the skills that one utilizes for successful social interaction. The Hearing Officer has previously found that the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs the area of pragmatic language. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that except to the extent that STUDENT’s pragmatic language needs were not met, the District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of social interaction.
II. Was the District’s program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
The use of speech and language is fundamental to a student’s academic progress and social interaction in regular education and RSP classes such as those attended by STUDENT. Unfortunately, STUDENT’s deficits in receptive and expressive speech and language are substantial, with his total language score on the CLEF:3 ranking him in the fourth percentile. STUDENT also has deficits in his ability to use pragmatic language. Pragmatic language, as described in Ms. Robinson’s report, essentially relates to one’s ability to interactively and effectively communicate with other people using oral speech and language. STUDENT’s deficits in the area of pragmatic language are intermingled with his deficits in receptive and expressive speech and language, as shown by the testimony of Ms. Robinson. Therefore, to the extent that STUDENT has been developing his skills in the areas of receptive and expressive language through the District’s program, the practical application of those skills in the classroom and other settings can be hampered by his deficits in pragmatic language. Thus, pragmatic language is both a critical skill for a student in STUDENT’s educational setting and a major area of need for STUDENT. The District’s failure to specifically address that major area of need was a serious omission to STUDENT’s program. The Hearing Officer finds that because of the District’s failure to provide services supported by goals and objectives to specifically address STUDENT’s deficits in the area of pragmatic language, the District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
III. Conclusions.
The program offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year appropriately addressedSTUDENT’s unique needs arising from his autism, except in the critical area of pragmatic language. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
REMEDIES
During the course of the hearing, the Petitioner identified two remedies that he is seeking. First, the Petitioner seeks an order that his eligibility category be designated as autism. Second, the Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to provide counseling services by an independent psychologist to address social deficits incurred as a result of the District’s failure to provide intervention services specific to autism.
I. Eligibility.
The Hearing Officer has found that the Petitioner meets the criteria for eligibility under the category of autism, pursuant to federal and State law. The Petitioner also meets the criteria for eligibility under the category of speech and language impairment, and his previous and current IEPs have listed speech and language as his eligibility category. The question to be determined is whether the District must change the Petitioner’s eligibility classification to autism.
The functions of an IEP team include, among other duties, determining eligibility, determining the content of an IEP, and making program placement recommendations. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56342. The written IEP must include a statement regarding “how the pupil’s disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum.” The written IEP must also include measurable goals and objectives related to meeting the pupil’s “needs that result from the pupil’s disability.” Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345. Thus, the formulation of an appropriate IEP is dependent upon the proper identification of the pupil’s disability. The IEP team must identify the pupil’s disability before it can determine how the disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum. The IEP team also must identify the pupil’s disability before it can write goals and objectives related to meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the disability.
Impaired speech and language is one of several conditions that may be manifested by a pupil with autism. Therefore, in comparison to eligibility under the category of speech and language impairment, the eligibility/disability category of autism encompasses a wider range of potential unique needs resulting from the pupil’s disability. In STUDENT’s case, “speech/language impairment” and “autism” are among the 16 alternative choices of eligibility categories that can be chosen by marking the appropriate box on the first page of District’s preprinted IEP forms. By marking the box for “speech/language impairment” instead of “autism,” the IEP team was approaching its task of identifying STUDENT’s needs from the narrower viewpoint of speech and language impairment. The appropriate choice would have been “autism” because the use of that term would be consistent with the necessity of having the IEP team consider the full range of needs that result from STUDENT’s disability.
II. Counseling services.
When a school District denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
The Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to provide counseling services by an independent psychologist to address social deficits incurred as a result of the District’s failure to provide intervention services specific to autism. The Hearing Officer has already determined that except to the extent STUDENT’s pragmatic language needs were not met, the District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of social interaction. Therefore, the Petitioner’s request for counseling services by an independent psychologist is denied. However, because of the District’s failure to appropriately address STUDENT’s needs in the area of pragmatic language, STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in the form of speech and language services.
STUDENT’s IEP team is in the best position to formulate the details regarding the nature, duration, frequency, and timing of compensatory speech and language services. The IEP team may also consider additional assessment of STUDENT as necessary to formulate appropriate services. The compensatory speech and language services shall focus on STUDENT’s deficits in pragmatic language. In fashioning the remedy, the IEP team shall consider the fact that STUDENT was denied services specifically addressing his pragmatic language deficits for the entire 2001-2002 school year.
With respect to the timing of STUDENT’s compensatory speech and language services in the area of pragmatic language, the IEP team shall be cautious of overburdening STUDENT with an excess of speech and language services. As discussed at the hearing and established by the evidence, the parties are already in agreement that STUDENT is entitled to approximately 84 “make-up” speech and language sessions as a result of matters unrelated to the issues in this hearing and, as the parties have acknowledged, fitting those make-up services into STUDENT’s schedule has been problematic. Therefore, to the extent practicable, compensatory services in pragmatic language shall be integrated into STUDENT’s concurrent school activities.
ORDERS
1. STUDENT’s current eligibility classification as an individual with exceptional needs shall be changed to autism, as defined in Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7 and Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56026.
2. STUDENT is awarded a compensatory education program as his remedy for the failure of the District to offer a program designed to meet his needs in the area of pragmatic language in the 2001-2002 school year.
3. At the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year and as necessary throughout the course of STUDENT’s compensatory education program, his IEP team shall meet to determine appropriate compensatory education services for STUDENT in the area of pragmatic language. The IEP team shall structure the compensatory education remedy in a manner consistent with finding that for the entire 2001-2002 school year, the District offered no services specifically designed to address STUDENT’s deficits in the area of pragmatic language.
4. The services that the IEP team designates for compensatory education shall be in addition to the level of special education and related services that the District is otherwise obligated to provide as a FAPE. However, the IEP team shall exercise caution not to overburden STUDENT with a schedule that is excessively demanding. To the extent practicable, the IEP team shall integrate compensatory pragmatic language services into STUDENT’s concurrently existing school activities.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue No. 1 Does the Petitioner qualify for special education under the eligibility category of autism? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2 Did the District offer a free appropriate public education to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue, although the Hearing Officer found that except in the area of pragmatic language needs, the program offered by the District was appropriate.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).
Dated: August 2, 2002 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Cheryl Pfent, mental health services supervisor for Riverside County Department of Mental Health (Mental Health), appeared on behalf of Mental Health for approximately one hour on July 2, 2002. By agreement of the parties, Mental Health was dismissed, and Ms. Pfent then left the hearing.
2. The issues listed here differ slightly in wording from the issues as stated by the Petitioner. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and analysis.
3. Two additional issues were initially presented by the Petitioner for resolution. Those additional issues were withdrawn by the Petitioner after the Petitioner had presented testimony from all of the witnesses for his case-in-chief. One issue involved the manner by which 84 sessions of “make-up” speech and language sessions would be provided. The other issue was whether, upon a finding of eligibility under the category of autism, the District should be ordered to provide an independent educational assessment, to be performed by someone other than District personnel. The District objected to the assessment issue being dropped. The District asserted that it had a right to have that issue determined at the present hearing. Because there had been no hearing request filed by the District regarding assessment, the Hearing Officer allowed the assessment issue to be withdrawn. However, the Hearing Officer informed the parties that findings or orders regarding assessment matters might still be made if they were required for resolution of the Petitioner’s remaining FAPE contentions.
4. The IEP forms from Hemet and the District have a preprinted area containing a list of eligibility categories. The IEP team designates the student’s eligibility category by marking the box that corresponds to the chosen eligibility category. The listed categories that may be chosen include autism, among others.
5. The Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Third Edition, (WISC III) is a standardized test.
6. The Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, Third Edition, (CELF: 3) is a standardized test.
7. Regarding behaviors, Dr. Robinson’s report states that STUDENT shows social awareness and expresses a desire to have friendships. His use of eye contact and facial expression is limited. He was reported to typically engage in parallel forms of play at school, occasionally enjoying interactive games. His interactions with others tended to be focused on his own needs and interests instead of mutual interaction. He could verbalize an understanding of emotions but had limited ability to demonstrate empathy with others. His emotional responses tended to be excessive for the situation. He exhibited encompassing interests and a need for daily routine, becoming upset with changes in his environment such as moving the furniture or his belongings. He was reported to become fixated on certain objects, which he manifested by carrying them, drawing pictures of them, and talking about them.
8. For purposes of clarity, unless the context indicates otherwise, the Hearing Officer will use the term “autism” in reference to both “autism” as defined in Sec. 300.7 and “autistic-like behaviors” as defined in Sec. 3030(g).
9. The evidence indicated that STUDENT had significant and ongoing stressors in his home life, including the death of his father in the spring in 2002.
10. Testimony from Dr. Robinson and the District school psychologist, Mr. Stradley, and information in the reports of Dr. Robinson and Dr. Lott confirmed that deficits in social interaction and verbal and nonverbal communication skills are characteristic of an autistic disorder.
11. Although the District disputes that STUDENT is autistic, there was no dispute that STUDENT’s speech and language deficits have adversely affected his educational performance, including his academic performance, to a degree that requires special education.
12. Sec. 3030 states that a pupil qualifies as an individual with exceptional needs pursuant to Sec. 56026 if the degree of the pupil’s “impairment” as described in Sec. 3030 requires special education in one of the program options authorized by Sec. 56361. The program options authorized by Sec. 56361 include, but are not limited to, RSP programs and designated instruction and services (DIS). Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56363, speech and language services are included within the definition of DIS. There is no dispute that STUDENT requires RSP and speech and language services.
13. State law thereby incorporates the term “related services” into the State definition of special education. This could be significant in certain situations because, under federal definitions, a child who needs only a “related service” such as speech and language pathology services but not “special education,” may not fit the definition of “a child with a disability” unless the applicable state law considers that particular related service to be special education. 34 C.F.R. Secs. 300.7(a), 300.24. In STUDENT’s case, the RSP services and the speech and language services that he receives pursuant to his IEP are two of the program options encompassed within the term “special education” under State law. Cal. Educ. Code Secs. 56361(b) and (c), 56362, and 56363(b)(1); Title 5, C.C.R. 3030.
14. State and federal law require that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. State and federal law also require that the district’s program conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031; Rowley, supra. The requirements of least restrictive environment and conformity with the IEP are not at issue in the present case.
15. Other matters regarding STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language needs and the services to meet those needs are not in dispute.
16. According to Ms. Robinson’s November 2, 2001 report, the pragmatic language skills tested by her were in 6 areas. The area known as “requesting” refers to the use of “if” statements to obtain information and clarify a speaker’s message. “Regulating” refers to using statements that in some way exert control over others. “Informing” refers to the use of statements of fact, clarification, description, opinion, and agreement. “Expressing” refers to the use of statements that provide information about a person’s emotions, sensations, intents, and beliefs, or that label or elicit emotions in others. “Ritualizing” refers to a specific kind of communication by which an automatic element exists in response to particular social situations. “Devices” refers to verbalizations that regulate the “contact” and flow of a conversation. Ms. Robinson testified that STUDENT’s responses indicated similar functioning across all 6 areas.
17. As stated above, the Petitioner withdrew the assessment issue after the commencement of the hearing.
18. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345(a) sets forth the requirements for stating measurable goals and objectives with reference to present levels of performance in a written IEP.
19. Ms. Robinson testified that a goal and objective for organizational skills in the February 14, 2002 IEP, was related to pragmatics. The goal and objectives involved keeping a homework reminder binder. This goal fell far short of addressing, for example, any of the 6 areas of pragmatic language cited by Ms. Robinson when she evaluated STUDENT with the TOPL.
20. In his May 2002 report, Dr. Martin describes pragmatic language as being related to a person’s “awareness of the appropriateness of language in relation to the situation in which it is used and ability to modify language to situations.”
