California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 27, 1997

Student v. Santa Barbara High School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1015-96, SN-1015-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Santa Barbara High School District prevails; Hearing Officer denies Lindamood-Bell placement and all reimbursement despite finding past violations.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision notes a California Department of Education compliance investigation, completed December 7, 1996, that found the District failed to assess the student on time. Evidence attached to the closing briefs was not considered. The District's motion to strike Patricia Lindamood's testimony was denied.

Summary

The student filed for due process against Santa Barbara High School District. He was an 18-year-old senior at Dos Pueblos High School, eligible for special education with a specific learning disability that affected his reading and writing. He claimed the District had not given him an appropriate education over four years and had not fully assessed him. He asked to be placed in the Lindamood-Bell program. He also sought reimbursement for a computer needs assessment, Lindamood-Bell testing, a computer and software, photocopying, and medical costs.

The Hearing Officer found that the District's programs met the student's needs and gave him educational benefit. Teacher testimony, rising Woodcock-Johnson scores, and a November 1996 recording of the student reading supported that finding. The Hearing Officer did find two problems. First, placing the student in a special day class for students with serious emotional disturbance in 1995-96 was not the least restrictive environment (LRE). Second, the District took about a year to assess him after his parent asked in 1991-92, which denied FAPE until he was found eligible in fall 1992. Relying on Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup, the Hearing Officer denied compensatory education. The delay was five years old, later services were appropriate, and the student was on track to graduate. The District's assessments were found adequate, and each reimbursement claim failed for lack of evidence. All relief was denied. The District prevailed on every issue.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO could find a one-year assessment delay and a placement outside the LRE, yet award nothing. The Hearing Officer weighed the equities under Student W. v. Puyallup: how long ago the violation happened, the benefit the student later received, and his progress toward graduation. It also held that progress testing under an agreed IEP did not need new parental consent.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1a. Has Santa Barbara High School District provided STUDENT with an appropriate education?

    District placements over four years met the student's unique needs and gave educational benefit. The Hearing Officer found that the 1995-96 special day class for students with serious emotional disturbance was not the LRE, and that a roughly one-year delay in assessing after the parent's 1991-92 request denied FAPE until the student was found eligible. Compensatory education was denied on equitable grounds under Student W. v. Puyallup, and the District was named prevailing party on all issues.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. If not, should STUDENT be placed in the Lindamood-Bell Program?

    Because the District had since provided appropriate services, the student received substantial benefit, and he was on track to graduate, no compensatory education was owed, so he was not entitled to placement in the Lindamood-Bell program.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2. Has Santa Barbara High School District adequately assessed STUDENT?

    The 1992 assessment covered all suspected disabilities, and the 1995 triennial reassessment was more comprehensive. Progress testing with the Woodcock-Johnson and audio-taped reading samples were not assessments that required parental consent.

  4. Issue 3a. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for a computer needs assessment?

    No evidence was presented beyond the fact that the assessment was done, so reimbursement was denied.

  5. Issue 3b. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for an assessment conducted by the Lindamood-Bell Program, including additional testing in January 1997?

    Because the District's assessment was found adequate, reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell assessments under Education Code section 56329 was denied.

  6. Issue 3c. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for a computer and computer software?

    No evidence showed why the student needed the computer and software to benefit from his education, so reimbursement was denied.

  7. Issue 3d. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for photocopying costs?

    No evidence was presented, so reimbursement was denied.

  8. Issue 3e. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with doctors' appointments and medications for flareups of STUDENT's stress and ulcers?

    No significant evidence was presented, so reimbursement was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order: Petitioner's claims for relief are denied. (Before the hearing, the District agreed to pay for an independent assessment by Jennifer Zvi on proof of cost. That issue was removed from the hearing and was not ordered.)

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992); Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 21 IDELR 723 (9th Cir. 1994); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Education Code §§ 56320, 56321, 56329, 56344, 56505(e)(7), 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Mark Harding, advocate for Student
  • Steven Wyner, attorney for Student (closing argument)
  • Sharon Watt, attorney for District, Santa Barbara High School District
  • Marcia McLish, SELPA director, Santa Barbara County SELPA
  • Jennifer Zvi, private neuropsychological assessor
  • Sabrina Tuyay, reading assessor, UCSB Reading Clinic
  • D. Watson, school psychologist (1992 psychoeducational evaluation), Santa Barbara High School District
  • Anne Pierce, resource specialist teacher (ninth grade), Dos Pueblos High School
  • Gloria Merigan, home instruction teacher (1994), Santa Barbara High School District
  • A.J. Dobbin, home instruction teacher and co-assessor (1995), Santa Barbara High School District
  • Joanne Freeman, educational consultant and assessor; District witness, Santa Barbara High School District
  • Valerie Vanaman, parents' attorney at August 1995 mediation
  • Elizabeth (Libby) Lama, special day class teacher (1995-96) and summer 1996 tutor; Student witness, Dos Pueblos High School
  • David James, resource specialist, one-on-one reading instruction (Project Read); District witness, Dos Pueblos High School
  • Lori Hill, resource specialist teacher; District witness, Dos Pueblos High School
  • Erin Egli, clinical director and assessor, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center
  • Patricia Lindamood, program director; expert witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Program
  • Pat Vanderhyden, private tutor, former Lindamood-Bell teacher
  • William Cirone, superintendent (as described in decision)
  • Diana Rigby, director of student services; District witness, Santa Barbara High School District
  • Colette Wright, speech-language pathologist and educational consultant; expert witness for District, Ocean View School District
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, private reading program and assessor
  • UCSB Reading Clinic, private reading evaluation provider, University of California, Santa Barbara

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Barbara, California, on February 13 and 14, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT attended a portion of the hearing and was represented by advocate Mark Harding. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER.(Footnote 1) Respondent Santa Barbara High School District (District) was represented by attorney Sharon Watt. Also present on the District's behalf was Marcia McLish, director of the Santa Barbara County SELPA.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the matter left open for the submission of closing arguments. Closing arguments were recieved, the record closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) (a) Has Santa Barbara High School District provided STUDENT with an appropriate education?

(b) If not, should STUDENT be placed in the Lindamood-Bell Program?

(2) Has Santa Barbara High School District adequately assessed STUDENT?

(3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following?(Footnote 2)

(a) A computer needs assessment.

(b) An assessment conducted by the Lindamood-Bell Program, including additional testing in January 1997. (c) A computer and computer software.

(d) Photocopying costs.

(e) Costs associated with doctors' appointments and medications for flareups of STUDENT's stress and ulcers.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Both parties attached additional evidence to their closing briefs submitted on April 28, 1997. Petitioner's additional evidence includes Woodcock Reading Master Test scores from 1985 and 1987, a speech and language assessment from 1986, a private neuropsychological assessment conducted by Jennifer Zvi in October 1984, and two competency test answer sheets. The District's additional evidence includes documentation indicating that the District reimbursed Petitioner $1,000 for Ms. Zvi's assessment.

On May 2, 1997, Ms. Watt submitted an objection to Petitioner's additional evidence. Ms. Watt's objection was based on Petitioner's failure to produce the evidence at the hearing in compliance with Education Code § 56505(e)(7). On May 8, 1997, Mr. Wyner responded to Ms. Watt's objection. Mr. Wyner contends that the District should be estopped from objecting to Petitioner's additional evidence because the District also submitted additional evidence. Mr. Wyner also contends that all but one of the additional documents are copies of STUDENT's school records in the District's possession.

Education Code § 56505(e)(7) grants to parties to due process hearings the right to "prohibit the introduction of any evidence at the hearing that has not been disclosed to the party at least five days before the hearing." At the conclusion of the hearing on February 14, 1997, the record was closed except for submission of written closing argument. Neither party made a motion to reopen the record for the submission of additional evidence. Therefore, any evidence submitted by the parties with their closing briefs will not be considered by the Hearing Officer.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an 18-year-old young man eligible for special education as a result of specific learning disabilities. He is currently a senior at Dos Pueblos High School in Santa Barbara. STUDENT attended Goletta Valley Junior High School within the District in 1991-92 and 1992-93.

On June 29, 1992, STUDENT was evaluated at the Reading Clinic at the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB). At the time he had just completed the seventh grade. The Reading Clinic determined that STUDENT had the ability to read "somewhat below grade level" and at the time his actual reading level was at the 4.8 grade level in vocabulary and at the 3.5 grade level in comprehension. In the "Summary and Recommendations" section of the evaluation, the assessor, Sabrina Tuyay, concluded that STUDENT had weaknesses in structural analysis, phonics, vocabulary development, and comprehension. However, Ms. Tuyay also questioned the validity of some of her conclusions because STUDENT did not appear to be motivated to complete most of the tasks during the evaluation. Ms. Tuyay recommended that STUDENT work on word recognition skills, using context to learn unknown words; phonics skills; structural analysis skills, breaking down words into their parts; comprehension skills, using directed reading and thinking activities, directed listening and thinking activities, and story mapping; vocabulary; and writing.

Subsequently, on October 25, 1992, Dr. D. Watson, school psychologist, conducted a psychoeducational evaluation. The evaluation was conducted because a student study team had been convened and the student study team and STUDENT's parents had concerns regarding his academic achievement. Dr. Watson noted that, although MOTHER referred to the UCSB evaluation, the District did not have any record of the evaluation. On the Woodcock-Johnson-Revised, STUDENT received standard scores of 81 on reading, 88 on mathematics, and 80 on written language. STUDENT's ability scores on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised were 106 on Verbal IQ, 105 on Performance IQ, and 105 on Full Scale IQ. Dr. Watson concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a result of discrepancies between his ability and achievement. Dr. Watson also determined that STUDENT had deficits in visual- and auditory-memory skills.

On October 28, 1992, STUDENT's IEP team met and determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education due to a specific learning disability. STUDENT was placed in the resource specialist program for 1-2 periods per day for individual and small-group instruction.

On December 2, 1992, STUDENT's IEP team met to review STUDENT's program because of an incident in which STUDENT threatened a teacher and partially exposed himself in his physical education class. The IEP team determined that STUDENT's behavior was not a result of his disability. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive home teaching until the second semester and that he then be transferred to high school. MOTHER signed the IEP in agreement with the recommendation of the IEP team. On March 22, 1993, the IEP team continued STUDENT's home instruction through the end of the school year.

On June 14, 1993, STUDENT's IEP team met to review STUDENT's placement for the ninth grade at Dos Pueblos High School. The IEP team, with MOTHER's agreement, placed STUDENT in the resource specialist program, again for 1-2 periods per day. When STUDENT started the ninth grade, he was placed in Anne Pierce's resource specialist class. He had a lot of absences and, during the 1993-94 school year, was diagnosed with bronchitis 12 times. STUDENT's ninth grade schedule included English in Ms. Pierce's resource specialist class, regular education driver's education, life sciences, math, computer typing, and JV football team.

On June 3, 1994, STUDENT's IEP team met to review his educational program for the 1994-95 school year. The IEP team decided, with the PARENTS' consent to provide STUDENT with vocational counseling, one period in the resource specialist program per day, and consultative psychological services. The IEP included goals and objectives addressing vocational interests, improving his G.P.A., and passing the reading competency test.

On August 18, 1994, the PARENTS submitted a letter indicating that they were withdrawing their consent to the IEP developed on June 3, 1994. The reasons cited by the PARENTS were that they did "not feel that the process so far has identified STUDENT's disability, nor addressed remediation in any significant way."

During the Summer 1994, STUDENT was diagnosed with cytomegalovirus (CMV), a virus marked by high fevers. Following the diagnosis, STUDENT's parents requested home/hospital, and STUDENT received home instruction for the entire 1994-95 school year. Gloria Merigan provided home teaching from September 1994 through December 1994. Ms. Merigan stopped providing home instruction at the PARENTS' request because she was not special education credentialed. STUDENT's home instruction resumed in March 1995, with A.J. Dobbin. Ms. Dobbin worked with STUDENT through the end of the school year and for ten weeks in Summer 1995.

During the 1994-95 school year, the PARENTS bought a computer and software for STUDENT based on a computer needs assessment and materials obtained from Lindamood-Bell. The computer and software were purchased to help STUDENT with writing and spelling.

On June 8, 1995, STUDENT was assessed for the District by Joanne Freeman and A.J. Dobbin. In the area of academic achievement, STUDENT scored at the fifth grade level (standard score 79) in broad reading, at the ninth grade level (standard score 94) in mathematics, and at the 4.2 grade level (standard score 70) in written language. The assessors determined that STUDENT had a deficit in long-term retrieval which includes memorization, association, retrieval, and transfer of information. The assessors recommended multisensory learning; sequencing materials from simple to complex; integrating acquired knowledge while learning new material; and specific strategies to aid retention, such as mnemonic aids and graphic organizers. The assessors also included specific recommendations for improving STUDENT's reading, including work recognition, word attack, reading comprehension, and oral reading.

On September 6, 1995, STUDENT's IEP team met to review his educational program. The placement called for in the IEP was based on a mediation agreement entered into on August 1, 1995. The mediation agreement called for a program that included the following:

(1) one period per day of one-to-one instruction in reading (2) one period per day of small group instruction with no more than five other students in writing, including hands-on instruction with a computer (3) three periods per day in the Center for Therapeutic Education (CTE) program (4) one period per day in physical education

During the mediation, the PARENTS were represented by attorney Valerie Vanaman. The mediation agreement was signed by the PARENTS and by Ms. Vanaman. Although the mediation agreement was made a part of the IEP, STUDENT's parents refused to sign the IEP. There is no indication on the IEP why the PARENTS refused to sign it.

During the 1995-96 school year, in compliance with the IEP and mediation agreement, STUDENT enrolled in the CTE program. The CTE program is a special day class for seriously emotionally disturbed students. STUDENT's class was taught by Libby Lama. STUDENT attended the class for second, fourth, fifth, and sixth periods, covering algebra, geometry, history and physical science. STUDENT's first period was computer lab, and his third period was one-on-one with Mr. James.

On January 19, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met to review his placement. The IEP team agreed to continue STUDENT's placement in Ms. Lama's class for two to three periods per day. STUDENT was also to receive one-on-one assistance in the resource specialist program and vocational counseling. The IEP team noted that "STUDENT is succeeding with the special ed support he's receiving -- he requires this assistance to be successful." The PARENTS signed the IEP in agreement with the recommendations of the IEP team.

Attached to the IEP dated January 1996 was an "Academic and Social Assessment" completed by Ms. Lama. In that assessment, Ms. Lama stated that STUDENT completed Algebra 1 and had started Geometry. Ms. Lama also stated that STUDENT "did very well in Algebra and is enjoying the challenge of Geometry." She indicated that "his reading has improved" and although he makes some mistakes, "he is doing much better than at the beginning of the school year." In the social area, Ms. Lama stated that STUDENT's self-esteem had greatly improved and he worked well in cooperative learning groups.

From June 1995 through May 1996, the District administered the Woodcock-Johnson-Revised to STUDENT three times. His scores on those three administrations were as follows:

6/95 1/96 5/96 Broad Reading 5.0 6.0 7.8 Broad Written Language 4.2 5.4 5.6 Basic Reading Skills 5.2 6.5 8.2 Reading Comprehension 6.1 7.8 8.4 Basic Writing Skills 3.8 5.3 5.1

On June 14, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met to consider his summer program. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would work one-on-one with Ms. Lama for two hours per day for four weeks. Ms. Lama would work with STUDENT on math, reading, writing, science, and physical education, with the objective that STUDENT would earn 18 credits. FATHER signed the IEP in agreement with the summer pgoram.

On September 6, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met pursuant to the mediation agreement in August. The IEP team developed goals and objectives relating to completion of units towards graduation, passage of competency tests, application of word analysis skills in reading, application of literal reading comprehension skills, written composition, spelling, independent reading, decoding, and vocational awareness. The IEP called for an interim placement in the resource specialist program and vocational counseling pending mediation. The mediation never took place, and the interim placement became STUDENT's permanent placement. The IEP included a transition plan and was signed by STUDENT's parents in agreement with the recommendations of the IEP team. STUDENT's Fall 1996 schedule included a resource specialist class with Lori Hill, regular education art, regular education computer skills, physical education, teacher's aide in physical education, and one period of one-on-one work on reading with Mr. James. Mr. James used the Project Read curriculum to work with STUDENT.

On October 30, 1996, STUDENT was evaluated at the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center. The assessor, Erin Egli, clinical director, concluded that STUDENT has significant difficulty with reading and spelling, including work attack, word recognition, spelling, and contextual reading. Ms. Egli also found weaknesses in decoding. receptive oral vocabulary, and oral language comprehension. On the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised, STUDENT scored at the fourth grade level in reading and spelling, and at the sixth grade level in arithmetic. STUDENT also scored at the 3.7 grade level on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-Revised. Ms. Egli recommended that STUDENT receive intensive "cognitive training" for four to six hours per day for ten weeks.

On November 7, 1996, Mr. James taped STUDENT twice while he was reading. The first time, Mr. James used a recorder he brought from home. The quality of the recording was not very good, so Mr. James taped STUDENT again in the class in which STUDENT was a teacher's aide. The quality was again not very good because of background noise, so Mr. James taped STUDENT one more time, on November 8, 1996.

STUDENT was withdrawn from school by his parents on December 10, 1996. Following STUDENT's withdrawal from school, the District requested permission to conduct an assessment for home instruction. The PARENTS did not give permission for such an assessment. STUDENT has not returned to school, and no home teacher was assigned.

On December 7, 1996, the California Department of Education completed a compliance investigation and found that the District had failed to timely assess STUDENT and convene an IEP meeting. Among the compliance investigator's findings were that MOTHER had requested an assessment in the early part of the 1991-92 school year, but that the District did not complete an assessment until October 1992.

On January 24, 1997, STUDENT's IEP team met to review his educational program. The IEP team drafted new goals and objectives and recommended placement to continue as it was when STUDENT was withdrawn from school. The PARENTS did not agree with the recommendations of the IEP team.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses

Elizabeth Lama

Elizabeth Lama was STUDENT's teacher during the 1995-96 school year in a special day class for seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) students. STUDENT was in Ms. Lama's class the entire day except for two periods when he attended the resource specialist program for reading and written expression. Ms. Lama worked with STUDENT primarily on math, science, and history.

Ms. Lama testified that she had to provide special materials for STUDENT because he was working at a level above the other students in her class. Ms. Lama testified that there were no other students in her class who just had learning disabilities. Ms. Lama testified that STUDENT was placed in her class because the IEP team thought he would do well in her class and because there were very few students in her class at the beginning of the school year. Ms. Lama testified that she decided her class was not appropriate for STUDENT after November 1995, when the number of students in her class increased to approximately thirteen. According to Ms. Lama, after this increase, STUDENT continued to make progress, but not as much.

Because there were few students in her class at the beginning of the school year, Ms. Lama was able to provide a lot of one-to-one assistance to STUDENT. Included in the curriculum of her class was Project Read, a program intended for children with learning disabilities or dyslexia. Ms. Lama testified that Project Read works on phonology, linguistics, and writing.

Ms. Lama stated that STUDENT thrived emotionally and educationally in her class. Ms. Lama also testified that STUDENT made progress in all areas addressed by his IEP and his self-esteem improved in her class.

Ms. Lama attended STUDENT's IEP meeting in June 1996 and signed in agreement with the placement. Ms. Lama testified that STUDENT's parents also signed in agreement with the placement. Ms. Lama served as STUDENT's tutor during the summer. Ms. Lama testified that STUDENT made progress on his goals and objectives and gained credits toward graduation.

Ms. Lama testified that STUDENT needs work on decoding skills and needs more one-on-one assistance. Ms. Lama testified that Lindamood-Bell would be beneficial for STUDENT because it has a proven track record. Ms. Lama indicated that Project Read is also an appropriate program for STUDENT.

Patricia Lindamood(Footnote 3)

Patricia Lindamood is the director of the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Program. Ms. Lindamood testified that STUDENT was tested twice by the Lindamood-Bell program using the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LACT). According to Ms. Lindamood, the LACT is not standardized and is normed on regular education students. The only time Ms. Lindamood has spent with STUDENT was during a three hour evaluation in October 1996. Ms. Lindamood has never visited STUDENT's classes, met with his teachers, or reviewed the District's assessments.

Based on the results from the LACT, she found that STUDENT had processing deficits in phonemic awareness, concept imagery, and visual-spatial judgment. These processing deficits have resulted in weaknesses in vocabulary, reading, writing, and spelling. Ms. Lindamood testified that STUDENT's lack of phonemic awareness also means that he does not realize when he mispronounces a word. Ms. Lindamood also testified that frustration, depression, discouragement, and lack of motivation could be attributed to STUDENT's reading problems. Ms. Lindamood also stated that written tests would not show STUDENT's true ability or potential, and that timed tests would aggravate his problems.

Ms. Lindamood pointed to STUDENT's reading scores at the fourth grade level on the WRAT-R as evidence that he has a weakness caused by his lack of phonemic awareness. Ms. Lindamood testified that STUDENT scores higher on reading comprehension because he can understand more based on the context.

Ms. Lindamood testified that traditional multi-sensory phonics programs do not develop phonemic awareness in a child who does not yet have the skill. Ms. Lindamood testified that using phonics programs with a child who does not have phonemic awareness may result in the child memorizing some words, but problems would persist. According to Ms. Lindamood, if STUDENT is working on reading based on a phonics program, he will not pass the reading competency test. Ms. Lindamood testified that STUDENT needs concept imagery and phonemic awareness, skills that are different than those taught in traditional classroom instruction.

According to Ms. Lindamood, the Lindamood-Bell program is certified by the California Department of Education and provides an intensive five day per week, four hour per day program. Ms. Lindamood stated that STUDENT would need at least six weeks of the program because of his reading, spelling, and vocabulary weaknesses. Ms. Lindamood testified that the teachers in the program are not necessarily credentialed, but they have undergone a special 40-hour training session. The services offered by Lindamood-Bell are at the program's office and not on a school site. The only interaction with other students occurs between sessions. All sessions are one-to-one.

FATHER

FATHER is STUDENT's stepfather. FATHER testified that he contacted William Cirone, District superintendent, in July or August 1996, because he and his wife were at an impasse with the District and SELPA. FATHER testified that he felt that the District was dictating to them what should be done rather than trying to work with them.

FATHER testified that during the mediation in Summer 1995, he tried to get Lindamood-Bell services for STUDENT. FATHER testified that, although he was represented by an attorney, he felt coerced into signing the mediation agreement at that time. According to FATHER, his attorney and the mediator explained to him and MOTHER that the special day class proposed for STUDENT at that time "was a safe place for STUDENT," and that it was a small class in a quiet environment. FATHER testified that he did not know at the time that the class was for seriously emotionally disturbed students.

FATHER testified that they requested a tutor for STUDENT in August 1995. The tutor was Pat Vanderhyden, a former teacher from the Lindamood-Bell program. According to FATHER, the District denied their request. Although the District denied the request, STUDENT had two sessions with Ms. Vanderhyden, and she indicated that STUDENT did well with the Lindamood-Bell system. FATHER also testified that he presented the results from the Lindamood-Bell assessments, but that the District ignored the results.

FATHER expressed concern that the goals and objectives on STUDENT's IEPs have stayed the same over the past couple of years. FATHER testified that STUDENT's program has not worked for him for at least three years. FATHER also testified that the IEP form provided to the PARENTS at the IEP meeting on January 24, 1997, was typed up before the meeting. FATHER stated that he did not have any real input on the goals and objectives, although District representatives told him the goals and objectives were only proposed goals and objectives.

Regarding the IEP from September 1996, FATHER testified that only three pages (pages 1, 8, and 10) were produced at the IEP meeting. FATHER testified that the additional seven pages were added later without his consent.

FATHER testified that an assistant superintendent told him that the District had a "Project Read expert," David James, to teach STUDENT. According to FATHER, however, Mr. James was not qualified to teach Project Read in mid-1995. FATHER testified that he contacted the Project Read company in Minnesota and was told that a special education credentialed teacher would need approximately one week of training in Project Read. FATHER testified that he has not seen any positive results as a result of STUDENT's participation in the Project Read program with Mr. James.

FATHER testified that STUDENT did not want to go to school in Fall 1996, and that STUDENT was having problems with Mr. James. FATHER testified that he tried to discuss these problems with District personnel, including Ms. McLish, Diana Rigby, the principal, and the counsellor, but was told he and his wife could not talk to them because of the due process hearing request.

FATHER testified that STUDENT did not know he was being taped by Mr. James on November 8, 1996. FATHER also testified that STUDENT has been frustrated about his participation in special education and his belief that nobody is helping him.

MOTHER

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT failed computer typing and driver's education in the ninth grade, and that his science class that year was a "disaster" because his teacher did not know STUDENT had a disability. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has not accomplished any of his goals and objectives from that year other than gaining credits to graduate. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's goals and objectives have not changed from 1995 to the present.

MOTHER testified that, although she requested Lindamood-Bell services at the August 1995 mediation, District personnel told her that STUDENT would be taught using the Project Read program. MOTHER testified that, as of September 1995, Mr. James had only had one day of training in Project Read. MOTHER testified that Mr. James has told her that he uses a whole language approach, utilizing flash cards, sight words, and whole language.

MOTHER testified that the District's educational program for STUDENT has not had any positive effect because he still cannot read. MOTHER stated that, while the District has identified all areas of discrepancy that STUDENT has, including listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, and reading comprehension, the District does not know how to meet his needs; if they did, he would be able to read and write by now.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT withdrew from school in November 1996 because his ulcers were acting up and he felt betrayed by Mr. James over the taping.

District Witnesses

Diana Rigby

Diana Rigby has been the director of student services for the District for the past one and a half years. As the director of student services, Ms. Rigby is responsible for implementing the special education programs.

Ms. Rigby participated in the mediation and IEP meeting in August and September 1995 which resulted in STUDENT's placement in Ms. Lama's special day class. Ms. Rigby testified that, based on the mediation agreement, STUDENT's IEP called for him to receive small group instruction in the resource specialist program and one-on-one with Mr. James. Ms. Rigby testified that Ms. Lama's class had the fewest number of students in it at the time. Ms. Rigby also stated that when MOTHER found out that Ms. Lama's class was an SED class, she still wanted STUDENT to remain in the class because he worked well with Ms. Lama.

Ms. Rigby attended the IEP meeting in September 1996. Regarding that meeting, Ms. Rigby testified that STUDENT's teachers brought proposed goals and objectives to the meeting for discussion purposes. Ms. Rigby testified that the PARENTS left the meeting without taking the proposed goals and objectives with them. According to Ms. Rigby, she told the PARENTS that the goals and objectives would be put in proper form and given to them at a mediation that was scheduled to take place ten days later.

Ms. Rigby testified that a mediation was scheduled for shortly after the September IEP meeting. According to Ms. Rigby, the PARENTS did not attend the meeting because their advocate did not advise them of the date and time of the meeting.

Ms. Rigby attended the IEP meeting in January 1997. Ms. Rigby testified that team members again prepared draft goals and objectives for discussion purposes. Ms. Rigby also stated that the goals and objectives developed at that meeting were not implemented because STUDENT's parents did not sign them. Ms. Rigby testified that the PARENTS did not agree with the assessment results discussed at the IEP meeting, but did agree with the areas of specialized instruction developed by the IEP team. Ms. Rigby testified that the PARENTS requested placement at Lindamood-Bell, but the District representatives did not believe placement at Lindamood-Bell was appropriate based on the IEP that was developed.

Ms. Rigby testified that she believes STUDENT's goals and objectives and the program offered by the District are appropriate because he was making appropriate progress. Ms. Rigby indicated that STUDENT needs 220 credits to graduate and if he completes all of his assigned courses for fall '96 and spring '97, he would qualify for graduation. Ms. Rigby testified that STUDENT has passed the math and writing proficiency tests and only needs to pass the reading proficiency test.

Colette Wright

Colette Wright is a mentor teacher and speech and language pathologist for Ocean View School District. Ms. Wright also works as an educational consultant for other school districts, including Santa Barbara High School District. Ms. Wright reviewed the assessment completed in October 1996 by Lindamood-Bell.

Ms. Wright expressed numerous concerns regarding the Lindamood-Bell assessment. Among these concerns were that Lindamood-Bell used subtests rather than complete batteries which reduces the reliability of the results. Ms. Wright also testified that the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude (DTLA), which Lindamood-Bell used as a diagnostic test, is supposed to be used only as a screening test. Ms. Wright expressed the same opinion regarding Lindamood-Bell's use of the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R). Ms. Wright testified that the PPVT-R may provide a general picture that a disability may exist, but a more detailed instrument should be used to determine the actual existence and identity of the disability. As to the Gray Oral Reading Test administered by the Lindamood-Bell program, Ms. Wright testified that it is a dated instrument and should not be included in a diagnostic evaluation. Finally, regarding the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LACT), Ms. Wright testified that the test is used to determine a child's ability to recognize specific sounds, and order and shift sounds. Ms. Wright testified that the LACT uses nonsense sounds and syllables that do not relate to everyday sounds and is, therefore, not relevant to everyday speech.

Ms. Wright also reviewed the District's assessment and concluded that the District used reliable instruments in a thorough and multi-disciplinary assessment. Ms. Wright testified that the District's assessment presented a more complete picture of STUDENT than did the Lindamood-Bell assessment. Ms. Wright testified that, based on the assessment results, the goals and objectives developed in January 1997 were appropriate and designed to address his areas of weakness.

Regarding Project Read, the reading program used by the District, Ms. Wright testified that it is a multisensory teaching strategy that works on phonology, comprehension, and written language. Project Read requires direct instruction and teaching directed to a student's own learning modalities in all three areas. Ms. Wright testified that the phonology component of Project Read teaches specific sound symbol relationships which are then used in words, sentences, and paragraphs. The Project Read methodology teaches strategies which allow a student to learn "around or through" their disability. For example, Project Read addresses phonemic awareness. However, if a student does not develop phonemic awareness, a teacher using Project Read would teach the student alternative strategies. The objective of the Project Read program is for students to learn the strategies rather than memorizing words and sounds.

Ms. Wright testified that she listened to the tape of STUDENT's reading made by Mr. James. Ms. Wright testified that she was impressed that his reading was as fluent as it was. She identified STUDENT's use of long and short vowels, recognition of silent letters, recognition of "ph" as the "f" sound, and the fact that he did not pause or have difficulty with phonetically irregular words as signs that he was reading at a higher level than his test scores may indicate.

Ms. Wright testified that a student with a learning disability will always have the disability. The responsibility of a school district is to provide such a student with strategies to work around the disability and learn skills.

Joanne Freeman

Joanne Freeman is an educational consultant with the Santa Barbara High School District. Ms. Freeman has administered the Woodcock-Johnson over 1,000 times. Ms. Freeman testified that the manual for the Woodcock-Johnson recommends giving the test no more often than every six months. Ms. Freeman also testified that there are two different versions of the Woodcock-Johnson that can be administered and that it was unclear which version was given the other times the Woodcock-Johnson was administered.

Ms. Freeman testified that the results from her assessment of STUDENT were valid and accurate. Ms. Freeman testified that STUDENT has a processing deficit which qualifies him for special education. specifically, Ms. Freeman pointed to his difficulty in retaining information for a long period of time.

David James

David James is a resource specialist at Dos Pueblos High School and was one of STUDENT's teachers for until November 1996. He worked with STUDENT for approximately one and a half years. Mr. James testified that he has received training in Project Read in September and November 1995 (total of five days), and August 1996 (three days).

Mr. James testified that when he first met STUDENT, STUDENT was lacking phonics skills, his reading was halting, and he had little reading comprehension. Mr. James testified that he has used a variety of techniques and strategies with STUDENT. He first used "echo reading" which involved STUDENT and Mr. James reading the same passage together. He has also had STUDENT work on silent reading for comprehension. Another strategy Mr. James has used is "directed reading and thinking" which requires STUDENT to read a passage and then predict what will happen next. Mr. James testified that the most successful strategy has been "reciprocal reading" in which he and STUDENT alternate reading paragraphs. Mr. James testified that he has also used flash cards to work on phonics with STUDENT.

Mr. James testified that he was responsible for the small-group instruction called for in the mediation and IEP from 1995. Mr. James testified that STUDENT's small-group instruction was never with more than five students.

Regarding the taping on November 7 and 8, 1996, Mr. James testified that STUDENT was reluctant at first to be taped on November 7, but he eventually did agree to do it. Mr. James testified that STUDENT agreed to do the recording on November 8, 1996, as well. Mr. James testified that the recording on November 8, 1996, took place in his classroom and that STUDENT did not express any problems with the recording. Mr. James testified that he did another recording on November 8, 1996, because the first one from November 7, 1996, was "scratchy" and the second one was made outside so there was too much background noise. Mr. James testified that STUDENT chose what to read for the recordings and the he had never read those articles prior to the actual recording. Mr. James testified that he never taped STUDENT without his permission. Mr. James also stated that he also records other students. He conducts these tapings to track the students' progress and to place in their files.

Mr. James testified that STUDENT's attitude "soured" around the beginning of November 1996. According to Mr. James, STUDENT told him that he did not want to come to school and that he did not have to do any work if he did not want to. Mr. James testified that STUDENT did not seem to care anymore. Mr. James testified that STUDENT's attendance has adversely affected his grades.

Lori Hill

Lori Hill is a resource specialist at Dos Pueblos High School. She has worked with STUDENT one period per day since September 1996. Ms. Hill testified that STUDENT's weaknesses are in reading comprehension and written expression. To address these weaknesses, Ms. Hill worked with STUDENT on literal and interpretive reading, and in the area of written expression on business letters and forms.

Ms. Hill testified that she uses some Project Read techniques with STUDENT, along with reciprocal reading, oral reading, and direct reading and thinking. Ms. Hill also uses Cloze paragraphs, which are paragraphs with blank lines that need to be filled in. The Cloze paragraphs involve reading comprehension..

DISCUSSION

(1) (a) Has Santa Barbara High School District provided STUDENT with an appropriate education?

(b) If not, should STUDENT be placed in the Lindamood-Bell Program?

State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions."

Special education law also requires that a student's educational program takes place in the least restrictive environment and that removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 34 C.F.R. § 300.550.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Centeral School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175, 200.

Taken together, the IDEA and Rowley provide four factors for analyzing whether a District's placement is appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:

(1) Did the District's placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?

(2) Did the District's placement meet STUDENT's unique needs?

(3) Did the District's placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit? (4) Did the District's placement take place in the least restrictive environment? _________________________________ (1) Did the District's placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?

There were no allegations, and no evidence, that STUDENT's placement over the past four years did not conform to his IEPs or that his parents did not consent to those IEPs.

(2) Did the District's placement meet STUDENT's unique needs?

The evidence establishes that STUDENT had a learning disability which affected his ability to read and write. The evidence also establishes that for much of the past four years the District has provided STUDENT with a significant amount of one-on-one and small-group instruction in reading and writing. During the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT received 1-2 periods of resource specialist services per day specifically geared to remediating his reading and writing deficits.

STUDENT spent the 1994-95 school year at home with two different home teachers. Little evidence was submitted regarding the 1994-95 school year, other than the fact that his first home teacher was not a credentialied special education teacher and there was a gap of several months when STUDENT did not have a home teacher.

During the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years, STUDENT continued to receive two periods of resource specialist services per day. One of these periods was devoted to one-on-one work while the other was devoted to small-group instruction. The resource specialist teachers who worked with STUDENT the past two years incorporated Project Read and other strategies to work with STUDENT's deficits and teach him alternative strategies to progress in reading and writing. STUDENT also spent several periods a day during the 1995-96 school year in Ms. Lama's class where, according to Ms. Lama, he received a significant amount of one-on-one assistance from Ms. Lama.

Petitioner contends that Ms. Lama's class did not meet STUDENT's unique needs because it was a class for seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) children. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that there is nothing in special education law which states or implies that an SED placement would automatically be inappropriate for a child who only has a learning disability. Instead, special education law is based on the idea that each child should be educated based on his or her own unique educational needs rather than on a particular label. See Education Code §§ 56001(i), 56031, and California Code of Regulations, Title 5, Division 1, § 3042.

Therefore, rather than focusing on the label of eligibility for the students in Ms. Lama's class, the Hearing Officer focuses on the fact that STUDENT received a significant amount of one-on-one assistance in a small group environment during much of the 1995-96 school year. STUDENT also received two periods of resource specialist assistance devoted specifically to his reading and writing deficits. Based on the level of services STUDENT received during the 1995-96 school year, the fact that STUDENT was in an SED class does render the placement inappropriate. Instead, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's placement during that school year was designed to meet his unique needs and did so.

The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT's placements during the 1993-94 and 1996-97 school were designed to meet his unique needs because of the level of assistance provided to meet his needs in reading and writing. With regards to the 1994-95 school year, there was insufficient evidence presented to find that the District's placement did not meet STUDENT's needs.

(3) Did the District's placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?

Much of Petitioner's argument that the District's placement was not appropriate rests on Petitioner's contention that STUDENT did not receive educational benefit while enrolled in the District's schools. The evidence, however, does not support Petitioner's contention.

STUDENT's teachers testified that STUDENT made progress during his years at Dos Pueblos High School. STUDENT's testing on the Woodcock-Johnson over the past two years shows steady progress in all of the areas tested. While there was some evidence to suggest that STUDENT's later scores on the Woodcock-Johnson were inflated because he had taken the test several times over a short period of time, the Hearing Officer finds that there was sufficient, credible evidence to support the conclusion that the later test results were valid.

First, there was testimony that indicated that the test was not given too frequently to impact STUDENT's scores through the practice effect. The test was given three times over the course of one year, or once every six months. Ms. Freeman testified that the manual suggests that the test should not be administered more often than every six months. Ms. Freeman also indicated that there are two different versions of the test and it is unclear which version STUDENT was given each time he took the test. Therefore, the evidence does not establish that STUDENT took the same version each time he took the test. Even if he had, it does not appear that he took the test too frequently to render the later results invalid or suspect.

Second, STUDENT's teachers testified regarding the progress STUDENT made. Ms. Lama testified that STUDENT progressed both academically and emotionally while in his class and during her tutoring with him during Summer 1996. Ms. Hill and Mr. James also testified regarding the progress they saw during their time with him. Additionally, Mr. James provided a tape recording of STUDENT's reading in November 1996. Based on the contents of that tape, Ms. Wright testified that STUDENT's reading level was actually higher than his test scores indicated.

Based on the progress STUDENT made as evidenced by his standardized test scores, the testimony of his teachers, and the contents of the tape recording, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement over the past four years provided STUDENT with educational benefit.

(4) Did the District's placement take place in the least restrictive environment?

The primary area of concern with regards to the least restrictive environment is STUDENT's placement during the 1995-96 school year. The evidence establishes that during the 1995-96 school year STUDENT was in a special day class for SED students for much of the day with very little interaction with his regular education peers. Although the evidence establishes that STUDENT's needs were met in that class, the evidence also establishes that STUDENT could have been successful in a regular education environment.

STUDENT's placement during the 1996-97 school was in the resource specialist program with several periods of regular education per day. STUDENT continued to progress in that placement and there is no evidence to suggest that STUDENT could not have experienced success in such a placement during the 1995-96 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement for STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year in a special day class for SED students was not in the least restrictive environment as required by § 300.550.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that, although the District's placements over the past four years met STUDENT's unique needs and provided him with educational benefit, the placement during the 1995-96 school year was not in the least restrictive environment.

In addition to the substantive requirements of the IDEA, Rowley also established that a school district's failure to comply with the procedural requirements of the IDEA could render its placement in appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, 204. Such procedural violations do not always render a school district's placement inappropriate. Rather, procedural violations may result in a finding of inappropriateness if they result in a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe the right of a student's parents to meaningful participate in the IEP process. See W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992).

Petitioner alleges numerous procedural violations relating to STUDENT's assessments, IEPs, and placement. Many of Petitioner's contentions are without merit. For instance, Petitioner contends that the District conducted illegal assessments without consent in January and May 1996 when Mr. James administered the Woodcock-Johnson test to STUDENT, and also when Mr. James taped STUDENT in November 1996.

Special education law requires parental consent for initial assessments, triennial reassessments, and assessments undertaken for the purpose of revising an IEP. Education Code § 56320 et seq. There is nothing to indicate that Mr. James' administrations of the Woodcock-Johnson were assessments requiring consent from the PARENTS. First, STUDENT's IEPs, consented to by his parents, call for progress on his goals and objectives to be measured by standardized tests. There is nothing in special education law or in STUDENT's IEPs which suggest that parental consent is required each time a student's progress is measured. The tests were administered to measure STUDENT's progress, not as a part of an initial assessment, triennial reassessment, or an assessment to revise his IEP. Second, there also is nothing about the taping in November 1996 which makes it an assessment requiring parental consent.

Furthermore, some of the alleged procedural violations also relate to substantive issues rather than procedural violations. For instance, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to adequately address his language processing deficits. The procedural violations which Rowley and W.G. refer to are, for instance, notice and opportunity to participate in IEP meetings. The procedural violations do not also include substantive issues relating to the actual provision of services to a student.

Ultimately, the most compelling procedural violations which Petitioner alleges relate to the District's failure to assess STUDENT until October 1992, although MOTHER requested an assessment at the beginning of the 1991-92 school year.(Footnote 4) The evidence establishes that MOTHER did request an assessment in the early part of the 1991-92 school year and that the District did not conduct any assessment until October 1992, approximately one year later. The evidence also establishes that STUDENT did not receive any special education services until after the assessment was completed and he was found eligible for special education services.

Education Code § 56321 requires that an assessment plan be developed within 15 days of a referral for assessment. Education Code § 56344 requires that, once an assessment plan is signed by the parent, an IEP team shall convene and develop an IEP within 50 days. Clearly, these timelines were not complied with by the District and the result was a denial of special education services for STUDENT for approximately one year. Such a denial is a significant loss of educational opportunity. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's failure to comply with the procedural requirements relating to conducting an assessment during the 1991-92 school year resulted in a denial of a free appropriate public education until STUDENT was found eligible for special education services in November 1992.

The issue is whether STUDENT is entitled to any relief for the District's failure to provide any special education services until November 1992. Courts have recognized a right to "compensatory education" pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e)(2), which provides that courts have the authority to "grant such relief as [it] determines is appropriate." Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 21 IDELR 723 (9th Cir., 1994). Equitable considerations are relevant in determining what relief, or compensatory education, is warranted. In Student W. court stated that the test should be to apply a fact-specific analysis ... compensatory education is not appropriate. There is no obligation to provide a day-for-day compensation for time missed. Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Student W., 21 IDELR 723, 726-727.

The Student W. case is remarkably similar to the present case. In Student W., the student was denied special education services during his eighth and ninth grade years, but was subsequently provided with services and was on track to graduate. The Student W. court held that the district court's denial of the student's claim for compensatory education was appropriate under the circumstances.

Similarly, in the present case, while STUDENT was denied services for approximately one year, it is significant that the denial took place approximately five years ago and the District has since remedied the situation by providing appropriate services to STUDENT to allow him to receive educational benefit. STUDENT is also on track to graduate. Furthermore, while the District failed to provide a placement in the least restrictive environment during the 1995-96 school year, the placement that STUDENT was in during that year provided him with substantial educational benefit and did meet his unique educational needs.

Based on the fact that the District has provided STUDENT with appropriate services over the past four years, that STUDENT has received substantial benefit, and that he is on track to graduate, the Hearing Officer finds that he is not entitled to compensatory education. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to placement in the Lindamood-Bell program.(Footnote 5)

(2) Has Santa Barbara High School District adequately assessed STUDENT?

Petitioner contends that the District did not adequately assess STUDENT in all areas of disability. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the District did not identify his auditory discrimination deficit as identified in the Lindamood-Bell assessment.

The evidence establishes that the District conducted a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT's ability and achievement in 1992. Based on those results, STUDENT's IEP team found him eligible for special education as a result of a specific learning disability. Subsequently, in 1995, the District conducted a more comprehensive assessment which uncovered additional areas of weakness.

Special education law requires only that school districts assess children in areas of suspected disability. Education Code § 56320(f). There is nothing in the record to suggest that the District should have suspected any disabilities other than those assessed for in 1992. Furthermore, when the District reassessed STUDENT three years later, the District conducted a more comprehensive assessment covering additional areas raised by the Lindamood-Bell assessment.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District adequately assessed STUDENT.

(3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the following?

(a) A computer needs assessment.

Other than the fact that this assessment was conducted, no evidence was presented regarding this assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that insufficient evidence was presented to justify reimbursement.

(b) An assessment conducted by the Lindamood-Bell Program, including additional testing in January 1997.

Based on the Hearing Officer's decision under issue #2, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell assessments pursuant to Education Code § 56329.

(c) A computer and computer software.

Again, other than the fact that these items were purchased for STUDENT during the 1994-95 school year, no evidence was presented to indicate why he needed these items in order to benefit from his education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that insufficient evidence was presented to justify reimbursement.

(d) Photocopying costs.

No evidence was presented regarding this issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that insufficient evidence was presented to justify reimbursement.

(e) Costs associated with doctors appointments and medications for flareups of STUDENT's stress and ulcers.

No significant evidence was presented regarding this issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that insufficient evidence was presented to justify reimbursement.

ORDER

Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: May 27, 1997 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: Upon the completion of the hearing, the PARENTS retained attorney Steven Wyner to prepare and submit the closing argument on Petitioner's behalf. Footnote 2: At the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner also requested reimbursement for an independent assessment completed by Jennifer Zvi. The District indicated that it would pay for that assessment upon presentation of proof of the cost of the assessment. Therefore, this issue was removed from the issues for hearing. Footnote 3: During Ms. Lindamood's testimony, the District requested that her testimony be stricken from the record because she had referred to an unspecified document and had consulted with another individual during her testimony. The District's request was denied because Ms. Lindamood's conduct took place on the record and was not prejudicial to the District's case. Footnote 4:Petitioner also contends that the District failed to conduct a triennial reassessment by October 1995. However, there was significant evidence presented that a triennial reassessment, including a psychological assessment, health and development summary, and speech and language assessment, was completed in May and June 1995. Footnote 5: The Hearing Officer notes that there may also be concern regarding the fact that STUDENT has not been receiving educational services since November 1996, when he withdrew himself from school. However, it is significant that STUDENT was eighteen years old at the time and that the District did convene an IEP meeting in January 1997, at which time the District continued to offer a program similar to the program being provided at the time STUDENT left school.