California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 30, 1999
San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1016-99 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
San Lorenzo Valley Unified's 1998 reassessment ruled inappropriate; district must reimburse parents for an independent neuropsychologist's evaluation.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District asked for this hearing to defend its 1998 three-year reassessment of a 15-year-old high school student. The student was eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability. The parents represented themselves. They disagreed with the assessment and asked the District to pay for an independent evaluation by Tina Guterman, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist and pediatric neuropsychologist.
Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait found that the assessment was not appropriate. Resource specialist Roni Bramwell filled out a standard assessment plan and mailed it to the parents. The IEP team, including the parents, never reviewed existing data first, as the 1997 IDEA amendments required. The tests themselves met legal standards. However, the written reports by Ms. Bramwell and school psychologist Mary Sue Budrow left out elements required by state law, such as whether the student needed special education and whether there was a gap between ability and achievement. The June 1998 IEP could not fill those gaps. It explained little, and no regular education teacher attended the meeting.
The Hearing Officer rejected the District's arguments that the parents wanted a new type of assessment, did not really disagree, or chose an unqualified evaluator. A licensed psychologist was qualified. The District must reimburse the cost of Dr. Guterman's assessment, but not her witness fees. It must also write a complete report within 20 days and hold an IEP meeting within 25 days.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to defend its assessment. Testing that met technical standards was still inappropriate because the reassessment plan was made without the IEP team and the reports left out required findings. The Hearing Officer also held that a licensed psychologist could perform an independent evaluation.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Was the District's 1998 assessment of STUDENT appropriate?
The assessment was not appropriate. The IEP team, including the parents, did not review existing data in developing the reassessment plan as the 1997 IDEA amendments require, and the written reports omitted elements required by Education Code section 56327. The tests themselves met the legal requirements.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of an assessment by Tina Guterman, Ph.D.?
The parents disagreed with the District's assessment and were not seeking a new kind of assessment. Dr. Guterman, a licensed psychologist, was qualified, because the school-psychologist credential rule applies only to district assessments. The District must reimburse her assessment and report, but not her expert witness fees.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days of the decision, the District shall reimburse the parents for the cost of Dr. Tina Guterman's assessment and assessment report. The amount is not stated. The request for reimbursement of her expert witness fees for testifying was denied.
- Within 20 days of the decision, the District shall prepare an appropriate assessment report containing all elements required by law and provide a copy to the parents.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 25 days of the decision, a properly constituted IEP team shall meet to review the assessment report and all other relevant information, including Dr. Guterman's report. The team shall decide whether more assessment is needed and review and modify the IEP as appropriate.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; David D. v. Dartmouth School Committee, 775 F.2d 411 (1st Cir. 1985); 20 U.S.C. 1414; Cal. Educ. Code 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code 56320; Cal. Educ. Code 56327; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, 3001
People named in the decision
- Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office
- Laurie E. Reynolds, attorney for District, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Mary Bevernick (also spelled Bevrnick, Beternick), director of special services, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- William Rosse, school psychologist (1995 initial assessment), San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Roni Bramwell, resource specialist; academic achievement assessor, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Mary Sue Budrow, school psychologist; 1998 reassessment, San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District
- Tina Guterman, Ph.D., independent evaluator, licensed psychologist and pediatric neuropsychologist; witness for Student, Private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1016-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: SAN LORENZO VALLEY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Assessment Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 44-69807 District: San Lorenzo Valley Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter was heard by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Felton, California, on August 31 and September 1, 1999.
Petitioner San Lorenzo Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Laurie E. Reynolds. Also present on the District's behalf was Mary Bevrnick, director of special services. Respondent STUDENT was represented by his parents, MR. AND MRS. PARENT.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. On September 10, 1999, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
ISSUE
1. Was the District's 1998 assessment of STUDENT appropriate?
2. Is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of an assessment by Tina Guterman, Ph.D.?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 15-year-old high school student who has ben receiving special education services because of a specific learning disability.
STUDENT was first assessed to determine his eligibility for special education services in June 1995. STUDENT had been receiving home schooling during the 1994-95 school year. The assessment report by school psychologist William Rosse dated June 12, 1995, summarized STUDENT's present level of performance and the examiner's recommendation as follows:
STUDENT is a 10 year-old 5th grade student with superior cognitive capacities, whose academic performance levels are reported to be significantly below his aptitude abilities. There is no significant difference between STUDENT's verbal and performance IQ scores. Weaknesses have been measured in his Freedom from Distractibility and Processing Speed indices. There is evidence of a moderate delay in visual-motor skills. Although STUDENT appears to possess an above average ability in understanding social rules and concepts, his poor self-esteem and body imagery tends to isolate him from his peers, and may contribute to an overall feeling of dysthymia. Significant discrepancies have been demonstrated between STUDENT's aptitude levels )i.e., WISC-III performance) and his current academic achievement levels (as measured by the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho educational Battery). Accordingly, STUDENT qualifies for Special Education services due t his specific learning disability in writing skills.
Based upon the assessment results, the IEP team, on June 12, 1995, concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services because he had a specific learning disability. The IEP on June 12, 1995, concluded that STUDENT had a disorder in sensory-motor skills with a discrepancy in the area of written expression. The IEP called for resource specialist services "for one period a day for written language in a small-group, collaborative consultive setting.
The following year an IEP dated June 10, 1996, concluded that STUDENT continued to have a disorder in sensory-motor skills with discrepancies in basic reading and written expression. Resource specialist services were increased by providing "small-group individual instruction in English for one period a day and in math one period a day by main streaming with consultation."
The IEP dated June 11, 1997, found that STUDENT still had a disorder in sensory-motor skills, but did not specifically indicate an area of discrepancy. It provided for one period a day in resource specialist services in language arts.
On May 1, 1998, resource specialist Roni Bramwell completed a Notice of Referral/Assessment Plan and forwarded it to STUDENT's parents requesting that they consent to the assessment plan. The plan was prepared in order to meet the requirement that STUDENT be reassessed every three years and provided for assessment in the areas of health/development history, cognitive, academic achievement and personal, social, and emotional development The assessment was to be performed by a psychologist and a resource specialist. On May 2, 1998, STUDENT's parents consented to the plan.
Testing of STUDENT in the area of academic achievement was performed by resource specialist Roni Bramwell on May 20, 1998, using a set of tests from the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery- Revised (WJ-R) Test of Achievement. Ms. Bramwell concluded the following in her report:
When compared to others at his grade level, STUDENT's performance is high average in Broad Reading and Broad Written Language, and his performance is average in Basic Reading Skills, Broad Mathematics, Basic Writing Skills, and Broad Knowledge. No significant intra-achievement discrepancies were found.
STUDENT will find the performance demands of grade-level tasks involving Broad Reading easy; grade- level tasks involving Broad Mathematics, Broad Written Language, Broad Knowledge, and Basic Reading Skills will be manageable; grade-level tasks involving Basic Writing Skills will be difficult for him.
On May 20, 1998, STUDENT was also interviewed and tested by school psychologist Mary Sue Budrow. Tests included the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III), the Bender Gestalt, and the Draw a Person. Ms. Budrow's Assessments Report contains the following preprinted statement:
This report shall include but not be limited to (a) background information, including reason for referral, (b) a list of assessment tools utilized and results obtained including grade level, standard scores and interpretation; (c) relevant behavior during observation and its relationship to academic and social functioning; (d) whether the pupil has a specific handicap and the basis for making that determination; (e) any discrepancy between achievement and ability that cannot be corrected without special education and/or related services; (f) effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, where appropriate, (g) educationally relevant medical finding if any.
In Ms. Budrow's Assessment Report dated June 5, 1998, there is a box titled "Summary of Present Level of Performance and Recommendations." In that box Ms. Budrow states:
STUDENT is a 13 year old boy currently enrolled in 8th grade with resource specialist help in the areas of English. Overall cognitive skills measured within the superior range. Both verbal and non-verbal reasoning skills were significantly above average. Perceptual difficulties were noted in freedom from Distractibility and short term auditory memory. STUDENT takes Prozac for depression.
In her report, Ms. Budrow states that the assessment was part of a three-year evaluation of STUDENT and she briefly reviews his educational history. She summarizes her observation of STUDENT during the testing and her interview with him. In discussing the test results, Ms. Budrow states:
Cognition: STUDENT continues to show reasoning skills far above average. Overall verbal skills were at the 90th percentile while non-verbal reasoning skills were at the 98th percentile. Such strong skills were noted as STUDENT described his life and troubles in such an adult manner. Arithmetic reasoning and short term auditory memory were significant weaknesses as compared to STUDENT's other strong skills. Freedom from Distractibility was weak.
Superior verbal skills were noted in the following areas: fund of general information, verbal abstract reasoning, fund of expressive vocabulary and verbal common sense judgement about every day life situations.
Superior non-verbal reasoning skills included: visual alertness to details, non-verbal understanding of social sequence of events, non-verbal abstract reasoning and ability to assemble puzzle pieces to make a meaningful whole. Speed of copying figures combined with visual short term memory measured average.
Perceptual skills: Short term auditory memory measured low average, significantly below that expected based on STUDENT's cognitive skills.
Short term visual memory measured average.
Visual motor integration was age appropriate on the Bender. STUDENT copied the figures accurately. Three different time he started a figure, crossed out the attempt and drew the figure somewhere else on the page.
Social/Emotional: STUDENT continues to take Prozac
Ms. Budrow's report did not contain any discussion of whether STUDENT has a specific disability or the basis for making such a determination. It also did not contain any discussion of whether there is a discrepancy between achievement and ability that cannot be corrected without special education and/or related services.
An IEP meeting was held on June 5, 1998, which was attended by an administrator (Footnote #1) Bramwill, resource specialist; Ms. Brudrow, school psychologist, and STUDENT's parents. The IEP concluded, with little discussion, that STUDENT had a disorder in attention and a discrepancy in the area of basic reading. The IEP contains the statement that "Overall cognitive skills were superior. Weaknesses in auditory attention and memory." The IEP sets out the results of testing of academic achievement and contains a discussion of teacher observations and parent comments. It also contains statements that the cognitive skills fall within the superior range and that STUDENT has adequate visual motor integration but weak auditory memory. The IEP also recognizes a history of depression. The District IEP members recommended counseling, but STUDENT's parents requested that they provide the counseling through their insurance. The IEP team agreed on a goal relating to independent study skills and developed short-term objectives in that area. The IEP provided that STUDENT would receive resource specialist services for one period a day consisting of individualized instruction to teach organization and work completion. STUDENT's parents approved and signed the June 5, 1998
IEP.
On June 17, 1998, the IEP team met after STUDENT was suspended for expulsion for bringing a firearm facsimile to a school function. The purpose of the IEP meeting was to determine whether STUDENT's conduct was a manifestation of his disability. The IEP dated June 17, 1998, states that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder with a discrepancy in the areas of written language. The team, without the concurrence of STUDENT's parents, concluded that his actions were not a manifestation of his disability. STUDENT's parents did not appeal this determination, but, instead pursued and appeal of the discipline in the regular disciplinary process.
STUDENT enrolled in high school in October 1998. At the end of his first semester in high school, STUDENT was receiving failing grades in two classes because of his failure to turn in some assignments. These failing grades were a surprise to his parents and they started taking a more active role in relation to his education. An annual IEP meeting was help on April 14, 1999, to review STUDENT's progress. The IEP dated April 14, 1999, stated that STUDENT had a auditory processing disorder with discrepancies in written expression and math reasoning. The IEP provided for resource specialist assistance for a minimum of one class per semester which was to consist of "directed studies to support math and language mechanics, possible placement in L.C. World History with support study skills." STUDENT's parents did not approve the April 14, 1999 IEP.
On April 28, 1999 STUDENT's father wrote a letter to Mary Bevernick, director of special services, in which he stated that "the IEP conclusions have been unclear and conflicting" and that the "District has relied on insufficient testing when it made the recommendations at the IEP meeting." He stated that "there is no one on the districts staff who is qualified to perform the tests needed for my son's evaluation." He then stated that he intended to "obtain an independent assessment at public expense from Tina Guterman, PhD Pediatric Neuropsychology." On may 4, 1999, Ms. Bevernick responded to STUDENT's father and defended the Districts assessment of STUDENT and his programs. She requested that STUDENT's father state the specific problems that he wanted to address. She stated that more testing could be arranged by District staff. She further recommended that an IEP meeting be scheduled to discuss the concerns raised by STUDENT's father.
In the following weeks, there was a continuing exchange of letters between STUDENT's father and Ms. Beternick. STUDENT's father continued to request the District to either pay for an independent assessment by Dr. Guterman or request a hearing. Ms. Beternick questioned the need for an assessment by a neuropsychologist, contended that the District's assessments were appropriate, asked STUDENT's father to explain why he disagreed with the Districts assessments, and requested an IEP team meeting to discuss the issues. Ms. Beternick also agreed to have a District neuropsychologist perform an assessment of STUDENT.
On June 8, 1999 STUDENT's father wrote that he did disagree with the Districts assessment and once again requested the District to fund an independent assessment. He also stated:
"You say that I am "demanding a neuropsychological assessment." I am not. I am asserting our right to an outside assessment. Dr. Guterman, who happens to be a neuropsychologist, has been well recommended to me by service providers that have been effective in helping STUDENT. Dr. Guterman has access to previous testing and IEP's, and will coordinate an assessment tailored to my son."
In a letter dated June 24, 1999, the District requested a hearing to determine whether the District is obligated to pay for an independent assessment of STUDENT by Dr. Guterman.
On August 6 and 12, 1999, STUDENT was evaluated by Dr. Guterman. Dr. Guterman is a licensed psychologist but is not a credentialed school psychologist. Her report reviews STUDENT's educational background, including prior assessments, and sets forth her observations of STUDENT's behavior while she interviewed and tested him. She administered the following tests: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III), Woodcock Johnson Tests of Academic Achievement-Revised (WJ-R), Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), Written Expression, selected subtests of the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), California Verbal Learning Test-Child Edition (CVLT-C), Rey Osterrieth Complex Figure (ROCF), Trail Making Test A and B (Trails), Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (WCST), Controlled Oral Word Association (COWAT), Purdue Pegboard, Tactile Perception Test (TPT), Beery Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), Child Depression Inventory (CDI), Thematic Apperception Test (TAT), Incomplete Sentences Blank-Hight School Form, and Drawings.
Dr. Guterman concluded:
In sum, STUDENT is an extremely bright boy who has a long standing language based learning disability consisting of phonological processing deficits, and resultant weaknesses in the areas of processing symbolic information, retrieval, and written language.
Dr. Guterman set forth her opinion, that for a variety of reasons, the District's assessments of and programs for STUDENT were inadequate, and stated that "STUDENT continues to need consistent instruction in study skills and organizational strategies across subjects, particularly as the demands for independent organization and complexity increase in the upcoming years." She made a number of recommendations, including assistance in developing compensatory strategies, assistance in developing keyboarding skills, possible placement in one of the Landmark schools on the East Coast, and counseling.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides that:
A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists, as defined by regulations of the board, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing...to show that its assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.
In this case, after STUDENT's parents requested that the District fund the cost of an independent educational assessment, the District requested a hearing to demonstrate that its assessment of STUDENT was appropriate
To be appropriate, an assessment must be conducted to a valid assessment plan and must meet the requirements set out in federal and State law. Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) as amended in 1997, reevaluation of children with disabilities must occur at least once every three years. For all reevaluations, the IEP team shall:
A)review existing evaluation data on the child, including evaluations and information provided by the parents of the child, current classrooms-based assessments and observations, and teacher and related service providers observations; and B)on the basis of that review, and input from the child's parents, identify what additional, if any, are needed to determine- (i)whether the child has a particular category of disability, as described in Sec. 602(3), or, in case of reevaluation of a child, whether the child continues to have such a disability; (ii) the present levels of performance and educational needs of the child; (iii) whether the child needs special education and related services, or in the case of a reevaluation of a child, whether the child continues to need special education and related services;
and (iv) whether any additions or modifications to the special education and related services are needed to enable the child to meet the measurable annual goals set out in the individualized education program of the child and to participate, as appropriate, in the general curriculum. (Footnote #2)
Was the reassessment plan of STUDENT in 1998 conducted pursuant to an appropriate assessment plan?
In this case, there is no evidence that the 1998 reassessment plan for STUDENT was developed according to the federal requirements. There is no evidence that the members of the IEP team performed the required review of existing data in developing the assessment plan. Rather, the resource specialist completed a standard form assessment plan and forwarded it to the parents for their approval. There is no evidence that the parents were consulted or that other District members of the IEP team, other than the resource specialist, were involved in the required review. While the federal law does not specifically require that an IEP team meeting be convened for the purpose of such a review, it does anticipate some collaboration by the members of the IEP team in formulation such a plan. This collaboration did not occur in relation to the 1998 assessment plan for STUDENT. While it is true that STUDENT's parents approved the plan sent to them by the resource specialist, the District cannot thereby avoid its responsibility to properly formulate the reassessment plan under the law In fact, it is possible that if the appropriate collaboration with STUDENT's parents and other members of the IEP team had occurred it might have resulted in a more comprehensive assessment of STUDENT and diminished the desire of STUDENT's parents for an independent assessment.
Was the assessment of STUDENT appropriate pursuant to federal and State law?
Even though the assessment plan was not developed according to the law, the District conducted an assessment of STUDENT with approval form STUDENT's parents. It is necessary to determine whether that assessment was conducted in accordance with the law.
California Education Code Section 56329 governs the appropriateness of the District's assessment and sets forth, in pertinent part, the following requirements. Testing and assessments materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the pupil's primary language or test instructions; and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56320(a)-(b). In addition, the pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56320(c) Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a special education child. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56320(e) Finally, psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56324.
In this case, Ms. Budrow testifies that the tests given to STUDENT during his 1998 reassessment were not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory to STUDENT, were administered in his primary language (English), and were administered in conformance with test instructions. The tests were validated for the specific purpose for which they were used. The achievement tests were administered by Ms. Bramwell, a resource specialist trained in administering such tests, and the psychological tests were administered by Ms. Budrow, a credentialed school psychologist. Ms. Budrow testified that she has administered more thank a thousand such tests and is trained to assess cultural and ethnic factors. STUDENT was assessed in the areas of health/development, cognitive, academic achievement and social and emotional factors. No single procedure was used in assessing STUDENT. The psychologist utilized the WISC-III, the Bender Gestalt, the Draw a Picture test and a personal interview of STUDENT. In addition, STUDENTs academic achievement was measured using the WJ-R tests. During the IEP meeting on June 5, 1998, teacher evaluations and information provided by STUDENT's parents were also utilized in determining his career status. Therefore, it is concluded that the legal requirements set out above were satisfied during STUDENT's 1998 reassessment.
Did the District prepare an appropriate assessment report?
California Education Code Section 56327 requires the personnel who assess a pupil to prepare a written report, or reports, of the results of each assessment. The report(s) must include all of the following:
(a) Whether the pupil may need special education and related services. (b) The basis for making the determination.
(c) The relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting. (d) The relationship of that behavior to the pupil's academic and social functioning.
(e) The educationally relevant health and development , and medical findings, if any. (f) For pupils with learning disabilities whether there is such a discrepancy between achievement and ability that it cannot be corrected without special education and related services. (g) A determination concerning the effects of environment, cultural, economic disadvantage, where appropriate.
(h) The need for specialized services, materials, and equipment for pupils with low incident disabilities, consistent with guidelines established pursuant to Section 56136.
In this case there were tow written reports relating to STUDENT's 1998 reassessment. The report by the resource specialist, Ms. Bramwell, merely reports on the results of her academic testing of STUDENT. The report does not include any opinion concerning STUDENT's need for special education and related services, does not discuss his behavior during the testing or its relation to his academic or social functioning. Her report does not include an opinion concerning whether there is a discrepancy between achievement and ability.
The report by the school psychologist, Ms. Budrow, also fails to include many of the elements required by law and include many of the elements promised in the preprinted section of the assessment report. She does not include an opinion concerning STUDENT's need for special education and related services. While Ms. Budrow did include observations concerning STUDENT's behavior during the testing and interview, she did not discuss the relationship of that behavior to his academic and social functioning. In her discussion of test results in relation to social/emotional functioning, she merely states that "STUDENT continues to take Prozac." Ms. Budrow also neglected to discuss whether there is a discrepancy between achievement and ability. Therefore, it is concluded that the written assessment reports concerning the 1998 reassessment of STUDENT do not comply with the requirements set out in Education Code 56327.
The District argues that any shortcomings in the written assessments reports were cured by information contained in STUDENT's June 5, 1998 IEP (Footnote#3) Even if the IEP could be used to supplement the assessment report in meeting legal requirements for the assessment report, a review of the IEP fails to support the Districts's contention that the written assessment reports and IEP taken together constitute compliance with the law. The IEP merely contains a preprinted box which is checked to indicate the existence of a disorder in attention with a discrepancy in basic reading skills. It does not explain how that conclusion was reached beyond the statement that there is "weakness in auditory attention and memory." There is no discussion of the observation of STUDENT's behavior or the relationship of the behavior to his academic or social functioning. There is merely a note stating, "History of depression-currently severe depression...Recommend counseling. Parents request they provide counseling through their insurance." There is also little discussion concerning the severity of the discrepancy between STUDENT's achievement and ability or whether the discrepancy can be corrected without special education and related services. In fact, the IEP is probably not sufficient to meet the requirement that an IEP set forth current levels of educational functioning, let alone stand in place of the requirements of the written assessment reports.
There is another problem with using the June 5 1998 IEP to supplement the written assessment reports in determining whether the legal requirements with respect to those reports have been met.
Federal law provides that the IEP team must include at least one regular education teacher of the child. 20 U.S.C 1414(d)(1)(b). One of the things that STUDENT's parents consistently objected to with respect to STUDENT's IEP's was that there was never one of his regular education teachers present at the meetings. The June 5, 1998 IEP does not reflect that of any of STUDENT's regular education teachers present at the IEP meetings. Therefore, using this IEP to supplement the written assessment reports is even less appropriate since there was not a properly constituted IEP team to review the information and prepare the report.
The District contends that the failures to comply with the law with respect to the preparation of the assessment plan and the assessment reports are mere procedural errors that did not prejudice STUDENT's right to receive a free, appropriate public education.
The United States Supreme Court in the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. Al. V. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175 emphasizes the importance of procedures in ensuing an appropriate educational program for disabled students. It states:
It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardian a large measure of participation at every state of the administrative process...as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard. We think that the "Congressional emphasis upon full participation of concerned parties throughout the development of the IEP,... demonstrate the legislative conviction that adequate compliance with the procedures prescribed would in most cases assure much if not all of what Congress wished in the way of substantive content in an IEP. 3EHLR 553.670
The requirement of federal law to have the IEP team collaborate on the development of the assessment plan and the requirement of State law concerning the written assessment reports are designed to ensure clear communication among those responsible for a child's education and the child's parents. Only through such clear communication can an appropriate educational plan meet a child's unique needs be assured.
This case reminds the Hearing Officer of a line from the motion picture Cool Hand Luke: "What we have here is a failure to communicate." The District failed to properly communicate with the parents and other IEP members concerning the development of an appropriate assessment plan. By failing to prepare an appropriate assessment plan, the District failed to communicate to STUDENT's parents the results of the assessment. The principle reason STUDENT's parents gave for requesting an independent assessment was that they did not understand STUDENT's disability or its effect on his ability to succeed in his educational program. If the District had communicated with STUDENT's parents as required by law, they may not have sough additional assistance in the form of independent assessment. Unfortunately, by the time Ms. Beternick requested STUDENT's parents to meet with the other members of the IEP to facilitate clear communications, STUDENT's parents had reached a level of frustration that led them to resist further meetings without some assistance from an independent evaluator.
In this case, it is not clear whether or how the failures by the District to comply with appropriate procedures may have been affected STUDENT's assessment or educational program. It is possible that if the District had followed appropriate procedures, STUDENT's assessment and educational program would have been different.
Because of the District's failure to comply with the law concerning the formulation of the assessment plan and its failure to prepare the necessary assessment report, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's assessment of STUDENT was not appropriate.
Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment by Dr. Guterman?
The District contends that it is not required to pay for the assessment by Dr. Guterman because STUDENT's parents had the were requesting a new kind of assessment (by a neuropsychologist) and the District had a right to perform its own neuropsychological assessment prior to the parents being able to request an independent neuropsychological assessment.
The facts demonstrate that STUDENT's parents were not requesting a new kind of assessment. In his letter dated June 5 1999, STUDENT's father stated"
"You say that I am "demanding a neuropsychological assessment." I am not. I am asserting our right to an outside assessment. Dr. Guterman, who happens to be a neuropsychologist, has been well recommended to me by service providers that have been effective in helping STUDENT. Dr. Guterman has access to previous testing and IEP's, and will coordinate an assessment tailored to my son."
Again we have a failure to communicate. The District thought that because Dr. Guterman was a neuropsychologist, STUDENT's parents were requesting a new kind of assessment. But they were not. They merely wanted an assessment by an independent expert who had been recommended to them by people they trusted. STUDENT's father clearly stated that in his June 8, 1999 letter.
The District contends that it should not be required to pay for Dr. Guterman's assessment because STUDENT's parents did not disagree with the Districts assessment. Education Code Section 56329 provides that a parent is entitled to an independent educational evaluation at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the public education agency. In this case, STUDENT's parents made it clear that they did disagree with the Districts assessment. In his letter date June 8, 1999, STUDENT's father wrote this to Ms. Bevernick,
I appreciate the legal advice you gave in your letter: "Code 56329 clearly gives the District the right to assess." You have, and you consider it "valid." "If you chose to disagree with the results of that assessment, then you may seek outside assessment." We do and we are.
While the law does not require that a parent state the reasons they disagree with an assessment, STUDENT's father did state in his letter dated April 28, 1999, a number of reasons for his dissatisfaction with the Districts actions, including that he believed the District had relied on insufficient testing and that they did not believe the Districts staff were qualified to conduct the assessment. They also stated that "the IEP conclusions have been unclear and conflicting." This is significant in that the District claims that the IEP of June 5, 1998 supplemented the assessment reports. Not only did STUDENT's parents state that they disagreed with the District's assessment, they also stated a number of reasons for that disagreement.
The District further contends that it should not be required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the assessment by Dr. Guterman because Dr. Guterman is not qualified to conduct psychological testing.
California Education Code Section56329 provides that the parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil "from qualified specialists, as defined by regulations of the board..." There does not appear to be any regulations by the board that address the specific qualification necessary for the specialists who perform independent evaluations. However, Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 3001(af), defines of "qualified" as follows:
"Qualified" means that a person has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services, or, in the absence if such requirements, the state-education-agency- approved or recognized requirements, and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation...
In this case, the evidence establishes that Dr. Guterman is a licensed psychologist in California. Therefore, it is concluded that she is qualified to conduct psychological assessments under the state regulation defining "qualified"
The District claims that Dr. Guterman is not qualified because Education Code Section 56320(e) states that psychological assessments must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Section 56320(e) is one of the provisions that establish the requirements for assessments performed by local educational agencies. While this section does not specifically state that it only applies to assessments performed by local educational agencies its placement in the Education Code would lead to the reasonable conclusion that it is applicable only to assessment performed by such agencies.
Therefore, because the Districts reassessment of STUDENT was not appropriate and because the independent assessment performed by Dr. Guterman met the requirements of an independent assessment, it is concluded that the District must reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of Dr. Guterman's assessment.
STUDENT's parents have requested reimbursement for the cost of having Dr. Guterman testify during the hearing. Education Code Section 56329(b) only provides the right of a parent to receive reimbursement for the cost of an assessment when the Districts assessment is not appropriate, It does not provide a right to reimbursement for expert witness fees. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT's parents are only entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Guterman's assessment and assessment report.
ORDER
1. Within 20 days from the date of this decision, the District shall prepare an appropriate assessment report that contains all of the elements required by law and shall provide a copy of the report to STUDENT's parents. Within 25 days of the date of this decision, a properly constituted IEP team will meet to review the assessment report and all other relevant information, including Dr. Guterman's report. The IEP team will determine if additional assessment is required and will review and modify STUDENT's IEP as appropriate.
2. Within 30 days of the date of this decision the District shall reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of Dr. Gutermans assessment of STUDENT.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d) the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Respondent prevailed on the issues of the appropriateness of the District's assessment and the issue of reimbursement for the independent assessment.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i)
Dated: September 30, 1999 Glenn A. Fait Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1. The identity of the administrator is not clearly shown on the copy of the IEP provided to the Hearing Officer. 2. California State law concerning the procedure for developing a reassessment plan did not change to comply with federal law until January 1, 1999. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56321(b), then in effect provided that the assessment plan be prepared by the local education agency and forwarded to the parent for approval. This was done by the District. The Hearing Officer believes that the provisions of the amended IDEA which were in effect at the time of the reassessment of STUDENT are more protective of the rights of STUDENT's parents than state law, in that they guarantee the parents ability to participate in the planning of the assessment. Therefore, it is concluded that the District should have complied with the new federal procedures to the extent that they required consultation of the members of the IEP in the planning of the reassessment. See, e.g., David D. v. Darmouth, 775 F.2d 411 (1st Cir. 1985) 3. It is interesting to note that while the District contended that the June 5, 1998 IEP supplemented the written assessment reports, the District did not even place into evidence the June 5, 1998 IEP. The only reason that the Hearing Officer has the June 5, 1998 IEP is that STUDENT's parents placed it in evidence.
