California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 4, 1997

Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1018-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Colton Joint Unified's resource program for a student with a reading disability found appropriate; IEP meeting ordered only to add objective target dates.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A mother represented her 14-year-old son herself in a case against Colton Joint Unified School District. He was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability: a reading disability affecting decoding and word recognition. He took resource specialist program (RSP) classes at Colton High School. An earlier SEHO decision had required multisensory instruction and computer access. The parent argued that the District was not following that decision. She asked for more tutoring, the Scottish Rite reading program, a laptop, and reimbursement for an evaluation by educational therapist Regina Richards.

Hearing Officer Mark Paxson found the RSP program appropriate under Rowley. The student's first math class of the year did not meet his needs. The District then moved him to teacher Fred Vartanian's class, which did. English teacher Tobin Brinker credibly described his multisensory methods, and the student was earning an A. In eight months, his reading goals rose from fifth-grade level to seventh- and eighth-grade level. The District could carry out IEP goals the parent had not signed. She had agreed to them in a mediation agreement and did not object to their content. Computer access met the earlier order. The District's progress testing was appropriate, so the $115 evaluation and $300 for testimony were not reimbursed. The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days to add target dates for short-term objectives. The District prevailed on all issues.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The case shows how SEHO used Rowley's three-part test and treated a district's fix of a weak class as curing the problem. It also shows that Ed. Code 56346 let a district carry out goals the parent had agreed to in substance. Finally, a narrow progress-testing assessment did not have to include recommendations.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Are the resource specialist services provided by the District for STUDENT appropriate?

    Under Rowley, the RSP placement met the student's unique needs, matched his IEPs, and gave him educational benefit. His early math class was not appropriate, but the District fixed this by moving him to a new math class.

  2. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1A. Has the District been following the Hearing Officer's orders by using multisensory techniques in English class?

    The prior order did not specify which multisensory techniques to use. The English teacher was using multisensory techniques, and they were giving the student educational benefit.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1B. Has the District been implementing the unsigned IEPs?

    The parent had agreed to the August 1996 goals in a signed mediation agreement and did not object to the content of the other goals, so Ed. Code 56346 allowed the District to implement them.

  4. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP content

    Issue 1C. Is the parent being provided a way to track the progress on short term instruction plans and is the instruction plan by the week, day, or month? (34 CFR 300.346)

    Section 300.346 does not require the District to give the parent lesson plans. However, the IEPs should state target completion dates for short-term objectives, so an IEP meeting was ordered to add them.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1D. Did the District fail to document an agreement on the IEP in May 1996 for a general education tech class? Did the District change the RSP placements without holding an IEP team meeting? Was the parent notified of the modification when RSP keyboarding was ordered? Did the District have an appropriate keyboarding program designed for dyslexics?

    No evidence was presented that would allow the Hearing Officer to resolve these questions.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1 (prewritten goals). Whether the District's practice of bringing prewritten goals and objectives to IEP meetings was appropriate

    The draft goals could be changed at the meeting, and there was no evidence that the parent was prevented from giving input, so there was no violation.

  7. Issue 2. If not, does STUDENT need additional tutoring for him to receive a free appropriate public education?

    Not reached because the current program was found appropriate.

  8. Issue 2a. If yes, is Corrective Reading appropriate?

    Not reached because the current program was found appropriate.

  9. Issue 2b. If Corrective Reading is not appropriate, is the Scottish Rite program appropriate?

    Not reached because the current program was found appropriate.

  10. Issue 3. If not, are the recommendations made by Regina Richards necessary for a free appropriate public education?

    Not reached because the current program was found appropriate.

  11. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Is the access to computer provided by the District for STUDENT appropriate?

    No evidence supported the request for a laptop. The student had access to computers in every class where he needed one, as the prior decision required.

  12. Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Regina Richards' assessment completed on September 12, 1996, and for her time spent testifying in this matter?

    The school psychologist's July 1996 progress assessment was appropriate for its purpose, and Ed. Code 56327 does not require recommendations. No reimbursement was ordered for the $115 evaluation, and there was no legal authority for the $300 testimony fee.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Colton Unified School District to convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of receipt of the decision to amend the IEP to include projected dates of completion for the student's short-term instructional objectives.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Education Code § 56346(a); Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56327; Education Code § 56381; 34 CFR § 300.346 and Appendix C; SN 44-96 (prior decision)

People named in the decision

  • Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office
  • Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer in prior decision SN 44-96, California Special Education Hearing Office
  • Gail Lindberg, program manager; District representative and witness, East Valley SELPA
  • Bonnie Russell-Hunt, director of pupil personnel services, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Susan Evans, program specialist; administered Corrective Reading Placement Test, East Valley SELPA
  • Al Ong, school psychologist, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Regina Richards, educational therapist; independent evaluator and witness for Student, Private
  • Tobin Brinker, RSP English teacher, Colton High School
  • Lejon Stewart, responsibility teacher (RSP case coordinator), Colton High School
  • Fred Vartanian, RSP math teacher, Colton High School

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Bloomington, California, on December 10 and 11, 1996, and January 16 and 17, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was FRIEND, a friend of the family. Respondent Colton Joint Unified School District (District) was represented by Gail Lindberg, program manager, East Valley SELPA. Also present on the District's behalf was Bonnie Russell-Hunt, director of pupil personnel services for the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until March 14, 1997, for the submission of closing briefs. Upon receipt of the closing briefs on March 17, 1997, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Are the resource specialist services provided by the District for STUDENT appropriate?

(2) If not, does STUDENT need additional tutoring for him to receive a free appropriate public education?

(a) If yes, is Corrective Reading appropriate?

(b) If Corrective Reading is not appropriate, is the Scottish Rite program appropriate?

(3) If not, are the recommendations made by Regina Richards necessary for a free appropriate public education?

(4) Is the access to computer provided by the District for STUDENT appropriate?

(5) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Regina Richards' assessment completed on September 12, 1996, and for her time spent testifying in this matter?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is fourteen years old and eligible for special education as a result of a specific learning disability. Specifically, STUDENT has a reading disability with particular difficulty in decoding and word recognition. STUDENT is in the resource specialist program (RSP) at Colton High School. His classes include RSP math, English, and typing, and regular education courses in physical education, drama, and science.

In an earlier due process hearing involving STUDENT, the Hearing Office issued a decision on April 2, 1996.(Footnote 1) In that decision, Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel found that, although the District's program was substantially appropriate, the District was required to provide ten compensatory one-hour tutoring sessions and amend STUDENT's IEP to include the criteria for success on objectives in language arts, that RSP instruction must use multisensory teaching techniques, and that STUDENT must have access to a computer for completing written assignments and an electronic spellchecking device.

In response to Hearing Officer Garfinkel's order, the District provided tutoring sessions in the Corrective Reading program and scheduled an individualized education program (IEP) meeting for April 10, 1996. Upon MOTHER's request, the meeting was rescheduled for May 9, 1996. On May 9, 1996, the IEP team reviewed the goals and objectives and made modifications. The IEP team determined that the Brigance Diagnostic Comprehensive Inventory of Basic Skills (Brigance) would be used to measure STUDENT's progress in reading and math. MOTHER also requested that the school psychologist complete standardized testing. The IEP team agreed that math progress notes would be sent home once per month and STUDENT would take home English progress notes twice per month. The IEP team determined that STUDENT continued to require the academic support provided in the resource specialist program and that STUDENT's IEP of December 7, 1995, remained valid with the additions developed on May 9, 1996. MOTHER did not sign the IEP developed on May 9, 1996, although there is a note indicating that she would do so at a later date.

The IEP dated May 9, 1996, included seven goals related to reading, oral reading and comprehension, phonics (two goals), writing, structural analysis, and math. Each of the goals, in the area marked "Methods, Materials & Activities" indicated the multisensory techniques and materials to be used. The target date for achievement of the goals and objectives was December 1996. Many of the goals included in the IEP of May 9, 1996, are similar to those contained in the IEP developed on December 7, 1995, and signed by MOTHER. However, there were additional goals in reading, phonics, and structural analysis included in the IEP dated May 9, 1996.

On July 23, 1996, Al Ong administered two academic achievement tests to STUDENT to review his progress. According to Mr. Ong's report, previous testing conducted in December 7, 1995, indicated that STUDENT was at the fourth grade level in math and reading. On July 23, 1996, the testing included the Woodcock-McGrew-Werder Mini-Battery of Achievement (MBA) and the Brigance. On the MBA, STUDENT scored at the 5.4 grade level in reading (standard score 87), 5.3 grade level in mathematics (standard score 82), and 5.6 grade level in factual knowledge (standard score 88). On the Brigance, STUDENT scored at the fifth grade level in word recognition, and his scores in reading comprehension ranged from 100% correct at the fourth and seventh grade levels to 20% to 40% correct at the fifth and sixth grade levels. Mr. Ong concluded that STUDENT had achieved at least a year's growth since December 1995.

The IEP team met again on August 7, 1996, as part of a mediation-only request. The IEP team agreed to provide taped texts, reviewed goals and objectives, and determined that STUDENT continued to need the electronic speller and access to a computer for written assignments. Goals and objectives developed by the IEP team again listed the materials and multisensory techniques to be used by STUDENT's teachers in addressing those goals. The goals developed on August 7, 1996, were substantially similar to those developed on May 9, 1996, although some had increased grade level or accuracy requirements. The goals again set December 1996 as the target date for completion.

Although MOTHER did not sign the IEP, she did sign the mediation agreement produced on the same date. The mediation agreement included a provision that parent and district agree to goals and objectives written on 8-7-96 but parent is questioning whether District is utilizing multisensory techniques as indicated in the methods, materials and activities section of the objectives.

Following the August IEP meeting, STUDENT enrolled at Colton High School. When the school year started, he was in an RSP English and an RSP Math class. STUDENT was also in physical education, drama, keyboarding,(Footnote 2) and science.

On October 22, 1996, Susan Evans, program specialist for the East Valley SELPA, administered the Corrective Reading Placement Test to STUDENT. Based on the results, Ms. Evans concluded that STUDENT no longer needed "a corrective program." Ms. Evans stated in her report that STUDENT told her he did not have any "difficulties understanding content-area text." Ms. Evans recommended that "limited adaptations and periodic follow-up on his reading level should meet his needs."

On September 12, 1996, Regina Richards, educational therapist, reevaluated STUDENT at MOTHER's request.(Footnote 3) Ms. Richards administered the Brigance Computation of Whole Numbers test (Brigance Computation) and the Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests (WRMT-R). On the Brigance Computation, STUDENT had grade equivalent scores of 5+ in addition and subtraction, 3 in multiplication and division, and 7 in division with a calculator. On the WRMT-R, STUDENT scored at the 3.4 grade level in the Total Reading Cluster. Ms. Richards recommended that STUDENT be taught using a multisensory reading and spelling program and suggested that the Scottish Rite Multisensory Program would be helpful. Ms. Richards also recommended that STUDENT be allowed to use a calculator in math and that he review the procedures of multiplication, the use of a comma, and place value in naming numbers.

On September 16, 1996, MOTHER requested this hearing to address her concerns that the District was not complying with the decision issued on April 2, 1996, and that the District was still not providing STUDENT with an appropriate education.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY(Footnote 4)

FRIEND

FRIEND is a friend of Petitioner's family who has known STUDENT since he was born. FRIEND, however, has never observed STUDENT in school. FRIEND is an eighth grade life sciences teacher in a neighboring district.

According to FRIEND, STUDENT has dyslexia, which she described as an interruption in processing of what is seen on paper and how the brain interprets that information. FRIEND testified that multisensory teaching techniques should be used for dyslexics to utilize all senses to learn information.

FRIEND testified that she believes that STUDENT is not getting an appropriate education in his current program. According to FRIEND, STUDENT does not know what algebra is. FRIEND testified that STUDENT's RSP teacher should have explained to him at the outset what algebra is. FRIEND testified she had STUDENT read from 6th, 7th, & 8th grade state adopted textbooks. FRIEND testified that, based on STUDENT's reading from those textbooks, his work attack skills and oral reading skills are at approximately the 6th grade level.

FRIEND testified that STUDENT loses information when he has to write things from the board because the process of looking at the board and writing things down causes him to lose information.

STUDENT

STUDENT testified regarding his school experience during the current school year. He stated that he did not get his electronic speller until the third or fourth week. STUDENT testified that computers are in his math, English, and typing classes, but not in his physical education, science, or drama classes. STUDENT did state that he does not need a computer in physical education or drama, but that he would like to be able use one in science for note-taking.

STUDENT testified that, although he is allowed to use the computer in math, he has used it only once in that class. STUDENT testified that he is also allowed to use a calculator. He testified that he does not work on fractions in his math class. STUDENT stated that his math teacher gave him a "fractions packet" at the beginning of the school year to work on in addition to the algebra work the other students were doing. STUDENT indicated that he has received one afterschool tutoring session in fractions. At the time STUDENT testified, he indicated that he had received a "D" in math on his last report card.

STUDENT testified that in English, his teacher helps him and makes sure he knows what to do. STUDENT testified that he has had access to computers in English since the class moved to the computer lab in October 1996, although he is only allowed to complete final drafts on the computer. STUDENT testified that he reads aloud in English and that the teacher reads to the class about once a week. According to STUDENT, the teacher uses videotapes to help the students understand and remember the stories they are reading. The students also use outlines and word webs, which STUDENT described as circular outlines.

STUDENT testified that he does not want to participate in tutoring if it is after school. He stated that he thinks his teachers should teach him during class time. However, STUDENT also stated that if afterschool tutoring is the only option, he will participate.

STUDENT testified that Mr. Stewart showed him where the computers were at the beginning of the school year. STUDENT testified that he needs to use a computer for note-taking because when he takes notes off the board, he cannot read them later. STUDENT also indicated that a note-taker would help, but that he has never asked friends for notes.

Tobin Brinker

Tobin Brinker is STUDENT's RSP English teacher. Mr. Brinker testified that to address STUDENT's goals, he uses a multisensory approach, including cooperative webbing, group brainstorming activities, acting-out analogies, role playing, and graphic organizers. Mr. Brinker testified that he uses these different strategies within the core curriculum to work on STUDENT's goals.

Mr. Brinker reviewed STUDENT's August 1996 IEP during his testimony and provided the following information regarding STUDENT's goals:

Goal #1 (subject matter: reading) -- STUDENT is at the sixth grade level, but not at 90% accuracy. Mr. Brinker indicated that STUDENT is at about 80% accuracy.

Goal #2 (subject matter: comprehension) -- STUDENT has achieved 80% accuracy so he has met this goal. Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT seems to really understand the concepts that he is reading.

Goal #3 (subject matter: prefixes and suffixes) -- Mr. Brinker testified that he has not directly addressed this goal yet. Based on his course schedule, he anticipated reaching this topic in January 1997. However, Mr. Brinker did indicate that he works on this goal informally by discussing prefixes and suffixes while the students are reading aloud.

Goal #4 (subject matter: phonics) -- STUDENT is at about 80% accuracy and is close to meeting this coal. Mr. Brinker testified that he keeps track of words STUDENT misses while he reads aloud.

Goal #5 (subject matter: writing) -- STUDENT has written three- and five-paragraph essays, including an outline with topic, body, and conclusion paragraphs. Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT gets his ideas across, but he still has problems with grammar and structure. Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT has met this goal by mastering the form of a three-paragraph essay.

Goal #6 (subject matter: punctuation) -- STUDENT has not met this goal. Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT needs special attention with punctuation and grammar. He stated that the importance of punctuation seems lost on STUDENT. Mr. Brinker testified that the use of a computer would not help STUDENT in this area.

Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT is a contextual learner because he is able to grasp the meaning of words he doesn't know. To work to STUDENT's strength in contextual learning, Mr. Brinker uses "cloze tests," which use five different word attack strategies using context to teach unfamiliar words. Mr. Brinker testified that he does not include a structured phonics program in his class. Instead, he teaches phonics while students are reading aloud by correcting the students and discussing word sounds.

Regarding computer access, Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT can access a computer any time he wants and that he is allowed to use the computer for final drafts. Mr. Brinker testified that he did not think STUDENT needed a computer or a note-taker for note-taking because his printing is fairly legible. Mr. Brinker noted that STUDENT has never used the computer to copy information from the board.

Based on his own observations of STUDENT, Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT's reading is almost at the seventh grade level. Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT is in the top 1/3 of readers in his class. In the area of comprehension, Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT is at the seventh/eighth grade level. Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT is one of only two students in his class who are receiving an "A" and that the other "A" student is a tenth grader who is repeating the class. Mr. Brinker testified that STUDENT is doing so well in his class that he believes STUDENT could be placed in a collaborative regular education English class at the end of the year.(Footnote 5) Mr. Brinker indicated that such a class would be more challenging for STUDENT and improve his self-esteem.

Susan Evans

Susan Evans is the program specialist for the East Valley SELPA. Ms. Evans administered the Corrective Reading Test in October 1996 and, based on the results, testified that STUDENT had mastered the skills covered by Corrective Reading. Ms. Evans testified that the skills addressed in Corrective Reading rise to approximately the sixth grade level. Ms. Evans testified that STUDENT no longer needs Corrective Reading and that in October 1996 he read very fluently and understood what he read.

Ms. Evans testified that STUDENT does not need tutoring or one-to-one help. Ms. Evans testified that further remediation will not improve STUDENT's decoding and comprehension skills and, instead, he needs to do a great deal of reading to reinforce the skills he has already mastered and to improve his comprehension.

Regarding computer access, Ms. Evans testified that there is one computer with a printer in both STUDENT's math and science classes and fifteen computers in English and typing. Ms. Evans questioned, however, whether STUDENT needs a computer for note-taking, because his handwriting is legible. Ms. Evans also testified that since STUDENT's typing speed is approximately 20 words per minute, using a computer for note-taking may not be effective.

Ms. Evans testified that STUDENT's current program is appropriate because he is making progress in areas of need, he is socially adjusted, and his teachers believe that he is progressing and learning. Ms. Evans testified that it is debatable whether STUDENT qualifies for special education anymore because he is at or near grade level in most areas. Ms. Evans testified that STUDENT's IEP team met on January 13, 1997, and discussed the fact that he was at the seventh to ninth grade level.

Regarding the goals and objectives discussed at different IEP meetings, Ms. Evans testified that although the goals and objectives were typed up prior to the meeting on May 9, 1996, they were not finalized until the team discussed them at the meetings. The goals and objectives could have been changed or deleted based on the IEP team's discussion.

Ms. Evans testified that at the IEP meeting MOTHER did not agree to the goals and objectives developed in August 1996, and that MOTHER indicated that she wanted to look over the goals before she consented to them.

Regarding the Scottish Rite Program, Ms. Evans testified that it is not appropriate because it is not field-tested and is not multisensory. Ms. Evans testified that the program involves watching 160 videotapes. Ms. Evans also testified that she conducted an extensive search of information relating to the Scottish Rite Program and did not find any research to indicate it is valid for dyslexics or for STUDENT.

Lejon Stewart

Lejon Stewart is STUDENT's responsibility teacher. As STUDENT's responsibility teacher, Mr. Stewart makes sure all of his teachers know STUDENT is an RSP student. He also coordinates STUDENT's program with STUDENT's teachers and makes sure STUDENT gets the help he needs. Mr. Stewart testified that he met with STUDENT's teachers at the beginning of the school year and discussed note-taking, made sure all the teachers had a copy of STUDENT's IEP, and discussed computer access.

Mr. Stewart testified that STUDENT's math teacher wrote a letter to STUDENT's mom indicating that STUDENT was not participating in class. The math teacher was of the opinion also that STUDENT was not working up to his ability. When Mr. Stewart found out about the letter, he tried to find out why STUDENT was not progressing in math.

Following Mr. Stewart's testimony on December 11, 1997, regarding STUDENT's math class, the District agreed to change STUDENT's math class. As a result, STUDENT was moved into one of Mr. Stewart's classes for math instruction, where he remained until the end of January 1997. Mr. Stewart later testified that he worked individually with STUDENT on math in one of his "advisement/counsel" classes, which he described as a study skills class. Mr. Stewart testified that he gave STUDENT a math test to determine the level of his skills. He also reviewed the goals from the IEPs developed in December 1995 and August 1996. Based on his review and his work with STUDENT, Mr. Stewart testified that STUDENT can add, subtract, and multiply, but is unable to divide, fractions with unlike denominators.

Mr. Stewart testified that, with his assistance in math, STUDENT was making progress. Mr. Stewart testified that he believed STUDENT could be successful in a collaborative math class because he is very social, high functioning, and cooperative. Mr. Stewart described the math he was working with STUDENT on as sixth to ninth grade work.

Regarding note-taking, Mr. Stewart testified that he told STUDENT the first or second week of school that STUDENT needed to take responsibility for getting notes from friends. Mr. Stewart also testified that a laptop computer would not work for STUDENT because of his slow typing speed. Mr. Stewart described STUDENT as a two-finger typist. Mr. Stewart testified that using a computer to write down assignments also would not solve STUDENT's note-taking problem because he has a perceptual problem, not a motor problem. In Mr. Stewart's opinion, STUDENT would end up typing the assignments incorrectly.

Mr. Stewart testified that, overall, STUDENT's program is very good for his needs. According to Mr. Stewart, all three IEPs -- December 1995, May 1996, and August 1996 -- are being implemented. Mr. Stewart testified that the goals and objectives from all three IEPs are being implemented, even though MOTHER has not consented to them, because the teachers have to have something to work with. He also testified that MOTHER has consented to a math goal relating to dividing unlike fractions and decimals.

Regina Richards

Regina Richards is the educational therapist who has assessed STUDENT twice in the past two years. Ms. Richards testified that STUDENT has dyslexia and dysnomia, which she described as a word retrieval problem. To address these disabilities, Ms. Richards recommended a multisensory program for coding and decoding. Ms. Richards testified that Mr. Brinker's multisensory techniques are good for learning context, but are not good for coding and decoding.

Ms. Richards testified that the Scottish Rite Program would be appropriate because it is a well-sequenced, phonics-based, multisensory program with emphasis on phonological awareness, and is designed for individuals from 14 years of age to adult. According to Ms. Richards, the program consists of 160 videotapes, each of which is 60 minutes in length.Ms. Richards testified that she has not seen STUDENT since September 1996 and has never spoken with his teachers or observed him in a school setting. Ms. Richards also testified that she has not had much involvement with the Scottish Rite Program, other than feedback from teachers who have used the program.

Gail Lindberg

Gail Lindberg is the program manager for the East Valley SELPA. Ms. Lindberg acknowledged that he has had only limited experience with STUDENT, but that from what she has seen of STUDENT he does not seem as handicapped as his mother perceives. Ms. Lindberg testified that STUDENT has been very successful in school and has shown growth in curriculum-based assessments and standardized assessments. Ms. Lindberg testified that STUDENT can read well enough that reading is no longer a major problem for him. According to Ms. Lindberg, STUDENT's disability no longer affects his educational program.

Ms. Lindberg testified that she thought MOTHER had agreed to the IEP developed in August 1996. Ms. Lindberg acknowledged that the goals and objectives were written before the meeting, but testified that changes could have been made during the meeting. Ms. Lindberg also testified that Ms. Richards' recommendations were considered by the IEP team, but the team determined that STUDENT's program at Colton High School was appropriate. Ms. Lindberg indicated that the IEP developed in August 1996 is an addendum to the previous IEPs developed in December 1995 and May 1996.

Bonnie Russell-Hunt

Bonnie Russell-Hunt is the director of pupil personnel services for the District. Ms. Russell-Hunt testified that she believes STUDENT's program is working because he is making progress. Ms. Russell-Hunt based her opinion on information shared by IEP team members and current levels of performance which show substantial growth based on Brigance and curriculum based measures. Ms. Russell-Hunt testified that although STUDENT has made a significant amount of progress, he still needs help and should remain in special education.

Regarding Ms. Richards' recommendations, Ms. Russell-Hunt testified that the IEP team changed STUDENT's program from a collaborative program to pull-out RSP based on Ms. Richards' original report. Ms. Russell-Hunt testified, however, that Ms. Richards' second evaluation used the Brigance, which the District had already administered. Ms. Russell-Hunt testified that the second evaluation did not provide any new information that would change STUDENT's program.

Ms. Russell-Hunt testified that the last IEP signed by MOTHER is the one developed in December 1995, so that is the base IEP used by STUDENT's teachers. However, Ms. Russell-Hunt also indicated that the goal areas in the subsequent IEPs are similar to those contained in the base IEP. While the grade levels have changed in subsequent IEPs, the subject and content of the goals have remained essentially the same. Ms. Russell-Hunt testified that she thought MOTHER agreed to the contents of the IEP developed in August 1996 and that she would sign it at a later date.

Al Ong

Al Ong is the school psychologist who evaluated STUDENT's progress in July 1996. Mr. Ong testified that STUDENT has adequate listening comprehension, visual/spatial abilities, and information processing. Mr. Ong testified that everybody agrees that STUDENT has a disability in decoding and word recognition. Based on that disability, STUDENT continues to need RSP help with reading. Mr. Ong testified that, based on STUDENT's age, he needs to use more contextual, whole language processes instead of basic phonics.

Mr. Ong testified that there was no dramatic difference between his assessment and Ms. Richards' first report. According to Mr. Ong, the tests he administered in July 1996 were administered only to evaluate STUDENT's progress. Mr. Ong described STUDENT as being upbeat, cooperative, and putting forth a lot of effort during the testing.

Fred Vartanian

Fred Vartanian is the RSP teacher who is currently teaching math to STUDENT. STUDENT enrolled in Mr. Vartanian's class at the beginning of February 1997. According to Mr. Vartanian, there are approximately 22 students in the class with one teacher and one aide.

Mr. Vartanian testified that he uses the core curriculum to address STUDENT's two math goals in fractions and decimals. He also utilizes several multisensory techniques, including calculators, graph paper, charts, writing examples on the board, work sheets, and group learning. Mr. Vartanian testified that he also uses "See It Right" transparencies, which are colored transparencies placed over work to help students focus on work and see things clearer. According to Mr. Vartanian, the transparencies help students write and read better.

Mr. Vartanian testified that STUDENT does the classwork, and the homework, and writes down notes. Mr. Vartanian testified that he does not see any problems with STUDENT and that he does not have any difficulty writing down assignments. Mr. Vartanian testified that STUDENT is on the way to meeting his math goals.

Regarding computer access, Mr. Vartanian testified that there is one computer in the room but that STUDENT has never asked to use it. Mr. Vartanian testified that STUDENT could use the computer to write down notes but he also indicated that he had seen STUDENT's handwritten notes and they looked fine.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

(1) Are the resource specialist services provided by the District for STUDENT appropriate?

State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 USC 1400 et seq. Pursuant to 20 USC § 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions."

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." 458 U.S. 175, 200.

Taken together the IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide three factors for analyzing whether the District's placement for STUDENT is appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:

1. whether the District's placement is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; 2. whether the District's placement conforms to STUDENT's IEP; and 3. whether the District's placement is designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.

The first factor -- whether the District's placement is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs -- requires an analysis of what STUDENT's unique needs are. The witnesses were in agreement that STUDENT needs a multisensory approach to benefit from his education. Petitioner contends that STUDENT's teachers are not using appropriate multisensory techniques to meet STUDENT's needs.

STUDENT's English teacher, Mr. Brinker, provided significant and credible testimony regarding the multisensory techniques he uses in his class. Mr. Brinker also testified regarding the progress STUDENT had made in his class and the fact that STUDENT is one of only two students receiving an "A" in the class. The Hearing Officer finds, based on Mr. Brinker's testimony, that STUDENT's needs are being met in his English class.

STUDENT's needs were not being met, however, in his math class at the beginning of the school year. The evidence shows that STUDENT was receiving an "F" in math and not receiving appropriate help in the math areas in which he needed it. On the other hand, by the conclusion of the evidentiary portion of this hearing, the District had transferred STUDENT to another math class. Mr. Vartanian, STUDENT's new math teacher, credibly testified regarding the multisensory techniques he uses to meet STUDENT's needs. Mr. Vartanian also indicated that STUDENT was doing well in the class and completing the work. Based on Mr. Vartanian's testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's needs in the subject of math were being met once the District enrolled STUDENT in Mr. Vartanian's class.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that while the RSP math class was not appropriate initially, the District has remedied the situation and Petitioner's current RSP classes are being provided in a manner that meets his unique educational needs.

Regarding the second factor -- whether the District's placement conforms to STUDENT's IEP -- Petitioner contends that STUDENT's IEPs still do not list the multisensory teaching techniques as required by the prior decision (SN 44-96). Petitioner also contends that STUDENT's teachers are not using multisensory teaching techniques.

The evidence establishes, however, that the IEPs developed since the prior decision (SN 44-96) have contained references to the multisensory teaching techniques that would be used for each goal developed by the IEP team in compliance with the prior decision. Furthermore, the testimony of Mr. Brinker and the other teachers who have worked with STUDENT establishes that STUDENT's teachers are using multisensory teaching techniques in the classroom in compliance with his IEPs and with the prior decision. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement conform's to STUDENT's IEPs.

The third factor requires an analysis of whether the District's placement is designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. Again, the evidence, provided primarily by STUDENT's teachers, establishes that STUDENT is receiving educational benefit from his program. Mr. Brinker, Mr. Stewart, and Mr. Vartanian all testified regarding the progress they observed in STUDENT during the school year. According to Mr. Brinker, STUDENT is at or near grade level in almost all areas. Mr. Stewart testified regarding STUDENT's mastery of all aspects of unlike fractions other than division and testified that STUDENT was working on the basic skills necessary to divide fractions and to move onto decimals (STUDENT's other math goal).

The present levels of performance contained in STUDENT's IEPs from December 1995 through January 1997 also show a steady progression in academic skills. In December 1995, most of STUDENT's grade equivalents were at the fourth and fifth grade level. In August 1996, all of STUDENT's grade equivalents were in the fifth grade range. The IEP also indicated that STUDENT had made one year's growth in reading and math since December 1995. By January 1997, STUDENT's grade equivalents reached as high as eighth grade in oral reading with 100% accuracy.

Another way to look at STUDENT's progress is to look at the grade level of work he was expected to do in his goals and objectives. In May 1996, most of STUDENT's language goals objectives were at the fifth grade level. For example, goal #2 was "given a 200 word passage at fifth grade level, STUDENT will read with fluency, expression and 90% accuracy and answer 4 of 5 questions literal and inferentially." By January 1997, the goals were written at the seventh, ninth, and tenth grade level. The goal similar to that quoted above was changed in January to "read a 300 word passage with fluency and accuracy and understanding orally and answer questions with 80% accuracy, 7th grade level." Another objective was for STUDENT to "read a 300 word passage, 8th gr level, silently and answer comprehension questions at 80% accuracy." In other words, in eight months time, STUDENT's reading comprehension goal had progressed from a 200 word passage at the fifth grade level to a 300 word passage at the seventh or eighth grade level.

The Hearing Officer finds, based on the testimony of STUDENT's teachers and the contents of his IEPs, that the District's program for STUDENT is designed to provide him with educational benefit and that STUDENT is acquiring a significant amount of benefit from the program.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement for STUDENT is appropriate pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley.

Petitioner raised numerous issues or questions regarding the appropriateness of the District's program which do not fit neatly into a Rowley analysis.(Footnote 6) The following issues are the issues identified by Petitioner on which evidence was presented and which are relevant to the appropriateness of the District's placement.

A) Has the District been following the Hearing Officer's orders by using multisensory techniques in English class?

It is important to note that the decision issued by Hearing Officer Garfinkel on April 2, 1996 (SN 44-96), only required that STUDENT's IEP be amended to reflect that language arts instruction use multisensory techniques. The order did not specify the type or nature of those multisensory techniques. Based on the evidence, Mr. Brinker is using multisensory techniques and those techniques are working and providing STUDENT with educational benefit.

B) Has the District been implementing the unsigned IEPs?

Initially, the Hearing Officer was concerned that unsigned IEPs were being implemented. However, based on a review of the IEPs, there is no significant difference between the IEPs developed in December 1995, May 1996, and August 1996, except as amended to incorporate the changes required by Hearing Officer Garfinkel. Each calls for STUDENT to receive RSP services for 45-180 minutes or 60-180 minutes per day, five days per week. Additionally, the goals and objectives in each IEP are remarkably similar in their content. The only significant changes are in the grade level and accuracy for those goals.

It is also important to note that it is by no means clear that MOTHER did not consent to the goals developed in August 1996. As noted above, MOTHER signed a mediation agreement which included the following provision:

[P]arent and district agree to goals and objectives written on 8-7-96 but parent is questioning whether District is utilizing multisensory techniques as indicated in the methods, materials and activities section of the objectives.

There is also no evidence that MOTHER objected to the specific content of goals developed at other IEPs. Instead, it appears that MOTHER's only objection to the goals and objectives developed by the IEP team was that they were not specific enough in terms of what multisensory techniques would be used.

Education Code § 56346(a) provides that

[i]f the parent does not consent to all the components of the individualized education program, then those components of the program to which the parent has consented shall be implemented so as not to delay providing instruction and services to the pupil.

The weight of the evidence supports a finding that the District had legitimate reason to believe that MOTHER had agreed to the goals and objectives in August 1996, based on her signature on the mediation agreement. The evidence also suggests that although MOTHER did not sign the IEPs developed in May 1996 or January 1997, her objection was such that she was not objecting to the specific content of the goals and objectives. Therefore, the District had the authority, pursuant to § 56346, to implement the goals and objectives contained in the IEPs developed on those dates.

The Hearing Officer notes that the District, by implementing the goals and objectives in the August 1996 IEP and May 1996 IEP, was complying with the prior decision. MOTHER's refusal to sign the IEPs may not be determinative as to whether the District was allowed, or required, to implement the goals and objectives developed in compliance with a decision of the Hearing Office.

C) Is the parent being provided a way to track the progress on short term instruction plans and is the instruction plan by the week, day, or month? (Cite: CFR § 300.346)

Throughout the hearing, it was unclear what Petitioner was referring to with this issue. At the outset, Petitioner requested copies of his teachers' lesson plans to track how the teachers are addressing his goals and objectives and cited § 300.346 in support of his request. There is nothing in § 300.346 which requires the District to provide lesson plans to Petitioner. Section 300.346 only refers to what must be contained in Petitioner's IEP. Included in those requirements are the following:

(2) [a] statement of annual goals, including short term instructional objectives; and (5) [a]ppropriate objective criteria and evaluation procedures and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether the short term instructional objectives are being achieved.

In the comment section to § 300.346, short term instructional objectives are defined as measurable, intermediate steps between the present levels of educational performance of a child with a disability and the annual goals that are established for the child. The objectives are developed based on a logical breakdown of the major components of the annual goals, and can serve as milestones for measuring progress toward meeting the goals. 34 CFR § 300, Appendix C.

The comment section goes on to distinguish between IEP objectives and instructional plans:

[O]bjectives in IEPs are different from those used in instructional plans, primarily in the amount of detail they provide. IEP objectives provide general benchmarks for determining progress toward meeting the annual goals. These objectives should be projected to be accomplished over an extended period of time (e.g., an entire school quarter or semester). On the other hand, the objectives in classroom instructional plans deal with more specific outcomes that are to be accomplished on a daily, weekly, or monthly basis. Classroom instructional plans generally include details not required in an IEP, such as the specific methods, activities, and materials that will be used in accomplishing the objectives.

As already stated, § 300.346 does not require an IEP to include the detail that lesson plans would contain. Instead, § 300.346 requires the IEP to include short-term instructional objectives which, according to the comment, "provide general benchmarks for determining progress toward meeting the annual goals." The IEPs developed for STUDENT include general benchmarks for determining progress toward meeting his annual goals.

For instance, one of STUDENT's math goals is in fractions and the objectives include adding, subtracting, multiplying, and dividing fractions. Each of these operations is a benchmark to measure STUDENT's progress in mastering fractions. Another goal is for STUDENT to improve his punctuation. The objective requires STUDENT to write a three-paragraph essay of 100 words using correct spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Again, each of these components, along with the length of the essay, provides benchmarks to measure STUDENT's progress toward his punctuation goal.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEPs include both annual goals and short-term objectives. The IEPs also provide for evaluation methods or methods of measurement for achievement for each goal and objective. However, there is no indication in the IEPs of when the short-term objectives must be completed. As stated in the comment, short-term objectives are intended to be intermediate steps toward the achievement of the annual goal and are, generally, projected to be achieved over a shorter timeframe than the annual goals. To track the progress on the short-term objectives, STUDENT's IEPs should indicate the target date of completion for the components which make up each objective and annual goal.

D) Did the District fail to document an agreement on the IEP in May 1996 for a general education tech class? Did the District change the RSP placements without holding an IEP team meeting to decide placement? Was the parent notified of the modification of the IEP of May 1996 when RSP keyboarding was ordered? Did the District have an appropriate keyboarding program designed for dyslexics?

Although Petitioner raised these and other issues, there was no evidence presented to allow the Hearing Officer to resolve them. Petitioner also questioned the appropriateness of the District's practice of bringing prewritten goals and objectives to the IEP meetings. The comments to 34 CFR § 300 state that

[i]t is not permissible for an agency to present a completed IEP to parents for their approval before there has been a full discussion with the parents.... It would be appropriate for agency staff to come prepared with ... a recommendation regarding annual goals, short term instructional objectives, and the kind of special education and related services to be provided. 34 CFR § 300, Appendix C.

All of the District witnesses testified that prewritten goals and objectives are a common practice and that members of the IEP team, including the parents, are free to offer suggestions and changes to those goals and objectives. Petitioner did not present any evidence that she was not allowed to offer input regarding the goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not violating the Code of Federal Regulations provisions relating to the development of goals and objectives.

Based on the Hearing Officer's finding above that the District's current program is appropriate, the Hearing Officer does not reach issues #2 and #3, which addressed additional services if the District's placement had been found to be inappropriate.

(4) Is the access to computer provided by the District for STUDENT appropriate?

On April 2, 1996, Hearing Officer Garfinkel ordered that STUDENT's IEP be amended to include that STUDENT have access to a computer for completing written assignments. Petitioner contends that STUDENT needs a laptop computer. However, there was no evidence presented to support that contention. The testimony of STUDENT's teachers establishes that STUDENT has access to computers in all classes in which he needs them and that he can use those computers as needed, in compliance with Hearing Officer Garfinkel's decision (SN 44-96).

(5) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for Regina Richards' assessment completed on September 12, 1996, and for her time spent testifying in this matter?

Education Code § 56329(b) provides that

[a] parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists ... if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency.

However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing ... to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.

In the present case, the District submitted an issue for decision relating to the appropriateness of its assessment. The District contends that its assessment was appropriate and that no evidence has been presented to show that it was inappropriate. Petitioner contends that the District's assessment was inappropriate because it did not include recommendations or interpretations of the results. Petitioner contends, therefore, that it was necessary to obtain an independent assessment from Regina Richards at a cost of $115.00. Petitioner also requests reimbursement in the amount of $300.00 for the time Ms. Richards spent testifying at the due process hearing.

When STUDENT's IEP team convened on May 9, 1996, MOTHER requested that academic achievement testing be administered to STUDENT to evaluate his progress. As a result, the District prepared an assessment plan to update STUDENT's academic progress. That assessment plan called for achievement tests to be administered. Al Ong, the school psychologist, administered the tests and produced a report of his results on July 23, 1996. Mr. Ong's report included the scores STUDENT received and a brief interpretation of those scores. At the conclusion of his report, Mr. Ong stated that "[i]t appears from the current test data that STUDENT had made at least a year's growth or more in the academic areas reviewed as compared to last year's testing (12/7/95)."

Education Code § 56320 provides that

[b]efore any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an individual assessment of the pupil's educational needs shall be conducted ...

Subsequent sections of the Education Code set out in detail the procedures by which such assessments should be conducted.

Section 56381 provides that a reassessment must be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, "if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment." A reassessment must be based on the procedures listed commencing with § 56320.

Petitioner does not challenge the tests administered to STUDENT in July 1996 or the qualifications of the assessor. Rather, Petitioner's only challenge is to the actual contents of the assessment report that was produced by Mr. Ong. Specifically, Petitioner objects to the fact that the assessment report does not provide adequate interpretation of the results or include recommendations based on those results.

Education Code § 56327 requires that the individuals who assess a student prepare a written report of the results of the assessment. The written report must include all of the following:

(a) Whether the pupil may need special education and related services. (b) The basis for making the determination.

(c) The relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting. (d) The relationship of that behavior to the pupil's academic and social functioning. (e) The educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, if any. (f) For pupils with learning disabilities whether there is such a discrepancy between achievement and ability that it cannot be corrected without special education and related services. (g) A determination concerning the effects of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantage, where appropriate. (h) The need for specialized services, materials, and equipment for pupils with low incidence disabilities ...

It is important when analyzing § 56327 and its requirements to look at the purpose of the District's assessment. The sole reason for MOTHER's request and the sole purpose of the assessment was to assess STUDENT's academic progress. To do that, Mr. Ong administered two standardized academic achievement tests, remarkably similar to those administered by Ms. Richards two months later. Mr. Ong analyzed STUDENT's results and provided some interpretation for the grade equivalent scores that he reported for STUDENT. Considering the purpose of Mr. Ong's assessment, many of the components of § 56327 are not necessary. For instance, STUDENT's eligibility was not at issue when Mr. Ong conducted his progress evaluation. Therefore, § 56327(a) does not appear necessary.

Ultimately, there is nothing in § 56327 which addresses Petitioner's contention regarding Mr. Ong's assessment. There is nothing in § 56327, or in comparable federal statutes, which requires that an assessment include the recommendations of the assessor or more detailed interpretations than those provided by Mr. Ong.

Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Ong's assessment was targeted to check STUDENT's academic progress. The assessment and report which Mr. Ong produced were appropriate to measure STUDENT's progress. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Richards' evaluation. The Hearing Officer also finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Richards' time in testifying at the due process hearing based on the absence of legal authority in support of Petitioner's request.

ORDER

(1) Colton Unified School District shall convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of receipt of this decision to amend STUDENT's IEP to include projected dates of completion for his short-term instructional objectives.

(2) All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: April 4, 1997 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1. STUDENT v. Colton Unified School District, SN 44-96, April 2, 1996. 2. It is unclear whether STUDENT's keyboarding class was an RSP class or a regular education class. When STUDENT started, the class was taught by an RSP teacher. At some point in the fall, STUDENT was moved out of that class without MOTHER's knowledge and into a keyboarding class taught by a regular education teacher. When MOTHER learned of the class change, she asked that STUDENT be moved back into the class taught by the RSP teacher. The District accommodated MOTHER's request. The evidence is not clear, however, that the keyboarding STUDENT is in currently is an RSP class. While MOTHER referred to it as an RSP keyboarding class, several District witnesses testified that the class, while taught by an RSP teacher, was not an RSP class. 3. Ms. Richards had initially evaluated STUDENT in May 1995.

4. The witnesses are listed in the order in which they testified. Several District employees were called by Petitioner. 5. Mr. Brinker described a collaborative class as one which is team-taught by a special education teacher and a regular education teacher. 6. These "issues" were submitted by Petitioner on January 29, 1997, prior to the due process hearing reconvening. When the Hearing concluded on January 17, 1997, it was apparent that both parties had additional issues they wished to be addressed. Rather than having the parties file for a new due process hearing, the Hearing Officer scheduled additional days for this hearing and provided both parties with the opportunity to submit additional issues, evidence, and witnesses.