California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 8, 1999
Student v. Moorpark Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1021-98, SN-1021-98 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Moorpark Unified must reimburse parents for an independent behavioral assessment because it never conducted a required functional analysis assessment.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Footnote 1 states that the Hearing Officer amended her earlier decision to correct typographical errors in how the student's name was referenced.
Summary
Moorpark Unified School District filed for a hearing in June 1998 to defend its assessment of a 16-year-old tenth grader. He was eligible for special education as a student with a serious emotional disturbance. The parents cross-filed, and the cases were consolidated. Through his IEP, the student had been placed at Kings View Center, a residential facility in Tulare County, where he attended Rio Canyon School. The Hearing Officer dismissed Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District because no evidence connected it to the issues. On the last day of hearing, the student withdrew every claim except one: reimbursement for an independent assessment that psychologist Dr. James Kehr did in September 1997.
The Hearing Officer found that during the student's first months at Kings View, his behavior was self-injurious and assaultive and caused serious property damage. This included kicking holes in walls in April and June 1997. Because of this behavior, he missed 11 of 52 school days and much of his therapy, so it significantly interfered with his IEP goals. Under the regulations for California's Hughes Bill, this counted as a "serious behavior problem," which required a functional analysis assessment (FAA). The District never planned or conducted an FAA, even after the parents asked for an assessment in August 1997. Dr. Kehr's report was not a formal FAA, but it contained key FAA components. The District had to reimburse the parents for its cost within one month.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the Hughes Bill regulations of the time. Behavior that was self-injurious, assaultive, or destructive and that significantly interfered with IEP goals triggered a duty to conduct a functional analysis assessment. When the District failed to do one, parents could get reimbursed for a private assessment that was not a formal FAA.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue I. Was the District required to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) following the June 9, 1997 incident when Student kicked a hole in the wall of his residential unit?
Student's self-injurious, assaultive, and property-damaging behavior significantly interfered with his IEP goals, so it was a serious behavior problem under the Hughes Bill regulations, and the District was required to conduct an FAA. It never did.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue II. If so, are the Parents entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. James Kehr on September 22, 1997?
The District did not show that its decision not to conduct an FAA was appropriate. Dr. Kehr's assessment was not a formal FAA but contained key FAA components, so the parents were entitled to reimbursement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Moorpark USD shall reimburse the parents for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. James Kehr within one month of the date of the decision (amount not stated).
Key authorities
Education Code section 56329(b); Education Code section 56520 et seq. (Hughes Bill); 5 C.C.R. section 3001; 5 C.C.R. section 3052; Education Code section 56500; Education Code section 56501(a)
People named in the decision
- Dolores Allen, special education administrator, Moorpark Unified School District
- Jan Mecagni, social worker; District witness, Behavioral Health
- Richard Jenkins, program specialist, Moorpark Unified School District
- Dr. Lowell Boldt, lead psychologist, Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District
- Jan Van Atta, school psychologist, Moorpark Unified School District
- Dr. James Kehr, clinical psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
- Dr. John Lutzker, expert witness for Student, Chairman, Department of Psychology, University of Judaism
- Lynn Kliewer, psychotherapist at residential facility, Kings View Center
- Kings View Center, residential treatment facility, Tulare County
- Rio Canyon School, public school on residential facility grounds, Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Moorpark, California, on April 29 and 30, and June 24 and 25, 1999. Moorpark Unified School District (District or Moorpark USD) was represented at hearing by attorney Andrew Arczynski. Also present on the District's behalf was Dolores Allen, special education administrator for Moorpark Unified School District. STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Tom Beltran. STUDENT's parents, PARENTS, were also present on STUDENT's behalf. Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District (Kings Canyon) was represented at hearing by attorney Raymond Dunn. Dr. Lowell Boldt, lead psychologist for Kings Canyon, was also present on Kings Canyon's behalf. Moorpark Unified School District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Jan Mecagni, social worker with Behavioral Health; Richard Jenkins, program specialist for Moorpark USD; Dr. Lowell Boldt, lead psychologist for Kings Canyon; and Jan Van Atta, school psychologist at Moorpark USD. STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER, STUDENT's mother; Dr. James Kehr, clinical psychologist; and Dr. John Lutzker, chairman of the Department of Psychology at the University of Judaism. Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Closing arguments were received on August 2, 1999. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.PROCEDURAL MATTERSA. Motion to Dismiss Kings Canyon as a party in this case At the start of the hearing, Kings Canyon made a motion to be dismissed as a party to this matter. Kings Canyon stated that the residential facility where STUDENT is placed is located within the Kings Canyon School District. Additionally, STUDENT and his parents are residents of the Moorpark School District and STUDENT was placed in the facility pursuant to a Mental Health referral by the Moorpark School District. Thus, Kings Canyon contended that Moorpark, not Kings Canyon, is the agency responsible for STUDENT's education and placement at Kings View. Kings Canyon also asserted that it is not involved in any of the issues at hearing. STUDENT joined in the motion to dismiss Respondent Kings Canyon, stating that it was not implicated in any of issues he submitted for hearing. (footnote 2) Respondent STUDENT also stated that none of his requested remedies is sought from Kings Canyon. (footnote 3) Moorpark USD, which joined Kings Canyon School District as a party, opposed the motion to dismiss, contending that Kings Canyon was responsible for providing STUDENT with educational services at the public school STUDENT attended at the Kings View residential facility site. Therefore, Moorpark asserted that Kings Canyon District was involved in STUDENT's placement and services at Kings View Center, and, thus, was a proper party to the present case. Special education due process procedures (and jurisdiction) extend to the parent, under some circumstances to the student, and to the public education agency involved in decisions regarding the student. California Education Code 56501(a). "Public agency" is defined as a "district, special education local plan area, or county office ... or any other public agency providing special education or related services." Education Code 56500. Because it was unclear as to the extent of the Kings Canyon's involvement in and responsibility for STUDENT's education, and because Petitioner claimed Kings Canyon had a joint responsibility for STUDENT's educational placement, the Hearing Officer declined to rule on the dismissal until after Petitioner had presented its case in chief. After hearing Petitioner Moorpark's case in chief, the Hearing Officer ruled that no evidence had been presented that implicated Kings Canyon in any of the issues presented at hearing in the consolidated case. Additionally, no party presented evidence that Kings Canyon failed to provide STUDENT services for which it was responsible. Therefore, Kings Canyon's motion was granted and it was dismissed from the present action.B. Respondent STUDENT's withdrawal of his issues On the last day of hearing, STUDENT, through his parents and attorney, withdrew all of his issues except those related to the issue of whether he is entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Kehr's assessment. The withdrawal of the issues was done on the record. Accordingly, the parties requested that the decision address the sole issue of whether the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Kehr's assessment of STUDENT. Because STUDENT's case was consolidated into the District's case and because his issues unrelated to the District's assessment issue were withdrawn on the last day of hearing, the District is identified as Petitioner in this decision. Furthermore, because Respondent Kings Canyon had been dismissed, all references to "Respondent" below are to Respondent STUDENT unless otherwise stated.ISSUESI. Was the District required to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) following the June 9, 1997 incident in when STUDENT kicked a hole in the wall of his residential unit?II. If so, are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. James Kehr on September 22, 1997?POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES STUDENT identified two primary reasons why he should be reimbursed for the independent assessment by Dr. Kehr. First, he argued that his behavior and act of kicking a hole in the wall necessitated that the District conduct an FAA, but that no FAA was performed by the District. Second, STUDENT asserted that the District did not conduct an FAA when one was requested by his parents on August 12, 1997. Thus, because the District failed to perform the FAA timely when one was required and after one was requested by his parents, STUDENT argued he was entitled to seek an independent evaluation at the District's expense to address his behavioral needs. Accordingly, Respondent requested reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Kehr on September 22, 1997. The District, on the other hand, made three arguments as to why STUDENT was not entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Kehr. First, the District argued that STUDENT's behaviors did not constitute "serious behavior problems," which are a requirement for an FAA. Therefore, the District was not required to conduct an FAA and there was no need for STUDENT to procure the independent assessment from Dr. Kehr. Second, the District asserted that, even if an FAA were warranted, Dr. Kehr's independent evaluation fell short of the requirements for an FAA and, thus, is not reimburseable as such. Third, the District argued that it fully and thoroughly assessed STUDENT in his triennial assessment during the fall of 1997. The District also asserted that Respondent procured Dr. Kehr's assessment prior to the District's completing the assessments listed on the assessment plan and that, therefore, no assessments existed with which Respondents could have disagreed. Thus, according to the District, if there were no assessments with which Respondents disagreed, it was premature for Respondent to seek an independent evaluation. Based on the above, the District contended that it is not required to pay for Dr. Kehr's assessment. BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old tenth-grader who has been qualified for special education since 1994 as a student with a serious emotional disturbance (ED). STUDENT and his parents are residents of the Moorpark Unified School District within Ventura County. At all the dates relevant to the issue of this case, STUDENT was attending Kings View Center, a residential facility in Tulare County. No information was provided at hearing regarding where, or whether, STUDENT currently attends school. Because of behavior including aggression, violence (which includes an attack of his father with a knife), verbal abuse toward others, refusal to attend school, and destruction of property, STUDENT was hospitalized at Vista Del Mar psychiatric hospital from January to April 1997. On February 11, 1997, STUDENT' s IEP team (which included Ventura County Mental Health) convened and agreed to place him in a special day class at a residential facility. The IEP team also agreed to continue his IEP goals and objectives from his prior November 11, 1996 IEP. Such goals included social and emotional development to promote positive interactions with peers in the school and community setting, as well as work on his arithmetic and written expression. Although STUDENT's placement at a residential facility was agreed to by the IEP team, the specific residential facility placement was to be determined at a later date. Pursuant to a mediated IEP, STUDENT was placed at Kings View Center (Kings View) residential facility on April 1, 1997. While STUDENT was at Kings View, he attended Rio Canyon School, a public school located on the grounds of the Kings View residential facility within the Kings Canyon Unified School District. His pscychotherapist at Kings View was Lynn Kliewer. Between April and June 1997 (during STUDENT's first quarter at Kings View), STUDENT's behavior included "defiance, pushing limits, kicking the walls when angry, leaving the facility without permission or escort, refusing to go to school, threatening others and suicidal ideation." According to his mother, he was also engaged in "picking" behavior, picking at his skin and eyelashes to the point of bleeding. Additionally, STUDENT missed 11 out of 52 days of school during his first quarter at Kings View. On June 9, 1997, while on the residential portion of the Kings View placement, STUDENT became upset after being denied television privileges and kicked a hole in the wall. Kings View staff, apparently following standard policy for all property damage at the facility, reported the incident to the local sheriff's department. Four days after the kicking incident, STUDENT's therapist, Lynn Kliewer, informed STUDENT's parents about his behavior and the property damage. STUDENT was eventually charged with a misdemeanor, but the charges were subsequently dropped after his parents appeared at the juvenile court proceeding. On August 12, 1997, the PARENTS sent Richard Jenkins, program specialist for Moorpark USD, a letter in which they requested that an independent "psychological and educational" assessment be conducted by Dr. James Kehr. Mr. Jenkins responded to the PARENTS by letter on August 25, 1997, which stated that the District intended to complete a full triennial assessment of STUDENT and, thus, an independent assessment would be unnecessary. Mr. Jenkins attached an assessment plan to his letter which called for assessments in the areas of academic achievement, health, cognitive functioning, speech and language, psycho-motor development, self-help/adaptive behavior, social emotional functioning, and vocation. The PARENTS responded to Mr. Jenkins by a letter stating that the assessment plan did not include the "psychological assessment" they had requested on August 12. The PARENTS consented to the assessment plan on September 19, 1997, but attached a letter from their attorney which clarified that they intended to pursue the independent assessment with Dr. Kehr since no FAA had been conducted by the District. Dr. Kehr met with and assessed STUDENT on September 22, 1997. The District performed its various assessments of STUDENT beginning October 20, 1997. According to a report by STUDENT's therapist, Lynn Kleiwer, STUDENT's behavior improved significantly from July 1997 until April 1998. However, by May 1998, STUDENT's behavior had "deteriorated significantly." STUDENT relapsed into refusing to attend school and had increasing difficulties in the residential unit. In mid-May, STUDENT again damaged property when he punched a hole in a wall through to another room. Fearing that STUDENT would harm himself or others, Mental Health was called and STUDENT was hospitalized at a psychiatric facility. After discharge, he was not allowed to return to Kings View Center. In his discharge summary, Lynn Kleiwer recommended that STUDENT be placed in a more restrictive environment than the Kings View residential facility could offer. No information was provided at hearing regarding where STUDENT currently attends school. On June 19, 1998, the District filed a request for a special education due process hearing with the Hearing Office to resolve the issue of whether its assessment of STUDENT was appropriate. The District submitted required supporting information on June 25, 1998. On October 5, 1998, STUDENT, through his parents and attorney, cross-filed a request for hearing. STUDENT's case was consolidated into the District's case on January 12, 1999. On the last day of hearing, Respondent STUDENT withdrew all his issues unrelated to issue of whether the District was required to reimburse the PARENTS for Dr. Kehr's independent assessment.FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAWI. Was the District required to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) following the June 9, 1997, incident when STUDENT kicked a hole in the wall of his residential unit? STUDENT's position is that the District failed to conduct a functional analysis assessment, as is required under the Hughes Bill, after he kicked a hole in the wall of his residential unit at Kings View on June 9, 1997. Thus, Respondent argued that the District's failure to assess him necessitated that he procure an independent evaluation from Dr. Kehr, for which he should be reimbursed. Because the District never conducted an FAA with regard to STUDENT's behaviors leading up to the June 9 incident, the issue of whether Respondent should be reimbursed for Dr. Kehr's assessment hinges on whether the District's decision not to conduct such assessment was appropriate. In 1990, California passed Education Code Section 56520 et seq., which is commonly known as the "Hughes Bill." Regulations implementing the Hughes Bill are contained in Title 5, California Code of Regulations 3001 and 3052. According to the Hughes Bill, a functional analysis assessment (FAA) forms the basis of a behavior intervention plan. C.C.R. 3052 (a)(3). Subsection (h) of 3001 states that the "behavior intervention plan" is a written document which is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual's IEP." The regulations define serious behavior problems as "behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP are found to be ineffective." 5 C.C.R. 3001(ah). When members of an IEP team find that the instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student's IEP are found to be ineffective, an FAA must be conducted. 5 C.C.R. 3052 (a)(6)(b). 1. Serious behavior problem The evidence established that STUDENT's behavior from April 1 to June 9, 1997, was self-injurious, assaultive, and caused serious property damage. According to STUDENT's Treatment Plan dated April 24, 1997, STUDENT made suicidal and homicidal threats, had angry and destructive outbursts, and threw things when he was angry. (Dist. Exh. 15.) According to the Serious Incident Logs from the residential staff at Kings View, STUDENT made suicidal threats and would cut scratches into his arm and pick at his skin and scabs until they bled. (Student's Exh. Z.) STUDENT also made racial, sexual, abusive, and homicidal threats and comments to the staff, his parents, and his peers. The logs also noted that STUDENT banged on walls, tipped over his dresser, destroyed peers' belongings, and scratched his name on the wall. Moreover, the logs indicated that STUDENT kicked a "big hole" in the wall on April 29, 1997, and then kicked another hole in the wall on June 9, 1997. Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's behavior during his first quarter at Kings View was self-injurious, assaultive, and caused serious property damage. 2. Significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the IEP For STUDENT's behaviors to trigger an FAA, they must have significantly interfered with the implementation of the goals and objectives in his IEP. As was noted above, STUDENT's February IEP indicated goals to work on his ability to do arithmetic computations, his ability to write legibly, and his social and emotional development to promote peer interaction. (footnote 4) The IEP team also indicated that STUDENT's behavioral needs were extensive, that he participated minimally in his educational program, and that his attendance had been inconsistent. While at his residential placement at Kings View, STUDENT's behavioral needs were addressed by treatment plans developed by an interdisciplinary team of staff at Kings View. The evidence established that STUDENT's behavioral problems interfered with the implementation of his IEP goals and objectives. In his discharge summary, Lynn Kliewer wrote that, during STUDENT's first quarter at Kings View, he missed 11 of 52 days of class, missed half of his individual therapy sessions, and occasionally missed his group therapy sessions. Mr. Kliewer also noted that STUDENT only met a few of his short-term behavior treatment plan goals during this time. (Student's Exh. I.) STUDENT's short-term treatment plan goals included reducing his destruction of property or throwing things when angry to no more than one or two times a week, intruding on other's space or speech to no more than two times most days, and responding to calls from parents, consequences, or limit setting with destructive or defiant outbursts to no more than one or two times a week. In his Serious Incident Logs, STUDENT was noted for being defiant and for leaving the residential facility without consent or escort on numerous occasions and for varying lengths of time. (Student's Exhs. A and Z.) On one such occasion, STUDENT ran away from the residential facility and wandered into a nearby town, where he was recognized by the residential facility staff and returned to Kings View. STUDENT's behaviors and actions resulted in his missing a significant amount of class and therapy time and being away from the residential facility where he was supervised and his behaviors monitored by the residential staff. As such, his behaviors interfered with the implementation of his academic goals because of his significant absences from class. Additionally, his absence from individual therapy and from the supervision of residential staff substantially interfered with his behavior treatment as provided by Kings View. Although STUDENT was placed at the residential facility because of his extensive behavioral needs, his behaviors were relatively uncontrolled during this time, and his social and behavioral development goal on his IEP was rendered virtually ineffective. Based on the foregoing, the evidence established that STUDENT's behaviors significantly interfered with the implementation of his IEP goals and objectives during this time. Although the District asserted that STUDENT's behaviors reflected his adjustment to the facility and not a serious behavior problem, his behaviors during his first quarter at Kings View (from April to July 1997) were similar to behaviors exhibited prior to his psychiatric hospitalization in January 1997. In January, STUDENT was hospitalized because he was aggressive, violent and verbally abusive, he refused to attend school, and he threw things and destroyed property. Such behaviors persisted despite STUDENT's being placed in a more restrictive residential placement where various treatment plans were implemented to address his behaviors. In summary, STUDENT met the criteria for an FAA. His behaviors were assaultive, self-injurious, caused property damage, and significantly interfered with the implementation of the goals and objectives of his IEP. Therefore, STUDENT's behaviors were "serious behavior problems" which would have triggered the need for an FAA and a behavior intervention plan. B. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. James Kehr on September 22, 1997? California Education Code 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. However, if the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. Id. Based on this code section, the District has the burden at hearing to prove the appropriateness of its actions. In this case, the Respondent procured an independent evaluation because no FAA was conducted by the District. Because no FAA was planned for or conducted by the District when Respondent asserted one should have been conducted, the District must prove at hearing that its decision not to plan for or conduct such assessment was appropriate. As discussed above, the District failed to do so. Because the District did not plan for or conduct an FAA when one was warranted, Respondent is entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment procured from Dr. Kehr. (footnote 5) Although the District asserted that it is not required to reimburse Respondents for Dr. Kehr's assessment because such assessment did not meet the formal requirements of an FAA, it provided no authority to support its contention. The Hearing Officer notes that, although it is not a formal FAA, Dr. Kehr's assessment outlined and identified STUDENT's behaviors which were antecedent to his behavioral outbursts. Additionally, Dr. Kehr and Dr. Lutzker testified that Dr. Kehr's assessment contained key components of an FAA. Both doctors are psychologists with extensive experience working with school Districts in conducting FAAs and developing behavior intervention plans. Such information reasonably could have been considered by an IEP team in developing a behavior intervention plan for STUDENT. The parents' decision to have STUDENT assessed by Dr. Kehr was a reasonable response to the District's failure to conduct any assessment that effectively addressed STUDENT's severe behavioral problems. Because the PARENTS procured an assessment of STUDENT's behavioral problems when the District failed to do so, they are entitled to reimbursement for such assessment. Thus, based on the foregoing, the District is required to reimburse Respondent for the cost of Dr. Kehr's independent evaluation.ORDER Moorpark USD shall reimburse PARENTS for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. James Kehr within one month of the date of this decision.PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent STUDENT prevailed on the issue decided.RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i).DATED: September 8, 1999 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes:1)The Hearing Officer amends her earlier decision to correct typographical errors indicating the student's name as "incorrect name" rather than "STUDENT." 2)The District's sole issue at hearing was whether its assessment of STUDENT was appropriate.3)At hearing, STUDENT sought reimbursement for the independent evaluation by Dr. Kehr and a finding that Moorpark Unified School District denied him a free appropriate public education (FAPE). He did not request any remedies which would have resulted from the denial of FAPE.4)Neither party entered STUDENT's April 1, 1997 IEP into evidence, which specifically placed STUDENT at Kings View residential facility. Based on the evidence presented, and because no information was offered that indicated STUDENT's needs changed between his February 11 IEP and his April 1 placement at Kings View, the Hearing Officer gleens from the record that STUDENT's goals from his February IEP were in effect when he was enrolled at Kings View.5)Because it is found above that the District's failure to conduct an FAA was inappropriate, and because the District's triennial evaluation did not include an FAA, it is unnecessary to determine whether the District's triennial evaluation was otherwise appropriate.
