California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 11, 2002

Student v. Stockton Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1040-00 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel

Stockton Unified and San Joaquin County Mental Health must add daily in-home services; request for residential placement at Devereux denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 3 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A high school senior's family filed for a hearing against Stockton Unified School District and San Joaquin County Mental Health. The student was eligible as emotionally disturbed and tended to withdraw into an elaborate fantasy life, especially at home. For 2001-2002, the agencies offered the Adolescent Day Treatment (ADT) program, a therapeutic day class. The offer also included one resource (RSP) class at Lincoln High School, therapy, and some in-home support. The father rejected it and sought a residential placement at the Devereux School in Santa Barbara.

The Hearing Officer found that ADT's peer group did not cause the student's more aggressive behavior. Major changes in his life better explained it. The offer was appropriate when it was made. Since then, a medication change had greatly improved his behavior at school. He should therefore split his time about equally between ADT and RSP classes at Stagg High School, his neighborhood school. The offer had a second flaw: services to build peer, community and vocational activities after school were listed only "as needed." Under Union School District v. Smith, services must be stated specifically, and he needed daily in-home help from trained Mental Health staff. Residential placement was denied because most experts said day treatment plus home services could meet his needs. The Hearing Officer therefore did not decide whether Devereux was appropriate. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to make these changes.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated needs outside the school day as legitimate IEP needs. Listing services "as needed" did not meet the requirement for a specific written offer. The Hearing Officer judged the offer by the facts when it was made, but he still ordered changes because the student had improved by the time of the hearing.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District's offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year constitute a free and appropriate public education?

    The ADT-based offer was largely appropriate and its peer group was not shown to harm the student, but transition services for after-school peer, community and vocational activities were listed only 'as needed' and lacked required specificity. The student's improvement also meant he should now attend RSP classes at Stagg about half time.

  2. Issue 2. Does STUDENT require a residential program for the 2001-2002 school year in order to receive an appropriate education?

    Residential placement was not required. Most experts agreed that a day treatment program, RSP classes, and enough in-home and after-school services could meet his needs in a less restrictive setting.

  3. Issue 3. Is the Devereux Foundation School in Santa Barbara an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?

    This issue was not reached because the student did not require a residential placement.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to modify the offer in the June 26/July 12, 2001 IEP and the August 23, 2001 letter.
  • Order to provide or change services. The revised IEP must provide specific daily in-home intervention to address the student's need to develop peer relationships and engage in community and vocational activities outside the normal school day. These services must be delivered wherever the student is actually residing, because the parents share custody.
  • Placement ordered. The revised IEP must provide for attendance in RSP classes at Stagg High School approximately one-half of the time and in the ADT program approximately one-half of the time.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education

People named in the decision

  • Vernon Uyeda, director of special education, Stockton Unified School District
  • Susan Hogue, acting director/administrator of special education; District witness, Stockton Unified School District
  • Carolee Johnstone, law clerk to District counsel, Office of Jan Damesyn
  • Karen Coleman, program manager; Mental Health representative and witness, San Joaquin County Mental Health
  • Kim Suderman, director of children's services, San Joaquin County Mental Health
  • Patricia Coward, court reporter
  • Mara Rosen, associate of Student's counsel, Office of Michael Zatopa
  • Robin Brennan, assistant to Student's counsel, Office of Michael Zatopa
  • Dr. Linda Burke, psychologist; expert witness for Student, Family and Community Enrichment Services (FACES)
  • Dr. Roger Wu, psychiatrist; expert witness for Student, Langley Porter Institute, UCSF
  • Alice Jackson, educational counselor; witness for Student
  • Lisa Rutherford, case manager; witness for Student, Devereux School
  • Amy Zerges, educational consultant; witness for Student, FACES
  • Donna Barranco, director of education; witness for Student, Devereux School
  • Kathleen Skeels, program administrator, Stockton Unified School District
  • Martha Hawley, RSP teacher, Stagg High School
  • Ward Downs, RSP teacher, Stockton Unified School District
  • Mel Suguitan, teacher, Stockton Unified School District
  • Robert Lichter, teacher, Stockton Unified School District
  • Stacie Edgar, instructional assistant, Stockton Unified School District
  • Elizabeth Jara, teacher, Stockton Unified School District
  • Diane McKinley, program specialist, Stockton Unified School District
  • Dr. Jeffrey Miller, psychologist; assessor and witness for District
  • Becky Bryan, teacher, Stockton Unified School District
  • Judith Laughner, case manager, San Joaquin County Mental Health
  • Michael Tarango, mental health clinician at ADT, San Joaquin County Mental Health
  • Dr. Guy Russell, treating psychiatrist, San Joaquin County Mental Health
  • Dr. Brink, evaluating clinician (1999)
  • Dr. Rompel, psychologist; psychological evaluation (2000)
  • Sue DeMotte, school psychologist, Stockton Unified School District
  • Dr. Newton, private psychologist; evaluation (2000)
  • Dr. Allen Giesen, D.O.; evaluation team member, FACES
  • Dr. Bryna Siegel, evaluator, Langley Porter Institute, UCSF
  • Dr. Elliott, evaluator, Langley Porter Institute, UCSF
  • Dr. Love, evaluation team head, Langley Porter Clinic, UCSF
  • Devereux Foundation School, private residential school sought by parent, Santa Barbara
  • Brush Ranch School, private residential school previously sought by parent, New Mexico
  • Adolescent Day Treatment (ADT) program, special day class/day treatment program, Stockton Unified School District / San Joaquin County Mental Health

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Stockton, California, on September 6 and 7, and October 15, 16, 17, 22, 23, and 24, and November 1 and 2, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Michael Zatopa. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were FATHER, his father, and FRIEND, a friend of the family. MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, was present on October 17, 22, 23, and 24 and November 2, 2001. Present on September 6 2001, were Mara Rosen, associate of Mr. Zatopa; Robin Brennan, assistant to Mr. Zatopa; and FAMILY MEMBER, a family member. FAMILY MEMEBER was also present on September 7, and November 2, 2001. Mara Rosen was also present on October 17, 2001.

Respondent Stockton Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan Damesyn. Also present on the District’s behalf was Vernon Uyeda director of special education on September 6 and 7, 2001. Susan Hogue, acting director of special education, was present on the District’s behalf on October 15, 16, 17, 22, 23, and 24, and November 1 and 2, 2001. Carolee Johnstone, Ms. Damesyn’s law clerk, was present on October 15, 16, 17, 22, and 24, and November 1 and 2, 2001

Respondent San Joaquin County Mental Health (Mental Health) was represented at the hearing by attorney Sheryle Sparks. Also present on behalf of Mental Health was Karen Coleman, program manager. Kim Suderman, director of children’s services, was present on September 6 and 7, 2001.

Also present throughout the hearing, except for October 15, 2001, was Patricia Coward, a court reporter, who was present at the request of Ms. Damesyn and paid for by Ms. Damesyn’s office. Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dr. Linda Burke, psychologist; Dr. Roger Wu, psychiatrist; Alice Jackson, educational counselor; FATHER, father; Lisa Rutherford, case manager at the Devereux School; Amy Zerges, educational consultant; and Donna Barranco, director of education at the Devereux School.

The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Kathleen Skeels, program administrator; Martha Hawley, RSP teacher; Ward Downs, RSP teacher; Mel Suguitan, teacher; Robert Lichter, teacher; Stacie Edgar, instructional assistant; Elizabeth Jara, teacher; Diane McKinley, program specialist; Dr. Jeffrey Miller, psychologist; Becky Bryan, teacher; and Susan Hogue, administrator of special education.

County Mental Health called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Judith Laughner, case manager; Michael Tarango, mental health clinician; Karen Coleman, program manager; and Dr. Guy Russell, psychiatrist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on December 10, 2001, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District’s offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year constitute a free and appropriate public education? 2. Does STUDENT require a residential program for the 2001-2002 school year in order to receive an appropriate education? 3. Is the Devereux Foundation School in Santa Barbara an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District and Mental Health offered a placement for the 2001-2002 school year that included placement in the Adolescent Day Treatment (ADT) program, with one Resource Specialist Program (RSP) class at Lincoln High School, and a variety of in-home interventions. Respondents contend that this offer constituted a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). Petitioner contends that this offer is not appropriate for STUDENT for three specific reasons. First, the ADT program is not appropriate for STUDENT because the students at ADT have acting-out behaviors, and exposure to these behaviors has had a detrimental effect on STUDENT. Second, the ADT program is not appropriate for STUDENT because he has recently demonstrated the ability to be successful in RSP classes at Stagg High School and, therefore, no longer needs a restrictive environment such as ADT. Third, the Respondents’ offer does not meet STUDENT’s needs in relation to his behavior at home, and outside of the school day in general. Petitioner contends that only a residential program, such as the program at the Devereux Foundation School in Santa Barbara, can adequately address these issues. (Footnote 2)

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. He is currently a senior in high school and is taking RSP classes at Stagg High School. STUDENT receives psychiatric services through Mental Health. STUDENT received speech and language services from 1985 through 1989. In 1989, STUDENT underwent surgery to repair a pharyngeal flap and correct velo pharyngeal incompetence. In 1990, testing found STUDENT to have a full scale IQ of 113. Between 1990 and 1994, STUDENT attended regular education classes at commodore Stockton Skill School. In 1994, testing showed that STUDENT had significant delays in speech and socialization. STUDENT also was noted to have many “autistic like” behaviors. STUDENT was noted to retreat into himself, and display self-stimulation rocking movements. An IEP team meeting in 1994 found STUDENT eligible for special education and related services based upon a specific learning disability. STUDENT has continued to be eligible for special education ever since. STUDENT had also been diagnosed as suffering from attention deficit disorder and was being treated with Ritalin.

STUDENT reported having auditory hallucinations from 1992 to 1994. STUDENT said that he would hear his parents calling his name during lunchtime. In 1995 or 1996, STUDENT began to develop an increasingly elaborate fantasy life. By 2001, STUDENT was withdrawing into this fantasy life daily. STUDENT’s fantasy life involved imaginary families that had extensive histories, with recurring themes of power, prestige, wealth, and revenge. STUDENT wrote, and continues to write, lengthy and detailed biographies about his fantasy families.

A psychological report done in 1997 found STUDENT to have a full scale IQ of 90. Testing indicated problems with peer relationships and social skills, and a sense of inadequacy. STUDENT began high school at Stagg High School during the 1998-1999 school year. The October 1998 IEP noted that STUDENT had made significant progress in math, written language and reading. However, he was not completing 80% of his class assignments, was having trouble focusing on tasks, and was working at a slower pace than the rest of the students in his class. In August 1999, STUDENT was examined by Dr. Brink. Dr. Brink diagnosed STUDENT as suffering from dysthymia, an anxiety disorder, and possibly an attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, inattentive type. Dr. Brink believed that STUDENT was using his fantasy life as a defense mechanism to reduce anxiety and depression and avoid emotional conflicts. The August 25, 1999 IEP placed STUDENT on home instruction. In October 1999, the IEP team recommended continuing STUDENT on home instruction. In December 1999, the IEP team referred STUDENT to San Joaquin County Mental Health (Mental Health) for an AB3632 evaluation. STUDENT was also moved from home instruction back to Stagg High School full time.

Dr. Rompel performed a psychological evaluation in January 2000. Testing found STUDENT to have a full scale IQ of 97. STUDENT demonstrated weaknesses in the areas of social comprehension and attention/concentration. Both STUDENT and his father reported to Dr. Rompel that STUDENT continued to regularly withdraw into his fantasy relationship with his imaginary families. However, STUDENT’s responses on the Rorschach did not reflect any psychotic features. Dr. Rompel felt it was more likely that STUDENT had a personality disorder rather than a psychotic disorder.

Mental Health completed its assessment in February 2000. STUDENT appeared to lack impulse control, and demonstrated poor judgment and a lack of insight. He would not get out of bed in the morning unless forced to. He would wear the same clothes day after day unless clean clothes were put out for him. If left alone during the day, he would only eat cookies and candy. STUDENT’s father reported that STUDENT spent a great deal of time writing about his fantasy family, and this was all STUDENT ever wanted to talk about. STUDENT’s teachers reported that STUDENT liked to talk about acquiring wealth and power, but stated that he had no concept of how to go about doing this. At this time, STUDENT’s fantasy family was called the “Maximoffs.” The recurring themes of his fantasy involved money and power. STUDENT also enjoyed watching Batman and Superman cartoons. STUDENT would become very involved in these cartoons and make strange sounds and odd body movements while watching them. It was recommended that STUDENT continue on Resperdol and be placed in an educational setting with a highly structured behavioral component.

An IEP team meeting was held on February 25, 2000. STUDENT’s primary disability was changed to emotionally disturbed. STUDENT was to continue at Stagg, with case-management services to be provided by Mental Health. The team recommended that STUDENT be considered for placement at Adolescent Day Treatment (ADT). The ADT program is a special day class program for emotionally disturbed students. The program emphasizes behavioral management. Generally, students attend ADT all day, and receive academic instruction as well as individual therapy and group therapy. A psychiatrist from Mental Health meets with the staff on a weekly basis. A teacher and a mental health clinician are teamed together to case-manage each student. The ADT program uses “daily behavior reports” (DBRs) to track a student’s behavioral progress. Students are scored from one to five in five categories: work, following directions, peer relations, adult interactions and following program structure. Each student’s score is based upon that student’s abilities and expectations. The students receive a combined score for each class period. Based upon the total score for the day, the student is given a color of either orange (the lowest), yellow, green (average), or purple. A student’s privileges are determined by his or her color group. A student in the purple group will have more independence and less supervision than a student in a lower group. If a student achieves purple for ten consecutive days, he or she is considered “off the charts.” ADT has up to 18 students in two classes. Staff consists of two teachers, two teaching assistants, two mental health clinicians, and a behavioral specialist. Most of the students have average academic abilities. The program is not designed for students with developmental disorders or conduct disorders. At the February 25, 2000 IEP meeting, FATHER informed the District that he believed STUDENT needed a residential placement, and that he was investigating possible private schools.

On March 2, 2000, a school consultation meeting was held. It was determined that the ADT program was appropriate for STUDENT. Judy Laughner, from Mental Health, was assigned to work with STUDENT and his family, and arrange for them to visit ADT so that they could make an informed decision. After he visited the ADT program, FATHER told Ms. Laughner that he didn’t think that program was appropriate. FATHER stated he was requesting placement at the Brush Ranch School in New Mexico. FATHER testified that he did not feel the ADT program was right for STUDENT because it did not meet STUDENT’s academic needs, and it had students with behavior problems such as hitting and throwing things. The District suggested conducting STUDENT’s triennial assessment and holding an IEP to further discuss placement options.

On March 14, 2000, Sue DeMotte, a school psychologist, performed a psychological consultation. STUDENT was reported as being oppositional at home, and spending most of his time in class with his head down on his desk pretending to sleep. He was not interacting in class or doing his homework. STUDENT was taking Effexor and Resperdol. Ms. DeMotte concluded that STUDENT met the criteria for an emotional disturbance. Ms. DeMotte recommended that a therapeutic component be added to STUDENT’s educational placement. She stated that STUDENT seemed to respond well to one-on-one situations.

On March 16, 2000, an IEP team meeting was held. The District offered placement in the ADT program. FATHER refused this placement and again stated that he felt Brush Ranch was an appropriate placement. On April 14, 2000, another IEP team meeting was held. At this time, the placement at Brush Ranch was no longer available. FATHER testified that Brush Ranch had changed its decision about accepting STUDENT when it learned he was diagnosed as emotionally disturbed.(Footnote 3) FATHER decided to agree to placement in ADT program, with a review in 60 days. However, FATHER stated that he was going to continue to look at possible residential placement options.

On April 27, 2000, FATHER took STUDENT to Dr. Newton for a psychological evaluation. Dr. Newton stated that STUDENT had been increasingly withdrawn over the past several years. STUDENT had intensified his obsession with his fantasy family, which he was writing about and fantasizing about almost continuously. However, Dr. Newton stated that STUDENT maintained clear boundaries between fantasy and reality. Nevertheless, Dr. Newton was concerned that STUDENT’s fantasy life had the potential to become all consuming. Testing revealed a very low self-image and low self-esteem. STUDENT also showed signs of a moderate depressive disorder. Dr. Newton recommended an academic boarding school with a high degree of structure and a supportive milieu. The placement needed to have a social growth track built into the program. Dr. Newton also recommended that therapy focus on countering STUDENT’s tendency to withdraw, and that efforts to enhance STUDENT’s social interaction should proceed in a slow, step-by-step manner.

STUDENT began attending the ADT program in April 2000. FATHER stated that it seemed to be going “O.K.” However, at home STUDENT was continually withdrawing into his fantasy life unless he was actively engaged by a family member. The ADT staff reported that, at first, STUDENT would not participate in class. He would put his head down, or read a newspaper. Gradually, STUDENT improved. He began to work more independently, but still needed prompts to stay on task. A review of STUDENT’s DBRs shows that he participated in most classes, completed his work, and interacted with peers and staff. There were recurring problems of off-task behavior. There were also some problems with impulsive and inappropriate behavior. STUDENT continued to have intermittent problems with putting his head down in class. STUDENT also tried to write about his fantasy family while at school. STUDENT asked his teacher if he could write about his fantasy family instead of writing on assigned topics. He was told he had to write on the assigned topics. From statements STUDENT made to his father, it appears he used some of his free time to write about his fantasy family on the school computer. Between April and July 2000, STUDENT was usually in the green group (average), with some purples and only one yellow. Mike Tarango, STUDENT’s mental health clinician at ADT, stated that he and STUDENT had developed a good relationship. Over time, STUDENT became more comfortable at ADT, participated in the group sessions more, and appeared to develop some friendships. He also participated in several field trips. At first STUDENT, did not want to go on the trips, but he was able to work through his anxiety. On the trips, STUDENT needed some prompting, but overall he did well. STUDENT was engaged and completed his assigned tasks. STUDENT’s peers did confront him on the trips about taking showers and putting on clean clothes. Peer feedback seemed to have a positive effect on STUDENT.

An IEP team meeting was held on July 19, 2000, to review the placement at ADT. STUDENT’s difficulties were listed as “difficulty in initiating and sustaining interactions with peers and adults. Limited independent living skills functioning.” The IEP notes state that STUDENT was involved in class activities, was relating to staff and to peers, and was asking staff what he should “do instead” after getting feedback from his peers. STUDENT attended the IEP meeting. He stated that he sometimes got carried away and needed prompts to stay focused. He said that the prompts helped. FATHER and MOTHER stated that they were not able to get STUDENT to do things on his own at home, but he would do things if someone else was doing them with him. The PARENTs also reported that STUDENT was spending a great deal of time at home in his room, involved with his fantasy family. STUDENT stated that he felt he had made academic progress at ADT. Both STUDENT and his parents stated that graduation from high school was a goal. STUDENT was eating lunch on the campus at Lincoln High School (across the street from ADT) without problems. The PARENTs again expressed a desire for residential treatment. They stated that STUDENT had made progress at ADT, but they felt his behavior at home had deteriorated.

STUDENT continued in the ADT summer program during the summer of 2000. As part of this program, he did volunteer work at a day camp for young children. STUDENT did very well at this activity, working well with the children and the staff. It was reported that a future paid position might be available. FATHER testified that STUDENT’s behavior at home did not improve.

In August, STUDENT had renewed problems at ADT. He was repeatedly refusing to do assigned work, was refusing to participate, and was arguing with the staff. By September, STUDENT’s behavior at ADT had improved, and he was again participating in the program. In September, FATHER began taking STUDENT for a series of psychiatric and psychological evaluations. FATHER started with the Family and Community Enrichment Services (FACES). STUDENT was evaluated by a team that included Dr. Linda Burke, a psychologist; Amy Zerges, an educational consultant; and Dr. Allen Giesen, D.O. STUDENT told Dr. Burke that he spent a great deal of time thinking and writing about his fictional family. Although Dr. Burke concluded that STUDENT was able to distinguish fantasy from reality, STUDENT told her that when he was thinking about his fantasy family, it seemed very real. STUDENT stated that his time in his fantasy world was comforting and exciting and that it was sometimes difficult to come back to reality. STUDENT also stated that he was trying to spend less time in his fantasy world. On testing, STUDENT received a full scale IQ of 102. Testing also revealed significant problems with attention. STUDENT displayed ongoing and pervasive social difficulties. He was connected with his parents, but showed indifference towards peer relationships. STUDENT was best able to be “present” when he was in a highly structured setting. One-on-one support was recommended along with an environment that was not overstimulating (too many people or too much activity). STUDENT was diagnosed as suffering from a pervasive developmental disorder, a depressive disorder and an attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Dr. Burke concluded that STUDENT needed support at school and at home to address his tendency to withdraw into his fantasy family when not in school. She recommended what she referred to as “wrap around” services, where the home and school programs are coordinated. STUDENT was referred to Dr. Bryna Siegel for further evaluations.

An IEP team meeting was held on October 3, 2000. The PARENTs were concerned that STUDENT was not getting enough academics at ADT and stated that his behavior at home continued to be a major problem. They were concerned that progress, particularly in relation to behavior, was too slow. It was agreed that ADT staff would go into the home to help set up written schedules for chores and activities of daily living such as eating and showering. The schedules would include time for STUDENT to write about his fantasy family so as to reduce his anxiety about not being able to spend time on this. The PARENTs agreed to the goals and objectives, but not the placement. The PARENTs continued to want a residential placement.

In October 2000 Mike Tarango began going to the home once a week to help set up STUDENT’s schedule, which was done in 30-minute increments. This program lasted about five weeks. Initially, STUDENT seemed receptive to the schedules, even though he was worried about losing touch with his fantasy family. It appeared that STUDENT was spending less time with his fantasy family. In mid-November, FATHER stated that STUDENT was not following the schedules and that the in-home program did not seem to be helping. Mike Tarango stopped going into the home to work on the scheduling because of FATHER’s belief that the program was not doing any good.

In November there was also an incident at ADT during which STUDENT became oppositional and threatened to destroy a computer. FATHER continued to tell Mike Tarango that he was concerned about the rate of STUDENT’s progress and the level of academics at ADT.

FATHER and MOTHER separated in November, which appears to have caused STUDENT considerable anxiety. STUDENT continued to live with FATHER, but would spend some nights at his mother’s.

STUDENT was evaluated by Dr. Siegel and Dr. Elliott at the Langley Porter Institute at UCSF in November 2000. The purpose of the assessment was to rule in or rule out a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD). PDD was ruled out. It was recommended that STUDENT be in an educational setting that did not have students with externalizing disorders and that if no suitable public or private schools could be found, a comprehensive residential placement should be considered. On November 28, 2000, FATHER contacted the District and informed them that he wanted an IEP meeting to consider changing STUDENT’s placement back to Stagg. On November 30, 2000, FATHER met with Dr. Russell, STUDENT’s treating psychiatrist through Mental Health. FATHER expressed concern that STUDENT was becoming more aggressive at ADT. Dr. Russell increased STUDENT’s Resperdol to 2 mg.

During December 2000, STUDENT achieved “off the charts” at ADT for two days. On January 8, 2001, STUDENT talked to Dr. Russell about his new fantasy family, the Wilkes. STUDENT told Dr. Russell that his character “John Wilkes” represented STUDENT’s feelings of vengeance toward authority. However, STUDENT stated that he had no thoughts of harming himself or others. On January 9, 2001, an IEP team meeting was held. The team agreed that STUDENT had made progress and was ready to begin attending an RSP class at a regular high school campus. It was also agreed that change was difficult for STUDENT and he would need continued support. It was recommended that STUDENT begin attending one period a day in an RSP class at Lincoln High School. FATHER did not agree with this. FATHER wanted STUDENT to attend Stagg for a full six periods. FATHER also expressed concern about increased aggression in STUDENT’s writings. MOTHER disagreed with her husband because she was concerned that STUDENT had had too many changes. MOTHER wanted STUDENT to remain at ADT. It was decided that STUDENT would stay at ADT and go to Lincoln for one RSP class a day. On January 12, both of the PARENTs met with Dr. Russell. FATHER still wanted STUDENT to attend Stagg. Dr. Russell suggested to FATHER that he re-examine his feelings about ADT in two months. STUDENT told the ADT staff that he was very anxious about starting the class at Lincoln. After STUDENT started the class at Lincoln, he seemed to settle in fairly quickly, although he continued to have intermittent behavior problems.

On March 1, 2001, an IEP team meeting was held. The purpose of the meeting was to consider the PARENTs’ request that STUDENT attend Stagg on a full-time basis. It was reported that STUDENT had been successful in his RSP class at Lincoln, and that ADT staff accompanying STUDENT to and from the class had been gradually withdrawn. Stagg and ADT staff were concerned about a move back to Stagg without some sort of transition period. It was recommended that STUDENT attend RSP classes at Stagg half time and continue in the ADT program half time. FATHER stated that he didn’t see anything in the ADT program that was dealing with STUDENT’s problems. He said he didn’t think that the ADT program could fix STUDENT. STUDENT stated he wanted to start the day at ADT, go to Stagg, and then go back to ADT. The ADT staff felt that STUDENT should be at ADT for some time every day. It was agreed that STUDENT would go to ADT all day on Wednesdays and Fridays, and start Monday, Tuesday and Thursday at Stagg, with Tuesday and Thursday afternoons at ADT. It was also agreed that an additional RSP class at Stagg could be added at the quarter.

Earlier, in February, 2001, FATHER had begun taking STUDENT back to the Langley Porter Clinic for additional evaluations. The evaluation team was headed by Dr. Love and Dr. Wu. Dr. Love and Dr. Wu sent a letter to the PARENTs dated March 7, 2001. The team’s major concern was STUDENT’s elaborate fantasy life. Of particular concern was STUDENT’s statement that the fantasy stories go on, even in STUDENT’s absence. On the other hand, the team noted that STUDENT maintained that he knew the difference between fantasy and reality, that STUDENT’s fantasy life could be set aside when STUDENT was engaged in other activities, that STUDENT had never acted on the events in the fantasy world, and that STUDENT interacted well with family members and expressed a desire for peer friends and even a girlfriend. The team recommended an educational setting that was more protective and did not involve students with externalizing disorders (students who were aggressive or had conduct disorders). The Devereux Foundation School in Santa Barbara was suggested as a possible placement. The full evaluation was dated March 21, 2001. The team considered several possible diagnoses, including a psychotic disorder, a developing schizotypal personality disorder, and a social anxiety disorder. It was concluded that STUDENT most likely suffered from a psychotic disorder. Dr. Wu testified that the main reasons that the team was leaning toward a psychotic disorder rather than a personality disorder was STUDENT’s history of auditory hallucinations, STUDENT’s statement that his fantasy world went on when he wasn’t there, and the fact that STUDENT’s stories seemed to be disintegrating - they no longer had a clear beginning, middle and end.

On March 14, 2001, an incident occurred during which STUDENT asked an ADT staff member what she would do if he, STUDENT, blew up the school. This apparently occurred in response to some students teasing STUDENT. STUDENT was counseled about the possible consequences of his statement, and the ADT staff met to discuss the incident. In the end, it was decided that STUDENT did not pose a threat to himself or other students. Dr. Russell was concerned about STUDENT’s lack of understanding of how other people would react to such a statement. On March 22, 2001, an IEP team meeting was held to consider increasing STUDENT’s participation at Stagg by adding another RSP class. The team decided to add the additional RSP class, and discussed ways to continue to support STUDENT at Stagg. FATHER again stated that he was looking for a residential placement for STUDENT. In late March, and April 2001, STUDENT was displaying more oppositional behavior at ADT, and not participating in group sessions as much as he had previously. On May 4, FATHER phoned Mike Tarango. FATHER stated that he felt STUDENT’s condition had gotten worse since he started taking classes at Stagg, and that STUDENT was failing all his classes at Stagg. FATHER stated that he intended to place STUDENT in a school in Santa Barbara. On approximately May 22, 2001, STUDENT stopped attending the ADT program all together. FATHER testified that he believed that STUDENT’s more aggresive behavior and the more violent nature of his fantasy writings were caused by his time at ADT.

An IEP team meeting was held on May 31, 2001, to discuss the summer term. STUDENT was offered placement in the summer program at ADT, but FATHER declined this offer. STUDENT’s progress at Stagg was reviewed. STUDENT had had a lot of absences, and had been failing all his classes. Although he had managed to pull up his English and Economics grades to Cs, he was still failing Art. FATHER did not sign the IEP.

On June 1, 2001, at the request of the District and Mental Health, STUDENT was assessed by Dr. Jeffrey Miller. STUDENT told Dr. Miller that he had had trouble relating to the other students at ADT because they all had more severe behavior problems than he did. He also said he had recently visited the Devereux school in Santa Barbara with his father and was strongly opposed to going there. STUDENT stated that he felt most comfortable in the resource program at Stagg. STUDENT’s goal was to go to college after high school. Dr. Miller concluded that STUDENT suffered from a personality disorder with schizoid and avoidant traits, a generalized anxiety disorder, and possibly an attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Testing indicated that STUDENT experienced social anxieties concerning possible failure, rejection, and criticism by others. He attempted to cope through withdrawal, excessive fantasizing and some obsessive-compulsive type behaviors. Dr. Miller concluded that for any educational program to be successful it would need to be a program which STUDENT also wanted and was motivated to become involved in.

During the summer of 2001, STUDENT taught swimming to disabled children at the Walton School and enrolled in a cooking class at Delta College. FATHER showed STUDENT how to take the bus to the Delta campus and how to get from the bus stop to the classroom. STUDENT would go to the Walton School in the morning and go to the cooking class in the afternoon. It appeared to FATHER that STUDENT was going to both activities and seemed to be doing well. FATHER later discovered that STUDENT stopped going to the cooking class at some point during the summer. STUDENT did continue to teach swimming though, and did very well in this program.

A two-day IEP team meeting was held on June 26, 2001, and July 12, 2001, to develop the District’s offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year. On the second day of the meeting, FATHER presented a list of proposed present levels of performance and goals and objectives that he wished to have incorporated into the final IEP. Both the present levels of performance and the goals and objectives related to STUDENT’s behavior during after-school hours. The final IEP is 56 pages long. The District summarized the program offered in a letter dated August 23, 2001. The offer was for placement in the ADT program with one RSP class at Lincoln, as well as lunch and special events at Lincoln. The number of classes at Lincoln would increase as STUDENT’s tolerance increased. STUDENT would have a one-on-one assistant for the entire school day. The District would contract for a functional behavior assessment of STUDENT in his home. STUDENT also would receive individual therapy one day a week for 50 minutes, and group therapy 3 times a week for 50 minutes a session as part of the ADT program. Family therapy would be provided twice a month for 50 minutes each session. STUDENT would receive psychiatric services every 6 to 8 weeks for 30 minutes per session with additional services provided as needed. In-home support would be provided twice a month for 50 to 60 minutes per session. Case management services would be provided for 8 hours per month. The IEP also included a transition plan that addressed using public transportation, learning to access mental health services, exploring volunteer services and paid employment, the acquisition of pragmatic social interaction skills in various environments, and exploring leisure activities. These needs were addressed in the transition plan because the IEP team determined that these needs related to STUDENT’s ability to successfully transition to post secondary education and independent living. Services to implement this transition plan were to be provided on an “as needed” basis. FATHER rejected the Respondents’ offer.

In August 2001, FATHER told Dr. Russell that STUDENT’s behavior at home was deteriorating. STUDENT was isolating more, and his hygiene was getting worse. Dr. Russell increased STUDENT’s Resperdol to 3mg a day. STUDENT enrolled in several RSP classes at Stagg for the 2001-2002 school year. FATHER is currently supplementing STUDENT’s classes with home schooling. STUDENT appears to be doing better this year at Stagg than he did during the 2000-2001 school year. His teachers report that he is interacting with his teachers and his peers. He brings his materials to class, has not displayed any behavior problems, and is completing the work. STUDENT is also willing to ask for help from his teachers when he needs it. FATHER has noticed an improvement in STUDENT’s behavior since his medication was changed. However, FATHER also states that STUDENT continues to withdraw into his fantasy world if not actively engaged. STUDENT will not shower, cook, or do chores unless prompted to do so.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District’s offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year constitute a free and appropriate public education?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that is provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000, 56031. The term “free appropriate public education”

means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208.

In summary, the inquiry is whether the proposed educational program is designed to meet the student's unique needs and to provide the student with some educational benefit, and whether the program conforms with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

The Respondents’ offer of placement is contained in the June and July 2001 IEP (Student Exhibit 31) and the August 2001 letter (Student Exhibit 33). The offer, in summary, is for placement in the ADT program, with one RSP class at Lincoln. In addition, Mental Health would provide a variety of in-home and transition services.

The ADT program

Dr. Burke, Dr. Wu, Dr. Miller and Dr. Russell all agree that STUDENT continues to need a structured, behaviorally oriented, day program that includes both group and individual therapy. All parties agree that the ADT program is just such a program. However, Petitioner argues that the offer of the ADT program with one RSP class at Lincoln is not appropriate for STUDENT because the acting-out behaviors of the other students in the ADT program caused STUDENT to exhibit more aggressive behavior, and caused an increase in the violent nature of STUDENT’s fantasies. In addition, Petitioner contends that STUDENT has demonstrated that he is capable of functioning in a less structured environment, such as a variety of RSP classes at Stagg High School, and therefore no longer needs a restrictive environment like the ADT program.

Is the peer population at the ADT program appropriate for STUDENT?

FATHER testified that he believed that many of the students in the ADT program had acting out behaviors. He based this belief primarily on his observation of behavior contracts posted on a bulletin board at ADT. FATHER also testified that STUDENT’s behavior changed after he started attending the ADT program. FATHER believed that STUDENT became more aggressive and that STUDENT’s fantasies became more violent in nature. FATHER cited four separate incidents that he believed showed STUDENT had become more aggressive. STUDENT had unusually long fingernails, and had told people he was growing them long to protect himself. FATHER stated that STUDENT told him that he had scratched another student with his fingernails on the school bus. At another time, STUDENT told FATHER that he had gotten in a fight with another student at ADT. There also was an incident with ADT staff when STUDENT became very angry and threatened to destroy a computer after he was told to stop writing on the computer and move on to another activity (this occurred on November 2, 2000). Finally, there was the incident when STUDENT asked an ADT staff member what she would do if he threatened to blow up the school (this occurred on March 14, 2001).

Although many of the students in the ADT program have some acting-out behaviors, the ADT program does not accept students with conduct disorders. Most of the acting-out behaviors consisted of acting out in class, inappropriate comments, and oppositional behavior. Furthermore, there were other factors that may have affected STUDENT’s behavior and caused the changes that FATHER observed.

FATHER and Mike Tarango both testified that STUDENT had difficulty dealing with change. The two most serious incidents - the time when STUDENT threatened to destroy a computer and the time he made the comment about blowing up the school - both occurred during times of change and increased stress. The computer incident happened in November 2000, the same month that STUDENT’s parents separated. The “bomb” incident happened just after STUDENT started going back to Stagg High School. There was testimony that STUDENT was extremely anxious about this transition. Beyond these specific incidents, STUDENT had several periods of time while in the ADT program during which his behavior deteriorated (based upon review of the DBRs). Each period lasted only a few days and was followed by extended periods of improved behavior. These periods of deterioration usually coincided with periods of change in STUDENT’s life.

Furthermore, Dr. Burke observed the ADT program in October 2001, and interviewed members of the staff. Dr. Burke felt that the ADT program, including the peer population, was appropriate for STUDENT.

It does appear that STUDENT’s fantasy writings became more violent after he started in the ADT program. STUDENT’s fantasies had always had some element of violence. Mike Tarango discussed STUDENT’s writings with him on many occasions. STUDENT told Mr. Tarango that the John Wilkes character represented his, STUDENT’s, feelings of anger and vengeance. Mike Tarango believed that the violent aspects of the fantasies were STUDENT’s way of dealing with his own anger and frustration and lack of control over his life. During the last month at the ADT program, STUDENT’s fantasy writings changed again. His new characters were captains of industry and were more philanthropic. Though STUDENT’s fantasies became more violent in nature after he started at ADT, there is no indication that this change was caused by the peer population in the ADT program. It is more likely that the change in his fantasies had to do with the same changes that had affected STUDENT’s other behaviors. In April 2000, STUDENT started at the ADT program, which was a significant change for him. In November 2000, his parents separated. In January 2001, STUDENT began attending an RSP class at Lincoln. In March 2001, STUDENT started taking classes at Stagg. In May 2001, STUDENT was pulled out of the ADT program. Throughout this time, FATHER was trying to get STUDENT placed in a residential facility, which STUDENT was aware of, and opposed to. These were a lot of changes for STUDENT to deal with, all occurring in a relatively short period of time. In light of this, Mike Tarango’s explanation that the violent nature of STUDENT’s fantasies was a way for STUDENT to deal with his feelings of frustration and lack of control over his life is well supported.

In conclusion, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that the peer population at the ADT program caused STUDENT to become more aggressive both in terms of his behavior and fantasy writings. Any changes in STUDENT’s behavior were more likely caused by the changes in STUDENT’s life that he had to deal with during the time he attended the ADT program.

Was the offer of the ADT program with one RSP class at Lincoln appropriate for STUDENT considering his recent success at Stagg?

An IEP is judged not in hindsight, but rather based upon the facts that existed at the time that the IEP was drafted. Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Circ. 1993). Therefore the Respondents’ offer must be judged based upon STUDENT’s level of functioning at the time that the offer was made, in June, July, and August 2001. At the end of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT had been attending ADT 59% of the time, and taking three RSP classes at Stagg High School. At the June/July 2001 IEP meeting, the team recommended that STUDENT spend more time at ADT and only take one RSP class at Lincoln. Testimony established that the IEP team recommended increasing the amount of time STUDENT spent in the ADT program because the IEP team concluded that STUDENT’s behavior, both at home and in class, had deteriorated since he had begun taking three RSP classes at Stagg in March 2001. The IEP team recommended STUDENT switching from Stagg to Lincoln for his one RSP class because Lincoln was physically closer to ADT, allowing the ADT staff to provide better support to STUDENT during his time at Lincoln.

At the June 26, 2001 IEP meeting, it was reported that, from March through June 2001, STUDENT had been absent or tardy a great deal of the time. One of STUDENT’s teachers from Stagg reported to the IEP team that STUDENT did not interact with peers in class, and required a significant amount of encouragement and individual attention (Student’s Exhibit 31). Martha Hawley, another of STUDENT’s teachers at Stagg during the third and fourth quarter of the 2000-2001 school year, testified that STUDENT’s performance had been somewhat inconsistent. Although at times he did well and participated in discussions, at other times he struggled, becoming frustrated and putting his head down on his desk. FATHER had told Mike Tarango that STUDENT’s behavior at home had deteriorated after he started going to three classes at Stagg in March 2001. In light of these facts, the IEP team’s decision to increase the amount of time STUDENT spent in the ADT program, and to move his RSP class from Stagg to Lincoln was appropriate.

It is undisputed that STUDENT’s behavior and performance in school improved dramatically after Dr. Russell increased STUDENT’s Resperdol to 3 mg. in August 2001. All of STUDENT’s current teachers at Stagg reported that STUDENT is interacting with his teachers and his peers. He brings his materials to class, has not displayed any behavior problems, and is completing his work. FATHER also testified that STUDENT’s attitude about school and learning has improved since August 2001.

Karen Coleman, the Mental Health program manager, had been involved with STUDENT’s case since STUDENT started receiving services from Mental Health. She testified that STUDENT’s level of functioning at the time of the hearing was improved, but did not seem to be better than it had been when STUDENT was at his highest level of functioning during the 2000-2001 school year. Ms. Coleman stated that STUDENT’s current level of functioning was roughly on a par with his functioning in March 2001.(Footnote 4) Both Dr. Russell and Susan Hogue, the acting director of special education for the District, testified that they believed that the IEP offer of one RSP class at Lincoln should be reconsidered given STUDENT’s current success at Stagg. However, both felt that it was necessary for STUDENT to continue in the ADT program.

Although the Respondents’ offer of one RSP class at Lincoln was appropriate when it was made, STUDENT’s significant improvement in his current classes at Stagg warrants reconsideration of this part of the offer. STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to tolerate, and be successful in, more RSP classes than the single class at Lincoln offered by the Respondents in the June/July 2001 IEP. Stagg is STUDENT’s neighborhood school. STUDENT has stated a preference for attending Stagg rather than Lincoln. By attending Stagg, STUDENT is more likely to develop friendships with peers who live in his neighborhood, and is therefore more likely to have these friendships extend beyond the school day. Based upon these factors, to properly meet STUDENT’s current needs, STUDENT’s program should include attendance in RSP classes at Stagg High School.

Although STUDENT is functioning better during the school day, the Hearing Officer finds that he still requires the additional support of a structured, behaviorally oriented, day program that includes both group and individual therapy, such as the ADT program. How much time in the ADT program is needed to meet STUDENT’s current needs? After comparing STUDENT’s current level of functioning (on the basis of descriptions of STUDENT’s behavior in his classes at Stagg) to his level of functioning in the past, it is found that he is currently functioning on a level equivalent to his level of functioning in March 2001. Therefore, the March 1, 2001 IEP team’s recommendation that STUDENT attend Stagg half the time and attend the ADT program half the time is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s current needs. FATHER acknowledged that STUDENT is doing well in his current class at Stagg, and both District and Mental Health staff testified that such a modification is appropriate given STUDENT’s improvement since August 2001.

Did the Respondents’ offer adequately address the issues relating to STUDENT’s behavior at home and during after-school hours? What are STUDENT’s needs in relation to his behavior during after-school hours?(Footnote 5) Unlike his behavior at school, STUDENT’s behavior at home and during after-school hours has not improved since Dr. Russell adjusted STUDENT’s medication. FATHER testified that STUDENT does do some simple cooking (STUDENT will make sandwiches, heat up soup and cook eggs). When STUDENT isolates more, he is less likely to cook for himself. There is no dispute that, at home, STUDENT requires prompts to eat. STUDENT eats without prompts at school and on field trips. There is also no dispute that STUDENT requires prompts to shower and put on clean clothes. This was true both at home and on ADT field trips. It is concluded that STUDENT’s unique needs include improving his independent living skills, including cooking, and taking care of his personal hygiene.

STUDENT also isolates himself and withdraws into his fantasy family a significant amount of time while at home. However, STUDENT does not withdraw into his fantasy family when he is engaged. STUDENT is able to be engaged by school, field trips, and after-school activities such as his volunteer work at the Walton school in the summer of 2001 and his volunteer work at day camp in the summer of 2000. In addition, FATHER testified that he is currently able to engage STUDENT in various activities for the entire weekend. Everyone agreed that it would be beneficial for STUDENT to reduce the amount of time he spends involved with his fantasy family. Dr. Russell and Dr. Miller testified that a reduction in the amount of time STUDENT spends in his fantasy life is the result of a proper program, but is not the goal itself. STUDENT’s need is to develop other aspects in his life during after-school hours, which will result in a reduction in the time STUDENT spends involved in his fantasy life. These other aspects include peer relationships, community activities, and vocational activities.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs in relation to the after-school hours are to improve his independent living skills, and to develop peer relationships, community activities and vocational activities.

The Respondents’ offer contained goals and objectives and a transition plan. The specific goals addressed, among other needs, peer interaction, communication, meal planning and preparation, utilization of a daily living schedule, and development of vocational skills such as phone skills, following directions, task completion, letter writing and resume preparation. The transition plan addressed using public transportation, learning to access mental health services, exploring volunteer services and paid employment, the acquisition of pragmatic social interaction skills in various environments, and exploring leisure activities. As set forth earlier, these needs were addressed in the transition plan because the IEP team determined that these needs related to STUDENT’s ability to successfully transition to employment, post-secondary education, and independent living. The combination of the transition plan and the specific goals and objectives appropriately addressed STUDENT’s needs to improve his independent living skills, and to develop peer relationships, community activities and vocational activities during after-school hours.

What kind of program is required to implement the transition plan and the goals and objectives? Dr. Burke testified that STUDENT needed a predictable, set structure, both in school and at home. To address his home behavior, she concluded that STUDENT needed “wrap around” services that would involve support in the home that is coordinated with the school program. She stated that it would be necessary to have someone going into the home on a daily basis. Dr. Burke also stated that family therapy and collateral parenting sessions would be also be appropriate (Student’s Exhibit 24).

Dr. Wu stated that STUDENT needed to be around people who knew how to engage him and pull him out of his fantasy world. Although Dr. Wu recommended residential placement, he testified that in-home services could address STUDENT’s needs if the services were of the right quality and quantity. The person or persons providing the in-home services would need to be trained and experienced in dealing with someone like STUDENT, who, Dr. Wu believed, had a psychotic disorder. Dr. Wu testified that it would be necessary for the in-home services to be provided on a daily basis. STUDENT would need behavioral inducements to encourage him to be engaged in reality. In addition, parental training would be necessary to educate the PARENT’s on proper ways to engage STUDENT.

Dr. Miller stated that for any program to be successful for STUDENT it would need to be a program that STUDENT supported and was motivated to participate in. Dr. Miller recommended a program that involved family therapy, social coaching, involvement in community activities, and in-home intervention and support services (District Exhibit 53). Dr. Miller also stated that STUDENT needed to spend more time on weekends with his peers, rather than his family.

Dr. Russell was part of the treatment team that developed the Mental Health recommendations that are part of the Respondents’ offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year. These services consisted of individual therapy once a week, group therapy three times a week, family therapy twice a month, psychiatric services every six to eight weeks, psychiatric parent services every six to eight weeks, in-home support services twice a month. The Respondents’ offer also included transition services “as needed” (these were the mental health services necessary to implement the transition plan contained in the IEP). The District has added eight hours a month of case management services to the above. The case manager would coordinate STUDENT’s program, provide linkage to the community, and coordinate the overall treatment plan. Dr. Russell stated that STUDENT’s in-home services should include efforts to engage STUDENT in peer and community activities outside the home. These interventions should be done by an appropriately trained member of the Mental Health staff. Dr. Russell stated that these in-home services should be provided on a daily basis.

On the basis of the recommendations of the doctors who have evaluated STUDENT, it is concluded that STUDENT requires the following services in order to address his unique needs:

• Services designed to help STUDENT engage in peer activities, community activities, and vocational activities during after-school hours. • In-home services to address STUDENT’s cooking, eating, and personal hygiene. • Family therapy to address STUDENT’s relationship with his parents. • Parental training to help STUDENT’s parents learn appropriate ways of engaging STUDENT and drawing him out of his fantasy life.

These services all need to focus on providing structured support, and be closely coordinated with the school staff. The services intended to help STUDENT engage in peer, community, and vocational activities during after-school hours must be provided on a daily basis. Did the Respondents’ offer meet these requirements? The offer of in-home services twice a month, and family therapy twice a month, combined with the case management services, are appropriate to address STUDENT’s need for an in-home program to address improving his independent living skills. These services also are appropriate to address STUDENT’s relationship with his parents. The need for parental training is appropriately addressed by a combination of the family therapy and the parental psychiatric services. However, STUDENT’s most compelling need, and the need of most concern to his father, is STUDENT’s need to develop peer relationships and to engage in community activities and vocational activities during after-school hours. In the Respondents’ offer, these needs were intended to be addressed by the transition plan. However, the transition plan services to be provided by Mental Health were listed as “as needed.” Dr. Russell testified that it would be possible, and appropriate, to have someone going into the home on a daily basis to help involve STUDENT in peer and social activities outside the home. Therefore, the Respondents’ offer has the potential to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. However, the law requires more. The Respondents were required to make a formal, specific written offer of placement and services. Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). This offer must include annual goals and short-term objectives, the specific special educational instruction and related services required by the student, as well as appropriate objective criteria for measuring the student’s progress toward his goals. Cal. Ed. Code § 56345(a)(2),(3),(6). The Hearing Officer finds that the Respondents’ offer meets the requirement as to specific goals and objectives, but fails to meet to the requirement of specificity of services. The transition plan services needed to be set out with specificity as to the actual services to be provided and the frequency of the services.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Respondents’ offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year, as set forth in the June/July 2001 IEP and the August 2001 letter, was an offer of FAPE except for one failing. In order to properly address STUDENT’s need to develop peer relationships and engage in community and vocational activities during after-school hours, STUDENT will need daily in-home intervention by a properly trained member of the Mental Health staff. The Respondents’ offer of placement did not set forth these services with sufficient specificity.

Even though the offer of one RSP class at Lincoln was appropriate at the time it was made, the improvement in STUDENT’s functioning since his medication was increased warrants a modification to this part of the offer. To meet STUDENT’s current needs, STUDENT’s placement should include approximately half of his time in RSP classes at Stagg High School. Not only is this modification necessary to meet STUDENT’s current needs, but was agreed to in principle by District and Mental Health staff.

2. Does STUDENT require a residential program for the 2001-2002 school year in order to receive an appropriate education?

Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031. Although the program at ADT is more restrictive that an RSP program, it is less restrictive than a residential program. The evidence shows that STUDENT made progress in relation to his in-school behavior while at ADT. In fact, STUDENT improved so much that he was able to attend three RSP classes at Stagg during the 2000-2001 school year, and is doing even better in his current RSP classes at Stagg. Whether STUDENT’s success is due to his time at ADT or due to a change of medication is not material. The fact remains that STUDENT is currently able to be successful in RSP classes at Stagg High School. Therefore, removal to a more restrictive environment is not warranted.

Petitioner contends that only a residential program will be successful in addressing STUDENT’s behavior during after-school hours. However, only Dr. Wu came to the conclusion that STUDENT required residential placement. Dr. Burke, Dr. Russell and Dr. Miller all testified that a comprehensive after school program, combined with an appropriate special day class program, could adequately meet STUDENT’s needs in relation to his after-school behavior. There is evidence that an appropriate level of “wrap around” services would be successful in addressing STUDENT’s behavior at home and during after-school hours. In the past, there had only been a brief trial of in-home services. In October 2000, Mike Tarango was working with STUDENT and FATHER once a week to set up a written schedule for STUDENT to follow at home. It appears that this limited level of intervention was successful, at least for awhile. From STUDENT’s statements to Mike Tarango and Dr. Russell, it appeared that STUDENT was reducing the amount of time he spent with his fantasy family while at home. FATHER discontinued this plan after only four or five weeks. Based upon the limited success of this one trial of in-home intervention, there is good reason to believe that a much more comprehensive system of in-home intervention and after-school services would be able to meet STUDENT’s needs in relation to his behavior at home and during after-school hours. Furthermore, Dr. Miller and Dr. Russell were both concluded that a residential program that removed STUDENT from his family would be very upsetting to STUDENT and might interfere with his progress.

The evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that STUDENT requires residential placement. STUDENT’s needs can be adequately met by a combination of a special day class program, RSP classes, and an appropriate level of in-home services.

3. Is the Devereux Foundation School in Santa Barbara an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year.

Given the conclusion set forth above, that STUDENT does not require a residential placement, there is no need to examine the specific program at Devereux.

CONCLUSION

As set forth above, the District’s offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year did constitute a FAPE except for one failing. The offer was not specific as to the level and frequency of in-home services that would be provided to address STUDENT’s need to develop peer relationships and engage in community and vocational activities during after-school hours. To address this need STUDENT requires daily in-home intervention by a member of the Mental Health staff. This daily intervention should address STUDENT’s needs in relation to peer relationships, community activities, and vocational activities outside of the normal school day. This intervention is in addition to those services specifically set forth in the in the June/July 2001 IEP and the August 23, 2001 letter that summarized the Respondents’ offer of placement.

Although the offer of one RSP class at Lincoln was appropriate at the time it was made, the recent improvement in STUDENT’s behavior at school requires modification of this part of the offer. Based upon STUDENT’s current level of functioning, his placement should include enrollment in more than one RSP class a semester, and the RSP classes should be at Stagg High School rather than Lincoln. However, STUDENT continues to need a structured, therapeutic day treatment program such as the ADT program offered by the District and Mental Health. STUDENT’s placement should be for approximately one-half of his time in the ADT program and one-half of his time in RSP classes at Stagg High School. Not only is this modification necessary to meet STUDENT’s current needs, but was agreed to in principle by District and Mental Health staff.

The District shall convene an IEP team meeting to modify its offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year. The revised IEP will provide for specific in-home services on a daily basis to address STUDENT’s need to develop peer relationships, community activities, and vocational activities outside of the normal school day. The IEP will also provide for attendance in RSP classes at Stagg High School for approximately half the time. However, to insure that STUDENT receives the necessary level of support during the school day, STUDENT shall continue to attend the ADT program for approximately one-half of the time.

ORDER

1. Within 15 calendar days of date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to modify the offer of placement contained in the June 26, July 12, 2001 IEP and the August 23, 2001 letter. The revised IEP will provide for the following:

a. Specific in-home intervention on a daily basis to address STUDENT’s need to develop peer relationships, and engage in community activities, and vocational activities outside of the normal school day. Because STUDENT’s parents are separated and share custody, these services must be provided wherever STUDENT is actually residing.

b. The IEP will also provide for attendance in RSP classes at Stagg High School approximately one-half the time.

c. To ensure that STUDENT receives the necessary level of support during the school day, the IEP will include attendance in the ADT program approximately one-half of the time.

2. All of Student's other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

1. Did the District’s offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year constitute a free and appropriate public education?

The District and Mental Health prevailed except that the offer of placement needed to be modified to set forth all services with specificity and as to the number and location of RSP classes that Petitioner would attend .

2. Does STUDENT require a residential program for the 2001-2002 school year in order to receive an appropriate education?

The District and Mental Health prevailed on this issue.

3. Is the Devereux Foundation School in Santa Barbara an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year.

This issue was not reached.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: January 11, 2002 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has revised the parties’ statements of the issues. 2. This last contention may seem inconsistent with Petitioner’s contention regarding STUDENT’s ability to be successful in a less restrictive environment. Petitioner concedes that STUDENT’s behavior during school hours has improved, but contends that his behavior outside of school hours has not improved and can only be adequately addressed by a residential program. 3. When Brush Ranch accepted STUDENT they were unaware that his designation had been changed to emotionally disturbed in February 2000. 4. Ms. Coleman was the designated representative for Mental Health at the hearing, and was present for the testimony of all of the witnesses. 5. It is undisputed that addressing STUDENT’s behavior during after-school hours is a legitimate need that should be addressed by his IEP.