California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 19, 2005
La Mesa-Spring Valley School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1044-05 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim
La Mesa-Spring Valley School District must reimburse nonpublic school tuition after an unclear behavior and mainstreaming offer denied FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
La Mesa-Spring Valley School District filed for due process to show that its February 22, 2005 IEP offered a FAPE. The student was a nine-year-old third grader eligible under mental retardation (now called intellectual disability) who also has ADHD. The District offered a special day class at Murray Manor Elementary for all academics, plus speech, occupational therapy, vision therapy, an FM listening system, a typing program, a behavior support plan, and behavior specialist support. The parents rejected the offer. On March 28, 2005, they placed him at Balboa City Schools, a certified nonpublic school.
The Hearing Officer found the offer procedurally defective. The IEP team had agreed that the student's behavior impeded learning, and he had several behavior referrals that year. Yet the IEP listed a behavior support plan without presenting one. It also listed behavior specialist support without stating its frequency, duration, or location. School psychologist Michael Laddon had drafted a plan but never shared it with the parents. The IEP also did not state how much time the student would spend in general education. Under Union School District v. Smith, these gaps seriously limited the parents' participation and denied FAPE. Balboa City Schools was appropriate: it offered small classes, a modified curriculum, one-to-one reading help, and behavior and social-skills support, and the student made progress. Its lack of mainstreaming did not bar reimbursement. The District must reimburse tuition and mileage from March 28 through the end of the school year, plus the 2005 summer session. Placement for 2005-2006 was denied because that year was not at issue.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith's written-offer requirement. It was not enough to list a "behavior support plan" and "behavior specialist support" without the plan itself or the service frequency, duration, and location. The IEP also had to state how much time the student would spend in general education. A nonpublic school's lack of mainstreaming did not defeat reimbursement.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment from February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The District denied FAPE because the February 22, 2005 offer listed a behavior support plan without presenting one, did not state the frequency, duration, or location of behavior specialist support, and did not state how much time the student would spend in general education. These gaps seriously infringed the parents' participation.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the expenses they incurred to place him at Balboa City Schools, a certified nonpublic school?
Balboa City Schools was appropriate. It offered small-group and one-to-one instruction, a modified curriculum, and behavior and social-skills support, and the student made progress there. The lack of mainstreaming did not bar reimbursement of tuition and mileage from March 28, 2005.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at Balboa City Schools for the 2005 extended school year (ESY) and 2005-2006 school year?
As a remedy for the denial of FAPE from February 22 to March 27, 2005, the student was awarded placement at Balboa City Schools for its 2005 summer session, paid as reimbursement. Prospective placement for 2005-2006 was denied because that year was not at issue in this District-filed case.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof, the District must reimburse the tuition the parents actually paid for Balboa City Schools from March 28, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year. The findings set tuition at $1,081.50 per month.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof, the District must reimburse transportation to and from Balboa City Schools at the District mileage rate for school days from March 28, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year. Mileage is calculated as a round trip each morning and a one-way trip each afternoon.
- Compensatory education. For the denial of FAPE from February 22 to March 27, 2005, the student was awarded placement at Balboa City Schools for the 2005 summer session (ESY). Because the session had likely ended, the order provides reimbursement of the tuition and transportation the parents incurred, if they placed him there at their own expense.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Cleveland Heights-University Heights v. Boss; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup; Seattle Sch. Dist. v. B.S.; Capistrano Unified v. Wartenberg; Honig v. Doe
People named in the decision
- Barbara Goodwin, director of special education, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Mary Shields, former program specialist (now special education coordinator at Newport Mesa Unified), La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Dan Petro, private behavior analyst/behavioral consultant contracted by District; conducted functional analysis assessment, Private practice
- Heather Difede, program specialist, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Julie Laing, inclusion support teacher/program specialist; conducted assistive technology screening, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Jaime Barawed, resource specialist teacher, Rolando Elementary, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Laura Cress, third-grade general education teacher, Rolando Elementary, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Amber Burmeister, speech-language pathologist, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Victoria Nojd, certified occupational therapy assistant, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Jan Diggs, audiologist and speech-language pathologist; conducted auditory processing assessment, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Michelle Kmak, special day class teacher, Murray Manor Elementary (proposed placement), La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Michael Laddon, school psychologist; triennial assessor and author of unshared behavior support plan, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Edward Woodruff, speech-language pathologist; speech-language assessor, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
- Whitney Ross, school counselor, Balboa City Schools (nonpublic school)
- Carolyn Chamberlin, director of special education and teacher, Balboa City Schools (nonpublic school)
- Katelyn Hassler, handwriting and language teacher, Balboa City Schools (nonpublic school)
- Yvonne Jamarillo, social studies and sports lab teacher, Balboa City Schools (nonpublic school)
- Kim Worobey, math and reading teacher, Balboa City Schools (nonpublic school)
- Kathleen Edwards, Ed.D., educational advocate, witness for Student, Coach Educational Advocacy
- Martin Rothschild, O.D., private optometrist; visual processing evaluation obtained by parents, Private
- Phillips Smith, O.D., private optometrist contracted by District; vision evaluation and therapy, Private
- Mary Kawar, private occupational therapist; OT evaluation at District request, Private
- Tom Trott, program director, Mad Science after-school program at Rolando, Mad Science program
- Robert Patterson, independent assessor proposed by District, Private
- Southern California Diagnostic Center, state diagnostic center; transdisciplinary assessment, California Department of Education
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in La Mesa, California, on June 1, 2, and 3, 2005. Additional testimony was taken by telephone on June 7, 2005.
Petitioner La Mesa-Spring Valley School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget Flanagan from the law firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District’s behalf were special education director Barbara Goodwin and, starting June 2, attorney Deborah Ungar from the law firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Thomas Nelson from the Law Offices of Thomas S. Nelson. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, PARENTS.
The District called the following witnesses: Mary Shields, a special education coordinator at Newport Mesa Unified School District and former program specialist for the District; Dan Petro, a behavior analyst in private practice; Heather Difede, a District program specialist; Julie Laing, a District inclusion support teacher; Jaime Barawed, a District resource specialist at Rolando Elementary School (Rolando); Laura Cress, a third-grade teacher at Rolando; Amber Burmeister, a District speech-language pathologist; Victoria Nojd, a certified occupational therapy assistant employed by the District; Jan Diggs, a District audiologist and speech-language pathologist; Michelle Kmak, a special day class teacher at Murray Manor Elementary School; Barbara Goodwin, the District’s director of special education; and Michael Laddon, a District school psychologist. The Student called the following witnesses: Whitney Ross, a school counselor at Balboa City Schools (BCS), a certified nonpublic school; Carolyn Chamberlin, BCS’s director of special education; PARENTS, his parents; and Kathleen Edwards, Ed.D., an educational advocate with Coach Educational Advocacy.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of the parties’ written closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year?
2. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the expenses they incurred to place him at Balboa City Schools, a certified nonpublic school?
3. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at Balboa City Schools for the 2005 extended school year (ESY) and 2005-2006 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old student who resides with his family within the boundaries of the District. STUDENT has been diagnosed with mild mental retardation (MMR) and attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD), inattentive type. He was identified as eligible for special education and related services while in preschool. He recently completed his third-grade year, which he began at Rolando Elementary School (Rolando), a District public school, and ended at Balboa City Schools, a certified nonpublic school, where he was unilaterally placed by his parents.
STUDENT began receiving early intervention services, including speech and language therapy, at twenty-six months of age through an Early Start program. Commencing in September 1998, at the age of three, STUDENT attended Glen Street Preschool in a non-categorical special day class (SDC). His primary disability at the time was identified as cognitive delay (i.e., mental retardation) with educational needs in the areas of preacademic, fine- and gross-motor, self-help, social/emotional, prevocational, and communication skills. At four years of age, STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD.
According to the testimony of FATHER, for the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT transitioned to Highlands Elementary School for kindergarten, where he was placed in a special education program with limited participation in the general education program for field trips, recess, and lunch. He then repeated kindergarten during the 2001-2002 school year at Rolando, where he was fully included in the general education program with the assistance of a full-time shadow aide and with ten percent of the school day spent in the resource specialist program (RSP), in direct speech-language therapy and occupational therapy (OT), and in counseling. He also received speech-language consultation and OT consultation services.
On February 27, 2002, the individualized education program (IEP) team met for STUDENT’s annual review. The RSP teacher and speech therapist indicated that STUDENT had made significant progress, but STUDENT’s parents had concerns that STUDENT was “falling through the cracks” and wanted to “tighten” STUDENT’s program and increase the communication between home and school. STUDENT’s parents requested monthly meetings with school staff to update progress, discuss new items, and ensure that team members understood programming changes as they occurred. The District agreed to conduct monthly meetings for STUDENT and also agreed to develop a new communication log to be sent home twice weekly.
In June 2002, the District conducted a triennial evaluation of STUDENT. District school psychologist Michael Laddon determined that STUDENT’s overall cognitive ability was in the below average range, and that he had difficulty with short-term memory and processing speed. Mr. Laddon noted that STUDENT’s academic skills in reading and math were in the below average to average range, and that his achievement in written language was in the average range overall. According to Mr. Laddon, STUDENT had significant deficits in auditory memory, sequencing, and discrimination. Mr. Laddon indicated that STUDENT continued to exhibit attention deficits at school but that he appeared to have discontinued picking at his skin, a behavior which he had exhibited earlier in the school year. Mr. Laddon concluded that there had been significant improvement in STUDENT’s overall cognitive ability score and conjectured that the significant improvement might have been due to age and developmental factors, attention factors, or a combination of both. Mr. Laddon stated in his written report that STUDENT’s cognitive ability was no longer in the intellectually deficient range and therefore suggested that STUDENT’s eligibility category be changed from mental retardation (MR) to other health impaired (OHI) due to his ADHD diagnosis. Mr. Laddon concluded that, although there were different factors adversely affecting STUDENT’s academic achievement such as auditory processing, memory, processing speed, and visual-motor integration, STUDENT’s attention deficits were the most significant factor adversely impacting his academic achievement. Mr. Laddon recommended that STUDENT continue to receive in-school counseling for social skills training.
At an IEP meeting held on June 19, 2002, the IEP team reviewed the triennial assessment findings and agreed to change STUDENT’s eligibility category from MR to OHI. The team also agreed to the following program: continued placement at Rolando in the general education program with participation in special education and related services during 4 percent of the school day—thirty minutes of OT one time per week, four hours of OT consultation per year, and forty-five minutes of counseling per week. STUDENT also received the support of a full-time shadow aide. The team noted that STUDENT had been receiving counseling in play situations, both inside and outside, to work on developing his parallel play to the next stage of play—playing a game with a partner. The team noted that in the classroom, he needed verbal directions to be repeated and then confirmed by having him repeat them back.
During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT attended a first-grade general education classroom at Rolando and received special education supports including RSP, a shadow aide, OT, and counseling. To monitor STUDENT’s progress and needs, the IEPT met on August 7, 2002, September 25, 2002, November 6, 2002, December 3, 2002, January 23, 2003, March 18, 2003, April 30, 2003, and June 18, 2003. During the September 25 meeting, the District introduced private behavioral consultant Dan Petro, whom the District had contracted to work on STUDENT’s behaviors, to STUDENT’s parents. The IEP team noted that during the last thirty weeks, STUDENT had reverted back to his old behaviors of picking, acting defiant, and being easily distracted. Team members stated that they were not sure why these behaviors had been occurring since they had been using the same consequences and rewards. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT was progressing and needed a lot of positive interventions, and agreed to implement the interventions suggested by Mr. Petro. During the November 6 meeting, the IEP team noted that STUDENT’s main issue was his attention span and that he stayed on task much better with one-to-one tasks.
By report dated December 2, 2002, Mr. Petro set forth the findings from his functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT and a recommended behavior intervention plan (BIP). Mr. Petro identified STUDENT’s problem behaviors as mild, including asking off-topic questions or making off-topic comments, touching peers or their property, and touching himself on his gums, buttocks, leg, arm, and nose. Mr. Petro identified the possible function of STUDENT’s behavior as obtaining control over his environment. Specifically, STUDENT engaged in the behaviors to get the attention of and/or exert control over adults and peers, access assistance, have a task changed, access a preferred activity, access comfort, obtain a break, and initiate interactions with people. Mr. Petro identified in his report an IEP goal and objective and interventions to decrease STUDENT’s problem behaviors. Mr. Petro presented his report and recommended BIP to the IEP team at the December 3, 2002 meeting. The team agreed to provide training to school staff, including the classroom teacher, RSP teacher, aide, and principal, and to STUDENT’s parents on December 10 to implement the BIP.
On January 13, 2003, STUDENT’s parents brought him to optometrist Martin Rothschild, O.D., for a visual processing evaluation. Dr. Rothschild noted that a visual processing evaluation had been recommended to determine if there were visual skills or visual processing problems that might be affecting STUDENT’s academic performance. Dr. Rothschild noted in his written report dated January 16, 2003, that all of his subjective testing with STUDENT had been difficult, with questionable reliability, due to STUDENT’s inability to maintain concentration to the task at hand. Dr. Rothschild found that STUDENT had adequate acuity, immature eye movement skills, fragile binocularity, immature visual motor integration skills, questionable motor-free visual processing, immature visual analysis and organization, and attention deficits that certainly affected STUDENT’s results and performance. Dr. Rothschild concluded that STUDENT did not need glasses but did need regular follow-up examinations to evaluate binocularity, with a recheck in three months, and that STUDENT might benefit from a vision therapy program in the near future. STUDENT’s parents presented Dr. Rothschild’s evaluation report to the IEP team at the IEP meeting held on January 23, 2003.
At STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting held on March 18, 2003, the occupational therapist reported that STUDENT had made significant progress over the past nine months, most notably in the area of distractibility. The occupational therapist noted that STUDENT was no longer distracted by small noises and voices. She suggested that STUDENT receive OT one time per month to assist with organizational skills as they related to the classroom environment. The IEP team also noted that STUDENT’s recovery time from undesired behavior or frustration had improved to a marked degree. STUDENT’s parents indicated that they were concerned about STUDENT’s comprehension and ability to work independently. The IEP team agreed to review intervention strategies for fading STUDENT’s dependence on his instructional aide. The annual IEP meeting was continued to June 18, 2003. At the June 18 meeting, the IEP team agreed to provide continued aide support to STUDENT through the first thirty days of the 2003-2004 school year, and that this “special circumstance” aide would help STUDENT gain independence and work to his success.
For the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s second-grade year, he continued to be fully included in the general education program at Rolando with support services. According to an IEP addendum dated November 12, 2003, STUDENT received forty-five minutes of RSP services four times per week, thirty minutes of OT one time per month, twenty minutes of counseling per week in a group setting, and support from the inclusion teacher in the form of periodic visits to STUDENT’s classroom and formal observation notes sent home to his parents, when appropriate. According to the testimony of former program specialist Mary Shields, the District also provided him with the full-time support of an instructional aide during second grade. At the November 12 meeting, the general education teacher reported that, in the area of reading, STUDENT had shown progress on formal reading assessments but that reading comprehension continued to be an area of need. District staff indicated that they felt that the supports and services being provided were appropriate for STUDENT to make progress, but nevertheless offered to refer him to the local community mental health agency for mental health services (i.e., an AB2726 referral). STUDENT’s parents indicated that they would inform the District later about their decision regarding the AB2726 referral, and requested that STUDENT be referred to the Southern California Diagnostic Center (Diagnostic Center) for an independent educational evaluation (IEE). The District members of the team stated that they would contact the special education director with regard to the Diagnostic Center request.
By report dated November 17, 2003, special education teacher Jamie Barawed indicated that STUDENT was “progressing nicely” towards his IEP goals and had achieved his benchmarks early. By letter dated November 21, 2003, the program director of the Mad Science program at Rolando, Tom Trott, informed STUDENT’s parents that they had decided to remove STUDENT from the program due to disciplinary and behavioral issues. By letter dated December 4, 2003, STUDENT’s parents informed the IEP team that they strongly felt that the supports and services being provided to STUDENT were inadequate and reiterated their request for a plan to catch STUDENT up to the State standards for second grade.
STUDENT’s IEP team met again on December 17, 2003, to review his program, progress, and behavior. STUDENT’s parents informed the team that they were working with Kaiser on STUDENT’s social-emotional issues and were not interested in AB2726. His parents indicated that they were concerned about STUDENT’s present levels of performance and his ability to meet second-grade standards by the end of the school year. STUDENT’s parents stated that they wanted him taught to second-grade standards rather than to his IEP goals. The Rolando principal responded that the school team was teaching STUDENT both to the standards and his IEP goals and that STUDENT was making progress. Behavioral specialist Dan Petro shared his recent observation of STUDENT in the general education classroom and described how the instruction was differentiated for STUDENT, when needed. Mr. Petro also discussed STUDENT’s social interaction with the other children in his class and how the interactions had improved since Mr. Petro’s first meeting with STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents expressed concerns about STUDENT’s interactions with other children and suggested different methods to address STUDENT’s social interactions with peers. Further, the District program specialist stated that there were other placements and methodologies available within the District that STUDENT’s parents might want to explore; his parents expressed a desire to visit other placements. Finally, the team agreed to conduct an auditory processing evaluation to determine if the FastForward program might be an appropriate intervention for STUDENT.
Shortly thereafter, by letter dated December 19, 2003, the District provided STUDENT’s parents with a list of nonpublic schools located in the greater San Diego area and a list of District placements that might fit STUDENT’s needs, including special day classes at Casa de Oro Elementary School, Glen-Murdock Elementary School, and Highlands Elementary School. The District also provided his parents with the curriculum vitae of an independent assessor, Dr. Robert Patterson, for their consideration.
In a letter dated January 2, 2004, STUDENT’s parents informed the District that they were not in agreement with the BIP developed by Dan Petro because, according to them, the BIP failed to address many areas of behavior and Mr. Petro had indicated at the last IEP meeting that he was at a loss as to how to address STUDENT’s behavior. STUDENT’s parents requested that the District contract with another, agreed-upon child behaviorist for the development of a new BIP for STUDENT. The District responded on January 13 that it saw no reason to consider a change in behavior specialists.
By letter dated February 10, 2004, the Diagnostic Center indicated that it had received an assessment referral from the District regarding STUDENT and that it was accepting the referral. While waiting for the Diagnostic Center to complete its evaluation, the District contracted with Phillips Smith, O.D., a private optometrist, for a complete optometric visual evaluation, including visual-motor and visual perceptual testing, of STUDENT. Dr. Smith examined STUDENT on February 11, 2004, and issued a written report on February 24, 2004. Dr. Smith found that STUDENT was experiencing significant difficulties with eye teaming, focus flexibility, depth perception, fixation accuracy, tracking ability, letter/number directionality awareness, visual-motor integration, and in all visual perceptual areas. Dr. Smith concluded that these visual conditions were likely affecting STUDENT’s visual comfort and efficiency in regards to reading and writing activities. Dr. Smith recommended that STUDENT be provided an initial program of optometric vision therapy consisting of twenty-four sessions to help STUDENT develop and stabilize these areas of visual deficits to an age-appropriate level. Dr. Smith stated that an evaluation should be conducted upon completion of the program to measure STUDENT’s improvements and determine if his visual skills were stabilized to an adequate level to support academic performance, or if additional therapy would be beneficial.
Additionally, on or about March 13, 2004, District audiologist and speech-language pathologist (SLP) Jan Diggs conducted an auditory processing assessment of STUDENT. In her report, Ms. Diggs noted that she saw STUDENT on two different occasions to complete the evaluation to help reduce the adverse effects of fatigue and weak attending on his performance and to take the time necessary to explain and/or demonstrate different testing tasks. She noted that the test results should be interpreted with caution because of STUDENT’s weak auditory memory, auditory attention, and auditory vigilance. Ms. Diggs concluded that STUDENT’s performance suggested the existence of an auditory processing disorder primarily in the area of integration, and that a prosodic and decoding deficit might also coexist with the integration deficit.
Further, on six dates between February 19 and March 15, 2004, District SLP Edward Woodruff evaluated STUDENT’s speech and language abilities. In a written report dated March 15, 2004, Mr. Woodruff noted that testing with STUDENT could be problematic because he had difficulty attending at times to tasks that proved difficult for him. Also, STUDENT could attend very well but then suddenly drift off and verbalize things that were completely unrelated to the task at hand. Mr. Woodruff noted that STUDENT could be very cooperative and that he tried very hard during testing. Mr. Woodruff found that STUDENT showed a relative strength in receptive language when compared to expressive language, and a relative strength in language content when compared to language structure. Mr. Woodruff reported that STUDENT showed significantly above average ability in the area of auditory word discrimination with words, which helped to contribute to his ability to decode grade-level text, but that STUDENT’s ability to comprehend grade-level text was negatively impacted by his difficulty remembering significant details about a story, difficulty remembering the sequence of events in a story, and difficulty describing how a story ends, as well as describing what happens to key characters in a story.
Finally, on or about May 2, 2004, private occupational therapist Mary Kawar conducted an OT evaluation of STUDENT at the District’s request. Among other things, Ms. Kawar found that STUDENT’s tactile discrimination was below average, suggesting that tactile information was not being registered as consistently and efficiently as desired to support the functional activities of his hands for object manipulation and tool use. Additionally, he reportedly had some auditory defensiveness and social-emotional concerns including poor self-regulation, impulsiveness, distractibility, and ease of frustration. She concluded that STUDENT would benefit from therapeutic intervention, which should improve his functional and academic performance, as well as enhance his self-confidence and self-esteem. She recommended twelve one-hour OT sessions per week, which should include consultation with the classroom teacher and physical education teacher so that strategies could be integrated into the curriculum throughout the day. She also recommended that STUDENT’s parents be guided in a home program so that they could address performance issues on a daily basis.
The Diagnostic Center completed its transdisciplinary assessment of STUDENT and issued a written report dated May 21, 2004. The Diagnostic Center thereafter shared its report at a meeting with STUDENT’s parents and District personnel. The Diagnostic Center found that STUDENT’s cognitive, communicative, and adaptive skills were consistent with mild mental retardation and that, while STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADHD, inattentive type, medications for ADHD had been ineffective in controlling his behavioral symptoms to date. The Diagnostic Center reported that STUDENT’s cognitive, communicative, and social skills cluster was in the four- to five-year-old range and that his academic skills cluster at the kindergarten to first-grade level. According to the Diagnostic Center report, STUDENT was friendly, wanted to please adults, and worked well for tangible and social reinforcements. However, when tasks became frustrating, STUDENT protested and requested breaks. When pressed to continue, STUDENT picked at his face, arm, and leg to the point of drawing blood.
The Diagnostic Center identified STUDENT’s critical needs as (1) developmentally appropriate instruction delivered in a direct and systematic daily program, (2) materials, curriculum, strategies, and pacing that are consistent, motivating, and appropriate, and (3) continued support for language development. In terms of programming and curriculum, the Diagnostic Center recommended for STUDENT a program that emphasizes functional academic skills at his success level, speech and language and OT services, the consideration of assistive technology to aid writing, social skills training, and a case manager to support a collaborative approach between the service providers and teaching staff. The Diagnostic Center provided the following recommendations for instructional planning: provide direct instruction on a one-to-one or small-group basis as needed, break instruction down into small sections with lots of repetition and review, aid the generalization of skills by finding useful applications across environments, work on skills in isolation until automatic, 80 percent of tasks should be at STUDENT’s independent success level, alternate preferred and non-preferred activities, use short sentences and phrases, allow for extra language processing time (ten to fifteen seconds), and provide visual cues, models, and hands-on learning. With regard to a classroom environment, the Diagnostic Center recommended the provision of direct instruction in a one-to-one or small group setting when assignments are not at STUDENT’s independent success level and for new instruction, clear structure and predictable routines, frequent opportunities for movement breaks, use of closure systems so STUDENT will learn that he is earning a break or preferred activity, a positive approach to discipline, and adult-structured recreational activities to promote positive peer interactions.
STUDENT’s IEP team met shortly thereafter on June 7, 2004, to discuss the assessments recently completed and to determine a placement for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. After reviewing the visual evaluation by Dr. Smith, the IEP team agreed to provide STUDENT six vision therapy sessions, followed by a review of progress to determine the need for additional therapy, and to develop educationally based vision therapy goals. The IEP team then reviewed the auditory processing assessment and discussed instructional approaches, as well as classroom modifications and supports, including the use of an auditory trainer for a trial period. Upon review of the OT assessment, the IEP team determined that STUDENT needed to work on his handwriting, motor control, balance, motor planning, and tactile processing. The occupational therapist recommended the provision of direct OT and OT consultation services. The speech-language assessor reported that STUDENT was developing language but had a difficult time putting his new skills into a sequenced, understandable order and had difficulty retrieving words when needed. Finally, the IEP team reviewed the Diagnostic Center report and recommendations. The team agreed that the Diagnostic Center recommendations could not be implemented in a regular education program, but his parents continued to want STUDENT included in the general education program up to this point. His parents also expressed a desire to discuss nonpublic schools as the IEP was developed. The team agreed to reconvene to continue the discussions about placement.
The IEP team met again nine days later on June 16. The IEP team discussed the Diagnostic Center’s finding that STUDENT’s primary diagnosis was mild mental retardation and agreed to change STUDENT’s eligibility category back to MR. The school staff reviewed STUDENT’s progress on his March 18, 2003 IEP goals and reported that STUDENT had met four of his goals and substantially met three. The IEP team developed present levels of performance for STUDENT and agreed to goals developed to address the following areas: vision therapy, OT, academics, and speech and language, including pragmatic language. The IEP team then discussed placement options, and STUDENT’s parents expressed their concern about mainstreaming opportunities and communication.
The IEP team met again on June 18, 2004, to continue discussing placement options. For the 2004 extended school year (ESY), the District offered STUDENT placement at Casa de Oro Elementary School (CDO) in a four-hour per day non-severely handicapped class and a minimum of one hour per day of pull-out services to provide intense specialized reading instruction and comprehension in a small-group setting. STUDENT’s parents consented to the District’s ESY offer. For the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered STUDENT the following: placement in an SDC setting for 50 percent of the school day to address his academic and functional needs, fifty twenty-minute speech and language therapy sessions per year, six one-hour vision therapy sessions, twenty-four thirty-minute OT sessions, and transportation to and from school. The District described to STUDENT’s parents the SDC at CDO and the non-severely handicapped SDC for third to fifth graders at Murray Manor Elementary School (Murray Manor). His parents indicated that they wanted to visit the proposed programs prior to making a placement decision for the 2004-2005 school year, but agreed to the District’s offer of transportation, OT, speech and language services, and vision therapy. The IEP team agreed that, in the interim, STUDENT would begin the 2004-2005 school year in the third grade at Rolando with two and a half hours of RSP per day, where he would be provided instruction in reading, writing, and math. The District indicated that STUDENT’s needs could best be met in an SDC and would not agree to an RSP placement for the entire school year. The team agreed to meet prior to September 20 to continue to discuss STUDENT’s placement.
Pursuant to the IEP team’s agreement, STUDENT attended CDO during the 2004 ESY and then began the 2004-2005 school year in the general education third-grade program at Rolando, with the supports of RSP, OT, speech and language therapy, and vision therapy. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT’s IEP team met again on September 14, 2004. The RSP teacher noted that she tries to follow what is being done in the general education classroom, but that the main academic focus in RSP has been working on STUDENT’s IEP goals. She stated that she provided STUDENT services through both a pull-out and in-class model. The SLP reported that in the short time she had worked with STUDENT, STUDENT had been a very hard worker and worked really well with students in his groups. The auditory specialist noted that she was working on identifying the times in school when STUDENT needed to be wearing the headset for his FM system. STUDENT’s general teacher provided the following comments: STUDENT performed better in the morning, the teacher broke assignments into smaller chunks for him so that he did not become frustrated, STUDENT did a great job of completing his homework and returning it daily, and the teacher assessed all the students with a third-grade math inventory test, spelling inventory, and writing prompt at the beginning of the school year and STUDENT scored 33 % in math, 32% in spelling, and wrote off task during the writing prompt. The parents asked why behavior goals and/or a behavior plan had not been developed to address STUDENT’s behavior; the IEP team agreed that the school psychologist would work on STUDENT’s behavior issues. Finally, the District presented as its offer placement in the SDC at Murray Manor. The District explained that the SDC could address STUDENT’s academics with a variety of methodologies in reading, writing, and math, and could address STUDENT’s behavior and OT issues. STUDENT’s parents rejected the District’s SDC offer and indicated that they would file for a due process hearing.
In a letter to STUDENT’s parents dated October 7, 2004, District special education director Barbara Goodwin clarified the District’s offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year as follows: placement in the SDC at Murray Manor five days per week for all academics; inclusion in the general education program during lunch, recess, and special events; two thirty-minute speech and language therapy sessions per week; six one-hour sessions of vision therapy (to complete the recommended twenty-four sessions begun during the 2003-2004 school year); twenty-four thirty-minute OT sessions; a behavior support plan developed by a District psychologist; an assistive technology device called an Easy Listener to assist STUDENT in focusing on auditorily presented information; and a slant board and pencil grip for writing. Additionally, Ms. Goodwin stated that the District had provided and continued to offer the support of behavioral consultant Dan Petro to assist the educational staff and STUDENT’s parents with positive behavioral interventions. Ms. Goodwin noted, however, that it was the District’s understanding that his parents wished to decline all services provided by Mr. Petro. Further, Ms. Goodwin indicated that, based on the Diagnostic Center report, the District was offering adapted physical education (APE) and assistive technology (AT) evaluations and that she had enclosed an evaluation plan for that purpose.
Following receipt of STUDENT’s parents’ consent for the APE and AT evaluations, District program specialist Julie Laing conducted a technology screening of STUDENT. In a written report dated November 29, 2004, Ms. Laing found that STUDENT would benefit from a simple typing program to increase his typing speed. Ms. Laing noted that once improvement was noted in this area, it would be easier to determine if typing, rather than writing, would aid STUDENT in the writing process. The District also completed an APE evaluation.
On January 20, 2005, the IEP team met again and reviewed the AT and APE evaluations. The IEP team agreed to implement a keyboarding program into STUDENT’s academic day, with all other students having access to the program as well, and that STUDENT did not require any APE services. Audiologist Jan Diggs reported that STUDENT was using the FM system for all tests and announcements and that the totable FM system was better than earphones for STUDENT. The team agreed to continue the use of the totable FM system. Ms. Diggs also suggested Dichotic Interaural Intensity Difference Training to increase STUDENT’s ability to attend and focus and to address his right ear dominance. Recommended implementation was three to four days per week for twenty minutes, with results typically seen by six weeks. STUDENT’s parents indicated that they would provide a response to the recommended training at a later date. His parents also indicated that they wanted to table discussions about STUDENT’s behavior, preferring to continue to monitor the strategies implemented by the occupational therapist to address self regulation. Finally, STUDENT’s parents stated that they were unaware that one of the purposes of the meeting was to discuss STUDENT’s placement and services, and thus were unwilling to discuss placement and services at the meeting. Regardless, the District stated that it wanted to make its offer of FAPE for STUDENT. The District offered STUDENT placement in the non-severely handicapped SDC at Murray Manor during 50 percent of the school day, with mainstreaming during 50 percent of the school day into a general education third-grade classroom. The District also offered STUDENT fifty twenty-minute speech and language therapy sessions per year, twenty-four thirty-minute OT sessions, twenty-four one-hour vision therapy sessions, implementation of a typing program, transportation to and from Murray Manor, and a twenty-day ESY program.
By letter dated February 4, 2005, STUDENT’s parents informed Ms. Goodwin that they felt that the District’s offer dated January 20, 2004, failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE. Therefore, his parents indicated that they intended to enroll STUDENT at Balboa City Schools and to seek reimbursement and funding for the placement because a FAPE had not been offered.
The IEP team met one more time on February 22, 2005, to review STUDENT’s placement. The District repeated, with some modifications, its offer of FAPE as placement in the non-severely handicapped SDC at Murray Manor five days per week for all academic classes; mainstreaming during lunch, recess, and special events; two thirty-minute speech and language therapy sessions per week; finishing the approved number of vision therapy sessions; a post-vision therapy evaluation by Dr. Smith; one thirty-minute OT session per week and self-regulatory strategies; a totable FM system; a typing program; four days per week of Dichotic Interaural Intensity Differential Training in twenty-minute sessions for six weeks; a behavior support plan; the support of a behavior specialist; and transportation to and from Murray Manor. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT a four-hour per day, twenty-day ESY program. The District noted that the methodologies used in the Murray Manor SDC varied in accordance with the students’ needs, that instruction was provided largely in a small-group setting, that the disability categories in the classroom varied, and that the class size was approximately thirteen students at the time. STUDENT’s parents expressed concerns based on their observations at Murray Manor and requested information about the reading and math stages of the students currently enrolled in the proposed SDC. His parents reiterated their belief that the District’s offer was not an offer of FAPE for STUDENT.
By memorandum dated February 23, 2005, District program specialist Heather Difede provided STUDENT’s parents with a detailed description of the proposed SDC at Murray Manor, including information to answer specific questions that had been posed by his parents about the program. Ms. Difede enclosed with her memorandum handouts from the SDC teacher about her class.
In response, STUDENT’s parents sent Ms. Goodwin a letter dated March 4, 2005. STUDENT’s parents indicated that the District had offered STUDENT the same placement rejected earlier and that, for the same reasons, they were again rejecting the District’s offer. STUDENT’s parents stated that they would be unilaterally placing STUDENT at a nonpublic school and seeking reimbursement for the placement. STUDENT’s parents subsequently removed him from Rolando and unilaterally placed him at Balboa City Schools beginning March 28, 2005. The District filed its request for the instant due process hearing on April 26, 2005.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year? Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. (Footnote 1)( 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (Footnote 2) 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The IEP, which is “the centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305, 108 S.Ct. 592, 598 (1988); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345. Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the child’s educational placement. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of FAPE, but procedural violations that result in loss of educational opportunity to the child or seriously infringe on the parent=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a child has been provided a FAPE in the LRE generally requires a two-part inquiry. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. First, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. Id.; Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884, 891 (9th Cir. 1995). Second, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the IEP developed through the IDEA’s procedures was substantively appropriate. Id. A public educational agency has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA, including that it offered or provided an appropriate educational placement for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir. 1996) (citing Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994)).
The District asserts that it complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA in making its offer for STUDENT and that it offered him a FAPE in the LRE through the IEPs that culminated in the IEP dated February 22, 2005. Specifically, the District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the period February 22, 2005, to the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year by offering him placement in the special day class taught by Michelle Kmak at Murray Manor Elementary School with participation in the general education program during lunch, recess, and special events, and the related services of speech and language therapy, vision therapy, occupational therapy, assistive technology, behavior specialist support, and transportation.
The Student argues that the District failed to offer him a FAPE in the LRE because it violated the procedural safeguards of the IDEA, and failed to offer him an appropriate program designed to address his unique needs that was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit in the LRE. Specifically, the Student asserts that the District violated the procedural safeguards by failing to make sufficiently clear its offer of related services, the proposed extent of opportunities for inclusion in the general education program, and proposed behavioral support, including a behavior support plan. According to the Student, the District’s failure to make a sufficiently detailed offer made it impossible for his parents to understand and seriously consider the District’s offer. Substantively, the Student argues that the SDC at Murray Manor was not designed to address his unique needs in terms of his ability level or his need for instruction in a very structured and small setting. Additionally, the Student asserts that the District failed to propose adequate goals and objectives and services to address his emotional, behavioral, and attentional needs. The Student argues that the District should have completed assessments in the areas of behavior and emotion prior to making its offer. Further, the Student contends that the proposed speech and language and OT goals were incomplete. Finally, the Student asserts that, with regard to the LRE, the District’s proposed opportunities for mainstreaming were unclear and/or inadequate.
Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA=s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3). As the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals noted in Union, the IDEA explicitly requires a school district to provide written prior notice to parents when it proposes to change the educational placement of a child with a disability. 15 F.3d at 1526; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). The Court stated, “We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” 15 F.3d at 1526. The Court held that the requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record “that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Id. The Court also held that a formal, specific offer greatly assists parents in presenting their complaints by alerting them of the need to consider seriously the appropriateness of the proposed placement and to decide whether to accept or reject the offer. Id. Finally, the Court found that, by making a formal offer, the school district would be more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to a hearing officer of the appropriateness of its proposed placement. Id.
The Student asserts that the District improperly failed to describe the proposed behavioral support services, failed to indicate the frequency, duration, and location of the proposed related services, and failed to indicate the amount of proposed inclusion in the general education program. The Student contends that the District’s failures in this regard rendered it impossible for his parents to understand and seriously consider the District’s offer. The District responds that its written offer was clear and met the procedural requirements of the IDEA.
With regard to behavioral support services, the Student claims that the District failed to provide a clear written offer regarding a behavior support plan (BSP) and behavior specialist services. The Student argues that he has a history of serious behavioral issues and that, as recently as the annual IEP held on June 18, 2004, the IEP team determined that his behaviors were impeding his learning and/or the learning of others. The Student further contends that, while the District indicated in the February 22 IEP that its offer included a BSP and behavior specialist support, the District did not present a specific BSP to his parents for their consideration and did not indicate the frequency, duration, or location of the proposed specialist support. The Hearing Officer agrees.
The IDEA requires that appropriate strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports, be considered in cases where the child’s behavior is impeding his learning or that of others. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1). If, in considering the child’s behavior, the IEP team determines that the child needs a particular device or service (including an intervention, accommodation, or other program modification), to receive FAPE, the IEP team must include a statement to that effect in the child’s IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(c). Additionally, the IDEA requires school districts to indicate in the IEP the anticipated frequency, location, and duration of services and modifications. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(6); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(6). “The amount of services to be provided must be stated in the IEP, so that the level of the agency’s commitment of resources will be clear to parents and other IEP team members.” 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12479 (1999). The amount of time to be committed to each of the services in the IEP must be stated in a manner that is clear to all involved in both the development and implementation of the IEP. Id.
In the annual IEP dated June 18, 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team agreed that STUDENT’s behavior was impeding his learning and/or the learning of others. In the February 22, 2005 IEP addendum, the District specifically included as part of its offer a BSP and behavior specialist services, but there was no BSP attached to the February IEP and no indication of the frequency, duration, or location of the proposed behavior specialist services. District school psychologist Michael Laddon testified that he recalled STUDENT’s parents asking at the IEP meeting held on September 14, 2004, why a BSP had not yet been developed. He testified that he replied at the meeting that there was a BSP in existence at the time, namely, a BSP he had developed during STUDENT’s kindergarten year and a BIP developed by Dan Petro in December 2002. Mr. Laddon further testified that he anticipated that the IEP team would revise the existing BSP once it had determined what placement STUDENT would attend. According to Mr. Laddon, following the September IEP meeting, he reviewed data collected the year before with regard to STUDENT’s ability to remain on task and need for redirection; observed STUDENT in the RSP room, general education classroom, and speech room; and interviewed STUDENT’s classroom teacher and RSP teacher about the incentive plans they were using to address STUDENT’s behavior. Mr. Laddon testified that he found that the main behavioral issue impeding STUDENT’s learning was his attention to academic tasks, that STUDENT was attending for only very short periods of time and then his attention appeared to wander. Mr. Laddon found that STUDENT became inattentive to academic tasks approximately five to ten times every fifteen minutes.
Mr. Laddon testified that he had a meeting with STUDENT’s RSP teacher and classroom teacher approximately two weeks before the IEP meeting held on January 20, 2005, during which he developed a written BSP with the teachers’ assistance. Mr. Laddon described the plan as an incentive-based system that increased the frequency by which STUDENT would receive incentives. Mr. Laddon then brought his written BSP to the January 20 meeting but did not present it to the IEP team. According to Mr. Laddon, the IEP team determined that STUDENT had been doing fairly well with the behavior modification systems being provided at the time by the classroom teacher and RSP teacher, and STUDENT’s parents indicated that they wanted to table the discussion of the BSP and instead monitor the strategies already in place. Mr. Laddon also testified that any BSP would have needed to be tailored to the placement eventually decided upon by the IEP team. Mr. Laddon then attended the February 22 IEP meeting, but still did not share his written BSP with the IEP team. There is no dispute that STUDENT’s parents were never provided a copy of the BSP developed by Mr. Laddon in January 2005.
As for the behavior specialist support offered, there was no indication in the February 22 IEP as to the frequency, duration, or location of the proposed support. Further, despite the District’s argument that the February 22 IEP should be considered in light of the prior IEPs that culminated in its development, the Hearing Officer notes that none of the prior IEPs, from the annual IEP dated June 18, 2004, to the January 20, 2005 IEP addendum, even included behavior specialist support as part of the District’s offer of FAPE. Further, while a letter from District special education director Barbara Goodwin dated October 7, 2004, mentions behavior support, she did not provide the frequency, duration, or location of the proposed support. She stated in her letter only that the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year included a BSP developed by a District psychologist (with no attached BSP) and that the District continued to offer the support of behavior consultant Dan Petro (with no indication of frequency, duration, or location) to assist the educational staff and STUDENT’s parents with positive behavioral interventions, but that his parents had declined all services provided by Mr. Petro. As stated previously, the IDEA requires school districts to indicate in the IEP the anticipated frequency, location, and duration of services and modifications so that the level of the agency’s commitment of resources will be clear to the parents and other IEP team members. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(6); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(6); 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12479 (1999). The District did not make clear its level of commitment in this regard.
The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District failed to present STUDENT’s parents with a proposed BSP and the frequency, duration, and location of behavior specialist support for their consideration, and that this failure violated the requirements of Union and seriously infringed on STUDENT’s parents’ opportunity to participate meaningfully in the IEP process. The IEP team had determined that STUDENT was a child whose behaviors were impeding his learning and/or the learning of others. The accuracy of this determination was supported by the testimony of STUDENT’s general education teacher, Laura Cress. Ms. Cress testified that STUDENT was in her classroom during only 50 percent of a school day and that, during that time, STUDENT was disorganized and frequently off task, required constant redirection and prompting, and that he struggled in all academic areas. The existence of these behaviors were confirmed through Mr. Laddon’s observations of STUDENT during the 2004-2005 school year, as described above. Further, STUDENT received four behavioral referrals from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to February 22, 2005. On September 20, 2004, STUDENT received a behavioral referral for slapping another child on the back of the head as he walked by the child. In December 2004, STUDENT punched a child and slapped a second child and, on another day, hit and spit on four students. On January 25, 2005, STUDENT threw a book while in the library and then spit on three students. Finally, according to the September 14, 2004 IEP addendum, STUDENT’s behavior was one of the reasons the District was recommending that he be moved to the more restrictive setting of an SDC. Consequently, the evidence showed that STUDENT’s behaviors were a significant barrier to his receiving educational benefit from his program and that it was important that his behaviors be addressed. In failing to provide STUDENT’s parents with adequate information as to how the District was proposing to address STUDENT’s behavior, his parents were left without sufficient information to seriously consider the District’s offer of FAPE.
The Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the District’s argument that a BSP existed at the time through either Mr. Petro’s BIP or Mr. Laddon’s BSP. The District failed to indicate to STUDENT’s parents what particular BSP it was offering. In any case, Mr. Petro’s BIP had been created more than two years earlier in December 2002 and Mr. Laddon’s BSP was never provided to STUDENT’s parents. The Hearing Officer also finds unpersuasive the District’s argument that a BSP could not be developed until the IEP team had determined a placement for STUDENT. The District had determined on a placement recommendation for STUDENT by February 22, 2005, namely Michelle Kmak’s SDC at Murray Manor. To make the recommendation to STUDENT’s parents, the District needed to include in its offer all the necessary components of a FAPE for STUDENT in that placement. Mr. Laddon credibly testified that STUDENT required a BSP in the proposed placement or, at the very least, consultation with the teacher to determine what behavior modifications would be needed. Mr. Laddon also testified that he had developed a new BSP for STUDENT by January 2005 but that the BSP had not been shared with STUDENT’s parents. According to Mr. Laddon, in a case like STUDENT’s, a BSP should be proposed before the child starts a new placement, with the knowledge that the plan will have to be revised once the child’s behaviors in that environment are known.
Finally, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District failed to indicate in its offer the amount of time to be spent in the general education program. A school district must include in the IEP the amount of time the disabled child will participate in the regular education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). Here, the February 22, 2005 IEP did not include a specific amount of time that STUDENT would be included in the regular education program. The IEP indicated only that the District was proposing to place STUDENT in the SDC “for academic classes” and to mainstream STUDENT during lunch, recess, and special events. There was no indication of whether there were any non-academic classes that STUDENT would attend in the general education program. Further, there was no description of the amount of time that lunch, recess, and “special events” (particularly special events) entailed. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents were not provided sufficient information about the amount of time the District was proposing for inclusion in the general education program.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE from February 22, 2005, to the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year. Additionally, there is no dispute that the program provided by the District during that time did not provide him a FAPE. While the District agreed at the June 18, 2004, IEP meeting to continue STUDENT’s placement in the RSP and general education program at Rolando for the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year, the agreement was made only because his parents needed to visit the SDCs under discussion by the IEP team at the time and had not agreed to change STUDENT’s placement to an SDC. The following was noted in the annual IEP dated June 18, 2004: “District continues to feel strongly that STUDENT’s needs can best be met in an SDC and would not agree to a full year of RSP placement.” Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for the period of February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year.
ISSUE NO. 2: If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the expenses they incurred to place him at Balboa City Schools, a certified nonpublic school?
When a school district denies a child a FAPE, the child is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement chosen by the parents are found to have been the exact proper placement required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the parents’ placement still must have met certain basic requirements of the IDEA, such as the requirement that the placement or services address the child’s needs and provide him educational benefit. Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993).
The Student requests reimbursement for expenses, in the form of tuition and transportation, related to his parents’ unilateral placement of him at Balboa City Schools (BCS), a certified nonpublic school. MOTHER testified that STUDENT began attending BCS on March 28, 2005. The District argues that reimbursement is not warranted because it offered STUDENT a FAPE from February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 school year and because BCS was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The District asserts that the instruction STUDENT received at BCS was not individualized to address his needs, was not provided by credentialed teachers qualified to individualize the curriculum to address his needs or shape his behavior, provided him only minimal special education services, and did not provide him any opportunities to be included with nondisabled peers.
The Hearing Officer determined above that the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT a FAPE from February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year. Thus, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the BCS placement if the placement met certain basic requirements of the IDEA. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence establishes that the BCS placement was appropriate enough to justify reimbursement in this case.
First, the Hearing Officer notes that the Diagnostic Center recommended direct instruction in a one-to-one or small group setting for STUDENT for assignments that are not at his independent success level and for new instruction. The testimony of BCS special education director Carolyn Chamberlin and BCS school counselor Whitney Ross established that the BCS placement provided STUDENT instruction in a small group setting. (Footnote 3) Ms. Chamberlin credibly testified that thirty-six students are currently enrolled at BCS and that STUDENT’s classes consist of four to six students each. The students in STUDENT’s classes are third graders, except for one student who is a fourth grader and another who is a second grader reading at the third-grade level. According to Ms. Chamberlin, STUDENT’s teacher for handwriting and language, Katelyn Hassler, has a multiple subject teaching credential and learning handicapped teaching credential. STUDENT’s social studies and sports lab teacher, Yvonne Jamarillo, also has a special education teaching credential. STUDENT’s mathematics and reading teacher, Kim Worobey, has a bachelor’s degree and no teaching credential, but has worked with special education children for the past six years and is presently working towards obtaining her credential. Further, Ms. Chamberlin provided STUDENT fifteen to twenty minutes of one-to-one instruction to address reading comprehension, his area of greatest academic weakness, two times per week. Moreover, Ms. Chamberlin testified that the curriculum was provided in accordance with State standards but was “greatly” modified for STUDENT. For example, because STUDENT was not able to read the social studies textbook used by his class, the material was presented to him in a different way and the teacher worked on building STUDENT’s vocabulary.
Additionally, Ms. Chamberlin and Ms. Ross testified that BCS staff worked on behaviors that were impeding STUDENT’s learning and the learning of others, including a lack of engagement to task, touching other students, leaving his seat and the classroom at inappropriate times, and behaviors that were gross or a turn off to other students such as picking his nose and rubbing it on others and spitting on children. Ms. Ross testified that she met with STUDENT’s father and teachers to discuss interventions to address his behaviors, particularly to address his leaving the classroom and inability to remain on task. BCS used an incentives-based system in which STUDENT was awarded “store points” (which allowed him to buy things from the school store) for appropriate behaviors such as remaining on task, staying in class, and interacting positively with his peers. Ms. Ross testified that she was involved with STUDENT approximately five to ten times per day when he first came to BCS to address his behaviors. She provided counseling and prompting to STUDENT, consulted with his teachers, and monitored his behaviors and peer interactions. STUDENT was also provided breaks and “calming events,” such as time outside the classroom in a rocking chair, to calm him and bring him back to task.
With regard to social skills, Ms. Ross testified that STUDENT did not know how to connect with his peers appropriately and would engage in behaviors that annoyed others to initiate interactions with them. Ms. Ross worked with STUDENT using social stories and scripts, and prompts and redirection. Staff also rewarded STUDENT for appropriate peer interactions with praise and store points.
Ms. Chamberlin and Ms. Ross persuasively testified that they saw progress in STUDENT after only a couple months at BCS. Ms. Chamberlin testified that STUDENT’s ability to stay in the classroom improved significantly, that he was leaving class only once per day rather than once every forty-five minutes, as had been the case when he first started attending BCS. Ms. Chamberlin testified that STUDENT’s ability to stay on task also improved, although he continued to need work in this area since he remained highly dependent on external cues and reminders. Ms. Ross testified that he made tremendous progress in his ability to remain on task and that, by early June 2005, he was able to consistently remain in the classroom and on task with teacher prompting and breaks. Additionally, Ms. Ross testified that STUDENT formed some friendships with other children and played with them during unstructured time. Ms. Ross further testified that STUDENT’s level of frustration and anxiety decreased.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the BCS placement met STUDENT’s needs in many significant respects. BCS provided STUDENT direct instruction in small group and one-to-one settings to address his academic needs and modified the curriculum to address his needs. BCS also was provided STUDENT positive interventions to address the behavioral needs that impeded his learning and that of others. Further, BCS addressed STUDENT’s social skills needs to an extent. Finally, Ms. Chamberlin and Ms. Ross persuasively testified that STUDENT was receiving educational benefit from the BCS placement. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the expenses they incurred to place STUDENT at BCS from March 28, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year.
The Hearing Officer finds unavailing the District’s arguments to the contrary. The evidence at hearing established that the program at BCS was sufficiently individualized to address STUDENT’s needs, was provided by teachers with special education credentials or significant experience with special education students, and addressed STUDENT’s behavioral needs. As for the District’s argument that reimbursement is not warranted because BCS did not provide any opportunities for interaction with nondisabled peers and thus was not the least restrictive environment for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer notes that in Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss, 144 F.3d 391, 399 n.7 (6th Cir. 1998), the Sixth Circuit found that, when a school district denies a student a FAPE, the parents’ right to reimbursement for a unilateral private placement should not be barred because of any failure to meet the mainstreaming requirement imposed on public agencies. The Sixth Circuit noted, “It will commonly be the case that parents who have not been treated properly under the IDEA, and who exercise the right of parental placement, will place their child in a school that specializes in teaching children with disabilities and thus will not satisfy the mainstreaming requirement. Adopting such a limitation on parental placements would therefore effectively vitiate that remedy.” Cleveland Heights, 144 F.3d at 399 n.7; accord Warren G. v. Cumberland County Sch. Dist., 190 F.3d 80, 84 (3d Cir. 1999).
MOTHER testified that they were charged $1,081.50 per month for tuition at BCS, with the first payment to BCS made on March 28, 2005, STUDENT’s first day at BCS. A written invoice from BCS confirmed that STUDENT’s parents were charged $1,081.50 per month in tuition. With regard to transportation, MOTHER testified she drove STUDENT to BCS in the mornings and that his father picked him up from BCS in the afternoons. According to MOTHER, BCS is located approximately twelve to fourteen miles from their home. MOTHER had to drive a round trip to BCS every morning to get STUDENT to school. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement from the District for BCS tuition in the amount of $1,081.50 per month for the period March 28, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year. STUDENT’s parents are also entitled to reimbursement for transportation expenses incurred for the same period in the form of mileage reimbursement at the District rate. The transportation reimbursement is to be calculated using the mileage from the family home to BCS for a round-trip every morning and for a one-way trip every afternoon for those days STUDENT attended school.
ISSUE NO. 3: If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at Balboa City Schools for the 2005 extended school year (ESY) and 2005-2006 school year?
Based on the principle set forth in Burlington that a child with a disability is entitled to “appropriate” relief when a school district fails to provide a FAPE, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not, however, necessarily involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. Id. at 1497. The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id.
The Student contends that he should be awarded prospective placement at BCS for the 2005 extended school year and 2005-2006 school year for the District’s failure to offer him a FAPE. The District argues that there is no basis upon which to award prospective placement for either the 2005 ESY or 2005-2006 school year because neither time periods were at issue in this case. The District asserted on the first day of hearing that it had not yet made a specific offer for the 2005 ESY.
By the time the record closed for any further testimony, the 2005 ESY had not yet begun. However, on the first day of hearing, the Student’s attorney indicated that BCS offered a summer session starting in June 2005 and his parents wanted placement in the BCS summer session. The Hearing Officer notes that, while STUDENT’s parents have been awarded reimbursement for the BCS placement from March 28, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year, STUDENT has not been provided any remedy for the denial of FAPE that occurred from February 22, 2005, through March 27, 2005. For this approximately one-month FAPE denial, the Hearing Officer finds that it is appropriate to award STUDENT placement at BCS for its 2005 summer session.
The Hearing Officer finds no basis to award prospective placement at BCS for the 2005-2006 school year. As clarified on the first day of hearing, the FAPE issue in this case involved only the 2004-2005 regular school year. Since the District requested this hearing, the District was the party entitled to frame the issues for hearing. The District stated on the first day of hearing that it was putting at issue only the period from February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year. Thus, there is no basis upon which to award prospective placement at BCS for the 2005-2006 school year because the 2005-2006 school year was not at issue in these proceedings and there is no other basis upon which to award prospective placement.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to placement at BCS during its 2005 summer session as a remedy for the District’s FAPE denial from February 22, 2005, through March 27, 2005. Since the 2005 ESY session at BCS has likely ended, such a remedy will take the form of reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents for the tuition and transportation expenses they incurred for STUDENT’s placement at BCS for the 2005 ESY, if they in fact placed him at BCS for the summer at their expense. The Hearing Officer finds no basis to award prospective placement at BCS for the 2005-2006 school year and therefore denies the Student’s request for such placement.
ORDER
1. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof from STUDENT’s parents, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the tuition they actually paid for his placement at Balboa City Schools for the period March 28, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year and during the 2005 extended school year.
2. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof from STUDENT’s parents, the District shall reimburse his parents for the expenses they incurred to transport STUDENT to and from BCS on the days he attended school from March 28, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year and during the 2005 extended school year. Reimbursement for transportation will be provided at the District rate established for mileage reimbursement, and is to be calculated using the mileage from the family home to BCS for a round-trip every morning and for a one-way trip every afternoon for those days STUDENT attended school.
3. The parties’ remaining requests for relief are denied in their entirety.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from February 22, 2005, through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year? *** The Student prevailed on this issue.
2. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the expenses they incurred to place him at Balboa City Schools, a certified nonpublic school? *** The Student prevailed on this issue.
3. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at Balboa City Schools for the 2005 extended school year (ESY) and 2005-2006 school year? *** The Student prevailed on this issue with respect to placement for the 2006 ESY, and the District prevailed on this issue with respect to the 2005-2006 school year.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety calendar days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: August 19, 2005 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1 Because the dispute in this matter arose prior to the July 1, 2005 effective date of the newly reauthorized IDEA, the Hearing Officer applies the law that was in effect at that time.
2 “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related service” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).
3 Ms. Chamberlin is the special education director for BCS and is a special education teacher for a couple of classes at BCS each school day. She has an associate degree in early childhood development, a bachelor’s degree in interdisciplinary studies, a master’s degree in special education, and holds regular education and special education teaching credentials. She has been working at BCS since 1992 and formerly taught for National City School District and worked as a reading consultant for Cajon Valley School District. Ms. Ross has a bachelor’s degree and a master’s degree in clinical counseling from Harvard University. She worked as a school counselor in New York and provided consultation to two private schools in New York. She has worked at BCS for one year.
