California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 9, 2001
Student v. Long Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1047-99 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Long Beach Unified prevails as Hearing Officer denies parents' request for an intensive Lindamood-Bell clinic program for a fifth grader.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student's family filed for due process in June 1999 and put the case back on the hearing calendar in September 2000. The student was a fifth grader eligible for special education under specific learning disability and had a severe language disorder. He had attended Long Beach Unified's special day classes and its Madison Elementary reading clinic, which used Lindamood-Bell methods. His parents wanted 20 hours per week of one-on-one instruction at the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center in Newport Beach.
Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke found two procedural violations. No school psychologist attended a May 1997 IEP meeting. The notices for the October 2000 and January 2001 meetings also did not say that the district's dispute resolution consultant, Stanley Perlo, would attend. Neither violation caused lost learning or limited the parents' participation. From January through June 2000, the district's program gave him more than minimal benefit. That program combined a special day class, resource specialist help, speech therapy, occupational therapy, after-school Lindamood-Bell instruction and Madison reading clinic cycles. The October 2000 offer was not a FAPE because it placed him in an Emerson Elementary special day class without speech or resource services. Since September 2000, however, he had been receiving the services the district later offered in January 2001, so the Hearing Officer found no harm. The January 2001 offer was appropriate: a Madison literacy class with resource and related services. In that class, he passed mid-third-grade reading benchmarks. The clinic request was not reached, and all relief was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard to a request for an intensive private clinic program. It also shows how the Hearing Officer treated a deficient IEP offer as harmless because the student was already receiving appropriate services. Defective meeting notices were likewise not a denial of FAPE without proof of harm.
Issues and holdings
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 1A. Did the District provide Petitioner a FAPE from January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year? Procedural appropriateness: absence of the assessing school psychologist from the May 30, 1997 triennial IEP meeting, and failure to give notice that the District's alternative dispute resolution coordinator would attend the October 17, 2000 and January 3, 2001 IEP meetings
Both the psychologist's absence in 1997 and the defective meeting notices were violations, but neither caused lost educational opportunity, made the meetings adversarial, or impaired parent participation.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B(1). Substantive appropriateness, January 4, 2000 through April 2000 (January 4 and January 20, 2000 IEPs)
The mild-to-moderate special day class with RSP, speech, OT, inclusion support and three hours weekly of after-school Lindamood-Bell instruction met his needs and gave more than minimal benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B(2). Substantive appropriateness, April 4, 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including extended school year (April 4, 2000 IEP)
One more month in the special day class, a third Madison reading clinic cycle and the summer clinic met his needs; minimal summer progress, with absences and no regression, did not deny benefit.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEFAPE: services offered
Issue 2A. Did the District offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year? September 2000 to January 2, 2001 (October 17, 2000 IEP offer)
The offer of an Emerson special day class without speech or RSP services was not a FAPE, but the error was non-prejudicial because he was actually receiving the services later found appropriate.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2B. January 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year (January 3, 2001 triennial IEP)
The Madison literacy class with RSP, speech, OT and inclusion support met his needs and produced real progress; an intensive one-on-one clinic program was not required.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Does Petitioner currently require an educational program that includes an initial 320 hours (20 hours/week for 16 weeks) of an intensive program to develop his language and literacy skills, such as that offered by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, and ongoing treatment as thereafter determined?
Not adjudicated given the rulings on Issues 1 and 2.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief denied. In a footnote, the Hearing Officer strongly recommended, but did not order, an IEP meeting to reevaluate how the student receives his RSP and related services because of his many transitions during the day.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; M.C. v. Central Regional School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16
People named in the decision
- Susan Melly, SELPA administrator, Long Beach Unified School District
- Stanley Perlo, District consultant and alternative dispute resolution coordinator, Long Beach Unified School District
- Margaret Towner, Madison reading clinic teacher, Long Beach Unified School District
- Angelica Dirtadian, Former director, Lindamood-Bell Newport Beach center; private provider, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center
- Kim Tooley, Administrator, private provider, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center (Newport Beach), Private clinic / provider
- M. Cardenas, Witness cited regarding Lindamood-Bell clinic attendance, Not stated
- Carol Dygean, School psychologist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Carol Ann Taylor, Special education program facilitator, Long Beach Unified School District
- Anne (Ann) Logue, Third grade special day class teacher, Cubberley Elementary; speech and language assessor; administrative designee at 1997 IEP, Long Beach Unified School District
- Gail Stoter, Speech and language specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Briana Graham-Ramos, Special education team leader, Long Beach Unified School District
- Pilar Centeno, Teacher, witness for Student, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Donald Speir, Resource specialist program teacher, Madison, Long Beach Unified School District
- Sherry Geller-Vogeli, Speech and language specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Nancy Littlefield, Resource specialist program teacher, Cubberley, Long Beach Unified School District
- Rachel Zgainer, General education fourth/fifth grade literacy teacher, Madison, Long Beach Unified School District
- Heather Porrino, School psychologist (2001 triennial assessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Christopher Russell, Advocate for parents at IEP meeting, Not stated
- Marlene Daniels, Program specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Barbara Harkleroad, School psychologist (1997 assessment), Long Beach Unified School District
- Clarise Penaranda, Teacher at May 1997 IEP, Long Beach Unified School District
- Mr. Carungcong, Mild-to-moderate special day class teacher, Cubberley, Long Beach Unified School District
- Tanya Sanderson, Speech and language specialist / RSP teacher providing Lindamood-Bell instruction, Long Beach Unified School District
- Bobbe Miles, Third grade general education teacher, Cubberley, Long Beach Unified School District
- Susan Weisenberger, Inclusion specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
- Mr. Hedges, Principal, Madison Elementary, Long Beach Unified School District
- Nancy Stansfield, Special day class teacher and speech-language pathologist, Emerson Elementary, Long Beach Unified School District
- Lerlene Lyles, Reading specialist, Madison, Long Beach Unified School District
- Trudy Cares, Reading specialist, Madison, Long Beach Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Long Beach, California on January 16 and 17, 2001, February 22 and 23, 2001, March 8 and 9, 2001 and April 24 and 25, 2001.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Bruce E. Bothwell and his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Jeffrey J. Riel. Also present on behalf of the District during different portions of the hearing were Susan Melly, Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA) administrator, and Stanley Perlo, administrator for the District.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Margaret Towner, teacher with the District, Angelica Dirtadian, director of development for Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center (LMB), Carol Dygean, school psychologist for the District, Carol Ann Taylor, program facilitator for the District, Anne Logue, STUDENT’s third grade special day class teacher at Cubberley Elementary School, Gail Stoter, speech and language specialist for the District, Briana Graham-Ramos, special education team leader for the District, MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, Stanley Perlo, District administrator, Pilar Centeno, teacher from the Los Angeles Unified School District, and Kim Tooley, administrator for Lindamood Bell Processes Center.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Donald Speir, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher for the District, Sherry Geller-Vogeli, speech and language specialist for the District, Nancy Littlefield, RSP teacher for the District, Rachel Zgainer, STUDENT’s current teacher, and Heather Porrino, school psychologist for the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Closing arguments were received from both parties and the record closed.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
1. Motion for Nonsuit
After Petitioner closed his case in chief, Respondent made a motion for nonsuit pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure § 581(c). Respondent argued that Petitioner had failed to present sufficient evidence that he was denied a FAPE and that the requested prospective placement is warranted. Respondent contended that the majority of Petitioner’s evidence dealt with years prior to January 4, 2000, the date from which Petitioner alleges he was denied FAPE. Respondent also argued that Education Code § 56505.2 restricts the Hearing Officer from ordering placement of a student in a location not properly certified by the State of California.
Petitioner responded that the District has the burden of proving that it provided Petitioner with a FAPE, and to that end, either party’s contention regarding whether Petitioner made progress is a factual dispute to be decided by the Hearing Officer. Regarding the requested prospective placement, Petitioner argued that if the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner was denied a FAPE, yet disagrees with the relief sought, the Hearing Officer can order whatever relief she deems appropriate.
Petitioner’s alleged failure to provide sufficient evidence that he was denied FAPE or that a prospective placement is warranted is not the appropriate basis for granting the motion. Moreover, the Hearing Officer has the authority to call additional witnesses to obtain additional evidence in this matter if she feels that the parties have not provided sufficient information necessary to render a decision. Therefore, the Hearing Officer denied Respondent’s motion on the basis that the District has the burden of proving it provided Petitioner with a FAPE.
2. Motion to Exclude Supplemental Evidence
After the record was closed, the Hearing Office received the parties' written closing briefs. Attached to Petitioner's brief was an exhibit containing documentary evidence. The exhibit had not been introduced into evidence at the hearing. Respondent made a motion to strike Petitioner’s supplemental evidence and portions of Petitioner’s closing brief relating to the supplemental evidence. The Hearing Officer notes that the parties' closing briefs are not evidence to be considered by the Hearing Officer. In any case, the record had already been closed for the submission of additional evidence. For these reasons, the only evidence that will be considered is that which was introduced by the parties at the hearing. Those portions of Petitioner's closing brief that contain facts or other evidence not introduced into the record during the hearing will not be considered by the Hearing Officer in rendering a decision in this matter.
ISSUES
1. Did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year?
2. Did the District offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
3. Does Petitioner currently require an educational program that includes the provision of an initial three hundred twenty (320) hours (20 hours/per week for 16 weeks) of an intensive program to develop his language and literacy skills, such as that offered by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, and ongoing treatment as thereafter determined?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE from January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999/2000 school year and for the 2000-2001 school year based on the District’s violation of several procedural and substantive provisions of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). Procedurally, Petitioner argues that the District failed to have present at the May 1997 triennial IEP meeting the District psychologist that had evaluated STUDENT, which in turn, contributed to the District’s inability to appreciate the complexity of STUDENT’s issues and to its inability to formulate an appropriate IEP. Petitioner also argues that Stanley Perlo’s attendance at the October 17, 2000, and January 3, 2001 IEP meetings, without giving prior notice of the fact to the parents, caused the IEP meetings to be conducted in an inherently adversarial manner and compromised STUDENT’s confidentiality rights.(Footnote 1)
Substantively, Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s placements and services for the time frames noted above were not appropriate and the District’s recommendations were not based on staff evaluations. These alleged procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA, Petitioner contends, denied him a FAPE and thus entitle him to prospective placement in an intensive multi-sensory program with the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center clinic for twenty hours per week, four hours per day, for a period up to twenty-four weeks.
Respondent contends that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE from January 4, 2000, until the end of the 1999-2000 school year, and offered and provided him with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. Specifically, Respondent argues that it did not commit procedural violations that denied Petitioner educational benefit because it properly reassessed Petitioner within the appropriate time frames. Respondent also argues that there was no evidence that Stanley Perlo’s attendance at two IEP meetings created an adversarial environment.
Regarding alleged substantive violations of the IDEA, Respondent contends that the District is not required to guarantee improvement. According to the District, it’s program and services were designed to meet Petitioner’s unique needs, were designed to provide, and did provide, Petitioner educational benefit, conformed to Petitioner’s IEP, and were provided in the least restrictive environment. Respondent argues that because the District’s placements and services were appropriate, Petitioner’s claims should be denied.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is ten years and eight months old, and in the fifth grade. He currently qualifies for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. STUDENT is enrolled in Madison Elementary School (Madison), where he attends a fourth-fifth grade regular education literacy class.
STUDENT was originally assessed by the Long Beach Unified School District (District) in 1993. The District speech and language specialist concluded at that time that STUDENT had a seven-month delay in his overall receptive and expressive language skills and his connected speech was mostly unintelligible, thus qualifying him for special education services as a student with a speech disorder in the area of articulation. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, had become concerned about STUDENT’s development when STUDENT was about 3 ½ years old. She felt that STUDENT, in comparison to his preschool classmates, had difficulty with understanding and expressing language. According to MOTHER, STUDENT’s speech was unintelligible and he had difficulty responding to questions. STUDENT’s initial individualized education program (IEP) was developed by the District’s IEP team in November 1993, placing STUDENT at Monroe Elementary School with designated instruction and services (DIS) that included weekly speech and language services.
STUDENT’s second IEP meeting was held on April 19, 1994. The IEP team placed STUDENT in a severe language disorder/aphasia (SLD/A) special day class with extended school year and door-to-door transportation. The IEP team certified STUDENT as a student with a specific learning disability; however, STUDENT was found eligible for special education based on a language disorder in the areas of morphology, syntax, semantics, and pragmatics which significantly interferes with communication. (Respondent’s Exh. 4, pgs. 1 & 8.) STUDENT’s IEP was amended by the IEP team in October 1994, with the addition of occupational therapy (OT) services to address STUDENT’s motor activities in the classroom in the areas of performance skills and endurance.
At STUDENT’s annual IEP in April 1995, the IEP team agreed to continue STUDENT’s program and placement in the SLD/A special day class, with door-to-door transportation, occupational therapy services, and extended school year.
In April 1996, the IEP team continued STUDENT’s program and placement in the SLD/A special day class. However, the IEP team qualified STUDENT for special education based on a language disorder and now also a speech disorder in the area of articulation. The IEP team did not identify him as a student with a specific learning disability.
In March 1997, STUDENT’s first grade year, a psychoeducational assessment was performed on STUDENT in order to reevaluate STUDENT’s needs and educational placement. (Resp.’s Exh. 9.) The assessor found that a severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in the basic skill of mathematics, apparently related to a deficit in psychological processes of auditory processing, short-term visual memory, and visual motor integration. According to the assessor, STUDENT continued to meet the federal and State criteria as a student eligible for special education services. In May 1997, the IEP team again found that STUDENT had a specific learning disability and continued his program and placement in the SLD/Aphasia class for all subjects, except for science, which he received in the regular education second grade class.
In April 1998, STUDENT’s second grade year, the IEP team found STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education services as a child with a language disorder. The IEP team noted on the IEP document dated April 30, 1998, that STUDENT had been mainstreamed into regular education second grade science on a trial basis during the fall 1997, but had experienced difficulty with comprehension of lessons and with the pacing of lessons. (Resp.’s Exh. 17.) The IEP team agreed, however, to continue STUDENT’s program and placement in the SLD/Aphasia special day class for all subjects, except for science. STUDENT continued to receive OT services and extended school year.
At STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting in April 1999, the IEP team continued to qualify STUDENT for special education services as a child with a specific learning disability. STUDENT continued in the SLD/A special day class at Cubberley Elementary School (Cubberley), where he continued being mainstreamed for science and social studies. The IEP team also agreed to continue mainstreaming STUDENT for physical education, lunch, recess and assemblies. The April 20, 1999 IEP document notes that summer school was discussed and that the facilitator would research placing STUDENT in the auditory discrimination and depth (ADD) and visualizing and verbalizing (VV) programs as the parent’s first choice. (Resp.’s Exh. 23.)
STUDENT’s mother testified that as of the April 20, 1999 IEP meeting, she was very concerned with STUDENT’s progress in that he was still reading only at the pre-primer level. According to MOTHER, school was very frustrating for STUDENT and he often told her that he did not want to go. As a result of STUDENT’s status, in May 1999, MOTHER wrote to Carol Ann Taylor, the District’s special education program facilitator, to follow up on her request for an immediate psychoeducational assessment for STUDENT. (Resp.’s Exh. 24.) At that same time, MOTHER also requested that a speech and language assessment be done immediately. On June 3, 1999, a re-evaluation assessment plan was drafted and signed by MOTHER. STUDENT was subsequently assessed in the area of academic/preacademic achievement, and speech and language.
On June 4, 1999, the school psychologist conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT “in order to gather information specific to STUDENT’s present levels of achievement and in order to formulate recommendations for interventions to assist STUDENT with acquiring academic skills.” (Resp.’s Exh. 27.) The assessor found that despite his current placement and program, STUDENT was struggling to acquire basic academic procedural skills, including decoding, reading comprehension, math computation, math reasoning, spelling and grammar. The assessor noted that all of STUDENT’s procedural academic skills were within the range of significantly below average as compared to the expected performance of same-grade peers. The assessor felt that several variables contributed to STUDENT’s failure to progress at the average level, including: (1) STUDENT’s weak sequential auditory and sequential visual processing abilities, (2) his severe language disorder, which was particularly apparent by his difficulty with organizing words within memory, and (3) emotionality that appeared to impact his learning.
The results of the June 15, 1999 speech and language assessment revealed that STUDENT demonstrated deficits in various aspects of semantics, including categorizing, determining absurdities, antonyms, definitions and multiple meanings. Deficits were also noted in tasks requiring auditory processing of information. The assessor recommended that STUDENT continue to be enrolled in a small class with emphasis on language development, including semantics development, auditory processing, finding patterns, sequencing, and categorizing. (Resp.’s Exh. 29.)
On June 21, 1999, another IEP team meeting was held at the request of STUDENT’s parents due to their concern that STUDENT was not making enough progress in academics. During the IEP team meeting, STUDENT’s parents requested that STUDENT attend the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center (LMB) in Newport Beach, California, for the program that was recommended by the Clinic -- four hours of one-on-one instruction daily for sixteen weeks. (Resp.’s Exh. 31.) A telephone conference was held during the IEP team meeting with Angelica Dirtadian from the LMB clinic. The District offered to provide STUDENT with the Lindamood-Bell auditory discrimination and depth and visualizing verbalizing (ADD(Footnote 2)/VV) programs for three hours per week on a one-to-one basis with District personnel. The District’s ADD/VV programs were to be in addition to STUDENT’s then-current SLD/A program. STUDENT’s parents refused the District’s offer and during the June 21, 1999 meeting provided the District with written notice that STUDENT would be receiving four weeks or more of LMB services that summer at the LMB Newport Beach clinic and that they would be seeking reimbursement for the program and transportation. (Resp.’s Exhs. 30 & 31.)
On June 29, 1999, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing. The parties subsequently went to mediation and the matter was taken off calendar.
Beginning on July 5, 1999, STUDENT attended the LMB Newport Beach clinic, where he received the LMB visualizing/verbalizing program. (Testimony of M. Cardenas; Resp.’s Exh. 32.) MOTHER testified that after STUDENT spent five weeks at the LMB clinic, she noticed progress in terms of STUDENT being able to visualize and verbalize. For example, she testified that STUDENT’s drawings of body parts were now like a whole -- connected. According to MOTHER, STUDENT previously could not draw body parts as connected. According to the LMB progress report, which listed the results of the June 1999 pretest and August 1999 post-test done by the LMB clinic, sensory-cognitive stimulation was effective for STUDENT in that it allowed him to make beginning improvement in oral language comprehension, following directions, critical thinking, and receptive vocabulary. (Resp.’s Exh. 32.) Due to the severity of STUDENT’s learning difficulties, the LMB assessor recommended a lengthy treatment in order to develop his language processing skills to a level that would allow him to function within a school classroom environment. (Id.) The assessor, however, qualified her recommendation of a one-to-one 16-24 week, 4-hour daily sensory-cognitive treatment with a “guarded” prognosis that STUDENT would attain age-level appropriate performance due to his then-present low-level test scores. (Id.)
STUDENT then attended the LBUSD reading clinic at Madison Elementary School (Madison) for 2 sessions -- once from September 16, 1999, to October 21, 1999, and again from October 29, 1999, to December 17, 1999. (Resp.’s Exhs. 34 and 36.) The sessions at Madison’s reading clinic typically last for 35 days and include receipt of the LMB LiPs, V/V, and Seeing Stars programs. The Madison Reading Clinic is a regular education intervention program that consists of 18 students, 2 teachers and 1 special education aide. The Madison Clinic services both regular and special education students; however, it is not a special education program. (Testimony of Margaret Towner.)
During the October 28, 1999 IEP team meeting, STUDENT’s parent indicated that she was pleased with the program at Madison; however, she reported that STUDENT’s teacher indicated during a conversation with her that she believed the program was “a little fast paced for STUDENT.” (Resp.’s Exh. 35.) Margaret Towner, STUDENT’s teacher during all school-year cycles at the Madison Reading Clinic (Madison), reported that STUDENT exhibited promising growth after the first cycle and recommended that STUDENT repeat a cycle at Madison. (Testimony of Margaret Towner; Resp.’s Exh. 35.) The IEP document notes, however, that STUDENT’s consistency and on-task behavior was not stable and that STUDENT required a lot of monitoring to stay on task. (Resp.’s Exh. 35, pg. 5). Ms. Towner testified that as of the October 28, 1999 IEP meeting, the plan was to work with STUDENT to stabilize his knowledge of words; thus laying the foundation for phonological skills. Comprehension and stability in his growth were two of STUDENT’s biggest issues. STUDENT could process information but he could not retain it. (Testimony of Margaret Towner). Mrs. Towner decided at that time to focus more on the symbol imagery portion of the reading clinic program. The IEP team also agreed to reconvene on January 4, 2000, to review the results of the second cycle of the reading clinic at Madison and determine appropriate placement for STUDENT thereafter.
The IEP team next met on January 4, 2000, to determine STUDENT’s next placement, since he was finishing his second cycle at Madison’s reading clinic. (Testimony of MOTHER). At that time, Carol Dygean’s June 4, 1999 psychoeducational report, Ann Logue’s June 15, 1999 speech and language report, and Angelica Dirtadian’s August 4, 1999 LMB post-test progress report, all made recommendations for meeting STUDENT’s needs.
Carol Dygean recommended a daily, intensive program that strengthens auditory and visual processing skills. (Resp.’s Exh. 27, pg. 4.) Ms. Dygean stated that an example of a daily intensive reading program would be five days a week for at least one hour a day, working on STUDENT’s hearing and visual channels. A reading specialist working one-on-one with STUDENT would be her first choice of providing this intervention, above and beyond what he could receive in the classroom. (Testimony of Carol Dygean.). Ms. Dygean believed that the IEP team should consider the LMB program administered by District personnel at Madison.
Ann Logue recommended that STUDENT remain enrolled in a small class with emphasis on language development, including semantic development, auditory processing, finding patterns, sequencing, and categorizing. (Resp.’s Exh. 29.)
Angelica Dirtadian, former director of the LMB Learning Processes Center in Newport Beach, CA, believed that STUDENT needed sensory-cognitive stimulation, which allowed him to make beginning improvement in oral language comprehension, following directions, critical thinking, and receptive vocabulary. (Resp.’s Exh. 32.)
The District ultimately recommended that STUDENT be placed in a mild to moderate third grade special day classroom (SDC) at Cubberley taught by Mr. Carungcong. (Resp.’s Exh. 38.) Mrs. Towner mentioned during that IEP meeting that it would be good to see how STUDENT was able to apply what he has learned at the Madison clinic by having him return to a special day class. (Testimony of MOTHER.) At the parents’ request, the District also offered STUDENT placement in a regular third grade classroom at Cubberley. (Testimony of MOTHER; Resp.’s Exh. 49.) The District also offered STUDENT support from the inclusion specialist, RSP, and related services, the specifics of which were later identified at the January 20, 2000 IEP meeting. STUDENT returned to the SDC at Cubberley on January 3, 2000, where it was intended that he transition into the regular education classroom depending on his comfort and skill level. According to the January 4, 2000 IEP, STUDENT’s placement in the special day class was to be temporary, until such time as the District identified staff and a schedule of services for STUDENT to transition into the regular third grade classroom. (Id. at pg. 11.) The IEP also stated that the District would identify staff who would provide continuity of STUDENT’s participation in the LiPs and V/V programs.
STUDENT’s parents requested that STUDENT continue with the program he had received at Madison, which included receiving the LiPs, Seeing Stars, and Visualizing/Verbalizing Lindamood-Bell programs. Christopher Russell, an advocate who attended the January 4, 2000 IEP meeting with the parents, wrote into the IEP that the parents would agree, under duress, to place STUDENT in a special day class since there were no “support services and staff available to provide the support for STUDENT in the regular education program.” (Resp.’s Exh. 38, pg. 11.) The parents’ statement also indicated that the parents were willing to be flexible about when and where the Lindamood-Bell program would be provided. The District disagreed that STUDENT’s parents were under duress during the meeting and believed the parents were accepting of STUDENT’s then-current placement at Cubberley in Mr. Curungcong’s special day class during the time the District was identifying staff and a schedule of services for STUDENT’s transition. (Id.) STUDENT’s mother indicated to the IEP team that she had contacted Madison Elementary School for STUDENT’s summer enrollment in the reading clinic.
On January 20, 2000, the IEP team reconvened to identify the staff and services that would be provided to STUDENT. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The District members recommended placement in the mild to moderate special day class with the following services:
1. Support and instruction in the LiPs and V/V programs three hours per week after the school day at Cubberley;
2. OT at Cubberley one time per week for sixty minutes;
3. Speech and language therapy two times per week, twenty-five minutes per session - small group;
4. Touch Math and reading support in RSP forty-five minutes per day, including individual time within the forty-five minute block;
5. Inclusion consultant (ISGI) one time per week to support STUDENT in his mainstreaming classroom placement -- third grade center based activities; and
6. Participation in the general education program 480 minutes per week.
Speech and language goals and objectives were written, and the IEP noted that STUDENT’s parents had now enrolled STUDENT in the Madison Reading Clinic for the extended school year. STUDENT’s parents partially agreed to implementation of the January 20, 2000 IEP, although they requested that STUDENT be provided with the LiPs and V/V programs four hours a day, five days a week. (Resp.’s Exh. 39, pg. 8.) STUDENT’s parents believed STUDENT needed intensive one-to-one instruction to address his sensory cognitive issues and felt that STUDENT’s language processing needs would be met by instruction at the Lindamood-Bell clinic. Although the District offered three hours per week of the LiPs and V/V methods to be received after school, his parents believed that adding on another hour to STUDENT’s school day was not what he needed because he would be tired. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The IEP team scheduled STUDENT’s annual IEP for April 2000. (Resp.’s Exh. 39.)
On February 9, 2000, STUDENT’s parents wrote the District’s program specialist, Marlene Daniels, requesting that at the April 2000 IEP meeting they be provided with various test results, benchmarks, and work samples for the program evaluation period of January 24, 2000, through March 31, 2000. STUDENT’s parents also requested that the next IEP meeting be held during the week of April 3, 2000. (Resp.’s Exh. 40.)
On February 29, 2000, STUDENT’s mother sent another letter to Ms. Daniels, withdrawing her agreement to attend the upcoming IEP meeting on behalf of STUDENT. (Resp.’s Exh. 41.) Since MOTHER had arranged with principal Hedges and the principal at Cubberley for STUDENT to attend the Madison reading clinic for a third cycle, she wanted to postpone the April, 2000 IEP meeting until STUDENT finished the cycle and she had an opportunity to see his progress. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
The April 4, 2000 annual IEP meeting was nevertheless held and STUDENT’s mother attended. The purpose of the meeting was to review annual goals and STUDENT’s present levels of performance, and to develop new goals and objectives for the upcoming school year. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The IEP team members reported on STUDENT’s progress from January through the end of March 2000 while at the Madison reading clinic.
STUDENT’s mother testified and reported at the April 4, 2000 IEP meeting that STUDENT had made some improvement in his spelling, although he was not at 100 percent. STUDENT’s mother indicated to the team that she felt an optimal program for STUDENT would be the Lindamood-Bell program during the first three hours of the day and mainstreaming during the second half of the school day. (Resp.’s Exh. 49, pg. 21.) The IEP team recommended that from April 3, 2000, to May 1, 2000, STUDENT continue in the same mild to moderate special day class with the same related services of speech and language, OT, and inclusion support, and RSP for reading, math and written expression. District support for the LiPs and V/V programs would also continue until STUDENT completed his time at Cubberley. It was decided that STUDENT would return to the reading clinic at Madison as of May 1, 2000, until the end of that school year. Other than occupational therapy, STUDENT would not continue to receive the other related services or RSP while at Madison after May 1, 2000. MOTHER reported to the IEP team that STUDENT would also attend the Madison reading clinic during the summer. The team decided to reconvene in late August to determine STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year and to review his reading clinic progress. (Resp.’s Exh. 49, pg. 21.)
STUDENT’s parents partially agreed to the program placement and services outlined in the April 4, 2000 IEP. They continued to request an intensive, twenty-hour per week clinic setting where STUDENT could receive the LMB LiPs, Seeing Stars, and VV programs, but allowed his April 4, 2000 IEP to be implemented. (Resp.’s Exh. 49, pg. 23.)
On May 2, 2000, STUDENT’s mother completed and submitted an application for a school transfer so that STUDENT could attend Madison’s fifth grade regular education literacy program for the 2000-2001 school year. MOTHER testified that she discussed the transfer to Madison with Ms. Towner and principal Hedges and the decision was made to put STUDENT in the regular education literacy program at Madison. MOTHER believed this would be a better setting to assist STUDENT with his language problems, as she did not want STUDENT to continue in a program in which he had not shown progress. (Testimony of MOTHER.) STUDENT’s transfer to Madison for the 2000-2001 school year was made unilaterally by his parents and not through the IEP process. STUDENT attended Madison’s summer reading clinic, and then began the 2000-2001 school year in Madison’s fourth/fifth grade regular education literacy program, where Rachel Zgainer was, and still is, his teacher. While at Madison, STUDENT continued to receive the related services and RSP instruction that he previously received at Cubberley. (Testimony of MOTHER.) MOTHER testified that principal Hedges told her that the services STUDENT had been receiving at Cubberley would continue at Madison. On September 12, 2000, STUDENT’s parents wrote to Marlene Daniels requesting an IEP meeting to determine STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year. (Resp.’s Exh. 58.) An IEP meeting was noticed for October 17, 2000; however, STUDENT’s parents chose not to attend.
On September 26, 2000, Petitioner’s counsel placed this case back on calendar and the matter proceeded to a due process hearing. (Resp.’s Exh. 60.) On October 17, 2000, MOTHER forwarded a letter to the “IEP meeting teachers/administrators” indicating her concern that STUDENT was having to go in and out of so many different places while at school. MOTHER also believed that STUDENT was not receiving enough support with the ADD, V/V and Touch Math programs and was not given sight word lists to bring home. (Resp.’s Exh. 63.) MOTHER stated that STUDENT required one-on-one instruction and continued to request twenty hours per week of the Lindamood-Bell program in a clinic setting. (Id.)
An IEP meeting was held on October 17, 2000, for the purpose of reviewing STUDENT’s placement. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s eligibility for special education services and decided that STUDENT’s primary eligibility would be speech and language impairment and secondarily specific learning disability. (Resp.’s Exh. 64, pg. 6.) Assessment results from the Madison reading clinic and the LMB program in Newport Beach were reviewed by the IEP team. The team also discussed STUDENT’s history and his progress and concluded “from the assessment data, that minimal progress occurred.” (Id. at pgs. 7-8.) According to the IEP notes, the team also considered written comments provided by MOTHER. It appeared to the IEP team that STUDENT continued to have difficulties in the areas of receptive and expressive language, and, therefore, the IEP team ultimately recommended that STUDENT be placed in a mild to moderate intermediate special day class at Emerson Elementary School that focuses on language development. Occupational therapy was recommended one time per week for sixty minutes. Speech and language services were not recommended since STUDENT would be in a class with a teacher who was a speech pathologist. (Testimony of Gail Stoter, Briana Graham-Ramos.) The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s current goals and decided they were appropriate, with the exception of one language arts goal, which the IEP team modified.
Also in attendance at the October 17, 2000 IEP meeting was Stanley Perlo, a consultant for the District to its alternative dispute resolution and special education programs.
A copy of the October 17, 2000 IEP was forwarded to STUDENT’s parents, who disagreed with the recommendations contained therein. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The October 17, 2000 IEP was never implemented. On November 15, 2000, an assessment plan was designed to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic, speech and language, intellectual development, social/emotional and adaptive behavior, health/physical status and occupational therapy. (Resp.’s Exh. 69.) MOTHER signed the assessment plan, giving the District permission to conduct the testing. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
On January 3, 2001, STUDENT’s three-year IEP meeting was held. (Resp.’s Exh. 72.) The IEP team discussed STUDENT’s present levels of performance, reviewed goals and objectives from the previous years, and drafted new ones. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The school psychologist presented her three-year assessment, and the speech and language specialist presented her assessment report. (Resp.’s Exh. 72, pg. 16.) MOTHER testified that she did not ask questions or give any input during the IEP meeting regarding the assessment reports or the goals and objectives, but that she was given the opportunity to do. The IEP team decided that in light of the assessment results STUDENT’s main eligibility category should be changed back to specific learning disability. The IEP document notes that MOTHER agreed that the assessments were consistent with her observations of STUDENT and that she agreed with STUDENT’s eligibility category and goals and objectives.
The District members of the January 3, 2001 IEP team decided it would be appropriate for STUDENT to continue in Madison’s regular education fourth/fifth grade literacy class for the following reasons: There was concern about the number of times STUDENT would have changed schools in one year, STUDENT was making progress toward his IEP goals, and STUDENT had grown socially and showed a higher level of comfort in the regular education literacy class at Madison. (Resp.’s Exh. 72, pgs. 16-17.) MOTHER did not agree with the District members’ recommendation to place STUDENT in the literacy class at Madison for the entire day, and continued to request that STUDENT attend the LMB center in Newport Beach for twenty hours per week.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education from January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not have been achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for each time frame in question must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comported with his IEP; and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment. The issue of whether or not the offered program and services were provided in the least restrictive environment does not arise in this matter and, therefore, is not addressed by the Hearing Officer.
The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Petitioner contends that the school psychologist, Barbara Harkleroad, who assessed STUDENT in 1997, did not attend the triennial IEP that took place on May 30, 1997. As a result, Petitioner argues that the May 30, 1997 IEP meeting was “a perfunctory exercise which contributed to STUDENT’s lack of educational progress,” and led to an appropriate education not being provided. (Petitioner’s Closing Argument, pgs. 4-5.) Petitioner alleges a denial of FAPE only for the time period from January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school yea and the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, Petitioner’s argument infers that alleged procedural violations that occurred in May 1997 caused him to be denied a FAPE from January 4, 2000, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year.
Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)
The District did not specifically respond to Petitioner’s argument regarding the attendees at the May 1997 IEP. However, Ann Logue, who also attended the May 1997 IEP meeting, testified that she did not remember whether Harkleroad’s psychoeducational report was discussed at the May 1997 IEP meeting. Ms. Logue also testified that if a psychologist cannot attend the IEP meeting, he/she will conduct a parent conference or meet informally with the parent regarding his/her report. Testimony from MOTHER indicated that the psychologist’s report was not discussed at the May 1997 IEP meeting.
If an IEP team is reviewing or revising the IEP of an individual who has been assessed for the purpose of that IEP, personnel who are required to attend that IEP team meeting include a person who has conducted an assessment of the student or who is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the student and is familiar with the results of the assessment. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(d).) Other than STUDENT’s mother, Ann Logue and Clarise Penaranda were the only other participants at the May 30, 1997 IEP meeting. (Resp.’s Exh. 13.) Ms. Logue signed the IEP document as the administrative designee and Ms. Penaranda signed it as STUDENT’s teacher. As the administrative designee, Ms. Logue testified that she attended the May 30, 1997 IEP meeting as someone familiar with the SLD-A special day class program.
It is uncontroverted that no school psychologist was present at the IEP team meeting held on May 30, 1997. However, no evidence was presented showing either that STUDENT lost educational opportunity or that his parents were prevented from participating in the IEP process due to the failure to have Ms. Harkleroad or another school psychologist present. In fact, an examination of the May 30, 1997 IEP reveals that assessment test scores from Ms. Harkleroad’s report were written into STUDENT’s May 1997 IEP, indicating his present levels of performance. Moreover, an additional six IEP meetings were held for STUDENT subsequent to the May 1997 IEP meeting and prior to the period of analysis in this matter. Therefore, linking the school psychologist’s failure to attend the May 1997 IEP meeting to STUDENT allegedly not being provided an appropriate education from January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year and for the 2000-2001 school year is a conclusion that requires a series of dubious inferences without direct proof that one situation caused the other.
Therefore, the procedural violation related to the absence of Ms. Harkleroad at the IEP meeting on May 30, 1997, did not, in and of itself, deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations in the 1997 school year that denied STUDENT a FAPE during the time frame of January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year and for the 2000-2001 school year.
Petitioner also argues that Stanley Perlo’s attendance at the IEP meetings of October 17, 2000, and January 3, 2001, without first disclosing to the parents that he would attend, resulted in a denial of STUDENT’s right to a FAPE because the District was conducting the IEP meetings in an inherently adversarial manner and thus compromising STUDENT’s confidentiality rights. (Petitioner’s closing brief.)
Mr. Perlo testified that since August 2000, he has contracted with the District to serve as a consultant and alternative dispute resolution (ADR) coordinator. His duties include informing District staff how to conduct IEP meetings and other matters, including complying with State and federal requirements for evaluation of special education students. Mr. Perlo also testified that he has never attended a District IEP meeting for the purpose of making a better case against a parent. Mr. Perlo signed both the October 2000 and January 2001 IEPs as the ADR coordinator, and testified that he attended the October 2000 IEP meeting for the purpose of personal instruction and observation, but he had no personal knowledge of or expertise relevant to the IEP. He testified that his purpose in attending the January 3, 2001 IEP meeting was to make sure that MOTHER had an opportunity to express her point of view and state it in the IEP document, and that she understood what was transpiring at the meeting. Regarding Petitioner’s claims that STUDENT’s confidentiality rights were compromised by Mr. Perlo’s attendance at the IEP meetings, Mr. Perlo testified that, like other IEP team members, he felt bound by any rules of confidentiality with respect to any information he obtained at the IEP team meetings.
STUDENT’s parents did not attend the October 17, 2000 IEP meeting; however, MOTHER attended the January 3, 2001 IEP meeting. MOTHER testified that during the January 3, 2001 meeting, the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s present levels of performance and his goals and objectives from previous years, and also drafted new goals and objectives. MOTHER testified that she was given an opportunity to give her input into the IEP, but that she did not do so. She also testified that during the January 2001 IEP meeting, Mr. Perlo asked her if she had anything to add to the IEP. MOTHER testified that it was difficult to review the assessment reports for the first time at the IEP meeting and be expected to formulate questions on the spot. According to MOTHER, it would have been beneficial if she had received the reports before the meeting so that she had time to formulate questions.
Both Education Code § 56341.5(c) and 34 CFR § 300.345(b)(1)(i) require that the notice of an IEP meeting indicate the purpose, time, and location of the meeting and who will be in attendance. Notices for both the October 17, 2000 and January 3, 2001 IEP meetings do not indicate that the District’s ADR coordinator would be present at the meetings. (Pet.’s Exhs. DDDD and EEEE.) The notice for the October 2000 meeting has the “other” box marked. However, in the space next to the box there is nothing written indicating the title of the person who would attend.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not disclose on the IEP notices that the District ADR coordinator would be present at the October 2000 or January 2001 IEP team meetings. The California Legislature intended that IEP team meetings be conducted in a nonadversarial manner and convened solely for the purposes of making educational decisions for the good of the student. (Educ. Code § 56341(h).) However, although the District violated the State and federal provisions requiring proper notice of an IEP team meeting, Petitioner has presented no evidence that either IEP meeting was conducted in an adversarial manner. In fact, MOTHER, who attended only the January 2001 IEP meeting, did not indicate in her testimony that she felt uncomfortable at the IEP team meeting or that the atmosphere of the meeting was adversarial. Rather, MOTHER’s only complaint regarding the conduct of the January 3, 2001 IEP meeting was that she would preferred to have had the assessment reports prior to the IEP meeting, giving her more time to review them and prepare questions. There is no evidence that the District’s failure to notice STUDENT’s parents that the ADR coordinator would be in attendance at the two IEP meetings made those meetings adversarial or compromised STUDENT’s confidentiality rights. The District’s failure to properly notice the parents as to Mr. Perlo’s attendance at the two IEP meetings did not, in and of itself, result in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no denial of FAPE for the time period from January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year and for the 2000-2001 school year based upon procedural violations of the IDEA.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
The standard for evaluating the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offer involves three factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, whether the placement and services provided him with educational benefit, and whether the placement and services conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S. C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176.)
The Hearing Officer must first determine STUDENT’s unique needs during the time frame of January 4, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year. This time frame is covered by two separate IEPs, one from January to April 2000, and the other from April 2000 through the extended school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will analyze both time frames separately, as each IEP contained different offers of placement and services.
At the time of STUDENT’s January IEP meetings, Carol Dygean had conducted her June 4, 1999 psychoeducational evaluation, Anne Logue had prepared her June 15, 1999 speech and language assessment report, and Angelica Dirtadian had prepared a report compiled after STUDENT completed his session at the LMB Newport Beach clinic in August 1999. Based on results of this testing and a review of STUDENT’s progress during the first two cycles at the Madison reading clinic, the parties agreed that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of sequential auditory and visual processing, organizing words in his memory, and processing language. He had specific difficulties with reading comprehension, focusing his abilities, remaining on task, completing his work, retaining information, and following oral directions. STUDENT also had difficulties with semantics and spelling. The IEP team again found STUDENT eligible for special education as an individual with a specific learning disability. The IEP team determined that STUDENT needed a daily, intensive program that strengthens his auditory and visual processing skills and improves his language development. The District members of the IEP team, however, believed STUDENT should remain in a small class and receive instruction in the LMB methods from District personnel. STUDENT’s parents and former LMB clinic director Angelica Dirtadian believed STUDENT needed one-on-one, individualized instruction at the LMB Newport Beach center.
1. January 4, 2000, through April 2000.
At the time of the January IEP meetings, the parties did not dispute the identification of STUDENT’s unique needs as noted above; however, they did dispute whether the District’s offered program and placement met those needs from January 4, 2000 to April 2000. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will first consider whether the District’s offer, as outlined in the two January 2000 IEPs, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
The District offered to place STUDENT in a special day class designated “mild to moderate” at Cubberley, with support and instruction in the Lindamood-Bell LiPs and V/V programs three hours per week after school, speech and language two times per week for twenty-five minutes per session, OT one time per week for sixty minutes, support from an inclusion consultant one time per week for one hour to assist STUDENT in his third-grade center-based activities, and assistance in reading and math through RSP each day for forty-five minutes, including individual time. The parties agreed on STUDENT’s goals and objectives, using those drafted in the Apri1 1999 IEP regarding math, reading, semantics, syntax, spelling, writing, work behavior (i.e., attending to task), and motor planning. They also drafted new goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s delays in the area of multiple definitions and word associations. (Resp.’s Exhs. 23 and 39.)
The parties disagreed, however, as to STUDENT’s placement and the number of hours of the LMB program necessary to address STUDENT’s reading, math, and written expression skills. Petitioner argues that the District’s placement and services were inappropriate and that STUDENT required an intensive program of four hours of instruction per day, five days per week, for a period up to twenty-four weeks from the LMB clinic in Newport Beach, California. The District argues that its offer of placement in the mild to moderate SDC with the related services and RSP noted above, which included three hours per week of the LMB LiPs and V/V programs administered by District personnel, met STUDENT’s needs. The District alleged that the LMB clinic-based program was more intensive than he needed and would have removed him from the school site for most of his school day.
Sherry Geller-Vogeli, a credentialed speech and language specialist for the District, testified credibly that she devised the reading and language arts goals noted in the January 20, 2000 IEP based on information obtained from Ann Logue’s triennial report. Ms. Vogeli testified that she worked with STUDENT in a small group of 2 students from January through April 2000, twice a week on a pull-out basis. The other student in STUDENT’s group graduated soon after STUDENT started working with her, so many of STUDENT’s sessions were administered on a one-on-one basis, each for twenty-five minutes.
Ms. Vogeli used a multi-sensory approach with STUDENT, first using pictures, then using auditory methods once STUDENT no longer needed visual cues. For instance, she used words in a sentence in order to help STUDENT understand what they were discussing. According to Ms. Vogeli, Lindamood-Bell also uses a multi-sensory approach. Ms. Vogeli testified that in 1996 she received District training in the LMB LiPs and V/V programs. Her LiPs training was a five-day course, seven hours a day, and the V/V training was a four-week course, two hours a night. She also attended a two-day LMB V/V training in Glendale, California, and another V/V training at Disneyland two years ago. Ms. Vogeli did not provide STUDENT with instruction in LMB programs. Rather, she understood that Tanya Sanderson, another District speech and language specialist and RSP teacher, provided the LMB LiPs and V/V program services to STUDENT on a one-on-one basis, after school, pursuant to his January 20, 2000 IEP. (Testimony of Sherry Geller-Vogeli.)
Ms. Vogeli worked on goal number one in the January 20, 2000 IEP regarding multiple definitions and found that although STUDENT progressed slowly, he did make progress in meeting the objectives. Ms. Vogeli testified that the reading/language arts goal number two was designed to work on comprehension and STUDENT’s ability to process information, specifically with regard to semantic absurdities, word associations, synonyms and antonyms. STUDENT was doing well with goal number two, although he sometimes needed cues in order to remember or respond. (Testimony of Sherry Geller-Vogeli.) Ms. Vogeli’s speech and language progress report dated April 1, 2000, indicates that STUDENT needed a lot of repetition, review of information, and examples to successfully respond to tasks worked on in therapy. (Resp.’s Exh. 47.) Ms. Vogeli recommended that STUDENT continue with speech and language therapy.
Ms. Vogeli also worked with Mr. Carungcong, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, assisting him with demonstrations in his class (i.e., developing diagrams for math) and sharing ideas with him about how the math demonstrations could incorporate language arts. Ms. Vogeli also supplemented Mr. Carungcong’s materials and discussed language topics with him. (Testimony of Geller-Vogeli.)
Nancy Littlefield, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, testified that she attended STUDENT’s January 20, 2000 IEP meeting and began providing RSP services to STUDENT the following school week. RSP took place each day for forty-five minutes. With the assistance of an aide, Ms. Littlefield worked with STUDENT on reading, written expression, and math on a pull-out basis in a group of approximately four to seven students; however, there were never as many as seven students in the group at once because the students had staggered schedules. Ms. Littlefield stated that her RSP program was able to address the goals that were continued from STUDENT’s April 21, 1999 IEP. In RSP, there was time to provide direct instruction to STUDENT, and because he often needed a lot of support, the RSP arrangement seemed to work for him. Ms. Littlefield also noted that she used the Touch Math program to assist STUDENT with math computations.
Mr. Carungcong, STUDENT’s special day class teacher from January through April 2000, did not testify at the hearing. However, a teacher report completed by him and dated March 31, 2000, was admitted as evidence. (Resp.’s Exh. 45.) The report indicates that Mr. Carungcong primarily worked on math goals with STUDENT.
STUDENT was also mainstreamed into Bobbe Miles’s third grade regular education class during the reading center activities, with the support of an inclusion specialist. (Resp.’s Exhs. 45 and 49.) The inclusion specialist, Susan Weisenberger, signed the April 4, 2000 IEP and reported that Ms. Miles provided an outstanding setting where STUDENT was able to effectively participate in the regular education program. She also reported that she collaborated with Ms. Miles and assisted her in modifying some of the reading center assignments by providing Ms. Miles with packets of reading and comprehension activities modified to STUDENT’s reading level. The IEP notes also report that Touch Math times tables were provided at the parents’ request so that STUDENT had an activity if and when his regular education class was working on math assignments. The inclusion specialist also noted that STUDENT appeared comfortable in Ms. Miles’s classroom activities. (Resp.’s Exh. 49, pg. 18.)
The evidence establishes that from January 2000 through April 2000, appropriate goals and objectives were drafted to address STUDENT’s specific needs. Additionally, interventions in reading, math, and written expression were carried out each day in the special day class, through RSP and related services instruction, through support with the inclusion specialist, and in after school instruction in the LMB LiPs and V/V methods three times each week. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed placement, program, and services identified in the IEPs of January 4, 2000, and January 20, 2000, were appropriate and met STUDENT’s unique needs for the period from January 4, 2000, through April 2000.
The next determination is whether the District’s offer and provision of services during the above-referenced time period provided STUDENT with educational benefit. To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996).) Of course, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his/her disability and must be gaged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997); Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 185 (3d Cir. 1988).) Nancy Littlefield, STUDENT’s RSP teacher during the January 2000-April 2000 period, testified that STUDENT met one of his language arts goals and partially met the other. When she started working with STUDENT, his phonics skills were at the primer level in decoding, and his comprehension was at a high first grade level. By the end of March 2000, STUDENT was reading at a high first, low second grade range. She also testified that although the records indicate that STUDENT did not meet the third math goal, she could have reported that he partially met that goal because STUDENT could read, write and recite his numbers to 100, fill in missing grid numbers, and count to 200 with assistance. Ms. Littlefield reported that she saw STUDENT progress in subtraction to where he no longer used blocks, but instead used his fingers and improved his speed. However, STUDENT could not write his numbers in the correct order. Ms. Littlefield worked with STUDENT for approximately three months. As to STUDENT’s progress in written expression, Ms. Littlefield reported that STUDENT spelled at a low-mid-first grade level and wrote consonant-vowel-consonant (cvc) words to dictation. She also reported that STUDENT had difficulty writing words with long vowel patterns and words with consonant blends. (Resp.’s Exh. 45 - Teacher’s report.)
Ms. Littlefield testified that she saw indications of growth at the end of the time she spent with STUDENT. The delay in the start of STUDENT’s growth was due to the fact that he had problems getting into a routine. Ms. Littlefield opined that in order to see STUDENT progress, he needs much consistency and an established routine for a length of time to get acclimated.
Regarding STUDENT’s language, both Ms. Littlefield and Mr. Caruncong reported that STUDENT speaks in simple sentences with hesitation and pauses. (Resp.’s Exh. 45 - Teacher’s report.) Sherry Geller-Vogeli, STUDENT’s speech and language specialist, reported that STUDENT could verbally express, without visual cues, how two target words are similar and different with 50 percent accuracy (i.e., chair/bed, brother/sister.) STUDENT could also orally express, without visual cues, two different meanings of target multiple-meaning words with 50 percent accuracy and could correctly use the multiple-meaning words in sentences with 60 percent accuracy. Ms. Geller-Vogeli also noted that STUDENT needed much repetition, review of information, and examples to successfully respond to tasks worked on in therapy. (Resp.’s Exh. 47 - Speech and Language report.)
Additionally, Margaret Towner, STUDENT’s teacher at the Madison reading clinic, testified that when STUDENT first left the Madison reading clinic after finishing the first two cycles in December 1999, he could not pass one of the District’s benchmarks. However, upon returning to the reading clinic in May 2000, after his time in the Cubberley SDC from January to April 2000, STUDENT could pass a mid-second-grade District reading benchmark using the book “Rosie’s House.” STUDENT was also retaining sight words for longer periods of time, and Ms. Towner felt that as of the end of April 2000, STUDENT was a reader.
The IEP team noted at the April 4, 2000 IEP meeting that STUDENT was reading at the second grade level, but had not shown a high degree of critical thinking skills and that his comprehension was very low due to his high concentration on decoding while reading. The IEP also reports that as of April 2000, in math, STUDENT could count to 139, write to 109, and read numbers to 100. He could read and write 2-digit numerals inconsistently and solve simple addition and subtraction word problems (sums and minuses to 10). STUDENT could add and subtract to and from 10 with his fingers; however, he could not yet regroup. STUDENT could tell time to the hour and state the name and value of the penny and nickel, and knew the names of all coins, except the half dollar. (Resp.’s Exhs. 49 and 45.)
STUDENT’s program and services were provided in a coordinated and collaborative manner by key District personnel. Additionally, the inclusion specialist confirmed that STUDENT received positive academic and nonacademic benefits. Although STUDENT did not progress in every area, the Hearing Officer finds that, in light of STUDENT’s disability, STUDENT received more than a de minimis benefit from his placement, program and services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program, placement and services from January 2000 to April 2000 provided STUDENT with educational benefit.
Finally, there is no dispute that the District’s offer conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.
On the basis of the findings above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program, placement and services provided by the District pursuant to the IEPs of January 4, 2000, and January 20, 2000, were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. Accordingly, the District offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE for the time period of January through April 2000.
2. April 4, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including extended school year
At the April 4, 2000 IEP meeting, STUDENT continued to be identified as having a specific learning disability, and thus the parties agreed to his eligibility category at that time.
The April 4, 2000 IEP does not show that STUDENT’s needs significantly changed from where they were at time of the previous IEP. However, regarding STUDENT’s attending and responding skills, Mr. Carungcong’s March 2000 teacher report noted that STUDENT attends and responds better in small group. The report also noted that STUDENT needs verbal cues repeated and directions rephrased in order to stay focused and to refocus to task at hand. (Resp.’s Exh. 45.)
The IEP team, including MOTHER, agreed as to the identification of STUDENT’s needs. MOTHER allowed implementation of the IEP, but continued to request that STUDENT be placed at the LMB clinic in Newport Beach, California, for intensive one-on-one instruction.
The IEP team of April 4, 2000, recommended STUDENT be placed in a mild to moderate SDC with the related services of speech and language, OT and inclusion support, and RSP for reading, math, and written expression. (Resp.’s Exh. 49.) New goals and objectives were drafted in the areas of reading, decoding and word analysis, writing, math, and attending to task. Additionally, instructional modifications were drafted for use in the general education program during his mainstreaming. The SDC placement and corresponding services outlined in the IEP dated April 4, 2000, were scheduled to end in May 2000, when STUDENT would begin a third, 35-day cycle at the Madison reading clinic and continue on at the Madison reading clinic for its summer session. The only related service that continued through the extended school year was OT. (Resp.’s Exh. 49.)
Having previously determined that the program and placement in the Cubberley SDC were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer need only determine whether the third cycle and summer program at the Madison reading clinic met STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT’s third cycle at Madison included eighteen students, two teachers, one special education aide, and a bank of computers. STUDENT received instruction in small groups of three to five students at a time, spending time each day with the teachers, the aide, and working on the computers. (Testimony of Margaret Towner.) The Madison reading clinic was a District-run clinic using the LMB LiPs, V/V, and Seeing Stars programs and the Touch Math program. Ms. Towner testified that she also worked with STUDENT on his sight words so as to help him with reading fluency, comprehension and spelling.
Madison’s summer program included approximately 100 students from all over the District. The Madison summer program was more intensive than the cycles conducted during the school year, and the District hired additional teachers to work the summer program at Madison (Id.; Testimony of Donald Speir.)
From the information obtained through witness testimony and documentary evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the additional month in the Cubberley SDC with RSP and related services, the third cycle of the Madison reading clinic, and the subsequent and more intensive summer reading program at Madison using the LMB methods and Touch Math, were appropriate to address STUDENT’s reading, written expression, and math needs.
With regard to whether the District’s program provided STUDENT with educational benefit, there was no dispute as to the areas in which STUDENT needed to work.
According to Margaret Towner, STUDENT passed a District benchmark at the end of the academic year in June 2000 and showed growth in most all areas. STUDENT also showed growth according to results of the LAC test. Ms. Towner reported, however, that she found the LiPs program was more difficult for STUDENT than the LMB symbol imagery program, which she felt was more appropriate for him, and in which he received instruction. Nevertheless, STUDENT benefitted from the small-group instruction at the Madison reading clinic, as reflected by the growth shown through his test scores. (Testimony of Margaret Towner.) STUDENT attended Cubberley from January to April 2000, and was able to use the skills he had previously acquired during the first two cycles at the Madison reading clinic. After returning and finishing his third Madison session, he showed at least another year’s growth on the Phonological Awareness test. (Resp.’s Exh. 52.) STUDENT also showed growth in some of his writing skills, even though they did not teach the LMB writing process at the Madison clinic
Donald Speir testified that STUDENT’s skill levels did not change much after the Madison summer clinic; however, he questioned whether the lack of significant progress could be attributed to STUDENT’s having missed two weeks of school. Mr. Speir later testified that the summer clinic is run four days a week and that STUDENT missed eight days. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was only absent from the Madison summer 2000 clinic for one week, and that the notation on the Madison summer clinic progress report that STUDENT only attended 50% of the program after a two-week absence is incorrect. (Resp.’s Exh. 57.) The evidence establishes that STUDENT missed approximately seven or eight days of instruction at the Madison summer reading clinic.
Given that STUDENT did not regress during the summer program and the summer program is not the primary program for the school year, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the minimal progress during a one-month period denied STUDENT educational benefit. Rather, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received some educational benefit during the one additional month in Mr. Carungcong’s class and during the third Madison cycle and summer clinic. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement, program, and services provided pursuant to the April 4, 2000 IEP provided STUDENT with educational benefit.
Lastly, there is no dispute that the District’s offer in the April 4, 2000 IEP conformed to STUDENT’s IEP. In conclusion, the District provided STUDENT a FAPE from April 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 extended school year.
2. Did the District offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
Pursuant to the IEP dated April 4, 2000, the IEP team agreed to reconvene by or before September 1, 2000, to determine STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year and review his reading clinic progress. However, in spite of this agreement, STUDENT’s mother applied for and received a school transfer, which allowed STUDENT to attend Madison’s regular education fourth/fifth grade literacy class taught by Rachel Zgainer. MOTHER testified that Madison’s principal, Mr. Hedges, knew that STUDENT was a special education student, although she was not sure who informed Mr. Hedges of this fact. STUDENT started the 2000-2001 school year in Rachel Zgainer’s fourth/fifth grade literacy class at Madison. At that time, the District had not yet held an IEP meeting to develop a new program for that school year. However, as of September 2000, STUDENT was provided with a placement, program and services that would later be formally offered in his January 3, 2001 IEP. Briana Graham-Ramos, the District’s special education program team leader, testified that the Madison site contacted her in September 2000 because STUDENT’s then current-IEP called for a program that Madison did not have on its campus. She was called in to help Madison develop a program that best met STUDENT’s needs. In spite of STUDENT’s not having a current IEP, Gail Stoter testified that she started providing individual speech and language services to STUDENT as of September 18, 2000. STUDENT’s RSP teacher, Donald Speir, testified that STUDENT was on his RSP list for the 2000-2001 school year when he started implementing services.
On September 12, 2000, MOTHER informed the District in writing that STUDENT was enrolled at Madison in Ms. Zgainer’s class and asked that an IEP team meeting be scheduled to determine STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year. (Resp.’s Exh. 58.) An IEP meeting was scheduled and held on October 17, 2000; however, STUDENT’s parents did not attend. MOTHER testified that she didn’t attend the October 17, 2000 IEP meeting because she knew the District could not offer the LMB clinic-based, intensive program that she was seeking for STUDENT. MOTHER received a copy of the October 17, 2000 IEP through the mail and disagreed with the placement and services offered to STUDENT therein. She specifically did not agree with the offer to place STUDENT in an SDC at Emerson Elementary School because STUDENT had been in similar settings for the last seven years and she believed he had not made progress. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The October 17, 2000 IEP was never implemented.
A. September 2000 to January 2, 2001
On October 17, 2000, the IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s records back to his initial evaluation in 1994, and gave much weight to the findings made by Carol Dygean in her last triennial evaluation of STUDENT. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT’s major needs involved his speech and language impairment and reading. (Testimony of Briana Graham-Ramos.) STUDENT’s more specific needs in October 2000 included difficulty retaining information and difficulty staying on task for a long period of time. (Testimony of Donald Speir.) In particular, in his October 6, 2000 teacher’s report, STUDENT’s RSP teacher concluded that STUDENT was reading at the first grade level with 87% accuracy. His word recognition was at the first grade level with 90% accuracy and at the second grade level with 75% accuracy. STUDENT’s reading comprehension was at a first grade level. Mr. Speir also reported that in math, STUDENT could only do addition facts under 10, was unable to give time to the hour, did not recognize all coins or their values, and was unable to measure accurately. Mr. Speir testified that STUDENT’s mind would wander, particularly when doing math. He reported that STUDENT’s written expression grade level was at 1.5 and noted that STUDENT wrote simple sentences with inconsistent capitalization, no punctuation, and poor spelling. (Resp.’s Exh. 61 - Speir’s teacher report.)
Ms. Zgainer’s October 4, 2000 teacher report noted that STUDENT was reading at the second grade level, but at the first grade level independently. STUDENT was performing at the first grade level in math and at the first to second grade level in written expression. Ms. Zgainer also noted that STUDENT was unable to write a paragraph and had no concept of sentence structure. (Resp.’s Exh. 61 - Zgainer’s teacher report.)
The IEP team agreed that STUDENT continued to have difficulties in receptive and expressive language and deficits in spatial and visual processing. According to teacher reports completed by Ms. Zgainer and Mr. Speir in October 2000, STUDENT exhibited some of the same problems he faced as of his last IEP. STUDENT continued to have needs in the areas of reading comprehension, spelling, written expression, and math. (Resp.’s Exh. 61.) Mr. Speir also noted in his report that STUDENT attended and responded well in small groups of six or less. (Id.)
STUDENT’s mother also wrote the Madison IEP team in October 2000, and related to them that STUDENT’s needs were very specific to dyslexia and any related processing issues. (Resp.’s Exh. 63.) The Hearing Officer gives little weight to MOTHER’s contention that STUDENT has dyslexia, as no proof was given that STUDENT had ever been diagnosed with this disorder.
On the basis of the information provided through documentary evidence and witness testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that at the time of the October 2000 IEP meeting, STUDENT still had deficits in visual and auditory processing. These deficits contributed to STUDENT’s difficulty in the areas of receptive and expressive language, which in turn, impeded his progress in academic areas. STUDENT continued to have trouble staying on task and retaining information. STUDENT required assistance in reading, math and written expression, because he was in the fifth grade, but not performing at grade level in any of these areas. (Resp.’s Exh. 61.)
After reviewing all of STUDENT’s assessments and records and written comments from MOTHER, the IEP team changed STUDENT’s eligibility category to speech and language impairment. The IEP team also recommended that STUDENT be placed in a mild to moderate special day class at Emerson Elementary School (Emerson), which focuses on language development and is taught by Nancy Stansfield, a speech and language pathologist. (Resp.’s Exh. 64.) Ms. Stoter contacted Ms. Stansfield during the IEP team meeting to discuss her class and determine whether it would meet STUDENT’s needs. (Testimony of Briana Graham-Ramos.) The IEP team believed that a small-group setting at Emerson, where he could get more one-on-one time and small-group attention, would be a better environment for STUDENT. (Id.) The IEP team did not offer any speech and language services, or RSP. The only related service offered was OT. According to Briana Graham Ramos and several other District witnesses, speech and language services were not offered because the SDC at Emerson was taught by a speech and language pathologist, and thus, STUDENT did not also need speech and language services on a pull-out basis. The team believed that Ms. Stansfield could incorporate socialization and academics into her class. The October 17, 2000 IEP team also believed STUDENT had not made the kind of progress that he could had he been in an intensive speech and language classroom. (Testimony of Gail Stoter.) The IEP team recommended STUDENT be mainstreamed in the general education program for physical education, lunch, recess, passing periods and school activities for 345 minutes each week.
The Hearing Officer considers whether the District’s offer set forth in the October 17, 2000 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Stansfield did not testify at the hearing, and there was no testimony received that persuaded the Hearing Officer that Ms. Stansfield’s class was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. The only evidence received in this regard was testimony from District witnesses that Ms. Stansfield is a speech and language pathologist who could provide STUDENT with what he needed in terms of speech and language and any additional services that would have been received during RSP.
Additionally, the information used by the IEP team in determining STUDENT’s needs as of October 2000 was essentially based on a psychoeducational evaluation done more than one year prior, and two teachers’ reports from the teachers who had worked with STUDENT for one month. Therefore, the District members of the IEP team made their recommendations after having known STUDENT for a short time.
The placement and services recommended in the October 2000 IEP were similar to those provided to STUDENT in Ann Logue’s class during the 1998-1999 school year. The October 2000 IEP team, however, did not consider the fact that in April 1999, the IEP team had recommended STUDENT also receive additional instruction in the ADD and V/V programs with District personnel because STUDENT needed a program more intensive than Ms. Logue’s SDC class. (Resp.’s Exh. 23; Testimony of Ann Logue.) Ms. Logue testified that in 1999, services through RSP became an option for special day class students to receive more intensive services. Additionally, in April 1999, STUDENT was classified as a student with a specific learning disability, not a speech and language impairment. However, the October 2000 IEP team offered no rationale for changing STUDENT’s eligibility category to speech and language impairment, even though they relied on the same information the earlier IEP team had used to conclude that STUDENT’s primary eligibility category was specific learning disability. Additionally, in October 2000, only one new goal was drafted for STUDENT in the area of writing. The IEP team determined that STUDENT’s goals from his April 4, 2000 IEP were appropriate and apparently concluded that goals previously being addressed through related services and RSP personnel could now all be addressed by one SDC teacher.
The evidence establishes that the placement, program and services offered in the October 17, 2000 IEP were not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. The District did not establish that Ms. Stansfield’s class alone could provide STUDENT with the specific interventions that he needed to address his unique needs.
Next, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the offer contained in the October 17, 2000 IEP was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Ms. Stoter testified that STUDENT’s needs go beyond reading, and therefore, she believed a small aphasia class with a certified speech and language pathologist was the appropriate placement for STUDENT and would benefit him more than a reading classroom. However, having found above that the offer to place STUDENT in an SDC without any related services or RSP did not provide him with the services he needed, the Hearing Officer concludes that the October 17, 2000 offer also was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
The October 17, 2000 offer could not conform to the IEP because STUDENT’s parent never agreed to the program and services offered therein, and the IEP was never implemented. A district cannot implement an IEP unless the parent consents in writing. (Educ. Code § 56346(a).) Where a district determines that part of the proposed IEP to which the parent does not consent is necessary to provide a FAPE, the district must initiate a due process hearing. (Educ. Code § 56346(b).) However, as stated earlier, when STUDENT’s parents refused to sign the October 17, 2000 IEP, this matter was already the subject of a due process hearing initiated by STUDENT’s parents.
The Hearing Officer finds that the offer contained in the IEP dated October 17, 2000, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, and did not conform to any IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the time period of September 2000 to January 2, 2001.
However, as will be discussed more fully below, the placement, program and services that STUDENT actually received as of September 2000, were those that were officially offered pursuant to the January 3, 2001 IEP, and which the Hearing Officer found to be appropriate.
B. January 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year
The parties do not dispute the identification of STUDENT’s unique needs at the time of the January 3, 2001 IEP. From the information contained in Heather Porrino’s January 2, 2001 three- year assessment/review and Gail Stoter’s December 2000 speech and language assessment report, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT was at the same average cognitive ability level, although he continued to experience difficulties in many academic areas. STUDENT’s below average academic performance and achievement in math, reading, and language arts were significantly discrepant from his average cognitive ability. Moreover, STUDENT continued to have a specific learning disability in the areas of auditory processing, visual-spatial processing, and visual-motor integration. (Resp.’s Exh. 71.) STUDENT demonstrated growth in reading and language skills and had expanded his vocabulary and his ability to define words. He had also improved in decoding and comprehension. However, he still needed special education support in strengthening his writing and math skills and concepts, as well as reading and language. STUDENT’s receptive vocabulary was above his chronological age; however, his general language and pragmatics were at least a year and a half below chronological age. (Resp.’s Exh. 70.)
The parties convened a triennial IEP meeting on January 3, 2001, at which time the District offered to place STUDENT in Ms. Zgainer’s fourth/fifth grade literacy class at Madison. The District also offered, and since September 2000, had provided STUDENT with, the related services of speech and language on a pull-out basis twice a week, inclusion support for thirty minutes one time a week, and OT one time a week for sixty minutes. The offer also included RSP instruction in reading, writing and math each day for a total of four hundred fifty minutes per week, mainstreaming for reading, math and language, physical education, lunch, recess and passing periods, and school activities for 1250 minutes each week. (Resp.’s Exh. 72.) The 1250 minutes represents the amount of time STUDENT spends in Ms. Zgainer’s room. The IEP team also developed instructional modifications for use in the general education program and devised new goals and objectives to address reading, including decoding and sight words; writing; math, including sequencing of numbers; and finally, oral communication, including antonyms and synonyms, answering “why” and “how” questions, and predictions. The IEP team also discussed STUDENT’s primary eligibility category and decided that in light of recent assessment results that STUDENT’s main eligibility category would be changed back to specific learning disability. MOTHER attended the January 3, 2001 IEP team meeting and agreed with the determinations made regarding STUDENT’s eligibility and his goals and objectives. However, she disagreed with the recommendation to place STUDENT at Madison for the entire school day, and believed that STUDENT should attend the LMB clinic in Newport Beach for four hours per day, with the remainder of his day spent at Madison.
The parties dispute whether placement in Ms. Zgainer’s literacy class at Madison with the stated program and services is designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer considers whether the District’s January 3, 2001 offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of writing, math, reading, language, and attending to task.
MOTHER testified that she disagrees with the manner in which the goals and objectives are being implemented at Madison. She believes that STUDENT will not make the type of progress that the goals and objectives are projecting. According to MOTHER, placement in Ms. Zgainer’s class is not the best way to help STUDENT meet his goals and objectives. She believes that STUDENT’s goals and objectives and language processing needs can be best met at the LMB clinic in Newport Beach in a program that includes one-on-one clinic instruction twenty hours per week, four hours per day, with the remainder of his school day spent at Madison. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s language processing needs must first be met before he starts to work on his math skills. According to MOTHER, the LMB clinic would provide a more intensive environment for STUDENT who, she believes, is currently working at the second grade level. MOTHER is a teacher currently on special assignment for the Long Beach Unified School District. She has previously taught kindergarten and third grade classes.
The District argues that the most appropriate placement for STUDENT to meet his educational needs is at Madison in Ms. Zgainer’s class. The District contends that it considered STUDENT’s severe language disorder, his processing disorders, and recent assessments, and offered STUDENT a program in the January 3, 2001 IEP that addressed his unique needs in the areas of reading, math and written language. The District members of the January 3, 2001 IEP team also believed that “staying at Madison would be appropriate for several reasons”: (1) it would have been detrimental for STUDENT to change schools at that point because it would have caused him to change schools three times in one year; (2) with RSP support, STUDENT was making progress toward his IEP goals; and (3) socially, STUDENT was showing a higher comfort level at Madison and had grown socially in the literacy class at Madison. (Resp.’s Exh. 72, pgs. 16-17.)
STUDENT’s progress suggests that he benefits from opportunities to work in small groups with teacher support. (Resp.’s 71, pg. 8.) Heather Porrino, a school psychologist for the District, made several recommendations that would assist STUDENT with sequencing concepts, following multi-step directions, refocusing, staying on task, writing, and in math. Additionally, Gail Stoter, a District speech and language pathologist, recommended that STUDENT continue to receive language services with respect to pragmatic usage and semantic expressive abilities. (Resp.’s Exh. 70.)
Rachel Zgainer teaches the regular education fourth/fifth grade literacy class in which STUDENT is enrolled. She has been teaching this class since August 2000, and is currently working under a California emergency teaching credential. She is currently enrolled in the multiple-subject teaching credential program and has her bachelor of arts degree in English education from California State University, Long Beach. (Testimony of Rachel Zgainer.) Ms. Zgainer’s class is designed for students who are below their grade level in reading. Her students are also typically one to one and one-half years behind in all areas. The goal of her classroom is to get the students back to grade level within a year. (Id.) Her classroom is considered an intervention program infused with literacy throughout the day, except for math. There are twenty-three students currently in her class, although she started the 2000-2001 school year with twenty five students. Whereas a typical regular education class has thirty-five students, her class is designed to have more one-to-one time with the students. Ms. Zgainer testified that she has a college aide who works with her in the class on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays from 8:00 a.m. to 9:30 a.m., and a reading specialist, Lerlene Lyles, who essentially team-teaches with her Monday through Thursdays from 8:00 a.m. to 11:30 a.m. The reading specialist has thirty-six years of reading experience and supplements Ms. Zgainer’s teaching.
The Hearing Officer found that Ms. Zgainer testified credibly regarding the particulars of her program, the services provided to STUDENT at Madison, and the progress he has made since attending her class. Ms. Zgainer stated that she starts the school year using “Soar to Success,” a program she uses with groups of no more than six students at a time. STUDENT was grouped with four other students who needed more attention than their peers, and they worked together with her for forty-five minutes each day. The program has five main focus areas, including clarifying phonics, summarizing a section of a story or an entire story, predictions of the next section of a story, and answering questions about a story. There are eighteen books in the program, with the lower levels having more pictures and each story based on a four- or five-day plan. Ms. Zgainer testified that they finished the Soar to Success program sometime in the beginning of March 2001, and they are now using grade-level text and doing traditional guided reading for forty minutes each day and adding on skills from the comprehension guide published by the District.
Ms. Zgainer also uses response journals in her class, where the students write about what they learned, what they already know, and what they want to know. According to Ms. Zgainer, this exercise activates the students’ prior knowledge and shows what they have already learned. She stated that STUDENT had difficulty with the writing portion of this exercise and would copy from her journal or the white board. STUDENT needs one-to-one assistance during writing exercises, which she is able to give him most of the time. (Testimony of Rachel Zgainer.) STUDENT can edit his writing if she shows him what is wrong. Ms. Zgainer also testified that she, along with Mr. Speir, worked on letter and word spacing with STUDENT. STUDENT has problems with periods, capitalization and other punctuation. She also works with students in groups to do guided writing. Then, during the time that she reviews their work, she has time to work directly with STUDENT.
Lerlene Lyles works with the students in groups in Ms. Zgainer’s class for forty-five minutes each day using “Breaking the Code,” a phonics program that focuses on phonemic awareness and writing. (Testimony of Rachel Zgainer.) In the beginning, this program focuses on writing and how to form letters. As of April 2001, STUDENT was still working with this program.
Ms. Zgainer also testified that her class works on inferencing, decoding skills, and comprehension skills. Additionally, Ms. Zgainer’s current aide uses LMB sight words with STUDENT, and he is tested periodically throughout the week. STUDENT is always studying at least five sight words at a time. Additionally, Trudy Cares, the reading specialist, also works on reading with STUDENT on a one-to-one basis for twenty-five minutes at a time, three to four days a week. The other two days a week, Ms. Cares works with STUDENT in a group of no more than six students.
In the area of math, Ms. Zgainer stated that STUDENT is in the “silver group,” which works on basic double digit multiplication (i.e., 25 x 2) and fractions. The current curriculum is designed to give STUDENT basic math skills, since he needs a basic foundation to work from. Modifications are also made to the curriculum because STUDENT is not at the fifth grade level.
Ms. Zganier also testified that she spends a lot of time at STUDENT’s desk, because he needs consistent reminders and he works well with special attention. She makes sure that he is staying on task and doing his work. She also asks other students or another adult to help STUDENT, although STUDENT feels a little uncomfortable with the aides and prefers to work with the other students.
Ms. Zgainer testified that she works on the reading comprehension, writing, and decoding goals from STUDENT’s April 4, 2000 IEP. She also addresses the goals in the January 3, 2001 IEP related to LMB sight words, decoding, reading comprehension, writing, and numbering. (Testimony of Rachel Zgainer.) Finally, Ms. Zgainer stated that STUDENT is receiving all of the program modifications identified on page 15 of the January 3, 2001 IEP.
The Hearing Officer notes, however, that Ms. Zgainer very candidly and sincerely testified that because she is not a special education teacher, she does not know about all of STUDENT’s disabilities. She stated that she understood that he had aphasia and a speech and language problem, but she does not specifically know the names of the disorders. She also stated that she needs more information about STUDENT in order to better modify his curriculum. Notwithstanding Ms. Zgainer’s testimony regarding her lack of knowledge of the specific names of STUDENT’s disorders, and her expressed need for additional information about STUDENT, the Hearing Officer places considerable weight on her testimony because every aspect of her program that she so conscientiously explained addressed an aspect of STUDENT’s identified disability and his specific needs. Ms. Zgainer testified that she addresses STUDENT’s reading, writing and math goals, gives STUDENT special attention and individual instruction, and implements all of the program modifications identified in the January 3, 2001 IEP. Moreover, the evidence establishes that STUDENT is making progress towards his goals and objectives, appears happy, is comfortable in that setting, and now has a positive attitude about going to school. (Resp.’s Exh. 72; Testimony of MOTHER.)
The full inclusion specialist comes to Ms. Zgainer’s class on Fridays and works with STUDENT’s group, but focuses on STUDENT. (Testimony of Rachel Zgainer.) The inclusion specialist assists Ms. Zgainer by making recommendations for modifications of her program for STUDENT. The inclusion specialist assesses STUDENT to determine what he might need, which in turn, helps Ms. Zgainer. (Id.)
STUDENT also receives RSP services on a pull-out basis two periods a day for reading, written expression, and math. There are 4-5 students in STUDENT’s group during RSP and the students work at a fan-shaped table with an aide. (Testimony of Donald Speir.) STUDENT is currently working on comprehension skills with exercises that require him to read passages, draw inferences, and answer questions using the LMB visualizing/verbalizing (V/V) technique. The RSP at Madison now only uses the V/V questioning technique when working on STUDENT’s comprehension. (Testimony of Donald Speir.) According to Mr. Speir, his aide is excellent at using the V/V technique when questioning the students. Mr. Speir also testified that his experience in using the LMB methods includes a five day training, three days of which was in LiPs and two days training in the V/V method. Mr. Speir also spent one year reviewing software for the LMB ADD program.
During RSP, STUDENT also works on sentence formation, capitalization, punctuation, paragraph formation, and sight words using the LMB sight word list. These activities are done as a whole group; however students may also receive individual instruction. (Testimony of Donald Speir.) Although STUDENT receives his RSP instruction from a noncredentialed instructional aide, Mr. Speir testified that both he and his aide work on the written language skills, and he is always present in the room when STUDENT is receiving instruction.
Mr. Speir also testified that STUDENT receives small-group instruction with five or six other students in math, where he works on regrouping in addition. The math, reading, writing, and numbers goals written in the January 3, 2001, are all currently being addressed in RSP.
Gail Stoter has provided speech and language services to STUDENT on a pull-out basis twice a week since September 2000. STUDENT receives these services with two other children and Ms. Stoter believes that the small-group atmosphere helps STUDENT with social and pragmatic skills. Ms. Stoter testified that she has incorporated the language arts goals from the January 3, 2001 IEP into STUDENT’s instructional time.
The LMB Seeing Stars and V/V methods that are currently being used with STUDENT both in the classroom and in RSP, along with the other related services and classroom instruction, specifically address STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goals and objectives in the January 3, 2001 IEP adequately address STUDENT’s needs. Again, the evidence does not show that STUDENT requires an intensive, one-on-one LMB clinic-based program for a sixteen to twenty-four week period. STUDENT’s program was designed to cover all aspects of his IEP and took into consideration the recommendations made by the District’s school psychologist and speech pathologist.
However, one flaw that the Hearing Officer found in STUDENT’s current program is related to the number of transitions he is required to make throughout the day. In October 2000, MOTHER expressed some concern that STUDENT was required to go in and out of too many places during his school day. (Resp.’s Exh. 63.) STUDENT is pulled out of class on four different occasions during the day for RSP, speech and language, OT, and to see the reading specialist. (Testimony of Donald Speir.) There was also testimony that for a two week period, STUDENT did not show up to the room to see his reading specialist and no one knew where he went during those times. Moreover, Ms. Zgainer testified that STUDENT has problems transitioning from one activity to the next. She put signs on STUDENT’s desk to remind him of his schedule; however, he tears them off his desk. She believes he may be embarrassed having the signs on his desk. (Testimony of Rachel Zgainer.)
Notwithstanding the disruption to STUDENT’s day due to the many transitions to different classrooms,(Footnote 3) and Ms. Zgainer’s uncertainty regarding the specifics of STUDENT’s disability, the evidence establishes that the placement, program, and services provided pursuant to the January 3, 2001 IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
The evidence also establishes that STUDENT’s January 3, 2001 IEP was reasonably calculated to provide him with reasonable educational benefit. First, STUDENT’s program was individualized based on current assessments and his performance. Additionally, all of the District personnel working with STUDENT essentially testified that STUDENT has made more than minimal progress since he has been in Ms. Zgainer’s class at Madison and receiving related services and instruction in RSP. (See also Resp.’s Exhs. 75-77.) Ms. Zgainer testified that STUDENT was more secure and confident in his reading due to his work with the Soar to Success books. Ms. Zgainer also reported that in January 2001, STUDENT passed the District’s mid-third-grade fiction and nonfiction reading running records and scored five out of six on both fiction and nonfiction mid-third-grade comprehension sections. (Resp.’s Exhs. 76 & 77.) STUDENT has already passed the language arts benchmark regarding his reading level five months ahead of schedule and is now writing sentences that are much more “verbose” and using capital letters and punctuation. (Testimony of Rachel Zgainer; Resp.’s Exh. 72, pg. 6.)
Mr. Speir testified that, currently, STUDENT is not performing at the fourth or fifth grade level in any academic area. However, STUDENT has made progress since the October 2000 IEP meeting in that he is now performing at the mid-third-grade level in reading, the mid- to high-second grade level in math, and the second- to third-grade level in written language. Mr. Speir also stated that they are very satisfied with STUDENT’s decoding skills and he is meeting his goals in this area.
The IEP dated January 3, 2001, states that STUDENT already met one of his language arts goals and partially met four of his other math and language arts goals. Additionally, the IEP team concluded that with RSP support, STUDENT is making progress toward his IEP goals, and socially, STUDENT has shown a higher comfort level, and has grown socially this year while in Ms. Zgainer’s class at Madison. (Resp.’s Exh. 72.) The evidence thus demonstrates that STUDENT received positive academic and nonacademic benefits. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement, program, and services pursuant to the January 3, 2001 IEP were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Lastly, the parties do not dispute that the District’s January 3, 2001 offer conformed to the IEP. In fact, MOTHER testified that STUDENT has been receiving the support and services listed on the IEP dated January 3, 2001, since September 2000, even though there was no IEP meeting held in September 2000. There is no dispute that the District provided the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives in the IEP dated January 3, 2001. Because the program, placement, and services met STUDENT’s needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to the IEP, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE from January 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year.
As noted earlier, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the period from September 2000 to January 2, 2001. However, given the fact that the Hearing Officer concluded the services provided in the January 3, 2001 IEP were appropriate and because the District has provided these services since September 2000, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has suffered no harm due to the District’s failure to timely offer a FAPE pursuant to an IEP. This failure did not result in STUDENT’s losing educational opportunity, nor did it seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process. (W.G. v. Board of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)
3. Does Petitioner currently require an educational program that includes the provision of an initial three hundred twenty (320) hours (20 hours/per week for 16 weeks) of an intensive program to develop his language and literacy skills, such as that offered by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, and ongoing treatment as thereafter determined?
The Hearing Officer does not reach this issue given the decision regarding the first two issues.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 4, 2000 to the end of the 1999/2000 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue, except to the extent that the District made a non-prejudicial error by failing to make an appropriate written offer of FAPE for the time period including September 2000 to January 2, 2001.
3. Does Petitioner currently require an educational program that includes the provision of an initial three hundred twenty (320) hours (20 hours/per week for 16 weeks) of an intensive program to develop his language and literacy skills, such as that offered by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, and ongoing treatment as thereafter determined?
This issue was not adjudicated.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: July 9, 2001 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Petitioner also argues that STUDENT’s IEP meetings were not convened in a timely manner and that there was no annual IEP held in 1997. However, these two issues were raised for the first time in Petitioner’s closing brief, and therefore, will not be considered by the Hearing Officer.
Footnote 2: The Lindamood-Bell ADD program has since been renamed the Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing (LiPS) program. Footnote 3: The Hearing Officer notes that this issue of STUDENT “getting lost” on his way to RSP or to his related services causes the Hearing Officer great concern. Because there was significant testimony at the hearing regarding the many transitions STUDENT is required to make each day, the Hearing Officer strongly recommends that the District convene an IEP team meeting to reevaluate the manner in which STUDENT receives his RSP and related services.
