California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 6, 2001

Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1048-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara

Colton Joint Unified denied FAPE for over three years and must provide compensatory Lindamood-Bell reading therapy near the student's home school.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. Before the hearing, an interim mediated agreement funded the Lindamood-Bell program for the first semester of 1999-2000.

Summary

A high school student with specific learning disabilities challenged Colton Joint Unified School District's special education program. For years his IEPs repeated the same reading, writing and math goals in a resource specialist program (RSP). His skills stayed at about a third- to fourth-grade level, and District witnesses admitted he got no educational benefit. After mediation, the District paid for a full-day Lindamood-Bell program for the first semester of 1999-2000. In December 1999 it ended that placement. It offered to return him to Colton High School with Corrective Reading, Writing and Math classes plus one hour a day of Lindamood therapy. His parent kept him home instead.

The Hearing Officer found that the District denied FAPE in 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99. The District did not change his program even though it knew he was not progressing, and it did not deliver the Corrective Reading class his IEPs called for. For spring 2000, the District had decided in advance to end the Lindamood placement. Its reading offer also failed. He had already taken Corrective Reading without progress, and the District had no staff trained in Lindamood's Seeing Stars program. The math and writing classes and the home-school setting were appropriate. As compensatory education, the District must provide two hours a day of Lindamood therapy for the rest of 2000-01 and eight summer weeks, plus transportation. It must also provide Corrective Math and Writing, supported general education classes, and credit-bearing extended school year classes.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled IEPs that repeated unmet goals despite flat test scores. It also addressed a district ending a trial private placement using progress data it never asked for. Under the Rowley standard, the Hearing Officer held that an offer can fail if it meets some needs but not a major one like reading.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years?

    The District kept the same RSP services and goals year after year, knowing the student was not progressing, and admitted he got no educational benefit. It also failed to deliver the Corrective Reading program in his IEPs. This denied FAPE in all three years.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year?

    The District decided in advance to end the Lindamood placement. Its reading offer repeated a Corrective Reading program that had already failed, and it added only one hour a day of Lindamood therapy without staff trained in Seeing Stars. This denied FAPE, even though the math and writing classes and the home-school setting were appropriate.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. If the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any or all of the above school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?

    The equities favored the student, so he received compensatory Lindamood LIPS and Seeing Stars therapy near his home high school rather than the requested 24 weeks of full-day therapy at the distant Lindamood site.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within ten business days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting and make a placement offer consistent with the decision (return to neighborhood high school as set out in Issue 3).
  • Compensatory education. Two hours per day of Lindamood LIPS and Seeing Stars programs for the rest of the 2000-2001 school year, at least one hour per day individual. The instructor must be trained in both programs. If District staff are not trained, the District must get the services from a nonpublic agency or tutor within two weeks. Any provider the student travels to must be within 30 miles of his high school.
  • Compensatory education. An additional eight weeks of Lindamood therapy, two hours per day, five days per week, during the 'summer of the 2000-2001 school year.' The District chooses a trained provider, who may be outside the 30-mile radius if the parties agree.
  • Reimbursement. The District must either transport the student to Lindamood services (school year and summer) or reimburse the parent for round-trip transportation at the District mileage rate.
  • Order to provide or change services. On return to his home school: Corrective Math and Corrective Writing classes, general education physical education, and other general education classes with appropriate accommodations, modifications, assistive technology, and individual aide support (Hearing Officer preferred Mr. Knudsvig's Corrective Math class but did not order it).
  • Order to provide or change services. Offer the student a choice of classes in an RSP extended school year program that provide course credits needed for high school graduation.

Total: 80 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Seattle School District v. B.S.; Union School District v. Smith; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696; Todd v. Andrews; Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts

People named in the decision

  • Christopher Russell, educational advocate/consultant for Student, ABC Child Advocacy
  • Angelica Dirtadian, regional director of development, nonpublic agency; witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell Learning Process
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Process, nonpublic agency providing reading remediation
  • Richard Pesqueira, school psychologist and counselor, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Rosemary Bratkowski, coordinator of special education, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Bonnie Russell-Hunt, director of pupil services, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager, East Valley SELPA
  • Alan Anapolski, resource specialist teacher, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • MaryAnne Phillips, SELPA program specialist, East Valley SELPA
  • Kaye Sheffeld, speech and language specialist, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Troy Knudsvig, resource specialist teacher (Corrective Math; student's summer school teacher), Colton Joint Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Poway, California, on April 25, 26, September 19, 20, 21, November 28, 29, and 30, 2000.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter Petitioner or STUDENT ) was represented by attorney Tania Whiteleather with the Law Offices of Tania Whiteleather. Also appearing on behalf of the Petitioner was educational advocate, Christopher Russell with ABC Child Advocacy. The Petitioner’s mother MOTHER, was also present on Petitioner’s behalf.

Respondent Colton Joint Unified School District (hereinafter Colton or District) was represented by attorney Andrew Arczynski, with the law firm of Filarsky & Watt. Also present on the District’s behalf was Bonnie Russell-Hunt, the District’s director of pupil services, and Gail Lindberg, program manager with East Valley Special Education Local Planning Agency (hereinafter SELPA)

The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Angelica Dirtadian, regional director of development for Lindamood-Bell Learning Process; Christopher Russell, educational consultant; Richard Pesqueira, school psychologist and counselor; Rosemary Bratkowski, District’s coordinator of special education; Bonnie Russell-Hunt, District’s director of pupil services; Gail Lindberg, program manager for East Valley SELPA; and STUDENT, Petitioner.

The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Alan Anapolski, resource specialist teacher; MaryAnne Phillips, SELPA program specialist; Kaye Sheffeld, speech and language specialist; Rosemary Bratkowski, District’s coordinator of special education; Gail Lindberg, program manager for East Valley SELPA; and Troy Knudsvig, resource specialist teacher.

Oral and documentary evidence was received during the hearing, and written closing arguments were submitted thereafter. The record was then closed and the issues were submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL ISSUES

Prior to the hearing, the parties entered into an agreement in which the District agreed to provide the Petitioner with private Lindamood Bell Learning Process services for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. This was an interim, not a final settlement agreement. Consequently, the Petitioner’s contention that he had been denied a free and appropriate education (FAPE) during prior years, as well as the latter portion of the 1999-2000 school year, had not been resolved, and remained issues to be determined at the hearing.

ISSUES

1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years?

2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year?

3. If the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any or all of the above school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner maintains that he made no progress between the l996-97 and the 1998-99 school years. He claims that the Individualized Education Program (IEP) team never reviewed his prior goals and objectives at any IEP meeting to determine whether his goals had been met, and, in fact, they were consistently unmet. He also contends that District testing established that he did not make educational progress during the above years. The Petitioner further alleges that, although the District knew this, it never made substantive changes to his special education program (RSP) to address his lack of progress. The Petitioner further argues that even once the District agreed to provide the Lindamood Bell Learning Process remedial program (hereinafter Lindamood) through a mediated agreement in 1999, it refused to continue the program for an adequate period of time, and failed to offer its own program to appropriately address his needs during the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year.

The Respondent essentially acknowledges that STUDENT did not receive educational benefit from its program during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-1999 school years; that is the primary reason it agreed to try the Lindamood program during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. Instead, the District focuses its attention on the Petitioner’s claim that he required continued Lindamood services to receive a FAPE during the later half of the 1999-2000 school year. The District contends that the evidence provided by Lindamood established that STUDENT did not benefit from the Lindamood program and it would have been inappropriate to continue those services. Moreover, the five-day-a-week, full-day Lindamood program was a highly restrictive environment. It was a substantial distance from STUDENT’s home, it delivered services to STUDENT in isolation or with a tutor, and it did not offer access to the required high school curriculum, team sports, or social activities. The District further alleges that it had instituted a District-wide, systematic remedial academic program, that when combined with District taught Lindamood programs, would have met STUDENT’s individual educational needs as well as have allowed him to return to the least restrictive environment (LRE) of his home school.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is currently an eleventh-grade student with specific learning disabilities in multiple areas. He has a medical diagnosis of attention deficit disorder (ADD). There are some references in the records to a past diagnosis of Oppositional Defiance Disorder (ODD). STUDENT is not currently attending school. After completing the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year in a nonpublic agency’s remediation program, STUDENT’s mother withdrew him from school. MOTHER disagreed with the District’s offer to return STUDENT to his home school with District provided special education services for the second semester. STUDENT has not returned to school, nor has he received any other educational services since that date. He has now been out of school for approximately one year.

STUDENT was first identified by the District as learning disabled during the second grade. The Individual Education Program (IEP) team determined that STUDENT had deficits in all academic areas and developed goals to address math, reading, and language arts. Each subsequent year’s IEP addressed his continued needs in the same areas of math, language and reading. During his elementary school years, STUDENT made some progress on his math goals, however he never met his reading or language goals. The IEP team essentially continued STUDENT’s unmet goals and objectives from one annual IEP to the next without changing his program and services.

At an IEP meeting held in May 1996 to prepare for STUDENT’s transition to middle school, the IEP team again determined that “STUDENT will continue with RSP support at the middle school level in content areas for three periods per day. Social studies/Science, math and language arts.” These are the services STUDENT received during his first year of middle school, until his mother called for an IEP meeting in March of the 1996-97 school year. MOTHER was distressed that STUDENT’s report card for the first semester had contained several “D’s.” In response to MOTHER’s concerns, the District changed STUDENT’s placement to a special day class (SDC) combined with RSP collaboration in science and history. His goals and objectives were unchanged. STUDENT’s physical education and enrichment classes continued to be in the general education program. Pursuant to MOTHER’S request to monitor STUDENT’s progress, the team agreed to meet again in June 1997 to discuss the effectiveness of this SDC placement. Because STUDENT was causing disruptions in class and failing to complete his assignments and homework, the IEP team met on April 29, 1997, rather than the planned meeting in June 1997. The IEP team was designated to act in the capacity of a pre-discipline panel. The team continued STUDENT’s placement in the SDC, with the exception of P.E. where he remained with his general education peers. A positive intervention plan was developed to respond to behavioral concerns identified as “impulsive; acts first; regrets later; cannot block out behaviors of others.” The IEP team identified the following behaviors and intervention strategies:

BEHAVIOR INTERVENTION

“Does not do h.w.” “Homework chart done and turned in” “Talks” “Behavior chart for good periods” “Distracts others” “Front of line lunch pass”

On May 19, 1997, the IEP team met for an annual review of STUDENT’s IEP. It was agreed that STUDENT would remain in the SDC for the remainder of the school year. He was also to be required to do one-and-a-half hours of extra work at home to catch up on his schoolwork, and have no more discipline referrals for the remainder of the year. If he did not complete his schoolwork and/or he had more referrals, the team stated that he could be referred to the District’s discipline panel. If STUDENT complied with the two requirements, he was to be “promoted to the eight grade and probably placed in a regular program.”

STUDENT completed the seventh grade and entered the eighth in the 1997-98 school year. On November 21, 1997, the IEP team met and changed STUDENT’s placement from the SDC after deciding that his behaviors had improved and needs could now be met in a less restrictive RSP program. He was returned to general education classes with RSP support to continue his same goals and objectives. Near the end of the first semester, an IEP meeting was convened to review STUDENT’s progress in the RSP program. It was reported that his efforts to complete his assignments had increased, and both his grades and behaviors had improved from the prior year. His primary problem remained talking in class. It was also agreed that STUDENT would be placed in the District’s reading program entitled “Corrective Reading” when the second semester began.

A three-year reevaluation was conducted on May 15, 1998, while STUDENT was in the eighth grade. Because STUDENT is an African-American student, the District did not administer an intelligence quotient (IQ) test. It relied instead upon alternate methods to determine his ability level, which it found to be in the low average range. Academic testing showed low skills in all academic areas, with significant struggles in reading, mathematics, and written language. The assessor recommended continued special education placement with a specific focus on the development of basic academic skills in reading, writing, and math. At an IEP meeting held on May 19, 1998, the results of the three-year reassessment were reviewed and STUDENT’s transition to high school for the 1998-99 school year was discussed. The District proposed continuing the same services in high school that STUDENT had received in middle school, one hundred and twenty minutes per week of RSP support and continued placement in the Corrective Reading program. STUDENT also was to attend both summer sessions of the District’s Jump Start program. This is not a special education extended school year program. Jump Start classes are offered to all entering high school students to help prepare them for high school. It was also agreed that over the summer, STUDENT would read daily at home, practice the DOLCH high-frequency word list, and complete math workbooks supplied by the District.

STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was held in June 1999, to assess the progress he had made during the ninth grade, review his continued needs, and determine his tenth grade placement. Although the IEP notes state that his last year’s goals were reviewed, as with each of STUDENT’s previous IEPs, there is nothing to indicate whether he met them, nor is there any reference to his academic progress. The IEP does mention concerns about STUDENT’s attendance, behavior, and disciplinary referrals, but does not provide responses to these problems. Although STUDENT’s last IEP stated that he would continue in the Corrective Reading program, this IEP suggests that he did not receive it when it states that “STUDENT can benefit from the Corrective Reading program if available.” The same RSP collaboration combined with pull-out services was continued for the tenth grade. The District agreed to MOTHER’s request for testing to determine STUDENT’s ability levels.

The testing requested by the mother was conducted in August 1999. Using the Brigance Test of Reading Mastery, STUDENT scored at a 2.0 grade level in word recognition with oral reading skills at a 3.1 grade level. On the Wide Range Achievement Test, Third Edition (WRAT-3), STUDENT’s total reading was at the third grade level. His total writing ability on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) was at a 2.2 grade equivalency, and his math skills were at a 4.5 grade level on the Woodcock-Johnson, Revised (WJ-R). The assessor concluded that these scores were essentially unchanged from those obtained by STUDENT one year earlier during the three-year reevaluation.

Believing that STUDENT was not making progress despite years of special education, MOTHER filed for a due process hearing. Through mediation and a resulting IEP meeting, the parties implemented an interim agreement whereby STUDENT would attend a full-day Lindamood program at District expense for three months. (In a subsequent agreement, the Lindamood program was continued until the end of the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year.) It was further agreed that another IEP meeting would be held in December 1999 to review STUDENT’s progress with the Lindamood services and determine whether it should be continued. At that IEP meeting, held on December 2, 1999, the District team members stated their concern that Lindamood had failed to submit adequate information to assess STUDENT’s progress in the program. In particular, there was no information regarding STUDENT’s progress on the IEP goals and objectives written by the District for the Lindamood program. The District IEP team members did review the only information received from Lindamood, scores from its pre-admission and post-service testing. Based on these test scores, they decided that STUDENT was not benefitting from the Lindamood program. The District also determined that its sequential Corrective Reading, Writing, and Math programs, combined with a District provided Lindamood program could meet STUDENT’s educational needs. It refused MOTHER’s request to continue funding the Lindamood program and offered STUDENT an RSP program at his home school.

Believing that STUDENT would be harmed emotionally and educationally by returning to a District program, MOTHER removed him from school and continued to hearing on the issues presented herein. STUDENT remained out of school during the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year and he has not currently returned for the 2000-2001 school year. He has not received educational services from any source during these months.

FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE ONE

Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years?

“Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . ” 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), “free and appropriate public education” means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the students individualized education program.

In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed placement. The criteria are not whether the parents desire another program, or if that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987) In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court held that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S., 24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); Rowley, supra.

As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.

Special education law also requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment can occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes, with the use of supplementary aids and services, cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code §56031.

Pursuant to the above law, a district has complied with its statutory obligations to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services: (1) is designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) provides the student with some educational benefit; (3) conforms to the student’s individual education program; and (4) occurs in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.

School districts must offer a disabled student an appropriate placement that meets his or her unique needs each school year. The Hearing Officer, therefore, would typically conduct a separate analysis of the appropriateness of the District’s offer of placement and services for each school year in which a denial of a FAPE is alleged. In this case, however, the District acknowledges that its special education services remained essentially unchanged during the1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years. The Hearing Officer will therefore set forth the facts relevant to each of the elements of a FAPE for these school years as a group.

1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years

1. Did the District identify and then design an individual program to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

A determination of STUDENT’s unique special education needs is a prerequisite to evaluating the appropriateness of the District’s program in responding to his needs. In this case, STUDENT’s areas of deficit are undisputed by the parties. The parties agree that STUDENT has a specific learning disability in attention and concentration. He also demonstrates significant visual-perceptual difficulties, with visual-motor and memory delays. Another contributing factor to his learning difficulties is his medical diagnoses of attention deficit disorder (ADD) and oppositional-defiance disorder (ODD). STUDENT struggles in all of his core classes with particular difficulties in reading, written language, and mathematics.

The IEP documents and the testimony of witnesses for both the Petitioner and Respondent established that the program offered to STUDENT by the District remained essentially unchanged between the 1996-97 and 1998-99 school years. With the exception of the period between March 1997, through November 1997, when STUDENT was placed in a combination SDC/RSP program, STUDENT’s program consisted of two-to-three daily periods of RSP collaboration and pull-out. The March 7, 1997 IEP meeting that resulted in partial SDC placement was not initiated by the District. It occurred solely as a result of MOTHER’s request for an IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s low grades. Although the District changed STUDENT’s placement from RSP to a combination of RSP and SDC at this meeting, it did not make any changes in STUDENT’s goals and objectives, nor did it discuss or implement any new strategies to respond to STUDENT’s lack of academic progress. The District appears to have had a purpose other than STUDENT’s academic needs for placing him in the SDC. The focus of the IEP meetings while STUDENT was in an SDC was behavioral, not educational. This creates the impression that the District used the SDC placement, not for academic reasons, but as both “a carrot and a stick” to gain desired behavior from STUDENT. The District threatened a referral to the District Discipline Panel if STUDENT’s behavior did not improve in the SDC. Alternatively, the District promised that STUDENT could return to general education with RSP support if his behavior, attendance, and school performance improved. Finding that STUDENT had improved his behaviors, the IEP team determined that his needs could be met by returning to general education classes with RSP support in November 1997.

During the second semester of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT’s IEP called for placement in the District’s Corrective Reading program. Pursuant to his IEP, he was to continue this program during the 1998-99 school year. However, the District witnesses specifically testified that STUDENT did not receive Corrective Reading during the 1997-98 school year, and the records and testimony established that he also did not receive it during the 1998-99 school year.

The Hearing Officer finds it irrefutable that year after year, the District offered STUDENT a comparable type and level of service, with the same goals to improve his reading, writing and math skills, knowing full-well that he was not making academic progress. Rosemary Bratkowski, the District’s coordinator of special education, admitted that even though all of the evidence available indicated that STUDENT was not making educational progress, no program adjustments were made at his IEP meetings. When STUDENT’s placement was changed to include an SDC, the change was not accompanied by new academic goals or new educational approaches. It was, instead, accompanied by a Behavior Modification Plan (BMP) that addressed disruptive behaviors and a failure to complete homework. The BMP did not acknowledge any relationship between STUDENT’s conduct and his disability, and it did not suggest methods to help him control his impulsive actions or perform his school and homework. When the District did make an offer of a systematic remedial reading program, it later claimed that it did not provide it. These facts convince the Hearing Officer that although the District recognized STUDENT’s significant academic needs, it consistently failed to offer a program designed to meet those needs during any of the school years between 1996-97 and 1998-99.

2. Did the District’s program provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

Each year, the IEP team convened its annual meeting for the stated purpose of assessing STUDENT’s progress during the prior year. However, the District witnesses acknowledged that at each of the IEP meetings held during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99, school years, the District failed to record whether STUDENT had met his prior year’s goals and objectives. The fact that STUDENT’s goals were simply continued to the next year, or reworded as new goals to accomplish old tasks, persuasively establishes that, with the exception of minor gains in math, STUDENT never met his goals and objectives for any of the above school years. Over each of these years, STUDENT’s test scores also consistently showed the absence of educational gains. Near the end of the 1996-97 school year, the District measured STUDENT’s reading level on the Brigance Oral Reading Test at a 4.0 grade level. His math tested at a 4.9 grade level, and his written language at a 4.5 grade level. During the summer of 1999, STUDENT’s reading level was at 3.0 grade level on both the Brigance and the WRAT-3. The grade levels of his math skills were: calculation 4.5 and applied problems 4.9. His total writing score was at a 2.2 grade level. Thus, all indicators were that this was a student who not only was failing to improve, but was falling further behind each school year. The District did not respond to this information during any of the relevant school years.

The District’s own witnesses provided the strongest evidence that STUDENT did not receive educational benefit from its program. Bonnie Russell-Hunt, the director of pupil services, who had attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings since 1992, testified that the District’s documents did not indicate that STUDENT had made adequate progress during the seven years of District-provided services; there was no evidence he had ever met his IEP goals; nor did his assessments show progress. Gail Lindberg, program manager for the East Valley SELPA, acknowledged that STUDENT’s test scores over seven years had not improved. Richard Pesqueira, a District school psychologist and counselor, tested STUDENT in 1999. Mr. Pesqueira testified that based upon his review of STUDENT’s prior test scores, he found that STUDENT had not evidenced any statistically significant gains. Rosemary Bratkowski stated that when comparing STUDENT’s scores on the WIAT and the Brigance from his fifth grade through the present in reading, writing, spelling, and math, they showed insignificant improvement. She further testified that STUDENT made “no significant progress from the District’s special education program,” and ultimately concluded that STUDENT had received no educational benefit while with the District.

Given the above information and admissions, it can only be concluded that STUDENT did not receive any education benefit from the District’s program during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years.

3. Did the District’s program conform to STUDENT’s individual education program?

The District acknowledges that it did not comply with STUDENT’s IEPs during the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. Interestingly, it argues that it did not provide the Corrective Reading Program specified in STUDENT’s IEPs for 1997-98, 1998-99 as justification for its contention that its offer of placement in this same program was appropriate for the1999-2000 school year. Confronted with questions of how the Corrective Reading Program could be an effective approach to STUDENT’s difficulties in the 1999-2000 school year, when he had already received it for one-and-a-half years without benefit, the District witnesses maintained that he had not actually received the program specified in his 1997-98 and 1998-99 IEPs.

Ms. Russell-Hunt testified on rebuttal that she had conducted an investigation and confirmed her recollection that the Corrective Reading Program was not available in the District’s middle schools as a consistent five-day-a-week class during the 1997-98 school year. Consequently, it could not have been provided as specified in STUDENT’s IEP for that year. She stated that, at most, STUDENT could have received some aspects of Corrective Reading sporadically in his language arts class. Ms. Russell-Hunt also testified that, contrary to his IEP, STUDENT was not in a Corrective Reading class during the 1998-99 school year. Mr. Pesqueira stated that to his knowledge, STUDENT had never received the Corrective Reading Program, as did Ms. Bratskowski.

Based upon other evidence that will be discussed later, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District’s claim that STUDENT did not receive Corrective Reading during the 1997-98 school year. However, the Hearing Officer is not going to dispute a District admission that it did not comply with STUDENT’s IEP for the 1997-98 school year. The Hearing Officer does agree that the evidence establishes that STUDENT did not receive the Corrective Reading Program specified in his IEP for the 1998-99 school year. As a result, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not implement the Corrective Reading Program specified in STUDENT’s IEPs during the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. It is further determined that none of the IEPs for the 1996-97 through 1998-99 school years were adequate. Thus, even had these IEPs been fully implemented, they would not have provided STUDENT with an appropriate education.

4. Was the District’s offer of placement in the least restrictive environment?

This was not a disputed issue between the parties for the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years.

The above evidence establishes that the District did not offer STUDENT placements and services during the three years at issue that were designed to meet his unique needs, provide him with educational benefit, or conform to his individual education programs. This constitutes a denial of a FAPE during each of the above school years.

ISSUE TWO

Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year?

The parties agreed that STUDENT would attend a full time Lindamood program for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. Therefore, this portion of the school year is not contested between the parties. The dispute arises out of the District’s refusal to continue the Lindamood program during the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year, and the Petitioner’s further contention that the District’s placement offer for this semester was inappropriate. The Hearing Officer will therefore address the District’s offer of placement and services for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year.

As discussed in the preceding issue, the District’s prior programs had not bestowed demonstrative benefits upon STUDENT. Consequently, the District agreed to a trial semester of the Lindamood program to determine whether it would be advantageous to STUDENT. At the conclusion of the semester, MOTHER believed that the Lindamood program was helping her son and she wanted it to continue. The District maintained that STUDENT had not improved with the Lindamood services, and that the Lindamood environment was too restrictive. The District further claimed that its proposed program for the second semester was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. Thus, the issue presented for the Hearing Officer’s determination is not whether the Lindamood program preferred by the mother would have been a better placement for STUDENT, for a student is not entitled to the best services available, but whether the District’s offer of placement would have addressed STUDENT’s needs, provided him with some educational benefit; conformed to his IEP; and occurred in the least restrictive environment. Seattle School District v. B.S.,; Union School District v. Smith; Rowley, supra.

1. Did the District identify and then design an individual program to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

Again, STUDENT’s areas of deficits during this school year are not in dispute. Everyone acknowledged that his overriding, immediate need was to increase his abilities to read, write, and do mathematical calculations. Because his needs had not been met in the past, STUDENT entered the tenth grade with academic skills commensurate with those of third and fourth grade students. Although the parties agree that STUDENT is delayed in all academic areas, the main focus of all hearing participants was on his inability to read. They dispute whether Lindamood services or the District’s Corrective Reading Program would best address his needs in this area. To determine whether the Lindamood methodology might be effective in responding to STUDENT’s severe delays, the District had agreed to place him in an intensive, full-time Lindamood program for the first semester of this school year. When the Lindamood placement was made in August 1999, the parties also agreed that another IEP meeting would be held in December 1999. The purpose of that IEP meeting would be to evaluate STUDENT’s progress after several weeks of Lindamood therapy and decide whether he should continue in that placement. The IEP team convened as agreed on December 2, 1999. Richard Pesqueira is the District school psychologist who conducted testing in August 1999 to determine STUDENT’s academic performance levels as he began tenth grade. Mr. Pesqueria attended both the August 1999 IEP meeting that determined STUDENT’s Lindamood placement and the December 2, 1999 IEP meeting to review his progress in that placement. Mr. Pesqueira stated that STUDENT needed a multi-modality educational program administered in a small group setting of five to seven students. The program should have a strong phonics component and emphasize word meanings and language development.

It was Mr. Pesqueria’s opinion that the District’s multi-sensory Corrective Reading program would meet STUDENT’s needs as well as return him to his home school. Based upon his analysis of the Lindamood test scores obtained when STUDENT entered the program, and his test scores three months later, he determined that STUDENT did not show appreciable growth. Any variations among the first set of scores and the second, appeared to be within the standard error of measurement, and were therefore statistically insignificant. Mr. Pesqueria also testified that because the two sets of tests were administered in close proximity, the scores were suspect due to a “practice effect.” A practice effect can occur when the same test is given to the same individual without adequate time (usually one year) elapsing between the administration of the two tests. It is thought that the familiarity gained from prior exposure to the test benefits the test taker when the same test is readministered, and thereby invalidates the second test scores. STUDENT’s initial Lindamood testing occurred in August 1999, and he was retested using the same test instruments in November 1999. Because only three months had elapsed between the pre and post testing, Mr. Pesqueria believed that any variations reflected between the two sets of test scores, should be attributed to a practice effect, not acquired knowledge. He therefore concluded that the available evidence indicated that Lindamood was an inappropriate placement, which was not benefitting STUDENT.

Rosemary Bratkowski also attended the December 1999 IEP meeting to discuss the effectiveness of STUDENT’s Lindamood program. In conjunction with Mr. Pesqueria, she too had tested STUDENT in August 1999. The primary purpose of Ms. Bratkowski’s testing was to establish STUDENT’s baseline performance levels before he began Lindamood. Ms. Bratkowski also helped draft the goals and objectives intended to measure STUDENT’s progress while attending Lindamood. She testified that STUDENT should have a multi-sensory program with the following components: decoding; word attack; contextual meaning; comprehension; immediate feedback; and be taught through direct teacher instruction rather than self-instruction. Ms. Bratowski said that Lindamood did not provide any information for the December IEP meeting about STUDENT’s progress on the IEP goals and objectives applicable to the Lindamood placement. Thus, there was no evidence of educational growth, or that Lindamood was providing a program directed toward STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Bratkowski testified that the District’s Corrective Reading program was appropriate for STUDENT. It met his need for a multi-sensory program and it had a high degree of success in enabling the student to transfer the skills learned in the program to the general curriculum. She therefore recommended that STUDENT be placed at his home high school and provided the Corrective programs.

Gail Lindberg attended STUDENT’s August and December 1999 IEP meetings on behalf of the SELPA to assist the District with STUDENT’s placement. Bonnie Russell-Hunt attended these meetings as the District’s administrator. Both Ms. Russell-Hunt and Ms. Lindberg testified that Lindamood did not send a representative to the December IEP meeting, nor did it provide information regarding STUDENT’s progress on the goals and objectives drafted by the District for the Lindamood program. Thus, there was insufficient data to establish that STUDENT had received any benefit from Lindamood. Ms. Lindberg and Ms. Russell-Hunt both said that the sole documentation provided by Lindamood for the December 1999 IEP meeting was a comparison of scores from tests given to STUDENT when he entered the Lindamood program and when the same tests were readministered three months later. Ms Lindberg stated that she was familiar with testing procedures and that she concurred with other District witnesses in discounting the Lindamood test results. She agreed that a comparison of the two sets of Lindamood test scores did not indicate meaningful growth, nor were they reliable because they were tainted by a practice effect. Based upon the available information, she believed that STUDENT had not made adequate progress in the Lindamood program to justify its continuation for another semester. Ms. Lindberg and Ms. Russell-Hunt also testified that the appropriate placement for STUDENT was his home school campus receiving daily Corrective Reading, Math, and Writing classes as well as Lindamood therapy provided by a District speech and language therapist.

Each of the District’s IEP team members concluded STUDENT had not made appreciable gains after a semester of Lindamood services and that continued placement in that program would not meet his needs. They testified that the program offered by the District would meet STUDENT’s needs at his home school in a less restrictive environment. Witnesses on behalf of the District testified that the District offered to return STUDENT to Colton High School for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year. His program was to consist of one period per day of each of the Corrective Reading, Writing, and Math classes. The District also offered one period per day of Lindamood therapy to be provided at the high school by the District’s speech therapist. The District witnesses emphasized that the Lindamood program was a very restrictive environment where STUDENT worked alone or with an adult instructor all day. Furthermore, the Lindamood site was located approximately ninety miles one way from STUDENT’s home which necessitated several hours of travel time each day.

The Petitioner maintains that Lindamood is the appropriate program to meet his needs, and he disagrees with the District’s determination that he was making inadequate progress. STUDENT testified that as a result of Lindamood, for the first time in his recollection, he voluntarily reads his favorite magazines. He also told of his increased confidence as well as his improved writing skills since learning the Lindamood method for organizing his written work. MOTHER testified that her son’s progress with Lindamood was dramatic, especially when compared to the absence of improved academic skills over the prior years. For the first time, she saw evidence that STUDENT’s educational needs were being effectively addressed. She was especially gratified to see that his self-esteem was improving. STUDENT’s academic efforts while at Lindamood resulted in success, not failure, which increased his confidence in himself. MOTHER verified that STUDENT was now sounding-out words and self-initiating reading for enjoyment, which he had never done before the Lindamood services. MOTHER also told of STUDENT’s improved writing skills and his ability to complete his homework without her assistance. These observations caused her to believe that the Lindamood program was meeting STUDENT’s needs.

MOTHER believed that the District’s offer to return STUDENT to his home high school with Corrective Reading, Writing and Math classes and some Lindamood therapy was inappropriate. In her opinion, the District was merely offering to return her son to the same Corrective Reading Program that had been tried without benefit in the past. She also found the District’s offer to provide Lindamood therapy inadequate. She did not agree that one hour of therapy was sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. She also understood that the District did not have personnel trained in each of the Lindamood therapies STUDENT required. MOTHER had been advised by Lindamood that its LIPS and Seeing Stars therapies must be provided in conjunction to be effective. According to the testimony of District witnesses, the District only had employees trained in the Lindamood LIPS program. The District also did not employ anyone trained to teach the Lindamood writing techniques, or its Cloud Nine math program. For these reasons, MOTHER rejected the District’s placement offer. She also decided that she would not return STUDENT to school during the pendency of this due process claim. MOTHER determined that it would be emotionally damaging for STUDENT to again be placed in a program that did not meet his needs and at which he could not succeed. Consequently, STUDENT had not attended school at any location since the end of the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year.

Lindamood regional director, Angelica Dirtadian, testified that based upon the initial Lindamood evaluation, STUDENT’s difficulties were “global,” in that he exhibited many language processing problems. His areas of language deficits were: oral and written comprehension; word attack; spelling; recall; sequencing; and reading fluency, decoding, rate, and comprehension. She also found that STUDENT had additional deficits in the areas of visual memory and phonemic awareness. Consequently, STUDENT could not adequately understand and process language. He only grasped fragments of language, and he used vague terms such as “stuff,” “it,” “you know” because he could not recall the correct descriptive words.

Based upon the Lindamood entry testing, Ms. Dirtadian concluded that STUDENT was a sixteen-year-old who possessed the academic skills of an early elementary school student. To address STUDENT’s disabilities, Lindamood provided a six-hour-per-day, five-day-a-week program for sixteen weeks. His program consisted of specific stimulation in phonemic awareness through the LIPS program, increasing his visual memory with the Seeing Stars program, and learning to visualize and retain the mental image of phonemic words and sounds using the Verbalizing and Visualizing (VV) program. STUDENT also worked on math skills with the Cloud Nine program and had one hour of integration in which he worked on his writing skills and the practical applications of his programs.

Ms. Dirtadian expressed her opinion that STUDENT was making progress at Lindamood as evidenced by his growth between his entry testing and that conducted when he left the program in January 2000. She also said that STUDENT no longer needed to write using the Lindamood “hamburger,” drawing method. This technique consisted of first drawing an outline of a hamburger on the paper. The student then creates a paragraph in the proper format by writing the introductory sentence within the top hamburger bun, supporting sentences were written in the areas depicted as the meat, cheese, lettuce, etc., and the concluding sentence was placed in the bottom portion of the hamburger bun. By the end of the semester, STUDENT was able to mentally visualize this hamburger format to write a paragraph. However, despite his improvement, Ms. Dirtadian testified that STUDENT’s academic delays remained substantial and he required continued Lindamood treatment six-hours-per-day, five-days-a-week, for twenty-four additional weeks to address his deficits.

In summary, the District maintained that continued Lindamood therapy was inappropriate for STUDENT because there was no evidence that he was benefitting from that program. It argued that the only information it had from Lindamood was its scores from two testing sessions. The District discounted this information, asserting, one, that the score variations on the two tests were statistically insignificant, and two, that the tests were administered too close together and were therefore unreliable. The District claimed that the information it sought to determine whether STUDENT was benefitting from Lindamood and should continue with that program, was evidence of STUDENT’s progress on the IEP goals and objectives drafted by the District for the Lindamood program. Because Lindamood did not report on STUDENT’s efforts on his goals and objectives, and because it did not send a representative to the December 1999 IEP meeting to describe his program or his progress, the District IEP team members concluded that the Lindamood services were not meeting STUDENT’s needs, and it refused to continue his nonpublic placement. Instead, the District maintained that its offer to return STUDENT to his home school with District provided Lindamood therapy and the multi-sensory Corrective programs would meet his unique needs.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the circular reasoning propounded by the District’s witnesses. Although they claimed that they wanted Lindamood staff present at the IEP meeting, they acknowledged never actually inviting anyone from the program to attend the IEP meeting. It simply mailed a copy of the notice of an IEP meeting to the Lindamood address. Ms. Dirtadian testified that even though she was not asked to attend the December 1999 IEP by the District, she had arranged with the Petitioner’s advocate to participate in the meeting by telephone. Although she was available in her office prepared to discuss STUDENT’s program and progress at the time agreed upon, she was not contacted during the IEP meeting. Both the District and the SELPA representatives further testified that neither of them had made any attempt to notify Lindamood that they required specific information and/or a statement of progress on STUDENT’s IEP goals prior to the December 1999 IEP meeting. In fact, the first request made by the District to Lindamood for information that the District claimed was crucial to placement decisions made at the December 1999 IEP meeting, was correspondence from the SELPA dated two months after the IEP meeting. Lindamood responded to this request with the information sought, including a report on STUDENT’s progress on the IEP goals. The District witnesses testified that this documentation evidenced STUDENT’s growth at Lindamood, and that he had met the majority of his goals and objectives.

Ms. Lindberg testified that neither the SELPA nor the District initiated any communication with Lindamood prior to the December 1999 IEP meeting, nor was Lindamood provided with any guidance concerning the type of information the District wanted regarding STUDENT’s progress. She relies upon the IEP document sent with STUDENT to Lindamood, which stated within the team notes that “a progress report will be provided to the District in November.” Ms. Lindberg maintained that the November retesting conducted by Lindamood was not the progress report referred to in the IEP, and asserted that from this single IEP statement, Lindamood “was just supposed to know what the District wanted.” This contention is not plausible.

The District based its determination that Lindamood was inappropriate for STUDENT on its claim that the test scores were inadequate and that there was no evidence provided that he was making progress on his IEP goals and objectives. It is difficult to understand the District’s reliance on the lack of reports setting forth STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives as a primary justification for terminating STUDENT’s Lindamood services. The IEP document sent to Lindamood upon STUDENT’s admission, contained a clear statement acknowledging that the District’s IEP goals will not be followed at Lindamood. Given this, one wonders how Lindamood could reasonably be expected to know that it should provide the District with information concerning progress on goals and objectives that the IEP document instructed it to disregard.

These actions cause the Hearing Officer to suspect that the District had decided prior to the December 1999 IEP meeting that it was not going to continue STUDENT’s placement at Lindamood. It then relied upon the absence of information it had never sought, and the nonattendance at the IEP meeting of Lindamood personnel it had never invited, to find that the Lindamood program was not beneficial to STUDENT and conclude that he should be removed. This suspicion is strengthened by the District’s admission that it received the documentation it desired in response to the SELPA’s correspondence sent several weeks after the IEP meeting, that the information showed that STUDENT had met the vast majority of his goals, and yet the District did not reconvene the IEP meeting to discuss the information contained in the Lindamood records and reports. In addition, when asked why no attempts were made to acquire the necessary information from Lindamood before the December IEP meeting, or before deciding to terminate his placement, Ms. Lindberg testified that it was already clear that the long distance placement was not going to work for STUDENT, that Lindamood was not initiating adequate communication with the District regarding STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives, and that continued placement in a nonpublic agency would make it difficult to transition STUDENT back to a public high school. These are reasons that are unrelated to STUDENT’s progress with Lindamood services and persuade the Hearing Officer that the District had predetermined that STUDENT would not be returned to Lindamood regardless of his success with the program.

The question thus becomes, once the District decided STUDENT’s placement would not continue at Lindamood, did its alternate offer to attend his home high school, placed in Corrective Reading, Writing, and Math classes with some Lindamood therapy meet his unique needs? The Hearing Officer concludes that it did not, specifically in the area of reading. Ms. Russell-Hunt returned as a rebuttal witness specifically to testify that the District had not provided the Corrective Reading Program specified in STUDENT’s IEP’s for the second semester of eighth grade and all of ninth grade. Ms. Russell-Hunt provided detailed assurances that the District had not implemented Corrective Reading as an independent class at the District’s middle schools during STUDENT’s eighth grade year. Thus, she maintained that Corrective Reading was not a program that had previously been unsuccessful with STUDENT and, therefore, the District’s current offer to provide it would meet STUDENT’s needs.

Although it is undisputed that the District failed to comply with the Corrective Reading portion of STUDENT’s IEP for the ninth grade, Ms. Russell-Hunt’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s enrollment in Corrective Reading during the eighth grade was patently false. MOTHER also returned as a rebuttal witness and produced STUDENT’s report card from the second semester of eighth grade. The report card clearly documented that STUDENT had participated in a five-day-a-week class entitled Corrective Reading for the entire semester. The District admitted that STUDENT had not made any significant gains from the District’s past services. Corrective Reading was one of those prior programs that had failed to benefit STUDENT. Thus, an offer to return him to a program that had been unsuccessfully attempted in the past could not reasonably be calculated to meet his needs.

When asked why the District would offer further Lindamood services if it had determined that this therapy were inappropriate for STUDENT, District witnesses responded that some elements of Lindamood were beneficial to STUDENT. Once again, the Hearing Officer does not agree with the District’s logic in finding that the entire Lindamood program was inappropriate, yet at the same time concluding that it was beneficial enough to be continued. Regardless of the District’s rationale, once offered, the offer must meet STUDENT’s needs and the District must be able to fulfill its offer. STUDENT had been receiving six hours per day of Lindamood therapy. The District offered only one hour per day. The testimony from the Lindamood representative established that to correctly provide the Lindamood methodology, both the LIPS and the Seeing Stars programs must be provided concurrently. This requires more than one hour of instruction per day and it also requires an instructor trained in both programs. The District did not employ personnel qualified to provide the Seeing Stars portion of the Lindamood program. Therefore, this aspect of the District’s offer is also inadequate to meet STUDENT’s needs.

Based upon the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that, specifically in the area of reading, the District did not identify STUDENT’s unique needs or design a program to meet them. The development of reading skills is a significant area of weakness for STUDENT. The District’s failure to appropriately address his reading deficits defeats the appropriateness of the District’s placement offer.

2. Would the District’s program have provided STUDENT with some educational benefit?

District teachers who worked with the Corrective Reading Programs testified credibly about its effectiveness with most students. They described it as a multi-sensory program taught through direct instruction. It utilizes a sequential method in which the student must establish through testing that he or she has mastered one chapter before preceding to the next. In this way the instructor is assured that the student has acquired the foundation necessary to understand and move onto the next level.

The Hearing Officer was impressed with the teachers’ confidence in the Corrective Reading Program, and their description of its methodology. If one did not know STUDENT’s educational history, it would appear to be an appropriate instructional method for him. This was what apparently occurred at STUDENT’s December 1999 IEP meeting. District personnel who had not familiarized themselves with STUDENT’s prior programs determined the placement offer for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year. Ms. Russell-Hunt, Ms. Lindberg, Mr. Pesqueira, and Ms. Bratkowski all participated in the December IEP meeting as District team members, and each agreed that the offer of the Corrective Reading Program was appropriate for STUDENT. They each reiterated this opinion at the hearing. However, these District witnesses also expressed surprise when they learned that two of STUDENT’s prior IEPs had offered the same reading program. They indicated that such knowledge may have affected their position at the December IEP meeting. They were at a loss to explain how offering a program that had previously been unsuccessful with STUDENT (these witnesses had already acknowledged that STUDENT had not received educational benefit from the District’s past programs), would provide educational benefit when reoffered. The District witnesses later tried to overcome the obvious implication that Corrective Reading had not benefitted STUDENT in the past, by claiming that the District had not actually provided the Corrective Reading Program specified in STUDENT’s previous IEPs.

The Hearing Officer accepts the undisputed evidence that establishes that the District did not implement STUDENT’s ninth grade IEP in this regard. However, the District’s testimony that STUDENT did not receive a semester of Corrective Reading during the eighth grade was directly contradicted by the report card furnished by STUDENT’s mother, which plainly stated that he had completed one semester of a five-day-a-week class entitled Corrective Reading. Troy Knudsvig, is a District RSP teacher who currently teaches Corrective Math classes. He had been STUDENT’s summer school teacher and had reviewed some of STUDENT’s educational records prior to testifying. He is also familiar with, and has taught the Corrective Reading Program. Mr. Knudsvig was a knowledgeable witness who appeared to be an unusually talented, motivated, and involved teacher. The Hearing Officer was impressed with his demeanor and found his testimony extremely credible. Mr. Knudsvig was an enthusiastic supporter of the benefits of all of the Corrective Programs. However, he testified that it, like any method, is not successful with every student. He stated that those students who do not benefit from the Corrective Reading Program typically have either behavioral issues and make no effort to learn, or their attention span is so severely impacted that they cannot focus long enough to make academic gains. There are also a few students who do try and who are focused, but still do not succeed with the Corrective Reading Program.

Mr. Knudsvig said he would have expected STUDENT to be a good candidate for the Corrective Reading Program. He had found STUDENT to be a student without behavioral problems, who participated in class, focused on his school work, and was eager to learn. Thus, he did not think that STUDENT displayed the characteristics of those students who generally had difficulties with the Corrective Reading Program. However, Mr. Knudsvig also testified that after attending a Corrective Reading class for a semester, there should have been demonstrative progress if the program were effective for STUDENT. According to Mr. Knudsvig, during the twenty weeks in a school semester, a student would complete two levels of the program. With STUDENT’s entry reading skills at a third to fourth grade level, he should have progressed to a fifth grade reading level after one semester of Corrective Reading. That he made no progress indicates that STUDENT is one of those few students for whom Corrective Reading is ineffective.

All witnesses agreed that STUDENT had not benefitted from the programs previously provided by the District. One of those prior programs was a semester of Corrective Reading. It is conceivable that reexposing STUDENT to this program with different instructors would improve the results. However, had the Corrective Reading Program been an effective means of addressing STUDENT’s reading disability, it is more likely that he would have shown appreciable growth after exposure to it for one semester. The evidence, therefore, suggests that it is more probable that STUDENT is one of those few individuals described by Mr. Knudsvig with whom the Corrective Reading Program is not successful. Moreover, STUDENT has been deprived of educational opportunities and benefits for too long to risk a further delay of his reading remediation by again providing a program that previously failed. The Hearing Officer consequently concludes that the District’s offer to repeat the Corrective Reading Program would not have conferred education benefit on STUDENT in the area of reading.

The only information provided about the Lindamood Cloud Nine math program preferred by the parent was testimony from the regional director of Lindamood, who testified that STUDENT worked on numbers, time, and money. The Lindamood writing program utilizing the “hamburger” has previously been described. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded that the Lindamood math and writing programs provided any unique methodology to benefit STUDENT. The Hearing Officer, does, however, find it probable that STUDENT would have benefitted from the District’s Corrective Math and Writing classes. Like the reading program, Corrective Math and Writing are sequential, multi-sensory techniques taught by direct instruction. The student must demonstrate proficiency at his or her current level before advancing to the next. The programs provide daily oversight by the instructor and feedback of the student’s progress. Mr. Knudsvig testified that STUDENT still needs to learn the basic math skills of addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division and gain confidence in his skills. He stated his belief that both the Corrective Math and Writing programs would benefit STUDENT. With each of the Corrective programs, an entry test is administered to determine the student’s current abilities so that the student is appropriately placed at the correct level, it identifies and provides remediation of the skills that have not yet been attained before the student progresses to the next level, performance is reassessed constantly, and attainable goals and immediate feedback instill confidence. The program also provides daily monitoring of the student’s progress. This enables the teacher to establish discernable growth over short periods of time and also to quickly identify and respond to areas of concern.

Although the Hearing Officer agrees that STUDENT would have received some educational benefit from the District’s offer of placement in its Corrective Math and Writing programs, a program that provides only partial educational benefit, yet fails to address a significant portion of the student’s disability, does not constitute a FAPE. Consequently, the placement offer made by the District was not adequate as it would not have conferred educational benefit in STUDENT’s major disability area of reading.

3. Would the District’s program have conformed to STUDENT’s individual education program?

Conformance with the District’s proposed IEP is not disputed between the parties.

4. Was the District’s offer of placement in the least restrictive environment?

The District argues that its offer to return STUDENT to his home high school is placement in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer agrees that attending his neighborhood school with his peers, and access to mainstreaming opportunities and involvement in high school sports and social activities is the LRE for STUDENT. Traveling from STUDENT’s home to the Lindamood site necessitates an approximately four-hour round-trip drive each day. Once there, STUDENT works alone or one-to-one with a Lindamood clinician. He is never integrated with either disabled or nondisabled peers while at Lindamood. The entire program is focused on Lindamood therapies. STUDENT does not receive instruction in the other subjects required for high school graduation. Physical education, team sports, and social events are not available.

STUDENT was described by everyone as a personable, social young man who was well-liked and enjoyed his friends. He also was very athletic and enjoyed sports. Pursuant to his mother’s decision, STUDENT did not attend school the last semester of the 1999-2000 school year, nor has he attended any of the ongoing 2000-2001 school year. Thus, for one year he has been without educational services, and excluded from the normal experiences of a high school student. To extend his seclusion from his peers and age-typical activities by sending him far from his neighborhood, to a building where he works without peers all day, and where he is deprived of physical activity, required high school courses, sports, and socialization, is both extremely restrictive and inappropriate. His teacher is a Lindamood “clinician” whose only qualifications are a high school diploma and a few days of Lindamood training,

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a placement that partially identified and met his unique needs and would have returned him to the LRE. However, an inability to be a functional reader is one of STUDENT’s most significant deficits. To address this problem, the District merely offered to return STUDENT to a reading program that had failed him in the past, augmented by one-half of his prior Lindamood reading program. It is not sufficient for a District to identify and provide educational benefit for some of a disabled student’s unique needs. To fulfill its obligation to provide a FAPE, the law requires a District to identify and service all areas of a child’s disability. An offer of a program that does not adequately address an entire segment of a student’s disability, does not constitute a FAPE.

ISSUE THREE

If the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during any or all of the above school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?

If it is determined that a school district failed to provide a disabled student with a FAPE, compensatory education designed to compensate that student for lost educational opportunity may be awarded. 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(2)(B)(iii); 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(10)(C)(I); Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (8th Cir.1996); Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir.1994); Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 360 (1985).

“The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services,” Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, (supra). As stated in Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir, 1991), compensatory education is an available equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief . . . Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra).

Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court, and by extension, a hearing officer, to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” Thus, a hearing officer may award compensatory education and fashion appropriate relief if the facts so warrant. When considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.

The Hearing Officer has determined that the District wrongfully denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years, as well as the second semester of the1999-2000 school year. STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education to remedy this specific loss of services. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. A consideration of equitable principles is therefore appropriate when fashioning an appropriate compensatory remedy. An application of equitable remedies requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child’s lost educational opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra).

In this case, the District knew that STUDENT repeatedly failed to achieve his IEP goals. In response, it did not make substantive changes to his IEP. It simply avoided the issue by eliminating the discussion and recording of his progress on his prior IEP goals from the agenda of each annual IEP meeting. Additionally, the District possessed multiple test results over several years that consistently established that STUDENT was not making academic gains. MOTHER also brought her concerns about STUDENT’s failure to progress to the IEP team year after year. Despite this knowledge, the District did not modify the educational services that it offered STUDENT. It merely continued the same program and the same goals and objectives from one IEP to the next. The District now admits that it provided years of special education services that did not confer educational benefit upon STUDENT. Based upon the facts surrounding STUDENT’s education, the inescapable conclusion is that the District knew, or reasonably should have known, that its services were not effectively addressing STUDENT’s needs, yet it did not alter his program in an attempt to provide an effective or appropriate education.

In contrast to the District’s actions, MOTHER made consistent efforts to secure an appropriate education for her son. At each IEP meeting, she pointed out STUDENT’s continued difficulties. She called for IEP meetings to discuss his lack of progress and requested additional IEP meetings to monitor whether he was making gains. In past years, she had secured private tutoring services for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer notes that MOTHER’s decision to remove STUDENT from school for several months was not beneficial. STUDENT’s delays are significant and a year without educational services will certainly have an adverse impact on his academic growth. Arguably, it would have been better to have returned STUDENT to the school environment, accepted some of the District services, and allowed him to participate in high school sports and social events. However, MOTHER was justifiably frustrated by the many years of District services that had failed her son, and she was understandably reluctant to return STUDENT to its programs. Therefore, in weighing the conduct of the parties, the Hearing Officer finds that the equities favor an award of compensatory education to the Petitioner in this case.

The Petitioner and his mother are requesting compensatory education in the form of an additional twenty-four weeks of six-hour-a-day Lindamood therapy at the Lindamood site. The Hearing Officer agrees that STUDENT should receive additional Lindamood LIPS and Seeing Stars reading therapy, as it appears to be the only method to date that has increased STUDENT’s reading abilities. However, the Hearing Officer has previously determined that the Lindamood program site is an extremely restrictive environment. Consequently, it would not be in STUDENT’s best interests to return to the Lindamood location for a full-day, five-day-a-week program.

It is the determination of the Hearing Officer that STUDENT should return to his neighborhood high school. As part of his program, STUDENT is to receive two hours per day of the Lindamood programs, LIPS and Seeing Stars. A minimum of one hour per day of the Lindamood service is to be individual instruction. The Lindamood services may be provided by District personnel who are trained in LIPS and Seeing Stars. If the District does not have employees trained to teach these two Lindamood programs, they must provide a private agency or tutor with the training to administer LIPS and Seeing Stars. If STUDENT must travel to the location of the Lindamood services, the provider is to be located within a thirty-mile radius of the high school STUDENT attends. The District will either transport STUDENT to the Lindamood services or reimburse the parent for the cost of round trip transportation at the District milage rate. As further compensatory education, STUDENT is to receive two hours per day of Lindamood therapy for eight weeks during the summer of the 2000-2001 school year. The District shall also either provide or reimburse for the cost of transportation to the summer Lindamood program.

Upon his return to his home school, STUDENT is to receive both Corrective Math and Corrective Writing classes. Although the Hearing Officer cannot order a particular teacher, it is the preference of the Hearing Officer that STUDENT be enrolled in the Corrective Math class of Mr. Knudsvig. Mr. Knudsvig knows STUDENT and his needs and he clearly has the experience and expertise to offer STUDENT the best chance of success with the math program. STUDENT is to participate in a general education physical education class with his peers. He is also to be placed in general education classes (the specific classes to be determined by the District and MOTHER), for the remainder of his classes, with appropriate accommodations, modifications, assistive technology, and individual aide support necessary to allow STUDENT to function as a full participant in those classes. STUDENT is to be placed in the general education classes with all necessary support, to compensate for the substantial amount of time he was placed at Lindamood, and has remained out of school, without appropriate peer interaction. STUDENT is also to be offered an extended school year RSP program that offers him a choice from classes that provide course credits for high school graduation.

CONCLUSION

STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the1996-97, 1997-98, 1998-99 and 1999-2000 school years as a result of the District’s failure to offer an appropriate program, provide educational benefit, and conform to his IEP. As a result of the District’s failure to offer adequate services and support, STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education and any resulting transportation costs.

ORDER

1. Within ten business days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting and make a placement offer to the Petitioner consistent with this decision and as set forth in Issue number three. 2. The District shall provide STUDENT with two hours per day of the Lindamood LIPS and Seeing Stars programs throughout the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year. A minimum of one hour per day is to be individual instruction. The District shall determine the provider of the Lindamood services. However, the instructor shall be trained and qualified to provide both the LIPS and Seeing Stars programs. If the District does not employ and/or utilize its own personnel trained in both LIPS and Seeing Stars to provide these services to STUDENT, it must obtain the services from a nonpublic agency or tutor within two weeks of the date of this order. If STUDENT is required to travel to the Lindamood services, the service provider must be located within a thirty-mile radius of the high school STUDENT attends. The District shall either provide transportation, or reimburse the parent for transportation costs at the rate set for District mileage reimbursement. As further compensatory education, STUDENT shall receive an additional eight weeks of two-hour-per-day, five-day-per-week, Lindamood therapy during the summer of the 2000-2001 school year. The District shall also determine the trained provider of STUDENT’s summer services. However, the summer Lindamood therapy may be provided by a trained individual or agency that is outside the thirty-mile radius if the parties mutually agree.

3. The District shall offer STUDENT a choice of a class(es) within an RSP extended school year program that provides course credits necessary for high school graduation.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on all issues presented for determination.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Education Code §56505(i).)

Dated: March 6, 2001 _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law