California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 13, 2004
Student v. Rim of the World Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1051-04 · Hearing Officer Christian P. Hurley
Rim of the World Unified must fund Tustin Center placement, a full-time aide, added speech therapy, and $2,000 monthly living costs.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Procedural rulings: before the hearing, the burden of going forward was shifted to the District. Motions for summary judgment and bifurcation were denied. Telephone testimony was allowed for Todd Eachus. The hearing location was moved from Blue Jay to Tustin.
Summary
A ten-year-old fourth grader eligible for special education under traumatic brain injury (TBI) filed for due process against Rim of the World Unified School District. He had serious behavior problems, including physical aggression, in district special day classes (SDCs). Under a December 2003 mediated agreement, the district placed him at the Tustin Center through June 30, 2004. The Tustin Center is a certified nonpublic school for students with brain injuries. The district also paid his mother $2,000 a month for living costs near the school. At an April 27, 2004 IEP meeting, the district proposed moving him to a "Rim District program or a County/SELPA program" with a one-to-one aide and related services. The Hearing Officer found that this offer named no placement, start date, behavior services or transition plan. That broke the written-offer rule in Union School District v. Smith. It also seriously limited the mother's role in the IEP process, so it denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE). District witnesses described SDCs at Lake Gregory and Lake Arrowhead Elementary. The Hearing Officer found those classes inadequate. They lacked a coordinated behavior program with an on-site behaviorist, small-group instruction, trained aides, and enough individual speech therapy. The Hearing Officer found the Tustin Center appropriate and the least restrictive environment for now. He ordered the district to fund placement there for 2004-2005, adding a full-time one-to-one aide and 30 more minutes a week of individual speech therapy. The district must also reimburse costs after June 30, 2004, and pay $2,000 a month for living expenses.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO enforced the Union v. Smith written-offer rule. An offer of an unnamed district or county program denied FAPE because it limited the parent's participation. District testimony at the hearing could not fill gaps in the written offer. The decision also treated reasonable living expenses near a distant nonpublic school as a related service the district must fund.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1A. Did the District commit a procedural violation and deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to make a clear written offer of placement and services for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The April 27, 2004 IEP offered only a vague 'Rim District program or a County/SELPA program' with no specific placement, start date, behavior services or transition plan. This seriously infringed on the mother's participation and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B. Did the District substantively offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The SDCs at Lake Gregory and Lake Arrowhead were not designed to meet his behavior and speech-language needs and were not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. They lacked an on-site behaviorist, coordinated staff, data collection, small-group instruction, trained aides, a transition plan, and enough individual speech therapy.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
Tustin, a certified nonpublic school, meets his needs, provides educational benefit, conforms to his IEP, and is currently his LRE. Placement was ordered with a full-time 1:1 aide, an extra half hour per week of individual speech therapy, and $2,000 per month for living expenses.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for tuition, a one-to-one aide, related services, and housing costs associated with STUDENT's placement at the Tustin Center following June 30, 2004?
Because the District denied FAPE and Tustin was appropriate, the District must reimburse Tustin costs after June 30, 2004, including the aide, added speech therapy, and $2,000 per month for living expenses. The requested $2,500 per month was not awarded.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Reimburse costs incurred by the mother for Tustin Center placement during the 2004 ESY after June 30, 2004. This includes tuition paid, a full-time 1:1 aide if provided, an additional half hour of 1:1 speech and language therapy if provided, and $2,000 per month in living expenses while attending. Payment is due within 15 calendar days of receiving proof of costs.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse Tustin Center costs incurred for the 2004-2005 regular school year until the District assumes responsibility. This covers the same categories as the ESY reimbursement, including $2,000 per month in living expenses. Payment is due within 15 calendar days of receiving proof of costs.
- Prospective funding of private placement. Immediately provide prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004-2005 regular school year, with current services plus a full-time 1:1 aide and an additional half hour of 1:1 speech and language services.
- Pay monthly living expenses near Tustin of $2,000 during the 2004-2005 regular school year while the student attends the Tustin Center. Payments go directly to the mother on the first of each month.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Ojai Unified School Dist. v. Jackson; Gregory K. v. Longview; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified; Student W. v. Puyallup; Alamo Heights v. State Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- David Brown, School psychologist and director of special services, Rim of the World Unified School District
- Mary Ann Klensky (also spelled Mary Anne Klenske), Program specialist / behavior intervention case manager; conducted FAA and wrote BIP, East Valley SELPA
- Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager; District's hearing representative, East Valley SELPA
- Gary Smith, Ph.D., School psychologist; District representative at IEP meeting, Rim of the World Unified School District
- Cynthia Downey, School psychologist, Rim of the World Unified School District
- Ward Lee, Special day class teacher, Lake Arrowhead Elementary, Rim of the World Unified School District
- Brandon Harms, Special day class teacher, Lake Gregory Elementary, Rim of the World Unified School District
- Elizabeth Paganini, Speech and language therapist, Rim of the World Unified School District
- Angelle Colvin, Speech and language therapist / instructional tutor in Lake Arrowhead SDC, Rim of the World Unified School District
- Todd Eachus, Director of nonpublic school operator; District witness and TBI trainer, Success for Kids, Inc.
- Christine Grandinetti, Independent TBI consultant (District witness who did not testify), Independent
- Juda Carter, Director, nonpublic school, Tustin Center
- Bethany Hwang, School psychologist and behaviorist, Tustin Center
- Katy Peck-Frost, Speech and language therapist, Tustin Center
- Douglas Harrington, Ph.D., Private neuropsychologist; expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Jackie Peebles, Tutor / 1:1 aide hired by parent, Private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Christian Hurley, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. The matter proceeded to hearing in Blue Jay, California, on May 27 and 28, 2004, and continued in Tustin, California, on June 1 and 2, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorneys Valerie Vanaman and Joel S. Aaronson of Newman, Aaronson & Vanaman. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER, and his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER. Respondent Rim of the World Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by Gail Lindberg of the East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). David Brown, school psychologist and director of special services for the District, was also present on behalf of the District.
The District called the following witnesses: David Brown; Mary Ann Klensky, program specialist for the SELPA; Gary Smith, Ph.D., District school psychologist; Cynthia Downey, District school psychologist; Ward Lee, special day class (SDC) teacher at the District’s Lake Arrowhead Elementary School; Todd Eachus, director of Success for Kids, Inc., which operates two certified nonpublic schools; Elizabeth Paganini, District speech and language therapist; Angelle Colvin, District speech and language therapist; and Brandon Harms, SDC teacher at the District’s Lake Gregory Elementary School. (Footnote 1)
Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Juda Carter, director of the Tustin Center, a certified nonpublic school (NPS); Jackie Peebles, tutor; Douglas Harrington, Ph.D., private psychologist; Katy Peck-Frost, speech and language therapist at the Tustin Center; and Bethany Hwang, school psychologist and behaviorist at the Tustin Center.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties submitted written closing briefs. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004 extended school year (ESY) and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
2. Is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for tuition, a one-to-one aide, related services, and housing costs associated with STUDENT’s placement at the Tustin Center following June 30, 2004?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer him a FAPE, both procedurally and substantively, with respect to the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. With respect to procedural violations, Petitioner maintains that the District failed to comply with the procedural protections afforded by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) when it proposed, in an individualized education program (IEP) document dated April 27, 2004, to move him to an unidentified “Rim District program or a County/SELPA program.” Petitioner argues that the offer failed to meet the specificity requirements imposed by federal and State law in that the District failed to identify a fully developed program that was specific as to place, teacher, program, starting date, transportation, behavior intervention services, and transition plan.
With respect to the alleged substantive violations of FAPE, Petitioner contends that the District’s offered programs for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year are not designed to meet his unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Specifically, Petitioner argues that the offered programs are not appropriate because: 1) they lack a behavioral team which should include the teacher, a speech and language specialist, and a behavioral specialist, 2) they would not provide him with an academic program in a group setting of no more than two students, 3) they do not include a positive behavior plan that would adequately address his problem behaviors without removing him from the class and the school, and 4) they do not include staff trained in physical assault response training (PART) or an available trained aide to provide him with one-to-one services.
Petitioner contends that the Tustin Center, the certified nonpublic school he has been attending since January of this year, is the appropriate placement for him because it has staff specifically trained in assisting students with brain injuries, and a program specifically designed for those students. Specifically, Petitioner maintains that he needs such a placement, in large part, because of the significant behavioral difficulties he has been experiencing. According to Petitioner, the Tustin Center is the least restrictive environment in which his needs can effectively be met at present. Petitioner seeks an order requiring the District to continue his placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year, along with the payment of reasonable living expenses for him and his mother, who have both been residing near Tustin on weekdays while he has been attending the Tustin Center.
The District contends that the offer presented at the April 27, 2004 IEP meeting was both procedurally and substantively appropriate. With respect to the alleged procedural violations, the District maintains that there was no intent on the part of the District to change Petitioner’s placement at the Time of that IEP meeting. Alternatively, the District argued that Petitioner and his mother knew enough about the offer to disagree with it at the IEP meeting and to visit the proposed placements at Lake Gregory Elementary and Lake Arrowhead Elementary. Finally, the District argues that even if a procedural violation occurred, Petitioner did not suffer any resulting harm or consequence as he is still at the Tustin Center placement.
With respect to the alleged substantive violation of FAPE, the District argues that it has offered Petitioner an appropriate program, which it asserts includes placement in a special day class (SDC) at either Lake Gregory Elementary School or Lake Arrowhead Elementary School with a one-to-one aide, a behavioral intervention case manager, and related services in the form of speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education. The District maintains that Petitioner should not continue his placement at the Tustin Center beyond the previously agreed-upon date of June 30, 2004, because the District has offered him a FAPE and because the Tustin Center is inappropriate for Petitioner. Specifically, the District argues that the Tustin Center is inappropriate for Petitioner because: 1) his placement there was not made pursuant to an IEP team decision, 2) his placement there is based on a specific type of disability (traumatic brain injury) rather than his unique needs, 3) he has not made progress there, and 4) it is not the least restrictive environment. The District maintains that Petitioner is not entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center, nor are his parents entitled to reimbursement for expenses related to that placement after June 30, 2004.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
1. Motion for Summary Judgment or Directed Verdict
Prior to the introduction of testimony or documentary evidence, and during a discussion of the issues, Petitioner moved for summary judgment or a directed verdict on the issue of whether the District violated the procedural protections of the IDEA and State law when it presented its offers for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year at the April 27, 2004 IEP meeting. Petitioner contended that, on their face, the offers set forth in that IEP were procedurally defective under the IDEA and California law because they did not constitute formal, written offers of placement in the IEP, as required by 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii) and (vi), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(3)(6), California Education Code section 56345(a)(3), and Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994). Specifically, Petitioner argued that the offers set forth in the IEP failed to meet the specificity requirements imposed by these federal and State laws in that the District failed to identify a fully developed program that was specific as to place, teacher, program, starting date, transportation, behavior intervention services, and transition plan. Petitioner argued that the Hearing Officer could determine, solely by examining the offers contained in the IEP document, that the offers were procedurally defective and that Petitioner was, therefore, entitled to the relief sought.
The District opposed Petitioner’s motion, arguing that it should be allowed the opportunity to present testimony and documentary evidence on the issue of whether the offers were procedurally appropriate. Specifically, the District contended that the Hearing Officer should hear testimony regarding the IEP meeting in question to determine whether offers of placement were made and whether Petitioner’s mother understood the offers.
Special education law does not set forth a procedure for summary judgment or directed verdict motions in due process hearings. In any event, if there is a disputed issue of material fact with respect to the issue(s) presented in a due process hearing, such a motion should be denied so that the hearing officer may take testimony and documentary evidence at hearing to resolve any such disputed factual issues.
The courts have held that the procedural safeguards of the IDEA are important and that certain procedural violations, including those that result in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process, may result in a denial of FAPE. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).)
Here, the Hearing Officer determined that it was necessary to receive witness testimony and documentary evidence at hearing to determine whether a procedural violation occurred and, if so, whether the violation resulted in a denial of FAPE. For example, the testimony of Petitioner’s mother and the District representatives who attended the meeting would aid the Hearing Officer in determining what was said at the meeting regarding the offers and what understanding Petitioner’s mother had of the offers at the meeting. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner’s motion for summary judgment or a directed verdict.
2. Motion to Bifurcate the Hearing
As an alternative to the motion for summary judgment or directed verdict discussed above, Petitioner argued that the Hearing Officer should bifurcate the hearing and initially hear only the issue of whether the District committed procedural violations with respect to its offers of placement and services as set forth in the IEP of April 27, 2004. Petitioner maintained that he was not clear as to what programs the District had specifically offered at the IEP meeting. Petitioner further maintained that if the Hearing Officer found that the offers were procedurally flawed, he would be entitled to the relief sought without the necessity of determining whether the offers were substantively appropriate, thereby limiting the scope of the hearing and promoting judicial economy.
The District opposed this motion, arguing that all of the issues presented for hearing should be heard together and that bifurcation of the issue of alleged procedural violations would not promote judicial economy or convenience.
Neither federal nor State special education law addresses the issue of bifurcation of due process hearings. Generally, the Hearing Office may grant a request for bifurcation in the furtherance of convenience or to avoid prejudice, or when separate hearings would be conducive to expedition and economy.
The Hearing Officer concluded that bifurcation was not appropriate in this case because it would not further convenience, avoid prejudice, or be conducive to expedition or economy. For example, if the Hearing Officer, after hearing the evidence, found that the District did not commit any procedural violations, the Hearing Officer would still need to evaluate the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offers. If the hearing were bifurcated, this determination of substantive appropriateness would require a second hearing which would presumably involve some of the same witnesses as the first issue. The Hearing Officer concluded that all of the issues should be heard as part of one hearing and denied the motion to bifurcate.
3. Motion for Telephone Testimony
On the first day of hearing, the District requested the opportunity to present the testimony of two of its witnesses, Todd Eachus and Christine Grandinetti, via telephone. (Footnote 2) The District asserted that Mr. Eachus was unable to testify in person because he resides in Northern California and that Ms. Grandinetti was unable to testify in person because she had previous business commitments in the form of training seminars.
Petitioner opposed this motion, arguing that it was not timely, that Petitioner had a right to confront and cross-examine the District’s witnesses, and that the witnesses did not have copies of the parties’ evidence binders with them, making it difficult to question them regarding exhibits.
Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3082, authorizes a hearing officer to conduct all or part of a hearing by telephone, television, or other electronic means if each participant in the hearing has an opportunity to participate in and to hear the entire proceeding while it is taking place and to observe exhibits.
The Hearing Officer granted the motion for telephonic testimony as to witness Todd Eachus, noting that Mr. Eachus lives in Northern California and that the District’s estimate for his direct examination was only thirty minutes. The Hearing Officer ordered the District to ensure that Mr. Eachus had copies of both parties’ evidence binders in advance of his testimony. As to Ms. Grandinetti, the Hearing Officer urged the District to attempt to secure her testimony in person during the course of the hearing, as she resides in Southern California and no evidence was presented which suggested that she had a conflict which would prevent her from testifying in person, such as an illness or the like. The Hearing Officer indicated that he would consider telephone testimony for Ms. Grandinetti as a last resort, provided that she had copies of the parties’ evidence binders or was at a location where exhibits could be faxed to her, if necessary, during the course of her testimony. The hearing proceeded over the course of four days, May 27, 28, June 1, and 2, 2004. The District was unable to secure the testimony of Ms. Grandinetti, either in person or by telephone, during those four days and did not request a subpoena to compel her testimony or a continuance of the hearing. As a result, her testimony was not presented in this hearing.
4. Motion to Change Location of Hearing
On the first day of hearing, Petitioner made an oral motion to change the location of the hearing from Blue Jay, California, to Tustin, California, after the District had concluded the presentation of its case in chief. Petitioner argued that moving the hearing to Tustin would be convenient for him and his mother because he attends school in Tustin and his mother resides there during the week to care for him. In addition, Petitioner noted that Tustin would be more convenient for his witnesses because most of them are employed by the Tustin Center and/or reside in Orange County. Petitioner maintained that a change in hearing location would promote efficiency in the hearing as the witnesses would be more likely to arrive at hearing on time if they did not have to travel up mountain roads to the town of Blue Jay.
The District opposed the motion, arguing that the Hearing Office had previously issued an order denying Petitioner’s motion to change the hearing location and that a change of location would prejudice the District’s representatives, who would have to travel to Tustin each day of the hearing.
California Education Code section 56505(b) provides that a hearing shall be held at a time and place “reasonably convenient” to the parent and the pupil. The Hearing Officer granted Petitioner’s motion, finding that changing the hearing location to Tustin would be convenient for Petitioner and his mother and would promote efficiency by locating the hearing much closer to the witnesses who would be testifying on behalf of Petitioner. Accordingly, the hearing convened in Tustin on June 1 and June 2, 2004, after the District concluded the presentation of its case in chief on May 28, 2004, save for the telephonic testimony of Todd Eachus.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a ten-year-old fourth-grader identified as eligible for special education and related services as a student with a traumatic brain injury (TBI). (Footnote 3) He has been diagnosed with a neurodevelopmental disorder caused by a stroke at birth. As a result, STUDENT has a seizure disorder, mild mental retardation, developmental delays, an attention disorder, learning disabilities in all three academic areas, visual disturbances, motor impairments, and significant behavioral difficulties. These deficits adversely affect his educational performance.
STUDENT has resided within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District since at least age three. Since January 5, 2004, STUDENT has attended the Tustin Center, a non-public school for students with TBI, pursuant to a mediated settlement agreement between his parents and the District dated December 9, 2003. (Footnote 4) The agreement provides that the District will cease funding STUDENT’s placement at the Tustin Center after June 30, 2004.
Prior to attending the Tustin Center, STUDENT attended special day classes at various District schools. On May 21, 1999, a triennial IEP meeting was held. At that time, STUDENT was five years old and in the first grade at Lake Arrowhead Elementary School. The IEP document identified STUDENT as eligible for special education and related services under the category of speech and language impaired and set forth goals and objectives in the areas of speech and language, fine motor, behavior, and social skills.
On June 6, 2000, STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was held. STUDENT’s parents requested a speech and language assessment. On October 30, 2000, the IEP team met to review the results of STUDENT’s speech and language assessment. STUDENT was found to be eligible for speech and language therapy and the team developed three goals and objectives for STUDENT in this area. STUDENT began receiving speech and language services one to two times per week for twenty to thirty minutes per session.
On June 21, 2001, STUDENT’s annual review was held. At the meeting, his parents requested the following: 1) a change in his eligibility designation from speech and language impairment to traumatic brain injury, 2) the development of a behavior plan for STUDENT, 3) a one-to-one aide, and 4) an increase in his speech and language therapy services. His parents also requested a psychoeducational assessment because they were concerned with STUDENT’s progress. The IEP team agreed that such an assessment was appropriate and on August 2, 2001, school psychologist David Brown conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT. In his report, Mr. Brown stated that STUDENT was primarily eligible under the category of traumatic brain injury. On October 9, 2001, STUDENT’s mother and teacher met for an addendum IEP meeting. According to the IEP document, STUDENT’s mother and teacher agreed that STUDENT did not require a behavior plan at that time but that they would continue to observe his behavior for any changes.
IEP meetings for STUDENT’s annual review took place on June 12 and September 13, 2002. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT was in need of a behavior support plan and indicated that one would be drafted. On September 13, 2002, a behavior support plan was presented to and approved by the IEP team. The plan sought to address the following behaviors: talking without raising his hand, grabbing people or objects without permission, and hitting or kicking other students. According to the plan, STUDENT exhibited the talking and grabbing behavior throughout each day, while he exhibited the hitting behavior approximately twice a month. The targeted behaviors occurred more often in situations in which the classroom structure was less demanding or where the activities deviated from the regular routine.
STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, testified at hearing that STUDENT’s behavior began to spiral downward significantly in January 2003. According to Ms. MOTHER, during this time STUDENT’s seizures increased and he became more volatile both at school and at home. On January 13, 2003, an addendum IEP meeting was held at which STUDENT’s parents requested a formal functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT’s behaviors by a non-District employee. On March 19, 2003, Mary Anne Klenske, SELPA program specialist, issued an FAA report. This report referenced the same targeted behaviors as the behavior support plan created in August of 2002. According to the report, STUDENT exhibited physically aggressive behaviors between one and four Times daily, with a duration of three to five seconds per incident. He was redirected or removed from the classroom immediately and was able to de-escalate. He was supervised for most of his school day due to prior conflicts with peers which had occurred when he was left alone. The report identified positive replacement behaviors for STUDENT, including asking for permission to see or hold an object that did not belong to him and waiting his turn to board playground equipment or use a ball. This report was discussed at an addendum IEP meeting on March 19, 2003. Ms. Klenske proposed a positive behavior intervention plan (BIP), which the IEP team approved and agreed to implement. The BIP called for STUDENT to earn adult and peer attention and interaction through the use of socially appropriate verbal imitation and by learning social cues such as taking turns and waiting for responses. It also called for the development and daily use of social stories to reinforce appropriate social behavior and communication and the use of data collection to keep track of the targeted maladaptive behaviors. At this meeting, STUDENT’s mother again requested that STUDENT be provided with a one-to-one aide. The IEP document does not indicate the response of the IEP team to this request.
According to Ms. MOTHER, during the summer of 2003, while STUDENT was attending Lake Gregory Elementary School for summer school/ESY, she was contacted by school officials to come and pick STUDENT up from school due to behavioral difficulties on at least nine different occasions. STUDENT’s problem behaviors were primarily physical in nature and included pushing, grabbing, biting, spitting, kicking, and throwing objects. On June 5, 2003, and September 5, 2003, STUDENT’s annual review was held. His primary disability was identified as traumatic brain injury. The IEP document states that STUDENT had experienced a significant reduction in verbal communication and verbal memory, rendering him unable to perform skills at levels previously obtained. Instructional personnel who worked with STUDENT reported noticing this regression in STUDENT’s ability to respond, express himself, and duplicate performance previously demonstrated. The IEP document states that the cause of this regression was unknown, but that one theory pointed to an increase in seizure activity as a possible cause. STUDENT’s doctors were in the process of changing or eliminating seizure medications in an effort to address the problem.
In the fall of 2003, STUDENT was placed in an SDC at Lake Arrowhead taught by Ward Lee. In the September 5, 2003 IEP document, the IEP team reported that on September 3, 2003, STUDENT was involved in an incident in which he hit, bit, and kicked staff. Although not reflected in that IEP document, David Brown, the director of special services for the District, testified that STUDENT was provided with a one-to-one aide at Lake Arrowhead during the fall semester of the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT’s mother testified that his behaviors continued and that she or her mother had to pick him up from school early on almost a daily basis from September to November 2003 due to behavioral incidents. According to his mother, his behavior during this period included throwing a chair, hitting, grabbing, and pinching school staff and students. She testified that on several occasions she found STUDENT being physically restrained by school staff when she arrived at school to pick him up. She stated that during this Time, STUDENT increasingly expressed fears about going to school and of being restrained at school.
Ward Lee, STUDENT’s SDC teacher at Lake Arrowhead from September to November 2003, also testified that STUDENT’s behavior was a problem at school. He testified that the frequency of STUDENT’s problem behaviors increased during the Time he spent with STUDENT. He described behaviors similar to those testified to by STUDENT’s mother, including kicking, hitting, scratching, spitting, screaming, and running away. According to Mr. Lee, school staff called STUDENT’s mother or grandmother for assistance in dealing with his behaviors and/or to pick him up from school early due to behavior problems between ten and fifteen Times during this period.
In December 2003, in an attempt to resolve two other prior due process hearing matters, the parties attended a mediation which resulted in a settlement agreement. Pursuant to the settlement agreement, the District agreed to place STUDENT at the Tustin Center, a certified nonpublic school for students with traumatic brain injuries, for a period of six months. The District further agreed to provide STUDENT’s mother with a monthly stipend of $2000.00 for living expenses in Tustin during this period.
STUDENT continued to experience significant behavioral difficulties after transitioning to Tustin, although the frequency of such behaviors appears to have declined somewhat in the months since he began attending Tustin. According to the Tustin records submitted as evidence by the District, during the period from January 5, 2004 through May 4, 2004, STUDENT had twenty-three separate behavioral incidents, most of which involved physical aggression directed toward a peer or a Tustin staff member, and some of which involved punching or hitting staff and students in the face. Several of these incidents required the use of physical prone containment techniques by Tustin staff whereby STUDENT would be physically brought to the floor and restrained in order to prevent injury to him or others. The behaviors referenced included attempting to leave the area or an activity and physical aggression in the form of hitting, kicking, scratching, throwing objects, biting, spitting, and screaming.
On February 3, 2004, and April 27, 2004, IEP meetings were held at the Tustin Center to review STUDENT’s placement, behavior intervention plan, goals and objectives, and progress. According to the IEP document dated February 3, 2004, the Tustin speech and language therapist recommended an immediate increase in speech and language therapy from sixty to ninety minutes per week, with an additional increase to 120 minutes per week in ninety days. The Tustin Center school psychologist recommended that STUDENT be provided with a one-to-one aide to meet his academic and behavioral needs. The IEP document indicates that David Brown, director of special services for the District, rejected the request for increased services on the basis that the mediated agreement between the parties superceded the IEP process. Mr. Brown indicated that the IEP meeting would resume at a later date after consultation with the SELPA program manager/due process facilitator.
On April 27, 2004, the IEP meeting continued at the Tustin Center. STUDENT’s speech and language therapist reviewed his goals and objectives and again recommended an increase in therapy from two sessions per week to three sessions per week. The Tustin Center staff recommended that STUDENT continue to be placed in a program that specializes in acquired and traumatic brain injury, that the behavior intervention plan continue to be implemented, and that STUDENT be provided a one-to-one instructional aide. According to the IEP document dated April 27, 2004, Gail Lindberg, the SELPA program manager, who was participating by telephone, “suggested that the programs recommended [by the Tustin Center] could be implemented in the Rim District.” The District representative, Dr. Gary Smith, “recommended that STUDENT be transitioned to a Rim District program or a County/SELPA program with appropriate support. A gradual transition back to his home school with a 1:1 support from an instructional aide (exclusive assignment) and continued support from LSH and APE services: LSH 1 hour/week; APE 2 Times 30 minutes/week; OT 1 hour/week.” STUDENT’s mother did not consent to the District’s offer. No further IEP meetings have been convened.
On May 5, 2004, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from STUDENT’s attorney in this matter. At some point between May 5 and May 21, 2004, STUDENT’s attorney received a written settlement offer from the District. According to STUDENT’s mother, the settlement offer indicated that STUDENT might be placed at either Lake Arrowhead Elementary School or Lake Gregory Elementary School. (Footnote 5) STUDENT’s mother ultimately rejected this offer and this matter proceeded to hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
Although the Hearing Officer is considering two different offers of placement for two different Time periods, the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year, and the legal requirements differ for these two placements, the Hearing Officer is analyzing the two placements together because the alleged deficiencies are the same for both Time periods.
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8).) An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. (34 C.F.R. § 300.340(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.) The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, of the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345.) “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).) The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.)
Extended school year programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. (Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).) In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2).) Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii).)
The determination of whether a student has been offered a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the requisite procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement is substantively appropriate. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200 (1982).) The Hearing Officer will address the alleged procedural violation first, and will then turn to the alleged substantive violations of FAPE.
A. Did the District commit a procedural violation and deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to make a clear written offer of placement and services for STUDENT for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
Petitioner maintains that the District failed to comply with the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA and denied him a FAPE when it proposed, in an IEP dated April 27, 2004, to move him to an unidentified “Rim District program or a County/SELPA program.” Petitioner argues that the offer failed to meet the specificity requirements imposed by federal and State law in that the District failed to identify a fully developed program that was specific as to place, teacher, program, starting date, transportation, behavior intervention services, and transition plan.
The District contends that its offer of placement for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year was procedurally appropriate. It argues that its intent in holding the April 27, 2004 IEP meeting was to meet a May 1, 2004 deadline for holding an IEP meeting that was set forth in the mediation agreement as a condition for Petitioner’s agreement to waive the right of stay put at the Tustin Center. The District maintains that there was no intent on its part to propose a change to STUDENT’s placement at that meeting and notes that STUDENT’s placement at the Tustin Center under the mediation agreement was not scheduled to end for another six weeks. It further contends that it was open to considering options other than the Tustin Center and STUDENT’s school of residence, Lake Arrowhead Elementary School. Finally, the District maintains that Petitioner knew enough about the District’s offer of placement to disagree with it during the IEP meeting.
The IDEA provides procedural protections to children with disabilities and their parents. The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 205-206.)
The courts have held that the procedural safeguards of the IDEA are important and that certain procedural violations, including those that result in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process, may result in a denial of FAPE. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d at 1483.) (Footnote 6)
A procedural violation that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. (Union School District v. Smith, supra, 15 F.3d at 1526; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).) As the Ninth Circuit stated in Union, “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” (15 F.3d at 1526.)
The written offer of placement must include a statement of the goals and objectives, of the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities to the maximum extent appropriate. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345.) It must also contain the projected date for the beginning of the services and modifications and the anticipated frequency, location, and duration of those services and modifications. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.) Additionally, as noted above, when a child requires ESY services, the written IEP must include an ESY program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii).)
The Union court explained that a formal, written offer alerts the parents “to the need to consider seriously” whether the particular placement is appropriate under the IDEA, would allow the parents to decide whether to oppose the placement or to “accept it with the supplement of additional educational services,” and would help the district to better prepare to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. (Union, supra, at 1526.)
On April 27, 2004, the IEP team met for the purpose of reviewing STUDENT’s placement, the behavior intervention plan, goals, and progress pursuant to the mediated settlement agreement of December 9, 2003. This meeting was characterized by the District as an addendum to the IEP meeting of February 3, 2004. The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s goals and objectives and his progress at the Tustin Center. According to the IEP document dated April 27, 2004, Gail Lindberg, the SELPA program manager, who was participating by telephone, “suggested that the programs recommended [by the Tustin Center] could be implemented in the Rim District.” The District representative, Dr. Gary Smith, “recommended that STUDENT be transitioned to a Rim District program or a County/SELPA program with appropriate support. A gradual transition back to his home school with a 1:1 support from an instructional aide (exclusive assignment) and continued support from LSH and APE services: LSH 1 hour/week; APE 2 Times 30 minutes/week; OT 1 hour/week.” No projected date was indicated for the implementation of these recommendations. According to the IEP document, both the Tustin Center representatives and STUDENT’s mother expressed their disagreement with these recommendations. The meeting ended without a consensus. There is no indication on the IEP document that this meeting was to be continued at a later date. Moreover, there was no indication from the District that it intended to convene another IEP meeting to discuss placement for the 2004 ESY and/or the 2004-2005 regular school year.
STUDENT’s mother testified that at the end of the IEP meeting on April 27, 2004, she lacked a clear understanding as to what the District had offered for both the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. It was not clear to her whether the District intended to place STUDENT in the same class at Lake Arrowhead that he had attended prior to the Tustin Center. She testified that her attorney received a written settlement offer from the District after she requested a due process hearing in May 2004. She stated that the settlement offer indicated that STUDENT might be placed at either Lake Arrowhead or Lake Gregory Elementary. (Footnote 7) After receiving this information, she visited both schools on or about May 21, 2004, to see if any changes had been made since STUDENT last attended these schools.
Dr. Gary Smith was the District representative at the April 27, 2004 IEP meeting. Dr. Smith testified that he met with David Brown, director of special services for the District, and Cynthia Downey, District school psychologist, one to two weeks before the April IEP meeting to review STUDENT’s records and prepare for the meeting. According to Dr. Smith, the three of them agreed to recommend at the upcoming IEP meeting that STUDENT return to a District SDC program after the Tustin Center placement ended at the end of June. He confirmed that he wrote the IEP Addendum summarizing the meeting, with the exception of a statement by a Tustin Center representative disagreeing with the District’s offer. Dr. Smith also testified that the District was open to considering placements other than the Tustin Center or STUDENT’s school of residence.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to make a clear written offer of placement and services for STUDENT for the 2004 extended school year (ESY) and the 2004-2005 regular school year as required by the IDEA and State law. First, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that an obligation to make a clear written offer arose at the IEP meeting of April 27, 2004. The testimony of the IEP participants and the IEP document, as set forth above, established that the District was recommending a change in placement which was to occur after STUDENT’s placement at the Tustin Center ended on June 30, 2004. The Hearing Officer finds the District’s assertion that it did not intend to change Petitioner’s placement unsupported by the evidence, particularly given Dr. Smith’s testimony that the District representatives had made just such a decision a week or two prior to the April IEP meeting. Furthermore, there is no indication in the record that another IEP meeting was scheduled or convened by the Time the record in this matter closed on June 2, 2004 and the parties had an agreement that an IEP meeting would be held by May 1, 2004.
The District’s offer, set forth in the IEP of April 27, 2004, fails to identify the particular placements offered, other than the vague description of a “Rim District program or a County/SELPA program.” The offer is also silent on other requisite components, such as the particular educational placement, the starting date, and the nature and extent of necessary services such as behavior intervention services and a plan to transition STUDENT from the Tustin Center to another placement. The Hearing Officer found the above-described testimony of STUDENT’s mother--that she lacked a clear understanding of the District’s proposed change of placement by the end of the April IEP meeting--to be credible and supported by the IEP document and the testimony of Dr. Smith, the District’s primary witness on this issue, who did not contradict her testimony. The District did provide Petitioner with a written settlement offer at some point between May 5 and May 21, 2004, that indicated, according to STUDENT’s mother, that STUDENT might be placed at either Lake Arrowhead Elementary School or Lake Gregory Elementary School. But the Hearing Officer did not receive any evidence which suggested that this written settlement offer provided sufficient information regarding STUDENT’s program as required by Union, including the level of participation in general education and any necessary program modifications or supports, such as a behavior intervention plan and a transition plan.
Having determined that the District committed a procedural violation, the Hearing Officer must now determine whether that violation rises to the level of a denial of FAPE to STUDENT. Specifically, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parent’s participation in the IEP process. No persuasive evidence was presented which suggests that the violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. STUDENT continued to attend the Tustin Center, which he contends is an appropriate placement for him. There was sufficient evidence, however, for the Hearing Officer to find that the violation seriously infringed on the right of STUDENT’s mother to participate in the IEP process. She credibly testified that she did not receive sufficient information from the District at the April IEP meeting or thereafter to adequately understand what the District was offering in terms of placement and services for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. She indicated that she was concerned that the District might want to return STUDENT to the same placement he attended prior to the Tustin Center, a placement which she considers inappropriate for his needs. As set forth above, the IEP document is vague on a number of components that are important for meeting STUDENT’s educational needs, including the particular educational program STUDENT would be receiving, the nature and extent of behavior intervention services, and the nature and extent of a transition from the Tustin Center to the placements offered by the District. Without such information, STUDENT’s mother was unable to properly evaluate the appropriateness of the District’s offer. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to make a clear written offer of placement and services for him for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year and that this infringed upon his mother’s opportunity to meaningfully participate in the IEP process.
B. Did the District substantively offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to make a procedurally appropriate offer. However, in light of the argument made at hearing that the District offered placement at both Lake Gregory and Lake Arrowhead, the Hearing Officer will analyze the substantive appropriateness of this alleged but procedurally defective offer.
Although not set forth in the IEP document dated April 27, 2004, the District’s witnesses testified that the District ultimately offered STUDENT placement at an SDC at Lake Gregory Elementary for the 2004 ESY and offered him two different placements for the 2004-2005 regular school year: 1) an SDC at the District’s Lake Arrowhead Elementary School and 2) an SDC at the District’s Lake Gregory Elementary School. According to the District’s witnesses, either of these offered placements would include a one-to-one instructional aide, speech and language therapy for one hour per week, APE for two thirty-minute sessions per week, and occupational therapy for one hour per week. The primary difference between the two offered placements is that the Lake Arrowhead placement is a “language-focused” classroom whereas the Lake Gregory placement is an SDC for mildly to moderately disabled students.
Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year and that the District’s offer to place him in an SDC at either the District’s Lake Gregory Elementary School or Lake Arrowhead Elementary School is insufficient to meet his unique needs, provide him with educational benefit, and address the goals and objectives set forth in the February 2004 IEP. Petitioner maintains that the District’s offer fails to address how his behavioral needs will be met and specifically how a positive behavior plan would be developed, implemented, and adjusted as needed. Petitioner also asserts that the District has failed to offer a highly structured, well-coordinated program in which the personnel working with him would be on-site and involved with his program and with each other on a daily basis, including a provision for regular meetings of the staff working with him.
The District contends that its offer of placement and services for the 2004 ESY at Lake Gregory Elementary and its offer for the 2004-2005 regular school year at either Lake Gregory Elementary or Lake Arrowhead Elementary are offers of FAPE. The District argues that it has offered and is able to provide one-to-one supervision of STUDENT through an instructional aide who would monitor and address his behaviors and that it has offered the related services of speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, adapted physical education, and behavioral case management.
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must first focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed programs. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id.) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F. 3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).) A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)
Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56342(b).) 20 U.S.C. section 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must meet the following three substantive requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program. It must: 1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; 2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; and 3) comport with his IEP. Finally, the District must have offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 8)
1. Identification of STUDENT’s Deficits and His Unique Needs
To determine whether the District’s offered program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs during the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s areas of deficit and his unique needs at the Time of the District’s offer in April 2004. There does not appear to be a dispute between the parties regarding most of STUDENT’s educational deficits. He has been diagnosed with a neurodevelopmental disorder caused by a stroke at birth. As a result, STUDENT has a seizure disorder, mild mental retardation, developmental delays, an attention disorder, learning disabilities in all three basic academic areas, visual disturbances, motor impairments, and significant behavioral difficulties, including impulsivity, hyperactivity, and physical aggression towards peers and school staff.
The parties’ disagreements with respect to STUDENT’s needs center on the areas of behavior and speech and language services. Petitioner contends that he has unique needs in the area of behavior that require highly specialized placement and behavioral services. Petitioner further maintains that he requires a minimum of two hours per week of speech and language therapy, with ninety minutes of that therapy as one-to-one direct therapy. The District disputes these contentions and argues that the placements and services it offered will meet STUDENT’s needs in these areas.
A. Behavior
1. Deficits
Several witnesses testified regarding STUDENT’s behavioral deficits during the period from January 2003 to the present. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, testified that STUDENT’s behavior has been an issue since at least 2001, but that it began to spiral downward significantly in January 2003. According to Ms. MOTHER, during that Time STUDENT’s seizures increased and he became more volatile both at school and at home. She testified that during the summer of 2003, while STUDENT was attending Lake Gregory for summer school/ESY, she was contacted by school officials to come and pick STUDENT up from school due to behavioral difficulties on at least nine different occasions. STUDENT’s problem behaviors were primarily physical in nature and included pushing, grabbing, biting, spitting, kicking, and throwing objects. In the fall of 2003, STUDENT was placed in an SDC at Lake Arrowhead. STUDENT’s behaviors continued and, according to his mother, she or her mother had to pick him up from school early on almost a daily basis from September to November 2003. His behaviors during that period included throwing a chair, hitting, grabbing, and pinching school staff and students. She testified that on several occasions she found STUDENT being physically restrained by school staff when she arrived at school to pick him up. According to her, David Brown, the director of special services, requested permission from her to “hogtie” STUDENT during behavioral episodes. During that Time, STUDENT increasingly expressed fears about going to school and of being restrained at school.
Ward Lee, STUDENT’s SDC teacher at Lake Arrowhead from September to November 2003, testified that STUDENT’s behavior was a problem at school. He testified that the frequency of STUDENT’s problem behaviors increased during the Time he spent with STUDENT. He described behaviors similar to those testified to by STUDENT’s mother, including kicking, hitting, scratching, spitting, screaming, and running away. Mr. Lee testified that a change in classroom teachers in his SDC in September may have caused STUDENT’s behavior to increase during that Time. Mr. Lee estimated that school staff called STUDENT’s mother or grandmother for assistance in dealing with his behaviors and/or to pick him up from school early due to behavior problems between ten and fifteen Times during that period.
According to the testimony of STUDENT’s mother and Mr. Brown, these behavioral difficulties ultimately led the parties to reach an agreement to place STUDENT at the Tustin Center from January 5, 2004, through June 30, 2004. Bethany Hwang, the school psychologist and behaviorist at the Tustin Center, has worked full Time at the Tustin Center since January 2004. She developed STUDENT’s behavior intervention plan and his behavioral goals and objectives for the February 2004 IEP. Tustin behavioral services updates, incident reports, and the testimony of Ms. Hwang reflect that STUDENT continued to experience significant behavioral difficulties after transitioning to Tustin, although the frequency of such behaviors appears to have declined somewhat in the months since he began attending Tustin. According to the Tustin records submitted as evidence by the District, during the period from January 5, 2004 through May 18, 2004, STUDENT had twenty-five separate behavioral incidents, most of which involved physical aggression directed toward a peer or a Tustin staff member. Several of these incidents required the use of physical prone containment techniques by Tustin staff whereby STUDENT would be physically brought to the floor and restrained in order to prevent injury to him or others. The behaviors referenced included attempting to leave the area or an activity, screaming, and physical aggression in the form of hitting, kicking, scratching, throwing objects, biting, and spitting. According to Ms. Hwang, “high likelihood” antecedents to problem behaviors included periods of transition, unstructured independent periods of Time, deviations from routine, unsupervised or unsupported interactions with peers, having someone refuse to comply with his desires, waiting, and losing a game or activity.
Based upon the evidence set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT began to exhibit significant behavioral deficits during 2003 and that these deficits became more problematic during the first half of the 2003-2004 school year, when STUDENT was in the “language-based” SDC taught by Ward Lee. STUDENT continues to exhibit these significant deficits at the Tustin Center.
2. Educational Needs
The Hearing Officer must now determine the type of educational program that STUDENT needs in order to address his significant behavioral deficits. Several witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner regarding this issue. Juda Carter, director of the Tustin Center, has overseen STUDENT’s program at Tustin since he began attending in January 2004. She testified that STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties must be addressed before he can be expected to meaningfully progress with his academic and social goals. According to Ms. Carter, the support of a full-Time behaviorist is critical to address STUDENT’s current behavioral needs. Both Ms. Carter and Bethany Hwang, the school psychologist and behaviorist at the Tustin Center, testified that daily consultation with all staff involved in STUDENT’s education and consistent data collection on behaviors are also crucial elements to STUDENT’s program because the interventions, antecedents, and reinforcers relative to STUDENT’s behavior change regularly. Ms. Hwang testified that data should be collected every fifteen minutes, totaled for each day and week, and then graphed on a monthly basis. Ms. Hwang also emphasized the importance of proper consequences for problem behaviors and reinforcement of appropriate replacement behaviors. According to Ms. Hwang, certain consequences for behaviors, such as removing STUDENT from class or calling his parents to take him home, can actually reinforce a problem behavior if the purpose of the behavior is to escape or avoid a difficult academic or social situation. Ms. Carter and Ms. Hwang further testified that STUDENT has significant language needs that dovetail with his behavioral difficulties. She stated that STUDENT’s difficulties with language someTimes lead to problem behaviors because STUDENT lacks the vocabulary to express his frustration.
Dr. Douglas Harrington, a private psychologist who specializes in the evaluation and treatment of individuals with traumatic or acquired brain injuries, conducted a neuropsychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in August 2003. Dr. Harrington spent approximately ten hours observing and assessing STUDENT over a period of several days. He also observed STUDENT at the Tustin Center and reviewed his behavioral data and incident reports in May 2004. He testified that children with brain injuries, such as STUDENT, typically exhibit an uneven profile of performance and behavior that requires specialized intervention. According to Dr. Harrington, the behavior of a child with a brain injury is neurologically or impulse driven as opposed to learned behavior, meaning that the child frequently reacts to a situation without a clear intent or purpose behind the behavior. He testified that STUDENT’s behavioral functioning level is that of a three to four year old. Dr. Harrington testified that attention and concentration are the primary areas of cognitive impairment for STUDENT. As a result, STUDENT requires frequent redirection and he experiences difficulty in transitioning from one activity to another. According to Dr. Harrington, STUDENT also has difficulty remembering rules or lists of rules and that verbally based rules, in particular, pose significant difficulty for him.
Dr. Harrington stated that STUDENT needs a small, highly structured class designed for TBI students with a low student-to-teacher ratio, very few students, limited distractions, one-to-one assistance, the related services of occupational therapy and speech and language therapy, and staff trained in addressing the needs of students with traumatic and acquired brain injuries. In addition, he recommends a concrete, consistent, and structured behavioral program that is incorporated into his entire educational program with an on-site behaviorist and a school psychologist with a neuropsychology specialty on his IEP team. Dr. Harrington also testified that staff working with STUDENT should be trained in the use of a recognized prone restraint system such as Physical Assault Response Training (PART). He noted that there have been behavioral incidents at Tustin during which the staff was required to physically restrain STUDENT and that such training allows staff to safely restrain STUDENT. Finally, he testified that if STUDENT’s behaviors are not resolved, they could lead to suspensions from school and ostracization, which, in turn, would result in a sense of failure and a lack of belonging.
Several District witnesses testified regarding STUDENT’s needs in the area of behavior. David Brown, director of special services for the District, conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in August 2001 when he was employed as the District’s school psychologist. He also observed STUDENT in class during the fall semester of the 2003-2004 school year. He testified that STUDENT needs a structured and supportive academic setting, instruction in reciprocal social relationships and parallel play, behavioral boundaries, a concrete schedule, small-group instruction, and assistance with transitions. Mary Anne Klensky, a program specialist/behavior intervention case manager for the East Valley SELPA, also testified on behalf of the District. Ms. Klensky did not specifically testify as to STUDENT’s needs in the area of behavior, except to the extent that she testified about a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT that she conducted in March 2003 and a behavior intervention plan (BIP) she subsequently prepared. In the BIP, she recommends the use of social stories to reinforce appropriate social behavior such as taking turns, asking permission to hold objects, a daily schedule to enable STUDENT to gain a visual understanding of tasks and activities that will be expected of him each day, verbal praise, and data collection of the targeted maladaptive behaviors. Todd Eachus, director of Success for Kids, Inc., also testified regarding STUDENT’s needs in the area of behavior. (Footnote 9) Mr. Eachus reviewed STUDENT’s educational records but has not met STUDENT. He stated that special attention should be paid to the visual and auditory stimuli in the classroom to increase STUDENT’s focus on task, that the triggers for STUDENT’s tantrums and non-compliance be examined and anticipated, and that scripting be done to eliminate aggression by providing alternate ways for STUDENT to respond to frustration or conflict.
The Hearing Officer notes that the parties’ witnesses agreed with respect to many of STUDENT’s needs in the area of behavior. Specifically, they all testified that STUDENT requires a structured and supportive academic setting, a concrete schedule, small-group instruction, assistance with transitions, a one-to-one aide, and behavioral intervention. The Hearing Officer generally found the testimony of Petitioner’s witnesses to be more persuasive regarding the nature and extent of STUDENT’s educational needs in the area of behavior. Dr. Harrington, Ms. Carter, and Ms. Hwang all have experience in the area of educating students with traumatic and acquired brain injuries. Dr. Harrington has a doctorate in educational psychology with an emphasis in neuropsychology and is certified by the American Board of Neuropsychology. He has over twenty years of experience evaluating and treating individuals with brain injuries. Juda Carter has served as the director of the Tustin Center since September 2003 and prior to that was employed as an educational consultant for the Orange County Regional Center, where she received training in traumatic and acquired brain injuries. Ms. Hwang is a credentialed school psychologist and is currently working toward certification as a board certified behavior analyst. She has extensive experience in providing behavioral support services to children. In addition to their experience, each of these individuals, with the exception of Dr. Harrington, has had the opportunity to observe and evaluate STUDENT on a daily basis since January 2004, when STUDENT began attending Tustin. In contrast, Mr. Brown and Ms. Klenske’s last detailed observations of STUDENT occurred in 2003, while Mr. Eachus has never met STUDENT, let alone observed him in an educational setting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s witnesses were more reliable and provided more specific information regarding STUDENT’s current needs.
Based upon the testimony set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires the following components in his program to meet his unique needs in the area of behavior: 1) a highly structured placement designed for TBI students in which all personnel working with STUDENT are able to be involved in his program and with each other on a daily basis and in regularly scheduled meetings, 2) a small, manageable physical setting, 3) academic instruction in small groups until STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to be integrated with a larger group of students, 4) a positive behavior plan applied in a consistent manner by all staff with regular and consistent data collection throughout the day, 5) a trained behaviorist on site full Time to regularly monitor STUDENT’s behavior, consult with staff, and adjust his behavior intervention plan as needed, 6) a trained full-Time one-to-one aide trained in a recognized prone restraint system such as PART and trained to work with students with brain injuries, 7) any one-to-one aide working with STUDENT requires training in these areas set forth in item 6, including any aides who relieve STUDENT’s primary aide, and 8) a school psychologist with a background in brain injuries on his IEP team.
B. Speech and Language
1. Deficits
There was no dispute between the parties regarding STUDENT’s deficits in the area of speech and language. Petitioner presented the testimony of witness Katy Peck-Frost, STUDENT’s current speech and language therapist at the Tustin Center. Ms. Frost has provided STUDENT with speech and language therapy since January 2004, when STUDENT first began attending the Tustin Center. Since that Time, she has provided STUDENT with speech and language therapy two Times per week: once a week for thirty minutes on a one-to-one basis and once a week for thirty minutes in a small group setting. She testified that STUDENT has deficits in the areas of expressive language skills/word finding, auditory processing, memory, attention, executive function, and social communication/pragmatics.
Elizabeth Paganini similarly testified on behalf of the District with respect to STUDENT’s deficits in the area of speech and language. She provided STUDENT with one-to-one speech therapy two Times per week for thirty minutes per session at Lake Arrowhead from September to December of 2003. She testified that STUDENT’s areas of deficit in speech and language are expressive language and pragmatic/social language.
2. Educational Needs
Ms. Peck-Frost also testified regarding the program and services STUDENT needs to address these areas of deficit. She indicated that STUDENT’s current goals and objectives in the area of speech and language include: 1) identifying and selecting verbal and nonverbal social behaviors, greeting and exiting, and initiating and responding to questions, 2) demonstrating attention to tasks, 3) identifying, expressing, and applying emotions to social scenarios, 4) labeling, tracking, and counting phonemes, and 5) answering biographical and orientation questions related to episodic recall. She testified that STUDENT will not meet all of these goals and objectives with the current level of speech and language services being provided to him. Specifically, she noted that goal number four (labeling, tracking, and counting phonemes) has only been addressed minimally due to Time constraints and the limited frequency of therapy sessions. Ms. Peck-Frost testified that all of STUDENT’s needs in the area of speech and language could be met if the frequency of his therapy was increased to three thirty-minute sessions of one-to-one therapy per week and one thirty-minute session of group therapy per week. According to Ms. Peck-Frost, STUDENT can currently only handle approximately ten to twenty minutes of group therapy (with the group consisting of one other student) before he starts exhibiting behaviors. In addition, she testified that STUDENT requires a specialized approach for speech and language therapy due to his behaviors. Specifically, she stated that a knowledge of behavior protocol is essential to understand the cycle of triggers and crisis management. She also emphasized the importance of daily contact and case management with the teacher and other staff involved in STUDENT’s program to ensure consistency in the management of his behavior. Finally, she testified that STUDENT needs a speech and language therapist with behavioral intervention experience and PART training due to STUDENT’s physically aggressive behaviors.
Ms. Paganini also testified regarding the type and amount of services STUDENT needs to address his areas of deficit in this area. She stated that a multi-modal speech and language program incorporating touch, smell, taste, movement, and visual stimulation had been beneficial for STUDENT while at the District. She further testified that the amount of speech and language therapy that the District had been providing for STUDENT, one-to-one speech therapy two Times per week for thirty minutes per session, was sufficient to meet his needs. David Brown, director of special services for the District, testified that STUDENT requires two to three thirty-minute sessions of speech and language per week, individual or small group. (Footnote 10) He defined a small group as two to three students.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Peck-Frost to be persuasive regarding STUDENT’s needs in the area of speech and language. She is licensed by the State of California as a speech and language pathologist and is credentialed by the American Speech and Hearing Association (ASHA). She is also active in a division of ASHA devoted to neuropsychology. She worked for the Alex Center (now the Tustin Center) for three years on a contract basis as a speech and language pathologist and joined the Tustin Center in September 2003 on a full-Time basis. Ms. Peck-Frost has worked with STUDENT two Times per week since January 2004 and is, therefore, in the best position to offer an opinion as to his current needs in the area of speech and language. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony that STUDENT is in need of an additional one-half hour of one-to-one speech and language therapy to be persuasive, particularly in light of the fact that she has not had sufficient Time to meaningfully address all of STUDENT’s goals and objectives in that area. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds her testimony persuasive that STUDENT requires a speech and language therapist trained in behavioral intervention techniques, due to his significant behavioral difficulties. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require a speech and language therapist trained in a recognized prone restraint system such as PART because STUDENT will have a one-to-one aide with this training present during his speech and language therapy sessions.
****
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires the following components in his program to meet his unique needs in the areas of behavior and speech and language: 1) a highly structured placement designed for TBI students in which all personnel working with STUDENT are able to be involved in his program and with each other on a daily basis and in regularly scheduled meetings, 2) a small, manageable physical setting, 3) academic instruction in small groups until STUDENT has demonstrated the ability to be integrated with a larger group of students, 4) a positive behavior plan applied in a consistent manner by all staff with regular and consistent data collection throughout the day, 5) a trained behaviorist on site full Time to regularly monitor STUDENT’s behavior, consult with staff, and adjust his behavior intervention plan as needed, 6) a trained full-Time one-to-one aide trained in a recognized prone restraint system such as PART and trained to work with students with brain injuries, 7) Any one-to-one aide working with STUDENT requires training in these areas set forth in item 6, including any aides who relieve STUDENT’s primary aide, 8) a school psychologist with a background in brain injuries on his IEP team, and 9) ninety minutes per week of one-to-one speech and language services and thirty minutes per week of small-group speech and language services provided by a therapist trained in behavioral intervention techniques.
3. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs
Now that the Hearing Officer has determined STUDENT’s unique educational needs, he must determine whether the District’s offer is designed to meet those needs for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year.
a. Behavior
Petitioner contends that the District’s offer of placement and services for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year fails to appropriately address his significant behavioral needs. Specifically, Petitioner focuses on the District’s alleged failure to show how a positive behavior support plan would be developed, implemented, and adjusted as needed. Additionally, Petitioner contends that the District has failed to offer a highly structured, well-coordinated program in which the personnel working with him would be on-site and involved with his program and with each other on a daily basis. Specifically, there was no discussion of providing for regular meetings of the staff working with him. The District contends that its offered programs appropriately address STUDENT’s educational needs, including his behavioral needs.
The District witnesses testified that the District offered STUDENT placement in an SDC at Lake Gregory Elementary for the 2004 ESY and offered STUDENT placement at either an SDC at Lake Gregory or Lake Arrowhead Elementary for the 2004-2005 regular school year. According to the District’s witnesses, either of these offered placements would include a one-to-one instructional aide, one-to-one speech and language therapy for one hour per week and small-group therapy for thirty minutes per week, APE for two thirty-minute sessions per week, and occupational therapy for one hour per week. Finally, District witnesses testified that District staff was receiving training regarding TBI students. Specifically, Mary Ann Klensky, program specialist for the SELPA, testified that District staff was receiving training in the area of TBI from herself, Todd Eachus, director of Success for Kids, Inc., and Christine Grandinetti, an independent TBI consultant. This training addresses the causes of TBI and its educational implications and interventions.
Brandon Harms, the teacher at the Lake Gregory SDC where the District proposed placing STUDENT for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year, testified that he has a preliminary multi-subject teaching credential but no special education credential. (Footnote 11) He testified that he had eight students in his class for the 2003-2004 school year and that he anticipated having five students in his class for the 2004 ESY. Mr. Harms could not recall the specific disabilities of each of his students for the 2003-2004 school year, but indicated that one has cerebral palsy and at least two have specific learning disabilities. He described all of his students as “socially mild” and “high functioning” in the area of speech and language, which he defined as having the ability to communicate effectively with peers and adults. According to Mr. Harms, his students mainstream with regular education students on the campus for physical education and health once a week.
Ward Lee, the teacher at the Lake Arrowhead SDC where the District proposed placing STUDENT for the 2004-2005 regular school year, testified that he has a multi-subject credential and is approximately halfway through his program for a mildly to moderately disabled special education teaching credential. He started teaching the SDC at Lake Arrowhead on September 19, 2003. He testified that there were eight students in his class for the 2003-2004 school year. He indicated that of those eight, four were placed under the disability category of specific learning disability, two were autistic, and one was orthopedically impaired. He could not recall the classification of the eighth student.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offered programs are not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs in the area of behavior for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. The evidence presented at hearing demonstrates that the District was unable to properly address STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties during the first half of the 2003-2004 school year when STUDENT attended the SDC at Lake Arrowhead. As set forth above, STUDENT’s mother testified that the District’s response to STUDENT’s behaviors was, in many cases, to “evacuate” the classroom and contact her or a member of her family to come and pick STUDENT up from school when he was experiencing behavioral difficulties. Not only does such a response interfere with STUDENT’s ability to benefit from his education by removing him from his educational environment, it also, according to Ms. Hwang, has the effect of reinforcing STUDENT’s behaviors, particularly when the function of his behavior is to escape a difficult task or activity. According to STUDENT’s mother and Jackie Peebles, a one-to-one aide hired by STUDENT’s mother to assist him in class in October 2003, District staff would also frequently physically take STUDENT down to a prone restraint position during behavioral episodes and keep him there, someTimes for as long as an hour or more. STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Peebles also testified that they never observed instruction utilizing social stories, even though STUDENT’s behavior intervention plan called for the development and use of such stories. They further testified that they had not observed District staff collecting data on STUDENT’s behaviors during this Time period, despite the fact that the behavior intervention plan in place called for such data collection. The District did not present evidence refuting these contentions, either in the form of testimony or actual records of data collection. As set forth above, the evidence presented at hearing establishes that such data collection is a critical component of STUDENT’s program because it drives the behavioral interventions used for STUDENT. District witnesses testified that the District agreed to send STUDENT to the Tustin Center in the hope that his behaviors could be brought under control there. Furthermore, the evidence established that STUDENT’s behaviors have continued at the Tustin Center and that, even though his behavior is slowly improving, it still remains a significant area of deficit. Finally, the District failed to present any evidence of a plan to transition STUDENT from the Tustin Center to a District program.
The District’s offer for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year fails to indicate how District staff would address STUDENT’s significant behavioral difficulties in a manner different from the previous year. It references continued implementation of the behavioral intervention plan, but fails to state the nature and extent of the behavioral support that STUDENT would receive, such as data collection and regular consultation between the teacher, staff, and a behaviorist. Moreover, none of the District witnesses addressed in any detail how STUDENT’s behavior would be addressed upon his return to a District school, other than to describe some training that the District is providing to its staff regarding students with brain injuries, the provision of a one-to-one aide, additional speech and language therapy, and a “relaxation room” for STUDENT to calm down in during behavioral episodes. While the Hearing Officer commends the District on pursuing such training for its staff, the training is not a substitute for the specific, structured program that STUDENT needs at this Time. With regard to the offer of a one-to-one aide, the Hearing Officer notes that, according to Mr. Brown, the District provided STUDENT with a one-to-one aide during the first half of the 2003-2004 school year but that despite this assistance, STUDENT’s behaviors could not be adequately addressed at Lake Arrowhead. With regard to behavior intervention, there was no testimony regarding how, when, or by whom data would be collected on STUDENT’s behaviors and how the behavior intervention plan would be implemented, monitored, and adjusted based upon the data collected. Moreover, the District failed to address how it would provide an academic program in a small-group setting and whether or how it would provide one-to-one aides trained in a recognized prone restraint system such as PART.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the District has failed to offer STUDENT the type of comprehensive and specialized program that specifically focuses on his unique needs as a student with TBI. As Dr. Harrington testified, children with brain injuries, such as STUDENT, exhibit an uneven profile of performance and behavior that requires specialized intervention. According to Dr. Harrington, the behavior of a child with a brain injury is neurologically or impulse driven as opposed to learned behavior, meaning that the child frequently reacts to a situation without a clear intent or purpose behind the behavior. Thus, traditional methods of addressing problem behaviors do not always work for a TBI student. Moreover, these students need an environment where the instruction and services are closely coordinated and “cross-pollinate,” ensuring that everyone addresses STUDENT’s instruction and behavioral intervention in the same manner each day.
The placements offered by the District at Lake Gregory and Lake Arrowhead do not offer the type of comprehensive and specialized program that STUDENT requires. Those classes each contain seven to eight students with a variety of disabilities other than TBI. In addition, the educational needs of those children appear to differ substantially from STUDENT’s. Specifically, the students in those classes lack the behavioral deficits found in STUDENT and the students at Lake Gregory also lack the speech and language deficits found in STUDENT. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offers are not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs.
b. Speech and Language
The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer also fails to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language. The District’s offer of April 27, 2004 indicates that the District would provide STUDENT with one hour per week of speech and language therapy. It does not indicate whether this hour would be one-to-one therapy, group therapy, or a combination of the two. At hearing, David Brown, director of special services for the District, testified that the District subsequently offered STUDENT ninety minutes of speech and language therapy per week, which would consist of sixty minutes of one-to-one therapy and thirty minutes of small-group therapy. (Footnote 12) In addition, there was testimony by Ward Lee and Angelle Colvin, an instructional tutor in Mr. Lee’s SDC, that his SDC at Lake Arrowhead is “language focused,” meaning that he provides additional small-group speech and language instruction to the students with the assistance of Ms. Colvin, who testified that she received an emergency speech and language credential in March or April of 2004.
As set forth above, the evidence demonstrates that STUDENT requires ninety minutes of one-to-one speech and language therapy per week and thirty minutes per week of small-group therapy to meet his educational needs. In addition, given his significant behavioral deficits, STUDENT’s therapy needs to be provided by a speech and language therapist trained in behavioral intervention techniques. The District has failed to offer STUDENT a program with these requisite components. While the “language-focused” SDC at Lake Gregory would provide additional small-group speech and language services to STUDENT on a daily basis, the evidence presented indicates that STUDENT would likely receive little benefit from such instruction at present due to his behavioral difficulties, his distractibility, and his inability to work in a classroom with more than two or three other students. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language therapy.
4. Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
As set forth above, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s offers are not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of behavior and speech and language. The evidence presented at hearing established that STUDENT’s behavior was declining significantly during 2003 in spite of the development of a behavior intervention plan, and that he would, therefore, likely receive little to no benefit if he returned to such a program at this point in Time because his behaviors have not significantly improved since then. District witnesses, including Mr. Brown, testified that the District representatives agreed to place STUDENT at the Tustin Center for the second half of the 2003-2004 school year in the hope that STUDENT’s behaviors could be brought under control. Although the District has offered the addition of a one-to-one aide and an additional one-half hour of speech and language, it has failed to develop and offer a comprehensive program designed to address STUDENT’s extensive and unique behavioral needs and to meet its burden of showing that it is now better equipped to address those needs. Furthermore, the District’s offer is not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit in the area of speech and language because it does not afford enough one-to-one Time to allow STUDENT to meet his goals and objectives and because it does not provide a speech and language therapist trained in behavioral intervention techniques. Because appropriate behavior and communication are essential for a student such as STUDENT to benefit educationally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
5. Comport with the IEP and Least Restrictive Environment
Here, the Hearing Officer has already determined that the programs offered by the District are not appropriate in that they are not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs nor are they reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Because the programs offered by the District are inappropriate, there is no need to determine if the programs comport with the IEP or if the District offered placements in the least restrictive environment.
****
The evidence established that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. First, the District committed a procedural violation by failing to make a clear written offer of placement and services for STUDENT for the 2004 extended school year (ESY) and the 2004-2005 regular school year as required by the IDEA and State law. This resulted in a denial of FAPE because STUDENT’s mother did not receive sufficient information from the District at the April IEP meeting or thereafter to adequately understand what the District was offering in terms of a program for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. Second, the District’s offer for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year were substantively inappropriate because the offered programs are not designed to meet his unique needs in the areas of behavior and speech and language and are not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in these areas. Specifically, the District failed to offer STUDENT a comprehensive and structured milieu centered and focused upon STUDENT’s significant behavioral needs. This milieu should consist of a small, manageable physical setting where all staff who work with STUDENT, including the behaviorist, speech and language therapist, and occupational therapist, are on-site and are able to confer with each other on a daily basis and participate in regular meetings of staff to ensure consistency in instruction and behavioral interventions.
Issue No. 2: Is STUDENT entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year?
Petitioner contends that he is entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. He maintains that the programs and related services offered by the Tustin Center are meeting his needs, providing him with educational benefit, and are doing so in a manner designed to address the goals and objectives found in the IEP of February 2004. Petitioner further contends that the Tustin Center is the least restrictive environment in which his needs can be effectively met. The District contends that the Tustin Center is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because an IEP team did not make the decision to place him there, he is not making progress there, and it is not the least restrictive environment for him.
To obtain prospective placement at an NPS such as Tustin, the evidence must establish that the District has failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, that Tustin can provide him with a FAPE, and that Tustin is certified by the State. (Cal. Educ. Code §56505.2(a)-(c).) , (Footnote 13 & 14) A. Can the Tustin Center Provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
The Hearing Officer previously found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must now determine whether the Tustin Center can provide STUDENT with a FAPE.
As previously set forth, under the IDEA and Rowley, the Tustin program must meet the following three substantive requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program for purposes of prospective placement. It must: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) comport with his IEP. Finally, it must offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.
1. STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT’s unique needs have been discussed in detail above.
2. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs
Petitioner presented several witnesses who persuasively testified that the Tustin Center can address his educational needs. Dr. Douglas Harrington, Juda Carter, and Bethany Hwang all testified that the Tustin Center has met, and will continue to meet, STUDENT’s needs including those enumerated above. Specifically, they testified that Tustin offers STUDENT a small, manageable physical setting and that all staff who work with STUDENT, including the behaviorist, speech and language therapist, and occupational therapist, are on-site and are able to confer with each other on a daily basis and participate in regular meetings of staff to ensure consistency in instruction and behavioral interventions. A full-Time on-site behaviorist is available to monitor, consult, and adjust STUDENT’s behavior intervention plan. In addition, STUDENT is receiving instruction in very small groups (two other students) due to his present inability to function in larger groups. A behavior plan, prepared by an on-site behaviorist, is in place to address STUDENT’s problem behaviors through positive reinforcement of appropriate replacement behaviors and is supported by the collection of data on STUDENT’s behaviors every fifteen minutes of his school day. The Tustin staff is trained in PART and Tustin has a one-to-one aide for STUDENT who is trained in PART and trained to work with students with brain injury. The Tustin speech and language therapist could also provide STUDENT with ninety minutes per week of one-to-one speech and language therapy and thirty minutes per week of small-group therapy. In addition, Dr. Harrington, or another qualified psychologist with an emphasis in neurodevelopmental psychology, would be available to serve as a member of STUDENT’s IEP team.
In addition to his needs in the areas of behavior and speech and language, STUDENT has needs in the areas of academics, attention, sensory integration, and fine and gross motor skills. The evidence established that the Tustin Center can meet these needs as well through classroom instruction, the provision of a trained one-to-one aide, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education.
3. Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
The testimony of the Petitioner’s witnesses, along with documentary evidence in the form of progress reports and evaluations, also establish that STUDENT has derived educational benefit from his placement in the Tustin program. Specifically, STUDENT’s latest progress report from Tustin, dated April 8, 2004, indicates that STUDENT is making progress on his academic goals and objectives in the areas of math, reading, speech and language, and task completion. In addition, the reports by Bethany Hwang, along with her testimony at hearing, establish that STUDENT is making progress in the area of behavior. Specifically, Ms. Hwang’s behavioral services report for the period covering January through March of 2004 documents declines in the frequency of several targeted behaviors, including leaving the area, screaming, throwing objects, and physical aggression. Dr. Harrington testified that it would be premature to consider transitioning STUDENT to a District placement at this juncture as he has only been at the Tustin Center for six months and is just now beginning to show some measurable progress in his learning and behaviors. He stated that STUDENT would likely require another calendar school year at Tustin before a transition back to his home district should be considered. Consequently, should STUDENT’s placement at the Tustin Center continue, it would be reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.
4. Conforms to the IEP
The District does not contend that the Tustin program fails to conform to the IEP of February and April 2004. In any event, the testimony of Petitioner’s witnesses, including behaviorist Bethany Hwang, speech and language therapist Katy Peck-Frost, and Juda Carter, and the Tustin progress reports submitted as evidence all establish that the Tustin program has conformed to the most recent IEP. Specifically, the goals and objectives set forth in that IEP are being addressed in an SDC at the Tustin Center and STUDENT is receiving the related services of speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education as called for in that IEP. Thus, the evidence establishes that the Tustin Center could continue to provide a placement in conformity with STUDENT’s IEP.
5. Least Restrictive Environment
Petitioner contends that the Tustin Center is the least restrictive environment in which his needs can be effectively met at this point in Time. He maintains that because of his behaviors, “mainstreaming” him even with other SDC children at a District school would put them all at risk.
The District contends that the Tustin Center is the most restrictive placement for STUDENT other than a residential or institutional setting. Specifically, the District maintains that the Tustin Center presents no opportunities for mainstreaming or interaction with nondisabled peers during the school day.
Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (Footnote 15) (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56342(b).) 20 U.S.C. 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
The Hearing Officer concludes that a special center for TBI students, such as the Tustin Center, is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT at this Time. The evidence presented at hearing clearly establishes that STUDENT has significant behavioral deficits that were not being adequately addressed in the prior District placement. STUDENT’s behaviors have impacted, and continue to impact, all of those around him, including other students and staff. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the evidence at hearing that Tustin can offer STUDENT a comprehensive and structured milieu centered upon his significant behavioral needs. Specifically, Tustin offers a small, manageable physical setting where all staff who work with STUDENT, including the behaviorist, speech and language therapist, and occupational therapist, are on-site and are able to confer with each other on a daily basis and participate in regular meetings of staff to ensure consistency in instruction and behavioral interventions.
Until his behaviors are brought under control and he is able to self-regulate them, STUDENT needs the small, highly structured and highly specialized environment that Tustin offers. Petitioner’s witnesses testified that once STUDENT’s behaviors have been successfully addressed, he should be in a position to return to a District SDC classroom and possibly participate in some mainstreaming with regular education students.
*****
The evidence established that the District has failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. The evidence further demonstrates that the Tustin Center can provide STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. Tustin’s program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of behavior, social skills, attention, speech and language, occupational therapy, and academics, is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in these areas, and comports with the most recent IEP. In addition, Tustin is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT at this point in Time. Finally, the Tustin Center is certified by the State Department of Education as a nonpublic school. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year is appropriate.
In light of the above, the District shall provide placement for STUDENT at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. This placement shall include the cost of a full-Time one-to-one aide and an additional one-half hour of one-to- one speech and language therapy.
Petitioner has also requested that the District be ordered to pay the living expenses of he and his mother during the period of Time that he attends the Tustin Center, as the Tustin Center is not a residential placement and is located over seventy miles from Lake Arrowhead. STUDENT’s mother testified that due to the extraordinary distance between Tustin and her residence in Lake Arrowhead, she rented an apartment in Irvine, California, so that she and STUDENT could live near Tustin during the week while he attended the Tustin Center. She testified that under the agreement entered into with the District in December 2003, STUDENT has been receiving $2,000.00 per month for living expenses while he has attended Tustin for the period from January through June of 2004. She testified that the costs, which include rent, gas, electric, phone, cable, trash, water, child care, and transportation, have exceeded that monthly allotment and that these expenses currently total approximately $2,500.00 per month. STUDENT requests an order that the District pay these living expenses in the amount of $2,500.00 per month. The District argues that Petitioner’s request is unsupported by the evidence.
Under the IDEA, related services include transportation and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(7); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.) The IDEA explicitly acknowledges that because of the lack of adequate services in the public school system, families are often forced to find services outside the public school system, often at great distance from their residence and at their own expense. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(b)(6).) Because the sole purpose of the IDEA is to assure that all children with disabilities are provided with a free appropriate public education at no cost to the parents, the language and spirit of the IDEA encompasses reimbursement for reasonable transportation and lodging in certain cases as related services. (See Ojai Unified School District v. Jackson, 4 F.3d 1467, 1478-1479 (9th Cir. 1992); Union School District v. Smith, supra, 15 F.3d at 1528.)
Here, the evidence supports the payment of STUDENT’s reasonable living expenses. The question is which expenses are reasonable. Petitioner did not present any itemization of the specific cost for each living expense, such as rent, electricity, or the like. Since STUDENT and his mother do not reside at their home in Lake Arrowhead during the week, however, some of the living expenses incurred by STUDENT and his mother in Tustin should not be reimbursed because these same expenses would have been incurred in Lake Arrowhead if STUDENT had not been placed at the Tustin Center and because these expenses are not duplicative. (Footnote 16) These expenses include electricity, water, child care, and transportation, other than the transportation between Lake Arrowhead and Tustin. In addition, STUDENT’s mother testified that she turned off the cable and the phone at their Lake Arrowhead residence, making reimbursement of these expenses at the Irvine residence inappropriate for the same reason. Therefore, taking account of the non-reimbursable expenses, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s prospective placement at the Tustin Center shall also include the payment of the reasonable living expenses of Petitioner and his mother in the amount of $2,000.00 per month while Petitioner is attending the Tustin Center. The District did not offer evidence that this amount was unreasonable and STUDENT’s mother did not establish the necessity of an increase in this amount.
Issue No. 3: Is STUDENT’s mother entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred for tuition, a one-to-one aide, related services, and housing costs related to STUDENT’s placement at the Tustin Center following June 30, 2004?
Petitioner contends that his mother is entitled to reimbursement for costs or obligations incurred as a result of his continued placement at the Tustin Center after June 30, 2004, when the District’s contractual obligation to fund this placement expired. Specifically, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the following: 1) tuition at the Tustin Center, including an anticipated increase in tuition due to the addition of a one-to-one aide and an additional thirty minutes per week of one-to-one speech and language therapy, and 2) living expenses in the amount of $2,500.00 per month while STUDENT attends the Tustin Center.
The District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for expenses related to the Tustin Center placement because the Tustin Center is not an appropriate placement for him. Specifically, it maintains that an IEP team did not make the decision to place him there, he is not making progress there, and it is not the least restrictive environment for him.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 131 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).) The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. (Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F. 2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).) In Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court expressly exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the State. (Id. at 13-14.) The Court recognized, however, that the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. (Id.) In summary, to be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private services, it must be determined that 1) the student was denied a FAPE, and 2) the student’s private placement or program addresses the student’s educational needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him or her with educational benefit.
As set forth above, the Hearing Officer has already determined that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. In addition, as set forth above, the Hearing Officer has determined that the program provided by the Tustin Center address STUDENT’s educational needs and is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer further found that the addition of a one-to-one aide and thirty additional minutes of one-to-one speech and language therapy per week are necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds reimbursement of expenses for the Tustin Center appropriate. The District shall reimburse Petitioner for costs of the Tustin Center that may have been incurred by STUDENT’s mother after June 30, 2004, the date the District’s contractual obligation to fund the Tustin Center placement ended, including any portion of the 2004 ESY after June 30, 2004 and the 2004-2005 regular school year. (Footnote 17)Said costs shall include the cost of a full-Time one-to-one aide, an additional one-half hour of one-to-one speech and language therapy, and living expenses in the amount of $2000.00 per month while STUDENT is attending the Tustin Center.
ORDER
1. The District shall reimburse Petitioner for any costs that might have been incurred by STUDENT’s mother for placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 ESY after June 30, 2004. Said costs shall include: 1) any tuition previously paid, 2) the cost of a full-Time one-to-one aide, if provided, 3) an additional one-half hour of one-to-one speech and language therapy, if provided, and 4) living expenses in the amount of $2,000.00 per month while Petitioner was attending the Tustin Center. Reimbursement shall be made within fifteen calendar days from the receipt of proof of such costs. (Footnote 18)
2. The District shall reimburse Petitioner for any costs of the Tustin Center for the period of the 2004-2005 regular school year that STUDENT’s mother has incurred or will incur until the District assumes responsibility for these costs in compliance with paragraph 3. Said costs shall include: 1) any tuition previously paid, 2) the cost of a full-Time one-to-one aide, if provided, 3) an additional one-half hour of one-to-one speech and language therapy, if provided, and 4) living expenses in the amount of $2,000.00 per month while Petitioner is attending the Tustin Center. Reimbursement shall be made within fifteen calendar days from the receipt of proof of such costs.
3. The District shall immediately provide prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004-2005 regular school year. The prospective placement shall include the placement and services currently being provided to Petitioner at Tustin with the addition of a full-Time one-to-one aide and an additional one-half hour of one-to-one speech and language services. The District shall also pay Petitioner’s monthly living expenses in Tustin in the amount of $2,000.00 during the 2004-2005 regular school year while he attends the Tustin Center. Said payments for living expenses shall be made directly to Petitioner’s mother on the first of each month.
4. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Date: August 13, 2004 ___________________________________ Christian P. Hurley, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Prior to the hearing, Petitioner filed a written motion to change the burden of going forward at hearing on the ground that it was unclear from the District’s offer as to the specific placement and program being offered. On May 24, 2004, the Hearing Office issued a minute order granting this motion. As a result, the District presented its case first at hearing.
2 The District represented that these two witnesses would be testifying regarding training provided to District staff in the area of traumatic brain injuries.
3 STUDENT was ten years old during the period this hearing was held. He turned eleven on August 5, 2004.
4 Neither party submitted the mediation agreement as evidence in this hearing.
5 Neither party submitted this written offer of settlement as evidence in this hearing.
6 The IDEA and State law assures the parents the right to participate in the IEP process. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(5)(B); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(1).)
7 Neither party submitted this written offer of settlement as evidence in this hearing. It was unclear from the record whether this settlement offer encompassed programs in addition to those at Lake Arrowhead or Lake Gregory Elementary.
8 There are additional requirements that a program must meet to constitute an appropriate educational program, including preparation for independent living, which are not at issue here.
9 Success for Kids, Inc. operates two nonpublic schools for profoundly disabled, medically fragile, technology-dependent children.
10 Mr. Brown is not licensed or trained as a speech and language therapist.
11 Mr. Harms testified that he was not sure whether he would be teaching the same class for the 2004-2005 regular school year.
12 No evidence was presented at hearing that this offer was presented in writing to Petitioner at any Time. The District may not supplement its offer by means of testimony at hearing.
13 Also, in decisions relating to the placement of individuals with exceptional needs, the Hearing Officer must consider cost. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(h).) The parties presented minimal evidence at hearing regarding the respective costs of each program. According to its brochure, the Tustin Center charges a daily rate of $205.00 per day, which does not include the cost of related services such as speech and language, occupational therapy, and one-to-one aides. The District did not present any evidence of the cost of its offered programs, making a comparison between the two difficult, if not impossible. Indeed, such a comparison is more complicated than it appears at first blush. In order to evaluate the cost of the District placement, the Hearing Officer must take into account the cost of books, the desk, the teacher and staff, and overhead expenses such as electricity, water, and building maintenance. Finally, cost can only be considered when more than one appropriate placement is on the table. Here, as set forth above, the Tustin Center is the only placement that has been established as appropriate for STUDENT by the evidence in this case.
14 Education Code section 56505.2(b) provides that the Hearing Officer shall consider sections 56365, 56365.5, 56366, and 56366.1 during a due process hearing concerning an issue of placement of an individual with exceptional needs in a NPS such as Tustin. Section 56365, subdivision (a), generally provides that services required by the student shall be provided by an NPS when no appropriate public education program is available. While these sections are binding on a district or a SELPA, they do not require a hearing officer to evaluate all available placements because the hearing officer, unlike a District or SELPA, does not have information on all available public education programs within a District or SELPA. Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that section 56365.5 has been repealed.
15 In determining whether a placement is the least restrictive environment for a student, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has indicated that four factors need to be considered. Those factors include: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to educational benefits of a special education classroom, (2) the non-academic benefits to the handicapped child of interaction with nonhandicapped children, (3) the effect of the presence of the handicapped child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom, and (4) the costs of supplementary aids and services necessary to mainstream the handicapped child in a regular classroom setting. (Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 1207 (1994).) The test set forth above, however, is designed to determine whether the least restrictive environment for a student is a regular education classroom or special education classroom. Here, the issue is whether a District SDC or a special center for TBI students is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. Therefore, the factors set forth in the Rachel H. case do not strictly apply here because no one is claiming that a regular education placement would be appropriate for STUDENT at this juncture.
16 In other words, during the Time that STUDENT and his mother are in Irvine during the week, they should not be incurring costs at their Lake Arrowhead residence for items such as electricity, water, child care, and transportation.
17 The Hearing Officer notes that neither party presented information regarding the beginning and ending dates for STUDENT’s 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. It is also unknown whether STUDENT’s mother has incurred any expenses related to STUDENT’s placement at Tustin for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year. The intent of the Hearing Officer’s order is to ensure that STUDENT’s mother is reimbursed for the expenses she has incurred for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 regular school year and that the District begin funding STUDENT’s placement at Tustin upon receipt of this Decision.
18 Petitioner is not required to submit proof of monthly living expenses, only proof of payment of expenses directly related to STUDENT’s placement at the Tustin Center, such as tuition.
