California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 14, 2003

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1056-02 · Hearing Officer Sherianne Laba

Los Angeles Unified wins: eighth grader not eligible for special education, and parent denied reimbursement for her independent assessment.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A mother filed for due process on behalf of her 13-year-old eighth-grade daughter. The daughter was in general education and was not eligible for special education. The mother asked for reimbursement for an independent psychoeducational assessment by Dr. David Allen. She also sought eligibility based on a specific learning disability or a speech and language disorder, plus compensatory education and reimbursement for private tutoring. A claim for court-ordered counseling was dismissed because it fell under the juvenile court's jurisdiction. The mother withdrew an autism eligibility claim during the hearing.

The Hearing Officer denied all relief. The District's assessment met legal requirements and was done on time, so there was no basis to pay for the independent assessment. Under the Larry P. v. Riles injunction, standardized IQ tests could not be used to find the African American student eligible. The Hearing Officer therefore relied on the District psychologist's alternative estimate that her cognitive ability fell between 85 and 95. Neither the District's oral language score (89) nor Dr. Allen's (78) showed the required 22.5-point severe discrepancy. Her teachers testified that her low grades came from motivation and missing work, and she was earning an A in English. Speech pathologist Nancy Chalnick found normal articulation, voice, and fluency, and language scores that did not meet the eligibility cutoff. Because the student was not eligible, she received no compensatory education or tutoring reimbursement.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the Larry P. ban on IQ testing for African American students when deciding learning disability eligibility. It used alternative estimates of cognitive ability and the 22.5-point discrepancy formula of that era. It also shows that teacher testimony about motivation and grades can weigh heavily against a finding that a student needs special education.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue Preliminary A. Reimbursement for counseling services (raised at prehearing conference)

    Dismissed as outside the Hearing Officer's jurisdiction because the counseling was court-ordered and under the juvenile court's jurisdiction.

  2. Dismissed / withdrawnEligibility

    Issue Preliminary B. Whether Student is eligible for special education as a student with autism

    Student withdrew the autism eligibility claim on the second day of hearing.

  3. Issue I. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent psychoeducational assessment completed by David Allen, Ph.D.?

    No reimbursement: the District's assessment met statutory requirements and was timely, and the later speech-language assessment had no connection to a psychoeducational IEE that did not cover speech and language.

  4. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue II. Is Student eligible for special education services as a child with a specific learning disability?

    No severe discrepancy of 22.5 points between estimated cognitive ability (85-95) and achievement under either assessment, and any discrepancy could be corrected in the regular program.

  5. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue III. Is Student eligible for special education services as a child with a speech and language disorder?

    Articulation, voice, and fluency were normal; language scores were not 1.5 standard deviations below the mean; the language sample was adequate; and there was no adverse effect on education.

  6. Issue IV. If Student is eligible for special education services is she entitled to compensatory education services and reimbursement for private tutoring sessions?

    Student is not eligible for special education, so she is not entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Larry P. v. Riles; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Cal. Educ. Code § 56337; Cal. Educ. Code § 56333; Cal. Educ. Code § 56324; Cal. Educ. Code § 56344; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030

People named in the decision

  • Laverne Dumay, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Shari Robertson, due process specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Jacqueline Samuel-Cato, Student's therapist
  • David Allen, Ph.D., independent clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Reynaldo Macis, seventh-grade history teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Candace Seale, eighth-grade English teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Sheldon Brown, M.A., school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Nancy Chalnick, speech and language pathologist, Los Angeles Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Sherianne Laba, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on January 14, 15, and 22, 2003, in Los Angeles, California.

Petitioner, STUDENT, who was present on the first day of hearing, was represented by her mother, MOTHER. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf on the first day of hearing was family friend, FRIEND. The Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Peter Sansom. Also present on behalf of the District were due process specialists, Laverne Dumay and Shari Robertson.

The following witnesses provided testimony at the hearing: Jacqueline Samuel-Cato, STUDENT’s therapist; David Allen, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; Reynaldo Macis, seventh-grade history teacher; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; STUDENT, student; Candace Seale, eighth-grade English teacher, Sheldon Brown, school psychologist; and Nancy Chalnick, speech and language specialist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties’ written closing briefs were received on January 30, 2003. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

During a prehearing telephone conference, Petitioner raised the issue of reimbursement for counseling services. At the start of the due process hearing, during clarification of the issues, Petitioner revealed that the counseling services were actually court-ordered services which were mandated as part of her probation for an incident at school where she brandished a knife. Because the counseling services at issue were court ordered and therefore under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, that issue was dismissed as outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Officer. Additionally, at the start of the Hearing, STUDENT asserted that she was eligible for special education services as a student with autism. However, on the second day of hearing she withdrew that issue.

ISSUES

During a prehearing telephone conference, and at the start of the due process hearing, the issues were clarified as follows:

I. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent psychoeducational assessment completed by David Allen, Ph.D.?

II. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a child with a specific learning disability?

III. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a child with a speech and language disorder ?

IV. If STUDENT is eligible for special education services is she entitled to compensatory education services and reimbursement for private tutoring sessions?

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old student in the eighth grade who is not currently eligible for special education services. On April 12, 2002, STUDENT’s mother requested a student study team meeting in order to evaluate her eligibility for special education services. The concerns noted by STUDENT’s mother were “low SAT scores 4th - 6th; grades (6-7) & before; Reading level/speech; math comprehension.” An assessment plan was developed to evaluate STUDENT’s social emotional development, cognitive development, academic achievement, communications and language functioning, and health. STUDENT’s mother signed the assessment plan on May 24, 2002.

On May 23, 2002, STUDENT was arrested for brandishing a knife at school. Subsequently she appeared in juvenile court and was placed on probation. As part of her probation she was required to attend anger management classes, individual therapy, and family therapy. Additionally, she was required to improve her school attendance and grades. Prior to this incident STUDENT received mostly passing grades; however, her teachers consistently reported that she did not complete assignments, exhibited little effort to improve, and had excessive absences or tardies. With respect to grades, STUDENT completed her sixth grade year with one failing grade (English), three Ds (Math, Science, and World History), and two Bs (Chorus and Physical Education (PE)) and the seventh grade with two failing grades (Math and English), one D (Health), one C (PE) and two Bs (Chorus and World History). Currently, STUDENT is receiving three Ds (U.S. History, Science, and Algebra), one B (Art), and two A’s (English and PE).

On May 24, 2002, Sheldon Brown, M.A., school psychologist, conducted a psychoeducational assessment using a variety of methods to determine STUDENT’s cognitive ability academic achievement level. Mr. Brown conducted parent, teacher, and student interviews, made observations, and reviewed STUDENT’s test results, and school records.(Footnote 1) Using this information, Mr. Brown concluded that STUDENT’s cognitive ability was in the average range, most likely between 85 and 95. STUDENT’s academic achievement was measured using the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTA). STUDENT received the following scores:

Standard Score Grade Equivalent Math Appl. 89 5.5 Reading Decoding 90 5.6 Spelling 95 6.8 Reading Comprehension 95 6.9 Math Computation 93 6.8 Reading Composite 92 6.3 Math Composite 91 6.2 Battery Composite 90 5.9 (Student’s A13-16; District’s 25)

In the area of speech and language, STUDENT was given the Woodcock Language Proficiency Battery (WLPB). STUDENT’s scores were as follows:

Standard Score Percentile Memory for sentences 81 10 Picture Vocabulary 90 25 Oral Vocabulary 91 27 Listening Comprehension 84 14 Verbal Analogies 109 73 Composite Oral Language 89 23 (Student’s A13-16; District’s 25)

From the assessment information he obtained, Mr. Brown determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD). An IEP meeting was convened on June 27, 2002 to review the District’s assessment results and determine if STUDENT was eligible for special education services. The District determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services under the category of specific learning disability.

STUDENT’s mother disagreed with the findings of the District’s psychoeducational assessment and obtained an independent assessment from David Allen, Ph.D. Dr. Allen’s assessment was conducted in October 2002 and included administration of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC); Woodcock Johnson Achievement Test (WJ-III); Child Behavior Checklist, and SCAN test for Auditory Processing Disorders in Children.

On the WISC, STUDENT received a full scale IQ of 76, performance IQ of 82, and Verbal IQ of 73. However, Dr. Allen determined that her overall cognitive abilities were likely to fall in the average range when her learning disorder was factored out. On the WJ-III STUDENT received the following scores:

Standard Score Range Oral Language 78 73-83 Total Achievement 94 92-95 Broad Reading 88 87-90 Broad Math 97 95-100 Math Calc Skills 98 95-102 Academic Skills 95 93-98 Academic Fluency 88 86-89 (Student’s A7-12) From the test results that he collected, Dr. Allen concluded STUDENT was eligible for special education services due to a severe discrepancy between her oral language achievement score (78). Dr. Allen estimated that when STUDENT’s disability is factored out, her cognitive ability would actually be in the average range (100). From that estimation, Dr. Allen found a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s cognitive ability and oral language achievement score.

In November 2002, the District developed a second assessment plan to assess STUDENT in the area of speech and language. A speech and language assessment was administered by Nancy Chalnick, speech and language pathologist, on December 19, 2002. That assessment included the Fisher Logemann Test of Articulation Competence and Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test. On the Test of Articulation Competence STUDENT was found to have normal articulation, voice quality and fluency. On the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive vocabulary test, STUDENT received a standard receptive language score of 86 and a standard expressive language score of 91. Based on the test information, Ms. Chalnick’s conclusion was that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services under the category of speech and language disordered. STUDENT’s mother disagreed with the District’s determinations and conclusions and subsequently filed for this due process hearing.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

I. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent psychoeducational assessment completed by David Allen, Ph.D.?

A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student from a qualified specialist, at public expense, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the district, unless the District shows at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324. In order for the District’s assessment to be appropriate it must meet the statutory requirements set forth in California Education Code section 56320. California Education Code section 56320 provides in pertinent part that the test materials used by the District must not be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory and must be provided in the pupil’s primary language, be validated for the specific purpose for which they were used, and be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions. There is no dispute that the District’s assessment complied with these requirements. Instead, Petitioner argued that she obtained an independent assessment because the District (1) failed to assess her in a timely manner and (2) failed to conduct a speech and language assessment until December 2002.

Timely Assessment

Following receipt of parental consent to the assessment plan, a school district is required to complete the assessment process and hold an IEP meeting within 50 days of the date that consent for the assessment is obtained. Cal. Educ. Code § 56344. Petitioner’s contention, that the District failed to conduct a timely assessment, is not supported by the evidence. Petitioner’s mother requested an assessment on April 12, 2002. (Student’s A1-2; District’s 33). STUDENT’s mother signed the District’s assessment plan on May 24, 2002 (Student’s A5) The District’s psychoeducational assessment was conducted by Sheldon Brown, school psychologist, May 24, 2002, immediately upon receiving consent to the assessment plan. This assessment was discussed at an IEP meeting held on June 17, 2002, well within the time frame required under California Education Code section 56344. Furthermore, the independent assessment obtained by Petitioner was not obtained until October 2002. By that time, the District’s assessment and an IEP meeting to discuss that assessment had already been held. Consequently, Petitioner’s argument that she obtained the assessment because the District had not completed a timely assessment is not supported by the facts. Consequently, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment on the premise that the District’s assessment was untimely.

Failure to Complete Assessment

Petitioner’s second contention, that she is entitled to reimbursement for a psychoeducational assessment because the District did not complete a speech and language assessment until December 2002, is also unfounded because there is no nexus between the alleged error and the requested relief. There is no dispute that the independent psychoeducational assessment Petitioner obtained from Dr. Allen did not include a speech and language assessment. It does not follow that Petitioner should be entitled to reimbursement for a psychoeducational assessment because of the District’s alleged failure to assess in the area of speech and language. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the independent psychoeducational assessment she obtained from Dr. Allen.

In summary, Petitioner has not shown any basis for granting reimbursement for the cost of the independent psychoeducational assessment she obtained from Dr. Allen. The District adhered to the required time lines in completing the assessment and no legal basis exists for awarding reimbursement to Petitioner.

II Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a child with a specific learning disability?

To be eligible for special education services as a child with an SLD, a child must meet eligibility criteria and also must need special education and related services because of that disability. 20 U.S.C § 1401(3)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a). California Education Code section 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met independently in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:

(1) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas: oral expression; listening comprehension; written expression; basic reading skills; reading comprehension; mathematics calculation; mathematics reasoning;

(2) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.

(3) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program

Petitioner contends that she is eligible for special education services due to an auditory processing disorder that results in a severe discrepancy between her intelligence and academic achievement in oral language. Petitioner further asserts that the independent assessment she obtained from David Allen, Ph.D. supports her contention. The District does not dispute that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder. However, the District contends that she does not qualify for special education services because a severe discrepancy between her intelligence and academic achievement does not exist, and assuming arguendo that one does exist, she does not require special education services. Generally, a severe discrepancy can be established by first, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. Cal. Educ. Code § 56337 However, in this case standardized tests cannot be used to determine STUDENT’s IQ because she is an African American Student.

In a 1979 decision, it was determined that intelligence tests were racially biased against African Americans. The court found that African American students scored, on the average, approximately 15 points below Caucasian students. The court also concluded that African American students were disproportionately represented in classes for E.M.R. (Educable mentally retarded) students. The court issued a permanent injunction preventing public educational agencies from “utilizing, permitting the use of, or approving the use of any standardized intelligence tests. . . for the identification of black E.M.R. children or their placement into E.M.R. classes without securing prior approval by the court.” Larry P. v. Riles (N.D. Cal 1979) 459 F. Supp. 929, aff’d in part, rev’d in part (9th Cir. 1986) 793 F. Supp. 969. In 1986, as the result of a stipulation by the Larry P parties, the court expanded the 1979 injunction prohibiting the use of intelligence tests to include the use of intelligence tests in the assessing of African American students for eligibility as learning disabled and when referring the students for any special education placement. (See Larry P. v. Riles (1986) Order Modifying Judgment.) The California Department of Education continues to follow this finding.

Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3030(j)(40(B) further provides that “[W]hen standardized tests are considered to be invalid for a specific pupil, the discrepancy shall be measured by alternative means as specified on the assessment plan.” In this case, because of the holding of Larry P. standardized test results cannot be relied upon to determine STUDENT’s IQ. Therefore, the Hearing Officer looks to other measures of intelligence to determine whether STUDENT qualifies for special education services as a student with an SLD.

Cognitive Functioning

To determine if a severe discrepancy between cognitive ability and achievement exists, it is first necessary to determine a student’s cognitive level. In this case, the District did not administer a standardized IQ test and instead relied upon other measures in determining STUDENT’s cognitive level. Sheldon Brown, the District’s psychologist used alternative means of cognitive assessment which included parent, student, and teacher interviews; observations; test results; and a review of records. (Student’s A13-16; District’s 34; Test. of Brown). Mr. Brown concluded, from the data he collected, that STUDENT’s cognitive functioning was in the average range, which he estimated to be between 85 and 95. (Test. of Brown) According to Mr. Brown, this estimate was further supported by STUDENT’s academic achievement testing, which was also in the average range (90-110), and full scale oral language score of 89.

Dr. David Allen, an independent psychologist retained by Petitioner, also conducted a psychoeducational assessment to determine STUDENT’s cognitive ability and academic achievement. Dr. Allen administered the WISC which indicated that STUDENT’s full scale IQ was 76, which is in the borderline range. (Student’s A11). However, Dr. Allen testified that he believed this score to be lower than STUDENT’s actual IQ, due to her auditory processing disorder, and estimated that her actual IQ would be in the average range of 100. According to Dr. Allen, because STUDENT’s academic achievement scores on the WJ-III ranged from 78 to 98 this indicates that her IQ is actually higher than tested.(Footnote 3)

Both the District and Dr. Allen estimated STUDENT’s cognitive functioning at a level to be in the average range, however they disputed what the actual range would be. According to the estimates made by the District, STUDENT’s cognitive range would be 85-95, but according to Dr. Allen, her IQ would be closer to 100. The District’s estimated IQ of 85-95 is supported by the academic achievement information it obtained, the oral language composite score it obtained, and by the entirety of the testing done by Dr. Allen. Dr. Allen’s estimation that STUDENT’s IQ is actually 24 points higher than the level she tested at is just an estimation which he has not supported through other test scores. While the District’ IQ determination is supported by both the test scores it achieved (ranging from 89-95) and the test scores obtained by Dr. Allen (ranging from 78-98). Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds, that for the purposes of determining eligibility for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability, STUDENT’s cognitive functioning is in the average range of 85-95.

Academic Achievement

To determine STUDENT’s academic achievement level, Mr. Brown administered the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTA). Mr. Brown also cross validated the scores obtained through administration of the Woodcock Language Proficiency Battery (WLPB). On the KTA, STUDENT’s standard scores ranged from 89 (math application) to 95 (spelling and reading comprehension). Additionally, her composite score in reading was 92 and was 91 in math. (Student’s A14; District’s 34; Test. of Brown) On the WLPB, STUDENT’s subtest scores ranged from 81 (memory for sentences) to 109 (Verbal Analogies). Her overall composite score for oral language was 89, which is consistent with the findings of the KTA. (Student’s A15; District’s 34)

Dr. Allen also administered academic testing to STUDENT. Dr. Allen administered the Woodcock Johnson Achievement Test -III (WJ-III). On that assessment, STUDENT’s subtest scores ranged from 63 (story recall) to 103 (calculation). Her broad reading standard score was 88, broad math was 97, and total achievement standard score was 94. (Student’s A11; Test. of Allen). Dr. Allen testified that his concern about STUDENT’s achievement is in the area of oral language. Dr. Allen testified that in the area of oral language, STUDENT’s overall score was 78, which is obtained by averaging the scores on the story recall and understanding directions subtests. On those subtests, STUDENT scored a 63 in story recall and an 88 in understanding directions. The understanding directions subtest score is within the range of ability that STUDENT demonstrated on other subtests. However, according to Dr. Allen, STUDENT’s story recall subtest score of 63 is well below what her ability would indicate.

The academic achievement information obtained by the District and by Dr. Allen, in an independent assessment, is, in most respects, consistent. It is only in the area of oral language that the scores diverge. The District’s assessment of STUDENT’s achievement in oral language puts her standard score at 89 and Dr. Allen’s assessment puts it at 78. Since both Dr. Allen’s results and the District’s results are reliable, for purposes of this Decision, an analysis of severe discrepancy using both scores will be undertaken.

Comparison of Cognitive Ability to Academic Achievement

To find a severe discrepancy between cognitive ability and academic achievement, assessments of the student must indicate a 22.5 point difference.(Footnote 4) As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT’s cognitive ability is in the average range at 85-95. Her academic achievement in all areas is within that range and does not indicate a severe discrepancy. However, her academic achievement in the area of oral language is lower than the other areas. Using the District’s assessment, STUDENT’s oral language score of 89 does not show a severe discrepancy because that score is in the range of her cognitive ability. Even assuming that her cognitive ability is as high as Dr. Allen estimated (100), with an oral language score of 89, no severe discrepancy exists because that score is only 11 points below her cognitive ability.

Using Dr. Allen’s assessment of her oral language achievement, estimated to be 78, STUDENT also does not establish a severe discrepancy. With a cognitive score of 85-95 the oral language score of 78 is a 7 to 17 point differential, which does not meet the 22.5 point discrepancy required. Again, even assuming that Dr. Allen’s cognitive score of 100 is accurate, with an oral language score of 78 the difference is 22 points which does not meet the 22.5 point requirement of California Education code section 56337. Moreover, the oral language score obtained by Dr. Allen is the result of one low subtest score in the area of story recall. The other subtest score (understanding directions) was an 88, which is well within the range expected for STUDENT’s cognitive ability.(Footnote 5)

The data obtained from both the District’s assessment and the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Allen are in most respects consistent with one another. In the area where they differ, oral language, regardless of the score used, a severe discrepancy between cognitive ability and achievement, is not established.

Even assuming, arguendo, that a severe discrepancy exists in the area of oral language, Petitioner must establish that the discrepancy between her ability and achievement cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code. § 56337. In this case, the evidence establishes that any discrepancy STUDENT has between ability and achievement can be corrected within the regular instructional program.

In the past, STUDENT has had difficulty passing some of her classes. However, according to her seventh grade history teacher, Mr. Macias, this was primarily due to her refusal to turn in work and socializing in class. Mr. Macias testified that STUDENT has the ability to do well when she is motivated and focused on her classwork. Mr. Macias was not the only teacher to report STUDENT’s ‘motivational’ difficulties. On her seventh grade report card, her teachers consistently reported that she talks too much; exhibits disruptive and or inconsiderate behaviors; has excessive absences and does not complete assignments or tasks. (Student’s A34)

STUDENT’s most recent grade reports indicate that she is passing all of her classes.(Footnote 6) STUDENT’s English teacher, Ms. Seale, testified that generally STUDENT’s class performance is in the average range. Ms. Seale also testified that STUDENT’s grade is above average because she works diligently in class, turns in assignments, and puts care and attention into the detail of her work. STUDENT testified that she enjoys her English class and that she does all her assignments for that class. On the other hand, STUDENT also testified that she does not like her algebra class and is not doing as well in that course because she does not do the assignments or participate in class. The Hearing Officer finds the above testimony persuasive. STUDENT has the ability to do well in school, if she is motivated, and does not require special education services to succeed.

In summary, STUDENT does not have a severe discrepancy between her ability and achievement. Additionally, her ability to succeed in the regular education environment indicates that she is able to progress in the regular education environment without special education support. Thus, Petitioner has not established that any discrepancy she may have cannot be corrected through regular or categorical services within the regular instructional program or that she needs special education services to benefit from her education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet the legal requirements for special education eligibility as a student with a specific learning disability.(Footnote 7)

III Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a child with a speech and language disorder?

California Education Code section 56333 identifies the eligibility criteria for speech and language disorders and provides that:

A pupil shall be assessed as having a language or speech disorder which makes him or her eligible for special education or related services when he or she demonstrates difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects his or her educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education or related services.

California Education Code section 56333 further provides that the language or speech disorder must be the result of (a) an articulation disorder, (b) abnormal voice, (c) fluency difficulties, or (d) inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension, or expression of spoken language that is significantly below the language performance level of the student’s peers.

STUDENT asserts that she is eligible for special education services under the category of speech and language disordered because of her difficulties in oral language and because she is below age level in her language development.

Articulation Disorder, abnormal voice, and fluency difficulties

The speech and language assessment results found that STUDENT’s articulation, voice quality, and fluency were within normal limits. (District’s 37). These results were obtained through administration of the Fisher Logemann Test of Articulation Competence, Comprehensive Expressive and Receptive Vocabulary Test, and a spontaneous language sample. (District’s 37; Test. of Nancy Chalnick) No evidence was presented to indicate that the results obtained from this assessment were not valid. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Ms. Chalnick, speech and language pathologist, and the test results she obtained and finds that STUDENT is not eligible for special education services under the category of speech and language disordered due to articulation disorder, abnormal voice, or fluency difficulties.

Inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension or expression of spoken language

The California Code of Regulations further defines the requirements for eligibility due to inappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension or expression of spoken language (otherwise termed as an expressive or receptive language disorder). Under the California Code of Regulations, a student has an expressive or receptive language disorder when she meets one of the following criteria: (A) scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean for her chronological age on two or more standardized tests or on one standardized test and (B) displays inappropriate or inadequate usage of expressive or receptive language as measured by a representative spontaneous language sample. Title 5, C.C.R. 3030(c)(4)

To assess STUDENT’s receptive and expressive vocabulary, Ms. Chalnick, a qualified speech and language specialist, administered the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary Test. On that assessment, STUDENT obtained a standard receptive score of 86, which correlates to an age equivalent of 10 years 3 months, and a standard expressive score of 91, which also correlates to an age equivalent of 10 years 3 months. Overall these results indicated that STUDENT’s vocabulary was below age expectation. (District’s 37; Test. of Chalnick). However, the uncontradicted testimony of Ms. Chalnick was that while STUDENT’s score was below average (100) it did not raise a ‘red flag’ for her because STUDENT did not exhibit any other difficulties with language (i.e. understanding directions or responding to directions) to indicate that she required special education services. Ms. Chalnick also reported that in obtaining a spontaneous language sample, STUDENT used complex and expanded sentences to share and respond to questions; tense makers to indicate past, present, irregular past, and future; subjective, objective and possessive pronouns; regular plurals; possessive markers and articles; action words; words denoting possession and words of description. Overall, Ms. Chalnick testified persuasively that while STUDENT’s test scores were somewhat low they did not meet the requirement of being 1.5 standard deviations (22.5 points) below the mean and she did not exhibit the inadequate usage of expressive or receptive language necessary to qualify for special education services.

Furthermore, even assuming that STUDENT has such a disorder, to receive special education services, it must also be shown that the language disorder adversely affects her education and cannot be corrected with regular education services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56333 At the time of her initial speech and language assessment, STUDENT was receiving passing grades in all her courses. Of particular note is the fact that she was receiving an A in English. STUDENT testified that she enjoyed her English class because she was able to perform by acting-out stories and giving oral presentations. STUDENT stated that her teacher, Ms. Seale, complimented her on her oral presentations.(Footnote 8) Ms. Seale testified that STUDENT always passes her spelling tests and has no incomplete assignments. Ms. Seale further stated that STUDENT has not demonstrated any expressive or receptive language difficulties. STUDENT asks for clarification when she does not understand something and has no difficulty following directions. (Test. of Seale)

The Hearing Officer finds the uncontradicted testimony of STUDENT and her teacher persuasive. STUDENT has demonstrated that any language difficulty she may have does not adversely affect her education. Furthermore, the evidence supports the finding that any difficulties that STUDENT may have do not require special education services as they are being addressed in the regular education setting.

In summary, STUDENT does not have a language disorder that would qualify her for special education services. Additionally, her success in English indicates that she is able to progress in the regular education environment without special education support. Thus, Petitioner has not established that any discrepancy she may have cannot be corrected through services within the regular instructional program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet the legal requirements for special education eligibility as a student with a language or speech disorder.

IV If STUDENT is eligible for special education services is she entitled to compensatory education services and reimbursement for private tutoring sessions?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, supra 471 U.S. at 369. When considering a request for compensatory education or reimbursement, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. In this case, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT is not eligible for special education services. Therefore, she is not entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with that statute:

The District prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: February 14, 2003 _________________________________________ Sherianne Laba Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. STUDENT is an African-American student, and under the ruling set forth in Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F. Supp. 926 (N.D. Cal. 1979) IQ tests cannot be administered to African American students for the purpose of special education placement. The District did not use standard IQ tests and instead relied upon alternative means, for determining STUDENT’s cognitive level. 2. Subsequent to the initial psychoeducational assessment, STUDENT’s mother requested that the District conduct a speech and language assessment. The issue of the timeliness of the speech and language assessment was not raised at hearing, and therefore is not addressed in this decision. 3. Although Dr. Allen administered a standardized IQ test, because of the ruling in Larry P. the Hearing Officer cannot rely solely upon the results obtained from that standardized test. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will consider both the information obtained from the standardized testing along with other criteria, in determining STUDENT’s eligibility. 4. article in the California School Psychologist calls into question this practice. Helm and Johnson, Updated Tables Needed to Determine a Severe Discrepancy Under California’s Title 5 Regulations, 8 Cal. Sch. Psychologist 19 (1998). According to this article, the formula must take into account the correlation between the specific ability and achievement tests used (by computing the correlation coefficient, r) rather than merely calculating simple differences between scores. The authors set forth tables showing standard criterion values for specific cognitive and achievement tests, based upon the correlation between the tests, and give the standard error of measurement to be applied. However, there is no known corroboration of the data, and the utility of the data provided is seriously limited. At hearing, no evidence was presented which applies the method presented in this article for the specific tests given to STUDENT. Moreover, the federal statute and regulations do not require a specified numerical difference in scores for a severe discrepancy. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(26); 34 C.F.R. § 300.541. Therefore, the methods set forth in California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 3030(j), including the use of the 22.5 point discrepancy, will be applied here. 5. The entirety of Dr. Allen’s conclusion that STUDENT is eligible for special education services is based upon the one low test score obtained on the story recall. California Code of Regulations, Title 5, section 3030(j)(4) states that in determining eligibility under the category of specific learning disability “[n]o single score. . . shall be used as the sole criterion . . .as to the pupil’s eligibility for special education.” 6. STUDENT is receiving A’s in PE and English; a B in Art, and Ds in U.S. History, Science, and Algebra. 7. During the Hearing, the District offered STUDENTa 504 plan to address any accommodations she may need to address her auditory processing difficulties and to help improve her grades. The District is encouraged to follow through with that offer. 8. STUDENT was receiving a grade of D in History, Science, and Algebra. However, STUDENT testified that she is not doing well in these courses because she does not enjoy the work and does not turn in all her assignments.