California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 5, 2001
Student v. Kentfield School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1062-00 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
Kentfield School District must repay half of a private preschool's tuition for failing to provide mainstreaming; its 2000-2001 offer was upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Before the hearing, the Hearing Officer denied the District's motion for a stay-put order and its motion for reconsideration.
Summary
The parents and Kentfield School District both filed, and the cases were consolidated. The student, age six, had been eligible for special education since age three because of a language disorder. In 1999-2000 she attended a Marin County Office of Education preschool special day class at the Marindale site, which had no typically developing children. Her parents also enrolled her in an afternoon program at ABC Academy, a private preschool. The parties agreed the special day class itself was appropriate. The Hearing Officer found that the May 1999 IEP team never seriously discussed mainstreaming. Her pragmatics and social skills goals required time with typically developing peers, and the District offered none. That denied her a FAPE in 1999-2000 and in the 2000 extended school year (ESY). Carrying goals over and weak progress tracking did not cost her educational opportunity. She also did not need one-to-one speech therapy, an aide at the private preschool, or consultant services. For 2000-2001, the Hearing Officer upheld the District's offer of a morning special day class at Coleman Elementary plus afternoon regular kindergarten at Bacich Elementary. The student was not yet ready for full inclusion, even with an aide. The District must reimburse half of the 1999-2000 ABC Academy tuition, half of tuition for 19 summer days, and mileage at the District rate. Requests for private speech therapy, consultant fees, occupational therapy, auditory integration training, and compensatory education were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated the least-restrictive-environment duty for preschoolers. It held that a county site with no typically developing peers did not excuse the IEP team from considering mainstreaming. It also shows a Hearing Officer cutting reimbursement in half on the equities because the private program also served as day care and exceeded what the student needed.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did STUDENT receive a free and appropriate public education during the 1999-2000 school year?
The IEP team's failure to discuss mainstreaming, and the lack of any time with typically developing peers to carry out pragmatics and social skills goals, denied FAPE. Claims about carried-over goals and progress reporting, one-to-one speech therapy, an aide, and consultant services were rejected.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate extended school year services during the summer of 2000?
ESY is not a transition to a new school year. However, the offered 19-day ESY continued the special day class without typically developing peers and was inappropriate for the same reasons as the 1999-2000 program.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
Applying Rachel H., the Hearing Officer found the student would not benefit from full inclusion even with an aide. The morning SDC at Coleman plus afternoon kindergarten at Bacich was the LRE. The claim about the administrator's authority failed.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4a. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT's program at ABC Academy and transportation?
ABC Academy gave the student the mainstreaming the District lacked. On the equities, the parents get half of 1999-2000 tuition and half of tuition for 19 summer days, plus mileage at the District rate but not the driver's hourly fee.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4b. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the speech and language therapy provided by Janet Rizzi, Teri-Lyn Cousley and/or Patricia Toboni?
Individual speech therapy was not needed for FAPE, there was no evidence it benefited the student, and the District's ESY offer already included the LINKS to Language methodology.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4c. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for consultation services provided by Ilene Lee?
The student did not need consultation services to receive FAPE, so reimbursement was denied.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4d. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for occupational therapy services?
There was no evidence that District occupational therapy was inadequate and no evidence about the parent-provided services.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4e. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of auditory integration training?
No evidence connected auditory integration training to the only defect in the District's program, the lack of mainstreaming.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?
The partly reimbursed private placement made up for 1999-2000. For ESY there was no evidence of the services needed, lost opportunity, or regression.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days after receiving proof, the District must reimburse the parents for one-half the cost of tuition at the ABC Academy after-school program for the entire 1999-2000 school year.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days after receiving proof, the District must reimburse one-half the cost of tuition for 19 days of the ABC Academy summer school program (summer 2000).
- Reimbursement. The District must reimburse the parents' actual mileage, at the District's standard rate, for driving the student from Marindale to ABC Academy and home during the 1999-2000 school year and during 19 days of the summer program. The private driver's hourly charge is not reimbursed.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Honig v. Doe; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Rodriecus L. v. Waukegan School Dist.; In re John K.
People named in the decision
- Kenneth Kammuller, Program manager, Marin SELPA; District representative at hearing, Marin Special Education Local Plan Area
- Amira Suzanne Mostafa, School psychologist; observed private preschool, Marin County Office of Education
- Laura Trahan, Program manager / Early Intervention Program service coordinator and speech-language pathologist, Marin County Office of Education
- Clara Yourman, Special day class teacher and speech-language pathologist (Marindale), Marin County Office of Education
- Holly Edde, Kindergarten teacher, Bacich Elementary, Kentfield School District
- Ilene Lee, Private psychologist / educational and behavioral consultant for family, Private practice
- Robert B. Caine, Superintendent, Kentfield School District
- Patricia Sweeny Toboni, Private speech-language pathologist (summer 2000, LINKS to Language), Private provider
- Jamaica Stevens, Summer program instructor, ABC Academy (private preschool)
- Pat Territo, Director, ABC Academy (private preschool)
- Paula Cline, Resource specialist teacher, Bacich Elementary; District representative at IEP meetings, Kentfield School District
- Judith Paton, Audiologist; provided auditory integration training, Private provider
- Robert Koegel, Expert witness for Student (autism, full inclusion), University of California, Santa Barbara
- Patty Reader Harrison, Aide, Trinity Lutheran Preschool
- Patricia Lynch, Principal, Bacich Elementary, Kentfield School District
- Robert Patterson, Licensed educational psychologist; expert witness for District, Not stated
- Erin Heath, Student's physician (referral), Private provider
- Robin Rossman, Private speech pathologist (1998 evaluation), Speech & Language Services of Marin-Sonoma
- Barbara Bennett, Developmental pediatrician (1998 assessment), California Pacific Medical Center
- Julie Lucero, Psychologist (1998 informal assessment), Marin County Office of Education
- Barbara Almquist, Occupational therapist (1998 assessment), Not stated
- Cynthia Viden, Speech-language therapist (1998 assessment), Marin County Office of Education Early Intervention Program
- Linda Ernst, Speech-language pathologist; observed private preschool, Marin County Office of Education Early Intervention Program
- Janet Rizzi, Private speech-language pathologist, Private provider
- Teri-Lyn Cousley, Private speech-language pathologist, Private provider
- Erin Aggson-Hurley, Occupational therapist (2000 report), Not stated
- Tony Dill, IEP meeting attendee (role not stated), Not stated
- Ann Morton, Private driver hired by parents for transportation, Private
- ABC Academy, Private preschool (parent placement), Private school
- Trinity Lutheran School, Private school where parents enrolled student for 2000-2001, Private school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Rafael, California, on August 10, 11, 31, September 1, 11, 12, 25, 28 and October 12, 16, 17, 2000. Petitioner and Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by attorneys Bob Varma and Roberta Savage. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were her mother, MOTHER, as well as her father, FATHER. Respondent and Petitioner Kentfield School District (District) was represented by attorney Jan Tomsky. Also present on behalf of the District was Dr. Kenneth Kammuller, the program manager for the Marin Special Education Local Plan Area. Respondent Marin County Office of Education (County) was not represented at the hearing.(Footnote 1)
The following witnesses were called by Student to testify: Kenneth Kammuller; Amira Suzanne Mostafa, school psychologist for the County; Laura Trahan, program manager for the County; Clara Yourman, teacher and speech and language pathologist for the County at Marindale; Holly Edde, kindergarten teacher in the District; Ilene Lee, educational consultant; Robert B. Caine, superintendent of Kentfield Elementary School District; Patricia Sweeny Toboni, speech and language pathologist; MOTHER; Jamaica Stevens, instructor at ABC Academy; Pat Territo, director of ABC academy; Paula Cline, resource specialist teacher for the District at Bacich Elementary School; Judith Paton, Audiologist; Robert Koegel, professor at the University of California, Santa Barbara; and, Patty Reader Harrison, aide at Trinity Lutheran Preschool.
Respondent District called the following witness to testify: Patricia Lynch, principal in the District at Bacich Elementary School; Robert Patterson, licensed educational psychologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on December 12, 2000, the case was closed, and the consolidated matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
(1) Did STUDENT receive a free and appropriate public education during the 1999-2000 school year?
(2) Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate extended school year services during the summer of 2000?
(3) Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
(4) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for:
a. the cost of STUDENT’s program at ABC Academy and transportation;
b. the speech and language therapy provided by Janet Rizzi, Teri-Lyn Cousley and/or Patricia Toboni;
c. consultation services provided by Ilene Lee;
d. occupational therapy services;
e. the cost of auditory integration training?
(5) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?
PROCEDURAL ITEMS
Before the first hearing day, the District requested an order clarifying “stay put.” The Hearing Officer denied the motion and also denied a subsequent request for reconsideration. The PARENTS have consistently rejected stay put and maintained throughout the due process hearing that STUDENT’s academic placement for the 2000-2001 school year “will not be in a District classroom and will be in a private school.” [Emphasis Added] See Petitioner’s Response to District’s Motion for Reconsideration, August 24, 2000.
Under federal and State special education law, unless the educational agency and the parent agree otherwise, a special education student must remain in his or her present educational placement pending completion of due process hearing procedures. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); California Education Code § 56505(d). This provision is commonly referred to as "stay put." The United States Supreme Court in Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305, affirmed that the right to stay put is "unequivocal." However, nothing in either federal or State law indicates that a public education agency, such as the Kentfield School District, is entitled to invoke the provisions of stay put. Indeed, stay put has never been construed by the courts as a remedy available for school districts. See, Burlington School Committee v. Massachusetts Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, EHLR 556:389, 395 (“we doubt that [the stay put] provision would authorize a court to order parents to leave their child in a particular placement”). The stay put provision requires only that the school district continue to fund and maintain the current placement while proceedings are pending. In re John K. 1985-86 EHLR Ded. 557:128, 131 (CA Ct. App 1985); Rodriecus L. Waukegan School District No. 60 (7th Cir. 1996) 90 F.3d 249 (“The purpose of the stay put provision is to give the child’s parents the choice of keeping the child in his existing program until their dispute with the school authorities is resolved.”)
The District has provided no authority for the proposition that an educational agency is entitled to a stay put order, where, as in the present case, the student’s parents have stated that they will not accept a District placement during the pendency of the due process hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion, and also denied the District’s subsequent motion for reconsideration.
Additionally, during the hearing, the Student moved to add the date of October 17, 2000, as a hearing date on the ground that her expert, Dr. Koegel, was available on that date.(Footnote 3) The District opposed the Student’s motion on the grounds that, in pertinent part, its attorney had to attend a previously arranged due process mediation on that date. The Hearing Officer weighed the various interests of the individuals involved in the due process hearing, including the witness, and both attorneys, along with the student’s rights. The Hearing Officer granted the Student’s motion because any further delay beyond October 17, 2000, would have unreasonably delayed the ultimate decision in this matter See, California Education Code § 56505(f).
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, age six, resides within the boundaries of the Kentfield School District. STUDENT has been eligible for special education services because of a language disorder since the age of three (1998).(Footnote 4) STUDENT currently attends Trinity Lutheran School, a private school, where she was enrolled by her parents at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year.
In April 1998, STUDENT was referred for a speech and language evaluation by her physician, Dr. Erin Heath. Robin Rossman, a speech pathologist with Speech & Language Services of Marin-Sonoma, and Dr. Barbara Bennett, a developmental pediatrician associated with the California Pacific Medical Center, assessed STUDENT. District’s Exhs. 1 and 2. Ms. Rossman was unable to complete a formal assessment of STUDENT’s receptive language skills due to her “severely limited attention span.” She observed, however, that STUDENT’s “overall language skills were . . . significantly delayed and judged to be most comparable to a 2 year old developmental level.” (At that time, STUDENT was three years and three months old.) District’s Exh. 1. Ms. Rossman recommended ‟consideration for a referral for complete developmental assessment to assist in differential diagnosis and development of an appropriate treatment plan,” an audiological evaluation, a referral to MCOE ‟as STUDENT might qualify for . . . Preschool special education services,” and speech and language therapy.
Dr. Bennett assessed STUDENT in May and June 1998. She was similarly unable to conduct ‘totally valid developmental testing with age levels . . . because of STUDENT’s speech/language issues, interaction style, short attention span, distractibility, and self directedness.” She agreed, however, that STUDENT evidenced communication delays. Dr. Bennett also found that STUDENT had ‟social relatedness issues, and a somewhat restricted play repertoire,” and concluded that these delays were ‟consistent with a diagnosis of PDD-NOS, Pervasive Developmental Disorder, Not Otherwise Specified.” Ms. Bennett recommended, in pertinent part, speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, that the PARENTS “work with a psychologist,” parent support through “Matrix” and continued involvement with the MCOE. District’s Exh. 2.
Also during the spring of 1998, the District began to assess STUDENT for special education eligibility through the Marin County Office of Education (MCOE) Early Intervention Program (EIP).(Footnote 5) STUDENT was “informally” assessed by Laura Trahan, the service cordinator for the EIP and a speech and language pathologist, and Julie Lucero, a MCOE psychologist. Testimony of Trahan.
STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting was held on June 19, 1998. The purpose of the meeting was to review the assessments conducted by Dr. Bennett and Robin Rossman, as well as the MCOE’s “informal” assessments, to determine if STUDENT was eligible for special education services and to develop an appropriate program. The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education services as a child with a language disorder. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in the areas of “attention,” relations with peers, following directions/task completion, and self concept. The District and County members of the IEP team recommended placement in a special day class at the County’s Marindale site during the summer extended school year program, along with speech and language services (two thirty-minute sessions each week). The team also recommended that STUDENT be further assessed by an occupational therapist. STUDENT’s parents agreed to the speech and language services but declined to accept the preschool special day class at Marindale during the summer. They agreed, however, to observe the Marindale preschool special day class.(Footnote 6) District’s Exh. 3.
Another IEP meeting was held on July 17, 1998, to review the recently completed occupational therapy assessment conducted by Barbara Almquist, as well as the draft goals and objectives she had prepared. District’s Exhs. 4 and 5. At that meeting, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT required occupational therapy. Her IEP was amended to include small-group occupational therapy two times each week.(Footnote 7)
In September 1998, STUDENT’s parents agreed to place her in a preschool special day class at Marindale. STUDENT was placed in Clara Yourman’s class, where she attended for five hours per day (8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m.), four days per week (Tuesday through Friday) during the entire 1998-1999 school year, as well as the 1999-2000 school year. Ms. Yourman is both a credentialed special day class teacher and a certified speech and language pathologist.
Also in September 1998, STUDENT was assessed by Cynthia Viden, a speech and language therapist with the MCOE EIP. Ms. Viden’s assessment included the Preschool Language Scale, the Preschool Command Continuum, Preschool Question Inventory, the Marin County Office of Education Preschool Curriculum, the Rossetti Infant Toddler Language Scale, a language sample analysis, and observations of STUDENT in a classroom setting. Ms. Viden found that STUDENT, at age 3 years and 8 months, exhibited a ‟severe speech and language disorder” with significant deficits in the areas of auditory processing, expressive and receceptive language, and pragmatics. She found STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills were delayed by more than one year. Ms. Viden determined that STUDENT’s ability to process information was commensurate with that of a child of 24 months, a delay of over two years. STUDENT’s pragmatic skills evidenced a ‟profound delay,” reflecting the skills that typically develop at 6-9 months of age. District’s Exh. 6. Ms. Viden recommended continued placement in Ms. Yourman’s “intensive language based special day class,” which she indicated presented “wonderful opportunities for STUDENT to interact with peers and to learn language in a naturalistic environment.”
On October 13, 1998, the IEP team met to review Ms. Viden’s assessment, as well as STUDENT’s current placement in Ms. Yourman’s special day class. At this meeting, it was agreed by all members of the IEP team that STUDENT should continue in Clara Yourman’s special day class for the communicatively handicapped, and that she should receive occupational therapy one time per week, for a total of thirty minutes.(Footnote 8) The IEP reflects that STUDENT’s goals and objectives from July 1998 were to be continued, and that she was to participate in ‟designated small group (2 to 3 children) playing in a facilitated group in the classroom 2 times per week.” District’s Exh. 7.
In March 1999, in preparation for the upcoming annual IEP meeting, Clara Yourman assessed STUDENT in the areas of receptive and expressive language “to determine her current functioning, goals and placement.” Ms. Yourman administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT), the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-R, the Preschool Language Scale -3 (PLS-3), the Command Continuum, and the Preschool Question Inventory. On the PPVT, which measures a child’s single-word receptive vocabulary, STUDENT received a standard score of 86 and an age equivalent of 3 years 8 months (at the time that Ms. Yourman administered the assessments, STUDENT was 4 years 2 months old).
On the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test -Revised, which measures a child’s ability to name single pictures of familiar objects, STUDENT received a standard score of 88 and an age equivalent of 3 years 8 months. The PLS-3 tests a child’s expressive and receptive language weaknesses and is divided into two sections, auditory comprehension and expressive communication. STUDENT’s raw score on the auditory comprehension portion was 30, an age equivalent of 3 years 0 months. Her raw score on the expressive communication portion was 27, an age equivalent of 2 years 7 months.(Footnote 9)
The Command Continuum, according to Ms. Yourman, assesses a child’s auditory processing skills. STUDENT’s raw score on this test was 11, an age equivalent of 28 to 44 months “with gaps.” Ms. Yourman also notes that STUDENT “demonstrated the ability to perform one-step directions with two objects (36 month old level) and one direction at the 44 month level.” On the Preschool Question Inventory, which assesses auditory processing skills, “STUDENT was able to answer 18 questions with gaps from the 32 to 44 month level. In comparing STUDENT’s scores on this test with the results of Ms. Viden’s assessment from September 1998, Ms. Yourman concluded that “while improvement is noted, STUDENT’s auditory processing skills continue to be delayed. STUDENT’s performance demonstrates her difficulty answering (processing) questions out of context and without visual aids.” Finally, Ms. Yourman estimated STUDENT’s MLU (mean length of utterance) to be 4 to 5 words, typical of a child of age 3 years 0 months. Ms. Yourman’s assessment reports concludes, in pertinent part, as follows:
In summary, STUDENT’s auditory processing skills continue to be significantly delayed. It should be noted that these assessments were administered in a quiet room in a one to one situation with numerous breaks. In the classroom, STUDENT is learning to compensate for her auditory deficits. A structured environment such as our classroom, with daily routines, with clear consistent consequences, provides STUDENT with a great deal of security. Conversely, changes in the routine cause her to become confused. STUDENT demonstrates difficulty formulating new thoughts for expressing herself. She uses short phrases and often is unable to expand to form syntactically correct sentences. STUDENT’s longer utterances appear to be rote learned (phrases learned as a whole). She also demonstrates word retrieval difficulties. Based on observation and assessment her IEP goal should continue.
District’s Exh. 8.
STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was convened on May 11, 1999. District’s Exh. 9. At the meeting, the team reviewed Ms. Yourman’s speech and language assessment and STUDENT’s goals and objectives, as written in the IEP. The team recommended continued placement in Clara Yourman’s special day class for the 1999-2000 school year, a continuation of STUDENT’s previous goals and objectives (none of which had been achieved), direct occupational therapy one time each week (no length is specified in the IEP), and a 19-day extended school year program in Yourman’s special day class for the communicatively handicapped. The IEP indicates under the heading “What are the reasons for service delivery outside the general education classroom?” that STUDENT requires a special day class because she needs specific skill training, alternative curriculum and a “structured classroom.”
In August of 1999, the PARENTS contracted with Dr. Ilene Lee, a psychologist in private practice, to provide behavioral consultation services for the family. Ms. Lee also (in 2000) observed STUDENT’s program at STUDENT’s private preschool (ABC Academy, discussed below) and provided some consultation services to teachers there. She also worked individually with STUDENT using the “floor time” approach one-on-one at STUDENT’s home.
STUDENT began attending ABC Academy’s “after-school” program in September 1999, where she attended three days each week for a total of 12 to 15 hours each week during the 1999-2000 school year. Testimony of MOTHER and Petitioner’s Exh. 197-198. According to MOTHER, STUDENT was enrolled at ABC Academy for “day care” and also, to provide STUDENT with opportunities to interact with nondisabled, same-age peers. ABC Academy is a private preschool located in the boundaries of the Ross Valley school District (outside Kentfield) which serves children from preschool through the second grade. STUDENT’s “after-school” program included nondisabled preschool-age children. STUDENT also attended ABC Academy’s summer school program taught by Jamaica Stevens for six weeks (for between three and four days each week for a total of 12 to 15 hours each week) during the summer of 2000. According to Ms. Stevens, the summer school program included nondisabled children from preschool age to second grade (children who would be entering kindergarten through the third grade in the fall).
In September 1999, the PARENTS contacted Paula Cline (from the District) and inquired whether the District would provide transportation for STUDENT from Marindale to the ABC Academy. Testimony of Cline and MOTHER. The PARENTS’ request was denied.
Beginning in either February or March 2000, the PARENTS sought private speech and language therapy services at the recommendation of Dr. Lee. They first procured the services of Janet Rizzi, and then later, Teri-Lyn Cousley, both of whom are speech and language pathologists. Ms. Cousley provided between six and eight sessions of individual speech and language services. It is unclear how many sessions were provided by Ms. Rizzi. Neither Ms. Rizzi nor Ms. Cousley testified at the hearing.
In the Spring of 2000, MOTHER contacted Paula Cline to discuss transportation for STUDENT from Marindale to her afternoon private preschool placement at ABC academy, and to discuss whether the District would provide an aide to work with STUDENT at ABC Academy. On March 6, 2000, an IEP meeting was convened to discuss MOTHER’s requests. At the meeting, MOTHER provided a letter, dated March 4, 2000, in which she requests that the District provide an aide at STUDENT’s ABC academy program “a minimum of 9 hours” each week to help STUDENT in the area of “language development,” and to help her “make a successful transition into the fully integrated kindergarten program at Bacich.” In the letter, MOTHER also renewed her request that the District provide transportation for STUDENT from her special day class program at Marindale to ABC Academy.(Footnote 10) The IEP team agreed that the EIP staff would take “an informal look at STUDENTs private program” to determine if STUDENT required an aide at ABC.
On March 29, 2000, pursuant to the March 6, 2000 IEP agreement, school psychologist Amira Mostafa and speech and language pathologist Linda Ernst conducted a joint observation of STUDENT’s ABC Academy after-school program. Their joint report (District’s Exh. 14) concludes, in pertinent part, as follows:
STUDENT is a delightful, spirited, and social child who enjoys interacting with others. Observation of STUDENT at ABC Academy and consultation with the preschool staff indicate that she is showing many age appropriate social skills. She has appropriate play interactions with both peers and adults, initiates creative fantasy play sequences, and joins in other children’s play. STUDENT has strong pragmatic skills, including responding to greetings, making requests, taking turns, maintaining eye contact, maintaining a topic, role playing, and initiating an activity or dialogue. STUDENT was observed to independently interact with others at an age appropriate level. Her social-emotional development is not an area of concern.
District’s Exh. 14. Their report also indicates that the staff at ABC expressed that they had “no concerns” with regard to STUDENT and that they had seen “remarkable progress in STUDENT over the last 6 months” Id.
The IEP team reconvened on April 7, 2000, to discuss Ms. Ernst’s and Ms. Mostafa’s observations and to discuss transportation reimbursement.(Footnote 11) District’s Exh. 13. Additionally, MOTHER presented a report prepared by Dr. Lee. The District and MCOE members of the IEP team concluded that “STUDENT would not benefit from additional assistant/facilitator as a part of her [special education] program.” Both of MOTHER’s requests – an aide at ABC Academy and transportation services – were denied by the District members of the IEP team.
Also in April 2000, Clara Yourman assessed STUDENT in preparation for the upcoming annual IEP meeting (May 1, 2000). She administered many of the same assessments she had administered in 1999, including the PPVT, the PLS-3, Preschool Question Inventory, Preschool Command Continuum and an informal language sample. On the PPVT, STUDENT received a standard score of 93, up from 86 on the same assessment one year prior, and a grade equivalent of 4 years 8 months, an increase of one year from her previous assessment. On the auditory comprehension portion of the PLS-3, STUDENT received a standard score of 89, and her grade equivalent scores increased by 1 year 8 months. Ms. Yourman noted that, although STUDENT showed improvement, she still experienced difficulty understanding complex (two step) directions, identifying pictures, and understanding quantity concepts.
On the expressive communication portion of the PLS-3, STUDENT received a standard score of 68, a grade equivalent increase of 10 months (from 2 years 7 months to 3 years 9 months) over a period of approximately one year. With regard to STUDENT’s performance on the PLS-3, Ms. Yourman noted that STUDENT established a ceiling (five consecutive incorrect answers) at the 5 years 0 month to 5 years 11 month level. She noted that STUDENT had difficulty with the following tasks:
Using irregular and regular forms of past tense.
Telling about remote events- What do you do when you lost something? Answering when questions.
Naming animals.
Responding to why questions by giving a reason.
Using adjectives to describe people and objects.
Building sentences.
Defining words.
Using words that express quantity.
Ms. Yourman concluded that STUDENT’s overall performance on the PLS-3 demonstrated her improvement since September 1998, “as well as her weakness/difficulty in the area of auditory processing.”
On the Preschool Question Inventory, Ms. Yourman found that STUDENT was able to respond to more questions, all twenty five, with eighteen correct answers and “scattered scores from 36 to 48 months.” On the Command Continuum, STUDENT was able to complete 12 of 16 tasks up to the 48-month level, but she demonstrated difficulty with locative prepositions. For example, STUDENT was told to “put the block on the box” and she put the block on the chair. With regard to the language sample of STUDENT’s spontaneous speech, Ms. Yourman found a mean length of utterance of 4.7 words. With regard to STUDENT’s expressive language, Ms. Yourman notes as follows:
Growth of STUDENT’s expressive language is clearly evident by her increased MLU and variety of structures. She appears much more verbal and at ease when speaking on her own terms rather than having to answer questions or in a conversational situation and especially without visual or contextual cues. In the past she was noted to be easily distracted and to demonstrate great difficulty focusing attention to questions and/or tasks. It is this examiner’s opinion that was due much in part to her weak auditory skills. STUDENT has demonstrated improvement in this area in her current SDC, a safe, structured environment. Without structure and a frame of reference to topics and visual or contextual cues STUDENT demonstrates much more difficulty. At times she has been observed to appear “distant” or “day dream like” or to respond to questions with silly and/or inappropriate verbiage and actions. The latter appears more often and appears to be a ‘coping’ strategy she uses when she may not know what is expected of her.Ms. Yourman administered the Kindergarten Readiness Test (KRT), a nonstandardized test that measures the skills “which are usually considered stepping stones for success in school,” including: (1) understanding, awareness, and interactions with one’s environment, (2) judgement and reasoning in problem solving, (3) numerical awareness, (4) visual and fine-motor coordination, and (5) auditory attention span and concentration. STUDENT received a raw score of 18 out of 49, which placed her below the “questionable readiness” range.
Ms. Yourman also administered the Berry Picture Vocabulary Test (Berry), which is a test designed to measure a child’s ability to name or “label” single pictures of familiar items. STUDENT received a standard score of 88, a percentile rank of 21. Ms. Yourman noted that many of STUDENT’s error responses were associative in nature, e.g., she called a skunk a squirrel, and indicated that she “performed reasonably well . . . reaching the starting point for a twelve year old before establishing a ceiling of eight consecutive wrong.”
The PARENTS sent a letter dated April 25, 2000, about one week before STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting (May 1, 2000) was scheduled to convene, to the superintendent of the District, Robert Caine, regarding their expectations and concerns related to STUDENT’s placement during the 2000-2001 school year. The letter expresses, among other things, their concern that placing STUDENT in a special day class would not be in her best interests and that the PARENTS were seeking to have STUDENT placed in the regular kindergarten classroom at Bacich Elementary (a District elementary school). Petitioner’s Exh. 176-177.
STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting convened on May 1, 2000. Ms. Yourman presented her report and discussed her observations regarding a proper placement for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year. District’s Exh. 18. The team also discussed a report prepared by occupational therapist Erin Aggson-Hurley, as well as her observations of “STUDENT’s performance during testing, and in other environments.” The team worked on developing goals and objectives in the areas of auditory processing; receptive language; expressive language; receptive language skills (specific to following directions); social/emotional development and on-task behavior; language arts readiness skills; math readiness skills; pragmatics; visual perception and perceptual motor skills; and motor planning and sensory processing. The team also discussed how these goals and objectives could be implemented in different environments, including an SDC and a regular education kindergarten such as Bacich Elementary.
The IEP team also discussed “related services . . . in relation to the parent’s request to have [STUDENT] in a regular ed setting.” Specifically, the IEP reflects that the PARENTS felt that “STUDENT would benefit from/requires daily speech therapy; occupational therapy 2 hours/week…” The IEP reflects that Paula Cline, the District’s representative, discussed the types of services available and that she agreed to discuss the parents’ concerns, as well as their recommendations, with Robert Caine, the District superintendent. The PARENTS indicated (again) that they felt STUDENT should be enrolled at Bacich Elementary during the 2000-2001 school year. The IEP reflects that “it was the recommendation of the Early Intervention Program that STUDENT continue in the special day class as the least restrictive environment upon entering Kindergarten.” The May 1, 2000 IEP concludes, in pertinent part, as follows:
At this point, the IEP team will need to reconvene to further discuss STUDENT’s program for next year 00-01. Parents are also requesting 1) Auditory Integration Training as an assistive technology services, assessed by an authorized, experienced and certified person; 2) Extended school year with regard to receiving related services (SLP, O.T.) as requested above based upon her enrollment in the regular ed. setting (daily SLP, O.T. 2x wk) she will receive these services in lieu of special day class, 1:1 assistant to provide “tutoring” of individual goals written by C. Yourman – during summer period; 3) Request that STUDENT’s Kindergarten classroom must closely fit the attached description by Ilene Lee . . .
STUDENT will remain in Clara Yourman’s special day class for the remainder of this school year (through 6/00).
District’s Exh. 18.
The IEP team reconvened on May 25, 2000. Present were Holly Edde, the regular kindergarten teacher at Bacich Elementary, Clara Yourman, Laura Trahan, MOTHER, Paula Cline, Ken Kammuller, Ilene Lee and Tony Dill. The IEP reflects that the IEP goals were approved by all members of the IEP team.(Footnote 12) The parties failed to reach an agreement, however, with regard to STUDENT’s placement for the 2000-2001 school year, or the 1999-2000 extended school year. The IEP reflects the following, in pertinent part:
The Early Intervention, Kentfield Dist. programs continue to feel that the Special Day class program continues to be the most appropriate placement. The following program was [offered]: Combined program 1) Special Day class program in a language based special day class, participation in a sensorimotor program in addition to 2) enrollment in regular Kindergarten for the afternoon for socialization. 2 programs would be overwhelming needs would not be met this way (parents concerns).
. . . Summer program would include implementation of LINKS to language program at Marindale. Also to continue to provide her sensorimotor program and direct occupational therapy. Parents will be doing the following: 1) Enrollment in private preschool; 2) Enrollment in private speech therapy; 3) Enrollment in private occupational therapy . . . Mom will provide a written copy of the intended plan of above will be seeking reimbursement from District . . . .
District’s Exh. 18.
The PARENTS attached a copy of a handwritten two-page document which describes the programs they believed would be appropriate for STUDENT during the 1999-2000 extended school year and the 2000-2001 school year. For the extended school year, the PARENTS requested that STUDENT be placed at ABC Academy for “six weeks . . . beginning June 19, 2000,” an aide (to be trained by Ilene Lee), speech therapy to be provided by Patty Toboni (who would implement the LINKS to language program), occupational therapy at ABC Academy, and audio integration training to be provided by Judith Paton.
Over the summer, the PARENTS procured private speech and language services as well as “auditory integration training,” and continued STUDENT’s placement at ABC Academy. She did not attend any District program, nor did she receive any related services from the District during the summer of 2000.
On August 7, 2000, the District sent a letter to the PARENTS regarding the proposed placement for the 2000-2001 school year. The District offered placement in the morning, kindergarten special day class at Coleman Elementary School taught by an “experienced and qualified special day class teacher who will focus on (among other things) language development; social skills development; sensorimotor skills developments; and academic readiness in order to address and implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives.” District’s Exh. 31. The District also offered “an inclusion experience for STUDENT in the regular education kindergarten class at Bacich Elementary School [STUDENT’s home school] . . . from 12:00 p.m. until 2:15 p.m. each day . . . .” Additionally, the District offered direct speech and language services, three sessions per week, thirty minutes per session; speech therapy consultation with teacher, once every two weeks, thirty minutes; direct occupational therapy services, two sessions per week, thirty minutes per session; occupational therapy consultation with teacher, sixty minutes per month; transportation services; “Clara Yourman to consult with each of STUDENT’s teachers for a total of 15-30 minutes per week;” and “the current SDC teacher to consult with the regular education teacher, 15-30 minutes per week.” Id.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did STUDENT receive a free and appropriate public education during the 1999-2000 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of possible related services are language and speech development and remediation, psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17) (1991)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b) (1983).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
In determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program reflects STUDENT’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with her IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.
Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that her removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, a substantively appropriate program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit; (3) comport with her IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student's educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child's IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b) (1997) (amending 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1994)). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990). Thus, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the hearing officer to determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and to determine whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.
Regarding procedural appropriateness, the Student alleges that the District committed several procedural violations that led to the loss of educational opportunity for her during the 1999-2000 school year: (1) failure to provide updated annual goals; (2) use of prewritten IEP objectives; (3) failure to report progress toward goals and objectives; (4) failure to discuss goals and objectives at an IEP meeting; and (5) failure to discuss mainstreaming at the May 1999 IEP meeting.
State law requires that an IEP contain, among other things, the present levels of a student’s performance (including how the pupil’s disability affects the pupil’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum) and measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to meeting the student’s needs that result from the student’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a). The purposes of short-term objectives is to provide a mechanism for a child’s teachers and parents to monitor the child’s progress -- or lack thereof -- in special education over the course of the year. See 34 C.F.R. § 300, Appendix C to Part 300 of the Federal Regulations.(Footnote 13)
With regard to the first two allegations, that the District failed to provide “updated annual goals” and that prewritten IEP objectives were used at the May 1999 IEP meeting, the evidence established that STUDENT’s goals and objectives did not change substantially between October 1998 and May 2000. At STUDENT’s annual IEP in May 1999, the annual goals and objectives, none of which had been achieved at that time, were simply carried over to the next year. However, although the evidence established that the District did indeed fail to develop new annual goals and used prewritten objectives, unless the goals and objectives were inappropriate, there was no loss of educational opportunity. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT’s goals and objectives were inappropriate for the 1999-2000 school year.
Regarding the third allegation, that the District failed to discuss the goals and objectives at the May 1999 IEP meeting, the IEP team participants who testified at the hearing – Ms. Yourman, MOTHER and Ms. Cline – could not recall the specifics of any discussions regarding STUDENT’s goals and objectives. However, the document reads that “draft goals and objectives” were “reviewed, revised, and are recommended,” and the signature page, signed by all three, refers to the goals/objectives pages (which are also attached). Based on the weight of the evidence, Hearing Officer finds that the District did discuss STUDENT’s goals and objectives at the May 1999 IEP meeting.(Footnote 14)
With regard to the Student’s fourth allegation, that the District failed to report progress, the evidence established that while Ms. Yourman did not prepare weekly or quarterly progress reports, she frequently spoke to MOTHER regarding STUDENT (although MOTHER testified that the frequency decreased, especially during the latter part of the year). Testimony of MOTHER and Yourman. Moreover, although Ms. Yourman testified that she typically tracks progress in her head (but does refer to a student’s goals and objectives periodically throughout the school year), she updated STUDENT’s goals and objectives in December 1999, about halfway through the school year. District’s Exh. 9. The IEP was required to include, among other things, “a statement of how the child’s parents will be regularly informed (through such means as periodic report cards), at least as often as parents are informed of their nondisabled children’s progress, of . . . their child’s progress toward the annual goals . . . .” 34 C.F.R. §300.347(7)(ii). The Hearing Officer finds that, based on the weight of the evidence, Ms. Yourman failed to appropriately track STUDENT’s goals and objectives.(Footnote 15) However, there was no evidence that this procedural violation actually resulted in loss of educational opportunity; the evidence established that there were ongoing communications between MOTHER and Ms. Yourman regarding STUDENT. Moreover, the Hearing Officer notes that there were four IEP team meetings during the school year (all in the winter/spring) where, at least in part, STUDENT’s general progress was discussed. As such, there was no loss of educational opportunity related to Ms. Yourman’s failure to appropriately track STUDENT’s goals and objectives.
Overall, with regard to the first four procedural violation allegations, all related to STUDENT’s goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no procedural violation that actually resulted in a loss of educational opportunity. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).
The Student also asserts that the District failed to discuss “mainstreaming” at her annual IEP meeting in May 1999, and that this violation resulted in prejudice to her. MOTHER testified that mainstreaming was not discussed. According to her, Ms. Yourman simply concluded that STUDENT was not yet ready for a regular education environment. District’s Exh. 9 and testimony of MOTHER. The IEP, indeed, does not reflect that the four members of the IEP team considered whether or not STUDENT should be mainstreamed during the 1999-2000 school year. The IEP was required to include, among other things, “an explanation of the extent, if any, to which the child will not participate with nondisabled children in the regular class . . .” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iv).(Footnote 16) Based on the weight of the evidence, including the deficient IEP and MOTHER’s undisputed testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not adequately discuss mainstreaming opportunities, as it was required to do, at the May 1999 IEP.
Moreover, the District’s failure to adequately discuss mainstreaming options actually resulted in loss of educational opportunity. Because the IEP team members failed to seriously consider whether or not STUDENT could and should be mainstreamed, STUDENT was never placed by the District in an environment with age-appropriate, typically developing peers.(Footnote 17) Furthermore, as discussed below, the IEP teams’ failure to discuss mainstreaming prevented it from recognizing the need for a placement that included, in addition to the SDC component, a component containing opportunities to interact with typically developing peers in order to implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives with respect to pragmatics and social skills.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team’s failure to adequately discuss mainstreaming resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year. As such, the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 1999-2000 school year.
Regarding substantive appropriateness, under the IDEA and Rowley, a substantively appropriate program for STUDENT must meet the following three requirements to constitute an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit; and (3) comport with her IEP. Additionally, the program must be provided in the least restrictive environment. Each requirement will be developed below.
Designed to meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
The first question is whether the District’s placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Regarding STUDENT’s deficits, it is undisputed that she had (and has) significant deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language, and that she has a severe auditory processing deficit.(Footnote 18) Testimony of MOTHER, Trahan, Yourman, Koegel, Lee and Patterson. There is similarly no dispute that, especially during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s pragmatic use of language and her social skills were significantly delayed. District’s Exh. 6 and Testimony of Yourman. That STUDENT had goals and objectives in all areas of need – including pragmatics and social skills – was also not seriously disputed. District’s Exh. 9.
The parties stipulated at the beginning of the hearing that the special day class component – Clara Yourman’s special day class for the communicatively handicapped at Marindale – was appropriate for STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year.(Footnote 19) Therefore, it is not necessary to determine whether Clara Yourman’s special day class was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or whether her goals and objectives, as they relate to her SDC placement, were also appropriate.
STUDENT asserts that the SDC was not sufficient by itself. She asserts that, to be designed to meet her unique needs, the District’s program should have also included opportunities to interact with typically developing peers – mainstreaming. Specifically, the Student asserts that the District should have placed her in a regular education preschool environment with a one-to-one aide, one-to-one speech and language therapy, and consulting services. Each one of these contentions will be developed below.
-Mainstreaming With Typically Developing Peers (in addition to an SDC)
The Student generally argues that, in addition to her SDC, she should have been placed with typically developing peers during the 1999-2000 school year for a portion of the day, three days each week, for a total of 12-15 hours each week.(Footnote 20)
The District argues that all of STUDENT’s pertinent goals and objectives, including pragmatics and social skills, were adequately addressed in Clara Yourman’s special day class, and that mainstreaming with nondisabled peers, i.e., placement in a regular education preschool for a portion of the day, was not necessary (or legally required).(Footnote 21) Again, it is undisputed that there were no opportunities at the Marindale campus through which STUDENT could be mainstreamed with nondisabled peers. Ms. Yourman testified that she, along with her experienced classroom aide did work on STUDENT’s pragmatics and social skills goals and the corresponding objectives on an ongoing basis, both in her class and in conjunction with another special day class comprising children diagnosed predominately with Autism.
The Hearing Officer finds that the SDC, alone, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of pragmatics and social skills, and that, to meet those needs, an appropriate program for STUDENT must have also provided her mainstreaming opportunities with typically developing peers.
First, in the deficit areas of pragmatics and social skills, STUDENT’s present levels of performance reads that “STUDENT demonstrates a profound delay in her use of language in social situations. She exhibits a year and a half delay in her play skills.” STUDENT corresponding objectives were as follows: (1) STUDENT will increase eye contact with conversational partners; (2) STUDENT will engage in parallel play with same age peers; (3) STUDENT will engage in verbal or nonverbal turn taking in play or classroom activities; and (4) STUDENT will initiate interaction with same age peers during situations or classroom activities. STUDENT’s pragmatics and social skills goals and objectives require participation in a placement with typically developing peers. The District did not provide persuasive testimony that its program offered these opportunities. Moreover, no such opportunities were even available at the Marindale site. The evidence established that there were no nondisabled, typically developing peers at Marindale. Therefore, the District was unable to implement the goals and objectives of STUDENT’s IEP in the SDC.
Second, as described above, the IEP does not reflect that the IEP team adequately considered mainstreaming opportunities. The District’s argument that it was not necessary because the Marindale site provided appropriate peer models, all of whom were disabled, is not supported by the law, which requires that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
U.S. Code § 1412(a)(5)(A) [emphasis added]. This requirement also applies to preschool-age children such as STUDENT.(Footnote 22) 34 C.F.R.§ 300.552. Third, STUDENT was enrolled by her parents in a regular preschool (which also served as daycare) and made significant progress during the 1999-2000 school year. This is not disputed. Two EIP members who observed STUDENT’s program at ABC Academy following the PARENTS’ request for a one-on-one aide confirmed that STUDENT, as of March 2000, was showing “many age appropriate social skills” and was engaging in “appropriate play interactions with both peers and adults” and that STUDENT showed “strong pragmatic skills, including responding to greetings, making requests, taking turns, maintaining eye contact, . . .” District’s Exh. 14 and testimony of Mostafa.(Footnote 23)
Finally, in developing STUDENT’s placement for the 2000-2001 school year, the District has essentially acknowledged that STUDENT’s placement should have included opportunities to interact with typically developing peers during the 1999-2000. The District’s proposed placement for the 2000-2001 school year is nearly identical to STUDENT’s actual program for the 1999-2000 school year (including her private placement at ABC Academy). The District has offered a morning SDC at Coleman Elementary, along with an afternoon regular program at STUDENT’s home school – Bacich Elementary – for mainstreaming. The District has provided no persuasive evidence of how STUDENT’s unique needs and ability to benefit from her typically developing peers has changed since the 1999-2000 school year.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that an appropriate program for the 1999-2000 school year also should have included interaction with typically developing peers by which her pragmatics and social skills goals and objectives could have been implemented.
-One-to-one Speech and Language Therapy
With regard to STUDENT’s claim that she also required direct one-to-one speech and language therapy during the 1999-2000 school year in order to meet her unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the great weight of evidence supports the District’s position – STUDENT did not require speech and language services in addition to those provided in the classroom by Clara Yourman. As developed above, Cynthia Viden’s speech and language assessment from October 1998 explained that
STUDENT will benefit from receiving language therapy in the classroom as part of the group to help her with transitions and establishing a routine so she will become successful in a classroom setting. Pull out speech/language therapy is not recommended as she needs to work on generalizing play social [sic] use of language with other children in a natural setting. It would be difficult for STUDENT to transfer skills learned in individual therapy to the classroom. It is recommended that STUDENT continue in the intensive, language based special day class where STUDENT’s needs can best be met. The classroom has wonderful opportunities for STUDENT to interact with peers and to learn language in a naturalistic environment.
Both Laura Trahan and Linda Ernst (both of whom are speech and language pathologists for the EIP) echoed Ms. Viden’s sentiment that STUDENT’s speech and language goals were properly addressed in Clara Yourman’s special day class. In sum, there was no persuasive evidence that, to meet her unique needs, STUDENT required individual speech and language therapy in addition to her structured, language-enriched special day class placement.
-One-on-one Aide
The parties also dispute whether STUDENT required a one-on-one aide in the parent-provided private preschool in order to meet her unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year. As developed above, the PARENTS requested that the District and County provide such an aide in STUDENT’s program at ABC Academy, as suggested by their consultant, Ilene Lee. The District convened an IEP meeting in March 2000 to, in part, consider the PARENTS’ request. Linda Ernst and Amira Mostafa observed STUDENT at ABC and prepared a report, which was discussed at a subsequent IEP meeting in April 2000. The District and County denied the PARENTS’ request.
The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT did not require an aide in her private preschool placement to meet her unique needs. The goals and objectives that were addressed (in part) by her parent-provided placement at the ABC Academy – pragmatics and social skills – did not require an aide. Moreover, although STUDENT had no aide at ABC, those two areas were two of STUDENT’s greatest areas of gain. While an aide may have been helpful to facilitate play, one was not necessary to meet her unique needs.(Footnote 24)
-Consulting Services
STUDENT also contends that her program was not designed to meet her unique needs because the District’s placement did not contain consulting services, such as those provided by Dr. Ilene Lee to the ABC Academy, during the 1999-2000 school year. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had a deficit area that required, in addition to her SDC placement, consulting services. Similarly, there was no persuasive evidence that her goals and objectives required consulting services. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT’s unique needs did not include consulting services in her private program.
In sum, STUDENT’s program was designed to meet her unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year in all aspects but one: STUDENT’s pragmatic and social goals and objectives should have also been implemented in a regular education environment with typically developing, age-appropriate peers. STUDENT did not require individual speech and language therapy, a one-on-one aide in the regular preschool environment, or consulting services, in order to meet her unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Some Educational Benefit
The next step is to determine if STUDENT’s program was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit. As discussed above, it was stipulated by the parties that the SDC portion of STUDENT’s program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Moreover, Ms. Yourman’s annual testing revealed that STUDENT made progress in the areas of expressive and receptive language, as well as auditory comprehension, and it is not disputed that she realized significant gains in the areas of pragmatics and social skills. STUDENT also made real progress on all of her goals and objectives during the school year – most had been met by the May 2000 IEP meeting.
Nevertheless, because the District placement did not include opportunities to interact with typically developing peers where STUDENT’s pragmatic and social skills goals and objectives could be implemented, it was not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
Comport with STUDENT’s IEP
The next step is to determine if her program as implemented actually comported with her IEP. As discussed above, the District failed to implement STUDENT’s pragmatic and social skills goals and objectives in an environment with typically developing peers. As such, the District’s placement failed to comport with STUDENT’s IEP.
In sum, to the extent that the District’s program for the 1999-2000 school year did not provide opportunities for STUDENT to interact with typically developing peers, by which her social goals and objectives should have been implemented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not designed to meet her unique needs, was not calculated to provide educational benefit, and did not comport with her IEP. It was also determined above that procedural deficiencies resulted in a loss of educational opportunities for STUDENT. Therefore, the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education during the 1999-2000 school year.
Least Restrictive Environment
The final step is to determine whether STUDENT’s program was provided in the least restrictive environment. While it was stipulated that STUDENT’s special day class was appropriate, the weight of the evidence supports the Student’s assertion that she should have also been mainstreamed with typically developing peers. The District did not provide her with such opportunities; therefore, STUDENT’s program for the 1999-2000 school year was not provided in the least restrictive environment.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate extended school year services during the summer of 2000?
Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043 (1999); compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2) (1999). Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:
Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
Education Code § 56345(b)(5) provides that where, as here, a child has been determined by his or her IEP team to be entitled to ESY services, the written IEP must include an ESY program. See also Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043(f).
STUDENT was offered a 19-day program for the extended school year at the May 1999 IEP meeting, essentially a four-week continuation of Clara Yourman’s special day class. At the May 25, 2000 IEP meeting, the District also agreed to provide LINKS to language as a part of STUDENT’s extended school year program.
The Student argues that the program offered by the District was properly rejected because it failed to confer a FAPE. She states that, while the special day class portion of STUDENT’s 1999-2000 placement was appropriate, during the 2000 ESY STUDENT should have been transitioned to a “full inclusion” placement. Essentially, she argues that her preschool placement ended at the conclusion of the regular school year and that the District was required to transition her to kindergarten over the summer in an ESY program.
The Student’s argument is not supported by the law. As discussed above, the purpose of an ESY program is to “extend instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months.” It is not, as she suggests, the beginning of a new school year.
Nevertheless, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the ESY. As discussed above with regard to the 1999-2000 school year, the District’s program was not appropriate because it failed to provide STUDENT with opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for identical reasons, the District-offered ESY – which was essentially a 19-day continuation of STUDENT’s 1999-2000 program (with the addition of the parent-preferred methodology, LINKS to Language) – was also not appropriate.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
It was not disputed that the District’s proffered program for the 2000-2001 school year is designed to meet her unique needs, that the goals and objectives developed at the May 1 and 25, 2000 IEP meetings were appropriate, or that the placement is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.(Footnote 25)
The central dispute with regard to the 2000-2001 school year is whether the District/County program was the least restrictive environment in which STUDENT could receive a free and appropriate education. Specifically, the parents request that STUDENT be placed in a full inclusion program at her home school, Bacich Elementary, with a one-on-one aide and other supplementary aides and related services (speech and language and occupational therapy). The District argues that STUDENT is not ready for a full inclusion placement, and that even with supplementary aides and services (including an aide), because of STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language delays, and more importantly, her severe auditory processing difficulties, she will not progress, but rather, will likely regress.
Special education law provides that a student such as STUDENT must be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
To determine whether a disabled child should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental services, four criteria must be considered: the educational benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aides and services, as compared with the educational benefits of a special education classroom; the nonacademic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and the other children in the regular classroom; and the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., (Holland) 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).(Footnote 26)
The first question to be answered is what, if any, educational benefits are available to STUDENT if she were to be placed at Bacich Elementary in the regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aides and services, as compared with the educational benefits of a special education classroom.
Clara Yourman, who has been STUDENT’s special day class teacher for the past two school years, testified extensively regarding STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses. Ms. Yourman presented as an exceptional witness. Her testimony was based on her observations of STUDENT, her assessments, and her substantial experience as both a credentialed special education teacher and a speech and language pathologist. Ms. Yourman testified that STUDENT would not receive educational benefit from placement in the regular kindergarten program at Bacich even with an instructional aide and modifications to the curriculum. She discussed the assessments she administered in the spring of 2000 and explained that, while STUDENT had made progress – especially in the areas of pragmatics and social skills – she continued to display significant deficits in the areas of expressive and receptive language, as well as auditory processing. Ms. Yourman also explained that she did not believe STUDENT had acquired the necessary academic readiness skills to be successful in a full inclusion kindergarten. All of the District and County employees echoed Ms. Yourman’s belief that because of STUDENT’s deficits in auditory processing as well as expressive and receptive language and academic readiness, she was not ready for a full inclusion program. Testimony of Trahan, Yourman, Mostafa,
Ilene Lee, who is generally aware of STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses, testified that STUDENT would be successful in a full inclusion program with a one-on-one aide. Dr. Lee’s opinion, however, was seriously undermined by her opinion that no child should be placed in a special day class.(Footnote 27)
Dr. Koegel is an expert in the field of Autism. He is a professor at the University of California, Santa Barbara, as well as the founder and director of the University’s Autism Research Center. He has published extensively, and has helped develop full inclusion programs for close to one thousand students. Dr. Koegel watched a video of STUDENT shot while she was at ABC Academy, reviewed her records and assessments, and briefly observed her in her current program at the Trinity School. Based on his observation, record review and video review, he testified that he believed STUDENT could be successful in a regular education program with a one-on-one aide. He testified about different strategies that may be helpful for STUDENT, including “priming,” by which STUDENT would be introduced to material prior to the lesson or activity in the classroom. He explained that it would be necessary for STUDENT’s aide, at least at first, to provide a lot of redirection and assistance, but that over time, STUDENT’s need for assistance would lessen and the aide could “fade.” Dr. Koegel also testified that standardized testing underestimated STUDENT’s abilities and that she exhibited few real weaknesses.(Footnote 28) Dr. Koegel did not talk to Ms. Yourman, the individual who worked the most with STUDENT over the past two school years. He also did not observe the proposed kindergarten program at Bacich(Footnote 29). Dr. Koegel also was of the opinion that full inclusion should always be attempted first; he testified that one cannot know if a child can be fully included until one tries. Dr. Koegel also testified that the only time full inclusion programs fail, in his experience, is when the local education agency and individuals involved fail to implement the program properly.
Dr. Robert Patterson also testified regarding whether STUDENT could be successful in a full inclusion program at Bacich. Dr. Patterson is a licensed psychologist, a licensed marriage, family, and child counselor as well as a licensed educational psychologist. Additionally, he has a doctorate in psychology and family therapy. Dr. Patterson presented as an excellent witness. In reaching his opinion, Dr. Patterson watched the video of STUDENT at ABC Academy, reviewed her educational records, and observed the afternoon Kindergarten class at Bacich taught by Holly Edde, as well as the proposed special day class at Coleman. He also spoke to her teachers at Marindale. Regarding STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses, Dr. Patterson testified that, broadly speaking, STUDENT is well within the average range in some areas, but significantly below average range in others. Her weaknesses are in the area of expressive and receptive language, and greater in the area of auditory processing. Based on the video, Dr. Patterson explained that STUDENT showed the ability to relate with her peers at times. He also stated that STUDENT had a tendency to tune out, particularly when the teacher was providing instruction. Dr. Patterson witnessed what he described as a large number of behaviors in STUDENT that are characteristic of children who have difficulty processing information or who simply are unable to maintain focus when significant amounts of auditory material is presented.
Dr. Patterson described the kindergarten classroom at Bacich as “very verbal.” He explained that there were a large number of “active verbalizers.” He observed a lot of social interaction and a “high level of language.” He explained that he did not believe STUDENT could be successful at this point in a full inclusion setting, even with a one-on-one aide and other support services. He opined that STUDENT has not yet acquired the pre-academic skills to succeed, and that an aide in a full inclusion setting would need to be a teacher. Essentially, STUDENT would have a class within a class, which would largely defeat the purpose of mainstreaming. Even then, he testified, she would likely regress.
The Hearing Officer finds, based on the weight of the evidence, including the testimony and relevant documents, that STUDENT would not benefit from a full inclusion program with supplementary aides and services at this time. Although STUDENT has progressed over the past two years, she does not yet have the requisite academic skills to be successful in a full inclusion program. The District is not required to place STUDENT in a program that is not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit. First and foremost, the program must be appropriate.
Because it has been determined above that STUDENT would not benefit from a full inclusion placement, it is not necessary to discuss the other Holland factors.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program–a morning SDC at Coleman, with mainstreaming in the afternoon kindergarten class at STUDENT’s home school, and the proposed related services and support is the least restrictive environment in which STUDENT can receive a FAPE.
ISSUE NO. 4(a): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s program at ABC Academy and transportation?
STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for the “supplemental” services they procured from September 1999 to the date of this decision.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court’s decision in Burlington:
The rationale behind Burlington’s holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an “empty victory.” [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if “appropriate relief” in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, “the child’s right to a free appropriate public education, the parent’s right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete.” [Footnote omitted.]
Id.
In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district’s must meet, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id.
As developed above, STUDENT attended the ABC Academy “after school” program from September through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, three days each week for a total of 12 to 15 hours weekly. The afternoon program consisted of up to twelve students and two teachers. She also attended the ABC Academy summer school program (taught by Jamaica Stevens) for three to four days each week (a total of 12 to 15 hours) for approximately six weeks. During the time that STUDENT has attended ABC Academy, she has attended with nondisabled children of the same age (and some older children, up to the second grade). The evidence also established that, in addition to providing STUDENT with opportunities to interact with typically developing peers, the parent’s placement also served the purpose of providing day care (both of STUDENT’s parents work). Testimony of MOTHER.
With regard to reimbursement for the ABC Academy, the District argues that because the program was also “day care,” the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement:
The evidence presented at hearing made it abundantly clear that STUDENT was enrolled at ABC Academy solely for the purpose of day care . . . there is simply no evidence that STUDENT’s enrollment in day care was in any way related to her special education needs, much less that such enrollment was required to allow STUDENT to benefit from her special education program.
District’s Closing Argument, at p. 35.
As held above, the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 and the 2000 ESY because it failed to seriously consider, offer, and ultimately provide STUDENT with opportunities to mainstream and to implement her pragmatics and social skills goals and objectives with typically developing peers. The ABC Academy provided STUDENT opportunities to interact with typically developing peers during the relevant time period. Pat Territo, the director of ABC Academy, as well as Jamaica Stevens, STUDENT’s summer program teacher at ABC Academy, testified regarding the numerous opportunities STUDENT had each day to socialize with typically developing, nondisabled preschool-age children, as well as kindergarten-age and older children. By providing STUDENT with “mainstreaming” opportunities, her ABC Academy program fulfilled unique needs that the District’s placement failed to address sufficiently.
Moreover, the weight of the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s growth in pragmatics and social skills coincided with her enrollment at ABC Academy. Yet, as the District correctly asserts, it is impossible to determine whether or not the program at ABC Academy was responsible, in whole or in part, for STUDENT’s improvements, i.e., whether it actually provided STUDENT with some educational benefit in the areas where the District-provided program was lacking.(Footnote 30) It is equally true that, had the District offered an appropriate program, there would be no need to speculate as to whether STUDENT’s gains were due to the parent-provided program or to her placement at Marindale.(Footnote 31)
Based on the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the ABC Academy placement provided STUDENT with mainstreaming opportunities and provided her with the opportunity to implement and generalize the skills she learned in her SDC related to her pragmatics and social skills goals and objectives during the 1999-2000 school year, as well as the extended school year. Thus, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement. However, with regard to the 1999-2000 school year, it was not established by a preponderance of the evidence that STUDENT required 12 to 15 hours of interaction, three days each week, with typically developing peers for mainstreaming and implementing her pragmatics and social skills goals and objectives. Moreover, as developed above, STUDENT’s goals and objectives in those areas were also implemented, at least partially, in the SDC. Finally, her placement also served as day care for the PARENTS. As such, in balancing the equities, the Hearing Officer determines that the PARENTS should be reimbursed for one half of STUDENT’s actual tuition during the 1999-2000 school year. With regard to the 2000 ESY, the program offered by the District was 19 days long; however the PARENTS seek reimbursement for a six-week program at ABC. The PARENTS provided no evidence that STUDENT required a summer program of longer than 19 days. As such, again, in balancing the equities, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are entitled only to one half of STUDENT’s actual tuition for 19 days of the ABC Academy summer school program.
The PARENTS also seek reimbursement for transportation services they incurred transporting STUDENT from Marindale to the ABC Academy during the 1999-2000 school year. MOTHER testified that because she and FATHER both work, they were forced to hire a personal driver, Ms. Ann Morton, to pick up STUDENT and drive her from Marindale to ABC Academy three days each week. She further testified that the driver charged $86.00 per week (which included $15 dollars per hour, two-hour minimum) plus a per-mile charge, and that for the last “couple of months” of the school year, Ms. Morton charged the PARENTS for one hour, plus mileage.
As discussed above, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, and the parents provided appropriate mainstreaming opportunities for STUDENT at ABC Academy. Transporting STUDENT from Marindale to the ABC Academy was part of the cost of her attending ABC Academy (she had to get there and back). As such, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for their transportation costs.
However, with regard to the amount charged by Ms. Morton ($15.00 per hour), the Student provided no authority for the proposition that the parents should receive reimbursement for her hourly charge in addition to the District’s standard mileage rate. Based on the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for their actual mileage at the District’s standard per-mile rate.(Footnote 32)
ISSUE NO. 4(b): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the speech and language therapy provided by Janet Rizzi, Teri-Lyn Cousley and/or Patricia Toboni?
With regard to the speech and language services provided by Janet Rizzi and Teri-Lyn Cousley, the Hearing Officer has previously determined that individual speech and language services were not necessary to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. Moreover, there is no evidence – Ms. Rizzi and Ms. Cousley did not testify – that those services even benefitted STUDENT. In fact, MOTHER testified that she was not happy with either service provider. Because one-on-one speech and language services were not necessary to confer a FAPE, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement.
Neither are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for Ms. Toboni’s speech and language services provided during the extended school year. As held above, the District’s extended school year program was inappropriate for the identical reasons the 1999-2000 program was inappropriate – because it failed to provide opportunities for STUDENT to implement her pragmatics/social skills goals and objectives in the regular education environment, not because it failed to meet STUDENT’s speech and language needs. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT’s speech and language needs changed from the 1999-2000 school year to the beginning of the extended school year. Finally, the District’s offer of extended school year, as amended in May 2000, actually included the specific methodology preferred by the PARENTS (and actually implemented by Ms. Toboni), LINKS to language. Testimony of Toboni.
ISSUE NO. 4(c): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the consultation services provided by Ilene Lee?
Because it was previously determined that STUDENT did not required consultation services in order to receive a FAPE, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for her services.
ISSUE NO. 4(d): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the occupational therapy services?
Although listed as an issue by STUDENT, there was no evidence adduced at the hearing that STUDENT’s occupational therapy services were not adequately provided by the District’s placement or proposed placement. Moreover, the student provided no evidence with respect to the services provided by her parents. As such, the PARENTS’ request for reimbursement is denied.
ISSUE NO. 4(e): Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the auditory integration training?
As developed above, the PARENTS requested that STUDENT receive auditory integration training (AIT) in May 2000, a request that was denied by the District. The PARENTS actually provided this service during the extended school year through Judith Paton.
A description and development of AIT is not necessary. As discussed above, the sole deficiency in the District’s offered program during the 1999-2000 school year, as well as the extended school year, was its failure to provide STUDENT opportunities to implement her pragmatics and social skills goals and objectives in the regular education environment. STUDENT provided no evidence of a connection between AIT and the deficiencies in the District’s program. As such, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement.
ISSUE NO. 5 Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?
As previously noted, when a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e) (1991) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id.
The PARENTS also seek compensatory education for the District’s denial of FAPE. With regard to the 1999-2000 school year, because STUDENT’s program, as supplemented by the parents private placement (for which they will be reimbursed in part), provided STUDENT with a FAPE, there is nothing to recompense.
With regard to the extended school year, the Hearing Officer similarly declines to award compensatory education. There was no evidence provided at hearing of the type and quantity of compensatory services required to recompense STUDENT for this period. Moreover, although the Hearing was conducted in large part after the expiration of the extended school year, there was no evidence that STUDENT lost educational opportunity or regressed during the summer.
ORDER
(1) Within 30 calendar days after receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the parents as follows: for one-half the cost of tuition of the ABC Academy after-school program for the entire 1999-2000 school year; for one-half the cost of tuition for 19 days of the ABC Academy summer school program; and for the parent’s actual mileage, at the District’s standard rate, incurred providing STUDENT with transportation from Marindale to the ABC Academy and to their home during the 1999-2000 school year, and during 19 days of the summer school program.
(2) All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did STUDENT receive a free and appropriate public education during the 1999-2000 school year? -The Student prevailed on this issue.
(2) Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate extended school year services during the summer of 2000? -The Student prevailed on this issue.
(3) Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year? -The District prevailed on this issue.
(4) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for:
a. the cost of STUDENT’s program at ABC Acacdemy and transportation; -The Student prevailed on this issue for one-half of tuition and reimbursement for transportation. b. the speech and language therapy provided by Janet Rizzi, Teri-Lyn Cousley and/or Patricia Toboni; -The District prevailed on this issue.
c. consultation services provided by Ilene Lee;
-The District prevailed on this issue.
d. occupational therapy services;
-The District prevailed on this issue.
e. the cost of auditory integration training?
-The District prevailed on this issue.
(5) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services?
-The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: January 5, 2001 ________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Although the hearing was convened at the Marin County Office of Education in San Rafael, California, no individual appeared on behalf of the County. Footnote 2: The issues listed here differ from the issues listed by the Student and the District in their respective formal issue statements. Changes were made for purposes of clarification, and to reflect the discussion which occurred on the first day of hearing. Footnote 3: The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Koegel, who lives in Santa Barbara, California, was scheduled to testify on a previous hearing date. However, the Hearing Officer was forced to vacate that confirmed date. The Hearing Officer further notes that both parties worked to find mutually convenient dates, especially for Dr. Koegel’s testimony, but were unable to do so. Footnote 4: There was considerable disagreement between the parties regarding the exact nature of STUDENT’s medical diagnosis. Specifically, the parties disagree whether STUDENT was properly diagnosed as having Pervasive Developmental Disorder, Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS). Whether STUDENT has PDD-NOS is not at issue in the present due process hearing, and such a determination is not necessary for the disposition of the noticed issues. Moreover, there is no disagreement between the parties that, at all relevant times, STUDENT has been eligible for special education due to a language disorder. Footnote 5: The EIP provides special education services for preschool aged children within the MCOE (which includes Kentfield Unified School District). Footnote 6: The IEP reflects that STUDENT was found eligible under the category of “speech or language impaired.” It also reflects that the team agreed to meet in early September “once parents have the opportunity to observe the preschool classes. Of primary consideration is the new class scheduled for children with Pervasive Developmental Disorders.” District’s Exh. 3. Footnote 7: The July 1998 IEP also indicates that STUDENT “meets eligibility criteria” under the categories “Autistic-Like Behaviors” and “Language or Speech Disorder.” It also indicates that “STUDENT has deficits in peer and adult interaction, socialization and focusing/attention.” District’s Exh. 5. Footnote 8: The IEP indicates that STUDENT is eligible for special education due to a language disorder and notes that “STUDENT presents with a significant deficit in the area of pragmatics – also accompanying auditory processing secondary to diagnosis of PDD-NOS.” Footnote 9: Ms. Yourman also compared STUDENT’s scores with the results of Ms. Viden’s assessment from September 1998. STUDENT’s age equivalent in auditory comprehension had increased from 2 years 7 months to 3 years 0 months, while her expressive communication age equivalent had decreased from 2 years 9 months to 2 years 7 months. STUDENT’s total language score on the PLS-3 increased from an age equivalent of 2 years 9 months to 3 years 1 month. District’s Exh. 8. Footnote 10: The letter states, in pertinent part, that “STUDENT cannot return home after school three days per week, since both parents work.” District’s Exh. 12. Footnote 11: In addition to continued discussions regarding the propriety of an aide at ABC Academy and transportation services, the IEP team generally discussed “placement for next year.” Footnote 12: Neither party disputes the appropriateness of STUDENT’s proposed goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year. Footnote 13: Appendix C of 34 C.F.R. § 300, provides detailed requirements in a question-and-answer format. Appendix C describes the purpose of goals and objectives as providing “a way for the child’s teacher(s) and parents to be able to track the child’s progress in special education.” Appendix C further describes short-term objectives as “measurable, intermediate steps between the present levels of educational performance . . . and the annual goals” which can “serve as milestones for measuring progress toward meeting the goals,” or “provide general benchmarks for determining progress toward meeting those goals.” Id. Appendix A of the regulations accompanying the new Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400-1485 (which became effective in California in October 1999, after the 1999-2000 school year had begun) contains almost identical language regarding the purpose of annual goals and short-term objectives:
Each annual goal must include either short-term objectives or benchmarks. The purpose of both is to enable a child’s teacher(s), parents, and others involved in developing and implementing the child’s IEP, to gauge, at intermediate times during the year, how well the child is progressing toward achievement of the annual goal. 34 C.F.R. § 300, Appendix A, Measurable Annual Goals, Including Benchmarks or Short-Term Objectives. [Emphasis added]. Footnote 14: With the benefit of hindsight, MOTHER testified that she believed that STUDENT had already met her goals and objectives as of May 1999. She also explained that she could not recall a specific discussion regarding goals and objectives. She did not explain, however, why it was that she signed the IEP indicating that she agreed that STUDENT’s goals and objectives had been discussed and were “recommended.” Footnote 15: Ms. Yourman should have checked STUDENT’s progress (or lack thereof) at some reasonable interval. Once during the year was not reasonable. Footnote 16: In her closing brief, the student cites the regulations accompanying new IDEA for this proposition (34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(4)). Those regulations were not effective in California until October 1999, after STUDENT’s program for the 1999-2000 school year had already begun Footnote 17: Mainstreaming was not discussed, in large part, because there are no preschool-age typically developing peers at the County’s Marindale site, and thus, no readily available options for mainstreaming. In fact, there was testimony that the County has no preschool program for nondisabled preschoolers. Testimony of Trahan. Footnote 18: As discussed above, Ms. Yourman found, in the spring of 1999 that STUDENT’s auditory comprehension skills were almost two years delayed and her expressive communication skills were similarly delayed. Footnote 19: Similarly, there is no dispute that the occupational therapy provided to STUDENT, at least during the 1999-2000 school year, as well as the concomitant goals and objectives, was appropriate for STUDENT. As such, this component of STUDENT’s program will not be discussed. Footnote 20: As discussed above, the District failed to adequately discuss mainstreaming at the May 1999 IEP meeting, and the District’s failure actually resulted in the loss of educational opportunity. Footnote 21: The District also emphasized in its closing argument the “importance of facilitated play” in addressing STUDENT’s goal and objectives with regard to pragmatics and social skills development and stated that the SDC provided “STUDENT with opportunities to practice her skills with students with superior pragmatic skills (as [was] true of most children in the classroom) and to model communication for children whose skills are lower than STUDENT’s.” Clara Yourman testified similarly. Footnote 22: Again, there were no typically developing peers at the Marindale site. Nonetheless, the IEP team was required to consider alternative mainstreaming options, especially when, as in the present case, a student’s goals and objectives require implementation in an environment with typically developing peers. The notes to the regulations accompanying the former IDEA at 34 C.F.R.§ 300.552 explain, in pertinent part, as follows:
Section 300.552 [Placement] includes some of the main factors that must be considered in determining the extent to which a child with a disability can be educated with children who are nondisabled. The overriding rule is that placement decisions must be made on an individual basis. The section also requires each agency to have various alternative placements available in Id. [Emphasis Added].
Footnote 23: While it may be true that STUDENT’s remarkable progress in the areas of pragmatics and social skills during the 1999-2000 school year (again, her present level of performance from her 1999-2000 goals and objectives indicates that there was a “profound delay” in that area) were due in no small part to Ms. Yourman’s work at Marindale, it is also likely true that STUDENT’s gains in those two areas were a result of STUDENT’s daycare program at ABC Academy, where she interacted with nondisabled peers. Footnote 24: The evidence established that Clara Yourman worked on pragmatics and social skills in the SDC (Testimony of Yourman), and that the parent-provided preschool placement provided STUDENT an opportunity to generalize those skills with her typically developing peers. Footnote 25: STUDENT did argue that the District failed to offer a FAPE because the IEP meetings in March, April, and May 2000 were procedurally inadequate because the District representative at those meetings, Paula Cline, lacked “full administrative authority.” The evidence established Ms. Cline had a tendency to “check in” with the District’s superintendent, Robert Caine. It was not established by a preponderance of the evidence that Ms. Cline lacked full administrative authority. Regardless, there was absolutely no evidence that this procedural violation resulted in prejudice to the parents’ right to participate in the IEP process, loss of educational opportunity by STUDENT or a substantive denial of FAPE. Footnote 26: The District does not dispute the last of the Holland factors. As such, the cost of a full inclusion program for STUDENT is not relevant. Footnote 27: Dr. Lee attempted to recant her opinion. The regulations accompanying the IDEA require that each public agency ensure that a continuum of alternative placements is available to meet the needs of children with disabilities. The continuum must include, among other things, special classes. Both the IDEA and State law anticipate that, for some children education outside of the regular classroom will be necessary in order for them to receive a FAPE. Footnote 28: Clara Yourman testified, in sharp contrast, that standardized tests, because they are administered in a relatively distraction free, safe environment (and STUDENT is easily distracted), tend to overstate STUDENT’s abilities Footnote 29: Although whether STUDENT has PDD-NOS was not at issue, Dr. Koegel’s analysis in that regard was enlightening. On one hand, Dr. Koegel, based on Dr. Bennett’s assessment from 1998 (which included no valid assessment results), stated that STUDENT had PDD-NOS. Nevertheless, he testified it was one of the “mildest cases” he had ever seen. (When asked whether it is possible that STUDENT may not have PDD-NOS, Dr. Koegel was adamant that she did.) Footnote 30: Again, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s offer for the 2000-2001 school year is remarkably similar to the program STUDENT actually participated in during the 1999-2000 school year (including the parent’s private placement at ABC Academy where STUDENT was able to interact with typically developing peers). Footnote 31: Again, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s offer for the 2000-2001 school year is remarkably similar to the program STUDENT actually participated in during the 1999-2000 school year (including the parent’s private placement at ABC Academy where STUDENT was able to interact with typically developing peers). Footnote 32: The PARENTS are also entitled to reimbursement for their actual mileage, at the District’s rate, for their unreimbursed transportation costs during 19 days of the ABC Academy summer school program.
