California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 3, 2000

Student v. Petaluma City Elementary School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1063-99 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Hearing Officer orders California School for the Deaf, Fremont, to enroll deaf student after finding Petaluma's day class denied FAPE.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 6 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that on July 27, 1999, Petitioner filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California, against CDE, Superintendent Delaine Eastin and the California Schools for the Deaf. The complaint seeks review of Issue 6 of the prior decision (STUDENT I, SN 585-98), which denied admission to CSD Fremont for 1998-1999, plus Section 504 and ADA claims. Before the hearing, a hearing officer dismissed CDE from the caption (July 28, 1999), and the motions to reconsider that dismissal were denied. Motions for stay put at CSDF, for summary judgment, and to dismiss were also denied.

Summary

The parent of an 11-year-old deaf student with developmental delays filed against Petaluma City Elementary School District, the Sonoma County Office of Education, and the California Schools for the Deaf in Fremont and Riverside. An earlier SEHO decision (SN 585-98) found that the student needed a specific kind of placement and ordered him placed by July 1, 1999. The placement needed signing peers near his developmental level, a teacher proficient in American Sign Language (ASL), small-group instruction, structure, a behavior program, and a functional curriculum. No such placement was found, and both Schools for the Deaf refused to admit him. He stayed in a district special day class for students with severe disabilities, where a deaf signing aide did most of his teaching.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that the student had made strong progress, but his core language and social needs had not changed. The day class had no signing peers or signing teacher. It was not designed to meet his needs, so it did not offer FAPE for 1999-2000. No suitable program was identified in nearby counties. The Hearing Officer rejected the Schools for the Deaf's claim that the student needed a custodial program. She gave more weight to staff who worked with him than to school witnesses who had never observed him. Riverside was generally appropriate but too far from his family. Fremont was ordered to enroll him within 50 days, with a transition plan set by the IEP team. The district and county office must provide a one-to-one aide, behavior services, and consultation from a credentialed severely-handicapped teacher.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO used Rowley and California's legislative findings on deaf education to judge a placement for a deaf student. A class without signing peers or a signing teacher was not designed to meet his needs. The Hearing Officer ordered a state School for the Deaf to admit a deaf student with developmental delays despite its admission criteria, with local agencies sharing support duties.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did Respondents offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year?

    The student's core language and social needs had not changed despite his progress. The district's SDC-SH had no signing peers and no teacher proficient in ASL, so it was not designed to meet his unique needs and did not offer FAPE for 1999-2000.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Is there an appropriate placement for STUDENT in any of the counties surrounding Sonoma County?

    No party identified any program in the surrounding counties with all the required placement components, so the Hearing Officer could not find that an appropriate placement existed there.

  3. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. With appropriate accommodations and modifications, does either the California School for the Deaf in Fremont or the California School for the Deaf in Riverside offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1900-2000 [sic] school year?

    The student met the CSD Manual criteria and did not need a custodial program; some one-to-one help did not bar admission. With reasonable modifications, CSD Fremont was appropriate. CSD Riverside was generally appropriate but too far from the student's home and family.

  4. Issue 4. If not, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to create a classroom program that meets STUDENT's educational needs as described in the decision in STUDENT I?

    Not reached. Because CSD Fremont's existing class could meet the student's needs with reasonable modifications, no separate classroom program had to be created.

  5. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5. Pending creation of a program at the California School for the Deaf Fremont, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to accept STUDENT with appropriate modifications and accommodations to the classroom program?

    CSD Fremont must enroll the student and make reasonable modifications. Working with Fremont, the district and the county office must develop a transition plan and provide a one-to-one aide, behavior services and consultation from a teacher with a severely handicapped credential.

  6. Issue 6. If STUDENT is placed at either California School for the Deaf, are Respondents Petaluma City School District and the Sonoma County Office of Education responsible for the costs of transportation and lodging so that STUDENT's family can visit him on weekends?

    Not reached. CSD students go home on weekends, so family visits were unnecessary, and under Education Code 59030.5 CSD Fremont must provide weekend and holiday transportation.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting. Along with the required participants, including the parents, it must include at minimum the CSDF classroom teacher and residential supervisor who will be responsible for the student, the DHH specialist (Ms. Maldonado), the one-to-one aide (Mr. McAllister), the current SDC-SH teacher, and administrators from the District, the Sonoma County Office of Education and CSDF.
  • The IEP team must develop a transition plan. The plan must set the length of the transition from the current placement to CSDF and the specific services needed during that period. Those services may include the parents and the current one-to-one assistant taking part at CSDF when the student is first placed.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must identify the services and modifications the student needs in both the CSDF classroom and the residential program. These include all services on his current IEP, including the one-to-one assistant and behavioral intervention services. The District and the county office must provide a qualified SH-credentialed teacher to help develop and carry out the classroom modifications. They must also provide a one-to-one aide during the school day and in the cottages as needed, for a period the IEP team sets.
  • Placement ordered. The student must be placed at the California School for the Deaf, Fremont as soon as practicable but no later than 50 days from the date of the decision, consistent with the transition plan.
  • Under Education Code 59030.5, CSDF is responsible for the student's transportation between home and CSDF on weekends and holidays.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(iv); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.5; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 59001, 59002, 59020, 59030.5; 34 C.F.R. § 300.514(c); Cal. Gov. Code § 11135; 42 U.S.C. §§ 12131-12132; Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 1008(a)

People named in the decision

  • Gerald Klor, Director of special services, Petaluma City Elementary School District
  • Ronald Kadish, Ph.D., Director of state special schools, services division, California Department of Education
  • Debra Guthman, Ed.D., Assistant superintendent; witness, California School for the Deaf
  • Cecilia Rossell, Interpreter for parent and counsel, North Bay Regional Center
  • Carmen Lish, Interpreter for parent and counsel, North Bay Regional Center
  • John Marquez, Certified Spanish language interpreter
  • Maria Romero, Certified Spanish language interpreter
  • Christie Lovejoy, SDC-SH teacher (1999-2000), Petaluma City Elementary School District
  • Jarvis McAllister, Full-time deaf signing one-to-one aide; ASL instructor for family, Petaluma City Elementary School District
  • On Our Own, Nonpublic agency providing behavioral intervention services, functional analysis assessment and BIP
  • Tim O'Brien, SDC-SH teacher, La Fiesta Elementary (1998-1999), Sonoma County Office of Education
  • Jill Kantor, DHH teacher and assessor, Sonoma County Office of Education
  • Nancy Grosz Sager, Deaf and hard-of-hearing specialist, California Department of Education
  • Cheryl Estradie, ESY SDC-SH teacher, Petaluma City Elementary School District
  • Jeri Maldonado, DHH specialist; witness for Student, Sonoma County Office of Education
  • Patricia Balthazor, Private speech-language pathologist; witness for Student, Private practice
  • Kathryn (Katherine) Henkel, Principal
  • Susan Flatmo, Behavioral specialist
  • Judy Ahern, Speech pathologist
  • Michelle (Shelly) Rempe, Principal, special needs program, California School for the Deaf, Riverside
  • Penny Valentine, Director of student support services, California School for the Deaf, Riverside
  • Keith Townsend, Teacher, California School for the Deaf, Riverside
  • Ronald Stern, Director of instruction, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Celia May (C.M.) Baldwin, Dean of students (residential), California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Diane Muscadine, Special needs class teacher, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Diane Caughrean, Special needs class teacher (did not testify), California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Northern California Assessment Center, Assessment center that assessed the student in 1997, California School for the Deaf, Fremont
  • Delaine Eastin, Superintendent of Public Instruction (named defendant in federal action), California Department of Education

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1063-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Placement CDS Code: 49-70854 District: Petaluma City Elementary Disability Type: Deafness Mentally Retardation

Case Details This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Petaluma, California, on July 29 and 30, August 26, 27, and 31, September 1 and 2, and October 18, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney F. Richard Ruderman of Ruderman & Roth. Attorney Geralyn Clancy of Varma & Clancy was present on behalf of Petitioner for a portion of the hearing, as was Attorney Jane Reid, who represents Petitioner in another matter. Petitioner's mother was present throughout the course of the hearing. Petitioner's father was present for a portion of the hearing. Also present on different days during the course of the hearing to interpret for MOTHER and her attorneys were Cecilia Rossell and Carmen Lish from the North Bay Regional Center.

Respondent Petaluma City Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lenore A. Silverman of Ed-Law. Also present on behalf of the Petaluma District was Gerald Klor, director of special services. Respondent Sonoma County Office of Education (SCOE) was represented at the hearing by attorney Joseph C. Kinkade of School & College Legal Services. Attorney Larry Schoenke represented SCOE on one day of the hearing. Respondents California Schools for the Deaf (Schools for the Deaf), Fremont (CSDF) and Riverside (CSDR), were represented at the hearing by Edmundo Aguilar, deputy general counsel for the California State Department of Education. On the first day of the hearing, Ronald Kadish, Ph.D., director of state special schools, services division, California Department of Education, was also present on behalf of the Schools for the Deaf. On all other days, Debra Guthman, Ed.D., assistant superintendent, was present on behalf of CSD. Certified Spanish language interpreters John Marquez and Maria Romero provided interpreter services throughout the course of the hearing.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Motion to Reconsider Dismissal of the California Department of Education (CDE) as a Respondent

On July 28, 1999, a hearing officer granted CDE's motion to be dismissed as a Respondent to this matter. At the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner made a motion to reconsider the order. Petitioner renewed the motion to reconsider the dismissal of the CDE a third time during the hearing.

There is no provision in special education law regarding reconsideration of orders by the Hearing Office. Civil law provides some guidance in this area. In civil law, a party affected by an order may move for reconsideration of the order when there are "new or different facts, circumstances or law." Ca. Code of Civ. Proc. § 1008(a). Petitioner presented no new facts, circumstances, or law in support of the motions for reconsideration that were persuasive as to the need to reconsider the prior rulings. Therefore, the motion for reconsideration was denied.

However, the Hearing Officer takes judicial notice that the CDE has administrative responsibility for the California Schools for the Deaf. The California Education Code specifically assigns the superintendent of public instruction with the responsibility of maintaining state special schools, which include the Schools for the Deaf and the Schools for the Blind. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56129 and 59002. The CDE prescribes rules for the government of the state schools and appoints, removes for cause, and fixes compensation for employees. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 59002 and 59003. The CDE is responsible for maintaining a comprehensive elementary educational program, including related services, for deaf individuals. Cal Educ. Code § 59002(b). The CDE fulfills its responsibilities by maintaining the Schools for the Deaf. Thus, the Schools for the Deaf are without legal distinction from the CDE.

Therefore, while the CDE was removed from the caption of the case, the CDE remains a party in its capacity as the administrator of the Schools for the Deaf and, as discussed below, the entity with responsibility for educating deaf students. Additionally, at the beginning of the hearing, counsel for the Schools for the Deaf, Mr. Aguilar, assured the Hearing Officer that the Schools for the Deaf would abide by any order of the Hearing Officer in this case.

Motion to Reconsider Order Assigning Petitioner Burden of Going Forward

On July 28, 1999, a Hearing Officer determined that Petitioner had the burden of going forward at the hearing. There is no provision in special education law regarding reconsideration of orders by the Hearing Office. Civil law provides some guidance in this area. In civil law, a party affected by an order may move for reconsideration of the order when there are "new or different facts, circumstances or law." Ca. Code of Civ. Proc. § 1008(a). Petitioner disagreed with the outcome of the motion; however, Petitioner presented no new facts, circumstances, or law in support of the motions for reconsideration that were persuasive as to the need to reconsider the prior ruling. Motion for Order Placing Petitioner in one of the Schools for the Deaf Pending Resolution of Due Process

At the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner requested that the Hearing Officer order that he be allowed to attend one of the Schools for the Deaf pending resolution of due process proceedings. Petitioner asserted that 34 CFR 300.514(c) provides that the placement called for by the decision in the prior case, STUDENT v. Petaluma City Elementary School District, Santa Rosa City School District, Sonoma County Office of Education, California School for the Deaf, Northern California, and California Department of Education, SN 585-98 (hereafter STUDENT I), constitutes his stay-put placement. (Footnote 1) Section 300.514(c) reads as follows:

If the decision of a hearing officer in a due process hearing conducted by the SEA [state educational agency] or a State review official in an administrative appeal agrees with the child's parents that a change of placement is appropriate, that placement must be treated as an agreement between the State or local agency and the parents for purposes of paragraph (a) of this section [right of student to remain in the current educational placement during the pendency of any administrative or judicial proceeding].

The decision rendered on March 18, 1999, did not identify a specific placement for STUDENT. Instead, the decision set forth certain components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT and ordered the Respondents to locate and place STUDENT in a placement consistent with those components by July 1, 1999. Until such a placement was identified, STUDENT was to remain in his placement in the District in a "severely handicapped" special day class (SDC-SH) with appropriate services. The decision found that, while placing STUDENT at the CSDF with modifications could be considered, CSDF was not determined to be an appropriate placement at that time. To this date, a placement that conforms to the components of an appropriate placement set forth in STUDENT I has not been identified and CSDF with modifications was not adopted by the individualized educational program (IEP) team as STUDENT's placement. CDE participants in the IEP process would not agree to STUDENT's placement at the CSDF with or without modifications. Therefore, placement at CSDF at this time would not be consistent with the decision in STUDENT I and also would not constitute Petitioner's stay-put placement. There is no other basis on which to place STUDENT at CSDF pending resolution of this matter. Moreover, at the heart of this dispute is whether CSDF or CSDR offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year. This dispute can only be resolved by agreement of the parties or by an evidentiary due process hearing. For these reasons the Hearing Officer denied the motion to place STUDENT at CSDF pending resolution of this matter.

Motion for Summary Judgment

At the beginning of the hearing, Petitioner made a motion for summary judgment. Petitioner contended that the motion should be granted because there are no disputed facts. Counsel for the Schools for the Deaf disagreed, asserting that there is a dispute regarding whether Petitioner meets eligibility criteria for placement at either of the Schools for the Deaf. The Hearing Officer denied the motion for summary judgment because there are disputed factual allegations which must be resolved through an evidentiary due process hearing.

Motion to Dismiss

At the beginning of the hearing, the SCOE made a motion to dismiss the case in its entirety. The SCOE contended that the matter should be dismissed because the appeal of the decision in the prior case (STUDENT I or SN 585-98) is pending in the U.S. District Court and, therefore, the Special

Education Hearing Office (SEHO) lacks jurisdiction over the matter. The Schools for the Deaf joined in the SCOE's motion. Petitioner contended that the matter pending in the District Court is related to the prior case, which adjudicated prior school years, whereas the current case is related to his placement for the 1999-2000 school year.

On July 27, 1999, Petitioner filed a complaint in the United States District Court Eastern District of California naming as Defendants the CDE, Delaine Eastin in her official capacity as Superintendent of Public Instruction, and the California Schools for the Deaf. Petitioner seeks review of only that portion of the decision denying him admission into the CSDF. Namely, Issue No. 6 in STUDENT I, which states, "Should STUDENT be placed at the California School for the Deaf (CSD), Northern California, for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year?" None of the other determinations made in STUDENT I has been challenged. Petitioner also seeks relief under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and Title II of the American with Disabilities Act (ADA) for the alleged discriminatory action of the Defendants in denying his admission to the CSDF for the 1998- 1999 school year. (42 U.S.C. § 12132.) The Hearing Officer does not have jurisdiction over these matters and made no findings under Section 504 or the ADA in STUDENT I.

Additionally, the 1999-2000 school year was not identified as an issue in STUDENT I, and no findings of fact were made as to that school year. The 1999-2000 school year was addressed in STUDENT I to the following extent. The decision was rendered close to the end of the 1998-1999 school year and it was anticipated that it would take some time to identify a placement for STUDENT that was consistent with the Decision. For these reasons, it was concluded that STUDENT was entitled to remain in the placement, once it was identified, for the 1999-2000 school year. Because Respondents did not identify a placement consistent with that called for by STUDENT I, STUDENT's placement for the 1999-2000 school year remains at issue. Placement issues are properly brought before the Special Education Hearing Office. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(a)(1) and (2).

Moreover, pending resolution of due process proceedings, a student is entitled to remain in his then-current placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). If the hearing decision agrees with the student's parents that a change of placement is appropriate, that placement is the stay-put placement during the pendency of any judicial proceeding, unless the parents and the District agree otherwise. 34 C.F.R. § 300.513(c). In STUDENT I, it was determined that the SDC-SH did not offer STUDENT an appropriate placement; however, he was to remain in the SDC-SH only until an appropriate placement was made. The Order called for STUDENT to be placed no later than July 1, 1999. Since no placement was ever identified and the Respondents did not comply with the Order, STUDENT remains in what has been determined to be an inappropriate placement. Federal and State special education law entitles special education students to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. Petitioner is entitled to a decision regarding whether he was denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.

Finally, Petitioner asserts that because of significant improvement in his behavior and the good progress he has made in other developmental areas since the evidence was presented in the prior hearing, the circumstances have changed to the extent that he now meets eligibility criteria for admittance to one of the Schools for the Deaf. After taking all of the above into consideration, the Hearing Officer concluded that nothing in the matter brought before the court appears to preclude the Hearing Officer from hearing the present dispute regarding the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer also concluded that it is incumbent that a determination is made as to what constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Therefore, the motion to dismiss was denied.

Stipulations

At the beginning of the hearing, all of the parties stipulated that no placement exists within the District or SCOE that includes the components of an appropriate placement identified in STUDENT I. The parties also stipulated to the inclusion of the background information from STUDENT I into this case (STUDENT II).

Petitioner, the District, and the SCOE stipulated that no placement exists within counties surrounding Sonoma County that includes the components of an appropriate placement identified in STUDENT I. The Schools for the Deaf did not join in this stipulation.

ISSUES

(1) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year?

(2) Is there an appropriate placement for STUDENT in any of the counties surrounding Sonoma County?

(3) With appropriate accommodations and modifications, does either the California School for the Deaf in Fremont or the California School for the Deaf in Riverside offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1900-2000 school year?

(4) If not, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to create a classroom program that meets STUDENT's educational needs as described in the decision in STUDENT I?

(5) Pending creation of a program at the California School for the Deaf Fremont, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to accept STUDENT with appropriate modifications and accommodations to the classroom program?

(6) If STUDENT is placed at either California School for the Deaf, are Respondents Petaluma City School District and the Sonoma County Office of Education responsible for the costs of transportation and lodging so that STUDENT's family can visit him on weekends?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eleven-year-old student who is eligible for special education because he is deaf and developmentally delayed. He currently attends a "severely handicapped" special day class (SDC-SH) in the Petaluma City School District. The class is taught by Christie Lovejoy. STUDENT has a full- time signing one-to-one aide, Jarvis McAllister. SCOE provides deaf and hard-of-hearing (DHH) itinerant services, and On Our Own, a certified nonpublic agency (NPA), provides behavioral intervention services. STUDENT also is entitled to occupational therapy (OT) and adapted physical education (APE). STUDENT's IEP dated July 19, 1999, includes the last agreed to goals and objectives, which are to increase receptive and expressive language/vocabulary, to initiate play and interact with peers, to use the toilet appropriately, to use the cafeteria, and to increase making simple requests and correct responses to simple questions without prompts. Goals and objectives from the IEP dated March 31, 1999, which continue to March 2000, also address the following: signing family names, responding to greetings, sequencing the days' activities, independently bringing a communication book to activities, signing numbers, working independently on fine-motor tasks, and walking to a designated area on the school campus. STUDENT also has goals and objectives for APE and OT.

At the commencement of the hearing, the parties stipulated to the "Background Facts" as presented in the decision in STUDENT I. They are as follows:

STUDENT's cognitive skills have been described as "mildly to moderately" delayed. (Footnote 2) He also has mild cerebral palsy and a seizure disorder, which may be related to his having meningitis when he was approximately five months old. [The following information pertains to STUDENT's placement during the 1998-1999 school year. Except as modified above, STUDENT receives the same services during the 1999-2000 school year.] STUDENT attends a special day class for students with significant disabilities (SDC-SH) at La Fiesta Elementary School. The class is taught by Tim O'Brien. STUDENT receives the following services pursuant to his IEP [individualized educational program]: a full-time one-to-one signing aide (Jarvis McAllister); direct speech and language therapy 30 minutes weekly; adapted physical education (APE) consultation for 30 minutes weekly; occupational therapy (OT) collaboration for 15 to 30 minutes weekly; and deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) consultation for two hours weekly. A behavioral intervention plan (BIP) was developed for STUDENT in November 1997. (Footnote 3) STUDENT's IEP includes goals and objectives to improve gross motor skills, behavior, self-help skills, language, and cognition. Additional goals are specifically designed to increase STUDENT's receptive and expressive sign language vocabulary, to increase making simple requests and correct responses to simple questions, to improve oral motor skills, and to string signed words together.

STUDENT was initially determined eligible for special education in January 1991. He attended school in the Vista Unified School District in southern California prior to moving with his family to Petaluma in approximately April 1993. STUDENT's educational program at Vista immediately before he moved to Petaluma included placement in an SDC, weekly speech and language therapy, and twice- weekly APE. It is unclear whether STUDENT received any educational services from April 1993 until the fall of 1993, when STUDENT was enrolled pursuant to a 30-day interim placement in an SDC-SH operated by the SCOE. The SDC was located on the campus of Valley Vista, an elementary school within the Petaluma District. STUDENT's IEP at the end of the 30-day interim placement, which is dated November 23, 1993, continued STUDENT's placement in the SDC-SH and added the weekly services of 60 minutes of speech and language consultation and 30 minutes of adapted physical education (APE). Following an assessment by Jill Kantor, an SCOE DHH teacher, the IEP team adopted her recommendations and added 15 minutes of DHH consultative services to STUDENT's IEP in June 1994.

For the 1994-1995 school year, STUDENT entered an SDC-SH operated by the SCOE at McKinley

Elementary School, which is within the Petaluma District. STUDENT's IEP dated December 15, 1994, indicates that he was entitled to weekly consultative services of 30 minutes of DHH, 40 minutes of speech and language therapy, and 30 minutes of APE.

For the 1995-1996 school year, STUDENT attended an SDC-SH at Wilson Elementary, which is located within the Wilmar Union Elementary School District. In January 1996, Ms. Kantor reassessed STUDENT. STUDENT's IEP developed in January 1996 calls for weekly DHH consultation for 30 minutes, speech and language direct/consultation services for 30 minutes, and APE consultation for 30 minutes. At an IEP meeting in June 1996, STUDENT's DHH services were increased to 45 minutes each week of direct services.

STUDENT continued to attend the SDC at Wilson during the 1996-1997 school year. STUDENT's IEP indicates that APE continued at the same level, DHH services were increased to 120 minutes per week, and speech and language was increased to 60 minutes of direct and consultative services. Additionally, the IEP calls for a full-time one-to-one signing interpreter. In October 1996, the Petaluma District and SCOE referred STUDENT to the Northern California Assessment Center, which is located at the California School for the Deaf in Fremont (CSD).

On February 24, 1997, a due process hearing was requested on behalf of STUDENT. (Case No. SN 197- 97.) The Northern California Assessment Center at the School for the Deaf completed an assessment of STUDENT during the week of May 12 through May 16, 1997. Pursuant to a mediation agreement reached in SN 197-97, STUDENT was placed for the extended school year program (ESY) during the summer of 1997 in a DHH class for preschool students. The class was located at Lincoln Elementary School in the Santa Rosa District.

For the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT continued in the preschool SDC for DHH students. During the regular school year, the program was located at Hidden Valley Elementary School, which also is within the Santa Rosa District. STUDENT's IEP dated August 21, 1997, added four hours per week of "sign language support" and continued speech and language and APE. DHH services were discontinued because the class was taught by a teacher credentialed to teach deaf students. Because of behavioral problems STUDENT experienced shortly after the beginning of the school year, SCOE contracted with On Our Own, a nonpublic agency (NPA), to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT's behavior and to develop a BIP. The report of the FAA and the BIP were completed on November 10, 1997. On February 17, 1998, the CSD informed STUDENT's parents that he was not eligible to attend CSD.

At an IEP meeting on February 11, 1998, the IEP team agreed to change STUDENT's placement from Hidden Valley to an SDC-SH at La Fiesta Elementary School. La Fiesta is located within the Cotati- Rohnert Park Unified School District. The SDC-SH is operated by the SCOE. The IEP team also added 120 minutes each week of DHH and increased weekly speech and language services to 60 minutes. The IEP indicates that speech and language therapy would be done by a therapist using American sign language (ASL). Another IEP meeting was convened on March 27, 1998. The IEP team agreed to additional goals and objectives and to the services set forth in the first paragraph above under "Background Facts." The IEP states that MOTHER consented to the placement "but feels [STUDENT's] communication needs are not being met."

On May 5, 1998, Petitioner requested a second due process hearing.

On March 18, 1999, a decision was rendered in the case of STUDENT I. The Hearing Officer ordered, among other things, that the District convene an IEP meeting with STUDENT's parents, his classroom and DHH teachers, and representatives from the SCOE and the CDE with expertise in educating deaf and developmentally delayed children. The primary purpose of the meeting was to identify a placement for STUDENT and to ensure that he was placed no later than July 1, 1999. The STUDENT I decision indicates that STUDENT's placement needed to include the following components:

(1) signing peers at or near STUDENT's age and developmental level; (2) a teacher proficient in ASL;

(3) opportunities for small group and individual instruction;

(4) a low student-to-teacher ratio;

(5) a structured environment;

(6) specific instruction in ASL;

(7) a structured behavioral intervention program; and (8) curriculum at STUDENT's developmental level that addresses independent living and social skills.

The Hearing Officer ordered the IEP team members to consider placement within and outside the State in either a public or a private school and stated that "the IEP team may also consider undertaking steps to make the CSDF an appropriate placement for STUDENT." Additional relevant parts of the Order state that (1) the District and SCOE were to maintain STUDENT's current placement until he was placed in an appropriate placement meeting the criteria set forth above, and (2) once STUDENT's enrollment was secured in that placement, he would remain there for the 1999-2000 school year, including the ESY 2000.

On March 31, 1999, the District convened an IEP meeting. Neither the CDE nor the CSDF participated in the IEP meeting. STUDENT substantially met a majority of his objectives from the prior school year. The IEP team agreed on compensatory services in compliance with the decision in STUDENT I, including six hours per week of direct signing instruction for STUDENT and his family. The IEP team also agreed to refer STUDENT to the CSDR. MOTHER rejected the District's offer to place STUDENT in the SDC-SH with a full-time signing interpreter. CSDR rejected STUDENT's application because he does not live in Southern California.

The District and parents initiated a search to identify placement options consistent with the decision in STUDENT I. (CDE's participation was nominal.) They were unable to locate any placements that include the components set forth above and in the STUDENT I decision. (Testimony of Mr. Klor and declaration of Mr. Ruderman.)

On June 29, 1999, the District again convened an IEP meeting. Nancy Grosz Sager, a deaf and hard- of-hearing specialist for the CDE, and the CDE's attorney, Mr. Aguilar, attended the meeting. The IEP indicates that STUDENT would remain in his current placement until such time as a program with signing peers could be located. Petitioner's parent did not consent to the placement. (Petitioner's Exhibits p. 42) On July 2, 1999, Petitioner requested the instant due process hearing.

STUDENT attended the extended school year program (ESY) in Cheryl Estradie's SDC-SH in the District. Mr. McAllister served as STUDENT's one-to-one assistant. He also provided STUDENT and his family instruction in ASL on Saturdays as part of the compensatory relief ordered in STUDENT I.

A third IEP meeting was convened on July 19, 1999. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would receive twenty-five hours of signing instruction, including instruction for his family, during the break between the ESY program and the start of the 1999-2000 school year. IEP team members from the District, SCOE, and MOTHER recommended that STUDENT be placed at the CSDF for the 1999-2000 school year. Mr. Aguilar, on behalf of CDE and CSDF, disagreed with the recommendation. (Petitioner's Exhibits p. 35)

As the CSDF and the CSDR refused to admit STUDENT and no placement consistent with the order in STUDENT I was identified, STUDENT began the school year in the District's SDC-SH with Ms. Lovejoy as his teacher. This decision addresses STUDENT's placement for the 1999-2000 school year.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that his current SDC-SH placement is not appropriate because it does not include all of the components of an appropriate placement set forth in STUDENT I and because he cannot communicate with his teacher and peers. Petitioner contends that both the CSDF and the CSDR offer appropriate placements for him. Petitioner asserts that he has the necessary skills to successfully attend either program.

The District and SCOE also contend that, with appropriate modifications and accommodations, both the CSDF and the CSDR offer appropriate placements for Petitioner; however, the District and SCOE contend that, pending Petitioner's placement at either of the Schools for the Deaf or at some other location that conforms to the Order in STUDENT I, they are providing Petitioner with a placement that meets his needs and allows him to benefit from his education.

The CSDF and CSDR contend that Petitioner does not meet eligibility criteria for their programs for the following reasons: he lacks requisite self-help skills; he needs one-to-one assistance; he is unable to respond to life-threatening situations; he is incapable of learning simple mobility patterns; and he cannot function independently in the residential component. The CSDF and CSDR assert that their programs merely are options for some of California's deaf children who meet their admissions' criteria. The CSDF and CSDR assert that Petitioner's current placement in the District's SDC-SH with an aide and supplemental services offers Petitioner an appropriate placement.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did Respondents offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999- 2000 school year?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student's individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students' abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

It was concluded in STUDENT I that STUDENT required a placement that included signing peers at or near his developmental level; a teacher proficient in ASL; opportunities for small-group and individual instruction; a low student-to-teacher ratio; a structured environment; specific instruction in ASL; a structured behavioral intervention program; and curriculum at his developmental level that addresses independent living and social skills. STUDENT's enrollment in a placement satisfying the above criteria was to be secured no later than July 1, 1999.

The parties stipulated that there is no placement available in the District or Sonoma County that satisfies the placement criteria set forth above and in STUDENT I. Nevertheless, because of the progress STUDENT has made since the prior hearing, the District contends that an appropriate placement under the IDEA and Rowley can be met by placement in Ms. Lovejoy's SDC-SH with a one-to- one assistant, a BIP, and DHH services from SCOE. The appropriateness of the services is not in dispute.

In order to determine whether the SDC-SH may now constitute an appropriate placement for STUDENT, it is first necessary to determine whether STUDENT's needs have changed since the prior hearing. All of the witnesses testified that STUDENT made a great deal of progress during the 1998-1999 school year. MOTHER testified that STUDENT appears more self-assured and is better able to follow directions. She provided examples of ways in which STUDENT's communication skills have improved. She testified that STUDENT uses signs when he wants something. For example, after school he comes home and signs "hungry" or "thirsty." He also is combining other signs with "I want." MOTHER is uncertain whether STUDENT knows the days of the week and whether he can distinguish school days from the weekend; however, she stated that STUDENT knows when it is Friday because he does not ask for lunch or expect to take a bath. He also knows on one of the weekend days to look for his soccer uniform so he can dress like his father, who plays soccer on the weekend.

Jeri Maldonado, who has served as STUDENT's DHH specialist during the 1998-1999 school year and in prior school years, testified that STUDENT is more focused, is able to sit longer, and signs more. She stated STUDENT's eye contact and visual skills also are much improved. He focuses more on persons signing and does not use his body as much as he previously did to communicate. Ms. Maldonado testified that the minute she comes into the room, STUDENT immediately signs something to her. He also spontaneously makes requests of her. For example, STUDENT tells her to come to his area and has asked for help with his shoes and jacket. Ms. Maldonado observed that STUDENT also is more independent and calmer.

Patricia Balthazor, speech and language pathologist in private practice, testified that STUDENT used 50 signs with Jarvis while she observed him during lunch and an activity period in the ESY program. Ms. Balthazor testified that STUDENT was "much" more willing to sign than when she had previously observed him in 1998. During her current observation, STUDENT appeared to be understanding what Jarvis was saying to him and so demonstrated by responding "no" to Jarvis. STUDENT also appeared to have some understanding that "the stuff he does with his hands" gets him what he wants. Ms. Balthazor compared STUDENT's current level of responding to her attempts in 1998 to get STUDENT to sign "help" when he wanted an orange peeled. At that time, STUDENT would not imitate her signing. Ms. Balthazor described other areas of improvement she noted in STUDENT. His attention span was longer, he was able to stay in his seat longer, and he looked at pictures, which he would not do before. Ms. Balthazor described STUDENT's behavior as "markedly improved." For example, in 1998 when STUDENT got frustrated, he would run out the door. In the summer of 1999, STUDENT was able to handle frustration better and did not run away. Ms. Estradie told Ms. Balthazor that STUDENT was more attentive, more independent, able to stay on task longer, and was using more signs. She also reported that STUDENT had recently appeared to enjoy participating in group language activities.

Jarvis McAllister, STUDENT's one-to-one aide, testified that STUDENT has made great gains since the prior school year. Mr. McAllister stated that STUDENT's behavior is improved and Mr. McAllister is now able to work on preacademic tasks with STUDENT. For example, at home and at school, they work on learning the signs for vocabulary cards. At school, STUDENT now will alert Mr. McAllister when he has to go to the bathroom rather than running out of the classroom as he used to do.

Kathryn Henkel, principal, supervised Ms. O'Brien's SDC-SH, STUDENT's placement during the 1998- 1999 school year. Ms. Henkel testified that STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors went "way down." In her estimation, STUDENT made so much progress that he needs to be placed with more appropriate peers.

The testimony regarding STUDENT's progress is further supported by a year-end report dated June 1, 1999, indicating that STUDENT has increased understanding of the purposes of communication and made "good progress in accepting a classroom routine." (Petitioner's Exhibits pp. 43 - 44) Additionally, a progress report related to STUDENT's behavioral support plan, prepared by Susan Flatmo, behavioral specialist, states that "STUDENT's oppositional behavior dropped from an average of 50X per week to an average of 3X per week. Low and moderate level oppositional behaviors have virtually become extinct." (Petitioner's Exhibits p. 55)

To summarize, STUDENT has shown growth in understanding the purposes of communication and in following a structured routine. His eye contact and attention have also improved and his behavior has improved remarkably. STUDENT also substantially met many IEP objectives. Despite STUDENT's progress, his development of communication skills remains significantly impaired, and both receptive and expressive language skills continue to fall well below the expected developmental norms for his age. The speech pathologist, Judy Ahern, noted that STUDENT "needs to continue to work on developing many of the early developmental preacademic and language skills." She also stated that STUDENT's language skills "may adversely affect his social and academic growth." (See Petitioner's Exhibits pp. 68-69.) A majority of STUDENT's goals and objectives address development of receptive and expressive language skills and social skills. (See IEPs dated March 31 and July 19, 1999, Petitioner's Exhibits pp. 35 - 73) Therefore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT's fundamental needs as a deaf and developmentally delayed student that were identified in the prior hearing--to develop receptive and expressive language skills and social skills--have not changed.

It was concluded in STUDENT I that to address these needs, STUDENT required placement with signing peers at or near his developmental level and with a teacher proficient in ASL. No persuasive evidence was presented at this hearing to alter the previous finding. As a matter of fact, the evidence in this hearing supports the importance of a signing environment for the development of communication skills. Shelly Rempe, principal of the special needs program at CSDR, testified that she generally believes that sign language should be learned with individuals who are signing so there are opportunities for exchange. Ms. Maldonado, Ms. Balthazor, and Mr. McAllister testified that a signing teacher is necessary to allow STUDENT to receive direct instruction from the teacher. They also testified that STUDENT needs signing peers to develop appropriate social skills. The Hearing Officer gives substantial weight to the testimony of Ms. Maldonado and Mr. McAllister, who have worked a great deal with STUDENT. Ms. Maldonado also holds the appropriate credentials and has a great deal of experience working with deaf children. Mr. McAllister is extremely familiar with STUDENT and his needs, has first-hand knowledge of the importance of having a teacher and peers with whom he can communicate, and also has a great deal of understanding of the deaf community. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes, consistent with the prior decision, that to address STUDENT's primary and fundamental areas of need, STUDENT continues to require a placement that includes signing peers at his age or near his developmental level and a teacher proficient in ASL. It was undisputed that STUDENT continues to require the other placement components set forth in

STUDENT I.

As to whether Ms. Lovejoy's class is designed to meet STUDENT's needs, Ms. Maldonado, Ms.

Balthazor, MOTHER, and Mr. McAllister testified that STUDENT is isolated in his SDC-SH placement because the only person in his class who signs fluently is Mr. McAllister. Currently, STUDENT receives instruction from Mr. McAllister, who is not a credentialed teacher. Mr. McAllister is himself deaf and cannot directly communicate with a teacher who does not sign. Ms. Lovejoy did not testify at the hearing; however, the testimony of Katherine Henkel, principal, establishes that Ms. Lovejoy's SDC-SH offers STUDENT opportunities for small-group and individual instruction, a low student-to-teacher ratio, a structured environment, and a curriculum at STUDENT's developmental level. The evidence also establishes that the class does not offer STUDENT signing peers or a teacher who is proficient in ASL. Therefore, placement in Ms. Lovejoy's class is not designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs.

Nonetheless, the District and SCOE argue that the requirements of Rowley have been satisfied because STUDENT made progress while attending the SDC-SH and receiving the services called for by his IEP. Under the IDEA and Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP (emphasis added). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176. Because the placement available in the District is not designed to meet STUDENT's needs, it does not satisfy the requirements of an appropriate placement. This is not to say that the District and SCOE have not attempted with earnestness to fulfill their obligations to serve STUDENT. They have provided him with multiple services, including a full-time signing aide, and have placed him in a class that most closely approximates his needs. However, the fact remains that STUDENT requires a teacher from whom he can receive direct instruction and peers with whom he can communicate and develop appropriate social skills.

ISSUE NO. 2: Is there an appropriate placement for STUDENT in any of the counties surrounding Sonoma County?

It has been concluded in Issue No. 1 that STUDENT continues to require the same placement components set forth in STUDENT I to address his current needs. Petitioner, the District, and SCOE stipulated that there are no programs in any of the counties surrounding Sonoma County that include all of the components identified in STUDENT I. Respondents CSDF and CSDR would not join the other parties in the stipulation; however, neither the Schools for the Deaf nor any other parties offered evidence of a placement in the counties surrounding Sonoma County that includes all of the components necessary to offer STUDENT an appropriate placement. Witnesses for the Petitioner, the District, and the SCOE testified persuasively that they had made such a search and were unable to identify a placement that conforms to the requirements of STUDENT I. Since no potential placements were identified, the Hearing Officer cannot draw any conclusions as to the existence of potentially appropriate placements in any of the counties surrounding Sonoma County.

ISSUE NO. 3: With appropriate accommodations and modifications, does either the California School for the Deaf in Fremont or the California School for the Deaf in Riverside offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1900-2000 school year?

The Schools for the Deaf are part of the public school system of the State. Their stated purpose is the education of the deaf "who, because of their severe hearing loss and educational needs, cannot be provided an appropriate educational program and related services in the regular public schools." Education Code § 59001. Pursuant to Section 59020, "every deaf person between the ages of three and 21 years" and who meets certain criteria is entitled to an education at the CSD. Priority for admission is given to elementary age deaf minors residing in sparsely populated regions for "whom appropriate comprehensive educational facilities and services are not available or cannot be reasonably provided by their local school districts or county educational agencies." Education Code § 59020. The Superintendent of Public Instruction determines admission criteria to the CSD. (Second Footnote 3) Section 5210 of the California Department of Education's Specialized Programs Branch Administrative Manual (hereafter CSD Manual) describes the admissions policy to State special schools, including the CSD. The following persons can be served by the CSD:

1. Deaf individuals with or without additional handicapping conditions. 2. Deaf individuals with moderate behavioral problems who are not considered a danger to self or others. . . .

3. Deaf individuals who are educationally deprived or from culturally different backgrounds, including recent immigrants. . . .

6. Hard of hearing individuals with an educationally significant hearing loss who live in rural or other areas without an appropriate educational program.

The Manual also states that the Schools for the Deaf cannot serve students with the following characteristics:

1. Those in need of a 24-hour psychiatric treatment program. . . . 2. Those developmentally delayed individuals who require a custodial program. Characteristics include: severe retardation, lack of self-help skills, or in need of one-to-one supervision. (Self-help skills include: ability to learn simple mobility patterns around campus, communicate basic needs to staff members, respond appropriately to life threatening situations, and function in a group setting; and demonstration of the potential to eat and dress without assistance and otherwise tend to personal care needs.)

3. Those with severe acting out/aggressive behaviors. Characteristics include: danger to self or others, assaultive, repeated contacts with law enforcement agencies, or in need of one-to-one supervision. . . .

(CSD's Exhibits pp. 7-8)

Ms. Maldonado, Mr. McAllister, Ms. Balthazor testified that STUDENT has made progress such that, with appropriate accommodations and modifications, either the CSDF or the CSDR offers him an appropriate placement and also satisfies the criteria set forth in STUDENT I. They testified that either of the Schools for the Deaf would offer STUDENT signing peers and ASL environment. The classes are small and structured and may have peers who are also developmentally delayed. Mr. McAllister expressed some apprehension as to whether STUDENT is currently ready to move to the CSDF and suggested that STUDENT would benefit from a stay of approximately six months in a program such as Hidden Valley before going to CSDF. (Footnote 4)

The District and SCOE have continued to pursue placement for STUDENT at either the CSDF or the CSDR. Mr. Klor testified that CSDF contains more of the components set forth in STUDENT I than any other placement of which he is aware. Mr. Klor and Ms. Henkel concurred with Petitioner's witnesses that CSDF, with some modifications, would provide a better placement for STUDENT than any other program identified. Ms. Henkel expressed the opinion that in a class of five students the teacher can "do just about anything±for example, individualize the program for each child." She also stated that a regular education teacher with consultation from an SH teacher should be able to modify the curriculum to appropriately address STUDENT's needs.

Witnesses for the Schools for the Deaf continue to assert that STUDENT does not meet their eligibility criteria. Because of STUDENT's significantly delayed level of functioning, they assert that he cannot benefit from group instruction and a signing environment. They also assert that to modify the program to meet STUDENT's needs would result in a fundamental change to the program. Ronald Stern, director of instruction for CSDF, has administrative responsibility for all educational programs and supervision of the high school principals. Mr. Stern testified that CSDF serves children who are primarily deaf and who have the ability to learn from others, to develop language, and to carry on conversations with others. Mr. Stern testified that about three years ago, the CSDF abolished its "special unit." Now, there are special classes at the elementary, middle, and high school levels. The classes provide modified and functional academics. Mr. Stern testified that none of the administrators or teachers at CSDF has an SH credential and none is trained to teach developmentally delayed children. It is unnecessary for the staff to have SH credentials because CSDF does not serve SH children. Mr. Stern testified that just like a regular school that cannot serve all children, CSDF cannot serve all deaf children. Mr. Stern testified that he has not seen any severely developmentally delayed deaf students benefit from emersion in the CSDF deaf environment. Mr. Stern expressed the opinion that it is a similar misconception that a severely developmentally delayed hearing child will benefit from a regular education environment.

As to the necessary skills a deaf child must have to benefit from placement at CSDF, Mr. Stern testified that "the ability to learn basic mobility patterns" means that students need to be able to go independently from the classrooms to the gym for physical education, to the cafeteria, to the infirmary, and so forth. Students need to be able to differentiate between "same" and "different." For example, students should know the difference between living and nonliving things, deaf and not deaf, and family and not family, and to be able to so sign sufficiently to indicate knowledge of those differences. Mr. Stern stated that students appropriate for the CSDF are able to function in a group setting. At the elementary level, 60% of the instruction is delivered in a group setting and 40% is delivered one-to-one. Students need to know who is speaking, to answer questions, and to work independently for 20 minutes. Additionally, Mr. Stern testified that it is not enough that the student is able to sit quietly in the classroom. The student also independently needs to give eye contact to whomever is speaking, to initiate conversation, and to be a social learner.

Mr. Stern testified that, after reviewing STUDENT's IEP, he concluded that a child of STUDENT's age and with his goals and objectives would not benefit from attending CSDF. Mr. Stern also stated that "obviously this child [STUDENT] needs one-to-one help and needs one-to-one service and, therefore, does not have the ability to benefit from the environment." Additionally, Mr. Stern testified that implementing STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives at CSDF would result in a "fundamental change" to

CSDF's program. Mr. Stern testified that there are no students at CSDF at STUDENT's chronological age who are functioning at the same developmental level as STUDENT. Mr. Stern testified that the lowest functioning child who is the same age as STUDENT is able to do academics such as adding and subtracting up to 20 or 30. Mr. Stern testified that there currently are two students at CSDF who have one-to-one aides; however, both entered the CSDF for an assessment and have remained there pursuant to stay put. Mr. Stern expressed concerns about the appropriateness of the students attending the CSDF.

Turning to whether STUDENT is among the students who can be served by either CSDF or CSDR under Education Code § 59001, it has been determined that STUDENT is an elementary-age student with a severe hearing loss and educational needs which cannot be met in existing local or regional programs. STUDENT also falls within the category of persons who can be served by the Schools for the Deaf as set forth in the CSD Manual, which states that the Schools for the Deaf serve deaf individuals with moderate behavioral problems who are not considered a danger to self or others. The testimony discussed above establishes that STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan has successfully remediated his more serious behavior problems. Mr. McAllister testified that STUDENT may bite or kick once a month; however, Mr. McAllister did not characterize STUDENT's behavior as dangerous to himself or to others. The CSD Manual states that the Schools for the Deaf serve deaf individuals who are "educationally deprived or from culturally different backgrounds." It was determined in STUDENT I that STUDENT did not receive instruction in ASL and did not receive an appropriate education since at least May 1995. STUDENT's family came to the United States from Mexico and Spanish is his family's primary language. Thus, STUDENT is among the students who may be served by the CSD.

Each criterion related to whether STUDENT falls within the group of individuals that the CSD Manual states that the Schools for the Deaf "cannot serve" will be addressed below. Regarding the criterion related to the need for a 24-hour psychiatric treatment program, the evidence establishes that STUDENT does not need such a program. Students who have severe acting out/aggressive behaviors are also excluded from attending the CSD. There is no evidence that STUDENT falls within this exclusion. As discussed above, STUDENT's behavior has improved, and there was no persuasive evidence of significant behavioral difficulties at the time of the hearing. Other deaf students that the Schools for the Deaf cannot serve are those whose developmental disabilities are so severe that they require a custodial program. The CSD Manual includes severe retardation, lack of self- help skills, or in need of one-to-one supervision as characteristics of a "custodial program." Mr. Stern described a "student requiring custodial care"as "one who cannot give eye contact to whoever is signing, sitting there and not interacting, not working independently, unable to advance beyond the stage of labeling several things, unable to communicate basic needs independently to others, unable to recognize dangerous situations, and unable to dress oneself or take care of toilet needs."

The position of the Schools for the Deaf in the present hearing is that STUDENT's developmental disabilities are so severe that he requires a "custodial program." STUDENT's skills are discussed below in relation to characteristics of a "custodial program." As to whether STUDENT is "severely retarded," assessments by the District and the Schools for the Deaf have described STUDENT's cognitive skills as "mildly to moderately" delayed. Ms. Maldonado testified that STUDENT appears moderately retarded; however, given his progress while working with Mr. McAllister and his belated instruction in communication skills, Ms. Maldonado testified persuasively that STUDENT's cognitive potential cannot be determined with certainty. In any case, it can be concluded that STUDENT is not severely retarded.

As to STUDENT's self-help skills, MOTHER testified that STUDENT dresses himself, bathes, and feeds himself at home. Mr. McAllister and Ms. Maldonado testified that STUDENT goes to the bathroom by himself at school. According to Ms. Maldonado and Mr. McAllister, STUDENT is able to learn simple mobility patterns. At school, STUDENT is able to get to and from the bathroom by himself, and to and from the cafeteria at lunch with his class. Ms. Maldonado has also observed STUDENT go to his class independently and then go to the playground. MOTHER also described STUDENT's independently going to a store some five blocks from the home he was visiting while on a trip to Mexico.

As to STUDENT's ability to communicate his basic needs, Ms. Maldonado testified that it remains somewhat challenging for STUDENT to communicate his needs; however, she described him as "resourceful." For example, if STUDENT does not know a sign, he will push, pull, or point to get his point across. STUDENT also uses adaptive communication skills. Ms. Maldonado stated that if STUDENT wanted a tuna sandwich, for example, but did not know the sign for "tuna," he would sign "sandwich" and then grab the can of tuna. MOTHER and Mr. McAllister concurred that STUDENT communicates some basic needs. For example, at home, STUDENT tells MOTHER what he wants to eat. At school, he communicates when he needs to go to the bathroom. Mr. McAllister testified that STUDENT signs well over 100 words and is stringing signs together. For example, he says, "I want to eat. I want to bathroom. I want to play outside."

One of the areas in which improvement has been noted over the past year is STUDENT's ability to function in a group setting. STUDENT's IEP dated March 3, 1999, states that STUDENT sits in class circle 15 minutes with occasional out-of-seat behavior. (Petitioner's Exhibits p. 47) Mr. McAllister testified that STUDENT's interest in group activities has increased and that he will remain in a group activity for five to ten minutes. Ms. Balthazor's observations supported Mr. McAllister's testimony. It should be noted that none of STUDENT's classmates sign. His teachers also do not sign. Both Ms. Maldonado and Mr. McAllister expressed confidently that STUDENT's attention would increase if group activities and circle time were directed by a signing teacher and the other students were responding by signing.

Some of the additional skills Mr. Stern believes are necessary to benefit from placement at the CSDF are giving eye contact and knowing who is speaking. Both Ms. Maldonado and Mr. McAllister testified that STUDENT watches them sign to each other and wants to know what they are saying. They both also testified that STUDENT's eye contact has increased and he is interested in communicating with peers.

One area of concern that persists is STUDENT's inability to recognize potential dangers in the environment and to respond appropriately to life-threatening situations. Ms. Maldonado and Mr. McAllister noted some improvement in STUDENT's paying attention to his environment; however, neither could testify with certainty that STUDENT recognizes potential dangers in the environment or that he would respond appropriately to a life-threatening situation. Mr. McAllister testified that STUDENT will stay with him on community outings and does not run away. Mr. McAllister has been working with STUDENT on learning to stop at the street corner before crossing the street.

In determining whether STUDENT possesses sufficient skills to be considered for attendance at CSD, the Hearing Officer needs to weigh the testimony of the witnesses. Witnesses for the Schools for the Deaf testified that STUDENT does not possess sufficient skills to benefit from placement at either school; however, none of the witnesses for the Schools for the Deaf have observed STUDENT at school or home. There also was no evidence that they had spoken with STUDENT's teacher or aide to obtain information as to his current abilities. They also did not participate in recent IEP meetings at which STUDENT's current levels of function were discussed. On the other hand, Ms. Maldonado and Mr. McAllister, who regularly work with STUDENT, and MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT can learn mobility patterns, has some ability to express his basic needs, can establish eye contact and work in a group, and has sufficient self-help skills, and, therefore, does not require custodial care.

Regarding whether STUDENT requires one-to-one supervision, Petitioner's witnesses admit that STUDENT will need some one-to-one assistance should he be placed at one of the Schools for the Deaf. As to the level of one-to-one assistance he will require, Petitioner's witnesses testified that STUDENT's independence and attentional skills have shown consistent improvement since Mr. McAllister began working with STUDENT in 1998. Additionally, Ms. Maldonado testified that STUDENT has become less reliant on Mr. McAllister, particularly to monitor his behavior. Mr. McAllister also testified that his role with STUDENT is changing. Whereas Mr. McAllister initially worked with STUDENT to improve his behavior, the present focus of his work is providing STUDENT with language and academic instruction. It should be noted that because STUDENT's teacher is not proficient signing, it has been necessary for Mr. McAllister to provide STUDENT's instruction.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's need for some one-to-one assistance from an aide, particularly as he learns the routine of the class and the residential component, does not rise to the level of his requiring custodial care. The Hearing Officer also does not find persuasive the argument by the Schools for the Deaf that STUDENT should be excluded from attending a School for the Deaf because he requires some one-to-one assistance. First, it is expected that would require some assistance to facilitate a change of placement. In this situation, the primary purpose of the assistance would be to help STUDENT learn the routines of the school and of the residential component. Second, the witnesses who know STUDENT best and who have worked with him in an educational environment reasonably predict that STUDENT will be more attentive and more involved in his educational program when the teacher and students sign. They also predict that STUDENT's need for one-to-one assistance will continue to decrease as his signing skills increase. Finally, the classes at the Schools for the Deaf are very small and have a more homogeneous population than the SDC-SH placements that STUDENT has attended. As Ms. Henkel testified, a School for the Deaf teacher should be able to provide a significant amount of attention to STUDENT and his needs given the small number of students in the class.

Therefore, based on the testimony of the witnesses who have direct experience with STUDENT and who observe him on a regular basis, the Hearing Officer concludes that, with reference to the criteria set forth in the CSD Manual, STUDENT demonstrates sufficient skills to fall within the group of deaf students who can be served by the CSD.

There is no dispute that the CSDR and the CSDF meet the following criteria for STUDENT's placement that were set forth in STUDENT I: signing peers, teachers proficient in ASL, opportunities for small-group and individual instruction, a low student-to-teacher ratio, a structured environment, specific instruction in ASL, and a structured behavioral program. The testimony of staff from the Schools for the Deaf must be analyzed to determine whether their classes have peers at or near STUDENT's developmental level and satisfy the requirements of an appropriate placement under the IDEA and Rowley.

Turning first to the CSDR, according to Penny Valentine, director of student support services at CSDR, and Michelle (Shelly) Rempe, principal of the special needs program, CSDR has a program for deaf students with additional disabling conditions. The CSDR has a dorm for the special needs students. Additional services, such as speech and language and counseling, are available. Ms. Rempe testified that there are 15 classes serving students from 6 to 22 years old. Typically, each class has four to five students, one teacher, and a half-time teaching assistant. The classes employ a functional curriculum. Ms. Rempe testified that academics are "infused in functional skills." For example, vocabulary concepts may be taught through cooking. Community-based instruction is also used. Ms. Rempe testified that there are opportunities for the students to mainstream with typically developing deaf students. According to Ms. Valentine, a student is not necessarily excluded because of behavior problems so long as the student is not a danger to himself or others, his behavior does not interfere with the learning of others, and there is not a pattern of aggressive behavior.

As to the make-up of the students in the special needs program, Ms. Rempe testified that there are approximately 13 students functioning at the four-year-old level who are between 7 and 11 years old. Ms. Rempe testified that one student had a one-to-one aide during the 1998-1999 school year. Some students are able to attend only five minutes. One to two students know fewer than 100 signs and one to two students know fewer than 50 signs. Some of the students entered a School for the Deaf with few signs. Ms. Rempe testified that she does not know STUDENT and could not determine whether CSDR offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

Keith Townsend described his class at CSDR. There are five students in the class. One of his students has residual hearing, so he uses ASL and voice. The reading skills of the students range from pre-primer (know some letters of the alphabet) to kindergarten level. In math, one student functions at the first-grade level, two count up to 40, and the others "struggle" to recognize and sign one to ten. Mr. Townsend testified that he provides an individualized program for each child in his class and adapts the curriculum to meet the child's needs. Additionally, instruction in functional skills, including shopping, safety in the community, simple cooking, and beginning vocational skills, comprises approximately 15% of the curriculum. Mr. Townsend's class is full.

Ms. Balthazor observed two classes at the CSDR on March 31, 1999. One class had five students who were 10 or 11 years old. The students were functioning from 18 months old to almost age level. During her observation, all students engaged in a writing activity at their own individual levels. For example, one student was tracing his first and last name and another student was copying sentences from a chart. The students then had a snack. During snack, each student was expected to ask for a snack, clean up after eating the snack, and line up to go outside. Ms. Balthazor observed that there was a wide range of materials. For example, there were manipulatives as well as flash cards for math, and picture books, as well as, story books for reading. According to Ms. Balthazor, when she described STUDENT to the teacher, the teacher said "STUDENT would fit in . . . too bad we do not have an opening." Ms. Balthazor concluded that CSDR offers an appropriate program for STUDENT; however, it is a long distance from his home.

The testimony of CSDR personnel establishes that a program can be implemented at a CSD that is designed to meet STUDENT's needs. The teachers are fluent in ASL. The classes consist of deaf or hard of hearing children of the appropriate age. STUDENT's current levels of functioning fall within the range of the students served by the CSDR. The small number of students in the class allows the teacher to provide individual and small-group instruction at each student's level. The teachers' testimony establishes that they modify the curriculum to address the needs of the individual students. The personnel at the CSDR have developed a curriculum that addresses development of functional skills, which would meet STUDENT's needs, including being safe in the community.

STUDENT's application for CSDR was returned because he does not reside in the area served by CSDR. CSDR serves students living south of San Luis Obispo. There are no statutory provisions prohibiting someone from northern California from attending the CSDR in southern California. However, Ms. Maldonado and Ms. Balthazor expressed concerns about placing STUDENT at CSDR because of the distance from his family. Weekly travel between home and the CSDR would be cumbersome and difficult for STUDENT. Additionally, Ms. Maldonado and Ms. Balthazor assert that it would be difficult to implement a transition plan because of the distance from Petaluma to Riverside. It is concluded that, in general, placement at the CSDR would meet the requirements of STUDENT I and offer STUDENT an appropriate placement consistent with the requirements of the IDEA and Rowley. However, because STUDENT resides in Northern California and the CSDR is some 400 or more miles away in Southern California, the CSDR is not appropriate for STUDENT because of its distance from STUDENT's home and his family.

Turning next to the CSDF, Celia May (C.M.) Baldwin, dean of students for students living at CSDF, described the CSDF campus and its residential program. Her testimony establishes that CSDF is located with the California School for the Blind and the Diagnostic Center on 98 unfenced acres in the city of Fremont, California. Approximately 300 residential students are housed in 67 cottages, with two of the cottages housing the special needs students. Each cottage can hold 22 students. One cottage houses special needs boys who are in middle school or senior high school. The other cottage houses the younger special needs boys as well as the special needs girls ranging from elementary to high school age.

Ms. Baldwin's testimony established the following regarding a "typical" day at CSDF. Each school day begins at 6:30 a.m. The students are expected to get up, independently get dressed, make their beds, and brush their teeth. They are supervised by two counselors. At 7:30 a.m., the counselors accompany the students to the cafeteria where they select and eat their breakfasts. After breakfast, the students are escorted to a play area. Following play time, the students line up by class groups and go to class. The students walk to the cafeteria for lunch and then to recess. They are supervised by three to four adults. After recess, the students return to class and, at 2:30 p.m., return to the cottages. To receive medication, students go independently to student health services, which is about a 10- to 12-minute walk. The students engage in after-school activities including training for special Olympics, cooking, group and team games, and stories. From 4:15 p.m. to 5:15 p.m., the students have study hour, which is followed by dinner in the cafeteria. After dinner, the students return to their cottages. They have unstructured activities until 7:00 p.m., when they shower. The nine-year-old students go to bed at 8:45 p.m. There is one night attendant per cottage.

Diane Muscadine teaches one of the classes at CSDF for special needs children. Her testimony establishes that she team-teaches with another teacher. Both teachers have five students in their respective class rooms, which are connected. Ms. Muscadine has an instructional assistant for two hours on two days per week. The students are 9 and 10 years old. Ms. Muscadine modifies the first- and second-grade curriculum from the Fremont Unified School District. Ms. Muscadine testified that she considers her class to be academic. The students are able to sit and attend, have eye contact, participate in group instruction, and use language to communicate. The students are able to answer simple questions, discuss a story in their own words, and communicate their basic wants, needs, and feelings. In math, the students are able to count from at least 15 to 100 and add to various levels. The students are reading at the first- to second-grade level. The students read the same story and then complete individualized work sheets. The lowest functioning student in the class has been at CSDF on assessment since last school year. This student is developmentally delayed and cannot read or count. The student signs approximately 10 words but does not functionally use sign language. Ms. Muscadine believes that this student is not benefitting from the instruction in her class and, therefore, is not appropriately placed at CSDF. Additionally, Ms. Muscadine testified that when a student cannot do the activities of the class, the student may become frustrated and engage in inappropriate behavior.

The other special needs teacher, Diane Caughrean, did not testify. The testimony of Ms. Muscadine and Mr. Stern establishes the following regarding Ms. Caughrean's class. The five students in the class are 11 and 12 years old and function at a higher level than the students in Ms. Muscadine's class. The students are reading between the first- and third-grade level. The student functioning at the highest level in math can do simple multiplication, can borrow and carry in addition and subtraction. The students in Ms. Caughrean's class appear to be functioning at a much higher level than STUDENT. For this reason, it would not be an appropriate class for him.

Ms. Muscadine's class would offer STUDENT a structured environment, signing peers and teachers, a low student-to-teacher ratio. Ms. Muscadine's students attend, have eye contact, participate in group instruction, and use language to communicate. The testimony discussed above establishes that

STUDENT also attends, has eye contact, participates in group instruction, and uses language to communicate. As to whether the students in Ms. Muscadine's class are at or near STUDENT's developmental level, the testimony establishes that the students in Ms. Muscadine's class are functioning higher in language arts than STUDENT. They are able to answer simple questions and discuss a story in their own words. Based on Mr. McAllister's testimony that STUDENT knows the letters of the alphabet, is learning vocabulary words, and is putting together up to three and four words, STUDENT currently would not be able to engage in the reading activity described by Ms. Muscadine. Based on Mr. McAllister's testimony, STUDENT would fall at the lower end of the functioning level of Ms. Muscadine's students in math. He knows numbers but is unable to add. Based on Ms. Muscadine's testimony, the one student she believes is not appropriately placed in her class functions at a lower rate than STUDENT. However, students are each unique and individual. The fact that one student is not benefitting from placement in Ms. Muscadine's class does not mean that STUDENT could not benefit from such a placement. Nothing in Ms. Baldwin's testimony regarding the residential program or the overall picture of the environment and schedule at the CSDF would preclude STUDENT's participation.

The CDE and the Schools for the Deaf have continued to maintain that STUDENT is not an appropriate candidate for the CSDF because the severity of his developmental disabilities would not allow him to benefit from the type of academic instruction that is provided at the Schools for the Deaf. As previously determined, STUDENT has not received an appropriate education for at least the last four school years. STUDENT did not receive language instruction when he entered the District and, for the most part, he has not had any opportunities to participate in an educational environment with signing peers. STUDENT's education has been delegated, for the past two school years, to an aide without formal education or a credential to teach deaf students. Moreover, because STUDENT's aide is deaf, his communication with STUDENT's teachers has been limited because STUDENT's teachers have not signed fluently. Thus, STUDENT has not had opportunities to develop the skills to the extent that he fully meets the criteria set forth in the "Admissions Policy" for the state special schools. Schools for the Deaf Exhibit a.

The placement STUDENT requires, as a deaf student with developmental disabilities, is consistent with state and federal guidelines for educating deaf children. The California Legislature has identified essential components of an educational program to appropriately address the educational needs of deaf and hard-of-hearing children. The following Legislative findings have been incorporated into the Education Code:

(1) Deafness involves the most basic of human needs--the ability to communicate with other human beings. . . .It is essential for the well-being and growth of hard-of-hearing and deaf children to have appropriate, ongoing, and fully accessible educational opportunities.

(2) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have an education in which their unique communication mode is respected, utilized, and developed to an appropriate level of proficiency.

(3) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children have an education in which special education teachers, psychologists, speech therapists, assessors, administrators, and other special education personnel understand the unique nature of deafness and are specifically trained to work with hard-of-hearing and deaf pupils. It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children have an education in which their special education teachers are proficient in the primary language mode of those children.

(4) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children, like all children, have an education with a sufficient number of language mode peers with whom they can communicate directly and who are of the same, or approximately the same, age and ability level.

(5) It is essential that hard-of-hearing and deaf children have an education in which their parents and, where appropriate, hard-of-hearing and deaf people are involved in determining the extent, content, and purpose of programs.

(6) Hard-of-hearing and deaf children would benefit from an education in which they are exposed to hard-of-hearing and deaf role models . . .

Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.5(a)

In identifying a placement for deaf children, federal law instructs the IEP team to:

consider the communication needs of the child, and in the case of a child who is deaf or hard of hearing, consider the child's language and communication needs, opportunities for direct communications with peers and professional personnel in the child's language and communication mode, academic level, and full range of needs, including opportunities for direct instruction in the child's language and communication mode . . .

20 U.S.C. 1414(d)(3)(B)(iv)

Despite these specific Legislative findings to guide the state in the education of its deaf children, the California Deaf and Hard-of-hearing Education Advisory Task Force (hereafter Task Force) concluded that the State's educational programs for deaf and hard-of-hearing children are "to a significant degree, ineffective" The report of the Task Force states that "the problem is not one of individual failure but, rather, of basic systemic inadequacies: school districts do not have an understanding of the unique communication needs of the deaf and hard-of-hearing children or the resources to meet those needs. To continue along this same path is to perpetuate the isolation of deaf and hard-of-hearing children and to accept unacceptable educational failure rates. To maintain the educational status quo is to set limits on deaf and hard-of-hearing children rather than to set them free to become healthy and productive citizens." (See Petitioner's Exhibit 179, pp. 19 and 21; Communication Access and Quality Education for Deaf and Hard-of-hearing Children (1999) )

The Task Force also found that, because deafness is a low incidence disability, the number of deaf children is limited in any particular local educational agency (LEA). Of approximately 550 LEAs with deaf and hard-of-hearing students in 1998, 406 of the LEAs had 10 or fewer deaf and hard-of- hearing students. Age distribution also reduces the possibility of similar age peers in many LEAs. The findings of the Task Force are substantiated by the findings in STUDENT I and in this case. It also should be noted that many of the state's deaf students are educated at one of the Schools for the Deaf, which decreases the opportunities for deaf students that remain in their LEAs to be educated with deaf peers. Additionally, because STUDENT has developmental disabilities, the probability of locating appropriate peers within his LEA is further minimized.

In its report released in 1999, the Task Force concluded that a regional system to educate deaf and hard-of-hearing students would bring together students within the region, thereby providing a "critical mass of language peers." The California Legislation also has made the finding that deaf and hard-of-hearing children would "benefit from the development and implementation of regional programs. . . ." Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.5(a)(10). The Task Force specifically called for the CDE to take steps to develop a coordinated, statewide, regional education delivery system for deaf and hard-of-hearing students, and to have such a program implemented within two years of the report. (Petitioner's Exhibit 179) There is no such regional program to serve STUDENT and there is no evidence that the CDE has taken steps to develop a regional program in the general geographical area in which STUDENT resides.

As stated earlier, both state and federal law afford students with disabilities the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The California Legislature has placed a specific burden on the CDE to educate deaf students. For example, the Education Code states that the continuum of program options that must be available within the state include state special schools for the deaf and for the blind. Cal. Educ. Code § 56361. Education Code §§ 59002 designate responsibility to the CDE and the Superintendent of Public Instruction to administer the Schools for the Deaf. The Superintendent of Public Instruction is specifically required to "maintain a comprehensive elementary educational program, including related services, for deaf individuals." Cal. Educ. Code § 59002(b).

The stated purpose of the Schools for the Deaf is the "education of deaf students who, because of their severe hearing loss and educational needs, cannot be provided an appropriate educational program and related services in the regular public schools." Cal. Educ. Code § 59001. STUDENT is a deaf elementary school student and there is no appropriate public school available to him in the general geographical area in which he resides. The posture of the CDE through the Schools for the Deaf that it has no obligation to serve STUDENT, or any other deaf children who have developmental disabilities, unless the developmental disabilities are mild, appears discriminatory and potentially invalid as underground regulations. Both state and federal law preclude exclusion of individuals with disabilities who, with reasonable modifications, including provision of auxiliary aids and services, meet essential eligibility requirements for participation in programs funded by the state. Cal. Gov. Code § 11135; 42 U.S.C.§§ 12131 -12132. Moreover, the CDE cannot escape its specific obligation to provide a free appropriate placement to deaf students by adopting admission policies for the Schools for the Deaf that discriminate against STUDENT and other deaf students who also have developmental disabilities. See e.g. Schools for the Deaf's Exhibit a; 20 U.S.C. 1412(a); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 59001 and 59002. Additionally, in STUDENT I, the CDE was ordered to participate in identifying an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The CDE failed to do so. The CDE also has not taken the leadership role called for by the Task Force to implement a regional program that could serve STUDENT.

While a regional school may be preferable for STUDENT, no such school exists and he should not be made to wait until one is created (if ever) when the CSDF has existing classes that can meet his needs with reasonable modifications. The parties have already endured two lengthy hearings while STUDENT remains without the placement to which he is entitled. The CSDF has the only placement offering STUDENT signing peers, a signing teacher, and the other components of an appropriate education for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer is left with no alternative and, therefore, is compelled to order the CSDF to accept STUDENT and to make appropriate modifications to meet his needs. At the same time, the District and the SCOE cannot escape their statutory obligations to STUDENT. Therefore, the District and SCOE must work in concert with the CSDF to provide STUDENT with the services and modifications he needs.

Placement in the CSDF, and Ms. Muscadine's class in particular, most closely approximates the requirements of the placement STUDENT requires to meet his needs. The class offers signing peers and a teacher proficient in ASL. With only five students, the class offers a low student-to-teacher ratio and opportunities for STUDENT to participate in individual and small group instruction. Petitioner's witnesses testified persuasively that, with some modifications, the curriculum in Ms. Muscadine's class can be appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Muscadine testified that she presently modifies the curriculum for reading and that the students do engage in individual work. Witnesses testified that, with assistance, STUDENT could continue to work on his vocabulary development during the period designated for reading.

ISSUE NO. 4: If not, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to create a classroom program that meets STUDENT's educational needs as described in the decision in STUDENT I?

It has been determined above that placement at the CSDF with reasonable modifications can meet STUDENT's needs. As discussed more fully below in Issue No. 5, STUDENT will require a transition plan and some modifications in place prior to his attending the CSDF. However, it is unnecessary to order that a separate classroom program be created for STUDENT.

ISSUE NO. 5: Pending creation of a program at the California School for the Deaf Fremont, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to accept STUDENT with appropriate modifications and accommodations to the classroom program?

It has been concluded above the CSDF shall enroll STUDENT. The CSDF, along with the District and the SCOE, also must make appropriate modifications to meet STUDENT's needs. The evidence establishes that STUDENT will require some modifications to the curriculum at the CSDF and the assistance of a one-to-one aide. The District and the SCOE have expertise in educating students with developmental disabilities. Thus, the District and the SCOE shall provide ongoing consultation to the CSDF by a teacher holding an SH credential. All of Petitioner's witnesses additionally agreed that STUDENT would require a structured transition plan to ensure that he has a successful move to the CSDF. MOTHER testified that STUDENT initially would require one-to-one assistance to help him learn the routines. Ms. Maldonado recommended a case manager to oversee STUDENT's transition to CSD. Ms. Maldonado proposed the following transition plan for STUDENT: have STUDENT visit the campus and dorms with his family and then return home; have Jarvis accompany him the next week; have Jarvis with STUDENT during the day for an extended period; and have someone with whom STUDENT is familiar ride the bus home with him. Actual transition plans need to be made in consultation with the CSD staff. Ms. Balthazor recommended a 30-day transition involving STUDENT and his parents. She suggested that Mr. McAllister and the parents repeatedly show STUDENT visual representations of what will occur as he is transitioning to the CSDF. For example, he should be shown pictures of his classroom and classmates at his CSD placement. Ms. Balthazor recommended that STUDENT's one-to-one aide assist him initially. She also suggested having STUDENT cross off the days on a calendar to help him gain an understanding of what time he will spend at school and when he would go home for the weekends. Ms. Henkel testified that SCOE has qualified staff that could help at least during a transition period. She noted that consultant services could also be obtained from a nonpublic school or nonpublic agency.

Based on the testimony, it is concluded that STUDENT requires a detailed transition plan that takes into consideration all of the findings made above. The IEP team is in the best position to make determinations as to the details and the period of time for a successful transition plan. The IEP team must include all of the required members, including District representatives and the parents, as well as his current classroom teacher, one-to-one assistant, and Ms. Maldonado. The IEP team must also include representatives from the CSDF, including the classroom teacher and the residential supervisor who will have responsibility for STUDENT. STUDENT also continues to be entitled to all of the services called for by his IEP that are provided by the District and the SCOE. The IEP team also shall determine modifications to the classroom at the CSDF that will address STUDENT's needs. The District and the SCOE shall provide a qualified SH teacher to assist with developing and implementing the modifications determined necessary by the IEP team. The District and the SCOE also shall provide STUDENT with services, including a one-to-one aide during the school day and in the cottages, as necessary. The IEP team shall determine the period for which STUDENT requires services.

ISSUE NO. 6: If STUDENT is placed at either California School for the Deaf, are Respondents Petaluma City School District and the Sonoma County Office of Education responsible for the costs of transportation and lodging so that STUDENT's family can visit him on weekends?

Students attending the CSD spend weekends at home. (Testimony of C. M. Baldwin.) Therefore, it is unnecessary for STUDENT's family to visit him on weekends. STUDENT lives within a reasonable bus ride of the CSDF. California Education Code § 59030.5 provides that the CSD shall provide for transportation to and from the student's home on weekends and holiday school periods.

ORDER

(1) Within 15 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting that includes the required participants, including the parents, and additionally, at a minimum, the classroom teacher and the residential supervisor who will be responsible for STUDENT at the CSDF, Ms. Maldonado, Mr. McAllister, STUDENT's current SDC-SH teacher, and administrators from the District, the SCOE, and the CSDF.

(2) The IEP team shall develop a transition plan that identifies the length of the period required to transition STUDENT from his present placement to the CSDF and the specific services he requires during the transition period. Those services may include participation by STUDENT's parents and his current one-to-one assistant at the CSDF when STUDENT initially is placed.

(3) The IEP team shall identify the specific services and modifications STUDENT requires to ensure that his needs are met at the CSDF in both the classroom and the residential components. Those services shall include the provision of all of the services presently identified on his IEP, including the one-to-one assistant and behavioral intervention services.

(4) STUDENT shall be placed at the CSDF as soon as practicable but no later than 50 days from the date of this decision and consistent with the transition plan developed by the IEP team.

(5) Pursuant to Education Code § 59030.5, the CSDF shall be responsible for STUDENT's transportation between his home and the CSDF on weekends and holidays.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

(1) Did Respondents offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(2) Is there an appropriate placement for STUDENT in any of the counties surrounding Sonoma County? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(3) With appropriate accommodations and modifications, does either the California School for the Deaf in Fremont or the California School for the Deaf in Riverside offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1900-2000 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(4) If not, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to create a classroom program that meets STUDENT's educational needs as described in the decision in STUDENT I? The Hearing Officer did not reach a decision on this issue.

(5) Pending creation of a program at the California School for the Deaf Fremont, should the California School for the Deaf Fremont be ordered to accept STUDENT with appropriate modifications and accommodations to the classroom program? Petitioner prevailed as to the need for the CSDF to accept STUDENT and to make reasonable modifications to its program and to develop, with the District and SCOE, a transition plan.

(6) If STUDENT is placed at either California School for the Deaf, are Respondents Petaluma City School District and the Sonoma County Office of Education responsible for the costs of transportation and lodging so that STUDENT's family can visit him on weekends? It was unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to reach a decision on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: March 3, 2000 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes * There are two for #3. 1. The CSDR was not a party to STUDENT I. 2. Petitioner disputes the accuracy of the estimates of his cognitive skills because of his "minimal exposure to any form of language prior to January 1997. . . ." (Petitioner's Closing Brief.) 3. The extent to which the BIP was implemented during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years was disputed. Second Footnote 3. Dr. Guthman testified that applications for CSDF are reviewed by a multidisciplinary team. If the team has concerns about whether the child is appropriate to admit to CSDF, the application is referred to the cabinet. The cabinet consists of multiple CSDF administrators including the director, assistant superintendent, business manager, director of personnel, director of outreach, and the dean of students. All students initially enter CSDF under a 50-day assessment process and are enrolled at CSDF upon a favorable review at the end of the assessment period. 4. Hidden Valley is a program in Santa Rosa that serves deaf students. It does not offer classes for students who are developmentally delayed. In STUDENT I, it was concluded that STUDENT's previous placement at Hidden Valley was not appropriate and Hidden Valley was not proposed as a placement for STUDENT in this hearing.