California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 21, 2001
Student v. Cabrillo Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1073-00 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Cabrillo Unified must reimburse $16,173 for private school and speech therapy after making an incomplete, contingent IEP offer.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions earlier related matters: a July 1999 mediation-only case filed by the District (interim agreement reached, case closed March 2000) and a September 1999 CDE compliance complaint that found no violation (reconsideration denied January 2000).
Summary
The parents of an 8-year-old boy with a severe speech and language disorder filed for due process against Cabrillo Unified School District. In kindergarten he split his day between a special day class and a regular class. For first grade (1999-2000), the district's May and June 1999 IEPs recommended a class for children with severe disorders of language (SDL). The district then proposed a San Mateo County Office of Education SDL class in Foster City. The parents rejected it and enrolled him at Stanbridge Academy, a private school for students with learning disabilities, and paid for private speech therapy.
The Hearing Officer found the district denied him a free appropriate public education. The IEPs listed no start date, no duration and no speech therapy. The placement also depended on a later County intake review. As a result, the parents never received a firm written offer, as Union School District v. Smith requires. The district also never arranged for the father to observe the class. On substance, once lunch and recess were excluded, the County class had a shorter instructional day than same-age peers, and his IEP did not justify that. The class also gave no speech therapy to students without articulation goals. The Hearing Officer found the teacher properly credentialed and rejected the parents' concerns about classmates' behavior. Stanbridge plus private therapy met his needs, and he made progress. The district had to reimburse $14,698.21 for tuition, books and uniforms, $1,475 for speech therapy, and daily mileage. The request for field-trip costs was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a "referral" IEP that left the placement to a later county review and did not list related services. The Hearing Officer treated that as a contingent offer that violated Union v. Smith. The decision also shows lunch and recess being left out of instructional time when the IEP had no goals tied to those periods.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1a. Did the District provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year? — Compliance with procedural safeguards (father's request to observe the proposed class; IEPs lacking start date, duration, and extent of regular education participation; lack of a final, firm written offer of placement and services under Union School Dist. v. Smith)
The May and June 1999 IEPs omitted required elements and speech therapy, and the offer was contingent on County intake review, so there was no firm written offer; this seriously infringed parent participation and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b. Did the District provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year? — Substantive appropriateness of the proposed County severe disorders of language (SDL) class (shorter instructional day than chronological peers; no speech and language therapy)
Excluding lunch and recess, the County SDL class gave less instructional time than same-age peers without IEP justification and provided no speech therapy for this student, so the program did not meet his unique needs; teacher credential and classmate-behavior concerns were rejected.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE, is he entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Stanbridge Academy during the 1999-2000 school year?
Stanbridge Academy plus parent-funded speech therapy was appropriate and the student made progress; parents gave notice and did not act unreasonably, so tuition, related costs, speech therapy and mileage are reimbursed (field trip costs denied).
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, reimburse tuition and related expenses (books and required uniforms) at Stanbridge Academy for 1999-2000: $14,698.21.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, reimburse costs of speech therapy from Ms. Buchwald during 1999-2000: $1,475.00.
- Reimbursement. Petitioner to submit proof of actual attendance days within 20 days; within 25 days of receipt, District reimburses transportation mileage of 30.6 miles per day actually attended (September 1999–June 2000) at the District's employee reimbursement rate.
Total: $16,173.21 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; Doe v. Maher; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ.; Warren G. v. Cumberland County School Dist.; In re Lifschutz; Letter to Lewis (OSERS 1986); Burger v. Murray County School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Allan Kass, assistant superintendent, Cabrillo Unified School District
- Suzanne Michelony, principal, Hatch Elementary School
- Misty Belmonte, regular education kindergarten teacher, Hatch Elementary School
- Gina Barlogio, special education kindergarten (SDC) teacher, Cabrillo Unified School District
- Dale Jacknow, M.D., developmental and behavioral pediatrician; witness for both parties, Private
- Caro Garabedian, program manager, San Mateo County SELPA
- Wendy Ames, program coordinator; private school assessor, Stanbridge Academy
- Valerie Flatt, senior credential analyst, San Mateo County Office of Education
- Emilia Tzetzos Turta (Tzetzos), former school psychologist, Cabrillo Unified School District
- Christine Atkinson, SDL special day class teacher, San Mateo County Office of Education (Brewer Island Elementary School)
- Erica Dunning, former speech and language pathologist, Cabrillo Unified School District
- Janet (Jan) Buchwald, private speech and language pathologist, Private, parent-funded
- Richard Bowen, headmaster, Stanbridge Academy
- Kathryn Varda, lower elementary language arts teacher, Stanbridge Academy
- Edith Schlesinger, lower elementary mathematics teacher, Stanbridge Academy
- Marian Clark, computer instruction teacher, Stanbridge Academy
- Stanbridge Academy, private school (unilateral placement)
- Los Listos Preschool, language-based preschool
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Half Moon Bay, California, on July 18, 19, October 3, 4, and 5, 2000.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner) was present on the second day of hearing. Petitioner was represented by attorney Patricia Roma on July 18 and 19, 2000, and by his mother, MOTHER, on October 3, 4, and 5, 2000. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf for part of October 3 and 4, 2000, was his father, FATHER. Respondent Cabrillo Unified School District (hereinafter District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Martha Buell Scott. Also present on the District’s behalf was Allan Kass, District assistant superintendent. Petitioner requested an open hearing, and a member of the public observed the hearing for part of the day on October 3, 2000.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother; Suzanne Michelony, principal, Hatch Elementary School (Hatch); Misty Belmonte, Hatch regular education kindergarten teacher; Dale Jacknow, M.D., developmental and behavioral pediatrician; Allan Kass, District assistant superintendent; Caro Garabedian, program manager, San Mateo County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA); Wendy Ames, program coordinator, Stanbridge Academy; Valerie Flatt, senior credential analyst, San Mateo County Office of Education (SMCOE); Emilia Tzetzos Turta (Tzetzos), former District school psychologist; and Christine Atkinson, SMCOE severe disorders of language (SDL) class teacher. Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: Misty Belmonte, Hatch kindergarten teacher; Dale Jacknow, M.D., developmental and behavioral pediatrician; Allan Kass, District assistant superintendent; Caro Garabedian, program manager, San Mateo County SELPA; Valerie Flatt, SMCOE senior credential analyst; Emilia Tzetzos, former District school psychologist; Erica Dunning, former District speech and language pathologist; and Christine Atkinson, SMCOE SDL class teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit closing briefs and reply briefs. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Motion to Dismiss
Following the conclusion of the testimony by Petitioner’s witnesses, Ms. Scott, attorney for the District, moved to dismiss the case on the ground that Petitioner had failed to meet his burden of producing sufficient evidence to show that the District had not offered him a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Ms. Scott asserted that according to the parent, the only obstacle to Petitioner’s enrollment in the County severe disorders of language (SDL) class offered by the District was the credential of the teacher. Ms. Scott argued, however, that the teacher of the proffered class was credentialed and that ample evidence existed of the teacher’s credential, including the teacher’s testimony. The mother opposed dismissal, arguing that Petitioner had shown that the District had not offered him a FAPE. First, the mother asserted that the District’s failure to respond to the parents’ reasonable questions regarding the type of credential held by the teacher of the County SDL class resulted in the denial of a FAPE. The mother further argued that a FAPE was denied because the hours of the County class at Brewer Elementary School (Brewer) were one hour short of the number of hours Petitioner’s chronological peers received at Brewer and at Hatch Elementary School, his home school. The mother also asserted that the change in placement on the May 18, 1999 individualized education program (IEP) did not have a proposed start date.
The Hearing Officer denied the motion to dismiss on the ground that once the parent claimed the denial of a FAPE, the District bore the burden of showing at the due process hearing that it offered a FAPE which met all the requirements of the law. See Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist., No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).(Footnote 1) The Hearing Officer also noted that in addition to the issue of the teacher’s credential, the parent had raised procedural issues, and questions of fact existed that required resolution through a full evidentiary hearing. For these reasons, the District’s motion to dismiss was denied.
Motion to Exclude Evidence
At the reconvened hearing on October 3, 2000, Petitioner’s mother objected to admission of the District’s proposed exhibits 146 and 147 on several grounds, including privilege. The two exhibits were letters from the mother to Petitioner’s developmental and behavioral pediatrician, Dale Jacknow, M.D., related to his educational placement and due process hearing case. The Hearing Officer deferred a ruling and requested that the parties submit written arguments related to the matter. On October 10, 2000, the mother submitted a motion to exclude the two exhibits on grounds that the documents were protected by the physician-patient privilege and that the subpoena duces tecum (SDT) for Dr. Jacknow’s records was procedurally defective in not meeting the requirements of California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1985.3. On October 16, 2000, the District submitted an opposition. The District argued in relevant part that the two proposed exhibits fell within the patient-litigant exception to the physician-patient privilege and that Section 1985.3 did not apply to an SDT issued in a special education hearing.
On December 6, 2000, the Hearing Officer issued an order denying the motion to exclude the evidence. The Hearing Officer stated that the two letters to Dr. Jacknow, which discussed educational placements to address Petitioner’s needs stemming from his speech and language disorder, were communications related to the impairment that was the subject of the due process hearing and thus fell within the patient-litigant exception to the physician-patient privilege. See In re Lifschutz, 2 Cal.3d 415, 433-35, 467 P.2d 557 (1970). Moreover, the Hearing Officer found that although Section 1985.3 does not apply to SDTs issued in special education hearings, the record in this case revealed that the parents received adequate notice of the District’s requests for an SDT to be issued to Dr. Jacknow and also the scope of the SDT.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
1. Did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?(Footnote 3)
2. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE, is he entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Stanbridge Academy during the 1999-2000 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT (Petitioner) is an 8-year-old boy who is eligible for special education as having a speech and language delay. He has been diagnosed with a severe developmental speech and language disorder, with significant delays in receptive and expressive language skills and auditory memory. He attended a language-based preschool for 1-1/2 years and a collaborative combination of a morning special day class and an afternoon regular education class during his kindergarten year. He was held back in preschool for one year and started kindergarten at age 6. He has attended Stanbridge Academy, a private school for children with learning disabilities, since the 1999-2000 school year, when he was in grade 1. He has received individual speech and language therapy. Occupational therapy has been recommended to address a visuospatial processing deficit.
STUDENT was referred for a special education assessment in January 1997, when he was 4-1/2 years old. Following a speech and language evaluation, an individualized education program (IEP) team found him eligible for special education as having a speech and language delay. The IEP recommends a language-based preschool, Los Listos Preschool (Los Listos), with speech and language therapy within the preschool setting. He started attending Los Listos in the morning. A June 1997 IEP recommends for the next year the language-based preschool, with speech and language therapy 90 minutes weekly within the preschool setting.
In a December 11, 1997 report, Dale Jacknow, M.D., developmental and behavioral pediatrician, sets forth the results of an assessment when STUDENT was age 5. She administered the Differential Abilities Scale (DAS) and the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration. Dr. Jacknow concluded that STUDENT had severe language delays which adversely affected his test performance in all areas. She recommended a special education class for children with severe disorders of language (SDL) for the following year, including a highly structured setting with small group instruction whenever possible. According to Dr. Jacknow, STUDENT’s language deficits contributed to his behavior problems in that he did not understand, and could not express himself, at an age-appropriate level. She stated that when STUDENT is uncooperative, his parents should ascertain whether he understands, and if he does not understand, they should rephrase what he is being asked to do.
In April 1998, District school psychologist Emilia Tzetzos conducted a psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT when he was age 5 years, 11 months, and set forth the results in a May 25, 1998 report. STUDENT’s general cognitive score on the McCarthy Scales of Children’s Abilities placed him in the significantly below average range of ability. On the Motor Free Visual Perception Test, he obtained a composite score in the below average range, and he exhibited signs of visual perceptual and processing delays. On the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills, his overall score placed him in the below average range and indicated auditory processing delays. STUDENT’s parent and teacher rated his development in the physical, self-help, social, academic, and communication areas on the Developmental Profile II. The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales was completed by the mother, and the Social Skills Rating System was completed by STUDENT’s mother and teacher. On the Burk’s Behavior Rating Scales, completed by the mother, STUDENT obtained significant ratings in the areas of excessive withdrawal, poor intellectuality, poor attention, and poor impulse control. His scores on the Child Behavior Checklist fell within the average range, except for Thought Problems and Attention Problems. Ms. Tzetzos observed STUDENT at school during both structured lessons and free play time and noted that he tended to play parallel to peers and had difficulty responding when his peers tried to engage him in play.
Ms. Tzetzos concluded that STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education based upon communication delays and required related services in speech and language development. He also demonstrated academic and cognitive delays indicating some learning concerns. His goal areas were social, academic, and speech and language skills. Ms. Tzetzos recommended a County program for children with severe language delays, which would permit services to be provided in class from a speech and language pathologist and provide for assistance with language development throughout the day.
In an April 22, 1998 follow-up report, Dr. Jacknow stated that STUDENT had a developmental speech and language disorder. She had reviewed a videotape of STUDENT at school and noted that he had difficulty attending in a group setting but showed an improved ability to focus when working one-on-one with the teacher. Besides an SDL kindergarten class, a highly structured setting, and small group instruction, she recommended twice weekly individual speech and language therapy. She emphasized that when he did not cooperate, his parents and teacher should ascertain whether he understood, and if he did not, they should rephrase what was being asked of him.
A May 1, 1998 IEP when STUDENT was age 5 years, 10 months, states that he was eligible for special education as communicatively handicapped. The IEP contains the recent psycho-educational assessment results. The IEP also sets forth STUDENT’s present level of performance in the communication area based upon the May 1998 assessment by the speech and language pathologist. STUDENT’s Preschool Language Scale-3 scores showed a general decline from the previous year. He was given the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised. However, the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised was not scored because the speech pathologist thought that it was not an accurate reflection of STUDENT’s ability because he did not point to a picture of an object, as directed. The language concerns were compounded by staring episodes when he required a verbal cue to draw him back and poor social interpersonal skills. The speech pathologist recommended that in the fall STUDENT attend a language-based kindergarten class where language skills were infused into all activities.
The IEP team recommended a County language-based kindergarten program and planned to visit County programs to determine an appropriate placement. A May 22, 1998 IEP addendum states that the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be referred to the County for consideration of placement in an SDL special day class in the fall. In addition, he was to receive speech and language services.
Correspondence between the parent and Allan Kass, District assistant superintendent, during July and August 1998 reveal that the parent visited a County class and decided that it was not appropriate. A September 2, 1998 IEP placed STUDENT in a regular education kindergarten classroom at Hatch with special education assistance and speech and language support through a collaborative model. A December 9, 1998 IEP states that STUDENT was mainstreamed in the regular education kindergarten program with consultative and collaborative language development.
On April 26, 1999, Gina Barlogio, STUDENT’s special education kindergarten teacher, administered the Woodcock Johnson-Revised (WJ-R) when STUDENT was age 6 years, 10 months. At the time, he was in Misty Belmonte’s regular education kindergarten class in the afternoon but spent the morning in Ms. Barlogio’s special day class (SDC). In the SDC, STUDENT received instruction in intensive language work, adapted physical education, and math. STUDENT’s WJ-R scores (with the norms based on grade ) were as follows: Broad Reading, 102 standard score, at the 55 percentile and 6 years, 0 months age equivalence; Broad Math, 69 standard score, at the 2 percentile and 4 years, 7 months age equivalence; and Broad Written Language, 106 standard score, at the 65 percentile and 6 years, 2 months age equivalence. Ms. Barlogio stated that STUDENT did well on the WJ-R and was where most kindergartners are. He knew his letters, sounds, shapes, and colors and could count and sort. He did well in writing because the directions were straightforward. However, although he could count and do the math, he struggled with the applied problems because he had difficulty understanding and then applying what was said. In class, Ms. Barlogio had observed that STUDENT had great difficulty comprehending what the class was discussing and in response to questions said that he did not know or gave an answer that did not make sense. He also was unable to carry on a normal conversation. Ms. Barlogio recommended that STUDENT spend more than 50 percent of the day in an SDC where he could work on language, socialization, and communication.
The May 17, 1999 academic development report of STUDENT’s regular education teacher, Ms. Belmonte, states that his language development was one of the greatest areas of concern. His vocabulary was very limited and he often had difficulty finding the right words to express himself. His syntax and semantics were confused and limited. He was receiving speech and language services in the SDC three days a week and language-based small-group instruction four days a week in the regular education class. His growth during the school year had been less than expected. In language arts, he knew all the letters and most of the sounds but was unable to come up with the words to identify objects, indicating a limited vocabulary. As for social development, STUDENT had made good friends during the year but had difficulty maintaining focused attention, was easily distracted, and sometimes looked very withdrawn. He had difficulty following instructions and frequently did not know what was expected. According to Ms. Belmonte, math was an area of strength. He could identify basic colors and shapes and identify and write numerals to 30 but had difficulty counting to 30. In the area of physical development, STUDENT was coordinated and active. As for fine motor skills, he used the scissors effectively and could reproduce letters, numbers, and shapes with crayons and pencils. He had some letter reversals in writing but nothing of concern. Ms. Belmonte stated that STUDENT had an interest in the world around him in history/social studies and in science themes explored by the class.
A May 18, 1999 IEP contains the results of an assessment by District speech and language pathologist Erica Dunning, M.S., C.C.C. According to Ms. Dunning, STUDENT had difficulty following the directions for conventional assessments. He was cooperative but fatigued easily. The Boehm Test of Basic Concepts was discontinued because of a lack of conformity to standard testing procedures. She administered the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test, CRIL Syntax test, and the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Revised (CELF-R) (including the Word Structure and Sentence Structure portions). Ms. Dunning summarized that STUDENT had abilities in the academic areas of prereading and letter identification. However, in the language areas, semantics (vocabulary) and syntax (order of words) were significantly delayed, and morphological (usage) understanding was also impaired. She recommended a highly structured environment which started at his language level and moved through a hierarchy using structured models and scripted responses. Although he was somewhat resistant to corrections and modeling and wanted to be independent, a clear structured model could provide the indirect language stimulation he required. She also recommended pullout speech therapy twice weekly and collaborative services within the SDC or SDL class.
The May 18 IEP, signed by the parent, states that STUDENT was eligible for special education as being speech and language impaired. The IEP states that a regular education program was insufficient to support STUDENT and recommends an SDL special day class as the appropriate and least restrictive environment. The placement and services were to be determined at the next IEP meeting (to be reconvened by June 17). The IEP indicates that STUDENT was to receive extended school year (ESY) services. The IEP contains goals and objectives to improve expressive and receptive language skills, to focus and attend to tasks, and to improve socialization skills. On June 2, 1999, STUDENT’s mother visited the proposed County SDL class at Brewer Island Elementary School (Brewer) in Foster City, along with the District school psychologist Ms. Tzetzos and the District speech and language pathologist Ms. Dunning.
In a June 7, 1999 report, Dr. Jacknow presented the results of a follow-up assessment when STUDENT was almost age 7. At the time, he was attending a regular kindergarten class in the morning and a noncategorical SDC in the afternoon to address his needs stemming from his developmental speech and language disorder. Although he had made gains, he still exhibited significant speech and language deficits. According to Dr. Jacknow, the special education assessment team had recommended a fall 1999 placement in an SDL class. However, the parents had been informed that the District had no SDL class. Dr. Jacknow administered selected subtests on the NEPSY, a developmental neuropsychological test, to assess attention/executive processing, language processing, visual- spatial processing, and memory. The results indicated that STUDENT had borderline attentional abilities for visual information. The auditory attention subtest could not be administered because he was unable to understand the directions. The results indicated that STUDENT’s language processing abilities were significantly below average. Although he had an average ability to hear sounds within words, he had significantly below average word retrieval abilities (expressive language processing) and comprehension abilities (receptive language processing). He also exhibited significant difficulties with visuospatial processing and auditory memory skills.
Dr. Jacknow stated that STUDENT was cooperative and rapport was readily established but that his severe language processing delays made it extremely difficult for him to understand the directions during many of the subtests. She summarized that STUDENT had a severe developmental speech and language disorder, with significant delays in receptive and expressive language skills and auditory memory. His visuospatial processing difficulties indicated problems in the nonverbal area as well. Dr. Jacknow concluded that STUDENT’s severe language delays adversely affected his ability to learn and that he needed comprehensive support to address his delays.
Dr. Jacknow recommended a first grade SDL class. If such a District or County class was unavailable, she recommended Stanbridge Academy. She also recommended individual speech and language therapy twice weekly. She recommended a classroom setting with a high degree of structure, a student-teacher ratio of 5 or 6 to 1, and small group instruction whenever possible. She recommended that the language instruction incorporate computer-assisted learning for a multi-sensory approach. She stated again that when STUDENT was not cooperating, his parents and teachers should assess whether he understood, and if he did not, they should rephrase what they asked of him. She recommended that STUDENT have occupational therapy weekly to address his visuospatial processing deficits.
A June 16, 1999 IEP reiterates the May 18, 1999 IEP’s recommended placement of an SDL class and ESY services. The June 16 IEP states that the IEP team discussed the referral to a language-based class. The District staff reviewed their observations of the proposed County class, and the mother raised concerns about behavioral problems in the class. The IEP states that the IEP team was to explore all public school options and reconvene prior to the beginning of the school year to discuss the specific school placement.
After the June 16 IEP meeting, correspondence between the mother and assistant superintendent Mr. Kass discussed placement options for STUDENT, including classes available through the County, San Mateo SELPA, and Stanbridge Academy.(Footnote 4) In August 2 and 4, 1999 letters to Mr. Kass, the mother raised a question related to whether the teacher of the County SDL class had the proper teaching credential. According to the mother, during the June 1999 visit to the County class at Brewer, the teacher was asked if she was certified in speech and language and she allegedly said that she had “training in language.” In response to the mother’s inquiry, senior credential analyst Valerie Flatt of the San Mateo County Office of Education informed her that Christine Atkinson, the County SDL class teacher, had the requisite communication handicapped (CH) teaching credential. Ms. Flatt noted that the records of the State Commission on Teacher Credentialing were incomplete but that the Commission was to update Ms. Atkinson’s records from the microfilm of her original CH credential. Ms. Flatt also indicated that her office had an official copy of the CH credential. In early August 1999, Mr. Kass visited Stanbridge and met with Richard Bowen, the headmaster. In an August 16, 1999 letter, Mr. Kass informed the parents that the District offered STUDENT a placement at the County class at Brewer.
On August 19, 1999, the parents informed the District in writing that they rejected the District’s proffered placement of the County SDL class at Brewer. They stated that they were going to remove STUDENT from the District effective September 2, 1999, place him in a private school, and seek reimbursement at public expense. STUDENT started attending Stanbridge Academy in September 1999.(Footnote 5)
In May 2000, Mr. Kass wrote to the parents informing them that if they wished to discuss STUDENT’s current special education status or to hold an IEP meeting, they should contact him. On June 14, 2000, the Hearing Office received a due process hearing request from STUDENT’s parents. They asserted that the District had failed to provide a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year and requested reimbursement for private school tuition and other costs. They claimed that they had been denied participation in the planning of their son’s education.
A June 22, 2000 academic evaluation report by Wendy Ames, program coordinator at Stanbridge, sets forth STUDENT’s June 19 and 20, 2000 test results when he was age 8 years, 0 months. At the time, he had been enrolled in the lower elementary division at Stanbridge since September 1999. Ms. Ames administered the WJ-R, which the District had administered in April 1999. Ms. Ames stated that she was unable to give STUDENT all of the subtests primarily because of his language processing difficulties but also due to a lack of skills. He often needed to have questions repeated or rephrased. His retrieval of information or the correct word was often slow, and he needed extra time. Many of the items in the Applied Problems subtest required much language processing. The physical act of writing is a slow process for STUDENT, and he showed signs of fatigue when completing the Writing Sample and Dictation subtests.
Ms. Ames presented the WJ-R scores based on age equivalent norms. The June 2000 WJ-R results are as follows (with the April 1999 scores in parentheses): Broad Reading, 81 (80) standard score, at the 10 (9) percentile and 6 years, 10 months (6 years, 0 months) age equivalence; Broad Mathematics, 72 (49) standard score, at the 3 (0.1) percentile and 6 years, 6 months (4 years, 7 months) age equivalence; and Broad Written Language, 73 (88) standard score, at the 3 (21) percentile and 6 years, 7 months (6 years, 2 months) age equivalence.(Footnote 6) Ms. Ames stated that in addition to academic progress, STUDENT’s self-esteem increased, and he was able more consistently to be a member of a group.
STUDENT’s Stanbridge Progress Report for the 1999-2000 school year reveals that in his language arts class, he received ratings of 1 (needs improvement) for the first and second semesters in all of the oral language skills (listening comprehension, speaking skills, concept development, and vocabulary). Among the reading skills, he similarly received 1 ratings for both semesters in vocabulary and reading comprehension. In other reading skills, he received the following ratings for the first and second semesters, respectively: decoding skills, decoding application, and sight words, 1-2, 3; letter recognition and sequencing the alphabet, 2-3, 4; and sound/symbol recognition, 3, 4.(Footnote 7) In fine motor skills (including cutting, coloring, pencil grasp, and handwriting), he received 3 ratings for both semesters.
In mathematical operations, STUDENT received 3 ratings for both semesters in numeration (number recognition, counting, and writing numbers). In other operations areas, he received these ratings for the first and second semesters, respectively: addition and subtraction, 2, 3; and shapes, 2, 2. In mathematical applications, he received 2 ratings for both semesters in mental computation, numerical reasoning, word problems, and missing element. In the applications areas of classification, pattern awareness, and sequencing, he received 2 and 3 ratings for the first and second semesters, respectively. In the combined social studies, science, and art class, for both semesters he received 1 ratings for reading application and written expression; 1-2 ratings for oral presentation; 2 ratings for concept development, participation, listening skills, retention, and generalization; and 3 ratings for artistic expression and cooperative group work. In all three of his classes, he had a 3 rating for effort by the second semester.
On July 7, 2000, licensed speech and language pathologist Janet Buchwald, M.A., C.C.C., who worked with STUDENT, with parental funding, during the 1999-2000 school year, prepared a speech and language progress note. Ms. Buchwald stated that she had reviewed STUDENT’s May 18, 1999 IEP and had worked on the speech and language goals and objectives in small group therapy. She set forth STUDENT’s percentage scores on the five objectives in May 2000 (in comparison with his May 1999 baseline percentage scores). Ms. Buchwald indicated that STUDENT’s progress on the first objective (label and identify common nouns and verbs) was affected by his word-retrieval difficulty. She concluded that he had met the goals and objectives in his IEP and was ready to address broader language goals for the coming school year, including basic concepts, asking questions, following auditory directions, and pragmatic skills. She stated that his placement at Stanbridge was appropriate for his academic, social, and language needs.
A September 19, 2000 report by Dr. Jacknow sets forth the follow-up neuro-developmental assessment results when STUDENT was 8 years old. On the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence-2, STUDENT obtained a score within the average range. On the Differential Ability Scales, he achieved a Verbal Skills Cluster score in the significantly below average range; a Nonverbal Reasoning Skills Cluster score in the average range; and a Spatial Skills Cluster score in the borderline range. On the Preschool Language Scale-3, he obtained Auditory Comprehension (receptive language skills) and Expressive Communication (expressive language skills) subscale age equivalence scores of 4 years, 8 months, and 4 years, 2 months, respectively, both in the significantly delayed range. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III, which assesses receptive vocabulary, STUDENT scored in the borderline range. On the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test-R, which measures expressive vocabulary, STUDENT obtained a score in the significantly below average range. Although STUDENT was cooperative and worked hard, his severe language processing delays made it extremely difficult for him to understand what was being asked of him during many of the subtests.
Dr. Jacknow summarized that STUDENT had a severe speech and language disorder, with significant delays in receptive and expressive language skills. His cognitive functioning was in the normal range of intelligence with regard to nonverbal reasoning ability. However, he functioned in the below average range of intelligence in verbal skills and in the borderline range in visuospatial processing. Because his severe verbal deficits adversely affected his ability to learn in all areas, he needed continued comprehensive support. In addition to recommendations previously made, Dr. Jacknow recommended that STUDENT continue to attend Stanbridge because he had made good academic gains during the past school year. He also should continue individual speech and language therapy three times per week. She also recommended that STUDENT have weekly OT to address his visuospatial processing deficits.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA provides such a student with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit.” Id. at 200-01. The Court stated that the specialized educational services furnished need not maximize each child’s potential. Id. at 198-99.
In addition, the IDEA requires that the states and local educational agencies guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b).
In Rowley, the Supreme Court noted the importance of these procedural safeguards. The Court stated: “It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” 458 U.S. at 205-06. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: (1) has the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA? and (2) has the District offered an appropriate educational program? Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07.
Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds.
a. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
Petitioner argues, in essence, that his father was precluded from participating meaningfully in the IEP process because the District failed to arrange for him to visit the proposed County class, as the parent requested. Although the mother had visited the class with District staff, since she had concerns about behavioral problems in the class and questions about the appropriateness of the class for STUDENT, a request for the father to observe the class was reasonable. The District has failed to provide a reason for not responding to the request. Depriving the father of a visit to assist the parents in making an informed decision about the appropriateness of the class precluded his meaningful participation in the IEP process.
Petitioner also argues that he was denied a FAPE because neither the May 18, 1999 nor the June 16, 1999 IEP contains the projected starting date for services, the anticipated duration, and the extent to which he would participate in regular education. Under federal and State law, the IEP must include, among other things, a statement of the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided to the child and the projected starting date, anticipated frequency, location, and duration of these services. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii), (vi); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3), (6). The omissions in the May 18 and June 16 IEPs violate this requirement.
Even more significant, however, is whether the District complied with the requirements of Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994). The IDEA requires that the educational agency give written prior notice to the parents when it proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3), (c). In Union School Dist. v. Smith, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated that this requirement of a formal, written offer “should be enforced rigorously.” The court noted that a formal offer serves several purposes: it would alert the parents of the need to consider seriously the appropriateness of the placement, it would permit the parents to decide whether to oppose the offer or accept it with supplemental services, and in a due process hearing, the District would be better prepared to introduce relevant evidence of the appropriateness of its proffered placement. Id.
Here, the May 18, 1999 and June 16, 1999 IEPs set forth the District’s proposed educational program for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year. As discussed below, these IEPs say nothing about speech and language therapy, which the Hearing Officer determined was one of STUDENT’s unique needs.
Assistant superintendent Mr. Kass testified that the May 18, 1999 and June 16, 1999 IEPs were “referral” IEPs, not “placement” IEPs. According to him, if the parent had consented to a County referral, after obtaining and reviewing the necessary information, the County would have developed a current IEP for placement.(Footnote 8) Although the District appears to argue that the parents’ failure to consent to a County referral precluded the formulation of a final, or “placement,” IEP, this argument is undercut by the May 1, 1998 IEP, supplemented by a May 22, 1998 addendum, for the previous school year. The May 1 IEP recommends a County language-based kindergarten program and states that the IEP team would visit County programs to determine an appropriate placement and reconvene within 2 to 3 weeks. The May 22 IEP sets forth proposed goals and objectives and states that the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be referred to the County for consideration of placement in an SDL class in fall 1998. The IEP indicates that his recommended educational program was an SDC and speech and language related services but no extended school year services. The IEP indicates that he would receive regular education physical education and states that he required multi-media and small-group instruction. Thus, in May 1998 of the previous school year, the IEP team recommended a County referral but formulated an IEP that contained not only proposed goals and objectives but also recommended a program that included an SDL special day class and speech and language related services.(Footnote 9) According to Mr. Kass’ testimony, the IEP formulated by the District would be sent to the County as part of the referral to a County program. Thus, an IEP setting forth the entirety of the District’s proposed educational program for STUDENT, including related services, would assist the County staff in determining whether the referral was appropriate. Because the May 1998 IEP and addendum included all aspects of the District’s proposed program, including related services, the Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the District’s argument that an IEP setting forth the entire program the District proposed for STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year could not be formulated because of the parents’ failure to consent to the County referral.
Based on the evidence, it appears that for the 1999-2000 school year, there was not a final IEP which gave the parents notice of the District’s offer of a placement and related services. This was a violation of the requirements of Union School Dist. v. Smith. Moreover, the parents had questions about the proposed County SDL class placement, including the qualifications of the teacher. The teacher, Ms. Atkinson, testified that she attempted to make clear to inquiring parents that although she has training in language, she is not a speech pathologist. This thus appears to be an area of confusion for the parents of prospective students in her class. If the District’s IEP for the 1999-2000 school year had stated that STUDENT would receive speech and language therapy in addition to placement in an SDL class, the parents may have been reassured that he would receive the specific assistance he required from a trained speech and language specialist.
The District argues that because of the mother’s preoccupation with obtaining reimbursement for private school tuition at public expense, she ignored the information provided by the District, SELPA, and County that the County SDL class teacher had the proper communicatively handicapped (CH) credential.(Footnote 10) However, the fact is that, based upon the testimony of assistant superintendent Mr. Kass, the May 1999 and June 1999 IEPs did not provide notice of a final offer of a placement and related services. In an August 16, 1999 letter, Mr. Kass notified the parents that “[a]t this point in time,” the District’s last recommended placement was the County class at Brewer. The letter says nothing about speech therapy or other special education services.
In addition to not containing an offer that provided STUDENT an appropriate program, neither the IEPs nor Mr. Kass’ August 16 letter apparently was a definite and firm offer of an educational program since the proposed program was contingent upon a review and decision by the County staff as to the propriety of the referral. According to Ms. Atkinson’s testimony, a County special education referral did not guarantee a child a place in the County’s SDL class since the County staff would conduct an intake and observation and obtain the necessary information to determine whether the child was correctly referred to the SDL class. To the extent that a referral to the County for consideration of a child for its SDL class was thus dependent upon the County staff’s independent determination of appropriateness, a referral to a County SDL class appears not to have been a definite offer of a placement and thus violative of Union School Dist. v. Smith. Such a contingent offer of a placement may not alert the parents of the need to give serious consideration to the appropriateness of the placement. Therefore, the contingent nature of the District’s offer and its failure to make a firm offer of a placement and services upon which the parents could rely seriously infringed upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process and caused prejudice to STUDENT, resulting in the denial of a FAPE.
b. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
As discussed above, to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and (3) conformed with his IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
Petitioner argues that he was denied a FAPE because the school day of the County SDL class proposed by the District was shorter than that of the regular education class of STUDENT’s chronological peers, and the County class also did not provide for speech and language therapy to meet his unique needs.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the 1999-2000 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, the first step is to identify his needs. STUDENT’s needs have been established by the assessments and academic and speech and language reports up through September 2000 and the testimony of assessors Dr. Jacknow, Ms. Tzetzos, Ms. Dunning, Ms. Ames, and teacher Ms. Belmonte. STUDENT has a severe developmental speech and language disorder, with significant delays in receptive and expressive language skills and auditory memory. His language processing abilities are significantly below average in word retrieval (expressive language) and comprehension (receptive language). He has significant delays in semantics and syntax and also impaired morphological (usage) understanding. His receptive vocabulary is in the borderline range, and his expressive vocabulary is in the significantly below average range. He has poor retention of vocabulary and basic concepts. His cognitive functioning related to verbal skills is below average. He also exhibits processing deficits in visual perceptual skills and significant difficulties with visuospatial processing. His auditory perceptual ability is in the below average range, indicating auditory processing delays. He has borderline attentional abilities for visual information. An auditory attention subtest on the NEPSY could not be administered because he was unable to understand the directions. He has difficulty following the directions for conventional assessments.
In class STUDENT has difficulty maintaining focused attention, is easily distracted, occasionally appears to be very withdrawn, and has difficulty following instructions. He has difficulty attending even in a group setting. He has great difficulty comprehending what the class is discussing and in response to questions says that he does not know or gives answers that do not make sense. He also cannot carry on a normal conversation. At school, STUDENT tends to play parallel to peers, often does not verbally initiate play with them, and has difficulty responding when they attempt to engage him. He needs to work on socialization and communication. When STUDENT does not cooperate, his parents and teachers should ascertain whether he understood, and if he did not, they should rephrase what is being asked of him.
In addition to the above, STUDENT has these instructional needs. His severe verbal deficits adversely affect his ability to learn, and comprehensive support is necessary. He requires a class for children with severe disorders of language (SDL). He further requires a highly structured class environment which starts at his language level and moves through a hierarchy using structured models and scripted responses to provide the requisite indirect language stimulation. He also needs a teacher-student ratio of 1-to-5 or -6 and small-group instruction whenever possible. His language instruction should incorporate computer-assisted learning for a multi-sensory approach. He requires individual speech and language therapy at least two times per week and collaborative services within the SDL class. He also requires weekly occupational therapy to address his visuospatial processing deficits.
The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs is to examine the IEP. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
The May 18, 1999 IEP, signed by the parent, sets forth goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s needs in expressive and receptive language, focusing and attention to task, and socialization. The expressive and receptive language objectives are designed to improve STUDENT’s ability to label and identify common nouns and verbs; to use and identify appropriate prepositional phrases; to use certain pronouns in connected speech; to formulate simple sentences with noun-verb agreement; and to describe an object or event using multiple sentences while remaining on topic. The focusing and attention objectives address the ability to attend and focus when the teacher is presenting information to the class. The socialization objectives address voluntary participation during classroom instruction. These goals and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in these areas as identified by the assessments and teacher observations.
The May 18 IEP provides the following placement and services for STUDENT. The IEP proposes an SDL class as the appropriate and least restrictive environment. The IEP states that the placement and services would be determined at the next IEP meeting that was to be reconvened by June 17. The IEP also indicates that STUDENT was to receive ESY services. Before the IEP meeting reconvened in June 1999, the mother, school psychologist Ms. Tzetzos, and speech and language pathologist Ms. Dunning visited the County SDL class at Brewer which had been proposed for STUDENT.(Footnote 11) The June 16, 1999 IEP reiterates the recommended placement of an SDL class and provides for ESY services. According to the IEP, during a discussion of staff observations of the proposed SDL class at Brewer, the mother expressed concerns about behavioral problems in the class. The IEP states that the IEP team decided to explore all public school options and to meet before the start of the coming school year to discuss the specific school placement. As discussed above, the May 18 and June 16 IEPs were deficient in making only a contingent offer of placement and in failing to offer a comprehensive program including speech and language related services to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
The placement in an SDL class was intended to provide STUDENT with a language-based learning environment to address his speech and language deficits. Ms. Atkinson, the teacher of the County SDL class, testified that the students in her class have language development as a primary need. She testified that the SDL class has a language emphasis and that the presentation of the material is visual and concrete. She further testified that class activities such as circle time and snack time as well as recess and lunch have a language component and promote social language and interactions. Ms. Atkinson’s class could address STUDENT’s language development needs and also his need to develop his social communication and socialization skills. Ms. Atkinson also testified that, as the spring 1999 videotape of her class showed, students receive academic instruction in a group or individually at their skill level.(Footnote 12) She testified that the class includes multi-modality learning and that in the library the students, each with a computer, receive 45 minutes weekly of instruction on the computer related to readiness and academic skills learning games. The students can also use a computer in the classroom during free time activities. Thus, the class could meet STUDENT’s need for computer-incorporated and multi-sensory instruction.
Moreover, the evidence is that the County teacher, Ms. Atkinson, has three teaching credentials: regular elementary education, communication handicapped (CH), and severely handicapped (SH). Ms. Atkinson testified that the education and training she received in working toward the CH credential focused on normal (in contrast to atypical) language development, the assessment and remediation of language deficits, and modification of the curriculum to address these deficits. In fall 2000, she was in her eleventh year of teaching the County SDL class. Thus, she has the education, experience, and credential to assist STUDENT in the classroom with his language development needs.(Footnote 13)
Petitioner argues, in essence, that the County SDL class failed to meet his need for an adequate amount of instructional time to work on his IEP goals and objectives. He contends that the County SDL class was for a shorter length of time than the regular education class of his chronological peers, in violation of California Code of Regulations, title 5, section 3053(b)(2).(Footnote 14) The District responds that during the 2000-2001 school year, the instructional day for students at Hatch Elementary School, STUDENT’s neighborhood school, is only 5 minutes shorter than the 5-hour instructional day of the County SDL class according to Ms. Atkinson’s testimony. See Petitioner’s Exhibit 20.(Footnote 15)
Ms. Atkinson testified that during the 1999-2000 school year, the hours of her SDL class were from 8:15 a.m. to 1:15 p.m. (5 hours), including recess and lunch, both of which together totaled 40 minutes. She further testified that during the same year, the hours of regular education classes at Brewer were from 8:20 a.m. to 2:40 p.m. (6 hours and 20 minutes), including a one-hour lunch and 20-minute recess (5 hours of instructional time).(Footnote 16) According to her, on Wednesdays, the regular education students had a minimum day schedule from 8:20 a.m. to 12:35 p.m., including recess but excluding lunch.
Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999), cited by Petitioner, is controlling. A reduction in the instructional schedule or in service hours does not violate the IDEA if the reduction is contemplated by the IEP and linked to valid educational goals and the child’s unique needs. 195 F.3d at 1150 (citing Doe v. Maher, 795 F.2d 1470, 1491 (9th Cir. 1986)). The California Code of Regulations also provides that a student may attend a special day class for less than the regular school day of his chronological peers only when the IEP team determines that he cannot function for the length of time of a regular school day and his IEP so specifies. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3053(b)(2)(B).
According to an August 15, 1986 policy letter of the Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services (OSERS) (Letter to Lewis, IDELR 211:411), cited by the District, lunch and recess generally cannot be counted as part of the instructional time for students with disabilities.(Footnote 17) However, in certain cases where it is appropriate to provide instruction during lunch or recess to develop specific functional skills, lunch or recess may be considered instructional time if the IEP contains goals and objectives regarding those skills and if appropriate instruction is provided during that time.
Here, STUDENT’s May 18, 1999 and June 16, 1999 IEPs do not contain goals and objectives specifically related to skills to be developed during recess and lunch. The assessments did not identify functional skills which he needed to develop specifically during recess and lunch. Ms. Atkinson testified that during recess and lunch, the students were directly supervised and she or the assistant provided language input. However, she did not testify as to specific goals or objectives in STUDENT’s IEPs for which instruction would be provided during these times. In fact, STUDENT’s focusing and attention and socialization objectives appear to be specifically related to classroom instruction. His language objectives involve technical aspects of language use more properly addressed in the classroom than in the lunch room or on the playground.
Therefore, the 40 minutes for recess and lunch in the County SDL class cannot be counted in the instructional day, and the instructional day was 4 hours and 20 minutes. The instructional day at Hatch is 4 hours and 55 minutes and at Brewer, 5 hours (except for Wednesday, when the instructional time is approximately 4 hours). Thus, regardless of whether the Brewer or Hatch regular school day is applicable, the County SDL class failed to provide an educational program for the same length of time as the regular school day for STUDENT’s chronological peers. To that extent, the proposed program was inappropriate.
In addition, the undisputed evidence is that one of STUDENT’s unique needs is speech and language therapy at least twice weekly.(Footnote 18) However, Ms. Atkinson testified that in her County SDL class, only students with physical language impediments, i.e., articulation difficulties, receive pullout speech therapy from a clinical speech pathologist. She further testified that STUDENT had no articulation IEP goals and objectives. Therefore, the District’s offer of a placement at the County SDL class taught by Ms. Atkinson did not provide for speech therapy for STUDENT since he did not have articulation IEP goals and objectives. Moreover, Ms. Atkinson testified that she is not a clinical speech pathologist. Thus, although she testified that at times she worked on language goals individually or in a small group if several students had the same needs, she lacked the qualifications to provide the equivalent of speech therapy.
If Ms. Atkinson’s County SDL class failed to provide for speech therapy, the District could have offered speech therapy outside the SDL class. However, neither the May 1999 nor the June 1999 IEP mentions speech therapy as a related service. The District argues that neither IEP was a final IEP setting forth the entire program and services it offered STUDENT because the parents failed to consent to the County referral. According to the testimony of Ms. Atkinson and assistant superintendent Mr. Kass, if the parents had consented, the County staff would have conducted a review of records, interviews, and observations and then decided whether the referral to the County SDL class was appropriate. If the County staff determined that it was appropriate, an IEP meeting would have been held to formulate an IEP setting forth the specific proposed goals and objectives, placement, and services.
However, if the District’s May 1999 and June 1999 IEPs were not final offers of placement, a question arises as to whether the District complied with the requirement of Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994). This matter is addressed in the section on Compliance with Procedural Safeguards, above. Here, the educational program offered by the District did not provide the same amount of instructional time as the school day of STUDENT’s chronological peers, and there is no evidence that for the 1999-2000 school year, the District offered STUDENT speech therapy, as he required. Therefore, the District’s proposed program failed to meet his unique needs.(Footnote 19)
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Because STUDENT did not attend the County SDL class, no measures of his progress in that proposed placement exist. However, Ms. Atkinson, the SDL class teacher, reviewed STUDENT’s May 18, 1999 and June 16, 1999 IEPs and testified that the proposed speech and language goals and objectives set forth in his IEPs were similar to those of students in her class and could be implemented in her class. She similarly reviewed the focusing and attention and socialization goals and objectives and testified that they also could be implemented in her class.
STUDENT’s mother testified that when she visited the County SDL class in June 1999, she observed behavior problems exhibited by some of the students which she felt would be detrimental to STUDENT’s progress in that class.(Footnote 20) Ms. Atkinson testified that a child whose primary need is behavior modification, not language development, would not be placed in her SDL class. She testified that during the 1998-1999 school year, a student in her class with behavior problems was provided with a separate area in the classroom to minimize distractions and was given the support of an extra assistant in the classroom. She further testified, however, that although the student’s behavior was distracting, it was not the focus of the class. According to her, there were other students in the class with the degree of distractibility indicated by the focusing and attention goal and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP, and she did not feel that these students were distracted by the one student with behavior problems. She also testified that the student had transferred from her class during the 1999 Easter break and no longer was in her class. Ms. Atkinson testified that during the 1998-1999 school year, when STUDENT’s mother visited the class, none of the students would have been characterized as having attention deficit disorder (ADD) or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) according to a rating scale, although children aged 6 to 7 are active and exhibit much movement. According to the teacher’s testimony, the composition of the class changes yearly, and there is no persuasive evidence that during the 1999-2000 school year at issue here, children with serious behavior problems were in that class and would have had an adverse effect on STUDENT’s progress in the class.
Just because STUDENT did not enroll in the County SDL class, it does not follow that the proposed placement, if implemented, could not have conferred any educational benefit on STUDENT. However, to the extent that the District’s proposed educational program did not provide instruction for the same length of time as the regular school day of his chronological peers and did not include speech and language therapy to address STUDENT’s severe language delay, it was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
(3) Conformity with IEP
Without a final IEP setting forth the placement and related services offered by the District (discussed above under Compliance with Procedural Safeguards), there was no IEP offering an appropriate program to which the proposed placement conformed.
The District’s proposed educational program failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and to that extent was not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit. Therefore, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year.
ISSUE 2: If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE, is he entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Stanbridge Academy during the 1999-2000 school year?
A hearing officer may require the District to reimburse the parents for the cost of a private school placement if the hearing officer finds that the District failed to provide the child a FAPE in a timely manner prior to enrollment at the private school, and the private placement is appropriate. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c); Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. To be appropriate, the private placement must be designed to meet the child’s unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. The Burlington rule does not limit reimbursement only to a private placement selected by the parent that is the “exact proper placement” under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).
Here, by an August 19, 1999 letter, the parents informed the District that they rejected the proffered placement at the County SDL class at Brewer and that they were going to remove him from the District effective September 2, 1999, and intended to enroll him in a private school at public expense. See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I); Cal. Educ. Code 56176(b).
The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year. The question is whether the unilateral placement at Stanbridge was appropriate under the IDEA.
According to Wendy Ames, program coordinator at Stanbridge Academy (Stanbridge), Stanbridge is a private school that serves only students with learning disabilities.(Footnote 21) She testified that STUDENT enrolled at Stanbridge in September 1999 and was placed in the lower elementary division, which serves children in grades 1 through 3.(Footnote 22) Ms. Ames testified that during the 1999-2000 school year, the student-teacher ratio in the lower elementary division was 12 students with 2 full-time teachers (Kathryn Varda and Edith Schlesinger), who teach language arts and mathematics, respectively) and a physical education teacher.(Footnote 23) According to Ms. Ames, Ms. Varda uses the Slingerland method and the SRA Reading Mastery program, both of which utilize the auditory, visual, and kinesthetic modes and have been successful with learning disabled students. Ms. Ames further testified that Ms. Varda also uses the Visualizing and Verbalizing portion of the Lindamood Bell program which has been used successfully with speech and language impaired students. According to Ms. Ames, the instruction at Stanbridge is eclectic and multi-modal (auditory, visual, kinesthetic, and hands-on almost all of the time).
Ms. Ames testified that at Stanbridge, the children are taught in groups according to their academic ability rather than age or disability. She testified that in language arts, there were only 2 students in a group and in math, 2 to 3 students in a group. According to her, a number of the students, like STUDENT, have a central auditory processing disorder, and in a small group, if a child is distracted or does not understand, the teacher can re-direct the child, repeat instructions, or present the material auditorily, visually, or kinesthetically to ensure that the child understands.
According to Ms. Ames, during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT also received pullout speech and language therapy, funded by the parents, from Jan Buchwald, a licensed speech and language pathologist, two times weekly for approximately 30 minutes each session.(Footnote 24) STUDENT also had computer instruction for one period daily from Marian Clark.(Footnote 25) Students worked on computer games in math and reading. Stanbridge also has the Earobics computer program to develop auditory processing skills.
Ms. Ames testified that when a child first enters Stanbridge, she develops a learning profile based upon a review of educational records and assessments and information from the parents. At that time, she formulates broad goals that the teachers will work on (e.g., fine motor skills). She acknowledged that although some students had IEPs, the teachers did not work specifically on the goals and objectives in the IEPs. Ms. Ames testified that at Stanbridge, she observes students in the classroom approximately once a month and also sees them interacting during recess. According to her, she has been teaching at special education schools for 20 years.(Footnote 26)
STUDENT’s unique and individual needs were set forth under Issue 1 above. The educational program at Stanbridge has met his need for a class with a teacher-student ratio of at least 1-to-5 or -6 and small-group instruction. The two-student grouping in language arts based upon ability and skill level rather than age meets his need for a structured learning environment which starts at his level of functioning. The language arts program taught by STUDENT’s teacher at Stanbridge, which includes the Slingerland method and portions of the Lindamood Bell program and utilizes the auditory, visual, and kinesthetic modes, met his need for multi-sensory instruction. The computer instruction he received met his need for a multi-sensory approach incorporating computer-assisted learning. The small group instruction also met his need to focus his attention and to have instructions and information rephrased when he did not understand. The speech therapy, funded by his parents, met his need for speech and language services from a speech pathologist.
Moreover, Ms. Ames testified that STUDENT had made the following progress on the objectives in the May 18, 1999 IEP in the area of receptive and expressive language skills: (1) label and identify common nouns and verbs - met the objective; (2) use and identify prepositional phrases appropriate for a five-year-old child - probably close to 50 percent achievement; (3) use certain pronouns correctly in running speech, a more difficult area, according to Ms. Ames - better than 5 percent, although she was uncertain if he had attained 80 percent; (4) formulate simple sentences using noun-verb agreement - much better than 20 percent and probably closer to 60 or 70 percent, if the objective had not in fact been met; and (5) remain on topic and describe objectives and events using two- to four-word sentences - probably 60 to 70 percent.(Footnote 27) Related to the second objective regarding prepositional phrases, Ms. Ames stated that she thought that prepositional phrases were more difficult than common nouns, although she did not know what would be expected of a child aged 5. She acknowledged that she was not a speech and language therapist but explained that her determination of STUDENT’s progress on the objectives was based primarily on the fact that he was now more verbal and better able and willing to speak than he had been in September 1999.
Dr. Jacknow testified that she has a specialty in developmental and behavioral pediatrics, which includes expertise in children with language delays. She testified that based upon Ms Buchwald’s July 2000 progress note, STUDENT had made no progress on the first objective but had significantly improved on the second objective--by 50 percent; and was now performing in the average range on the third and fourth objectives and in the high average range on the fifth objective. Dr. Jacknow testified that STUDENT had met his IEP goals and made significant improvement at Stanbridge. There were different interpretations of the amount of STUDENT’s achievement in meeting the IEP objectives. However, except for the first objective, which was adversely affected by his word retrieval deficit, he did show improvement on the objectives.
Misty Belmonte, STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher in the regular education class he attended in the afternoon at Hatch (he had attended a special day class in the morning), testified that he was not able to speak full sentences but spoke only single words and phrases. According to her, STUDENT spoke more like a second language learner and seemed to have his own language. Thus, STUDENT’s ability by the end of his first grade year at Stanbridge to be able to use sentences and remain on topic in describing an object or event demonstrates marked progress.
Speech and language pathologist Ms. Buchwald, who worked with STUDENT on speech and language goals in small group therapy during the 1999-2000 school year, stated in her July 2000 progress note that STUDENT had met the goals and objectives in his May 18, 1999 IEP and was ready to address broader language goals for the coming school year, including basic concepts, asking questions, following auditory directions, and pragmatic skills. She further stated that his placement at Stanbridge was appropriate for his academic, social, and language needs.
Ms. Ames testified that she has been administering the Woodcock Johnson test for a number of years and that she administered the WJ-R to STUDENT.(Footnote 28) She acknowledged deviations from the prescribed manner of test administration but stated that pursuant to test administration procedures, she documented these in her assessment report.(Footnote 29) She testified that she did not know how the modifications affected the comparison with the April 1999 WJ-R results obtained through the standardized method. School psychologist Ms. Tzetzos testified that the results of standardized and nonstandardized test administration cannot be compared, although in “limit testing,” a nonstandardized test procedure might be used purely to find out what the child knows. In her report, Ms. Ames stated that with his difficulties, STUDENT’s progress seemed slow, but it was steady. He did better on subtests ( such as Letter-Word Identification, Calculation, and Word Attack) that did not require listening to verbal directions. Ms. Ames testified that STUDENT had shown academic progress in some areas in the June 2000 Woodcock Johnson test results based upon his education at Stanbridge but that he had a learning disability which he would have for quite some time.
STUDENT’s mother testified that Ms. Ames’ June 2000 assessment report revealed gains of from two months to two years in WJ-R test scores. Based upon Ms. Ames’ June 22, 2000 academic evaluation report, a comparison with the April 1999 WJ-R test results reveals the following age-equivalence gains on the WJ-R in June 2000: Broad Reading, 10 months; Broad Mathematics, 1 year, 11 months; and Broad Written Language, 5 months. On the subtests, STUDENT’s age equivalence scores increased from 2 months in Dictation to as much as 2 years, 6 months in Calculation. In her report, Ms. Ames stated that in addition to academic progress, STUDENT had shown a dramatic increase in self-esteem, ability to consistently be a member of a group, and willingness to accept social and academic challenges during the 1999-2000 school year. Although the comparison with the previous year’s scores must be viewed with caution, the improved scores were an indication of what STUDENT knew.
STUDENT’s mother also testified that his work samples revealed that he was able to perform double-digit arithmetic calculations and to read and write letters and words after one year at Stanbridge.(Footnote 30) Petitioner’s Exhibit 14. According to her, he had lacked these abilities before attending Stanbridge. She also testified that his report cards indicated that he was doing well in academics, which was pretty good since he came to Stanbridge from kindergarten.
Ms. Ames testified that STUDENT’s Stanbridge progress report for the 1999-2000 school year was an accurate record of his progress. The progress report reveals that in his language arts class, he received 1, or needs improvement, ratings, throughout the year in oral language skills and the reading skills of vocabulary and comprehension. However, in other reading skills, he received by the second semester a good rating for decoding skills, decoding application, and sight words and excellent ratings for letter recognition and sequencing the alphabet and for sound/symbol recognition. In mathematical operations, STUDENT maintained throughout the year a good rating in numeration (number recognition, counting, and writing numbers) and a satisfactory rating in shapes. By the second semester, he had a good rating for addition and subtraction. In mathematical applications, he maintained a satisfactory rating during the entire year for mental computation, numerical reasoning, word problems, and missing element and, by the second semester, had achieved a good rating for classification, pattern awareness, and sequencing. In his combined social studies, science, and art class, he maintained throughout the year a “needs improvement” rating for reading application and written expression; a “needs improvement” to satisfactory rating for oral presentation; a satisfactory rating for concept development, participation, listening skills, retention, and generalization; and a good rating for artistic expression and cooperative group work. In all of his classes, he received a good rating for effort by the second semester.
Thus, STUDENT’s speech and language and auditory processing deficits limited his progress to some extent, but he did show progress in decoding and sight words, letter recognition, the alphabet, and sound-symbol recognition. Moreover, as his mother noted, he showed improvement in addition and subtraction. He also exhibited improvement in the mathematical application areas of classification, pattern awareness, and sequencing. His effort also went up.
The June 2000 WJ-R test results, STUDENT’s Stanbridge progress reports for the 1999-2000 school year, and his progress on his IEP goals and objectives reveal that the program at Stanbridge, including the speech therapy, was reasonably calculated to bestow on him educational benefit. Ms. Ames testified that she had seen a big change in STUDENT’s verbal ability and also self-esteem during the school year. At the end of the year, he was more outgoing and could be very verbal when he needed something. She testified that Stanbridge had met STUDENT’s needs, and he had made progress, and she believed that Stanbridge was an appropriate placement for him. Dr. Jacknow testified that she knew that Stanbridge teachers need not have a special education credential and do not work on IEPS, but that she had observed classes at Stanbridge and knew that it was an appropriate placement for STUDENT.(Footnote 31)
The District argues that any reimbursement should be reduced or denied even if the private unilateral placement is appropriate because the mother exhibited bad faith in “pre-selecting a private placement, obstructing the District’s efforts to offer her placement in the County program, and adhering stubbornly to her own version of reality concerning what she saw and heard at the time of the visit and later when she was undertaking her perseverative inquiry into the teacher’s credential status.” District’s Closing Brief at 27. The cost of reimbursement for a private school placement may be reduced or denied “upon a judicial finding of unreasonableness with respect to actions taken by the parents.” 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(III). Here, Dr. Jacknow testified that during an office visit by the mother on May 24, 1999, Dr. Jacknow wrote down four schools that could offer STUDENT the type of class he required. These schools included three County schools and Stanbridge if no other suitable school was available. Dr. Jacknow testified that during the office visit, she had discussed Stanbridge with the mother, and the mother had wanted to visit Stanbridge. In her June 7, 1999 report, Dr. Jacknow recommended Stanbridge if an SDL County or District class was not available. She testified that previously she had not recommended Stanbridge because STUDENT had been too young. As discussed above, the District failed to offer STUDENT a program that met his unique needs and failed to make a firm and definite offer to satisfy the requirements of Union School Dist. v. Smith. Therefore, the parents’ efforts to find an appropriate placement for STUDENT do not constitute actions so unreasonable as to warrant a reduction or denial of reimbursement for the costs of tuition and other expenses at Stanbridge during the 1999-2000 school year.
The District failed to offer STUDENT a program that would meet his unique needs. The program at Stanbridge, including parentally funded speech and language therapy, met these needs and provided him with the small group instruction and low student-teacher ratio he required due to his language delays and attention difficulty. The program at Stanbridge, including the speech therapy, also was reasonably calculated to bestow on him educational benefit. Thus, although his teachers lacked CH or special education credentials, Stanbridge provided an appropriate program for STUDENT under the IDEA. As a result, his parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his tuition and related expenses (books and required uniforms) at Stanbridge during the 1999-2000 school year in the amount of $14,698.21.(Footnote 32) In addition, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of speech therapy from Ms. Buchwald in the amount of $1,475.00. The District shall also reimburse the parents for transportation mileage of 30.6 miles for each day STUDENT actually attended school during the school year from September 1999 through June 2000 at the rate the District reimburses its employees. See Petitioner’s Exhibit 16.
ORDER
1. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the following:
(a) Costs of tuition and related expenses (books and required uniforms) at Stanbridge Academy during the 1999-2000 school year in the amount of $14,698.21 (see Petitioner’s Exhibit 16); and (b) Costs of speech therapy from Ms. Buchwald during the 1999-2000 school year in the amount of $1,475.00 (see Petitioner’s Exhibit 16).
2. Within twenty days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the actual number of days that he attended Stanbridge Academy during the school year from September 1999 through June 2000. Within twenty-five days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for transportation mileage of 30.6 miles for each day that he actually attended Stanbridge during the school year at the rate the District reimburses its employees (see Petitioner’s Exhibit 16).
3. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on both of the issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: February 21, 2001 ____________________________________ Judy F. Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: The Hearing Office follows the general rule that the party seeking to change the status quo bears the burden of going forward. See Burger v. Murray County School Dist., 612 F.Supp. 434, 437 (N.D. Ga. 1984). Here, the District proposed to change Petitioner’s placement from a collaborative arrangement of a regular education class and special education class to an SDL special day class.
Footnote 2: The issues have been clarified to facilitate the analysis.
Footnote 3: In his closing brief, Petitioner requests reimbursement for the denial of a FAPE from fall 1999 to the present, including summer 2000. However, Petitioner’s June 21, 2000 statement of the issues for hearing sets forth as an issue the provision of a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year only and requests reimbursement for tuition and incidental costs. On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer reviewed the parties’ written statements of the issues for hearing. At that time, Petitioner, who was represented by an attorney, indicated that the time period at issue was the 1999-2000 school year, specifically, September 1999 to June 2000. The hearing was reconvened in October 2000, and at no time during the hearing did Petitioner state that he wished to add issues related to other time periods. On the last day of hearing, in a discussion of the issues to be addressed by the parties in their written arguments, the mother reiterated that Petitioner’s statement of issues alleged denial of a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year. She did not mention summer 2000. Therefore, this hearing was limited to the issue of whether a FAPE was offered during the 1999-2000 regular school year (not including summer 2000). Petitioner is not foreclosed, however, from filing another due process hearing request to raise issues related to other time periods.
Footnote 4: In July 1999, Mr. Kass filed with the Hearing Office a request for mediation only to address STUDENT’s first grade special education placement for the 1999-2000 school year. A mediation was held at the end of July and an interim agreement was reached, but the ultimate question of a fall 1999 placement for STUDENT was not resolved. In March 2000, the Hearing Office closed the mediation only case.
Footnote 5: In September 1999, the parent filed a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE) asserting that the District had failed to implement the May and June 1999 IEPs by not providing STUDENT an SDL class during summer 1999. The CDE’s Compliance Report found that the District was not required to implement these IEPs because the parent did not give written permission to implement either IEP. In January 2000, the CDE denied the parent’s request for reconsideration. The provision of educational services during summer 1999 was not raised as an issue for hearing.
Footnote 6: Ms. Ames testified that pursuant to test administration procedures, she documented in her report deviations from the prescribed test administration method and did not know how the difference affected the comparison with the District’s WJ-R results.
Footnote 7: The explanations of the other ratings are as follows: 2, satisfactory; 3, good; 4, excellent; and NA, does not apply at this time. STUDENT received NA ratings for oral and silent reading skills and for all of the written language skills, including letters; for multiplication and division; and for fractions, percentages, measurement, time, and money.
Footnote 8: School psychologist Ms. Tzetzos testified that a referral for placement in a County class is accompanied by a proposed assessment plan signed by the parent. The District’s proposed assessment plan for STUDENT, not signed by the parent, provides for assessment in academic achievement, intellectual development, communication development, social/adaptive behavior, and psycho-motor development. District’s Exhibit 67.
Footnote 9: In May 1998, the mother initially consented to a referral to a County class but later informed Mr. Kass that the County class she had visited was inappropriate and that she wished to visit District classes. The fact that there was initial consent does not alter the fact that the District, in contrast to the County, is able to develop a final IEP which includes related and other special education services.
Footnote 10: Speech pathologist Ms. Dunning testified that a CH credential is now required to teach a CH or SDL class. Following inquiries by the mother, senior credential analyst Valerie Flatt of the San Mateo County Office of Education notified her in an August 5, 1999 letter that the teacher had a CH credential and that although the records of the State Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CTC) did not reflect this credential, Ms. Flatt had been informed that their records would be updated. Ms. Flatt also stated that her office had an official copy of the teacher’s credential. When the mother sought updated information from the CTC in September 1999, their records still had not been updated. The mother testified that she did not see a copy of the teacher’s CH credential until she received the District’s proposed exhibits several days before the hearing.
Footnote 11: School psychologist Ms. Tzetzos testified that the District offers only an SDL preschool and refers students above the preschool level to a County SDL class. Thus, when a child above the preschool level needs an SDL placement, the next step is to look to a County class.
Footnote 12: Ms. Atkinson testified that in the south County, there are three SDL classes for elementary age students: classes for grades 1 to 2, 3 to 4, and 5 to 6. According to her, during the 1998-1999 school year, her class was composed of grade 1 and 2 students, aged 6 to 8.
Footnote 13: Ms. Atkinson testified that the average number of students in the class was 10 to 12, with the number varying by 1 to 3 students each year. Thus, the average number of students could range from 7 to 15. Ms. Atkinson testified that besides herself, there were two assistants in the class at the time the spring 1999 videotape was made. She testified that at one time, the second assistant worked primarily with a child who had behavior problems but that this child left her class during the 1999 Easter break. School psychologist Ms. Tzetzos testified that when she visited Ms. Atkinson’s class in June 1999 with STUDENT’s mother, she saw one teacher and two aides; however, STUDENT’s mother testified that she observed one teacher and one aide. Thus, the evidence is not clear as to the consistent number of class assistants, and there was no evidence about their training or experience. Therefore, it cannot be ascertained how the assistants’ presence affected the average teacher-student ratio range of from 1-to-7 to 1-to-15. Consequently, it is not clear that this class met STUDENT’s need for a 1-to-5 or -6 teacher-student ratio.
Footnote 14: Section 3053(b)(2) states that students in a special day class shall be provided with an educational program in accordance with their IEPs “for at least the same length of time as the regular school day for that chronological peer group.”
Footnote 15: According to Petitioner’s Exhibit 20, the hours of the school day for grades 1 to 3 at Hatch Elementary School are from 8:30 a.m. to 2:20 p.m. (5 hours and 50 minutes), and the instructional time is 295 minutes (4 hours and 55 minutes).
Footnote 16: Ms. Atkinson did not indicate the age of the students in the regular education classes with these hours, but she also did not indicate that the hours of students of STUDENT’s age were different.
Footnote 17: This policy letter was interpreting the Education of the Handicapped Act, the predecessor statute to the IDEA.
Footnote 18: The May 18, 1999 IEP contains the current assessment results and recommendations of the District’s speech and language pathologist Ms. Dunning, who recommended a highly structured language-based learning environment, pullout speech therapy twice weekly, and collaborative services within the SDC or SDL class. Further, following a June 1999 follow-up assessment, Dr. Jacknow recommended, among other things, an SDL class and individual speech and language therapy twice weekly. Following a September 2000 neuro-developmental assessment, Dr. Jacknow recommended that STUDENT continue individual speech and language therapy three times weekly.
Footnote 19: Assistant superintendent Mr. Kass testified that the District attempted to find an SDL class that was in closest proximity to Half Moon Bay, where Petitioner resides, because of the length of time of transportation over Highway 92 (to other parts of San Mateo County). No evidence was presented of any other class offered by the District other than Ms. Atkinson’s SDL class in Foster City. Moreover, no evidence was submitted of the length of a bus ride from Half Moon Bay to Foster City. In any event, Petitioner has not raised as an issue the distance to the school in Foster City.
Footnote 20: Stanbridge Academy program coordinator Wendy Ames testified that STUDENT does not have behavior problems, and it would be inappropriate for him to be with children with prominent behavior problems.
Footnote 21: Stanbridge, established in 1982, is accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges and during the 2000-2001 school year had 82 students from grades 1 to 12. According to the declaration of headmaster Richard Bowen, Stanbridge is not certified by the State of California to provide special education to students with disabilities. However, reimbursement is not barred for this reason. See Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993). Ms. Ames testified that the disabilities of students at Stanbridge include dyslexia, central auditory processing disorder, ADHD, Asperger’s syndrome, Tourette’s syndrome, and obsessive-compulsive disorder. They do not have behavior problems as a primary problem.
Footnote 22: Ms. Ames testified that the school day ran from 8:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., with a one-half hour recess and one-half hour lunch.
Footnote 23: According to Ms. Ames, Ms. Varda has a bachelor’s degree from a college in England and taught in England before coming to the United States. Ms. Schlesinger has a degree in early childhood education from a university in Guatemala.
Footnote 24: Ms. Ames testified that for the 2000-2001 school year, Stanbridge had contracted with speech and language pathologist Ms. Buchwald and another speech and language therapist to work with students four days a week, and the cost was included as part of the tuition.
Footnote 25: According to Ms. Ames, Ms. Clark has a lifetime California education credential and a lifetime speech and language credential. She did not provide speech therapy to STUDENT.
Footnote 26: Ms. Ames testified that she has a lifetime California elementary teaching credential and Arizona elementary and special education learning handicapped or learning disability credentials for grades kindergarten to 12. She testified that she has been at Stanbridge since 1991, had taught for seven years at a school in Arizona similar to Stanbridge, and also had taught regular education kindergarten and grade 2 classes in California.
Footnote 27: In her July 7, 2000 progress note, speech and language pathologist Ms. Buchwald set forth STUDENT’s progress on the following goals and objectives in small group therapy during the 1999-2000 school year, with these May 2000 percentage scores (May 1999 baseline percentage scores are in parentheses): (1) label and identify common nouns and verbs, 1% (1%); (2) use and identify prepositional phrases appropriate for 5-year level, 50% (1%); (3) use the pronouns “he,” “she,” and “they” correctly in running speech 80% of the time, 60-70% (5%); (4) formulate simple sentences with noun-verb agreement 80% of the time, 40% (20%); and (5) remain on topic and describe objects and events using two- to four-word sentences, 80% (20%). Ms. Buchwald indicated that STUDENT’s progress on the first objective was affected by his word-retrieval difficulty. Although the wording of the fifth objective differs slightly from the IEP objective (which states “using 2-4 sentences”), the difference does not appear to be material. Ms. Ames overestimated STUDENT’s progress on the first and fourth objectives compared to Ms. Buchwald’s evaluation; however, they appeared to concur substantially on the other objectives. District speech pathologist Ms. Dunning testified that based upon Ms. Buchwald’s July 7, 2000 progress note, STUDENT had not met the first and fourth objectives. Related to the second objective, she testified that a five-year old child would be using prepositional phrases greater than 50 percent of the time. She testified that STUDENT did make progress on the third objective and had met the fifth objective, but not if he had achieved these percentage scores only in small group therapy because these goals and objectives were intended to be implemented in both the class and therapy. According to Ms. Dunning, STUDENT would have been expected to perform in the average range on these objectives if language had been the focus everyday in class.
Footnote 28: Ms. Ames testified that she was not able to give STUDENT all the subtests because he was not cooperative. She did not administer the writing fluency timed test or the reading vocabulary test because STUDENT was not able to read words.
Footnote 29: Ms. Ames testified that STUDENT’s mother was present during the testing, and STUDENT whispered answers in his mother’s ear and was also accommodated by being given extra time and having directions restated a different way. Footnote 30: By contrast, according to Ms. Belmonte, STUDENT’s regular education kindergarten teacher, in his journal, he wrote only random letters except for his name, “Mom,” and, occasionally, “Dad.” Footnote 31: The District argues that the County SDL class provided STUDENT the least restrictive environment because of the opportunity for mainstreaming on an individual basis. However, if a private school offers a student an appropriate education, the program need not be provided in the least restrictive environment for the parent to be entitled to tuition reimbursement. Warren G. v. Cumberland Cy. School Dist., 190 F.3d 80, 83-84 (3d Cir. 1999). Moreover, there was no indication of what specific mainstreaming opportunities were offered to STUDENT. Footnote 32: Petitioner has requested reimbursement for the cost of field trips during the school year; however, this reimbursement item is denied because of a failure to show what these trips entailed and how they were necessary for Petitioner to benefit from his education at Stanbridge. Petitioner also has requested reimbursement for the costs of the hearing, including attorney fees. However, the Hearing Officer lacks the authority to make such an award.
