California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 21, 2001

Student v. Temecula Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1090-01 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu

Temecula Valley Unified must keep a health-trained instructional assistant III for a student with multiple impairments and return a records-copying overcharge check.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 6 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Stay put order issued by the Hearing Office on June 11, 2001, reinstating instructional assistant III services. No remand, appeal, or correction is noted.

Summary

The parents of a 10-year-old fourth grader at Vail Elementary School filed for due process. She had been eligible for special education since 1994 with "multiple impairments." Her IEP gave her a one-to-one instructional assistant III for six hours a day. That aide was qualified to help with schoolwork and also to empty or change her urostomy bag. In spring 2001 the District replaced that aide with an instructional assistant II, who could not provide health care, and planned to have the school's only health clerk handle the bag.

Hearing Officer Van T. Vu found that this plan would not meet the student's needs. Bag leaks were unpredictable and needed fast attention. The aide often had no phone nearby, for example on the playground. The health clerk also served about 700 students. The District was ordered to provide an instructional assistant III six hours a day through the 2002 extended school year (ESY).

The Hearing Officer also found that the special day class teacher had regularly sent the student's one-to-one aide to teach small groups of other students. That changed the student's services without the IEP team's approval. Compensatory aide time was denied, because there was no evidence of harm and the student had made good progress. Finally, the District charged more than the actual cost of copying records. Because it never cashed the parents' check, it was ordered to return the check, and the parents must pay ten cents per copy.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a "one-to-one" aide as serving only the named student. A teacher could not reassign the aide to other students without IEP team action. It also shows that a district's chosen way of delivering health services must work in practice, and that copy charges for records were limited to actual cost.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I. Does Student require the assistance of an instructional assistant III as a related service from the present through the end of the 2002 extended school year?

    The District's plan to use an instructional assistant II plus the school's only health clerk could not reliably meet Student's unpredictable, time-sensitive urostomy needs. Student requires an instructional assistant III through the 2002 ESY.

  2. Not reachedIEP procedure

    Issue II. Did the District inappropriately replace Student's instructional assistant III with an instructional assistant II without the agreement of the IEP team?

    Not adjudicated, because Issue I already granted the remedy sought.

  3. Student prevailedRecords

    Issue III. Did the District charge the parents more than the 'actual cost' of reproducing Student's educational records?

    The District corrected the miscount of copies. It never corrected the 15-cent rate or the staff-time fee, both above its own 10-cent actual-cost rate under Education Code section 56504.

  4. District prevailedRecords

    Issue IV. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for any charges in excess of the actual cost of copying Student's educational records?

    No reimbursement because the District never cashed the parents' check. The District must return the check, and the parents must pay 10 cents per copy.

  5. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue V. Did the District fail to provide Student with a one-to-one aide during the 2000-2001 school year?

    The special day class teacher redirected Student's IEP-required one-to-one aide to lead small groups of other students during instruction. That was a change in services only the IEP team could make. The violation ran from late October 2000.

  6. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue VI. Is Student entitled to compensatory education in the form of one-to-one aide services equal to the amount of time the District denied such services?

    Compensatory aide time was denied. The current-year aide was already ordered, there was no evidence of how the lost services harmed Student, and Student made substantial progress on her goals.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. District shall continue to provide Student with the services of an instructional assistant III for six hours per day until the end of the 2002 extended school year.
  • Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the District shall return to the parents the uncashed check for copies of Student's records (the order dates the check July 13, 2001). The parents then shall pay the District the actual cost of the records, set at ten cents per copy.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696; Todd v. Andrews; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Education Code § 56504; Education Code § 56363; 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, Attachment 1 (comment to § 300.340)

People named in the decision

  • Elizabeth (Beth) Jensen, school nurse, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Rosemary Voelker, special day class teacher, Vail Elementary School
  • Nancy Fouts, special day class teacher and inclusion specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Arlene Williams, health clerk, Vail Elementary School
  • Lisa Solarzano, instructional assistant III, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Penny Kubly, principal, Vail Elementary School
  • Catherine McIntyre, school nurse, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Debra Leeper, instructional assistant III (Student's aide), Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Jana Main, secretary to the principal, Vail Elementary School
  • Deborah Miller, director of special education, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Christa Smith, program specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Mike Runyen, director of child welfare and attendance, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Kim Kaffka, instructional aide III (Student's one-to-one aide, April 1998 to April 2001), Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Richard Glock, assistant superintendent for educational support services, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Guadalupe "Lupita" Arias, instructional assistant II, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Judy Lotspeich, third grade general education teacher, Vail Elementary School
  • Chris Cordner, assistant superintendent of human resources, Temecula Valley Unified School District
  • Patti-Jo Picinich, special day class teacher, Vail Elementary School
  • Jim Madden, associate attorney for Student, working with J.S. Hermanson

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Temecula, California, on September 18 and 19, October 3, 4, 5, and 22, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at hearing by attorney J.S. Hermanson. Petitioner’s parents, PARENTS, were also present on her behalf. Jim Madden, an associate working with Mr. Hermanson, was present on September 19, 2001. Observing the hearing were STUDENT’s maternal grandparents, GRANDPARENTS, and STUDENT’s brothers, BROTHERS. Other persons observing the hearing were Linda Betts, Patrick Bourassa, and Lieutenant Colonel Linda Ray Tyler, some of the PARENTS’ family friends.

Respondent Temecula Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Alexa Jackowski. Deborah Miller, the director of special education, and Christa Smith, a program specialist, were also present on the District’s behalf.

The District, which presented its case first, called the following witnesses to testify at hearing: Elizabeth Jensen, school nurse; Rosemary Voelker, special day class teacher at Vail Elementary School; Nancy Fouts, special day class teacher and inclusion specialist; Arlene Williams, health clerk; Lisa Solarzano, instructional assistant III; Penny Kubly, principal of Vail Elementary School; Catherine McIntyre, school nurse; Debra Leeper, instructional assistant III; and Jana Main, secretary to Penny Kubly. Deborah Miller and Christa Smith also testified on behalf of the District.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Mike Runyen, director of child welfare and attendance; Kim Kaffka, instructional aide III; Richard Glock, assistant superintendent for educational support services; Guadalupe “Lupita” Arias, instructional assistant II; Judy Lotspeich, third grade regular education teacher at Vail Elementary School; Chris Cordner, assistant superintendent of human resources; and Patti-Jo Picinich, special day class teacher at Vail Elementary School. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT also testified on STUDENT’s behalf. Additionally, Petitioner called back Debra Leeper, Rosemary Voelker and Elizabeth Jensen.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and written closing briefs were received by the Hearing Office on November 26 and 27, 2001. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

New Issue:

On October 4, 2001, during the fourth day of hearing, the Petitioner moved to add the additional issue of whether the District failed to provide her with one-to-one aide services during the 2000-2001 school year. The District objected to Petitioner’s motion as untimely. After discussions with the parties, the Hearing Officer determined that Petitioner’s issue was extremely limited in scope, the issue was related to the aide services already at issue, and that the hearing would not be unduly extended by adding the new issue. Thus, in order to foster judicial economy and to ensure that all relevant issues pertaining to STUDENT’s education during the time periods in dispute were timely and effectively resolved, the Petitioner’s request was granted. Prior to the last day of hearing, the District was given adequate time to research and prepare for the new issue.

Closing Briefs:

The parties’ closing briefs were originally due to be received at the Hearing Office on November 12, 2001. However, on November 9, 2001, the parties jointly requested an extension of the deadline for the submission of closing briefs until November 16, 2001. The parties’ request was granted by minute order of the Hearing Office on the same date. Then, on November 19, 2001, the parties jointly requested another extension to the deadline for the submission of closing briefs “due to personal reasons.” Specifically, the parties requested that they be allowed to mail the briefs by no later than November 19, 2001.

The parties’ joint request was granted. The record was held open until the receipt of the parties’ closing briefs and those briefs were considered in the rendering of this decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

I. Does STUDENT require the assistance of an instructional assistant III as a related service from the present through the end of the 2002 extended school year?

II. Did the District inappropriately replace STUDENT’s instructional assistant III with an instructional assistant II without the agreement of the individualized education program team?

III. Did the District charge the PARENTS more than the “actual cost” of reproducing STUDENT’s educational records?

IV. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for any charges in excess of the actual cost of copying STUDENT’s educational records?

V. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide during the 2000-2001 school year?

VI. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of one-to-one aide services equal to the amount of time the District denied such services?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a ten-year-old fourth-grader who has been eligible for special education and related services since 1994 as a student with “multiple impairments.” STUDENT suffers from “multiple congenital anomalies as well as scoliosis, fused kidneys, neurogenic [bowel], vertbral [sic] anomalies, missing lower vertebrae, … covered right ear, imperforate anus, and bilateral Duane’s retraction syndrome.” (Dist. Exh. 30 at page 2.) Additionally, STUDENT has mild ataxia, mild asthma, cerebral palsy, an immature retina, and an allergy to latex. As a result of her disabilities, STUDENT has developmental delays, renal and bowel movement difficulties, deafness in her right ear, severe astigmatism, the inability to move her eyes from side to side, and impaired fine and gross motor skills. Due to her renal and bowel problems, STUDENT also has a urostomy bag for the drainage of urine and a cecostomy “button” for manual voiding of her neurogenic bowel. (Id.; Test. of MOTHER; see also Pet. Closing Brief.) While at school, STUDENT’s urostomy bag must be emptied at least once per day and changed as needed when the bag PARENTS.(Footnote 2) (Test. of MOTHER, Kim Kaffka, and Elizabeth Jensen.) Although no special education support services are required pertaining to the cecostomy “button,” the button should be inspected at least once per day to ensure that it has not been dislodged. (Test. of Kim Kaffka.) STUDENT currently attends the fourth grade at Vail Elementary School within the District. STUDENT lives at home with her adoptive parents and two older brothers.

Until the fall of her third grade year, STUDENT was fully integrated into the general education program with a one-to-one instructional assistant III, RSP pull-out, and various related services.(Footnote 3) On October 23, 2000, MOTHER consented to changing STUDENT’s placement to a special day class for reading and writing and math, and placement in general education at all other times during her school day. (Dist. Exh. 16.) Other than the change in placement and the addition of transition specialist consultation services once per week, all other aspects of STUDENT’s education program remained the same, including the services of a one-to-one instructional assistant III throughout the six hours of her school day. (Id.; see also Dist. Exh. 19.)

From November 2000 through mid-January 2001, STUDENT missed from twenty to thirty-two days of school due to three surgeries, illnesses, and various complications of her surgeries.(Footnote 4) (Testimony of MOTHER; Dist. Exh. 15.) On January 19, 2001, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss, in part, STUDENT’s numerous absences from school. (Dist. Exh. 15.) At the meeting, program specialist Christa Smith questioned STUDENT’s need for a one-to-one instructional assistant III. However, the IEP team agreed not to change STUDENT’s aide services at that time and also agreed that they would revisit issue of STUDENT’s need for the aide when her health improved. (Id.)

STUDENT’s IEP team convened again on February 13 and on April 19, 2001, at which time the topic of the reassignment of STUDENT’s medical aide was again raised. (Dist. Exhs. 9 and 13.) During the April IEP meeting, the District proposed to change the services of a health instructional assistant III to services provided by an instructional assistant and a health clerk. (Dist. Exh. 9.) The District’s proposal to change the instructional assistant services was met with some resistance from the parents. (Id.; see also Test. of MOTHER.) The parents did, however, finally agree to the transition but only on a trial basis. (Dist. Exh. 9.) The IEP that the parents signed on that date states:

Training of aides will begin on April 24 with a minimum of 8 days of training and 5 days of trial. After this trial period, team will meet to discuss the implementation of this new plan. Team agrees that the level of aide support that student is to receive will continue to be classified as a Health Aide III until the alternate service delivery model has been determined to be effective by the team meeting which was tentatively scheduled for May 14, 2001 at 1:00.(Footnote 5)

On May 14, after the aide training and trial period, the IEP team met. (Dist. Exh. 7.) The team was not able to agree on the effectiveness of the alternate service delivery model. (Id.) The IEP from May 14 states, “Some team members feel this is working. Others feel that it is not. Parents do not agree with this.” The parents did not agree that the new model was effective for STUDENT and requested that STUDENT again be provided with the instructional assistant III. (Id.) The District refused.

On May 23, 2001, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested a special education due process hearing to resolve the dispute with the District regarding STUDENT’s need for an instructional assistant III. On May 31, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested stay put to reinstate the service of an instructional assistant III for STUDENT. By Order of the Hearing Office dated June 11, 2001, the parents’ request for stay put was granted. While the District reassigned an instructional assistant III to STUDENT the next day, they did not return STUDENT’s original instructional assistant III, Kim Kaffka, to the position. (Test. of MOTHER.) Ms. Kaffka worked with STUDENT from April 1998 through the end of April 2001, when she was replaced with the instructional assistant II. (Test. of Kim Kaffka.)

On June 8, 2001, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested from the District copies of STUDENT’s educational records. (Student Exh. 38.) When FATHER went to the District to pick up the records five days later, he was presented with a bill for 1009 copies at a rate of fifteen cents per copy and an additional labor charge of $8.58 per hour for 4.5 hours (for a total of $186.96). (Student Exh. 39.) FATHER gave a check to the District for the full amount requested in exchange for the copies of STUDENT’s records. Upon the review of the documents, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT discovered that they had only received approximately six hundred copies. (Student Exh. 41.) Additionally, they were informed by the District’s Superintendent’s office that the District’s standard charge for copies of student records is ten cents per copy, which includes both materials and labor(Footnote 6). (Id.) Michael Runyen, director of child welfare and attendance, verified that the policy of the District was to charge a flat fee of ten cents per copy for educational records.

PARENTS brought these discrepancies to the District’s attention the next day, and they were later informed that they had been mistakenly charged for 1009 copies due to a clerical error and that they only should have been charged for a little over six hundred copies. (Id.; Test. of Ms. Kubly and Ms. Main.) The PARENTS were also informed that their check would not be cashed and that they would need to resubmit another check for the approximately six hundred copies. (Test. of Ms. Main.) No mention was made regarding the overcharge of five cents per copy and the “staff” fee. (Id.; see also Dist. Exh. 50.) To date, the PARENTS’ check remains uncashed and in the possession of the District. (Test. of Ms. Kubly.)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. Does STUDENT require the assistance of an instructional assistant III as a related service from the present through the end of the 2002 extended school year?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are school health services to be provided by a school nurse or other qualified individual. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363; 34 C.F.R. § 300.24(b)(12).

In this case, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT requires school health services to empty and change her urostomy bag in order for her to benefit from her education. The parties also do not dispute that STUDENT requires a one-to-one aide for six hours per day to help her with her academics.(Footnote 7) Specifically, the aide helps STUDENT with her schoolwork, helps her to integrate into the general education environment, helps her to attend to tasks, modifies her class work, and maintains communication between STUDENT’s teachers and providers regarding her needs. The parties only disagree as to the level of STUDENT’s health needs and the method of delivery of STUDENT’s school health services.(Footnote 8) Petitioner argues that she requires an instructional assistant III, who could meet both her health and academic needs throughout the school day. The District argues that STUDENT’s academic needs could be met with an instructional assistant II, and that her health needs are limited in scope and could be met through the health clerk a few minutes per day.

Under the District’s plan, STUDENT would be assisted by an instructional assistant II throughout her school day. When the need to empty or change her urostomy bag arises, the aide would use a classroom phone to call the health clerk at her office located in the school office. The aide would then walk with STUDENT to the bathroom, where the health clerk would meet them to empty or change STUDENT’s urostomy bag. According to the District, STUDENT’s bag generally only needs to be emptied once per day and her bag rarely requires changing and, thus, her health needs typically only require approximately five minutes of the health clerk’s time. In contrast, Petitioner argues that STUDENT’s needs are more extensive and that an instructional assistant III, who is already assigned to STUDENT throughout the day for academic purposes, could provide the needed health services immediately as the situation arises.

The evidence supports Petitioner’s position. When conditions are ideal (i.e., STUDENT’s needs are predictable and not time sensitive, STUDENT’s instructional assistant II has access to a phone to call the health clerk, the health clerk is at a location where she can be reached, and the health clerk is available to tend to STUDENT), the District’s delivery of services through the instructional assistant II and health clerk would likely meet STUDENT’s health needs. However, that is not the situation in this case.

First, while STUDENT’s urostomy bag can be emptied on a schedule and in a relatively short time, delay in emptying the bag when it is significantly filled could result in the bag pulling away from its adhesive and leaking. (Test. of MOTHER and Ms. Jensen.) Additionally, it cannot be predicted when STUDENT’s bag will leak for other reasons, which would result in her requiring more extensive services to change the bag. According to MOTHER, STUDENT’s bag required changing four times during the first six weeks of the current school year.(Footnote 9) Aside from the times when the bag actually requires changing, there are many more times when STUDENT suspects that the bag is leaking and requests that the condition of the bag be checked. If the bag is leaking, it requires changing immediately or else the urine from the bag will leak onto and soil STUDENT’s clothing, which greatly upsets and embarrasses her. (Test. of Arlene Williams and MOTHER.) Thus, STUDENT’s needs related to the urostomy bag are more involved and unpredictable than the District contends.

Second, while STUDENT’s instructional aide may be able to quickly contact the health clerk by telephone in the classroom, there are times throughout STUDENT’s school day when the aide would not have immediate access to a telephone to seek the health clerk’s assistance. For example, a phone is not readily accessible when STUDENT is on the playground. If STUDENT requires health services while she is on the playground, the instructional assistant II would need to either walk to the health clerk’s office to find the health clerk or walk to a classroom to use a classroom phone. (Test. of Arlene Williams and Lupita Arias.) Ms. Arias, STUDENT’s instructional assistant II during April and May 2000, testified that she had to walk with STUDENT to a nearby classroom when STUDENT requested health services while on the playground in order to contact the health clerk. According to Arlene Williams, the health clerk at Vail Elementary School who would serve STUDENT under the District’s plan, if she is not present when the aide calls her, the office personnel could contact her by walkie-talkie or pager.(Footnote 10) In such an event, STUDENT’s health services would be delayed, possibly risking leakage to the bag or resulting in STUDENT waiting in urine-soaked clothing as the health clerk is located.

Third, the Hearing Officer is not convinced that health clerk Arlene Williams is always available to adequately provide STUDENT with health services. Ms. Williams testified that her responsibilities include tending to students when they are ill or injured. She also testified that she is the only health clerk at Vail Elementary School and that there are approximately seven hundred students at that school for whom she is responsible. By her count, she sees between fifteen to twenty students on an average day for health related matters, and she acknowledged that the students seek her services throughout the day whenever the need arises. While Ms. Williams is qualified to provide STUDENT with health services, her availability to provide such services is affected by her other, extensive duties. In light of the unpredictability of Ms. William’s schedule and the unpredictability of STUDENT’s need to check or change her urostomy bag, Ms. William’s ability to readily provide STUDENT with health services is inconsistent at best and is premised on many contingencies out of her control.

In light of STUDENT’s specific health needs and the logistical problems related to the District’s proposal to serve those needs with a health clerk, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposal would not meet STUDENT’s needs. The District’s proposed method of delivery of services is prone to unnecessary delay and would likely result in unacceptable harm to STUDENT. In comparison, it is undisputed that STUDENT’s health (as well as academic) needs could be handled quickly, efficiently, and appropriately through the services of an instructional assistant III. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires an instructional assistant III from the present through the 2002 extended school year.

II. Did the District inappropriately replace STUDENT’s instructional assistant III with an instructional assistant II without the agreement of the individualized education program team?

Petitioner asserts that the District inappropriately failed to return her instructional assistant III services after the IEP meeting on May 14, 2001. In raising this alleged procedural violation as an issue, Petitioner again requested a finding that she be entitled to the services of an instructional assistant III from the present through the end of the 2002 extended school year. Because it was found above that Petitioner is entitled to such services, it is unnecessary to consider this issue.

III. Did the District charge the PARENTS more than the “actual cost” of reproducing STUDENT’s educational records?(Footnote 11)

California Education Code Section 56504 grants parents the right and opportunity to examine all school records of the child and to receive copies within five days after such request is made. A public educational agency may charge no more than the actual cost of reproducing such records. Cal. Educ. Code § 56504.

In this case, Petitioner contends that the District charged her parents an unreasonable rate for the copies of her educational records (1) by charging them for approximately four hundred more copies than were provided to her, (2) by charging them five cents per copy over the District’s standard rate for copies, and (3) by charging them a fee for “staff” time to copy the charges. The District acknowledges that it initially charged the PARENTS for more copies than were provided to them and at a higher cost than they should have been charged. The District asserts that the overcharge was due to a clerical mistake in computing the number of copies made and a misunderstanding regarding the rate at which the District charges for copies. However, the District asserts that when the overcharge was brought to its attention the next day, the mistake was corrected by adjusting the copy charge to the actual number of copies provided and at the standard District rate of ten cents per copy. Additionally, the District has never cashed the PARENTS’ check and has offered to return the check when another check for the adjusted amount is provided.

While the evidence indicates that the District appropriately corrected the mistake of charging the PARENTS for more copies than were provided to them, there is no indication, as the District contends, that the District ever attempted to correct the mistake of overcharging them for the cost per copy and of charging them for the staff time to make the copies. (Test. of Ms. Kubly and Ms. Main; Dist. Exh. 50.) Mike Runyen, the District’s director of child welfare and attendance, testified that the District’s policy for the duplication of student records is a flat ten cents per copy. He also testified that while the District originally charged fifteen cents per copy, a communication was sent to all principals’ offices within the district last year to inform District staff of the revised policy of charging only ten cents per copy. Thus, the staff at Vail Elementary School should have been on notice of the appropriate charge for copying educational records. Moreover, it is uncontested that the District’s charge of ten cents per copy is the “actual cost” of reproducing educational records. Because the District never corrected the overcharge for the cost per copy and the staff copying fee, the PARENTS were still required to pay more for the copies than the actual cost of copying the documents according to the District’s own witness. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS were charged in excess of the actual cost of reproducing STUDENT’s educational records.

IV. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for any charges in excess of the actual cost of copying STUDENT’s educational records?

Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for charges in excess of the actual cost of reproducing such records. Although it was found above that the PARENTS provided the District a check for more than they were required to pay for STUDENT’s education records, the undisputed evidence indicates that the District never cashed the PARENTS’ check. Thus, there is no reimbursement to order. Accordingly, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement is denied.

However, the Hearing Officer notes that the District is still entitled to a copy fee for reproducing the records but is not entitled to the amount of the PARENTS’ check that it currently possesses. Thus, the District is ordered to return the check to the PARENTS and the PARENTS are ordered to pay the District for the cost of the records at ten cents per copy.

V. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide during the 2000-2001 school year? (Footnote 12) As was noted above, as part of the provision of FAPE, districts must provide a child with special education and related services that conform to the student’s individualized educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). Petitioner contends that her May 2000 IEP required the District to provide her with a one-to-one instructional assistant III for six hours per day during the 2000-2001 school year, but that her aide was often used to lead small-group instruction of other students in her class. The District essentially asserts that the use of STUDENT’s aide to assist other students in small groups is appropriate and is described as a function of the aide in the aide’s job description. Basically, the District asserts that a “one-to-one” aide does not necessarily have to shadow a student all of the time.

The District’s argument fails. The very definition of “special education” emphasizes that the instruction must be specifically designed to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s May 2000 IEP indicates that she be provided a “one-to-one” aide. (Dist. Exh. 19 at page 11.) While the District is correct that the IEP also states that STUDENT’s aide be an instructional assistant III, it overlooks the distinction between the requirement that the aide be “one-to-one” and the requirement that the aide be a “health” aide. Regardless of the aide’s general employment job description, STUDENT’s IEP qualified that her health aide be also one-to-one. The District’s argument that a one-to-one aide may assist other students is also unpersuasive. By its definition, a “one-to-one” aide requires that the one aide be responsible for only one student. To interpret the descriptor otherwise and allow the aide to be used as a general classroom aide would deprive STUDENT of services the IEP team determined she needs.

With all of that said, the uncontested evidence established that STUDENT’s aides during the 2000-2001 school year were redirected by special day class teacher Rosemary Voelker to lead small group instruction during a significant portion of STUDENT’s time in her class. (Test. of Kim Kaffka and Ms. Leeper.) By all accounts, Ms. Voelker decided when STUDENT’s aides would work with STUDENT and when they would work with other students. Although Ms. Leeper and Ms. Kaffka testified that STUDENT did not appear to require their assistance while they were assisting other students, decisions regarding changes in the child’s special education services are up to the IEP team and not any individual person.(Footnote 13) While STUDENT’s IEPs do indicate that her aide should be faded to foster independence during peer socialization time (such as lunch time), the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s aides were redirected during her instruction time in the special day class and not only when she was interacting with peers. From the above, it is concluded that the District failed to provide STUDENT with necessary services during the 2000-2001 school year. Because the evidence provided related only to violations occuring during the time in Ms. Voelker’s class, and because STUDENT did not enter Ms. Voelker’s class until late October 2000, the Hearing Officer finds that the violations occurred from late October 2000, at the earliest.

VI. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of one-to-one aide services equal to the amount of time the District denied such services?

Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996). Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991). There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief... Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994). Equitable considerations are therefore appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies.

Petitioner requests compensatory education in the form of instructional assistant III services for a time equivalent to that which was denied her in Ms. Voelker’s class, to be provided during the current school year. As the Hearing Officer has already found above that Petitioner is entitled to such aide services during this time, an order for the same services as compensatory education appears unnecessary.

The Hearing Officer also declines to order the aide services for the following school year because STUDENT’s aide services for that year have yet to be determined. Additionally, although the evidence indicates that District’s failure to provide her all of her aide services may have deprived her of the opportunity to work on assistive technology programs such as the “Co-Writer” to assist her language skills, the evidence is void as to how such deprivation actually, or likely, would have affected her. Moreover, Petitioner never alleged that she failed to progress during the 2000-2001 school year, and her IEPs indicate that she substantially progressed towards meeting her goals. Without information as to how the loss of educational opportunity adversely affected STUDENT, it is impossible to fashion a compensatory education remedy. In summary, Petitioner’s request for compensatory education is denied.

ORDER

1. The District shall continue to provide STUDENT with the services of an instructional assistant III for six hours per day until the end of the 2002 extended school year.

2. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall return to the PARENTS the check the PARENTS provided to the District on July 13, 2001. Upon return of the check, the PARENTS shall pay the District for the actual cost of the reproduction of STUDENT’s educational records, which is determined to be ten cents per copy.

3. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

I. Does STUDENT require the assistance of an instructional assistant III as a related service from the present through the end of the 2002 extended school year? -The Petitioner prevailed.

II. Did the District inappropriately replace STUDENT’s instructional assistant III with an instructional assistant II without the agreement of the individualized education program team? -This issue was not adjudicated.

III. Did the District charge the PARENTS more than the “actual cost” of reproducing STUDENT’s educational records? -The Petitioner prevailed.

IV. Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for any charges in excess of the actual cost of copying STUDENT’s educational records? -The District prevailed.

V. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide during the 2000-2001 school year? -The Petitioner prevailed.

VI. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of one-to-one aide services equal to the amount of time the District denied such services? -The District prevailed.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: December 21, 2001 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Petitioner’s issues have been framed to reflect the discussions with the parties and for proper analysis 2. According to the District’s Exhibit 49, to empty STUDENT’s urostomy bag, a qualified individual must “Pull cap off bag, hold it up to the right side… Move valve from left to right to open… Squeeze bag from top and work down to empty [c]ontents into the toilet…Tap/Shake bag while it is still down… Turn bag up, close valve, and replace cap.” By all accounts, the procedure for emptying the urostomy bag takes approximately five minutes.

The procedure for changing the urostomy bag when it leaks entails removing STUDENT’s clothes, removing and discarding the urostomy bag, placing a warm towel over the stoma (i.e., opening) to absorb drainage, placing a circle of “stomahesive… on [a] wafer,” allowing the stomahesive to dry, using an adhesive remover to remove the old adhesive on the skin, washing and drying the stoma area, placing the wafer on the skin, warming the adhesive for several minutes with the fingers, attaching a new urostomy bag onto the wafer, attaching the urostomy bag onto a belt, and assisting STUDENT with putting on clean clothes. (Dist. Exh. 49.) By all accounts, the process for changing STUDENT’s urostomy bag generally takes approximately thirty minutes. 3. According to the District’s job specification, an instructional assistant III is qualified to provide both health-related support services and instructional assistance in the classroom. (Student Exh. 51.) As is discussed below, the District proposed to change STUDENT’s aide services from an instructional assistant III to services provided by an instructional assistant II and a health clerk. In comparison to the instructional assistant III, an instructional assistant II provides instructional assistance and support in the classroom but no health services. (Student Exh. 52.) Additionally, a health clerk is a person trained to provide limited health services under the supervision of a nurse. (Student Exh. 53.) 4. According to MOTHER, STUDENT had three surgeries during the fall of 2000, at least one of which was to install a cecostomy tube to assist with STUDENT’s bowel movement. The cecostomy tube was later replaced during another surgery in February 2001 with the “button” that she currently has. 5. The parties and witnesses in this matter often interchanged the term “instructional assistant III” with the term “health aide III.” 6. According to Petitioner, the PARENTS should have only been charged approximately $60 for the copies of STUDENT’s educational records, which is one third of what the District originally charged them. 7. As discussed below, although the District does not dispute that STUDENT’s requires a ”one-to-one aide” for academic support, the parties differ as to whether the aide assigned to STUDENT can assist other students in STUDENT’s classroom 8. Petitioner does not dispute the District’s general proposition that districts have discretion to determine how services outlined in an IEP are to be provided. However, Petitioner argues that the change in the way her services would be delivered under the District’s plan would result in a substantive change in her services because the services (as provided) would no longer be designed to meet her unique needs. Because the District is ultimately responsible for providing STUDENT with a FAPE regardless of the manner in which the services are delivered, the analysis of this issue will consider whether the District’s plan meets STUDENT’s health needs 9. The Hearing Officer notes that the hearing in this matter convened and ended during the first two months of the current school year. 10. Although Vail Elementary School is also served by various school nurses, there are times when no nurses are present at the school campus. At those times, the nurses are on-call and can reach the school up to twelve minutes from being paged. (Test. of Beth Jensen.) 11. Petitioner originally framed her issue as whether the District charged her parents an “unreasonable” fee for the cost of copying her educational records. Because California law requires that the District’s charge only the “actual cost” of reproducing the records rather than a “reasonable” fee, the Hearing Officer rephrased Petitioner’s issue to correspond with the existing legal standard. 12. The Hearing Officer notes that this issue overlaps with issue II above in that the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with the health aide services could have resulted from the District’s alleged procedural violation during this time. However, the Petitioner did not raise the alleged procedural violation under this issue and requested a different remedy here than raised in issue II. Thus, no mention of the alleged procedural violation will be discussed under this section. In any event, there is no evidence that STUDENT was prejudiced by the alleged procedural violation and, therefore, it would not have been considered in fashioning a compensatory education remedy below. 13. According to the comments following the regulations to the IDEA, specific day to day adjustments in instructional methods and approaches that are made by a special education teacher to assist a disabled child to achieve his or her annual goals would not normally require action by the child’s IEP team. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, Attachment 1, Comment regarding §300.340. However, the commentors noted that changes to the child’s services or program modifications must be addressed by an IEP team. Id. Therefore, changes to STUDENT’s aide services is a change that requires IEP team input. In any event, there is no significant evidence that the redirecting of STUDENT’s aide to assist other students was for the purpose of assisting STUDENT to achieve any of her annual goals. Accordingly, the limited exception to the requirement that any changes in a student’s IEP be made by an IEP team does not apply in this case.