California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 7, 1997

Student v. Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1090-95 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Santa Monica-Malibu Unified need not reimburse Park Century tuition but must pay a psychiatrist's IEP meeting attendance costs.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 5 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that the prior decision on the 1994-1995 placement (SN 319-94) was affirmed by the U.S. District Court, Central District of California, on December 7, 1995 (23 IDELR 543). There is no subsequent history of this decision in the document.

Summary

A sixth grader filed this case against Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District. He was eligible for special education because of specific learning disabilities in reading and written language. He also had ADHD and Tourette's Syndrome, which caused tics and required frequent medication changes. His mother placed him at Park Century School, a nonpublic school, in fall 1994. An earlier SEHO decision (SN 319-94), later affirmed by a federal district court, found the District's offer for 1994-1995 appropriate. The family now sought Park Century reimbursement for spring 1995 and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years. It also sought payment for the treating psychiatrist, Dr. Patrick Bezdek.

The Hearing Officer held that a prior placement decision can be revisited if circumstances materially change. But the student's tics and needs had always varied, and the evidence showed no significant change. Res judicata therefore barred relitigating spring 1995. For the next two years, the Hearing Officer found Carol Gibson Timmerman's special day class at Grant Elementary appropriate. It was small and structured and offered one-to-one instruction, a strong behavior system, and mainstreaming. The District also offered speech therapy, counseling, and adapted physical education. Tuition reimbursement was denied. Dr. Bezdek's office visits were medication management, a medical service the District need not fund. His expertise was essential to the IEP team, however. On proof, the District must reimburse the cost of his attending IEP meetings since 1994.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied res judicata to a repeat placement claim, allowing a fresh look only if the student's condition materially changed. It also separates a psychiatrist's medication management, treated as a medical service the District need not pay for, from his participation as an IEP team member, which the Hearing Officer found reimbursable.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Did STUDENT's condition after October 1994 necessitate that he remain at Park Century School for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year?

    A material change in circumstances could justify revisiting the placement, but the student's tics and needs had always varied and showed no significant change after the prior hearing (SN 319-94), so res judicata barred relitigating the spring 1995 placement; the District prevailed.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did the District offer an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

    The special day class at Grant Elementary was small and structured and offered one-to-one instruction, a behavior system, and mainstreaming, plus offered speech-language, counseling, and adapted PE; it met the student's unique needs and was designed to provide educational benefit for both years.

  3. Issue 3. Was Park Century School an appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENT for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

    Not decided because the District offered an appropriate placement.

  4. Issue 4. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT's placement at Park Century School, including tuition, transportation, and related expenditures, for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

    Because the District offered an appropriate placement for each year, it is not responsible for Park Century costs.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Is STUDENT's parent entitled to reimbursement for the related service of counseling/therapy provided by Patrick Bezdek, M.D.?

    The psychiatrist's office visits were medication management, a medical service the District need not fund, but his expertise was essential to the IEP team, so the District must reimburse the cost of his IEP meeting attendance; the District substantially prevailed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 15 days of proof from the mother, the District shall reimburse her for the costs of Dr. Patrick Bezdek's attending IEP meetings from 1994 to the present. No dollar amount stated.
  • Reimbursement for Park Century School placement denied; reimbursement for other services by Dr. Bezdek denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Clovis Unified School Dist. v. California Office of Administrative Hearings; Nakash v. Superior Court; Guardianship of Case; Letter to Breecher (1990) 16 IDELR 1401; Landgraf v. USI Film Products; Arnold v. Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District (C.D. Cal. 1995) 23 IDELR 543

People named in the decision

  • Rick E. Bagley, District director of student services / pupil personnel, Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District
  • Patrick Bezdek, M.D., treating psychiatrist; witness for Student, Private
  • Jill Rosten, Park Century teacher (1994-1995); private educational therapist, Park Century School
  • Teri Solochek, Ph.D., clinical psychologist and private educational consultant; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Deborah Early, reading and mathematics specialist, Park Century School
  • Meryl Kesten, Park Century teacher (1995-1996), Park Century School
  • Jon Hay, Park Century teacher (1996-1997) and physical education teacher, Park Century School
  • Carol Gibson Timmerman, special day class teacher, District's proposed placement (also referred to as Geralyn Timmerman), Grant Elementary School, Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District
  • Jerry Lee Harns, Ph.D., adapted physical education assessor, Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District
  • Ruth Punt, speech and language pathologist; assessor, Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District
  • Jack Herman Schnel, Ed.D., educational psychologist; assessed student for District, Palos Verdes school district / private practice
  • John M. Bayne, Jr., Student's attorney in prior hearing SN 319-94
  • Park Century School, nonpublic school (unilateral parent placement), Santa Monica

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Monica, California, on October 21-24, 1996, January 21 and 22, and March 20, 1997. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother. Respondent Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Sharon A. Watt. Also present on behalf of the District was Rick E. Bagley, District director of student services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on May 12, 1997, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Did STUDENT’s condition after October 1994 necessitate that he remain at Park Century School for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year?

(2) Did the District offer an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

(3) Was Park Century School an appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENT for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

(4) Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s placement at Park Century School, including tuition, transportation, and related expenditures, for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

(5) Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the related service of counseling/therapy provided by Patrick Bezdek, M.D.?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a 11-year-old boy who is in the sixth grade. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of specific learning disabilities (SLD) in reading and written language. He has been diagnosed with an attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD) and Tourette’s Syndrome (TS).(Footnote1) STUDENT recently was also diagnosed with Asperger’s Syndrome.(Footnote 2) STUDENT has been treated with a number of medications to alleviate tics and to address his behavioral needs. At the time of the hearing, Ritalin, Clonidine, Risperdal, and Vitamin E were prescribed by Patrick Bezdek, M.D., STUDENT’s treating psychiatrist. In the fall of 1994, STUDENT’s parent elected to enroll him in Park Century School, a certified nonpublic school in Santa Monica. STUDENT continues to attend Park Century.

STUDENT attended school in the District prior to his enrollment at Park Century. Beginning in the spring of 1991, while in preschool, STUDENT received speech and language services. At the end of STUDENT’s kindergarten year, speech and language services were discontinued. During the 1992-1993 school year, STUDENT was in a regular education first-grade class and received special education services in the resource specialist program (RSP). At the end of the first grade, the individualized educational program (IEP) team changed STUDENT’s special education eligibility from other health impaired (OHI) to SLD. The team recommended continuing STUDENT’s placement in a regular class with RSP and added speech and language services. STUDENT’s parent did not agree to the District’s proposed placement, declined special education services, and enrolled STUDENT in a regular second-grade class in the District. At an IEP meeting in March 1994, following STUDENT’s triennial assessment, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class (SDC) with counseling and speech and language services. STUDENT’s parent did not agree with the proposed placement. The District then agreed to maintain STUDENT in his regular class until the end of the school year and to provide him with RSP, counseling, and speech and language services. In June 1994, prior to the end of the school year, STUDENT’s parent withdrew him from the District based on the advice of Dr. Bezdek.

District members of the IEP team proposed placing STUDENT in Geralyn Timmerman’s SDC at Grant Elementary School for the 1994-1995 school year with the services of weekly counseling, twice-weekly speech and language therapy, and one-to-one tutoring in reading. STUDENT’s parent declined the District’s offer of placement and enrolled him in Park Century for the 1994-1995 school year. In a decision resulting from another due process hearing in December 1994 (SN 319-94) regarding the issue of the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 school year, it was concluded that the District’s offer of placement was appropriate and that STUDENT’s parent was not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attending Park Century. On December 7, 1995, the United States District Court Central District of California affirmed the decision of the Hearing Officer regarding STUDENT’s placement for the 1994-1995 school year. STUDENT by PARENT v. Santa-Malibu Unified School District (C.D. Cal. 1995) 95-1372; 23 IDELR 543.

On November 7, 1995, the Hearing Office received a new request for a special education due process hearing from Ms. Dobel on behalf of STUDENT (SN 1090-95).(Footnote 3) Petitioner contends that his medical condition worsened after the previous hearing, which further rendered inappropriate Ms. Timmerman’s class. Petitioner contends that the appropriate placement for the 1994-1995, 1995-1996, and 1996-1997 school years was Park Century. The District contends that Ms. Timmerman’s SDC supplemented with services including speech and language, counseling, and adapted physical education (APE) would have provided Petitioner an appropriate placement for each of the school years in question.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did STUDENT’s condition after October 1994 necessitate that he remain at Park Century for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.1; California Education Code § 56000.(Footnote 4) Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child. . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 176, 200. Special education law also requires that a student is educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 34 C.F.R. § 300.550. To summarize, under IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate education must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, comport with the student’s IEP, and be provided in the least restrictive environment.

Petitioner contends that following the close of the first due process hearing in November 1994, his medical and social-emotional status “took a nose dive.” He asserts that his tics surfaced at school and impacted his ability to function in class. He also became physically uncomfortable and self-conscious. For these reasons, Petitioner maintains that circumstances changed to such a degree that Ms. Timmerman’s class would not have afforded him with an appropriate placement for the second half of the 1994-1995 school year. Petitioner did not cite any authority for readdressing the issue of the appropriate placement for Petitioner for the 1994-1995 school year, which had been determined in the decision rendered as a result of the first special education due process hearing (SN 319-94). The District contends that the doctrine of res judicata precludes Petitioner from relitigating issues already heard and decided.(Footnote 5) The District also asserted that the court hearing the appeal of the first decision did not allow Petitioner to supplement the existing record of the hearing or to raise any change in circumstances or change to Petitioner’s condition that may have occurred after November 1994. It is not entirely clear from the Memorandum of Decision whether the court specifically addressed whether there was a change in circumstances. For this reason, the Hearing Officer addresses the question de novo.

A decision rendered in a special education due process hearing constitutes a final administrative determination and is binding on all parties. Education Code § 56505(g). The doctrine of res judicata bars a losing party from relitigating a new action on the same cause of action. In deciding whether the party is raising the same cause of action, one factor considered by courts is “whether the two suits arise out of the same transactional nucleus of facts.” Nakash v. Superior Court (1987) 196 Cal.App. 3d 59, 68. In determining that res judicata did not apply to the case before it, the Nakash court reasoned that ongoing business relationships in the case were “not unlike that of a marriage, where res judicata has had limited application, or of parental status where the courts have traditionally recognized the need for serial adjudication, dependent upon changes in circumstance.” Nakash, supra, p. 69. In one such parental status case, the court asserted that:

In the conduct of guardianship proceedings it is proper for the court always to consider changed conditions to the end that it may make such orders with respect to a guardianship as will prove to be for the welfare of the minor. A material change in the mode of life, habits, or behavior of petitioner in the period elapsing between the hearings of two successive petitions may justify the court in making new and different orders with reference to the guardianship.

Guardianship of Case (1943) 57 Cal.App.2d 844, 847.

In requiring that the IEPs of special education students undergo revision annually, special education law recognizes that the needs of children change.(Footnote 6) Thus, in special education cases, it is proper for the Hearing Officer to consider a material change in conditions which may justify providing a different educational program to the student. (See also Letter to Breecher (July 25, 1990) 16 IDELR 1401, which states that a determination to whether there is a res judicata effect depends, among other factors, whether circumstances have changed form the original complaint.)

As to whether there has been a material change in circumstances in this case following the hearing in November 1994, the testimony of Dr. Bezdek, who has treated STUDENT since 1991, establishes that STUDENT’s symptoms are subject to ongoing changes and that his medication regime also undergoes continuous revisions to attempt to alleviate the tics and to lessen the physical discomfort caused by the tics. Dr. Bezdek testified that a new combination of medications may be accompanied by changes to STUDENT’s tics and behavior. Dr. Bezdek currently sees STUDENT approximately once every two weeks. He primarily provides medication management for STUDENT and has had occasion to address some social and emotional issues as they arose. Dr. Bezdek testified that STUDENT has continued to exhibit severe ADHD, which has been only partially controlled by the equivalent of 30 mg. of Ritalin daily. Dr. Bezdek indicated that his concerns regarding STUDENT’s emotional status increased during the 1994-1995 school year. At one point STUDENT was hitting himself, talking about setting fires, and expressing somatic complaints. Dr. Bezdek attributed some changes in STUDENT’s behavior to the change in medications. He also described some improvement that STUDENT had made during the course of the school year. Dr. Bezdek’s testimony did not establish that changes to STUDENT occurred during a specific time frame or that the nature of his disabilities varied.

Jill Rosten, STUDENT’s teacher at Park Century during the 1994-1995, testified regarding changes to STUDENT following the last due process hearing. Ms. Rosten holds a teaching credential authorizing her to teach children with learning disabilities and, at the time she testified, was writing her thesis for a master’s degree in special education and multiculturalism. Ms. Rosten presently is a private educational therapist. Ms. Rosten’s testimony in the current hearing established that throughout the 1994-1995 school year STUDENT’s condition varied. There was a pattern of his tics worsening and then improving. The same applied to his comfort level in class and his academic achievement. Ms. Rosten testified that toward the end of fall 1994, STUDENT’s tics became more pronounced and were physically uncomfortable for him. For example, STUDENT complained that his neck hurt. The tics also interfered with his ability to keep his fingers on the home keys of the computer and affected his handwriting. STUDENT also became more self-conscious and concerned about how the other students perceived him. Ms. Rosten testified that STUDENT acted on her suggestion to speak to the other students about T.S. STUDENT presented a video about T.S. to his class and, because he felt so good about the presentation, he made a second presentation to another class. Ms. Rosten testified that toward the end of the school year, STUDENT’s self-confidence improved and he “buried” himself in his work. She also testified that STUDENT’s reading and math skills improved, as did his work habits. STUDENT was able to sit at his desk and was completing assignments.

MOTHER also testified regarding changes to STUDENT following the prior decision. It was unclear from MOTHER’s testimony whether the concerns she expressed occurred at a specific period of time during the 1994-1995 school year or, as it appeared to the Hearing Officer, occurred over the period of time that has elapsed since the prior hearing. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has continued to experience tics and that the tics have changed over time. She stated that he initially was happy to be at Park Century where he believed he was accepted and understood by the other students; however, the tics increased, and STUDENT reverted to having what she described as “rages,” and his fear of aliens escalated. STUDENT also expressed fear of other children, ghosts, wasps and bees, and people wearing capes. MOTHER testified that, at times, STUDENT has felt so bad about himself that he has pulled out his hair, stuck pencils in his arms, and hit himself. MOTHER testified that STUDENT stopped participating in any group activities such as scouting and did not have any friends. On the positive side, MOTHER stated that STUDENT enjoyed building things at home. He also has responded to positive reinforcement such as hugs, stickers, and books for stickers.

Petitioner’s tics and concerns about his social and educational deficits were described at length in the prior hearing and were taken into consideration in determining what constituted an appropriate placement for him for the 1994-1995 school year. The testimony during the prior hearing established that Petitioner’s tics and behavior have varied over time. Petitioner has not now established that at one particular point in time during the 1994-1995 school year that his tics or ongoing social and academic deficits changed dramatically. As discussed more fully below in Issue No. 2, the evidence establishes that Petitioner continued to have the same general special education needs in academic and social areas. The Hearing Officer concludes that in this case, Petitioner has not established that any changes to his tics, educational needs, or his social or emotional or behavioral status were remarkable or were of a significant magnitude. Thus, given the lack of substantial change in this case, the doctrine of res judicata bars Petitioner from relitigating his placement for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

1995-1996 School Year

STUDENT’s Educational Needs

In order to determine what constituted an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year, it is first necessary to define what his educational needs were at that time. Dr. Bezdek described STUDENT during the 1995-1996 and ensuing school years as “self-absorbed.” He stated that STUDENT perceverated on a topic of interest to him, lacked the ability to engage in reciprocal conversations with peers, lacked ongoing relationships with peers, and was more comfortable with adults. Dr. Bezdek continued to have concern about STUDENT’s ongoing tics and attentional problems, academic deficits, significant anxieties, speech deficits, and significant deficits in social skills. Dr. Bezdek also made recommendations regarding STUDENT’s instructional needs. He testified that STUDENT needed adults to provide him with structured social interactions. He recommended that individual social skills be broken down for STUDENT into small, concrete steps. Dr. Bezdek testified that an appropriate placement for STUDENT was in a small and safe educational environment that included opportunities for small-group and individual instruction. STUDENT’s needs included medication management at school and a staff sufficiently knowledgeable of the potential side effects from the medication to address needs as they may have arisen. Dr. Bezdek testified that appropriate rewards for STUDENT included use of the computer, opportunities to build something, and access to science-related toys.

Teri Solochek, Ph.D., is a clinical psychologist and private educational consultant. At the request of MOTHER, Dr. Solochek observed STUDENT at Park Century and at his home during February and March of 1996, for the purpose of making recommendations regarding an appropriate placement for him. She has not assessed STUDENT. Dr. Solochek made the following observations of STUDENT’s behavior at school: STUDENT exhibited head, neck, and shoulder tics; he fumbled with his notebook and fidgeted; he exhibited difficulty sitting and maintaining focus; he sought assistance from the teachers with great frequency; and in physical education, he required a lot of attention to get him involved in the activity. Dr. Solochek expressed concerns about STUDENT’s lack of peer interactions and stated that he may be “vulnerable” in a large environment because of his poor social skills. Dr. Solochek concluded that STUDENT needed to be taught social skills before he would be able to socialize with his peers. He also needed positive behavioral reinforcement to increase independent on task behavior, and to learn relaxation techniques and ways to release anxiety. Dr. Solochek testified that an appropriate placement for STUDENT was a small and safe environment where he would receive one-to-one instruction and an individualized program to address his needs. He also required speech and language therapy, adapted physical education, and counseling.

STUDENT’s IEP for the 1995-1996 school year includes a description of the placement requested by MOTHER:

STUDENT needs a small contained classroom with a maximum of 10-12 students with a teacher and instructional assistant, on a small structured campus with no more than 60 students, where STUDENT can participate fully in the school community, and have the opportunity for constant teacher feedback, intervention and redirection and maximum 1:1 instruction from STUDENT’s teachers (minimum of 3.5 hrs. Daily), and immediate staff availability to provide attention to STUDENT’s needs as they arise, and available safe, quiet space to allow privacy as needed to handle embarrassment and discomfort from STUDENT’s Tourette’s symptoms, as well as the ability of staff to monitor daily his medication needs and effect and coordinate with his parent and Dr. Bezdek.

(Petitioner’s Exhibit FF)

Ms. Rosten testified that when STUDENT was in her class, he required a lot of encouragement to socialize, frequent intervention from the teacher, and ongoing modifications to classroom activities to allow him to be successful. Ms. Rosten described STUDENT’s tics as “ongoing.” She stated that he chose not to leave the class to tic. As to academics, Ms. Rosten testified that STUDENT had difficulty formulating written expression and did not use cursive writing. In math, STUDENT performed multiplication functions. Ms. Rosten was not aware of STUDENT’s reading level.

Deborah Early is a reading and mathematics specialist at Park Century. Ms. Early holds regular and special education teaching credentials in Maryland and emergency teaching credentials in California. She is in the process of completing a master’s degree in special education. Ms. Early testified that when she began working with STUDENT in 1994, he was very fearful and would not even attempt to read because of his fear of failure. She began instructing him at a kindergarten level to foster success. By the end of the 1995 school year, STUDENT was reading at the beginning second-grade level in both decoding and comprehension. STUDENT has had difficulty with handwriting and, at times, his speech has been unintelligible. Ms. Early testified that an appropriate placement for STUDENT was in a small classroom environment where he could receive individualized instruction. In her opinion, STUDENT could only learn when material was presented to him in a one-to-one environment outside of the classroom. She anticipated that in a class with other students, STUDENT’s ticing would have been distracting and he would have been humiliating to him.

Meryl Kesten, STUDENT’s teacher at Park Century during the 1995-1996 school year, holds a master’s degree in special education and teaching credentials that authorize her to teach students in regular education classes and students with learning disabilities. Ms. Kesten testified that while in her class STUDENT required a lot of one-to-one instruction, prompting, cuing, and reinforcement. He also required constant refocusing and reminders to pay attention to task. He had difficulty structuring and beginning writing assignments. Actual handwriting was also difficult for STUDENT and he had problems spelling. Ms. Kesten reiterated that STUDENT required encouragement to mix with students. His interests were limited to computers, insects, and the solar system. Ms. Kesten testified that STUDENT had a lot of tics which could make him tired. He did leave her classroom frequently because of the tics. Ms. Kesten testified that STUDENT had a great fear of aliens and would not go to the bathroom alone. In general, Ms. Kesten recommended that STUDENT be educated in a small classroom with a structured and therapeutic environment that could address his social and academic needs and provide him with individual attention. Ms. Kesten expressed the opinion that STUDENT would be overwhelmed by the number of students in a regular public school.

Of primary concern to all of the witnesses was STUDENT’s significant lack of social skills. Additional deficits were identified in academic areas, especially in reading and written language, and in speech and language.(Footnote 7) Attention also presented as a problem area for STUDENT as well as the impact of his tics on his ability to sustain focus. The testimony of Dr. Bezdek and others establishes that STUDENT needed specific interventions to meet his needs, including having social skills taught to him by using a social skills curriculum and providing him opportunities for structured interactions with peers. The witnesses concurred that STUDENT required one-to-one instruction for academics because of attentional problems. Ms. Early, STUDENT’s reading teacher at Park Century testified that STUDENT can only learn when information is presented to him one-on-one; however, other witnesses who also testified on behalf of STUDENT did not agree that STUDENT required one-to-one instruction to the exclusion of small group instruction. STUDENT’s witnesses generally expressed concern about the potential for STUDENT to be stigmatized and embarrassed by having a one-to-one aide. Additionally STUDENT’s significant deficits in peer interactions would be amplified rather than ameliorated if he exclusively received individual instruction. Moreover, STUDENT has never exclusively received one-to-one instruction. At Park Century STUDENT receives individual math and reading instruction; however, he also participates in group learning with his classmates in science, social science, physical education, and other subject areas. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT required opportunities for one-to-one instruction, particularly in reading; however, he did not require an educational program that consisted exclusively of one-to-one instruction. (See also MOTHER’s description of an appropriate placement for STUDENT, Petitioner’s Exhibit FF) As to an appropriate educational environment, there was general agreement among the witnesses that STUDENT required a classroom that had a small number of students. In summary, STUDENT’s primary needs for the 1995-1996 school year were in the areas of social skills, academics, and speech and language. Because of attentional problems, STUDENT required a small, structured classroom environment and opportunities for one-to-one instruction.

The Appropriateness of the District’s Placement

An appropriate placement must have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, as determined above, and to provide him with educational benefit. The placement must also have conformed with STUDENT’s IEP.

Turning to the adequacy of the IEP developed on May 23, 1995, the evidence establishes that the IEP includes goals and objectives to improve social and emotional skills, peer interactions, school adjustment, reading comprehension, reading decoding, math computation, multiplication, division, use of a calculator, math problem solving skills, written language, and grammar. (Petitioner’s Exhibit Q) On January 22, 1996, additional goals and objectives were developed in generally the same areas. (Petitioner’s Exhibit FF). Based on a comparison of STUDENT’s identified needs during the 1995-1996 school year with the goals and objectives on his IEP, the Hearing Officer concludes that the goals and objectives were designed to address STUDENT’s deficits and, thereby, addressed his unique and individual needs. The District offered to provide STUDENT with the DIS of speech and language therapy; however, MOTHER and witnesses from Park Century testified that speech and language services were rejected at that time because STUDENT’s other needs took priority and they wanted to focus on those needs. The District also offered to provide extended school year services to STUDENT. These services were declined as well. (Petitioner’s Exhibit Q)

Witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT recommended that STUDENT remain at Park Century for the 1995-1996 school year, including MOTHER and Dr. Bezdek, testified that Ms. Timmerman’s class was too far above STUDENT’s current levels of functioning and that the campus at Grant was too large and offered less supervision than STUDENT required. MOTHER testified that during her observations of Ms. Timmerman’s class, the students engaged in activities that were too advanced for STUDENT. She stated that he would have been humiliated because he would not have been able to keep up with the third-grade students who were younger than he was. MOTHER testified that STUDENT would also have been embarrassed in front of his peers because he would not have been able to earn stars for academic accomplishments. MOTHER also does not believe that STUDENT would have received sufficient one-to-one instruction in Ms. Timmerman’s class. MOTHER testified that at all times it has been imperative that she is involved in STUDENT’s education. She asserted that the District has not valued her opinion and that she has been alienated by the District.

Based on his observation of Ms. Timmerman’s class in June 1996, Dr. Bezdek also concluded that Ms. Timmerman’s class would not have provided STUDENT with sufficient one-to-one instruction and that STUDENT would not have been able to participate in the cooking lesson they observed. Dr. Bezdek held the opinion that STUDENT would not have been motivated by Ms. Timmerman’s behavioral system because the rewards would not have been of interest to him. He also concurred with MOTHER that STUDENT would not have felt good about the math progress chart because his skills were so much lower than the other students’ skills.

Dr. Solochek, who observed Ms. Timmerman’s class on June 13, 1996, described the cooking project that the students were engaged in as “stimulating and creative.” She also stated that Ms. Timmerman is a wonderful teacher. However, Dr. Solochek also did not believe that STUDENT’s math skills were sufficient to allow him to participate in the cooking activity, which required the students to use fractions to measure ingredients. She also did not believe that STUDENT could have participated in the daily problem solving activity which required the students to read a problem on the chalkboard and to record how they solved the problem in their individual journals. Dr. Solochek stated that STUDENT could not at that time read cursive and would have been unable to read the problem. Dr. Solochek also expressed concern that STUDENT would not have been able to sit still long enough in the class and that his self-esteem would have suffered because he could not do the same activities as the other students. Dr. Solochek also expressed concern about whether STUDENT would have been able to fill in the checks on the behavioral check sheet because of the small size of the sheet.

The classroom, curriculum, and behavioral intervention program offered at the District’s proposed placement were described at length by Carol Gibson Timmerman, who teaches the class proposed by the District. She provided the majority of the testimony regarding the District’s proposed placement for STUDENT. Ms. Timmerman supplemented her testimony from the prior hearing regarding her class and the ways she would specifically address STUDENT’s needs and implement his IEP goals and objectives.(Footnote 8) Ms. Timmerman holds standard elementary and special education credentials and a master’s degree. She has been teaching for 23 years and has received a number of awards and honors for her work and has been a mentor teacher. Ms. Timmerman testified that her classroom offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year. Mr. Bagley, District director of pupil personnel, concurred with Ms. Timmerman’s regarding the appropriateness of her class for STUDENT. Mr. Bagley has attended IEP meetings regarding STUDENT but has not met him. The evidence establishes that there were 13 students in Ms. Timmerman’s class for the majority of the 1995-1996 school year and that the maximum number of students at one time was 14. One of the students was ill and did not attend school regularly. Additionally, some students were mainstreamed for portions of the school day. Ms. Timmerman testified that she sometimes introduced an assignment to the whole class and then followed up that discussion with individual attention to each student. As discussed more fully below, the class schedule included many opportunities for one-to-one work with students by both Ms. Timmerman and her instructional assistant, who also is a credentialed teacher. Therefore, Ms. Timmerman’s classroom offered both a small environment and opportunities for one-to-one instruction.

Witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT contend that he also requires a small school environment and that a comprehensive elementary school campus would be overwhelming for him. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s disabilities restrict his ability to maneuver around the school campus. The concern appears to derive primarily from STUDENT’s difficulties with peer interactions. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of District witnesses on this issue to be persuasive. Traditional elementary schools have self-contained classes and the students are not required to move from classroom to classroom. Moreover, the District proposes to place STUDENT in an SDC, which is self-contained. There also is a bathroom inclose proximity to the classroom.

Regarding the age and academic levels of the students, Ms. Timmerman’s unrebutted testimony establishes that eight of the students were in the fifth grade, four of the students were in the fourth grade, and one student was in the third grade. During the 1995-1996 school year, STUDENT was in the fourth grade and, therefore, would have had classmates in Ms. Timmerman’s class who were in the same grade. Ms. Timmerman described the students academic achievement levels and concluded that STUDENT’s abilities fell within the functional levels of the other students. For example, in math computation, the students’ skills ranged from kindergarten to eighth-grade level. In broad reading, their abilities ranged from kindergarten to fifth grade. In reading comprehension, decoding, and applied mathematics their abilities ranged form kindergarten to sixth grade. Ms. Timmerman described the school schedule and the activities in which the students were engaged. Her testimony established the following. At 8:30 a.m. school began. The students first worked on phonics and handwriting. The students may have worked in a phonics book or individually read or did spelling activities with Ms. Timmerman. They may also have completed an activity described on the chalkboard. For example, on some days, Ms. Timmerman removed some letters from words the students had studied the previous day. The students assignment was to determine the missing letters. At 9:00 a.m. the president of the class led the students in the pledge of allegiance, the vice president read the menu with the assistance of the aide, and the office manager took role. The students rotated jobs weekly. At 9:08 a.m. the students had reading. They each had a core curriculum book that Ms. Timmerman supplemented with a number of individualized activities. Ms. Timmerman engaged students in reading to each other while she and her instructional aide worked with students individually or in small groups. Reading was followed by a 20-minutes recess and nutrition. From 10:20 a.m. to 10:45 a.m. the students had silent reading. The students read from books they selected during their weekly trip to the library. The students also had an opportunity to work on the computer. Additionally, Ms. Timmerman or the aide used the time to work individually with some students. From 10:45 a.m. to 11:30 a.m. the students had language arts activities. Each student had an individual spelling list and individualized spelling dictation. Third-grade students began learning to trace cursive writing. At 11:30 a.m. the students engaged in mathematics activities. Ms. Timmerman first taught to all of the students the skill and how to apply the skill. She then provided the students with individual instruction. The students also copied a word problem from the board which they solved in their personal journals. The whole class then discussed the problem and solved it together. Each student had a calculator at his or her desk and the class had many manipulatives for the students to use. There were computer programs available for the students to practice basic math skills and word problems. Ms. Timmerman engaged the students in some cooperative math projects. She assigned homework for practice with math skills. Lunch was at 12:15 p.m., which was followed by recess with other third, fourth, and fifth grade classes. At 12:30 p.m. there were sports activities that were open to all students’ participation. At 1:00 p.m. Ms. Timmerman engaged the students in activities to enhance listening skills. For example, Ms. Timmerman may have read a story and asked the students to respond to comprehension questions. From 1:45 p.m. to 2:40 p.m. the students had physical education (PE) two days per week. On Fridays, PE was 25 minutes. On other days the students had science, social studies, music, dance, library, and art activities. The science curriculum was hands-on. Ms. Timmerman used the state-adopted core curriculum so that the special education students learned the same concepts as regular education students. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Timmerman described a structured class in which activities are well planned and executed with many opportunities for individual instruction.

Ms. Timmerman further described some of the ways she would have implemented STUDENT’s goals and objectives. To address learning multiplication facts, she had a “twos” week and a “threes” week and so forth. Students worked in pairs to check each other and she asked parents to help the students practice at home. She would have allowed STUDENT to use his calculator for math activities. The students employed math skills in activities in other subject areas. For example, the students had to solve problems on a scavenger hunt related to a science lesson. To address language arts goals and objectives, STUDENT would have been required to write in his journal. The class had a weekly newspaper and the students all drafted stories on the computer for the weekly publication. The students read their own news to the rest of the class. On Mondays, the homework assignment was to read aloud to a parent. For the core literature program, STUDENT would have been provided a tape of the book which he could also take home.

One of the parameters of placement described by MOTHER was related to STUDENT’s need to receive constant feedback from the school staff. Ms. Timmerman testified regarding the behavioral intervention program implemented in her class. Ms. Timmerman employed a well-defined behavior modification system. The students received check marks for appropriate behavior. About every 30 minutes or at the end of an activity the aide and Ms. Timmerman went to each student and told them what they had done right. Students could earn 10 points per period. Five points were earned for meeting an individual goal and another five points were earned for appropriate behavior. If students required more frequent feedback, Ms. Timmerman testified that she modified the time that elapsed between evaluations. The students earned money, which they could accumulate and spend at the class store by writing checks from their personal checkbooks. Ms. Timmerman maintained items in the student store that are of interest to the students, such as toys and food. The store also had homework passes that excuse the student from having to complete a homework assignment. Ms. Timmerman testified that she would provide items of interest to STUDENT in the store and would modify the size of his checkbook, as well. Ms. Timmerman testified that students who completed their homework all week were part of the Friday Club which entitled them to a treat of popcorn and games while the students who did not complete their homework remained in their seats to complete their work. When their homework was done, they were allowed to join the rest of the students. Ms. Timmerman testified that she has always created a positive environment in her class and stressed that the class maintain a sense of family. She has taught students to ignore the behavior of other students, provided a lot of activities to build students’ self esteem, and found and encouraged each student’s strengths and interests. Ms. Timmerman stated that she and the aide have modeled appropriate behavior for the other students. Ms. Timmerman testified that she has employed time out only for a severe or dangerous behavioral problem. Ms. Timmerman’s description of her behavioral intervention program establishes that the students in her class received ongoing feedback regarding their behavioral and academic achievement and, therefore, comports with STUDENT’s needs as described by MOTHER and STUDENT’s teacher at Park Century.

In regard to addressing STUDENT’s attentional problems, Ms. Timmerman testified that her class was generally quiet. She stated that she has always asked students to raise their hands and she speaks in a calm and quiet manner. Additional modifications she has employed for students with short attention spans include reinforcing appropriate attention, shortening assignments, catching the student before failure ensues, allowing them a break, assigning a task that will allow the student to move such as taking a book to another location, and carefully selecting where the student sits. Ms. Timmerman additionally testified that there was a room available next to her room and there is a patio outside of her room that STUDENT could use if he wanted to be alone to tic or to work individually.

MOTHER expressed concern about STUDENT’s ability to be a part of the school community on a regular elementary school campus. Ms. Timmerman described ways in which her SDC participates in the school community. Approximately every other month, the school had an educational or awards assembly in which her class participated and received rewards. The school also had an annual science fair and the principal has public speaking activities such as a re-enactment of an historical event. A representative from Ms. Timmerman’s class served on the school council. Ms. Timmerman testified that all of the students in her class mainstreamed for recess and lunch, which would allow STUDENT to participate in activities with regular education peers while supervised by school staff. The recess and lunch periods would also allow him an opportunity to practice social skills with regular education peers. Ms. Timmerman’s class also mainstreamed with a fourth-grade class for music and physical education, which would have provided opportunities for STUDENT to engage in structured nonacademic activities with regular education peers with support from Ms. Timmerman and the aide. In these subject areas STUDENT would not have suffered embarrassment because of reading and written language deficits.

As to MOTHER’s concern that STUDENT would drop out of school if he had to attend Ms. Timmerman’s class, the evidence establishes that STUDENT has missed school and has had attendance problems while attending Park Century. The evidence was not persuasive that his attendance would further worsen if he were attending school in the District. Ms. Timmerman described many ways that her program and class were designed to foster self-esteem and to provide the support STUDENT needed to improve social and academic skills. Ms. Timmerman’s testimony regarding her class and the ways in which she would have modified the curriculum and individualized it to address STUDENT’s deficits was also credible. Ms. Timmerman has a great deal of experience with children with varying disabilities and is highly respected by peers and students. She has been a mentor teacher and has received many awards from various professional organizations. Ms. Timmerman described at length the number of activities she employs with the students in her class and shared at the hearing many materials she utilizes. The class had an appropriate number of students and an appropriate peer group for STUDENT. The class offers opportunities for one-to-one instruction and there are computers and a calculator available for STUDENT’s use. There is no doubt that Ms. Timmerman is a highly enthusiastic and capable teacher. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by her testimony that she would have provided an academic program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Ms. Timmerman, who knew her students well, testified that STUDENT fell within the academic achievement range of the other students. Regarding Dr. Bezdek’s concern whether the rewards available in the school store would be motivating for STUDENT, Ms. Timmerman testified that she would provide rewards in the school store that would be of interest to STUDENT. The concerns expressed by STUDENT’s witnesses were primarily based on one observation in her class. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Timmerman’s testimony persuasive as to the appropriateness of her class for STUDENT.

Based on all of the discussion above, the Hearing Officer finds that the program provided in Ms. Timmerman’s class was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. As to whether the District’s offering was also designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, Ms. Timmerman testified persuasively regarding the ways in which she would work with STUDENT and provide him instruction to address academic deficits. The evidence also establishes that one-to-one instruction was available to take into account STUDENT’s lack of attention. Because Ms. Timmerman’s program included instruction to meet those needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. There was no testimony nor did anyone dispute that the placement conforms with the IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year.

1996-1997 School Year

STUDENT’s Needs

As to whether STUDENT’s needs changed from the prior school year, MOTHER testified that STUDENT was constantly ticking and that he had head and neck tics, arm jerks, shoulder shrugs. He also stretched his fingers and would swing his torso and legs. STUDENT also said his toes ticked within his shoes. MOTHER stated that ticking included coughing, rapid breathing, and rapid eye blinking. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has had several incidences of tardive dyskinesia which has resulted in mouth, tongue, and facial movements. He missed school for a number of days in January 1997; however, the reason for his absences was not entirely clear. Dr. Bezdek, on the other hand, stated that STUDENT had made progress during the 1996-1997 school year, appeared to have a more positive attitude toward school, and would have had a better chance to succeed in Ms. Timmerman’s class than during the prior school years. Dr. Bezdek anticipated, however, that STUDENT could regress academically and socially should a change in placement.(Footnote 9)

Ms. Early, STUDENT’s reading and math tutor at Park Century during the 1995-1996 school year, testified that STUDENT completed the second-grade reading program by the end of the 1995-1996 school year and was able to independently read second-grade materials. At the time of the hearing, Ms. Early described STUDENT’s sight word vocabulary as falling at the beginning of the third grade, his literal comprehension level falling at the second-grade level, and his inferential skills falling at the third or fourth grade. Ms. Early testified that STUDENT relied on the computer to complete written language assignments. She does not believe that STUDENT should have changed schools for the 1996-1997 school year, because he was comfortable at Park Century and it took him a great deal of time to reach his current level of comfort. She also stated that STUDENT would have been distracting others and he would have been distracted by them. She also believes that he would have been teased by other students and would have been fearful of them.

Dr. Solochek stated that STUDENT’s needs continued to be the same for the 1996-1997 school year. She has not observed STUDENT since March 1996.

Ms. Kesten testified that STUDENT’s computer skills improved and he made some small improvements in written language, spelling, reading, and mathematics. At the end of the school year he was at the second to third grade in written expression and somewhere above the fourth-grade level in mathematics. She was uncertain of his reading level. Ms. Kesten’s greatest concern for STUDENT remained in the area of social skills.

Jon Hay was STUDENT’s teacher at Park Century during the 1996-1997 school year. He was also STUDENT’s physical education teacher during prior school years. Mr. Hay holds a teaching credential in physical education and an emergency credential that allows him to teach students with learning disabilities. Mr. Hay observed that STUDENT laked self-confidence and self-esteem and had more success in structured activities. Mr. Hay testified that during the past three years, STUDENT’s tics had increased in variety and intensity and have become more pronounced. Mr. Hay testified that during the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT required small class and school environments and constant individual attention from an aide or teacher. Mr. Hay stated that a class with more than 15 students would cause STUDENT to be anxious.

The District assessed STUDENT prior to the 1996-1997 school year and the following witnesses provided information regarding their findings. District Jerry Lee Harns, Ph.D., holds a master’s degree in APE and a teaching credential in physical education. Dr. Harns conducted an APE assessment of STUDENT in July 1996 and testified that STUDENT met the criteria for APE services because of deficits in complex skills, balance, and social skill difficulties. Dr. Harns testified that APE would help STUDENT develop social skills as well. Dr. Harns proposed to initially work one-to-one with STUDENT, then increase the group to four or six students, and gradually introduce him into the regular PE class where he could be provided assistance by an aide.

Ruth Punt, speech and language pathologist, holds a master degree in speech pathology and audiology, and is a licensed speech pathologist. Ms. Punt assessed STUDENT in July 1996. STUDENT received receptive vocabulary scores of 102 and expressive vocabulary score of 125. These scores are above the mean of 100. On following oral directions, STUDENT’s score of four was well below the mean of 10. He also scored significantly below the norm on measures of semantic relationships, auditory processing, and sentence assembly, and exhibited difficulty dealing with abstract language and auditory processing problems. STUDENT’s pragmatic skills were poor as well. Ms. Punt testified that STUDENT required speech and language therapy to address these deficits. She proposed that he receive two individual sessions of 20 minutes per week and one group session per week with a few other students.

Jack Herman Schnel, Ed.D., is an educational psychologist employed by the Palos Verdes school district and is also in private practice. He assessed STUDENT on behalf of the District in April 1996. Dr. Schnel’s assessment included administration of a number of cognitive, academic, and social measures, interviews with STUDENT’s teacher, and observations of STUDENT at school. STUDENT’s teachers and parent also completed behavior rating scales. Dr. Schnel found that STUDENT’s cognitive skills fell within the average range. STUDENT’s academic skills fell within the low average to average range. He found STUDENT’s visual motor skills were considerably below age level. STUDENT also appeared impulsive and disorganized in his approach to school work. Dr. Schnel concluded that STUDENT has attentional difficulties that affect his ability to process data and memory. At the time of testing, Dr. Schnel found that STUDENT had good perceptual skills and profited from understanding reasoning. Dr. Schnel observed that STUDENT’s attention was good when engaged in hands-on activities. Tasks requiring internal organization were the most difficult for STUDENT. Dr. Schnel found STUDENT’s academic achievement fairly consistent. Dr. Schnel noted that STUDENT’s percentile ranking on assessment measures has not changed since Dr. Bezdek’s testing in 1993. Thus, STUDENT’s ranking with peers has not changed. Dr. Schnel concluded after his testing that STUDENT required a very rich and organized educational program that focused on language and social and emotional areas. Dr. Schnel testified that STUDENT needed opportunities to participate in activities with regular education peers to develop social skills and general knowledge. Dr. Schnel testified that STUDENT also required counseling to develop social skills and to address individual concerns. STUDENT needed to practice what he learns in a group setting. Dr. Schnel’s testing did not indicate that STUDENT had fears. Dr. Schnel also testified that speech and language therapy and other services should be integrated with the class. Dr. Schnel testified that STUDENT would require a plan to facilitate his transition to another school.

Based on the information provided by the above witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs for the 1996-1997 school year continued to be similar to his needs during the 1995-1996 school year as determined above.

The District’s Proposed Placement

STUDENT’s IEP dated June 4, 1996, and July 30, 1996, includes goals and objectives to address all of the areas of need described above. MOTHER and STUDENT’s counsel participated in the development of the IEP and the adequacy of the goals and objectives is not in dispute.

Dr. Schnel described Ms. Timmerman’s class as extremely enriched. His testimony established that Ms. Timmerman employed a calm, positive approach and that she used core curriculum materials and had California state textbooks at varying grade levels. The students had computers available to them. Ms. Timmerman’s testimony established that during the 1996-1997 school year, there were 12 students in her class. Five of the students were in the fifth grade, four of the students were in the fourth grade, and three of the students were in the third grade. At one point in the year, there was an additional student in the fourth grade. All of the students in her class participated in PE, dance, and music with a fifth grade class. Two students mainstreamed for academic classes. All students mainstream for lunch and recess. Ms. Timmerman testified that she would have begun integrating STUDENT by pairing him with another student. She may have introduced them to a game. Ms. Timmerman’s testimony that there were other students in her class with needs similar to STUDENT’s was unrebutted. She also testified credibly that STUDENT would fit in with the class both academically and socially.

Based on the testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Timmerman’s class remained the same as described above for the 1995-1996 school year. Additional services were proposed by the District to further address STUDENT’s lack of social skills and language deficits. Following a recommendation by the Dr. Schnel, the District evaluated STUDENT’s need for adaptive physical education and found that he qualified. The District offered APE as well. The testimony did not establish that STUDENT’s needs have changed so greatly that they render what has consistently been determined an appropriate placement inappropriate for the 1996-1997 school year. All of the prior discussion established that Ms. Timmerman’s class was designed to meet STUDENT’s individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit. Moreover, the additional counseling and speech and language therapy offered by the District were designed to address STUDENT’s ongoing social and language deficits, which have not been remediated through the private services STUDENT has been receiving. APE services would also have been available to address motor deficits identified through testing. Based on the testimony of all of the witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs did not change significantly nor was there a change in circumstances from the prior school year. Moreover, the IEP, services, and placement were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit, and conform with his IEP. Therefore, the District offered an appropriate placement for the 1996-1997 school year.

ISSUE NO. 3: Was Park Century School an appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENT for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for placement and/or services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the placement and/or services provided by the parent were appropriate. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.

Because it was determined above that the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT, it is unnecessary to also determine whether Park Century offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

ISSUE NO. 4: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s placement at Park Century School, including tuition, transportation, and related expenditures, for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?

A parent may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a nonpublic school when a free appropriate public education is not available in the public school. Because it has been determined that the District did offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1994-1995, 1995-1996, and 1996-1997 school years, the District is not responsible for reimbursing the costs of STUDENT’s placement at Park Century

ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the related service of counseling/therapy provided by Patrick Bezdek, M.D.?

Petitioner contends that the District did not provide him with psychological services, that Dr. Bezdek has played an integral part in designing an appropriate educational program for him, and that, therefore, he is entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Bezdek’s services. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for services rendered to him from November 1992 forward and asserts that no prior claim has been made for reimbursement for Dr. Bezdek’s services. MOTHER additionally contends that the District’s services were not appropriate for STUDENT because they would not be provided at Park Century and he would have to travel from Park Century to a District site, which would require him to miss school, and his medication management and education would be interrupted. MOTHER asserted that STUDENT’s difficulty transitioning would further negatively impact a change to his usual routine. She also asserted that it would be difficult for STUDENT to bond with a psychologist, that it would take a long period of time before he would make any progress with the new therapist, and that STUDENT would be fearful of the large and unfamiliar environment where the District proposed to provide services.

The District contends that the services provided by Dr. Bezdek are medical rather than educational in nature and, therefore are not the responsibility of the District. The District also asserts that Petitioner should be barred from reimbursement for any claims related to Dr. Bezdek’s services that originated prior to the previous hearing.

The term "related services" includes transportation and other services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. Medical services shall be for diagnostic and evaluation purposes only. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.

Dr. Bezdek’s testimony and the logs of his meetings with STUDENT establish that the nature of his office consultations with STUDENT was medication management. These services are medical in nature and are not included in the list of related services for which the District may have responsibility. See also Clovis v. California Office of Administrative Hearings, et al. (9th Cir. 1990) 903 F.2d 635. The evidence establishes, however, that Dr. Bezdek’s participation in STUDENT’s IEP meetings has been for educational purposes. STUDENT’s case is unique because he takes a number of medications that impact his needs within the classroom. This medication regime is constantly being revised. The information Dr. Bezdek provides to the IEP team is helpful to the teaching staff to plan and revise STUDENT’s behavioral intervention program and to meet his physical needs in the classroom, such as providing bathroom facilities and an area in which STUDENT may tic. California Education Code § 56341(c) identifies persons who may be appropriate members of a student’s IEP team. It states “when appropriate, the team shall also include the following persons . . . other individuals, at the discretion of the parent, district, or special education local plan area, or county office who possess expertise or knowledge necessary for the development of the individualized education program.” Because of STUDENT’s complicated diagnoses and medication regime, the need for monitoring for potential side effects, the fact that medications are administered while STUDENT is at school, and because the medications may impact STUDENT’s educational performance, the Hearing Officer concludes that Dr. Bezdek has expertise that is essential in the development of STUDENT’s IEP. As an essential member of the IEP team, the Hearing Officer concludes that Dr. Bezdek’s services as an IEP team member are reimbursable. Therefore, subject to proof, the District shall reimburse MOTHER for the cost of Dr. Bezdek’s participation at IEP team meetings.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

ISSUE NO. 1: Did STUDENT’s condition after October 1994 necessitate that he remain at Park Century for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year? The District prevailed.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years? The District prevailed.

ISSUE NO. 3: Was Park Century School an appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENT for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years? No determination was made on this issue because the District prevailed on Issue No. 2.

ISSUE NO. 4: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT’s placement at Park Century School, including tuition, transportation, and related expenditures, for the second semester of the 1994-1995 school year, and for the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years? The District prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT’s parent entitled to reimbursement for the related service of counseling/therapy provided by Patrick Bezdek, M.D.? The District substantially prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).

ORDER

(1) Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for the costs of his placement at Park Century is denied.

(2) Within 15 days of proof from MOTHER, the District shall reimburse her for the costs of Dr. Bezdek’s attending IEP meetings from 1994 to the present.

(3) Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for other services provided by Dr. Bezdek is denied.

DATED: November 7, 1997 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES: 1. Tourette's syndrome is characterized by multiple motor and vocal tics. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV). 2. Asperger's Syndrome is a severe impairment in social interaction and the development of restricted, repetitive patterns of behavior, interest, and activities. In contrast to Autistic Disorder, there are no clinically significant delays in language, cognitive development, or in the development of age-appropriate self-help skills, adaptive behavior, and curiosity about the environment. DSM-IV . 3. Attorney John M. Bayne, Jr. represented STUDENT at the first due process hearing (SN 319-94). Ms. Dobel represented STUDENT during the appeal of that decision. 4. Amendments to the IDEA were signed into law on June 4, 1997. The hearing in this matter was requested and the record closed before the 1997 amendments became effective. According to the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Landgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244, retroactive application of such amendments are not favored. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer will apply the law as it stood at the time of the hearing request. 5. Res judicata is a judicial doctrine that gives "conclusive effect to a former judgment in subsequent litigation involving the same controversy. It seeks to curtail multiple litigation causing vexation and expense to the parties and wasted effort and expense in judicial administration." Witkin, 7 California Procedure (4th ed., 1997) Judgment 280. 6. The California Special Education Hearing Office has also generally held that its decisions regarding a student's placement cover no more than the period of one year. 7. The District witnesses did not specifically address STUDENT's needs during the 1995-1996 school year. STUDENT did not attend a District program during that school year. The District also did not assess STUDENT. 8. The entire record of the prior case was introduced into evidence in this case. Ms. Timmerman's testimony in the first case is over 100 pages of the written transcript of the hearing. (See Respondent's Exhibits 1-74.) 9. Several witnesses testified that STUDENT has some difficulty with transitions. Should MOTHER decide to return STUDENT to the District, it will be necessary for the IEP team to carefully draft a transition plan to facilitate the change to STUDENT's placement.