California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 18, 1996
Student v. Sequoia Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1092-95 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Sequoia Union High School District must treat tenth grader as eligible because of serious emotional disturbance and develop an IEP within 15 days.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 16-year-old tenth grader, represented by the East Palo Alto Community Law Project, filed for a hearing after Sequoia Union High School District's IEP team found her not eligible for special education in October 1995. The only issue was whether she qualified as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). She did well in school through eighth grade. In ninth grade at Menlo-Atherton High School, she rarely attended, was suspended many times, and faced expulsion. She then enrolled at Mid-Peninsula High School, a private school. A private psychologist, Dr. Michael Shore, diagnosed major depression. Her therapist, Nancy Gray, diagnosed posttraumatic stress disorder. The district argued that she was socially maladjusted, not emotionally disturbed.
Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that the student could maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers, so she did not qualify on that characteristic. However, the Hearing Officer found that she showed a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. The Hearing Officer credited Dr. Shore, and especially Ms. Gray, over district staff whose views rested on brief observations in one setting. The depression had lasted more than a year, was marked, and hurt her schooling. By December 1995 she had 26 absences and had earned only 4 of 8 possible credits. The Hearing Officer added that some antisocial behavior does not rule out SED eligibility. The district was ordered to develop an appropriate IEP within 15 calendar days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed a district's "social maladjustment" argument against clinical evidence of depression. The Hearing Officer held that antisocial behavior does not bar SED eligibility. She gave more weight to clinicians who assessed or treated the student than to staff who observed her briefly at one school.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student who is seriously emotionally disturbed?
The student did not meet the interpersonal-relationships characteristic, but she showed a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression over a long period and to a marked degree that hurt her educational performance, so she is eligible as SED. Antisocial behavior does not rule out SED eligibility.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the order, the District shall develop an appropriate IEP for the student as a student eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(a)(9); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026; 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3030(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Michael D. Shore, Ph.D., independent psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Nancy Gray, private therapist (LMFCC); witness for Student, Private practice; San Mateo County Mental Health
- Elda Aghazarian, school psychologist, Sequoia Union High School District
- Carol Holder, special education teacher; academic assessor, Sequoia Union High School District
- Susan Fan, speech pathologist; assessor, Sequoia Union High School District
- Ann Lloyd Brown, licensed clinical social worker; counselor arranged by school
- Philip Bliss, headmaster; witness for Student, Mid-Peninsula High School
- Roberto Martinez, vice principal, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Lisa Jelinsky, sixth- and eighth-grade teacher, Ravenswood City School District
- Ruben Avelar, former counselor; District witness
- Judith Whitcomb, school psychologist; student study team chair, Sequoia Union High School District
- Joyce A. Willett, special education coordinator, Sequoia Union High School District
- Marielena Hincapie, law student assisting Student's counsel, East Palo Alto Community Law Project
- Scott W. Kester, Ph.D., author of guidelines on telling SED apart from social maladjustment (not a witness), California Association of School Psychologists manual
- Stephan (surname not stated), former counselor, New Perspectives
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Redwood City, California, on December 14 and 15, 1995, and January 8 and 22, 1996.
Petitioner was represented by attorney David R. Giles of the East Palo Alto Community Law Project. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were her aunt and law student Marielena Hincapie. Respondent Sequoia Union High School District (District) was represented by Peter K. Finck, deputy county counsel for San Mateo County. Also present on behalf of the District was Joyce A. Willett, special education coordinator.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing briefs. Respondent's closing brief was received on February 14, 1996. Petitioner's closing brief was received on February 15, 1996. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a student who is seriously emotionally disturbed?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner is a 16-year-old tenth-grade student. Since the fall of 1995, STUDENT has attended Mid-Peninsula High School, a private school located in Palo Alto. She is not currently eligible for special education. At time of hearing, STUDENT was four months pregnant.
STUDENT, her brother, and her sister, who is one year older than STUDENT, lived in Colorado with their mother until some time in 1984, when they returned to California to live with their paternal aunt and grandmother. According to STUDENT's aunt, the children had not been well cared for by their mother and arrived malnourished and infested with lice. STUDENT attended preschool in San Francisco. From kindergarten through the third quarter of the fourth grade, STUDENT attended school in Pittsburg, California.(Footnote 1) STUDENT and her siblings then moved to Palo Alto to live with their father and stepmother. STUDENT attended the last quarter of the fourth grade through the sixth grade in the Ravenswood City School District. STUDENT's educational records through the sixth grade are uneventful, and she generally performed well academically.
In 1992, when STUDENT was in the seventh grade, she and her siblings returned to live with their mother in Colorado. According to STUDENT's aunt, STUDENT's mother tried to commit suicide several times in front of STUDENT, attempted to murder her own boyfriend, shot a BB gun at STUDENT's brother, tried to cut STUDENT on the face with a piece of broken glass, moved nine times during the course of the school year, and threw STUDENT out of the house into the snow when she was wearing only shorts. At the end of the seventh grade, STUDENT and her siblings returned to California to live with her father's family. STUDENT entered the eighth grade in the Ravenswood City School District.
According to STUDENT'S AUNT, STUDENT had a difficult time adjusting upon her return to California. STUDENT'S AUNT arranged for STUDENT to be seen by a counselor named Stephan at New Perspectives. Unfortunately, Stephen died suddenly and unexpectedly. During the eighth grade, as well as the summer following the eight grade, Ruben Avelar provided counseling for STUDENT. Mr. Avelar then took another job and was not able to continue seeing STUDENT. At the end of the eighth grade, STUDENT received "B-" grades in two classes and one each of "C," "C-," "D+," and "D" grades. (Respondent's Exhibit B 14b)
STUDENT entered the ninth grade at Menlo-Atherton High School in the fall of 1994.(Footnote 2) She seldom attended school and was frequently referred and/or suspended for hostile, defiant, and disruptive behavior. In September 1994, STUDENT was suspended for five days for fighting; in October, she was suspended for one day for inciting a disturbance and for five days for defiance of authority, flashing gang colors, and possession of alcohol; in November, she was suspended for five days for rude behavior and defiance of authority; and in December, she was suspended for five days for defiant and disruptive behavior. On January 13, 1995, STUDENT was suspended for five days pending expulsion for the following reasons: defiance and disrespect of school personnel; disruption of the learning environment; fights; vandalism of school property; threatening the safety of others; participation in gang-related activity; inciting a fight; and disregard of the student behavior policy.(Footnote 3) (Respondent's Exhibit E pages 1-4)
On March 6, 1995, Mr. Giles requested that the District evaluate STUDENT for special education eligibility under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (Section 504).(Footnote 4) On March 14, 1995, the District convened a student study team (SST) regarding STUDENT's 504 eligibility. The SST deferred making a decision pending receipt of information from STUDENT's therapist Nancy Gray, a licensed marriage, family, and child counselor (LMFCC).(Footnote 5) Ms. Gray diagnosed STUDENT as having a posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Her diagnosis was based on professional observations during therapy, interviews with family members, and a review of the family history and school records.
STUDENT appealed the District's proposal to expel her. A hearing officer appointed by the District upheld the recommendation for expulsion. The District's Board of Trustees then suspended the expulsion to allow the District to convene a meeting, to which STUDENT's therapist, Ms. Gray, would be invited. Ms. Gray's presence was requested to assist in the development of a behavioral contract under which STUDENT would be allowed to return to school for the fourth quarter of the 1994-95 school year.
On April 4, 1995, the SST reconvened and determined that there was no basis for conducting a 504 evaluation of STUDENT.(Footnote 6) The behavioral contract was developed on April 7, 1996.(Footnote 7) (Petitioner's Exhibit C.30-6) The school arranged for Ann Lloyd Brown, licensed clinical social worker (LCSW), to provide weekly counseling for STUDENT. Ms. Brown conducted an assessment interview of STUDENT on April 19, 1995. STUDENT attended one counseling session on May 3, 1995. Because STUDENT did not live up to the terms of the behavioral contract, the suspension of her expulsion was rescinded on June 7, 1995.
Michael D. Shore, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist in private practice, conducted an independent psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT on July 19, 1995.(Footnote 8) Dr. Shore has taught courses in psychological assessment for 17 years and is a consultant to Laguna Honda Hospital. Dr. Shore estimated that he has assessed between 1,000 to 2,000 children and currently conducts approximately five assessments per week. Dr. Shore administered the following tests to STUDENT: the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-R), which measures cognitive ability; the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), which assesses academic achievement; the Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test; the Beery Visual Motor Integration Test; the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test; and the Rorschach and Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI), which are projective measures of social/emotional status. Dr. Shore also interviewed STUDENT and her father and reviewed educational records. Dr. Shore diagnosed STUDENT with major depression and concluded that she meets eligibility criteria for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed. (Petitioner's Exhibit E.9-1 to 9-12)
In October 1995, the District completed an assessment of STUDENT. The psycho-educational portion of the assessment was conducted by Elda Aghazarian, school psychologist. To assess STUDENT's cognitive abilities, Ms. Aghazarian administered the WISC-III. To assess STUDENT's social/emotional status, she administered the Hand and Incomplete Sentences tests. Ms. Aghazarian also administered the Beery test to look for signs of neurological damage, reviewed STUDENT's educational records and assessments conducted by Dr. Shore and Ms. Gray, and observed STUDENT at Mid-Peninsula for approximately three hours. On testing administered by Ms. Aghazarian, STUDENT's cognitive abilities fell within the low average range. Her responses on the Incomplete Sentences Test indicated sadness, anger, frustration, difficulty sleeping, and fear of loss of her father. (Respondent's Exhibit A, pages 1-9) Carol Holder, special education teacher, assessed STUDENT's academic achievement utilizing the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R) and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R). Standard scores measuring academic achievement were commensurate or above STUDENT's ability as measured by either the WISC-III or the WISC-R. On the broad reading subtest of the WJ-R, STUDENT received a grade-equivalent score of 10.6; however, in broad math, she received a grade-equivalent score of 7.9 and, in broad written language, she achieved a grade-equivalent score of 6.6. (Respondent's Exhibit A, pages 14-17) Susan Fan, speech pathologist, assessed STUDENT's speech and language skills. She found that STUDENT possessed adequate speech and language skills. (Respondent's Exhibit A, pages 10-11) No problems were identified during the health appraisal. (Respondent's Exhibit A, page 13)
On October 25, 1995, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss the results of testing and to consider STUDENT's eligibility for special education. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility criteria because of either a significant learning disability (SLD) or a serious emotional disturbance (SED). On November 8, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from Mr. Giles on behalf of STUDENT regarding the issue of eligibility for special education as SED.
On December 6, 1996, Dr. Shore completed a second report regarding STUDENT. Prior to writing the report, Dr. Shore reviewed the District's report of its assessment, and spoke with STUDENT's counselor at Mid-Peninsula, STUDENT, and her aunt. Dr. Shore concluded that STUDENT continued to have frequent absences from school but that she was doing better when she actually was present at school. At home, STUDENT continued to be moody, irritable, withdrawn, sad, and angry. She was cooperative and helpful at home on some days. Dr. Shore noted that STUDENT has stayed away from any gang involvement since he last saw her. Dr. Shore's report notes that STUDENT continues to exhibit major depression that affects her attendance and grades at school, as well as her social and emotional behavior. (Petitioner's Exhibit E.1-1 to 1-5)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); California Education Code § 56000. "Children with disabilities" includes children who, because of a serious emotional disturbance, require special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1)(A); California Education Code § 56026(a-b). The federal regulations implementing IDEA set forth at 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(a)(9) the criteria that must be met to satisfy eligibility for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed:
(i) The term means a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a child's educational performance-- (A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors;
(B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers;
(C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances;
(D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal of school problems.
(ii) The term includes children who are schizophrenic. The term does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance.(Footnote 9)
Petitioner contends through her attorney that she is eligible for special education as SED. She asserts that she has been diagnosed with depression and PTSD and exhibits the following SED characteristics: an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers (B); and a general pervasive mood of unhappiness of depression (D). She also asserts that this condition has existed over a long period of time and to a marked degree, and has affected her educational performance.
Respondent Sequoia Union High School District contends through its attorney that STUDENT is socially maladjusted and, for the following reasons, does not meet special education eligibility criteria as SED: STUDENT's school problems are related to anti-social behavior and gang affiliation; she is a leader and has friends, including a boyfriend with whom she lives; she does not suffer from thought disorders; she does not exhibit unhappiness or depression that is pervasive; and she does not have a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears related to personal or school problems.
Does STUDENT exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?
Witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT described her relationships with peers as "poor" and her behavior toward adults in authority as "defiant." STUDENT's aunt, testified that STUDENT is not able to sustain friendships and gets in fights with her peers.
Michael Shore, Ph.D., testified that STUDENT's peer relationships until the age of 12 had been good; however, she presently has trouble maintaining relationships and clearly has problems with everyone. Dr. Shore noted that STUDENT fights with peers and adults. He also noted that STUDENT's fights are not limited to members of opposing subgroups. During the hearing, Dr. Shore evaluated STUDENT's behaviors utilizing guidelines developed by Scott W. Kester, Ph.D., to assist psychologists in differentiating between social maladjustment and SED.(Footnote 10) Dr. Shore testified that under Dr. Kester's category regarding "personal and social relationships," STUDENT's behavior leans more toward behaviors listed by Dr. Kester as characteristic of SED than the behaviors characteristic of social maladjustment. Dr. Shore concluded that STUDENT meets eligibility criteria as SED because of poor peer relations.
Nancy Gray, LMFCC, testified that STUDENT has poor relations with peers and adults in authority. Ms. Gray testified that STUDENT has difficulty trusting others and is very sensitive. For example, STUDENT reacts in anger if she perceives that a peer does not respect her. Ms. Gray attributes STUDENT's reactions to a posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).(Footnote 11) Ms. Gray testified that STUDENT was involved in and witnessed a number of events during the year she spent with her mother in Colorado that qualify as "traumatic," including her mother trying to kill her stepfather in STUDENT's presence, as well as trying to kill STUDENT. Ms. Gray testified that STUDENT exhibits many of the symptoms of trauma, including recurrent nightmares, a startle response, intrusive thoughts, and avoidance of thinking about the traumatic incidents. (See Petitioner's Exhibit E.11-3)
Philip Bliss, headmaster of Mid-Peninsula High School, was called to testify by Petitioner. Mr. Bliss did not offer an opinion regarding STUDENT's eligibility for special education. He testified that there are no reports of STUDENT's having problems with authority and that her teachers report that STUDENT is cooperative, enthusiastic, and trusting, and is capable of doing her school work independently.
District witnesses acknowledged that STUDENT has engaged in fights with her peers; however, they also testified that STUDENT has a boyfriend and has had some positive relations with teachers. Elda Aghazarian, school psychologist, testified that STUDENT "fit in" with her peers and that, when she observed STUDENT at Mid-Peninsula, STUDENT did not appear different from any of the other students. Ms. Aghazarian testified that STUDENT is able to initiate, establish, and maintain social relationships. In determining whether STUDENT meets SED eligibility criteria, Ms. Aghazarian also reviewed Dr. Kester's guidelines. She testified that STUDENT's behaviors fall more on the side of social maladjustment than SED, under the category of "intrapersonal dynamics." Ms. Aghazarian testified that, under Dr. Kester's category of "personal and social relationships" STUDENT exhibits the following behaviors that are indicative of social maladjustment rather than SED: she has a circle of friends; is a leader; is manipulative; and has conflicts with authority figures and peers.
Carol Holder, special education teacher, testified that during her observation at Mid-Peninsula, STUDENT behaved like the other students in her class and did not demonstrate poor social skills. Ms. Holder testified that STUDENT appeared to be an average student with control over her academic achievement and social interactions. Ms. Holder related an incident told to her by STUDENT's teacher at Mid-Peninsula. Apparently STUDENT carved up a chair and wrote obscenities on it in response to another student "looking wrong at her." The teachers indicated that STUDENT had been told not to take her anger out directly on the student.
Roberto Martinez, vice principal of Menlo-Atherton, testified regarding STUDENT's behavior during the 1994-95 school year. Mr. Martinez testified that STUDENT had a series of problems both in and out of class. She was late to class, was not prepared, and did not follow the teacher's instructions. Outside of class, STUDENT wandered around the halls and engaged in conflicts with other students. Mr. Martinez testified that he attempted to work with STUDENT, as did a number of other staff members; however, as a result of her behavior, she was suspended numerous times for fighting, defiance of school staff, shouting in class, and flashing gang colors.
Lisa Jelinsky was STUDENT's teacher in both the sixth and eighth grades. She testified that STUDENT did better academically in the eighth grade than she had in the sixth grade. She described STUDENT as "happy and mature"; however, she was tardy a lot during the eighth grade. Ms. Jelinsky testified that she was surprised by the January 13, 1995, "Report of Suspension," which describes STUDENT as defiant, disruptive, and involved in fighting, vandalism, and threatening behavior. Ms. Jelinsky testified that STUDENT did not respond in that manner to her and that they had a good relationship.
As to whether STUDENT meets the SED criteria because she exhibits an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, there is no dispute that during the ninth grade, STUDENT engaged in fights with her peers and behaved defiantly toward adults in authority. The evidence establishes, however, that on some occasions, including the incident for which the District proposed to expel STUDENT, she engaged in activities with her peers. STUDENT also "hangs out" with her sister and has had the same boyfriend for a period of time. As a matter of fact, the boyfriend lives with her family. There also is evidence that STUDENT has established some positive relationships with teachers. Ms. Jelinsky, for example, testified that she had a very good relationship with STUDENT during both the sixth and eighth grades. Mr. Bliss also reported that the teachers at Mid-Peninsula view their relationship with STUDENT in a positive light. Based on the testimony of the persons who have observed STUDENT with her peers, and on the testimony of Ms. Jelinsky, STUDENT's teacher, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has the ability to sufficiently maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. STUDENT, therefore, does not meet SED eligibility under this category.
Does STUDENT exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression?
Petitioner contends that she also satisfies SED criteria for special education based on Dr. Shore's diagnosis of depression. District witnesses acknowledged Dr. Shore's diagnosis of depression; however, they contend that his clinical diagnosis of depression is insufficient to satisfy educational criteria of SED.
Witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT described at length the depression they assert affects STUDENT's behavior and her ability to succeed at school. STUDENT'S AUNT testified that STUDENT has significant emotional problems related to issues of abandonment and abuse by her mother.(Footnote 12) STUDENT'S AUNT described STUDENT as an "emotional wreck" when she returned from living with her mother while in the seventh grade. She stated that STUDENT was always crying, appeared angry, and no longer wanted a "relationship" with other family members. The unexpected death of STUDENT's counselor, Stephen, also affected STUDENT emotionally and resulted in further deterioration of her behavior. An additional significantly upsetting event was the death of STUDENT's 23-year-old cousin just after Thanksgiving 1995.(Footnote 13) STUDENT'S AUNT noted that following the cousin's death, STUDENT wanted to run away from home. STUDENT'S AUNT testified that STUDENT's emotional well-being is currently "up-and-down." She cries a lot, spends a significant amount of time in her room, and cannot sleep at night. STUDENT'S AUNT testified that when STUDENT does not attend school, she generally is at home in bed. STUDENT'S AUNT also testified that STUDENT also suffers from anxiety attacks. Although STUDENT'S AUNT has not personally witnessed one of these attacks, based on information from other family members, she understands that STUDENT has had five to six such attacks and was taken to the hospital as the result of an attack.
Dr. Shore described depression as an enduring abnormality of the way a person experiences, feels, and behaviorally displays feelings. He reported that STUDENT is restless, sad, angry, and depressed, and has sleep problems, nightmares, and intrusive thoughts. Dr. Shore noted that these behaviors are characteristics of SED pursuant to Dr. Kester's guidelines. Based on observations, biological, and behavioral factors, and the results of testing, Dr. Shore concluded that STUDENT is significantly depressed. He testified that biological indicators of depression include sleep problems, nightmares, crying spells, moodiness, and sadness. STUDENT's behavior that manifests depression includes anger, hostility, impulsivity, defiance, anxiousness, and fearfulness, as well as difficulty sustaining social relationships. Dr. Shore testified that on testing, STUDENT demonstrated increasing difficulty in her ability to concentrate.
Dr. Shore testified that the conclusion by Elda Aghazarian, the District's psychologist, that STUDENT is socially maladjusted is "simply wrong" and is inconsistent with the evidence. Dr. Shore testified that he was puzzled by Ms. Aghazarian's conclusion, particularly in light of the fact that Ms. Aghazarian relied on the same background information as he did, utilized the results of his assessment of STUDENT, and accepted his diagnosis of depression. Dr. Shore noted that the only independent information on which Ms. Aghazarian could have based her opinion was the results of her administration of the hand and sentence completion tests. Dr. Shore testified that these tests are ancillary testing procedures and would not on their own constitute a comprehensive assessment.
Ms. Gray concurred with Dr. Shore's conclusion that STUDENT is depressed. She noted that STUDENT often is tearful, anxious, and upset, has nightmares, and wonders if life is worth living. Ms. Gray testified that STUDENT "fits within" the body of students she serves through County Mental Health who are identified as SED.
Mr. Bliss stated that he did not find STUDENT to be "extremely" depressed. He understood from STUDENT and her attorney that poor school attendance is related to "massive" personal issues that include difficulty communicating with her father and stepmother, problems with her boyfriend, pregnancy, and the recent homicide of her cousin.
Ruben Avelar, who provided counseling to STUDENT during the eighth grade, was called as a witness by the District. Mr. Avelar contradicted STUDENT'S AUNT's testimony that she had submitted to the District a letter from him regarding STUDENT having anxiety attacks. Mr. Avelar did recall, however, some anxiety on the part of STUDENT. He also testified that STUDENT lacked skills to make good decisions and to practice good judgment.
Ms. Aghazarian, school psychologist, testified that, in light of Dr. Shore's report, she carefully considered whether STUDENT met the criteria for SED as depressed. Ms. Aghazarian concluded that STUDENT did not. Ms. Aghazarian testified that Dr. Shore administered an older version of the WISC to STUDENT, and she also questioned how he could have completed his assessment in the amount of time he testified he spent with STUDENT. Ms. Aghazarian testified that during her observation of STUDENT in September 1995, STUDENT did not appear depressed, anxious, sad, down, lethargic, or tearful. During the visit to Mid-Peninsula, none of STUDENT's teachers mentioned to Ms. Aghazarian that STUDENT is depressed or has mood swings. STUDENT's teacher did mention, however, that STUDENT was capable of doing good work but that her attendance and tardiness interfered with her achievement. Ms. Aghazarian testified that STUDENT also does not appear depressed in social interactions in the community. She noted that STUDENT holds a job.
Ms. Holder testified that STUDENT did not appear withdrawn or despondent during testing or observations during the fall of 1995. She also did not exhibit a lack of control or mood swings. She concluded that STUDENT did not "present" like an SED student.
Judith Whitcomb, school psychologist, chaired a student study team (SST) meeting regarding STUDENT. She has not met STUDENT. Ms. Whitcomb testified that the SST did not find any information in STUDENT's files that would lead them to conclude that she has a disability. On the contrary, it appeared to her that STUDENT's behavior was under her operant control. Joyce Willett, District special education coordinator, testified that STUDENT's teacher at Mid-Peninsula concurred with the IEP team decision that STUDENT does not meet SED or any other special education eligibility criteria.
There was a great deal of discussion at the hearing regarding whether STUDENT is socially maladjusted. District witnesses took the position that the behavior STUDENT engaged in demonstrates that she is socially maladjusted rather than emotionally disturbed. Dr. Shore testified that STUDENT does not fit the description of socially maladjusted. He defined socially maladjusted as "behavior in accordance with a subgroup which is under the control of the individual and results in a collision of values with the rest of society." Dr. Shore testified that STUDENT is not able to control her own behavior.
As to gang affiliation, Ms. Holder testified that when she tested STUDENT, she had a gang mark between her thumb and index finger. Mr. Martinez testified that STUDENT boasted to him that she was the leader of a gang. Mr. Avelar, STUDENT's counselor during the eighth grade, testified that STUDENT was steeped in affiliation with gang images and activities. Dr. Shore testified that STUDENT "flirted" with gang activity but currently reports that she has severed all ties to gang activity. Ms. Gray testified that she had a sense that STUDENT had been exposed to gang activity but that she did not want to be in a gang. STUDENT'S AUNT unequivocally denied that STUDENT is a member of a gang. In response to the District's assertions that STUDENT dressed in "gang attire," STUDENT'S AUNT testified that STUDENT dresses like every other Latino from East Palo Alto. Ms. Holder noted that STUDENT had a gang-related tatoo between her thumb and index finger. At the hearing, STUDENT displayed that area. There was no visible tatoo. STUDENT explained that she often writes her boyfriend's name on her hand.
Dr. Shore and Ms. Gray both testified that even if STUDENT engages in some behaviors that are characteristic of social maladjustment, she also exhibits characteristics under Dr. Kester's analysis that are clearly SED. Dr. Shore and Ms. Gray concluded, therefore, that STUDENT satisfies eligibility criteria for SED. Special Education law does not state that because a student has some anti-social behaviors the student cannot also satisfy SED criteria.
Turning to whether STUDENT exhibits a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, the facts establish that STUDENT suffered significant and traumatizing events and neglect while living with her mother and again with the unexpected and untimely deaths of a counselor and a cousin. Dr. Shore, Ms. Gray, and STUDENT'S AUNT described behavior on the part of STUDENT following these events that is consistent with the diagnosis of depression, including problems sleeping, crying, and sadness. The Hearing Officer finds credible the testimony of Dr. Shore and especially the testimony of Ms. Gray that STUDENT suffers from depression. The Hearing Officer also relies on the results of testing by Dr. Shore. Dr. Shore has a significant amount of experience assessing students. Ms. Gray has had opportunities to come to a greater understanding of STUDENT than have other witnesses because of the time she spent with STUDENT during individual therapy sessions. The Hearing Officer notes also that Ms. Gray provides services through San Mateo County Mental Health to students who meet special education eligibility criteria as SED and, thus, is familiar with the characteristics of students eligible under this criteria. It also is doubtful that professionals with the credentials possessed by Dr. Shore and Ms. Gray would recommend therapy or an assessment for psychotropic medication unless they identified significant problems warranting such a course of treatment.
The results of the District's testing do not contradict Dr. Shore's findings or testimony that STUDENT is depressed. Ms. Aghazarian, in fact, recognized Dr. Shore's diagnosis of depression and disagreed only as to whether the limiting characteristics set forth above in the statute and discussed below were satisfied. Ms. Aghazarian's critique of Dr. Shore's use of the WISC-R, a measure of cognitive ability, has no effect on his diagnosis of depression. As to one of STUDENT's teachers from Mid-Peninsula who agreed with the IEP team's decision that STUDENT does not qualify for special education, the Hearing Officer notes that the teacher did not testify at the hearing and her credentials to express an opinion regarding SED eligibility are unknown. It is also noted that the IEP team met in October 1995, shortly after STUDENT entered Mid-Peninsula and, given STUDENT's poor attendance, the teacher could only have known STUDENT for a short period of time. (STUDENT had been absent from school at least 13 times up to the date of the IEP meeting.)
As to the opinion of District personnel that STUDENT did not "appear" depressed, the Hearing Officer notes that their opinions were based on relatively brief observations on a single day of STUDENT in a small, nonpublic school. Moreover, persons without significant education and training in the field of psychology are not particularly suited to diagnosing depression and may not be aware of the ways in which depression is manifested by adolescents. For example, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) notes that "In children and adolescents, the mood may be irritable rather than sad..." (DSM-IV, p. 320) Additional characteristics of depression include insomnia or hypersomnia, diminished ability to think or concentrate, diminished interest in activities, and psychomotor agitation or retardation. The evidence establishes that STUDENT exhibited these characteristics. The fact that STUDENT did not entirely fall apart in the eighth grade can be attributed, at least in part, to the fact that the family provided her with counseling during that period.
Therefore, based on the testimony as discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT exhibits depression that satisfies SED criteria.
Has STUDENT exhibited SED characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree?
Dr. Shore testified that STUDENT's scores on the MMPI indicate severe psychological stress that interferes with her daily life and that depression significantly affects a number of areas in her life. It is destroying her ability to function in school, interfering with her relationships, and affecting her health. According to Dr. Shore, STUDENT's poor school attendance is the primary manifestation of her depression. STUDENT'S AUNT testified that she observed severe changes in STUDENT upon her return from living with her mother during the seventh grade. The changes have affected the way she interacts with her family. STUDENT began receiving counseling at that time. Ms. Gray made her diagnosis approximately one year ago.
Ms. Aghazarian concluded that, even if STUDENT suffers from depression, it does not meet the three limiting conditions. Ms. Aghazarian testified that STUDENT's depression is not pervasive because it does not affect all areas of her life. She does not appear depressed at school or in the community.
The evidence establishes that STUDENT's school performance and behavior significantly changed when she entered the ninth grade in the fall of 1994. This was over one year ago and is a lengthy period of time for an adolescent to manifest clinical depression. STUDENT did not earn school credits during most of the ninth grade. Prior to that time, STUDENT was a good student and her school attendance, behavior, and grades were acceptable. STUDENT continues to have problems with school attendance even though she currently is enrolled in a private school with small classes that is designed to address student's individual needs. STUDENT's relations with her family are reported to have suffered due to her condition as well. As to Ms. Aghazarian's testimony that STUDENT does not exhibit depression in the community, the Hearing Officer notes that there was no evidence that Ms. Aghazarian has ever observed STUDENT in the community or has spoken to anyone in the community regarding STUDENT. Therefore, based on the length of time STUDENT has exhibited depression and the credible testimony by Dr. Shore and STUDENT'S AUNT regarding the significant affects of the depression, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has exhibited SED characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree.
Has STUDENT's condition adversely affected her educational performance?
Witnesses who appeared on behalf of STUDENT, including Dr. Shore, Ms. Gray, and STUDENT'S AUNT, testified that STUDENT's poor school attendance is directly related to her emotional problems. Dr. Shore noted that when STUDENT is at school, she appears to try her best; however, her mood and anxiety impair her ability to attend consistently. Dr. Shore testified that STUDENT exhibited a clear pattern of success at school until a traumatic period in her life, which was followed by depression. He concluded that STUDENT's failure to attend school is the primary manifestation of her depression.
STUDENT'S AUNT testified as well that changes in STUDENT's school performance began when she returned to California after living with her mother in Colorado during the seventh grade. She noted that STUDENT's grades went down, she cut classes, and she had behavioral problems. STUDENT'S AUNT reported that STUDENT told her that "her life is school" and that her goals are to graduate from high school and to be a counselor for troubled children. STUDENT'S AUNT testified, however, that STUDENT misses school frequently because she is too sad or depressed to get out of bed in the morning.
There is some evidence that STUDENT is doing better at Mid-Peninsula. The evidence establishes, however, that she continues to be absent from school frequently. For example, as of December 8, 1995, STUDENT had earned 4.0 out of a possible 8.0 credits and 1.5 out of 4.0 credits in algebra. She had been absent 26 times. It is significant that STUDENT has earned so little credit toward high school graduation, which is a goal she wishes to achieve.
Based on the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's emotional condition has adversely affected her educational performance. Therefore, STUDENT meets the SED criteria and is eligible for special education as a student with a serious emotional disturbance.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
ORDER
Within 15 calendar days of the date of this order, the District shall develop an appropriate IEP for STUDENT as a student eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed.
DATED: March 18, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES:
1. STUDENT was retained for a second year in kindergarten due to distractibility.
2. STUDENT resides within the attendance boundaries for Carlmont High. She applied for an intra-district transfer to Menlo-Atherton, which the District granted because STUDENT's sister was already attending Menlo-Atherton. Both high schools are within the Sequoia Union High School District.
3. According to Roberto Martinez, vice principal of Menlo-Atherton, STUDENT served only 20 days of suspension and additional days were waived.
4. Section 504 prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability. The Hearing Office, however, has responsibility only for due process hearings under IDEA. Therefore, this decision does not address the availability of remedies to STUDENT under Section 504.
5. At the request of Mr. Giles, Ms. Gray saw STUDENT February through April of 1995 for five therapy sessions of 50 to 60 minutes each. Therapy was discontinued because the family had difficulty providing transportation for STUDENT to Ms. Gray's office. Ms. Gray is in private practice and also provides services to youth through San Mateo County Mental Health.
6. The SST noted that the information from Ms. Gray regarding her diagnosis of a PTSD was too general to provide the basis for a decision to evaluate STUDENT. It was also noted that STUDENT objected to disclosure of information supporting Ms. Gray's diagnosis.
7. Petitioner's attorney and Ms. Gray attended the meeting and their signatures appear on the behavioral contract. They later disputed the appropriateness of the contract.
8. The assessment was completed at the request of STUDENT's attorney, Mr. Giles.
9. California's definition of SED is almost identical to the federal definition. Under (C) above, the California requirement includes that the inappropriate behavior must be "exhibited in several situations." Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3030(i)(3).
10. Dr. Kester's guidelines are contained within the Educational Diagnostic Manual for the Seriously Emotionally Disturbed Student (EDM), which was published in June 1984 by the California Association of School Psychologists. (See Respondent's Exhibit A-9, a-x) In assessing whether STUDENT meets SED criteria, several other witnesses also referred to the EDM. The Hearing Officer notes that this manual does not constitute either policy or law.
11. According to Ms. Gray, a diagnosis of PTSD is based on the person experiencing a traumatic event outside the realm of normal human experience and having recurrent symptoms. She noted that children who have been abused often suffer from PTSD.
12. According to STUDENT'S AUNT, at a conference with Mr. Martinez, she requested that the school provide counseling for STUDENT, and following Ms. Gray's report, she requested that the school assess STUDENT for special education.
13. The cousin was killed by a pipe bomb.
