California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 19, 1998
Student v. San Diego Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1093-98 · Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare
San Diego Unified denied FAPE with an IEP lacking reading goals; parent's request for first-grade placement rejected.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
An 11-year-old fifth grader's parent filed for a hearing against San Diego Unified School District. The student was eligible for special education because of global developmental delays, a visual impairment, and a speech disorder. She attended an independent living skills (ILS) special day class at Hage Elementary School. In fourth grade, her mainstream academic classes upset her. A short trial in a regular first-grade class ended in January 1998. For 1998-99, the District offered the ILS class plus inclusion with fifth graders. The parent wanted her in a regular first-grade class for academics.
The Hearing Officer found that the District's placement could give the student educational benefit. He credited two ILS teachers who had mainstreamed her successfully in earlier grades. However, the offer did not deal with her anxiety or her need to feel successful in regular classes. The IEP also had no reading goal and weak academic goals. For these reasons, the District did not offer a FAPE. The Hearing Officer also rejected the first-grade placement. The student was six years older than most first graders, did not progress during the trial, and had little contact with classmates. The least restrictive environment presumption favors peers close to her age. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days, add an outside inclusion specialist, write full academic goals including reading, and weigh listed factors. Attorney fees were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. factors when a parent asked for placement with much younger children. The Hearing Officer read the mainstreaming presumption to favor peers near the student's own age. He also found a denial of FAPE because the offer ignored a known problem and the IEP lacked reading goals.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1. Has San Diego Unified School District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 1998-99 school year?
The ILS class with inclusion in fifth-grade academics could provide educational benefit. But the offer did not address the student's anxiety and need to feel successful in regular education, and the IEP lacked reading and other appropriate academic goals, so the District did not offer a FAPE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Should STUDENT be placed in a regular education first-grade class for her academic instruction for the 1998-99 school year?
A first-grade placement was inappropriate and did not conform with the LRE mandate. The student did not benefit academically or socially in the trial, was six years older than most first graders, and the LRE presumption favors peers close in age.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to attorney fees and other legal costs associated with this hearing?
The Hearing Officer had no authority to award attorney fees or costs without the consent of both parties, so the request was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP team to develop a new IEP and a new offer of placement for 1998-99. The team must consider: the student's need to feel comfortable and successful in regular education; her eagerness to learn; why the fourth-grade placement failed; the full range of curriculum modifications and supplementary aids and services; incremental approaches to mainstreaming; the presumption of placement with peers reasonably close in age; and whether the ILS class may be inadequate for academic needs that cannot be met in regular education.
- The IEP team must include a fully qualified inclusion specialist with expertise in developing mainstream placements. This person cannot be a current IEP team member, one of the student's prior teachers, or a District witness. The discussion adds that the specialist must be readily available for the rest of 1998-99 to monitor progress and help modify the program.
- Order to provide or change services. The new IEP must contain a full set of appropriate academic goals and objectives, including a reading goal.
Key authorities
Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H. (Holland), 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994); Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. 874 (E.D. Cal. 1992); Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036 (5th Cir. 1989); 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56507
People named in the decision
- Sheila Weinberg, program manager, District representative at hearing, San Diego Unified School District
- Debbie Lustigson, private tutor (former special education teacher), witness for Student, Private
- Dr. Judith Fogel, principal, District witness, Hage Elementary School, San Diego Unified School District
- Margaret Fleury, regular education first-grade teacher, District witness, Hage Elementary School, San Diego Unified School District
- Pat Howell-Schmidt, special education ILS teacher (student's teacher for grades 1-3), District witness, Hage Elementary School, San Diego Unified School District
- Sharon Kramer, regular education teacher, long-term substitute in ILS class, District witness, San Diego Unified School District
- Tricia de Luna, current ILS special day class teacher, District witness, Hage Elementary School, San Diego Unified School District
- Patricia Cromer, attorney who filed the hearing request for Student (later replaced)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Edwin Villmoare, Chief Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Diego, California, on October 6, 1998.
Petitioner, STUDENT, was represented by attorney Richard D. Gann. STUDENT’s PARENT, was present on STUDENT’s behalf. Respondent, San Diego Unified School District (District), was represented by Richard J. Soto, Deputy General Counsel for the District. Sheila Weinberg, program manager, was present on behalf of the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the receipt of closing briefs. The briefs were subsequently received. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Has San Diego Unified School District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the l998-99 school year?
2. Should STUDENT be placed in a regular education first-grade class for her academic instruction for the 1998-99 school year?
3. Is STUDENT entitled to attorney fees and other legal costs associated with this hearing?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eleven-year-old student currently enrolled in the fifth grade at Hage Elementary School within the District. She is eligible for special education on the basis of global development delays, visual impairment, and a speech disorder. If placed solely on the basis of her age, STUDENT would be in the sixth grade.
STUDENT is currently placed in the independent living skills (ILS) class of Ms. Tricia de Luna, a special day class (SDC) for students mildly to moderately mentally retarded. As a result of a disagreement between STUDENT’s PARENT and the District concerning the appropriate grade level for STUDENT’s mainstream regular education classes, STUDENT is not attending any regular education academic classes. STUDENT spends her entire school day in the ILS class except for activities such as adaptive physical education (APE), occupational therapy (OT), and recess, where she mingles with other fifth-graders. STUDENT receives only limited academic instruction in the ILS class.
During her first, second, and third grade years, STUDENT attended the ILS class of Ms. Pat Howell-Schmidt, with mainstreaming in regular education classes for most of her academic instruction. Ms. Howell-Schmidt and her aides prepared the instructional materials for the regular education teachers to use with STUDENT. These materials were described as adaptations of the curricula used with the regular education students.
During the first semester of the fourth grade (academic year 1997-98), STUDENT once again attended an ILS class while receiving most of her academic instruction in regular fourth grade classes. As in the previous years, special academic materials geared to STUDENT’s abilities were prepared by ILS staff.
At some point during the first semester of the fourth grade, according to PARENT, STUDENT became extremely distressed and indicated that the work in her fourth grade academic classes was too advanced for her. PARENT and the District agreed to reduce STUDENT’s mainstreaming to one hour per day. However, STUDENT continued to express anxiety and unhappiness over her academic work.
In December 1997, at PARENT’s urging, the District agreed to place STUDENT on a trial basis in Margaret Fleury’s regular first-grade class for language arts. STUDENT received no fourth grade regular education academic instruction thereafter. In early January, the District ended the first-grade experiment on the grounds that it had proved inappropriate for STUDENT. The District proposed returning STUDENT to at least some regular fourth grade academic classes. PARENT refused. Thereafter, STUDENT spent her school day in the ILS class except for activities such as APE, lunch, and recess.
In the spring of 1998, PARENT prepared a draft IEP, dated May 8, 1998, calling for STUDENT to spend up to 40 percent of her time in a regular first-grade class, with the rest of her day to be spent in an SDC. It is unclear whether PARENT gave this draft to the District. In any case, no District representative signed it.(Footnote 2)
On May 29, 1998, the District convened an IEP meeting. At that meeting, the District presented PARENT with an IEP which called for STUDENT to spend up to 39 percent of her day in regular fourth grade activities.L(Footnote 3) None of these activities listed were academic classes. The narrative portion of the IEP indicated that the District offered academic instruction, including reading, in either an ILS class or an age appropriate regular classroom. PARENT refused to sign the District’s proposed IEP, and rejected all goals for STUDENT relating to independent living skills.
At the same IEP meeting, PARENT presented the District with a proposed IEP that would place STUDENT in a regular first-grade class for 30 to 70 percent of the school day. STUDENT was not to receive any services in an SDC. There was no indication where STUDENT would spend her time when not in the regular first-grade class. The District representatives refused to sign PARENT’s proposed IEP.
On July 20, 1998, attorney Patricia Cromer filed a request for a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT. Ms. Cromer was eventually replaced on the case by Mr. Gann.
As indicated above, STUDENT is currently attending the ILS class of Ms. Patricia de Luna, where she receives limited academic instruction. She attends no regular education academic classes.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Witnesses for Petitioner
1. Debbie Lustigson is a former special education teacher who serves as a private tutor for STUDENT. She testified as follows: She tutors STUDENT once a week for one-half an hour using regular first-grade reading materials. During the last six months, she has worked with STUDENT on reading comprehension since STUDENT decodes words without comprehending their meaning in context. STUDENT can print legible letters, if the line on the page has been highlighted. STUDENT is not at a fourth or fifth-grade social or emotional level and probably could not receive academic or social benefit from contact with fifth-graders. STUDENT would not be able to understand much of the vocabulary used in fifth-grade work. STUDENT’s social skills are approximately at the kindergarten level. STUDENT can socialize more effectively with first-graders, most of whom are approximately five years old. Her language, interests, and abilities are at a first-grade level. Ms. Lustigson acknowledged that she did not observe STUDENT in last year’s first-grade experiment.
2. STUDENT’s PARENT, testified as follows: STUDENT became very upset over her fourth grade academics because she found the work, even as adapted by the ILS teachers, too difficult. Even when fourth grade academic work was reduced to an hour per day, STUDENT remained agitated and continued to complain that the work was too complex for her. During the 1997-98 year, the fourth grade teacher told PARENT that STUDENT’s presence in the fourth grade was not beneficial to her.(Footnote 4) At this point, PARENT arranged to have STUDENT placed in a first-grade class. PARENT served as an occasional volunteer in the first-grade class. Her observation was that STUDENT was well accepted by the first-graders and that STUDENT enjoyed them. STUDENT made no specific academic progress in the first-grade class because she was allowed to stay there only a brief period of time.
In PARENT’s view, placing STUDENT in a fifth-grade class for academics with the appropriate modifications would mean, in effect, that STUDENT would have her own separate curriculum and that this arrangement would isolate STUDENT from her fellow fifth-graders and make her feel like a failure, particularly since she learns in large part by watching others and could not learn from students as advanced as fifth-graders. STUDENT’s current ILS class is inadequate for her academically because her level of skills far exceed the level of skills of the other pupils in the class. Confining STUDENT to the ILS class places her at risk of regression. The regular first-grade class is the appropriate placement for STUDENT because she socializes and learns at this level, particularly by observing students of this age group.
Witnesses for Respondent
1. Dr. Judith Fogel, principal at Hage Elementary School, testified on STUDENT’s experimental placement in the first grade as follows: STUDENT was placed in the first grade at her PARENT’s request. STUDENT’s reading education continued in the ILS class. STUDENT could not manage first grade academics without an aide and, even with an aide, needed the skills of an ILS teacher to adapt first grade academics to reflect her limitations. STUDENT cannot move at the pace of first-graders, nor can she learn through the teaching methodologies used with first-graders. If STUDENT were to remain in the first grade without ILS support, as her PARENT proposes, STUDENT would need several years to cover the first-grade curriculum.
With regard to STUDENT’s current ILS class, Dr. Fogel indicated that it has six to eight students at the fourth and fifth-grade age levels. All are developmentally delayed, most with additional disabilities. Not all are capable of reading, although most, but not all, are verbal and capable of some speech.
2. Margaret Fleury was STUDENT’s teacher during the month STUDENT spent in the first grade during the 1997-98 year. Ms. Fleury testified as follows: She agreed to accept STUDENT into her class on an experimental basis when asked to do so by Dr. Fogel. Initially, STUDENT was in her class for approximately two hours per day. STUDENT did not perform well despite the assistance of an aide and, on occasion, help from her PARENT, PARENT. STUDENT did not keep up with the academics in the class and was unable to share ideas with her fellow students. She could read words but not sentences. In general, she was not at the level of the first grade students, especially in regard to reading and comprehension. The first grade was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT, in part because first-graders have a complex language structure that exceeds STUDENT’s present capacities. With regard to socialization, the first-graders were politely interested in STUDENT but there was relatively little interaction between STUDENT and the other students. STUDENT seemed more interested in adults and did not appear to know any of the names of the other first-graders. Ms. Fleury further stated that STUDENT should not receive any language arts from a regular education class. In fact, all of STUDENT’s academics should be special education in nature because her comprehension is so limited that she cannot process the ideas of her fellow students, whether first-graders or fifth-graders. To a large extent, adaptation of regular education courses is not realistic for STUDENT. Even when substantial adaptation was tried in the first grade, STUDENT still missed a lot of what was going on in the classroom.
3. Pat Howell-Schmidt, a special education ILS teacher at Hage School, testified as follows: She has been a special education teacher for eleven years. Her ILS class is designed for students with IQs under 69. The goal of the class is to impart independent living skills. The students in her class range from mildly to severely mentally retarded. She has two aides to assist her in the class, one a special education technician, and the other a teaching assistant. She had STUDENT in her class for first, second, and third grades. Compared with the other ILS students, STUDENT was eager to learn and possessed high verbal skills and an inquisitive mind. STUDENT is the highest functioning student Ms. Howell-Schmidt has ever had out of the approximately 110 students that have attended her ILS class. Overall, STUDENT’s reading level is somewhere above the first grade. STUDENT can read and spell to an extent from first, second and third grade curricula. During the first, second, and third grades, STUDENT was successfully integrated into some regular academic classes. The ILS staff adapted educational materials for use by the regular education teachers.
Ms. Howell-Schmidt testified that she is strongly opposed to STUDENT’s going into a regular first-grade class. STUDENT would regress socially and emotionally in such a placement, and would lose self-esteem. A fifth-grade class would be challenging and beneficial for STUDENT because she is bright and needs the advanced social skills she will acquire from association with fifth-graders. STUDENT can learn in a fifth-grade class with appropriate adaptation and support, and the students in such a class would provide better role models in terms of socialization, verbalization, and vocabulary. STUDENT is currently scheduled to go to the middle school next year, where social skills will be even more important.
According to Ms. Howell-Schmidt, STUDENT does not need her own personal one-to-one aide in a regular class. Providing such an aide would lead to STUDENT’s becoming excessively dependent. STUDENT will need significant adaptations of materials and teaching techniques for the fifth-grade, but the adaptations, if handled appropriately, will enable STUDENT to learn and to feel good about herself. Specifically, STUDENT can be successfully mainstreamed for library, fitness, lunch, assembly, physical education, science, class opening, part of language arts, current events, and possibly social studies. Regardless of where she is placed, STUDENT will need to work on her reading skills with separate one-to-one support.
4. Ms. Sharon Kramer, a regular education teacher who served as a long-term substitute teacher in STUDENT’s ILS class during the spring of 1998, testified as follows: In her ILS class, the students worked on art, printing, use of computers, math, and science. STUDENT was a very high functioning student in the ILS class. STUDENT interacted reasonably well with her nondisabled age peers. She attended play practice, recess, and lunch with nondisabled fourth-graders. Ms. Kramer agreed with the conclusion that STUDENT did not make much progress in the fourth grade regular education academic classes and Ms. Kramer initially agreed with the experimental placment of STUDENT in the first grade. However, she later regarded the experiment as a failure. She concluded that STUDENT cannot attend any academic regular education classes without major adaptations. Social studies and parts of language arts would be the best subject areas for STUDENT to study in regular education.
5. Tricia de Luna is STUDENT’s ILS teacher for the current year. She testified as follows: Her ILS class is geared to fourth- and fifth-graders with severe disabilities. There are currently six students in the class, all of whom attend some regular education classes. Ms. de Luna adapts material for regular education teachers to use with her special education students. STUDENT is currently in the ILS class for the entire school day, except for activities such as APE, recess, and occupational therapy. Because PARENT will not consent, STUDENT has no access to the fifth grade regular education curriculum. STUDENT is currently working on some reading and writing in the ILS class. Her word decoding is between second and third grade levels; however, her comprehension is at a first-grade level. STUDENT would benefit educationally and socially from a regular education fifth-grade class. She needs access to peers close to her age in order to work on social skills needed for her transition to middle school, scheduled for next year. In particular, she needs access to the syntax of age appropriate regular education students. Ms. de Luna further stated that STUDENT can be effectively integrated into regular fifth-grade classes to some extent for writing, art, reading aloud, working with manipulatives, and social studies. The specific benefits STUDENT would receive from attending fifth grade regular education include knowledge of government, science, geography, an expanded vocabulary and better conversational arts. It will be necessary to proceed experimentally with STUDENT’s mainstreaming in order to ascertain what actually works for her. Most of the learning STUDENT would experience in the fifth grade would have to be developed through substantial adaptations of curricula and course materials by ILS teachers. Without major ILS support, STUDENT’s attending the fifth grade would be just a socialization event for her. A first-grade placement would be inappropriate since STUDENT would be denied access to the complex sentence structure of fifth- graders, and she would not develop relationships with students who would move on to middle school with her next year.
DISCUSSION
Summary of Applicable Law
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and comparable state law, students with disabilities have a right to free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standard of the state educational agency and conform with the student’s individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ..." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175(1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the special education maximize the student’s potential. The Court stated that "the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
Special education law also requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). U.S.Code § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as "mainstreaming," or education in the "least restrictive environment" (LRE). The law demonstrates a "strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption." Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir.1989).
To determine whether a disabled child should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental services, four criteria must be considered: the educational benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aides and services, as compared with the educational benefits of a special education classroom; the nonacademic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and the other children in the regular classroom; and the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., (Holland) 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir.1994).
Thus, special education statutory law and the Rowley decision taken together constitute a four part test for analyzing whether a school district’s proposed placement satisfies IDEA: (1) whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to the student; (2) whether the placement is designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (3) whether the placement conforms with the student’s IEP; and (4) whether the placement satisfies the LRE mandate.
Issue No. 1. Has San Diego Unified School District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 1998-99 school year?
The testimony on whether STUDENT can benefit educationally from some inclusion in a fifth-grade regular education class was contradictory and, at times, confused. PARENT and Ms. Lustigson insisted that STUDENT is socially and academically at approximately a first-grade level and cannot possibly benefit from fifth-grade academic classes, even with modifications. PARENT argued that adaptations appropriate for STUDENT would result in her having a separate curriculum that would isolate her from fifth-graders and lower her self-esteem. However, PARENT did not object to STUDENT’s taking recess, lunch, and APE with older students. Ms. Fleury seemed to express a view that in some ways paralleled the views of PARENT and Ms. Lustigson. Ms. Fleury testified that STUDENT cannot process ideas or language structure of either first- or fifth-graders. Ms. Fleury testified that STUDENT cannot move at the pace of first-graders or learn through the same methodologies. One inference to be drawn from Ms. Fleury’s testimony (and possibly the testimony of Dr. Fogel) is that if STUDENT cannot successfully receive academics in the first-grade class with adaptations, she cannot succeed in a fifth-grade class with adaptations. If this conclusion is correct, STUDENT would need to be confined to the very restrictive placement of an SDC for all her academics. However, no witness recommended or even discussed confining STUDENT to her ILS class. Moreover, no witness discussed the existence of an SDC with an academic component that is more academically comprehensive and advanced than STUDENT’s current ILS class. Therefore, there is no basis for considering an SDC placement on a full-time basis.
On the other hand, the two special education teachers who know STUDENT best, Ms. Howell-Schmidt and Ms. de Luna, testified that with proper modifications and careful monitoring STUDENT can participate and learn from certain fifth-grade academic courses, albeit at a lower level of comprehension than that achieved by nondisabled fifth-graders. Ms. Howell-Schmidt, who taught STUDENT’s ILS classes for three years and modified material allowing STUDENT to participate in regular education academic classes for these three years, and Ms. de Luna, STUDENT’s current ILS teacher, testified that students far more limited than STUDENT have been successfully included in regular education academic classes and have received educational and social benefit. While Ms. Howell-Schmidt had a more expansive list of regular educational courses STUDENT might benefit from, both teachers testified that STUDENT should be included in a regular class for science, current events, and part of language arts. They indicated that it would be necessary to take an experimental approach to determine exactly how STUDENT should be included in fifth-grade academics. The qualifications of Ms. Howell-Schmidt and Ms. de Luna as special education teachers, their substantial experience in working with mildly to severely delayed students, and their success in including such students in academic courses with nondisabled peers of approximately the same age lend substantial weight to their testimony. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Ms. Howell-Schmidt and Ms. de Luna that STUDENT can receive academic benefit in a fifth-grade class.
With regard to nonacademic benefits, Ms. Howell-Schmidt, Ms. Kramer and Ms. de Luna -- all teachers who have worked with STUDENT on mainstream academics -- agreed that STUDENT needs access to fifth-graders across a broad domain of activities that include academics and nonacademics to help her communication and oral comprehension skills. These witnesses also agreed that these activities are necessary to enable STUDENT to develop relationships that will endure as her education progresses from grade to grade. Even PARENT had no objection to STUDENT socializing at recess and lunch with fifth-graders.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement of an ILS class with some inclusion in regular fifth-grade academics, supported by appropriate modification, can reasonably be expected to provide STUDENT with educational benefits, both social and academic. With regard to STUDENT’s unique needs, PARENT’s primary complaint involved STUDENT’s limited progress in reading and the anxiety and fear of humiliation STUDENT expressed while attending the fourth grade class. Almost all witnesses agreed that reading is a special problem area for STUDENT that must be addressed through a one-to-one instructional methodology regardless of her placement. Thus, reading methodology is not a real issue.(Footnote 5)
PARENT testified credibly about STUDENT’s finding fourth grade too difficult, and STUDENT’s distress and plea to be allowed to avoid the fourth grade class. PARENT’s testimony was that of a dedicated, concerned parent. Her daughter’s anxiety and agitation drove PARENT to first seek a reduction of fourth grade academics and, when that failed, to arrange the first-grade trial placement. The District’s willingness to cut fourth grade academics and to try a first-grade placement indicates that the District implicitly acknowledged that STUDENT was having a significant problem. In effect, the District failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for participation and a sense of accomplishment free from excessive anxiety and fear of humiliation. The courts have placed substantial emphasis on the comfort of cognitively limited students in inclusion placements. See, i.e., Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, supra. The District’s offer of placement for 1998-99 does not acknowledge STUDENT’s problem during the fourth grade, nor does it contain a plan for addressing that problem. STUDENT will need to feel comfortable and productive for the placement that the District is currently proposing to succeed. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer does not address this critical unique need.
With regard to STUDENT’s IEP, there is a disconnect between the IEP and the offer of placement. As noted above, the IEP contains no reading goal, and those goals that might be characterized as academic (such as improving language skills and learning to count and to tell time) bear little relationship to proposed courses such as science and current events. The offer of placement does not conform to the IEP. More importantly, the Hearing Officer concludes that IEP itself is legally deficient because it lacks appropriate reading and other academic goals.
As determined above, the District’s proposed placement will likely provide STUDENT with educational benefit. However, the District’s proposed placement does not meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and the IEP is legally inadequate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has not offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for 1998-99.
The District’s argument that STUDENT should receive some academic instruction with regular education fifth-graders pursuant to the LRE mandate is addressed below, under the discussion of the first-grade placement that PARENT seeks for STUDENT.
Issue No. 2 Should STUDENT be placed in a regular education first-grade class for all her academic instruction?
PARENT argued that first-grade (without ILS support) is the appropriate, least restrictive placement for STUDENT because she is academically and socially at approximately the first-grade level, and that significant participation in a first-grade class would give her greater access to nondisabled regular education students. PARENT’s argument is not without a surface appeal, especially given the problems that STUDENT encountered last year in her fourth grade regular education class. However, the results of the first-grade experiment and the drawbacks of the fourth grade placement do not justify placing STUDENT four grades behind where she would otherwise be.
STUDENT’s stay in the first grade was limited, and only limited lessons can be drawn from it. Based on her occasional participation as a volunteer in the first-grade class, PARENT concluded the experiment a success. PARENT’s knowledge of the first-grade placement was limited and she possesses no special knowledge concerning special education or mainstreaming. Ms. Lustigson, who also advocated a first-grade placement for STUDENT, admitted she never visited the first-grade class. Both Dr. Fogel and Ms. Fleury reached a contrary conclusion concerning the appropriateness of a first-grade placement. In their opinion, STUDENT could not participate in first-grade academics, even with the assistance of an aide. In their view, she cannot move at the pace of first-graders or learn through the pedagogical methods used with them. According to Ms. Fleury, there was relatively little social interaction between STUDENT and the first-graders: STUDENT had little interest in the first-graders, and she did not appear to know the names of any of them. Ms. Fleury testified persuasively that STUDENT was not cognitively or socially a first-grader and that all STUDENT’s academic education would have to be specially designed by knowledgeable special education teachers. Ms. Howell-Schmidt and Ms. de Luna testified that a first-grade placement would leave STUDENT socially isolated and cause a loss of self-esteem and a regression in social skills.
Clearly, the preponderence of the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s experiment in the first grade did not meet her unique needs and was not educationally or socially beneficial and, therefore, was not appropriate. The same evidence also establishes that returning her to the first grade for the l998-99 year would be equally inappropriate.
Petitioner argued that the LRE doctrine as set forth in the Holland case compels a placement in the first grade. Using the Holland criteria, Petitioner asserted that STUDENT will receive substantial academic and nonacademic benefit from a regular education first-grade placement and that her presence in the first grade would not cause adverse effect on the first-graders or involve excessive costs. Petitioner’s position is correct with regard to the last two criteria. However, it has been established above that STUDENT cannot be expected to benefit from a first-grade placement, academically or nonacademically.
Petitioner also argued that language in the district court opinion in Holland requires placement with nondisabled students even if they are not age appropriate peers. Petitioner misread Holland. The district court clearly started from the premise that the LRE requirement creates a presumption that the disabled child will be educated with nondisabled peers of the same or similar age. In a footnote, the Court simply observed that an exact age match is not necessary. Rachel was no more than two years older than the children with whom she was placed. The Court found "this age difference is not so pronounced that she [Rachel] is learning inappropriate behavior or is not perceived as part of the class." Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. 874, 882, n.10 (E.D. Cal. 1992). In the instant case, Petitioner proposes a situation in which STUDENT would be six years older than most of the first-graders. Ms. Fleury testified persuasively that first-graders would not perceive STUDENT as part of the class. Moreover, it is clear from the evidence that STUDENT would be modeling her behavior from children much younger than the third- and fourth-graders with whom she has recently socialized. Such a placement represents a major step back that is not justified by evidence. If anything, such a placement runs counter to the LRE mandate.
The Hearing Officer finds Petitioner’s proposed placement neither appropriate nor in conformity with the LRE mandate. Thus, the placements proposed by both parties are inappropriate under special education law.
* * *
Given the legal presumption for mainstreaming with age comparable, nondisabled peers and the fact that STUDENT has worked comfortably in regular education classes through the third grade, the Hearing Officer turns to the question of whether the District’s offer can be modified so as to be made appropriate for STUDENT.
The question of STUDENT’s ability to handle language structure presents a puzzle. Ms. Fleury concluded that STUDENT’s limitations with language and comprehension were so great that she doubted any inclusion or mainstreaming, even with adaptation, was realistic for STUDENT. However, Ms. Fleury is not a special education teacher or an inclusion specialist. STUDENT has been receiving academic instruction in age appropriate regular education classes for four years. According to Ms. Howell-Schmidt, STUDENT made important progress academically during the first three of these years, and improved her social skills. No one, including PARENT, testified that STUDENT was not happy in school during these years. Difficulties for STUDENT arose solely during the fourth grade year. Whatever STUDENT’s communications limitations, she was able to participate in first, second, and third-grade regular education classes. It is reasonable to conclude that with effective adaptation she could continue such participation in the fifth grade (or possibly a repeat of the fourth grade).
None of the witnesses concluded that STUDENT should be fully included in a regular fifth-grade class, and none endorsed a full SDC placement. Clearly, STUDENT requires independent living skills and she cannot receive all her academics in regular classes. However, she requires academic instruction that markedly exceeds the capabilities of her fellow ILS students, none of whom can read. For such instruction she must have access to regular education. However, there was no persuasive evidence establishing that STUDENT’s mainstreaming must occur in a fifth-grade class. Perhaps a fourth grade class with appropriate modifications would better suit her at this point. What is clear is that STUDENT must have better support than she received last year in the fourth grade. This support may require more substantial curriculum modifications, a better tailored schedule, better training of the regular education teacher, and at least a part-time aide able to work effectively with STUDENT. STUDENT’s mainstreaming will have to proceed carefully and experimentally in order to help ensure that STUDENT feels accepted and comfortable. In particular, her self-esteem and natural motivation must be reinforced.
The Hearing Officer is in no position to design a specific appropriate placement for STUDENT. That is a matter for the IEP team. However, the record in this case establishes issues and concerns that the IEP team must consider in redesigning STUDENT’s placement. Specifically, the IEP team must consider the following:
1. STUDENT’s need to feel comfortable and successful in regular education. 2. STUDENT’s genuine eagerness to learn.
3. The reasons the fourth grade placement failed.
4. The full spectrum of curriculum modifications and supplementary aides and services that might enable STUDENT to succeed in a regular education setting. 5. Incremental approaches to mainstreaming.
6. The presumption that STUDENT should be with peers that are reasonably close to her in age. 7. The possibility that STUDENT’s ILS class, as presently constituted, is inadequate to meet STUDENT’s academic needs that cannot be effectively addressed in a regular education class.
In addition, the IEP team must include in STUDENT’s IEP more detailed and comprehensive academic goals and objectives, including a reading goal.
Given the failure of the District to identify and think through the problems with STUDENT’s fourth-grade placement, and to modify its l998-99 offer of placement accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP team requires additional expertise. Therefore, the Hearing Officer orders the District to add to the IEP team a fully qualified, inclusion specialist with substantial expertise and experience in mainstreaming students such as STUDENT. Given the District’s failure in the past, the Hearing Officer concludes that the inclusion specialist must be someone other than the present members of STUDENT’s IEP team, her prior teachers, or the District witnesses in this case. Moreover, this inclusion specialist must be readily available throughout the remainder of the 1998-99 school year to monitor STUDENT’s progress and to assist in making such modifications to her program as are necessary.
Issue No. 3 Is STUDENT entitled to attorney’s fees and all other legal costs associated with this case?
Neither state nor federal law gives the Hearing Officer the authority to award attorney’s fees or other legal costs absent the consent of both parties. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i); California Education Code § 56507(b). The Petitioner’s request for fees and costs is denied.
ORDER
1. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team to develop a new IEP and a new offer of placement for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. The IEP team shall include a fully qualified inclusion specialist with expertise in developing mainstream placements for students such as STUDENT. The inclusion specialist must be someone other than the present members of STUDENT’s IEP team, her prior teachers, or any of the District’s witnesses in this case.
2. The new IEP must contain a full set of appropriate academic goals and objectives, including a reading goal.
3. When designing the new IEP and the new offer of placement, the IEP team shall consider the following factors:
(a) STUDENT’s need to feel comfortable and successful in regular education. (b) STUDENT’s genuine eagerness to learn.
(c) The reasons the fourth grade placement failed.
(d) The full spectrum of curriculum modifications and supplementary aides and services that might enable STUDENT to succeed in a regular education setting. (e) Incremental approaches to mainstreaming.
(f) The presumption that STUDENT should be with peers that are reasonably close to her in age. (g) The possibility that STUDENT’s ILS class, as presently constituted, may be inadequate to meet STUDENT’s academic needs that cannot be effectively addressed in a regular education class.
4. Petitioner’s request for legal fees and costs is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d) a hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue No. 1: the Petitioner prevailed.
Issue No. 2: the Respondent prevailed.
Issue No. 3: the Respondent prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this decision have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 19, 1998 Edwin Villmoare Chief Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
CASE NO. SN 1093-98Footnotes:1. The issues have been adjusted to reflect the law applicable to the case and to allow for more effective adjudication.2. Apparently, PARENT prepared a similar IEP, dated January 16, 1998, and gave it to the District. The District did not sign it. This proposed IEP was not submitted into evidence.3. The parties agreed that the reference to the fourth grade covered only the remainder of the 1997-98 school year and that the District's offer of placement for 1998-99 involved fifth-grade activities.4. The evidence did not establish the name of the fourth grade regular education teacher.5. It should be noted that the District's IEP contains no reading goal for STUDENT.
