California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 5, 2001

Student v. Las Virgenes Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1101-99 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Las Virgenes Unified must repay half of 1999-2000 private school tuition ($8,910) and provide 120 compensatory hours; seventh-grade program upheld.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 7 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. Footnote 27 says the Petitioner's closing brief reported an IEP meeting in October 2000. Footnote 1 says the 2000-2001 school year was not decided.

Summary

The parents of a student with a specific learning disability filed for due process against Las Virgenes Unified School District. They challenged his special day class program at Lindero Canyon Middle School in sixth and seventh grade (1997-1999). They also challenged the 1999-2000 year, after they enrolled him at Westmark School, a private school for students with learning disabilities.

The Hearing Officer found that the sixth-grade program denied a FAPE. The student made progress in most areas. But District testing after sixth grade put him at kindergarten-to-first-grade levels in spelling, punctuation, capitalization and usage, and the District did not show how it taught those skills. The seventh-grade program was a FAPE. His grades, goal progress and test scores improved, and staff had no reason to think he needed counseling. Extended school year services were not needed in any disputed year.

For 1999-2000, the District never held the annual IEP meeting that the June 1999 IEP scheduled for October 1999. That left the parents with no way to take part in the IEP process while the student's behavior and self-esteem problems grew at Westmark, and it denied a FAPE. Westmark was appropriate even though it offered no counseling. After weighing the equities, the Hearing Officer ordered the District to reimburse half of Westmark's 1999-2000 base tuition ($8,910) and half of private counseling costs from January 2000. The District must also provide 120 hours of one-on-one compensatory instruction in writing mechanics and assistive technology.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a missed annual IEP review as a denial of FAPE because it cut parents out of the IEP process for a whole year. It also shows a Hearing Officer cutting reimbursement in half based on equitable factors. Those factors included benefit outside the student's areas of need and the prior year's appropriate program.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1A. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year?

    The sixth-grade SDC program helped in most areas, but the District did not show benefit in spelling, usage, capitalization and punctuation, so it denied FAPE.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B (school year). Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?

    The seventh-grade SDC program met his needs and gave educational benefit. The WJ-R was an appropriate measure, and staff had no reason to think counseling was needed.

  3. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1B (ESY). Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 extended school year?

    There was no showing of limited recoupment capacity, so extended school year services were not required.

  4. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1C (school year). Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?

    The District failed to hold the annual IEP review due in October 1999. This seriously infringed on the parents' participation and denied FAPE for 1999-2000.

  5. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1C (ESY). Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 extended school year?

    Extended school year services were not required for 1999-2000.

  6. Issue 2. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his placement at the Westmark School for the 1998-1999 ESY and the 1999-2000 school year and ESY, including any designated instruction and services provided by his parents?

    Westmark was appropriate for 1999-2000. On equitable grounds, the District must reimburse 50% of base tuition ($8,910) and 50% of private counseling costs from January 2000. No reimbursement for summer programs or tutoring.

  7. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District's failure to provide FAPE for the years outlined above?

    The Hearing Officer awarded 120 hours of one-on-one compensatory instruction for the 1997-1998 denial, not the three years requested. Compensatory education was not appropriate for 1999-2000.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 20 business days, reimburse the parents for 50% of the cost of the student's counseling with Dr. Harris from January 1, 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, according to proof.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 business days, reimburse the parents for 50% of the base tuition for Westmark School for the 1999-2000 school year, a total of $8,910.
  • Compensatory education. One school year (120 hours) of one-on-one compensatory instruction, 3 hours per week, in writing mechanics (spelling, usage, capitalization, punctuation) and in using assistive technology for writing and editing. It must be delivered by a credentialed teacher experienced with students with learning disabilities and visual processing disorders. If the District has no such teacher, a certified nonpublic school or agency chosen by the parents may provide it. Services must begin within 30 days. Scheduling may be changed by agreement during holidays and vacations, as long as total hours are not reduced.

Total: 120 hours of compensatory services; $8,910 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Burlington; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Joseph Nardo, Director of pupil services (later director of secondary education), Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Peggy Woodall, Director of pupil services, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • James Christianson, Assistant superintendent of educational services, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Dr. Esther Sinclair, Licensed educational psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • Dr. Scott Owen Harris, Private clinical psychologist; student's counselor, witness for Student, Private practice
  • Lyn Lockhart-Mummery, Ph.D., Private psychologist; 1994 independent assessment, Private
  • Marilyn E. Quisenberry, School psychologist (1998 triennial assessment), Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Barbara Katz-Starr, School psychologist (1995 triennial and 2000 assessment), Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Gayla Meseck-Lafferty, Resource specialist; resource math teacher, Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Alissa Anne (Alicia) Williams, SDC teacher and special education case manager, Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Catheryne Khmara, SDC teacher (seventh-grade language arts, science, math), Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Evelyn Klein, SDC teacher (fifth grade), Yerba Buena Elementary School
  • Elaine Watt, School counselor, Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Robert Coryell, General education teacher (woodwork), Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Marilyn Fine, General education teacher (art), Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Mary Reyna, General education teacher (physical education), Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Barbara Lynn Brammer, General education teacher (reading discovery), Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Toni Cooley, General education teacher (language arts and computers), Lindero Canyon Middle School
  • Ben Shifrin, Co-headmaster, private school, Westmark School
  • Jane Wagmeister, Co-headmaster, private school; former District SDC teacher and administrator; District witness, Westmark School
  • Lori Zaragoza, History and study skills teacher, Westmark School
  • Aimee Cohen Weltmann, One-on-one tutor, Westmark School
  • Westmark School, Private school for students with language-based learning disabilities (unilateral placement)
  • Fast Forward Program, Private auditory processing assessment program, Westmark School

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Calabasas, California, on June 20, September 26, 27, 28, 29, and November 2, 3, and 7, 2000.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, STUDENT’S PARENTS. STUDENT was present at the hearing on September 27 and November 7, 2000, only for the purpose of testifying.

Respondent Las Virgenes Unified School District (hereafter the District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrew V. Arczynski. Also present on the District’s behalf were Joseph Nardo, in his capacity as director of pupil services on June 20, 2000, and in his capacity as director of secondary education on September 27, 2000; Peggy Woodall, current director of pupil services, on September 26, 28, 29, and November 2 and 7, 2000, and James Christianson, assistant superintendent of educational services, on November 3, 2000.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: STUDENT, STUDENT’S PARENTS, licensed educational psychologist Dr. Esther Sinclair, clinical psychologist Dr. Scott Owen Harris, Westmark School history teacher Lori Zaragoza, Westmark School co-headmaster Ben Shifrin, Westmark tutor Aimee Cohen Weltmann, and Joseph Nardo.

The District called the following witnesses: District school psychologists Marilyn E. Quisenberry and Barbara Katz-Starr; Lindero Canyon Middle School special day class (SDC) teachers Gayla Meseck-Lafferty, Alissa Anne Williams and Catheryne Khmara; Yerba Buena Elementary School SDC teacher Evelyn Klein; Lindero counselor Elaine Watt; Lindero regular education teachers Robert Coryell (woodwork), Marilyn Fine (art), Mary Reyna (physical education), Barbara Lynn Brammer (reading discovery), and Toni Cooley (language arts and computers); Westmark School co-headmaster Jane Wagmeister; and Joseph Nardo.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. On January 8, 2001, the last closing brief was received. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for:

A. the 1997 - 1998 school year, B. the 1998 - 1999 school and extended school year, and C. the 1999-2000 school and extended school year?

2. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his placement at the Westmark School, a private school, for the 1998-1999 extended school year (ESY), and the 1999-2000 school and ESY, including any designated instruction and services provided by his parents?

3. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide FAPE for the years outlined above?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

STUDENT contends that he did not receive a FAPE during the sixth (1997-1998) and seventh (1998-1999) grades in the SDC program at Lindero Canyon Middle School (Lindero), because he made little progress in the areas of reading, math, and written expression in relation to his average cognitive ability. STUDENT contends that he made educational progress in prior placements within the District only because his parents supplemented his education by hiring private educational therapists. Beginning in the sixth grade, when he entered Lindero, his family no longer provided private tutoring. STUDENT also contends that the District should have offered him DIS counseling services to address self-esteem issues. For the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT contends that the District did not provide a FAPE, because it failed to conduct an annual IEP review and decreased his level of services from special day class in language arts to resource support for language arts. Consequently, STUDENT’s parents unilaterally placed him at the Westmark School, where he attended summer school in 1999, eighth grade for the 1999-2000 academic year, and summer school in 2000. STUDENT was dismissed from Westmark in early November 2000 for ongoing behavior problems. Despite his dismissal, STUDENT contends that the Westmark program was appropriate and that his parents should be reimbursed for the tuition and other expenses they incurred during this time. In the alternative, STUDENT requests one-on-one educational therapy by a qualified educational therapist for three hours per week for three years to compensate him for the District’s denial of FAPE.

The District contends that STUDENT received educational benefit in the SDC program at Lindero consistent with his cognitive abilities. Although it acknowledges STUDENT’S PARENTS’ desire for STUDENT to perform at grade level, the District contends that the Lindero SDC program allowed him to make appropriate progress and constituted a FAPE. In addition, the District contends that there was no indication from STUDENT’s behavior while at Lindero that he required DIS counseling services. In its view, STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated at Westmark School solely because he wanted to return to his friends at Lindero. The District contends that the Westmark School was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT, was not the least restrictive environment, and did not provide him with educational benefit. In its view, Westmark’s inappropriateness as an educational placement for STUDENT was underscored by his ultimate dismissal from that school. Accordingly, the District asserts that reimbursement or compensatory education is not appropriate.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old ninth-grade student who has been eligible for special education services because of a specific learning disability (SLD) for most of his educational career.(Footnote 2) In 1993, STUDENT moved to Agoura Hills, in the Las Virgenes District.(Footnote 3) He entered the second grade at Yerba Buena Elementary School (Yerba Buena), was determined to be eligible for special education as a student with an SLD, and was placed in the resource services program (RSP).

In November 1994, at the beginning of the third grade, the STUDENT’s PARENTS had STUDENT privately assessed by Lyn Lockhart-Mummery, Ph.D. After conducting an extensive battery of tests, Dr. Mummery concluded that STUDENT’s specific learning disability “may be described as a memory deficit with a particular weakness in visual processing, including visual memory, visual-perceptual organization, and visual-motor integration.” STUDENT’s scores on the WISC-III revealed a 32-point discrepancy between his average range verbal skills and his below-average performance scales. His full scale I.Q. was described to be in the low average range. Dr. Mummery recommended that STUDENT be served in a more specialized classroom than the RSP, provided specific recommendations regarding educational strategies to address STUDENT’s needs, and recommended consistent support from his private educational therapist. (Footnote 4)

STUDENT was placed in a special day class (SDC) at Yerba Buena for his fourth and fifth grade years. In his October 1995 triennial review, District school psychologist Barbara Katz-Starr concluded that STUDENT’s “verbal abilities are at an average level with non-verbal abilities falling at a Borderline level.(Footnote 5) Significant weaknesses are manifested in visual organizational skills.” STUDENT continued “to exhibit a disorder in visual processing (ability to recognize and interpret visual stimuli) which adversely affects his school performance in math and some areas of written language and reading.”

In the fall of 1997, STUDENT entered Lindero as a sixth grade student. As indicated in his November 18, 1997 annual IEP, STUDENT’s educational placement was in the SDC with the exception of physical education and an elective. He was in Alicia William’s SDC for language arts, social sciences and science. Ms. Williams was also STUDENT’s special education case manager. STUDENT had one period of resource math with Ms. Meseck-Lafferty. Extended school year was not authorized and no DIS services were provided. Under present levels of academic performance, STUDENT was noted to be working on a fifth-grade level in reading, a fourth-grade level in math and a third- to fourth-grade level in spelling. He was described as well liked, friendly and cooperative. STUDENT was to be given extended time on tests and weekly input from general education teachers regarding his progress and any concerns in those classes. STUDENT successfully completed sixth grade. With the exception of one incident, no behavior concerns were noted. (Footnote 6)

In the fall of 1998, STUDENT entered seventh grade in the SDC at Lindero. In his October 1998 triennial evaluation, school psychologist Marilyn Quisenberry administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Third (WISC-III) to determine STUDENT’s intellectual potential.(Footnote 7) STUDENT’s verbal IQ was 92, his performance IQ was 71, and his full scale IQ was 80. Ms. Quisenbery found that STUDENT’s WISC-III scores confirmed previous testing by Dr. Mummery that placed him in the average range of verbal ability, the borderline range of performance ability, and in the low-average range on his overall ability. STUDENT’s significant verbal - performance IQ discrepancy of 21 points suggested that his verbal-based abilities were more developed than his performance-based abilities and that, in the classroom, his auditory/vocal channel of learning was more efficient than his visual/vocal channel of learning. Relative strengths in the areas of verbal comprehension skills and verbal concept formation were noted. Relative weaknesses were noted in skills relating to part-to-whole reasoning, visual-spatial relationships, processing speed, visual discrimination, motor coordination, and perceptual organization. Ms. Quisenberry noted that, in addition, STUDENT “continues to display visual-motor/perceptual-motor processing problems which appear to be significantly affecting [his] educational performance.” (Emphasis in original)

As part of October 1998 triennial assessment, Ms. Williams administered the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R). STUDENT’s standard score on broad reading was 87, with a grade equivalent at the 4.9 level. His standard score in broad written language was 82, with a grade equivalent of 4.5. His standard score on broad math was 89, with a grade equivalent of 6.0.

On October 15, 1998, the IEP team confirmed STUDENT’s eligibility as SLD based upon the triennial assessment. Using the results from the WISC-III and the WJ-R, STUDENT’s full scale IQ of 80 was compared with his WJ-R standard scores to determine if there was a significant discrepancy between his intellectual ability and his achievement for the purposes of continuing eligibility. Based upon this comparison, the IEP team determined that there were no significant discrepancies between STUDENT’s cognitive ability and his academic achievement in the areas of broad reading, broad math or broad written language. STUDENT’s academic achievement in these areas was slightly higher than his ability. STUDENT’s subtests in the areas of usage (SS=65), spelling (SS=0), and punctuation/capitalization (SS=23), however, were significantly below his intellectual ability. The IEP team determined that a significant discrepancy existed in areas of usage, spelling and punctuation/capitalization.(Footnote 8) Processing disorders were noted in visual processing and in sensory-motor skills. STUDENT was again placed in the SDC class for math, language arts, social science and science, with regular education for physical education and an elective. He was in Ms. Khmara’s SDC for language arts, science, math, and “RAD” (reading awakens dreams). He was in Ms. William’s SDC social science class. Extended school year was not authorized and no DIS services were offered. The team noted that STUDENT’s skills “fall far short of grade level requirements. Thus, handling core curriculum material needs considerable modification.” STUDENT’S PARENTS consented to this IEP.

Despite their agreement with this IEP, STUDENT’s parents were concerned that he was not performing at grade level. At or shortly after the 1998 triennial assessment, STUDENT was independently assessed at the Fast Forward Program, located at the Westmark School, to determine if he had auditory processing problems. After being informed that he did not, the family decided to have another independent evaluation to obtain a better understanding of STUDENT’s educational struggles. Upon a referral from the Westmark School, the family contacted Dr. Esther Sinclair, a licensed educational psychologist and associate professor of psychiatry and biobehavioral sciences at the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute, Department of Behavioral Medicine.

In January and February 1999, Dr. Sinclair assessed STUDENT in two ninety-minute sessions and observed him in the SDC at Lindero for the first three periods of one day. The purpose of Dr. Sinclair’s evaluation was to determine how much growth STUDENT had made between educational evaluations and to give an opinion about the appropriateness of his current placement at Lindero. Dr. Sinclair administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) to STUDENT as well as the WJ-R. She compared the grade equivalents on STUDENT’s three most recent WJ-R scores: the November 1994 scores from Dr. Mummery, the October 1998 triennial scores from the District, and her January 1999 test. From these tests, she determined that written expression was STUDENT’s greatest academic weakness while reading and math represented his academic areas of greatest relative strength. Dr. Sinclair concluded that, over the years he had been in special education, STUDENT’s progress had been slow in reading and math and that his writing skills “look weaker as he gets older.” She also noted that STUDENT was happier in this setting “because he feels less anxiety and pressure to perform. However, it is questionable whether the RSP [sic] is meeting his academic needs.” Dr. Sinclair noted that it “was very distressing that his RSP [sic] teacher responsible for 3 periods of special help and support could not discuss his individual goals and objectives for the 1998-1999 academic year. IEP goals in all academic domains need to be reviewed to determine their appropriateness.” Dr. Sinclair recommended that the parents request an immediate review of STUDENT’s IEP to discuss his placement and stated that private school placements would be discussed with the family.

On April 20, 1999, an IEP meeting was conducted at the parents’ request. The IEP Addendum indicated that the parents were concerned “with how much STUDENT struggles, but believe he would benefit from more challenge in some subject.” The team concluded that math would be the most appropriate subject in which to challenge STUDENT but that, due to the lateness of the year and the schedule disruption it would entail, language arts would be the choice. Dr. Sinclair did not attend this IEP meeting, and her report was not presented.

STUDENT successfully completed the seventh grade at Lindero. During the year, however, his teachers noted that his performance had declined. STUDENT told District staff that he had given up, that his parents were going to place him in a private school, and that, as a result, his work at Lindero did not matter. STUDENT had nine reported behavioral incidents during the seventh grade.(Footnote 9) He was occasionally given brief time outs (2-3 minutes) for “silly” behavior that disrupted the class. His regular and special education teachers generally considered him to be cooperative, compliant and polite.

On June 24, 1999, an IEP meeting was convened at the parents’ request to review STUDENT’s placement and their concerns that he was not making sufficient academic progress. Dr. Sinclair was present and the results of her assessment were reviewed. The IEP described STUDENT’s present level of academic progress as at approximately the fourth-grade level in reading comprehension. He was able to formulate basic paragraphs but still struggled with basic mechanics. STUDENT’s math skills were reported to be at approximately the sixth-grade level. The IEP notes indicate that there was a discussion “about STUDENT’s distress about the possible change in placement since parents have discussed their desire to change his placement.” STUDENT’s teachers reported that STUDENT was “working hard and doing well until February when he seemed to stop participating in the learning process.” The parents requested funding for a private school placement.

After reviewing prior assessments, Dr. Sinclair’s assessment and input from team members, the IEP team offered STUDENT an educational placement in the SDC for math, social studies and science, and in the RSP for language arts. STUDENT was to use an Alpha Smarts to assist him with his writing process. Extended school year was not authorized and no DIS services were offered. The parents agreed with the eligibility determination but disagreed with both the goals and objectives and the placement. This was the last IEP meeting in 1999. An IEP was not conducted on the historical annual review date in the fall of 1999, and the parties dispute whether the June 1999 IEP was an annual review.

On June 29, 1999, Mr. Nardo, then the director of pupil services, formally rejected the PARENT’s request at the IEP meeting for funding for a nonpublic school placement. Mr. Nardo explained that the request was refused because the placement at Lindero was providing STUDENT with FAPE in the least restrictive environment as demonstrated by his progress.

On July 9, 1999, the STUDENT’s PARENTS filed a request for due process to challenge the District’s denial of funding for a private school that specializes in serving students with STUDENT’s type of learning disabilities.

On July 19, 1999, Dr. Sinclair assessed STUDENT a second time on the WIAT in order to evaluate his progress during the second semester of the seventh grade. At the time, STUDENT was enrolled in summer school at the Westmark School in math, study skills, computers, and wood shop. During this evaluation, Dr. Sinclair noted that STUDENT was compliant but easily distracted. He “expects to fail in most academic tasks and is not challenged by difficult items. He constantly yawns and does not want to deal with areas that represent deficits to him.” From STUDENT’s scores on the WIAT, Dr. Sinclair concluded that he continued to be seriously behind in all academic domains. She noted that his math skills on the WIAT were in the low fifth-grade level, which was considerably lower than the sixth-grade-level skills reported by the District. She concluded that, although STUDENT was about to enter the eighth grade, he “does not have the reading, writing, or math skills to handle a middle school curriculum, even at the 6th grade level. His reading and writing disabilities are more serious than his math disability but all domains of function are significantly below expectation. He has been in special education for his entire middle school and most of his elementary school career. His memory and concentration deficits necessitate much review, individual attention and practice. The special education programs at Lindero...are not meeting his educational needs.” Dr. Sinclair concluded that “STUDENT needs to attend a school that offers an integrative, intense approach to remediation of learning disabilities such as Westmark School or Summit View School.” She also stated that STUDENT needs a one-on-one tutorial program designed to remediate his deficits in reading, writing, math, study skills, organization, time management and specific subject areas.

STUDENT was admitted to Westmark School as an eighth-grade student in the fall of 1999. During the year, STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated. Disciplinary actions were taken against him for a variety of reasons. The most significant of these involved a threat to kill another student, a rumor that he was offering drugs on campus, an incident in which he talked about a looking like the “trench coat mafia,” and an incident in which he wrote a disturbing essay entitled “A Biography on Mrs. Luella.” This essay included themes of homelessness, alcohol and drug abuse, promiscuity, gang involvement, rape, imprisonment, incest and blowing up a school. As a result of the last two incidents, STUDENT was required to participate in weekly counseling outside of Westmark and in a behavior plan in school.

Beginning in January 2000, STUDENT saw Dr. Scott Harris for counseling.(Footnote 10) Dr. Harris described STUDENT as “under the gun” both at home and at Westmark School about his ability to remain in school. Dr. Harris met with STUDENT fourteen times during the end of the eighth grade and twice during the summer of 2000. He diagnosed STUDENT with depressive disorder NOS. Dr. Harris did not formally assess STUDENT or review any school records from Lindero or Westmark.

In April, 2000, Dr. Sinclair administered the WIAT to STUDENT for the third time to determine his academic progress while at Westmark. A comparison of STUDENT’s results on the WIAT from July 1999 to April 2000 revealed that he had achieved one year or more in grade equivalent progress in math reasoning, reading comprehension, listening comprehension, and written expression. STUDENT’s grade equivalent remained the same in basic reading and his spelling declined slightly. As a result of STUDENT’s progress, in particular his “outstanding growth” in reading comprehension, Dr. Sinclair recommended that he continue his placement at Westmark School with ongoing one-to-one tutoring. She also recommended assistive technology support, particularly in the area of improving his typing and word processing skills.

STUDENT completed the 1999-2000 school year at Westmark and attended Westmark School in the summer session of 2000. During summer school, the District conducted a multi-disciplinary assessment of STUDENT to determine an appropriate placement for him for high school. School psychologist Barbara Katz-Starr observed STUDENT at Westmark, and was advised by his teachers that he was not doing well in class, had little interest, and did not work well independently. He had not completed enough work to receive a letter grade for his English class. During Ms. Katz-Starr’s interview with STUDENT, he stated that he would prefer returning to the Agoura High School because he wanted to go to a larger school so he could make more friends. No significant social or emotional concerns were indicated by either STUDENT or his parents on the Achenbach. STUDENT’s responses on the Millon Adolescent Personality Inventory suggested a possible adjustment disorder or conduct disorder.

As part of this assessment, Ms. Katz-Starr administered the WISC-III, which indicated a marked decline in STUDENT’s IQ scores from those obtained in the October 1998 triennial. His verbal IQ declined from 92 to 80; his performance IQ declined from 71 to 55, and his full scale IQ declined from 80 to 65. These results placed STUDENT’s verbal abilities in the lower limits of the low average range and his visual processing and perceptual organizational abilities in the significantly delayed level. More severe weaknesses in visual processing were noted. Although Ms. Katz-Starr found that the test results were valid for STUDENT’s functioning on that day, she indicated that they should be viewed cautiously due to the decline in overall functioning since the October 1998 assessment. In her opinion, STUDENT’s decline in scores might be attributable to a change in medication, to motivational and emotional issues, to his diagnosis of depressive disorder by Dr. Harris and the fact that therapy was discontinued in May 2000, or to STUDENT’s tiredness that day. She recommended a reevaluation in six months and a referral to county mental health.

STUDENT began ninth grade at Westmark School for the 2000-2001 academic year. On November 3, 2000, STUDENT was dismissed from Westmark because of ongoing behavior problems. The Hearing Officer is unaware of STUDENT’s current educational placement.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE ONE: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997 - 1998 school year, the 1998-1999 school and extended school year, and the 1999-2000 school and extended school year?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). Education Code § 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of possible related services are psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (22) (1997); California Educ. Code § 56363 (b) (1987).

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F. 3d at 130 (2nd Cir. 1998). Rather, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F. 3 1114, 1121 (2nd Cir. 1997).

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is thus twofold, requiring the hearing officer to determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and to determine whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S at 206-207.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s placement for each contested academic year must comply with procedural requirements and meet the following substantive requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; and (3) comport with his IEP. (Footnote 11)

ISSUE I.A.: DID THE DISTRICT PROVIDE STUDENT FAPE

DURING THE 1997 - 1998 SCHOOL YEAR?

a. Was the 1997-1998 SDC placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

The first step in this analysis is to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were during his sixth-grade year. STUDENT has been identified as a pupil with a specific learning disability (Footnote 12) who has a visual processing disorder which affects his ability to recognize and interpret visual stimuli. In 1994, Dr. Mummery concluded that visual memory and perceptual processing, including organization, planning and production issues, were interfering with STUDENT’s performance domain of learning, which was at the third percentile, as compared to his verbal score which was at the sixty-first percentile. Dr. Mummery noted a severe discrepancy in academic achievement in the areas of written mechanics, spelling and arithmetic calculation. A delay in reading comprehension was also noted. As described in STUDENT’s 1995 triennial, this processing disorder adversely affected his school performance in math, in some areas of written language, and in reading.According to Ms. Quisenberry, STUDENT’s visual processing disorder implicates his retention, memory and organization skills. STUDENT’s visual-perceptual deficits would affect him in the classroom in the following ways: he would have a problem copying information from the blackboard; his performance on timed written tasks would be affected; he would have difficulty organizing his notebook, his desk, his backpack or any visual material; and his writing would be affected. In her opinion, small class size such as in an SDC is beneficial to a child with visual processing and visual perceptual problems because there is more one-on-one instruction, assistance in copying and organizing materials, extra test time, and a quiet environment. Dr. Sinclair testified that STUDENT had poor retention and an inability to generalize from one learning situation to another, and therefore needed an educational plan with specific, incremental goals, with opportunities for rote learning and practice.

On the basis of this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that, during the 1997-1998 year, STUDENT’s unique needs required that he be placed in a small class setting that would provide him intensive instruction in the areas of math, spelling, written language and reading. STUDENT also required accommodations or services that would address his visual-motor and visual-perceptual deficits, including his organization, planning and production of school work.

The next step in determining whether the educational program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs is to examine the goals contained in the IEP. The IEP is a written statement of measurable annual goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii). Because STUDENT’s annual IEP review date was in November, his sixth- grade program involved two IEPs: the IEP dated November 6, 1996, which was in effect for approximately the first two months of the school year, and the IEP dated November 18, 1997, which was in effect for the remainder of that school year.

The evidence demonstrated that the November 6, 1996 IEP addressed STUDENT’s areas of unique need. Annual goals, which were to be met by November 1997, were prepared for STUDENT in the areas of reading, math, written expression, spelling, and use of a word processor. These goals were written and primarily worked on with STUDENT by Evelyn Klein, his fifth grade SDC teacher at Yerba Buena. Ms. Klein testified that STUDENT met these goals during his fifth grade year and that he passed the District writing proficiency exam with minor modifications (extra time, a hint about the number of errors seen by the teacher, and an opportunity to edit).

The IEP dated November 18, 1997, addressed STUDENT’s needs, but in a less specific manner. Present levels of performance, by teacher observation, were provided: STUDENT was noted to be working on a fifth-grade level in reading, a fourth-grade level in math and a third- to fourth-grade level in spelling. Annual goals, which were to be met by November 1998, were prepared for STUDENT in the areas of sentence writing skills, work and study habits, participation in the core curriculum with modification for success, and time, measurement, and/or money skills. STUDENT’s short-term objective for his sentence writing goal was “to write appropriate responses in complete sentences to given questions.” His short-term objectives for work/study habits goal were to “stay on task in class” and to “keep a daily assignment notebook of class assignments and homework expectations....” His short-term objective for his core curriculum goal was “to complete at least one novel or play with the assigned listening, speaking, reading and writing tasks....” His short-term objectives for his time, measurement, and/or money skills goal were to “recognize relationships between and relative values of ounce, pound, and ton” and to “solve examples and word problems involving money.”

Several witnesses testified that it was difficult to determine whether STUDENT’s sentence writing goal was designed to address the content of his writing or his writing mechanics. (Ms. Quisenberry, Dr. Sinclair). Dr. Sinclair also testified that STUDENT’s goal to “stay on task” by using an assignment notebook was an oversimplification of the range of his disorganization, and that not enough detail was provided in STUDENT’s reading goal to determine what was required or what strategies or methods were to be used to achieve it.

Because of the lack of specificity of STUDENT’s November 1997 IEP goals, the Hearing Officer reviews the testimony of STUDENT’s SDC teachers to determine if his placement during the 1997-1998 school year was, in fact, designed to meet his unique needs. First, the Hearing Officer finds that both Alicia Williams, STUDENT’s SDC teacher for language arts, social science and science, and Gayla Meseck-Lafferty, STUDENT’s math teacher, taught STUDENT in a small class environment that provided the opportunity for intensive instruction and interaction.(Footnote 13) Ms. Williams testified that there were between ten and twelve students in both the language arts and social sciences classes with one aide and that there were twelve students and one aide in the science class. Ms. Meseck-Lafferty testified that the math resource class had ten students with one aide.

Second, both Ms. Williams and Ms. Meseck-Lafferty testified that they used a variety of instructional methods in their classes. Ms. Meseck-Lafferty used visuals both on overhead projectors and on the board, color coding to teach specific math procedures, and manipulatives (fraction cubes, cardboard pieces). STUDENT was allowed to use a calculator as a tool both to learn and to demonstrate that he understood the particular mathematical process that was being taught. The class had both small-group and individualized instruction. Ms. Williams testified that all of the students in her language arts class had learning disabilities, although some also had emotional disabilities. She tried to incorporate every learning style and used auditory (students read outloud), visual (students read along with her), acting out and written assignment techniques. The language arts class read together approximately 30 minutes daily out of a 50-minute class. The class used core curriculum literature book and novels, as well as supplemental materials. An average of 15 to 20 minutes daily was spent on writing and writing techniques. Audio tapes were available to students to check out for both the language arts and the social sciences class. Ms. Williams testified that writing programs, including a keyboarding program, were installed on the four student computers in her class.

Third, both teachers testified that STUDENT was provided appropriate modifications, as required by the November 1997 IEP, in the form of additional time on tests, extra time on any assignments, opportunities for make-ups on tests on which he performed poorly, and individual help. Ms. Williams testified that the same texts were used in the SDC in language arts and social sciences as in the general education, but that the amount of work was reduced and supplemental materials were provided. The science class did not use the sixth grade regular text, but worked on similar topics.

Based upon the testimony of Ms. Williams and Ms. Meseck-Lafferty, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC placement was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Their testimony also indicated that many of the educational strategies recommended for STUDENT by Dr. Mummery were implemented in the SDC. (see footnote 4, ante).

b. Was the SDC placement reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives.

The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT successfully passed each of his sixth-grade classes. A review of his report card reveals that, during the course of the year, STUDENT was able to overcome poor grades in several core classes. Ms. Williams testified that she based STUDENT’s grades on class participation, completion of class work and homework, projects, tests, and progress toward goals and objectives. In Ms. Williams’ classes, STUDENT’s grades for the first semester of the sixth grade were a C in language arts, a D in social science and a C- in science. He needed improvement in his citizenship in each of these classes, had low test scores and did not complete assignments in social sciences. Ms. Williams attributed these grades to STUDENT’s low test scores, as well as to assignments and tests that were not made up. During the second semester of sixth grade, STUDENT demonstrated academic improvement. He began language arts with an F in his first progress report. By the end of the year, his final grade was C+, which Ms. Williams’ testified was the result of a “significant effort” by STUDENT. He also began social science with an F in the first progress report and concluded the semester with a C+. In science, STUDENT began with a D in the first progress report and achieved a C for his semester grade. His citizenship grades remained unchanged.

STUDENT’s grade in his math class for both the first semester and second semester was a C. Ms. Meseck-Lafferty testified that STUDENT had difficulty with following through on his assignments but that he would eventually make up his work with “lots of pushing.” Ms. Meseck-Lafferty testified that STUDENT would occasionally come in at lunch to finish his assignments with her and that STUDENT’s FATHER would help him as well. She testified that, in addition to working on his goals and objectives, she exposed STUDENT to curriculum at the fourth-, fifth- and sixth-grade levels, depending upon his weaknesses. By the end of the sixth grade, Ms. Meseck-Lafferty determined that STUDENT was working within a fifth-grade math range. This was an increase in ability from the fourth-grade math level indicated in STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the November 1997 IEP. This conclusion was based upon her normal class testing. To her knowledge, no standardized testing was given. She based STUDENT’s grades on both his progress on goals and objectives and on his exposure to the core curriculum. In his regular education classes, STUDENT received a B for both semesters of physical education and pass grades in each of his five-to six-week elective rotation classes. He also received pass grades for each semester in RAD.

The evidence also established that, in the opinion of STUDENT’s SDC teachers, he made academic progress in the sixth grade, both towards achieving his goals and objectives and understanding the core curriculum. In Ms. Williams’ opinion, STUDENT “definitely” made academic progress in the sixth grade. She testified that STUDENT’s C grades included a comprehension of the general sixth-grade curriculum. Even though STUDENT could not read on a sixth-grade level, he was able to comprehend the core curriculum. She tested his comprehension by tests at the end of the unit, by constant questioning during lessons, and by class worksheets and activities to see if he was understanding. In her opinion, STUDENT comprehended more than on a C level in each of her classes but did not do some of the work he was supposed to do. In Ms. Meseck-Lafferty’s opinion, STUDENT “absolutely made progress” in her math class as demonstrated by his ability to function and follow through in class. In her opinion, STUDENT’s ability to obtain an average grade (C) showed that he could function well within an average range and was learning.

Evidence of STUDENT’s academic growth based on results of standardized tests was less clear. As pointed out by the Petitioner, the District did not conduct standardized academic achievement tests during the 1995 triennial evaluation. (Footnote 14) As a result, the only measures for comparison were two WJ-R tests administered four years apart: Dr. Mummery’s November 1994 WJ-R and the District’s October 1998 WJ-R. A comparison of STUDENT’s subtest scores on the WJ-R from the 1994 assessment with those of the 1998 triennial indicates that STUDENT’s grade equivalent increased in all previously tested areas, with the exception of writing samples, which decreased from 7.0 to 6.6. There is no way to parcel out how much growth occurred in a given year within those four years. Over this four-year period, STUDENT experienced 4.9 years growth in calculation, and an average of approximately one-half year of growth in the following areas: letter-word identification (2.5), applied problems (2.1), dictation (1.9) and passage comprehension (1.6). STUDENT’s grade equivalent declined in the area of writing samples.

STUDENT argues that his academic growth during the 1997-1998 year was de minimus. Dr. Sinclair testified that the concept of grade-level scores is based upon a hypothetical average child who makes one month of growth for each month in attendance. She testified that there was no formula for determining the amount of educational progress a child with STUDENT’s WISC-III cognitive scores should have made. In her opinion, however, STUDENT’s average verbal ability does not limit how much academic growth he can achieve. What is more relevant to how much progress he can make is the actual support and intervention given. Ms. Quisenberry testified that, because of STUDENT’s cognitive ability, she would not be concerned if he did not demonstrate year-for-year growth. She would be concerned if his standard scores were significantly different from his ability scores. Regarding STUDENT’s standard scores, Ms. Katz-Starr testified that STUDENT’s 1 point decline in broad reading from 1994 to 1998 was within the standard of measure of error and meant that he was maintaining his level in relation to his peers. She testified that STUDENT’s 16 point increase in broad math showed an increase of a standard deviation, from a score in the borderline range to one in the upper limits of low average. In broad written language, however, STUDENT’s standard score declined eight points. Ms. Katz-Starr opined that this may be related to STUDENT’s visual-processing disorder.

Although the evidence indicated that STUDENT did make progress during the 1997-1998 school year in some areas of need, the District did not meet its burden of demonstrating that STUDENT received benefit in the areas of written language and spelling. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not make progress in the area of written language mechanics, specifically in usage, spelling, capitalization and punctuation. The WJ-R testing conducted by the District in October 1998, after the sixth grade, demonstrated that STUDENT was on the kindergarten level in spelling (K.0), at the K.4 level in punctuation and capitalization, and at the 1.9 level in usage. These test results establish that STUDENT did not receive educational benefit in these areas of unique need while in the sixth grade. STUDENT’s deficits in these areas were demonstrated in the results of his April 1997 Iowa Test of Basic Skills, given while he was in the fifth grade. The narrative report of that test stated that STUDENT’s “relative weaknesses which may need the most work” were spelling, which was at the sixth national percentage rate (NPR) and punctuation, which was at the ninth NPR. He was at the twentieth NPR in capitalization, at the twenty-third NPR in usage and expression. Significantly, there was no testimony from Ms. Williams about how the sixth-grade SDC language arts class addressed STUDENT’s needs in any of these areas or about how STUDENT benefitted from these interventions. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT’s placement during the 1997-1998 school year was not designed to provide him with educational benefit.

c. Did the SDC placement comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

There was no argument or evidence presented at the hearing that the SDC placement did not comport with the IEP. (Footnote 15)

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year. As discussed in Issue II, infra, the benefit that STUDENT received in his other areas of unique need during this school year will be considered in determining the appropriate remedy for this denial of FAPE.

ISSUE I.B.: DID THE DISTRICT PROVIDE STUDENT FAPE DURING

THE 1998-1999 SCHOOL AND EXTENDED SCHOOL YEAR?

a. Was the 1998-1999 SDC placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

1. STUDENT’s Unique Needs

A. Academic Areas of Need

STUDENT’s unique needs for the 1998-1999 school year again required that he be placed in a small class setting that would provide him intensive instruction, and be provided accommodations or services to address his visual-motor and visual-perceptual deficits, including his organization, planning and production of school work. Following the District’s October 1998 triennial evaluation, STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education services as a student with an SLD whose academic achievement was commensurate with his intellectual abilities in all areas, except usage, spelling, punctuation and capitalization. This determination was made by comparing STUDENT’s WISC-III cognitive scores to his WJ-R achievement scores. The IEP team also determined that STUDENT continued to require assistance in the area of math and, as a result, goals and objectives were written in this area. No goals in reading or in reading comprehension were included.

STUDENT contends that, for the purpose of determining his areas of unique academic need, it is more accurate to compare his achievement scores from the WIAT to his WISC-III cognitive scores than it is to use his WJ-R achievement scores for this comparison. Dr. Sinclair testified that the WIAT is the only test that allows for a direct psychometric comparison with the WISC-III for the purpose of determining the discrepancy between a student’s expected academic achievement by age and IQ and his/her actual academic achievement. This comparison, which Dr. Sinclair termed the “WIAT paradigm,” will measure whether the student is at, above, or below the expectation at increasing levels of probability (.05 and .01 levels). Using this paradigm, STUDENT’s academic achievement was not commensurate with his ability, as seen in his verbal IQ, in all areas.(Footnote 16)

The question is whether STUDENT’s unique needs include deficits in the areas of reading and reading comprehension. Dr. Sinclair testified that the most significant difference between the WIAT and the WJ-R is in the test of reading comprehension. The WIAT requires a student to read a passage and respond to comprehension questions in multiple domains (e.g., main idea, sequence of events, making inferences), whereas the WJ-R asks a student to fill in a blank in a sentence. STUDENT received a standard score of 82 in reading comprehension on the WIAT (grade equivalent of 4.3) and a standard score of 89 on passage comprehension on the WJ-R (grade equivalent of 4.6). In basic reading, STUDENT’s standard score was 75 on the WIAT and 91 on the WJ-R. Even using STUDENT’s verbal IQ of 92 as the measure of his ability, however, there was not a significant discrepancy between his ability and achievement in these areas.(Footnote 17)

District school psychologist Barbara Katz-Starr testified that either the WIAT or the WJ-R can be used to formulate discrepancies, but that the WJ-R is an appropriate assessment tool to use with STUDENT because it focuses more on specific “splinter skills” which provide different aspects of his strengths and weaknesses. Other District witnesses also testified that they had never been advised that the WJ-R was an inappropriate tool for schools to use in comparing to the WISC-III. (Testimony of Nardo, Quisenbery).(Footnote 18) The Hearing Officer finds that the WJ-R was an appropriate tool by which to assess STUDENT’s academic achievement and thereby determine his unique needs.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s unique academic needs for the 1998-1999 school year were in the areas of spelling, usage, capitalization and punctuation, and math.

B. Emotional Areas of Need

The parties also dispute whether STUDENT required DIS counseling services to address his self-esteem issues. As previously indicated, in California, DIS services such as counseling shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Education Code § 56363 (a). After STUDENT entered Lindero, neither of STUDENT’s parents requested DIS counseling services. At the October 15, 1998 IEP meeting, however, the parents expressed their concern, as indicated on the IEP, that “STUDENT will keep his self-esteem up and have confidence in himself.” DIS counseling services were not offered to STUDENT in his October 1998 IEP or at any time during the 1998-1999 school year.

Dr. Scott Harris testified that he began providing counseling to STUDENT in January of 2000, while he was attending the Westmark School. He diagnosed STUDENT with depressive disorder NOS and described him as a quiet young man who tends to get lost in a group and who operates on a low to moderate level of depression. Because STUDENT does not open up, frustration, anger and resentment build up and he could explode depending on the situation. In Dr. Harris’ opinion, STUDENT has low self-esteem, not much hope for himself, suffers when he makes mistakes and feels that he is stupid. Dr. Harris did not formally assess STUDENT and he had not reviewed any school records. While he generally understood that STUDENT had done “okay” at Lindero, he also understood that STUDENT’s participation in school had always been minimal. Dr. Harris attributed this to STUDENT’s self-esteem issues. Dr. Harris testified that he had no information as to whether STUDENT had a depressive disorder at any time prior to June 1999. Nonetheless, from his observations in January 2000 and thereafter that STUDENT had low self-esteem, it was his opinion that STUDENT needed counseling in order to obtain educational benefit during the 1998-1999 school year.

The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Harris’s testimony about STUDENT’s self-esteem issues in January of 2000 and thereafter to be persuasive.(Footnote 19) However, Dr. Harris’s opinion of whether such services should have been provided a year earlier was given with the benefit of hindsight and carries little weight. The issue is whether the District had a reason to believe that counseling services were necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his placement during the 1998-1999 school year.

Because self-esteem issues are not uncommon among students with learning disabilities, providing counseling to all such students is undoubtedly wise.(Footnote 20) Nonetheless, the evidence at the hearing persuasively established that, while at Lindero, District staff, including teachers, school psychologists and counselors, observed STUDENT’s behavior to be predominantly positive and cooperative, with no “red flags” to suggest a need for DIS counseling services. First, Ms. Quisenbery found no evidence of a need for such services during her triennial assessment.(Footnote 21) Second, as he entered the seventh grade, there was no indication from STUDENT’s sixth-grade teachers that he needed counseling, based upon his behavior in class, to benefit from his education. (Testimony of Alicia Williams, Gayla Meseck-Lafferty, Robert Coryell, Marilyn Fine, Toni Cooley, Mary Reyna). On the whole, his teachers testified that STUDENT was a quiet, well-liked youngster who tried hard in class and did not have behavior problems that required referral for discipline. Third, during the first semester of the seventh grade, STUDENT appeared to be engaged in his classes. Ms. Khmara (Footnote 22) testified that, in her SDC language arts class, STUDENT liked to be called on to read aloud and enjoyed giving the characters voices. In her science class, despite his difficulties with writing, STUDENT volunteered to be the recorder (secretary) on several occasions and did so successfully even though his notes were brief. These actions show self-confidence on STUDENT’s part. Although STUDENT seemed surprised and unsure when Ms. Khmara praised him for his work, it did not affect his ability to learn and to attend in her classes. Fourth, during the second semester of the seventh grade, STUDENT was noted to be distracted, uninterested in school and, in early 1999, seemed to have “given up” because of his belief that he was leaving Lindero. Nonetheless, as discussed below, STUDENT was able to overcome his poor grades during the first progress report period of the second semester and engaged in his classes to achieve passing marks. His ability to do so demonstrates that he did not require DIS counseling to benefit from his instructional program.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT did not have any unique emotional needs that would have required the District to provide DIS counseling services during the 1998-1999 school year.

C. Extended School Year Needs

Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F. 3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. Tit.5 § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. §300.309(a)(2).(Footnote 23)

There was little direct evidence presented of STUDENT’s need for ESY services. Neither of STUDENT’s parents testified that he/she ever requested ESY services. Mr. Nardo testified that the IEP team in June 1999 determined that STUDENT was not eligible for ESY because his deficits were “not severe enough.” While STUDENT’s processing disorder involves issues of memory retention, according to his SDC teachers in both sixth and seventh grade, STUDENT was able to earn passing grades and to participate in and understand the core curriculum. This testimony demonstrates that STUDENT does not have a limited recoupment capacity. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT’s needs did not require the provision of ESY services for the 1998-1999 school year.

2. Designed to Meet Unique Needs

As previously discussed, the next step in determining whether the educational program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs is to examine the goals and the placement contained in the IEP. Following the October 1998 triennial, new goals and objectives were written for STUDENT. Annual goals were written in the areas of solving math story problems, improving paragraph writing skills, and in attending to task without bothering or talking to peers. Ms. Quisenberry testified that, even though the assessment indicated that STUDENT’s math skills were commensurate with his ability, he was delayed compared to his peers. As a result, a math goal was developed by agreement with the parents and teachers. The short-term objectives for this goal were for STUDENT to solve story problems using two or more of the four basic operations, first with teacher prompts, and later, independently. Regarding STUDENT’s sentence writing goal, Ms. Quisenbery testified that the goal in the IEP for the previous year did not distinguish between writing content and writing mechanics. She wrote the sentence writing goal to focus on STUDENT’s areas of weakness as shown in the triennial assessment. The short-term objectives for the paragraph writing goal were for STUDENT to write a paragraph of at least five sentences in class using correct capitalization, punctuation and grammar, first with teacher prompts, and later, independently. Dr. Sinclair testified that the goals in STUDENT’s 1998 IEP were much more specific and easier to follow than those in the previous IEP.

The October 1998 IEP placed STUDENT in the SDC class for his academic subjects. STUDENT was in Ms. Khmara’s SDC class for three and a half periods each day: language arts, science, math and a 20-minute silent-reading RAD (reading awakens dreams) class. Ms. Khmara had an aide in each of these classes, with a student-teacher ratio of 2:18 in language arts class, 2:16 in both science and math, and 2:16-19 in the RAD period. Ms. Khmara testified that, due to his visual processing disorder, STUDENT needed multiple instructional modalities, including auditory and visual learning techniques in addition to reading. She provided these in all three classes by using audio tapes of stories, flash cards for vocabulary, role playing with characters in stories, three-by-five cards for sequencing stories to test comprehension, pictures and videos. In the language arts class, the students used the standard seventh-grade education text book. Because she knew STUDENT’s reading level--as well as that of other students--was lower than that, she modified the work to his level. Each story was first read as a group and then listened to again on tape. By the time the class was ready to analyze the story, STUDENT had heard it twice, was aware of its content, and could participate in the lesson. The class then worked on story vocabulary, which was higher than half the students could read, and on story sequencing. In addition to reading activities, students wrote self-generated stories or she would suggest topics. Writing was very difficult for STUDENT, who had a hard time putting his thoughts down on paper and organizing them. Ms. Khmara testified that she taught brainstorming story topics using the web technique. One-on-one instruction was provided when the students were completing individual assignments.

In Ms. Khmara’s science class, the regular seventh-grade text was not used because it was too technical. The text used in the SDC class had the same information, but was at a fourth-grade reading level, with pictures and photographs on one side of the page and narrative on the other. This text broke the subject into short, manageable paragraphs and was used in conjunction with a workbook, videos, flash cards and games.

Ms. Khmara testified that instruction in the math SDC class was individual because the students were at very different levels. The math class had peer tutors, in addition to the aide. The class was not on the level of the regular seventh-grade math. All students began with a pretest to determine their appropriate levels. STUDENT started with subtractions with borrowing and then did multiplication. Much of his work focused on basic computation and multiplication facts. Individual instruction took place as the teacher, aide and peer tutors circulated through the class.

For each of STUDENT’s classes, a “minder binder” or weekly planner was used to ensure that STUDENT accurately recorded his assignments. At the end of each day, Ms. Khmara had STUDENT check with her to ensure the assignments were accurately recorded. STUDENT received accommodations in the class. None of her tests was timed. In addition to modifying the curriculum to his level, Ms. Williams also modified the tests to his skill level.

STUDENT was in Ms. Williams’ social science SDC class in the seventh grade. This class had twelve to thirteen students with one aide and was based upon the seventh-grade curriculum with the same text as the regular education classes. As in the previous grade, modifications and accommodations included providing fewer projects, reducing the amount of work and giving more time on tests. Ms. Williams used auditory, visual, acting out and written assignment techniques and made audio tapes available to students to check out. STUDENT’s FATHER testified that he discussed STUDENT’s organizational issues with Ms. Williams and that she was helpful and gave him suggestions on how to assist STUDENT in organizing his school work in the home setting. On occasion, STUDENT’s FATHER brought STUDENT to school early so that Ms. Williams could help him with his homework issues. STUDENT’s FATHER testified that Ms. Williams was a “very helpful teacher.” The testimony of Ms. Khmara and Ms. Williams established that STUDENT was receiving instruction in small, structured classes with opportunity for one-on-one instruction, and accommodations to address his needs. The Hearing Officer finds their testimony to be persuasive and credible. The adequacy of this placement was challenged by Dr. Sinclair’s three-hour observation in STUDENT’s SDC class in February 1999. Dr. Sinclair testified that STUDENT’s language arts/science/math teacher, whose name she did not know, told her that she had only worked with the District for one year, did not really know STUDENT, suggested she speak to his teacher from the previous year, and could not discuss STUDENT’s goals and objectives. These were the classes taught by Ms. Khmara. Dr. Sinclair’s testimony raises doubts about the quality of the instruction actually being provided to STUDENT on that day. Based upon the evidence presented, however, the Hearing Officer is unable to conclude that the teacher Dr. Sinclair observed on this occasion was actually Ms. Khmara.(Footnote 24)

The Hearing Officer concludes that the SDC placement and the goals in the IEP of October 1998 were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

b. Was the SDC class reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?

As discussed below, the evidence demonstrated that the seventh-grade SDC placement was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

STUDENT’s class grades and teacher reports demonstrate that he achieved academic growth and experienced educational benefit during the seventh grade at Lindero. In the first semester of the seventh grade, STUDENT received grades of B+ in science, math, and his elective of woodwork/stained glass. He received a pass in RAD, a B in language arts, and a C- in both physical education and social sciences. During the second semester, STUDENT’s grades generally declined.(Footnote 25) Nonetheless, with the exception of physical education (D-), he received passing grades in all his classes: a C+ in language arts, a C in social science, a C- in both science and math, a pass in RAD, and an A- in his art elective.

Even though STUDENT’s teachers recognized that he was not as involved in his classes in the second semester, they testified that he made academic progress over the course of the year. Ms. Khmara testified that, in language arts, STUDENT’s writing production had improved by the end of the year: he wrote longer sentences, and his paragraphs were more coherent. When STUDENT began that year, his paragraphs were disjointed, brief, with incomplete sentences. Toward the middle of the year, STUDENT was using the web technique for organizing his thoughts and he was improving in his paragraph length and sentence structure. Because STUDENT was not reading on a seventh-grade level, his grade reflected his ability to comprehend the concepts, vocabulary and sentence structure of the seventh-grade curriculum. He had good comprehension of the materials. STUDENT received an unsatisfactory in citizenship in this class because he was not producing at the same level he had during the first semester. Ms. Khmara testified that, in math, STUDENT began the year computing simple multiplication problems; by the end of the year, he was working on multiplication, division and fractions. STUDENT’s science grade improved from a D- at the first progress report of the semester to a C- for the semester. In Ms. Williams’ social sciences class, STUDENT began the semester with an F for the first progress report. After STUDENT told her about the possible change in schools, Ms. Williams spoke with STUDENT’s FATHER and they jointly met with STUDENT to encourage him to do his work. By the end of the semester, STUDENT had raised his grade to a C. In Ms. William’s opinion, this grade indicated that STUDENT had put a great effort into his work. She also testified that, during this semester, STUDENT asked her if she thought that he was improving and if she thought he could stay at Lindero.

The evidence also indicated that STUDENT made progress on the goals and objectives contained in the October 1998 IEP. As his special education case manager, Ms. Williams reported STUDENT’s progress in November 1998, and in February and June 1999. Copies of these reports were sent home. STUDENT was reported to be making progress in each of his goal areas. In June 1999, Ms. Williams reported that he met his first math objective on solving story problems. At the IEP of June 24, 1999, three new math goals were added. STUDENT was making progress in his other goals, which were to be reviewed again in October 1999.

Finally, STUDENT’s standardized scores demonstrate that he made academic growth during the 1998-1999 school year. In Dr. Sinclair’s January 1999 evaluation of STUDENT, she compared his grade equivalent scores on the WJ-R over three test periods: November 1994 (Mummery), October 1998 (LVUSD), and January 1999 (Sinclair).

Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement by Grade Equivalents

Subtest 11/94 10/98 1/99 Growth from 10/98 To 1/99 Letter-Word Identification 2.6 5.1 7.1 +2.1 Passage Comprehension 3.0 4.6 5.1 + .5 Calculation 1.3 6.4 6.2 - .2 Applied Problems 3.3 5.4 6.3 + .9 Dictation 1.8 3.7 3.1 - .6 Writing Samples 7.0 6.6 2.8 -2.8 Proofing 2.9 4.0 +1.1 Punctuation & Capitalization K.4 2.3 +1.9 Spelling K.0 3.6 +3.6 Usage 1.9 4.7 +2.8

A comparison of STUDENT’s grade equivalent scores from October 1998 to January 1999 reveals that STUDENT had improved significantly in the areas of most concern; i.e., spelling, usage, punctuation and capitalization.

In July 1999, Dr. Sinclair administered a new WIAT to STUDENT and compared its results to STUDENT’s scores on the January 1999 WIAT. These scores reveal that, in an approximately six-month period, STUDENT achieved academic growth in all areas. While the WIAT subtests do not include usage, or capitalization and punctuation, STUDENT’s written expression score indicated 2.1 years of growth with a 15-point increase in his standard score.

Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) Scores Comparison by Standard Score and Grade Equivalent

Subtest Grade Equivalent Standard Score 1/99 7/99 Growth 1/99 7/99 Basic Reading 3.8 4.5 + .7 75 75 Mathematics Reasoning 3.1 3.8 + .7 72 73 Spelling 4:5 5.0 + .5 79 80 Reading Comprehension 4.3 4.5 + .2 82 79 Numerical Operations 4.3 5.3 +1.0 69 75 Written Expression K.0 2.1 +2.1 63 78

Reading Composite 4.1 4.6 + .5 75 73 Mathematics Composite 3.8 4.6 + .8 68 71 Writing Composite 3.6 4.4 + .8 70 76

STUDENT argues that the July 1999 WIAT scores actually show the educational benefit that he achieved during his four-week summer school at Westmark. The Hearing Office rejects this argument. First, there was no clear evidence regarding where STUDENT was in his summer school program at the time the second WIAT was administered. Second, Dr. Sinclair expressly stated that her purpose in readministering the WIAT was to “evaluate STUDENT’s progress in his school placement for the 2nd semester of the 7th grade.” Third, STUDENT’s summer school classes at Westmark were in predominantly non-academic areas. While some improvement in math might be attributable to summer school, that would not account for more than a small portion of the gains shown.

Based upon the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the SDC placement during the 1998-1999 year was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

c. Did the SDC placement comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

There was no dispute that the SDC placement comported with STUDENT’s IEP.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that, for the 1998-1999 school year including the extended school year, the District offered STUDENT a FAPE.

ISSUE I.C.: DID THE DISTRICT PROVIDE STUDENT FAPE DURING

THE 1999-2000 SCHOOL AND EXTENDED SCHOOL YEAR?

As previously indicated, the last IEP team meeting for STUDENT during the 1999 calendar year occurred on July 24, 1999. On its face, this IEP document indicates that the next review was to occur in October 1999, which is STUDENT’s historical annual review date.(Footnote 26) The Petitioner asserts that the failure of the District to convene an IEP meeting in October 1999 constituted a procedural violation. The District argues that the June 24, 1999 IEP was a complete IEP and thus became the annual review.

The June 24, 1999 IEP indicated that the “parents requested an IEP to make plans for STUDENT accomplishing more in school. They believe he can make more progress.” The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s goals and objectives from the October 1998 IEP, which were to be accomplished within twelve months. The IEP team noted that progress had been made in all areas and agreed to continue these goals. Three new math goals were drafted, with target accomplishment dates of June 2000, and interim review dates of October 1999 and March 2000. The IEP team notes state that the team considered the results of the outside assessment. The placement offered to STUDENT was identical to his previous program with one exception: STUDENT’s language arts class was to be provided in the resource program rather than the SDC program. The STUDENT’s PARENTS disagreed with the goals and objectives and with the placement. The IEP indicated that the “next review” would be in October 1999.

Under both the IDEA and California law, a student’s IEP must be reviewed at least annually. 20 U.S.C. 1414(d)(4)(A); Calif. Educ. Code §§56343(d), 56380. California regulations specify that the “public education agency shall ensure that review schedules are specified in the individualized education program and contract for the pupil.” 5 Cal. Code Regs. §3069.

District witnesses testified somewhat inconsistently on whether the June 24, 1999 IEP constituted an annual IEP meeting. In discussing STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives, Ms. Williams testified that the annual review should have occurred in October or November of 1999, as indicated on the IEP document. She later testified that it would not be unusual for a new annual review date to start if there had been a comprehensive review. Mr. Nardo, the District’s director of pupil services during this period, testified during the Petitioner’s case that the annual review was October 1999. He then testified that the District has a policy to start a new annual review date anytime there is a new IEP meeting which is a complete IEP. He stated that the June 1999 IEP appeared to be complete but could not answer why a different IEP date appeared on the face of the document. During the District’s case, Mr. Nardo testified that, if there was an agreement, there would be no need for an annual review until June 2000; however, because the parents disagreed with the goals and objectives, there should have been another IEP in October 1999. This later testimony was consistent with Mr. Nardo’s letter of June 29, 1999 to the STUDENT’s parents, just one week after the IEP meeting. In it, he stated that “STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting is due October, 1999.” No evidence was presented at the hearing that an IEP meeting was conducted for STUDENT at any time during the 1999-2000 school year.(Footnote 27)

The Hearing Officer concludes that the June 24, 1999 IEP meeting was not STUDENT’s annual review and that the annual review should have been conducted in October 1999, as the review schedule specified in the IEP. Because the STUDENT’s PARENTS were disputing whether the District had provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the preceding years at Lindero, the District had continuing responsibility for conducting an IEP even after his enrollment at Westmark. 20 U.S.C. § 1412 (10)(C) (Footnote 28)

Procedural violations do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, unless there is a showing of prejudice; i.e., a loss of educational opportunity to the student or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479.

Under the IDEA, the local educational agency must ensure that the IEP team:

(i) reviews the child’s IEP periodically, but not less than annually, to determine whether the annual goals and objectives for the child are being achieved; and (ii) revises the IEP as appropriate to address– (I) any lack of expected progress toward the annual goals and in the general curriculum, where appropriate; (II) the results of any reevaluation conducted under this section; (III) information about the child provided to, or by, the parents, as described in subsection (c)(1)(B); (IV) the child’s anticipated needs; or (V) other matters.

20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(4)(A).

One of the primary purposes of the annual IEP meeting requirement is to ensure that the parents have an opportunity to provide updated information to the school about their child and their child’s needs. In this case, the District’s failure to convene an annual IEP left the STUDENT’s PARENTS without any opportunity to voice their concerns about STUDENT’s education, his offered placement, his current placement, or to provide the District with updated information on his progress from Dr. Sinclair’s second evaluation or from Westmark. While the District may have maintained its position about STUDENT’s placement even with this information, the failure to convene the annual IEP meeting created a situation where communication among the IEP team members simply could not occur. Of greatest concern is the fact that there was no opportunity for the parents to discuss STUDENT’s behavioral deterioration and to consider whether DIS counseling services might have been appropriate in light of his circumstances at that time. Evidence regarding STUDENT’s behavior at Westmark indicated that disciplinary referrals began in October, that he was suspended in early November and that his negative behaviors continued to escalate in frequency and seriousness, until Westmark required that the family obtain private counseling for STUDENT.(Footnote 29) On the basis of Dr. Harris’s testimony, the Hearing Officer rejects the District’s theory that STUDENT’s behaviors were attributable solely to his frustration with attending Westmark. STUDENT’s behavior may have given the IEP team reason to seriously consider whether he required further assessments of his emotional condition, his need for additional services, or a revision in placement. While many of STUDENT’s behaviors occurred after the annual IEP review date, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure of the District to convene the annual IEP meeting signaled a closing of communication between the family and the District members of the IEP team.

As a result, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to convene an annual IEP in October 1999 seriously infringed on STUDENT’S PARENTS’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process for the 1999-2000 school year and that this resulted in a denial of FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.

ISSUE TWO: Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the cost of his placement at the Westmark School for the 1998-1999 ESY, the 1999-2000 school and ESY, and for any designated instruction and services provided by his parents? (Footnote 30)

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); see also, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parents are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. V. State Bd. Of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court’s decision in Burlington:

The rationale behind Burlington’s holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an “empty victory.” [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if “appropriate relief” in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, “the child’s right to a free appropriate public education, the parent’s right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete.” [Footnote omitted.] Id.

In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 113 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. Although the Court has recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district’s must meet, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id. Equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Burlington, supra, at 374.

In light of the conclusion reached on Issues I.A and I.C., that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-1998 or the 1999-2000 school years,(Footnote 31) the Hearing Officer must determine the appropriate remedy. Although the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC placement at Lindero during that year was designed to and did provide STUDENT educational benefit in his areas of need other than spelling, usage, capitalization and punctuation. Furthermore, the SDC program for the following year did, in fact, provide STUDENT with a FAPE. In balancing the equities, therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the appropriate remedy for the denial of FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year is compensatory education. See: Issue III, infra.

In considering the appropriate remedy for the denial of FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the program at Westmark School provided by STUDENT’s parents was proper under the IDEA.

The evidence established that the Westmark School was an appropriate placement. Westmark is a private school dedicated to serving students with language-based learning difficulties who have high potential. Its total enrollment is approximately 245 students in grades two through twelve. Westmark’s curriculum for the eighth grade follows California’s state curriculum, modified to the needs of the student. Westmark’s teachers either have teaching credentials or are on a waiver. Multi-sensory teaching techniques, including visualizing-verbalizing, are utilized to enhance a student’s comprehension. Westmark follows the goals and objectives for any student with an IEP. For those without an active IEP, the school develops a student profile that contains goals, modifications and necessary assistive technology. This profile is reviewed by all teachers and by the academic counselor. Students attend seven classes daily, and may also participate in a tutorial program. Westmark’s program is complete without the tutorial, which is an optional service to accelerate a student’s learning. The District has placed other students at Westmark when it believed such placement to be appropriate.

The evidence indicated that Westmark was not able to address STUDENT’s emotional needs. On the basis of Dr. Harris’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year required DIS counseling services to address his self-esteem issues and behavioral issues. Both of Westmark’s headmasters, Mr. Shifrin and Ms. Wagmeister testified that (1) Westmark does not accept students whose primary issue is emotionality or behavior, (2) Westmark does not provide a therapeutic environment, is not able to provide DIS counseling to students and would not be able to accept students who need such services to maintain their behavior in class, and (3) Westmark would not have accepted STUDENT if it had known the level of behavior problems which he ultimately presented during the eighth grade.(Footnote 32) Because DIS counseling services were not available through Westmark, STUDENT’s PARENTS were required to obtain and pay for private counseling services for STUDENT. In light of the conclusion reached in I.C., the Hearing Officer finds that Westmark was not rendered an inappropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year because the STUDENT’s PARENTS had to pay for a private counselor for STUDENT. The evidence established that STUDENT was able to complete the school year and was, in fact, offered a new contract by Westmark for the 2000-2001 school year. Similarly, the fact that STUDENT was dismissed from Westmark for behavioral problems in the following school year does not mandate the conclusion that Westmark was inappropriate during the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that Westmark was an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year.

The parties dispute whether Westmark provided STUDENT with educational benefit. STUDENT testified that he learned more at Westmark, was assigned more homework there than at the District, and that the “inspirations” computer program helped him to write. Both of STUDENT’s parents testified that, despite STUDENT’s behavior problems, he seemed to be learning and to be more excited about learning than while at Lindero. In Mr. Shifrin’s opinion, STUDENT benefitted from the Westmark program and experienced gains during the 1999-2000 year. The benefit he observed was that STUDENT’s attitude switched from not wanting to attend Westmark to wanting to attend. While there was some academic improvement in testing, STUDENT’s behaviors were distractions to his learning process.

STUDENT completed the eighth grade at Westmark, with the following grades: a D in pre-algebra, a C- in both English and American history, a C+ in earth science, and a B in both P.E. and woodshop. Ms. Wagmeister testified that, based solely on her knowledge of STUDENT’s grades, it appeared that STUDENT experienced educational benefit at Westmark. Nonetheless, STUDENT’s history teacher, Ms. Zaragoza,(Footnote 33) testified that STUDENT’s progress was not adequate. He did not master the subject or all the skills, and his behavior was inappropriate and interfered with the learning environment of other students. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Zaragoza’s testimony was inconsistent with the grade she gave STUDENT, which she testified had not been modified.

Aimee Cohen Weltman testified that she worked with STUDENT in the one-on-one tutorial during the 1999-2000 school year.(Footnote 34) She worked individually with STUDENT in a booth for 50 minutes per day and primarily gave him support in pre-algebra. He was very vocal when he did not understand things. She testified that it was hard to determine if STUDENT progressed academically because he was not consistent with reviewing at home and his math skills were very poor. After the tutoring, STUDENT could probably add and subtract negative and positive numbers, which he could not do before. He needed repetition because he would forget a lot. In her opinion, although she could not say STUDENT “improved dramatically,” the tutorial helped him to progress academically in math by helping him memorize different techniques. She also testified that she did some work with STUDENT in reading comprehension.

It is clear from Dr. Sinclair’s WIAT testing in April 2000, that STUDENT received educational benefit at Westmark, particularly in the area of reading comprehension. The issue, however, is whether he received educational benefit in his areas of unique need: i.e. in math, spelling, usage, capitalization and punctuation. A determination of whether STUDENT received educational benefit at Westmark in his areas of unique need is complicated by the fact that neither his math nor his English teacher from Westmark testified. STUDENT’s grade in pre-alegbra for the year was a D, which does not indicate educational benefit. Weighed against this are the results of his April 2000 WIAT, which demonstrated that STUDENT progressed in his standardized scores. Based upon a comparison of STUDENT’s WIAT scores from July 1999 to April 2000, Dr. Sinclair found that STUDENT’s mathematics reasoning had increased from 3.8 grade equivalent (GE) to a 6.0 GE. While his numerical operations score declined slightly, his overall mathematics composite increased from 4.6 GE to 5.6 GE. Furthermore, Dr. Sinclair observed that STUDENT was able to perform mathematical calculations that he had previously been unable to perform. Ms. Katz-Starr testified that the inconsistency between these scores and STUDENT’s class grade might have been explained if the tutorial were focused on test performance. Because she had no factual support for this opinion, it is entitled to little weight. Considering both STUDENT’s standardized scores and Ms. Weltman’s testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT received some educational benefit in math from his optional tutorial program at Westmark.

There was no direct evidence that STUDENT progressed in the specific areas of spelling, usage, capitalization and punctuation while at Westmark. Nonetheless, STUDENT received a passing grade of C- in his English class. The April 2000 WIAT indicates a slight decline in spelling from 5.0 to 4.8 GE. STUDENT’s written expression subtest on the WIAT, however, demonstrated an marked increased from 2.1 GE in July 1999 to 5.1 G.E in April 2000. While Dr. Sinclair attributed this increase primarily to the length of STUDENT’s writing and its content, she also indicated that his grammar and word usage was fair, and that he made “some errors in capitalization and punctuation that did not seriously interfere with his intended communication.” Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received educational benefit in these specific areas of need at Westmark School.

STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that, for the 1999-2000 school year, they paid Westmark $17,820 for the basic program, an additional $5,800 for the optional tutorial program, and $650 for the “after school program.” No testimony was received on the nature of Westmark’s after school program. The total cost of STUDENT’s program for the 1999-2000 school year was $23,620.00. For Westmark’s summer school program, STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that the cost was an additional $2,700.00.

In determining the appropriate amount of reimbursement, the Hearing Officer considers several factors. First, there was no dispute that the parents advised the District of their intention to place STUDENT at a private school at the June 1999 IEP meeting based on their belief that he was not being appropriately educated at the District. 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c). Second, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the SDC program for the 1998-1999 school year did, in fact, provide STUDENT with a FAPE and that extended school year services were not required. Third, while the PARENTS’ decision to place STUDENT at Westmark was questionable in light of that finding, the District’s failure to convene an IEP meeting at any time during the 1999-2000 school year seriously infringed on their opportunity to participate in the IEP process for STUDENT for that entire year. Fourth, part of the benefit STUDENT received while at Westmark School was in educational areas which were not his specific areas of need. In addition, considering his final grade in pre-algebra, the Hearing Officer finds that the educational benefit received from the optional tutoring program was slight. Fifth, based upon the testimony of Dr. Harris, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s need for counseling services affected his ability to function in class during the 1999-2000 school year and that he suffers low self-esteem arising from his learning disabilities. Sixth, the Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT’s desire not to be placed at Westmark by his parents was a contributing factor to his emotional and behavioral needs during the 1999-2000 school year. Seventh, the District’s failure to conduct an IEP meeting during the 1999-2000 school year prevented the IEP team from considering appropriate services to address STUDENT’s self-esteem and behavior issues, and the STUDENT’s PARENTS incurred costs of therapy as a result of this denial.

After consideration of the above factors, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement from the District as follows: (1) for fifty percent of the costs incurred by the STUDENT’s PARENTS for STUDENT’s counseling services with Dr. Harris from January 1, 2000, through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, according to proof, and (2) for fifty percent of the base tuition for Westmark School for the 1999-2000 school year, in a total amount of $8,910.

ISSUE THREE: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure to provide FAPE for the 1997-1998 and the 1999-2000 school years?

Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See: Parents of Petitioner W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not require day-for- day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. At 1497. STUDENT requests that he be awarded one-on-one educational therapy by a qualified educational therapist for three hours per week for three years to compensate him for lost educational opportunity arising from the District’s denial of FAPE. As discussed in Issue II, the Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education is the appropriate remedy for the District’s denial of FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year. Compensatory education is not appropriate for the District’s denial of FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT requires one school year (120 hours) of one-on-one compensatory educational services for three (3) hours per week to compensate him for the denial of FAPE in the 1997-1998 school year. The compensatory educational services must be designed to assist STUDENT (1) in writing mechanics, specifically in the areas of spelling, usage, capitalization and punctuation, and (2) in the use of appropriate assistive technology devices to help him in writing and editing his work. The compensatory educational services must be provided by a credentialed teacher who has experience working one-on-one with students with learning disabilities and, in particular, with students with disorders in visual processing, including visual memory, visual-perceptual organization, and visual-motor integration problems. In the alternative, if the District is unable to provide such a teacher, compensatory services may be provided by a certified nonpublic school or certified nonpublic agency of the parents’ choice. The parties may agree to alter the scheduling of the compensatory services during school holidays and vacations so long as the total hours of compensatory services are not reduced.

ORDER

1. The Petitioner’s requests for relief for the 1998-1999 school and extended school year are denied.

2. Within 20 business days of the date of this order, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner’s parents as follows:

a) for fifty percent of the costs incurred by the STUDENT’s PARENTS for STUDENT’s counseling services with Dr. Harris from January 1, 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, according to proof; and b) for fifty percent of the base tuition for Westmark School for the 1999-2000 school year, in a total amount of $8,910.

3. The District shall provide STUDENT with one school year (120 hours) of one-on-one compensatory educational services for three (3) hours per week to compensate him for the denial of FAPE in the 1997-1998 school year. The compensatory educational services must be designed to assist STUDENT (1) in writing mechanics, specifically in the areas of spelling, usage, capitalization and punctuation, and (2) in the use of appropriate assistive technology devices to help him in writing and editing his work.

4. The compensatory educational services must be provided by a credentialed teacher who has experience working one-on-one with students with learning disabilities and, in particular, with students with disorders in visual processing, including visual memory, visual-perceptual organization, and visual-motor integration problems. In the alternative, if the District is unable to provide such a teacher, compensatory services may be provided by a certified nonpublic school or certified nonpublic agency of the parents’ choice.

5. The provision of compensatory educational services shall begin no later than thirty (30) days from the date of this order. The parties may agree to alter the scheduling of the compensatory services during school holidays and vacations so long as the total hours of compensatory services are not reduced.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

I. On Issue I, the Petitioner prevailed in part and the District prevailed in part, as follows:

On Issue I.A., for the 1997-1998 school year, the Petitioner prevailed. On Issue I.B., for the 1998-1999 school year, the District prevailed. On Issue I.B., for the 1998-1999 extended school year; the District prevailed. On Issue I.C, for the 1999-2000 school year, the Petitioner prevailed. On Issue I.C., for the 1999-2000 extended school year, the District prevailed.

II. On Issue II, the Petitioner prevailed.

III. On Issue III, the Petitioner prevailed in part and the District prevailed in part.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: February 5, 2001 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues here differ slightly in numbering and content from those noticed by the parties before the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis, and to reflect the discussion held with the parties on the first day of hearing; e.g., the type of placement STUDENT requires is discussed in the context of determining his unique needs. At the hearing, the Petitioner requested to include the 2000-2001 school year as an issue due to the passage of time. The District objected to adding this issue. The Hearing Officer tentatively denied the Petitioner’s request but invited him to brief this issue. Because the Petitioner made no argument in his closing brief on this issue, it is not addressed by this decision

Footnote 2: STUDENT was initially determined to be eligible for special education by the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) in the first grade, based upon his visual-motor delays. Placement in an SDC was recommended but STUDENT’s parents chose to continue his private placement. In May of 1993, at the end of the first grade, STUDENT was again assessed for special education by the Santa Monica-Malibu School District (SM-MSD). Although visual-motor processing problems were noted, the District determined that STUDENT did not qualify as a student with an SLD because there was no significant discrepancy between his cognitive function and his academic achievement.

Footnote 3: STUDENT’s parents were divorced in approximately 1992. STUDENT resides with his father and his younger brother. He has frequent visitation with his mother. Although STUDENT’s FATHER has been the family’s primary liason with the District, STUDENT’s MOTHER has remained actively involved in STUDENT’s education.

Footnote 4: Dr. Mummery recommended the following strategies for STUDENT at school: (1) STUDENT would benefit from having visual cues readily available for work that requires perceptual organization or memory for carrying out a process. For example, in math, operation signs could be reviewed and highlighted before a calculation; (2) STUDENT could have a table of math facts to work with when needed; (3) STUDENT should have additional time to complete assignments, have open book tests, and other bypass strategies for his memory deficit as he learns processes; (4) Some of STUDENT’s assignments must be tailored to afford task completion, whether by decreasing the amount required or giving credit for work done that meets specific criteria with a certain time frame; (5) STUDENT will need adjustments made on content area assignments as well “to match his current reading and writing skills;” (6) STUDENT’s assignments must be non-ambiguous and structured in a step-by-step manner, with opportunity for reworking errors without penalty; (7) STUDENT will need to do more drill and practice activities and repetitive “overlearning” than his third-grade peers; and (8) STUDENT will need support and encouragement and should be rewarded for effort and attitude rather than outcome

Footnote 5: Ms. Katz-Starr is a licensed school psychologist who has been with the District for approximately 13 years. She has been a licensed educational psychologist since 1981 and a nationally certified psychologist since 1989. She has completed her course work for her doctorate.

Footnote 6: Ms. Meseck-Lafferty testified that STUDENT loved to work on the computer and frequently chose this as his reward. During this year, STUDENT took a computer game disk and she contacted the office. He later admitted taking it and appeared to be upset at disappointing her. A conference was held with his parents.

Footnote 7: Ms. Quisenberry has a master’s degree in psychology, a pupil personnel services credential, and a behavior intervention case manager credential. She is also a certified 504 case manager. She has been employed as a school psychologist with the District for four years.

Footnote 8: Ms. Quisenbery testified that, while low scores on these subtests alone were not generally used to make a child eligible as SLD, in her opinion, these scores were delayed enough to require that they be specifically addressed. As a result, STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education services as SLD in spelling, usage, punctuation and capitalization.

Footnote 9: These involved one ten-minute truancy, four incidents of class disruptions, two incidents of playing with a watch during class, one incident of fighting (“destruction of another student’s property”), and one incident of banging on the window before class.

Footnote 10: Dr. Harris is a licensed clinical psychologist in private practice. He is not affiliated with the Westmark School.

Footnote 11: Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U. S.C. § 1412 (a) (5) (A); Education Code § 56031. STUDENT does not contend that the SDC placement was not in the least restrictive environment.

Footnote 12: The IDEA defines the term “specific learning disability” as a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations. It includes such conditions as perceptual disabilities, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia, and developmental aphasia. 20 U.S.C. 1401(26)(a) and (B). Under California law, a pupil will be found eligible for special education based upon a specific learning disability when a “severe discrepancy” exists between the student’s intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following academic areas: oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation or mathematics reasoning. The severe discrepancy must be due to a “disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes,” not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.” Educ. Code § 56337. “Basic psychological processes” include attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities, including association, conceptualization and expression.” 5 C.C.R. 3030(j).

Footnote 13: Ms. Williams testified by telephone from Knox County, Tennessee, where she is currently employed as a resource specialist. She has a master’s degree in special education. She had a California credential in special education for learning disabled and severely handicapped, which have now lapsed. Ms. Meseck-Lafferty has been a resource specialist with Lindero for ten years. She is a certified resource specialist.

Footnote 14: In February 1995, the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT) was administered to STUDENT. The results of the WRAT were handwritten on the 1995 triennial. Ms. Katz-Starr did not administer this test and did not know who wrote its results on the triennial report. STUDENT’s WRAT standard scores were 84 in reading, 81 in math and 79 in spelling.

Footnote 15: In his closing brief, the Petitioner contends that the District’s failure to conduct achievement testing in the 1995 triennial constitutes a procedural violation because, in its absence, there was no way to ascertain whether he was making appropriate growth in his educational placement at the time of the 1998 triennial. He also contends that this argument is not barred by the three-year statute of limitations because its effects are ongoing. The Hearing Officer rejects this argument. The District’s 1995 triennial adopted the testing of Dr. Mummery done the prior year and concluded that its results were consistent with those reached by the SM-MUSD in 1993. Dr. Mummery’s WJ-R test results provide a baseline from which to measure academic progress, which can also be determined by other measures, such as the observations of teachers and class grades. Footnote 16: Dr. Sinclair’s testimony that the “WIAT paradigm” does not allow for an interpretation of the type used by school districts in determining special education eligibility suggests that its results would encompass children with learning disabilities who do not qualify for special education as SLD. (see Calif. Code of Reg. Title 5, 3003 (j)(4)(A)).

Footnote 17: Ms. Quisenberry testified that, in cases where there is a wide discrepancy between a child’s verbal and performance IQ, it was fairer to a child to use his verbal ability score, rather than his full scale IQ.

Footnote 18: The use of the WJ-R by school districts is not uncommon. It has been noted that “some practicing psychologists use only parts of a [diagnostic] system. For example, it is not uncommon for a psychologist to use the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised in conjunction with the achievement battery from the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery -Revised....although such practices do not give a diagnostician the advantage of a shared normative sample, they do make sense; relevant domains are assessed in a way that provides the tester with technically adequate and meaningful information.” “Diagnostic Systems,” Assessment (6th Ed. 1995) John Salvia and James Ysseldyke, p. 652.

Footnote 19: Dr. Harris’s testimony is consistent with Ms. Katz-Starr’s current recommendation that STUDENT receive DIS counseling and be referred to County Mental Health. Her recommendation was made following the District’s August 2000 reassessment of STUDENT and was based on his precipitous decline in both ability and achievement scores.

Footnote 20: As noted in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (1994) p. 47, “demoralization, low self-esteem, and deficits in social skills” may be associated features of learning disorders and the school drop-out rate for students with learning disorders “is reported at nearly 40% (or approximately 1.5 times the average).”

Footnote 21: Ms. Quisenberry testified that, during her October 1998 assessment, STUDENT was quiet, well-mannered, compliant, and willing to try tasks even when they became difficult for him. She administered the Child Behavior Checklist (CBLC), a behavior screener. No significant concerns were raised on the CBCL’s subtests for anxiety, acting out or aggressive behavior. The only significant range was in the area of somatic complaints, which was based upon Student’s Father’s report that STUDENT had some somatic complaints, such as aches and pains, headaches, and stomach aches. STUDENT’s responses on the projective “three wishes” test were normal for boys of his age. Input from STUDENT’s teachers also raised no concerns. In her opinion, no significant social-emotional concerns were apparent that necessitated DIS counseling services.

Footnote 22: Ms. Khmara has a master’s degree in education. She has credentials in learning handicapped (1988) and resource (1992). She was an SDC teacher at Lindero for nine years and is currently a resource specialist at an elementary school within the District.

Footnote 23: Cal. Code Regs. Tit.5 § 3043 provides that “such individuals [to be provided ESY programming] “shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition. The lack of clear evidence of such factors may not be used to deny an individual an ...[ESY] program if the [IEP] team determines the need for such a program and includes [ESY] in the [IEP]....”

Footnote 24: Ms. Khmara testified that she had been at the District as an SDC teacher for nine years. During much of Ms. Khmara’s testimony, she assumed that Dr. Sinclair had been a woman from Westmark School who observed STUDENT in her class and with whom she had interacted. This woman did not leave her business card and did not question Ms. Khmara about her teaching approaches with STUDENT. Later in Ms. Khmara’s testimony, it became clear that the woman she recalled was not Dr. Sinclair, but an employee of Westmark. Ms. Khmara had no recollection of anyone observing in her class for three full periods and did not remember Dr. Sinclair when she later saw her at the June 1999 IEP. The Hearing Officer has no reason to doubt the accuracy of Dr. Sinclair’s observations on that day, but also finds Ms. Khmara’s testimony to be credible. It is possible that this observation was conducted during a day when a substitute teacher was present. Both of STUDENT’s parents testified that they had never observed the SDC class at Lindero or discussed the teaching methods used in class at Lindero.

Footnote 25: Evidence was introduced that STUDENT’s motivation affected his grades during the second half of the seventh grade. District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s motivation declined during this time because of his belief that his parents were planning to enroll him in a private school and that, as a result, nothing he did at Lindero mattered because this work would not follow him to the new school. STUDENT did not want to change schools. Witnesses testified that STUDENT talked about this sometime during the period from January to March 1999. (Testimony of Ms. Williams, Ms. Khmara, Ms. Watt) Both of Student’s parents testified that they believed they did not tell STUDENT about going to a private school until after they received Dr. Sinclair’s first report sometime in April 1999. The evidence demonstrated, however, that STUDENT was well aware that his parents were interested in his changing schools before that time. Ben Shifrin, Westmark School’s co-headmaster, testified that the STUDENT’s PARENTS sought to have STUDENT admitted to Westmark before the 1998-1999 school year (seventh grade). According to Mr. Shifrin, STUDENT was adamant during his admissions interview that he did not want to attend Westmark and refused to respond to any questions during the interview. As a result of STUDENT’s unwillingness, his admission to Westmark School was declined at that time. STUDENT’s MOTHER also testified that in February 1999, STUDENT’s FATHER remarried. She believed that this affected STUDENT, and she observed changes in his behavior.

Footnote 26: STUDENT’s initial IEP within the District was held on September 29, 1992. STUDENT’s annual IEPs, at least since 1995, have been in October or November.

Footnote 27: In his closing brief, the Petitioner indicated that an IEP meeting had been held on October 2000.

Footnote 28: Mr. Nardo testified that, if a student is attending a nonpublic school at the time an IEP is due, it is the District’s policy to give notice of an IEP to those students and that the case manager is responsible for following up and conducting the IEP. He did not know of any reason why the STUDENT’s PARENTS were not notified of an IEP for STUDENT in October 1999.

Footnote 29: On October 19, 1999, STUDENT received a warning for disrespect and refusal to participate in P.E. On November 5, 1999, STUDENT was suspended for two days for verbally and physically harassing a student and shouting “I’m going to kill you.” On November 12, 1999, a conference with STUDENT and his parents was conducted because of reports that STUDENT had offered drugs to students on campus. STUDENT denied that this had happened but admitted joking about it. On December 8, 1999, STUDENT was given a warning and time-outs for repeated disrespectful behavior to his tutor after numerous time-outs. On December 9, 1999, STUDENT wrote the previously described essay, “A Biography on Mrs. Luella.” On December 13, 1999, STUDENT commented that his coat looked like “the trench coat mafia,” and he continued to be rude to his teacher. These incidents led to a meeting with the family and numerous administrators at Westmark. A behavior plan was developed that required STUDENT to participate in weekly counseling outside of school and a daily point system for positive behavior at school. On February 10, 2000, STUDENT was referred to the office for disrupting his class, tearing up a detention slip then removing his pants and shoes. On February 11, 2000, he was again referred to the office for continued disruptive behavior (throwing a pen in class, play fighting, poor attitude and not working). On February 18, 2000, STUDENT was suspended for two days for using a racial slur and profanity regarding a staff member. On June 2 and 5, 2000, he was given detentions for continued disruptive behavior and disrespect.

Footnote 30: The Petitioner phrased this issue to include reimbursement for any services provided by “the parents or the nonpublic school.” Because the evidence established that no services were provided by Westmark that were not paid for by the family, this issue is not addressed.

Footnote 31: As previously discussed, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide a ESY services during for the 1998-1999 school year. This conclusion is also applicable to the 1999-2000 year.

Footnote 32: Ms. Wagmeister previously worked at the District as an SDC teacher, a vice-principal and principal. As an SDC teacher at Yerba Buena Elementary School, she had STUDENT in her fourth grade class. Ms. Wagmeister has no current affiliation with the District. She has a master’s in education with an emphasis in special education. Her credentials include multiple subject, severely handicapped, learning handicapped and resource

Footnote 33: Ms. Zaragoza has an master’s degree in cross-cultural education and an emergency teaching credential. She has taken two special education courses. She also taught STUDENT “study skills” during the 1999 summer session and testified that he benefitted from that class

Footnote 34: Ms. Weltman testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in special education and that she is in the process of obtaining a master’s degree in educational therapy. She has a California emergency credential.