California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 9, 1997
Student v. Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1105-97 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Hacienda La Puente Unified prevails; Hearing Officer dismisses credit and football claims and finds summer 1997 program provided FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
An 18-year-old senior at Wilson High School asked for a hearing against Hacienda La Puente Unified School District. He had been found eligible for special education in April 1997 because of a specific learning disability. His main goal was to play football. He raised three issues: the District's revocation of 10 credits from the spring 1997 semester, whether his summer 1997 program provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE), and whether he could play football.
Hearing Officer Mark Paxson dismissed the credit issue. Education Code section 49066 has its own procedure for challenging grade changes, and nothing linked the revocation to special education. He also dismissed the football issue. The Hearing Office had no jurisdiction over Section 504 claims. The May 28, 1997 IEP addendum, which the student's side signed, expressly said he was not eligible for athletics. A later July 1997 document was never signed by the District, so it was not an IEP. There was also no evidence that he needed football to benefit from his education.
On the summer program, the student had the burden of proof because he sought to change the status quo. He did not meet it. The IEP made him eligible for special day classes in summer school. It did not require an all-special-day-class program. He earned 15 credits after failing almost all his classes the year before, which showed some educational benefit under Rowley. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO limited its jurisdiction to identification, assessment, placement and FAPE. Grade or credit disputes and sports eligibility were outside that scope unless tied to the IEP or to the student's educational needs. It also shows SEHO putting the burden of proof on the party seeking to change the status quo, and refusing relief first requested in a closing brief.
Issues and holdings
- Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 1. Is Student entitled to 10 academic credits the District revoked at the end of the 1996-1997 school year?
Dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. Section 49066 has its own procedure for challenging grades, and nothing tied the credit revocation to special education under Education Code section 56501(a). The Hearing Officer added that the claim likely would fail anyway, given the 17-week attendance board policy and the parties' IEP agreement that no spring credit would be earned.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District provide Student with a free appropriate public education during summer 1997?
Petitioner had the burden as the party seeking to change the status quo and did not show the summer program failed to meet unique needs, departed from the IEP, or denied some educational benefit under Rowley. The IEP made Student eligible for special day classes in summer school, not an all-special-day-class program, and he earned 15 credits.
- Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 3. Is Student entitled to play football for Wilson High School?
Dismissed as outside SEHO jurisdiction. SEHO cannot hear Section 504 claims. The May 28, 1997 IEP addendum expressly excluded athletics. The July 2, 1997 document was never signed by the District and was not an operative IEP. No evidence showed Student needed football to benefit from his education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's requested claims for relief denied. New relief first raised in the closing brief (other extracurricular activities, accommodation at adult school, compensatory education) was not considered because it was not disclosed as required by Education Code section 56505(e)(6).
Key authorities
Rowley; Burger v. Murray County School District; Education Code section 56501(a); Education Code section 49066; Education Code section 35179(a); Education Code section 56505(e)(6)
People named in the decision
- Victoria Baca, advocate for Student
- Raul Wilson, advocate for Student
- John Wagner, attorney for District
- Mike Shaw, director of pupil personnel services, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Tom Herman, school psychologist (psychoeducational evaluation), Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
- Cindy Haslock, resource specialist, Wilson High School
- Stu Reeder, principal, Wilson High School
- John Kramar, superintendent, Hacienda La Puente Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard in Hacienda Heights before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, on November 18 and 19, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by advocates Victoria Baca and Raul Wilson. STUDENT, who is eighteen years old, was present during the hearing, and his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER, was present for a portion of the hearing. Respondent Hacienda La Puente Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney John Wagner. Also present on the District’s behalf was Mike Shaw, director of pupil personnel services.
The record was left open for the submission of closing argument. The parties submitted closing briefs, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
(1) Is STUDENT entitled to 10 academic credits the District revoked at the end of the 1996-1997 school year?
(2) Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during summer 1997?
(3) Is STUDENT entitled to play football for Wilson High School?(Footnote 2)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an 18-year-old young man enrolled in his senior year at Wilson High School in the Hacienda La Puente Unified School District. STUDENT was first found eligible for special education services due to a specific learning disability in April 1997.
STUDENT enrolled at Wilson High School in the fall of 1996 as a regular education student. In addition to his academic courses, STUDENT played for the Wilson High School football team until just prior to the championship game. At the end of the fall semester, STUDENT was found ineligible for extracurricular activities, including football, because of grades. At the time, STUDENT was failing all of his courses. The District also recommended that STUDENT enroll in the alternative program at Valley High School because of his poor grades, lack of credits needed for graduation, failure to take advantage of additional tutoring, failure to follow up on a six-week student study team plan, and suspension for possession of stolen property. Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 2. STUDENT and his parents refused to accept a transfer to Valley High School, and the District, on January 9, 1997, implemented an involuntary transfer of STUDENT to the alternative program. STUDENT never attended the alternative program.
On April 7, 1997, Tom Herman, school psychologist, completed a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT. Mr. Herman found that STUDENT had deficits in auditory processing and was performing “inconsistently below expectancy ... in his academic areas.” As a result of this assessment, an IEP team convened on April 15, 1997. The IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education services and stated the following:
Deficits are noted in the areas of auditory processing, especially in short and long term ordered recall. There appears to be a significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement, especially in the area of written language. The IEP team recommends that STUDENT qualifies for special education.
The IEP team did not agree on placement for STUDENT until a meeting held on May 28, 1997. This meeting was convened following an agreement reached after Petitioner had requested a due process hearing. The IEP addendum developed at that meeting states the following:
Enroll STUDENT at WHS pursuant to sp. ed. hearing process agreement -- STUDENT may enroll immediately, however, no credit for 2nd semester 96-97 can be earned. He is not eligible for athletics while enrolled in the future at WHS. ... STUDENT indicates that he will request a waiver for athletic eligibility. The team agrees that STUDENT is eligible for extended year SDC if he chooses to catch up on credits.
As a result of the IEP developed on May 28, 1997, STUDENT enrolled at Wilson High School for the final three weeks of the school year. STUDENT’s teachers gave him grades of C in math and A in physical education. STUDENT did not receive grades in his public safety or in his directed study courses. When the school administration learned that STUDENT had received the grades and 10 credits in those two classes, the administration revoked the credits.(Footnote 3)
On July 2, 1997, STUDENT, along with his advocates and relatives, attended a meeting with representatives of the District and Wilson High School. Prior to the meeting, at Ms. Baca’s request, Cindy Haslock, resource specialist at Wilson High School, prepared a preliminary document. Testimony of Ms. Haslock. This document was prepared on an IEP addendum form. The document was then discussed at the meeting on July 2. The document prepared by Ms. Haslock states the following:
(1) STUDENT will earn 10 credits during summer school on the Wilson campus. (2) He will also enroll in and complete 10 credits in Adult School during the summer. If the 10 credits are completed before school begins in September 1997, the school will petition CIF for academic eligibility. Continued eligibility = same as other Wilson students.
This document, signed by STUDENT and his representatives, was not signed by District representatives because they did not believe that the meeting constituted an IEP meeting. In addition, the District representatives believed that the topics discussed during the meeting -- the awarding of academic credits and participation in football -- were not appropriate subjects for an IEP. Testimony of Ms. Haslock and Mr. Shaw.
The contents of the document dated July 2, 1997, however, were confirmed in a letter dated July 3, 1997, and signed by Stu Reeder, the Wilson High School principal. The letter states that all parties, including parents and student have agreed on the following:
STUDENT will earn a minimum of 20 units during the summer of 1997, combining 10 units of Wilson HS summer school with 10 units of adult school. If this is accomplished, the school will petition CIF for academic eligibility. His continuing eligibility will be on the same basis as all other Wilson students (i.e. must pass four classes each grading period and maintain a 2.0 GPA with five classes passed at the end of the semester).
During summer 1997, STUDENT earned 15 credits (5 credits in regular education art and 5 credits in a special day math class at Wilson High School, and 5 credits in science at the adult school). Because STUDENT did not earn the required 20 credits, the District refused to allow him to play on the football team, although they allowed him to practice with the team.
STUDENT returned to Wilson High School for the fall semester 1997 and has continued to practice with the football team. On November 13, 1997, the school issued a progress report for STUDENT. STUDENT was receiving the following grades: C+ in English RSP; B in Public Safety; D+ in Science SDC; D in World History; F in Art; and A in Athletics. STUDENT’s overall GPA based on these grades is under 2.0.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the outset of the hearing, Petitioner contended that the District’s revocation of STUDENT’s grades was not in compliance with procedures set out in the Education Code. Petitioner further contended that STUDENT should be entitled to play football as a result of a CIF waiver.(Footnote 4) In addition, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during summer 1997 and, as a result, Petitioner should be allowed to play football. The District contended that issues #1 and #3 are not appropriate issues for a special education due process hearing. With regards to issue #1, the District contended that the Education Code provides for a separate procedure for challenging grades and credits. With regards to issue #3, the District contended that decisions regarding a student’s eligibility for sports are governed by District policies, the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF), and are subject to procedures that are not subject to special education due process hearings.
Prior to the introduction of evidence, the Hearing Officer indicated to the parties that he would reserve a decision on the question of dismissing issues #1 and #3 to provide Petitioner an opportunity to present legal authority for the proposition that the awarding or revocation of grades and decisions regarding interscholastic athletics could appropriately be addressed in a special education due process hearing. Petitioner was provided with the opportunity to present evidence during the hearing and to present legal argument regarding the dismissal of issues #1 and #3 in his closing brief.
In his closing brief, Petitioner contended that Education Code Section 49066 provides the procedures for school districts to change grades and that the District did not following those procedures in this case. Therefore, STUDENT’s grades should not have been changed. While citing Section 49066, Petitioner does not cite any legal authority that suggests that Section 49066 falls within the jurisdiction of the Special Education Hearing Office. Petitioner further contends that whether STUDENT should be allowed to play football is an appropriate issue and cites as legal authority, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Petitioner also contends that the federal regulations governing special education include recreation, physical education, and interscholastic sports in the definition of special education.
In its closing brief, the District contends that Section 49066 provides the procedures for changing grades. Based on those procedures, the District contends that Petitioner is required to go before the District’s governing board in order to challenge the grade change, that Petitioner has not done so, and that the Special Education Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over grade changes. With regard to STUDENT’s eligibility for football, the District contends that the CIF governs eligibility and that STUDENT has failed to comply with CIF rules. The District further contends that CIF has a waiver policy that Petitioner has not pursued. The District also points to Education Code Section 35179(a), which provides that each school district governing board shall have general control of, and be responsible for, all aspects of the interscholastic athletic policies, programs, and activities in its district, including, but not limited to, eligibility, season of sport, number of sports, personnel, and sports facilities. In addition, the board shall assure that all interscholastic policies, programs, and activities in its district are in compliance with state and federal law.
Dismissal of Issue #1
Issue #1 addresses the question of whether STUDENT is entitled to receive 10 credits for two courses he was enrolled in during the spring semester of the 1996-97 school year. The evidence establishes that STUDENT was only enrolled at Wilson High School for approximately the final three weeks of the spring semester. The District’s governing board adopted a policy, Board Policy IH-F, which requires attendance for a minimum of 17 weeks in order to earn units toward graduation. Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 9. Apparently pursuant to that policy, District administrators revoked 10 units STUDENT received from teachers at the end of the spring semester.
In his closing brief, Petitioner did not provide any legal authority for the proposition that the Special Education Hearing Office has jurisdiction to address the revocation or assignment of grades and academic credits. While Education Code Section 49066 provides procedures for school districts to follow when changing grades, there is no indication that section 49066 may appropriately be raised in a special education due process hearing. Instead, section 49066 sets up its own procedure for challenging grades.
In looking to special education law, the Hearing Officer also finds no legal authority giving the Hearing Office jurisdiction over issue #1. Education Code Section 56501(a) provides the jurisdictional statement for due process hearings in the State of California. Section 56501(a) states that parents and public education agencies may initiate due process hearings under any of the following circumstances:
(1) There is a proposal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a free, appropriate public education to the child. (2) There is a refusal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a free, appropriate public education to the child. (3) The parent refuses to consent to an assessment of the child.
In the present case, Petitioner has made no contention, nor is there any evidence to suggest that the revocation of STUDENT’s units was the result of a proposal to initiate or change his educational placement or a refusal to initiate or change his educational placement. Instead, Petitioner contends that the District did not appropriately follow procedures contained in section 49066, procedures that are not a part of special education law. Petitioner did not provide any evidence or argument which ties the revocation to issues of special education. Because there is no indication that the District’s decision to revoke STUDENT’s units had any connection to the provision of special education services, issue #1 is dismissed.
The Hearing Officer notes that, even were issue #1 an appropriate issue for a special education due process hearing, it is unlikely that Petitioner’s request would be granted based on Board Policy IH-F and the IEP dated May 29, 1997, in which Petitioner and his representatives agreed that he would not receive any credit for the spring semester of the 1996-97 school year.
Dismissal of Issue #3
Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction over claims brought under section 504. There is a separate procedure for addressing section 504 claims. Therefore, claims arising under section 504 are not appropriate for special education due process hearings.
Petitioner cites as additional legal authority the federal regulations which define special education. Although those regulations do refer to physical education and intramural athletics, there is no indication in special education law that students with disabilities should be allowed to participate in such activities without meeting the same requirements that their nondisabled peers must meet. Furthermore, for STUDENT’s participation in football to fall within the jurisdiction of the Special Education Hearing Office, it must be demonstrated that, either his IEP included football as a part of his educational placement or that he needed to participate in football to benefit from his education and that the District’s failure to allow him to do so denied him an appropriate education. Education Code Sections 56031 & 56501.
There is no indication that STUDENT’s participation in football was made a part of his educational placement pursuant to an IEP. The IEP addendum dated May 28, 1997, states that STUDENT would be enrolled at Wilson High School pursuant to an agreement reached by the parties. The addendum further states that STUDENT would receive “no credit for 2nd semester 96-97" and “he is not eligible for athletics while enrolled in the future at WHS.” The addendum was signed by STUDENT, his mother, MOTHER, Ms. Baca, and Mr. Wilson. In other words, as of May 28, 1997, participation in football was specifically excluded by STUDENT’s IEP.
Petitioner also submitted a document dated July 2, 1997. This document is on an IEP addendum form and states that STUDENT would earn 10 credits in adult school during the summer, as well as 10 credits during summer school. The addendum also states that if STUDENT completed the 20 credits before school began “in September 1997, the school will petition CIF for academic eligibility.” This addendum, although signed by STUDENT, MOTHER, Ms. Baca, Mr. Wilson, and two other relatives of STUDENT, was not signed by any representatives of the District. Therefore, this addendum is not operative because it was not agreed to by STUDENT’s IEP team.
There is also reason to believe that the document dated July 2, 1997, was not really intended to be a part of STUDENT’s IEP and special education placement. Ms. Haslock testified the document was prepared only because Ms. Baca requested that it be prepared prior to the meeting. Both Ms. Haslock and Mr. Shaw testified that the District personnel who attended the meeting did not believe it was an IEP meeting and also believed that the items discussed were not appropriately included as part of an IEP.
With regard to whether STUDENT needs to play for the football team to benefit from his education, Petitioner presented evidence that STUDENT enjoys football and that he is a good football player. However, Petitioner did not present any evidence to suggest that STUDENT needs football in order to benefit from his special education.
Based on the fact that football was not made a part of STUDENT’s special education placement and services, and that there is no showing that STUDENT requires football to benefit from his special education, the Hearing Officer dismisses issue #3 as not within the jurisdiction of the Special Education Hearing Office.
The Hearing Officer notes that, if issue #3 were an appropriate issue for a special education due process hearing, it is unlikely that Petitioner’s request would be granted based on Petitioner’s agreement on May 28, 1997, that STUDENT would not be eligible for sports, and on STUDENT’s failure at each step to meet the grade and credit requirements established by the CIF and the District. Contempt/Sanctions
Finally, contrary to an order of the Hearing Officer, the District did not make available several of its employees which had been subpoenaed by Petitioner and included on Petitioner’s witness list. The two witnesses who the District did not make available -- the superintendent and the principal of Wilson High School -- are not relevant to the issues identified for this hearing. Because those witnesses’ appearance was ultimately not necessary for a decision in this matter, an action for contempt will not be initiated at this time. However, the Hearing Officer notes that this office has sanction authority. Parties and their attorneys who violate orders of the Hearing Office or who refuse to obey properly served subpoenas run the risk of sanctions.
DISCUSSION
Issue #2 Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during summer 1997?
State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Chapter 33. “Free appropriate public education” means special education and related services, provided at public expense, that conform with the student’s individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specifically designed instruction designed to meet the unique needs of a disabled child. 20 U.S.C. Section 1401(25).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialist instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 175,200.
Taken together, the IDEA and Rowley provide three factors for analyzing whether the District’s proposed placement is appropriate, which are as follows:
(A) Was the District’s placement for STUDENT during summer 1997 designed to meet his unique needs? (B) Did the District’s placement for STUDENT during summer 1997 conform to his IEP? (C) Did the District’s placement for STUDENT during summer 1997 provide him with educational benefit?
Petitioner contends that the District’s placement for STUDENT during summer 1997 was not appropriate because the District did not provide him with appropriate special education services at the adult school. Petitioner contends that since STUDENT’s IEP dated May 28, 1997, stated “STUDENT is eligible for extended year SDC if he chooses to catch up on credits” he should have had the opportunity to enroll in special day classes to earn 10 credits at the adult school. Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s program at the adult school -- one regular education course for five credits -- was inappropriate because it did not comply with his IEP. As a remedy, Petitioner seeks an order that STUDENT be allowed to play football for Wilson High School.
This case is unusual in that much of the evidence which was presented by Petitioner related to issues #1 and #3. There was very little evidence presented by either party regarding STUDENT’s placement during summer 1997. Because of the lack of evidence, the question of which party bears the burden of proof on the issues identified for hearing is significant.
There is no provision in special education law which specifically addresses the question of burden of proof. Furthermore, courts have adopted different standards for determining which party in a due process hearing bears the burden of proof.(Footnote 5) The Hearing Office has previously adopted the standard identified by some courts which requires that the party seeking to change the status quo bear the burden of proof at a special education due process hearing. Burger v. Murray County School District, 612 F.Supp. 434 (N.D. Ga. 1984). The issue before the court in Murray was whether the student must establish that the [District’s] proposed IEP and change of placement are inappropriate or whether the School District has the burden of proving their propriety. (Ibid.)
The court concluded that “the party advocating the move should bear the burden of proving its propriety.” Therefore, because Petitioner is seeking to change the status quo by including football in STUDENT’s special education program, Petitioner bears the burden of proving that the District’s placement was not appropriate.
(A) Was the District’s placement for STUDENT during summer 1997 designed to meet his unique needs?
Petitioner failed to present any evidence regarding STUDENT’s unique needs other than the statement contained in his IEP that he was eligible for special day class services if he chose to catch up in summer school. The District also failed to present any significant evidence regarding STUDENT’s unique needs. Based on Petitioner’s failure to present evidence regarding STUDENT’s unique needs or that STUDENT needs to participate in football as a part of his special education program, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not established that the District’s summer program for STUDENT did not meet his unique needs.
(B) Did the District’s placement for STUDENT during summer 1997 conform to his IEP?
STUDENT’s IEP called for him to be eligible for SDC if he enrolled in summer school. Once STUDENT enrolled in summer school, he enrolled in an SDC math class and a regular education art class at Wilson High School, and a regular education science class at the adult school. There is no indication on STUDENT’s IEP that his entire summer program was expected to consist entirely of special day classes. There is also no other evidence that suggests that STUDENT’s entire summer school program was meant to consist of special day classes. Rather, the evidence suggests that STUDENT’s IEP team had determined that STUDENT requires a mix of regular and special education classes. STUDENT’s education program at the end of the 1996-97 school year consisted of a mix of regular education and special education classes. Furthermore, his current class schedule for the fall semester of the 1997-98 school year consists of one resource specialist class in English, a public safety class, a science special day class, a regular education world history class, a regular education art class, and athletics.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP team intended for him to receive a mix of regular and special education classes. Therefore, Petitioner has failed to establish that the District’s summer program for STUDENT did not conform to his IEP.
(C) Did the District’s placement for STUDENT during summer 1997 provide him with educational benefit?
Again, Petitioner has failed to present evidence that supports a finding that the District failed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit during summer 1997. Petitioner appears to argue that since the District did not provide STUDENT with a program that provided him with 20 credits, the District did not provide him with educational benefit. Petitioner’s criteria for educational benefit appears to be met only if STUDENT receives the credits necessary for him to play football. Petitioner’s argument ignores the fact, however, that STUDENT did receive passing grades in three courses and received 15 credits after receiving failing grades in almost all of his classes during the previous school year.
Petitioner’s argument also ignores the fact that the Supreme Court has held in Rowley that a school district does not have to maximize a student’s potential to provide educational benefit. Rather, a school district is required only to provide a floor of opportunity that provides students eligible for special education with some educational benefit. There is simply no evidence that the District failed to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit during the summer 1997. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that the District’s program for STUDENT did not provide him with educational benefit.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that the District did not provide STUDENT with an appropriate education during the summer 1997. The Hearing Officer notes that, even if the District failed to provide an appropriate education for STUDENT during summer 1997, allowing STUDENT to play football would not be an appropriate remedy in the present case. As outlined above, whether STUDENT should play football is not an appropriate issue for a special education due process hearing. Furthermore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT has failed to meet the minimum requirements of both the District and the CIF.(Footnote 6)
ORDER
Petitioner’s requested claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
DATED: December 9, 1997 ______________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner’s only requested relief in his statement of issues was that he be allowed to play football for Wilson High School. In his closing brief, however, Petitioner added new claims for relief, including that he be allowed to participate in other extracurricular activities, that he “be accommodated at the adult school,” and that he received compensatory education. Education Code Section 56505(e)(6) provides that parties must notify each other of their issues and proposed resolutions at least 10 days prior to the due process hearing. To add claims for relief in a closing argument does not comply with section 56505(e)(6) and prevents the District from presenting evidence regarding those claims. Therefore, this decision will address only those claims raised in Petitioner’s statement of issues. 2. The Hearing Officer notes that, at the time of the hearing, the regular season for Wilson High School’s football team had ended. However, according to Petitioner, the football team had qualified for the playoffs and, potentially, the playoffs could last for an additional five weeks. 3.The circumstances of the revocation are unclear. Nobody who was involved in that decision testified during the hearing. John Kramar, superintendent, sent a letter, dated September 11, 1997, to Wilson High School’s principal, Stu Reeder, directing him to “correct any errors that have been made in the granting of credits” for students whose coursework did not meet the attendance requirements adopted by the school board. Petitioner’s Exhibit No. 9. 4. At some point during summer 1997, CIF gave STUDENT an “unconditional waiver.” This waiver was for the purposes of giving STUDENT a fifth year of eligibility and was not intended to allow him to participate in interscholastic sports without meeting the academic requirements of the CIF and the District. 5. See Special Education Law and Litigation Treatise, Weber, Mark, LRP Publications (1992). “On the issue of appropriateness of the district’s proposed program and placement, some courts have placed both burdens on the school system as the plans’ proponent. A greater number of courts have placed the burdens on the parent as the person challenging the district’s plans. Still others have placed the burdens on whichever party is proposing a change from the status quo.” [citations omitted] Weber, § 20.11. 6. Stated briefly, both the District and CIF require that students maintain a 2.0 GPA and earn 20 credits each semester to maintain eligibility for extracurricular athletics. The evidence establishes that STUDENT has not met these requirements since enrolling at Wilson High School in fall 1996.
