California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 25, 2004
Student v. San Francisco Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1114-03 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
San Francisco Unified must reimburse home-program costs and add behavior consultation; Hearing Officer finds FAPE denied 2002-2004.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of an eight-year-old third grader with autism filed for due process against San Francisco Unified School District. The District filed its own case, and the two were consolidated. For January through April 2002, the Hearing Officer found that the IEP's vague "1-39%" mainstreaming offer violated Union School District v. Smith but caused no harm. The special day class at Yick Wo Elementary gave some educational benefit. However, the District did not deliver one weekly hour of in-class behavioral services. The April 2002 IEP denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) because it dropped behavior services and autism resource teacher consultation without explanation. That denial ran through 2002-2003. The vague mainstreaming offer also contributed to lost opportunity once the parents removed the student, and the District made no written extended school year (ESY) offer. For 2003-2004, the District's attorney sent a placement offer by letter instead of holding an IEP meeting. The September 2003 IEP ignored behavior analyst Denise Pollard's assessment, had no behavior plan, and did not say how much mainstreaming the student would get. All of this denied FAPE. The Hearing Officer rejected requests for a half-day placement, a 50-hour-per-week one-on-one aide, and more speech therapy using a particular program. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 30 days, add 12 hours a month of behavior consultation, and build a mainstreaming plan. It must also reimburse tutoring and consultation costs from November 2002 through September 18, 2003. Compensatory education was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith to vague "1-39%" mainstreaming offers. The same vagueness was harmless in one year and a denial of FAPE in another. It also treated a placement offer drafted by district counsel outside an IEP meeting as a serious violation of parent participation. Finally, it required districts to explain why they removed services.
Issues and holdings
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 1.1(a). FAPE January 10 – April 24, 2002: whether the April 30, 2001 IEP made a formal, specific written offer of mainstreaming ("1-39%" during appropriate structured activities) as required by Union v. Smith
The mainstreaming offer was too vague under Union, but the student was actually mainstreamed and the parents participated fully, so there was no denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1.1(b). January 10 – April 24, 2002: whether the program was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit without more one-to-one instruction
The SDC with a roughly 1:2 adult-to-student ratio, plus consultation by Demmerle and Provo, gave educational benefit. The student progressed on her goals and did not need added one-to-one instruction.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 1.1(c). January 10 – April 24, 2002: whether the program comported with the IEP, including the one hour per week of in-class behavioral services added by the February 2002 addendum
The District offered no evidence that it provided the one weekly hour of in-school behavioral services, so the program did not fully comport with the IEP. The District still substantially prevailed for this period.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1.1(d). January 10 – April 24, 2002: whether the program was provided in the least restrictive environment
There was no argument or evidence that a less restrictive setting was needed. The student was mainstreamed daily, reverse-mainstreamed, and joined general education peers at lunch and recess.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 1.2(a). April 24 – June 2002: whether the April 24, 2002 IEP made a specific written offer of mainstreaming
The "1-39%, determined by teacher" offer violated Union, but it caused no lost educational opportunity during the rest of 2001-2002.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1.2(b). April 24 – June 2002: whether the April 24, 2002 IEP was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit after it eliminated behavior services, Provo consultation and autism resource teacher services
The District did not meet its burden to explain why behavior and consultation services were dropped when the student's behavior needs had not changed, so it denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2(a). Did the District provide a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year?
The inappropriate April 2002 IEP stayed in effect. Its vague mainstreaming offer contributed to lost educational opportunity when the parents removed the student, so FAPE was denied for the whole year.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 2(b). Did the District offer an appropriate extended school year program?
Although the student was found eligible for ESY, no IEP specified ESY services. The parents' likely refusal did not excuse the District from making a written offer.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3(a). 2003-2004: whether the July 31, 2003 offer of placement letter from District counsel, developed outside an IEP meeting, violated the parents' right to participate
An offer drafted by the District's attorney outside the IEP process seriously infringed on parent participation and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3(b). 2003-2004: whether the District failed to invite Denise Pollard or consider her assessment at the September 18, 2003 IEP meeting
The District did not have to invite Pollard, but the IEP team was required to consider her assessment and did not, which denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3(c). 2003-2004: whether the September 18, 2003 IEP lacked a specific written offer of mainstreaming under Union
The vague offer did not state how often or how long the student would be mainstreamed or what supports she would get. That prejudiced the student and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 3(d). 2003-2004: whether the September 2003 IEP was designed to meet unique needs given the absence of a behavior plan or behavior goals
The IEP did not address documented behavior needs, such as tantrums and escalating behaviors, so it was not designed to meet the student's unique needs.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3(e)(1). Should STUDENT be placed in Cathy Demmerle's SDC for one half day only, with mainstreaming or one-on-one tutoring the rest of the day?
The student needed the full day in the SDC to benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3(e)(2). Does STUDENT require a one-on-one aide or tutor, chosen by the parents, for 50 hours each week?
The SDC's low ratio and supervised paraprofessionals were adequate. The student was progressing without a dedicated aide.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3(e)(3). Must STUDENT receive five hours of speech and language services weekly, including private services, using Links to Language?
The District's offer of three 30-minute push-in/pull-out sessions a week was adequate, and methodology is left to the District.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3(e)(4). Must STUDENT receive behavioral supervision services, provided by Diane Provo or an appropriate NPA?
The student requires behavior consultant services. The District must provide 12 hours per month.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 3(e)(5). Must STUDENT receive mainstreaming, accompanied by a one-on-one aide, for appropriate academic subjects? / Least restrictive environment
The District did not offer the LRE because it made no specific mainstreaming offer. The student showed no persuasive need for a one-on-one aide, so the IEP team must develop the mainstreaming program.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private educational services from November 2002 through the date of the Decision?
The parents get reimbursed for tutoring and Provo consultation from November 2002 through September 18, 2003, which benefited the student. Tutoring after September 18, 2003 was not needed for FAPE and is not reimbursable.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
No evidence was offered about the student's compensatory education needs, so the request was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 30 days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting, inviting at minimum Diane Provo, Denise Pollard and Maureen Mckeown plus required members, and conform the IEP to the decision.
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must add behavioral specialist (behavior consultant) services of 12 hours per month.
- The IEP team must develop an appropriate mainstreaming program based on input from all members and Denise Pollard's assessment report.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving appropriate proof, reimburse the parents for all tutoring and consultation services they provided from November 2002 through September 18, 2003 (no dollar amount stated in order; parents had claimed $14,400.31 for this period).
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Capistrano Unified v. Wartenberg; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Alamo Heights; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified; Honig v. Doe; Roland M. v. Concord
People named in the decision
- Katharine McCauley, District special education administrator, San Francisco Unified School District
- Sophronia Brown Bess, special education elementary program administrator, San Francisco Unified School District
- Diane S. Provo, behavior consultant; expert witness for Student, Provo and Associates
- Cathy Demmerle, special day class teacher (Starr King); former autism resource teacher, San Francisco Unified School District
- Kimberly Russell, special day class teacher (Yick Wo Elementary), San Francisco Unified School District
- David Macarchick, private tutor, Family-hired
- Suzanne Forrester, private tutor, Family-hired
- Sasha Mandapat, private tutor, Family-hired
- Maureen Mckeown, private speech therapist, California Pacific Medical Center
- Betty Zuckerberg, speech and language pathologist, District witness, San Francisco Unified School District
- Cara Price, speech and language pathologist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Denise Pollard, behavior analyst; assessor of home program, Consultants for Learning and Autism Support Services (C.L.A.S.S.)
- Kay Cook, program specialist; educational assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
- Kerri Everett, speech and language pathologist; assessor
- Norma, paraprofessional (mainstreaming support), San Francisco Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This consolidated matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Francisco, California, on December 2-5, 2003.
STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER. San Francisco Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Lenore Silverman. Also present on behalf of the District was Katharine McCauley, administrator for the District in special education services. Sophronia Brown Bess, special education elementary program administrator, was present instead of Ms. McCauley on the second hearing day.
The Student called the following witnesses: Diane S. Provo, behavior consultant; Cathy Demmerle, special day class teacher; David Macarchick, tutor; Suzanne Forrester, tutor; Sasha Mandapat, tutor; MOTHER; NEIGHBOR, the PARENT’S neighbor; Maureen Mckeown, speech therapist at California Pacific Medical Center; FATHER.
The District called the following witnesses: Betty Zuckerberg, speech and language pathologist; Cara Price, speech and language pathologist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments, the last of which was received by the Hearing Officer on January 5, 2004. The record was then closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 school year, after the January 10, 2002 mediation agreement?
2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year?
4. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private educational services that they provided for STUDENT from November 2002 through the date of this Decision?
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eight-year-old third-grade student who is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. She is enrolled in a Special Day Class (SDC) at Starr King, an elementary school in the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD) taught by Cathy Demmerle. She also receives the related service of speech and language therapy five times a week, thirty minutes each session. (Footnote 2)
STUDENT attended an SDC at Yick Wo Elementary School taught by Kimberly Russell during the 2001-2002 (first grade) school year. Ms. Russell’s SDC classroom was very small, even for the small number of students in the class. (Testimony of Russell, Provo, Demmerle.) STUDENT received speech and language services, five times each week for thirty minutes (four individual sessions and one group session). STUDENT’s operative IEP for most of the year, developed on April 30, 2001, indicates that she was to receive consultation by an “autism resource teacher ” for four hours each month. The same April 2001 IEP also provided her with mainstreaming “during appropriate structured activities, excluding lunch and recess,” in the amount of between one percent and thirty-nine percent of the day, according to the IEP. (Exh. 10, 170-172.)
The April 30, 2001 IEP identifies “communication” (including expressive and receptive language) as a significant need area. The IEP notes that STUDENT rarely utilized spontaneous, unprompted language:
She says “Here” at roll call, “Hi”, “Bye, and “Thank You” following prompts, as well as numerous words throughout the day. Rarely, a spontaneous, appropriate utterance is heard: “Here” (roll call) or “Thank you” for cafeteria tray. Most words are approximations and the listener may need to know the context to be understood. Most approximations are accepted as the desired word. “Purple” is stated very clearly. Can initiate naming a few letters of the alphabet presented randomly, but not consistently. Does not necessarily respond to her name being called; is responding some to “sit”, “chair”, “come”, “stop”, “no”, but not “shh” yet. And adult may have to intervene with action for most directions. “I want __” is emerging, following patterning. Without first securing eye contact, a verbal response is difficult to elicit.
(Exh. 10, p. 176.)
In addition to significantly delayed communication skills, STUDENT’s April 2001 IEP team identified other needs, including close monitoring, turn taking, transitions, one-to-one direct teaching to learn new skills, as well as the need for a “constant arousal state” to improve her ability to learn:
Needs close monitoring or can be destructive to hers or peers property (class scissors are kept up out of reach). Still isn’t taking turns 2:1. STUDENT needs a significant amount of visual support to manage transitions independently. Needs direct 1:1 teaching to learn new skills which should then be fostered and generalized to small group activities prior to large group. STUDENT benefits from having sensory stimulation provided throughout the day to assist with providing a constant arousal state which improves her ability to learn. STUDENT benefits from having therapists consult with classroom staff to generalize skills across environments.
(Exh. 10, p. 175.)
The April 2001 IEP contained annual goals and short term objectives in the areas of behavior, independent work skills, peer interactions, receptive language, expressive language, pragmatics, reading skills, math skills and “following classroom directions.” (Exh. 10., pp. 185-195.) The IEP team also developed a behavior plan to address STUDENT’s tantrums. (Exh. 10, p. 193.)
Beginning in February 2001, the PARENT’S began procuring speech and language services for STUDENT from Maureen Mckeown of the California Pacific Medical Center. (Footnote 3) Ms. Mckeown has provided these services two times each week, fifty minutes each session. She has used a program called Links to Language, which she estimates STUDENT will complete in June 2004 or possibly the fall of 2004.
During the 2001-2002 school year, the District and STUDENT’s parents were involved in a dispute regarding STUDENT’s program and placement in Kimberly Russell’s SDC at Yick Wo. (Footnote 4) The dispute was resolved in mediation on January 10, 2002. On February 14, 2002, an addendum IEP meeting was held to add new services to STUDENT’s program pursuant to the mediation agreement. STUDENT’s program was amended to include five hours of weekly “behavioral services,” including four hours in the home and one hour at Yick Wo, to be provided by a tutor supervised by Provo and Associates. Consultation services were also added, to be provided by Provo and Associates, at a frequency of 12 hours (not to exceed) for February 2002, 8-10 hours per month for March and April 2002 and 6-8 hours per month for May and June 2002. (Ex. 10, pg. 162). (Footnote 5)
STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting was held on April 24, 2002, a little over two months after the February 2002 addendum IEP team meeting. The IEP team eliminated the behavior services, both the direct instruction and the consultation by Provo and Associates, and the IEP lacks any explanation as to why the services were eliminated. Additionally, the “autism resource teacher” services previously provided by Cathy Demmerle were removed from STUDENT’s IEP, and her speech and language services were changed to three weekly one-on-one sessions, one small-group session with a “regular education peer,” and one “class group” session. Occupational therapy services were added “to be delivered in 1x mo, 30-40 min or 2x mo 15-20 min or as tolerated.” STUDENT was also to be mainstreamed with general education peers between one and thirty-nine percent of each day, “as determined by teacher to maximize social interactions and peer [modeling].” (Exh. 10, 155.) Goals and objectives were drafted that addressed the same general need areas as the April 2002 IEP. STUDENT’s parents signed the IEP a little more than a week after the meeting.
During the summer of 2002, FATHER, STUDENT’s father, received training in the Son Rise program, a child-centered, parent directed educational program for autistic children. (Testimony of FATHER.) The parents provided this program during the summer, at home, with supervision provided by Diane Provo and funded by the District pursuant to the February 14, 2002 Addendum IEP. (Testimony of FATHER, Sasha Mandapat, and Diane Provo.)
STUDENT returned to Ms. Russell’s SDC at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, which had been moved from the smallish, crowded room to a larger room, and the same number of students as the previous year. (Testimony of Russell.) However, STUDENT’s parents allowed her to attend only half of the day; for the remainder of each school day, they continued to provide STUDENT’s home-based Son Rise program. (Testimony of Russell, FATHER.)
At the end of October 2002, the PARENTS completely removed STUDENT from Ms. Russell’s SDC and exclusively provided the Son Rise program. FATHER and Sasha Mandapat, a tutor hired by the family who also worked with STUDENT during the summer, acted as tutors in the program. Diane Provo provided infrequent consultations to STUDENT’s parents, beginning in January 2003. (Exh. 19, p. 1.) STUDENT’s parents continued to provide the program through September 2003. (Footnote 7)
On November 26, 2002, a month after the PARENTS had completely removed STUDENT from Ms. Russell’s SDC, the District convened an addendum IEP team meeting. (Exh. 10, p. 131.) The District did not offer to change the program or add services. The IEP team notes indicate, in pertinent part, that the PARENTS “want STUDENT fully included next year.” The PARENTS were informed of the application process and that “STUDENT requires a structured routine with 1:2 ratio and 1:1 instruction for learning new skills. IEP team recommends SDC with mainstreaming.” Kimberly Russell prepared a type-written “addendum” that generally summarizes STUDENT’s progress while she was a student in her class from August 2001 through October 2002. The addendum was attached to the November 26, 2002 IEP. Additionally, the IEP indicates that the meeting would reconvene in April 2003 for STUDENT’s annual IEP.
STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting was not held until May 28, 2003 IEP. The meeting notes reflect that the PARENTS requested “inclusion at Lilienthal,” the school attended by STUDENT’s siblings. No new goals and objectives were written, nor were placement or services offered or even discussed for the remainder of the 2002-2003 term, or for ESY 2003, or for the 2003-2004 term. (Ex. 10, p.129). Instead, the IEP team determined that the District needed to observe and evaluate STUDENT in order to make placement recommendations “since the District hasn’t seen STUDENT in a year.” The District requested an updated report from STUDENT’s private speech therapist, and arranged a time to observe STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents agreed to the IEP and the proposed assessments. (Exh. 10, pp. 127-129.)
Three days after the IEP team meeting, the Student requested the instant due process hearing through their attorney, Kathryn Dobel. (Exh. 1, p. 10A.)
Denise Pollard, behavior analyst and director of Consultants for Learning and Autism Support Services (C.L.A.S.S.) assessed STUDENT’s home program during June and July, 2003, at the request of the District. According to her report, the purpose of her assessment was to evaluate the home program and to provide recommendations for placement for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 8) According to her report, she visited the home program on four occasions and she used the Assessment of Basic Language and Learning Skills (ABLLS) to measure skill areas “that are important for learning readiness and academic areas of strength and weakness.” In the summary section of her report, she expressed great concern over the behavioral challenges STUDENT displays “when transitions are necessary, re-direction occurs, or change happens.” Ms. Pollard observed tantrums lasting at least ten minutes on four separate occasions. She recommended an SDC placement, a “high level” of mainstreaming with a “backwards mainstreaming” approach, at least initially, along with a “strong behavioral program . . . used consistently between environments.” (Ex. 3, pp. 45-48).
Following Ms. Pollard’s assessment, on July 31, 2003, the attorney for the District sent a letter to the parent’s attorney that included the District’s “offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year.” The letter indicates that the offer was developed prior to agreed-upon academic and speech and language assessments, but that the offer had been developed “based upon Ms. Pollard’s assessment and information from District staff that has worked with and observed STUDENT.” The “offer” includes placement in Cathy Demmerle’s SDC at Star King School with occupational therapy, speech and language therapy “until the IEP meeting,” mainstreaming, a “behavior plan” to address behavior issues documented in Ms. Pollard’s report, monthly team meetings, transportation, a transition plan, and extended school year services for the summer of 2004. It further states that “the District would like to schedule an IEP meeting within the first 30 days of the new school year to review assessment results and finalize goals and objectives based on newly obtained assessment information and data from the home program.” (Exh. 1, p. 5A.)
The PARENTS responded to the District’s “offer of placement” in a letter dated August 7, 2003. They rejected the proposal, stating they felt that STUDENT was then ready for “full inclusion.” The PARENTS stated that the District’s offer was “inappropriate,” but reserved the right to “form a different conclusion after observing the program.” (Exh. 1, p. 4A.)
On September 3, 2003, Kay Cook, a District program specialist, conducted an educational assessment for SFUSD. According to her report, she administered the Peabody Individual Achievement Test (PIAT) and the Woodcock Johnson III Tests of Achievement (WJ3). (Footnote 9) Ms. Cook found that, overall, STUDENT’s skills fell “below the Kindergarten level, except letter and word recognition (decoding) and spelling (phoneme and grapheme awareness) which fall within an early first grade level.” (Ex. 2, pp. 1-3).
Kerri Everett, a speech and language pathologist, also assessed STUDENT on September 3, 2003. (Footnote 10) She administered several tests, and observed STUDENT on two occasions. Overall, Ms. Everett found that STUDENT had significant delays in receptive and expressive language, and pragmatic skills related to her autism, and that “she presented with overall language ability, content (meaning), form (grammar) and use (pragmatics) below age-expected limits for a child of her same chronological age.” Ms. Everett stated:
STUDENT communicates effectively for wants and needs when in a structured environment and communicative expectations are known. She appeared to have more difficulty using verbal language when novel questions were asked of her that were beyond already learned responses, with the exception of labeling objects. STUDENT had relative difficulty responding to spontaneous and novel questions. She has made significant progress in her home program and individual speech and language therapies which are structured and 1:1 but continues to need assistance in generalizing these skills beyond her structured environment.
(Exh. 2, p. 32.)
The PARENTS eventually agreed to allow STUDENT to attend Ms. Demmerle’s SDC at Star King. She began attending in the middle of September 2003, roughly a month after school started. According to Mr. FATHER, they placed her in the SDC in part because they could not afford to maintain STUDENT’s home program. (Testimony of FATHER.)
The District convened an IEP team meeting on September 18, 2003. Ms. Pollard was not invited and did not attend the IEP team meeting, and the IEP does not reflect that her assessment was discussed. (Exh. 10, p. 110.) The only related services proposed by the IEP team include three thirty-minute “pull-out/push in” speech and language per week; the IEP notation does not reflect if the services were to be individual or group. Regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, the IEP states as follows:
STUDENT continues to demonstrate significant delays in receptive, expressive and pragmatic language. She continues to need support in generalizing her learned skills for language. STUDENT will occasionally demonstrate inappropriate or negative behaviors although this has significantly decreased in relation to [the] past.
(Exh. 10, p. 110.)
Annual goals and short-term objectives were developed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of communication (expressive and expressive language, as well as social/pragmatic language), socialization/peer interaction, mathematics and literacy/reading. In the area of behavior, the IEP reflects that STUDENT’s behavior does not impede her learning, or the learning of others, and no behavior plan or goals and objectives were drafted to address behaviors such as those observed by Ms. Pollard in her assessment. The IEP indicates that STUDENT would be placed in the general education environment for between one and thirty-nine percent of each day, but there is no mention of the actual amount of mainstreaming. The only notations related to mainstreaming (other than the variable percentage discussed above) was that STUDENT will “attend special day class with reverse mainstreaming” and that she requires “additional support to maximize participation during mainstreaming.” (Exh. 10, p. 116).
The “continuing notes” specify the following “supports for school personnel”:
While STUDENT demonstrates the ability to function independently with specific activities or tasks she needs additional support during the following times of the day: To and from the bus and excursions in the community to insure she remains safe and with the group. STUDENT requires additional support to maximize participation during mainstreaming in the general ed classroom and to facilitate learning new skills within the general ed. curriculum. She benefits from additional support during open-ended activity times both in and out of the classroom to promote positive/appropriate social interactions with peers and to assist in the development and use of communication. At this time IEP team recommends classroom placement which implements strategies commiserate with STUDENT’s learning needs as they relate to autism and is staffed accordingly in order to meet her goals. The classroom should be staffed with a ratio of 2 students to 1 adult and not exceed 9 students.
(Exh. 10, p. 114.)
The PARENTS did not agree to the IEP. (Ex. 10, p. 123.) They drafted a dissenting statement, dated September 22, 2003, in which they indicate their “agreement only to SDC placement in Cathy Demmerle’s class with additional supports and services,” including: (1)speech and language therapy five times per week (one group session with no more than three students and four individual, pull-out sessions using Links to Language); (2) behavioral specialist consultation services, eight hours each month, provided by Diane Provo for “home and school consultation, individual program development, and staff training”; (3) fifteen hours per week of one-on-one instruction “after school for academic, social, communication, and behavioral skill development”; (4) an experienced and trained one-on-one teacher’s assistant who will address “safety, group interaction, mainstream, inclusion assistance, and individual learning needs”; (5) structured mainstreaming for academic subjects and social skill development; (6) “additional goals and objectives.” (Exh. 10, p. 123A.)
Beginning in September, Ms. Demmerle introduced annual goals and short term objectives related to school vocabulary, yes and no questions, answering “Wh_” questions and “set value up to 10.” In October, she introduced STUDENT’s goals related to sight word reading and reading a book. In November, she introduced STUDENT’s previous goals related to social greetings, conversation/turn-taking, counting objects up to 20 and yes/no questions, answering “wh” questions, increasing responses to 4-5 words and set value up to 10. In October 2003, Ms. Demmerle introduced the goal from the April 2002 IEP related to sight word reading and reading books. In November 2003, Ms. Demmerle introduced goals for social greetings, conversation/turn-taking and counting objects to 20 and identifying set values. (Ex. 9, p. 99, Testimony of Demmerle.)
In November 2003, the District requested its own due process hearing. The two matters were consolidated, and the hearing convened on December 2, 2003.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 school year, after the January 10, 2002 mediation agreement?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir.1988). The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S. C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305 (1988).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir.1996). De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist. 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997). Moreover, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121(2d Cir. 1997).
Special education law also requires that disabled students be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of the disability is such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, a substantively appropriate program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit; (3) comport with her IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir.1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. Id. at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm. 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir.1990).
One procedural violation that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994) cert denied, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). In Union, the district failed to make a formal written offer of a particular placement because it believed the parents would reject the placement. According to the district, the parents had expressed their “unwillingness” to consider it as a placement. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the district could not “escape itsobligation under the IDEA to offer formally an appropriate education placement by arguing that a disabled child’s parents expressed unwillingness to consider it as a placement.” The Court of Appeals stated, “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced rigorously.” Regarding the purpose of the requirement of a written offer of placement, the Court stated:
The requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any. Furthermore, a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in “present[ing] complaints with respect to any matter relating to the . . . educational placement of the child.” Id.
The Court further explained that, under the facts of Union, a formal written offer would have alerted the parents “to the need to consider seriously” whether the particular placement was appropriate under the IDEA, would have allowed the parents to decide whether to oppose the placement or to “accept it with the supplement of additional education services,” and would help the district to better prepare to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. Id.
In addition, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that a district has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396 (9th Cir.1994); Seattle Sch. Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., et al., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir.1996).
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a child has been provided a FAPE in the LRE is generally twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps were followed and whether the proposed placement was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884, 891 (9th Cir.1995). Moreover, it is the districts burden of proving it complied with the IDEA. Seattle Sch. Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., et al., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir.1996).
STUDENT contends that the District committed a number of procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA that denied her a FAPE after the January 10, 2002 mediation agreement through the end of the 2001-2002 school year (June 2002). The District contends that it offered/provided STUDENT with a FAPE during this entire period. (Footnote 11) Because STUDENT’s annual IEP convened on April 24, 2002, and her overall placement changed after that date, the Hearing Officer will separately analyze (1) whether STUDENT was provided a FAPE from January 10, 2002 through April 24, 2002, and (2) whether STUDENT was provided a FAPE from April 24, 2002 through the end of the school year.
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE from January 10, 2002 through April 24, 2002?
Procedural Violations
The first question that must be answered is whether the April 30, 2001 IEP (this IEP was operative during the period in question) met the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (Footnote 12) (Exh. 10, p. 167.) As discussed above, one of the District’s obligations was to make an appropriate, written offer of placement pursuant to Union. In the April 30, 2001 IEP, the District offered to place STUDENT in an SDC with the related services of speech and language therapy and consultation by an autism resource teacher. The IEP also states that STUDENT was eligible for extended school year services (Footnote 13) and transportation services. Thus, the IEP meets the requirement of Union that the District make a formal, written offer of placement with regard to the SDC and the related services.
The April 30, 2001 IEP does not meet the requirement of a formal, written offer related to STUDENT’s interaction with typically developing peers. As developed above, the IEP indicates that STUDENT’s “total time in general education” would be “1-39% during appropriate structured activities, excluding lunch and recess.” The “continuing notes” indicate that STUDENT would receive “additional support . . . to maximize participation in group activities in special day class and general ed classroom as well as to foster appropriate social interactions.” This does not meet the Union requirement of a specific, written offer because it is unclear (1) how much time STUDENT would participate with typically developing peers, (2) what “additional support” STUDENT requires and would receive, and (3) what “appropriate structured activities” might include.
Having found that the District failed to make an appropriate written offer related to STUDENT’s interaction with typically developing peers, the next question is whether this failure resulted in lost educational opportunity or seriously infringed upon the parents’ right to participate in the IEP process.
There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT lost educational opportunity nor was there persuasive evidence that the PARENTS were unable to fully participate in the IEP process because of the District’s failure to make a specific written offer of mainstreaming services. STUDENT regularly participated in activities with typically developing, non-disabled peers with the assistance of a one-on-one aid (“paraprofessional”) during the time period at issue. Kim Russell, STUDENT’s SDC teacher testified that STUDENT was mainstreamed with a paraprofessional named “Norma” from 11:30 to 12:00 p.m. daily, that she was “reversed-mainstreamed” – meaning typically developing students come into the SDC – from 9:45 to 10:15 for a “reading buddies” activity, and that she participated in lunch and recess with typically developing peers. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE during this time period because of the District’s failure to make a specific, written offer of mainstreaming services.
Substantive Violations
Again, a substantively appropriate program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit; (3) comport with her IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.
Was STUDENT’s program designed to meet her unique needs?
The first determination is whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. STUDENT’s unique needs were not in dispute; it was not disputed that the STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of behavior, independent work skills, peer interactions, receptive language, expressive language, pragmatics, reading skills, math skills and following classroom directions. It was similarly not disputed that STUDENT’s April 30, 2001 IEP appropriately addressed those unique needs through appropriate, agreed-upon goals and objectives.
Was STUDENT’s program reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit?
While STUDENT’s unique needs were generally not in dispute, the parties disputed whether the District’s offer of placement and related services from January 10, 2002 through April 24, 2002 period were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The placement and services STUDENT received during this period included placement in an SDC taught by a credentialed teacher named Kimberley Russell (Footnote 14) with three full time “paraprofessionals,” and another paraprofessional who was shared with another special day class. There were six other autistic students in Ms. Russell’s SDC; as a result, the adult to student ratio in the SDC was approximately 1:2. STUDENT also received speech and language services. Additionally, STUDENT received the consulting services of an “autism resource teacher” for four hours each month; those services were provided by Cathy Demmerle. (Footnote 15) Finally, beginning in February 2002 (following a mediation agreement), STUDENT’s IEP was amended to include five hours of weekly “behavioral services,” including four hours in the home and one hour at Yick Wo, to be provided by a tutor supervised by Provo and Associates. Consultation services were also added, to be provided by Dianne Provo, at a frequency of 12 hours for February 2002, 8-10 hours per month for March and April 2002 and 6-8 hours per month for May and June 2002. (Ex. 10, pg. 162).
Student’s primary contention was that STUDENT did not receive enough “individual attention” or “one-on-one instruction” throughout the school day and therefore, she did not receive some educational benefit. STUDENT’s IEP indicates that STUDENT requires direct instruction to learn new skills:
[STUDENT] needs close monitoring or can be destructive to hers or peers property (class scissors are kept up out of reach). Still isn’t taking turns 2:1. STUDENT needs a significant amount of visual support to manage transitions independently. Needs direct 1:1 teaching to learn new skills which should then be fostered and generalized to small group activities prior to large group. STUDENT benefits from having sensory stimulation provided throughout the day to assist with providing a constant arousal state which improves her ability to learn. STUDENT benefits from having therapists consult with classroom staff to generalize skills across environments.
[Emphasis Added.] (Exh. 10, p. 175.)
The PARENT’S testified that STUDENT requires one-on-one instruction throughout the day in order to benefit. They testified that on several occasions (typically when they picked STUDENT up from school), they observed her sitting by herself, not engaged and not learning. (Testimony of MOTHER and FATHER.) FATHER testified, however, that STUDENT did benefit from Ms. Russell’s class during the times when she was engaged by an adult.
The Student called Diane Provo to testify about STUDENT’s needs and services during all periods in dispute. It was not disputed that Ms. Provo is an expert in the area of autism (the District has contracted with Ms. Provo’s company to provide IEP services in the past, including services to STUDENT). (Footnote 16) Ms. Provo taught for approximately twenty years, and for the past sixteen years, she has operated a private consulting business that focuses on designing programs for children with Autism. In addition to consultation services for autistic children, she also works directly with students. Ms. Provo provided behavior consultation services to STUDENT beginning in February 2002 pursuant to the January 10, 2002 mediation agreement. She spent several hours each month during the period at issue working with STUDENT in Kim Russell’s classroom. She also worked with STUDENT during the summer of 2002, and continued to provide consultation services to STUDENT’s parents after they removed her from Kim Russell’s SDC during the 2002-2003 school year and the summer of 2003. (Footnote 17)
Ms. Provo testified that, during the period in question, she provided training to the paraprofessionals in Ms. Russell’s class, and that she consulted with Ms. Russell. She testified that Ms. Russell’s classroom at Yick Wo was small and that some of the other children in STUDENT’s class had extreme needs and behavioral problems and that, as a result, the class was very noisy. This combination of noise and the small environment caused STUDENT to “remove herself” according to Ms. Provo. She generally testified that the paraprofessionals were undertrained, that no particular paraprofessional was assigned to STUDENT all of the time. Ms. Provo also explained that Kim Russell was appropriately qualified, but she could not solely work with STUDENT because of the needs of the other children. Ms. Provo testified generally that STUDENT’s needs were not adequately met in the Kim Russell’s classroom because of the severity of the needs of the other children. She further opined that STUDENT required (and continues to require) individual attention throughout the school day, i.e., a trained paraprofessional, assigned only to STUDENT, overseen by an appropriately qualified teacher. (Footnote 18) However, on cross-examination, Ms. Provo further explained that it was not her belief that STUDENT did not progress in Ms. Russell’s class, but rather that STUDENT’s progress in Ms. Russell’s class was “inhibited” by the lack of sufficient individual attention. She also testified that STUDENT did not require individual instruction all of the time. Ms. Provo did not testify that STUDENT failed to progress on her goals and objectives during the time period at issue.
Cathy Demmerle testified on behalf of the District about STUDENT’s needs and services during the period at issue. She is also an expert in the area or autism, according to Diane Provo (this fact was not disputed at the hearing). Ms. Demmerle has taught children with autism for the past 15 years, and she has taught for a total of 23 years. Ms. Demmerle is STUDENT’s current SDC teacher, but during the period in question, she worked as the “autism resource teacher” whose duties included consulting with Kim Russell about STUDENT’s program and services under STUDENT’s IEP. She testified that she was present in Ms. Russell’s classroom from January 2002 through the end of the school year one time a week for approximately on one and one half to three hours. Ms. Demmerle observed STUDENT on multiple occasions during this period.
Ms. Demmerle testified that her and Ms. Provo were in agreement that STUDENT’s classroom was too small, and that Kim Russell’s organizational skills needed a “boost.” She also testified, however, that she and Ms. Provo worked with Kim Russell during the period at issue, and that they helped reorganize the environment by weeding out some of the unnecessary materials. Ms. Demmerle had ongoing conversations with Ms. Russell regarding STUDENT’s progress on her goals and objectives from January 2002 through the end of the school year and she testified that, despite the size of the classroom, STUDENT made progress on her goals and objectives. She did not believe that STUDENT required one-to-one instruction throughout the day in order to benefit from her education. (Testimony of Demmerle.)
Kim Russell, who was STUDENT’s teacher throughout the period at issue, testified that STUDENT made progress on all of her goals and objectives. She also generally testified how she was able to provide direct instruction to STUDENT to introduce new skills, despite the needs of the other autistic children in the smallish SDC. Ms. Russell believed that STUDENT did not require a full time one-on-one aid assigned solely to her. (Testimony of Kim Russell.)
The Hearing Officer finds, based on the weigh of the evidence, that STUDENT’s program was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit during the period at issue – STUDENT did not require additional one-to-one instruction or individual attention in order to receive some educational benefit. The Hearing Officer found persuasive the fact that STUDENT actually made progress on her goals and objectives with the combination of services and placement that she received, which included Ms. Russell’s special day class, at least three paraprofessionals, as well as the consultation services provided by both Ms. Demmerle and Ms. Provo. Ms. Demmerle and Ms. Russell testified persuasively that STUDENT actually made progress on her agreed-upon annual goals and short term objectives during this period. STUDENT’s parent also believed that she made progress when she was engaged. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that the combination of a small student-to-teacher ratio, a qualified special day class teacher, as well as the consultation services provided by Ms. Provo and Ms. Demmerle were adequate, and no additional one-on-one instruction was required to be written into STUDENT’s IEP for her to receive some educational benefit.
Did STUDENT’s program comport with her IEP?
STUDENT contends that her program did not comport with her IEP. As developed above, STUDENT’s program was amended in February 2002 to include five hours of “behavioral services” and one of the five hours were to be provided in the classroom.
In short, the District provided no testimony or evidence that STUDENT actually received the one hour of behavioral services that was to be provided in STUDENT’s SDC. It is unclear if anybody was ever assigned the task. (Footnote 19) The subsequent (April 24, 2002) IEP does not reflect that this service was provided. As such, as Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s program during the period in question did not comport with her IEP because she was not provided with the one hour of behavioral services in the classroom as required by the February 2002 IEP.
Was STUDENT’s program provided in the Least Restrictive Environment?
Special education law also requires that disabled students be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of the disability is such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031. In the present case, there was neither argument or evidence that STUDENT’s program during the period at issue (January 10, 2002 through April 24, 2002) was not the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. The Student did not contend that STUDENT should be placed in a less restrictive environment, or that she could benefit from increased mainstreaming during this period. Again, STUDENT was mainstreamed with a paraprofessional named “Norma” from 11:30 to 12:00 p.m. daily, and she was “reversed-mainstreamed” from 9:45 to 10:15 for a reading activity, and she also participated in lunch and recess with typically developing peers. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE during this time period because of the District’s failure to make a specific, written offer of mainstreaming services.
In summary, it has been found above that the District’s offer of mainstreaming services for the period from January 10, 2002 through April 24, 2002, was not procedurally adequate, but that this failure did not prejudice STUDENT or infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process. Moreover, it has been found that, while STUDENT’s program and placement was substantially appropriate, STUDENT’s program did not completely comport with her IEP in that she did not receive the one hour of in-school behavioral services required by the February 2002 Addendum IEP.
2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE after April 24, 2002, through June 2002?
Procedural Violations
The first question is whether the April 24, 2002 IEP met the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (Exh. 10, p. 137.) As discussed above, one of the District’s obligations was to make an appropriate, written offer of placement pursuant to Union. In the April 24, 2001 IEP the District offered to continue the bulk of STUDENT’s program from the previous period (April 30, 2001 through April 24, 2002), including placement in an SDC and speech and language services, transportation and extended school year services (although the lengthy and type of ESY services are not described). Occupational therapy was also added as a related service, and the frequency and duration is specified. Thus, the April 24, 2002 IEP meets the requirement of Union that the District make a formal, written offer of placement with regard to the SDC, the related services, and transportation services. (Footnote 20)
Unfortunately, like the April 30, 2001 IEP, the April 24, 2002 IEP states that STUDENT’s “total time in the general education would be “1-39%.” It indicates that the actual amount of time STUDENT would spend in general education would be “determined by teacher to maximize social interactions and peer modeling.” It does not indicate which teacher would determine the amount of time (a regular education teacher, the special day class teacher, or an autism resource teacher.)
For the identical reasons described above, the April 24, IEP does not meet the requirement of a formal, written offer related to STUDENT’s interaction with typically developing peers.
Having found that the District’s failed to make an appropriate written offer related to STUDENT’s interaction with typically developing peers, the next question is whether this failure resulted in lost educational opportunity or seriously infringed on the parents right to participate in the IEP process. STUDENT’s actual mainstreaming opportunities remained the same after April 24, 2002, and like the previous period, there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT lost educational opportunity nor was there persuasive evidence that the PARENTS were unable to fully participate in the IEP process because of the District’s failure to make a specific written offer of mainstreaming services. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE during this time period because of the District’s failure to make a specific, written offer of mainstreaming services. (Footnote 21)
Substantive Violations
Was STUDENT’s program designed to meet her unique needs?
It was not disputed that the April 24, 2002 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. (Footnote 22) Appropriate, agreed upon goals and objectives were developed, as well as a behavior plan, which addressed all of STUDENT’s need areas. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s April 24, 2002 IEP was designed to meet her unique needs.
Was STUDENT’s program reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit?
While STUDENT’s unique needs were not in dispute, the adequacy of her services were disputed. Student argued both at the outset of the hearing and in her closing arguments that STUDENT’s program was changed and services were eliminated which were necessary to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The IEP team eliminated the behavior services, including the five hours per week of direct instruction as well as the consultation services provided by Provo and Associates. The IEP lacks any explanation as to why the services were eliminated. Additionally, the “autism resource teacher” services previously provided by Cathy Demmerle were removed from STUDENT’s IEP, also without explanation.
It is well established that the District had the burden of proving that its program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396 (9th Cir.1994); Seattle Sch. Dist., No. 1 v. B.S., et al., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir.1996).
Simply put, the District failed to meet its burden. It provided no persuasive evidence or argument as to why the above-listed behavioral and consultation services were no longer required to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Nor was there evidence that STUDENT’s behavioral needs changed after April 24, 2002 -- in fact, the IEP team developed a behavioral plan to address STUDENT’s tantrumming and screaming behaviors (Exh. 10, p. 148) as well as an annual goal and corresponding short term objective to address “appropriate behavior across all environments.” (Exh. 10, p. 140.) Despite the fact that the above listed services were eliminated from the April 24, 2002 IEP, the services were actually provided to STUDENT for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year (until June of 2002) and Provo and Associates continued to provide consultation services and direct tutoring during the summer.
The Hearing Officer finds that the April 24, 2002 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Behavioral and consultation services were eliminated and no persuasive evidence was provided that STUDENT’s need for such services had changed. As such, the District denied STUDENT a free and appropriate public education during the period at issue. (Footnote 23)
In summary, it has been found above that the April 24, 2002 IEP failed to meet the procedural requirements of the IDEA, but that the failure did not prejudice STUDENT or infringe on her parents participation in the IEP process. However, it has also been determined that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from April 24, 2002 through June 2002 because the District’s offer was substantively inappropriate.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
For purposes of analysis, the Hearing Officer must separately discuss the 2002-2003 school year and the 2002 ESY.
Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year?
As developed above, it has been found that the April 2002 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, therefore, STUDENT was denied a FAPE. That IEP was to be implemented through April 2003 and was operative when STUDENT returned to Kim Russell’s SDC in the fall of 2003. No substantive changes were made to STUDENT’s IEP during the interim period. As such, STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 IEP school year for the reasons previously discussed regarding the substantive appropriateness of the April 24, 2002 IEP.
Moreover, as discussed above, the April 24, 2002 IEP was procedurally inadequate because it lacked a specific offer of placement related to STUDENT’s participation with typically developing peers. While it was found above that this procedural failure did not result in loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT during the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year, it did result in lost educational opportunity during the 2002-2003 school year. Dissatisfied with a perceived lack of progress in her school placement, the PARENTS removed STUDENT from her school placement beginning in the fall of 2002. (Testimony of FATHER.) Initially, they removed STUDENT for half of the school day and at the end of October, the PARENTS removed STUDENT completely. Because STUDENT lost educational opportunity at least in part because of the failure to offer a specific program, STUDENT was denied a FAPE during this period.
Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program?
The next question is whether the District offered STUDENT an appropriate ESY program for the summer of 2002. Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043.
The April 24, 2002 IEP and the November 26, 2002 IEP indicate that STUDENT was eligible for ESY services, but the May 2003 IEP does not indicate that STUDENT was eligible for ESY services. No IEP specifies what ESY services were to be offered, including whether the ESY would be simply an extension of the regular school year program (that was previously found to be inappropriate.) Although unclear, apparently the District’s position is that it was not obligated to make a specific offer of ESY because STUDENT’s parents expressed that they would not return STUDENT until the fall of 2003.
The Districts’s position is not supported by the law. Education Code § 56345(b)(5) provides that where, as here, a child has been determined by his or her IEP team to be entitled to ESY services, the written IEP must include an ESY program. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043(f). The California regulations do not relieve the District of its obligation to make a written offer of ESY in an IEP because the parent will likely refuse the offer. Moreover, as developed above, Union requires districts to make a specific written offer, in pertinent part, so that parents are alerted to the need to consider the offer. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program for the summer of 2003.
In sum, it has been found above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the entire 2002-2003 school year, as well as the ESY of 2003.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year?
The Student alleges both procedural and substantive violations that she alleges denied her a FAPE during the current school year. The procedural and substantive violations will be separately discussed.
Procedural Violations
The Student alleges that the District committed procedural violations (1) related to an offer of placement letter dated July 31, 2003 and (2) at an IEP team meeting that convened on September 18, 2003. Each will be discussed below.
The July 31, 2003 Offer of Placement
The Student’s first contention is that the District developed an IEP and an offer of placement without the participation of the IEP team members, especially STUDENT’s parents. She alleges that this violation seriously infringed on the parents’ right to participate in the IEP process, and that it denied STUDENT a FAPE. The District’s position is unclear.
It is not disputed that the District’s attorney sent a letter to the parents dated July 31, 2003 in which she offers STUDENT’s placement for the 2003-2004 school year. The letter provides the following explanation regarding why the offer was made without any parent input, and totally outside of the IEP process:
The following is an offer of a District placement for the 2003-2004 school year. It is unfortunate that the final offer could not be made at a regularly scheduled IEP meeting. As you recall from our discussion, an IEP meeting was held on May 28, 3003 [sic]. At that time, the parents claimed STUDENT had made excellent progress in her “home program” and that her needs were now very different. Based on the parent’s assertions, the District recommended that assessments be conducted before making an offer of placement. The district and parents agreed to have Denise Pollard . . . conduct an assessment to look at placement options. It was also agreed that the District would conduct speech and language and academic assessments to look at appropriate goals and objectives and DIS services. Unfortunately, school ended on June 8 and scheduling the assessments has been difficult.
(Exh. 1, p. 5A.)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District committed the serious procedural error alleged by the Student, and that this violation seriously infringed on the parents opportunity to participate in the IEP process. The law is clear and unequivocal: it provides that “IEP means a written statement for a child with a disability that is developed, reviewed, and revised in a meeting in accordance with Secs. 300.341-300.350.” (34 C.F.R. § 300.340(a).) Attorney Silverman’s “offer of placement” was not developed at an IEP team meeting. The May 28, 2003 IEP team discussed little more than three agreed-upon assessments, which had not been completed before the District’s attorney drafted the District’s offer of placement outside of the IEP process. (Footnote 24) Because parents are members of the IEP team, the PARENTS were deprived of the opportunity to participate in the development of their daughter’s IEP. (34 C.F.R. § 300.344(1).)
The September 18, 2003 IEP Team Meeting
The Student also contends generally that the District (1) failed to invite Denise Pollard or to discuss her assessment, and (2) failed to make a specific written offer of services pursuant to Union. Each will be discussed below.
Regarding the first contention, a district must invite to an IEP meeting an individual who conducted an assessment of the pupil or is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the pupil and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b).) Ms. Pollard, who conducted the subject assessment, was not invited to the September 18, 2003 IEP team meeting. At least two individuals who are experts in the area of autism (Diane Provo, Cathy Demmerle) and one who provides behavioral consultation services (Diane Provo) were present at the IEP meeting. As such, the District wasn’t required to invite Ms. Pollard. However, the IEP team was required to consider the results of Ms. Pollard’s assessment when it developed the IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(a)(2).) The IEP does not reflect that Ms. Pollard’s assessment was discussed or considered in developing the IEP. The “summary of assessments” page does not list Ms. Pollard’s assessment. (Exh. 10, p. 110.) Moreover, the non-specific offer of mainstreaming does not reflect that Ms. Pollard’s detailed recommendations regarding mainstreaming were considered. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to consider Ms. Pollard’s assessment at the September 18, 2003 IEP team meeting.
The second allegation is that the September 18, 2003 IEP lacks a specific written offer of placement and services pursuant to Union. Indeed, probably because Ms. Pollard was not invited to the IEP team meeting and her assessment was not considered, the IEP lacks any specifics regarding STUDENT’s participation in the general education environment with typically developing peers. The IEP indicates that STUDENT would be placed in the general education environment for between one and thirty-nine percent of each day. The only notations related to mainstreaming (other than the variable percentage discussed above) was that STUDENT will “attend special day class with reverse mainstreaming” and that she requires “additional support to maximize participation during mainstreaming.” (Exh. 10, p. 116).
For the identical reasons discussed previously in this decision, the District’s vague offer is inappropriate and clearly violates Union; the offer lacks any specificity regarding the duration and frequency, what type of support services (e.g., whether a paraprofessional will accompany STUDENT to the general education classroom) or, who will oversee and provide recommendations regarding STUDENT’s general education participation. Moreover, the lack of specificity has resulted in prejudice to STUDENT because STUDENT’s parents have (to date) rejected the IEP.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has denied STUDENT a FAPE during the current school year.
Substantive Violations
The next question is whether the District’s offer of placement and related services for the current school year is substantively appropriate. As discussed above, the District offered STUDENT placement in Cathy Demmerle’s special day class (with a student to adult ratio of two-to-one, not to exceed nine students) along with the related services of speech and language therapy, “pull-out/push in” three times a week for thirty minutes, along with an unspecified amount of mainstreaming with unspecified supports. The Hearing Officer must determine whether the above program is (1) designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit; (3) comports with her IEP; and (4) whether it is provided in the least restrictive environment. Each will be discussed below.
Was STUDENT’s program designed to meet her unique needs?
There was general agreement regarding STUDENT’s unique needs. The September 18, 2003 IEP contains goals and objectives which address her needs in the areas of communication, socialization/peer interaction, math and literacy/reading. The parties stipulated that the goals and objectives were appropriate.
However, noticeably absent from the September 2003 IEP is a behavior plan or goal and corresponding objectives related to STUDENT’s behavioral needs. There was ample evidence of STUDENT’s behavioral needs; Denise Pollard observed behavioral problems during her home visits and recommended that they be addressed. Cathy Demmerle has observed behavioral issues since STUDENT entered her classroom in September 2003.
Because the IEP fails to address STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs, it is not designed to meet her unique needs.
Was STUDENT’s program reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit? The next question is whether the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The parties did not dispute that STUDENT should be placed in Cathy Demmerle’s class and that she must receive speech and language services in order to benefit from her education. However, the Student contends that (1) STUDENT should only attend Cathy Demmerle’s class for half of each day and that she should be mainstreamed/included or she should receive one-on-one tutoring for the other half of each day; (2) STUDENT should be assigned a one-on-one aid or tutor, chosen by STUDENT’s parents, for a total of 50 hours each week; (3) STUDENT should receive five hours total of speech and language services each week, three provided by the school (pull-out) and two provided by STUDENT’s private provider, Maureen Mckeown, and both providers must use a program called “Links to Language;” (4) STUDENT should receive behavioral supervision services to be provided by Diane Provo or an appropriate NPA; (5) STUDENT must receive mainstreaming, accompanied by a one-on-one aid, for appropriate academic subjects. Each of the Student’s contentions will be discussed below.
(1) Should STUDENT be placed in Cathy Demmerle’s SDC for one half day only?
Student’s first contention is that STUDENT should attend Ms. Demmerle’s class for only one half day, and for the remainder of each day, she should be either mainstreamed or she should receive one-on-one tutoring. The District contends that STUDENT cannot receive benefit if she is removed from Ms. Demmerle’s class during the afternoon.
The District provided persuasive evidence that STUDENT would not receive some educational benefit if she were to be removed from Cathy Demmerle’s classroom for the afternoon. Cathy Demmerle testified persuasively that she cannot adequately address all of STUDENT’s agreed-upon goals and objectives in only one half of a school day. The Student’s expert, Diane Provo, did not testify that it would be appropriate to remove STUDENT for one half of each school day from Ms. Demmerle’s SDC. In fact, she described Ms. Demmerle’s class as “great” and that Ms. Demmerle was an expert in the area of autism, although she was concerned that Ms. Demmerle would not have enough time, even with the small number of students in STUDENT’s classroom, to provide STUDENT with sufficient one-on-one attention.
Based on the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT must attend Cathy Demmerle’s SDC for the entire school day in order to benefit. There was simply no persuasive evidence that STUDENT could benefit if she were removed for half of the school day.
(2) Does STUDENT require a one-on-one aid or tutor, chosen by STUDENT’s parents, who will work with her 50 hours each week?
The Student alleged at the beginning of the hearing that STUDENT requires a one-on-one tutor who will work with her throughout the day, for a total of 50 hours each week. The District contends that Cathy Demmerle’s SDC, with the small student to adult ratio, is adequate.
Diane Provo testified on behalf of the student regarding the need for a one-on-one aid. She testified generally that STUDENT needs to be constantly aroused and redirected in order to learn, and that she therefore must have a one-on-one aid. She did not testify, however, that STUDENT requires 50 hours of tutoring/aid services each week in order to benefit from her education. The parents testified that they have observed STUDENT not engaged in Ms. Demmerle’s classroom. One of STUDENT’s private tutors, Dave Macarchick, worked with another student in Ms. Demmerle’s classroom as a tutor during the fall before he was asked not to come back. He testified that STUDENT requires the services of a one-on-one aide in order to benefit from her education. Mr. Macarchick, who has a bachelors degree in journalism, has no formal training in the area of Autism or education, holds no relevant degrees or certificates, and has had no formal training in the area of education. He testified that, despite his lack of training, education or certification, he is developing his “own program” for children with autism.
Cathy Demmerle testified that STUDENT does not require the services of a one-on-one aid, who is assigned only to STUDENT, in order to benefit from her education. She testified that STUDENT is not currently assigned the same paraprofessional, and yet, she is progressing on her goals and objectives with the small student-to-teacher ratio as well as her direct instruction and the paraprofessional services. She also documented STUDENT’s progress during the current school year in progress reports during the entire school. (Exh. 6.)
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Cathy Demmerle. STUDENT does not require the services of a one-on-one aid, 50 hours each week, in order to benefit from her education. Diane Provo’s testimony that STUDENT must be constantly aroused was not persuasive because there is no reason why the paraprofessionals in STUDENT’s current SDC, properly supervised by Cathy Demmerle, cannot maintain STUDENT’s interest and facilitate her learning. Ms. Demmerle’s testimony that STUDENT is currently benefitting from the low student to teacher ratio was persuasive.
(3) Must STUDENT receive five hours of speech and language services each week, three provided by the school (pull-out) and two provided by STUDENT’s private provider, Maureen Mckeown, and must both providers use “Links to Language”?
The District offered three thirty-minute sessions, of push in/pull out speech and language services each week, to be provided by speech and language pathologist Cara Price.
The Student called Maureen Mckeown to testify regarding STUDENT’s speech and language needs. As described above, Ms. Mckeown had worked with STUDENT for all but a four month period since February 2001, two times each week. She described at length STUDENT’s slow but steady progress in the Links to Language program. Ms. Mckeown did not testify that STUDENT required five hours per week of speech and language services. Similarly, she did not testify that only Links to Language will benefit STUDENT.
STUDENT’s current speech and language provider, Cara Price testified that she has worked with STUDENT five times per week during the current school year because that is what the last agreed upon and implemented IEP requires. She explained that STUDENT was making progress on all of her speech and language goals. Ms. Price does not utilize Links to Language; she uses a variety of strategies and methodologies, including social stories, visual schedules, and floor time/play time. Ms. Price keeps daily progress notes in which she tracks STUDENT’s progress on her goals and objectives. She opined that STUDENT does not require her current level of services (five sessions each week) because Cathy Demmerle’s class is “rich” in language.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of speech and language services, three thirty minutes sessions of push in and pull out services, is adequate to confer educational benefit. STUDENT does not require the use of Links to Language; there was no persuasive testimony that Ms. Price’s approach is inappropriate. Additionally, there is no legal requirement that the District conform its methodologies to those privately provided by the parents outside of the IEP process. Indeed, the courts have consistently ruled that as long as a disabled student is benefitting from his education, educational methodologies are left up to school authorities. Rowley at 208; see also Renner v. Bd. Of Educ. Of Ann Arbor, 185 F. 3d 635 (6th Cir. 1999); Tucker v. Calloway Co. Bd. Of Educ., 136 F. 3d 495(6th Cir. 1998); Ft. Zumwalt Sch. Dist. v. Clynes, 119 F. 3d 607 (8th Cir. 1997).
(4) Must STUDENT receive behavioral supervision services, provided by Diane Provo or an appropriate NPA, in order to benefit from her education?
No behavioral supervision services have been offered by the District. STUDENT has behavior needs; as discussed above under Issues 1 and 2, STUDENT has exhibited behavior problems during all three school years currently at issue. Denise Pollard witnessed significant tantrums and difficulty with transitions during her home observations. Cathy Demmerle testified that STUDENT has recently exhibited escalating behaviors, including vomiting and playing with the vomit.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does require the services of a behavior consultant, such as Diane Provo. (Footnote 25) There was no persuasive testimony regarding the required amount of such services; accordingly, the District shall provide the same amount it provided when it first began providing behavior consultation services February 2001, twelve hours per month.
(5) Must STUDENT receive mainstreaming, accompanied by a one-on-one aid, for appropriate academic subjects?
As discussed above in the procedural section of this issue, the District has completely failed to make a specific offer of placement of mainstreaming. The District also failed to invite Denise Pollard to the September 2003 IEP team meeting and failed to consider her assessment, and failed to call Ms. Pollard as a witness at the hearing so that she could describe an appropriate mainstreaming program for STUDENT. The Student similarly, provided no persuasive, relevant testimony supporting her request.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer orders the District to conduct an IEP meeting. In addition to conforming STUDENT’s IEP to this Decision, the District shall invite Denise Pollard who shall discuss her assessment and recommendations. The IEP shall develop an appropriate mainstreaming/inclusion program for STUDENT based on the input of the entire IEP team.
Will STUDENT’s program comport with her IEP?
There was no testimony or other evidence that the District cannot provide a program that will comport with the above-required services.
Will STUDENT’s program be provided in the least restrictive environment?
There is not enough information regarding the amount and type of mainstreaming or inclusion services that STUDENT should be provided. The IEP does not include a clear, specific offer of mainstreaming. However, it was not disputed that STUDENT should be placed primarily in a special day class. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a program in the least restrictive environment because it failed to make a specific offer of mainstreaming/inclusion services.
In summary, it has been found above that the District’s “offer of placement” letter was procedurally inappropriate, and denied STUDENT a FAPE. Moreover, the lack of specificity in the September 2003 IEP regarding mainstreaming failed to comply with Union and denied STUDENT a FAPE, as did the District’s failure to discuss and consider Denise Pollard’s assessment at the same IEP team meeting. Finally, while the bulk of the District’s offer in the September 2003 IEP was substantively appropriate, the District failed to offer STUDENT necessary behavioral specialist services, and failed to offer appropriate mainstreaming.
ISSUE NO. 4: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private educational services that they provided for STUDENT from November 2002 through the date of this Decision?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir.1994). However, parents are not required to have procured an exact proper placement under the IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 79 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir.1986). The parents may receive reimbursement so long as their placement met the student’s unique needs and provided the student with educational benefit. Id.
The parents seek reimbursement for educational services, including private tutoring and consultation services, that they procured for STUDENT from November 2002 through the present.
Regarding the services provided from November 2002 through September 18, 2003, it has been found above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during that entire period. Thus, STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement as long as the services they provided are appropriate, i.e., they meet her needs and provide her with some educational benefit.
The District argued in closing that the Son Rise program, upon which the parents’ home-program was based was not “educational” and therefore reimbursement should be denied. Sasha Mandapat, one of STUDENT’s tutors, testified that the program initially lacked an academic component, but that her and FATHER modified the program and introduced an academic component. The Student also provided persuasive testimony from STUDENT’s parents, Sasha Mandapat, David Macarchick and Diane Provo that STUDENT actually benefitted from the educational tutoring and consultation services that the PARENTS procured during this period. The District provided no persuasive testimony that STUDENT did not benefit from these services. Accordingly, the Student is entitled to reimbursement for all educational services provided from November 2002 through September 18, 2003. This includes all tutoring services and Diane Provo’s consultation services.
Regarding the period after the September 18, 2003 IEP team meeting, the Student failed to provide persuasive evidence of any nexus between the tutoring services provided by David Macarchick, Suzanne Forrester or Sasha Mandapat and a denial of FAPE. It has been found above that, during this period, STUDENT did not require one-on-one tutoring in order to receive a FAPE. As such, the tutoring services provided after September 18, 2003 were not necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and are not reimbursable.
ISSUE NO. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when a school district has failed to provide a student with appropriate special education services. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir.1994). The Ninth Circuit has held that compensatory education does not involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. The purpose of compensatory education is “to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. In crafting appropriate relief, a hearing officer has broad latitude. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359 (1985).
Student contended at the Hearing that, if the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT’s current program does not require the services discussed above under Issue 3 in order for STUDENT to receive a FAPE, that these services should be provided as compensatory education. The Student provided no testimony or other evidence regarding STUDENT’s compensatory education needs, including why it is that services not necessary to confer a FAPE would be appropriate compensatory education services. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education services.
ORDER
1. Within 30 days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting. The District shall invite, at a minimum, Diane Provo, Denise Pollard and Maureen Mckeown, in addition to all required IEP team members. The IEP shall conform STUDENT’s IEP to this Decision. Specifically, the IEP team shall add the behavioral specialist services described in Issue No. 3, and shall develop an appropriate mainstreaming program based on the input of all IEP team members and Denise Pollard’s assessment report.
2. Within 30 days of receipt of appropriate proof, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for all tutoring and consultation services they provided from November 2002 through September 18, 2003.
3. All other request for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 school year, after the January 10, 2002 mediation agreement? -The District substantially prevailed for the period from January 10, 2002 through April 24, 2002. The Student prevailed for the rest of the period at issue.
2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year? -The Student prevailed.
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year? -The Student substantially prevailed.
4. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private educational services that they provided for STUDENT from November 2002 through November 2003? -The Student substantially prevailed.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
-The District prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: March 25, 200 Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues were clarified at length at the beginning of the hearing. The above-listed issues, which have been reorganized for purposes of analysis, are the Student’s issues. The District’s issues were the same as the Student’s first three issues (whether the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during those three periods.) 2. This quantity and frequency of speech and language services represents the last agreed upon and implemented (“stay put”) service for STUDENT.
3. She provided these services to STUDENT from February to April 2001, and from September 2001 to the present.
4. The exact nature of the dispute was never explained.
5. The same addendum IEP provides for an ESY (extended school year) program identified in the February 14, 2002 IEP as a “behavior program . . . with Provo and Associates for 10 weeks of 20 hours per week.”
6. The IEP notes indicate that “STUDENT needs to improve her ability to comply and to state when she is angry appropriately and not scream or tantrum. This behavior must be brought under STUDENT’s control if she is going to increase her mainstreaming time.”
7. STUDENT’s parents are seeking reimbursement for the money they spend on tutors and Diane Provo’s consultation during the period from November 2002 through September 2003, in the amount of $14,400.31. They are also seeking reimbursement of expenses incurred to date during the current school year (2003-2004).
8. Ms. Pollard was not called as a witness at the hearing. She did not attend the subsequent IEP team meeting in September 18, 2003, nor was she invited. (Exh. 10, p. 123-124.)
9. Ms. Cook was not called as a witness at the hearing.
10. Ms. Everett was not called as a witness at the hearing.
11. As discussed above, the District cross-filed, and the two matters were consolidated. At the beginning of the hearing, the District explained that its issues were whether it provided a FAPE for STUDENT during the latter part of the 2001-2002 school year, the entire 2002-2003 school year, and the current school year (the same periods covered by the Student’s first three issues).
12. The Hearing Officer notes that it was not alleged that the January 2002 mediation agreement settled all procedural or substantive defects of the April 2001 IEP.
13. The February 2002 IEP described STUDENT’s ESY services for the summer of 2002; the appropriateness of these services were not in dispute at the hearing.
14. The Student alleges (for the first time) in her closing brief that Kimberly Russell lacks the required teaching credential. Ms. Russell testified that she has an appropriate credential and no evidence was presented at the hearing supporting Student’s assertion that she does not. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that she has the appropriate teaching credential.
15. Ms. Demmerle returned to the classroom the following school year (2002-2003 school year). She is currently STUDENT’s SDC teacher at a different school in the same district.
16. While the District did not dispute that Ms. Provo is an expert in the area of Autism, it is similarly not disputed that Ms. Provo’s business is not a state-certified non public agency.
17. As discussed below, the parents seek reimbursement for Ms. Provo’s services.
18. Ms. Provo did not testify that Ms. Russell was not appropriately qualified.
19. Although unclear, it may be that this one hour of behavioral services was provided at the PARENT’S’s home, overseen by Diane Provo. However, the February 2002 IEP requires this service to be provided in school, not at home.
20. However, the April 24, 2002 IEP eliminated the autism resource teacher services previously provided under the April 30, 2001 IEP, although the services continued to be provided by Cathy Demmerle through the end of the school year. The behavior services added by the February 2002 IEP were also eliminated, although, again, the services were actually provided through the end of the 2001-2002 school year as well the summer of 2002 (but not the one-on-one in-class behavioral services). There was no testimony or other evidence regarding why these services were eliminated from the IEP, but continued to be provided through the end of the school year.
21. However, as will be discussed below, STUDENT’s parents removed her from school in the fall of 2002. At this point, STUDENT did begin to lose educational opportunity and therefore, she was denied a FAPE.
22. The Student’s attorney stipulated at the outset of the hearing that the goals and objectives were appropriate. However, in her closing brief, she argues that they were not appropriate. Given the stipulation of the Student’s attorney at the beginning of the hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were appropriate.
23. Because it has been found that STUDENT’s April 24, 2002 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, it is not necessary to discuss the other substantive FAPE factors.
24. There are circumstances where a local educational agency may appropriately finish, finalize or clarify an offer of placement that was developed during the IEP process, e.g., the IEP team discusses placement at a properly convened IEP team meeting with all appropriate personnel, goals and objectives are developed, recent assessments are discussed, parent concerns and suggestions are considered, and the team attempts to develop an appropriate program and related services. Thereafter, a District might appropriately provide further specificity in a subsequent letter in order to fully inform the parents of the specific offer of placement and services. In the present matter, the District chose to bypass the IEP process completely, and as a result, it completely deprived the parents of meaningful participation in the IEP process.
25. The Hearing Officer lacks the authority to require the District to procure Ms. Provo’s services because she is not a certified NPA. The Hearing Officer urges the District to use Ms. Provo because of her familiarity with STUDENT.
