California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 15, 2003

Student v. Richmond Elementary School District et al. (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1129-03, SN03-01129, SN03-01332 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Richmond Elementary must fund Tustin Center placement and a parent's living expenses after its vague offer denied FAPE.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated in the decision.

Summary

Richmond Elementary School District filed for hearing to show that its May 29, 2003 offer gave a 12-year-old seventh grader with a traumatic brain injury (TBI) a FAPE for 2003-2004. The student cross-filed against the District and the Lassen County Office of Education. He sought placement at a nonpublic school that specializes in brain injury. The District offered a self-contained classroom at Richmond Elementary, where he would be the first student. He would have a special education teacher, an aide as needed, and the same related services he received at the Alex Center. The District said it would add details, including a transition plan, at a later IEP meeting if it won.

Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard found that the offer was not the single clear written offer that Union School District v. Smith requires. It did not cover staff training and consultation on brain injury, a transition plan, how often and how long behavior services would be given, or who would be in his small groups. This seriously limited the parents' ability to take part. The offer also failed on substance. It did not meet his need for an intensive brain-injury program or his social-emotional needs. The District was ordered to fund the conditionally certified Tustin Center for 2003-2004. It must also repay up to $4,300 in living expenses, plus mileage and hotel costs for trips home. Placement for the 2004 extended school year was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO enforced Union v. Smith. A district could not make a sketchy offer and promise to fill in the details after the hearing. It also shows that a conditionally certified nonpublic school counted as certified under Education Code section 56505.2(a). Living and travel costs could also be ordered as related services.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Has the District offered Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 extended school year?

    The May 29, 2003 offer of a self-contained Richmond classroom was not a single coherent written offer. It omitted staff training and consultation, a transition plan, behavior service frequency and duration, and small-group details, which seriously infringed on parent participation. It also failed on substance to meet the student's need for an intensive TBI program and his social-emotional needs, so the District denied FAPE for 2003-2004.

  2. Issue 2. Is Student entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 extended school year, and, if so, is the District required to pay for reasonable living expenses for himself and one parent and for visits with his family?

    The conditionally certified Tustin Center was appropriate and met Education Code section 56505.2(a), so the District must fund it for 2003-2004 with reasonable living, mileage, and travel-hotel expenses. The Hearing Officer declined to order placement for the 2004 extended school year.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Prospective funding of private placement. For the 2003-2004 school year, the District shall fund the student's placement at The Tustin Center as long as it remains a certified or conditionally certified nonpublic school.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. If The Tustin Center loses its certification or has it suspended during 2003-2004, the IEP team shall meet and identify a comparable certified nonpublic school for students with traumatic brain injury, and the District shall fund that placement for 2003-2004.
  • Reimbursement. Reasonable living expenses for one parent to live in the Tustin area, including housing and meals, subject to proof, not to exceed $4,300.00. Meals are reimbursed only if the housing lacks kitchen facilities.
  • Reimbursement. Mileage at the District employee rate for two round trips a day between the temporary Tustin-area home and the Tustin Center, plus travel between Susanville and Tustin before and after the 2003-2004 school year and for official school closures (winter and spring breaks).
  • Reimbursement. One night's hotel for each trip between the Tustin Center and Susanville, in either direction.

Total: $4,300 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Glendale Unified School Dist. v. Almasi; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Ojai Unified School Dist. v. Jackson; People v. Moore

People named in the decision

  • Cynthia Nellums, superintendent and principal, Richmond Elementary School District
  • Michael Justice, associate superintendent and SELPA director; LCOE representative at hearing, Lassen County Office of Education
  • Erich Johnson, behavior specialist, Lassen County Office of Education
  • Gene Russell Tackett, speech and language specialist/speech pathologist, Lassen County Office of Education
  • Linda Adams, retired special education teacher, Lassen County Office of Education
  • Jessica Ocoboc, school psychologist, Lassen County Office of Education
  • Elizabeth Lynne Sella, resource specialist teacher, Lassen County Office of Education
  • Janice McLeod Springer, occupational therapist, Lassen County Office of Education
  • Anita Osborn, school psychologist (functional analysis assessment), Lassen County Office of Education
  • Bethany Mealey, classroom teacher, Alex Center (nonpublic school)
  • Katy Peck, speech therapist, Alex Center; The Tustin Center
  • Sharon Grandinetti, director; expert on brain injury; later District training consultant, Alex Center (nonpublic school)
  • Charles Hwang, adapted physical education teacher, Alex Center; The Tustin Center
  • Mark Eric Hauber, director of marketing and admissions, Alex Center; The Tustin Center
  • Juda Carter, director, The Tustin Center (nonpublic school)
  • Mr. Hardy, classroom teacher, The Tustin Center
  • Scott Temple, executive director, The Tustin Center
  • Dr. Diane Sommers, psychologist (neuropsychological evaluation), UC Davis Medical Center
  • Robin Timms, psychology intern (neuropsychological evaluation), UC Davis Medical Center
  • Dr. McGee-Williams, clinical neuropsychologist (independent neurocognitive assessment)
  • Dr. Lynn Thull, psychologist (mental health eligibility assessment), Lassen County Mental Health
  • Michael LeMay, independent audiologist
  • Richard Tompkins, director of education, Texas NeuroRehab Center
  • Alex Center, certified nonpublic residential school for students with TBI (closed August 2003), Bancroft NeuroHealth
  • The Tustin Center, nonpublic school (conditionally certified)
  • Texas NeuroRehab Center, private neurorehabilitation program (unilateral placement fall 2002)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Susanville, California, on October 16, 17, 22, and 23, 2003.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Richmond Elementary School District (hereafter District) was represented by attorney Kirin K. Sandhu of the Law Firm of Pinnell & Kingsley, LLP. Also present on the District’s behalf was its superintendent and principal, Cynthia Nellums. Cross-Respondent Lassen County Office of Education (hereafter LCOE) was represented at the hearing by its associate superintendent and Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA) director, Michael Justice. The District and LCOE will be referred to in this Decision as Petitioners. (Footnote 1) Respondent/Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Student) was represented throughout the hearing by attorney Roberta Savage of the Law Firm of Varma and Clancy. Also present on Student’s behalf throughout the hearing was his mother, STUDENT’S MOTHER. On October 22 and 23, 2003, Student’s stepfather, STEPFATHER, was also present on his behalf.

The District called the following LCOE employees or former employees as witnesses: LCOE superintendent and SELPA director Michael Justice, behavior specialist Erich Johnson, speech and language specialist Gene Russell Tackett, retired special education teacher Linda Adams, school psychologist Jessica Ocoboc, resource specialist teacher Elizabeth Lynne Sella, and occupational therapist Janice McLeod Springer. The District also called its principal and superintendent, Cynthia Nellums, as a witness. LCOE joined in the argument, evidence, and witnesses presented by the District. Student called the following witnesses from the former Alex Center, the certified nonpublic residential school he attended from February 2003 through its closure in August 2003: teacher Bethany Mealey, speech therapist Katy Peck, director Sharon Grandinette, adapted physical education teacher Student Hwang, and director of marketing and admissions Mark Eric Hauber. Both Ms. Peck and Mr. Hauber are currently employed by The Tustin Center, the nonpublic school Student currently attends. Student also called Tustin Center director, Juda Carter, and his parents, MOTHER and STEPFATHER, as witnesses. All witnesses from the Alex and Tustin Centers testified by telephone.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. By November 12, 2003, the Hearing Officer had received all parties’ closing briefs. In his closing brief, Student requested that the Hearing Officer take judicial notice of the asserted full certification of the Tustin Center by the California Department of Education. Petitioners were provided an opportunity to respond to this request by November 17, 2003; however, no response was received. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision (see: November 13, 2003 Memorandum of Minute Order).

ISSUES (Footnote 2)

1. Has the District offered Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 extended school year?

2. Is Student entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year and 2004 extended school year, and, if so, is the District required to pay for reasonable living expenses for himself and one parent and for visits with his family?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioners contend that the District offered Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year at the May 29, 2003 and August 12, 2003 IEP team meetings and that he does not require placement in a remote nonpublic school (NPS) specializing in serving students with traumatic brain injury in order to receive a FAPE. The District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year was to place Student at his home school, Richmond Elementary, in a self-contained classroom where he would receive intensive one-to-one instruction from an experienced special education teacher, services of a one-to-one aide as needed, some small group instruction with two to six other students, mainstreaming opportunities with regular education students as appropriate, the same amount of designated instruction and services (DIS) at Richmond that he has received at the Alex Center NPS, and continued implementation of both his behavior intervention plan (BIP) and his goals and objectives. Petitioners assert that this offer constitutes an appropriate offer of FAPE and that Student has failed to produce sufficient evidence that he was not offered a FAPE. Petitioners further contend that their staff is currently qualified to work with Student, but that they will receive training and consultation services from former Alex Center director, Ms. Grandinetti, to better assist them in their work with students like Student with a traumatic brain injury and stroke. Petitioners contend that, if the Hearing Officer decides that the offered placement at Richmond is a FAPE, an individualized education program (IEP) team meeting will then be convened to develop details relating to Student’s transition to and placement at Richmond.

Student contends that the District’s placement offer for the 2003-2004 school year was both procedurally and substantively deficient. Procedurally, Student asserts that the offer is unclear and lacks specificity about how it can meet his extremely complex unique needs. Specifically, Student asserts that the offer lacks detail regarding his actual program, including the initial and ongoing training of District/LCOE staff who will work with him, the manner in which service providers will collaborate regarding his program, the number of small group instructional opportunities he will have, whether the students in those groups will be typically developing or special education peers, the exact nature of his behavior services and the data collection methods to be used, and the transition plan to ensure consistency from his current nonpublic school to a public school setting. In Student’s view, Petitioners’ plan to convene an IEP team meeting to provide the details of the offered program after a ruling by the Hearing Officer violates Union v. Smith and gave his parents insufficient information to seriously consider the offer. Substantively, Student asserts that the District’s offer was not designed to meet his unique need for an intensive program designed for brain injured students as recommended by Alex Center staff, who advised Petitioners he was not ready to transition to a less restrictive environment. The Student further asserts that any program created by Petitioners for him would require an initial intensive staff training and ongoing consultation. Student contends that, while the District entered into a contract for consultation services with Ms. Grandinetti, these services were not contained in the offer to the parents. Student further contends that he requires ongoing placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year and he requests reimbursement for reasonable living expenses of one of his parents to live with him in the Tustin, California area.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Student is a twelve-year-old, seventh-grade student who is currently attending the Tustin Center, a nonpublic school in Tustin, California. In March 2001 following an automobile accident, Student became eligible for special education as an individual with a traumatic brain injury (TBI). From February through August 2003, Student was placed at the Alex Center, a certified nonpublic school with a residential facility in Tustin, that specialized in providing special educational services to students with TBI. This placement was the result of a mediated settlement agreement. In late May 2003, the parents rejected the District’s offer of placement at Richmond Elementary School (Richmond) in Lassen County and requested stay put at the Alex Center. In October 2003, several months after the closure of the Alex Center, the District agreed that the Tustin Center was Student‘s appropriate stay put placement and to pay reasonable living expenses for one of Student’s parents to live with him in the Tustin area pending resolution of this dispute. On October 9, 2003, Student’s mother accompanied him to southern California to attend school at the Tustin Center.

On December 28, 2000, when he was nine years old, Student was involved in an automobile accident that killed his biological father and slightly injured his sister. At the time of the accident, Student was a regular education student in the fourth grade in the District. Student sustained a traumatic brain injury in the accident and, the following day, suffered a right parietal cerebral vascular accident (stroke) that resulted in left hemiparesis. Student was in a coma for two weeks and remained hospitalized at UC Davis Medical Center for two months. From these injuries, Student suffered significant motor and cognitive impairments. Student was initially easily fatigued, with stamina slowly increasing over time. Student wears a brace on his left leg, uses a quad cane to walk, and occasionally uses a wheelchair for longer distances. His left arm, severely impaired by the stroke, has been in a splint for significant periods of time. In addition, beginning shortly after the accident, Student began to demonstrate behaviors that were at times aggressive, disruptive, and difficult to control. (Footnote 3) Student’s behavioral difficulties have continued.

On March 28, 2001, following Student’s return home, the District convened an initial individualized educational plan (IEP) team meeting and determined him eligible for special education and related services as an individual with a traumatic brain injury. Student received home/hospital teaching services once a week and speech and language therapy beginning in July 2001. Student’s parents privately provided him with occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), and additional speech and language therapy in Reno, Nevada. Student continued to be evaluated by his medical team at UC Davis. In their August 2001 neuropsychological evaluation, UC Davis psychologist Dr. Diane Sommers and psychology intern Robin Timms determined that Student had both a cognitive disorder and a learning disorder and that he experienced difficulty with both short-term memory and long-term encoding. As a consequence, Student had retrieval problems even with cues. They also noted that Student exhibited impairment in the areas of attention, memory, visual-spatial ability, mental flexibility, and processing speed, as well as weaknesses in tasks of dexterity or motor speed. Challenging academic areas were basic reading, math reasoning, spelling, and numerical operations.

In the fall of 2001, Student returned to school on a part-time basis. At the November 2, 2001 special IEP team review, Student was offered additional DIS services of OT and PT; however, the IEP team did not offer him any behavioral services and determined that academic goals would be developed at a later date. The relationship between the parties became strained. From the parents’ perspective, Petitioners ignored Student’s academic needs and failed to establish a consistent behavior plan that would enable him to access his education. For example, Student’s mother testified that she was frequently called to pick Student up from school due to the school’s inability to manage his aggressive and assaultive behaviors which LCOE behavior specialist Mr. Johnson characterized as “suspendable offenses.” From Petitioners’ perspective, the parents’ previous gratitude for the school’s positive response to Student’s injury drastically changed. Mr. Justice testified that the parents began to express their belief that none of Petitioners’ personnel was sufficiently qualified to work with Student.

By January 2002, Student’s family began to express their desire to place him at the Alex Center. The parents invited Alex Center’s director, Sharon Grandinetti, to participate in the April 12 and 18, 2002 IEP team meetings, at which the team discussed the need to document Student’s behavior and to develop a behavior plan. From these IEP meetings, the team determined that a functional analysis assessment (FAA) would be conducted to determine whether or not a positive behavior intervention plan was needed. Student’s parents subsequently requested that Student be placed at the Alex Center.

On May 9, 2002, Student returned to school full time and continued at Richmond through the 2002 extended school year. During the late spring and summer of 2002, Student was assessed in multiple areas: clinical neuropyschologist Dr. McGee-Williams conducted an independent neurocognitive assessment; Lassen County Mental Health psychologist Dr. Lynn Thull conducted an assessment to determine his eligibility for mental health services; LCOE school psychologist Anita Osborn and behavior specialist Erich Johnson conducted a functional analysis assessment (FAA); independent audiologist Michael LeMay assessed Student’s auditory processing; and LCOE speech pathologist Gene R. Tackett conducted a speech and language assessment.

Significant findings from these assessments included Dr. McGee-Williams’ conclusion that Student suffered a substantial brain injury, not just from his traumatic brain injury, but from his stroke. Specifically, Dr. Williams explained that “substantial personality changes occur not only with TBI but in patients who have suffered a right hemisphere stroke. These personality characteristics are often pervasive, enduring, and very disruptive to the person’s life and the lives of those around them. Such [well-documented] active personality characteristics...include irritability, agitation, belligerence, anger, episodic violent behavior, impulsiveness, restlessness, socially inappropriate behavior, emotional lability, sensivity to noise, suspiciousness, and paranoia. The more passive personality traits documented include lack of spontaneity, loss of interest in the environment, loss of drive or initiative, and easy fatigability.” From his evaluation, Dr. McGee-Williams recommended that Student participate in a vigorous, “around-the-clock” behavioral program with “an academic program that focuses on remediation and improvement of deficit areas using brain rehabilitation methods… to put it in a simplistic way, ...Student needs a behavioral program with school, as opposed to school with a behavioral program.”

LCMH’s Dr.Thull diagnosed Student with depressive disorder NOS (not otherwise specified), rule out post-traumatic stress disorder, and a learning disorder NOS. In addition, Dr. Thull determined that Student was eligible for Chapter 26.5 services of individual outpatient mental health therapy by a professional experienced in working with TBI individuals. (Footnote 4)

From their functional analysis assessment (FAA), Ms. Osborn and Mr. Johnson concluded that Student’s behavior “most likely meets the definition to be considered a ‘serious behavior problem’ in areas of assaultive and other pervasive maladapted behaviors based on frequency, intensity and duration of data collected.” Student’s behaviors interfered with his learning to a moderate-to-severe degree and appeared to occur in multiple environments. The FAA recommended that the IEP team consider and, “if deemed appropriate, ”choose between a positive behavior intervention plan (BIP) or a more general behavior support plan (BSP).

Student was also determined to have a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD) by audiologist Michael LeMay. This conclusion was supported by LCOE speech pathologist Gene R. Tackett, in his July 16, 2002 speech and language assessment. From his standardized testing, Mr. Tackett determined that, at age 11.3, Student achieved an age-equivalent (AE) score of 8.0 years on the Comprehensive Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF), showing moderately delayed receptive and expressive language abilities. Student’s receptive language was 1.5 to 2 standard deviations below the mean. Similarly, on the one-word picture vocabulary tests, Student scored at the 11.11 year AE on the expressive test (EOWPVT) but at the 9.10 AE on the receptive test (ROWPVT). Mr. Tackett also observed that Student’s inappropriate behaviors were triggered in areas of testing that were difficult for him (i.e., tasks involving short term and working memory). For example, during these tests, Student hit and kicked Mr. Tackett three times, swore at and threatened him, physically withdrew from the testing environment, and began sexual self-stimulation.

On July 24, and August 5, 2002, the IEP team convened to review these new assessments. The IEP team determined that a behavior plan was required and would be developed once placement was determined. At these IEP meetings, the parents again requested placement at Alex Center. In response, the District made a formal written offer to place Student in a quiet structured class in Richmond with no more than six students. In addition to his existing related services, Student was offered two hours a week of behavior therapy by the behavior specialist, one hour a week of mental health therapy and forty-eight hours of cognitive re-training therapy by Dr. McGee Williams. The parents did not accept this offer.

In the fall of 2002, Student did not return to school at Richmond. Instead, his parents kept him at home while seeking an appropriate program. (Footnote 5) On October 14, 2002, Student was unilaterally placed at the Texas NeuroRehab Center (TNRC) in Austin, Texas, where he remained until December 13, 2002. The goal noted in Student’s master plan review was for him to return either to home or to the Alex Center. On discharge, Student’s treating physician indicated that his behavioral problems at TNRC included impulsivity, oppositional defiance, aggression, attention, concentration, and sporadic bouts with refusal of tasks in school. Student’s diagnoses on discharge were personality change due to TBI, chronic post-traumatic stress disorder, learning disorder NOS, and depressive disorder, NOS. Student’s general academic content was felt to be at the 3rd grade level. In Student’s educational discharge summary, TNRC’s director of education Richard Tompkins recommended that Student “begin a school program in a self-contained environment for all content areas” with mainstreaming tried later in select environments and school contents such as lunch, music and art. (Footnote 6)

Placement at the Alex Center

On February 12, 2003, Student was placed at the Alex Center pursuant to a mediated settlement agreement that also provided for a thirty-day IEP team meeting to review his goals and objectives. On placement, the Alex Center implemented a draft FAA and Behavior Intervention Plan, modeled on that completed by LCOE. On admission, Student’s behaviors targeted for reduction included task refusal, negative verbalizations, cussing, name calling, flipping off, biting, hitting, kicking, spitting at, throwing/pushing objects and elopement. By the time of the thirty-day review, the Alex Center noted that Student averaged five outbursts a week with average duration of sixty-four minutes, with frequency increasing from admission to report date. Following his admission, new targeted behaviors, including inappropriate touching, exposing, attempts to stab, and threats to urinate, were added. A thirty-day review by the physical therapist indicated that Student’s hypertonicity in his splinted left arm affected his gait and that he was at risk for falls because he did not always respond to verbal cues to slow down for safety reasons.

March 28, 2003 Annual IEP

On March 28, 2003, the IEP team met for Student’s annual review. At that time, Student was 11.11 years old and in the sixth grade. Both the parent and the Alex Center staff participated in the IEP team meeting by telephone from Tustin.

The IEP team affirmed Student’s TBI eligibility, as well as his placement at the Alex Center, with one hundred percent of his time outside of general education. Student’s program was as follows: full time SDC class at Alex Center, one hundred twenty (120) minutes a week of speech and language therapy, ninety (90) minutes a week each of OT and PT, sixty (60) minutes a week APE, and extended school year ESY. In addition, Student was provided with a one-to-one aide seven hours a day at the school, and a maximum of three hours per day of one-to-one aide support for outside of the school day. It was also agreed that Student would receive up to 60 minutes a week of counseling with personnel and goals to be established later. The March 28, 2003 IEP included a draft Behavior Intervention Plan (BIP) for Student that targeted the initial behaviors outlined above and provided for specific proactive and reactive strategies. While the IEP was written for a year, through March 28, 2004, pursuant to the mediated agreement, Student’s ongoing placement was subject to review at the May 29, 2003 IEP meeting.

The May 29, 2003 IEP and District Offer

On May 29, 2003, the IEP team again met and prepared an addendum to the March 28, 2003 IEP. As requested by the parent, the IEP team added and amended some of Student’s goals and objectives that were then agreed upon. Alex Center staff reported on their assessments and Student’s progress. The addendum provided that the time and frequency of Student’s services would remain the same as on March 28, 2003 IEP. At this IEP team meeting, the District made an offer to place Student at Richmond Elementary in a self-contained classroom with a special education teacher and one-to-one aide as needed for the 2003 extended school year (ESY) and for the 2003-2004 school year. The parents rejected the offer and requested stay put at the Alex Center.

On June 2, 2003, the District filed its request for due process hearing to determine whether it had offered Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year at the May 29, 2003 IEP meeting.

On June 19, 2003, Student filed his request for a due process hearing and named LCOE as an additional party. Student asserted he required ongoing residential placement at the Alex Center for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year in order to receive a FAPE.

August 12, 2003 IEP Meeting, Alex Center’s Closure, and Stay Put at The Tustin Center

On August 12, 2003, a week before the Alex Center was scheduled to cease operation, the IEP team met at the parents’ request. The IEP team reviewed reports from Alex Center staff, as well as the newly completed assistive technology assessment that recommended Student and his staff be trained to use “cowriter” software. The team discussed what placement would be appropriate for Student in light of the Alex Center’s pending closure. While the parties were aware of the potential opening of the Tustin Center, its actual availability was unknown. The IEP notes indicated that “the Alex Center staff expressed concerns with Student going through a transition period at this time. It was reported that currently he has difficulty with daily transitions or any changes to the usual daily schedule.” In discussing whether Student required a residential placement, his residential manager at Alex Center’s Laburnum House advised the IEP team that Student’s after school time must be “highly structured” for him to be successful. Student’s mother told the team that Student did not necessarily need residential placement but that consistency and intensity were needed wherever he lived. Alex Center director Sharon Grandinetti advised the IEP team that the goal remained to return Student to his home school in Richmond, but that he was not ready to return at this time. When asked about the use of consultation services in a Richmond placement, Ms. Grandinetti told the IEP team that consultation services were not appropriate “at this time, because Student is not ready for transition.” The District reiterated its placement offer at Richmond.

On August 19, 2003, the Alex Center was closed by its parent company, Bancroft NeuroHealth. Student returned to his home in Susanville, but his parents did not accept the offer of placement at Richmond and he did not begin school there in the fall.

On September 8, 2003, the Tustin Center opened as a day school, without a residential component, on same site as the Alex Center. At the time of its opening and through the conclusion of the due process hearing, the Tustin Center operated on a “conditional certification” from the California Department of Education (CDE) as a nonpublic school specializing in the treatment of children with traumatic and acquired brain injury. The Tustin Center’s new director, Juda Carter, hired many of the Alex Center’s former staff and accepted its former students. Following the Alex Center’s closure, the parties discussed whether the Tustin Center was Student’s appropriate stay put placement. On October 1, 2003, Petitioners agreed that Tustin Center was the stay put placement and they ultimately agreed to fund reasonable living expenses. On October 9, 2003, Student and his mother returned to Tustin and began living in a motel while he attended the Tustin Center.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE 1: Has the District Offered Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 School Year and Extended School Year (ESY)?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code § 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

To determine whether the District offered Student a free appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). At the administrative hearing, the school district has the burden of proving that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it has offered an appropriate educational placement for the student. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205.

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. The hearing officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the FAPE offered was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s offer must meet the following substantive requirements: (1) have been designed to meet Student’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit; and (3) have comported with his IEP. Because Student has not been placed in the offered program, it is not necessary to address whether the services provided comported with his IEP.

1. Procedural Appropriateness

In the May 29, 2003 addendum to the March 28, 2003 IEP, the District offered Student placement for the 2003-2004 school year as “the initial student” in a newly designed program in Room 111, a self-contained classroom at the District’s Richmond Elementary School Campus, with an age-appropriate fifth- through eighth-grade population. Student would be provided services of a “special education teacher” and one-on-one assistance “as needed.” Within this class, Student would work “with small groups (2-6) in age and curricular appropriate materials,” as well as one-on-one when needed in a quiet space. He could be mainstreamed to other classes when appropriate, and would be provided the opportunity to participate in campus-wide activities and age-level field trips. Student would receive the same level and frequency of DIS services as on the March 28, 2003 IEP, i.e., two hours (120 minutes) a week of speech and language therapy, ninety (90) minutes a week each of OT and PT, sixty (60) minutes a week of adapted physical education (APE), and up to 60 minutes a week of counseling. Student’s existing goals would be implemented and his “old behavior plan” would be followed until a new behavior plan was developed and implemented. (Footnote 7)

At the due process hearing, Richmond’s superintendent and principal Cynthia Nellums testified about Petitioners’ strong belief that Student should and could be educated while living at home, as well as about the efforts of the District and SELPA to create a program that would enable him to be educated at Richmond Elementary. In discussing the specifics of the May 29, 2003 offer, Ms. Nellums testified that a transition plan for Student to move from his nonpublic school back to Richmond was not written, but that the District would be ready “when it is time.” She also testified that the May 29, 2003 offer was “not the entire packet” and that “the entire packet has not yet been placed into writing.” Ms. Nellum acknowledged that further detail would be required to implement the offer and that this detail would be provided because the District “plans well.” Ms. Nellums testified that if the Hearing Officer determines that Student does not require placement at a nonpublic school, an IEP team meeting would be convened to provide the details of the offer necessary for its implementation. These details would include how to appropriately transition Student from his current NPS to Richmond and how to configure the self-contained classroom to address Student’s unique needs.

Student asserts that the May 29, 2003 offer lacks detail regarding his actual program, including the initial and ongoing training of District/LCOE staff who will work with him, the manner in which service providers will collaborate regarding his program, the number of small-group instructional opportunities he will have, whether the students in those groups will be typically developing or special education peers, the exact nature of his behavior services and the data collection methods to be used, and the transition plan to ensure consistency from his current nonpublic school to a public school setting. Student asserts that, by withholding details about the placement until a ruling by the Hearing Officer, Petitioners have violated the requirement for a single coherent written offer as required by Union v. Smith and subsequent case law. The Hearing Officer concurs. (Footnote 8)

“The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child.” Union v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Pursuant to this obligation, a school district must make a formal written offer of placement to the parents of a student with a disability. Id. Referring to the “great importance” the Supreme Court in Rowley placed on such procedural components of the IDEA, the Union court found that “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and ...should be enforced vigorously.” The Court also emphasized that a school district cannot escape its obligation to make a written offer of placement based upon the parents’ unwillingness to accept it. The Union court identified three important purposes of a written offer. First, “the requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Second, “a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in ‘presenting complaints with respect to any matter relating to the …educational placement of the child’…by alerting [them] to the need to consider seriously whether [the offered school] was an appropriate placement under the IDEA” and whether they should oppose it or accept it with the supplement of additional educational services. Third, “by making a formal offer, the District would have been more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the hearing officer of the appropriateness” of the placement. Id. In Union, the Court left intact the hearing officer’s conclusion that she was unable to determine the appropriateness of the placement because the District had failed to set forth sufficient evidence about it. Subsequently, in Glendale v. Almasi, 122 F. Supp.2d 1093, 1107 (N.D. Ca. 2000), the district court found that the formal written offer addressed in Union requires a school district to make a “single coherent placement offer,” rather than multiple formal offers from which a parent may choose.

In this case, the District has in essence made a partial offer, with a full offer contingent upon a future ruling by the hearing officer. By failing to provide the parents with specific details regarding the placement, including the manner in which the offer would be implemented, one of the key reasons articulated in Union for requiring a written offer was ignored: i.e., Student’s parents were not provided with sufficient information to seriously consider the offer. From the totality of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that a detailed written offer was particularly essential in this case in light of the pervasive nature of Student’s disability, its considerable impact on him in multiple domains, and the substantial placement change contemplated by Petitioners at the time the offer was made, i.e., from a TBI-specialized residential nonpublic school to an entirely new day program on a comprehensive public school campus. The Hearing Officer further finds that the sketchy nature of the offer made it impossible for Student’s parents to seriously analyze and consider Petitioners’ proposed placement due to its failure to address four key areas: initial training and ongoing consultation of staff, transition from a nonpublic school designed for students with TBI to a comprehensive general school campus, the frequency and type of behavior services, and the specifics of classroom small-group work.

First, the District’s offer does not include a provision for either initial training or ongoing consultation for LCOE/District employees who would work directly or indirectly with Student on the Richmond campus. Petitioners essentially agreed with the testimony of former Alex Center staff that Student requires placement in an intensive program specifically designed for students with TBI that is highly structured, consistent across environments, with frequent opportunities for collaboration and consultation among and between team members. (Footnote 9) Petitioners did not dispute this need; rather, they asserted that this program did not have to be in a nonpublic school and that they could provide such an intensive program for Student in the least restrictive environment at Richmond. However, as further established by the testimony of former Alex Center director Sharon Grandinetti, training and ongoing consultation in the area of brain injury and stroke, including how these injuries are manifested in Student’s educational, social, and behavioral needs, are essential components of the intensive program Student requires. Ms. Grandinetti testified that before Petitioner’s program could be appropriate for Student, their staff would need to participate in the same type of forty (40) hour training program as that she designed for all Alex Center staff before they began working with students. This program included three days focused on understanding the anatomy of the brain, the nature of brain injuries, and students’ resulting learning needs and strategies. The final two days of training was for “personal assault response training” or PART training. (Footnote 10)

Initial training and ongoing consultation is required both (1) for Student’s core educational team, including his teacher/s, one-on-one aide, behavior specialist/assistant, and DIS providers, and (2) for non-core school employees, with whom Student interacts during breaks and in the hallways. This latter point was established by the testimony of Student’s Alex Center teacher, Ms. Mealey, that it is crucial that all staff with whom Student comes into contact be knowledgeable of his behavioral program, and able, for example, to use the same techniques and terminology. Ms. Mealey testified that, without this consistency, Student’s behavior would quickly escalate into a tantrum.

The Hearing Officer gives great weight to the testimony of Ms. Grandinetti and Ms. Mealey. As detailed in her curriculum vitae (Dist. Ex. 92), Ms. Grandinetti’s knowledge and expertise in special education and brain injury issues span both public and private school settings, and entail the development of several special education NPS programs for students with brain injuries, including the Alex Center, as well as college instruction and lecture and workshop presentations. Her expertise in this field was undisputed by the parties. In addition, Ms. Mealey’s testimony established her six months of experience as Student’s classroom teacher from February through August 2003, as well as her training and two years of experience with TBI students at the Alex Center.

At the hearing, COE/SELPA director Michael Justice testified that the parents’ primary concern about any program or services offered by Petitioners has consistently stemmed from their belief that District/LCOE staff were not qualified or trained to work with Student. Despite this understanding and Petitioners’ acknowledgement that Student requires an intensive, specialized program as described above, the May 29, 2003 offer failed to include any provision for staff training or consultation, or description of the training and experience of staff members in TBI. The only mention of staff qualifications in the offered new program was to a “special education teacher.” In addition, while Petitioners may have intended to provide an intense program (for example, by training their staff pursuant to their September 2003 consultation contract with Ms. Grandinetti) and to further delineate it at a subsequent IEP team meeting, the offer must be viewed at the time it is made, not in hindsight, fleshed out by speculative or potential future additions. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141,1149 (9th Cir.1999). (Footnote 11)

Second, the May 29, 2003 offer did not contain a plan to transition Student from his current nonpublic placement to Richmond. The testimony of both Ms. Nellums and Ms. Grandinetti established that a transition plan is an essential component of a complete offer for Student. As revealed by Ms. Nellums’ testimony, the District planned to develop a detailed transition plan for Student at a later time, if the hearing officer determined a nonpublic school placement was not required. This failure was particularly egregious in light of the undisputed testimony that transitions are difficult for Student and that collaboration and consistency are crucial to Student’s ability to access his education in a manner that is safe for himself and others. Ms. Grandinetti’s testimony persuasively established that such a transition plan was crucial. In her words, there is a “whole science” to transitioning a TBI student like Student from one educational placement to another. In her opinion, any transition plan must be highly individualized, flexible to account for the TBI student’s rapid changes (including behavioral peaks and valleys), include slow introduction to the environment, and ensure that staff at the new placement clearly understand how to manage the student’s behavior. Thus, Ms. Grandinetti’s testimony established that a detailed, well-designed transition plan was a necessary part of any program offered. For the reasons previously stated, the Hearing Office gives great weight to her testimony.

Third, the offer does not specify whether Student will receive services from the behavior specialist, presumably LCOE’s Erich Johnson, or provide any detail regarding the frequency or duration of behavior services or the data collection methods to be used. Rather, the offer simply states that Student’s old behavior plan will continue to be implemented until a new plan, in the process of development, is implemented. A review of the draft behavior intervention plan (BIP) attached to the March 28, 2003 IEP document reveals that it is tailored for implementation at the Alex Center school and residential program and does not describe the duration or frequency of services. The testimony regarding Student’s behavior at the Alex Center demonstrates a need for behavior services that are clearly detailed in the offer. For example, Ms. Mealey’s testimony established that from two to five individuals may be needed to respond to one of Student’s tantrums. As indicated in the testimony of both Richmond and Alex Center staff, Student’s tantrums involve task refusal, throwing work off his desk, using his cane or brace as a weapon, running unsafely without his cane or brace, hitting, kicking, biting, exposing himself, and aggressively grabbing others in a sexual manner (grabbing staff’s genitals, trying to pull down staff’s pants). In addition, the most recent available Alex Center behavioral report (May 29, 2003) noted that Student’s behavior episodes had an average duration of 244 minutes. In light of the substantial nature of the placement change contemplated by the offer and Student’s history of behavior outbursts, the absence in the offer of clear detail regarding behavior services left the parents without sufficient information to seriously consider the proposed placement.

Fourth, the offer did not provide sufficient detail regarding the small group of students who would interact with Student in his self-contained classroom. In light of Student’s unique social-emotional needs discussed below, this omission reasonably gave the parents the impression that Student would be in a “class of one” for the indefinite future. While the offer indicated that Student would be joined periodically by two to six students from the Richmond campus for small-group work, the offer does not sufficiently describe the frequency of group interaction with Student, the type of student who would join Student, whether they would be regular or special education students, or whether the same group of students would regularly be added to his class for small-group work. (Footnote 12)

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the generic offer to place Student in a self-contained classroom with a special education teacher and a one-on-one aide as needed does not constitute a single coherent written offer as contemplated by Union and Glendale because it lacks sufficient details regarding the intensity of the program, including staff training and consultation, to enable Student’s parents to seriously consider it. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was not a single coherent written offer because it made no mention of the manner in which Student would be transitioned from one program to another, did not specify the frequency or duration of behavior services, and did not provide sufficient detail regarding the small group of students who would interact with Student in his self-contained classroom. These findings comport with California’s definition of specific educational placement as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program, in any one of a combination of public, private, home and hospital, or residential settings.” Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3042(a).

A procedural violation does not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE unless it has resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992). The Hearing Officer finds that the offer’s failure to include crucial components of the intended intense program as discussed above seriously infringed on the parent’s rights to participate in the IEP process. In this case, the vagueness of the offer resulted in the parents’ inability to fully participate in the IEP process. Although Petitioners argued that the parents were at the IEP team meetings and were able to ask questions, under Union, the burden of making an appropriate full offer is on the educational agency. In addition, as recognized in Union, the failure to provide a single coherent written offer of placement can, as in this case, result in insufficient relevant evidence for the hearing officer to determine the appropriateness of the placement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.

Moreover, even examining the substantive components of the program described, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer failed to meet Student’s unique needs.

First, as discussed above, Student has a unique need for placement in an intensive program specifically designed for students with TBI and an inherent component of such a program is an appropriately trained and qualified staff. While it was apparent at the hearing that LCOE occupational therapist, Ms. Springer, and LCOE speech and language therapist, Mr. Tackett, had training and experience working with TBI students, the evidence also established that they would not be readily available to Student’s teacher and staff. (Footnote 13) Rather, if Student were placed at Richmond, the evidence established that Mr. Tackett and Ms. Springer, both of whom serve students throughout Lassen County, would not be on site except during their provision of services. At Richmond, the offer envisions that a special education teacher would be Student’s one-on-one teacher, with a one-on-one aide only “as necessary.” The evidence also established that Student would come into contact with “non-core” school employees who do not work directly with him, and that Student would potentially be engaged with the entire Richmond population during lunch, recess, and/or at the gym. It is imperative for the safety of both Student and others, including the special education teacher, that Richmond staff have knowledge and training of how to respond to his behaviors using antecedent behavior management techniques to avoid escalation of behaviors or PART techniques in situations posing a threat of danger to self or others. Thus, the existence of some well-qualified staff in other locations does not ensure that Student will be provided the intensity and consistency of structure he requires in his educational and behavioral program. (Footnote 14)

Second, the weight of the evidence established that Student has unique social-emotional needs. Student was determined eligible for Chapter 26.5 mental health counseling services due to his anxiety and depression that have interfered with his ability to benefit from his educational program. Student’s most recent diagnoses, in October 2002 by the Texas NeuroRehab Center, include depressive disorder and chronic post-traumatic stress disorder. The parties agree Student requires the same level and duration of mental health DIS services as outlined in the March 28, 2003 IEP document: i.e., sixty (60) minutes a week of mental health counseling. As indicated in the testimony of staff from both Richmond and the former Alex Center, Student experiences feelings of anger, grief, and loss of self-esteem relating to the loss of “the old Student,” with his greater physical, social, behavioral, and cognitive capabilities. Ms. Mealey testified that Student is very aware of his limitations, is embarrassed by them, and feels different. At the same time, the evidence established that Student is a social boy who is slowly increasing his time spent in activities with his peers. For example, in her August 12, 2003 academic report, Ms. Mealey reported that Student requires “moderate cueing and reinforcement to get him to participate in social activities with his peers. ...Some of his reluctance to socialize with peers may be due to his physical handicaps. He has greater difficulty manipulating his environment than his classmates. He also seems to prefer adult interaction. Peer socialization is beginning to increase ...from 10% to over 45% of the day. Student is even beginning to initiate interaction. This is an area Student will continue to need encouragement.”

From the information provided in the offer as written, the Hearing Officer finds that placement of Student in a self-contained classroom as the “initial” student for the indefinite future is not designed to meet his unique social-emotional needs. Petitioners provided no evidence from Student’s mental health therapist or any other assessor regarding his current emotional well being or regarding the effect such a placement would have on him. By contrast, Alex Center staff persuasively testified that such a placement would be detrimental to Student. For example, Student’s speech therapist Ms. Peck testified that he must be taught social skills in a social environment, but that he is not yet able to generalize these skills with unfamiliar peers. As previously discussed, the District’s offer did nothing to dispel these substantial concerns that Student would be isolated at Richmond.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 29, 2003 offer was not a single coherent written offer as required by Union, and Glendale, supra, and that this violation seriously infringed upon the ability of Student’s parents to participate in the IEP process. Furthermore, as a substantive matter, the offer did not meet Student’s unique need for an intensive program designed for students with TBI and did not meet his unique social-emotional needs. While an intensive highly structured program of the type discussed above does not necessarily have to be in a nonpublic school, any offer for such a program must clearly describe the components of the proposed placement in detail. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for Student for the 2003-2004 school year.

ISSUE 2: Is Student Entitled to Prospective Placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 School Year and Extended School Year, and, if So, is the District Required to Pay for Reasonable Living Expenses for Himself and One Parent and for Family Visits?

Student assert that, because he was not offered a FAPE, he is entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year. Petitioners argue that the Tustin Center is not appropriate because it is a fledgling program that is substantially different from the Alex Center and because it is not certified as an NPS. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year is appropriate and will provide Student with a FAPE.

Appropriateness of Tustin Center (Footnote 15)

The Hearing Officer finds that the Tustin Center is substantially similar in its education program to the Alex Center and that it is designed to meet Student’s unique needs. The weight of the evidence established that the Tustin Center offers an intensive program specifically designed for students with TBI that is highly structured, consistent across environments, with frequent opportunities for collaboration and consultation among and between team members. As discussed below, the Tustin Center is an appropriately certified nonpublic school designed to provide special education services to TBI students. Three former Alex Center staff members-- speech therapist Katy Peck, APE specialist Charles Hwang, and director of marketing and admissions Mark Hauber – are currently employed by and interact with Student at the Tustin Center. These witnesses testified that the Tustin Center, which is on the same site as the former Alex Center, provides substantially similar training, services, and ongoing staff collaboration regarding Student’s needs and progress as the Alex Center. Mr. Hauber testified that the Tustin Center has fifteen students compared to the twenty served by the Alex Center and that all of the Tustin Center’s students are former Alex Center students.

The testimony of these witnesses established that, at the Tustin Center, Student is continuing to receive services in a setting with familiar peers, and by familiar and highly trained individuals who can ensure the intensity, structure, consistency, and collaborative framework provided by the Alex Center. Ms. Grandinetti testified that Mr. Hardy, Student’s current teacher at the Tustin Center, was trained and worked with students at the Alex Center for several years. Although he is currently teaching in California under an emergency credential, Ms. Grandinetti testified that he is an experienced special educator from Massachusetts. With the exception of a new physical therapist, all of Student’s DIS services providers worked with him at the Alex Center. For example, speech therapist Katy Peck began working with Student at the Alex Center in February 2003 and continues as his speech therapist at the Tustin Center. Ms. Peck testified that, because Student’s behavior escalates when his communication fails, she has worked with him on issues of intelligibility, memory, critical thinking, pragmatic skills, and behavioral problem solving, i.e., teaching him self-expression and alternative coping and calming strategies. Ms. Peck testified that she continues to work with Student on these issues at the Tustin Center and continues to implement his current goals. In her opinion, the Tustin Center is an appropriate placement for Student at this time. Ms. Peck is a licensed speech pathologist with three years of experience in clinical rehabilitation of brain-injured adolescents and three years of experience providing similar services to students at the Alex and Tustin Centers. The Hearing Officer gives Ms. Peck’s testimony great weight due to her extensive training and experience in the area of Student’s disability, as well as her extensive direct experience in working with him. Similarly, Mr. Hwang testified that he continues to work with Student on his goals from the Alex Center, that the collaborative approach at both the Alex and Tustin Centers ensured intensity of services in all areas, and that, in his opinion, the Tustin Center is an appropriate placement for Student at this time.

The weight of the evidence demonstrated that both the academic and behavior program at Tustin Center will meet Student’s unique needs. Academically, Student requires predominantly one-on-one instruction, with the slow addition of some small group work. Tustin Center director Juda Carter testified that Student is in a class with a current total of five students and a maximum enrollment of six students; that Student knows his program and is highly motivated by an instructional aide who is an adult survivor of TBI. The evidence established that Student requires the use of an SRA methodology or another applied behavior analysis/task analysis type of methodology that breaks his work down, repeats it for him, and has many positive opportunities for success. According to Ms. Grandinetti, SRA is the only curriculum that has demonstrated success with TBI students. The evidence also establishes that Student requires curriculum appropriate for students with central auditory processing disorders. Ms. Carter testified that the Tustin Center is continuing the SRA curriculum used at the Alex Center. In addition, Ms. Carter testified that curriculums such as the Lindamood Bell LIPS and Seeing Stars programs are particularly helpful for Student, in addition to the SRA, due to his auditory processing deficits. Ms. Peck also testified regarding Student’s need for this type of method and that she is trained in and will begin implementing this method with Student as well. Ms. Carter testified the Tustin Center is developing more opportunities for students to interact with typically developing peers with the addition of a peer buddy program and a vocational component. Finally, the evidence also established that the Tustin Center has a highly structured and well managed behavior program. Ms. Carter testified that the Tustin Center program provides multiple layers of behaviorists to ensure proper documentation and implementation of Student’s BIP using antecedent behavior management techniques with data collection tracking on goals. (Footnote 16)

For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year is appropriate.

Finally, the Hearing Officer declines to order placement at the Tustin Center for the 2004 extended school year. In this case, even though Student is eligible for extended year services, the May 29, 2003 offer was designed for the 2003 extended school year and the 2003-2004 school year. In addition, as indicated in the testimony of Ms. Grandinetti, the IEP team should meet on a regular basis to reassess Student’s progress and needs. If Student is ready to transition out of the Tustin Center and back to Susanville, the extended school year would be an ideal time for the implementation of a carefully planned transition contained in a fully-detailed coherent offer of placement.

Certification of Tustin Center

There are three types of certification status for a nonpublic school or agency: (1) approved certification with no conditions or limitations; (2) conditional certification for a limited period of time; or (3) suspended certification for a defined period of time. A conditional certification indicates that the nonpublic school or agency has not met all the certification requirements. tit. 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3067 (c). The undisputed evidence at the hearing established that, effective September 8, 2003, the Tustin Center was conditionally certified by the California Department of Education (CDE) as a nonpublic school (NPS) to provide special education services to students with traumatic brain injury. Tustin Center’s director of marketing and admissions Mark Hauber testified that a full site visit of the facility by CDE was scheduled for November 5, 2003. Because Student seeks prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school and extended school year, the impact of the “conditional” nature of its certification was raised in light of the statutory mandate that a hearing officer not issue a decision prospectively placing a student in an NPS that “has not been certified pursuant to Section 56366.1.” Calif. Educ. Code § 56505.2(a).

Request for Judicial Notice of Tustin Center’s Asserted Full Certification

In his closing brief, Student requested that the Hearing Officer take judicial notice of the full certification of the Tustin Center by the CDE, pursuant to California Evidence Code section 452(c) which provides in pertinent part that “judicial notice may be taken of the following matters...: (c) official acts of the legislative, executive, and judicial departments of the United States and of any state of the United States.” In support of his request, Student attached a copy of an e-mail message from the Tustin Center’s executive director, Scott Temple, to families and school districts announcing that it had received full certification effective November 5, 2003. (Footnote 17)

On November 13, 2003, Petitioners were notified of Student’s request for judicial notice and provided an opportunity to respond; however, neither the District nor LCOE submitted any response to the Hearing Office.

There is no provision in the Education Code regarding judicial notice in a due process hearing; however, it is generally well established that the burden is on the party requesting judicial notice to supply the court with sources of information that provide a sufficiently reliable and trustworthy basis upon which to take such notice. People v. Moore, 59 Cal.App.4th 168, 177 (1997). The Hearing Officer finds that the e-mail document provided by the Student does not provide a sufficiently reliable basis for taking judicial notice of an official governmental act. The e-mail is an assertion of fact by a nongovernmental employee with a financial interest in the outcome of this litigation. While Student asserts that certification can be readily confirmed by the CDE, this would require the Hearing Officer to assume an inappropriate, investigative role. “A court is not required to seek out on its own initiative indisputable sources of information.” Id. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer declines to take judicial notice of the asserted full certification of the Tustin Center based upon Mr. Temple’s e-mail message. (Footnote 18)

Compliance with Cal. Educ. Code Section 56505.2(a)

The Hearing Officer finds that an order in this Decision to place Student at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year does not conflict with Cal. Educ. Code section 56505.2(a), which provides that “a hearing officer may not render a decision that results in the placement of an individual with exceptional needs in a nonpublic, nonsectarian school, …, if the school or agency has not been certified pursuant to Section 56366.1.” Education Code Section 56366.1 outlines the procedures for certification of a nonpublic school or agency and specifically authorizes conditional certifications. In pertinent part, that section requires that, prior to certification, the superintendent of public instruction must conduct “an onsite review of the facility and program for which the applicant seeks certification ....[and] an additional onsite review of the facility and program within four years of the certification effective date, unless the superintendent conditionally certifies the school or agency or unless the superintendent receives a formal complaint against the school or agency. In the latter two cases, the superintendent shall conduct an onsite review at least annually.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56366.1(d) [italics added]. Further, pursuant to subdivision (e), where the superintendent fails to act on an application for certification within 120 days of receiving the application, “the applicant is automatically granted conditional certification for a period terminating on August 31, of the current school year....” Cal. Educ. Code § 56366.1(e). Thus, construing Education Code section 56505.2(a) in light of Section 56366.1, subdivisions (d) and (e), it is clear that the Tustin Center has been certified, albeit conditionally, pursuant to Section 56366.1. In this case, if the CDE’s scheduled site inspection has not taken place, the conditional certification remains in effect. If no action is taken within 120 days or by approximately January 8, 2004, the conditional certification is automatically granted until August 31, 2004. This conclusion comports with the experience of other NPS; for example, Ms. Grandinetti testified that the Alex Center operated under conditional certification for an extended time period due to site visit delays. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student is entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer now concludes that an order for placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year complies with Cal. Educ. Code Section 56505.2(a). As indicated in Order No. 1 below, however, if during the 2003-2004 school year, the Tustin Center’s certification is suspended or lost, the IEP team shall meet and identify a comparable certified nonpublic school designed to provide services for students with traumatic brain injury and the District shall fund Student’s placement at that school for the 2003-2004 school year.

Reasonable Living Expenses (Footnote 19)

Reasonable living expenses that are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education are appropriate related services. Ojai Unified School District v. Jackson, 4 F. 3d 1467, 1478 (9th Cir. 1993), Union v. Smith, 15 F.3d at 1527. As explained by the Ninth Circuit in Union, “if a child’s appropriate special education placement is at a non-residential program not within daily commuting distance of the family residence, transportation costs and lodging near the school are related services that are required to assist the child to benefit from the special education.” In this case, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and that the Tustin Center is the appropriate placement for him for the current school year. Due to the great distance involved and the fact that the Tustin Center is not a residential placement, Student cannot access his educational program unless one of his parents reside with him in the Tustin area. Thus, reasonable living expenses for Student and one parent to reside in or near Tustin are necessary for Student to receive benefit from his educational program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).

Student has requested an order that the District pay for reasonable living expenses for himself and his parent, including living accommodations, meals, transportation to and from the Tustin Center, plus twice yearly visits with his siblings and his stepfather. The District did not specifically oppose any of these requests but generally asserted that FAPE could be provided in Richmond.

In light of the conclusions reached above, the Hearing Officer finds that reasonable housing and transportation expenses must be reimbursed. Student has provided copies of receipts for hotel accommodations; however, from the testimony at the hearing, it appears that ongoing efforts are underway to locate an apartment or other suitable living arrangement. The Hearing Officer encourages the parties to work together to locate reasonable yet economical living accommodations. Transportation to and from the Tustin Center in the form of mileage is reasonable and will be ordered at the mileage rate used for District employees. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is entitled to transportation costs for Student and his parent to commute from Tustin to Susanville both at the beginning and at the end of this school year, and when the school is officially closed to students (i.e., winter and spring breaks) and Student can visit with his family in Susanville. Because the undisputed evidence established that Student cannot safely participate in the lengthy drive between these locations in one day, reimbursement shall also be provided for the cost of one night’s hotel accommodation during each trip to and from the Tustin area and Student’s home in Susanville.

Little evidence was provided about Student’s request for meal reimbursement. It is obvious that Student and his mother will incur food expenses regardless of where they live. Additional expenses will be incurred by Student only if the parties are unable to locate housing or extended stay hotel accommodations in the Tustin area that contain kitchen facilities. The Hearing Officer finds that, if some or all meals must be eaten at restaurants due to the lack of kitchen facilities, the District shall reimburse Student’s parent for the cost of meals.

In summary, during the 2003-2004 school year, the District shall reimburse Student’s parent for reasonable living and transportation expenses as described in Order No. 2 below.

SUMMARY

The District has not offered Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer has no doubt about Petitioners’ willingness to create an appropriate public school program for Student that will allow him to return home and be educated in Susanville. As discussed above, however, this willingness must be translated into a specific coherent offer of placement that is comprehensive and incorporates the key elements outlined above. Student is entitled to prospective placement at the Tustin Center for the 2003-2004 school year and reasonable living expenses.

ORDER

1. For the 2003-2004 school year, the District shall fund Student’s placement at The Tustin Center, as long as it remains a certified or conditionally certified nonpublic school. If The Tustin Center loses its certification or its certification is suspended during the 2003-2004 school year, the IEP team shall meet and identify a comparable certified nonpublic school designed to provide services for students with traumatic brain injury and the District shall fund Student’s placement at that school for the 2003-2004 school year.

2. For the 2003-2004 school year, the District shall reimburse Student’s parents for the following reasonable living expense for one parent to live in the Tustin area to enable Student to attend the Tustin Center:

a. Reasonable living expenses, including costs of housing and meals, subject to proof, in an amount not to exceed $4,300.00. Meal reimbursement shall be provided only if Student’s housing does not include kitchen facilities.

b. Mileage reimbursement as follows: (i) two round trips a day from his temporary home in the Tustin area to the Tustin Center to access his educational program, plus, (ii) transportation from Susanville to Tustin before and after the 2003-2004 school year, and for breaks when the school is officially closed to students (i.e., winter and spring breaks). Mileage shall be reimbursed at the rate the District reimburses its employees.

c. Hotel reimbursement for one night for each trip between the Tustin Center and Susanville or Susanville and The Tustin Center.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: the Student substantially prevailed on all issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: December 15, 2003 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. LCOE was not a Petitioner in SN03-01129. Student named LCOE, along with Lassen County Mental Health (LCMH), in his subsequent cross-filing, SN03-01332, and the cases were consolidated for hearing. On October 7, 2003, at Student’s request, LCMH was dismissed as a party [see: Order of October 7, 2003]. 2. On the first day of hearing, the issues as outlined in the PHC Order were amended to clarify the parties’ positions. First, the parties agreed that Issue 1 in the PHC order [whether the District was required to fund parental visits to the Alex Center during the 2003 extended school year] had been resolved by the District’s agreement to reimburse Student’s parents for the costs of their visits to the Alex Center in August of 2003. Second, regarding reimbursement outlined in PHC order Issue 4, the parties advised the Hearing Officer that the District had agreed to fund the Tustin Center as Student’s stay put placement and to pay up to $4,300 a month for reasonable living expenses for one parent to live in the area with him. Student represented that there were no out-of-pocket expenses to date and that he only sought an order for prospective reasonable living expenses. The Hearing Officer notes that, in its closing brief, the District also contends that it provided Student an offer of FAPE for the 2003 extended school year (ESY). Because ESY 2003 was not at issue, however, it is not addressed in this Decision. 3. For example, the family reported that Student tried to hit his therapists and had threatened his sister with a knife. Student’s mother also testified that Student’s first behavioral outburst occurred during a therapy appointment in Reno and that Student had to be medicated before she could begin the two-hour drive home. 4. In California, Chapter 26.5, codified at Government Code '' 7570-7588, describes interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to children with disabilities under the IDEA. Pursuant to that Act, the State Department of Mental Health, or any community mental health service, Ashall be responsible for the provision of mental health services, as defined in regulations by the State Department of Mental Health, developed in consultation with the State Department of Education, when required in the pupil’s individualized education program.@ Gov. Code ' 7576(a). See also Cal. Educ. Code ' 56500. 5. The District attempted to have Student return to school or to provide services to him at home and the parents were informed of a possible action before the School Attendance Review Board (SARB). 6. Because Mr. Tompkins did not testify, whether he contemplated a public school special day class for Student, as asserted by Ms. Nellums, or a placement at the Alex Center, as asserted by Student’s mother, cannot be determined.

7. The offer indicated that Room 111 had a bathroom, internet service, cable tv, and video hook ups, was next door to the resource (RST) room, and was easily accessible to the gym and blacktop areas. The offer stated that it was “envisioned that unless more students than Student are assigned to this program, the teacher may be able to provide much of the one-on-one assistance.” Regarding the behavior plan, the addendum indicated a new place was in development and would be implemented in the summer 2003.