California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 15, 2003
Student v. Alameda City Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1132-02 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Alameda City Unified must reimburse behavioral services, therapies and a $1,300 IEE and fund a preschooler's 30-hour program.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Alameda City Unified School District and the parents of a 3-year-old girl with autism both filed for hearing in May 2002. The District had found her eligible under multiple disabilities, including developmental delay, which its school psychologist treated as mental retardation. The Hearing Officer ordered her category changed to autism alone. Her scattered test scores and young age did not support mental retardation. The District's preschool team assessment was inappropriate because it included no formal speech-language testing, and the District did not show that the team was trained to give its main test. The District held the May 21, 2002 IEP meeting without the parents, on one business day's notice and with no phone option. That denied FAPE. The IEP also had no present levels of performance and repeated goals she had already met. It offered a mixed preschool class with under five hours a week of one-to-one instruction, speech therapy that did not specify individual sessions, and only consultative occupational therapy (OT). The summer and 2002-03 offers failed for the same reasons. The District must reimburse Behavioral Intervention Association services, one hour weekly each of speech therapy and OT, and the $1,300 IEE. It must also fund the 30-hour behavioral program for the rest of the year, provide therapy, and provide a regular preschool or fund Temple Sinai. Reimbursement for the private preschools and music therapy was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated an IEP meeting held without parents on very short notice as a denial of FAPE. It also shows that an offer of two possible classes had to be appropriate in both classes. Finally, it held that a prospective award cannot direct services from providers that are not certified nonpublic agencies.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Should the Student's special education eligibility category be changed to autism from multiple disabilities (autism, speech and language impairment, and developmental delays)?
Scatter in cognitive and adaptive scores and the child's young age did not support mental retardation, developmental delay is not a category for ages 3-5, and speech delay is part of autism, so the category must be autism alone.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. Was the District's April 2002 preschool team assessment of the Student appropriate?
The assessment was inappropriate: no formal speech-language assessment, no showing that the team was trained to give the PEP-R or gave it according to the manual, and one tester left out of the report. The social-emotional area was adequately assessed, and the assessment plan was late under the 15-day rule.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment from May 22, 2002 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the summer 2002 extended school year (ESY) session?
Holding the May 21 IEP meeting without the parents, on short notice and with no phone option, denied FAPE. The IEP also lacked present levels, had inappropriate goals, offered too little one-to-one instruction, no individual speech therapy and no direct OT, and offered an ESY program without continuity.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Did the District offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 2002-2003 school year?
The same May 21, 2002 IEP governed 2002-03 with no significant change, so it again failed to offer FAPE.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5(1)(a). Reimbursement for Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA) services, including the cost of transportation
The 30-hour BIA program, including a one-to-one preschool aide, was appropriate, so costs from May 22, 2002 are reimbursed. No transportation was awarded for BIA services.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5(1)(b). Reimbursement for ABC preschool and Temple Sinai preschool, including the cost of transportation
There was too little evidence about either preschool to show it was appropriate, so reimbursement was denied.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5(1)(c). Reimbursement for speech therapy from Sarah Thompson and Margaret Bourne, including the cost of transportation
Individual speech therapy and mileage are reimbursed, limited to one hour weekly, including during summer 2002.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5(1)(d). Reimbursement for occupational therapy from Stacy Frauwirth, including the cost of transportation
Direct OT, related auditory integrative therapy expenses, and mileage are reimbursed, limited to one hour weekly because no basis was shown for the increase to twice weekly.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5(1)(e). Reimbursement for music therapy from Susan Rancer
There was no evidence that music therapy met a unique need, so it was not reimbursed.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 5(2). Continuation of her current program (BIA services, Temple Sinai preschool, speech therapy, occupational therapy, and music therapy) for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year?
The District must fund the 30-hour BIA program and provide one hour weekly each of individual speech therapy and direct OT, but not necessarily from the current private providers, who are not certified nonpublic agencies. It must also provide a regular education preschool or fund Temple Sinai. Music therapy was not continued.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 6. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement of $1300 for the independent developmental assessment by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D.?
Because the District's assessment was inappropriate and the licensed clinical psychologist was a qualified specialist, the $1,300 IEE is reimbursable. She did not need to be a school psychologist.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Within 15 calendar days, amend the IEP to show the eligibility category as solely autism.
- Reimbursement. Within 25 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse the cost of Behavioral Intervention Association services from May 22, 2002 to the date of the decision.
- Reimbursement. Within 25 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse speech therapy (one hour weekly total) from Sarah Thompson or Margaret Bourne from May 22, 2002 to the decision date, plus round-trip mileage at the District employee rate.
- Reimbursement. Within 25 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse occupational therapy (one hour weekly total) from Stacy Frauwirth, including reasonable auditory integrative therapy expenses, from May 22, 2002 to the decision date, plus round-trip mileage at the District employee rate.
- IEE at public expense. Within 25 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse the $1,300 cost of Dr. Melanie Lenington's developmental assessment.
- Prospective funding of private placement. Fund the 30-hour BIA program (15 hours in-home one-to-one and 15 hours of one-to-one preschool aide) for the rest of the 2002-2003 regular school year.
- Order to provide or change services. Within 15 calendar days, provide one hour weekly of individual speech therapy and one hour weekly of direct OT. If other providers are used, within 14 calendar days obtain, at District expense, written reports from Ms. Bourne and Ms. Frauwirth. The District may instead contract with them. Mileage is reimbursed if nonpublic providers are used.
- Placement ordered. Within 15 calendar days, provide an appropriate public or private regular education preschool class with typical peers, or fund Temple Sinai preschool for the rest of the 2002-2003 regular school year. On parent request, provide transportation or mileage reimbursement at the District employee rate.
Total: $1,300 ordered
Key authorities
Board of Educ. v. Rowley; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ.; W.G. v. Board of Trustees; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist.; Burger v. Murray County School Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2
People named in the decision
- David Wax, Ed.D., Director of pupil personnel services, Alameda City Unified School District
- Thomas Anderson, Program specialist (administrator designee for IEP), Alameda City Unified School District
- Sally Sweatfield, Program specialist, Alameda City Unified School District
- Elizabeth Kowal, Program specialist, Alameda City Unified School District
- Lois Sonneman, Speech pathologist (preschool assessment team), Alameda City Unified School District
- Judith Auston, Occupational therapist (preschool assessment team), Alameda City Unified School District
- Danielle Walters, Special education teacher, integrated preschool and extended day program, Woodstock Child Development Center, Alameda City Unified School District
- Thomas Mushaney, School psychologist, Alameda City Unified School District
- Patricia Rannefeld, Integrated preschool special education teacher; administered PEP-R items, Woodstock Child Development Center, Alameda City Unified School District
- Mr. Kruze, Integrated preschool special education teacher (2002-2003), Woodstock Child Development Center, Alameda City Unified School District
- Sharon O'Neil, Severely handicapped SDC teacher; 2002 ESY teacher, Edison Elementary School, Alameda City Unified School District
- Nadine Pardini, Paraprofessional, Woodstock Child Development Center
- Olga Patton, Paraprofessional, Woodstock Child Development Center
- Ruperta Cabarles, Paraprofessional, Woodstock Child Development Center
- Rosalina Carbajol, District accounting assistant, Alameda City Unified School District
- Elissa Garske, Speech pathologist, District witness, Progressive Therapy
- Deanne Detmers, Associate director, nonpublic agency, Behavioral Intervention Association
- Anna Kern, Program director, nonpublic agency, Behavioral Intervention Association
- Behavioral Intervention Association, State-certified nonpublic agency providing in-home behavioral services and one-to-one aide
- Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., Clinical psychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Susan Rancer, Private music therapist
- Stacy Frauwirth, Private occupational therapist
- Sarah Thompson, Private speech-language pathologist
- Margaret Bourne, Private speech-language pathologist
- Casey Rider, Speech pathologist (September 2001 assessment), Children's Hospital Oakland
- Renee Wachtel, M.D., Developmental pediatrician (November 2001 assessment), Children's Hospital Oakland
- Lori Wensley, Ph.D., Clinical child psychologist (November 2001 assessment), Children's Hospital Oakland
- Susan Campodonico, Early intervention teacher, Small Voices program, Alta Bates Medical Center
- Don Wachelka, Consultant (reserved District rebuttal witness)
- Diane Ashton, Ph.D., Reserved District rebuttal witness
- Quality Behavioral Outcomes, Behavioral consultant providing training to District staff
- Temple Sinai preschool, Private preschool
- ABC preschool, Private preschool (summer 2002)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Alameda, California, on September 17-20, 30, October 1-2, 4, and 7-9, 2002. Alameda City Unified School District (District) was represented by attorneys Edward Sklar on most of the days and Charmaine Huntting on one day and legal representative Cathleen Hall on a few days. Present on different days were director of pupil personnel services David Wax, Ed.D., and program specialists Thomas Anderson, Sally Sweatfield, and Elizabeth Kowal. STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented by attorney Ralph Lewis and her parents, MOTHER and FATHER.
The District and the Student called the following witnesses: District speech pathologist Lois Sonneman, M.S., CCC; District occupational therapist Judith Auston, M.S., O.T.R.; Danielle Walters, M.Ed., special education teacher, District Woodstock Child Development Center (Woodstock); District school psychologist Thomas Mushaney, M.A.; and Dr. Wax. The District called the following witnesses: Elissa Garske, speech pathologist, Progressive Therapy; and Mr. Anderson. The Student called the following witnesses: Sharon O’Neil, severely handicapped (SH) special day class (SDC) teacher, Edison Elementary School; Nadine Pardini, Olga Patton, and Ruperta Cabarles, paraprofessionals, Woodstock; Deanne Detmers, M.A., associate director, Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA); Anna Kern, M.F.T., BIA program director; Susan Rancer, music therapist; Rosalina Carbajol, District accounting assistant; Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; MOTHER, STUDENT’S mother; and FATHER, her father. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Burden of Going Forward. On the first hearing day, the Student raised the matter of which party had the burden of presenting its case first and argued that the District sought to change her placement. The District argued that the Student also sought to change her placement from her stay put placement, which did not include BIA services.(Footnote 1) Generally, the party seeking to change the status quo bears the burden of going forward. Burger v. Murray County School District, 612 F.Supp. 434, 437 (N.D. Ga. 1984). The Hearing Officer stated that if both parties seek to change the status quo, as a general rule, the burden of going forward is placed on the party that requested a hearing first. In this case, the District did not dispute that it sought to change the status quo and that it had filed first for a due process hearing. Thus, the Hearing Officer ruled that the District bore the burden of going forward. The Hearing Officer noted that the District had been informed of the Student’s issues through a prior clarification of the issues.
Rebuttal Witnesses. The District sought to recall as a rebuttal witness special education teacher Ms. Walters to rebut BIA program director Ms. Kern’s testimony about a conversation the two had while she was observing Ms. Walters’ class.(Footnote 2) The District asserted that it needed to address questions raised about Ms. Walter’s qualifications and the quality of the District’s class. The Student objected. The Hearing Officer ruled that no basis existed for recalling Ms. Walters because District witnesses, including Ms. Walters, had provided extensive testimony regarding her qualifications and the District’s program; the District had the opportunity to impeach Ms. Kern’s credibility; and the Student had stipulated that Ms. Walters would disagree with Ms. Kern’s testimony about their conversation. The Hearing Officer noted that the testimony about the conversation would be considered in the context of all the evidence.
ISSUES(Footnote 3)
1. Should the Student’s special education eligibility category be changed to autism from multiple disabilities (autism, speech and language impairment, and developmental delays)?
2. Was the District’s April 2002 preschool team assessment of the Student appropriate?
3. Did the District offer the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment from May 22, 2002 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the summer 2002 extended school year (ESY) session?
4. Did the District offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 2002-2003 school year?(Footnote 4)
5. If the Student was denied a FAPE from May 22, 2002 to the present, is she entitled to the following remedies:
(1) Reimbursement for the following, including the cost of transportation: (a) Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA) services;
(b) ABC preschool and Temple Sinai preschool;
(c) Speech therapy from Sarah Thompson and Margaret Bourne;
(d) Occupational therapy from Stacy Frauwirth;
(e) Music therapy from Susan Rancer?
(2) Continuation of her current program (BIA services, Temple Sinai preschool, speech therapy, occupational therapy, and music therapy) for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year?
6. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement of $1300 for the independent developmental assessment by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D.?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was found eligible for special education by the District because of multiple disabilities (autism, speech and language impairment, and developmental delays).(Footnote 5) She has also been diagnosed with hypotonia(Footnote 6) and sensory processing issues. She has received speech therapy, occupational therapy (OT), an early intervention program at Alta Bates Medical Center (Alta Bates), and BIA in-home behavioral therapy. Since age 3 she has attended a private preschool with a one-to-one BIA aide.
A September 2001 Children’s Hospital of Oakland (CHO) speech and language assessment report stated that STUDENT’S Rosetti Infant-Toddler Language Scale (Rosetti) results and informal observation revealed moderate receptive and expressive language delays and a mild articulation delay and recommended speech therapy. She started receiving speech therapy. (Testimony of MOTHER.) An October 2001 Regional Center of the East Bay (RCEB) administration of the Revised Gesell Developmental Schedules (Gesell) found a significantly delayed cognitive level. The assessor noted difficulty engaging her in the testing activities. An October 5, 2001 individualized family service plan (IFSP) indicates that STUDENT was eligible for RCEB services because of generalized developmental delays. The IFSP notes that she had little communicative language, limited eye contact, difficulty connecting with adults and children, and oral sensitivity. The IFSP provides for a CHO developmental assessment, oral motor OT assessment, Alta Bates Small Voices infant development program, and speech therapy.
A November 2001 CHO assessment of STUDENT at age 30 months by Renee Wachtel, M.D., developmental pediatrician, and Lori Wensley, Ph.D., clinical child psychologist, diagnosed an autistic disorder, developmental delay, hypotonia, and sensory processing issues. She obtained a Bayley Scales of Infant Development (Bayley), second edition, 69 Mental Developmental Index and 23-month age-equivalent (AE) score, indicating significantly delayed overall intellectual performance. The report notes that because of many language-based test items, the score may not reflect her true cognitive ability due to her limited language skills. Her lowest subarea AE score was Social-Emotional, 11 months. STUDENT obtained a 65 Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (Vineland) composite score, in the low functioning range. Her lowest AE scores were Socialization, 11 months, and Communication, 13 months. Her Gilliam Autism Rating Scales and Childhood Autism Rating Scale scores indicated mild to moderate autism. Speech therapy, OT, and autism intervention services were recommended. A November 2001 Small Voices early intervention program report sets forth STUDENT’S Hawaii Early Learning Profile (HELP) Strand scores and recommends the early intervention program, speech therapy, and an OT assessment.
A December 2001 OT assessment of sensory processing problems was conducted by occupational therapist Stacy Frauwirth. From a Sensory History Questionnaire and clinical observation, Ms. Frauwirth concluded that STUDENT showed signs of sensory defensiveness, sensory modulation difficulties, and decreased muscle tone throughout. She recommended weekly OT using a sensory integrative and play-based approach and a Therapeutic Listening Program as part of her sensory integration treatment. A January 2002 report by BIA associate director Deanne Detmers sets forth assessment results stemming from a parent questionnaire, CHO assessment reports, a video of STUDENT, and observation and interaction with her. She recommended a preschool class with a one-to-one aide; 21 hours weekly of one-to-one home intervention using methods such as discrete trial training (DTT), TEACCH, and Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) to develop play skills, language processing and production, communication skills, and social relatedness; and several supported peer-interaction opportunities weekly.
A February 22, 2002 transition IFSP meeting was attended by District director of pupil personnel services David Wax. The IFSP states that the mother requested OT (sensory integration), developmental, and speech and language assessments. On March 29, 2002, she was presented the District’s assessment plan, which she signed. School psychologist Thomas Mushaney completed a history questionnaire and the Developmental Profile II (a parent interview). (Testimony of Mr. Mushaney.)
An April 2002 Small Voices status report sets forth STUDENT’S then-current HELP Strand scores and recommends intensive individual work on speech production skills in addition to classroom language instruction; continued DTT intervention and also group experience to practice skills learned one-to-one; and a small, structured learning environment where she has typical peers as models. It also recommends an OT fine-motor assessment and OT consultation for sensory defensiveness and modulation in her new learning environment.
An undated report sets forth the results of the District’s assessment by the preschool team (school psychologist Mr. Mushaney, speech pathologist Lois Sonneman, occupational therapist Judith Auston, and special education teacher Danielle Walters) when STUDENT was age 35 months. Her Psychoeducational Profile-Revised (PEP-R) Developmental Quotient was 66, indicating significant developmental delay.(Footnote 7) Her Cognitive Verbal and Cognitive Performance AE scores were 30 months and 23 months, respectively. Her fine- and gross-motor AE scores were 25 and 24 months, respectively. She obtained the following Developmental Profile II AE scores: Physical, 30 months; Social, 18-24 months; and Self-Help, 28 months. A sensory integration screening completed by STUDENT’S mother indicated sensory processing delays in all of the sensory systems covered. Noting autistic characteristics and significantly impaired communication skills, the report recommended special education eligibility for multiple disabilities and placement in the integrated preschool (IPS) class, with speech therapy, consultative OT to address sensory needs, and the extended day program (EDP) providing small-group and individual instruction.
At a May 9, 2002 individualized education plan (IEP) meeting, the preschool team assessment report was reviewed. The parents disagreed with the District’s assessment and requested an independent assessment. The IEP meeting ended before goals and objectives and placement were discussed, over the parents’ objection. (Testimony of Mr. Anderson, MOTHER.) A May 21, 2002 IEP meeting was held without the parents present. The May 21 IEP provides for placement in a Woodstock IPS class and EDP; direct and collaborative, in-class and/or pull-out speech therapy; in-class consultative OT; in-home parent education; and an ESY program. The IEP contains proposed goals and objectives in the academic and preacademic, self-help, prewriting and fine motor, gross motor, and communication areas. On May 22, 2002, the parents were sent a copy of the May 21 IEP, with a request that they sign it if they approved. On May 22 and 23, 2002, respectively, the District and the Student submitted due process hearing requests. The Student’s request to consolidate the two cases was granted.
In a June 2002 independent developmental assessment, clinical psychologist Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., administered to STUDENT the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scales of Intelligence-Revised (WPPSI-R); the Differential Abilities Scales (DAS); the NEPSY, a developmental neuropsychological test; several Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement (Woodcock-Johnson), third edition, subtests; and some sensorimotor and visuospatial processing tasks. She concurred with the prior autism diagnosis and found mild to moderate motor and sensory processing difficulties. She recommended an intensive one-to-one program to address learning, behavioral, language, and social-emotional difficulties; individual speech therapy; and OT. A July 2002 OT report by Ms. Frauwirth found continuing tactile defensiveness and also vestibular (sense of movement) processing difficulties, both of which can affect bilateral integration, visual-motor skills, and self-regulation ability. She recommended continued OT. An August 2002 BIA progress report states that STUDENT had made marked progress and recommended continued 30 hours weekly of services (15 hours one-to-one home instruction and 15 hours one-to-one aide services at her preschool) and several weekly facilitated play sessions with typical peers. The report also recommended continued speech therapy and OT.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Should the Student’s special education eligibility category be changed to autism from multiple disabilities (autism, speech and language impairment, and developmental delays)?
It is undisputed that STUDENT is eligible for early childhood special education services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.11. The May 9 and May 21, 2002 IEPs indicate that she qualified for special education services because of a multiple disability (autism, speech and language impairment, and developmental delays)(Footnote 8). (Stud. Exhs. 23, 27.) Her eligibility because of autism is not at issue. Rather, the Student contends that the District erroneously found her eligible for special education as being mentally retarded, in addition to autistic, and that her eligibility category should be solely autism.(Footnote 9) The District claims that STUDENT meets the mental retardation criteria because she is functioning in the mentally retarded range and that it is necessary to consider her needs stemming from cognitive delay in addition to autism.
A preschool child, between the ages of 3 and 5 years, may qualify for early childhood special education services because of mental retardation. Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.11(b)(1)(E). To qualify as mentally retarded, a child must have “significantly below average general intellectual functioning existing concurrently with deficits in adaptive behavior and manifested during the developmental period.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(h).
The May 2002 IEPs do not mention mental retardation, only developmental delays. However, the District appears to treat the two as synonymous. In the District’s assessment report, school psychologist Mr. Mushaney stated that STUDENT’S 66 PEP-R Developmental Quotient (DQ) indicated significant developmental delay and that she was functioning in the mentally retarded range and would qualify for special education in that category. He stated that the DQ was consistent with previous assessment results, specifically, the 69 Bayley Mental Developmental Index (MDI) obtained by the November 2001 CHO assessment. He recommended special education eligibility because of multiple disabilities: “Developmental Delay/Mental Retardation,” speech and language delay, and autism.(Footnote 10)
The CHO assessment conducted by a clinical child psychologist and a developmental pediatrician diagnosed, in part, autistic disorder and developmental delay. They noted, however, that the MDI may not reflect STUDENT’S true cognitive ability because many of the test items were language-based, and she had limited language skills. They noted varied cognitive abilities, with strengths in concrete rote knowledge and weaknesses in social and motor integration with her knowledge. They also pointed out the subarea AE score range, for example, 21 or 22 to 35 months in the language and cognitive areas when she was age 30 months. Independent clinical psychologist Dr. Lenington emphasized that the scatter, or range, in test scores, including above age-level scores, indicated that STUDENT was not mentally retarded. According to Dr. Lenington, a mentally retarded child has a flat profile, that is, depressed scores across domains, or assessment areas. The CHO assessors stated that although STUDENT’S overall results revealed slowed learning, the pattern of cognitive abilities was typical of autistic children. Dr. Lenington has conducted psychological assessments of children for over ten years, including about three years at the University of California at Los Angeles Infant and Preschool Clinic, where she supervised the administration of standardized tests (with a primary diagnostic purpose) to children, at least 70 percent of whom were autistic. She also worked with a professor on a UCLA research project assessing the cognitive development of children age six months to 3-1/2 years. She has received training in the assessment of preschool autistic children and has assessed hundreds of them. (Testimony of Dr. Lenington.) Given her considerable experience assessing children, particularly preschool autistic children, the Hearing Officer gives great weight to her testimony. Even on the PEP-R, STUDENT’S AE scores in the 7 domains (from which the DQ was derived) ranged from 19 months for Imitation to 48 months for Perception when she was age 35 months. Her 23-month Cognitive Performance and 30-month Cognitive Verbal AE scores showed variability also.(Footnote 11)
Notably, developmental delay is an eligibility category for infants and toddlers between birth up to age 3, but not for preschool children age 3 to 5. Cal. Code Reg. tit. 17, § 52022; Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.11.(Footnote 12) Thus, at age 3, STUDENT could not be eligible for special education because of developmental delay, although she could be eligible because of mental retardation. According to Mr. Mushaney, she is functioning in the mentally retarded range and may qualify for the mental retardation eligibility category, but the evidence does not support this conclusion at this time. No assessment has diagnosed STUDENT with mental retardation, and Mr. Mushaney acknowledged that the mental retardation diagnosis is made only when a cognitive delay persists over time, and generally not before age 7 or 8. Under the Education Code classification, deficits in adaptive skills must accompany significantly below-average general intellectual functioning. The District’s assessment report indicated that STUDENT’S adaptive skills displayed a scatter, with “relative strength in her physical skills [30-month AE score] and significant weaknesses in socialization skills [18-24 month AE score].” With the scatter in both her cognitive and adaptive skills and lack of persistent delayed cognitive functioning to age 7 (since she is still only 3-1/2), the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that STUDENTmeets the eligibility criteria for mental retardation at this time. Further, speech and language delay is a characteristic of autism and does not form a separate basis for the speech and language impairment eligibility category. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(g). Therefore, the IEP shall be modified to reflect the change in STUDENT’S eligibility classification from multiple disabilities to autism.
ISSUE 2: Was the District’s April 2002 preschool team assessment of the Student appropriate?
The appropriateness of the District’s assessment is governed by the requirements commencing at California Education Code section 56320. Tests and other assessment materials must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b). The pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development; hearing; motor abilities; language function; general ability; academic performance; self-help; orientation and mobility skills; and social and emotional status. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The assessment shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). No single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a special education child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e). Moreover, psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56324. Assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322. Personnel who assess the pupil shall prepare a written report of the results of the assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56327. The report shall include relevant behavior noted during observation in an appropriate setting and its relationship to the child’s academic and social functioning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56327(c), (d).
An initial matter is the timeliness of the District’s proposed assessment plan. The February 22, 2002 transition IFSP states that the mother requested OT (sensory integration), developmental, and speech and language assessments. (Dist. Exh. 28.) The February 22 transition IFSP constituted a referral for an assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56029. District director of pupil personnel services Dr. Wax was present at the meeting and signed the transition IFSP on the District’s behalf. However, the District did not present an assessment plan to the parent until March 29, 2002. (Stud. Exh. 34; Testimony of Mr. Mushaney.) Thus, it failed to comply with the requirement that a written proposed assessment plan be given to the parent within 15 days of a referral for an assessment.(Footnote 13) Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).
The Student contends, in essence, that the District’s preschool team assessment was inappropriate in that the District failed to assess all areas of suspected disability, such as the speech and language and social-emotional areas, and the PEP-R was not administered by trained personnel in accordance with test instructions. The District disagrees.
a. Areas of Suspected Disability (1) Speech and Language. Initially, adherence to the procedural requirements with regard to the speech and language assessment will be addressed. In the February 22, 2002 transition IFSP, the mother had requested a speech and language assessment. However, the District’s March 29, 2002 proposed assessment plan provided for assessment of communication development by the preschool team but not a formal speech and language assessment. (Stud. Exh. 34.) The law required that the District either present the parent with an assessment plan for a speech and language assessment within 15 days of her February 22 request, pursuant to California Education Code section 56321(a), or provide prior written notice of its refusal to conduct a speech and language assessment, pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). The notice must include, among other things, a description of the action; an explanation for the refusal to take the requested action; other options considered and rejected and the reasons; each test, record, or report used as a basis for the refusal; and other relevant factors. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(c). The District failed to provide the prior written notice and thus violated the statutory requirement.
The Student asserts that speech and language was an area of suspected disability that the District failed to assess. Speech and language was clearly an area of suspected disability for STUDENT. The September 2001 CHO speech and language assessment by speech pathologist Casey Rider found that when STUDENT was age 28 months, her Rosetti Language Comprehension and Language Expression AE scores were both 12 to 15 months, with scatter higher, indicating moderate receptive and expressive language delays. Informal observation revealed a mild articulation delay. Ms. Casey recommended speech therapy to address expressive vocabulary, verbal imitation skills, verbal comprehension, and articulation. The April 2002 Small Voices early intervention program report set forth STUDENT’S HELP Strand language scores when she was age 34 months as follows: Receptive Language, 23-24 months, with scatter higher; and Expressive Language Skills, 22-24 months, with scatter higher.(Footnote 14) The report recommended speech therapy. Even District speech pathologist Ms. Sonneman testified that she recommended speech and language services for STUDENT because of a language delay and articulation errors.
The question is whether the District adequately assessed this area of suspected disability. The District contends generally that it conducted a comprehensive assessment which considered all areas related to the suspected disability. District speech pathologist Ms. Sonneman was part of the preschool team that assessed STUDENT. Her portion of the assessment report is headed “Language Development” and “Communication.” Her part of the assessment included a review of records; an April 2002 conversation with STUDENT’S then-current speech pathologist, Ms. Thompson; behavioral observations, including observations during the play portion of the PEP-R administration; and administration of the “language areas” of the PEP-R. (Dist. Exh. 20; Testimony of Ms. Sonneman.) However, the PEP-R does not provide a language domain score, and the assessment report is not clear as to the domains in which Ms. Sonneman administered test items to STUDENT.(Footnote 15) She testified that of the seven domains for which scores are reported, the Cognitive Verbal domain is primarily the language part of the PEP-R. However, she further testified that the Cognitive Verbal 30-month AE score (when STUDENT was age 35 months) did not indicate a severe delay because that domain tested not only language, but also cognitive ability.
Ms. Sonneman testified that the PEP-R is not a speech and language test and that she did not administer any speech and language or articulation tests to STUDENT. She acknowledged that the District’s assessment yielded no scores for expressive or receptive language or articulation and no separate language score at all. She testified that she did not administer a standardized speech and language test like the Preschool Language Scale, which can be used to assess the receptive and expressive language of children from birth to age 6, because, at STUDENT’S level, she would be able to complete little of the test. Ms. Sonneman instead preferred to base her assessment on observations. (She testified that she did not discuss any PEP-R scores in her portion of the report but only reported her observations.) She testified that she also reported on her conversation with STUDENT’S speech therapist, Ms. Thompson, but acknowledged that Ms. Thompson did not have standardized test data on STUDENT. In describing STUDENT’S language functioning level, Ms. Sonneman testified that her language was delayed, she exhibited a severe expressive language delay compared to a moderate receptive language delay, and some of her articulation errors were age-appropriate. However, her conclusion about expressive-versus-receptive language was not consistent with other assessment reports. The September 2001 CHO speech and language assessment and the April 2002 HELP Strand scores indicated receptive and expressive language skills to be essentially at the same level. Moreover, she was the only assessor who noted age-appropriate articulation errors, and in her report she in fact found articulation delays and, like other assessors, recommended working on improving articulation.(Footnote 16)
One of the characteristics set forth in the special education eligibility criteria for autistic disorder is an “inability to use oral language for appropriate communication.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(g). Speech and language was a critical area of deficit for STUDENT, as identified by multiple assessors, and assessing this area of suspected disability required using test instruments that would provide standard or age-equivalent language scores to ascertain the progress, if any, that she had made since the September 2001 speech and language assessment and also her areas of need. Her language skills had been formally assessed in the past, and there was no evidence that she could not participate in the PEP-R standardized testing. Thus, relying on the PEP-R, which yielded no language score; observation; and a conversation with STUDENT’S speech pathologist was not an adequate assessment of this area. Because the District did not formally assess this area of suspected disability, its assessment was inappropriate.
(2) Social-Emotional Area. The Student further asserts that the social-emotional area was an area of suspected disability that the District failed to assess.(Footnote 17) In the November 2001 CHO developmental assessment when STUDENTwas age 30 months, she obtained an 11-month Bayley Social-Emotional subarea AE score and an 11-month Vineland Socialization domain score. According to the April 2002 Small Voices report, at age 34 months, STUDENT obtained a HELP Strand Social-Emotional Skills AE score of 24 months, with scatter higher. Thus, the social-emotional area was an area of suspected disability for STUDENT.
The District’s March 29, 2002 assessment plan provided for an assessment of “social/adaptive behavior.” Special education teacher Ms. Walters wrote the portion of the assessment report dealing with the social-emotional and self-help areas. It is undisputed that she did not administer any part of the PEP-R, was not present during its administration, and, according to her testimony, has not even seen STUDENT for more than a couple of minutes when she was leaving with her father after the second testing day. Moreover, the PEP-R does not provide a score for either the social-emotional or adaptive area. Ms. Walters’ report states that the assessment method was a telephone conversation with STUDENT’S then-current teacher, Susan Campodonico at Small Voices. Because she administered no test instruments to assess the social-emotional area, Ms. Walters provided no standard or age-equivalent scores for this area.(Footnote 18) Her report recounts her conversation with Ms. Campodonico in describing STUDENT in the social-emotional area. According to Ms. Campodonico, STUDENT initiated and maintained interactions with familiar adults, for example, by playing simple games. She was starting to initiate interactions with peers in a prescribed way, although she did not necessarily face them when addressing them. (Previously, she would leave the area when they approached.) Her greatest difficulty was during free-choice time, when she had to cope with sharing and trading with peers. This, in essence, is the extent of Ms. Walters’ “assessment” of STUDENT’S social-emotional area.
However, in another portion of the assessment report, school psychologist Mr. Mushaney sets forth the results of the Developmental Profile II, an interview questionnaire administered to the mother when STUDENT was age 34 months. On this interview tool, STUDENT obtained a Social domain AE score of 18-24 months, similar to the April 2002 HELP Social-Emotional 24-month AE score. Mr. Mushaney noted that STUDENT would observe the activities of others, tended not to initiate interactions with peers, and was not playing games with other children even with adult supervision. She imitated household activities she observed her parent carry out and was starting to engage in more functional and symbolic play. The District’s overall assessment of the social area confirmed the delay in social skills revealed by the April 2002 Small Voices report and set forth some of the parameters of STUDENT’S social skills and needs in this area. The Hearing Officer finds that the District adequately assessed this area of suspected disability. b. Administration of PEP-R
The Student first contends generally that the preschool team members lacked the requisite qualifications to administer the PEP-R. A team consisting of school psychologist Mr. Mushaney, speech pathologist Ms. Sonneman, occupational therapist Ms. Auston, and special education teacher Patricia Rannefeld administered the PEP-R to STUDENT. State law requires that “individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning . . . be administered by a credentialed school psychologist.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b)(3). The question is whether the assessment team members other than Mr. Mushaney lacked the requisite qualifications to administer the PEP-R. As noted above, the PEP-R did not assess emotional-functioning. Further, independent clinical psychologist Dr. Lenington testified that the PEP-R’s purpose is not to determine intelligence. According to Mr. Mushaney, the PEP-R provides information about different developmental areas to help develop a program for the child. From the testimony of Mr. Mushaney and Dr. Lenington, it appears that the PEP-R does not necessarily assess intellectual functioning. Both testified that “intelligence” and “development” are theoretical constructs of what a test measures; some tests purport to test intelligence and others development. The PEP-R provides a developmental, not an intelligence, quotient. Further, no evidence was presented that only a credentialed school psychologist or other psychologist is qualified to administer the PEP-R. Thus, this statutory requirement was not violated.
Next, the Student contends that the preschool team members lacked the necessary training to administer the PEP-R and failed to administer the test pursuant to the test manual. Tests must be “administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b)(3). The testimony of team members Mr. Mushaney, Ms. Sonneman, and Ms. Auston was that they did not receive specific training in administering the PEP-R but that they read the instructions in the test manual, practiced, and followed the instructions in administering the test items. Ms. Auston testified that she obtained the test equipment, went over the wording of test items, and read the profiles as to the criteria for passing and emerging skills. Ms. Rannefeld, a Woodstock IPS special education teacher during the 2001-2002 school year, also administered some of the PEP-R test items, but she did not testify, and her training and preparation for administering the PEP-R are unknown. Dr. Lenington testified that becoming qualified to administer the PEP-R requires not only reading the test manual but also doing several training tapes and five supervised PEP-R administrations.(Footnote 19) The preschool assessment team members did not testify that they had used training tapes or had done any supervised PEP-R administrations. Mr. Mushaney testified that he had administered the PEP-R five times, to preschool children, but no evidence was presented that the PEP-R administrations were supervised. Even if he substantially met the training requirement by having administered the PEP-R four or five times prior to STUDENT’S assessment, there was no evidence that the other team members met these requirements.
Mr. Mushaney further testified that the PEP-R can be administered by one individual or two or more individuals. The testimony of three team members who administered the PEP-R was that one person presented the tasks or test items to STUDENT and another person took notes and marked the scores on the score sheet. After each of the two testing sessions, the team members went over the scores and also did the behavior items on the test protocols, which were separate from the tasks on the test. (Testimony of Mr. Mushaney.) Dr. Lenington, however, found problematic the administration of test items by pairs of team members, with one member presenting the items and another scoring. She testified that, for example, a speech pathologist might not know if a child passes a fine-motor item falling within the OT area. She stated that consistency of the person taking notes and making observations is important and that all assessors need proper training in the administration and interpretation of the entire test. More importantly, according to her, it is difficult for a preschool child to interact with four different assessors, and having assessors switch back and forth in their roles was not a good practice. While Mr. Mushaney testified that the PEP-R could be administered by more than one person, there was no evidence that a division of labor between two assessors on given test items was permitted by the test manual.
The District had the obligation to show that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). As discussed above, Dr. Lenington has considerable experience assessing and supervising the assessment of preschool children, specifically preschool autistic children, and she testified about the training she had received in administering a variety of standardized tests to preschool children. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds her testimony persuasive in this matter. Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer determines that the evidence failed to establish that the preschool team members had the requisite training to administer the PEP-R and administered it pursuant to the test manual.
Finally, the personnel who assess a child must prepare a written report of the assessment results. Cal. Educ. Code § 56327. It is undisputed that special education teacher Ms. Rannefeld administered some of the PEP-R test items. (Stud. Exh. 61; e.g., Testimony of Ms. Auston.) However, there is no evidence that she participated in preparing the assessment report, including her observations during the testing, as the other team members did, and in fact, she is not even mentioned in the report. Thus, the team assessment report failed to meet this requirement. For the reasons discussed above, the District’s team assessment was inappropriate.
ISSUE 3: Did the District offer the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment from May 22, 2002 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the summer 2002 extended school year (ESY) session?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A FAPE is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from special education). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 198-99, 200-01 (1982), the United States Supreme Court held that the IDEA provides students with disabilities with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit” but stated that these services need not maximize each child’s potential.
An early education program for children with disabilities aged 3 to 5 shall include “specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.2. The program “shall include both individual and small group services which shall be available in a variety of typical age-appropriate environments for young children, including the home, and shall include opportunities for active parent involvement.” Id. In addition, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that a child be removed from the regular education environment only when the nature or severity of the child’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
The IDEA also requires the State and local educational agencies to guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). In Rowley, the Supreme Court stated: “It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents . . . a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” 458 U.S. at 205-06 (citation omitted). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes or refuses to initiate or to change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: whether the District (1) has complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA and (2) has offered an appropriate educational program. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07. When STUDENT turned 3 years old on May 22, 2002, the District became responsible for providing her a FAPE. Up to then, she had been attending the Small Voices early intervention program and was receiving speech therapy, OT, and one-to-one BIA home intervention services, all funded by the RCEB. She contends that from May 22, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 ESY session, she was denied a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds.
A. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
The Student argues that the District denied her a FAPE on procedural grounds by holding the May 21, 2002 IEP meeting without her parents present.(Footnote 20) Under federal and State law, the District must take steps to ensure that at least one parent is present at each IEP meeting or is afforded the opportunity to participate, including giving notice of the meeting early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend and scheduling the meeting at a mutually agreed-upon time and place. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a)-(c). If neither parent can attend, the District shall use other methods to ensure parent participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f). A meeting may be conducted without a parent present if the District “is unable to convince the parents that they should attend.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(d); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g). In this event, the District must maintain a “record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed on time and place.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(d); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).(Footnote 21) It is undisputed that the District held the May 21, 2002 IEP meeting without the parents present. The May 9, 2002 IEP meeting had ended without a discussion of goals and objectives and program and services. In a May 14, 2002 letter to the parents, a copy of which was faxed to the Student’s attorney, District program specialist Mr. Anderson (administrator designee for STUDENT’S IEP meeting) stated that the District wished to schedule another IEP meeting to complete the IEP before STUDENT’S third birthday on May 22, 2002, and offered two dates for the meeting, Monday, May 20, 2002, or Tuesday, May 21, 2002, at 1:00 p.m. He requested a response agreeing to a date by 12:00 p.m. on Friday, May 17, 2002. Mr. Anderson testified that before he wrote the May 14 letter, he probably checked with District staff regarding their availability for the next IEP meeting. In a May 15, 2002 letter to the District, the Student’s attorney, Mr. Lewis, stated that, despite the parents’ objections, the District had refused to complete the prior IEP meeting and now had decided unilaterally to reconvene the meeting on May 20 or 21. He stated that because of prior commitments, the parents could not attend an IEP meeting on fewer than three business days’ notice. He noted, however, that the parents did “insist” on being involved in any IEP meeting. Mr. Anderson testified that because STUDENT’S third birthday was near, the decision was made to send notice of the scheduled IEP meeting. The District sent a notice dated May 17, 2002, informing the parents that the IEP meeting was scheduled for May 21, 2002, at 1:00 p.m. After the District held the May 21 IEP meeting without the parents, a copy of the May 21 IEP was sent to them with the request that they sign it if they approved.
The mother testified that the parents received Mr. Anderson’s May 14 letter, sent by certified mail, on May 15 or 16, 2002. Service providers and other individuals invited by the mother had attended the May 9 IEP meeting, and after she received the letter, she contacted them about their availability on either May 20 or 21. Not all of them were available on those dates. She also had speech therapy and doctor’s appointments and a BIA session for STUDENT on Monday and the Small Voices program in the morning and BIA session in the afternoon on Tuesday. The mother testified that she did not receive the notice of the scheduled May 21 IEP meeting until Saturday, May 18. Thus, she had short notice to attempt to find someone to cover for her at the BIA session. She testified that between May 9 and the date that the parents received Mr. Anderson’s May 14 letter, no one from the District contacted her regarding IEP dates. After Mr. Lewis’s letter was sent to the District, no one contacted her about IEP dates.
Mr. Anderson testified that after he received Mr. Lewis’s letter, he did not call the parents directly because they were being represented by an attorney. He testified that his May 14 letter gave the parents three business days to respond. However, even if the parents received his letter on May 15, they had only about one-and-a-half to two days to respond by 12 noon on May 17. He testified that he asked for a response by May 17 so that the staff could arrange their schedules. He acknowledged, however, that the May 17 notice of IEP meeting (which the parents received on May 18) gave them only one business day before the Tuesday, May 21 meeting.
The District must take the necessary steps to afford the parents the opportunity to attend each IEP meeting by giving sufficient notice of the meeting and scheduling the meeting at a mutually agreed-upon time and place. Here, there is no evidence that the meeting was scheduled for a mutually agreed-upon date. Further, the notice gave the parents little time to rearrange their schedules and obtain the presence at the IEP meeting of service providers and other persons. Parents have the right to bring to the IEP meeting individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the child with a disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(c). That right is meaningless without sufficient notice to obtain the presence of these individuals.
Moreover, if the parents are unable to attend an IEP meeting, the District must use other means to ensure their participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. Mr. Anderson testified that he did not offer the parents a conference call for the May 21 IEP meeting. He testified that at the May 21 meeting, he did not recall discussing calling the parents, and his telephone contact log contained no entries to the parents for the May 21 IEP meeting. The mother testified that on May 21, no one from the District called, came by the home, or left a message on the answering machine. There is no evidence that the District used other means such as a telephone call to ensure the parents’ participation.
In its brief, the District suggests that the parents failed to make a good-faith effort to attend the May 21 IEP meeting so as to place the District in a legal bind by not offering a placement before STUDENT’S third birthday. However, when the mother still had not heard from the District about a month after the February 22, 2002 transition IFSP meeting at which she had requested assessments of STUDENT, she made a written inquiry about the status of the District’s assessment. (Stud. Exh. 36.) It appears that the mother was more than willing to have the assessments completed in timely fashion. If the District’s assessment had been conducted earlier, the time between the IEP meeting and STUDENT’S third birthday might have not have been so short. Thus, it is disingenuous for the District to attempt to place blame on the parents.
Special education law emphasizes the important role that parents play in developing their child’s IEP and in determining a placement for their child. See, e.g., 20 U.S.C. § 1414(f); 34 C.F.R.§ 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a)-(c). The Hearing Officer finds from the evidence presented that the District committed a procedural violation which seriously infringed upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the formulation of the IEP and thus denied the Student a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484. Because the District held an IEP meeting and offered STUDENT a program and services, it is necessary to determine the appropriateness of its offer in order to fashion appropriate remedies. Thus, the Hearing Officer will now turn to substantive FAPE.
B. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 ESY session, it is necessary to address whether its proposed program (1) was designed to meet her unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to confer benefit, (3) conformed with the IEP, and (4) was designed to provide all of the above in the LRE. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. IEP meetings were convened on May 9 and 21, 2002. The parents disagreed with the District’s proffered program in the May 21 IEP and began paying for a private preschool with a one-to-one BIA aide, one-to-one BIA home services, speech therapy, and OT for STUDENT.
May 22, 2002 to the End of the 2001-2002 Regular School Year
The Student argues, in effect, that she was denied a FAPE from May 22, 2002 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year in that the IEP fails to contain her present levels of performance and appropriate goals and objectives and fails to offer an appropriate program and services.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a program that was designed to meet her unique needs, the first step is to identify her needs. The Hearing Officer determined above that her eligibility category should be solely autism and should not include mental retardation. There was little disagreement about her deficits as set forth in the speech and language, developmental, OT, BIA, and preschool team assessment reports and Small Voices and BIA reports. While she has shown some improvement over the past year with the interventions and services she has received, she continues to have essentially the same deficits discussed below. A September 2001 speech and language assessment found that STUDENT had moderate receptive and expressive language delays and a mild articulation-phonological skill delay. When she was age 28 months, her October 2001 Gesell AE scores were as follows: Language, 16 months; Gross Motor, 21.5 months; Fine Motor, 18 months; Personal-Social, 14.5 months; and Adaptive, 15 months. She had little communicative language and limited eye contact, would not follow verbal instructions, and had difficulty connecting with adults and other children. In November 2001, she was diagnosed with mild to moderate autism, developmental delay, hypotonia, and sensory processing issues. Her Bayley Mental Developmental Index (MDI) was 69, with a 23-month AE score, when she was age 30 months. She showed mild deficits in the communication and socialization domains. Her motor skills and daily living skills were in the moderately low range. As in the October assessment, her 11-month Social-Emotional AE score was her lowest score. A December 2001 OT sensory processing assessment found sensory defensiveness and sensory modulation difficulties. Unable to tolerate certain textures, she had a limited food repertoire. She exhibited decreased muscle tone throughout and used proprioceptive (joint and muscle sense) input, such as jumping, to calm herself when overstimulated.
In April 2002, at age 34 months, STUDENT obtained the following HELP Strand AE scores: Receptive Language, 23-24 months; Expressive Language, 22-24 months; Gross Motor, 24-36 months, Fine Motor, 24 months; Social-Emotional, 24 months; and Self-Help, 24 months. Her April 2002 PEP-R Developmental Quotient (DQ) was 66, at the 23-month level, and her gross and fine motor scores were comparable to the HELP scores. Her 48-month PEP-R AE score revealed an area of strength, but her 18-24 Social AE score on the Developmental Profile II indicated that this continued to be a deficit area for her. The preschool team noted overall developmental functioning and cognitive, gross-motor, and fine-motor skills to be well below age expectations. STUDENT’S communication skills were significantly impaired. Her level of social withdrawal and behavioral abnormalities was relatively less impaired. Her adaptive skills showed a relative strength in physical skills and significant weakness in socialization skills.
In a June 2002 assessment by Dr. Lenington, on one Woodcock-Johnson subtest, STUDENT readily named the upper- and lower-case letters presented to her except for “b” and “U.” She obtained a 78 NEPSY language standard score, in the borderline range. No other domain scores were derived because of her difficulty understanding directives. Dr. Lenington concurred with the prior diagnosis of autistic disorder given her impairments in social relationships, communication, behavior, and difficulty with change and transition. As the November 2001 CHO developmental assessment found, she indicated that STUDENT had mild to moderate motor and sensory processing difficulties. Dr. Lenington testified that STUDENT needs individual attention because she tries to get out of doing things. In July 2002, STUDENT continued to show tactile defensiveness and also vestibular (sense of movement) processing difficulties and continued to seek heavy proprioceptive input to help her organize when overstimulated.
An area of difference was STUDENT’S cognitive ability. In June 2002, she obtained WPPSI-R IQ scores of 72, Verbal; 74, Performance; and Full Scale, 70.(Footnote 22) She obtained DAS standard scores of General Cognitive Ability, 86; Language composite score, 85; and Nonverbal composite score, 89.(Footnote 23) However, the WPPSI-R IQ scores, while higher, are not markedly discrepant from the Bayley MDI or PEP-R DQ. Further, although there was disagreement about her IQ or DQ scores, her serious needs as set forth above were not disputed.
Because of the above deficits, STUDENT had the following agreed-upon instructional needs. She required a structured, consistent program; intensive intervention services, including at least some one-to-one discrete trial instruction; speech therapy; and OT. She required typical peers with whom she could interact and who could serve as models. There was disagreement about the nature and amount of intensive intervention services and the type of speech therapy and OT that STUDENT required, but because these matters are intertwined with the specific proposed program and services, they will be addressed in the discussion of program and services below.
Next, it is necessary to examine the IEP to determine whether the District’s proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
(a) Present Levels of Performance
A May 9, 2002 IEP, signed by the parents “attendance only,” indicates under “Review Present Levels of Performance” on a preprinted page headed “Agenda” that Mr. Mushaney presented the team report.(Footnote 24) The IEP notes indicate that preschool team members Mr. Mushaney, Ms. Walters, Ms. Auston, and Ms. Sonneman reviewed their portions of the assessment report. The May 21, 2002 IEP, unsigned by the parents, is actually the May 9 IEP, with additional information and pages. On the page for present levels of performance, in the areas of cognitive functioning, academic-preacademic skills, social-emotional functioning, speech-language and communication skills, psychomotor abilities, and self-help/adult living skills, the notation “See Attached” is typed. However, the May 21 IEP does not contain an attachment. (Dist. Exh. 27.)
The IEP must set forth the student’s present levels of performance, including how the disability affects her involvement and progress in the regular education curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1)(i). The District’s assessment team witnesses testified that the IEP referred to the team assessment report for STUDENT’S present levels of functioning. Some District witnesses also testified that the present levels could be found in the baselines for the goals. However, as Ms. Walters testified, the goals are kept to a manageable number and thus do not address the range of a child’s needs. If referral to an assessment report or the baselines for goals could substitute for a statement of a child’s present levels of performance, this IEP requirement would, in effect, be nullified. That would be contrary to the intent of the law. Moreover, a referral to the District’s assessment report would not incorporate the input of the parents and current service providers in determining the child’s present levels of functioning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(3), (c)(2). The absence of STUDENT’S present levels of performance in the IEP violated the statutory requirement. Further, other parts of the IEP (such as the goals and objectives and special education and related services) must address the deficiencies identified by the statement of present levels of educational performance. See 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 36 (1996). Thus, this omission affected other components of the IEP.
(b) IEP Goals and Objectives
Proposed goals and objectives dated May 9, 2002, were presented to the parents but were not discussed at the May 9 IEP meeting. (Stud. Exh. 26; e.g., Testimony of Mr. Mushaney.) The May 21 IEP contains goals and objectives in the academic and preacademic, social-emotional, self-help, prewriting and fine motor, gross motor, and communication areas.
The Student argues that the goals and objectives are inappropriate because they are vague and unmeasurable and are not tailored to her level of functioning. At the hearing, BIA program director Ms. Kern testified about the District’s proposed goals and objectives.(Footnote 25) She had been working with STUDENT since February 2002 and had developed the curriculum for her BIA program. Ms. Kern and the program manager decide on the activities for the tutors to work on with STUDENT, but Ms. Kern has responsibility for making changes to her program. A data book contains quantitative and qualitative data about her activities in the targeted areas, including a weekly summary. Ms. Kern does a 2-hour hands-on session with STUDENT twice monthly, working with the assigned staff. (Testimony of Ms. Kern.) Ms. Kern’s testimony about the District’s goals and objectives was based upon a document dated May 22, 2002, in which she gave feedback to the mother on the District’s goals and objectives, and her testimony below thus incorporates by reference information in this document.(Footnote 26) (Stud. Exh. 22.) The discussion of Ms. Kern’s testimony synthesizes her testimony regarding the May 9 and May 21 goals and objectives that were essentially the same. (Stud. Exh. 26; Dist. Exh. 27.)
Regarding academic and preacademic goals, Mr. Mushaney testified that the basis for objective 1 (give one of an item) of goal 1 (give the correct number of items up to 3) was that STUDENT had failed a PEP-R counting task. According to him, the team assessment report states that she needed to “develop higher order reasoning skills (e.g., counting, sorting)” because she could count verbally but not objects. Ms. Walters acknowledged, however, that the assessment report does not state that STUDENT did not understand the concept of one. Ms. Kern testified that by May 2002, STUDENT had already achieved goal 1 in limited contexts (i.e., not yet generalized to all settings) and had achieved not only objective 1 but also objectives 2 and 3 (match two sets of items and count up to 3 objects).
Special education teacher Ms. Walters testified that the basis for goal 2 (group 3 sets of objects by color, shape, and size) was that the assessment report indicated difficulty with sorting, but she acknowledged that a March 13, 2002 Daily Notes entry in STUDENT’S BIA data log indicating that she had matched five pictures did not support having objective 1 (match 5 sets of pictures and/or objects). (Stud. Exh. 68.) The November 2001 CHO developmental assessment report also had noted that at that time, STUDENT understood the matching of colors and shapes. (Dist. Exh. 23.) Ms. Kern testified that STUDENT had already achieved goal 2 and all 3 objectives. Ms. Kern further testified that STUDENT had already achieved objectives 1 and 2 (imitate 5 gross- and 5 fine-motor movements and 5 actions with objects) and goal 3 (imitate 5 simple play schemes). According to Ms. Kern, STUDENT could imitate sounds associated with functions (e.g., drink from a cup and slurp) on 3 out of 5 occasions, though not 4 out of 5 trials as required by objective 3, and thus this goal did not need to be continued after May 9, 2002.
Ms. Kern testified that by May 2002, STUDENT had surpassed the social-emotional goal to initiate social interactions with peers (she already joined peers 2 to 4 times per day, a higher rate than the twice daily required by the goal). She had achieved objectives 1 and 3 (interact with a peer in parallel play for 5 minutes and share a toy with a peer upon request and say “My turn” to receive a toy from a peer), though she may not wait 10 seconds before grabbing a toy from a peer, as required by the objective. According to Ms. Kern, even typical peers may not wait 10 seconds. She testified that objective 2 (respond appropriately to a peer’s social behavior, for example, by holding hands) was an appropriate area that BIA was working on and that by the November 2002 targeted date, STUDENT may have surpassed the criterion of 3 out of 5 opportunities.
As for the self-help goal (wash and dry her hands), Ms. Kern testified that STUDENThad already achieved objective 1 (tolerate her hands in water for 30 seconds) and that unlike the goal’s baseline (that STUDENT did not like her hands wet), BIA’s observation was that STUDENT had difficulty not with wet hands but with sticky or gooey substances on her hands. Ms. Auston testified that she did not write the self-help goal and did not like the baseline. The preschool assessment report indicates that STUDENT did not like to touch “messy” items, but there was no evidence that she did not like her hands wet. Ms. Kern noted that objective 2 and the goal (wash her hands independently and wash and dry her hands) were appropriate but that the objective could probably be reached much sooner than the March 2003 targeted date.
In the prewriting and fine-motor area, Ms. Kern testified that the May 21 goal (the same as the May 9 fine-motor goal) to improve fine-motor prewriting skills and objective 1 (exhibit functional grasp of a writing utensil) were appropriate but that the 100 percent criterion accuracy for the goal and 3 objectives was unrealistic in that even typical peers accomplish tasks with only about 80 percent accuracy. She testified that STUDENT had already achieved objective 2 (scribble randomly), though with a fist grasp, but that the objective did not specify a functional grasp, as in the prior objective. She testified that she was uncertain that she had observed STUDENT coloring within 1/4 inch of the margin of a 4-inch basic geometric shape, as required by objective 3.
Ms. Kern testified that the sensory processing and integration goal to improve the ability to integrate incoming sensory stimuli was appropriate but that objectives 1 and 3 (decrease tactile defensiveness and increase food repertoire to include a variety of textures and tastes) lacked objective measurable criteria to determine if they were met. As for objective 2 (request deep-tissue stimulation or brushing protocol when needed), Ms. Kern testified that it lacked identifiable antecedent behaviors indicating sensory processing difficulties to determine when STUDENT felt the need for these sensory organizing techniques. Ms. Kern testified that the goal to increase gross-motor skills from the current 24-month functioning level was appropriate but that the May 21 objective 1 (ascend stairs with alternating feet) did not specify the number of stairs required to meet the objective and the May 21 objective 2 (hop on one foot 3 or more times and kick a rolled ball 5 feet) contained the phrase, “no deviations,” which was unclear and made it difficult to measure whether the objective was met.
Regarding the communication area, Ms. Kern testified that goal 1 and objective 3 (greet peers by name and say good-bye to them) are appropriate but that the goal does not specify whether STUDENT was merely to respond to peers’ greetings or to initiate greetings, making it difficult to measure her level of achievement. She further testified that the 50 percent criterion accuracy level for the first 2 objectives was chance and did not indicate achievement of the skill. According to her, the level of accuracy should be 80 percent. Ms. Kern testified that goal 2, to develop a greater variety of carrier phrases (e.g., “I see” and the name of what she sees), addressed an appropriate area but did not specify a targeted number so that it would be difficult to know when the goal was met. She found objectives 1 and 3 (use the “I see” phrase and use the name of a person or animal with an action word) appropriate but noted that the 50 percent criterion level for objective 2 was too low, as discussed previously. Ms. Kern testified that goal 3 and the 3 objectives (use 1, 2, and then 5 or more known verbs with different known objects in pivot open phrases, for example, “open bag”) had already been achieved by May 9, 2002. She further testified that goal 4 (a new May 21 goal) to follow 2-step directions for a classroom activity spontaneously, with a May 2003 targeted date, was not appropriate because STUDENT was already following 2-step directions at home, and although Ms. Kern was not certain if this had been tested at the preschool, it might have taken STUDENT about a week to generalize to the school setting. The preschool assessment report states that in April 2002 STUDENT’S speech pathologist reported that she was starting to understand two-step commands in structured settings. A general criticism that Ms. Kern voiced was that most of the goals required achievement only in the preschool setting, not at home or in the community, so the skills may not be generalized across all settings.
The Hearing Officer found Ms. Kern to be credible and knowledgeable, with extensive training and experience in providing instructional services to develop the skills of autistic children and with in-depth knowledge of STUDENT’S BIA program and her progress in the program. Further, her BIA duties include developing and implementing IEP goals and objectives. Thus, the Hearing Officer places great weight on her testimony. The District’s goals and objectives were developed without input at the May 21 IEP meeting from the parents and service providers who had been working with STUDENT. Some were vague and unmeasurable, and STUDENT had already accomplished many by May 2002 so that they failed to address her still considerable needs. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were inappropriate.
(c) Placement, Program, and Services
The Student argues that the District failed to offer her an appropriate placement in the LRE, individual speech therapy, and direct OT to meet her needs. The May 21 IEP proposes the IPS class for 3 hours per day, five times weekly, and the EDP for 2.5 hours per day, five times weekly.(Footnote 27) School psychologist Mr. Mushaney testified that because STUDENT’S autism and developmental delays were mild, the District thought that the IPS class and EDP were adequate.
As noted above, there was disagreement about the nature and amount of intensive intervention services that STUDENT required. The District thought that the EDP offered adequate intensive services to meet STUDENT’S needs. The testimony of Mr. Mushaney and Ms. Walters was that the EDP, based upon TEACCH and ABA, provided intensive educational services for 2-1/2 hours daily through a combination of one-to-one DTT, small-group activities, and independent activities at work stations. The testimony of Dr. Lenington and Ms. Kern, however, established that to learn new skills, STUDENT required structure, consistency, and one-to-one instruction. No credible evidence was presented that STUDENT can learn basic skills in her areas of weakness (speech, language, social, play, motor, and sensory processing) in a group setting. Ms. Walters stated in the preschool team assessment report that, according to STUDENT’S teacher at the early intervention program, STUDENT responded well to the classroom routine, joined activities during table time, and appeared to enjoy school. However, there is no evidence that STUDENT was able to learn necessary language, social, and preacademic skills in a group setting. Ms. Walters’ report states that, according to the teacher, STUDENT had shown “growth” since November 2001, but by May 2002, when Ms. Walters spoke to the teacher, STUDENT had been receiving individual speech therapy since September 2001, direct OT since December 2001, and one-to-one BIA behavioral therapy since February 2002, in addition to small-group early intervention services since October 2001. According to BIA program director Ms. Kern, STUDENT had a relatively fast rate of acquisition of skills one-to-one with the discrete trial and other methods BIA used. The mother testified that STUDENT“bloomed” after she started receiving BIA services because an adult made her stay focused and pay attention and she learned language and play skills and started communicating with other children more. Moreover, Ms. Walters’ portion of the assessment report relied upon a telephone conversation with the teacher, not firsthand knowledge, since she did not observe STUDENT in the Small Voices setting.(Footnote 28)
In addition, Dr. Lenington, who spent about 16 hours assessing STUDENT and also observed her in her BIA behavioral therapy home program, testified that at this time, because of her multiple serious developmental problems, STUDENT required a substantial amount of one-to-one treatment to develop basic skills, including attending and compliance. She recommended a 40-hour one-to-one intensive behavioral program using ABA and DTT to address her learning, behavioral, language, and social-emotional needs. In addition, she testified that when the home program providers thought it appropriate, STUDENT should transition part-time to a regular education preschool with the support of a one-to-one aide who understood the components of her home program and goals and objectives. When asked whether STUDENT needed aide support, Ms. Walters testified that STUDENT required the support of an adult, whether an aide or a teacher. According to Dr. Lenington, with her developmental challenges and inclination to avoid tasks that are difficult or not of her choosing, STUDENT required a one-to-one aide to be able to learn in a preschool class setting. Because of Dr. Lenington’s considerable training and experience assessing preschool children with autism (discussed above); her extensive experience reviewing preschool programs, including ABA programs;(Footntoe 29( and the substantial amount of time she spent assessing and observing STUDENT(several times the approximately 2 or 3 hours spent by the entire preschool assessment team), the Hearing Officer places great weight on her testimony. From the evidence set forth above, including the testimony of Dr. Lenington, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required extensive one-to-one structured, consistent, and systematically presented instruction for her to learn basic skills in her developmental areas of weakness, and she required the services of a one-to-one aide in a preschool setting to benefit from the group setting. The Hearing Officer now turns to the District’s program.
(1) IPS Class. Two of the three IPS classes are taught by special education teachers, and the parties stipulated that STUDENT would have been placed in one of these two classes.(Footnote 30) The evidence was that during the 2001-2002 school year, the special education teachers were Ms. Walters and Ms. Rannefeld. Because the District offered STUDENT a placement in the IPS classes of two different teachers, the District would have offered a FAPE only if both classes were appropriate for STUDENT.(Footnote 31) Ms. Rannefeld is no longer with the District and did not testify.
Ms. Walters testified that the IPS class, for children age 3 to 5, is from 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon 5 days a week.(Footnote 32) There are two paraprofessional aides in each class. According to her, there are about 12 to 14 children in a class, one-half students with disabilities (such as Down syndrome, autism, hearing impairment, global developmental delays, and speech disorder) and the other half nondisabled students from the State preschool program. The IPS program begins with play time outside, where there are bicycles, blocks, and a sand box. The objective is to facilitate play or parallel play among the children, including taking turns and trading items. Next is snack time, when the children have assigned seats at tables. Then there is opening circle time, followed by small-group time, when the children work on a specific project such as coloring and cutting activities at a table with about 3 or 4 children to 1 adult. Next is free-choice time, when the children can choose to work on activities set up in different areas of the classroom. After a closing circle time, the children leave for the bus or the EDP. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.) Ms. Walters testified that when a child with a disability enters her class, she observes the child for a couple of days and then looks at the IEP progress notes to determine where the child is with regard to level of skills and IEP goals and objectives. On her classroom matrix, she will determine the most appropriate time for her or an aide to practice the goals and objectives. Weekly, she talks to the speech therapist and occupational therapist in class about the students’ progress and discusses with the aides progress toward the goals and any changes in the program. Ms. Walters testified that strategies to foster interaction between the typical and special education children include proximate seating during circle time, snack time, and small-group time and having them hold hands when entering the classroom. She mentioned a peer coaching method of acting as a shadow to a nondisabled child to model how to interact with a child with a disability, although she did not indicate when this was to be done. She also testified that social skills training includes learning to share, for example, limited available supplies.
Independent clinical psychologist Dr. Lenington testified that in early September 2002, she observed Ms. Walters’ class for about 1-1/2 to 2 hours and a short part of the EDP.(Footnote 33) During this time, she also observed four aides. She observed circle time, free play, small-group time, some outside time, an art activity, lunch, and the transition of some children leaving. She testified that in Ms. Walters’ class, there were 12 children and two aides. She saw some picture prompts to choose songs during circle time but no other visual support such as a picture schedule on the wall. She testified that Ms. Walters’ class seemed somewhat disorganized, for example, during transitions from one activity to the next, and Ms. Walters often gave directions to the aides over the children’s heads. Dr. Lenington also observed a scrambling to obtain for one child a PECS symbol for raisins, although, according to her, the necessary symbols should be on hand. BIA program director Ms. Kern, who observed Ms. Walters’ IPS class 2 or 3 times for a total of about 4 to 6 hours during the last school year, testified that the class was not highly structured. There was a standard routine but not a microroutine. For example, after circle time, all of the children just got up instead of picking up the carpet square and putting it away, lining up, and then sitting down. There was not consistency about minor routines such as putting the backpack away. According to Ms. Kern, STUDENT was less likely to gain new skills if presented inconsistently (e.g., sometimes she hangs up the backpack herself and at other times someone helps her). Dr. Lenington also observed a child’s maladaptive behavior (writhing on the floor during circle time) reinforced when Ms. Walters permitted him to do something special, in this case, turn the page in the book. Dr. Lenington noted that it is inappropriate to reinforce misbehavior.
Dr. Lenington testified that during free-play time, it was apparent that the number of adults was insufficient. One child tried unsuccessfully to get someone to play with him, and he finally had food talk to each other. She testified that there were opportunities to teach but no one to do so, and she did not see any one-to-one instruction during the time that she observed. According to her, no aide was assigned to any particular child. Having been told that typical children were in the class, she noticed two quiet girls who seemed more typical than the others, but no one tried to facilitate interactions between them and the other children. Ms. Kern also testified that she did not see interactions between the regular education and special education students. According to her, Ms. Walters tried to keep the children playing productively. However, one aide was setting up snacks and cleaning tables and the other removed from the classroom a child throwing a severe tantrum. The aides were not facilitating interactions between the typical and special education children.(Footnote 34) Dr. Lenington testified that during snack time, one aide (Nadine Pardini) tried to elicit interaction or conversation. She observed Nadine in the classroom applying applied behavioral analysis (ABA) principles but not consistently. According to her, Nadine typically expected more than one behavior or did not give the child enough time to respond. Dr. Lenington testified that two other aides seemed to be primarily babysitters. One cleaned tables and did not interact much with the children. It was difficult to understand another, who did not speak English well, and she used a harsh tone with the children.
Dr. Lenington testified that Ms. Walters’ IPS class was not appropriate for STUDENT because there was not enough structure, consistency of expectation, or support staff. According to her, it failed to meet STUDENT’S need for individual attention, and it would be easy for her to get away with not doing much because of the number of children with behavior problems and other deficits in the class. Dr. Lenington also believed that with the maladaptive behavior in the class, STUDENT’S protesting behavior could escalate to throwing a tantrum to get what she wanted. Dr. Lenington, who is also a licensed occupational therapist, further testified that during the entire time that she was there, a boy had on a weighted vest and weights on his ankles, although this sensory technique generally is intended to be used for only 10 to 15 minutes at a time.
Ms. Kern testified that during the 2001-2002 school year, she visited the IPS class and EDP multiple times to assess the appropriateness of the program for BIA clients and also to provide for a transition of one client from the BIA program to the District program, and she visited Ms. Rannefeld’s IPS class once for about an hour. There were about 15 children in her class. Ms. Kern observed Ms. Rannefeld doing DTT with a former BIA client.(Footnote 35) She noted that Ms. Rannefeld had difficulty getting the child’s attention and improperly repeated the instruction 8 times. The child did not have his PECS book and could thus only communicate verbally. According to Ms. Kern, PECS was used mainly at snack time, so it was essentially food-based. She testified that the regular education and special education children did not interact, and she did not observe anyone trying to facilitate interactions between them. According to her, the two aides were primarily managing disruptive and safety-related behavior, such as preventing one child from playing with the computer’s electrical cords. Ms. Kern testified that she did not believe that in May 2002, Ms. Rannefeld’s class was appropriate for STUDENT because, in addition to the above concerns related to DTT and peer interactions, there was a lack of toys and materials to promote the variety of play of which STUDENT is capable, and she did not observe any sensory activities during the time that she was there.
Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer determines that the preponderance of the evidence established that neither Ms. Walters’ nor Ms. Rannefeld’s IPS class met STUDENT’S unique needs. Ms. Walters’ class lacked the organized structure and consistent routine that STUDENT requires. Further, the evidence established that the classes of both teachers did not meet STUDENT’S need for individual assistance; facilitated interactions with typical peers; aides well-trained in the components of her home program, such as DTT and facilitated play sessions; and appropriate sensory activities. The evidence also did not establish an organized curriculum and appropriate materials to meet STUDENT’S need to develop more complex play skills. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that the IPS classes, containing both special education and typical children, did not meet STUDENT’S need for typical peers as social, language, and behavioral models. Mr. Mushaney testified that in May 2002, some students in the IPS classes exhibited behaviors such as hand-flapping, verbal self-stimulatory behavior, toe-walking, and disruptive behavior such as yelling.
(2) EDP. Ms. Walters testified that the EDP, based on TEACCH and ABA, provides more intensive educational services to children with more significant needs, primarily autistic children. According to her, autistic children need intensive learning opportunities to gain skills and to generalize these skills to different settings and with different people. In May 2002, the EDP was in one classroom, with 9 children and 4 to 7 adults. The two special education teachers and the aides from the IPS classes staff the EDP. During the first few months of the school year, a SELPA autism consultant provided training and support in DTT to the teachers and aides. Since winter or spring 2002, Ms. Walters has received training and support in TEACCH, DTT, PECS, and data keeping from a Quality Behavioral Outcomes (QBO) behavioral consultant. According to her, the EDP has a high level of structure, and each child has a schedule to learn where to go next. At independent work stations, the children do individual activities. For 15 minutes daily the aides work one-to-one with each child on discrete trials to teach a skill that is observable and countable and can be tracked over time.(Footnote 36) A minimum of 10 trials are done and data collected to keep track of the percent correct to determine whether a change is necessary. A child may receive a maximum of three 15-minute discrete trial sessions daily, depending on the child’s IEP goals. The EDP begins with supervised outside time, followed by a lunch period focusing on the functional skills of eating and cleaning up. Next are four different sessions, based upon skill level: an independent period, with work stations set up; one-to-one time, when specific skills are taught through discrete trials; small-group time, with 1 adult and 2 children; and circle time, with 1 adult and 3 to 5 children. During circle time, the children practice imitation and preacademic skills based upon their IEP goals. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.)
Ms. Kern testified that during the 2001-2002 school year, she observed the EDP twice, for 2 hours each time, in March and about May 2002. One day, there were about 5 or 6 children and an equal number of adults. The EDP classroom was two small rooms with no door between used as one room. The noise level varied. During much of the session, a girl screamed and cried and, to varying degrees, adult instructions could be heard coming from the work stations where the children were working. After circle time, which lasted about 10 minutes, the children checked the schedule and went to the one-to-one stations. According to Ms. Kern, each child had a schedule, although not individualized, posted in the one-to-one area. She testified that she is familiar with TEACCH because BIA uses TEACCH with clients and that in May 2002, she did not see TEACCH work stations in the EDP or in the IPS classes as she knows them to be and she did not see work being done with children in the TEACCH style or format. (Footnote 37)
Ms. Kern testified that she saw DTT being done in the EDP but felt at times that the prompting should have occurred sooner or should have been more varied, for example, using positional prompting (putting an item in a specific position to assist the child to respond without a full physical prompt).(Footnote 38) One day she observed paraprofessional Nadine working for 2 hours primarily on DTT with a BIA client who had been transitioned into the District’s program. She observed her commit frequent errors, such as not waiting to gain the child’s attention, varying the instruction, and not providing reinforcement (e.g., praise or a toy) for every correct response. When the child was unresponsive, Nadine overused his name and changed the seating arrangement so that he could not leave. She also did not adhere to the DTT procedure of giving a prompt if the child did not provide the targeted response twice in a row, followed by a trial without a prompt if the child responded correctly. Ms. Kern testified that in March 2002 she also observed paraprofessional Olga Patton, who was assigned to take over BIA’s home services for 5 hours weekly for the BIA client being transitioned to the District program.(Footnote 39) According to her, Olga could implement only highly structured tasks for which BIA supplied the language and materials, and when the child was unmotivated, she could not re-focus him. She had difficulty with unstructured activities such as play dates that BIA had designed for the child. Ms. Kern testified that she did not believe that Olga was competent to do DTT without supervision, and she understood that someone from QBO was to have supervised her.
Dr. Lenington testified that she observed only lunch and the outside part of the EDP. According to her, lunch was disorganized because few staff were available due to people being in transition and taking breaks. She saw PECS used but not in a manner she was trained to use it. Ms. Kern testified that she did not observe PECS being used during the lunch period, although most of the children in that class used PECS and, based on her training, PECS should be used throughout the day to communicate. During the outside time, Dr. Lenington noticed that the few toys were dirty and unappealing, and it appeared that the aides were on break. She observed no organized attempts to facilitate interactions between the children. Dr. Lenington testified that this was a time for the children to learn social and play skills but that they were not learning anything. Ms. Kern testified that except for a minimal amount during circle time, she saw hardly any facilitated interactions between the children, including during lunch and free play. She observed Ms. Walters trying to interact with Ms. Kern’s client but saw no other adults trying to interact with the children. According to her, the aides were preparing things and watching.
Ms. Kern testified that STUDENT’S ability to learn new skills in the EDP would be limited because the staff exhibited difficulty implementing DTT properly, and the curriculum was fairly restricted, with standard activities that did not take into account individual needs. For example, a child with little communication was trying to identify animals although he had more basic communication needs. She testified that STUDENT’S greatest areas of weakness were play and social development but that she did not observe one-to-one activities for these areas and there was not a strong curriculum during play time. She noted that a verbal child in the free play area seemed to be playing on his own and that the free play area contained few materials for learning. Ms. Kern testified that with STUDENT’S sensory processing issues, it would be difficult for her to learn new information in the EDP because she would first need to cope with the visual and auditory stimuli in that classroom. According to her, when STUDENT is overly stimulated, her behavior becomes more disorganized, and for her to carry out complex motor planning sequences, she would need a clear, uncluttered environment. Ms. Kern testified that she has observed 25 to 30 preschool classes, has worked in preschools, and has assessed preschools for appropriateness for children. She testified that in May 2002, neither the IPS class nor the EDP was appropriate for STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the EDP failed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs for essentially the same reasons that the IPS class was found to be lacking, specifically, lack of clear organization, little individual attention, hardly any facilitated peer interactions, limited curriculum and materials for play, and a difficult learning environment for STUDENT given her sensory processing issues.
The Student further argues that she required at least 30 hours of one-to-one intervention services and that the EDP failed to meet this need. Regarding the appropriate number of hours of one-to-one intervention services that STUDENT required weekly, Dr. Lenington recommended an initial 40-hour weekly in-home program until the home provider determined it appropriate for her to transition to a preschool part time with a one-to-one aide. BIA associate director Ms. Detmers, who initially assessed STUDENT, recommended 21 hours weekly of one-to-one home intervention services, plus a one-to-one instructional aide in the preschool classroom.(Footnote 40) The mother testified that STUDENT started with approximately 18 to 21 hours of in-home behavioral therapy while attending the Small Voices early intervention program and did not need a one-to-one aide at that time because there was a 1 to 3 specialist-to-children ratio at Small Voices and she accompanied STUDENT to each session. In June 2002, when STUDENT began a private preschool with a one-to-one BIA aide, she received 15 hours of in-home behavioral therapy and 15 hours of aide services. Because BIA had the opportunity to work with her for several months and determined that a total of 30 hours weekly was adequate, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that 30 hours weekly of one-to-one intervention services, including 15 hours of a one-to-one aide’s services, was an appropriate amount.(Footnote 41) Thus, the District’s offer of 15 to 45 minutes daily of one-to-one DTT in the EDP, that is, less than five hours weekly, did not meet her needs.
Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offered program during the 2001-2002 school year, which consisted of an IPS class taught by Ms. Walters or Ms. Rannefeld and the EDP, failed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. In the IPS class and the EDP, there was little evidence of one-to-one instruction. However, as discussed above, STUDENT requires extensive structured one-to-one instruction to learn basic skills in her developmental areas of weakness. In addition, a critical area of need for STUDENT was social and play skills, and the evidence did not establish that the IPS class or EDP met her needs in these areas. According to the testimony of Dr. Lenington and Ms. Kern, there was little facilitation of social interactions and no apparent curriculum or appropriate materials to expand play skills in either setting. There was also no evidence of appropriate sensory activities to meet STUDENT’S sensory integration needs.
3. Speech Therapy. The May 21, 2002 IEP provides for direct and collaborative, in-class and/or pull-out speech and language therapy for 30 to 60 minutes 1 or 2 times weekly. The Student argues that because she can only learn in a one-to-one setting, she required individual speech therapy. The testimony of District speech pathologist Ms. Sonneman varied as to the amount and type of speech therapy she would provide to STUDENT. She testified that direct services (working directly with STUDENT) could be provided in the therapy room (pull-out) or in the classroom. She testified that with the range set forth in the IEP, she could provide 30 to 60 minutes of pull-out therapy only or a total of 30 minutes of direct services and collaborative services (collaborating with the teacher) and nothing else. The May 2002 IEP does not specify whether the direct speech therapy was to be individual or group. The question is whether STUDENT required individual speech therapy and the IEP should thus have specified this type of therapy.
The record indicates that STUDENT required individual speech therapy. The September 2001 CHO speech and language assessment report recommended speech therapy, and STUDENT started receiving individual speech therapy. The October 2001 IFSP provided for speech therapy, paid by RCEB until STUDENT turned 3. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The November 2001 CHO developmental assessment and Small Voices early intervention program reports recommended continued speech therapy. The April 2002 Small Voices report specifically recommended intensive individual work on speech production skills in addition to classroom language instruction. After a June 2002 formal assessment of language skills, Dr. Lenington also recommended individual speech therapy. (Stud. Exh. 18; Testimony of Dr. Lenington.) As discussed under Issue 2, the District’s preschool team assessment did not include a speech and language assessment or even a formal assessment of language skills, specifically. Thus, it is unclear on what basis the District recommended primarily direct and collaborative services in the classroom and, perhaps, some pull-out therapy. (Testimony of Ms. Sonneman.) After the only formal speech and language assessment in September 2001, STUDENT began individual speech therapy, which she has continued to the present. Other assessors have recommended a continuation of her speech therapy. The Hearing Officer finds that the preponderance of the evidence established that STUDENT required individual speech therapy. Thus, the District’s vague offer of merely direct and collaborative speech and language services, not specifically individual speech therapy, failed to meet her unique needs.
4. OT. The May 21 IEP provides for 60 minutes weekly of in-class consultative OT. The Student argues that she required direct, not merely consultative, OT. The October 2001 IFSP provided for an oral motor and OT assessment. The November 2001 CHO developmental assessment and Small Voices reports recommended OT or an OT assessment. The December 2001 OT assessment recommended OT to address sensory processing and related attentional, self-care, and play skills, and a Therapeutic Listening Program as part of the sensory integration treatment. STUDENT started receiving direct OT. District occupational therapist Ms. Auston’s assessment report concluded that STUDENT exhibited sensory processing delays in all of the sensory systems reviewed. However, the preschool assessment team recommended only consultative OT. Dr. Lenington, a licensed occupational therapist as well as a clinical psychologist, recommended clinic-based OT in addition to consultative OT to address fine- and gross-motor skills planning and sequencing and sensory sensitivity. Since December 2001, STUDENT has been receiving clinic-based direct OT, paid by RCEB until she turned 3. (Testimony of MOTHER.) Ms. Auston testified that clinic-based OT is appropriate for STUDENT but that the District provided only school-based OT. From the evidence in the record, including Ms. Auston’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required clinic-based direct OT in addition to consultative OT services in the classroom.(Footnote 42) Because the District failed to offer direct OT, it failed to meet her needs.
In conclusion, a number of the District’s proposed goals and objectives were inappropriate in addressing skills that STUDENT had already achieved or in failing to set forth measureable criteria to assess her progress. The IPS class and EDP failed to meet STUDENT’S need for extensive one-to-one instruction to learn basic skills, for facilitated social interactions, and for a curriculum and materials to develop her play skills. In addition, the District’s offer failed to meet her need for individual speech therapy to address her communication and speech production deficits and for direct OT to address her motor and sensory processing issues. Thus, the District’s offer was not designed to meet her unique needs.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Benefit
Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide benefit requires consideration of various measures, such as standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives. Because STUDENT did not attend the Woodstock IPS class and EDP during the 2001-2001 school year, there are no measures of her progress in that program. However, because many of the District’s proposed goals and objectives addressed skills that she had already attained, the proposed program to implement them would not have provided more than de minimis benefit. De minimis benefit or trivial advancement does not satisfy the Rowley requirement of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998); M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist., 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir.), cert. denied, 519 U.S. 866 (1996).
In addition, as Dr. Lenington noted, there was insufficient staff to provide STUDENT with individual assistance and instruction, particularly in light of the classroom aides’ failure to take an active role in facilitating language and peer interactions among the children. Moreover, the observed difficulty of the staff in implementing DTT properly, combined with the meager DTT amount of 15 to 45 minutes daily, made it unlikely that STUDENT would reap benefit in the development of necessary basic skills in that program. The frequency and amount of DTT were not reasonably calculated to bestow benefit. Further, both Dr. Lenington and Ms. Kern testified that if STUDENT continued to receive a substantial, intensive one-to-one program to develop her cognitive, language, communication, social, and play skills, she would be prepared to enter a regular education kindergarten class with aide support. Notably, no District witness testified that by attending the IPS class and EDP, STUDENT likely would be able to attend a regular education kindergarten class at age 5.(Footnote 43) Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with benefit.(Footnote 44)
In conclusion, because a number of the District’s proposed goals and objectives addressed skills already achieved by STUDENT and the District did not offer individual speech therapy, direct OT, or a substantial amount of one-to-one instruction, its proffered program and services were not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and were not reasonably calculated to confer benefit. The result was denial of a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds from May 22, 2002, to the end of the school year.
Summer 2002 ESY Session
The Student contends, in effect, that the District’s 2002 ESY program was inappropriate because it failed to meet her needs, including her need for consistency. The May 21, 2002 IEP provides for an ESY program from July 1, 2002 to August 2, 2002, consisting of the Woodstock IPS class for 2.5 hours per day, 5 times weekly; the EDP for 1.5 hours daily, 5 times a week; and 30 to 60 minutes of speech therapy 1 to 2 times weekly. The program was similar to that during the regular school year, except with shorter hours and a different teacher. The question is whether the District’s ESY program was an appropriate program to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist., 967 F.2d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. The 2002 ESY session was taught by Ms. Rannefeld, who taught the IPS class and EDP during the 2001-2002 regular school year, and Sharon O’Neil, SH SDC elementary school teacher, who did not. (Testimony of Ms. O’Neil.) The District did not specify which teacher STUDENT would have had. Thus, as discussed above, for the District’s offer of a 2002 ESY program to be appropriate, the IPS classes and EDP taught by both teachers needed to be appropriate. As noted above, Ms. Rannefeld did not testify.
Ms. O’Neil’s summer 2002 IPS class, which went from 8:30 to 11:00 a.m., contained about five each of special education and typically developing children and three aides(Footnote 45). Ms. O’Neil worked on developing language and social skills through structured play situations and other activities. The EDP, which went from 11:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., included the children from the two IPS classes. Besides the two teachers, there were five aides, including Nadine Pardini. Ms. O’Neil provided no direct services but oversaw the aides’ implementation of the EDP program. In fall 1998, she had received training about DTT but not training to implement a DTT program. She had no formal training in play techniques, PECS, or ABA. She lacked training in language skills for autistic children other than what she learned from the District speech pathologist when she taught a Woodstock preschool SDC for three years from fall 1998 to June 2001.(Footnote 46) She acknowledged, however, that no autistic children were in her class because at that time there was a separate class for autistic children. Before the 2002 ESY session, Ms. Walters left notes about appropriate activities for the children. (Testimony of Ms. O’Neil.)
No evidence was presented about Ms. Rannefeld’s summer 2002 IPS class or her role in the EDP. However, Ms. Kern’s testimony about her observations of Ms. Rannefeld’s difficulty implementing DTT, the lack of facilitated peer interactions in her class, lack of toys to build STUDENT’S play skills, and lack of sensory activities applies here absent evidence that in summer 2002, Ms. Rannefeld’s class and instruction were markedly different from the regular school year. Thus, the conclusion above that Ms. Rannefeld’s IPS class and the EDP during the 2001-2002 school year were not appropriate for STUDENT applies here as well. Because one of the two 2002 ESY teachers’ classes was inappropriate, it is unnecessary to address the appropriateness of Ms. O’Neil’s IPS class and EDP instruction.
The Student asserts that the ESY session did not meet her need for a continuous instructional program throughout the summer without breaks. Conflicting testimony was given about the ESY session’s length and starting date. Mr. Mushaney testified that the ESY session was five weeks long, starting two weeks after the end of the regular school year and ending 2-1/2 weeks before the start of the next school year. According to Ms. O’Neil, the ESY session was for six weeks and started about one week after the regular school year ended in June. According to her, the new regular school year began on August 22, 2002. She testified that she left after the fifth week, and a substitute teacher taught the last week of the ESY session.
The testimony of Dr. Lenington and Ms. Kern established that STUDENT requires structure and consistency to learn new developmental skills. From May 22, 2002, when she turned 3, to about mid-June, the District offered a program including an IPS class taught by Ms. Walters or Ms. Rannefeld. One or two weeks after the regular school year ended, the District offered an ESY program taught in part by Ms. Rannefeld or Ms. O’Neil. If STUDENT had been in Ms. O’Neil’s IPS class, she would have had a substitute teacher after five weeks. Then, 2-1/2 weeks later, the District offered a program for the next school year that included an IPS class taught by Ms. Walters or Mr. Kruze. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.) During the 3-month period from May 22 to August 22, 2002, when the new school year started, STUDENT might have had at least two different teachers in different classrooms, with two breaks of 1 to 2-1/2 weeks. This program did not provide the structure and consistency that STUDENT required. Ms. Kern testified that although STUDENT had not gone for an extended period without BIA services, after just two or three days of being ill and missing sessions, she showed regression, and it was necessary to go back and redo skills or structure tasks more than before to elicit the same level of functioning. According to her, with BIA’s experience with this population, it recommends not taking more than an extended weekend off during the first 2 years. The 2002 ESY program, with the possibility of a different teacher from the regular school year and two fairly lengthy breaks, was not appropriate to prevent serious regression. With her relatively low functioning level in various developmental areas, STUDENT required a continuous program throughout the summer to prevent serious regression.
Further, there was no evidence as to whether the ESY speech and language services were to be direct or collaborative, pull-out or in the class, or one-to-one or small-group. Because the Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT required individual speech therapy, the evidence thus failed to establish the appropriateness of the speech and language services to prevent serious regression. In conclusion, the District failed to offer a FAPE during summer 2002.
ISSUE 4: Did the District offer the Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 2002-2003 school year?
During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT has attended Temple Sinai preschool with a one-to-one BIA aide and has received one-to-one BIA home services, speech therapy, OT, and music therapy, all paid by her parents. During this school year, the May 21, 2002 IEP continues to embody the District’s placement offer until May 2003. With a few changes, the program is essentially the same as that offered from May 2002 to the end of the 2001-2002 school year. During this year, another IPS special education teacher, Mr. Kruze, replaced Ms. Rannefeld.(Footnote 47) (Testimony of Ms. Walters.) Mr. Kruze did not testify. A QBO consultant continued to provide training and support to Ms. Walters in organizing the EDP, for example, using TEACCH methodology and developing a data keeping system and also to the aides in using the data keeping system. Ms. Walters testified in September 2002 that the data keeping system was being revised to enable the teachers to take data on every trial while an aide worked with a child. The EDP was now in two classrooms, with 3 to 5 students per class. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.)
The changes that occurred during this school year did not substantially alter the program and services offered by the May 21 IEP. Moreover, no evidence was presented that STUDENT’S needs changed significantly from May 22, 2002, to August 22, 2002, when the 2002-2003 school year began. Thus, the discussion above about the District’s proposed program and services and the determination that they failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE applies here. In September 2002, Dr. Lenington observed the IPS classes of both Ms. Walters (discussed above) and Mr. Kruze, including their aides, and testified that neither IPS class was appropriate for STUDENT because of insufficient structure, consistency of expectation, and support staff. The Hearing Officer found above that the class, program, and instruction provided by Ms. Walters failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE. The evidence does not establish any significant change in her class and program, the EDP, or any proffered related services during the current school year. Because one of two alternative classes offered by the District and the program in the EDP were found inappropriate, the District’s program and services for the 2002-2003 school year did not meet STUDENT’S unique needs, were not reasonably calculated to confer benefit, and failed to offer a FAPE.
ISSUE 5: If the Student was denied a FAPE from May 22, 2002 to the present, is she entitled to the following remedies:
(1) Reimbursement for the following, including the cost of transportation: (a) Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA) services;
(b) ABC preschool and Temple Sinai preschool;
(c) Speech therapy from Sarah Thompson and Margaret Bourne;
(d) Occupational therapy from Stacy Frauwirth;
(e) Music therapy from Susan Rancer?
(2) Continuation of her current program (BIA services, Temple Sinai preschool, speech therapy, occupational therapy, and music therapy) for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year?
When a school district has denied a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to appropriate relief in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). The Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from May 22, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year, including the summer 2002 ESY session, and also during the 2002-2003 school year. The Student seeks as remedies for denial of a FAPE reimbursement for certain educational programs and services and continued placement in these programs and services for the remainder of the school year.
(1) Reimbursement for the Costs of Programs and Services
Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for services that they obtained for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate program and services, and the program or services obtained by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Burlington rule does not limit reimbursement only to a placement or program selected by the parent that is the “exact proper placement” under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Student seeks reimbursement for the costs of BIA services, private preschools, speech therapy, and OT from May 22, 2002, to the present and music therapy from September 2002 to the present.
(a) BIA Services. The documentary evidence and the mother’s testimony establish that from February 2002 to the present, STUDENT has received BIA services, initially about 18-21 hours and, after May 22, 2002, when she turned three, 30 hours (15 hours of in-home one-to-one behavioral therapy and 15 hours of a one-to-one instructional aide’s services at her preschool). The evidence is that BIA is a State-certified nonpublic agency (NPA) that provides intensive individualized behavioral intervention programs for autistic children. (Testimony of Ms. Kern.) Under Issue 3 above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT required extensive one-to-one instruction to learn new skills and the services of a one-to-one aide in her preschool class to benefit from a group setting. The one-to-one services she has received from BIA have thus met a fundamental need. Through BIA, she has received home and community instruction and activities (such as facilitated peer play sessions), with goals and objectives in the language and communication, cognitive (preacademic and play), social and emotional, motor, and sensory processing areas. (Stud. Exh. 9; Testimony of Ms. Kern.) The evidence is that BIA monitors a child’s progress with detailed records and data and close supervision and is thus able timely to update or modify the child’s program. Ms. Kern testified that STUDENT had shown remarkable progress toward her goals, including improvement in peer interactions. (See also Stud. Exh. 9.) According to the mother, with BIA services, STUDENT showed a rapid acquisition of language skills, displayed new play skills, and started connecting more with other children. The evidence establishes that the BIA services addressed STUDENT’S needs in the communication, language, cognitive, play, social, and sensory processing areas, and she made progress in the BIA program. The Hearing Officer determines that the BIA program, including a one-to-one aide’s services in the preschool, was appropriate. Further, it was determined above that 30 hours of one-to-one intervention services was an appropriate amount.
Because the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE and the Hearing Officer has determined that the BIA program obtained by the parents was appropriate, they are entitled to reimbursement for the expenses incurred in providing the BIA program from May 22, 2002, through the date of this Decision. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Detmers; Stud. Exh. 42.)(Footnote 48) Because part of the program has been provided in the home and part at the preschool and it was determined, below, that entitlement to private preschool reimbursement had not been established, there is no transportation reimbursement related to the BIA services.
(b) Private Preschool. The mother testified that after STUDENT turned three on May 22, 2002 and was no longer eligible for the Small Voices early intervention program, she started attending a private preschool with a one-to-one aide provided by BIA. During summer 2002, STUDENT attended ABC preschool from June 10, 2002, to August 30, 2002, three mornings a week from 8:30 to 11:30 a.m. From September 3, 2002, to the present, STUDENT has been attending Temple Sinai preschool five mornings a week with a one-to-one BIA aid her home, to learn new skills, and the purpose of her preschool class was for her to generalize acquie.(Footnote 49) Ms. Kern testified that STUDENT required one-to-one instruction, as she was receiving in red skills, use them in a more stimulating environment, and become comfortable with classroom routine. She testified that in her current regular education preschool class, STUDENT was already able to act independently without support and could follow the class routine and teacher’s directions and participate in all activities. She testified that STUDENT still needed an aide, however, because she required support primarily with play, sensory, language and communication, and social skills. However, little evidence was presented with respect to the preschool class itself.
Ms. Kern’s August 2002 BIA report had recommended, in addition to a one-to-one aide, a regular education preschool class with typical peers who modeled appropriate language, play skills, and behavior; consistent schedule and clear expectations; activities providing varied tactile experiences; ample play materials; and outdoor play with supported peer interactions. Ms. Detmers’ February 2002 report had made substantially similar recommendations. However, little, if any, evidence was presented regarding either ABC or Temple Sinai with respect to the other children in STUDENT’S class (such as their age and ability to interact with her), the structure or size of the class, the teacher’s methods and strategies, or the class activities. Because of the paucity of information regarding either preschool, the Hearing Officer determines that there is insufficient evidence to determine the appropriateness of either preschool class to support reimbursement for the costs. Reimbursement for the preschool costs is thus denied.
(c) Speech Therapy. The Hearing Officer determined under Issue 3 that STUDENT required individual speech therapy and that the District failed to offer a FAPE by not offering individual speech therapy. The September 2001 CHO speech and language assessment recommended speech therapy for one hour weekly with goals to improve verbal imitation skills, expressive vocabulary, comprehension of verbal commands, and articulation. The mother testified that the parents obtained individual speech therapy for one hour weekly from speech pathologist Ms. Thompson. According to the mother, in July and August 2002, there was an overlap when a second speech pathologist, Ms. Bourne,(Footnote 50) started providing therapy, and during this time, STUDENT received speech therapy for two hours twice weekly. Since then and up to the present, Ms. Bourne, rather than Ms. Thompson, has provided speech therapy to STUDENT once weekly.
The mother, who has attended the sessions with STUDENT, testified that Ms. Thompson worked on expanding STUDENT’S language, communication, and vocabulary and that she noticed that STUDENT was talking and requesting more. She testified that Ms. Bourne has focused on oral motor therapy using certain-sized straws, a horn or kazoo, and blowing with the purpose, she believed, to de-sensitize STUDENT and assist the muscles in her mouth to work correctly to improve her ability to articulate better. The mother testified that she believed that STUDENT’S speech was improving, although the result may be due to all of the services she received. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence establishes that the speech therapy STUDENT received addressed her needs related to language, communication, and speech production, or articulation, and that she has shown progress. Consequently, because the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, including individual speech therapy, she is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of individual speech therapy, including the cost of transportation, from May 22, 2002, to the present. The summer 2002 twice-weekly speech therapy was apparently temporary; thus, STUDENT shall be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of a total of one hour weekly of speech therapy, including during summer 2002.
(d) Occupational Therapy. The mother testified that from December 2001 to September 2002, STUDENT received once-weekly direct OT, which included a therapeutic listening program, from occupational therapist Ms. Frauwirth. In September 2002, the OT was increased to twice weekly. The mother testified that the OT has included work on fine-motor skills; oral-motor skills because of tactile defensiveness in the mouth (trying to get STUDENT to increase the types of foods she will tolerate); listening therapy, with instruction to the mother for the home component; and sensory integration. For the latter, the mother was instructed in the Wilbarger brushing protocol (giving a massage with a scrub brush to help STUDENT to self-regulate and calm down). Ms. Frauwirth also talked to the mother and BIA regarding strategies for a sensory diet.
The mother testified that listening therapy is auditory integrative therapy for autistic children, who tend to be sensitive to certain sounds and frequencies. According to her, the twice-daily 30-minute periods of listening to specially programmed music while doing gross- or fine-motor activities like puzzles seemed to help STUDENT to self-regulate and not be overwhelmed by things. Ms. Frauwirth consulted with BIA on fine-motor activities such as encouraging a pincer grip by using short pencils. She also worked with STUDENT on movement and balance. (Testimony of MOTHER; Stud. Exh. 16.) According to the mother, STUDENT seemed more alert and attentive after the OT sessions. The evidence establishes that direct OT met STUDENT’S needs related to tactile defensiveness, sensory integration, and motor skills and that she has shown progress. The Hearing Officer found under Issue 3 that the District’s offer of solely consultative OT was not appropriate. Thus, she is entitled to reimbursement for the direct OT costs, including reasonable expenses related to the auditory integrative therapy and the cost of transportation, from May 22, 2002, to the present. However, because no evidence was presented of the basis for increasing the OT to twice weekly, she shall be entitled to reimbursement for one hour of OT weekly.
(e) Music Therapy. Since September 2002, STUDENT has been receiving music therapy from registered music therapist Ms. Rancer for 1/2 hour weekly. The mother testified that STUDENT’S Small Voices teacher said that music is a channel of learning for STUDENT as an autistic child. According to Ms. Rancer, her music therapy involves, among other things, motor skills and coordination (using musical instruments) and language to the extent that singing is utilized. She acknowledged, however, that she is not an occupational therapist or speech pathologist. There is no evidence that music therapy is a unique need for STUDENT. Therefore, music therapy is not reimbursable in this hearing.
In summary, because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from May 22, 2002 to the present, she is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of BIA services, individual speech therapy, and direct OT. Reimbursement for the costs of the private preschools and music therapy is denied.
(2) Continuation of Program and Services for the Rest of the 2002-2003 School Year
An appropriate placement for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year, if the District’s program was found inappropriate, was not specifically addressed as a separate issue. However, the Student made clear at the hearing and in her closing brief that she sought a determination that her current program and services were appropriate and should continue during the rest of the year. The District’s May 21 IEP denied STUDENT a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds. By holding an IEP meeting without the parents and service providers familiar with her needs, the District not only violated the parents’ procedural rights but also failed to avail itself of their input to develop an appropriate program for her. The Hearing Officer, above, found appropriate the 30-hour BIA program currently provided to STUDENT, including 15 hours of one-to-one aide services at her regular education preschool; individual speech therapy for one hour weekly from Margaret Bourne; and direct occupational therapy for one hour weekly from Stacy Frauwirth. There are only about 5 months remaining in the 2002-2003 school year and only about 4 months until the May 2003 annual review IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer finds, given the deficiencies described above in the District’s program, including the aides’ difficulty implementing the DTT program, that there is insufficient time for the District to develop a revised program to address STUDENT’S unique needs during the rest of the school year. Further, in light of her need for structure and consistency, the Hearing Officer determines that continuation of her current program and services, to the extent feasible, would be appropriate.
The evidence established that BIA is a State-certified NPA. Thus, the District shall continue to fund the 30-hour BIA program for the rest of the regular school year. However, no evidence was presented that either Ms. Bourne or Ms. Frauwirth is a State-certified NPA. A hearing officer may not render a decision that results in service provided to a child with a disability by an NPA not certified by the State. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2. The statute prohibits the Hearing Officer from awarding prospective speech therapy and OT from Ms. Bourne and Ms. Frauwirth, respectively. Thus, prospective services from these two providers are denied. The Hearing Officer determines that the District shall provide STUDENT individual speech therapy for one hour weekly and direct OT for one hour weekly for the rest of the regular school year. The District shall obtain, at the District’s expense, from her current speech therapist, Ms. Bourne, and her current occupational therapist, Ms. Frauwirth, written reports describing her current levels of functioning and current therapeutic goals and activities in the speech and language and OT areas, respectively. Alternatively, because STUDENT has established relationships with both of these service providers, the District may wish to consider contracting for their services.
Further, because of insufficient information about Temple Sinai, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for the costs of this preschool. However, as discussed under Issue 3, the Hearing Officer found that a preschool class like the IPS class containing special education students who had behavioral problems and who would not serve as appropriate language and social models was not appropriate for STUDENT. The District did not offer STUDENT, with support, a preschool class containing solely regular education children. The evidence is that with one-to-one aide support, she is functioning independently in her regular education preschool class. (Testimony of Ms. Kern.) The Hearing Officer determines that for the remainder of the current regular school year, the District shall provide STUDENT a regular education preschool class with typical peers who are appropriate language, social, and behavioral models; a clear organization and consistent schedule; adequate play materials; and supported peer interactions. (See Stud. Exh. 9; Testimony of Ms. Kern.) Since STUDENT has been at Temple Sinai since September 2002 and consistency is important for a young autistic child like her, if the District determines that Temple Sinai meets the requirements set forth above, it is recommended that the District consider funding this preschool through the end of the regular school year.(Footnote 51)
ISSUE 6: Is the Student entitled to reimbursement of $1300 for the independent developmental assessment by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D.?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) of the student from a qualified specialist, at public expense, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the District, unless the District shows at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). The parents disagreed with the District’s preschool team assessment at the May 9, 2002 IEP meeting (Stud. Exh. 27), and the Hearing Officer determined above that the District’s assessment was inappropriate in failing to conduct a speech and language assessment. In June 2002, Dr. Lenington assessed STUDENT’S language, cognitive, neuropsychological, and academic functioning and concluded, among other things, that STUDENT did not meet the mental retardation diagnostic criteria. The evidence established that Dr. Lenington is a licensed clinical psychologist in California with the requisite education and training. Therefore, she is a qualified specialist to conduct an IEE. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).(Footnote 52) Consequently, subject to proof, the Student is entitled to reimbursement of $1300 for the cost of Dr. Lenington’s June 2001 developmental assessment.
ORDER
1. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the Student’s IEP shall be amended to reflect her special education eligibility category as being solely autism.
2. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof of the cost of the Behavioral Intervention Association services that the Student has received from May 22, 2002, to the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse the Student for this cost.
3. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof of the cost of speech therapy for a total of one hour weekly that the Student has received from either speech pathologist Sarah Thompson or speech pathologist Margaret Bourne during the period from May 22, 2002, to the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse the Student for this cost.
Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof of the number of speech therapy sessions that the Student attended during the above time period and the round trip mileage for these sessions, the District shall reimburse the Student for transportation mileage for those sessions at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
4. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof of the costs of occupational therapy for a total of one hour weekly that the Student has received from occupational therapist Stacy Frauwirth, including reasonable expenses related to the auditory integrative therapy, from May 22, 2002, to the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse the Student for these costs.
Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof of the number of occupational therapy sessions that the Student attended during the above time period and the round trip mileage for these sessions, the District shall reimburse the Student for transportation mileage for those sessions at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
5. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof of the $1300 cost of the developmental assessment by Melanie Lenington, Ph.D., the District shall reimburse the Student for this cost.
6. The District shall fund STUDENT’S 30-hour BIA program for the remainder of the 2002-2003 regular school year.
7. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall provide STUDENT individual speech therapy for one hour weekly and direct occupational therapy for one hour weekly. If the District uses providers other than her current providers, it shall obtain at its own expense, within fourteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, written reports of STUDENT’S current level of functioning and therapeutic goals and activities in the speech and language area from speech pathologist Ms. Bourne and in the OT area from occupational therapist Ms. Frauwirth. Alternatively, the District may contract for the services of Ms. Bourne and Ms. Frauwirth. If the services are provided by nonpublic agencies or providers, the District shall reimburse the parents for transportation mileage, at the District’s rate for its employees, subject to proof as indicated above.
8. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall provide an appropriate public or private regular education preschool class, as discussed above under Issue 4, or shall fund STUDENT’S Temple Sinai preschool class for the rest of the 2002-2003 regular school year. If the parents so request, the District shall provide transportation or reimburse the parents for transportation mileage at the District employee rate for the offered preschool class or Temple Sinai, subject to proof of the number of sessions attended and the round trip mileage for the sessions.
9. All of the District’s claims and all of the Student’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Student prevailed on Issues 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6.
The Student substantially prevailed on Issue 5.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: January 15, 2003 ____________________________________ Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The parent produced a letter from the Regional Center of the East Bay providing for BIA services. The Hearing Officer noted that because no motion was pending, the stay put placement did not need to be determined.
2. Earlier, the District had reserved the right to call as rebuttal witnesses consultant Don Wachelka and Diane Ashton, Ph.D. Later, the District stated that it wished to recall as rebuttal witnesses the school psychologist, speech pathologist, and occupational therapist to rebut Ms. Kern’s testimony about the proposed goals and objectives. The Student objected. The Hearing Officer stated that the District had already presented testimony in its case-in-chief about the goals and objectives and that this did not appear to be in the nature of rebuttal testimony.
3. The District’s and Student’s issues involve essentially the same matters and time periods and have been consolidated into one set. Following an October 3, 2002 memorandum of issues for hearing, the issues were further clarified at the hearing to include as a separate issue the Student’s special education eligibility category. The issues have been further clarified and their order changed to facilitate the analysis. The Student seeks attorney fees, costs, and damages. However, as noted at the hearing, these matters generally are not addressed in a due process hearing. 4. The District asserts that the appropriateness of the 2003 ESY session cannot be addressed at this time because the annual IEP review is scheduled for May 2003 and no program has yet been offered for summer 2003. Because the May 21, 2002 IEP has a review date of May 9, 2003, no summer 2003 program has yet been proposed. Thus, the appropriateness of the 2003 ESY program is not ripe for adjudication and will not be addressed.
5. The Student asserts that her eligibility category should be solely autism. This is an issue in this hearing. 6. Hypotonia is “a condition of diminished tone of the skeletal muscles.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 17, § 52000(b)(23) (pertaining to children from birth up to age 3). 7. The PEP-R protocols indicate that this test was given on April 19 and 26, 2002. (Stud. Exh. 61.) 8. The multiple disabilities category is for “concomitant impairments (such as mental retardation-blindness, mental retardation-orthopedic impairment, etc.), the combination of which causes such severe educational needs that they cannot be accommodated in special education programs solely for one of the impairments.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.7 9. The District asserts that the Legislature has expressed the intent to avoid the unnecessary use of labels in providing special education services to students with disabilities. Cal. Educ. Code § 56001(i). However, preschool children must meet the criteria for identified disabling conditions to be eligible for early childhood special education services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.11(b); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030. 10. Mr. Mushaney has assessed about 100 children in the District, the only District in which he has been employed. Perhaps three-fourths of them had a cognitive delay. During the past 4 years, he has assessed about 25-30 children on the autistic spectrum, including about 20 preschool children. (Testimony of Mr. Mushaney.) 11. Dr. Lenington testified that the PEP-R is a skill-based test to develop goals and objectives for educational programming and that its purpose is not to determine intellectual functioning. The preschool assessment team members indicated that the PEP-R has an educational purpose to assist in developing goals and objectives. 12. Federal law provides for including as a child with a disability, at the discretion of the State and local educational agency, a child age 3 through 9 with developmental delays. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(B); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b). However, California has not included developmental delays as an eligibility category for children age 3 and older. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56026(a) (citing 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)), 56441.11; Cal. Code Reg. tit 5, § 3030. 13. School psychologist Mr. Mushaney completed a District “Pupil Referral Form” dated March 29, 2002, the same date that he presented the District’s proposed assessment plan to the parent. (Stud. Exh. 33; Testimony of Mr. Mushaney.) However, the February 22, 2002 transition IFSP constituted a referral for an assessment at the parent’s request, and for the District to attempt to restart the running of the time line by completing a referral form more than 15 days after the initial referral for assessment would be to subvert the statutory requirement. 14. According to Mr. Mushaney, the HELP gives a baseline at which a child needs to start in a program. 15. Ms. Sonneman testified that she presented all of the items on Score Sheets 6 and 8; items 90-92 on Score Sheet 5; and items 120-124 on Score Sheet 7. About one-half of these items were in the Cognitive Verbal domain and the remaining items were in the other domains excluding gross motor. (Stud. Exh. 61.) She testified that school psychologist Mr. Mushaney, rather than she, reported on the Cognitive Verbal results in the assessment report. 16. The CHO assessment recommended speech therapy to address articulation and the April 2002 Small Voices early intervention report recommended intensive individual work on speech production skills. Dr. Lenington, who assessed STUDENT’S language skills in June 2002, noted that her articulation was not consistently clear and recommended speech and language services that addressed oral motor functioning, including articulation. 17. Assessors have identified the area of social relations and interactions with peers and adults to be problematical for STUDENT. Mr. Mushaney testified that he did not assess STUDENT’S emotional functioning because there was no indication of an emotional disorder. The Student has not argued to the contrary. 18. It is not clear that she would be qualified to assess the social-emotional area. “[I]ndividually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b)(3). There is no evidence that she is a credentialed school psychologist. 19. Dr. Lenington testified that she does not give the PEP-R because she has not performed five supervised administrations of the test. 20. The Student has alleged other procedural violations, some of which are addressed elsewhere. It is unnecessary to address others in light of the determination here and below that the Student was denied a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds. 21. The District must also ensure that the parents of a child with a disability are members of any group that makes decisions about the educational placement of their child. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56342.5. 34 C.F.R. § 300.501(c)(3), (4) provides: If neither parent can participate in a meeting in which a decision is to be made relating to the educational placement of their child, the public agency shall use other methods to ensure their participation, including individual or conference telephone calls, or video conferencing[.] . . . A placement decision may be made by a group without the involvement of the parents, if the public agency is unable to obtain the parents’ participation in the decision. In this case, the public agency must have a record of its attempt to ensure their involvement, including information that is consistent with the requirements of § 300.345(d). 22. School psychologist Mr. Mushaney argued that the Performance IQ and, thus, Full Scale IQ should not have been reported because STUDENTlacked at least 3 Performance subtest raw scores of 1 or more. Dr. Lenington testified that the manual might state that if the sole purpose is to obtain an IQ but that, because of STUDENT’S major communication problem, the intent was also to gain insight into her cognitive process. Dr. Lenington stated that her report mentions any test procedure deviations, as required. Mr. Mushaney also argued that the WPPSI-R should not have been administered because of the floor effect (i.e., not having a range of scores at the bottom so that zero raw scores can lead to low average standard scores) at STUDENT’S age and developmental level. He acknowledged, however, that, at age 3, she was above the minimum age for administering the WPPSI-R and that her scores were derived pursuant to the test manual. Mr. Mushaney also argued that testing the limits before completing the entire test resulted in inflated scores. Dr. Lenington’s report mentions when she tested the limits, and she testified that the scoring was done pursuant to standardized procedure. She asserted that testing the limits had no effect on STUDENT’S scores because the WPPSI-R subtest items are completely different from one another and the WPPSI-R, DAS, and NEPSY are entirely different tests. According to her, she tested the limits to see how STUDENTmight function if the task was presented differently. Mr. Mushaney acknowledged testing the limits for the same purpose. A disputed conclusion of Dr. Lenington that STUDENThas at least average cognitive ability is not at issue in this hearing and does not affect the hearing result. However, she carefully assessed STUDENTover 2-1/2 days and, with her extensive background, training, and experience assessing preschool autistic children, her detailed description of STUDENT’S deficits and relative strengths and her observations during the assessment are helpful to understanding STUDENT’S needs as a child with a disability. Thus, while all of Mr. Mushaney’s arguments are well-taken, they do not require disregarding Dr. Lenington’s assessment report for purposes of this hearing. 23. Mr. Mushaney argued that STUDENT’S DAS scores were inflated because Dr. Lenington violated the discontinue rule (stopping after a certain number of consecutive incorrect items) and improperly provided sample items. Dr. Lenington testified that the she did not believe that she departed from the DAS standardized procedure. According to her, the DAS discontinue rule (when 5 or 6 consecutive items are missed) did not apply when STUDENTcompleted only 2 of 9 subtest items because of the scatter (i.e., she got 1 correct, then several wrong). She stated that the DAS sample items must be administered, and that when she used a “hand over hand” technique with a sample item, she merely showed STUDENTthat she could touch the blocks and did not teach her the task. 24. There is no other page for present levels of performance in the copy of the 4-page May 9 IEP submitted as Student’s Exhibit 27. The District submitted as an exhibit only a copy of the May 21, not the May 9, IEP. 25. Ms. Kern has a master’s degree in counseling and license in marriage and family therapy. Her master’s thesis was on the treatment of autism, primarily applied behavioral analysis (ABA). She has worked for BIA since 1995, as a tutor, case manager, program manager, and now program director. Her duties include providing direct intensive instructional services and developing and modifying curriculum for such a program for autistic children; developing treatment activities to address IEP goals and objectives; developing IEP goals and objectives; collaborating with speech pathologists, occupational therapists, and school district staff to develop and implement IEP goals and objectives; and providing hands-on training to BIA staff and school district employees. She has taught at preschools and has taken early childhood education course work. (Stud. Exh. 2; Testimony of Ms. Kern.) 26. Ms. Kern could not recall whether she had reviewed the May 9 or May 21, 2002 set of IEP goals and objectives but testified about the goals and objectives that were virtually the same in both sets (academic and preacademic, social-emotional, self-help, and the first three communication goals) and also the remaining goals and objectives in the May 21 set, which are pertinent here, with reference to similar goals in the May 9 set. 27. The IPS class is a preschool class containing both special education and regular education children. The EDP provides more intensive services to children with more severe needs. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.) The Student asserts that the District failed to offer a continuum of program options. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56360, 56361. Program specialist Mr. Anderson testified that the IPS class and EDP constituted the District’s program for preschool children with disabilities. However, school psychologist Mr. Mushaney testified that a preschool child with more severe needs could also be given 5 hours of home services. 28. Hearsay evidence may be used to supplement or explain other evidence but is not sufficient by itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in a civil action. Cal. Code Regs. tit 5 § 3082(b). 29. The District objected to Dr. Lenington giving an opinion about the District’s program, particularly its ABA program, on the ground that she is not an ABA treatment provider. Dr. Lenington testified that she has observed hundreds of preschool classes to see how a child is functioning with support or to determine if a placement is appropriate for a child. She has evaluated the ABA programs in those classes and has been hired by school districts to do so. She has training in learning theory, on which ABA is based, as part of her training to become a psychologist and has read the initial and follow-up Ivar Lovaas studies, which developed and implemented ABA. She has reviewed at least 100 ABA programs that contained a discrete trial aspect to determine if the programs were effective and whether the ABA and discrete trial principles were being applied correctly. She has reviewed ABA and discrete trial programs provided by private agencies as a primary function. The Hearing Officer ruled that the breadth of her experience qualified Dr. Lenington to give her opinion about this matter. 30. The third IPS class is taught by a State preschool teacher who is not a special education teacher. 31. The IDEA requires that the District make a written firm, definite offer of a placement and services to alert the parents to the need to consider seriously the appropriateness of the placement and to permit the parents to decide whether to oppose the offer or accept it with supplemental services. Further, in a due process hearing, the District would be better prepared to introduce relevant evidence of the appropriateness of its proffered placement. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994). If the District offered two different classes, its offer would meet the Union requirement of a definite offer only if both classes were appropriate. The District possesses the educational knowledge and expertise to determine what placement and services a child with a disability requires to be provided a FAPE. The District cannot place upon a parent the duty to choose the appropriate placement if one alternative offered is appropriate but the other is not. 32. Ms. Walters obtained a master’s degree in early childhood special education in December 2000 and has a California Preliminary Level I Education Specialist Instruction Credential in early childhood special education. She has worked for the District as an IPS class and EDP special education teacher since August 2001. She has several years’ experience as a preschool teacher and also a special education assistant teacher with the Experimental Education Unit of the University of Washington in Seattle. For her master’s degree, she took classes on educating children with autism and ABA. In recent years, she has received in-service training in PECS, ABA, DTT, and training paraprofessionals to work with autistic children. (Dist. Exh. 29; Testimony of Ms. Walters.) 33. Although Dr. Lenington observed Ms. Walters’ class in September 2002, her testimony is pertinent to the period from May 22, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year since there was no evidence that the IPS class or EDP had changed substantially, except for the location of the EDP. Dr. Lenington also testified that Ms. Walters said that the day observed was a typical day in her class. 34. Ms. Kern testified that during one observation, an aide was swinging on the swing herself on the playground and another aide, Nadine, was playing with the typical children. During a 20- to 30-minute period, only the general education teacher attempted to communicate with Ms. Kern’s client, but he was not able to respond. 35. Ms . Kern testified that one of her BIA responsibilities is to train tutors to do discrete trials. According to her, the DTT components are an instruction or stimulus, the child’s response, and a reinforcement or consequence for the behavior. The standard method is to first obtain the child’s attention and give a clear unit of instruction, which should not be repeated 5 times. The child, depending on skill level, may be given a visual or verbal instruction or gesture. The response should be a specific targeted behavior. If the child demonstrates the targeted behavior, the consequence may be praise or a toy. BIA prepares an Activity Sheet so that the tutor knows what the targeted response is. According to Ms. Kern, consistency across tutors is critical. 36. Ms. Walters testified that a discrete trial involves getting the child’s attention; giving a direction, perhaps with verbal, gestural, or physical support; and giving a reinforcement (e.g., a toy or hug) for the child’s response. After a brief break, the trial is repeated. According to her, less support should be given as the child learns the skill. 37. According to Ms. Kern, a TEACCH work station has a well-defined area, with specific tasks laid out on a shelf, and, possibly, a numerical or token system or pictorial sequence of the activities that are to be done. She testified that in the EDP, she saw organized areas but not independent activities lined up that a child could retrieve and work with at a desk and no visual system to support that. 38. Ms. Kern testified that the prompt hierarchy (from least to most intrusive) is essential for generalization of skills learned in DTT. Prompts range from full physical (hand over hand), partial physical (nudge), verbal, voice inflection, initial sound, and positional to model. According to her, prompts must be gradually eliminated to enable the child to use skills independently. 39. Ms. Kern testified that her role was to train Olga to do DTT with the child. Although Olga started BIA training sessions, Ms. Kern did not know if she finished the training packet because of a high number of absences. 40. Ms. Detmers has a bachelor’s degree in psychology and a master’s degree in special education. For 2-1/2 years over 10 years ago, she worked as a research and clinic assistant at the Pervasive Developmental Disorders (PDD) Clinic at the Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute, University of California at San Francisco. Under the supervision of Drs. Bryna Siegel and Glen Elliott, she administered standardized developmental tests, compiled and analyzed data studying language loss in autistic children, and assisted with diagnostic play sessions. She has experience working as a one-to-one tutor to children with autism and PDD using behavioral techniques and also as a behavioral consultant providing, in part, services to school districts such as developing family-based intervention plans and full-inclusions plans and implementing and supervising behavioral portions of IEPs. 41. School psychologist Mr. Mushaney testified that a child can become heavily dependent upon a one-to-one aide, to the child’s detriment. However, no evidence was presented that this had occurred with STUDENT. Ms. Kern testified that with aide support, STUDENTwas able to function independently in her preschool class. 42. If a related service such as OT is not medically necessary but is educationally necessary to assist a child to benefit from special education, the local education agency is responsible for providing the service. Cal. Gov’t Code § 7575(a)(2). 43. The Legislature found that special education services for children with disabilities age 3 to 5 may “[r]educe societal dependency and institutionalization,” “[r]educe the need for special class placement in special education programs once the children reach school age,” and “[s]ave substantial costs to society and our schools.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56441(e), (f), (g). A FAPE includes special education services designed to prepare the student for independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A). 44. Conformity with the IEP is not disputed. Because the District failed to offer STUDENTa FAPE, it is not necessary to determine whether the LRE requirement was met. 45. Ms. O’Neil has a master’s degree in education and an emergency education specialist credential to teach moderately to severely disabled students and is currently set to complete a credential program in spring 2003. She testified that, according to the District, her emergency credential permits her to teach preschool. From fall 1998 to June 2001, she taught a Woodstock preschool SDC for moderately to severely handicapped children with disabilities other than autism. During the 2001-2002 school year, she taught a District high school SDC for grade 9 to 12 students. Over 10 years ago, for 3 years she was the director of a private preschool for typical children.46. The current Woodstock preschool program consisting of the IPS class and EDP started in August 2001. (Testimony of Ms. Walters.) 47. The parties stipulated that Mr. Kruze is operating under an emergency education specialist instruction permit and anticipates obtaining a Preliminary Level I education specialist instru 48. The mother testified that BIA’s rates set forth in Student’s Exhibit 42 went up in approximately May 2002. The parents are entitled to reimbursement for the actual amount of the cost they incurred. 49. According to the mother, STUDENTattended ABC during the summer because, although she had been accepted to Temple Sinai preschool starting in fall 2002, the summer program there was only for children already enrolled in that program. 50. The mother testified that Ms. Bourne is a speech pathologist who works as a consultant for another school district. According to the mother, Ms. Bourne provides speech therapy in the family home. 51. The parents shall be entitled to transportation mileage reimbursement at the District’s rate for its employees for Temple Sinai or the offered preschool class, or transportation, pursuant to the May 21, 2002 IEP. 52. It does not appear that any regulations define a qualified specialist. However, under Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 3001(y), “qualified” means that “a person has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services . . . and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation, including . . . the California Business and Professions Code.” The District argues that the Student is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Lenington’s assessment because an IEE must meet the requirements of District assessments, and Dr. Lenington is not a school psychologist. This argument is without merit. When an IEE is at public expense, the “criteria under which the evaluation is obtained . . . must be the same as the criteria that the public agency uses when it initiates an evaluation, to the extent those criteria are consistent with the parent’s right to an [IEE].” 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(e). State law does not impose such a requirement for an IEE to be reimbursable. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Further, requiring an assessor who is a clinical psychologist to be licensed by the State Department of Education is inconsistent with a parent’s right to an IEE. See OSEP Letter to Petska, 35 IDELR 191 (Sept. 10, 2001).
