California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 16, 1996

Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1137-95 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Colton Joint Unified must reimburse Action School costs; Advocate School placement lacked a required behavioral intervention plan.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 7 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 13-year-old student with serious emotional disturbance lived at the ACTS residential facility. He challenged Colton Joint Unified School District's continued placement at Advocate School, a nonpublic school in Grand Terrace. An ACTS staff member with educational rights filed in November 1995 after the student's aggression increased. In July 1996, ACTS moved him to Action School, a nonpublic school on the ACTS site. The District argued that Action could not be considered because an ACTS administrator sat on the board of the company that runs Action. The Hearing Officer rejected this argument because Education Code section 56042 covers only a parent's attorney or advocate.

The Hearing Officer found that Advocate was not appropriate. The November 1995 IEP was never signed, so it never took effect. That meant Advocate added a one-to-one aide and made other changes outside the last valid IEP. The student had serious and growing behavior problems but no Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan. Advocate's internal treatment plans had no functional analysis assessment, no case manager, and no input from the IEP team. His behavior goals stayed the same for three years. On one point the District won: a one-to-one aide on the van had solved the transportation problems. Action was also found not appropriate going forward. Even so, the student had made progress there. The District was ordered to reimburse Action costs from July 8, 1996, and to pay for Action until a new IEP is in place. It must also hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to develop a compliant behavior plan.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied California's Hughes Bill rules. A nonpublic school's internal treatment plan did not replace a behavioral intervention plan based on a functional analysis assessment. It also shows reimbursement ordered on equitable grounds for a parent's own placement that the Hearing Officer found not fully appropriate.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue Procedural. Whether Action School may be considered, given the District's contention that Education Code § 56042 bars it because the ACTS administrator who supervises the educational decision-maker is a board member of CalPace, which operates Action School.

    Section 56042 applies only to a parent's attorney or advocate; Student's attorney had no conflict, so the District's request to disqualify Action School was denied.

  2. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue I-A. Is the Advocate Program in Grand Terrace an appropriate placement? Whether the placement conformed to Student's IEP.

    The November 1995 IEP was never signed and so never took effect; Advocate provided therapy, treatment plans and a one-to-one aide that were not in the last operative IEP (June 12, 1995), so the placement did not conform to the IEP. The District should have filed for due process instead of implementing changes without consent.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I-B(1). Whether daily van rides to Advocate prevented Student from benefiting from his education, so that his unique needs required placement on the ACTS site.

    With a one-to-one aide on the van, Student's transportation problems decreased, so his needs related to van rides were being met.

  4. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue I-B(2). Whether Student's unique needs required a Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan, and whether Advocate's treatment plans met that need.

    Student had serious, pervasive, escalating assaultive behavior that interfered with his goals, so he needed a behavioral intervention plan. Advocate's treatment plans lacked a functional analysis assessment, a case manager, IEP team development and required content, and did not address his behavior during transitions.

  5. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I-C. Whether the instruction and services were individually designed to provide educational benefit.

    Recent test gains were of questionable validity because of a possible practice effect and medication. Behavior goals stayed the same for about three years while incidents increased, so Advocate gave no benefit in behavior, the area of greatest need.

  6. Not reachedIEP procedure

    Issue I-D. Whether alleged procedural violations (lack of communication, inadequate IEP meeting notice, denial of full participation, failure to develop a behavioral plan) rendered the placement inappropriate.

    Because the placement already failed substantively, the Hearing Officer did not decide the procedural claims.

  7. Issue II. If Advocate is not appropriate, is Action School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

    Action was not appropriate going forward because it lacked a compliant behavioral intervention plan, gave little information about instruction, and placed Student with much younger peers. Because Student had progressed there and the District's placement was inappropriate and poorly supervised, equity supported reimbursement from July 8, 1996.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. District shall reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with placement at Action School from July 8, 1996, to the date of the decision (December 16, 1996), within 30 calendar days of receiving proof from Petitioner. No dollar amount stated.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. District shall convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the decision, with all required members, to develop an appropriate IEP that complies with the decision, including a behavioral intervention plan developed within the timelines required by special education law.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. Until the IEP and behavioral intervention plan are completed, the District shall arrange for, maintain, and pay for Student's placement at Action School.
  • Placement ordered. Once the IEP and behavioral intervention plan are completed, the District shall provide and arrange a placement that complies with the decision and the IEP and meets Student's unique needs. Guidance given: a compliant behavioral intervention plan, a small and highly structured setting with direct instruction, and a one-to-one aide or other safe special transportation if transportation is needed.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992); Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153; Education Code § 56042; Education Code § 56346; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, §§ 3001(f), 3052 (Hughes Bill); 34 CFR §§ 300.344, 300.348

People named in the decision

  • Bruce Blatchford, ACTS facility supervisor; educational decision-maker for Student from April 1996, ACTS
  • Ike Kerhulas, ACTS clinical director; educational decision-maker for Student before April 1996, ACTS
  • John Galioto, ACTS administrator and CalPace board member, ACTS / CalPace
  • Bonnie Russell-Hunt, Director of pupil personnel services, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager, East Valley SELPA
  • Dr. Edward Ryan, Clinical psychologist; 1991 psychological evaluation requested by ACTS
  • Dr. Steven Wagner, Assessor (1991 assessment and 1994 triennial), East Valley SELPA
  • James Kaufman, Special education teacher, Advocate School
  • Ron Wyatt, Aide (transitions, math and reading), Advocate School
  • Elizabeth Lenoir, Junior high special education teacher, Advocate School
  • Lindy Ross, Therapist, Advocate School
  • Mark Thomas, District witness (role not stated)
  • Donna Calhoun, 1:1 aide on van
  • Dr. Mark Diamond, Clinical psychologist; April 1996 psychological assessment requested by ACTS
  • Melissa Wisner, Principal, Action School (CalPace)
  • Cheryl Simpson, Professor of counseling and family science; assessed Student in July 1996, Loma Linda University
  • Anne Briggs, School psychologist; July 1996 assessment, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Robin Mitchell, School psychologist; July 1996 assessment, Colton Joint Unified School District
  • Advocate School, Nonpublic school (District placement), Grand Terrace
  • Action School, Nonpublic school (unilateral placement), CalPace
  • ACTS, Residential treatment center

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Colton, California, on July 23 and 24, 1996, and in Bloomington, California on October 1, 2, and 16, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Cynthia Ludvigsen. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was Bruce Blatchford, ACTS facility supervisor and the individual responsible for education decisions for Petitioner. Respondent Colton Joint Unified School District (District) was represented by attorneys Jim Baca and Karen Meyers. Also present on behalf of the District were Bonnie Russell-Hunt, director of pupil personnel services, and Gail Lindberg, program manager for the East Valley SELPA.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the request of the parties, the record was held open to allow for the submission of written closing arguments. On November 12, 1996, the Hearing Office received closing arguments from Petitioner and Respondent. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(I) Is the Advocate Program in Grand Terrace an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

(II) If Advocate is not appropriate, is Action School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

PROCEDURAL ISSUES

The District contends that Action School may not be considered pursuant to Education Code § 56042, which provides that an attorney or advocate for a parent of an individual with exceptional needs shall not recommend placement in a non-public, nonsectarian school or agency with which the attorney or advocate is employed or contracted, or otherwise has a conflict of interest or from which the attorney or advocate receives a benefit.

In the present case, John Galioto, administrator of the ACTS program, the residential facility where STUDENT lives, also serves as a board member for CalPace schools, which operates Action School. As administrator of ACTS, Mr. Galioto is the supervisor of Mr. Blatchford, the individual responsible for educational decisions for STUDENT. The District contends that this relationship violates § 56042 and that, therefore, Action should not be considered.

The District's attempt to include the present set of facts in the prohibition contained in § 56042, however, goes beyond the language of the section. Section 56042 clearly refers to the attorney or advocate of the parent of an individual with exceptional needs. In the present case, that individual is Ms. Ludvigsen. There is no evidence that Ms. Ludvigsen has a relationship with ACTS or Action which would raise any concerns. While Mr. Galioto's dual relationship with ACTS and Action may raise questions regarding his impartiality, he is not serving as the attorney or advocate for STUDENT and, therefore, the present case does not fall within the scope of § 56042.

The District's request that Action School be disqualified from consideration is denied.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is thirteen years old and eligible for special education as a result of a serious emotional disturbance (SED). STUDENT has also been diagnosed with a seizure disorder and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and as mildly mentally retarded. STUDENT's seizures are petit mal and are usually 10-30 seconds in length. The seizures can be stress-induced, and STUDENT may shake or move about uncontrollably. When STUDENT has seizures, he gets tired and often has to take a nap.

STUDENT came to the District from Redlands in 1991. At that time, STUDENT was at Advocate School, a nonpublic school certified to serve SED students, and the District continued his educational program at Advocate. In 1991, STUDENT was also placed at ACTS, a residential treatment center for boys with extreme behavior problems. In December 1992, STUDENT was returned to his mother. At that time, he was removed from both ACTS and Advocate. However, in November 1993, STUDENT was again placed at ACTS as a ward of the court by order of the Kern County Juvenile Court. STUDENT has remained at ACTS since that time and has had little contact with his mother and father. STUDENT also returned to Advocate in January 1994, where he remained until July 1996. While at Advocate, STUDENT received group therapy every week.

Since STUDENT was placed at ACTS in 1993, various employees of ACTS have been granted the authority to make educational decisions for STUDENT. In April 1996, Bruce Blatchford, the ACTS facility supervisor, was given such authority by STUDENT's father. Prior to that time, Ike Kerhulas, the ACTS clinical director, was the individual responsible for educational decisions for STUDENT.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

On March 19, 1991, Dr. Edward Ryan, clinical psychologist, conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT. The evaluation was requested by ACTS. At the time, STUDENT was almost eight years old and in the second grade. Dr. Ryan diagnosed STUDENT as having a developmental disorder and ADHD. On the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), STUDENT scored at the 1st percentile or below in reading, spelling, and arithmetic. STUDENT's IQ scores on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-R) were verbal IQ of 74, performance IQ of 61, and full scale IQ of 66.

On June 14, 1991, Dr. Steven Wagner completed an assessment of STUDENT for the East Valley SELPA. Dr. Wagner administered some behavioral measures and relied on Dr. Ryan's achievement and IQ results from March 19, 1991. Dr. Wagner concluded that STUDENT has substantial difficulty with social/emotional development and that he was eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). STUDENT was administered the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test (Woodcock-Johnson) on May 21, 1991, and at that time received grade equivalent scores ranging from K.0 (kindergarten, 0 month) on Passage Comprehension to 1.4 (first grade, fourth month) in Calculation and Applied Problems. An IEP was developed in June calling for continued placement at Advocate.

On June 3, 1992, STUDENT's IEP team met for the annual review of his IEP. At that time, the IEP continued placement at Advocate. Goals were adopted to address on-task behavior, aggressive behavior, ability to follow directions, use of materials, self-esteem, reading comprehension, reading vocabulary, math, and handwriting. Prior to the IEP, on May 26, 1992, STUDENT was administered the Woodcock-Johnson. At that time, his grade equivalent scores ranged from K.9 on Passage Comprehension to 1.6 on Calculation.

When STUDENT returned to ACTS in December 1993 after spending approximately one year with his mother, the District convened an IEP meeting on December 2, 1993, to discuss placement options. The IEP called for STUDENT to return to Advocate and continue the goals and objectives adopted in June 1992.

STUDENT's IEP team convened again on February 24, 1994.

Placement at Advocate was continued and new goals and objectives were drafted. The new goals addressed on-task behavior, aggressive behavior, ability to follow directions, utilizing materials, peer relationships, impulse control, letter sounds, reading, writing, and math. Prior to the IEP meeting, on February 18, 1994, STUDENT was administered the Woodcock-Johnson. His grade equivalent scores ranged from 1.6 on Passage Comprehension to 3.0 on Calculation.

On March 1, 1994, Advocate staff developed a treatment plan for STUDENT. The treatment plan, also referred to as a treatment team summary, is a treatment program developed by Advocate staff to address each student's social, behavioral, and social needs at Advocate. The treatment plans developed for STUDENT did not include any functional analysis assessments and he was not assigned a behavioral intervention case manager. The plans include goals and objectives relating to behavior and are developed annually and reviewed each six months. In addition, the treatment team meets to review the treatment plan any time a serious incident occurs. The treatment team does not include parents and the treatment plan is not incorporated into a student's IEP. Additionally, parents are not notified of changes in the treatment plan unless the changes directly involve the parents. For example, parents would be notified if the treatment team was recommending a medical referral.

STUDENT's treatment plan identified problem areas such as poor impulse control, including jumping out of his seat, touching others' belongings, stealing, throwing books or materials off his desk, and deliberately misplacing things; and aggressive behavior, including throwing objects, kicking, and hitting. The treatment plan indicated that STUDENT had 8-10 episodes of impulsive behavior per day and that he was on task 30-40% of the time with 3-4 prompts per direction. In addition, STUDENT had 6-8 episodes per week of hitting, kicking, or throwing. The goal of the treatment plan was to increase compliance and on-task behavior, and develop appropriate communication skills.

On June 8, 1994, Dr. Wagner conducted a triennial assessment of STUDENT for the East Valley SELPA. Dr. Wagner indicated in his report that STUDENT had experienced limited success at Advocate. Dr. Wagner administered the WISC-III, and STUDENT's IQ scores were a verbal IQ of 80, performance IQ of 75, and full scale IQ of 76. On the Woodcock-Johnson, STUDENT received grade equivalent scores of 1.4 in Spelling/Written Language, 1.7 in Reading Recognition/Comprehension, and 2.3 in Math Computation.

On June 22, 1994, the IEP team met for STUDENT's annual review. The team continued to recommend placement at Advocate because of STUDENT's extreme behavioral problems. In the "Present Levels of Performance" section of the IEP, the IEP team noted that:

[STUDENT is] reading in middle 1st grade -- can read some material using a cueing system. Written language is negligible. Can do some computation at 3rd grade level, but cannot apply math facts. Expressive language at 9-10 year level. Problems with receptive language and poor short-term auditory memory. Very short attention span -- needs almost constant guidance and supervision. Problems maintaining friendships. Poor visual motor planning and processing. Can do some pointing. Poor fine-motor, age appropriate gross skills. Is not aware of how his behavior impacts on others.

The goals adopted by the IEP team were identical in substance and scope to those adopted by the IEP team in February 1994.

On September 21, 1994, STUDENT's treatment team met to review STUDENT's treatment plan. The treatment team noted that STUDENT's behavior had regressed and that his problem areas included physical and verbal aggression as well as poor impulse control. Concerns regarding STUDENT included stealing, withdrawal and depression, and increased bizarre behavior. The treatment team decided to continue with the plan as developed in March 1994.

From January through October 1995, STUDENT was in a class of approximately 6-8 students taught by James Kaufman. Initially the class was self-contained with its own bathroom and time-out room. After three to four months, the class was moved to a "regular" room. An aide, Ron Wyatt, was assigned to STUDENT for transition periods during the school day. Mr. Wyatt also instructed STUDENT in math and reading. The curriculum at Advocate is "SRA Direct Instruction." According to Mr. Kaufman, SRA Direct Instruction is phonics-based and requires that every lesson be scripted. SRA is used for reading, math and language arts.

Mr. Kaufman testified that when he first started teaching STUDENT, he was withdrawn, did not participate, and it was difficult to keep him on task for more than a couple of minutes. However, by April 1995, STUDENT was participating more; and by the end of the school year, if he was participating in an activity he enjoyed, he could stay on task for 15-20 minutes. STUDENT also began enjoying group activities.

On June 8, 1995, STUDENT was administered the Woodcock-Johnson. His grade equivalent scores ranged from 1.5 on Dictation and Writing Samples to 2.8 on Calculation. In the broad subject areas, STUDENT's grade equivalent scores were 2.5 on Broad Reading, 2.4 on Broad Math, and 1.5 on Broad Written Language.

On June 12, 1995, STUDENT's IEP team convened for his annual review. The goals and objectives adopted on June 12, 1995, were essentially the same as those in June 1994 except that the math goals now involved multiplication and division rather than addition and subtraction, and the reading goal was for STUDENT to read a short story at the fourth grade level with 80% accuracy. His prior reading goal was to learn 150 Dolch words with 100% accuracy. The IEP team noted that STUDENT had made progress in his nonpublic school placement and that he would continue placement there for the 1995-96 school year.

In the section of the IEP describing present levels of performance, the team noted that his reading was improving; he continued to exhibit delays in receptive language and have difficulty with expressive language; he needed a great deal of redirection and was verbally and physically aggressive to his peers; and he needed constant reassurance and prompts to remain on task.

From September 1994 through August 1995, STUDENT had fifteen incident reports.(FOOTNOTE 1) Six of those incidents involved physical assaults or attempted physical assaults on other persons. Two incidents involved destruction or attempted destruction of property. Other reports included threatening or abusive language.

On September 12, 1995, STUDENT's treatment team met to review his program. The team noted that his verbal and physical aggression had increased and his poor impulse control and on-task behavior continued to be problems. According to the treatment plan, STUDENT had 8-10 behavioral incidents per day and 6-8 incidents of physical or verbal aggression per week. The team noted that STUDENT was on task 10-20% of the time and the rest of the time he was disassociating. The team established a goal for STUDENT to be able to stay on task 50% of the time. No new goals regarding impulse control or aggressive behavior were adopted. The team recommended that his current treatment be continued with a change in his one-on-one time with male staff. The treatment team noted concerns for STUDENT as including increased aggressive behavior, not learning from experience, eating out of trash cans, picking nose more, and demonstrating very unsociable behavior.

On October 3, 1995, Ike Kerhulas, who was responsible for educational decisions for STUDENT at that time, requested an IEP meeting for STUDENT. At the end of October 1995, STUDENT was involved in an incident in which he attempted to stab another student in the eye with a pencil. Advocate staff notified ACTS staff of the incident and an emergency IEP meeting was requested by ACTS staff.

Following the incident, STUDENT's treatment team at Advocate also decided to assign a one-to-one aide to STUDENT and remove him from his class for much of the school day. During each class period, STUDENT spent most of the period in another room with his one-to-one aide. STUDENT would return to the class with his aide for the final 10-15 minutes of the period. This arrangement lasted for approximately two weeks. STUDENT was then returned to the classroom with the one-to-one aide assigned permanently to him. Two weeks after STUDENT was returned to his classroom, the treatment team at Advocate decided to move STUDENT to the junior high school program. The decision was made because the team believed STUDENT needed a more age-appropriate peer group.

Because of difficulties with schedules, including Mr.

Kerhulas', the IEP meeting was not held until November 13, 1995. The meeting held on November 13, 1995, functioned as both the emergency IEP meeting and the IEP meeting requested by Mr. Kerhulas on October 3, 1995. At the IEP meeting, ACTS staff raised the stabbing incident, problems STUDENT was having on the van, and concerns regarding STUDENT's apparent lack of progress. They requested placement at Action on the ACTS site. District representatives on the IEP team determined that Advocate continued to be appropriate while ACTS staff dissented. The IEP team also decided to continue STUDENT's one-to-one assistant, assign him to a class with older students, and place a one-to-one aide with STUDENT on the van.

On November 15, 1995, Mr. Kerhulas submitted a letter expressing his concerns regarding STUDENT's educational program to Bonnie Russell-Hunt. Mr. Kerhulas repeated the concerns expressed at the IEP meeting and recommended that STUDENT be placed at Action, where he would have "realistic behavioral and academic goals" and be monitored throughout the entire day. In addition, Mr. Kerhulas pointed out that placement at Action would eliminate problems relating to transportation and would be less expensive than Advocate. On the same day, Mr. Kerhulas requested a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT.

When STUDENT was transferred to the junior high program, he was placed in Elizabeth Lenoir's class, where he started in December 1995. At that time, there were two aides in the class, one of whom was assigned specifically to STUDENT. For the first six weeks, the aide sat next to STUDENT to make sure he did not engage in aggressive behavior and to meet his needs without his having to act out. After the six weeks, the aide began working with the other students. STUDENT continued receiving weekly therapy and continued receiving his instruction through the SRA Direct Instruction program.(FOOTNOTE 2)

On April 8, 1996, Mark Diamond, clinical psychologist, conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT at Mr. Kerhulas' request. Dr. Diamond administered the WISC-R and STUDENT's scores were as follows: Verbal IQ - 64, Performance IQ - 78, Full Scale IQ - 69. According to Dr. Diamond, these scores indicate that STUDENT is performing in the mild mental retardation range of intelligence. Dr. Diamond also administered the Woodcock-Johnson-Revised. On that test, STUDENT's grade equivalent scores ranged from 1.2 on Calculation to 3.1 on Science and Social Studies. On the broad measures of achievement, STUDENT's grade equivalent scores were 2.0 on Broad Reading, 1.6 on Broad Mathematics, 1.4 on Broad Written Language, and 2.7 on Broad Knowledge.

Dr. Diamond noted that STUDENT "has a tendency to discharge his emotions in an impulsive manner, with a drive towards the immediate satisfaction of his needs, without thinking of the appropriateness of his behavior. His affective impulses frequently interfere with his ability to adequately perceive his environment." Dr. Diamond recommended individual psychotherapy to decrease STUDENT's feelings of worthlessness, inadequacy, and depression, and to harness his angry impulses and minimize his explosive actions. Dr. Diamond also recommended consistent structured daily activities to help with his ADHD.

Dr. Diamond also made numerous recommendations regarding STUDENT's program and the specific steps that could be taken to improve his skills. For example, Dr. Diamond recommended that STUDENT's understanding of basic arithmetical processes needed to be further developed. STUDENT's work on arithmetic should include practice and drill work, the basic processes should be applied to everyday practical problems, and his math work should include basic calculations with whole numbers, decimals, common fractions, and percents. As another example, Dr. Diamond recommended that STUDENT's short term verbal memory and attention span be increased through the use of memory aides, such as outlines, notes, or other brief reminders. STUDENT should also be given clear, sequential directions and he should repeat those directions.

From September 1995 through June 1996, STUDENT had twenty-four incident reports, nineteen of which involved assaults or destruction of property. These incidents ranged from striking or punching students in the face to throwing a pencil sharpener to the ground and crushing it with his foot to biting and kicking staff.

On May 13, 1996, STUDENT's treatment team met to develop a new treatment plan for STUDENT. The treatment plan identified goals in the areas of on task behavior and task completion, aggressive behavior, following directions, respect for school property, peer relationships, and impulse control. According to the treatment team notes, STUDENT's time on task had improved, and his aggressive behavior did not involve hitting or kicking anymore. According to the treatment plan, this information was based on staff notes.

On July 8, 1996, STUDENT was unilaterally placed at Action School, a certified nonpublic school, by Mr. Blatchford. Action School is a nonpublic school operated by CalPace. Action serves primarily SED students from kindergarten to 12th grade. The Action school site STUDENT was enrolled at is on the same site as the ACTS residential facility. As of July 1996, there were approximately 12 students at Action in two different classes. The students are divided into their classes based on ability and developmental level. STUDENT's class is the lower functioning class, and the students in that class are working on basic skills such as reading and writing. The curriculum at Action is similar to that of a public school, and STUDENT's class uses state adopted textbooks and the state approved framework for the curriculum.

Action has an extended-year program during which time the students take more field trips and the instruction focuses on a chosen theme. While Action could provide therapy if STUDENT needed it, his therapy is presently provided by ACTS. ACTS also provides a one-to-one aide for STUDENT at Action during the school day.

When STUDENT first enrolled at Action, he had several serious behavioral incidents that required prone restraint within the first few weeks. However, since August, STUDENT has not had any serious behavioral incidents or required prone restraint. In addition, when STUDENT first enrolled at Action, the one-to-one aide was with him during the entire school day. The one-to-one aide now leaves Action at 1:00 p.m. and STUDENT remains until the end of the school day without the aide. STUDENT is able now to function in the classroom on his own, develop his own daily goals, and discuss those goals at the end of the day. Finally, STUDENT has fewer timeouts and has had no behavioral reports since August 1996.

Melissa Wisner, Action School principal, testified that STUDENT also requires less help from aides on academics, is better able to follow directions, stays on task longer, is more willing to cooperate and do work, and has shown growth in his writing skills.

On July 9, 1996, Cheryl Simpson, professor of counselling and family science at Loma Linda University, assessed STUDENT at Action.(FOOTNOTE 3) In addition to testing conducted during the assessment, including a vocabulary test, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale, the Wide Range Achievement Test, the Peabody Individual Achievement Test, and the Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test, Dr. Simpson reviewed records provided by ACTS. Dr. Simpson did not review records from Advocate or Action other than STUDENT's IEPs from 1992, 1994, and 1995. Dr. Simpson also did not observe STUDENT in a school setting or discuss him with school staff.

During the assessment, STUDENT's attention span was limited to seconds, and he needed constant encouragement and rewards. On the achievement test administered by Dr. Simpson, STUDENT's scores were at or below the first percentile. According to Dr. Simpson, STUDENT's achievement scores were consistent with his IQ level and were where he would be expected to perform. Dr. Simpson did not conduct any social-emotional testing because his behavior during the testing and his educational history established that he met the SED criteria.

Based on her assessment of STUDENT, Dr. Simpson concluded that STUDENT's behavior needs to improve before he can make significant academic progress. Dr. Simpson testified that STUDENT was the most out-of-control child she has ever assessed. Dr. Simpson also indicated that STUDENT would not be safe during transportation or in a school setting without one-on-one supervision and that the more familiar the environment STUDENT is in, the safer he will feel. Regarding STUDENT's on-task behavior, Dr. Simpson stated that STUDENT does better with manipulatives and that he responds well to verbal praise and rewards.

On July 10, 1996, STUDENT was assessed by Anne Briggs and Robin Mitchell, school psychologists with the District. Neither Ms. Briggs or Ms. Mitchell was aware that STUDENT had been assessed by Ms. Simpson on July 9, or by Dr. Diamond in April 1996. On the Woodcock-Johnson academic testing administered on July 10, 1996, STUDENT received grade equivalent scores ranging from 1.8 on word recognition and math computation to 2.2 on reading comprehension and math reasoning. STUDENT's verbal IQ score on the WISC-III was 60. Ms. Briggs concluded that STUDENT is functioning within the developmentally delayed range and that his academic levels are commensurate with his present level of intellectual functioning. Ms. Briggs also concluded that STUDENT continues to qualify for special education as a result of a serious emotional disturbance.

According to Ms. Briggs, her assessment was a valid indicator of STUDENT's performance on that day. However, because of his heavy medication and unwillingness to be tested, Ms. Briggs was of the opinion that the assessment was not a valid indicator of STUDENT's potential.(FOOTNOTE 4) Ms. Briggs made numerous recommendations regarding how STUDENT's instruction should be delivered. For instance, he should be given as many "hands-on experiences" as possible; his curriculum should be based on his interests, primarily sports; oral responses should be encouraged; he should be allowed to use a computer as a reinforcer, to enhance such skills as memory, and in lieu of handwritten work; and all instruction should be given in small, sequential steps.

DISCUSSION

(I) Is the Advocate Program in Grand Terrace an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have a right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982), 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide a three factor analysis for determining whether an educational placement is appropriate.

A. A free appropriate public education must conform to the student's IEP.

B. The special education services must be designed to meet the student's unique needs.

C. The instruction and services must be individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student.

Rowley also establishes that procedural violations committed by a school district may, by themselves, result in a placement being inappropriate. The Rowley Court stated that

Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process... Rowley, EHLR 553:656,670.

The Rowley Court stated that claims brought under the IDEA involve two issues. First, whether the placement offered by the school district was substantively appropriate. Second, whether the school district complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. See also W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit (1992) 18

IDELR 1019.

Petitioner contends that placement at Advocate is inappropriate because STUDENT failed to progress there, both academically and behaviorally. Petitioner contends that the daily van ride to and from school adversely impacts STUDENT's ability to benefit from his education. Petitioner also contends that Advocate's failure to develop a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT renders the placement inappropriate. Finally, Petitioner contends that there has been a lack of communication between ACTS, Advocate, and the District, which has excluded ACTS from the educational planning for STUDENT, and that the District has committed other procedural violations.

The District contends that placement at Advocate is appropriate because it is designed to enable STUDENT to benefit from his education and that he demonstrated progress, both academically and behaviorally. The District also contends that placement at Advocate is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT and that placement at Action School would be more restrictive.

A. A free appropriate public education must conform to the student's IEP.

Education Code § 56346 states that

[n]o pupil shall be required to participate in all or part of any special education program unless the parent is first informed, in writing, of the facts that make participation in the program necessary or desirable, and of the contents of the individualized education program, and after this notice, consents, in writing, to all or part of the individualized education program.

Section 56346 also provides that the portions of the IEP to which the parent, in this case Mr. Kerhulas, consents may be implemented. Several District witnesses, including Ms. Russell-Hunt and Lindy Ross, STUDENT's therapist at Advocate, testified that Mr. Kerhulas consented orally to the assignment of the one-to-one aide and removal of STUDENT from his class immediately after the pencil incident at the end of October 1995. However, as of November 15, 1995, Mr. Kerhulas expressed his dissent to the entire placement at Advocate in writing and there is no substantial evidence to indicate that he consented to any of the changes made by Advocate following the IEP meeting in November 1995.

Furthermore, the IEP developed on November 13, 1995, is not signed by Mr. Kerhulas. Without signed consent from Mr. Kerhulas, the IEP dated November 13, 1995, is not an operative IEP, nor was any portion of it operative.(FOOTNOTE 5) Therefore, for purposes of analyzing the appropriateness of Advocate, the last operative IEP is the one dated June 12, 1995.(footnote 6)

Education Code § 56345(a) lists the required elements of an IEP. Among those elements is that the IEP list the specific special educational instruction and related services required by the pupil. See also 34 CFR § 300.346. Those designated instruction and services are defined by Education Code § 56363 to include, but not be limited to, counseling and guidance, and psychological services. According to the IEP dated June 12, 1995, STUDENT's education was to take place in a nonpublic school placement. Although the therapy and treatment plans are clearly included in the list of related services required to be designated on a student's IEP, there is no mention of therapy or treatment plans in STUDENT's June IEP.

As of November 1995, two changes in STUDENT's program took place -- the provision of a one-to-one aide and the transition to the junior high school program. A one-to-one aide is not specifically included in the list of designated instruction and services contained in § 56363. However, designated instruction and services are defined by § 56363 as those services which "are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." District witnesses, including James Kaufman, Lindy Ross, and Mark Thomas, testified that STUDENT's behavior was deteriorating during the fall and that the culmination of that deterioration was the pencil incident. The testimony of those witnesses established that STUDENT was in need of extra supervision at that time for him to "benefit educationally."

STUDENT's behavior had deteriorated to the point that he was a risk to himself and others. At that time, a one-to-one aide constituted a service necessary for him to benefit from his education. As such, it was a designated instruction and service that should have been listed on his IEP and agreed to by his IEP team. STUDENT's last operative IEP, however, does not list a one-to-one aide.

Therefore, STUDENT's placement at Advocate was not in compliance with his IEP once a one-to-one aide was assigned to him and not included in a valid IEP.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's placement at Advocate at the time the dispute arose between the parties was not in conformance with his last operative IEP dated June 12, 1995.

Services, in the form of therapy and treatment plans, were provided which were not included on the IEP. In addition, the assignment of a one-to-one aide was made without the consent of Mr. Kerhulas. The Hearing Officer notes that Education Code § 56346 provides a school district with a mechanism by which to request a due process hearing if a parent does not consent to an IEP the school district believes is appropriate. Once Mr. Kerhulas refused to consent to the IEP developed by Advocate on November 13, 1995, the District should have requested a due process hearing rather than implementing services which were not agreed to by Mr. Kerhulas in a signed IEP.

B. The special education services must be designed to meet the student's unique needs.

The parties do not dispute that STUDENT needs a small, structured setting with direct instruction techniques in which to receive his education. In addition, the parties agree STUDENT's behavioral needs must be met to allow him to benefit from his education and he should be positively and immediately rewarded for appropriate behavior.

There are two areas, however, in which the parties differ regarding STUDENT's needs. First, Petitioner contends that the van ride to and from school adversely impacts his ability to benefit from his education and that his unique needs require that he be educated at the Action School on the ACTS site. The District contends that the van rides do not interfere with STUDENT's ability to benefit from his education. Second, Petitioner contends that STUDENT's unique needs must include a Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan and that Advocate's treatment plans do not constitute such a plan. The District contends Petitioner did not require a Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan and that the treatment plans developed by Advocate meet STUDENT's unique needs in the area of behavioral management.

1. Van Rides

As already stated, STUDENT has a significant problem with transitions, including the van rides. However, the evidence establishes that, with the provision of a one-to-one aide, STUDENT's problems on the van decreased. Donna Calhoun, the one-to-one aide assigned to STUDENT on the van from November 1995 through March 1996, testified that STUDENT was well-behaved after about one week with her as his one-to-one aide. Ms. Calhoun also testified that STUDENT was usually very calm when he arrived at school in the morning. Ms. Calhoun testified that she never had to complete an incident report for STUDENT.

In addition to Ms. Calhoun's testimony, the documentary evidence establishes that STUDENT had only two incident reports regarding van rides once the one-to-one aide was assigned.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique needs relating to the van rides were being met by the provision of a one-to-one aide.

2. Behavioral Management

A student requires a behavioral intervention plan when he or she has a serious behavior problem that is self-injurious, assaultive, or causing property damage, or which is pervasive and maladaptive and that requires systematic and frequent application of behavioral interventions. In addition, the serious behavioral problem must significantly interfere with the implementation of the student's goals and objectives. See California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3001(f) and (y).

While District witnesses, including Ms. Ross, Ms. Lenoir, and Mr. Kaufman, testified that STUDENT's behavior was improving, the incident reports indicate that STUDENT's behavior was deteriorating. As stated above, STUDENT had fifteen incident reports for the twelve month period from September 1994 through August 1995. For the nine month period from September 1995 through June 1996, STUDENT had twenty-four incident reports. Of those twenty-four incident reports, nineteen involved assaults or property destruction. The incident reports establish that STUDENT's behavior was becoming more aggressive and more frequent.

Based on the content of the incident reports, treatment plans, and testimony of witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had a serious behavior problem which was self-injurious, assaultive, or causing property damage.

Furthermore, there is evidence that his behavior problem was pervasive and maladaptive and required systematic and frequent behavioral interventions. STUDENT's IEPs, treatment plans, and assessments refer to his needs for constant rewards and redirection, and to his frequent behavioral problems. As already stated, STUDENT's treatment plans refer to a significant number of behavioral incidents occurring each day and each week. STUDENT's IEP from June 22, 1994, refers to his need for almost constant guidance and supervision. The IEP dated June 12, 1995, states that he "needs [a] great deal of redirection -- verbally and physically aggressive to peers and adults" and "needs constant reassurance and prompts to remain on task." STUDENT's IEPs also include more goals regarding behavior than academics and cover such areas as on task behavior, aggression, impulse control, and following directions.

Ms. Lenoir, STUDENT's teacher from December 1995 until July 1996, testified that STUDENT required daily timeouts which lasted as long as thirty minutes in December 1995. By the time STUDENT left Advocate in July 1996, he still needed several timeouts per week. Ms. Lenoir also testified that STUDENT required at least 15 positive reinforcing statements for each negative statement regarding his behavior and school work.

Based on the documentary evidence outlined above and Ms.

Lenoir's testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's behavior problem was pervasive and maladaptive and required systematic and frequent behavioral interventions.

The final question is whether STUDENT's behavioral problem was interfering with the implementation of his goals and objectives. Mr. Kaufman testified that STUDENT's behavior was impeding his academic progress in February 1995. Although Mr. Kaufman testified that STUDENT's behavior had improved by April 1995, he along with other witnesses, including Ms. Ross, testified that STUDENT's behavior again deteriorated in Fall 1995. As already stated, Ms. Lenoir also testified regarding the number of timeouts STUDENT required while he was in her class. STUDENT's behavior also led to his removal from his class for a period of several weeks and the assignment of a one-to-one aide for a period of several months.

The Hearing Officer also notes that many of STUDENT's goals and objectives specifically relate to the behavior problems he has which interfere with his ability to benefit from his education. Goals relating to on-task behavior, impulse control, following directions, and respecting property all pertain to issues that need to be addressed before he can benefit from his education.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's behavior problems were interfering with the implementation of his goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required a behavioral intervention plan to meet his unique needs. For the following reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the treatment plan developed by Advocate does not meet the requirements for a behavioral intervention plan:

a. The treatment plan has never been made a part of STUDENT's IEP and does not include information regarding the frequency of consultation as required by CCR, Title 5, § 3001(f). The treatment plan also was not developed by STUDENT's IEP team as required by CCR, Title 5, § 3052(c)

b. No functional analysis assessment was completed as required by CCR, Title 5, § 3052(b).

c. There is no evidence that a behavioral intervention case manager has been assigned to monitor STUDENT's behavior and the implementation of the treatment plan as required by CCR, Title 5, § 3052.

d. The treatment plan does not include much of the detailed information required to be in a behavioral intervention plan by CCR, Title 5, § 3001(f)(1)-(8). For instance, there is no reference in the treatment plan relating to behavioral interventions at home or in other settings, there are no specific schedules for recording the use of interventions or criteria for discontinuing interventions.

In addition to the fact that STUDENT's treatment plan does not comply with the legal requirements for a behavioral intervention plan,(footnote 7) the treatment plans were not meeting STUDENT's needs. As already stated, there is a wealth of evidence regarding STUDENT's behavior problems. The most compelling evidence regarding STUDENT's behavior problems is the fact that virtually every incident report written on STUDENT for the 1994-95 and 1995-96 school years involved incidents during transitions; for example, while he was leaving for a break, returning from a break, or on the van going to or from school. Interestingly, when District witnesses were questioned, none of them believed there was a specific time of day when STUDENT's behavior was worse. There is no mention in any of STUDENT's treatment plans of transition periods or unstructured times and how to deal with those times. Additionally, while Advocate staff testified that STUDENT's behavior was improving, the incident reports tell a different story. Compared to the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT's behavior problems not only increased in number but in severity as well.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's placement at Advocate did not meet his unique needs because he did not have a behavioral intervention plan developed in compliance with education law.

Additionally, the treatment plan developed by Advocate did not meet STUDENT's needs because his behavior was escalating and there was nothing in the plan to address his problems with transitions.

C. The instruction and services must be individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student.

The District points to STUDENT's report cards and test scores as demonstrating that he was progressing in his placement at Advocate. Over the past five years, STUDENT's scores on standardized achievement tests have improved from kindergarten and first grade level to high second grade level in several subjects. However, the validity of STUDENT's more recent achievement test scores may be questioned for two reasons.

First, by the District's psychologist's testimony, the results from the most recent assessment were of questionable validity due to the drug regimen STUDENT was on at the time. Second, it is a generally accepted principle that a student may gain a "practice effect" on a test if he or she takes the same test too frequently or too often. The "practice effect" could result in a student's scores being higher than his or her actual achievement or ability. In the present case, STUDENT has taken the Woodcock-Johnson achievement test in May 1991, May 1992, February 1994, June 1994, June 1995, March 1996, and in July 1996. At least the last three times STUDENT has taken the test, it was the Woodcock-Johnson-Revised version. Considering that STUDENT has been administered the same version of the Woodcock-Johnson three times within a thirteen-month period of time and the potential practice effect, his most recent results are of questionable validity in assessing how much progress he really has made.

In the area in which STUDENT is in most need of benefit -- behavior -- STUDENT has not received benefit from his placement at Advocate. The witnesses were in agreement that STUDENT's behavior is the primary concern for him at this time and that his behavior needs to be controlled before he can benefit from any sort of academic or functional living program. Yet, as already described above, the evidence establishes that Advocate was not meeting STUDENT's needs relating to behavior.

Furthermore, the IEPs establish that STUDENT was not progressing in his behavioral goals and objectives. While it may be true that certain behavioral goals and objectives will have to be repeated from year to year for STUDENT, it is also true that some progress should be made. Instead, STUDENT's IEPs establish that his behavioral goals and objectives remained essentially the same over a two- to three-year period. STUDENT's on-task goal on his June 1995 IEP was identical to his on-task goal on his June 1992 IEP. STUDENT's goal relating to aggressive behavior increased from 80% to 90% from June 1992 to June 1994. However, in June 1995, the goal remained at 90%. STUDENT's goal relating to following directions remained the same from June 1992 through June 1995. In June 1994, the IEP team added additional goals relating to impulse control and peer relationships. These goals remained the same on STUDENT's IEP of June 1995.

The behavioral goals and objectives outlined in STUDENT's IEPs establish that STUDENT did not progress significantly on those goals and objectives over a three-year period. Furthermore, the incident reports establish that STUDENT's behavior was deteriorating rather than escalating. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that in the area that mattered most for STUDENT -- behavior -- the placement at Advocate was not providing him with educational benefit.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement at Advocate did not conform to STUDENT's IEP, was not meeting his unique needs, and was not providing him with educational benefit in compliance with the IDEA and Rowley.

D. Procedural Violations

Petitioner raises several potential procedural violations which he claims render his placement inappropriate. Petitioner's alleged procedural violations include lack of communication, failure to develop an appropriate behavioral intervention plan, failure to provide adequate notice for IEP meetings, and failure to provide full participation in educational decision-making. The District's lack of supervision and involvement in STUDENT's program at Advocate raises concerns regarding procedural violations as well.

However, based on the Hearing Officer's finding above that the District's placement at Advocate did not satisfy the substantive requirements of the IDEA and Rowley, the Hearing Officer does not reach the issue of whether alleged procedural violations rendered the placement inappropriate.

(II) If Advocate is not appropriate, is Action School an appropriate placement for STUDENT?

Petitioner contends that Action is an appropriate placement because it will provide him with a highly structured program in a familiar setting, along with better coordination between the school and his residential facility and availability of ACTS staff to assist with crisis intervention. Petitioner further contends that STUDENT's behavior and school work have improved since his first few weeks at Action.

The District contends that Action is not appropriate for STUDENT because the Action curriculum is not designed to meet his needs, the other students in his class are too young, there was no evidence of therapy or counseling being provided for STUDENT at Action, and placement at Action is a more restrictive placement than at Advocate.

Using the Rowley test, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's program at Action is not appropriate for prospective placement for the following reasons. As already stated, STUDENT requires a Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plan based on a functional analysis assessment, monitored by a behavioral intervention case manager, and including the components contained in CCR, Title 5, § 3052. While Ms. Wisner testified that he has a behavioral intervention plan at Action, the plan she described is similar to that developed at Advocate and does not comply with the requirements contained in the California Code of Regulations.

Without such a comprehensive behavioral intervention plan, STUDENT's program at Action does not meet his unique needs and is not appropriate pursuant to Rowley.

It is also not clear what type of instruction and curriculum STUDENT is working with at Action. Ms. Wisner testified that Action uses state approved textbooks and curriculum. However, she provided very little information on how that curriculum is delivered to STUDENT. Petitioner has failed to provide sufficient information regarding the curriculum and manner of instruction at Action to ensure that the program is meeting STUDENT's unique needs.

Also of concern is the age of the students in STUDENT's class. As testified to by Advocate staff, STUDENT is at an age where he needs to be placed with children his age to assist him with his socialization skills and behavior modification. Placement in a class with students as young as nine years of age and in which STUDENT is one of the oldest students does not meet his socialization needs.

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the present program at Action School is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year.(footnote 8)

Although the placement at Action is not an appropriate placement pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley, the District may still be required to reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with his placement at Action. Equitable considerations must be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Courts have authorized reimbursement to a parent even though the unilateral placement was not the "exact proper placement" required under the IDEA. See Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153.

The testimony of Ms. Wisner establishes that STUDENT has progressed both academically and behaviorally at Action since July 1996. The evidence establishes that Action is a very small school with a highly structured program that allows a substantial amount of coordination between Action staff and the staff at ACTS. Ms. Wisner testified that she meets weekly with Mr. Blatchford and talks with him or other ACTS staff more frequently. STUDENT also has continued to receive therapy through the ACTS facility during his placement at Action. Furthermore, so long as STUDENT is placed at the Action site at the ACTS facility, van rides will not be an issue which affects his education.

The District has consistently proposed Advocate as the placement for STUDENT even though ACTS staff have raised questions of its appropriateness since at least June 1995 and possibly June 1994. Advocate has made several significant changes to STUDENT's program -- assignment of one-to-one aide, removal from his class, transition to junior high program -- without a signed IEP indicating that Mr. Kerhulas consented to such changes. The District has not appropriately supervised STUDENT's placement at Advocate by failing to participate in his most recent IEP.

Ultimately, the District's placement for STUDENT at Advocate was not appropriate because it failed to meet his unique needs, conform to his IEP, or provide him with educational benefit.

Based on STUDENT's progress at Action School since he enrolled there and the District's provision of an inappropriate placement and the lack of supervision by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of STUDENT's placement at Action from July 8, 1996, to the date of this decision.

Since neither placement proposed by the parties is appropriate pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley, the parties will need to convene and IEP meeting to develop an appropriate placement for STUDENT. With that in mind, the Hearing Officer provides the following guidance for the IEP team in developing an appropriate placement.

First, STUDENT's behavior requires a behavioral intervention plan developed and implemented in compliance with the sections of the California Code of Regulations, Title 5, relating to behavioral intervention plans. Second, as all witnesses agreed, STUDENT requires a small, highly structured educational environment with direct instruction. Third, if STUDENT's placement requires transportation, he should have a one-to-one aide assigned to him on the van or have other safe special transportation provided.

ORDER

1) Colton Joint Unified School District shall reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with placement at Action School from July 8, 1996, to the date of this decision.

Reimbursement shall be made within 30 calendar days of receipt of proof from Petitioner.

2) Colton Joint Unified School District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate IEP in compliance with this decision, including the development of a behavioral intervention plan in accordance with the timelines required by special education law. The IEP meeting shall be held within 15 days of the date of this decision and include the members required by state and federal education law.

3) Pending completion of the IEP and behavioral intervention plan, Colton Joint Unified School District shall arrange for, maintain, and pay for STUDENT's placement at Action School.

4) Upon completion of the IEP and behavioral intervention plan, Colton Joint Unified School District shall provide and arrange for a placement for STUDENT which is in compliance with this decision, his IEP, and meets his unique needs.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

ISSUE NO. 1: Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 2: Petitioner partially prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: December 16, 1996 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. For purposes of this decision, the incident reports reflect misbehavior and reports involving sleeping or seizures are not included.

2. STUDENT remained in Ms. Lenoir's class until he was removed from Advocate and unilaterally placed by Mr. Blatchford at Action School in July 1996.

3. At the time Ms. Simpson testified, a written report was not available. The information regarding Ms. Simpson's assessment is taken entirely from her testimony.

4. At the time of the assessment, STUDENT was on Thorazine, Cogenten, Depakote, Tegretol, and Haldol. 5. Even if the IEP dated November 13, 1995, had been agreed to by Mr. Kerhulas, it is unclear from the document what exactly the IEP called for. In relevant part, the comments section of the IEP states

[STUDENT] was provided with a one-to-one assistant to assist him to stabilize his behavior. Staff expresses concern about transportation. Individual support will continue, as needed. While dangerous behaviors are evidence, a one-to-one aide will be on the bus with separate transportation, if needed.... He will be moved to a classroom with older students with an emphasis on social skill development.

There is no mention of moving STUDENT to the junior high school program. In addition, the language is unclear exactly what type of aides would be provided and under what circumstances. The language also indicates that a one-to-one aide of some sort was assigned to STDENT before the IEP team even met. 6. There is an additional question regarding the validity of the November 1995 IEP. Much of what took place in November 1995 took place without apparent involvement from the District. Federal special education law places the burden of developing an appropriate IEP and educational placement on the District. 34 CFR § 300.344(a)(1) requires that "a representative of the public agency, other than the child's teacher, who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, special education" be present at all IEP meetings. Section 300.348 provides that when a private school initiates an IEP meeting for a child already placed at the school, a school district representative must be (a) involved in any decision about the student's IEP, and (b) agree to any proposed changes in the program before those changes are implemented. No personnel from the District attended the IEP meeting; the only individuals present were employees of ACTS and Advocate. The IEP was not developed in compliance with § 300.344(a)(1), and without a District representative present at the IEP meeting, it is difficult to imagine how the District could have been involved in the decisions being made about STUDENT's placement. Therefore, it is questionable, even if Mr. Kerhulas had consented to the IEP, whether it could be considered a valid and operative IEP for STUDENT. 7. Also of significance is that the treatment plans provide a box to be checked if the plans are behavioral intervention plans. That box was not checked on any of STUDENT's treatment plans. 8. Given the lack of information regarding the Action School, the Hearing Officer is unable to find that it is appropriate at this time. However, the Hearing Officer's ruling does not preclude Action School from being considered in the future if changes are made which result in the program at Action School complying with this decision and the

IDEA.