California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 23, 2000

Student v. William S. Hart Union High School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1138-00 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke

William S. Hart Union High must fund a year of Kelter Center math and writing remediation; transition claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 7 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that an earlier 1998 due process request on many of the same issues was dismissed without prejudice. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.

Summary

A former Saugus High School student filed for due process in June 2000, two years after graduating with a diploma. She was eligible for special education with a learning disability affecting math and also received speech and language services. Because of the three-year statute of limitations, the Hearing Officer reviewed only July 1997 through the end of 12th grade (1997-1998).

The Hearing Officer found that William S. Hart Union High School District denied her a FAPE that year. Her January 1997 IEP was still in effect and had a math goal, but she was in no math or resource class where the goal could be worked on. She had met graduation math requirements and chose not to take math, but that did not excuse the District from implementing the goal. The District also failed to address her writing needs, though she tested well below grade level and teachers reported weak writing.

Her transition plans lacked detail. But the District gave real transition services through its transition partnership program, a Strategy class, and links to the Department of Rehabilitation and College of the Canyons. The Hearing Officer held that the thin plans were harmless.

The Hearing Officer rejected the District's argument that graduation made the claim moot. She ordered the District to pay for Kelter Center remediation four hours a week for one school year, about two-thirds math and one-third writing. The student had asked for 1,200 hours.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated an IEP goal that a district never implemented. A student's choice to skip a course did not excuse the district, which had to find another way to work on the goal. It also shows graduation did not make a request for compensatory education moot, and that thin transition plans could be harmless when real services were given.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1a. Did the District deny a FAPE from July 1997 to the end of the 1997-1998 school year by failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address Petitioner's academic difficulties in math and written expression?

    The January 1997 IEP math goal, still in effect, went unimplemented in 12th grade, and the District failed to address the student's identified written expression needs or report progress on goals; this denied FAPE.

  2. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1b. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to provide Petitioner with an appropriate educational placement?

    The District placed the student in no math, resource or tutorial setting where her math goal could be worked on. Her choice not to take math after meeting graduation requirements did not relieve the District of its duty.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPETransition

    Issue 1c. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to develop a proper transition plan based upon Petitioner's individual needs?

    The individual transition plans lacked detail but reflected the student's preferences and goals. The flaw was harmless because appropriate transition services were actually provided; each party partially prevailed.

  4. District prevailedTransition

    Issue 1d. Did the District deny a FAPE by failing to provide appropriate transition services?

    The transition partnership program, the Strategy class, and links to the Department of Rehabilitation and College of the Canyons gave the student a coordinated set of appropriate transition services.

  5. Not reachedTransition

    Issue 1e. Did the District deny a FAPE by changing Petitioner's placement without her consent or knowledge by reason of issuance of a high school diploma?

    Issuing the diploma did not affect services during the period at issue, and post-graduation years were not at issue. The Hearing Officer also held that graduation did not make the compensatory claim moot. Neither party prevailed.

  6. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2a. If the District denied a FAPE, is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education in the form of 1200 hours of designated instruction and services provided by a certified nonpublic agency such as the Kelter Center to address her educational deficiencies?

    The Hearing Officer awarded Kelter Center math and writing remediation, four hours a week for one regular school year, which is less than the 1,200 hours requested.

  7. District prevailedTransition

    Issue 2b. If the District denied a FAPE, is Petitioner entitled to compensatory transitional services to permit her to transition from high school to post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, continuing and adult education, and independent living?

    No compensatory transition services were awarded because the District provided appropriate transition services.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. The District shall provide remediation through the Kelter Center, a certified nonpublic agency, in math and written language. Services are four hours a week for an amount of time equal to one regular school year, with about one-third on writing and two-thirds on math. The District arranges and pays for the services. The student and the Kelter Center decide scheduling and order.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; T.S. v. Independent School District No. 54; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; S.V. v. Sherwood School District

People named in the decision

  • Marty Lieberman, Director of special education, William S. Hart Union High School District
  • Ilene Blok (also spelled Block), Guidance counselor, Saugus High School
  • Andrea Ackerman, Licensed psychologist, expert witness for Student, Private practice
  • Laurel Baer, Former assistant principal, Saugus High School
  • Eileen Pola, Resource specialist; Career Visions class instructor, William S. Hart Union High School District
  • Gary Clark, Professor of special education, transition expert witness for Student, University of Kansas
  • Sasha Borenstein, Founder and director, expert witness for Student, Kelter Center (nonpublic agency)
  • Kelter Center, Certified nonpublic agency providing academic remediation, Private
  • Eileen Volpe, Resource specialist teacher, William S. Hart Union High School District
  • Madhavi Williams, School psychologist, William S. Hart Union High School District
  • Gary Wexler, Director of curriculum and assessment, William S. Hart Union High School District
  • Jacquelyn (Jackie) Dearmon, Vocational rehabilitation counselor, California Department of Rehabilitation
  • Douglas R. Worley, Strategy class teacher, Saugus High School
  • Ronald J. Rudzinski, Career education specialist, William S. Hart Union High School District
  • Ty Devoe, English / creative writing teacher, Saugus High School
  • Jane Feuerhelm, Director, Disabled Students Programs and Services, College of the Canyons
  • Diane Delavara-Solomon, Disabled Students Programs and Services counselor, College of the Canyons
  • Louise Willard, Career transition advisor / vocational case assistant, transition partnership program, William S. Hart Union High School District
  • Deidre Bradford, Career transition advisor / vocational case assistant, transition partnership program, William S. Hart Union High School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Santa Clarita, California on October 2 and 3, 2000, January 15, 16, 17, and 18, 2002, February 21, 22, 26, 27, and 28, 2002, and March 21 and 22, 2002.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Steven Wyner. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was her father, FATHER. Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER, was also present on behalf of Petitioner on various days of the hearing. Respondent William S. Hart Union High School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Barrett K. Green of Littler Mendelson law firm. Also present on behalf of the Respondent was Marty Lieberman, director of special education for the District.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Ilene Block, counselor at Saugus Highschool; Andrea Ackerman, licensed psychologist; Laurel Baer, former assistant principal at Saugus High School; Eileen Pola, resource specialist for the District; Gary Clark, professor of special education at the University of Kansas; STUDENT; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Sasha Borenstein, founder of the Kelter Center; Eileen Volpe, resource teacher for the District; and Madhavi Williams, school psychologist for the District

The following witnesses were called by Respondent to testify: Gary Wexler, director of curriculum and assessment for the District; Jacquelyn Dearmon, vocational rehabilitation counselor with the Department of Rehabilitation; Douglas R. Worley, teacher at Saugus High School in the District; Ronald J. Rudzinski, career educational specialist with the District; Ty Devoe, English teacher at Saugus High School; Marty Lieberman, Jane Feuerhelm, director of disabled students programs and services at the College of the Canyons; Diane Delavara-Solomon, counselor with the disabled students programs and services at the College of the Canyons; Louise Willard, career transition advisor for the transition partnership program in the District; and Deidre Bradford, career transition advisor for the transition partnership program in the District.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from July 1997 to the end of the 1997-1998 school year by a. Failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address Petitioner’s academic difficulties in math and written expression?

b. Failing to provide Petitioner with an appropriate educational placement?

c. Failing to develop a proper transition plan based upon Petitioner’s individual needs?

d. Failing to provide appropriate transition services?

e. Changing Petitioner’s placement without her consent or knowledge by reason of issuance of a high school diploma?

2. If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of a. 1200 hours of designated instruction and services provided by a certified nonpublic agency such as the Kelter Center to address Petitioner’s educational deficiencies, and b. Transitional services as may be required to permit Petitioner to transition from high school to postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, continuing and adult education, and independent living?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a twenty-two-year-old student who previously attended Saugus High School in the William S. Hart Union High School District (District). She currently resides with her parents and attends College of Canyons in Valencia, California.

In 1994, STUDENT entered Saugus High School in the District, where she continued receiving the same special education services as a student identified with a learning disability as she had been receiving in middle school. STUDENT started high school receiving services through the resource specialist program, and also received speech and language services. According to MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT was in body brace from the beginning of eighth grade to her senior year in high school in order to correct a curvature of the spine resulting from the physical conditions of kyphosis and lordosis. STUDENT wore the body brace one hundred percent of the time, thus inhibiting much of her movement. In January 1995, adaptive physical education (APE) was added to STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) to help her improve her upper body strength and increase her understanding of human musculature. Results of a June 1995 three-year psychoeducational re-evaluation confirmed that STUDENT had a specific learning disability that manifested as a deficiency in visual motor integration and numerical reasoning, contributing to a severe discrepancy between measured ability and academic achievement in math calculation and reasoning.

STUDENT was in the tenth grade during the 1995-1996 school. Her first IEP meeting at Saugus High School was held on September 28, 1995. That IEP team indicated that STUDENT demonstrated average cognitive ability and recommended that STUDENT continue her placement in the resource specialist program (RSP) as the least restrictive environment. In September 1996, an IEP team identified that STUDENT had delays in the area of pragmatic skills and had decreased intelligibility as a result of her increased rate of speech. The IEP team recommended that she continue receiving speech and language services one time each week for forty minutes.(Footnote 2)

For the 1996-1997 school year (eleventh grade), STUDENT was selected to participate in the District’s transition partnership program (TPP), which included a two-semester career visions class at Saugus High School. The TPP is a collaborative program between the District and the California Department of Rehabilitation (DOR) that a student begins two years before graduation from high school and continues on a monitor status after the student graduates from high school. The program includes a coordinated set of sequential events that is designed to help students prepare for their future after high school.

On November 6, 1996, an individual transition plan (ITP) that identified her desired postschool outcomes and exit goals was first developed for STUDENT. The November 1996 ITP indicated that STUDENT had an ultimate career/employment goal of working as a sound or recording engineer and that she intended to take adult education classes. STUDENT also planned to live with family and relatives and establish semi-independence with assistance from family and relatives. STUDENT was enrolled in a photo class at Cal Arts at that time.

On January 29, 1997, STUDENT’s second annual IEP meeting was held, at which time all members of the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be placed in an RSP class on an as-needed basis and continue enrollment in the transition partnership program. Receiving RSP on an as-needed basis meant that STUDENT would be mainstreamed into regular education classes and given assistance in the context of the general education classroom, if necessary. APE was also offered. The IEP indicates that at that time, STUDENT’s broad reading grade level score was 10.0, broad math was 5.9, and broad written language was at the 6.7 grade level. One math goal and related objectives were drafted. However, there was no formal recommendation on the IEP document that STUDENT enroll in a math course. After having discussed her class schedule with her school guidance counselor, STUDENT ultimately made the decision not to enroll in any math courses during her junior or senior year of high school. According to STUDENT’s then-guidance counselor, Ilene Blok, although she encouraged STUDENT to take a math course during her junior year, she believed it was STUDENT’s right to decide not to take math in both her junior and senior years because she had fulfilled the math requirements for graduation. On January 29, 1997, another ITP was drafted indicating that STUDENT would attend a trade school on a full-time basis, obtain an AA degree, and become a music mixer/sound engineer. The ITP also indicated STUDENT’s desire to obtain her driver’s license.

An ITP dated May 22, 1997, indicated that STUDENT planned to work the summer at Magic Mountain as an usher, but that she still had a long-term goal of becoming a music engineer. That document also lists educational vocational goals of attending College of the Canyons (COC) on a full-time basis, then receiving music training in music engineering and attending the Liverpool Institute. The ITP also indicated that STUDENT was in the process of being accepted by the Department of Rehabilitation (DOR) to receive vocational rehabilitation services.

On May 27, 1997, the DOR deemed STUDENT eligible to receive vocational rehabilitation services. The DOR provides services to individuals who have disabilities that prevent them from gaining access to employment. According to DOR records, the DOR determined that STUDENT’s kyphosis and lordosis, which required her to wear a body brace that restricted her physical activity and mobility, as well as her specific learning disability, placed her in the severe disability priority category, which the DOR was then serving.

During the fall semester of the 1997-1998 school year (twelfth grade), among other classes, STUDENT was enrolled in a semester-long class called “Strategy.” The purpose of the Strategy class was to teach students how to be successful in life and to assist students with the transition from high school to adult living. An ITP dated October 21, 1997, indicated that STUDENT desired to find full-time employment in the area of art and design. She still planned to attend COC, but now planned to go on to John Moore University in England and major in art. On November 7, 1997, during an IEP meeting specifically regarding speech and language services, the IEP team changed STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition to speech and language, and indicated that STUDENT exhibited moderate delays in the areas of oral language and speech. According to the IEP, these delays were exhibited in pragmatic skills, speech intelligibility, vocabulary, and recalling information from orally presented material. Speech and language goals were written to help improve STUDENT’s auditory comprehension and expressive language skills, and speech and language services were offered on a one-time-a-week basis for fifty minutes. STUDENT also continued to remain eligible for special education and related services through the 1997-1998 school year under the category of learning handicapped. According to the parties, three different IEPs were simultaneously in effect from July 1997, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year - the IEPs of January 29, 1997, November 7, 1997, and June 11, 1998.

On June 6, 1998, the District psychologist conducted a three-year psychoeducational re- evaluation of STUDENT. The evaluation revealed that STUDENT’s nonverbal cognition was in the low average range of ability. Scores that were well below age expectation on the Learning Efficiency Test II test of visual and auditory memory indicated that STUDENT may have had significant difficulty recalling information that she saw and heard, particularly in the order the information is presented, and that she may have had significant difficulty recalling what she had read, taking notes in class, and following verbal directions. In the area of social-emotional development, the assessor indicated that STUDENT’s psychology teacher reported that although STUDENT was a lovely, cheerful young woman, she had low writing skills and scored poorly on class tests. STUDENT’s twelfth grade creative writing teacher also indicated that STUDENT had difficulty with the writing portion of the class.

On June 8, 1998, just eight days before STUDENT’s June 16, 1998 graduation date, the District noticed an IEP meeting for June 11, 1998. Although STUDENT’s mother expressed discontent that ten days’ notice had not been given, the IEP meeting was held on June 11, 1998. The IEP document indicated that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education services as a learning disabled student and that the resource program continued to be the least restrictive environment. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT remain in the resource specialist program on monitor status once a week for fifteen to twenty minutes. One math goal was written to address STUDENT’s continued severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in math calculation. However, the IEP document also noted that STUDENT was not enrolled in a math class and that she had completed the required courses in math to graduate high school. An ITP was written at that IEP meeting indicating that STUDENT was uncertain whether she would work and that she planned to attend COC on a full-time basis and study art and design. The ITP also indicated that STUDENT would live at home with her family while attending college and that she would obtain her driver’s license.

Although STUDENT had reached eighteen years of age on July 24, 1997, STUDENT’s parents signed the June 1998 IEP and her mother indicated that she approved of STUDENT’s eligibility for special education but disapproved of the goals and objectives and the placement. A statement signed by the parents indicated their disappointment over the fact because STUDENT was graduating in six days, she would be unable to work on algebraic goals and meet them while in high school. The box requesting a due process hearing was checked. The IEP document acknowledged that STUDENT was not then enrolled in math and that she had already taken the required courses in math to graduate high school. The contents of IEP appear to have served as a guide for her enrollment in college in the fall of 1998, because one of the objectives indicated that STUDENT needed to take required math classes while attending COC after graduation. (Pet.’s Exh. 1.)

STUDENT received a diploma and graduated from Saugus High School in June 1998 with a grade point average of 2.57 and a class ranking of 261 in a class of 438.

On June 23, 2000, the Hearing Office received a request on behalf of Petitioner for a due process hearing. The hearing request alleged that the District failed to provide Petitioner with a FAPE for a number of reasons, including failing to provide transition services and a proper transition plan, failing to timely notify Petitioner of her rights under IDEA, failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives, and failing to provide Petitioner with an appropriate educational placement. According to Petitioner’s counsel’s opening statement, Petitioner had previously filed a due process hearing request in 1998 involving the District and alleging many of the same issues in the case at hand. That case, however, was dismissed without prejudice.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

The incidents surrounding the issues in this case occurred by or before the effective date of the 1997 IDEA amendments and related federal regulations. The 1997 amendments to the IDEA became effective on July 1, 1998. Therefore, in analyzing the issues in this case, the Hearing Officer will apply the laws and regulations in effect prior to July 1, 1998.

In addition, during the hearing in this matter, the Hearing Officer ruled that the three-year statute of limitations precluded Petitioner from raising claims that arose more than three years prior to the date of the filing in this case -- June 23, 2000. The Hearing Officer informed the parties that, therefore, she would hear only those issues regarding alleged acts and/or omissions that occurred from July 1997 through the end of the 1997-1998 school year. (CA Educ. Code §56505(j).)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from July 1997 to the end of the 1997-1998 school year by a. Failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address Petitioner’s academic difficulties in math and written expression?

b. Failing to provide Petitioner with an appropriate educational placement?

c. Failing to develop a proper transition plan based upon Petitioner’s individual needs?

d. Failing to provide appropriate transition services?

e. Changing Petitioner’s placement without her consent or knowledge by reason of issuance of a high school diploma?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with her IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of her disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not have been achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Educ. Code § 56031.)

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, (3) comported with her IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.

What are STUDENT’s unique needs?

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE from July 1997 to the end of the 1997-1998 school year, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of math and written expression during the same time frame. The parties generally agreed that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services based on her needs in the area of math. Testing indicated that STUDENT had deficiencies in math calculation and reasoning due to processing deficits in sensory motor integration and conceptualization. (Pet.’s Exh. 6.) According to the IEP dated January 29, 1997, STUDENT was then performing at the 5.9 grade level in math and required a math goal and objectives to address her ability to understand and solve problems in the areas of general math processes and simple algebra.

The parties also did not dispute that given STUDENT’s learning disability, her restricted mobility due to her having to wear a back brace, and her indicated apprehension about getting accepted into college and obtaining a job, STUDENT required transition services in the form of instruction, community experiences, and the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives. (Resp.’s Exh. T-1 to T-2.)

The parties disagree, however, as to whether STUDENT had needs in the area of written expression that should have been addressed by the IEP team during her senior year. Having conducted intelligence testing of STUDENT and having reviewed all of STUDENT’s IEPs since second grade and assessment reports, licensed psychologist Andrea Ackerman testified that the intelligence data indicated STUDENT is of average intelligence. Ms. Ackerman also testified that the documents regarding written language were in some areas consistent in reflecting a deficit in written language and other documents were slightly inconsistent in that respect. Ms. Ackerman believed, however, that based on her review of test scores on the Woodcock Johnson-Revised test, STUDENT had a deficiency in writing, particularly in the areas of writing mechanics, dictation, and punctuation/capitalization. The assessments also reflected an ongoing indication of language difficulties in the area of verbal pragmatics.(Footnote 3) (Pet.’s Exh. 26A.)

Sasha Borenstein, founder and director of the Kelter Center, a private agency that provides academic remediation services to children and adults, conducted a review of STUDENT’s educational records and held a discussion with STUDENT over the telephone regarding her educational history. Ms. Borenstein believed that given STUDENT’s fifth-grade level of functioning while in the eleventh grade, STUDENT’s two areas of greatest need were in mathematics and writing skills. Ms. Borenstein testified that STUDENT needed assistance with writing, specifically in the areas of spelling, syntax and grammar, organizing ideas, punctuation and capitalization, pre-writing and brainstorming, editing, and drafting.(Footnote 4) According to Ms. Borenstein, if a student is testing in the below average range, there is a need for intervention until the student masters the skill.

Ty Devoe, STUDENT’s Creative Writing teacher in the twelfth grade, testified that because STUDENT put a great deal of effort into the class, she received an A in the class the first semester, and a B+ the second semester. However, according to Mr. Devoe, STUDENT had difficulties with the more formal components of his class, such as the writing. (Resp.’s Exh. 5.)

District school psychologist Madhavi Williams testified that STUDENT’s June 1998 standard test score of 88 in broad written language did not necessarily reflect a need for a goal in that area.(Footnote 5) According to Ms. Williams, the Wechsler and Satler professional manuals interpret a standard score of 88 to be in the broad average range of ability (80-119), not the below average range. However, Ms. Williams’ June 1998 re-evaluation report indicates that STUDENT’s senior year psychology teacher reported that STUDENT had low writing skills and scored poorly on tests. Ms. Williams also reported that STUDENT’s responses on a sentence completion test suggest that she had age-appropriate concerns. (Pet.’s Exh. 28.) Ms. Williams’ testimony appeared to suggest that STUDENT must be eligible for special education and related services specifically in the area of written expression in order to receive services to address that need. However, it is well settled that once a student is deemed eligible to receive special education and related services, she is entitled to an educational program that addresses all of her unique needs and affords her an opportunity to benefit educationally. (Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg (9th Cir. 1995) 59 F.3d 884.) The evidence sufficiently demonstrated that STUDENT’s writing difficulties probably arose out of the same processing disorder (sensory motor integration and conceptualization) that was the primary cause of her learning disability in math calculation and math reasoning. Accordingly, written expression was as an area of demonstrated need that should have been addressed by the IEP team.

The above summarizes STUDENT’s needs as expressed by the witnesses and in the documentary evidence. Given STUDENT’s average intelligence and identified deficiencies in the areas of math and written language for the time period of June 1997 through the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT required goals and objectives to address deficiencies in the those areas of deficit. The documentary evidence also indicates that the least restrictive mode of providing special education services to STUDENT could have been best provided in a resource specialist program where she could have received instruction and assistance in math and worked on necessary goals and objectives. In addition, transition services were necessary to help STUDENT transition from school to post-school activities, including attending college, receiving vocational training, and obtaining employment. Next, it must be determined whether the goals and objectives, services, and placement provided by the District were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit.

Issues 1a. and b. - Goals and Objectives and Educational Placement in the Areas of Math and Written Expression(Footnote 6)

Math

Petitioner argues that the District’s repetition of the same math goals and objectives year after year, without reporting on her progress, or lack thereof, is conclusive proof that STUDENT made no progress in math. Petitioner also contends that the District failed to implement her previously drafted math goal and objectives because it did not place her in a math class and a resource class during the eleventh and twelfth grades and thus failed to provide instruction in this subject area.(Footnote 7)

The District argues that by the end of STUDENT’s tenth-grade year, she had completed the requirements for mathematics to graduate from high school. It also argues that STUDENT’s counselor repeatedly urged STUDENT to take math during and following her junior year in high school, but STUDENT steadfastly refused to take math. The District contends that it could not force STUDENT to take a math class if she chose not to and that STUDENT was within her rights in making a decision to defer until college the math course work she found difficult. According to STUDENT, she attempted to take pre-algebra in the tenth grade, but it was recommended that she drop that class and take the basic math class instead, since she was not making any progress despite her extra work during the lunch hour with the class teacher. STUDENT’s struggles in math were also demonstrated by the math grades of D, D+, F, and two Cs that she received in the ninth and tenth grades and by her 5.9 grade level performance scores in math as of January 1997. (Pet.’s Exh. 6.)

STUDENT’s tenth-grade IEP dated September 28, 1995, included one math goal with two objectives to assist STUDENT in understanding and solving any given math problem in the area of math applications. The subsequent IEP dated January 29, 1997, however, does not indicate whether the previous math goal and objectives from 1995 had been addressed or met. The January 29, 1997 IEP included one math goal similar to that included in the September 1995 IEP. It stated: “By the end of the school year, STUDENT will be able to understand and solve any given math problem in the area of math app.” The January 1997 IEP also contained the following two objectives: “1) STUDENT will be able to solve math problems in areas including general math processes and simple algebra. 2) STUDENT will proofread all work before handing in completed assignments.” (Pet.’s Exh. 6.) Aside from the one math goal and two objectives written into her IEP of January 29, 1997, no math goals or objectives were drafted again for STUDENT until the June 6, 1998 IEP meeting, just ten days before her graduation date. In addition to including one math goal and related objectives, the most recent January 29, 1997 IEP indicated “RSP class added as needed.” According to Ms. Blok, this notation meant that if STUDENT was not successful in her classes, she could add a resource vocations class as she needed it. The resource vocations class was taught in a separate room and covered study skills that apply to all subject areas, but not any particular subject. Eileen Volpe, the resource specialist instructor assigned to STUDENT during her senior year, testified that during STUDENT’s twelfth-grade year, she provided instruction to STUDENT in math as it related to her economics class and general math processes. However, since there was no specific RSP class, if STUDENT asked for assistance, Ms. Volpe would occasionally meet with STUDENT during her library science class for fifteen to twenty minutes. (Testimony of E. Volpe.) Ms. Volpe, however, did not describe the extent to which she provided such instruction or whether such instruction related to STUDENT’s January 29, 1997 math goal and objectives. Ms. Volpe also testified that she did not provide STUDENT with any instruction related to simple algebra, which was a part of her January 1997 math goal. (Pet.’s Exh. 6, pg. 3.)

According to Ilene Blok, STUDENT’s guidance counselor in high school during the time frame in question, Saugus High School had no pull-out RSP services and had no RSP classes in any specific subject. Rather, students at Saugus High School were mainstreamed into regular education classes and given assistance within the context of the general education system. Ms. Blok testified that STUDENT last took a math class during the summer program just after her sophomore year. When she discussed with STUDENT her junior year class schedule, Ms. Blok testified that she suggested to STUDENT that she take pre-algebra, but STUDENT responded “no.” According to Ms. Blok, she tried to encourage STUDENT to take a math class during her junior year, but Ms. Blok believed she could not force STUDENT to do so because it was STUDENT’s right to determine whether she would take math in her junior and senior years.(Footnote 8) Ms. Blok also testified that Eileen Volpe never informed her that STUDENT had math goals and objectives written into her IEP or that she needed to be re-enrolled in a math class or resource class.

According to MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, she reminded Ms. Blok that STUDENT’s IEP included a math goal that required her to take a math class and receive some assistance. According to MOTHER, she attended the January 29, 1997 IEP meeting at which the math goal was written and asked why the goal was written at such a low level. The response she received was that they had to keep the goal at a reasonable level because they could only expect STUDENT to achieve so much. STUDENT testified that she assumed STUDENT would be enrolled in a math class, and when she asked how they would work on the math goal, the response from the District was that they would make sure it was addressed.

Both the District and STUDENT’s mother agreed to implement the goals and objectives in the IEP of January 29, 1997. (Pet.’s Exh. 6, pg. 2.) Moreover, neither party disputes that the IEP of January 29, 1997, was in effect during the 1997-1998 school year. (See Resp.’s closing brief, pg. 17; Pet.’s closing argument, pg. 3.) IEP goals and objectives are generally written to cover a one-year period, and once the IEP team agrees to include a goal and objectives in an IEP, the District has the obligation to implement the IEP accordingly. The only way for the District to relieve itself of that obligation would be to hold an IEP meeting, which it did not do again until November 7, 1997. The November 1997 IEP, however, addressed only STUDENT’s speech and language needs. (Pet.’s Exh. 3.) In addition, the District conceded that the IEP held in June 1998 was a follow-up to the January 1997 IEP and that it should have been held by no later than January 29, 1998. (Resp.’s closing brief, pg. 17.) The January 29, 1997 IEP does not indicate how the math goal and objectives would be implemented. Therefore, although STUDENT opted out of taking a math class, the District could have implemented the January 1997 IEP by arranging a separate class, a RSP class, or tutorial for STUDENT, during which she could have worked on the math goal and objectives. Taking a math class was not the sole manner in which the math goal and objectives could have been implemented.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that by the end of her sophomore year, STUDENT had satisfied the District’s math requirements for graduation and had expressed little interest in taking a math class during her senior year. However, because the District had included a math goal and related objectives in her then-current IEP, and because all parties agreed that the January 1997 IEP was in effect during her senior year and neither the parents nor STUDENT objected to that IEP, the District had the responsibility to implement the IEP in that respect. There was no evidence that STUDENT had completed her prescribed course of study with respect to math, since the District never reported on STUDENT’s progress, or lack thereof, on any of the previous math goals and objectives. Moreover, the math goal and objectives from STUDENT’s IEP dated January 29, 1997, were not implemented during STUDENT’s senior year because she was not enrolled in a math or resource class during that time. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Volpe’s vague testimony that she worked on basic math processes with STUDENT in relation to her economics class during her senior year was not sufficient indication that she provided instruction specifically related to STUDENT’s previously drafted math goal and objectives. The Hearing Officer also notes that the math goal and objectives continued to be a part of STUDENT’s then-current IEP. Therefore, having already identified math as an area of need for STUDENT, and having previously drafted a goal and related objectives to address that need, the District had an obligation to call an IEP meeting to propose placement, support, and services to address that need during STUDENT’s senior year.(Footnote 9)

To meet STUDENT’s unique needs, provide her with some educational benefit, and comport with her IEP, the January 29, 1997 IEP math goal and objectives required implementation during STUDENT’s senior year. The District, however, failed to implement the January 29, 1997 math goal and objectives by not providing an appropriate educational placement where she could have worked on them. (Rowley, supra 458 U.S. at 200-201.)

Written Expression

Petitioner contends that her difficulties in written expression were clearly known to the District and that the District failed to address her need in that area. Accordingly, Petitioner argues that she continued to require goals and objectives for written expression when her IEP dated January 29, 1997, was written. Because the January 29, 1997 IEP carried over into STUDENT’s senior year, Petitioner contends that the IEP failed to report whether she had made any progress toward achieving the previously drafted written expression goal and objectives, thus violating 34 C.F.R. §300.346(a)(1).

The District contends that there existed no discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and achievement in written language during her senior year in high school. According to the District, STUDENT performed very well in her English class and received a benefit from the class, as noted by the progress she made in the area of written language. The District also argues that although it believes that the IEP team was correct in concluding that STUDENT’s performance in written language did not warrant preparation of a goal and objective in that category, even if it were established that she needed such, STUDENT did not establish that the lack of any such goal or objective had any adverse impact on her.

STUDENT’s tenth-grade IEP dated September 28, 1995, indicates that STUDENT’s written language skills were at the 5.4 grade level. The IEP included a goal and three objectives designed to improve her use of grammar, correct punctuation, spelling, and sentence writing. (Pet.’s Exh. 9, pg. 4.) However, no subsequent IEPs indicate whether STUDENT met or made any progress toward achieving that goal and the related objectives. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT demonstrated a need in the area of written language. STUDENT’s twelfth-grade creative writing teacher, Mr. Devoe, testified that STUDENT’s broad written language grade-level score of 6.7 noted on her January 29, 1997 IEP would have made her an appropriate candidate for the eleventh- and twelfth-grade English labs that he taught, and that were designed to assist students who performed significantly below their grade levels.

STUDENT’s twelfth grade psychology and creative writing teachers both indicated that STUDENT had difficulty with writing. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT could have worked on written language goals and objectives in the creative writing class that she completed during her senior year; however, there was no indication that STUDENT’s creative writing teacher worked on any of STUDENT’s previously drafted written language goal and objectives. The IEP team should have evaluated and determined, on at least an annual basis, whether STUDENT’s short-term instructional objectives had been achieved. (20 U.S.C. §1401(20)(F); 34 C.F.R. §300.347(a)(5).) Therefore, given STUDENT’s 6.7 grade-level performance in written language as indicated in the January 29, 1997 IEP, the IEP team’s previous identification of a need for a written language goal, and the absence of documentation of her progress on meeting that goal, or lack thereof, the Hearing Officer concludes that during STUDENT’s senior year, written expression was an area of need related to her learning disability that required addressing by the IEP team. In order to have met STUDENT’s unique educational needs and provided her with some educational benefit, the District should have either drafted new written language goals and objectives or ensured that STUDENT was able to continue working during her classes on any previously drafted goals and objectives not yet addressed or met. (Rowley, supra 458 U.S. at 200-201.)

***

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program and services provided by the District during STUDENT’s senior year were not appropriate. Standardized testing demonstrated that, during her senior year, STUDENT was performing significantly below grade level in both math and written language, and that there was no evidence she had met or made any progress on previously drafted math and written language goals and objectives. The January 29, 1997 IEP, which contained a math goal and two objectives, was still in effect during her senior year; however, STUDENT was not enrolled in either a math or RSP class in which the goal and objectives could have been implemented. There were no new written language goals and objectives and no evidence that her creative writing teacher worked on the previously drafted written language goal in class. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that during the 1997-1998 school year, neither the IEP nor the services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or provide her with educational benefit. Issues 1c. and d. - Transition Plan and Services

Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide transition services. Specifically, Petitioner argues that the District failed to develop a proper transition plan based on her individual needs, taking into account her preferences and interests, and that it failed to coordinate needed transition services across, and linkages between, agencies responsible for providing or paying for transition services.

In response, the District contends that it provided STUDENT with appropriate transition services to assist her in achieving her goal of attending College of the Canyons and continuing on to attend a four-year college or trade school thereafter. The District also contends that it provided STUDENT with services consistent with those recommended by the State of California in the Transition Survival Guide, thus enabling STUDENT to transition from the District. Additionally, the District argues that the transition plans prepared by the District comported with the requirements of the IDEA, and the extent to which they did not comprehensively document all of the services that were provided did not rise to the level of a denial of a FAPE under the IDEA.

An amendment to the IDEA, effective October 1991, requires that when a student reaches age 16, and annually thereafter, the student’s IEP must include a statement of transition services the student needs before leaving the school setting. (20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20).) California law, which became effective January 1993, contains similar provisions. (CA Educ. Code §56345.1.)

Transition services provided to special education students must include instruction, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, acquisition of daily living skills and a functional vocational evaluation. (20 U.S.C. §1401(19).) The IEP team may decide, however, that services are not needed in one or more of the above-noted areas, as long as the IEP includes a statement to that effect and the basis upon which the determination was made. (34 C.F.R. §300.346(b)(2).) The services are to be designed within an “outcome-oriented process, which promotes movement from school to post-school activities, including post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment (including supported employment), continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation.” (20 U.S.C. §1401(19).)

A determination of appropriate transition services must be based upon the individual student’s needs, taking into account the student’s preferences and interests. (Id.) Toward this end, the District was required to invite STUDENT to attend each of her IEP meetings, and, if she did not attend, to take other steps to ensure that her preferences and interests were considered. (34 C.F.R. §300.344(c)(1), (2).) In addition, the IEP must include, when appropriate, “a statement of the interagency responsibilities or linkages (or both)” that are required for transition services. (20 U.S.C. §1401(20); 34 C.F.R. §300.346(b).)

STUDENT turned sixteen years of age on July 24, 1995. Although an individual transition plan (“ITP”) was not written for STUDENT until November 1996, Petitioner has not raised this as an issue in this case. Additionally, that time frame falls outside the three-year statute of limitations and the applicable time frame (July 1997 through the end of the 1997-1998 school year) being considered by the Hearing Officer. After the first ITP was prepared for STUDENT in November 1996, ITPs were thereafter written for STUDENT in January 1997, May 1997, October 1997, and June 1998. Additionally, during both semesters of the eleventh grade, STUDENT enrolled in the District’s transition partnership program (TPP), a program sponsored by the California Department of Rehabilitation for the purpose of exposing students to various career options.

All of STUDENT’s ITPs prior to her senior year, starting with the first one dated November 6, 1996, indicated that STUDENT’s ultimate career goal was to become a sound or recording engineer. As of the October 21, 1997 ITP, however, STUDENT’s career goal was modified to finding employment in the field of art design. Upon graduation, STUDENT was uncertain of her employment goals.

In the area of education, STUDENT’s ITPs document that her goal was to attend school full-time and attend a trade school in the area of music training to become a music engineer. By May 1997, STUDENT had specifically decided to first attend College of the Canyons after high school and obtain her AA degree, then take music training, and then attend the Liverpool Institute in England. (Pet.’s Exhs. 1, 4, 5, 6, and 7; Resp.’s Ex. 11.) As of October 1997, however, STUDENT’s educational goals focused on majoring in art. All of the witnesses associated with the District’s TPP testified that they were well aware that STUDENT’s career goal was to become a music/sound engineer and that she planned to attend COC and obtain her AA degree, and later study in England. (Testimonies of Eileen Pola, Louise Willard, Deidre Bradford, Ron Rudzinski, and Jackie Dearmon.) STUDENT’s ITPs also indicated that she intended to live at home with her family while attending college full time. (Pet.’s Exh. 1 and 7.)

Petitioner called Gary Clark, a special education professor at the University of Kansas who has taught college-level courses in transition services, as a witness to testify regarding the transition plan and services provided by the District. Professor Clark has written several books on transition planning and services. He also was involved in the drafting, review, and editing of various phases of the Chanda Smith Consent Decree, Los Angeles Unified School District’s coordinated implementation plan for students with disabilities to transition from school to adult living. According to Professor Clark, based on his review of STUDENT’s educational records, STUDENT’s individual transition plans did not include any instructional goals and objectives for transition, particularly in the areas of math and self-advocacy skills.

A review of the individual transition plans shows that they clearly identified STUDENT’s career and educational goals. Although the objectives and activities could have been written in a more comprehensive and detailed manner to reflect active transition planning, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s actual goals were clearly identified and the ITPs clearly took into account STUDENT’s preferences and interests in attending COC and studying music and/or art, traveling abroad, and obtaining employment. Moreover, as will be discussed in detail below, a coordinated set of transition services were, in fact, provided that met her need for instruction, community experiences, and the development of employment and other post-school objectives. In addition, no evidence was presented showing either that STUDENT lost educational opportunity or that her parents were prevented from participating in the IEP process due to the failure to prepare complete ITPs. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT made progress towards and met most of the goals and objectives identified in her ITPs. Moreover, all of the ITPs included STUDENT’s and/or one of her parent’s signature, indicating their participation in the meetings held to discuss transition services. Only procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)

Regarding actual transition services, Dr. Clark testified that in reviewing the documentary evidence provided to him in this case, he saw no evidence of a coordinated set of activities and no evidence of transition services that would assist STUDENT in getting into the music industry. According to Mr. Clark, a class that incorporated, in a coordinated manner, activities on how to find a job, write a resume, draft a business card, role playing on how to get an interview for a job and what to do in an interview, completing an employment application, how to find an apartment and make a budget, and guest speakers regarding various areas of employment, would be an appropriate transition service from which most disabled students could benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s TPP-Career Visions program provided just such a class as part of its provision of transition services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer recognizes that STUDENT was enrolled in the Career Visions class during the 1996-1997 school year, which was prior to the year in question. Although much was accomplished in terms of transition services during the 1996-1997 school year, what remained to be done during the 1997-1998 school year was adequately accomplished by the District.

STUDENT received direct instruction through participation in the transition partnership program. In the spring of each year, the District gives a presentation to tenth-grade special education students about the TPP. The students fill out questionnaires, indicating their interest in the TPP, and the District then selects the students who will participate in the program. (Testimony of Ronald Rudzinski.) In March 1996, STUDENT completed the TPP questionnaire, indicating her hobbies and interests of listening to music and playing on the computer. She also listed her knowledge of how to use money as a frustration for her. STUDENT wrote that she saw herself becoming a music history teacher or a mixer for a studio, and indicated that she wanted to be considered for the Career Visions-TPP because she was nervous about getting into college and getting a job. She indicated that she thought the program might help her get into a school in which she was interested. (Resp.’s Exh. T1-T2.) STUDENT was informed by letter dated April 29, 1996, that she was accepted into the Career Visions-TPP. (Resp.’s Exh. T-3.) A student questionnaire completed by the parents indicated that they saw STUDENT going to a junior college directly out of high school and that they thought music, theater arts, or photography was a good course of study for her to pursue. (Resp.’s Exh. 5.) The parents also indicated that they did not see her working full-time, but saw her working part-time while going to school. (Resp.’s Exh. T-5.) On May 1, 1996, STUDENT and her mother completed the TPP-Career Visions agreement and STUDENT began the first semester of the TPP-Career Visions class in the fall of 1996 at Saugus High School. Eileen Pola was STUDENT’s Career Visions class instructor for both semesters during the 1996-1997 school year.

The Career Visions class curriculum consists of five components designed to assist a student in identifying his/her skills, talents, and interests, determining what opportunities exist, finding job opportunities, acquiring a job, and learning proper on-the-job skills. (Testimony of R. Rudzinski.) By the end of the program, the students have completed a portfolio consisting of a sample resume, letters of request, thank you letters, and letters of resignation. The portfolio also includes a sample job application and printed business cards. (Testimonies of R. Rudzinski and Eileen Pola.) Students also have a job market scrapbook, which includes work-related articles and issues found in newspapers on which the students are required to prepare a written analysis. The syllabus includes topics on how to find a job, the role of one’s personality, criticism and how to accept it, role playing, getting an apartment, budgeting, and minimum wage laws. The students also are required to complete a class project as their final exam. (Testimony of E. Pola.) STUDENT’s final project included a board game that she developed regarding the music industry. The project was so outstanding that STUDENT was invited to make a presentation to Mr. Rudzinski and all of the TPP teachers. (Id.) Students in the TPP class also are provided with access to a number of books dealing with music, composers, and engineering, which the students use to do research in their areas of interest. Ms. Pola testified that she had a recollection of going to the library with STUDENT to look for books in her area of interest.

Additionally, STUDENT was assigned a vocational case assistant (now called career transition advisor), Louise Willard, who worked with students in the TPP class on an individual basis regarding interviews, appropriate job behavior, and punctuality. Ms. Willard testified that at the time that STUDENT was in the Career Visions class, the class usually took 3-4 field trips per year, which she usually coordinated. Class field trips during the year that STUDENT was in the class included going to the College of the Canyons, El Chollo restaurant, and the North Valley Occupational Center. STUDENT went on all of the field trips, except the trip to the North Valley Occupational Center.

Having indicated a desire to concurrently enroll at College of the Canyons (COC) while attending Saugus High School, the COC field trip directly related to STUDENT’s educational interests. According to Ms. Willard, since STUDENT was interested in music, while on tour at the COC, they made a point of visiting the college’s music centers. Ms. Willard also testified that she contacted a small business that sold musical instruments, obtained information about that industry, and provided that information to the students in STUDENT’s Career Visions class. Ms. Willard also stated that the year that STUDENT was in the Career Visions class, a small record producer came to class as a guest speaker, talked about what it took to succeed in that field, and gave the students an idea of a typical day in the life of a record producer. Additionally, Cal Arts also offered classes in music and arts -- STUDENT’s stated areas of interest -- and Ms. Willard testified that she provided STUDENT with flyers about the courses offered at Cal Arts and suggested that she learn to read music through these free classes. She also brought community-based magazines to class and showed the students the different types of classes available and encouraged them to take classes related to their career goals.(Footnote 10) Ms. Willard testified that she had a specific recollection of speaking to STUDENT about taking goal-related classes and that STUDENT took a photography class at Cal Arts after Ms. Willard suggested that possibility to her.

During high school, STUDENT worked part-time at Magic Mountain as a usher. STUDENT had indicated to Ms. Willard that she was not interested in seeking additional employment during her junior year, because she had already obtained a job on her own. According to Ms. Willard, STUDENT was one of the more independent students in the class, and although she had obtained a job on her own, Ms. Willard testified that she asked STUDENT if there was anything she could help her with on the job.

Ron Rudzinski, career education specialist for the District, referred STUDENT to the California Department of Rehabilitation (DOR). On May 27, 1997, STUDENT was deemed eligible for vocational rehabilitation services from the DOR based on the following identified needs: counseling and guidance; a need for physical aids, changes or modifications to the work environment; a need to determine work options and labor market outlook; limited work skills; and her need for training to obtain employment and obtain independent living skills. (Resp.’s Exh. 10, pgs. 22, 24, & 80.) The DOR provided STUDENT with a rehabilitation counselor, who regularly met with STUDENT and her vocational case assistant from the District from May 1997 through the 1997-1998 school year to discuss STUDENT’s goals and objectives, interests, strengths, needs, resources, vocational plans, progress at school, and involvement in the TPP-Career Visions program. (See Resp.’s Exhs. 10, pgs. 77-103.) The DOR counselor provided guidance and counseling services to STUDENT. (Testimony of Jackie Dearmon; Resp.’s Exh. 10.) Additionally, testimonial and documentary evidence from the Department of Rehabilitation indicate that academic training was provided to STUDENT by the District through the Career Visions and Strategy classes and at the College of the Canyons. (Resp.’s Exh. 10.) The Department of Rehabilitation essentially treated STUDENT as an independent client and provided services to her that appeared to be above and beyond that normally provided to clients not enrolled in the District’s transition partnership program.

Although STUDENT was enrolled in the District’s Career Visions class during the 1996-1997 school year, the District continued to provide transition services to STUDENT during the 1997-1998 school year through the linkages the District had established with the COC and the DOR and through the Strategy class in which she was enrolled during the fall 1998 semester.

STUDENT was enrolled in the District’s Strategy class during the fall semester of the 1997-1998 school year. Dougles Worley has taught the Strategy class at Saugus High School for the last twenty years and testified that the overall theme of the class and teaching techniques are still essentially the same as they were when STUDENT took the class. Mr. Worley testified that the Strategy class is designed to prepare students to be successful as they transition from high school to adult life. The course curriculum includes maintaining a personal notebook and goal board, completing various assignments and exams, actively participating in class discussions, and maintaining a good attitude and attendance. The students are given strategies, such as how to conduct successful interviews, set goals, cure poor self-esteem, be assertive, and deal with emotional issues such as depression. Mr. Worley recalled having personal contact with STUDENT and testified that STUDENT was very friendly and outgoing. He believed that STUDENT benefitted from the class in that she understood the concepts and ultimately received a grade of “B” in the class, indicating that she did better than average. The Hearing Officer finds that the Strategy class provided direct instruction that helped STUDENT develop better self-advocacy skills, an area of stated need for STUDENT.

During the spring semester of 1998, while still attending Saugus High School, STUDENT also enrolled concurrently at College of the Canyons and took a class entitled Planning for College Success, a personal development course designed to help students adjust to and be successful in college life. STUDENT testified that this class taught her time management skills that helped her become more organized. (Pet.’s Exh. 68.) Deidre Bradford, a District vocational case assistant assigned to STUDENT during the 1997-1998 school year, testified that she assisted STUDENT in registering to take a spring 1998 class at the COC by taking her to the school, standing in line with her to register, assisting her with completing the registration application, and submitting it to COC. Ms. Bradford also assisted with linking STUDENT with the Disabled Students Programs and Services (DSPS) office on the COC campus to meet with DSPS counselor Diane Solomon about the services available to disabled students. On the first day of classes, because STUDENT had indicated that she was apprehensive about going to COC, Ms. Bradford met STUDENT at the COC and helped her find the appropriate classrooms. Ms. Bradford also stated that during the 1997-1998 school year, when discussing with STUDENT whether she was interested in working, STUDENT responded that her parents thought she should focus only on school at that time.

Once STUDENT graduated from high school, she enrolled in COC and began receiving services and accommodations through the campus DSPS, which included tutoring, counseling regarding her educational plans, and general support. DSPS counselors also serve as liaisons with the DOR by ensuring DOR receives a student’s final grades and student educational plans and by communicating with DOR regarding anything else involving the student. This process ensures that the student continues to remain eligible for DOR services and financial assistance. (Testimony of Diane Solomon.) Witness testimony and documentary evidence demonstrate that STUDENT received financial assistance from the DOR to cover the costs of books and supplies for her classes at COC, tuition, registration fees, and transportation. (Resp.’s Exh. 10; Testimony of J. Dearmon.) In addition, DSPS provided STUDENT with pre-registration services, tutorial assistance, counseling, and access to accommodations in the classroom. (Testimony of Jane Feuerhelm.) After reviewing information from testing, STUDENT’s IEP from high school, and any requests made by STUDENT, the following academic accommodations and recommendations were made for STUDENT: small-group instruction, extended time on tests, quizzes or tests taken in an area with reduced distractions, use of computer for written assignments, participation in a peer study group, tape recorded lectures, assistance with arrangement of note takers, subject area tutoring, DSPS counseling, and career center. (Pet.’s Exh. 82, pg. 3; Testimony of Jane Feuerhelm.) STUDENT also studied abroad for approximately four to five months in England on an exchange program through the COC. The Department of Rehabilitation paid for STUDENT’s courses in England because the courses were consistent with her educational goals. (Testimony of J. Dearmon.) STUDENT also completed her goal of obtaining her driver’s license. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

As discussed above, the curriculum of the TPP-Career Visions and Strategy classes provided STUDENT with the basic tools for transitioning into adult life, taking into account her need for developing skills to be successful in college, obtain employment, study abroad, obtain her driver’s license, work toward a career in art, and learn strategies on how to be successful in life. Additionally, the transition partnership program incorporated a coordinated set of activities and linkages among the District, the DOR, and the COC. These activities and linkages included the following: the initial application phase while in high school; the actual Career Visions and Strategy class instruction; the DOR’s coordination with the student and the District’s vocational case assistant regarding the student’s progress on goals; and the DOR’s provision of direct services, including individual guidance counseling, training, and financial assistance for transportation, college registration, tuition, and books and supplies. Additional post-high school coordinated activities that occurred during STUDENT’s senior year included connecting STUDENT with the COC and its Disabled Students Program and Services office, having District staff assist her with college application and registration procedures and escort her to the college campus, and having DOR and District staff continue to monitor her status and provide support, all of which worked to assist STUDENT in meeting her stated educational and career goals. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District provided STUDENT with the necessary transition services as required by law, except that it failed to adequately prepare detailed and comprehensive transition plans. Proper transition services were provided to address STUDENT’s needs and provide her with educational benefit and, therefore, the relative lack of specificity in the individual transition plans did not result in the denial of a FAPE. (Rowley, supra 458 U.S. at 200-201.)

Issue 1.e. Changing Petitioner’s Placement by Virtue of Graduation

Petitioner argues that the District denied her a FAPE by changing her placement without her consent or knowledge by issuing her a high school diploma even though she had not satisfied the District’s proficiency standards for graduation or California’s framework standards for demonstrating proficiency with respect to course content standards required for graduation. Moreover, Petitioner contends that she is entitled to compensatory education based upon the denial of a FAPE during high school even if her graduation were considered a terminating event, because STUDENT failed to satisfy the District’s proficiency standards for graduation.

The District contends that Petitioner passed all of her proficiency exams and at no time prior to or following her graduation did she express or desire not to graduate. The District argues that Petitioner’s case is, therefore, moot because she has graduated from high school. (T.S. v. Independent School District No. 54 (10th Cir. 2001) 265 F.3d 1090.) According to the District, Petitioner’s post-facto challenge to the quality of educational services received in the District is not authorized under the IDEA.

The short answer to the question, as posed by Petitioner, is that Petitioner was not denied a FAPE from July 1997 to the end of the 1997-1998 school year because of issuance of a high school diploma at the completion of the 1997-1998 school year. Issuance of the high school diploma, in and of itself, did not in any way affect the services and program provided by the District during the time frame in question. Therefore, the issue of Petitioner’s graduation is not within the scope of the issues as defined by Petitioner. What Petitioner essentially argues in her closing brief is that because the District wrongfully awarded her a diploma and, consequently, failed to continue to provide her with special education and related services until she reached age 22, she is entitled to compensatory education for the three years following graduation. (Pet.’s closing argument, pg. 27-28.) However, the years after STUDENT’s graduation were not put at issue in this case, thus making Petitioner’s argument in this regard irrelevant and foreclosing her from relief for claims related to the three years after graduation.

The District’s argument, that STUDENT’s case is moot because she has graduated and is therefore not entitled to compensatory education as a form of relief, has been presented as an affirmative defense that must be addressed by the Hearing Officer. Thus, the question still remains as to whether Petitioner’s graduation serves as a terminating event, thus precluding her from receiving the requested compensatory relief. The Hearing Officer addresses, here, the issue of whether Petitioner is entitled to consideration of relief in the form of compensatory education, notwithstanding her graduation, and addresses in Issue 2 below, whether she is entitled to the specific relief requested.

The District’s analysis of the rationale used by the court in the Independent School District No. 54 case is misguided and distinguishable to the case at hand. In that case, the Tenth Circuit held that once a student has graduated, he/she is no longer entitled to a FAPE; thus any claim that a FAPE was deficient becomes moot upon a valid graduation. However, the District, in its closing brief, neglected to mention that the Court indicated that this rule applies only where a student does not contest his graduation, and he/she is seeking only prospective, rather than compensatory relief. (Independent School Dist. No. 54., supra, 265 F.3d at 1092.)

From the beginning of this case, Petitioner has very clearly alleged that she was denied a FAPE and has sought only compensatory educational services as a remedy. Therefore, because Petitioner has requested relief in the form of compensatory education and is not seeking prospective relief, her case is not moot by virtue of her having graduated. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer need not consider Petitioner’s claim regarding her alleged erroneous graduation because Petitioner need not prove this issue in order to move forward with her case and receive consideration of her request for relief. Rather, Petitioner is entitled to, at the very least, consideration by the Hearing Officer of the necessity of compensatory education by virtue of the Hearing Officer’s decision above that the District failed to provide her with appropriate math and written language services during the 1997-1998 school year, thus causing her lost educational opportunity.

Conclusion

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to provide STUDENT with appropriate educational services during the 1997-1998 regular school year in that it failed to implement the math goal and objectives in her then-current IEP when it neglected to place STUDENT in an educational environment that would have allowed her to address her math needs. The District also failed to develop and implement appropriate goals and objectives in the area of written language that would have addressed her immature thought and written expression pattern, her specific writing mechanic deficiencies, and her delays in spelling, syntax, grammar, punctuation, and capitalization.

With regard to transition services, the District, overall, provided STUDENT with appropriate educational services, and its failure to draft detailed and comprehensive transition plans did not deny her educational benefit or cause STUDENT to lose any educational opportunity. Therefore, the flawed ITPs were harmless error and did not result in any substantial deprivation of her right to a FAPE.

Finally, whether or not STUDENT’s graduation was proper is not relevant for purposes of determining compensatory education for the time frame in question.

2. If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of:

a. 1200 hours of designated instruction and services provided by a certified nonpublic agency such as the Kelter Center to address Petitioner’s educational deficiencies, and b. Transitional services as may be required to permit Petitioner to transition from high school to post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, continuing and adult education, and independent living?

In Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 358, the Supreme Court concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is an equitable remedy that may be available when the school district has failed to provide the student with appropriate, special education services. (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; see also S.V. v. Sherwood School District 75 F.Supp.2d 1153, 1157 (D. Oregon, 1999).) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” (Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497.)

2.a. Designated Instruction and Services

In light of the Hearing Officer’s decision above regarding the goals and objectives in written language and math and placement in RSP and math class, the Hearing Officer considers whether compensatory education is warranted.

In her original pleadings, Petitioner requested 1200 hours of designated instruction and services to compensate her for denial of a FAPE. However, in her closing brief, Petitioner contends that she is entitled to compensatory education because she has proven that she was denied a FAPE commencing with the second semester of eleventh grade through the date of her erroneous graduation. She also contends that she is entitled to compensatory education for the three years following graduation (until she reached age 22) because the District failed to continue to provide her with special education and related services up to the age of her eligibility after having graduated her with a diploma to which she was not entitled.(Footnote 11) Petitioner argues that the District should be required to provide 219 weeks of compensatory education to include intensive remediation for at least three to five days a week for approximately three to four hours per day to work on the following:

(1) Writing: complex set of skills, spelling syntax, grammar, concepts of organizing ideas, sequencing, punctuation, capitalization, pre-writing, organizing, editing, etc.;

(2) Mathematics: higher math, but lower math facts needed to be fluid and in place first, basic concepts used in algebra, practical mathematics used in everyday life; and (3) Reading comprehension and vocabulary so that she can read an age appropriate text, understand it, be able to reconstruct the information and be able to use that information.(Footnote 12)

In its closing brief, the District argues that Petitioner should not be entitled to compensatory education given her selection of classes while attending the College of the Canyons from the summer of 1998 to the present. The District also contends that Petitioner presented no evidence regarding any of the following: her current educational needs, whether there is a nexus between any current needs and any purported deficiency in her FAPE while in the District four years earlier, how that deficiency, if any, should be redressed and why, whether she is interested in such services, and how such services would differ from the services already available through the College of the Canyons DSPS or the Department of Rehabilitation.

The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District failed to provide STUDENT with necessary special education instruction and services in math and written language during her senior year. There was no evidence, however, demonstrating that STUDENT had needs in the area of reading that the District failed to address. Petitioner presented evidence that she needs compensatory academic instruction to help overcome lost academic instruction. After graduation from high school, STUDENT began classes at the College of the Canyons (COC) in the fall of 1998. STUDENT took Math 025 - arithmetic at COC for the first time in the spring semester of 1999. Additionally, STUDENT testified that by the fall of 2000, she had taken the Math 025 - arithmetic class twice, having received a D in class the first time, and a B when she took it for a second time in the fall of 1999. STUDENT next took Math 059 - developmental algebra, which she failed two times, once in the fall of 2000 and once in the spring of 2001. (Testimony of STUDENT; see also Resp.’s Exhs. 12-7 to 12-9.) During each semester that STUDENT was enrolled in a math class at COC, she also took either a math tutorial assistance class or a math lab for mediated learning. STUDENT testified that at the time of the hearing, she was in the process of taking Math 059 for a third time. The Hearing Officer also notes that all of the 0-level math courses at COC are remedial-level courses and do not count toward graduation credits. (Testimonies of J. Dearmon and J. Feuerhelm.)

With respect to written expression, STUDENT’s COC transcripts indicate that she took a grammar/writing class during the fall 1998 semester and received credit, but no grade. During the spring 1999 semester, STUDENT took a sentence writing class and received credit, and in the fall of 1999, she took a writing skills class and received a grade of D. She received a C in her writing skills class in the summer of 2000. (Resp.’s Exhs. 12-6 to 12-9.) STUDENT testified, however, that she received tutorial assistance in writing essays from COC’s DSPS, which she believed helped her pass all of her English classes. According to STUDENT, next semester she plans to take English 101, which is a nonremedial, transferrable class required to receive an AA degree.

The evidence indicates that upon entrance into college, STUDENT immediately experienced difficulties in both her math and writing classes. Sasha Borenstein, founder and director of the Kelter Center, testified that it would be appropriate to screen STUDENT at this time to clarify further her precise current needs at this moment and then write some goals to address those needs. However, she believed that based on her review of STUDENT’s records from the COC and her discussions with STUDENT, her previous recommendations regarding STUDENT’s need for intensive remediation were still valid. According to Ms. Borenstein, STUDENT should have received remediation in math and English in the eleventh and twelfth grades in order to receive some educational benefit. Since STUDENT had not received such remediation in high school, and given her chronic record of difficulties, Ms. Borenstein concluded that STUDENT continues to need remediation in those areas.(Footnote 13) She also testified that she believed the Kelter Center could provide STUDENT with appropriate training to address her math and writing skill needs. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Borenstein testified very persuasively that STUDENT’s continuing needs in the areas of math and written language are a hold over from previous years of neglect and that the need for current remediation fits the pattern of STUDENT’s past and present educational difficulties.

Ms. Borenstein testified that the Kelter Center works with children and adults who have learning disabilities, but who are of average to above-average intelligence. The Kelter Center is a State of California certified nonpublic agency. The majority of the teachers at the Kelter Center have credentials in special education, and every teacher has a teaching credential and a master’s degree in the subject area in which they teach. Its services include one-to-one remediation in vocabulary, reading comprehension, writing skills, and math. Every student at the Kelter Center is given a very specific set of goals and objectives that are measurable, defined, and specific, and remediation is based upon each student’s individual needs. Ms. Borenstein recommended that STUDENT receive remediation work in the areas of math and writing, two hours a day, for a maximum of three days a week, over a period equal to one school year.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s deficiencies in math and written language and her history of failures in math and writing courses warrant remediation. The Hearing Officer finds there is a nexus between the educational services missed during the 1997-1998 school year and STUDENT’s resulting deficiencies. It is also clear that the services that can be provided by the Kelter Center can address those deficiencies in the areas of math and written language. The evidence demonstrated that the Kelter Center’s program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual educational needs, and would be appropriate to provide her with the remediation services she should have received during her senior year in high school. Given the totality of the circumstances, including the fact that STUDENT’s educational problems have continued now for almost four years after graduation, the Hearing Officer grants, in part, Petitioner’s request to receive remedial instruction in the areas of math and written language from the Kelter Center.

The Hearing Officer recognizes that given STUDENT’s severe deficits and neglect in the areas of math and written language, she needs intensive remediation with services that focus on these skills. However, in light of the fact that STUDENT’s skills have not been formally reviewed since 1999, a current review of her academic abilities and achievement in the areas of math and written language is necessary in order to determine the best manner in which to provide this training. The academic pretest described by Ms. Borenstein that is typically used by the Kelter Center should adequately serve this purpose. Additionally, because of STUDENT’s critical needs in the areas of math and written language, and given the fact that she is currently 22 years of age and has been enrolled at COC since 1998, she requires provision of this training as quickly as possible so that she can finish her AA degree and move on to accomplish her other identified educational and career goals.

The Hearing Officer notes, however, that STUDENT has received some remedial help in math and written expression while in college through the DSPS office, which, according to STUDENT, has proven particularly beneficial with respect to her writing skills. In designing a remedy, the Hearing Officer considers the fact that Ms. Borenstein’s recommendation for compensatory education was based on two school years, instead of the one school year in question. The Hearing Officer also considers that the remediation STUDENT has received at COC has more profoundly impacted her writing skills than her math skills. STUDENT is no longer taking remedial English courses and has passed all of her English classes since she started attending COC. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that an amount of time equal to one regular school year of remediation in math and written language skills, four hours each week, is appropriately suited to ensure STUDENT’s needs are met as expeditiously as possible and that her skills are brought to the level they would otherwise have been. Approximately one-third of the total time awarded shall be dedicated to addressing STUDENT’s writing needs, and two-thirds of the total time shall be dedicated to addressing her math needs. Petitioner and the Kelter Center can determine how the total hours will be scheduled and the order in which the two areas will be addressed. The District shall make the arrangements, and pay for these services to be provided by the Kelter Center.(Footnote 14)

The Hearing Officer notes that the District has not offered any alternatives to Petitioner’s request for services from the Kelter Center. Nor has it demonstrated that the District itself, the College of the Canyons, the Department of Rehabilitation, or any other public or private agency can provide the intensive remediation services in math and written language that Petitioner requires. Additionally, Ms. Borenstein provided credible testimony that the Kelter Center has the ability and personnel to meet STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Borenstein based her recommendation for remediation services on her discussions with Petitioner and her review of Petitioner’s educational records, which included assessments of her educational needs. The validity of those documents was not disputed by either party.

2.b. Transition Services

Given the Hearing Officer’s decision above that the District provided STUDENT with appropriate transition services, Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory education in this regard.

ORDER

1. The District shall provide STUDENT with appropriate remediation training through the Kelter Center in STUDENT’s areas of need in math and written language, four hours a week, for an amount of time equal to one regular school year. Approximately one-third of the total time shall be dedicated to addressing STUDENT’s writing needs, and two-thirds of the total time shall be dedicated to addressing her math needs.

2. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.

1. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from July 1997 to the end of the 1997-1998 school year by:

a. Failing to develop appropriate goals and objectives to address Petitioner’s academic difficulties in math and written expression?

b. Failing to provide Petitioner with an appropriate educational placement?

c. Failing to develop a proper transition plan based upon Petitioner’s individual needs?

d. Failing to provide appropriate transition services?

e. Changing Petitioner’s placement without her consent or knowledge by reason of issuance of a high school diploma?

Petitioner prevailed with regard to Issues 1.a. and b., and partially prevailed with respect to issue 1.c.

The District prevailed with regard to Issue 1.d., and partially prevailed with respect to Issue 1.c., because although the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to develop a complete transition plan, it was harmless error and the actual transition services provided to Petitioner satisfied the requirements of the law.

Neither party prevailed on Issue 1.e.

2. If the District denied Petitioner a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education in the form of:

a. 1200 hours of designated instruction and services provided by a certified nonpublic agency such as the Kelter Center to address Petitioner’s educational deficiencies, and b. Transitional services as may be required to permit Petitioner to transition from high school to post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, continuing and adult education, and independent living?

Petitioner prevailed in part regarding Issue 2.a. in that compensatory education in the form of academic services provided by the Kelter Center was awarded, but not for the total amount of hours requested by Petitioner.

The District prevailed with respect to Issue 2.b.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code §56505(i).)

Dated: May ____, 2002 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis. 2. The record is not entirely clear as to whether speech and language services were provided to STUDENT during all four years of high school or added and dropped along the way. At any rate, the provision of speech and language services is not at issue in this case. 3. Ms. Ackerman testified that she has performed approximately 750-800 psychoeducational assessments over the past twenty years. However, she has no experience writing goals and objectives for an IEP since she does not work for a school district. As a professional, however, she has made suggestions to students in the private school in which she works and in her private practice. 4. Ms. Borenstein testified that she has both bachelor’s and master’s degrees in special education and a lifetime California teaching credential in special education. She also possesses a California resource specialist credential. She has taught in both the public and private special education setting, and in July 1977, she founded the Kelter Center, a nonprofit organization serving children and adults by conducting evaluations and providing remediation services. 5. Ms. Williams testified that she has been a school psychologist since March, 1994. She has a bachelor’s degree in sociology, a master’s degree in school counseling, and currently is a doctoral candidate in education and school psychology. She also possesses a credential in school psychology and a multi-subject teaching credential. 6. While in the twelfth grade, Petitioner received speech and language services to address her articulation disorder and does not dispute the appropriateness of those services and whether they addressed her identified speech and spoken language needs. 7. Finally, Petitioner argued for the first time in her written closing brief that based on her overall lack of progress in math over her entire education, the IEP team should have determined her eligible for extended school year services during the summers of 1997 and 1998. The issue of whether STUDENT was entitled to extended school year services during 1997 and 1998 was not raised by Petitioner during the hearing in this matter, thus the District was not provided proper notice or given an opportunity to respond to this allegation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not address extended school year services in this decision as it was not properly raised by Petitioner. 8. STUDENT turned eighteen years old on July 24, 1997, the summer before her senior year in high school. 9. Petitioner also argued that the District failed to hold an annual review of STUDENT’s tenth-grade performance at the January 29, 1997 IEP, and that, therefore, the IEP meeting held on June 11, 1998, actually should have been held in January 1998. The District later conceded in its closing brief that the IEP held in June 1998 should have been held no later than January 29, 1998, and that, therefore, it was approximately four and a half months late. (Resp.’s closing brief, pg. 17.) Given the Hearing Officer’s determination above that the District failed, substantively, to implement STUDENT’s math goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer need not consider Petitioner’s alleged procedural allegation regarding the untimeliness of the June 11, 1998 IEP meeting. 10. STUDENT testified that she recalled a video producer coming to the Career Visions class to speak, but not a record producer. STUDENT also testified that she did not recall Ms. Willard giving her any magazines or suggesting to her any magazines regarding the music industry. However, the Hearing Officer gives less weight to STUDENT’s testimony regarding specific events because when questioned about many of the meetings and incidents that occurred from July 1997 through the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT often stated that she did not specifically recall the meetings or anyone who attended those meetings, even where she had signed documentation indicating her attendance and participation. 11. Petitioner requests compensatory education to cover a denial of a FAPE that allegedly occurred before and after the time frame in question in this matter. The Hearing Officer cannot award compensatory education based on alleged acts or omissions that occurred before July 1997 or after the end of the 1997-1998 school year, because those time frames were not put at issue. 12. Although Petitioner requests 219 weeks of remediation services, her request is premised on time frames not at issue in this case, including the second semester of eleventh grade, the extended school years following both the eleventh and twelfth grades, and the three years following her graduation until she reached age 22. (Pet.’s closing argument, pgs. 27-28.) In any case, the Hearing Officer finds this request of time excessive and not associated with the time frames covered for a remedy in this matter. 13. The Hearing Officer recognizes that only the time frame from July 1997 through the end of STUDENT’s twelfth grade year are to be considered in determining an award for compensatory education. However, Ms. Borenstein, in making her recommendation for remediation services, took into account both STUDENT’s eleventh and twelfth grade years. STUDENT’s eleventh grade year, however, is not at issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer gives Ms. Borenstein’s testimony regarding the amount of necessary remediation services less weight since her recommendation was not based on one school year, but two. 14. The Hearing Officer notes that the District attempted to hold an IEP team meeting on September 3, 1998, to try to formulate an IEP and resolve the disputed issues; however, Petitioner, at the advise of her counsel, refused to attend. (Testimony of Marty Lieberman; Resp’s Exhs. 15 & 16.) The Hearing Officer questions the wisdom of Petitioner’s attorney in advising his client not to attend an IEP meeting. Had that IEP meeting been held and resulted in an effective remedy to the dispute, this matter would have been resolved sooner, and without the parties having to resort to litigation.