California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 15, 1997
Student v. Los Alamitos Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 114-97 · Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman
Los Alamitos Unified must keep funding a 40-hour weekly CARD autism program; its autism special day class offer is rejected.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated. An earlier Hearing Office order dated February 28, 1997, granted stay put in the CARD program under the September 25, 1996 IEP and shifted the burden of going forward to the District.
Summary
Parents of a four-and-a-half-year-old boy who qualified for special education under autism filed for due process against Los Alamitos Unified School District. Since May 1996 he had been in a 40-hour-per-week home program run by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), a nonpublic agency. The district agreed to fund that program in a September 1996 IEP. He had also started at a regular Montessori preschool with a CARD-trained shadow aide. In January 1997 the district offered five half-days in a regional autism special day class at Weaver Elementary. It also offered 20 hours a week of in-home discrete trial training by district staff, supervised by Autism Partnership. Under a stay put order, the boy remained in the CARD program, and the district had to present its case first.
The Hearing Officer found the offer inappropriate for 1997-98. Three of the four experts, including the district's own rebuttal expert, Dr. Bryna Siegel, said an autism class did not fit his needs. Two of them warned that he would regress there. He needed typically developing peers as language models. The district's preference for a different provider did not justify changing a program in which he had made large gains. Moving him from a regular preschool to an autism class was also not the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer held the CARD program appropriate. The district must fund it at 40 hours a week, including the shadow aides, through the 1997-98 extended school year, but not the Montessori tuition. CARD was to write a transition plan for the IEP.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO weighed a district's change-of-placement offer against an established intensive home behavior program for a young child with autism. The district had the burden of proof. The Hearing Officer credited experts who warned of regression and held that a district's preference for another provider was not enough reason to change providers.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Is the District's change of placement offer of January 1997 an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year?
With the burden on the District, the offer of five half-days in the Weaver autism special day class plus 20 hours of in-home discrete trials by District staff did not meet the student's needs, would not provide educational benefit, and was not the least restrictive environment.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. If not, is STUDENT's continuing home and community program of intensive behavior intervention through CARD an appropriate placement?
The 40-hour-per-week CARD program, with in-home discrete trials, community socialization, and Montessori preschool with a 1:1 shadow aide, was appropriate for 1997-98 including extended school year; CARD would decide how to split the hours.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. If STUDENT's program through CARD is appropriate, must the District contract specifically with CARD rather than other certified nonpublic agencies, and must the District hire aides trained by CARD?
Because of the student's progress with CARD and the risk of regression, the District had to keep using CARD and CARD-trained aides; CARD was certified and adequately supervised, and the District's preference for Autism Partnership did not justify a change.
- Dismissed / withdrawnUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue Withdrawn A. Retroactive reimbursement for CARD in-home services (withdrawn by Petitioner by letter received July 2, 1997)
Petitioner withdrew this issue before submission, so it was not decided.
- Dismissed / withdrawnFAPE: services offered
Issue Withdrawn B. Compensatory education (withdrawn by Petitioner on the last day of hearing)
Petitioner withdrew this issue on the last day of hearing, so it was not decided.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the order, the District must convene an IEP meeting that includes a CARD representative paid for by the District.
- Placement ordered. The IEP must be amended to continue the 40-hour-per-week CARD intensive behavior intervention program for the duration of the 1997-98 extended school year. The program includes in-home discrete trial training, community socialization activities, a regular Montessori preschool class with a 1:1 shadow aide, and CARD clinics, consultation and supervision as required.
- The District must ask CARD staff to design and implement a flexible transition plan, with specific goals and objectives, for a continued gradual transition into the Montessori preschool. The plan must be completed within 15 days and incorporated into the amended IEP.
- Prospective funding of private placement. The District must fund the CARD program for the 1997-98 extended school year, including the 1:1 CARD-trained shadow aides, CARD supervision of the aides, and CARD consultation to the private preschool. The District does not have to pay the Montessori preschool tuition or related costs.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Grymes v. Madden; Landgraf v. USI Film Products
People named in the decision
- Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, Clinical director and owner of nonpublic agency; witness for both parties, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Dawn Enoch, Clinic supervisor, Orange County office, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Carolyn Ann Brown, Therapist, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Melanie Ann Foshee, Senior therapist and 1:1 shadow aide, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Tammy Heekyung Heo, Private therapist and 1:1 shadow aide (CARD-trained), CARD program
- Dawn S. Walsh, SELPA administrator, Greater Anaheim SELPA
- Anne Klentz, Director of pupil services, Los Alamitos Unified School District
- Dr. Colleen Jamison, Consulting school psychologist; expert witness for District, Consultant
- Dr. Bryna Siegel, Developmental psychologist; District rebuttal expert, Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic, Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute
- Dr. Jacqueline Wynn, Expert witness for Student, UCLA Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention and Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children
- Patricia Ann Polcyn, Consulting occupational therapist, Independent, serving McGaugh Elementary School
- Shirley Owens, Speech pathologist, McGaugh Elementary School, Los Alamitos Unified School District
- Cathy Pieper Wieschendorff, School psychologist, Los Alamitos Unified School District
- Debbie Harrison, Speech and language specialist (initial evaluation), Los Alamitos Unified School District
- Glenda McHale, Preschool speech and language specialist; District witness, Cypress School District
- Kimberly B. Metcalfe, Preschool special day class teacher (described as regular education teacher for the District), McGaugh Elementary School, Los Alamitos Unified School District
- Susan G. Barnett, Special education teacher, Weaver Elementary School, Los Alamitos Unified School District
- Dr. Sandra Kaler, Psychologist who made initial diagnosis, Private
- Maureen Graves, Parents' former attorney
- Dr. John McEachin, Co-director of District-contracted behavior program, Autism Partnership
- Dr. Ronald Leaf, Co-director of District-contracted behavior program, Autism Partnership
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Nonpublic agency providing intensive behavior intervention
- Autism Partnership, Agency under contract with the District for intensive behavior intervention training
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Los Alamitos, California, on May 20, 21, 22, and 23, 1997, and July 8, 9, 10, and 11, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by Shelli J. Lewis, of Lewis & Lewis, Attorneys and Counselors at Law. PARENT, STUDENT’s mother, was also present on his behalf throughout the hearing. Ralph O. Lewis, Jr., of the same law firm, and STUDENT’s father, PARENT, were present on behalf of STUDENT at various times. Respondent Los Alamitos Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Bobbi F. Albanese. Also present on behalf of the District was Anne Klentz, director of pupil services. From May 22 on, Dawn S. Walsh, SELPA administrator, was present at the hearing on behalf of the District.
The District, which presented its case first for reasons noted below, called the following witnesses: Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director for the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD); Dawn Enoch, clinic supervisor for the Orange County office of CARD; PARENT, STUDENT’s mother; Dawn Walsh, Greater Anaheim SELPA administrator; Carolyn Ann Brown, therapist for CARD; Dr. Colleen Jamison, consulting school psychologist; Patricia Ann Polcyn, consulting occupational therapist; Shirley Owens, speech pathologist at McGaugh Elementary School in the District; Cathy Pieper Wieschendorff, school psychologist for the District; Glenda McHale, preschool speech and language specialist for Cypress School District; Melanie Ann Foshee, senior therapist for CARD; Kimberly B. Metcalfe, regular education teacher for the District; Anne Klentz, director of pupil services for the District; and, on rebuttal, Dr. Bryna Siegel, developmental psychologist.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Susan G. Barnett, special education teacher at Weaver Elementary School in the District; Dr. Jacqueline Wynn, assistant director for two UCLA programs--the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention and the Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children; PARENT; Tammy Heo, private therapist; Dawn Enoch; and Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing briefs. Petitioner’s closing brief was received on July 29, 1997. The District’s closing brief was received on July 30, 1997, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Is the District’s change of placement offer of January 1997 an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year?
2. If not, is STUDENT’s continuing home and community program of intensive behavior intervention through CARD an appropriate placement?
3. If STUDENT’s program through CARD is appropriate, must the District contract specifically with CARD rather than other certified nonpublic agencies, and must the District hire aides trained by CARD?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Petitioner’s request for due process hearing, filed by his attorney, Shelli J. Lewis, was received by the Hearing Office on January 31, 1997.
On February 7, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for stay put from Petitioner to continue STUDENT in his CARD program pursuant to the Individualized Education Program (IEP) of September 25, 1996. This request was unopposed by the District. In an order dated February 28, 1997, the Hearing Office granted Petitioner’s stay put request and ordered STUDENT maintained in his program with CARD per the September 25 IEP.
On February 11, 1997, the Hearing Office received a motion from Petitioner to shift the burden of proof and going forward to the District. The District opposed this motion. In the February 28 order, the Hearing Office granted Petitioner’s request, and ordered the District to present its case first because the District was proposing to change the status quo.
On the first day of hearing, Petitioner objected to the presence of a second District representative, Dawn S. Walsh, SELPA administrator. Ms. Walsh was excluded until after the completion of her testimony on the second day of hearing, May 21. Respondent’s motion to allow Ms. Walsh to return as an advisor under California Education Code Section 56505(e)(1) was granted on the morning of May 22.
Immediately before and during the hearing, both parties filed motions to quash various witness subpoenas. All motions to quash were denied.
Petitioner’s evidence packet was received in evidence on the second day of hearing, May 21, due to Respondent’s objection that the packet was received one day late.
On the second day of hearing, May 21, Petitioner’s request for a protective order regarding the name of STUDENT’s preschool was granted.
On the seventh day of hearing, July 10, Respondent’s request to allow rebuttal witness, Dr. Bryna Siegel, to testify by telephone was granted over objection of Petitioner.(Footnote 2) Respondent had originally scheduled Dr. Siegel to testify in person, but because of scheduling conflicts with Petitioner’s witnesses, she was not able to do so. Due to prior professional commitments, Dr. Siegel was unable to appear in person at the only available time on Friday afternoon, July 11, 1997. Both the Hearing Officer and Petitioner questioned Dr. Siegel before her substantive examination. The Hearing Officer was satisfied that Dr. Siegel was testifying alone in the room with the parties’ exhibits available for reference.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Diagnosis and evaluation of STUDENT
STUDENT is a four and one-half year-old boy who was first diagnosed with autism by psychologist Dr. Sandra Kaler in November 1995, when he was almost three years old. (Pet. Exh. 2; Resp. Exh. 1.) Dr. Kaler recommended that STUDENT’s parents consult a speech therapist(Footnote 3) as STUDENT was effectively nonverbal, using about five to ten Farsi(Footnote 4) words to communicate along with grunts and gestures. STUDENT had begun speaking between the ages of 12 and 18 months, and then stopped. STUDENT also exhibited fear of loud noises and large groups of people, sleeplessness at night, lack of toilet training, and certain other behaviors, including stubbornness, tantruming, hitting and screaming when frustrated, and hand-flapping. (Pet. Exh. 2; Resp. Exh. 1.)
In December 1995, school psychologist Cathy Pieper Wieschendorff, and speech and language specialist Debbie Harrison evaluated STUDENT for the District. They determined that STUDENT had severe delays in language (expressive and pragmatic) and social-emotional development. They concluded that STUDENT met criteria for special education consideration based on the diagnosis of autism. (Pet. Exh. 3; Resp. Exh. 2, 3.)
An initial IEP team meeting was convened on January 8, 1996, and STUDENT was found eligible for special education based on the condition of autism. (Pet. Exh. 7, 8; Resp. Exh. 4.) The IEP team agreed on placement in a preschool special day class for children with communication handicaps at McGaugh Elementary School. The IEP team established goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of expressive and receptive language, fine motor skills, math skills, social adaptive skills, and self-help skills. (Pet. Exh. 8; Resp. Exh. 4.) STUDENT’s need for speech and language services was to be determined by the March 1996 parent conference.
Special day class at McGaugh Elementary School
On January 9, 1996, STUDENT began attending the special day class at McGaugh five days per week for the entire half-day session. PARENT testified that she remained on the school campus nearly every day and heard STUDENT “crying a lot” in class; she was afraid he was being hurt. STUDENT had difficulty separating from her and would cry when she left.
PARENT found that STUDENT’s behavior did not improve, and that his behavior at home differed from that reported in class. At home, STUDENT would touch his feces and pick his nose, and would bite if especially frustrated. PARENT testified that she withdrew STUDENT from class the last week of March 1996 because she felt there were no role models in language or behavior for STUDENT.(Footnote 5) She also stated STUDENT did not learn words as a result of the McGaugh class, but, rather, due to private speech therapy and “work at home.”
STUDENT’s teacher, Kimberly Metcalfe, assessed STUDENT’s present levels of performance during his first week in class. Ms. Metcalfe identified areas of concern for STUDENT to include: (1) attending skills and hand-flapping; (2) interaction with peers; (3) toilet training; and (4) language, especially expressive language. (Resp. Exh. 14.) She never saw him playing with feces, but did note that he picked his nose “at times,” although this behavior had stopped by May 1996. On April 25, 1996, when Ms. Metcalfe was absent, it was noted that STUDENT bit another child. (Resp. Exh. 52.)
Ms. Metcalfe testified that she was satisfied with STUDENT’s progress on the January 1996 IEP goals when he stopped attending in May 1996. In fact, she stated she was so satisfied, that she considered reconvening the IEP team to rewrite the goals. Ms. Metcalfe testified that STUDENT was no longer tantruming or aggressive when he left her class.
Ms. Metcalfe also testified that, after March 1996, STUDENT received speech therapy on a consultation basis in class two times per week for about 30 minutes each time. Shirley Owens, speech pathologist at McGaugh, was the therapist who provided an “oral motor program” to groups of three to four children in Ms. M etcalfe’s class during spring 1996. (Pet. Exh. 10.) According to Ms. Owen, STUDENT participated in one of these groups, and was imitating some words, like “ball” and “duck.” Ms. Owens was not sure when STUDENT withdrew from class but thought it was in March or April. STUDENT also received occupational therapy on a consultative basis according to Patricia Polcyn, the independent occupational therapist who served McGaugh.
Initiation of CARD services
On March 20, 1996, PARENT met with Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director of CARD, for an interview regarding a program for STUDENT. Dr. Granpeesheh did an intake evaluation of STUDENT(Resp. Exh. 57) which was followed-up by Dawn Enoch, clinic supervisor for the CARD Orange County office. Ms. Enoch saw STUDENT at home in April 1996 and determined his “deficits” to be: (1) no language (STUDENT had 10 labels for words but no language on command); (2) poor attending and no eye contact; (3) play that was self-stimulatory in nature and not age appropriate; and (4) social skills indicating affection for adult family members. Ms. Enoch found STUDENT’s “excesses” to be: (1) striking out, hitting and biting when angry; (2) crying a lot and screeching; (3) self-stimulatory behavior including hand-flapping and verbals; and (4) tantrums involving screaming or crying, bucking in his chair, physical avoidance, crying on the floor, and flopping out of his chair. Ms. Enoch concluded that STUDENT was “low functioning” at that time. (Testimony of Dawn Enoch.)
In a letter dated May 9, 1996, PARENT notified the District that she was proceeding with an “intensive home program” for STUDENT “since it is not offered by the District.” (Pet. Exh. 11; Resp. Exh. 34.) PARENT considered this letter to be a request that the District provide STUDENT’s intensive home program, but the District did not consider the letter to be a “formal parent request.” (Testimony of PARENT, Dawn Walsh.)
The PARENTS started the CARD program for STUDENT with a two-day training workshop in early May 1996. This workshop was designed to educate family members and therapists who would work with STUDENT about intensive behavior intervention therapy provided by CARD. (Pet. Exh. 46.) Immediately after the workshop training was completed, STUDENT began a schedule of 40 hours per week of CARD therapy at home. STUDENT’s initial CARD program consisted of a series of discrete trials designed by Dr. Granpeesheh and the senior therapist staff at CARD, and supervised by Ms. Enoch.(Footnote 6) Clinics were held every two weeks to review STUDENT’s progress and to change his program as necessary. Ms. Enoch, STUDENT and his parent(s), and his therapists attended the clinics every two weeks; Dr. Granpeesheh also attended, but less frequently.
On June 27, 1996, an IEP meeting was held at the request of attorney Maureen Graves on behalf of the PARENTS to request District funding for STUDENT’s CARD program. (Pet. Exh. 13.) The District agreed to pay for much of STUDENT’s program but the agreement was never finalized. In late August 1996, the PARENTS changed attorneys and their present counsel requested an IEP meeting, which was eventually set for September 25, 1996. (Pet. Exh. 18.)
Fall 1996
On September 25, 1996, an IEP meeting was held at the parents’ request to further discuss STUDENT’s progress, placement and District funding. STUDENT’s parents felt he was making good progress in the CARD program and wanted to continue the 40 hours of in-home intensive behavior intervention. The District agreed to fund 40 hours of in-home CARD therapy from October 1, 1996, through January 31, 1997, including consultation by Dr. Granpeesheh and clinic supervision. Half of the 40 hours was to be provided by SELPA therapists who were to be trained by CARD staff to ensure consistency in STUDENT’s program.(Footnote 7) The parents agreed to waive reimbursement for CARD services prior to October 1, and to visit the preschool special day class for autistic children at Weaver. (Pet. Exh. 22; Resp. Exh. 5.) CARD goals and objectives for STUDENT were incorporated into the IEP document along with his present levels of performance. (Pet. Exh. 16, 26, 27; Resp. Exh. 22, 23.) The parties also signed an agreement to not disclose the services to be provided to STUDENT under the September 25 IEP. (Pet. Exh. 25, 29.)
In November 1996, STUDENT started in a community Montessori preschool program for three- and four-year-old children.(Footnote 8) STUDENT’s group had about 18 to 20 nondisabled children, one teacher and two aides. (Testimony of PARENT.) The program was selected by STUDENT’s mother, but Dr. Granpeesheh made the decision that STUDENT was ready for regular preschool integration. STUDENT attended one day per week for three to four hours, and was accompanied by a shadow aide trained by CARD. (Resp. Exh. 59.) The aide was to "shadow" STUDENT to facilitate his peer interaction and socialization. Except for the shadow aide, no other special accommodations were made for STUDENT.
January 1997 placement offer
On January 28, 1997, an IEP meeting was held.(Footnote 9) Before the meeting, PARENT visited the preschool special day class at Weaver Elementary School, and concluded that it was not appropriate for STUDENT. She wanted STUDENT in a “normal” classroom setting, not in a class for children with autism.
As a result of the January 28 IEP meeting, the District agreed to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for 529 hours of in-home therapy, and CARD agreed to reimburse the parents for October 1996 services after receiving payment from the District. The District offered to provide STUDENT with “20 hours of in-home services by District-employed staff, trained in discrete trial method,” and five half-days per week placement at Weaver Elementary School in the “SELPA’s regional autistic preschool program.” (Pet. Exh. 34; Resp. Exh. 6.)
STUDENT’s parents wrote a “dissent” to the District’s placement offer. They requested continuation of the CARD 40-hour per week, in-home program with CARD supervision, and a regular preschool inclusion component with a 1:1 aide. The parents stated that they believed this to be the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. They specifically disagreed with placement of STUDENT in a special education classroom, and use of District/SELPA staff who were “not trained for STUDENT’s individual program with CARD.” (Pet. Exh. 34; Resp. Exh. 6.)
Spring 1997
After the January 28 IEP meeting, STUDENT continued in his 40-hour per week CARD program. In early April 1997, at the age of four years, four months, STUDENT was assessed by CARD. The CARD assessor reported that STUDENT’s IQ score on the Leiter International Performance Scale (LIPS) was 120, placing him in the superior range of intellectual functioning.(Footnote 10) On the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3), STUDENT scored at the level of two years, three months for total language. On the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (VABS), STUDENT scored at the age equivalent of three years, five months in overall adaptive behavior. (Pet. Exh. 35.)
For approximately six weeks during April and early May 1997, STUDENT discontinued his Montessori preschool program because of a dislocated shoulder, illness, and tantruming behavior. During this time, STUDENT also had a higher non-response rate in his discrete trials at home, which his mother attributes to STUDENT’s medications and loss of concentration due to illness. In early May, STUDENT’s preschool program was increased to two half-days per week for a total of six to eight hours per week.
According to PARENT, STUDENT has made “tremendous behavior changes” in the past year. He sleeps in his own bed through the night, and may wake up one or two times instead of 20 times as before. His tantrums are very short, usually about 10 seconds, and hitting is “almost no longer an issue.” STUDENT can be in a group of five or more people now, where before he could not. He still does hand-flapping but tries to control it. STUDENT goes to the toilet by himself, but still has some accidents.(Footnote 11) He has two “good friends,” and will have “play dates” at home arranged by his mother. STUDENT has a vocabulary of about 400 words and knows the alphabet and phonics. He reads simple children’s books and is able to count to 50. He can add and subtract one-digit numbers and seems to understand the meaning of numbers.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EXPERT TESTIMONY
Respondent’s experts
Dr. Colleen Jamison
Dr. Colleen Jamison has an Ed.D. in educational psychology, and is a licensed educational psychologist in California. She is currently a school psychologist for the State of Hawaii and a consultant. She has been consulting as an educational and school psychologist for 31 years, and has experience with severely disabled and autistic children. Dr. Jamison is on the faculty of the School of Education at California State University, Los Angeles. Earlier in her career, Dr. Jamison taught both regular and special education classes. She has testified twice previously in administrative proceedings. (Resp. Exh. 47.)
Dr. Jamison testified that she is familiar with discrete trial training format and has seen dramatic gains for children through an individual program. However, she considers discrete trial to be “just a methodology,” and finds it “limiting.” Discrete trials should not be the format for the entire day because children learn incidentally and need contact with other children and adults.
Dr. Jamison testified that she had not seen or assessed STUDENT, but that she reviewed the latest psychological evaluation by CARD (Pet. Exh. 35), and all of the District’s exhibits through Exhibit 46.(Footnote 12) From her review of the CARD evaluation, Dr. Jamison stated that STUDENT’s language skills are delayed and his expressive communication also is weak. He lacks generalization, and functional language. STUDENT’s rank in the first percentile for total language on the PLS-3 means that 99% of children the same age have language superior to STUDENT’s.
Dr. Jamison recommended that STUDENT have a “structured language program with a communication emphasis” and “content in the environment to talk about.” STUDENT needs “real objects and experiences” in his educational environment for content and application of language skills. STUDENT needs to learn by successive approximations, first with an adult, then with other children.
Dr. Jamison testified that STUDENT’s school program should be a “combination of broad band programs,” including socialization with other children (preferably one or two others), a variety of activities, and 1:1 work for skills and particular behaviors. STUDENT’s teacher should have a rich speech and language background. STUDENT also needs a “rich” home program which is an extension of his school program. Dr. Jamison stated that STUDENT has “serious need” for daily living skills training. She also emphasized that home is not the same as a school environment and is more restrictive because the opportunity for learning is not as great.
Dr. Jamison testified that she visited the special day class proposed for STUDENT at Weaver Elementary School, and found it to be the “ideal class” for STUDENT. The class offers a discrete trial format throughout the day, and would be appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs for social language and communication, interpersonal skills, behavior and activities of daily living. The class offers a “high scope curriculum” which is literature-based. The classroom has been carefully arranged and reflected meticulous planning for preschool children with autism. Dr. Jamison is familiar with the Best Practices Task Force recommendations for programs for individuals with autism spectrum disorders (Resp. Exh. 46), and found the Weaver special day class consistent with those recommendations. She considers the class “state of the art.” However, she does not know if the class would help STUDENT enter kindergarten in 1998. Dr. Jamison stated this would not be her goal for STUDENT because he will “not be in the same place as other typically-developing children by fall 1998.”
Dr. Jamison testified that she was aware that STUDENT is receiving 40 hours of in-home therapy. She believes some things are not happening which should be, given 40 hours training. For example, STUDENT’s toilet training should have responded to behavior modification techniques. Also, STUDENT lacks peer models at home. Some of STUDENT’s behaviors have been going on too long as reflected in various progress reports.
Dr. Bryna Siegel
Dr. Bryna Siegel has a Ph.D. in early childhood development and has completed four post-doctoral fellowships in developmental psychopathology and autism. Dr. Siegel is a developmental psychologist and specializes in studying the processes of growth in children who are developing both typically and atypically. Dr. Siegel is the director and founder of the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute in San Francisco, and a co-founder of the Autism Clinic at Stanford University. She has clinical expertise in assessment of children with autism, and estimates that she has assessed 1800 children identified as autistic. Dr. Siegel has written between 75 and 90 publications, most of which address issues in the field of autism. She has also testified several times in administrative proceedings, and state and federal courts.
Dr. Siegel testified that she had reviewed the CARD discrete trial log books, assessment and other documents regarding STUDENT, but did not personally assess him or visit his proposed special day class. Dr. Siegel found that STUDENT had made marked progress in his CARD program over one year, from having no language at the beginning, to currently being at a two and one-half to three-year-old level. She stated that STUDENT now needs more generalization and functional language. He also needs to be educated in a group setting to develop social skills and to have more natural language models.
Dr. Siegel stated her first choice for a group setting “probably” would not be a Montessori preschool, but rather a smaller, “playschool” model class, where play is less structured.(Footnote 13) The smaller class should have 10 to 15 children with a t eacher/student ratio of 1:4 or 1:5, and a 1:1 aide to facilitate STUDENT’s interactions. Based on his level of language development, STUDENT should be with two and one-half to three-year-old children. However, because of STUDENT‘s large size, a mixed age group would, potentially, be more appropriate.(Footnote 14)
Dr. Siegel testified that either a regular preschool class or a class for communicatively handicapped preschool children would be appropriate for STUDENT, if his classmates have language and play at his same developmental level. Dr. Siegel stated she is unable to determine which type of class would be more appropriate without seeing STUDENT. Even if she saw STUDENT, appropriateness would depend on the particular class. In either setting, STUDENT should have an aide, and a consultant to supervise the aide and assist the teacher. Dr. Siegel stated that a class for autistic children is not appropriate for STUDENT.
Dr. Siegel recommended a gradual transition for STUDENT into a preschool class, from two or three days a week up to five days per week, with corresponding reduction in discrete trial training at home. Dr. Siegel testified that very few children continue to benefit from 40 hours of discrete trials after one year. She suggested reducing STUDENT’s discrete trial time to 15 hours per week, and then 10 hours per week over the next year. Even if STUDENT was only receiving 15 to 20 hours per week in discrete trials, his home program would still need to be supervised, according to Dr. Siegel. She also suggested that STUDENT’s language training include more play activity. Dr. Siegel stated that STUDENT could benefit from having an aide who knows him to assist with this transition. If the transition is successful, after three months at five days per week, STUDENT could switch to an aide with no discrete trial experience to avoid prompt dependence.
Dr. Siegel summarized her recommendations stating she was suggesting a combination program for STUDENT with an “integrated, group-based, preschool program” and discrete trial training. She testified that an intensive program like CARD has “definite efficacy and effectiveness with high functioning autistic children.” She characterized STUDENT as high functioning. Petitioner’s experts
Dr. Jacqueline Wynn
Dr. Jacqueline Wynn has a Ph.D. in psychology and has had two positions as a post-doctoral scholar at University of California-Los Angeles (UCLA). Dr. Wynn is the assistant director for both the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention, and the Clinic for Behavioral Treatment of Children, UCLA, Department of Psychology. Dr. Wynn has done research and presented papers in the field of autism, taught and supervised students in behavior modification techniques, and supervised clinical work with autistic children. Dr. Wynn has also served as a consultant to school districts and families concerning intensive behavior intervention techniques. (Pet. Exh. 47.)
Dr. Wynn testified that Lovaas therapy is called intensive behavior intervention because of the number of hours of therapy, the location in the child’s home, and the discrete trial format. Parental involvement is a “must” because when parents are involved the child’s gains are maintained, generalized, and extended to other settings. Dr. Wynn does not believe that the home is a more restrictive environment for a child who is STUDENT’s age of four and one-half years old. Dr. Wynn testified that a 1993 research study concluded that 12 year-old autistic children who had received 40 hours per week of intensive behavior intervention maintained gains in IQ and adaptive skills over time, and eight of the nine children in the study were functioning like "typically-developing" children.
Dr. Wynn testified that the CARD program is very similar to the program at the UCLA Clinic. Dr. Wynn is also familiar with Dr. McEachin, and testified that his program is “somewhat different” from Lovaas therapy.(Footnote 15)
Dr. Wynn testified that she had observed STUDENT during in-home therapy. She also read several documents on STUDENT’s program and progress, including an assessment report and his current CARD therapy log book. Dr. Wynn stated she did not personally assess STUDENT. She recommended that STUDENT transition from home to school as soon as possible, preferably into a “typical” class placement or regular education. STUDENT needs the classroom structure with an aide who would “fade” in and out as needed, and who knows STUDENT. Other children are important for STUDENT’s transition plan as he needs to spend time with “normally-developing children.” Dr. Wynn stated that the manner of the transition depends on the child, and should begin with either one, or one and one-half hours two times per week, not five days per week because it is important to avoid failure. Dr. Wynn stated that it is a realistic goal for STUDENT to go to regular kindergarten with an aide in one and one-half years.
Dr. Wynn testified that she had not visited STUDENT’s preschool program. She stated that it would be important to evaluate his teacher, the classroom structure and flexibility during transition. Goals for the transition would be to handle STUDENT’s negative behavior, to use an aide, to have the teacher take over the aide’s role eventually, and to modify the environment, if possible.
Dr. Wynn testified that she would not recommend an autistic class for STUDENT because he would show negative behavior from being around the other children, and would not benefit. STUDENT needs peers who are the “highest level language and social peers” possible and who will model appropriate behavior. Dr. Wynn stated that she would not recommend transitioning from a 1:1 home program to a special day class, but would try a “typical” class first based on the child’s needs as shown in the home program. Dr. Wynn was aware of the program offered to STUDENT by the District and stated that it sounded very different from a Lovaas program. Dr. Wynn stated she also would not recommend the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) for STUDENT as he has enough pre-requisite skills already, and does not need PECS.(Footnote 16) Dr. Wynn acknowledged that she had never visited the Weaver special day class proposed for STUDENT.
Concerning therapy hours, Dr. Wynn stated that the UCLA Clinic does not recommend an overall intensive behavior intervention program of only 20 hours per week. However, if a child is transitioning to school, then the in-home therapy hours may be reduced to 20 hours per week. If STUDENT’s overall hours were cut in half, there would be an increase in his difficult behaviors, reduced acquisition of skills and loss of skills already acquired. Dr. Wynn stated that STUDENT has had good success in his CARD program so far, and the goal should be the “highest level placement possible.” She would not change STUDENT’s services, but would continue what has worked.
Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh
Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh is clinical director and owner of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), which she founded in 1990. She has a Ph.D. in psychology and is a licensed psychologist in California. Dr. Granpeesheh worked under Dr. Ivar Lovaas at UCLA for approximately 12 years before starting CARD. She has done research on the etiology of autism, and specializes in developmental disabilities, autism and pervasive developmental disorders, and assessment and treatment of childhood disorders.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that CARD uses about 300 drills for discrete trials. Children are assigned drills according to their needs at the start of the program. Drills are also created for children and changed as needed by Dr. Granpeesheh and senior staff. Each drill progresses to another one and all the drills are connected. Drills cannot be done with two children at the table at the same time as timing of the inter-trial interval is very important. Dr. Granpeesheh also testified that her staff and program at CARD meet all government regulations to her knowledge. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that she is quite familiar with the curriculum and approach used by the Autism Partnership under Dr. McEachin. She believes that the program’s drills and consequences do not follow a typical Lovaas format.
Dr. Granpeesheh stated that she had observed STUDENT at a CARD clinic at the end of June 1997, and has reviewed his log books and behaviors. STUDENT is generally doing very well and moving rapidly through the CARD program. He is modeling, generalizing well, has no compliance issues, and has only two minor behavior (self-stimulation) issues. STUDENT needs to develop more verbalization; however, Dr. Granpeesheh was “not concerned” about this given how well STUDENT is doing overall. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that she believes STUDENT can eventually be “mainstreamed” into regular school. STUDENT has not hit any blocks yet, which suggests that he will continue to do well. Dr. Granpeesheh characterized STUDENT as high functioning and a “model student” in the CARD program.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT’s program has changed since fall 1996. In fact, she stated the program changes somewhat every other week as drills are modified during clinic sessions. The changes are planned and are considered part of the 40-hour program. The next level for STUDENT is to move to the school environment and reduce his hours at home.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that a 40-hour per week program is "absolutely appropriate" for STUDENT. STUDENT’s 40 hours are not just discrete trial training, but also include preschool. Dr. Granpeesheh indicated that STUDENT’s program must be extremely consistent, and yet flexible enough to respond to any change in his needs. Within the 40-hour program, CARD will re-distribute hours in specific program components, such as preschool and discrete trials, if STUDENT’s performance in these settings indicates a shift is needed. STUDENT is not yet through the initial drills, and has "a long way to go," according to Dr. Granpeesheh. Once STUDENT has completed his initial drills, then his 40 hours can be reduced.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that if STUDENT’s CARD program stopped and the District’s proposed program were implemented, STUDENT would definitely regress because his entire staff would change, and they would not know STUDENT. Even if the quality of STUDENT’s staff remained high, the sudden change and inconsistency would be confusing for STUDENT and he would suffer. Then the quality of staff skills would determine whether STUDENT could be "brought back." If STUDENT’s in-home program were reduced to 20 hours per week it would be impossible to appropriately address all his behavior needs. STUDENT has 20 to 30 drills at one time and it would be hard to pick which drills to eliminate. Also, if STUDENT’s hours were reduced, he would exhibit negative behavior because no one would be dealing with it during his unprogrammed hours. Dr. Granpeesheh also testified that a special day class is not appropriate for STUDENT. He is high functioning, and needs to be around “normal” children because he is modeling a lot and needs to learn proper behavior and language from peers. STUDENT also does not need the PECS program in class as this would be counter productive for him.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District’s January 1997 offer of 20 hours per week of in-home discrete trial training by District aides, combined with five half-days per week in the autistic special day class at Weaver Elementary School, is inappropriate for STUDENT for several reasons. Petitioner states that the special day class at Weaver offers no inclusion component, and would move STUDENT from his current regular preschool class to a more restrictive placement with nonverbal autistic children. This change would not prepare STUDENT for placement in a regular kindergarten class next year. (Pet. Closing Argument Brief, pgs. 2-3.)
Petitioner also contends that the proposed placement does not offer related services or “designated instruction and services (DIS)” which STUDENT needs. Petitioner maintains that the District’s offer is both a reduction in hours and a different type of 1:1 instruction than STUDENT is now receiving from CARD because the District aides providing in-home discrete trial training would not be trained or supervised in a “Lovaas approach.” Petitioner states that STUDENT cannot learn in a group setting, even if only one other child is present; he must learn 1:1, master the skills taught, and then generalize to a group setting with the assistance of a shadow aide. (Pet. Closing Argument Brief, pgs. 2-3.) Petitioner concludes that continuation of STUDENT’s current CARD program, with a regular preschool inclusion component, is the appropriate placement to prepare STUDENT for regular kindergarten next year.(Footnote 17)
The District contends that its offer to place STUDENT in the “regional autism class” at Weaver Elementary School was appropriate for him in January 1997 for several reasons, including better staff supervision than CARD’s, “richer curriculum,” and resources and methods similar to those used by CARD. (Resp. Closing Brief, pgs. 41, 43-44.) The District requests a finding that the autism class was appropriate for STUDENT when it was offered last January.
The District also contends that STUDENT does not require 35 to 40 hours per week of discrete trial training, along with a shadow aide at a regular community preschool program, to benefit from his education. According to the District, STUDENT’s current preschool program is inappropriate due to a teacher/student ratio of 1:12, and unqualified CARD staff in supervision and shadowing roles. The District also states that STUDENT no longer requires the “isolation of home teaching,” which is “presumed by the state statute to be the most restrictive environment.” (Resp. Closing Brief, pgs. 45-46.) The District argues that it should not be required to contract with CARD because the District has an existing contractual relationship with Autism Partnership for a training program for intensive behavior intervention. (Resp. Closing Brief, pgs. 41-43.)
Finally, the District intimates that the Weaver special day class is no longer appropriate for STUDENT at the conclusion of the hearing in July 1997. The District argues, in essence, that, during the pendency of the hearing, STUDENT’s needs changed and he became ready for a placement in a District preschool program--either a communication handicapped class, regular preschool class with support, class for older autistic children opening this school year, or a combination of these programs. Given these developments, the District requests that the Hearing Officer order all parties back to an IEP meeting to determine the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year. (Resp. Closing Brief, pgs. 43-45, 48-49.)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Is the District’s change of placement offer of January 1997 an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year?
The District requests a finding that the Weaver special day class was appropriate for STUDENT when offered in January 1997. However, a finding regarding the appropriateness of the Weaver class for STUDENT at that time is not necessary because there is no longer an issue of retroactive reimbursement between the parties. That issue, along with the issue of compensatory education, was withdrawn by Petitioner by the close of hearing. Further, as a result of the IEP meeting of September 25, 1996, and the stay put order of February 28, 1997, STUDENT remains in his current placement with the CARD program, which must be funded by the District to the conclusion of these impartial review proceedings. (Grymes v. Madden (3rd Cir. 1982) 672 F.2d 321.) Thus, whether the District’s January 1997 offer was appropriate then is no longer an issue which must be resolved by the Hearing Officer.
The issue now is whether the District’s prior offer is an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year. As to this issue, the District all but concedes in its closing brief that the January 1997 offer is no longer appropriate for STUDENT. The District states, “The educational program offered at the January 28, 1997 IEPT meeting was appropriate at the time it was offered even if the same class was no longer appropriate six and one half months later at the time of hearing.” No evidence was presented that another, more recent District placement offer was made that would address STUDENT’s current needs. There is also no evidence that the District has convened an IEP meeting since January 1997 to propose an updated placement. In the District’s closing brief, Ms. Albanese mentions several alternatives as possible programs for STUDENT currently. However, these possibilities do not reflect the specific recommendation of an IEP team, and do not satisfy the requirements of Union School District v. B. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519 that a "formal written offer" be made. Therefore, even though the District appears to concede that its prior offer is no longer appropriate, the Hearing Officer will review that placement offer as the law requires, and because there was no subsequent, legally sufficient offer.
The District’s prior placement offer proposed 20 hours per week of “in-home services” by District staff trained in discrete trials, combined with five half-days per week of special day class for autistic children at Weaver Elementary School. By previous order of the Hearing Office, the District bears the burden of proof to show that its placement offer, which would change the status quo, is appropriate for STUDENT.
Under federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education. (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 et seq., Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56000 et seq.)(Footnote 18) Federal law defines “free appropriate public education” to mean special education and related services, including an appropriate preschool education, that conform with the student’s individualized education program.(Footnote 19) (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(a)(18)(C)-(D).) “Special education” means “specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents..., to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability including-- instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home,...and in other settings;...” (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(a)(16)(A).)
The United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided to a disabled student under the IDEA in Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services, or that the services maximize each child’s potential. Rather, “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit” to the student. (Id. at 200.)
The right to a free and appropriate education (FAPE) also includes the right to educational services in the least restrictive environment. (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1412(5)(B); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) The “least restrictive environment” provisions require that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities be educated with children without disabilities. (34 CFR Sec. 300.550.) Special classes, separate schooling or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment can occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 CFR Sec. 3 00.550(b)(2).)
Thus, under the IDEA, Rowley, and state law, an appropriate educational placement for a preschool child with disabilities must include instruction and services which (1) are designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) provide educational benefit, (3) are provided in the least restrictive environment, and (4) conform to the student’s IEP.
STUDENT’s unique needs
As a preschool child diagnosed with autism, STUDENT has significant needs in several areas, including speech and language development, social-emotional development, self-help skills, and socialization. The District initially identified STUDENT’s primary areas of need to include expressive and pragmatic language, and social-emotional development. (Pet. Exh. 3; Resp. Exh. 2, 3.)
Approximately one year ago, at the September 1996 IEP meeting, the parties agreed that STUDENT’s needs could be appropriately addressed in his existing 40-hour per week, in-home intensive behavior intervention program with CARD. The parties also agreed that this in-home program was necessary for at least another four months through January 1997, when STUDENT’s progress would be assessed. (Pet. Exh. 22, Resp. Exh. 5.)
In November 1996, Dr. Granpeesheh and staff at CARD determined that STUDENT needed to begin regular preschool for integration with non-disabled peers, socialization, and for generalization of skills learned in his in-home program. STUDENT began to attend a regular preschool one half-day per week for approximately three to four hours with a CARD-trained shadow aide.
At the time the due process hearing began in May 1997, STUDENT had completed about one year in his CARD program. In April 1997, CARD re-assessed STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. 35.) The assessor noted that, despite significant progress, STUDENT still had severe delays in both expressive and receptive communication skills. STUDENT’s spontaneous language was described as “limited,” typically involving specific needs or wants. STUDENT was also noted to have delays in daily living skills, specifically toileting, bathing, complex dressing tasks, and personal safety. STUDENT was still exhibiting several self-stimulatory behaviors which interfered with his ability to learn. STUDENT’s social and play behavior was described as limited, although it was noted that he did pretend play, imitation and sharing. The assessor concluded that STUDENT continued to need “40 hours per week of home-based discrete trial behavior modification therapy.” (Pet. Exh. 35.)
Witnesses testifying at the hearing essentially agreed that, at this point, STUDENT needs more generalization of language skills and more functional language. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT needs to develop more verbalization. Dr. Jamison emphasized that STUDENT needs a structured language program with a “communication emphasis.” She also stated that he needs more content and application of language skills. Glenda McHale, a preschool speech and language specialist in a neighboring school district, also testified that STUDENT needs more language to continue learning that words are representative and convey meaning. Based on this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs to continue developing his speech and language skills through more verbalization and communication. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT needs to generalize and apply his language skills in a variety of settings, and needs to develop more functional language.
Several witnesses testified that STUDENT also needs to be in a group setting to increase his social skills and to have more natural language models. Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT be placed in either a regular preschool class or a class for communicatively handicapped preschool children, depending on details of the specific class proposed. She expressed a preference for a “playschool” model class where play is less structured and more interaction and communication can occur between the children. Dr. Siegel stressed that STUDENT needs to be in a class with children who have the same level of language development as he does.
Dr. Wynn recommended a “typical” class rather than a special day class because STUDENT needs to spend time with peers who will model appropriate language and behavior. She stated that STUDENT needs to be in the “highest level placement possible” to further develop his language and social skills. Dr. Granpeesheh also stated that STUDENT needs to be around “normal” children because he is now modeling quite a bit and will learn appropriate behavior and language from his peers.
The only expert who did not support placing STUDENT in a regular preschool class was Dr. Jamison.(Footote 20) She testified that the Weaver special day class for autistic children would be “ideal” for STUDENT. However, the other three experts testified that placement in a class with other autistic children would not meet STUDENT’s needs currently. Both Drs. Wynn and Granpeesheh stated that STUDENT would regress in such a placement. Dr. Siegel testified simply that STUDENT does not need a class for autistic children at this time.
The Hearing Officer accords greater weight to the testimony of Drs. Siegel, Wynn and Granpeesheh because their testimony was clear and unequivocal in stating that an autistic class was not appropriate for STUDENT. These three experts have extensive experience with autistic children, and Dr. Granpeesheh knows STUDENT well. Further, Dr. Siegel was a District witness, and her testimony on this point was not helpful to the District’s position. Finally, both Drs. Wynn and Granpeesheh testified about the likelihood of regression for STUDENT if he were placed in the autistic class. Dr. Jamison never addressed this point. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a group setting with his developmental peers in speech and language to further improve his social skills and to model appropriate behavior and language. Considering the testimony about the importance of natural language and behavior models for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT needs to be placed in a regular education (“normal” or “typical”) preschool setting rather than a categorical special day class.
Each of the four experts testified that STUDENT needs a program which includes continued 1:1 discrete trial training. The experts differed as to the number of discrete trial hours necessary for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer will discuss and decide the issue of overall number of hours for STUDENT later in this decision. In August 1996, for purposes of the IEP team meeting in September, Dr. Granpeesheh recommended an in-home, 1:1, behavior modification program to help STUDENT develop the basic skills in attending, use of language, compliance, managing frustrations, and socialization which he needs to “eventually achieve success in a school setting.” (Pet. Exh. 16; Resp. Exh. 23.) Both Drs. Wynn and Granpeesheh recommended continuation of STUDENT’s existing discrete trial, behavior modification program. Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT’s discrete trials include more play activity. Dr. Jamison stated that STUDENT needs training in daily living skills in a home program which is an extension of his school program. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a program component of 1:1 discrete trial training for speech and language, social-emotional, self-help/daily living, and socialization skills in preparation for the classroom environment.
Finally, there was considerable testimony concerning t ransitioning STUDENT into a preschool class. At least one witness who testified was apparently unaware that STUDENT is already transitioning to a Montessori preschool program with CARD assistance. Dr. Wynn testified that STUDENT should be transitioned from home to school as soon as possible, starting with a few hours per week in class. She also recommended that STUDENT have an aide who knows him to assist in class, and to “fade” in and out as needed. Dr. Siegel concurred in the recommendation for a gradual transition to a preschool class facilitated by a 1:1 shadow aide who knows STUDENT. She testified that there should be a corresponding reduction in STUDENT’s discrete trial program at home as he increases his time in the preschool class. Based on this testimony and other evidence concerning STUDENT’s current transition into the Montessori preschool program, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires a 1:1 shadow aide to help him adjust and function in a regular preschool class. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT needs to transition gradually from his in-home program into his regular preschool class.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a combination program of a group-based regular education preschool class and in-home discrete trial training to address his many language and social development needs. The preschool class must be with “typically-developing” children who are STUDENT’s developmental peers. The other component of STUDENT’s program must provide 1:1, in-home, discrete trial training to further prepare STUDENT for school. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a gradual transition into his preschool class, and a 1:1 shadow aide to facilitate his participation. Given the extent of STUDENT’s needs, and the danger of regression if his program stops, the Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT needs an extended school year program.
Considering these needs, it is clear that the District’s January 1997 special day class offer is not appropriate for STUDENT at this time. The Weaver autism class would not allow STUDENT the natural language and behavior models of “typically-developing” children which he needs. There was also testimony from three of the four experts that an autism class is not appropriate for STUDENT currently and could cause him to regress, as discussed above. The Hearing Officer has already found the testimony of those three experts more persuasive than the testimony of District expert, Dr. Jamison, who strongly recommended the autism class for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s January 1997 offer of the Weaver special day class for autistic children is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs at present.
The District also offered to provide STUDENT with "in-home services" of 20 hours per week of discrete trial training by District-employed staff. District witnesses testified that this in-home program would be supervised by the Autism Partnership under the leadership of Dr. John McEachin and Dr. Ronald Leaf. The exact nature of the discrete trial program was not indicated in the written offer or in testimony. However, both Drs. Wynn and Granpeesheh testified that the Autism Partnership program is different from a typical Lovaas-type program. In addition, there was considerable testimony concerning the unique nature of the intensive program provided by CARD, and the risk of regression and return of behavioral problems for STUDENT if his entire program were to change. Both Drs. Wynn and Granpeesheh stressed the importance of consistency in STUDENT’s program to insure continued progress.
Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT had made significant progress in the CARD program, and no evidence was presented as to why STUDENT’s needs required a different provider. Dawn Walsh testified that the District “preferred” to deal with the Autism Partnership rather than CARD. This is not adequate justification for change, especially in light of STUDENT’s gains in the CARD program. Further, the risk of regression for STUDENT is sufficiently great to persuade the Hearing Officer that change to another provider would not be in STUDENT’s best interests and is not appropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the second portion of the District’s offer, for 20 hours per week of discrete trials by District-employed staff, is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs at present. Educational benefit
Both parts of the District’s placement offer would be of questionable educational benefit to STUDENT currently. As already discussed above, the weight of the evidence indicated that the Weaver autism class would not provide STUDENT with the language and social/behavioral modeling he needs. The evidence also indicated that STUDENT would likely regress if placed in a special day class. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that this portion of the District’s offer would not provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
As for the 20 hours per week of in-home services, the evidence indicated that implementation of this program would result in a total staff change and discrete trial program changes for STUDENT. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that a total change in STUDENT’s program and staff would precipitate regression and likely return of behavioral problems for him. He could be “brought back,” according to Dr. Granpeesheh, assuming high quality skills in his new staff. However, the Hearing Officer notes that time which would have to be spent “bringing STUDENT back” would also be time lost in productive program and learning. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that these changes would slow, stop or reverse STUDENT’s progress in behavior and learning. The Hearing Officer concludes that the second portion of the District’s offer, for 20 hours of in-home services provided by District-employed staff, would not provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Least restrictive environment
The District argues that its placement offer is the least restrictive alternative for STUDENT because he “no longer requires an isolated home program which is presumed by the state statute to be the most restrictive environment,” and he would have “ mainstreaming experiences at recess” during the Weaver special day class. (Resp. Closing Brief, pg. 46.) The District also states that STUDENT would have some undefined “opportunities for integration” because the Weaver site also houses a state day care and preschool program.
The District’s proposal would place STUDENT in a special day class with other autistic children for five half-days per week. This would be a dramatic change in STUDENT’s educational environment. STUDENT has been functioning effectively in a regular preschool program in the community since November 1996 with the assistance of a shadow aide. At the conclusion of the hearing, STUDENT was attending that program two half-days per week. Thus, if the District’s proposed placement were implemented, STUDENT would move from a class with nondisabled peers for six to eight hours per week to a class with disabled peers for 17½ hours per week. This is clearly not a placement in the least restrictive environment.
The District’s contention that recess time would provide “mainstreaming experiences” does not convert the more restrictive environment of a special day class into the least restrictive alternative. The federal regulations refer to recess periods as nonacademic settings. (34 CFR Sec. 300.553.) The opportunity that STUDENT would have for interaction with nondisabled peers in approximately 30 minutes of recess each day is not remotely comparable to six to eight hours per week of interaction in the Montessori preschool educational setting.(Footnote 21)
Finally, there seems to be some inconsistency between the District’s position concerning the restrictiveness of an in-home program and its offer of 20 hours per week of in-home therapy for STUDENT. If the District does indeed believe that the “isolation of an in-home program” is no longer appropriate for STUDENT, then it is unclear why the District has offered 20 hours per week of just such a program.
Further, the District offers no specific authority for its contention that state statute “presumes” the home to be the most restrictive environment. In fact, two provisions in Chapter 4.45 of the Education Code, regarding preschool programs for disabled children, specifically identify the home as a “typical, age-appropriate” or “regular” environment for young children. (See Cal. Ed. Code Secs. 56441.2, 56441.4.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s placement offer, particularly the offer of a preschool special day class for autistic children, does not satisfy the requirements for educating STUDENT in the least restrictive environment.
Conforms to the IEP
This requirement is not relevant because the Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s offer is not appropriate for STUDENT.
Based on the foregoing discussion, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s January 1997 placement offer is not appropriate currently because it is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, would not provide STUDENT with educational benefit, and would not place STUDENT in the least restrictive educational environment. The District has not met its burden to justify a change in placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year.
ISSUE NO. 2: If the District’s placement is not appropriate, is STUDENT’s continuing home and community program of intensive behavior intervention through CARD an appropriate placement?
Because the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District’s change of placement offer is not appropriate for STUDENT, the next issue is whether his current CARD program of 35 to 40 hours per week of intensive behavior intervention is appropriate. STUDENT’s CARD program provides “related services,” called "designated instruction and services" (DIS) under California law. (20 U.S.C. 1401(a)(17); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56363(a).) DIS services are required when necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56363(a).) Due to STUDENT’s delays in speech and language, social-emotional development and socialization skills, he requires a variety of services to benefit educationally from his instructional program. These services include intensive behavior intervention with 1:1 discrete trial training, and a 1:1 shadow aide to facilitate STUDENT’s transition to a preschool class with “typically developing” peers.
STUDENT’s CARD program was selected by his parents, and was found to be appropriate and adopted by the IEP team in September 1996. Since that time, the program has evolved such that at the close of the hearing, it consisted of a combination of two half-days (six to eight hours) per week of regular Montessori preschool class, 27 to 32 hours per week of in-home, 1:1 discrete trial training, and additional community activities to help STUDENT with his socialization needs. (Testimony of PARENT.)
The District challenges STUDENT’s continued need for 35 to 40 hours per week of the CARD program. However, the clear weight of the evidence indicates that STUDENT has made tremendous progress since he started with CARD in May 1996. According to Dr. G ranpeesheh, STUDENT is doing very well and moving rapidly through the in-home program. Dr. Wynn testified that STUDENT has had good success in his CARD program thus far, and recommended that it be continued. Dr. Siegel stated that STUDENT has done “quite nicely” in the CARD program, and noted that this kind of intensive program has “definite efficacy and effectiveness” for a high functioning autistic child such as STUDENT. Dr. Jamison expressed some concerns about STUDENT’s 40-hour program, but did not testify that he had failed to progress overall in his CARD therapy.
Dr. Granpeesheh also testified that a 40-hour per week program is very appropriate for STUDENT considering the skills he still must acquire and his need for consistency. The 40 hours provide time to address STUDENT’s behavior and learning needs in both the discrete trial format and in preschool. STUDENT has not yet completed the initial drills in the CARD program, and, according to Dr. Granpeesheh, has "a long way to go."
Dr. Wynn testified that 1993 research findings indicate that autistic children who had received 40 hours per week of intensive behavior intervention maintained gains in IQ and adaptive skills over time. Most of the autistic children in the study were also functioning as "typically developing" children years after they had received the intensive behavior intervention program.
The District’s evidence which challenged STUDENT’s 40-hour per week program focused on 40 hours of actual, in-home, 1:1 discrete trial training. However, STUDENT has not received this number of discrete trial hours since at least November 1996 when he began to transition to the community preschool program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is satisfied that STUDENT’s 40 hours per week of intensive behavior intervention are justified and finds that this overall number of hours should continue considering STUDENT’s progress and continuing significant needs.
As for the appropriateness of the components of STUDENT’s CARD program, the Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT needs a combination program of a group-based regular education preschool class and in-home discrete trial training to address his needs. STUDENT’s 40-hour per week CARD program contains these components, specifically in-home, discrete trial training and community socialization activities, and Montessori preschool, which are designed to prepare him for the classroom setting. STUDENT’s discrete trial therapy and community socialization component have resulted in his significant gains in speech and language, socialization, self-help, and other behaviors already documented and discussed. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the in-home discrete trial training and community socialization component of his CARD program is appropriate and is meeting STUDENT’s unique needs.
The Montessori preschool class with younger age “typically developing” children has also benefitted STUDENT. Since November 1996, he has been gradually transitioning into this class, and was attending two days per week by the conclusion of the hearing. STUDENT has a 1:1 shadow aide in class, who is a CARD-trained therapist also working with him at home. The uncontested evidence indicates that STUDENT is doing well in this preschool class and progressing in his socialization and language skills while there. Both of STUDENT’s shadow aides, Melanie Ann Foshee and Tammy Heekyung Heo, testified that they had received CARD training and supervision for their shadowing and ongoing therapy roles with STUDENT.
Ms. Foshee testified that STUDENT is doing well because he is "implementing without being pushed," sitting well, interacting with other children, and is using new language constructs. STUDENT uses words to get the attention of other children, and can do one to two conversational turns. Ms. Foshee testified that she had begun to “fade” herself in her social facilitation role for STUDENT. Ms. Foshee coordinates with the classroom teacher by talking with her during class time, and finds that the teacher often asks her for help.
Ms. Heo testified about STUDENT’s preschool class schedule. She stated he is able to sit for 20 minutes during circle time with prompts from her for attending, but that he does not share during sharing time. STUDENT usually has two or more other children who want to work with him during work station time. Ms. Heo prompts STUDENT and the other children to talk with each other, but STUDENT will also make some spontaneous statements like, “Hey, where you going?”. Other children ask STUDENT to read to them and he does so using simple books.(Footnote 22)
Ms. Heo also works with STUDENT on skills like waiting his turn. She stated STUDENT participates in free play time with the other children and that he likes school and doesn’t want to leave. STUDENT still has some negative behavior like tantruming or screaming, but the tantruming is much less than earlier, and the screaming occurs when STUDENT has to transition to circle time from an activity he likes. During CARD clinics every two weeks, STUDENT’s performance at school is discussed. (Testimony of Tammy Heekyung Heo.)
Two aspects of STUDENT’s preschool class do not fit with recommendations made by Dr. Siegel. There is a 1:12 t eacher/student ratio, and the class format follows Montessori not “playschool” principles. Although these differences render the class apparently less than ideal, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT has, nevertheless, done well according to the testimony of his shadow aides. Further, Dr. Siegel qualified her testimony by indicating that the specific class proposed for STUDENT would have to be evaluated to determine if it is appropriate to meet his needs. STUDENT’s parents are not requesting reimbursement for the preschool portion of his CARD program. STUDENT is clearly benefitting from his preschool experience, and has 1:1 attention with his shadow aide. No purpose would be served to disturb STUDENT’s progress, solely to accomplish a lower teacher/student ratio or find a “playschool” format. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the preschool component of STUDENT’s CARD program with a 1:1 shadow aide is also meeting his unique needs.
There was conflicting testimony concerning the specific number of hours of in-home, discrete trial training STUDENT needs. The District argues that STUDENT does not need 27 to 32 hours per week, and provided Dr. Siegel’s research findings and other documentary evidence in support of this position. (Resp. Exh. 41, 42.) Dr. Siegel testified that children receiving 35 hours per week of discrete trials showed no more gains than did children who received 25 hours per week. Dr. Siegel also specifically recommended that STUDENT’s hours be reduced to 15 and then 10 hours per week over the next year.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that, within a 40-hour per week program, flexibility is needed to adjust hours according to STUDENT’s needs and ongoing program performance. For example, if STUDENT "hit a block" in his in-home discrete trials, an adjustment would be made by CARD, perhaps by increasing his preschool hours. Dr. Granpeesheh did not identify a fixed number of hours for STUDENT’s in-home discrete trials, but rather testified to the need for a fluid program which will allow STUDENT to transition successfully to preschool. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not specifically allocate hours between the components of STUDENT’s CARD program as this would not allow the flexibility needed to address his changing needs. The Hearing Officer finds that allocation of hours in STUDENT’s 40-hour per week program must be done by those who are most intimately aware of his needs and program performance, Dr. Granpeesheh and the CARD-trained staff.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s CARD program, including in-home discrete trial training and community socialization activities, and the Montessori preschool class with a 1:1 shadow aide, is meeting his unique needs. As already noted, STUDENT has received substantial educational benefit from his CARD program. The preschool component of his program provides STUDENT with the least restrictive environment because he is with “typically developing” children who are his developmental peers. Contrary to the District’s assertion, the in-home component of STUDENT’s program is an appropriate environment for young children under state law. (See Cal. Ed. Code Secs. 56441.2, 56441.4.) Over the next year, STUDENT will be reducing his time at home and increasing his time in the Montessori preschool environment as he continues to transition.
The CARD program for STUDENT also emphasizes parent involvement. STUDENT’s parents are included in biweekly clinic sessions where his therapy and progress are reviewed and modified as needed. STUDENT’s parents have already learned behavior modification concepts and have received other training from CARD which has clearly assisted STUDENT in achieving the progress he has shown to date. STUDENT’s mother testified that she works with him constantly and is aware of his level of performance. This “active parent involvement” is identified in state law as an important component of preschool programs for disabled children. (Cal. Ed. Code Secs. 56441, 56441.2, 56441.3.)
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT may be able to be mainstreamed in regular kindergarten based on his progress to date. Dr. Wynn also concurred that this was a realistic goal for STUDENT given his progress so far. This mainstreaming possibility is consistent with goals for preschool education of disabled children, identified in state law, as well as the emphasis on mainstreaming in the IDEA. Education Code Section 56441.1 (b), states, “As the preschool child approaches the age to enter an elementary school environment, the child’s preparation shall be geared toward a readiness for kindergarten and later school success.”
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s continuing home and community-based CARD program of 40 hours per week is an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year. Because the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT requires an extended school year program, his placement with CARD must continue through the 1997-98 extended school year. STUDENT’s continued transition into the Montessori preschool program must be designed and implemented by CARD in a transition plan with specific goals and objectives. The continuation of STUDENT’s 40-hour per week CARD program as his placement for the 1997-98 extended school year and the transition plan must be incorporated in STUDENT’s amended IEP.
ISSUE NO. 3: If STUDENT’s program through CARD is appropriate, must the District contract with CARD rather than other certified nonpublic agencies, and must the District hire aides trained by CARD?
The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT’s current program through CARD is appropriate and must continue as his placement in the 1997-98 school year. Based on the unique nature of the services provided by CARD, and the considerable progress made by STUDENT as a result of the CARD program, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must continue to use this service provider and aides trained by CARD.
The District attempted in its case to prove that CARD staff were inadequately trained and supervised, and that CARD was operating beyond the limits of its certification. This position is rather anomalous considering that the District itself agreed to contract with CARD for STUDENT’s services as a result of the September 25, 1996 IEP meeting. (Resp. Exh. 15, 16; Pet. Exh. 30, 28, 24.) Petitioner provided a letter dated July 31, 1996, from the State Department of Education which indicates that CARD was certified for the academic year 1995-96 to provide behavior management therapy throughout the State, at school district sites and in the child’s home.(Footnote 23) (Pet. Exh. 17.) Dr. Granpeesheh testified that CARD’s certification as a nonpublic agency remains intact currently under her license as a psychologist. Dr. Granpeesheh also testified in detail about the supervisory structure at CARD. Other witnesses, associated with CARD, described initial and ongoing training provided to therapists, as well as supervision received. (Testimony of Dawn Enoch, Carolyn Ann Brown, Melanie Ann Foshee, Tammy Heo.)
Further, Petitioner’s evidence indicates that STUDENT’s program was closely monitored every two weeks through clinic sessions and supervision by Dawn Enoch and, less frequently, by Dr. Granpeesheh. All of STUDENT’s therapists received training and ongoing supervision in the CARD discrete trial format. Thus, based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s CARD program is adequately supervised and that CARD provides behavior management services to STUDENT pursuant to its certification as a nonpublic agency.
ORDER
(1) Within 15 days of this order, the Los Alamitos School District shall convene an IEP meeting for STUDENT. The IEP team shall include a representative of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), paid for by the District.
(2) The IEP team shall amend STUDENT’s IEP consistent with the findings and conclusions in this decision. Specifically, STUDENT’s IEP shall be amended to provide for his continued placement in his 40-hour per week intensive behavior interven-tion program through CARD for the duration of the 1997-98 extended school year. STUDENT’s CARD program shall include in-home, discrete trial training and community socialization activities, a Montessori regular education preschool class with a 1:1 shadow aide to facilitate STUDENT’s integration and participation in class, and CARD clinics and other ongoing consultation and supervision, as required.
(3) The District shall request that CARD staff design and implement a flexible transition plan which provides for STUDENT’s continued gradual transition into his Montessori preschool program. The transition plan shall include specific goals and objectives for STUDENT’s smooth integration into his preschool program consistent with the findings and conclusions in this decision. The transition plan shall be completed within 15 days of this order and shall be incorporated into STUDENT’s amended IEP.
(4) The District shall fund STUDENT’s CARD program as outlined in (2) above for the 1997-98 extended school year, except that the District is not responsible to fund STUDENT’s private Montessori preschool tuition and related costs, if any. The District shall fund the 1:1 CARD-trained shadow aides who assist STUDENT at his preschool program, as well as any CARD supervision of these aides and any CARD program consultation to the private preschool required to assist or facilitate STUDENT’s integration.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner substantially prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56505(i).)
DATED: October 15, 1997 _______________________________ JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1.Petitioner initially identified four issues for hearing, but withdrew two issues before the matter was submitted. The issue regarding retroactive reimbursement for CARD in-home services was withdrawn by Petitioner by way of letter to the Hearing Office received July 2, 1997. The issue of compensatory education was withdrawn by Petitioner on the last day of hearing. 2. Respondent’s request was granted pursuant to Title 5 California Code of Regulations Section 3082(g). 3.STUDENT was evaluated by a speech and language pathologist in December 1995. (Pet. Exh. 4.) He received speech therapy for about two months, from December 1995 through February 1996. The parents are not requesting reimbursement for this therapy. 4.When he first began to speak, STUDENT used only Farsi words and sounds. He is now bilingual, speaking in both Farsi and English. STUDENT’s parents and older brother are also bilingual. 5. There was conflicting testimony as to when STUDENT left the McGaugh class. School records submitted by the District established that STUDENT attended through May 3, 1996. (Resp. Exh. 13.) 6. “Discrete trials” in this context consist of a predetermined stimulus presented 1:1 by a therapist to a child, followed by the child’s response, followed by reinforcement by the therapist. The discrete trials progress in incremental steps and are designed to address the specific learning needs and reinforcers for the child. (See Resp. Exh. 33; Pet. Exh. 46.) 7. There was a delay in scheduling the training for the SELPA aides. The parties disagree as to who was responsible for the delay. The training was ultimately held in late January 1997. (Testimony of Dawn Walsh.) 8. The PARENTS are not seeking reimbursement for the costs of this private preschool program for STUDENT. 9. The parties disagree as to whether this was an annual IEP meeting (Petitioner’s position) or simply a meeting to revise the IEP (Respondent’s position). Determination of an annual IEP meeting date is not (cont.) (Ftnt. 9 cont.) necessary to resolve this case and, so, will not be addressed by the Hearing Officer. 10.The assessor noted that this IQ score may be somewhat inflated. The LIPS is a nonverbal measure of general intelligence, which evaluates a child’s performance abilities. Children with autism often are relatively stronger in performance abilities than in verbal skills. 11. At the re-convened hearing in July 1997, PARENT testified that STUDENT is now toilet-trained and will go to the bathroom by himself about 90% of the time. 12.On cross examination, Dr. Jamison acknowledged that she had not reviewed the CARD discrete trial log books, had not seen any videotapes of STUDENT, and had not talked to STUDENT’s mother personally or visited his in-home program. 13.Dr. Siegel stated she understood STUDENT was in a 40-hour program at home and just beginning to transition to a Montessori pre-school class. 14. PARENT testified that STUDENT weighs 65 lbs., is 43" tall and wears a size 12 in clothing. His size tends to intimidate other children. 15. Dr. John McEachin and Dr. Ronald Leaf operate a program called Autism Partnership. The District contracts with Autism Partnership, and proposed to use that program to supervise STUDENT’s discrete trials if the District’s placement offer were implemented. 16. The Weaver special day class offered by the District includes PECS as part of its program. (Resp. Exh. 24.) 17. Petitioner also identified several errors in STUDENT’s written January 1997 IEP. However, the District asserts that STUDENT has not been denied FAPE due to any procedural violations, and Petitioner does not appear to contend that FAPE has been denied on these grounds. 18. The IDEA 1997 amendments were signed into law on June 4, 1997. However, in this decision the Hearing Officer will apply the prior law in accordance with rules regarding retroactivity. (Landgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244.) 19. In special education law, a preschool child includes children between the ages of three and five inclusive. (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(a)(1)(B), Cal. Ed. Code Secs. 56440-56449.) 20. Ms. McHale also testified that she didn’t think STUDENT was ready for a regular preschool class with a shadow aide. While Ms. McHale is a speech and language specialist who has some experience with autistic children, she is not an established expert in the field of autism. She also testified that she did not know STUDENT. 21.According to District evidence, Weaver School recesses with “typically developing preschoolers” are four days per week for approximately 30 minutes each day. (Resp. Exh. 27.) 22. STUDENT is hyperlexic, that is, his reading and recognition of language are better than his use of language. (Testimony of Dr. Siegel.) 23. The District provided three letters from the State Department of Education (the Department) in support of its position, namely Respondent’s Exhibits 17, dated 3/25/96, and 18, dated 4/24/96, and 20, dated 12/22/95. Each of these letters is superseded by the letter from the Department submitted by Petitioner, dated July 31, 1996 as referenced above.
