California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 1, 2005

Student v. San Diego Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1143-05, SN-1143-05 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

San Diego Unified must provide 25 hours of make-up speech and OT; autism eligibility and life skills placement upheld.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 16 issues (4 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

References prior SEHO matters between the same parties: SN01-00725 (settled August 8, 2002), SN02-02632 (dismissed for nonappearance), and SN04-02742 (decision of January 5, 2005 authorizing DCPC assessment). No later history is noted.

Summary

A 12-year-old nonverbal student, who had been taught at home for about three years and was eligible for special education under autism, filed through his mother against San Diego Unified School District. His mother believed he was deaf and sought placement at the California School for the Deaf, Riverside. The Hearing Officer ruled that an earlier SEHO decision barred her claims that the 2005 assessment had to be done in American Sign Language and had to include vision and assistive technology. He found the adapted physical education (APE) and hearing assessments appropriate. Physical hearing tests consistently showed normal hearing. The Hearing Officer found that poor responses on behavioral hearing tests more likely reflected the student's developmental disability. He upheld autism as the primary disability, along with the integrated life skills special day classes, APE, the March 2005 goals, and alternate state testing. He rejected requests for academic tutoring and computer access. He found that the mother took full part in IEP meetings and that the District did not have to invite its deaf and hard of hearing program staff. However, the District had lost track of the student for 16 months. Its September 2004 IEP relied on old data, offered too little speech and occupational therapy (OT), and had inadequate goals. The March 2005 IEP did not clearly state time with nondisabled peers. The Hearing Officer ordered the IEP amended to provide 10 percent of the day with typical peers, plus 12.5 hours each of compensatory speech and OT.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied collateral estoppel to assessment claims already decided in an earlier hearing. It also refused to let a district rely on the "snapshot" rule for an IEP built on old data after the district lost track of a student. Finally, it treated a short diagnostic stay as not being a stay put placement.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1a. Whether the DCPC assessment in February and March 2005 was inappropriate because it was not conducted in Student's claimed primary language, American Sign Language (ASL)

    Dismissed on collateral estoppel; the prior SEHO decision (SN04-02742) found English, not ASL, is Student's primary language.

  2. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1b. Whether the adapted physical education (APE) component of the assessment was incomplete

    The informal APE assessment gave the IEP team enough present-levels information; a planned further assessment at the school site did not make it defective.

  3. Issue 1c. Whether the assessment was inappropriate because it had no vision component

    Dismissed on collateral estoppel; the prior decision found no additional suspected areas, including vision, needed reassessment.

  4. Issue 1d. Whether the assessment was inappropriate because it had no assistive technology component

    Dismissed on collateral estoppel because the assessment plan had been adjudicated in the prior SEHO case.

  5. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1e. Whether the hearing assessment was inconclusive

    Physiological hearing tests consistently showed normal hearing; unreliable behavioral responses were more likely due to his developmental disability, so the hearing assessment was appropriate.

  6. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2a. Whether Student's mother was denied full participation in the IEP process because the District failed to carefully consider her views and refused her request to invite a person from the District's deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) program

    The mother gave input that was considered; the District had discretion not to invite DHH staff, whose attendance would have been superfluous given normal hearing.

  7. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 2b. Whether the proposed program misidentified autism as Student's primary disability when his primary disability is a hearing impairment

    Evidence showed no significant hearing impairment and autistic-like behaviors; identifying autism as the primary disability did not deny FAPE.

  8. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2c. Whether the proposed integrated life skills (ILS) class placement was inappropriate because Student required placement at the California School for the Deaf, Riverside (CSDR)

    The ILS special day classes at Taft and Wagenheim met Student's needs for structured functional-skills instruction and were reasonably calculated to provide benefit.

  9. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2d. Whether speech and language offers of 30 minutes (September 2004) and 60 minutes (March 2005) weekly were inappropriate because Student required three 30-minute individual sessions weekly

    September 2004 offer of 30 minutes was inadequate (60 needed) and the District could not rely on the snapshot rule after losing track of Student; March 2005 offer of 60 minutes was appropriate.

  10. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2e. Whether the offer of 30 minutes weekly of APE was inappropriate because the APE assessment was incomplete and needs unidentified

    Uncontradicted testimony of the APE specialist supported 30 minutes weekly of APE.

  11. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2f. Whether the occupational therapy (OT) offer was inappropriate because Student required three 30-minute clinic-based OT sessions weekly

    March 2005 offer of 60 minutes weekly was appropriate; September 2004 offer of 30 minutes had no basis and should have been 60 minutes.

  12. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2g. Whether the program failed to include required academic tutoring (five 30-minute sessions weekly in reading, writing, and math taught in ASL and English)

    Student functions at a prekindergarten cognitive level and needs a functional-skills curriculum, not academic tutoring.

  13. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2h. Whether the program lacked adequate opportunities to be educated and participate with nondisabled children in extracurricular and nonacademic activities

    September 2004 offer of 10 percent of the day with nondisabled peers was appropriate; the March 2005 IEP was unclear (listing 100 percent special education) and must be amended.

  14. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2i. Whether the program failed to provide required access to a computer to assist with written work

    Student lacked the skills to produce written work and did not need computer access for that purpose.

  15. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 2j. Whether the proposed goals and objectives were inappropriate

    September 2004 goals, based on outdated data after the District lost track of Student, were not appropriate; the eleven March 2005 goals based on DCPC assessment were appropriate.

  16. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2k. Whether the program improperly stated Student would not participate in standardized testing (requiring the California Alternative Performance Assessment instead)

    Alternate assessment through the California Alternative Performance Assessment (CAPA) was appropriate given Student's significant deficits.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. March 29, 2005 IEP shall be amended to provide opportunities to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities with typically developing peers for 10 percent of the school day.
  • Compensatory education. Within the first school year after Student returns to the public school placement in the March 29, 2005 IEP, District shall provide 12.5 hours of individual speech and language therapy, in addition to services required for his then-current needs.
  • Compensatory education. Within the same period, District shall provide 12.5 hours of individual OT, in addition to services required for his then-current needs.

Total: 25 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Adams v. State of Oregon; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Honig v. Doe; Zvi D. v. Ambach; Levy v. Cohen; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup

People named in the decision

  • Terry Tyll, District audiologist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Patricia Laurick, special education administrator for September 21, 2004 IEP meeting, San Diego Unified School District
  • Beverly Terry, special education teacher, ILS diagnostic class at DCPC, San Diego Unified School District
  • Bruce Dake, school psychologist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Deborah Clemm, speech-language pathologist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Stephanie Venturino, speech-language pathologist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Amy Crammer, adapted physical education specialist, San Diego Unified School District
  • Julie Urbanick, occupational therapist, San Diego Unified School District (DCPC)
  • Roxie Jackson, executive director of special education (not called as witness), San Diego Unified School District
  • Karen Faillace, private clinical audiologist (brainstem evoked response test)
  • Amy Bozone, assistant general counsel, San Diego Unified School District
  • California Diagnostic Center, Southern California, state diagnostic assessment center
  • Children's Hospital of San Diego, audiological evaluation provider
  • San Diego State University communications clinic, audiological evaluation provider (at parent's request)
  • Children's Workshop, prior placement/provider
  • California School for the Deaf, Riverside, parent's requested placement

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Diego, California, on May 17, 18, and 19, 2005.

Student STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, Ms. PARENT.

The San Diego Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Patrick Frost. Amy Bozone, assistant general counsel for the District, was also present.

Student called the following witnesses: Terry Tyll, a District audiologist; Patricia Laurick, a District special education professional who acted as the District’s administrator of an individualized education program (IEP) meeting on September 21, 2004; Mr. PARENT, STUDENT’s father; Beverly Terry, STUDENT’s teacher during the weeks that he was in the integrated life skills (ILS) diagnostic class at the District’s Diagnostic Center for Positive Change (DCPC); District psychologist Bruce Dake; Deborah Clemm and Stephanie Venturino, District speech and language pathologists; Amy Crammer, an adapted physical education (APE) specialist for the District; Julie Urbanick, a District occupational therapist; and Ms. PARENT.

The District did not call any additional witnesses. However, the District’s counsel examined all of the witnesses called by Student.

Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. The parties’ closing arguments were heard, and the record was closed on May 20, 2005.

ISSUES

According to a prehearing conference order issued by the Hearing Office on May 16, 2005, Student sought to have the following issues adjudicated at the hearing.

Issue No. 1: Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of Student in February and March 2005?

Issue No. 2: Has the District offered or provided Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004-2005 school year, including the 2005 extended school year (ESY)?

CONTENTIONS

Regarding the District’s assessment, Student contends that the District did not conduct an appropriate assessment of him prior to planning for his education during the 2004- 2005 school year in the following respects:

(a) The assessment at DCPC in February and March 2005 (DCPC assessment) was not conducted in Student’s primary language, American Sign Language (ASL); (b) The adapted physical education (APE) component was incomplete; (c) There was no vision component;

(d) There was no assistive technology component; and (e) The hearing assessment was inconclusive.

The District contends that its assessment was appropriate and that it was conducted in compliance with the Decision issued by the Hearing Office on January 5, 2005. It also contends that some or all of the assessment issues raised by Student are barred by the doctrine of collateral estoppel.

Regarding the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year, including the 2005 ESY, Student contends the District has not offered him a FAPE in the following respects:

(a) Student’s mother was not allowed to fully participate in the IEP process in that the District failed to carefully consider her view and information supplied by her and refused her request to invite a person from the District’s deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) program; (b) The proposed program misidentified autism as Student’s primary disability when his primary disability is a hearing impairment; (c) The proposed placement in an “integrated life skills” class was inappropriate because Student required placement at the California School for the Deaf, Riverside (CSDR); (d) The offers of speech and language services for thirty minutes (September 2004 IEP) and sixty minutes (March 2005 IEP) per week outside the classroom were inappropriate because Student required three thirty-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy weekly to supplement a CSDR placement; (e) The offer of APE services for thirty minutes per week was inappropriate because Student’s APE assessment has not been completed and his needs in this area have not been identified; (f) The offer of occupational therapy (OT) services for sixty minutes per week outside the classroom was inappropriate because Student required three thirty-minute clinic-based OT sessions weekly to supplement a CSDR placement to; (g) The proposed program did not include the academic tutoring that Student required to receive a FAPE (i.e., five thirty-minute sessions weekly covering reading, writing, and math taught in ASL and English to supplement a CSDR placement to receive a FAPE); (h) The proposed program does not include adequate opportunities for Student to be educated and to participate with disabled and nondisabled children in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities; (i) The proposed program failed to provide required access to a computer to assist Student with written work; (j) The proposed goals and objectives were inappropriate; and (k) The proposed program improperly stated that Student would not participate in standardized testing.

Student requests that the presiding Hearing Officer find that the District has not offered a FAPE, that his primarily qualifying disability is hearing impaired, and that he requires placement at the CSDR to receive a FAPE. Alternatively, Student requests that the presiding Hearing Officer order the IEP team to take such steps as may be necessary to place Student at the CSDR.

The District contends that Student has been offered a FAPE during the entire time at issue. It also contends Student’s proposed issue regarding his eligibility classification is barred by the doctrine of collateral estoppel.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer addressed several motions relating to Student’s claims, a witness, and an item of proposed evidence. Later, the Hearing Officer ruled on Student’s motion for a stay put order and his request for site visits. Each is discussed below.

District’s Motion to Dismiss Claims

The District made a motion to strike or dismiss Student’s claims or contentions that the District’s assessment was not conducted in Student’s primary language, ASL, did not include a vision component, and did not include an assistive technology component (See contentions (a), (c), and (d) under Issue No. 1, above) on the ground that these claims have already been decided in the decision issued in a prior due process case between the same parties, Hearing Office Case No. SN04-02742. Student opposed the motion.

The doctrine of collateral estoppel precludes parties from relitigating an issue that has been finally determined in prior litigation. Application of the doctrine requires that the issue presented for adjudication be the same one that was decided in the prior action, that there be a final judgement on the merits in the prior action, and that the party against whom the plea is asserted was a party to the prior action. (Levy v. Cohen, (1977) 19 Cal. 3d 165, 171.)

In J.F. and N.F., etc. v. School District of Philadelphia, etc. ( D.C. PA 2000) 32 IDELR 93, the court states its analysis of the need for such application to special education due process hearings, in part, as follows:

The Supreme Court has explained that giving preclusive effect to the findings of an administrative agency serves the underlying purposes of issue preclusion which include "both the parties, interest in avoiding the cost and vexation of repetitive litigation and the public's interest in conserving judicial resources." University of Tenn. v. Elliott, (1986) 478 U.S. 788, 798. The Court has also held that "[w]hen an administrative agency is acting in a judicial capacity and resolves disputed issues of fact properly before it which the parties have had an adequate opportunity to litigate, the courts have not hesitated to apply res judicata to enforce repose." United States v. Utah Constr. & Mining Co., (1966) 384 U.S. 394, 422.

The Hearing Office has long applied the doctrine of res judicata to its own decisions. The doctrine serves the legitimate purpose of curtailing multiple actions between the same parties on the same issue and thus avoiding unnecessary effort by and expense to the parties and to the tribunals to which the issues are presented. Once litigated and finally determined between the parties, an issue should be laid to rest.

In the prior matter between these same parties, the District requested a due process hearing to determine its right to assess STUDENT pursuant to an assessment plan dated October 28, 2004. According to the Decision issued on January 5, 2005, in Case No. SN04-02742, the assessment plan proposed to assess STUDENT “using informal observations and review of his class work in the following areas: social/emotional/adaptive, communication, academic/preacademic achievement, and motor development.” Ms. PARENT objected to the assessment on various grounds. She claimed that the assessment should be performed at the CSDR and that it should be conducted in ASL, STUDENT’s primary language. She also contended in that prior matter that the assessment plan should have included other areas of need, specifically vision. A review of the prior Decision reveals that the hearing officer specifically found that ASL is not STUDENT’s primary language, that English is his primary language, and that “there were no additional areas of suspected disability, including vision, that needed to be reassessed.”

The Hearing Officer held that the challenged claims were determined in the prior hearing and that those determinations are binding on the parties here. The District was required to conduct the assessment pursuant to the plan that had been adjudicated by the hearing officer in the prior matter. If Ms. PARENT disagreed with those determinations, the remedy was an appeal, not an attempt to litigate the same issues in subsequent special education administrative due process hearing. Therefore, the District’s motion was granted as to all challenged contentions.

District’s Motion Regarding Production of Witness

The District explained that it has agreed to produce its employees for Student and has suggested a schedule for the witnesses that Student wants to call with the exception of Roxie Jackson, the executive director of special education for the District. The District argues that Ms. Jackson has no personal knowledge regarding STUDENT or any of the issues to be addressed in this case. It requests that it not be required to produce Ms. Jackson, at least not without a prior offer of proof from Student to show that her attendance at the hearing is reasonably required.

Ms. PARENT stated that Roxie Jackson, as the director of special education for the District, should have knowledge regarding STUDENT. In addition, the report of the assessment conducted by the California Diagnostic Center, Southern California (CDC) is addressed to Ms. Jackson.

The Hearing Office generally encourages school districts and other parties to voluntarily produce witnesses under its control upon reasonable notice. In addition, parties to a special education due process hearing have the power to compel the attendance of witnesses by proper service of a subpoena. (Cal. Code Regs., tit 5, § 3082(c)(2).)

In this case, Student did not serve a subpoena on Ms. Jackson. The District had agreed to produce its employees as witnesses and was concerned that it might require an order to support its refusal to produce Ms. Jackson. The Hearing Officer informed Ms. PARENT that he would not require the District to produce Ms. Jackson as a witness, but that he would revisit the issue at her request if she is able to demonstrate that Ms. Jackson’s testimony is reasonably required to provide Student due process. (Footnote 1)

Student’s Motion to Admit Audiotape

Ms. PARENT indicated at the time of the prehearing conference on May 13, 2005, that she would seek to admit an audiotape of STUDENT’s vocalizations. (Footnote 2) At the hearing, Ms. PARENT asked the Hearing Officer to admit the tape. The District objected on several grounds, including the lack of statutory notice, authentication, and relevance. Ms. PARENT argued that the vocalizations were relevant to the nature, severity, and possible cause of STUDENT’s speech and language impairment.

The Hearing Officer determined that he did not have the expertise to learn anything of relevance to the issues to be addressed based solely upon the content of the audiotape. He sustained the District’s relevance objection, but informed Ms. PARENT that she could seek to have the tape admitted later if, for example, an audiologist, speech and language pathologist or other professional testified at the hearing that listening to the tape might provide them with information upon which they could base a relevant opinion.

Student’s Motion Regarding Stay Put

On September 13, 2005, the Hearing Office received from Ms. PARENT a motion for an order designating the Whittier Center as STUDENT’s stay put placement. She asserted in her written motion that STUDENT’s last placement was at Whittier Center, which was also “the managing site for his assessments.”

The District filed a written response opposing the motion on May 16, 2005. It argued that the last agreed-upon and implemented placement for STUDENT was in a home program agreed upon and implemented in August 2002 and that Ms. PARENT had refused all public placements offered to STUDENT since that time. The District also stated that STUDENT was at the District’s Diagnostic Center for Positive Change (DCPC) at the Whittier Center only on a temporary basis for the sole purpose of carrying out the assessment pursuant to the Decision and order dated January 5, 2005, and that DCPC was never his placement.

Because the motion and response were received just before the hearing was to be convened, further consideration was deferred to the time of the hearing.

Under both federal and State law, a special education student is entitled to remain in his or her then-current educational placement pending resolution of the due process hearing procedures, absent an agreement by the parties otherwise. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d).) Application of stay put is automatic upon filing of a request for due process hearing. No motion or other action by or on behalf of the student is required, and the right to stay put is unequivocal. (Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305.) The purpose of stay put is to ensure some stability in a disabled student's school placement pending resolution of due process proceedings. (Stacy G. v. Pasadena Independent School Dist., 695 F.2d 949 (5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2nd Cir. 1982).)

Neither federal nor California stay-put provisions are limited to placements called for in a student’s IEP. The laws refer to a student’s “current educational placement” or “present placement” and make specific reference to an agreement between the parties as an adequate basis for stay put. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d).) Furthermore, when a school district has made clear that a placement is for a short and temporary period, that placement does not ordinarily constitute the “current educational placement” for purposes of stay put. (Zvi D. supra, at 907; Leonard v. McKenzie, 869 F.2d 1558, 1564 (D.C. Cir. 1989).)

STUDENT was at DCPC only for an assessment pursuant to the Hearing Office Decision and order dated January 5, 2005. Although the assessment process entailed a temporary “placement” in a classroom environment for a period of weeks, STUDENT was the only student in the environment. His attendance there was not intended by anyone to constitute a placement for the purpose of stay put. Ms. PARENT stated that she was aware of the temporary nature of STUDENT’s attendance at DCPC. The Hearing Officer found that DCPC did not constitute STUDENT’s stay put placement. The last agreed-upon and implemented placement for STUDENT is the home program referred to in the settlement agreement executed by the parties on August 8, 2002.

Student’s Motion for a Site Visit by the Hearing Officer

On the second day of the hearing, Ms. PARENT requested that the Hearing Officer visit the placements that were offered to STUDENT in the September 2004 and March 2005 IEPs – the ILS SDCs at Taft Middle School (Taft) and Wagenheim Middle School (Wagenheim), respectively – and the CSDR placement that Ms. PARENT prefers. The motion was made on the ground that the Hearing Officer personally needed to see how the classrooms were set up, how the curriculum was taught, the modes of communication used, and the overall interpersonal dynamics. The District opposed the motion on the ground that site visits would provide no relevant information for the Hearing Officer’s consideration and were therefore unnecessary.

A hearing officer may visit a proposed placement site or sites when the physical attributes of the site or sites are at issue. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.1(c).) Although Student argued on this motion that the way the classrooms are set up was at issue, a review of the issues identified by the parties at the outset of the hearing prompted the Hearing Officer to conclude that the physical attributes of the proposed placements were not at issue. Therefore, the motion to conduct site visits was denied. (Footnote 3)

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is twelve years and eleven months old. He lives with his mother, Ms. PARENT, within the geographical boundaries of the District. STUDENT has been eligible for special education since he was three years old on the basis of an autism spectrum disorder (ASD). He is also nonverbal. Although he is able to vocalize, he cannot say words or word approximations. According to the assessment data, his cognitive functioning is well below the pre-kindergarten level. STUDENT has been in a home-school program for approximately three years. The District has offered public school placements, but the parties have been unable to agree on an appropriate program. Recently, the dispute has centered on Ms. PARENT’s belief that her son is deaf or hearing impaired and that this disability alone accounts for his inability to acquire communication skills.

There was only sketchy information provided about STUDENT’s earlier years. Ms. PARENT testified that he was generally healthy but did have frequent ear infections. He timely met all of the typical physical and behavioral milestones with the exception of speech development. STUDENT had some behavioral problem that may have interfered with his early education.

According to a request for a due process hearing filed on April 9, 2001, (Hearing Office Case No. SN01-00725) those behavior issues caused the District to take steps to change STUDENT’s placement from general education to a more restrictive environment in September 1999, when STUDENT was seven years old. At that time, Student alleged, among other things, that the District had failed to properly assess him in the area of speech and language, failed to provide adequate behavioral supports and alternative or augmentative modes of communication. The case was concluded by a settlement agreement signed by the parties on August 8, 2002. Among other things, the agreement provided that:

1. The CDC would conduct a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT; 2. The District would conduct an audiogram of STUDENT;

3. The District would refer STUDENT the CSDR for consideration for admission; 4. STUDENT would undergo psychoeducational, speech and language, and assistive technology assessments by agreed-upon assessors; 5. Ms. PARENT would share with the District the results of privately obtained occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), and vision assessments, a diagnostic evaluation, and an audiogram if she obtained any of those; 6. The District would convene an IEP meeting to consider the assessment data and develop an IEP for STUDENT; and 7. Ms. PARENT would maintain STUDENT in a home school program pending the development of an IEP.

On November 12, 2002, the CSDR advised Ms. PARENT by letter that the admissions committee of that institution had concluded that STUDENT should not be placed there due primarily to the fact that he did not appear to have a significant hearing impairment and secondarily to his inability to effectively communicate in ASL, the primary mode of communication at the school in both the classroom and residential settings.

On November 25, 2002, Student filed another due process hearing request alleging that the District had failed to comply with the settlement agreement and requesting placement of STUDENT at the CSDR. The Hearing Office assigned this matter Case No. SN02-02632.

The CDC conducted its comprehensive assessment of STUDENT during the week of February 18, 2003. The April 4, 2003 report of that assessment is in evidence. It indicates that STUDENT’s cognitive level is consistent with abilities that are usually acquired by one- to two-year-old children. However, he has problem solving strategies that are usually acquired by two- to three-year-old children, and these have enabled him to acquire skills related to high-interest activities and routine “chores” that exceed his developmental level.

The assessors concluded that STUDENT’s delay in communication skills was greater than his delay in cognitive skills, probably due in part to his limited interests. He had fewer forms of communication, fewer messages, and, because of his limited interests, less content. The assessment team concluded that STUDENT’s delayed communication skills had a profound impact on all aspects of his life and that the top priority of his educational program should be to develop spontaneous and functional skills, especially multimodal communication skills, including the use of natural gestures, communication boards, object schedules, and simple voice output communication devices, such as a “talking picture frame” that would allow a picture to be displayed with a single recorded message. The team concluded that STUDENT would not benefit from reliance on sign language or cued speech and reported that STUDENT was not ready for a picture exchange communication system, but might benefit from the use of photographs endowed with communicative intent through training.

The assessors at the CDC recommended that STUDENT be in a functional skills program of highly structured interventions with meaningful outcomes presented in a one-to-one or very small group environment with planned teaching opportunities. They also recommended predictable schedules and routines, clear expectations, and frequent hands-on learning experiences, with instructional strategies focused on pivotal skills (e.g. choice making and sequencing), shared or joint attention, partial participation, global chaining, interrupted behavior chains, and graduated prompting.

The District convened an IEP meeting to consider the report of the CDC on May 30, 2003. Consistent with the CDC report, the District proposed placement in an integrated life skills (ILS) special day class (SDC) for thirty hours per week on a comprehensive campus. In addition, the District offered thirty minutes of speech and language weekly, thirty minutes of OT weekly, and thirty minutes of APE weekly. Eighty percent of STUDENT’s school day was to be in special education. Lunches, assemblies, and physical education were to be with the general student population.

STUDENT’s mother did not give her consent to the IEP at the May 2003 meeting. According to the IEP notes, she was concerned about the language of instruction, inadequate peer interaction, and the lack of academic goals, among other things. However, in her testimony, Ms. PARENT explained that she did not and does not believe STUDENT is autistic. She believes that his disability is a hearing impairment and that he would be able to function academically at grade level and ultimately receive a regular high school diploma if the District would provide an appropriate bilingual education in English and ASL. Nevertheless, Ms. PARENT informed the IEP team that she would consider the offer and respond by June 3, 2003. There was no response.

On July 10, 2003, a hearing officer briefly convened a due process hearing in Case No. SN02-02632. The hearing was later continued to September 2003 and was ultimately dismissed by the Hearing Office on the ground that Student had failed to appear or to offer any acceptable excuse for his nonappearance.

On July 31, 2003, STUDENT underwent surgery to remove a cholesteatoma, or mass, from his left middle ear. Taking advantage of the fact that he was under general anesthesia for that surgery, a clinical audiologist, Karen Faillace, performed an audiological brainstem evoked response test at Ms. PARENT’s request. This test revealed that STUDENT had normal neural transmission through the auditory brainstem pathways when each ear was stimulated.

The District appears to have “lost” STUDENT for approximately sixteen months after the May 2003 IEP meeting. Although the evidence showed that the due process matter filed by Student in November 2002 continued into September 2003, it appears that the District made no effort to contact Ms. PARENT regarding the educational planning for her son between the conclusion of the May 2003 IEP meeting and August 2004 when the District delivered to Ms. PARENT an invitation to attend another IEP meeting in September 2004.

On September 21, 2004, the District convened an IEP meeting. Ms. PARENT had requested that a representative from the District’s DHH program be invited to attend the IEP meeting, but the District denied the request on the ground that assessments indicated that STUDENT’s hearing was within normal limits. The most recent assessment data in the District’s possession at the time was from the CDC assessment nineteen months earlier. At the IEP meeting, the District essentially reiterated the offer that had been made at the May 2003 IEP meeting: thirty hours per week in an ILS SDC at Taft, a comprehensive campus, and thirty minutes per week each of speech and language, OT, and APE. Goals were proposed in the areas of functional living skills (dressing completely, including all fasteners), functional mathematics (money exchange), functional communication (requesting a break using a single message voice output device), vocational skills (attention to task), and social skills (turn taking). The IEP document also states that because the IEP team did not have current present levels of performance in the areas of OT and APE, an assessment plan for those areas would be provided and the team would meet again in the latter part of November to consider the results of those assessments. Ms. PARENT did not consent to the proposed IEP.

By October 28, 2004, STUDENT was still at home. The District wrote to Ms. PARENT on that date to offer a short-term diagnostic placement at its DCPC. An assessment plan to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance was included. It provided, in substance, that STUDENT would be assessed through record review, observation, and other informal means in the classroom setting at DCPC. Ms. PARENT responded by requesting that the staff at the University of California, San Diego, assess her son, but she later insisted that the assessment be conducted using ASL at the CSDR.

Ms. PARENT continued to assert that STUDENT’s difficulties with communication were related to a hearing impairment. An audiological screening was conducted by the District on November 16, 2004. The results of that screening were consistent with earlier assessments of STUDENT’s hearing: measures that required a behavioral response from STUDENT could not be performed or were inconclusive, but those that were based on measures that did not depend on some behavioral response from STUDENT, such as tympanometry, otoacoustic emissions screenings, and the audiological brainstem evoked response test, indicated that his hearing was within normal limits.

On January 5, 2005, the Hearing Office issued its Decision holding that the District was entitled to conduct the planned assessment at DCPC. The District conducted that assessment of STUDENT at DCPC over a period of approximately six weeks in February and March 2005. On March 9, 2005, the District sent Ms. PARENT a notice of an IEP meeting to take place on March 29, 2005. Ms. PARENT requested that an audiologist and a representative of the District’s DHH program attend the meeting but the District denied her request on the ground that the assessment data demonstrated that STUDENT had normal hearing.

The District convened the most recent IEP meeting on March 29, 2005. The District again offered STUDENT a placement in an ILS SDC at Wagenheim, a comprehensive campus, to begin on April 4, 2005. DCPC staff were to assist with STUDENT’s transition during the first two weeks. In addition to the thirty hours per week in the SDC, STUDENT was offered thirty minutes per week of APE and sixty minutes per week of both speech and language and OT. Transportation and ESY services were also offered. The IEP indicates that STUDENT would have opportunities to be with nondisabled peers during lunch, recreation, and physical activities. The District also recommended that STUDENT participate in the California Alternative Performance Assessment (CAPA) as an alternative to statewide standardized assessments administered pursuant to California’s Standardized Testing and Reporting (STAR) Program. In addition, a plan for further assessment of STUDENT at the school site in the areas of OT and APE was to be provided to Ms. PARENT within ten days of STUDENT’s start at Wagenheim.

According to the IEP notes, Ms. PARENT was to consider the District’s offer and respond by March 31, 2005. On April 1, 2005, she wrote to the District to request some additional time and an opportunity to visit the site, with a delay in the planned start date to April 11, 2005. She also stated that she wanted STUDENT to have a male instructional assistant (IA) who is qualified to interpret ASL. The District responded with contact information so that Ms. PARENT could arrange the site visit with the SDC teacher. The site visit occurred during the week of April 4, 2005. On April 11, 2005, Ms. PARENT notified the District that she would not consent to the proposed IEP. She also disagreed with the CAPA recommendation and requested that STUDENT be allowed to participate in the State standardized testing and reporting (STAR) program.

STUDENT remains in his home schooling stay put placement.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of Student in preparation for educational planning for the 2004-2005 school year?

A reassessment of the student must take place at least every three years or more often if conditions warrant, or if the parent requests a reassessment and the development of a new IEP. (Footnote 4) (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a).) The reassessment must include a review of the existing assessment data, including classroom-based assessments and teacher’s and service provider’s observations, by the IEP team and other qualified professionals. On the basis of that review and after considering input from the student’s parents, the IEP team is to determine what additional data, if any, is needed to determine, among other things, the present levels of performance and educational needs of the pupil. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b).)

There is no dispute that at the September 2004 IEP meeting, the team reviewed existing data and considered the input from Ms. PARENT before concluding that it needed current information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance. That was the focus of the reassessment at DCPC, which was conducted pursuant to the Hearing Office’s Decision of January 5, 2005.

State law requires that any reassessment must be conducted in accordance with California Education Code section 56320. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(e).) However, a logical reading of the law indicates that a reassessment may be narrowly focused to obtain specific information. In such a case, the question is whether the reassessment produced the required additional data. In this case, Student does not challenge any of the requirements of California Education Code section 56320. He makes only the specific claims discussed below: that the APE assessment was incomplete and that the hearing assessment was inconclusive, neither assessment producing the information needed by the IEP team.

The APE Assessment

In essence, Student contends that the APE assessment conducted at DCPC was not appropriate because it was incomplete. The District asserts that the assessment was appropriate because it provided the required information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance.

APE is for pupils who require developmental or corrective instruction and who are precluded from participation in the activities of the general physical education program, modified general physical education program, or in a specially designed physical education program in a special class. (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5 § 3051.5.) It is one of the designated instruction and services (DIS) that a local educational agency (LEA) must provide to the pupil when necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. (Cal Educ. Code § 56363(a) and (b).) APE cannot be added to a pupil’s IEP unless a qualified person who has conducted a formal assessment has recommended the service for the child to benefit from special education. (Cal. Govt. Code § 7572(d).) However, there is no specific statutory or regulatory provision that requires a formal assessment of a pupil’s APE needs in order to continue the provision of that DIS.

The assessment at DCPC included an informal assessment of STUDENT’s APE needs by Amy Crammer, a District APE specialist. Ms Crammer testified that she observed STUDENT while he was alone and while he was with other students to assess his present levels of performance in all areas related to his physical development, including strength, balance, and motor planning. In addition, Ms. Crammer provided APE services to him during his weeks at DCPC. On the basis of her work with STUDENT, Ms. Crammer concluded that STUDENT continued to have a need for APE and that thirty minutes per week of APE was appropriate to address that need. However, because the DCPC setting contained fewer opportunities for physical activity than a comprehensive campus, she believed that a further and more definitive APE assessment should take place at STUDENT’s actual placement and that it was possible that the APE provider there might recommend some adjustment to the level of services.

Ms. Crammer credibly testified that she conducted as thorough an assessment of STUDENT’s APE needs as was possible under the circumstances. No other witness contradicted her testimony that the District’s offer of thirty minutes of APE weekly was appropriate. The fact that some further assessment at STUDENT’s actual educational placement was contemplated did not call the District’s offer into question. Ms. Cramer persuaded the Hearing Officer that the further assessment was standard practice and no more than what one would expect under the circumstances. Student offered no evidence to show otherwise.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s APE assessment was appropriate in that it provided the IEP team with adequate information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance to allow it to make an informed decision regarding his continuing need for APE services and the level of services required to meet that need. The fact that that the District’s APE assessor contemplated a further APE assessment at the school site did not render the District’s assessment defective in any way.

The Hearing Assessment

Ms. PARENT has long asserted that her son is hearing impaired and not autistic. She argues here that the District’s various assessments of STUDENT’s hearing have not conclusively shown otherwise and are, therefore, defective. In support of this argument, Ms. PARENT points to the fact that various hearing assessors have been unable to produce reliable results on certain kinds of tests – those that require STUDENT to attend, listen, and respond behaviorally to auditory input.

The evidence does show that various attempts to assess STUDENT’s hearing using behavioral measures have been unsuccessful. However, this does not mean that the District has not had reliable information to determine that STUDENT has normal hearing. There is abundant evidence to support the District’s view.

Five audiological evaluations are in evidence. In addition, District audiologist Terry Tyll testified at the hearing to explain the evaluations and provide his opinion regarding STUDENT’s hearing.

The District conducted an audiological evaluation on August 29, 2002. According to the report, STUDENT had normal eardrum mobility. Although parts of the assessment were compromised due to STUDENT’s constant vocalizations and the assessor’s inability to obtain consistent behavioral responses, overall reliability was rated as “good” and the assessor concluded that his hearing was within normal limits, at least in one ear. Mr. Tyll, who participated in this assessment, testified that consistent interpretable responses in the sound field (without headphones) supported this conclusion.

Another District assessment on January 24, 2003, produced “fairly reliable . . . localizations to speech.” In addition, tympanometry demonstrated normal eardrum mobility bilaterally. STUDENT also passed an otoacoustic emissions test, which measures the function of the cochlear outer hair cells, on both right and left. According to Mr. Tyll, that test showed that STUDENT could not have anything worse than a mild hearing loss.

An audiological evaluation conducted by Children’s Hospital of San Diego on June 27, 2003 produced similar results. The audiophysiological tests showed normal function and the tests requiring a behavioral response to auditory input did not produce reliable results.

Mr. Tyll testified that tympanometry and otoacoustic emissions testing are audiophysiological assessments of the sensing apparatus for hearing. The audiological brainstem evoked response test assesses the transmission of the sensory information through the neural pathway to the brain. STUDENT underwent such a procedure on July 31, 2003. The test showed normal neural transmission from both ears through the auditory brainstem pathways. Mr. Tyll testified that this test demonstrated normal function of the eighth cranial nerve.

There were two more recent audiological assessments. The District conducted one on November 16, 2004. At Ms. PARENT’s request, the San Diego State University communications clinic conducted the most recent audiological evaluation of STUDENT on April 25, 2005. The results of these assessments were consistent with the earlier ones: the hearing mechanism appears to be functioning normally but the assessors were unable to illicit consistent and reliable behavioral responses. Although the reason for the unreliable behavioral responses is not specifically stated, there is no evidence to suggest that it is a result of a problem with hearing acuity.

As indicated by Mr. Tyll, all audiophysiological testing demonstrates normal functioning of STUDENT’s hearing mechanisms from both ears to the nerve that transmits the input to his brain and the absence of reliable behavioral responses to auditory input does not demonstrate abnormal hearing but only a difficulty determining how STUDENT interprets and responds to the auditory input.

There was also other evidence that STUDENT’s hearing is not significantly impaired. Three people who have spent time, in some cases significant time, with STUDENT over the years testified at hearing about their experiences in this regard. Mr. PARENT, STUDENT’s father, testified that he communicates with his son primarily through spoken English and believes STUDENT’s receptive language skills to be good. He also testified that STUDENT can hear. Not only does he respond to spoken words, he also listens to music and appears to be bothered by some sounds. Beverly Terry spent at least five weeks with STUDENT as the special education teacher who interacted with him daily at DCPC. She testified that STUDENT followed verbal instruction, indicating that he both heard and understood them. Stephanie Venturino, a District speech and language pathologist who worked with STUDENT at DCPC, had a similar experience with STUDENT using spoken English.

As credibly testified to by Mr. Tyll, the fact that the various audiological assessments did not produce consistent and reliable results on tests that required a behavioral response by STUDENT was more likely than not due to his developmental disability and not to any hearing deficit. The District’s audiological assessments were not incomplete. They produced as much data as they could be expected to produce. Even the assessment conducted by audiologists at San Diego State University at the request of Ms. PARENT produced similar results. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s hearing was appropriate.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of Student in preparation for educational planning for the 2004-2005 school year.

Issue No. 2: Has the District offered or provided Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2004-2005 school year, including the 2005 extended school year (ESY)?

The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. section 1400 et seq., and State special education law provide that a disabled student is entitled to a FAPE. (Footnote 5) A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions.

Procedurally, the law requires that the student and parents be allowed to meaningfully participate in the process for the development of the IEP. (Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982).) Not every procedural flaw is critical. However, one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of a FAPE. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).)

Substantively, a FAPE is special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) It includes special education and related services that are designed to meet the child’s unique needs when those needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.)

The term “related services,” which in California also is referred to as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.) DIS may include speech and language, APE, and OT services. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(1), (5), and (6); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3051.1, 3051.5, and 3051.6.)

The United States Supreme Court stated in Rowley that the LEA is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198-200.) The Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. (Id. at 201.) Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. (Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).) Moreover, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)

In summary, to provide a child with a FAPE, an IEP must be the result of a process that adequately protected the procedural rights of the parents and student. In addition, the student’s educational placement must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. A disabled child also must be provided an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE). This means that the student must be educated and allowed to participate in school activities with nondisabled students to the maximum extent appropriate. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).) The LEA has the burden of proof on all of these issues. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).)

PROCEDURAL CLAIMS

Participation of Parent in IEP Process

Student alleges that his mother was not allowed to fully participate in the IEP process in that the District failed to carefully consider her view and information supplied by her and refused her request to invite a person from the District’s deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) program to the IEP meetings.

The Rowley Court notes that parents can be the most ardent advocates for their children, and that their full participation can be the best way to ensure that all appropriate services are being offered to the handicapped child. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 208-209.) At least one parent is to be present at all IEP team meetings unless all reasonable efforts secure attendance have failed. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.501(c); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56341(b)(1) and 56341.5(a), (b), (g), and (h).) However, allowing a pupil’s parent to fully participate in the process does not require that other members of the IEP team accede to the parent’s requests. Ultimately, it is the LEA, in this case the District, which is responsible for providing a FAPE. The LEA is not required to take any particular action in response to input or a request from a parent. Rather, it is required to allow the parent to provide input and to give that input the weight that it deserves.

According to the testimony of several District members of the IEP team who attended the September 2004 and March 2005 IEP meetings, Ms. PARENT asked questions that were answered and provided other input at both meetings. She provided significant input regarding goals at a progress meeting that was convened at DCPC in early March 2005, and this input led to the development of six additional goals that were presented to the IEP team at the March 29, 2005 IEP meeting. Ms. PARENT acknowledged that she asked questions and provided input at the meetings. However, she complained at the hearing that the District erred in failing to ask about skills that STUDENT displayed outside of the school environment and in failing to change the IEP in response to her input.

There was no evidence that Ms. PARENT was prevented in any way from participating in the IEP process. The testimony and documentary evidence show that she did provide input and that her input was considered. The real dispute centers on the District members of the IEP team not agreeing to Ms. PARENT’s requests. Ms. PARENT has long maintained that STUDENT’s primary disability is a hearing impairment. She continued to press for placement at the CSDR or in the District’s DHH program. She continued to insist that her son’s primary need was a bilingual education in ASL and English. This was not a situation in which the District failed to allow Ms. PARENT to provide input. This was a situation in which Ms. PARENT steadfastly adhered to a view of STUDENT’s disability that was simply not supported by the facts. The District’s refusal to adopt that view was appropriate.

The same is true of the District’s refusal to invite a representative of its DHH program to the IEP meetings. Pursuant to federal law, in addition to the specifically identified team members (e.g., parents, a regular education teacher, a special education teacher, etc.) both the LEA and the parents have the discretion to include “other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the [pupil]. . .” (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B)(vi); See also: 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(6).) State law provides that the determination regarding whether a person has the required “knowledge or special expertise” is made by the party who invites the person to become a member of the IEP team. (Cal. Educ. Code § 5634(b)(6).) Ms. PARENT was not inviting the representative of the DHH program to the meetings. She was asking the District to invite that person. It was entirely within the District’s discretion in this case to decide whether a representative of its DHH program should attend. The District bore the risk of a subsequent determination by the Hearing Office that attendance of that person was wrongfully refused. In this case, there was no good reason to have a representative of the District’s DHH program present at either meeting because the assessment data demonstrated that STUDENT did not have a significant hearing loss. The participation of a representative of the District’s DHH program would have been superfluous.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. PARENT was allowed to fully participate in the IEP process and that there was no procedural violation.

SUBSTANTIVE CLAIMS

STUDENT’s Needs

Before the Hearing Officer addresses the specific substantive claims, the Hearing Officer must identify STUDENT’s unique needs. In short, Ms. PARENT believes her son is deaf or hard of hearing and that, but for that disability and his resulting communication deficit, he would be able to function at grade level. However, she offered no evidence in support of that belief. The substantial weight of the evidence shows that STUDENT has normal or nearly normal hearing. The undisputed evidence shows that STUDENT is thirteen years old but functions cognitively in the prekindergarten range. He has no speech and only minimal functional communication skills. He can follow a few simple directions, but has little ability to express his wants and needs. Ms. PARENT speculates that STUDENT can read, but the evidence proves otherwise. He cannot write.

According to the 2003 report by the CDC, STUDENT is able to learn new skills by using cognitive abilities that are usually acquired by age three. He is more likely to learn high-interest, meaningful skills. The assessors at CDC recommended a placement that would provide highly structured interventions with predictable outcomes and a program that focuses on the acquisition of functional skills that will serve STUDENT across environments. These include communication, domestic, vocational, recreation/leisure, and community skills. The assessors at CDC did not recommend an academic program.

Several witnesses testified regarding STUDENT’s needs. Patricia Laurick has been an employee of the District since 1987. She holds a master’s degree in special education and an administrative credential issued by the State of California. During her thirty years in the field, she has been an SDC teacher, a resource specialist program (RSP) provider, an inclusion specialist, and a diagnostic resource teacher. She has provided instruction, classroom support, and curriculum development for students of all ages and various disabilities, including students who were blind, deaf or hard of hearing, mentally retarded, and on the autism spectrum.

Ms. Laurick first met STUDENT in 2000 when he was in an ILS SDC. At that time, according to Ms. Laurick, STUDENT was difficult to manage and teach due, at least in part, to behavioral issues. When she next had contact with him at the CDC in February 2003, Ms. Laurick observed that STUDENT had matured and his problematic behaviors had improved. STUDENT was able to be in a classroom and participate in table tasks, but he still had significant cognitive and communication deficits. She agreed with the recommendations of the CDC regarding placement and instruction.

Beverley Terry has been a special education teacher with the District for the last six years. She holds a master’s degree in special education and a California teaching credential for moderate to severe handicaps. Ms. Terry’s focus is ILS and similar alternative curricula. She has been at DCPC for the last two years and was STUDENT’s teacher during his stay there. Ms. Terry also agrees that STUDENT requires an ILS curriculum delivered in a highly structured environment with systematic instruction in functional skills that will increase his independence across environments, including communication and social skills.

Ms. PARENT offered no convincing evidence to suggest that STUDENT does not have the deficits identified by the District. As established above, there is no evidence to indicate that STUDENT requires a program designed to meet the needs of a deaf and hard of hearing student. However, there is abundant evidence that STUDENT needs the kind of program recommended by CDC, Ms. Laurick, and Ms. Terry. On the basis of that convincing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a placement in a structured environment where trained staff will use systematic instruction techniques with predictable outcomes to teach him functional living skills.

The parties agree that STUDENT needs speech and language therapy and OT services. They dispute only the level of those services. There is also no dispute that STUDENT needs opportunities to participate in school and community activities with typically developing peers.

The District believes that STUDENT needs some APE services. Student’s position is only that his needs in this area are unknown because the assessment is incomplete. The Hearing Officer has already addressed the APE assessment issue, above.

The District has consistently offered some APE services to STUDENT in recent years. In a February 2002 progress report from the Children’s Workshop, STUDENT’s placement at the time, it is noted that STUDENT did not reliably roll, throw, or bounce a ball to a direct target or imitate a series of gross motor movements. According to the notes of the May 30, 2003 IEP, APE services were not available at the Children’s Workshop and STUDENT had not received APE services “since he was in public school.” There is no indication that CDC assessed STUDENT’s APE needs as part of its assessment in February 2003. At the time of the May 2003 IEP meeting, the District asked the PARENTs to consent to an APE assessment, but it nonetheless offered APE services for thirty minutes weekly. That IEP was not implemented and STUDENT’s parents did not consent to any further assessment.

The assessment to determine STUDENT’s current levels of performance, conducted at DCPC pursuant to the Hearing Office’s January 2005 Decision and order, included an evaluation by an APE specialist, Amy Crammer, who testified at the hearing. Ms. Crammer is a credentialed and experienced APE provider. On the basis of her observations of STUDENT at DCPC, Ms. Crammer believes that he has delays in all areas of gross motor development, including strength, balance, and motor planning. She admits that she did not conduct a thorough assessment, stating that such an assessment should be conducted at STUDENT’s actual school site, but Ms. Crammer expressed confidence in her opinion that STUDENT needs APE services. Student offered no evidence to the contrary. On the basis of Ms. Crammer’s uncontroverted testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that during the time at issue STUDENT needed some APE services.

Student claims that he needs academic tutoring to receive a FAPE. However, STUDENT offered no evidence in support of this contention. There was sufficient evidence to demonstrate that additional tutoring was not required for a FAPE. The assessments showed that STUDENT functions at a prekindergarten cognitive level. He has minimal functional communication skills. He does not read or write. There is no evidence that he is capable of meaningful participation in an academic curriculum. As stated above, the CDC and qualified education professionals, Ms. Laurick and Ms. Terry, all recommend a functional skills curriculum and not an academic curriculum. In addition, Ms. Terry testified convincingly that STUDENT’s cognitive skills are such that he would not benefit from academic tutoring. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not need academic tutoring to receive a FAPE.

Ms. PARENT also alleges that her son needed access to a computer receive a FAPE. She claims that he needed to use a computer to help him with written work but offered no evidence to support this claim. The evidence offered by the District shows that, although STUDENT may have enjoyed playing on a computer, he did not need that access to assist with written work. STUDENT did not possess the cognitive skills to produce written work. Furthermore, according to Ms. Terry, she had to motor STUDENT through his tasks at the keyboard because he lacked fundamental letter recognition and may not have understood the cause and effect relationship between the keyboard/mouse input and the displayed output. On the basis of this persuasive evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need access to a computer to assist with written work.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT needs a placement in a structured environment where trained staff will use systematic teaching with predictable outcomes to improve his functional living skills. In addition, he needs speech and language services, OT, and APE services and opportunities to participate in school- and community-based activities with typically developing peers. He does not require academic tutoring or access to a computer to assist with written work.

The Hearing Officer will now address Student’s contentions regarding substantive FAPE.

Misidentification of Primary Disability

Ms. PARENT contends that the proposed program misidentifies autism as STUDENT’s primary disability when his primary disability is hearing impairment. As discussed in some detail above, the evidence shows that STUDENT does not have a significant hearing impairment. Assessment data also indicates that STUDENT displays autistic-like behaviors and that his cognitive functioning in probably in the two- to three-year-old range, with some scattered skills at a higher level. The assessors and educators are in agreement. Even Mr. PARENT agrees that his son’s primary disability is probably autism. Only Ms. PARENT’s unsubstantiated opinion stands in opposition. The Hearing Officer finds that the identification of STUDENT’s primary disability as autism does not result in the denial of a FAPE. (Footnote 6)

Designed to Meet Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Benefit

In essence, Student contends that the offered IEPs were not designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide education benefit.

Placement

At the time of the September 2004 IEP, the District offered an ILS SDC at Taft Middle School (Taft), a comprehensive campus. At the time of the March 2005 IEP, the District offered an ILS SDC at Wagenheim Middle School (Wagenheim), also a comprehensive campus, because of its proximity to STUDENT’s daycare provider and his father’s residence. According to Ms. Laurick and Ms. Terry, the offered placements were adequately staffed with qualified special education teachers and support staff with a student-to-adult ratio of approximately two to one. The curriculum focused on independent and functional living skills taught in a highly structured environment using systematic approaches with predictable outcomes, similar to the TEACCH methodologies. In addition, the placement offered opportunities to participate in school-based activities with typically developing peers and to practice and generalize learned skills in community-based instruction. Both witnesses testified convincingly that the offered placements were appropriate. Student offered no persuasive evidence to the contrary.

The Hearing Officer finds that the offered placements in the ILS SDCs at both Taft and Wagenheim were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Proposed Speech and Language Services

The dispute here is over the level of services. STUDENT contends that the proposed speech and language services for thirty minutes (September 2004 IEP) and sixty minutes (March 2005 IEP) per week outside the classroom were inappropriate because he required three thirty-minute sessions of individual speech and language therapy weekly. (Footnote 7)

Deborah Clemm is a licensed speech and language pathologist with thirteen years of experience assessing and meeting the speech and language needs of students, including deaf, hard of hearing, and autistic students. Ms. Clemm first met STUDENT when she assessed him in June and July 2001. She last saw him when she participated in his assessment at the CDC in Los Angeles in February 2003. When she participated in the September 2004 IEP meeting, she relied principally on the results of the CDC assessment.

According to Ms. Clemm’s testimony, when she last saw STUDENT he was able to make sounds but did not speak. In her opinion, STUDENT demonstrated some but little communicative intent and his greatest communication need was the development of a system for making his needs and wants known. Ms. Clemm believed, on the basis of her then current information, that the functional communication system that would have best served STUDENT at the time of the September 2004 IEP was a multimodal system that included vocalizations, natural gestures, objects, and possibly pictures. She did not believe that STUDENT had the skill to use ASL effectively at that time, but she also acknowledged that ASL might be a useful component of a communication system for STUDENT at some point in the future. At the September 21, 2005 IEP meeting, Ms. Clemm recommended thirty minutes per week of speech and language services. In her opinion, the proposed services were appropriate.

Stephanie Venturino is a speech and language pathologist who participated in the assessment of STUDENT at DCPV in February and March 2005. She also participated in the March 2005 IEP meeting. Ms. Venturino agreed that STUDENT needs a multimodal system of communication that can be used by him across all environments. At the March 2005 IEP meeting, she recommended that the District offer speech and language services at the rate of sixty minutes per week and believed that level of service was appropriate.

Ms. PARENT disagreed with Ms. Clemm and Ms. Venturino. She testified that at all times at issue STUDENT has needed ninety minutes per week of speech and language services to help him with his academics. Ms. PARENT offered nothing in support of this opinion.

The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Ms. Venturino to be the most persuasive. She is a qualified and licensed speech and language therapist and has the most recent experience with STUDENT. Ms. Venturino testified that she spent six sessions with STUDENT at DCPC in February and March 2005. She evaluated his progress on his goal of requesting a break using a picture card and she made an effort to determine his present levels of performance, though STUDENT’s inconsistent responses made some measures difficult. Ms. Clemm is also a qualified speech and language pathologist, but she has had no current information regarding STUDENT and her opinions were based upon her last contact with him during the CDC assessment in 2003. And although Ms. PARENT expressed her opinions regarding STUDENT’s speech and language needs, she lacks the knowledge, experience, and qualifications that lend weight to such opinions.

Neither of the District’s speech and language specialists explained why STUDENT needed thirty minutes of services weekly in September 2004 but sixty minutes weekly in March 2005. Ms. Clemm testified that she relied on the nineteen-month-old CDC assessment because it was the most current information that was available to her at the time. Although the District did not make the argument, it was implied in the evidence that the September 2004 offer of thirty minutes weekly might be found reasonable if the CDC assessment data were viewed as an accurate “snapshot” of STUDENT’s needs at the time the offer was made. (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999), citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993).) However, the Adams case prohibits the use of hindsight to judge the actions of a school district that reasonably relies on information available at the time an offer is made. It does not protect a school district from the consequences of simply loosing track of one of its students. Although it is true that the September 2004 IEP documents the District’s erroneous belief that STUDENT had moved outside of the District’s geographical boundaries, the evidence showed that, in fact, STUDENT continued to be schooled at home within the District and that the District had simply lost track of him for sixteen months. Under the circumstances, the District is not entitled to rely upon the snapshot rule to avoid responsibility for providing a FAPE to STUDENT.

On the basis of the persuasive testimony of Ms. Venturino the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of thirty minutes weekly of speech and language services in the September 2004 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs nor reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. He should have been offered those services at the rate of sixty minutes weekly. On the same basis, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of sixty minutes weekly of speech and language services in the March 2005 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

APE Services

Physical education includes APE. (34 C.F.R. § 300.26(a)(2)(i).) APE “is for individuals with exceptional needs who require developmental or corrective instruction and who are precluded from participation in the activities of the general physical education program, modified general physical education program, or in a specially designed physical education program in a special class.” (34 C.C.R., tit. 5, § 3051.5(a).) In addition, APE services can be provided through consultive services to parents, teachers, or other school personnel “for the purpose of identifying supplementary aids and services or modifications necessary for successful participation in the regular physical education program or specially designed physical education programs.” (Id.)

Ms. Crammer testified that, on the basis of her informal assessment of STUDENT at DCPC, she believes that he needs thirty minutes per week of APE services, at least initially, probably in conjunction with a regular physical education class.

Ms. PARENT testified that she was not convinced that STUDENT needs any APE services. She stated that he can run and bounce a basketball, but admits that she did not share this information with the District.

The Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s assessment of STUDENT’s APE needs was appropriate and that he needs some level of services. Ms. Crammer persuasively stated her opinion that the offer was appropriate. The IEP team had sufficient information to warrant an offer of APE services for thirty minutes per week, at least until STUDENT could be further evaluated in his school placement. The Hearing Officer has no evidence to the contrary. Therefore, he finds that the proposed APE services of thirty minutes per week were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

OT Services

Student contends that the offer of occupational therapy (OT) services for sixty minutes per week outside the classroom was inappropriate because Student required three thirty-minute clinic-based OT sessions weekly to receive a FAPE.

Julie Urbanick was the only occupational therapist to testify at the hearing. She is a registered occupational therapist with nine years of experience and currently works for the District at DCPC. Ms. Urbanick assessed STUDENT in February and March 2005 to establish baselines for his OT needs. Her assessment consisted of a review of pertinent portions of STUDENT’s file and a series of approximately six observation/assessment sessions, each for about thirty minutes. She also informally observed STUDENT periodically around the campus. In her opinion, STUDENT has OT needs in the areas of self-help (clothing fasteners) and fine motor skills (mature grasp, pre-writing, and cutting skills). Ms. Urbanick attended the March 29, 2005 IEP meeting and believes that she had sufficient information at the time to recommend sixty minutes weekly of OT services (two thirty-minute sessions). In her opinion, that the offer was appropriate.

Ms. Urbanick did not participate in any assessment of STUDENT before February 2005 and she did not participate in the September 2004 IEP meeting. The CDC assessment, upon which the District purportedly relied at that IEP meeting, did not specifically address STUDENT’s OT needs. The only evidence offered by the District to explain the basis for the September 2004 offer of OT services for thirty minutes weekly was the District’s identical offer in the February 8, 2002 IEP. Even that offer was not explained and there is no indication that an occupational therapist participated at that meeting.

Ms. PARENT was the only witness to testify in opposition to Ms. Urbanick. Ms. PARENT has no demonstrated expertise in the area of OT. Nevertheless, she is of the opinion that her son requires at least ninety minutes of OT weekly. She testified at the hearing that she believes these services are required to teach STUDENT to operate a computer, a calculator, and a TTY (teletypewriter) machine.

Julie Urbanick spent a considerable amount of time with STUDENT at DCPC and was qualified to evaluate his OT needs and recommend services to meet those needs. The Hearing Officer gave substantial weight to her testimony. Ms. PARENT’s testimony, on the other hand, must be viewed as the opinion of a layperson, albeit one who has considerable personal knowledge about STUDENT and an undeniable commitment to his welfare. However, Ms. PARENT is not qualified to evaluate STUDENT’s OT needs or to recommend services to meet those needs.

The Hearing Officer does not believe that STUDENT needs OT to train him to use keyboards like those on computers, calculators, or TTY machines. As previously indicated, STUDENT does not possess the cognitive ability to benefit from such training and may not even recognize the cause and effect relationship involved. The Hearing Officer was convinced by Ms. Urbanick’s testimony and on that basis finds that the District’s March 2005 offer of OT services at the rate of sixty minutes (two thirty-minute sessions) weekly was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Ms. Urbanick’s assessment was reasonably close in time to the September 2004 IEP meeting and there was no evidence to suggest that STUDENT’s OT needs were different at the time of that meeting. Furthermore, the District has no basis for claiming that its September 2004 offer of OT services at the rate of thirty minutes weekly was based on the information that was reasonably available at the time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s September 2004 OT offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs nor reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. STUDENT should have been offered two thirty-minute OT session weekly at that time.

Academic Tutoring

Student contends that the proposed program did not include the academic tutoring that Student required to receive a FAPE. He alleges that he needed five thirty-minute sessions weekly with a focus on reading, writing, and math taught in ASL and English.

The Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT did not need academic tutoring to receive a FAPE. No further discussion of this claim is required.

Least Restrictive Environment

Student alleges that the subject IEPs did not include adequate opportunities for him to be educated and to participate with disabled and nondisabled children in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities.

Ms. Terry testified that STUDENT would not benefit from a general education placement. Bruce Dake, the school psychologist who observed STUDENT daily at DCPC, agreed. The Hearing Officer has already found that the ILS SDC placement was appropriate. (Footnote 8) But STUDENT has needs that cannot be adequately met in that class. The parties agree that STUDENT needs to develop social skills and that he needs to have opportunities to interact with typically developing peers to work on those skills.

STUDENT’s father describes him as a very social child. Bruce Dake testified that he observed STUDENT’s increased social awareness at DCPC, with better eye contact, smiling, and social interaction, as compared with social skills observed by him when STUDENT was exiting his last school placement years before. Ms. PARENT did not disagree. Therefore, in spite of the fact that STUDENT has been home schooled for years with no proven opportunities to interact with peers in a school environment, he has become more sociable. This suggests to the Hearing Officer, and should have suggested to the District, that this is an area that requires attention. If STUDENT has been able to increase his social awareness and responsiveness without opportunities to socialize with peers at school, he should be able to make even more progress if those opportunities were provided in his IEP.

The September 2004 IEP states that “Taft also provides access to non-disabled peers” and that STUDENT would participate in the general education environment at “lunch, recreation, and physical activities,” for an estimated 10 percent of his school day. On the basis of a seven-hour school day (8:50 a.m. to 3:45 p.m.) four hours per week and a minimum day, consisting of approximately four and one-half hours (8:50 a.m. to 1:30 p.m.), on Wednesday, STUDENT would have been provided opportunities for social interaction with typically developing peers for approximately twenty-seven minutes on Wednesdays and for approximately forty-two minutes on the other four school days weekly. Ms. Terry persuasively testified that this was appropriate. No witness contradicted that testimony. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s September 2004 offer of daily opportunities to interact socially with typically developing peers for 10 percent of the school day was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. (Footnote 9)

The March 2005 IEP refers to participation with the general education population during lunch, recreation, and physical activities, but it also states that STUDENT will spend 100 percent of his time in special education. It is unclear from these IEPs how much opportunity STUDENT would have had to participate with nondisabled peers at school. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that to the extent that the March 2005 IEP does not clearly provide for opportunities to interact socially with typically developing peers, it was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs nor reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

The March 2005 IEP shall be amended to specify that 10 percent of STUDENT’s school day shall be opportunities for STUDENT to socially interact with typically developing peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities.

Computer Access

Student contends that the proposed program failed to provide him required access to a computer to assist with written work. However, the Hearing Officer has already found that this was not one of STUDENT’s needs. No further discussion of this claim is necessary.

Goals and Objectives

Student alleges that the goals and objectives contained in the IEPs were inadequate. Generally, Student claimed that the goals were for skills already mastered or allowed too much time for mastery. He also claimed that some were vague.

The IEP document is the blueprint that guides educators, service providers, and parents in the efforts to provide a FAPE to the student. In order to meet a student’s unique special education needs, an IEP must contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, which relate to meeting those needs. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2).) The IEP must also contain appropriate and objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for measuring progress. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(7).) Without appropriate measurable goals, the measurement of progress is problematic.

The September 2004 IEP contained five goals designed to improve STUDENT’s ability to:

(1) fully dress himself, including all fasteners;

(2) pay for a purchase;

(3) use a single voice output device to request a break;

(4) attend to task; and (5) take turns in a social/play setting.

The March 2005 IEP contained the following eleven goals designed to improve STUDENT’s ability to:

(1) Spontaneously greet peers and adults by waving;

(2) Indicate agreement or disagreement with a simple question (e.g. Do you want the [object]?) by nodding or shaking his heard; (3) Point to animals, shapes, colors, and objects upon request; (4) Point to picture, in an array of four, to indicate a choice relating to a want or need; (5) Indicate matching coins;

(6) Complete a two- to five-step task during a ten-minute session; (7) Correctly manipulate clothing fasteners;

(8) Take turns in a social setting;

(9) Use a mature grasp with his dominant hand to hold and manipulate a writing instrument and eating utensils; (10) Use a static tripod grasp to copy lines and shapes; and (11) Accurately cut out simple shapes.

Various District staff testified that the goals contained in both IEPs were all appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. The only explanation offered for the change in goals from September 2004 to March 2005 was that Ms. PARENT requested additional goals. The Hearing Officer found this explanation unpersuasive. There is more than twice the number of goals in the March 2005 IEP than in the IEP six months earlier, and the five from the September IEP are not all repeated in the March IEP. A far more likely explanation for the change in the goals is that the District had reliable information about STUDENT’s present levels of performance in March 2005 following his assessment at DCPC that it did not have in September 2004 after having basically “lost” STUDENT for more than a year.

The Hearing Officer was simply not persuaded that the goals contained in the September 2004 IEP were sufficient. Because the District had lost track of STUDENT, it had no current and reliable information about his needs and present levels of performance. The evidence strongly suggests that the District realized its error and rushed through the IEP process, rather than conduct an immediate reassessment, so as not to further delay the presentation of an offer. (Footnote 10) The evidence established that the goals that were included were designed to meet some of STUDENT’s needs based upon the outdated information that was then available to the District, but subsequent assessment demonstrated that some of those goals were not appropriate. The second, third, and fourth goals were not repeated in any form in the March 2005 IEP. Instead of learning to “pay” for a purchase given the correct amount of money and a prompt, STUDENT was to be taught the more basic skill of recognizing coins. The use of a single voice output device to request a break was abandoned because it was found on reassessment to be unrealistic. It is unclear why the goal for attention to task was abandoned. The Hearing Officer finds that the goals contained in the September 2004 IEP were not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

According to various witnesses, the eleven goals contained in the March 2005 IEP were based upon the current reassessment data produced during STUDENT’s time at DCPC and were appropriate. Ms. PARENT testified that some were for skills already mastered and others were too vague or allowed too much time for mastery. The Hearing Officer asked Ms. PARENT about every goal. She objected to all of them. However, Ms. PARENT did not disagree with the testimony of Ms. Laurick and others to the effect that she specifically requested some of the goals and stated no particular disagreement to any proposed goals at the IEP meetings. Nothing more than Ms. PARENT’s statements was offered by Student in support of his contention that the goals were inadequate but, as previously stated, the evidence does not support Ms. PARENT’s estimates of STUDENT’s skills.

The persuasive testimony of District staff shows that the goals proposed in March 2005 all address an area of need and are based on present levels of performance that were properly determined during the assessment at DCPC. The Hearing Officer finds that they were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Standardized Testing

Student contends that the subject IEPs are inappropriate because they require that he participate in alternative testing, CAPA, rather than the usual Statewide standardized testing administered to most of the student population.

Federal and State law require that disabled students be included in appropriate statewide and districtwide assessment programs. (34 C.F.R. § 300.138; Cal. Educ. Code § 56385.) However, the law does not require that all special education students participate in the regular assessment program, such as the STAR. Such students may be required to participate in an alternative assessment program like the CAPA. (34 C.F.R. § 300.138(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56385(b).)

Ms. Laurick and Ms. Terry testified that STUDENT could not take the regular statewide standardized testing such as the STAR program and that he required alternative assessment because of his significant deficits. Other District members of the IEP team agreed. Only Ms. PARENT did not, but she offered no evidence other than her own belief in support of her position.

On the basis of the persuasive testimony of Ms. Laurick and Ms. Terry, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP provisions requiring that STUDENT take an alternative assessment such as the CAPA program were appropriate.

* * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that the IEPs of September 2004 and March 2005 were appropriate and offered STUDENT a FAPE except in the following respects. The September 2004 IEP should have offered speech and language services and OT services for sixty minutes per week, rather than thirty minutes per week; the September 2004 IEP did not contain adequate goals; and the March 2005 IEP should have more clearly provided for adequate opportunities for STUDENT to interact socially with the general education population for part of each school day.

Remedy

Ms. PARENT requested a remedy to which STUDENT is not entitled. And although it may be unlikely that Ms. PARENT would have agreed to either of the proposed programs even if they had included appropriate services and inclusion time, the Hearing Officer is inclined to find that STUDENT is entitled to a remedy.

Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990); Miener v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986).) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” (Puyallup, supra, 31 F.3d at 497.)

The District’s failure to clearly provide for adequate opportunities for STUDENT to interact socially with the general education population for part of each school day is correctable by an amendment to the March 2005 IEP. To compensate STUDENT for the District’s failure to include adequate speech and language and OT services on the September 2004 IEP, the Hearing Officer awards twelve and one-half hours each of individual speech and language therapy and individual OT. These services are to be spread out over the next year of school and are in addition to the speech and language therapy and OT specified on the March 2005 IEP.

ORDER

1. The March 29, 2005 IEP shall be amended to provide that Student will be provided opportunities to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities with typically developing peers for 10 percent of his school day.

2. Within the first school year following STUDENT’s return to the public school placement described in the March 29, 2005 IEP, the District shall provide STUDENT twelve and one-half hours of individual speech and language therapy and twelve and one-half hours of individual OT, in addition to any similar services that may be required to meet his then current needs.

3. All of Student’s other claims to relief are denied

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The District prevailed on all issues except with respect to the level of speech and language therapy and OT offered in September 2004 and the lack of clarity in the description of the time that Student would be educated and participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities with typically developing peers in the March 2005 IEP.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Dated: August 1, 2005 _________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 There was no such request.

2 It is agreed by the parties that STUDENT is nonverbal. He is able to make sounds but not words or word approximations.

3 There was no change of circumstances in the course of the hearing that warranted reconsideration of this ruling.

4 The Hearing Office has generally held that there are reasonable limitations on the right of the parents to compel a reassessment at the expense of the local educational agency. For example, a showing of changed circumstances may be required if successive requests are made within a relatively short time. Student v. Fresno Unified School District SN96-00235.

5 Because the events that are the subject of this dispute occurred prior to the July 1, 2005 effective date of the reauthorized IDEA, the Hearing Officer applies the law that was in effect at that time.

6 In any event, there is no dispute regarding STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related services and it is the District’s obligation to provide him with an educational program that meets his exceptional needs, regardless of the basis for his eligibility. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.)

7 Several of Student’s allegations regarding DIS claimed that a particular level of services was required “to supplement a CSDR placement.” Student did not argue that the level of those services would be different if placement was other than at CSDR.

8 Ms. PARENT’s preferred placement is a residential placement at a State operated school for the deaf and hard of hearing. Aside from the evidence demonstrating that STUDENT is not deaf or hard of hearing, the mother’s preferred placement would seem to be more restrictive than that recommended by the District.

9 There was testimony suggesting that the District might not have been able to properly implement this component of the IEPs. However, because STUDENT’s mother did not allow the District to implement them, the Hearing Officer addresses only the offers and not whether the District implemented STUDENT’s program in conformity with the offers.

10 STUDENT’s annual review should have occurred in May 2004.