California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 24, 1999
Student v. San Ramon Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1154-98 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
San Ramon Valley Unified must reimburse $8,714.37 for in-home autism program over an unclear IEP offer; other claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Earlier stay put orders were issued in this matter on January 9, 1998 and February 17, 1998 (clarifying order). No later history is noted.
Summary
The parents of a five-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against San Ramon Valley Unified School District. Their son's in-home behavioral program provider, Behavioral Intervention Associates, had stopped serving him in July 1997. The District's August 1997 and May 1998 IEP offers proposed a preschool special day class, 10 hours a week of behavior technician services, behavior specialist support, parent training, and speech therapy. The parents instead paid for a full-time Lovaas-style home program supervised by Dr. Greg Buch.
The Hearing Officer found that the District's offers would have provided a FAPE under the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard. She rejected the argument that California preschool law sets a higher standard. The two-month timeline for moving behavior services from the home to school was too short, but it was not a significant denial of FAPE. Pre-drafting goals was not a violation. Neither was the provider's own decision to end services, or the District's decision not to reassess. However, the August 1997 IEP did not clearly say that behavior services would move from the home to the classroom. This unclear written offer seriously limited the parents' participation and denied FAPE from September 4, 1997, to May 11, 1998. After weighing the equities, including the parents' lack of cooperation, the Hearing Officer ordered the District to repay 25% of the net home program costs, or $8,714.37. She denied reimbursement for private speech therapy and independent assessments.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Union School District v. Smith. An IEP that did not clearly say where services would be delivered denied FAPE even though the offer was otherwise appropriate. The Hearing Officer then cut reimbursement sharply, based on how narrow the violation was and on the parents' lack of cooperation.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District offer educational services which would have provided STUDENT with a FAPE from July 31, 1997 through November 1998?
The August 25, 1997 and May 11, 1998 offers (preschool SDC, behavior technician and specialist services, speech, parent training) met the student's needs and the Rowley standard. California preschool law does not set a higher standard. The two-month timeline for moving behavior services from home to school was too short but was not a significant denial of FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did the District commit procedural violations which denied STUDENT a FAPE?
Pre-drafting goals, BIA's own termination of services, and not reassessing were not violations. The August 1997 IEP did not clearly state that behavior services would move from the home to the classroom. This seriously infringed parent participation and denied FAPE from September 4, 1997 to May 11, 1998.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational services provided from July 31, 1997 through November 1998?
The in-home Lovaas program was appropriate and provided benefit. Because the violation affected only one aspect of the offer and the parents did not cooperate, the Hearing Officer ordered 25% reimbursement of net program costs for September 4, 1997 to May 11, 1998 ($8,714.37). Private speech therapy was not shown to be appropriate, so it was not reimbursed.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational assessments obtained since July 31, 1997?
The parents offered no evidence that the District's 1996 assessments were inappropriate, so they were not entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within fifteen days, the District shall reimburse the parents $8,714.37. This is 25% of the net cost ($34,857.49, after subtracting $7,800 in Regional Center funding) of the in-home program from September 4, 1997 to May 11, 1998.
Total: $8,714.37 ordered
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School District v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Hudson v. Wilson
People named in the decision
- Dr. Dana Sassone, special education director, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Valerie Baugh, coordinator of special programs, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Gregory Buch, consulting psychologist supervising in-home program; witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention
- Dr. Deborah Sedberry, pediatrician; expert witness for Student
- Schelley Conklin, District behavioral specialist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Malisa Cochran, program specialist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Tracie Vickers, former case manager, Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA)
- Hillary Stubblefield, director, Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA)
- Carolyn Miller, special education teacher / special education liaison, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Catherine (Cathy) Nicoll, SELPA program specialist, Contra Costa SELPA
- Alyce Engelhardt, preschool special day class teacher (proposed placement), Neil Armstrong School, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Bryna Siegel, director, Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic; witness for District, Langley Porter Institute, University of California at San Francisco
- Heidi, assistant to Dr. Siegel who assessed student, Langley Porter Institute
- Dr. Michael Jones, expert for Student (did not testify)
- Cheryl Kondrat, speech and language therapist (1996 assessment), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Mary Heyward, school psychologist (1996 assessment), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Kathy Wickman, speech therapist (December 1996 assessment), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Winnie Stribling, early intervention class teacher, Twin Creeks School, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Elaine Penning, preschool special day class teacher (extended school year), Rancho Romero School, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Linda Still, speech and language therapist, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Shirley Convirs, school psychologist (PEP-R, March 1998), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Patrick Garguilo, school psychologist (PEP-R, March 1998), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Joyce Christensen, private evaluator (report for Student)
- Dr. Joan Bradus, private evaluator (report for Student)
- Howard Shaw, private evaluator (report for Student)
- Susan Bluma, private speech therapist, Children's Hospital of Oakland
- Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA), nonpublic agency, in-home behavioral program provider
- Center for Autism-Related Disorders (CARD), in-home discrete trial training provider (1995-96)
- Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention, private in-home program provider
- Merriwood School, private regular education preschool
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1154-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: Student Issue: Procedural Safeguards, Violation of Reimbursementand Funding Assessment CDS Code: 07-61804 District: San Ramon Valley Unified Disability Type: Autism
Case Details This matter was heard before Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, on August 27 and 28, September 21, October 1, 2, 6, 7, 8, 9, 26, 29, and 30, November 17 and 18, and December 1 and 2, 1998, in Danville, California. Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter referred to as Petitioner) was represented by attorney David LaDue. Advocate Laurine Guido also was present as a representative of Petitioner on some hearing days. Petitioner's father, FATHER, was present on most hearing days. Petitioner's mother, MOTHER, was present on some hearing days. Respondent San Ramon Valley Unified School District (hereinafter referred to as District) was represented by attorney Sandra Woliver. Attorney Fernando Acosta also represented the District on some hearing days. Also present on the District's behalf was Dr. Dana Sassone, special education director for the District. (Footnote 1) Additionally, Valerie Baugh, District coordinator of special programs, was present at the hearing on behalf of the District during the testimony of Dr. Sassone. The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, STUDENT's father; MOTHER, STUDENT's mother; Dr. Gregory Buch, psychologist; Dr. Deborah Sedberry, pediatrician; and Schelley Conklin, District behavioral specialist. The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Malisa Cochran, District program specialist; Tracie Vickers, former case manager for Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA); Carolyn Miller, District special education teacher; Dr. Dana Sassone, District special education director; Hillary Stubblefield, director of BIA; Catherine Nicoll, Contra Costa SELPA program specialist; Alyce Engelhardt, District special education teacher; and Dr. Bryna Siegel, director of Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at the Langley Porter Institute, University of California at San Francisco. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments, and if necessary for evidence concerning Petitioner's reimbursement claims. (Footnote 2) Upon receipt of the parties' closing briefs, the matter was submitted for decision. At a telephone conference on Feburary 24, 1999, the Hearing Officer admitted one exhibit concerning reimbursement evidence, and then ordered that the record was closed. ISSUES (footnote 3) (1) Did the District offer educational services which would have provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from July 31, 1997 through November 1998? (2) Did the District commit procedural violations which denied STUDENT a FAPE? (3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational services provided from July 31, 1997 through November 1998? (4) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational assessments obtained since July 31, 1997? PROCEDURAL MATTERS At the start of the hearing, Petitioner moved that Respondent be prohibited from calling Dr. Bryna Siegel to testify and from submitting as evidence a December 1997 report Dr. Siegel prepared regarding Petitioner. In support of his motion, Petitioner argued that Dr. Siegel's communications with FATHER and MOTHER were protected as work product and as privileged psychotherapist-patient communications, that the PARENTS had not consented to Dr. Siegel's July 1997 examination of Petitioner, and that Dr. Siegel had produced her July 1997 report in direct contradiction of the PARENTS' request that no report be generated. Petitioner further moved that Sandra Woliver be disqualified as counsel for the District in this matter, on the grounds that Ms. Woliver allegedly improperly revealed to Dr. Siegel confidential information regarding Petitioner. In opposition, the District moved for sanctions against Petitioner for bringing these motions. The Hearing Officer denied Petitioner's motions, and ruled that Dr. Siegel's testimony and report could be admitted into evidence. The Hearing Officer found that the PARENTS' contact with Dr. Siegel was not attorney work product, because the contact was not in preparation for hearing, nor arranged or even suggested by an attorney. Moreover, the "parent work product" protection asserted by Petitioner is not recognized by any court or by the Hearing Office. The Hearing Officer ruled that the PARENTS' communications with Dr. Siegel were not privileged because Dr. Siegel was not a licensed psychologist as described in Evidence Code section 910, and in any event, the PARENTS had waived the psychotherapist-patient privilege by putting STUDENT's condition at issue. The Hearing Officer held that the PARENTS' request that no report be generated did not constitute grounds for excluding that report from evidence at a due process hearing. The Hearing Officer also denied the District's motion for sanctions, and denied Petitioner's motion to disqualify counsel as without adequate basis. On November 25, 1998, the District moved that Petitioner be prohibited from introducing case-in-chief evidence as part of Petitioner's rebuttal; the District requested that this prohibition extend to prohibit the testimony of Dr. Michael Jones. On December 1, 1998, in response to the District's motion, Petitioner moved that the Hearing Officer order the District to allow Dr. Jones and MOTHER to observe the District's proposed placement site, a District preschool class taught by Alyce Engelhardt. Regarding the District's motion, the Hearing Officer ruled that Dr. Jones could testify as rebuttal witness. Regarding Petitioner's motion, the Hearing Officer noted that neither Education Code section 56505.1 nor any other applicable statute or regulation provides that the Hearing Office may order that a witness be permitted to visit a proposed placement site. Moreover, while the parties were aware at the beginning of the hearing that the appropriateness of Ms. Engelhardt's classroom would be at issue, Petitioner made his request on the penultimate day of hearing, at which point a total of thirteen witnesses had testified over the course of nearly three and a half months. The Hearing Officer determined that ordering the District to permit the observation at that late date would have caused unfair prejudice and unjustifiable delay. Given the factual circumstances and the absence of clear statutory authority, the Hearing Officer declined to order the District to allow the classroom observation. Additionally, at the hearing the parties presented extensive direct and cross examination testimony regarding reimbursement claims. The District subsequently made a motion to cease further introduction of evidence concerning reimbursement, so that the Hearing Officer could first render a decision on placement and thereafter hear further evidence on reimbursement if necessary. The Hearing Officer granted the District's motion, and ruled that if further reimbursement evidence was necessary, the Hearing Officer would reconvene the hearing to allow entry of that evidence. On February 24, 1999, after the hearing had closed, the Hearing Officer held a telephone conference with the attorneys for both parties. During the telephone conference, the Hearing Officer admitted into evidence Petitioner's Exhibit P-32, which consisted of receipts and records concerning Petitioner's expenses for reimbursement. Petitioner had provided these documents to the District in a timely manner, in compliance with Education Code section 56505(e)(7). The Hearing Officer ruled she would not reconvene the hearing to admit further reimbursement evidence, and ordered that the record was closed. After the parties submitted their closing briefs, the District made a motion to exclude as evidence Exhibits A and B to Petitioner's closing brief, on the grounds that Petitioner was attempting to submit those pages as evidence in violation of the five-day rule. Petitioner submitted his opposition to the District's motion, arguing that the exhibits to the brief did not constitute evidence, but instead were merely previously admitted evidence summarized in chart form, and therefore constituted argument. Regarding the District's motion, the Hearing Officer rules that Exhibits A and B constitute argument, not evidence. The Hearing Officer will consider the documents solely as argument. BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a five year-old boy who is eligible for special education services based on a diagnosis of autism. STUDENT was first diagnosed as autistic in November 1995, at the age of two. Shortly thereafter, STUDENT became a client of the East Bay Regional Center (Regional Center). The Regional Center provided funding for STUDENT's attendance at the Center for Autism-Related Disorders (CARD); from December 1995 to June 1996, CARD administered an in-home discrete trial training program for STUDENT. During approximately that same time period, STUDENT attended the District's Early Start Program, which services consisted of one-to-one instruction. To prepare for STUDENT's transition from the Early Start Program to a preschool program once he turned three years old, Cheryl Kondrat, District speech and language therapist, and Dr. Mary Heyward, District psychologist, conducted an assessment of STUDENT in May 1996. (Respondent's Exhs. 7, 9.) On June 10, 1996, Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA) began providing STUDENT's in-home program, and STUDENT stopped receiving services from CARD. Like CARD, BIA provided in-home discrete trial training and parent training, based largely on the methods designed by Dr. Ivar Lovaas. The Regional Center continued to provide the funding for STUDENT's program. On June 26, 1996, as STUDENT's third birthday approached, the District IEP team met for the first time to propose a program for STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exh. P-11.) The IEP provided that the District would fund STUDENT's BIA program for 91 hours per month and the Regional Center would fund the program for 69 hours per month. The IEP stated that "[d]ue to STUDENT's diagnosis of autism, the IEP team agreed to continue his current in-home program as he transitions from the infant program to preschool." The IEP specifically provided for two hours a week of speech and language therapy, 40 hours a week of behavior intervention services, three hours a month of services from a behavior specialist to provide the intensive behavior intervention plan, and two hours per month of case management and consultation from a special education teacher. (Petitioner's Exh. P-11.) From June 1996 until July 1997, BIA provided STUDENT's in-home program, initially through funding from RCEB, and subsequently with funding from both RCEB and the District. The program consisted primarily of home tutoring in speech and language, play and social skills, cognitive skills and gross motor skills. (Petitioner's Exhs. JE-2, P-13.) The tutoring was usually conducted by two tutors who worked directly with STUDENT; generally one tutor would teach a skill while the other tutor would model what STUDENT was supposed to do. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-2.) STUDENT's case manager, Tracie Vickers, visited the PARENTS' home two to three times a week to observe the tutoring, supervise the tutors, and confer with the tutors and the PARENTS. Hillary
Stubblefield, director of BIA, was also involved in overseeing STUDENT's program, although she became more involved in spring 1997, after Ms. Vickers had tendered her resignation. (Testimony of Ms. Stubblefield, Ms. Vickers.) In fall 1996, STUDENT attended a regular education preschool, Merriwood School, twice a week for three hours a day. In November 1996, STUDENT's father, FATHER, agreed to a speech and language assessment of STUDENT by Kathy Wickman, a District speech therapist. (Respondent's Exhs. 14, 15.) Ms. Wickman's report, dated January 3, 1997, concluded that STUDENT was ready to participate in a group-based educational environment. (Respondent's Exh. 20.) On January 9, 1997, the IEP team met to hold a second IEP meeting, in conjunction with the Regional Center's Early Intensive Behavioral Intervention (EIBI) meeting. The IEP/EIBI team agreed that STUDENT was making progress and should continue with the BIA-supervised in-home discrete trial training program. The IEP also provided for a 225-day extended school year. Based on the findings and recommendations in BIA's six-month progress report, the team agreed that STUDENT should begin attending preschool regularly. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-4.) In order to assist the IEP team in determining STUDENT's preschool placement, FATHER agreed to visit proposed classrooms by March 1 and report back to Malisa Cochran regarding his preferred classroom. (Testimony of Ms. Cochran, FATHER; Petitioner's Exh. JE-4.) In February 1997, FATHER and Ms. Vickers visited two of the proposed classes, a special day class at the Mauzy Center and Winnie Stribling's early intervention class at Twin Creeks School. (Testimony of Ms. Vickers, FATHER.) FATHER subsequently informed Ms. Cochran that he felt that Ms. Stribling's early intervention class would be the more appropriate placement for STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Cochran, Ms. Vickers.) STUDENT subsequently attended Ms. Stribling's class three mornings a week from March until June 1997, when the school year ended. Since Ms. Stribling's class was not offered during the extended school year, the District and the PARENTS agreed that STUDENT would enroll in another preschool special day class, Elaine Penning's class at Rancho Romero School, for the extended school year. (Testimony of Ms. Cochran.) STUDENT did attend Ms. Penning's preschool class during the extended school year and, also during that time, received speech therapy from District speech therapist Linda Still. In spring and summer 1997, difficulties with the BIA program arose. Several BIA employees, including Ms. Vickers, tendered their resignations from BIA. (Testimony of Ms. Vickers, FATHER, MOTHER.) Initially Ms. Stubblefield wrote to all parents with children in the BIA program to assure them that the quality of the BIA program would continue despite the employee resignations. (Petitioner's Exh. P-3.) However, a few weeks thereafter, Ms. Stubblefield wrote to the PARENTS to notify them that BIA would cease providing STUDENT's program after August 8, 1997, at which time the District would take over in providing the program. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-5.) On July 8, 1997, the PARENTS met with Ms. Stubblefield to review STUDENT's final BIA progress report. In the days immediately following that meeting, MOTHER and Ms. Stubblefield exchanged hostile words via letter and telephone message. (Testimony of Ms. Stubblefield, MOTHER.) Apparently as a result of these exchanges, Ms. Stubblefield decided that BIA could not continue to provide STUDENT's program through August 8, and notified the PARENTS of her decision. BIA ceased providing supervision for STUDENT's program on July 14, 1997, and BIA personnel ceased providing services to STUDENT on July 24, 1997, the last day of STUDENT's summer preschool class. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-6.) In mid-July 1997, FATHER left messages for both Dr. Sassone and Ms. Cochran that he wanted to request an IEP meeting. (Testimony of FATHER, Dr. Sassone; Petitioner's Exh. 43.) Ms. Cochran was on summer break and did not receive FATHER's messages until she returned in August. (Testimony of Ms. Cochran.) Dr. Sassone returned FATHER's call and left a message containing instructions on how he could reach her, but Dr. Sassone did not receive a call from FATHER before she left for summer break. (Testimony of Dr. Sassone.) On July 21, 1997, the PARENTS wrote a letter to the District, stating that they did not agree to change STUDENT's in-home behavioral intervention program and that they expected the last IEP to be implemented. On August 11, 1997, Dr. Sassone wrote back to the PARENTS, stating that the District intended to continue to implement STUDENT's last IEP until a new IEP was approved. On that same date, Ms. Cochran scheduled an IEP meeting for August 25. Prior to the IEP meeting, District special education liaison Carolyn Miller, District speech and language therapist Linda Still, and District special education teacher Alyce Engelhardt met to draft new goals and objectives for STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Engelhardt, Ms. Miller; Respondent's Exh. 52.) They based their draft goals and objectives on the information and recommendations in the BIA final progress report dated July 16, 1997, and on information from Ms. Penning, STUDENT's summer school teacher, and from Ms. Still, STUDENT's summer school speech therapist. (Ibid.) Concerned about continuing STUDENT's program, the PARENTS contacted Dr. Bryna Siegel for advice regarding finding a service provider to replace BIA. (Testimony of FATHER, MOTHER.) Over the previous year and a half, Dr. Siegel had twice met with the PARENTS and assessed STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exh. P-12, Respondent's Exh. 2.) While previously the PARENTS had made appointments with Dr. Siegel well in advance, on this occasion Dr. Siegel set up an appointment for the PARENTS for the following day. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The PARENTS brought with them to the appointment both STUDENT and their other son, Derek. Dr. Siegel met with the PARENTS and recommended Dr. Greg Buch, consulting psychologist at the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention, as a potential service provider for STUDENT. (Testimony of FATHER, MOTHER, Dr. Siegel.) Dr. Siegel also had her assistant, Heidi, take STUDENT out of the room to be assessed. (Footnote 4) (Testimony of Dr. Siegel.) In August 1997, Dr. Buch met with the PARENTS and assessed STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exh. P-14.) In September 1997, Dr. Buch reported to the PARENTS that he believed that STUDENT would benefit from a full-time, intensive discrete trial training program using the Lovaas methodology. (Testimony of Dr. Buch, FATHER, MOTHER.) The PARENTS agreed to enlist Dr. Buch's services, and therefore Dr. Buch commenced a full-time, intensive in-home discrete trial training program for STUDENT. On August 25, 1997, STUDENT's IEP team met again. The District presented STUDENT's recently drafted goals and objectives, and proposed the following placement: a preschool special day class five mornings a week; behavior technician services for two hours a day, five days a week; behavior specialist services for six to eight hours a month "to provide support in planning and transitioning [STUDENT] to his new setting"; and speech and language sessions twice a week. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-8.) The preschool special day class in the offer was Alyce Engelhardt's class at Neil Armstrong School, and the behavior specialist was to be Schelley Conklin. (Testimony of Ms. Cochran, Dr. Sassone.) Neither FATHER nor MOTHER checked the boxes on the IEP form indicating their consent to the District's placement offer. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-8; testimony of FATHER, MOTHER.) Instead, FATHER wrote that he "did not agree to shadow aid[e] not being the therapists from the in-home program as before...Parents to meet with behavior specialists from school. I agree to other items." (Petitioner's Exh. JE-8.) MOTHER wrote that she would "submit the changes to this proposal at a later date after review." (Ibid.) The PARENTS stated that, before they agreed to the IEP, they wanted to meet with Schelley Conklin to learn more about her background and discuss STUDENT's program. MOTHER and Ms. Conklin scheduled an appointment for September 3, for Ms. Conklin to visit the FAMILY home and observe STUDENT's program. (Testimony of Ms. Conklin, MOTHER, Ms. Cochran.) However, when Ms. Conklin arrived for her scheduled appointment on September 3, she was unable to gain entry through the gates surrounding the PARENTS' gated community. (Testimony of Ms. Conklin.) MOTHER later explained that she had thought the appointment was set for a different day. (Ibid.) MOTHER and Ms. Conklin agreed that they would reschedule the appointment, but no meeting ever occurred. On September 11, 1997, MOTHER, STUDENT and one of STUDENT's tutors visited Alyce Engelhardt's classroom for approximately one hour. (Testimony of Ms. Engelhardt, MOTHER.) The visitors primarily observed the class and did not participate in any group activities. (Ibid.) Other than this visit, STUDENT never attended the class on any occasion. STUDENT continued with his full-time in-home program, supervised by Dr. Buch, and did not receive any services from the District. (Footnote 5) On September 23, 1997, the PARENTS filed their first request for a due process hearing. In October 1997, Cathy Nicoll, a program specialist for the Contra Costa SELPA, attempted to contact the PARENTS regarding the situation. (Testimony of Ms. Nicoll.) Ms. Nicoll wrote to the PARENTS that she was concerned that STUDENT was not in school, and noted that STUDENT could still receive speech therapy and other services from the District even if he was not attending a District preschool. (Respondent's Exh. 28; testimony of Ms. Nicoll.) On January 9, 1998, the Hearing Office issued a stay put order specifying that STUDENT's stay put placement was the placement the parties had agreed to in spring 1997, consisting of a 34-hour per week in-home program and six hours per week in a school program. The District then notified the PARENTS that it would provide the program specified in the stay put order and that the program would be provided by District personnel. (Respondent's Exhs. 36, 37.) The District formally presented this offer at an IEP meeting on February 9, 1998. At that meeting, the PARENTS presented Dr. Buch's proposed six-month IEP goals for STUDENT, a request for retroactive reimbursement for the expenses of STUDENT's program since August 1997, and assessment reports from Joyce Christensen, Dr. Deborah Sedberry and Dr. Joan Bradus. (Respondent's Exh. 37; testimony of FATHER, MOTHER.) Petitioner subsequently filed a motion for reconsideration and clarification that sought clarification as to whether the stay put placement consisted of a program provided by District personnel or by the Lovaas Institute. On February 17, 1998, the Hearing Office issued a clarifying order which explained that the stay put placement was the placement the parties had agreed to in spring 1997. The Hearing Officer ruled that since the District never agreed to the Lovaas Institute providing STUDENT's program, the Lovaas Institute was not the stay put placement. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-11.) After the Hearing Office issued its February 17, 1998 order, the District again notified the PARENTS that the District sought to implement STUDENT's in-home program pursuant to the stay put order, using District personnel to provide the program. (Respondent's Exh. 40.) The parties could not agree on service providers to implement the stay put placement and, as a result, the parties never implemented that placement. STUDENT continued in his in-home program, supervised by Dr. Buch, and did not receive any services from the District. In May 1998, the District convened another IEP meeting. Again the PARENTS and the District could not agree on a placement. The District again offered a school-based placement, as follows: a preschool special day class four hours a day, five days a week; ten hours a week of intensive behavioral intervention services provided by a behavior technician; five to eight hours a month of behavior specialist services, including provision of parent consultation and training; speech and language sessions twice a week; and bi-weekly team meetings with all service providers and parents invited. (Respondent's Exh. 52; testimony of Dr. Sassone.) The District proposed that this placement last until November 1998. The PARENTS stated that the District's offer was not appropriate for STUDENT because it did not include 40 hours per week of a Lovaas-type program. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW (1) Did the District offer educational services which would have provided STUDENT with a FAPE from July 31, 1997 through November 1998? Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. 1400(d); California Education Code 56000.) Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. 1400 et seq.; California Education Code 56000.) "FAPE" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. 1401(8).) California special education law further provides that for students between the ages of three and five years, special education shall include "specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families. To meet this purpose, the program focus is on the young child and his or her family and shall include both individual and small group services which shall be available in a variety of typical age-appropriate environments for young children, including the home, and shall include opportunities for active parent involvement." (Education Code 56441.2.) In determining whether the District must provide the program the PARENTS are requesting, one must focus on the adequacy of the program that the District offered. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314.) The U.S. Supreme Court has held that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the [IDEA] consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.) Pursuant to Rowley, if the District's offer meets the child's needs, would provide some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents' preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. Petitioner asserts that, by enacting Education Code section 56441.2 and other Education Code sections regarding preschool children, the California Legislature has created a higher standard for educating preschool children than the Rowley standard. However, Education Code section 56000 provides that "nothing in this part shall be construed to set a higher standard of educating individuals with exceptional needs than that established by Congress under the [IDEA]." Since Rowley was the Court's interpretation of the IDEA, California law does not set a higher standard than that specified in Rowley. Thus, determining whether STUDENT received a FAPE requires an analysis of whether the District's offer met STUDENT's unique needs, would provide him with some educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. Regarding STUDENT's unique needs, Petitioner offered the testimony of Dr. Greg Buch, who conducted his first evaluation of STUDENT in August 1997 and thereafter supervised STUDENT's in-home program. When Dr. Buch first evaluated STUDENT in August 1997, he assessed STUDENT's language skills using the Reynell Developmental Language Scales, and assessed STUDENT's cognitive skills using the Merrill Palmer Scale of Mental Age. (Testimony of Dr. Buch; Petitioner's Exh. P-14.) From those tests, Dr. Buch concluded that, in comparison to his chronological age, STUDENT had a 24-month delay in receptive language, a 28- month delay in expressive language, and a 14-month delay in cognitive functioning. (Petitioner's Exh. P-14.) Dr. Buch agreed that these results from the Merrill Palmer and the Reynell were generally consistent with STUDENT's performance on portions of the Psychoeducational Profile-Revised (PEP-R), which District psychologists Shirley Convirs and Patrick Garguilo administered to STUDENT in March 1998. (Testimony of Dr. Buch; see Respondent's Exh. 51.) Dr. Buch testified that when he began supervising STUDENT's program in September 1997, STUDENT showed significant deficits in expressive language, including poor articulation and an absence of expressive object labels. Dr. Buch explained that STUDENT had some verbal imitation skills, but could not imitate complete words. STUDENT also occasionally displayed self-stimulatory behaviors and tantrums, although these problem behaviors were not excessive. STUDENT also had delays in his social skills. STUDENT's problem behaviors and delayed social skill level remained essentially the same through September 1998, although his expressive language skills, receptive language skills and verbal imitation skills improved. Petitioner also submitted reports from Dr. Deborah Sedberry, Dr. Joan Bradus, Howard Shaw and Dr. Joyce Christensen, and called Dr. Sedberry to testify as a witness. According to the evidence submitted, these experts each reviewed STUDENT's history and observed him on one or two occasions but did not use any tests to evaluate STUDENT and did not offer any test results to support their opinions. Given this absence of any norm-based tests, the Hearing Officer gives less weight to the opinions of these experts. The BIA report dated July 6, 1997, offered further information regarding gains that STUDENT had made as of that date. In that report, Ms. Vickers and Ms. Stubblefield described how STUDENT had learned to follow simple directions and to make spontaneous requests, how he enjoyed playing with another child during weekly peer play sessions, and how he would sometimes self-initiate play during structured play sessions with his tutors. (Petitioner's Exh. P-13.) The report notes that STUDENT was able to partially dress himself and was able to use the toilet when taken to the bathroom and given verbal prompting. In her testimony, Ms. Vickers described STUDENT's progress in the BIA program, including goals that STUDENT had met by January 1997, such as being able to identify different shapes by touch and being able to imitate isolated sounds. Regarding STUDENT's progress from January to May 1997, Ms. Vickers testified that STUDENT was continuing to progress in speech and language skills, vocabulary, play skills and was completing simple two-step commands. Ms. Vickers noted that STUDENT did not make much progress in cognitive areas and thus, arguably, he may have reached a plateau. BIA's observations did conflict with Dr. Buch's observations regarding STUDENT's expressive language skills. The BIA report states that STUDENT's expressive vocabulary included over two hundred and fifty nouns and verbs, whereas Dr. Buch reported an absence of expressive vocabulary. (Petitioner's Exh. P-13; testimony of Dr. Buch.) Such contradictory reports suggest that STUDENT's language skills regressed somewhat between June 1997 and August 1997. (See testimony of Dr. Buch, FATHER.) STUDENT also appears to have regressed in his potty training during that time period. (Petitioner's Exh. P-21; testimony of FATHER, Dr. Buch.) Ms. Vickers testified that she agreed with Dr. Buch's assessment of STUDENT's cognitive functi
Regarding the District's offer of behavioral intervention services, Schelley Conklin was qualified to provide the behavioral specialist services STUDENT needed. Prior to joining the District as a behavioral consultant, Ms. Conklin had four years' experience supervising intensive behavioral intervention programs for autistic children, through her work for the Strategic Teaching and Reinforcement Systems (STARS) program and Behavioral Analysts, Inc.. (Testimony of Ms. Conklin, Dr. Sassone; Respondent's Exh. 61.) In particular, Ms. Conklin had experience managing programs for autistic children transitioning from in-home to school-based programs. (Testimony of Ms. Conklin; Respondent's Exh. 61.) Additionally, Ms. Conklin had a master's degree in education with an emphasis on teaching severely handicapped children, had a multi-subject teaching credential with an emphasis on teaching severely handicapped children, and had two years' experience as a special education classroom teacher. (Respondent's Exh. 61.) The remaining consideration regarding the District's offer of behavioral intervention services is location. Petitioner disputes the District's proposal to provide the services in the classroom instead of the home. Ms. Conklin testified that she anticipated continuing STUDENT's behavioral intervention services at his home until he was ready to transition to receiving those services at school. While the August 1997 IEP does not specify the length of this transition period, the May 1998 IEP specifies that the location of the provision of those services would change from home to school after two months. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-8, Respondent's Exh. 52.) Likewise, Dr. Sassone testified that the August 1997 IEP team envisioned that STUDENT would continue to receive his behavior intervention services at home for two months, after which time the location would switch to school. Dr. Siegel persuasively testified that her recommendation in July 1997 was to continue STUDENT's discrete trial training in the home for six months or so. Dr. Siegel noted that whether discrete trial training is provided in the home or at school makes no educational difference, but explained that if the child, parents and tutors all feel comfortable with the home setting, then it is preferable to continue in that setting. Ms. Stubblefield testified that she had envisioned that the behavioral intervention services would continue to be provided in the home, although she acknowledged that those services could be provided at school if done properly. Autistic children such as STUDENT have difficulty with change, and therefore need regularity and familiarity with all aspects of their programs, including location. (Testimony of Dr. Sedberry, Ms. Vickers.) The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed to continue his behavioral intervention services in the home, and therefore the District's plan to transition STUDENT's behavioral intervention services to a school location after two months was inconsistent with his needs. While the behavioral intervention services could have eventually been relocated to a school setting after STUDENT became more comfortable with that setting, the two-month timeline on the transition plan was too short. However, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Dr. Siegel and Ms. Stubblefield that STUDENT could have received his behavioral intervention services at school and learned as much as he would have learned in the home setting. Moreover, while the two-month time transition period was shorter than recommended, nevertheless STUDENT most likely would have become comfortable enough with his classroom after two months that he would have received educational benefit from behavioral intervention services provided in a classroom. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the brevity of the transition plan did not constitute a significant denial of FAPE. Finally, witness testimony established that STUDENT needed a program with significant parent involvement, so that STUDENT's learning at school could be generalized to home and vice versa. (Testimony of Dr. Buch, Dr. Siegel, Ms. Stubblefield.) The District's offer included parent training and consultation provided by the behavior specialist, and biweekly team meetings which the PARENTS could attend. (Testimony of Dr. Sassone, Ms. Cochran, Ms. Conklin; Respondent's Exh. 52.) Thus, the District's offer is appropriate to the extent that it provided for needed parent involvement. Since there has been no evidence or allegation that the District's offer failed to conform to STUDENT's IEPs, conformity to STUDENT's IEPs is not an issue. Thus, given that the District's placement offers met STUDENT's unique needs, provided educational benefit, and conformed to the IEPs, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's placement offers of August 25, 1997 and May 11, 1998, would have provided STUDENT with a FAPE through November 1998. (2) Did the District commit procedural violations which denied STUDENT a FAPE? Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. 1400 et seq.) Such procedural protections include: the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the child's IEP; and the opportunity for mediation and due process hearing. (20 U.S.C. 1415(b); see Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519.) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every step of the administrative process...as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard." (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.) Petitioner alleges that the District committed several procedural violations which resulted in the denial of FAPE. First, Petitioner alleges that the District's presentation of previously drafted goals and objectives at the IEP meeting on August 25, 1997, and the District's failure to invite the parents to attend the meeting where the goals and objectives were drafted, constitutes a denial of the parents' right to participate in the IEP process. Given the complexity of determining goals and objectives for a child such as STUDENT, predrafting proposed goals and objectives may be necessary to facilitate meaningful discussion at the IEP meeting. Given that the parents were able to participate in the discussion on the goals and objectives, and could have suggested changes to the goals and objectives, the District's decision to predraft proposed goals and objectives prior to the IEP meeting does not constitute a denial of FAPE. (See, e.g., Hudson v. Wilson (W.D. Va. 1986) 1986-87 EHLR Dec. 558:186, 189.) Second, Petitioner alleges that the District committed a procedural violation by unilaterally changing STUDENT's placement in July 1997. In July 1997, Ms. Stubblefield notified the PARENTS that BIA would no longer be able to provide STUDENT's in-home program. (Testimony of Ms. Stubblefield, FATHER.) In a letter dated July 17, 1997, BIA notified Dr. Sassone and the PARENTS that it had ceased providing supervision for STUDENT's program on July 14, 1997, and that BIA personnel would cease providing services to STUDENT on July 24, 1997, the last day of STUDENT's summer preschool class. (Petitioner's Exh. JE-6.) STUDENT's extended school year ended on August 8, 1997, and the 1997-98 school year began on September 4, 1997. The District did not terminate or change STUDENT's placement prior to the IEP meeting on August 25; rather, the service provider unilaterally terminated its services to STUDENT a few weeks earlier than previously agreed. A service provider's unilateral decision to terminate services does not constitute a change in placement by the District, because presumably the District had no power to prevent the termination. Thus, BIA's termination of STUDENT's program in July 1997 does not constitute a procedural violation by the District. Third, Petitioner argues that the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT before proposing to change his placement at the IEP meeting on August 25, 1997. Special education students must be reassessed every three years, "or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new [IEP] is to be developed." (Education Code 56381.) In the present case, STUDENT's triennial assessment was not due until 1999, and the PARENTS had not requested a new assessment. Reports of STUDENT's progress in his intensive in-home program and his summer school special day class were available to and utilized by the drafters of STUDENT's new goals and objectives. The evidence presented at hearing did not establish that conditions warranted a new assessment in August 1997 or, in any event, that failure to reassess STUDENT constituted a denial of FAPE. Finally, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to notify the PARENTS in writing of the District's intent to change STUDENT's placement in August 1997. On August 25, 1997, the IEP team met and presented the PARENTS with the District's proposal to change STUDENT's placement to a preschool special day class five times per week, from "(9:15 - 12:00) Preschool length day [with] Individual and small group support throughout the school day." (Respondent's Exh. 26.) The IEP also specifically provided for continued behavior technician services five times per week for two hours each day. In the section for "Eligibility, Category and Rationale for Least Restrictive Placement," the IEP states: "Due to STUDENT's diagnosis of autism, the IEP team recommended a special day class placement with speech and language services and additional classroom support as he transitions to a new setting." The IEP team also presented the PARENTS with proposed goals and objectives that District employees had drafted prior to the meeting. (Respondent's Exh. 26.) Petitioner contends that neither the written language of the IEP nor the discussion at the IEP meeting informed the PARENTS that the District intended to transition STUDENT from his intensive in- home program to a school-based program. Petitioner contends that the IEP language that behavior technician and behavior specialist services were "continuing" conveyed that the services would continue in the home setting. Both Mr. and MOTHER testified that they had no idea at the IEP meeting that the District was proposing to terminate STUDENT's in-home program. The August 1997 IEP clearly states that the behavior technician services would be provided five days per week for two hours each day. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP gave the PARENTS full notice that STUDENT would no longer be receiving his intensive behavioral program full-time, and that that portion of his program would be reduced to ten hours per week. However, the Hearing Officer agrees with Petitioner that this IEP does not clearly convey the District's plan to transition the behavioral services from the home setting to a classroom setting. While the proposed goals and objectives consistently stated that STUDENT would learn to generalize home school skills to a classroom setting, this language was not sufficient to notify the parents that the District intended to transition STUDENT out of the home setting entirely. This procedural violation continued until the District provided the May 1998 IEP document, which specifically explains the plan to transition the services entirely to the classroom. That IEP states that the behavioral technician services are
'to be provided as an extension of the school day on school site" and that "[i]n September 1998 all services would be provided on the school site." (Respondent's Exh. 52.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process" clearly result in the denial of a FAPE. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1484.) In the present case, while the procedural violation involved information regarding the location of only one portion of STUDENT's services, the violation significantly affected the IEP process. The August 1997 IEP team members all left that IEP meeting under the impression that they had reached agreement on the majority of STUDENT's program, and needed only to address details regarding the identity of the tutors and the PARENTS' concerns about Ms. Conklin as the behavioral specialist. (Testimony of Ms. Cochran, FATHER, Ms. Nicoll.) Mr. and MOTHER both testified that they did not understand from the IEP meeting or the IEP document that the District was proposing to relocate the behavioral intervention services from home to school. The PARENTS only learned about the proposed change in the weeks following the IEP meeting, when Ms. Cochran spoke to MOTHER over the telephone and explained about the change in placement. (Testimony of MOTHER.) In large part because of the disagreement regarding the transition plan, the PARENTS disengaged from dealing with the District altogether, and instead focused entirely on obtaining STUDENT's services through private providers. Had the District provided a clear written offer which detailed the transition plan, the PARENTS would have had the opportunity to hear the other IEP team members' explanations in favor of the transition plan and explain to the other team members why they disagreed with the transition plan. Additionally, the IEP team would have been far more likely to resolve the dispute under those circumstances than under the circumstances that actually occurred. Overall, the violation resulted in a serious infringement on the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process, and constituted a denial of FAPE from the beginning of the 1997-98 school year on September 4, 1997, until May 11, 1998. (3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational services provided from July 31, 1997 through November 1998? In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 105 S.Ct. 2003, the United States Supreme Court determined that when the proposed public school placement is inappropriate, parents of a student eligible for special education may be entitled to reimbursement for expenses that they incur in educating their child. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting relief. (Burlington, supra; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.) In the present case, the District's failure to provide a clear written offer of placement regarding the location of behavioral intervention services constituted a denial of FAPE from September 4, 1997 until May 11, 1998. (Union School District v. Smith, supra.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the program provided by the PARENTS is proper under the IDEA. In Florence County School District, Four v. Carter (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361, the Court held that parents may receive reimbursement for their unilateral placement even if the placement does not meet certain requirements of the IDEA. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the child's IEP, and need not provide a placement that is certified by the state. However, the parents' unilateral placement still must have met the child's needs and provided educational benefit. (Florence v. Carter, supra; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.) In the present case, from September 4, 1997 through May 11, 1998, STUDENT received a full-time in-home intensive behavioral intervention program from the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention, and also received speech therapy from speech therapist Susan Bluma at Children's Hospital of Oakland. In STUDENT's in-home program, tutors conducted discrete trial training, teaching STUDENT to imitate, follow instructions, identify objects, use expressive language, and engage in play activities. (Testimony of Dr. Buch.) The program also taught STUDENT to reduce negative behaviors like tantrums and learn self-help skills like toilet training. (Ibid.) The program utilized discrete trial training techniques such as discrimination training, which teaches the child to discriminate between objects. Dr. Greg Buch supervised the program, and the PARENTS employed a total of four tutors, usually with two tutors working with STUDENT at one time. (Ibid.) Dr. Buch and the tutors kept written records of STUDENT's progress. Because parent involvement is a key component of the program, MOTHER attended parent training workshops and became directly involved in many aspects of STUDENT's program. (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Buch.) As stated in a previous section, STUDENT needed behavioral intervention services, speech therapy and opportunity for social interaction such as a preschool special day class. Based on the evidence received at the hearing, the in-home program met STUDENT's needs for behavioral intervention. (See testimony of Dr. Buch, FATHER, MOTHER.) The in-home program addressed all of STUDENT's key areas of need: imitation, language, cognitive skills, reduction of negative behaviors, and social skills. (See testimony of Dr. Buch; Petitioner's Exh. P-6.) Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that the program met STUDENT's need for social opportunities. While the program did not include a preschool class during the time period in question, the program did provide opportunities for STUDENT to interact with typically developing peers. The tutors often facilitated STUDENT's play with a typically developing peer, usually STUDENT's brother, Derek. (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Buch.) Little evidence was received regarding the speech therapy STUDENT received from September 1997 to May 1998. STUDENT's speech therapist, Susan Bluma, did not testify, and no recent reports from Ms. Bluma were submitted into evidence. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner did not meet his burden of proof in establishing that Ms. Bluma's speech therapy services were appropriate for STUDENT. Regarding whether STUDENT received educational benefit from his in-home program, Dr. Buch, FATHER and MOTHER all testified regarding the progress that STUDENT had made. (See Petitioner's Exh. P-6.) During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT developed an expressive vocabulary with numerous object labels, improved his receptive language skills, initiated communication with family members more frequently and improved his imitation skills, particularly verbal imitation skills. (See testimony of Dr. Buch, FATHER, MOTHER.) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the in-home intensive behavioral intervention program provided STUDENT with educational benefit, and therefore finds that the in-home program was an appropriate placement. In considering an award of reimbursement for the appropriate placement the PARENTS provided, the Hearing Officer must balance the equities involved. (See Alamo, supra.) Most notably, while the District failed to make a clear written offer, that failure was limited to only one aspect of one type of service. Regarding the majority of STUDENT's program, the District's offer was entirely clear. Another factor weighing against reimbursement is that, after the August 1997 IEP, the PARENTS often did not cooperate with the District in attempting to find an appropriate placement for STUDENT. In particular, immediately after the dispute arose, the PARENTS simply declined any contact the District, leaving the District to wonder whether STUDENT was receiving any services whatsoever. (See Respondent's Exh. 28.) Moreover, the Hearing Officer notes that while the area of the District's denial of FAPE concerned the written offer of behavioral intervention services, the PARENTS' failure to agree to the IEP was due in part to unrelated factors, such as MOTHER's negative evaluation of Ms. Engelhardt's special day class. However, weighing in favor of reimbursement is the fact that the PARENTS expended some effort in securing an appropriate alternative placement for STUDENT. The PARENTS researched appropriate service providers in their area, and consulted with Dr. Siegel regarding an appropriate placement. (Petitioner's Exh. P-42; testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Siegel.) Regarding the PARENTS' request for reimbursement for speech therapy, the Hearing Officer found that Petitioner has failed to meet his burden of proof in establishing that the speech therapy was appropriate. Thus, the Hearing Officer declines to order reimbursement for speech therapy services. (Footnote 7) Regarding reimbursement for the in-home program, based on the factors discussed in this section, the Hearing Officer finds that the balance of the equities favors the District. The Hearing Officer thus finds that only partial reimbursement for the in-home program shall be awarded. The Hearing Officer notes that the services at the heart of the denial of FAPE only constituted 25% of the program STUDENT eventually received. Given also the equitable factors weighing against the PARENTS, the Hearing Officer orders that the District shall pay 25% of the cost of STUDENT's in-home program from September 4, 1997 to May 11, 1998. In providing the in-home program, the PARENTS claim as expenses not only the services of Dr. Buch and the in-home tutors, but also additional expenses such as educational supplies for the program and costs of "help wanted" advertisements for tutors. At the hearing, Petitioner submitted extensive evidence detailing these expenses. The Hearing Officer finds that while a portion of these expenses was necessary to provide STUDENT's in-home program, another portion was unnecessary and excessive, and/or included items which the PARENTS would have bought for STUDENT in any event, such as toys and daytime snacks. Excluding costs incurred after May 11, 1998, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS claim additional expenses of $5,402.47 for advertising, photocopying and educational supplies. (Petitioner's Exhs. P-4(R2), P-25, P-32; testimony of FATHER, MOTHER.) Based on the extensive testimony of the PARENTS and the documents admitted into evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that $950.00 of that amount should not be subject to reimbursement. The remaining $4,452.47 constitutes the cost of STUDENT's in-home program, and the PARENTS shall be reimbursed for 25% of that amount. Based on the evidence admitted at the hearing, Dr. Buch's services, tutor services and workshop costs totaled $38,205.02 from September 4, 1997 to May 11, 1998. (Petitioner's Exhs. P-4, P-4(R), P-4(R2), P-24, P-28 and P-31.) Adding in the $4,452.47 spent on advertising, photocopying and educational supplies, the total cost of the in-home program for the time period in question was $42,657.49. The PARENTS also received $7,800 as program funding from the Regional Center. (Testimony of FATHER; Petitioner's Exh. P-4(R2).) Subtracting the Regional Center funding, the in- home program costs from September 4, 1997 to May 11, 1998 totaled $34,857.49. Thus, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for 25% of that amount, which is $8,714.37. (4) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational assessments obtained since July 31, 1997? Special education students must be reassessed every three years, "or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new [IEP] to be developed." (Education Code 56381.) When a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency's assessment was appropriate. (Education Code 56329(b).) In May 1996, approximately two months prior to STUDENT's third birthday, Cheryl Kondrat, District speech and language therapist, and Dr. Mary Heyward, District psychologist, conducted the District's initial assessment of STUDENT. (Respondent's Exhs. 7, 9.) In December 1996, Kathy Wickman, District speech and language therapist, conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. (Respondent's Exh. 20.) Petitioner has not offered any grounds as to why these assessments were inappropriate. The Hearing
Officer finds that Petitioner did not provide any evidence substantiating that the District's assessment was inappropriate, and the Hearing Officer concludes that the assessment was appropriate. Because the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments. ORDER Within fifteen days, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS in the amount of $8,714.37. All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to California Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: (1) Did the District offer educational services which would have provided STUDENT with a FAPE from July 31, 1997 through November 1998? The District prevailed on this issue. (2) Did the District commit procedural violations which denied STUDENT a FAPE? Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the District committed one procedural violation which denied STUDENT a FAPE, and the District prevailed on the remainder of this issue. (3) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational services provided from July 31, 1997 through November 1998? Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that he is entitled to reimbursement in the amount of $8,714.37, and the District prevailed on the remainder of this issue. (4) Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational assessments obtained since July 31, 1997? The District prevailed on this issue. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code 56505(i). DATED: February 24, 1999 ___________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
1. Dr. Sassone was employed as the District's special education director when the hearing commenced on August 27, 1998, but left that employment prior to the last day of hearing on December 2, 1998. Dr. Sassone continued to attend on behalf of the District throughout the entire hearing. 2. During her testimony, Dr. Bryna Siegel agreed to Petitioner's request that she send to Petitioner's expert, Dr. Michael Jones, protocols for tests she had given to STUDENT. Accordingly, Petitioner requested that the record be left open in the event that he chose to call Dr. Jones as a final rebuttal witness. The Hearing Officer left the record open for this purpose, but Petitioner eventually did not to call Dr. Jones to testify. 3. The Hearing Officer has clarified Petitioner's statement of the issues. 4. While Dr. Siegel contends that the PARENTS knew that Heidi was going to examine STUDENT, the PARENTS contend that they were unaware that STUDENT was assessed during this visit. MOTHER testified that she thought Heidi was removing STUDENT from the room so that the adults could concentrate on their discussion without the distraction of watching after STUDENT. 5. The Regional Center had been scheduled to terminate its funding for STUDENT's in-home program on October 31, 1997. In fact, the Regional Center continued to partially fund STUDENT's in-home program until June 1998. 6. The District's offer in August 1997 included approximately 14 hours of preschool per week, while the offer in May 1998 provided for 20 hours per week. Additionally, the District's May 1998 offer provided more written details about the program being offered. In all other respects, the two offers were essentially the same in substance. Therefore, this Decision will discuss the offers together, and will distinguish between them only when a reason to do so exists. 7. Additionally, the Hearing Officer previously concluded that the District's offer of speech therapy was procedurally and substantively appropriate. In fact, the District attempted to arrange for STUDENT to receive speech therapy even if the parties could not agree on other services, but the PARENTS never responded to the District's efforts. (Testimony of Ms. Nicoll, Respondent's Exh. 28.) Thus, even if Petitioner had established that Ms. Bluma's speech therapy services were appropriate, other factors would weigh against reimbursement.
