California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 16, 2001

Student v. Sacramento City Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1158-01 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy

Sacramento City Unified wins: student with a learning disability is not eligible as emotionally disturbed, and placement claims are denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 12-year-old seventh grader filed for due process against Sacramento City Unified School District. Both sides agreed he was eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability. In December 2000, his mother placed him at Via Americana, a nonpublic school. He claimed he should also qualify as a child with an emotional disturbance. On that basis, he asked the Hearing Officer to order prospective placement at Via Americana. The parties agreed that if he was not emotionally disturbed, the other issues would not be decided. Student conceded that the District's special day class offer met his learning disability needs.

The Hearing Officer found that Student met none of the three emotional disturbance characteristics he claimed. First, he kept friendships with peers and teachers. His mother and his former teacher, Kathleen Goebel, both said he made friends easily. Second, his behavior problems did not occur "under normal circumstances." They came during repeated changes of home and school, a family move to a motel, and enrollment at a school that was not addressing his learning disability. During a stable period at Martin Luther King School, his behavior improved greatly. Third, he did not show a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. His sadness was tied to particular events, and his mother said he did not seem depressed. The Hearing Officer gave little weight to the nonpublic school's evaluation. All claims for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the "under normal circumstances" part of the emotional disturbance criteria. Misbehavior during major upheavals at home and school did not establish eligibility. Behavior that improved once the student was in a stable setting pointed away from emotional disturbance. A parent's own view of the child's mood and friendships carried significant weight.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance in the 2001-2002 school year?

    Student did not meet the criteria in 5 C.C.R. §3030(i)(2), (3) or (4). He kept friendships with peers and teachers. His behavior problems happened during abnormal circumstances, not normal ones. His sadness was tied to particular situations and was not a pervasive mood.

  2. Issue 2. If STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance, did the District offer him a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

    Not decided. The parties stipulated that this issue fell away if Student was found not eligible as emotionally disturbed. Student also conceded that the offer met his learning disability needs.

  3. Issue 3. If STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance is Via Americana, a certified NPS, an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?

    Not decided under the parties' stipulation, because Student was found not eligible as emotionally disturbed.

  4. Issue 4. Did Ms. Joy Robinson, an administrator at Via Americana, an NPS, advocate for STUDENT's placement at that school? If she did advocate for STUDENT, should her advocacy prohibit STUDENT's placement there?

    Not decided under the parties' stipulation, because Student was found not eligible as emotionally disturbed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. §1401(3)(A)(i); Cal. Ed. Code §56026; 5 C.C.R. §3030(i)

People named in the decision

  • Rebecca Bryant, Interim Administrator for Special Education, Sacramento City Unified School District
  • Lynne Yost, legal analyst, District legal office, Sacramento City Unified School District
  • Cynthia Smith, interim for District counsel, Sacramento City Unified School District
  • Joy Robinson, nonpublic school administrator; attended IEP meeting as a "friend", Via Americana
  • Patricia Webster, special day class teacher, nonpublic school, Via Americana
  • Nancy Veach, LCSW retained by Via Americana to assess for emotional disturbance, Via Americana
  • Kyla Volpis, part-time aide and clerk, nonpublic school, Via Americana
  • Mark Robinson, aide, nonpublic school, Via Americana
  • Kathleen Goebel, special day class teacher, Martin Luther King School, Sacramento City Unified School District
  • Christina McCarty, school psychologist, Sacramento City Unified School District
  • Jean Tracy, principal, Martin Luther King School, Sacramento City Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on August 21, and 22, September 12, 26, 27, and 28, and October 3, 2001, in Sacramento, California.

STUDENT (hereinafter “STUDENT” or “Petitioner”) was represented by attorney Frank J. Ferris. Also present on his behalf was his foster mother. Sacramento City Unified School District (hereinafter “District” or “Respondent”) was represented by attorney Diane Marshall-Freeman. Rebecca Bryant, the District’s Interim Administrator for Special Education, and, Lynne Yost, a legal analyst with the District’s legal office, were also present on behalf of the District. Cynthia Smith, an interim for Ms. Marshall-Freeman, was also present on behalf of the District.

The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. The parties submitted written closing arguments. The briefs, postmarked October 29, 2001, were received by the Hearing Officer on October 31, and the record was closed.

ISSUES(Footnotes 1)

1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance in the 2001-2002 school year?

2. If STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance, did the District offer him a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

3. If STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance is Via Americana, a certified NPS, an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?

4. Did Ms. Joy Robinson, an administrator at Via Americana, an NPS, advocate for STUDENT’s placement at that school? If she did advocate for STUDENT, should her advocacy prohibit STUDENT’s placement there?

POSITION OF THE PARTIES

STUDENT takes the position that he is eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance. STUDENT alleges that he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers or teachers, that he engages in inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations, and that he suffers from a general pervasive mood of unhappiness and depression. STUDENT takes the position that he has exhibited these characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, and that they adversely affect his educational performance. He also contends that the District did not offer him an appropriate program to address his emotional disability and, thus, denied him a FAPE. STUDENT asserts that Via Americana School meets his unique needs and requests that the Hearing Officer order prospective placement for him there. STUDENT’s mother does not seek reimbursement for past services at Via Americana because she was not obligated for any costs to that school.

The District contests Petitioner’s claim that he has an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers or teachers and suffers from a general pervasive mood of unhappiness and depression. The District also takes the position that while STUDENT has had behavior problems in the past, any inappropriate conduct he engaged in did not occur under normal circumstances. Specifically, the District contends that STUDENT’s misbehavior occurred when he was removed from his family for a two-year period, placed in a group home and in multiple foster placements, changed schools several times, and was forced to relocate to a motel for a period of time after eventually being reunited with his family. The District further takes the position that even if STUDENT is eligible as a child with an emotional disorder, its offered program constituted a FAPE by addressing his learning disabilities and related behavioral problems. Moreover, notwithstanding the adequacy of the District’s offered program, the District claims that Via Americana is not an adequate placement to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Neither party disputes the fact that STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability. Additionally, STUDENT concedes that if he does not qualify for special education as an emotionally disturbed child, the District’s offered program for the 2001-2002 school year was adequate to address his specific learning disability.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], was 12 years and 11 months at the time the hearing concluded. He presently lives with his mother and father and is the fourth child in a family of eight children. STUDENT currently resides in Sacramento and attends the seventh grade at Via Americana, a nonpublic school in the area.

STUDENT began school at Father K.B. Kenny Elementary School in the Sacramento City Unified School District. At that time, STUDENT lived at home with his parents and seven siblings. He attended Father Kenny from kindergarten until midway through his fourth grade year. In January 1997, while STUDENT was in the second grade at Father Kenny, he was assessed for special education services. The assessment indicated that STUDENT had learning difficulties related to perceptual and visual motor skills. The assessment also noted that STUDENT appeared to be functioning in the average range in the areas of socialization and self-help skills, but was below average in the area of communication skills. In August 1997, STUDENT was enrolled in special education as a student with a specific learning disability.

Toward the end of 1998 or in early 1999, halfway through his fourth grade year, STUDENT was separated from his parents and siblings. At that time, he was placed in a group home (licensed children’s institution). As a result of his relocation, STUDENT left Father Kenny School for Lisbon Elementary School, also in the Sacramento City School District. In January 1999, an IEP meeting was held at Lisbon School. The IEP team observed that STUDENT could be appropriate and pleasant, had friends and liked to talk, but that he had made little progress in academics. It also noted that he had behavior problems and was inconsistent with his homework. According to the last IEP document, past interventions for STUDENT included one and a half years of RSP services, individual counseling through “Visions,” and a half-day schedule due to his behavior problems. The IEP team identified STUDENT as having a specific learning disability with disorders noted in visual processing and sensory-motor skills. The team found that he had a significant discrepancy in his intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of basic reading, reading comprehension, written expression, and math calculation. STUDENT was also diagnosed at that time with ADHD. The IEP team placed him in a special day class with additional RSP services. The IEP team also selected a classroom management system as the appropriate intervention to deal with STUDENT’s behavior problems.

On April 26, 1999, a functional assessment analysis (FAA) was undertaken on STUDENT. The assessment indicated that STUDENT had engaged in assaultive and maladaptive behavior. Specifically, the FAA noted that STUDENT had assaulted peers, thrown desks, kicked a student in the stomach, was defiant, did not complete his school work, was out of his seat, talked out of turn, and kicked chairs. STUDENT had been suspended from school five times for a total of eighteen days. The assaults that led to the suspensions occurred during the afternoon recess and before school. The FAA also noted that STUDENT had attention problems as well as “daily difficulties” at the group home where he was staying. On May 6, 1999, an emergency behavior plan was implemented that called for STUDENT to receive home instruction.

Prior to September 1999, STUDENT was transferred to another foster family in Stockton, California. In Stockton, he was enrolled in the fifth grade at Adams Elementary School in the Stockton Unified School District for the 1999-2000 school year. In October 1999, STUDENT was reassessed by school officials in Stockton. The assessment included testing instruments pertaining to basic psychological processing impairments and learning disorders, as well as assessments to evaluate STUDENT’s behavior and emotional state. The latter assessment tools included the Connor’s Teacher Rating Scale– Revised, a human figure drawing analysis, interviews with teachers and parents, evaluators observations, and a review of school records. The assessment report noted that STUDENT’s teacher at Adams School described him as basically compliant as long as he maintained a structured and consistent schedule. The report also mentioned STUDENT’s learning and attention problems. It further noted that he was friendly toward others, but liked to “tattle” and pull others into confrontations. As a result, the assessor found that he did not maintain friendships long. While the assessment addressed behavior and emotional issues, the assessor did not identify any emotional disorders. In November 1999, the IEP team found that STUDENT had a specific learning disability and he was placed in a special day class.(Footnote 2)

In March 2000, while still in the fifth grade, STUDENT returned to Sacramento to yet another foster placement. His foster parent at this point was FOSTER PARENT. Upon returning to Sacramento, STUDENT was enrolled in Martin Luther King (MLK) School– a kindergarten through eighth grade school in the Sacramento City Unified School District. As an initial interim placement, STUDENT was placed in Ms. Kathleen Goebel’s special day class at MLK. On April 6, 2000, an IEP team met to determine STUDENT’s educational program. The team noted that STUDENT enjoyed sports and art, but that he was delayed in all areas of academics. The IEP team also indicated a concern over STUDENT’s “explosive behavior [in response] to instruction [that he] does not want to participate in.” The team agreed to place STUDENT in Ms. Goebel’s fifth grade special day class at MLK to address his specific learning disability.

In September 2000, STUDENT returned to Ms. Goebel’s special day class at MLK for his sixth grade year.(Footnote 3) At that point STUDENT was still living in a foster home with Ms. FOSTER PARENT. In late September or early October 2000, STUDENT was reunited with his mother, STUDENT’s mother, and his siblings. At or about that same time, STUDENT’s mother moved STUDENT to Kit Carson Middle School, STUDENT’s neighborhood school, which was also in the Sacramento City Unified School District. Shortly thereafter, Ms. Goebel contacted STUDENT’s mother and school officials at Carson regarding STUDENT’s educational welfare. By November 2000, STUDENT’s mother transferred STUDENT back to Ms. Goebel’s special day class at MLK.

In early December 2000, STUDENT’s mother removed STUDENT from MLK and enrolled him at Via Americana, an area nonpublic school that his brother also attended. In February 2001, the District assessed STUDENT for an emotional disturbance. The District psychologist, Ms. McCarty, concluded that STUDENT did not meet the applicable legal criteria for a child with an emotional disturbance. On March 29, 2001, an IEP team meeting was held. At the meeting, the District team members took the position that STUDENT did not suffer from an emotional disturbance and recommended that he remain in a special day class with a “positive behavior support plan” and behavioral goals and objectives. STUDENT’s mother and Joy Robinson, the administrator at Via Americana who also attended the IEP team meeting and signed the document as a “friend,” disagreed with the District’s recommendation. STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Robinson took the position that STUDENT was a child with an emotional disturbance and that he should be placed at Via Americana.

On February 15, 2001, STUDENT’s mother signed an authorization for a psychological assessment for STUDENT. An IEP meeting was convened on March 29, 2001, to review the results of the assessment. The District members of the IEP team took the position that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as an emotionally disturbed student and offered him a placement to address his specific learning disability. STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Robinson disagreed with the District’s position. On May 31, 2001, STUDENT’s mother requested a due process hearing to resolve the dispute regarding STUDENT’s eligibility as a child with an emotional disturbance. On August 28, 2001, prior to commencement of the pending due process hearing, another IEP meeting was convened and the District recommended placement for STUDENT in a special day class at the District’s Einstein Middle School to address his specific learning disability.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance in the 2001-2002 school year?

Applicable Law

A child is eligible for special education services if he suffers from an emotional disturbance. (20 U.S.C. §1401(3(A)(i); Cal. Ed. Code §56026.) Title 5 C.C.R. §3030(i) specifically sets forth the criteria for determining when a pupil is eligible for special education with an emotional disturbance:

(i) Because of a serious emotional disturbance, a pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance: (1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

In short, for a student to be eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance, the Hearing Officer must find that the child exhibited one or more of five enumerated characteristics. If the evidence supports a finding that the child exhibited one or more of the specified characteristics, the Hearing Officer must then determine whether the exhibited characteristic occurred over a long period of time, to a marked degree, and adversely affected the pupil educational performance. In this case, Petitioner put into issue three of the characteristics set forth in C.C.R. §3030(i), subparagraphs (2), (3), and (4). In his clarification of the issues, Petitioner specifically conceded that he was not claiming to exhibit the characteristics described under subparagraphs (1) and (5).

Evidentiary Analysis (1) An Inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers or teachers:

Patricia Webster, STUDENT’s special day class teacher at Via Americana, testified that STUDENT could be a friend one moment and hostile the next moment. She observed that he does not work well with others. But Ms. Webster pointed out that she was able to talk with STUDENT and that he would discuss baseball and current events with her. Ms. Nancy Veach, an LCSW retained by Via Americana to assess STUDENT for an emotional disturbance, testified that he does not develop relationships with peers because he tends to withdraw from others. But Ms. Veach did not give any specific information regarding STUDENT’s alleged inability to build or maintain interpersonal relationships with peers or teachers.

In contrast, Ms. Volpis, a part-time aide at Via Americana, testified that she and another aide, Mark Robinson, get along well with STUDENT. She added that STUDENT has a lot of respect for Mr. Robinson. Ms. Goebel, STUDENT’s special day class teacher at MLK between March and June of 2000, and again for most of the fall 2000 school term, testified that STUDENT had many friends and easily built relationships. She said that STUDENT liked being with the other children, particularly when they played basketball. Ms. Goebel recalled how STUDENT would coach and encourage other children in sports, and how he would applaud others when they helped win a game. She observed that he had a good smile, said she liked him personally, and believed that he liked her. At the end of his fifth grade year at MLK, STUDENT even asked Ms. Goebel if she would be back the following year.

STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT’s mother, said that STUDENT gets along with all of his friends, many of whom he has had since kindergarten. She testified that she did not see STUDENT as having a problem developing friendships.

Thus, while STUDENT’s behavior put off friends and peers at times, it seems clear that he continued to maintain friendships with peers and teachers alike. STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT’s mother, is in the best position to evaluate STUDENT’s ability to build and maintain friendships. She was firm in her statement that he had many friends and has maintained those friendships since early childhood. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not support a finding that STUDENT has an inability to build and maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers as set forth under C.C.R. §3030(i)(2).

(2) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances

Ms. Webster, Ms. Robinson, Ms. Veach, and STUDENT’s mother testified in support of STUDENT’s claim that he exhibited inappropriate types of behaviors and feelings under normal circumstances. Ms. Webster testified that since STUDENT was placed at Via Americana she has observed him to be distracted by other students or classroom noise. She stated that when STUDENT gets frustrated he tends to “strike out.” She described how STUDENT used curse words, refused to work, and on one occasion threw a chair when he became frustrated. Ms. Webster said that STUDENT’s behavior occurred in the classroom as well as the playground at Via Americana. She explained that STUDENT would get angry at his classmates if they performed poorly in a sporting event or got too close to him. Ms. Webster added that STUDENT’s behavior was so bad when he arrived at Via Americana that he was unable to do anything.

Ms Robinson, Via Americana’s administrator, described STUDENT as “explosive and volatile.” She testified that he became angry over minor incidents and that his demeanor ranged from “pleasant to out-of-control.” Ms. Kyla Volpis, Ms. Robinson’s daughter as well as a part-time aide and part-time clerk at Via Americana, testified that she had observed STUDENT “exploding over minor incidents.” She testified that she observed him yell out in class, curse, threaten other students, kick chairs, and throw books and papers. Ms. Volpis described STUDENT as “aggressive and volatile.” She noted that he behaved this way all day long when he first arrived at Via Americana, but he has improved to the extent that the behavior only occurs two to four times a day.

In her report, Ms. Veach broadly concluded that STUDENT exhibited inappropriate types of behaviors and feelings under normal circumstances. She also noted in her report that STUDENT lacked basic coping skills and that his behaviors have included property destruction and acts of violence against peers. Ms. Veach did not provide any examples of STUDENT’s behavior in her report, and she admitted in her testimony that she had not personally observed his aggressive or destructive behavior. She also stated that she did not obtain records or input from STUDENT’s mother or his teachers at Via Americana and the District when she conducted her evaluation of him. Ms. Veach indicated, however, that she had learned of STUDENT’s behavior at home and at Via Americana from STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Robinson. She testified that her evaluation of STUDENT was based on a one-hour evaluation during which she met with STUDENT personally. Ms. Veach pointed out that she also had had opportunities to meet with STUDENT in counseling therapy both before and after his enrollment at Via Americana, but she did not articulate any instances where she observed him destroy property or act aggressively.

STUDENT’s mother stated that she had observed STUDENT at home, at Father Kinney School, at MLK, and at Via Americana. She explained how STUDENT would joke with others but could not take a joke himself. She also described how STUDENT would fight with his brother and engage others in name-calling or pushing if they stepped on his toes. She added that STUDENT was a challenge at any given moment and difficult to control. Perhaps most illuminating of all was STUDENT’s mother’s assessment as to the source of STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties. She believed that his problem was due to the fact that he had such difficulty with his academics. STUDENT’s mother related that STUDENT acted out when he became frustrated at his inability to do school work. In her opinion, STUDENT would not act out if he did not have so much difficulty with his school work.

Ms. McCarty, Dr. Tracy, and Ms. Goebel testified for the District regarding STUDENT’s behaviors and feelings. Ms. Christina McCarty, a school psychologist for the District, assessed STUDENT for an emotional disturbance. Her evaluation included interviews with STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Robinson. Ms. McCarty reported that STUDENT’s mother told her that STUDENT has a temper, and engages in name-calling and hitting. STUDENT’s mother also explained to Ms. McCarty that STUDENT liked to tease but gets angry if others tease him. Ms. McCarty testified that Ms. Robinson told her that STUDENT became angry and refused to work when a new academic concept was introduced, but that once he grasped it he was all right. Ms. McCarty noted that Ms. Robinson did not share with her that STUDENT was out of control, aggressive, explosive, or volatile. She testified that Ms. Robinson also did not inform her that STUDENT acted out several times a day for two to four hours at a time.

Dr. Jean Tracy, the principal at MLK, testified that she was familiar with the children at her school, including STUDENT. She recalled that when STUDENT first arrived at MLK in March of 2000, he wanted to test the system. She said he acted out a few times the first couple of weeks but the incidents were minor. She described a pushing episode on the playground as well as some examples of verbal conflicts during ball games on the playground. Dr. Tracy stated that STUDENT’s conduct at MLK was not unusual for a new student who wanted to test the rules, but that after a couple of weeks his behavior improved. Dr. Tracy noted that for the most part STUDENT was not a behavior problem. She explained that he was not verbally abusive, did not use curse words with adults, and did not walk out of class. Dr. Tracy testified that she was able to talk to STUDENT about his choices and discuss options with him. She added that he came up with the right answers.

Ms. Goebel, STUDENT’s special day class teacher at MLK, provided specific information regarding STUDENT’s conduct in her class and at MLK. She testified that when STUDENT arrived at MLK he exhibited behavior problems. Ms. Goebel articulated how over the course of his first 10 days in her class, STUDENT acted out on four occasions. She related that on these four occasions STUDENT shouted inappropriately and on one occasion tipped over a chair. Ms. Goebel said that each episode lasted about five minutes. She also recounted that STUDENT twice pushed another student in a threatening manner. One of these incidents occurred on the basketball court, and STUDENT was suspended for his conduct. Ms. Goebel testified convincingly that after an initial ten-day transition, STUDENT’s behavior improved greatly. She stated that by April STUDENT was no longer a behavior problem. Ms. Goebel testified that STUDENT followed expectations in her class, was respectful to her, never cursed, and seemed happy in school. STUDENT also indicated to Ms. Goebel that he liked his most recent foster parent, Ms. FOSTER PARENT, with whom he had come to live when he returned to Sacramento from Stockton in March.

Ms. Goebel testified that when STUDENT returned to her class after the summer break in September of 2000, he was still living with Ms. FOSTER PARENT. Ms. Goebel stated that STUDENT seemed happy and was well-behaved in school. She explained that sometime in September STUDENT was reunited with his mother and siblings. At that point, his mother, STUDENT’s mother, moved him to Kit Carson Middle School. After a few weeks, STUDENT returned to Ms. Goebel’s class at MLK. According to Ms. Goebel’s observations, STUDENT still seemed happy at school and was not a behavior problem. Ms. Goebel then explained that in November or December 2000, near the end of STUDENT’s stay at MLK, he began to appear unhappy. She also described how STUDENT at that time stood up from his chair a couple of times and shouted, “this class is stupid” and “I don’t have to do this.” Ms. Goebel spoke with STUDENT regarding his change in attitude and conduct. She testified that STUDENT explained to her that he was very unhappy because his family had to move out of their home and live in a motel.

There is no question that STUDENT has engaged in episodes of misbehavior and has exhibited feelings of anger. To the extent that STUDENT’s misbehavior and feelings of anger can be deemed inappropriate, the question for the Hearing Officer is whether his behavior occurred under normal circumstances. (See C.C.R. §3030(i)(3).)

In this case, the record indicates that STUDENT did not exhibit inappropriate feelings or behavior during his first three grades of elementary school at Father Kinney. According to his report cards, he respected others as well as school rules. (See District Exhibit 2, pp. 6-8.) When STUDENT was in the fourth grade, he was removed from his parents and family and placed in a group home; he was also transferred to Lisbon School. At this point, the record reflects that his behavior took an abrupt turn for the worse. His report card and IEP at Lisbon School indicate a marked increase in behavior problems. (District Exhibit 2, p. 5; Exhibits 19-20.) Thus, the evidence indicates that STUDENT reacted adversely to a significantly negative circumstance–his abrupt removal from his home, placement in a group home, and change of schools.

While in the fourth grade at Lisbon School, STUDENT was placed on home-schooling while living at the group home. By the beginning of his fifth grade year, STUDENT was moved to another foster home in a new city–Stockton– and enrolled in yet another school–Adams Elementary. STUDENT’s teacher at Adams reported that STUDENT had a short attention span, poor memory skills, occasionally refused to work, and showed defiance. (District Exhibit 9, p. 70.) STUDENT’s misbehavior again occurred at a time when he was away from his family and forced to change schools and move in with a new foster parent in a new city–certainly not a normal circumstance. Moreover, the psychoeducational assessment conducted by Stockton noted the relationship between some of STUDENT’s off-task and defiant behavior and his learning disability and his ADHD. (District Exhibit 9, p. 70.)

Within several months of STUDENT’s being moved to Stockton, he was placed in yet another foster home, moved back to Sacramento, and enrolled in a new school–MLK. During his first couple of weeks at MLK, STUDENT engaged in several acts of defiance and misbehavior as described above by his teacher, Ms. Goebel, and his principal, Dr. Tracy. But, again, STUDENT’s behaviors and expressions of defiance and anger were not displayed under normal circumstances. By the time STUDENT arrived at MLK in March of his fifth grade year, he had been removed from his family, placed in three foster or group homes, attended four elementary schools (Father Kenny, Lisbon, Adams, and MLK), and lived two cities, all in little more than a year. Once STUDENT adjusted to the apparent stability of Ms. FOSTER PARENT’s home and the structure of Ms. Goebel’s class at MLK, his behaviors improved markedly. Between April and November 2000, except for a pushing incident in a basketball game, there is no evidence of any significant inappropriate behavior or feelings of anger by STUDENT while he was attending MLK. Thus, it is reasonable to infer that under relatively more normal circumstances, STUDENT’s behavior was appropriate for his age. The conclusion is supported by the fact that when STUDENT was yet again thrust into an abnormal situation–removal of his family from their home to a motel room–he began to display some degree of unhappiness and anger. Again, not surprising under the circumstances.

While Ms. Webster, Ms. Robinson, and Ms. Volpis testified that STUDENT displayed more severe feelings of anger and engaged in more significant acts of misbehavior at Via Americana than that reported by his teacher and principal at MLK, they did not record any specific incidents. Nor was STUDENT’s conduct at Via Americana reported to Ms. McCarty when she interviewed the staff there for STUDENT’s emotional evaluation. However, to the extent that STUDENT did display any inappropriate behaviors and feelings at Via Americana, it appears they did not occur under normal circumstances. First, STUDENT was moved to Via Americana during the same period of time that his family was displaced from their home to a motel. And this displacement occurred within only a few weeks of his being reunited with his family after a succession of foster home placements. Second, Via Americana was the fifth school that STUDENT had attended in less than two years. Neither of these circumstances is normal.

Additionally, Ms. Webster’s testimony established that she was not familiar with processing disorders and specific learning disabilities. She also testified that she was not familiar with STUDENT’s particular processing disorders and his associated learning disability. As a result, she had not designed and implemented strategies and interventions especially designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs (specific learning disability). Placement in a program that did not address STUDENT’s specific learning disability also created a situation that was not normal. STUDENT’s had been diagnosed with a specific learning disability in the second grade. At Via Americana, and for the first time since he was eligible for special education services, STUDENT’s specific learning disability needs were not being addressed. Ms. Robinson told Ms. McCarty that STUDENT became angry and refused to work when a new academic concept was introduced, but that once he grasped it he was all right. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT’s feelings and behavior were a result of his difficulty with academics. She opined that STUDENT acted out when he became frustrated at his inability to do school work, and believed that STUDENT would not act out if he did not have so many difficulties with his schoolwork. In short, the fact that STUDENT’s specific learning disability is not addressed at Via Americana is also not a normal circumstance. To the extent that he exhibits inappropriate feelings and behaviors at Via Americana, these have not occurred under normal circumstances.

Thus, while STUDENT has exhibited inappropriate feelings and behaviors at both MLK and Via Americana, those feelings and behaviors were not exhibited under normal circumstances. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance based on inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations as set forth under C.C.R. §3030(i)(3). (3) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness and depression

Ms. Webster testified that STUDENT appeared to be sad or depressed sometimes and happy and charming at other times. She noted that in a second he would slip back into what she described as a depressed state. Ms. Webster explained that her assessment of STUDENT’s emotional condition was based on her observations as a lay person and that she had no expertise in diagnosing mental or emotional disorders. Ms. Veach’s report concluded that STUDENT exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness and depression, but she did not expound on her diagnosis. In testimony, she stated that she was not qualified to do a psychological evaluation and that her evaluation was not meant as such.

Ms. Volpis and Ms. Robinson both testified that STUDENT could be happy one moment and sad or angry the next. Ms. Robinson added that STUDENT was pleasant most of the time. Ms. Volpis gave examples of how STUDENT would clap and cheer for another student when he did well. Ms. McCarty testified that STUDENT told her during her evaluation of him that he was very happy. Dr. Tracy stated that STUDENT was a happy student and was involved with other children. Ms. Goebel observed that STUDENT was generally happy and made friends easily, and he only became sad when his family had to move to a motel. She did not describe his sadness over the situation as being a general pervasive mood of unhappiness and depression. Ms. Goebel noted that his sadness was situational to the event.

Most importantly, STUDENT’s mother, who was in the best position to assess STUDENT’s emotional state, testified that STUDENT did not appear depressed to her and that she did not see depression as a problem for STUDENT. Moreover, the testimony of teachers and staff at both schools indicate that STUDENT’s mood was situational to the circumstance and not pervasive.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not support a finding that STUDENT exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness and depression as set forth under C.C.R. §3030(i)(4).

Issue Number 2: If STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance, did the District offer him a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year?

As a result of a stipulation entered into by the parties at hearing, the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance removes this issue from consideration.

Issue Number 3: If STUDENT is eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance is Via Americana, a certified NPS, an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year?

As a result of a stipulation entered into by the parties at hearing, the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance removes this issue from consideration.

Issue Number 4: Did Ms. Joy Robinson, an administrator at Via Americana, an NPS, advocate for STUDENT’s placement at that school? If she did advocate for STUDENT, should her advocacy prohibit STUDENT’s placement there?

As a result of a stipulation entered into by the parties at hearing, the Hearing Officer’s finding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance removes this issue from consideration.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statue:

The District prevailed on all of the issues that were heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).)

Date: November 16, 2001 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The parties stipulated that if the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance, the Hearing Officer would not be required to rule on issues 2, 3,and 4. The Petitioner agreed that the District’s offered program met STUDENT’s unique needs as it related to his learning disability.

2. In contrast to Sacramento’s findings in 1997, Stockton found that STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder and manifested severe discrepancies between intellectual ability and academic achievement in the areas of written expression, mathematics reasoning, and mathematics calculation.

3. Ms. Goebel’s special day class at MLK was a combination fifth and sixth grade class. While STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT’s mother, testified that STUDENT repeated the sixth grade at MLK, the records indicate that he completed the fifth grade at MLK in the spring of 2000 after transferring to Sacramento from Stockton, and that he began the fall 2000-2001 school term at MLK in the sixth grade.