California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 17, 2004

Student v. Las Virgenes Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1160-04, SN-1160-04 · Hearing Officer Roberta M. Ward

Las Virgenes Unified prevails as Hearing Officer finds eighth grader with ADD not eligible and denies residential reimbursement.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 14-year-old eighth grader filed against Las Virgenes Unified School District after the district found him not eligible for special education. He had been diagnosed with attention deficit disorder (ADD) years earlier. In 2003-2004 he failed most of his classes at A.E. Wright Middle School and had many discipline incidents. His parents then sent him to a wilderness camp and later to Discovery Academy, a residential treatment center in Utah. They asked for eligibility based on emotional disturbance or other health impairment. They also sought reimbursement for private assessments and placements, plus a prospective residential placement.

Hearing Officer Roberta M. Ward ruled for the district on every issue. She found no child find violation. The district had no record of earlier problems, his first semester was unremarkable, and the district assessed him after a March 2004 student study team meeting. The IEP meeting was one day late, but she called that de minimis, partly because the parents had asked to postpone it. The student met none of the emotional disturbance criteria. Teachers described a capable, popular student. His worst behaviors came during medication changes and lasted less than six months. ADD did limit his alertness and hurt his schoolwork. Still, he was not eligible as other health impaired, because modifications and accommodations in general education could meet his needs. Assessment reimbursement was denied because the parents got their assessments before the district finished its own. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This shows how SEHO separated a qualifying condition from eligibility. ADD was found to affect the student's schoolwork, but he still did not qualify, because general education accommodations could meet his needs. The decision also treated behavior during medication changes as not occurring under "normal circumstances." It denied reimbursement for private assessments obtained before the district's assessments were finished.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedChild find

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to identify and assess Petitioner for special education (child find) and to provide him a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year?

    The district had no notice of past problems and the first semester was unremarkable, so assessing after the March 2004 student study team meeting met its child find duty. The IEP meeting was one day late, but the Hearing Officer called this de minimis and partly caused by a parent-requested postponement. No FAPE was owed in 2003-2004.

  2. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 2A. Did the District improperly determine that Petitioner was not eligible for special education and thus fail to offer and provide a FAPE during 2004-2005? Eligibility as emotionally disturbed

    The student met none of the five emotional disturbance criteria. He could learn, kept good relationships with peers and teachers, and showed no pervasive depression or physical symptoms. His most inappropriate behaviors happened during medication changes, so not under normal circumstances, and lasted less than six months.

  3. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 2B. Did the District improperly determine that Petitioner was not eligible for special education and thus fail to offer and provide a FAPE during 2004-2005? Eligibility as other health impaired based on ADD

    ADD limited the student's alertness and hurt his educational performance. He was still not eligible as other health impaired, because general education with modifications and accommodations could meet his needs.

  4. Issue 3. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments conducted by speech and language pathologist Karen Schnee and psychologist Jonathan Greene?

    No reimbursement. The parents got private assessments in April 2004, before the district finished its own assessments, so they did not obtain them because they disagreed with a district assessment. There was also no child find violation.

  5. Issue 4. Are Petitioner's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational placements and services provided during the 2003-2004 school year and the 2004-2005 school year to date?

    The student was not eligible for special education, so the parents were not entitled to reimbursement. A footnote also noted there was no evidence that Discovery Academy met his needs.

  6. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5. In order to receive a FAPE, does Petitioner require a prospective placement for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year in a residential program at a certified NPS?

    The student was not eligible for special education, so he was not entitled to a FAPE or to a prospective residential placement.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Capistrano Unified School Dist. v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884 (9th Cir. 1995); Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Student v. Napa Valley Unified School District, SN 02-01815 (SEHO 2003); Manhattan Beach U.S.D., SN-1313-99 (SEHO 1999); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300, 56302, 56329(b), 56339(a)

People named in the decision

  • Mary Schillinger, director of pupil services, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Jonathan Greene, private psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Karen Schnee, private speech-language pathologist/educational therapist; independent assessor and witness for Student, Private
  • Patti Koss, private behavior consultant; classroom observer and witness for Student, Private
  • Trisha Kane, resource specialist; academic assessor, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Ankie Jansen, special education assistant, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Anne Leslie, speech and language pathologist; assessor, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Angi Harris, school psychologist; assessor, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Bob Robbins, science teacher, A.E. Wright Middle School
  • Gayle Unzueta, drama teacher, A.E. Wright Middle School
  • Robert Elliott, licensed psychologist; expert witness for District, School psychologist, Redondo Beach Unified School District; consultant
  • Mr. Holland, school counselor, A.E. Wright Middle School
  • Thomas Locke, private psychologist (therapy), Private
  • Ed Jesalva, private psychiatrist, Private
  • Steve Rosentsweig, principal, A.E. Wright Middle School
  • Discovery Academy, residential treatment center/nonpublic school (not California-certified), Provo, Utah, Private
  • Odyssey wilderness camp, private wilderness program, Washington state, Private
  • Pinecrest Middle School, private school attended in grades 6–7, Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Roberta M. Ward, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Calabasas, California on October 13 and 14 and November 3 through 5, 2004.

STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Adam Michael Sacks. Present on behalf of STUDENT were his MOTHER (Footnote 1), and his FATHER. Respondent Las Virgenes Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Wesley B. Parsons from the law firm Lozano Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf was Mary Schillinger, director of pupil services.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Jonathan Greene, psychologist; Karen Schnee, speech pathologist; Patti Koss, behaviorist; FAMILY FRIEND, teacher; MOTHER; and FATHER.

The District called the following witnesses: Trisha Kane, resource specialist; Ankie Jansen, special education assistant; Anne Leslie, speech and language pathologist; Angi Harris, school psychologist; Bob Robbins, teacher; Gayle Unzueta, teacher; and Robert Elliott, psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of written closing arguments on November 15, 2004, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

1. Did the District fail to identify and assess Petitioner for special education (child-find) and to provide him a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2003-2004 school year?

2. Did the District improperly determine that Petitioner was not eligible for special education and thus fail to offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year?

3. Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments conducted by speech and language pathologist Karen Schnee and psychologist Jonathan Greene?

4. Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational placements and services provided to Petitioner during the 2003-2004 school year and the 2004-2005 school year to date?

5. In order to receive a FAPE, does Petitioner require a prospective placement for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year in a residential program at a certified non-public school (NPS)?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner is seeking a determination that he is eligible for special education services on the basis of an emotional disturbance (ED) and/or other health impairment (OHI) based on an attention deficit disorder (ADD). Petitioner contends that the District responded to his special educational needs by a pattern of repeated suspensions and thus failed in its duty to identify and assess him for special education while he was an eighth grade student at A.E. Wright Middle School. Petitioner also contends that his enrollment in a summer “boot camp”/wilderness program and subsequently in a residential treatment facility/nonpublic school was necessary to respond to his escalating dangerous behaviors, and that the District is obligated under special education law to pay for these services.

The District contends that Petitioner is not eligible for special education services. The District asserts that Petitioner has a conduct disorder and is socially maladjusted. According to the District, Petitioner did not demonstrate signs of emotional disturbance at school and his test scores and school grades do not support a finding of an attention deficit disorder.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old boy who currently attends Discovery Academy in Provo, Utah, a nonpublic school that is not certified by the State of California. Discovery Academy is a residential treatment center that provides counseling and therapy services as well as educational and academic services.

Prior to being sent to the Discovery Academy by his parents, STUDENT lived at home with his two siblings and his parents. From the age of two years through first grade, STUDENT was enrolled in a private school by his parents. He entered Round Meadow Elementary School, a public school in Calabasas, in the Las Virgenes Unified School District, in second grade and remained there through the fifth grade. In October 1997, STUDENT was diagnosed as having an attention deficit disorder (ADD) by his pediatrician and began taking medications to address this condition. STUDENT was evaluated in public school for learning disabilities twice, in 1998 and 2000, and found not eligible for special education on that basis. He did receive special education services for an articulation speech disorder in the 2000-2001 school year.

STUDENT was enrolled by his parents in Pinecrest Middle School, a private school, for sixth and seventh grades. At Pinecrest, STUDENT obtained B and C grades, and was evaluated “excellent” in work habits and citizenship in the second semester of the 2002-2003 school year. For the 2003-2004 school year, he was enrolled as an eighth grade student at A.E. Wright Middle School in the Las Virgenes Unified School District. While at A.E. Wright, STUDENT had a series of suspensions for disruptive behaviors. There were 32 separate incidents of discipline recorded at A.E. Wright, resulting in eight separate suspensions for a cumulative total of ten days. At A.E. Wright, STUDENT received failing grades in language arts, math, science and social science, a D in physical education, and a C in beginning drama.

Because of continuing discipline issues at A.E. Wright, STUDENT was referred in November 2003 by his school counselor, Mr. Holland, to a private psychologist, Dr. Thomas Locke. STUDENT saw Dr. Locke for weekly therapy. Dr. Locke referred STUDENT to a psychiatrist named Dr. Ed Jesalva. Dr. Jesalva saw STUDENT initially on February 16, 2004. For STUDENT’s escalating disruptive behavior in school, and for what Dr. Jesalva described as STUDENT’s depression and anxiety, he prescribed varying dosages of Paxil, Metadate, and Depakote ER. At about this time, STUDENT’s behavior appeared to worsen. From September 2003 through February 18, 2004, STUDENT had eight recorded disciplinary incidents at A.E. Wright. Between February 23 and May 28, 2004, there were 24 separate discipline notations. Dr. Jesalva noted that STUDENT’s symptoms worsened under the drug regimen prescribed, with an increase in aggressiveness and impulsivity, both at home and at school. The parents reported that STUDENT was found in the park in the middle of the night, hiding in the bushes, and that he had made suicidal gestures.

On March 18, 2004, a student study team meeting was held to address STUDENT’s behavioral and academic problems at A.E. Wright. Teachers complained that STUDENT was missing assignments, disengaging during class activities, and had poor academic skills. The recommendation was for a full evaluation by a school psychologist. On or about March 30, 2004, the District’s assessment plan was sent to the parents for signature. However, the parents did not receive it. Subsequently, a second assessment notice was sent on April 22, 2004, which the parents returned on April 23, 2004, agreeing to the assessment plan. In the interim, the parents had arranged for their own assessment of STUDENT. On April 14, 19, and 22, he was tested by Karen Schnee, speech/language pathologist, who administered a battery of tests, including the Woodcock Johnson III, cognitive and achievement tests. On April 20, 2004, a behavior consultant, Patti Koss, observed STUDENT in the school setting for two and a quarter hours at the parent’s request. STUDENT was also evaluated by a psychologist, Dr. Jonathan Greene. In April and May, 2004, STUDENT was assessed for special education by Las Virgenes staff, namely, Anne Leslie, speech and language pathologist, Trisha Kane, resource specialist, and Angi Harris, school psychologist. An IEP team meeting to analyze and discuss the results of the District assessment was scheduled for June 4, 2004, but FATHER was not able to attend. The meeting was then postponed to the beginning of the next school year, and held on September 3, 2004.

Because of escalating behaviors at home, and on the advice of a family friend who is a teacher, the parents sent STUDENT to the Odyssey wilderness camp in Washington state at the end of the school year. They then enrolled him at the Discovery Academy in Provo, Utah, a residential treatment center.

At the September 3, 2004 IEP team meeting, the District staff determined that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services. The parents disagreed with that determination and filed for the instant hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District fail to identify and assess Petitioner for special education (child find) and to provide him a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2003-2004 school year?

STUDENT contends that he is eligible for special education on the basis of ED and/or OHI. He contends that the District should have assessed him during the first semester of the school year when he was an eighth grade student at A.E. Wright, because of his disruptive behaviors in school and failing academics.

Pursuant to State and federal law, school districts are required “to systematically seek out” all persons under the age of 22 who reside within their boundaries and have exceptional educational needs. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56300; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)). To implement this “child find” obligation, “(e)ach district, special education local plan area, or county office shall provide for the identification and assessment of an individual’s exceptional needs, and the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56302.)

Petitioner contends that the assessments done by the District were late in the school year and only undertaken after his escalation of behavioral problems was impossible to ignore. Petitioner also contends that the District had to be compelled to act by repeated parent complaints and demands, and that the original reaction of the District, through the counselor, Mr. Holland, was to refer the parents to an outside psychologist. Further, Petitioner complains that the District was not taking remedial measures to help him and concentrated mainly on punitive responses to his misbehaviors. The District argues that it fulfilled its child find obligations, was not obligated to assess Petitioner prior to the SST meeting in March 2004, and then timely and appropriately assessed Petitioner for special education, finding him ineligible.

The documentary evidence does not indicate that the District had knowledge of STUDENT’S past history of behavioral or academic problems. STUDENT transferred from Pinecrest Middle School, where he had attended sixth and seventh grades. STUDENT’S transcript showed fairly good grades and satisfactory to excellent citizenship and work habits. (District’s Exhibit 1.) On his Student Registration Form, STUDENT’S parents answered in the negative to the question of whether STUDENT had ever been in a special education program. (District’s Exhibit 3.)

While both parents testified that they repeatedly were in contact with the school regarding STUDENT’S failing academics and school disciplinary problems, there is no documentary evidence that a special education assessment was ever requested by the parents, orally or in writing. This is particularly significant because MOTHER admitted that she was familiar with the special education process from STUDENT’S elementary school experience and had attended IEP team meetings. The Hearing Officer also finds that there was nothing remarkable in STUDENT’S performance during the first semester at A.E. Wright to alert the District to the need for a special education assessment. STUDENT’S disciplinary record from the first semester has only six notations and no suspensions. Regarding his academics the first semester, STUDENT received two Ds, one B, and three Fs. The teachers’ notations were “working below performance standards,” “homework not completed,” “tests not made,” and “low test scores.”

It is reasonable that a large middle school might need one semester of acquaintance with a new student to recognize the need for an assessment. As STUDENT’S poor academic performance continued, STUDENT’S parents were sent a warning notice in February 2004 that STUDENT might not graduate from middle school. (District’s Exhibit 5.) The SST meeting was scheduled on March 19, 2004, at which STUDENT’S teachers appeared. Their reports as noted on the SST summary form were that STUDENT was missing assignments, had low test scores, a difficult time in class, and poor basic academic skills. The concerns noted were that STUDENT would not graduate, had poor basic skills, and problem behavior. It was the team’s recommendation at that time that the District do a full evaluation. It is noteworthy that when the SST meeting was finally held on March 19, 2004, the notation under “parent input” is that the parent was asking for modifications. There is no mention of special education.

Once the team recommendation was made, STUDENT’S parents were alerted by a notice on March 22, 2004, that they would receive an assessment plan within 15 days. (District’s Exhibit 9.) From testimony and documentary evidence, it appears that the first assessment plan was sent to the parents on approximately March 30, 2004. (District’s Exhibits 30 and 31.) The parents testified that they did not receive the form. Subsequently, a second form was sent on April 22, 2004, signed and returned to the District by the parents on April 23, 2004. During April and May 2004, STUDENT was assessed by District personnel. On May 24, 2004, the parents were sent a notice by the District of an IEP team meeting scheduled for June 4, 2004, but FATHER indicated that he would be unable to attend and asked to reschedule the meeting. By that time, he had hired an attorney and indicated that his attorney would be attending the meeting. (District’s Exhibit 16.) District staff testified that they could not reschedule the IEP team meeting until the following September, as there were only a few days left of the school year. The District finally convened the IEP team meeting on September 3, 2004. Under the law, the District has 50 days, excluding school vacations in excess of 5 days, from receipt of the signed Assessment Plan to hold an IEP team meeting. As the 2003-2004 school year ended on June 10, and the 2004-2005 school year reconvened on September 1, 2004, 50 days from April 23, 2004, not counting the summer vacation, would be September 2, 2004. (District’s Exhibit 33.) Thus, the District was late by one day in convening the IEP team meeting. This was a de minimis violation caused, in part, by the cancellation of the first scheduled IEP team meeting, at the parents’ request.

On this basis, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not violate its child find obligations under the law with regard to the assessment of STUDENT. Further, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not have an obligation to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year, as the IEP team meeting to determine STUDENT’S eligibility for special education did not occur until the 2004-2005 school year.

2. Did the District improperly determine that Petitioner was not eligible for special education and thus fail to offer and provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year?

To be eligible for special education, a student must be identified as a child with a disability as defined in Title 20 U.S.C., section 1401 (3)(A), and by reason thereof, require instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Qualifying disabilities include emotional disturbance (ED) and other health impairments (OHI), as long as the student needs special education and related services because of these conditions. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7 (a)(1).)

At the IEP team meeting held on September 3, 2004, it was determined by District staff that STUDENT is ineligible for special education. Petitioner disputes this finding and contends that he is eligible as an ED student and/or as OHI.

A. Eligibility for Special Education as Emotionally Disturbed

To be eligible for special education as ED, a student must exhibit one or more of the following characteristics, over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:

(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors.

(2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.

(3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations.

(4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

34 C.F.R. § 300.7 (b)(9)(i); Cal. Code Reg. Tit. 5 § 3030 (i).

The student does not meet special education eligibility criteria as ED if the student is socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that the student has a serious emotional disturbance. (34 C.F.R. § 300.7 (b)(9)(ii).)

Petitioner argues that he meets all five criteria for eligibility for special education as an ED student. Each criterion will be discussed below.

(1) Did Petitioner exhibit an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors?

Petitioner argues that because he failed almost all his courses at A.E.Wright, he was not learning. However, the teachers and counselors who testified gave the unanimous opinion that STUDENT was capable of learning. Mr. Robbins, STUDENT’S science teacher, who was Las Virgenes teacher of the year, testified that STUDENT was capable of average to above average work when he chose to do the assignments. In particular, he pointed to a series of laboratory assignments in which STUDENT’S performance varied widely. According to Mr. Robbins, STUDENT did a great job on his second assignment, mastered the early labs, and turned in reports that were very well done, even in some difficult labs in chemistry. STUDENT was selective on what he chose to do or not to do, repeating those labs which he enjoyed over and over again. It was Mr. Robbins’ opinion that as so long as STUDENT was engaged, he could learn. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’S grades on his science assignments over the 2003-2004 school year included ten As, seven Bs, ten Cs, three Ds and forty-one Fs. Of the forty-one F grades, all but eight were for not doing the assignment at all. (District’s Exhibit 32.) Mr. Robbins testified that he asked STUDENT early in the second semester why he was not turning in his work, when STUDENT stopped doing homework in his science class. STUDENT’S response was that if he failed, he could go into special education.

Ms. Unzueta, STUDENT’S drama teacher, similarly testified that STUDENT could do well in her class, which required the skills of reading comprehension and writing. STUDENT received a B+ in the first and third quarters of the school year, with a final grade of C. Ms. Unzueta explained that STUDENT put in less effort for the last quarter of the school year. The Hearing Officer finds the teachers’ testimony persuasive that STUDENT is able to learn, as it is corroborated by some of his grades and by test scores, as discussed below.

STUDENT’S academic test scores also demonstrate an ability to learn. In April 2004, Ms. Schnee, an educational therapist hired by STUDENT’S parents, administered the Woodcock-Johnson III Tests of Achievement. She also administered the Woodcock-Johnson III Tests of Cognitive Abilities, which indicated that STUDENT has an overall General Intelligence Ability (GIA) standard score of 85, which is in the low average range. His achievement scores of 83 for broad reading, 90 for oral expression, 91 for listening comprehension, 94 for written expression, 87 for reading comprehension, 80 for mathematics calculations, and 89 for mathematics reasoning demonstrate that STUDENT is functioning academically commensurate with his overall ability. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 1; testimony of Trisha Kane.)

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not exhibit an inability to learn.

(2) Did Petitioner exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?

STUDENT’S parents and Dr. Greene testified that STUDENT lacked real friendships and good relationships with others. With regard to interpersonal relationships with peers, the evidence is overwhelmingly that STUDENT could and did maintain good relations with his peers. STUDENT’S teachers testified that he was well-liked in class. According to Mr. Robbins, STUDENT had a lot of friends in the science class and enjoyed talking with them during group activities. Ms Unzueta testified that STUDENT seemed happy and socialized with other students. He was popular and other students wanted him in their drama scenes. According to Ms. Harris, the school psychologist who evaluated STUDENT and observed him in the classroom and during testing, STUDENT was very well-liked by his peers and valued friendships.

The testimony of the District’s witnesses is corroborated by testimony from some of the Petitioner’s own witnesses and documentary evidence. Dr. Greene, the psychologist hired by the parents, admitted seeing STUDENT at the mini-mall with four or five “chums,” who were “neighbor kids” he was hanging out with FAMILY FRIEND, a family friend and STUDENT’S tutor, testified that STUDENT had friends like any teenager. On the Parent Rating Scales for the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC), STUDENT’S parents admitted that STUDENT sometimes has friends who are in trouble, thereby acknowledging that he has friends. (District’s Exhibit 14.) On the BASC Self-Report of Personality, STUDENT himself answered true to the following statements: “I am good at making new friends”; “I am a likeable person”; “I enjoy making new friends”; “People like me because I am easy to talk to”; “I enjoy meeting others”; “My friends are usually kind to me”. (District’s Exhibit 15.) FATHER indicated on the Health and Developmental History, which he filled out on April 22, 2004, in preparation for the school assessments, that STUDENT was “friendly, caring, and loves all animals.” He also checked the box indicating that STUDENT “gets along well with friends.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 7.) With regard to relations with teachers, both Mr. Robbins and Ms. Unzueta testified that they had a good relationship with STUDENT. Their description of positive interactions and discussions with STUDENT were persuasive.

On the basis of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT demonstrated the ability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with his peers and with some of his teachers.

(3) Did Petitioner exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances in several settings?

The parents assert that their son engaged in inappropriate behaviors which escalated during the last three months of the 2003-2004 school year, while the teachers and staff of A.E. Wright did not observe inappropriate behaviors that would make STUDENT eligible under this criterion.

The parents testified that STUDENT engaged in several behaviors at home that were inappropriate. MOTHER said that STUDENT was gouging his legs and hands in November 2003, making little holes with a pencil or pen. Unusual behaviors intensified after STUDENT was prescribed Paxil by a psychiatrist in February 2004, according to FATHER. FATHER described gestures such as STUDENT’S standing on the second floor ledge outside his room as if he wanted to jump. He also said that STUDENT was hiding under the table during weekly gatherings of relatives. STUDENT was found in the park in the middle of the night, hiding in the shrubs. STUDENT was running away and hiding out in the bushes in the open space near his home where there were coyotes. He was playing with fire. According to FATHER, STUDENT tried to jump out of the car once while his father was driving.

The seriousness of STUDENT’S alleged self-mutilating or suicidal behaviors is called into question by the parents’ statements on several documents. On item number 69 of the BASC, completed in May 2004, the parents answered “never” to the query “tries to hurt self.” (District’s Exhibit 14.) On the Health Information Report filled out by the District nurse, with input from the parents, in May 2004 as part of the assessment, there is a list of medications, and the mother’s obstetrical history. Under “special problems,” there is no mention of any suicidal or self-mutilating behaviors. (District’s Exhibit 10.)

Further, Dr. Greene, the psychologist whom the parents hired to evaluate STUDENT, concluded in a report in June 2004 that STUDENT suffered more from communication problems than from a psychiatric disturbance. He did not describe any suicidal gestures or other atypical behaviors in his opinion letter. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2.) In a brief letter of recommendation which Dr. Greene wrote, at the family’s request, for STUDENT’S admission to a camp, he does not describe any inappropriate behaviors of an ED child:

[STUDENT] needs more structure and fewer distractions and diversions than his present environment provides. Although in a comfortable home- he lives fairly comfortably in his own world where he has attempted to push his wants and needs on others- and ignore the responsibilities and obligations that he does not feel are important for him to attend to. His performance in school and in the home reflects his style….

[STUDENT] will be a very good candidate to a camp/school environment which emphasizes the importance of structure- individual responsibility- the beauty of world outside him and the value of hard work.

(Petitioner’s Exhibit 2.)

Thus, the Hearing Officer does not find the description of inappropriate behaviors at home and in the community by STUDENT’S parents to be persuasive in meeting this criterion.

Additionally, the school staff who testified painted a picture of STUDENT that was in sharp contrast to the testimony of the parents. This picture does not support a finding of inappropriate types of behavior in the school setting. School personnel did not note any unusual or bizarre behaviors during school. They did describe much attention-seeking behavior, such as talking out loud and acting as the “class clown.” Ms. Harris, the school psychologist, testified that she believed that STUDENT picked and chose where he was going to be disruptive and had control over his behavior. From her testing and observations, she did not believe that STUDENT was an ED child. According to Ms. Harris, inappropriate behaviors should be out of the control of the student in ED cases, and she concluded that STUDENT’S acting out behaviors were purposeful and done for pay offs, such as escaping school work and getting attention from peers. When she observed STUDENT, she found that his behaviors were appropriate to students in general education.

Mr. Robbins testified that STUDENT liked attention and wanted the spotlight on himself. He had a tremendous number of toys he would play with in science class and asked inappropriate questions to make the class laugh. Mr. Robbins did not note any bizarre behaviors or withdrawal and stated that STUDENT needed to be managed. Ms. Unzueta testified that STUDENT was not completely compliant with classroom rules and blurted things out to get the attention of peers. He acted as the “class clown.” STUDENT settled down in drama class eventually and his behavior was very good.

The testimony of the District witnesses as to STUDENT’S school behavior is corroborated by Patti Koss, a behaviorist hired by STUDENT’S parents. She observed STUDENT in three classes and he was aware of her presence. Ms. Koss admitted that this awareness could have impacted STUDENT’S behavior. She noted that STUDENT made verbal comments out loud not directed to anyone, generally was not paying attention to the classwork, played with small toys at his desk, sketched in a notebook, fidgeted, and put a shoe on his desk. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 3.) He disrupted one class by periodically raising his hand and shouting “me, me, me.” None of these behaviors, while possibly disruptive, could be classified as inappropriate types of behavior for a middle school student.

Furthermore, STUDENT’S discipline record at A.E. Wright Middle School is filled with adolescent misbehaviors and class disruptions which were generally not so severe or unusual as to rise to the level of inappropriate types of behavior to a marked degree. STUDENT was disruptive in classes by making noises and talking, was off task, ran around at lunchtime, was disrespectful to adults, threw paper objects around the room (when a substitute was present), threw a pen at a teacher, knocked a girl into a wall with his backpack, and hit another girl on the head with a book in class. (District’s Exhibit 23.) Mr. Robbins, the target of the pen throwing incident, testified that it was a harmless prank.

As was the case with STUDENT’S behaviors at home, these behavioral incidents at school were impacted by the medication regimen given to him during the second semester. STUDENT’S disruptive behaviors and acting out at school escalated when he was being medicated by Dr. Jesalva. The number of recorded discipline incidents jumped from seven before February 16, the date of his first visit with Dr. Jesalva, to 25 from that date until the end of the semester. (District’s Exhibit 23.)

A changing drug regimen was prescribed to STUDENT by Dr. Jesalva during the second semester of the 2003-2004 school year, which is when the majority of behavioral problems occurred. The District asserts that this indicates that STUDENT’S behaviors worsened under circumstances which were not normal. In making this argument, the District cites the case of Student v. Napa Valley Unified School District, SN 02-01815 (SEHO 2003), in which the Hearing Officer determined that the student’s behavior problems did not occur under normal circumstances, due to student’s inconsistent and changing administration of medications for ADHD. (District’s Closing Brief, p. 29.) The escalation in STUDENT’S behaviors occurred after he was prescribed a virtual medicine cabinet of psychoactive medications by Dr. Jesalva. A medications list produced at the hearing indicates that from February 16, 2004 to June 9, 2004, STUDENT was prescribed between 25 and 50 mg. of Paxil, 40 mg. of Metadete, a dosage of Depacote which was increased from 250 mg. to 1000 mg., 5 mg. of Zyprexazydis, and 25 mg. of Seraquel Quetiapin Fumarate. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 8.) Dr. Elliott, the District’s expert witness, who is a licensed psychologist, is program chair of the Neuropsychology Division of the American Psychological Association. (Footnote 2) He testified that both Paxil and Depacote have the side effects of increasing acting out behaviors and impulsivity, as well as sleeplessness. Dr. Elliott further stated that the Food and Drug Administration took Paxil off the list of recommended medications because of the high incidence of suicidal ideations with adolescents. In a letter dated April 22, 2004, Dr. Jesalva noted that STUDENT did not present in February with any suicidal ideations, pressured speech, tangentiality or psychotic symptoms. He did admit that increasing Paxil, as well as increasing Adderall or changing the stimulant to Metadate, had been observed to worsen STUDENT’S behavior. (Peititioner’s Exhibit 9).

The Hearing Officer finds that the home and school behaviors that were the most inappropriate occurred after STUDENT was on these medications and, therefore, did not occur under normal circumstances.

Finally, the inappropriate types of behavior must be exhibited over a long period of time. There was no testimony at the hearing about STUDENT’S behaviors since the end of the 2003-2004 school year. While the law requires that the criteria for ED be exhibited over a long period of time, there is no time period specified in law. However, at least six months has been found in other decisions to constitute a long period of time. (See Manhattan Beach U.S.D., SN-1313-99 (SEHO 1999.) In this case, the period of time of the escalating inappropriate behaviors described by the parents, which coincided with the change in the drug regimen for STUDENT, was less than six months.

Therefore, for all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior under normal circumstances that were exhibited in several settings or situations, to a marked degree, and for a long duration.

(4) Did Petitioner exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression?

Petitioner contends that he was unhappy and depressed during the 2003-2004 school year. The District asserts that STUDENT never exhibited any evidence of depression in the school environment, and to the contrary, seemed happy and outgoing at school.

Dr. Jonathan Greene testified at the hearing in October 2004 that STUDENT had an agitated depression, was anxious, and likely suffered from bipolar disorder. The credibility of this testimony is undermined by written statements made by Dr. Greene immediately after he stopped treating STUDENT, in a report dated June 20, 2004. Dr. Greene expressed opinions in that report which were directly contrary to his testimony: “The careful review of the data available both from psychologist, psychiatrist, behavioral specialist, and speech and language pathologist, speak much more to some clearly delineated burdens of communication rather than a foundational psychiatric disturbance….There was some discussion on the affective disturbance in the vein of depression or even a bipolar disturbance. I could not find, or isolate a constricted affect or even hypo manic delineation that speaks to these elements.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2.) Dr. Greene saw STUDENT for a few months before the June 20, 2004 report and stopped seeing him in mid-June 2004, when STUDENT was placed in a wilderness camp in Washington state. After the placement, he had no further contacts with STUDENT. He could not explain why his oral testimony was contradicted by his report, when he had no current contacts with STUDENT.

Dr. Ed Jesalva, a psychiatrist who saw STUDENT from mid-February 2004, was not called to testify at the hearing. According to a April 22, 2004 letter, Dr. Jesalva diagnosed STUDENT with anxiety disorder NOS and depressive disorder NOS. The Hearing Officer does not give the diagnoses in Dr. Jesalva’s letter much weight, as the letter is hearsay and does not explain the bases of his conclusions. While Dr. Jesalva noted a history of mood disorder with respect to the father and paternal grandmother, which was not treated, his only observation of STUDENT was a mild psychomotor agitation and restlessness. He also described STUDENT’S affect as predominantly pleasant, but often becoming oppositional, especially when his mother was in the room. He stated that STUDENT does not have suicidal ideations. He indicated in the letter that his initial intervention was to treat depression and anxiety and that he prescribed Paxil, which, according to the parents, only worsened STUDENT’S behavior. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 9.)

As discussed earlier, STUDENT’S parents pointed to two incidents that they described as possible suicidal behavior, both in the months after Paxil was prescribed, during which STUDENT’S behavior was reported to be getting worse. (Footnote 3) One was when STUDENT stood on the second floor ledge outside his window. The second incident was when STUDENT tried to jump out of the car while his father was driving. The import of these incidents is called into question by the parents’ response on the May 4, 2004 BASC of “never” to the question of whether STUDENT “tries to hurt self.” (District’s Exhibit 14.)

There is also contradictory information in the record about whether STUDENT withdrew from activities in the second semester. While Dr. Greene and FATHER mentioned that STUDENT quit participating in extracurricular activities, Ms. Harris testified that FATHER told her at the SST meeting on March 19, 2004, that he withdrew enjoyable activities from STUDENT to turn his behavior around.

Furthermore, while the Petitioner’s parents testified that there were some depressive indications at home in the three months after STUDENT visited the psychiatrist, there is a lack of evidence in the record that this depression was pervasive. According to school personnel, STUDENT appeared happy at school. He had a lot of friends and was never alone. He came into class tardy with a big smile on his face, according to Mr. Robbins. Ms. Unzueta, the drama teacher, testified that she did not observe any change in STUDENT’S appearance, dress, or hygiene over the course of the second semester. Even though STUDENT acted out in school, the teachers did not think of him as depressed, according to Ms. Harris. The Hearing Officer finds this testimony persuasive because it was consistent across the witnesses who had observed STUDENT in school throughout the year.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence does not support a finding of pervasive depression, lasting over a long period of time.

(5) Did Petitioner have a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems?

According to the evidence in the record, STUDENT did not develop physical symptoms associated with his personal or school problems. Dr. Greene testified that he did not notice any physical symptoms in STUDENT. On the BASC, STUDENT scored low in somatization, in the self-report, and average on the parents’ report. STUDENT was not absent from school because of sickness. FATHER reported on the Health and Developmental History that STUDENT was absent from school only three days per year on average because of sickness and that his current medical condition was good. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 7.) The attendance record at A.E. Wright shows that STUDENT was absent because of illness only four days for the whole school year. (District’s Exhibit 22.)

Thus, the evidence establishes that the Petitioner does not meet the fifth criterion of the test for special education eligibility based on ED. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner does not qualify for special education on the basis of ED.

B. Eligibility for Special Education as Other Health Impaired (OHI)

Petitioner contends that he qualifies for special education as other health impaired because of an attention deficit disorder (ADD) that was diagnosed in 1997. (Footnote 4) The District disputes that Petitioner’s poor educational performance is the result of ADD, or lack of attentiveness, and asserts that Petitioner has a conduct disorder and/or is socially maladjusted. The District further argues that the Petitioner’s needs can be met by accommodations to the general education program.

To meet federal eligibility criteria for special education as OHI, the student must have “limited strength, vitality or alertness, including a heightened alertness to environmental stimuli, that results in limited alertness with respect to the educational environment,” because of chronic or acute health problems, such as attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, which adversely affects a child’s educational performance. (34 Code of Federal Regulations § 300.7 (b) (8).) Under state law, OHI eligibility for special education is set forth at Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030 (f) as follows:

A pupil has limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems… which adversely affects a pupil’s educational performance…. such physical disabilities shall not be temporary in nature…

OHI eligibility for special education can be established with a diagnosis of ADD if the disorder adversely affects the pupil’s educational performance, the pupil otherwise meets the eligibility requirements for OHI, and because of the disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be met by modification of the regular school program.

A pupil whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria specified in subdivision (f) … of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations… is entitled to special education and related services.

(California Education Code § 56339(a).)

1. Limited strength, vitality, or alertness

The first criterion for eligibility on the basis of OHI is that the student exhibit limited strength, vitality, or alertness. In STUDENT’S case, the evidence indicates that he exhibited limited alertness in several learning environments: during tutoring, testing, and classroom teaching.

FAMILY FRIEND, a family friend of the parents who has been a school teacher for thirty years, tutored STUDENT for several years. He testified that STUDENT could not read or write in the third grade, but covered it up. FAMILY FRIEND said that STUDENT was average intellectually, but had a difficult time staying focused. He misbehaved during tutoring sessions. He observed that STUDENT began to misbehave to distract his brothers and the tutor when he could not handle intellectual games.

Dr. Greene noted that STUDENT shut down during testing by regressing and avoiding, and acted out by becoming disruptive and leaving the room when he was overwhelmed. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 2.) Karen Schnee, a speech and educational therapist, was hired by STUDENT’S attorney to test for learning disabilities and processing disorders. She testified that STUDENT’S behavior during testing was odd, and that she had to manage him like a seven or eight year old child to get test results. Ms. Schnee found STUDENT to have low to average abilities on the Woodcock Johnson III, and did not discover any significant aptitude/achievement discrepancy. She, therefore, concluded that STUDENT did not have a learning disability. She did, however, note a processing speed deficit, a difficulty in picking up social cues, and a weakness in working memory. (Exhibit 1.) She testified that STUDENT had a lack of ability to attend.

Ms. Harris, the school psychologist, tested STUDENT and observed him in class. In science lab, she found STUDENT to be attentive and not disruptive at all. In language arts, she observed him three times. He was playing with his shoes a lot, generally quiet, and not doing his work. She expressed some concerns about STUDENT’S ability to learn in the classroom, as testing uncovered significant processing delays and a memory deficit. She testified that she did not believe that STUDENT qualified for special education on the basis of OHI. According to Ms. Harris, the student with attentional issues should be unable to do the work in every setting. She testified that she believes that STUDENT chose not to do the work. The Hearing Officer is concerned that Ms. Harris discounted some of her own observations in reaching this conclusion. (Footnote 5) The narrative of her test administration indicates that STUDENT’S concentration and focus were extremely limited, that he required numerous urgings to complete tasks, and that he was weak in his ability to sustain attention, concentrate, and exert mental control. Ms. Harris’ observations of STUDENT’S behavior during testing are as follows:

[STUDENT] is an attractive young man, both physically and in personality. He has brown hair with beautiful brown eyes, and is small in stature. He related well to the examiner in a comfortable, forthcoming manner. He easily left his general education classes to begin this lengthly assessment. [STUDENT’S] approach to challenging or novel material was characterized by “giving up” or “not to respond.” His concentration and focus is extremely limited. When the task appeared too difficult, [STUDENT] pushed it away, and responded “I can’t do it.” Often times he would distract himself by asking questions that were only marginally related to the material or protest that he felt tired. Many times, [STUDENT] appeared tired and unable to focus. At these times, the examiner would ask if he wanted to return to class, or if he needed a break. [STUDENT] replied “no” to both options. The more difficult the task, the more he deteriorated.

(District’s Exhibit 18, p. 2.)

Trisha Kane, a resource specialist at the District, administered academic achievement tests to STUDENT and found him to be a difficult subject to test. She had to test him on three consecutive days and humor and cajole him to complete the testing. She noted that during testing,STUDENT read items out loud, sang to himself, and was generally very distracted. He scored low in fluency with academic tasks, and the examiner could not determine if the low fluency was due to inattention or to slow processing. Ms. Kane admitted that STUDENT may have some attention issues.

STUDENT’S classroom behavior was observed directly by Patti Koss, a behavior consultant, who was hired by the parents to go into the classroom at A.E. Wright with STUDENT. According to Ms. Koss, STUDENT spent his time in social science class sketching in his notebook while the class watched an educational video, and played continuously with two small toys from his backpack, while talking to himself. STUDENT was the only student playing with toys at his desk. He was observed in pre-algebra putting one of his shoes on top of the desk for a while and paying very little attention to the class lesson. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 3.)

The Hearing Officer notes that the form filled out by the District for the SST meeting referral on March 18, 2004 indicates that STUDENT has a short attention span, is easily distracted, slow to start, and unable to work independently. Further, on the BASC, the results of which were considered valid by Ms. Harris, the parents rated STUDENT’S hyperactivity and attention problems as being in the clinically significant range. (District’s Exhibit 14.)

Based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner exhibited limited alertness.

2. Due to chronic or acute health problems

To qualify for special education based on OHI, the student must exhibit limited alertness due to chronic or acute health problems. In STUDENT’S case, he was first diagnosed with ADD in 1997. At that time, the student study team of Round Meadow Elementary School was notified. According to MOTHER, STUDENT was prescribed medications by his pediatrician for ADD. These medications varied from Ritalin to Concerta to Adderall. He was continued on 30 mg. of Adderall in the 2003-2004 school year, until Dr. Jesalva changed the stimulant to Metadete. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 8.) According FATHER, attention deficit medications were discontinued when Dr. Jesalva put STUDENT on Depakote.

At the hearing, Dr. Greene testified that STUDENT’S ADD was secondary to his emotional disturbance and that STUDENT was likely ADD by record and observation. The observation was of the way STUDENT took the psychometric tests administered by Dr. Greene and his staff. On cross-examination, he responded that STUDENT had been diagnosed and treated for ADD before Dr. Greene saw him and there was nothing to exclude it.

Dr. Robert Elliott, who testified as an expert for the District, did not assess STUDENT. He relied on a record review for his opinions. Dr. Elliott has been a school psychologist in the Redondo Beach Unified School District since 1993 and serves as a psychology consultant for school districts. Dr. Elliott provided background information on ADD, stating that this is an older term and that ADHD is the preferred term now. He acknowledged that the symptoms of ADHD and the diagnostic procedures are not agreed upon. He identified various types of ADHD, including the impulsive type, the predominant symptom of which is impulsivity, and the combined type, which is marked by inattention and behavioral impulsivity. He noted that ADHD is manifested before age seven. Dr. Elliott criticized Dr. Jesalva for diagnosing STUDENT as ADHD by history, while making no independent observations of ADHD, other than perhaps a mild psychomotor agitation and restlessness. According to Dr. Elliott, limited alertness, an inability to concentrate or focus or pay attention, is one of the symptoms of ADHD. Dr. Elliott acknowledged that some of the Woodcock-Johnson subtests that Ms. Schnee administered to STUDENT, on which STUDENT obtained low scores, were dependent on intact ability to concentrate. These were processing speed, working memory, visual matching, decision speed, and fluency testing. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’S score on cognitive fluency was quite depressed. Also depressed were reading fluency and math fluency, which were six and fourteen points below his GIA (general intellectual ability), respectively. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 1.) If the performance is inconsistent with the ability level, then there is a disability, according to Dr. Elliott. Dr. Elliott also stated that behavioral impulsivity in all settings is persuasive of a diagnosis of ADHD. According to District exhibits, STUDENT’S classroom teachers all noted impulsivity as a problem. (District’s Exhibit 18.)

In spite of a history and some test scores indicative of ADD/ADHD, Dr. Elliott concluded that Ms. Schnee’s data ruled out ADHD, as STUDENT’S cognitive and achievement scores were at or above average, which would eliminate auditory attentional problems. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that Dr. Elliott admitted that some students do well in one-on-one tests, but have difficulties in group settings. Dr. Elliott also ruled out ADHD based on the good grades that STUDENT achieved in science class when he did the assignments. He further noted that STUDENT had good grades in drama. According to Dr. Elliott, students with attention problems have difficulty progressing in an environment where they are working on projects with groups, as in the drama class. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Elliott’s conclusions to be of limited value, as he admitted that he had not diagnosed STUDENT and had not interviewed, tested, or observed him.

In conclusion, based on the long history of medications for ADD, some test results, and the testimony that STUDENT exhibited inattention and behavioral impulsivity, the Hearing Officer finds that his limited alertness is due to a chronic condition of ADD.

3. Adverse effect on educational performance

District witnesses at the hearing discounted STUDENT’S attentional problems and theorized that they were not stopping STUDENT from learning at school. It was their opinion that STUDENT was socially maladjusted and had chosen to act out at school. The District’s attitude to STUDENT’S attentional issues was to minimize their role in his academic problems and blame his failures solely on behaviors under STUDENT’S control.

The Hearing Officer does not accept that STUDENT’S academic failure in the 2003-2004 school year was completely attributable to a conduct disorder or social maladjustment. From the observations of numerous witnesses who tested STUDENT, tutored him, or observed him in class, the Hearing Officer finds sufficient evidence in the record that STUDENT has attentional deficits that limit his alertness and affect his educational performance. Mr. Robbins, the science teacher, noted at the SST meeting that STUDENT had “a difficult time in class, doesn’t comprehend material; disengages during class activities.” (District’s Exhibit 8.) The family tutor, FAMILY FRIEND, a teacher with three decades of experience, pointed out that STUDENT misbehaved to distract from his inability to do the work and his difficulty focusing. He described STUDENT’S disruptiveness as a protective mechanism and explained that STUDENT gets panicky when he realizes that he has to demonstrate his skills. FATHER pointed out in the letter to the principal of A.E. Wright, written with the assistance of Dr. Locke, that attention disorders are accompanied by behavioral problems. The courts have recognized that a disorder in attention may be a cause of negative behaviors and that attentional deficits and behavioral problems may be intertwined. See Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884 (9th Cir. 1995).

Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’S limited alertness due to his ADD adversely affected his educational performance in the 2003-2004 school year.

4. Need for special education services

The next question that must be answered in order for a student to qualify for special education based on OHI is whether the student requires instruction or services that cannot be provided by modification of the regular school program. For a student to receive special education services, it must be shown that the student requires these services to receive a free, appropriate public education and cannot have his or her needs met in the general education program with modifications or accommodations. (California Education Code § 56026 (b); Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030.)

It is undisputed that the District did not provide STUDENT with modifications or accommodations in his 2003-2004 middle school program to address his ADD. Both psychologists who testified for the District conceded that STUDENT would need modifications and accommodations to succeed in the general education program. Ms. Harris admitted that it would take STUDENT more time to finish tasks, and indicated that he would need accommodations for this problem, as well as for his visual/motor delays. She recommended allowing STUDENT more time to finish tests and projects. Dr. Elliott had numerous recommendations for STUDENT. He suggested counseling services on the school campus and in the community. With regard to medications, he would refer STUDENT to a diagnostic center to look at all areas, cognitive as well as behaviors. He recommended a shortened school day, matching STUDENT with certain teachers, placing him in a smaller school, and giving him access to a counselor in the school setting. He also suggested counseling for STUDENT’S parents and training them in discipline techniques. Overall, he did not believe that STUDENT needed special education and thought that he could function in a general education program within the school setting.

The students’ witnesses also agreed that STUDENT needed modifications and accommodations. While FAMILY FRIEND eventually recommended a wilderness camp, the tutor admitted that he had dealt with students similar to STUDENT, and that such students need modifications. In fact, he testified that he achieved good results with STUDENT by modifying his environment and assignments. He mentioned such modifications to the general education program as one-on-one attention, modification of assignments, isolation from more advanced students, and tutoring after class. In a letter written by FATHER on March 23, 2004, after the SST meeting, to the principal of A.E. Wright, Steve Rosentsweig, FATHER asked for modifications of the regular school program, to address STUDENT’S disability. The Rosentsweig letter is particularly persuasive because FATHER admitted that it was written with the assistance of Dr. Locke, the psychologist who saw STUDENT weekly for therapy. In the letter, there are recommendations for accommodations to STUDENT’S school program:

According to Section 504 of the California Educational Code, your school must attend to the problems of children with special needs…My son needs a modified school program with modified school environment. An experienced personal TA must be assigned to him to help him cope with his psychological and academic deficiencies. Tutoring after classes should be considered…[STUDENT] is a bright young man, but he needs assignments that will capture his attention and stimulate his imagination. He also needs frequent breaks in order to control his attention deficit… The psychologist must see [STUDENT] at least twice a week and help him discuss and evaluate his progress… I expect to get a detailed letter from you with a plan of modified instruction for my son and all additional measures directed at behavioral and academic success of children with needs similar to those of my son.

(Petitioner’s Exhibit 5.)

The notes from the SST meeting in March also indicate that STUDENT’S parent is asking for modifications. (District’s Exhibit 8.) (Footnote 6)

Ms. Schnee, the speech pathologist who tested STUDENT for his parents, concluded from her testing that STUDENT would not be able to access the curriculum in a full classroom of students. According to Ms. Schnee, because of STUDENT’S lack of ability to attend, he would need one-on-one instruction. She recommended a nonpublic school residential placement, which is what the parents eventually chose, but did not give her reasons for a residential placement. She did, however, recommend accommodations which could be implemented in a general school environment, such as seating STUDENT in front of the teacher in all his classes, allowing STUDENT to use an Alpha Smart to improve his handwriting, encouraging STUDENT to repeat directions so as to ensure that he has interpreted them correctly, placing STUDENT in classes with a small teacher-to-pupil ratio with little ambient noise, and testing STUDENT in a multiple choice format. (Peititioner’s Exhibit 1.)

The Hearing Officer finds that there is persuasive evidence that STUDENT’S educational needs can be met in a regular education environment with sufficient modifications and accommodations. This conclusion is based not only on the testimony of the District’s experts and the recommendations of Dr. Locke conveyed through the Rosentsweig letter, but on STUDENT’S academic record. When he was at Pinecrest Middle School, a private school, he was not in special education for the sixth and seventh grades. Nonetheless, he was able to achieve B and C grades and satisfactory to excellent in citizenship and work habits. (District’s Exhibit 1.) The parents’ input at the SST regarding Pinecrest was that it had smaller classes and was more personal, and that, therefore, STUDENT did okay. At A.E. Wright, STUDENT did very well on certain science labs when he was interested. He also did well in drama class, which required some academic skills, and also gave him an outlet for his attention-seeking.

In light of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet the eligibility criteria for special education as OHI because his needs can be met in the general education program with modifications and accomodations. Because of STUDENT’S ineligibility for special education, the District was not obligated to provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2004-2005 school year.

3. Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments conducted by speech and language pathologist Karen Schnee and psychologist Jonathan Greene?

A parent or guardian has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student, at public expense, from qualified specialists, if the parent or guardian disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329 (b)).

Petitioner contends that the District failed to do appropriate child find and, hence, appropriate assessments were not timely completed. He contends that his parents therefore took it upon themselves to contact private professionals to make appropriate assessments. Petitioner also disagrees with the reports made by the District, which he characterizes as conflicting and incomplete. As he considers the independent assessments necessary and appropriate because of how the District was handling the matter, he argues that the costs should be reimbursed. The District counters that it met its obligation to timely identify and assess STUDENT for special education, and that the parents sought independent assessments without informing the District, requesting that the District fund the assessments, or disagreeing with District assessments.

From the statutory language, the key to parents’ obtaining reimbursement for an assessment is that they disagree with the District assessment. As the District’s assessments were not completed until the end of May 2004, it cannot be argued that the parents undertook private assessments in April 2004 after disagreeing with the content or conclusions of District reports. Furthermore, the parents received a notice on March 22, 2004, that they would get an assessment plan from the District in two weeks, and that fifty days from receipt of the signed plan, there would be an IEP meeting at which they could review the District assessment results. It is not credible that the parents rushed to obtain an independent assessment from a psychologist and speech/language pathologist in April because of frustration with the District’s inaction, when they had just received notice of the impending District assessment. (Footnote 7) Moreover, the Hearing Officer has found above that the District did not violate its child find obligations.

FATHER testified about the actual sequence of events and motivation for the private assessments. He said that after the SST meeting, he was not sure what would happen about STUDENT’S problems. When he did not receive the District’s assessment plan, he called Ms. Harris, the school psychologist. According to FATHER’S testimony, he said that he would hire a private team to do an assessment and Ms. Harris said that the school would run some tests. They then would compare results to see how STUDENT’S problems could be addressed. FATHER stated that it was at that point that he hired Ms. Schnee and Ms. Koss. He also hired an attorney, who recommended Dr. Greene. There is no evidence in the record that the District ever agreed to pay for the private assessments

For the reasons above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’S parents are not entitled under the law to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments conducted by Ms. Schnee and Dr. Greene.

4. Are Petitioner’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational placements and services provided to Petitioner during the 2003-2004 school year and the 2004-2005 school year to date? (Footnote 8)

Based on the conclusion in issue number two above that Student was not eligible for special education, Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to these costs.

5. In order to receive a FAPE, does Petitioner require a prospective placement for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year in a residential program at a certified nonpublic school (NPS)?

As the Hearing Officer concluded in issue number two that Petitioner was not eligible for special education, he is not entitled to a FAPE.

ORDER

Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505( i )).

Date: December 17, 2004 _______________________________________ Roberta M. Ward, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

MOTHER was not present on November 3, 4, and 5, 2004.

2 Neuropsychology, according to Dr. Elliott, deals with the relation between the brain and behavior and studies how neurological conditions and medications may affect behavior.

3 As discussed above, Paxil is known to cause suicidal ideations in adolescents and, according to Dr. Elliott, is not recommended for adolescents by the Food and Drug Administration for that reason.

4 Although eligibility on the basis of OHI was identified as an issue at the pre-hearing conference, counsel for Student did not address it in his written closing argument, basing his argument on ED.

5 The Hearing Officer is also concerned that Ms. Harris only discusses the specific learning disability category under “Special Education Eligibility” in her report. She does not address OHI or ADD. (District’s Exhibit 18.)

6 According to testimony, Dr. Locke also attended the SST meeting .

7 The parents hired their experts in the first half of April. Karen Schnee assessed Student beginning on April 14, 2004. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 1.) According to Dr. Greene’s records, he was contacted on April 8, 2004 to work with STUDENT. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 9.)

8 The Hearing Officer notes that Student produced no direct evidence at the hearing about the program at Discovery Academy, his current placement, or how it was suited to meet his needs and provide an educational benefit, as required under the test of Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. Of Educ., 790 F.2d. 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).