California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 17, 1998

Student v. Solana Beach Elementary School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1160-97 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Solana Beach Elementary School District offered an appropriate 1997-98 program; parents' claims for City School tuition and costs denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Parents of an 11-year-old boy with a specific learning disability in written language filed for due process against Solana Beach Elementary School District. The boy also had ADHD and motor and speech difficulties. He had been in a regular class with resource specialist services at Carmel Creek Elementary. After the District funded a summer session at the nonpublic City School, the parents kept him there for 1997-98. They sought tuition, transportation and private speech therapy costs. They argued that his nervous habits, including skin picking, teasing by peers, tactile defensiveness and distractibility, made a large campus unsuitable. Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait found that the IEP developed in spring and summer 1997 met the boy's needs. It included resource help, speech, counseling, adapted physical education, occupational therapy, vision therapy and a laptop. The evidence did not show that Carmel Creek caused his nervous habits. Only one teasing incident was proven, and the District responded to it. Other teasing evidence was hearsay that could not alone support a finding. Test scores, grades, goal progress and teacher testimony showed he made progress in 1996-97. The team had also made a plan for handwriting. Because the parents removed him before the District could implement the IEP, the Hearing Officer did not decide whether City School was appropriate. All reimbursement claims were denied, and the District prevailed on every issue.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO used the Rowley "educational benefit" standard to measure progress through grades, goal reports, test scores and teacher testimony. It also shows how hearsay limits under 5 CCR 3082(b) affected proof of teasing. When the District's offer was found appropriate, reimbursement for a unilateral private placement was denied without deciding whether the private school was appropriate.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1a. Did the District offer a free appropriate program and placement for 1997-98: was the District's proposed program designed to meet Student's unique and individual needs (including in the least restrictive environment)?

    The April 22, 1997 IEP, as supplemented May 28 and September 3, 1997, addressed Student's needs. His nervous habits, reported teasing, tactile defensiveness and distractibility did not require a more restrictive placement than RSP at Carmel Creek.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Was the District's proposed program designed to provide Student educational benefit?

    Test scores, grades, goal progress and teacher reports showed Student made educational progress in 1996-97. The team adopted an appropriate plan for handwriting, his area of greatest concern, so a similar program would provide benefit.

  3. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1c. Did the program and placement conform to the student's IEP?

    The parents removed Student before the District could implement the 1997-98 IEP. No evidence showed the District was unwilling or unable to provide the program.

  4. Issue 2. If the District did not offer an appropriate program, was the City School an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year?

    Not decided because the District offered an appropriate placement.

  5. Issue 3. Should the District reimburse Student's parents for the cost of tuition at City School for the 1997-98 school year?

    No tuition reimbursement, because the District offered an appropriate placement.

  6. Issue 4. Should the District reimburse Student's parents for the cost of private speech pathology services?

    No reimbursement. The parents signed the April 22, 1997 IEP, which offered speech and language services twice a week for 60 minutes.

  7. Issue 5. Should the District reimburse Student's parents for the cost of transportation to and from the City School during the 1997-98 school year?

    No transportation reimbursement, because the District offered an appropriate program.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3082(b); Education Code section 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Christine Watts, Director of Pupil Personnel Services, Solana Beach Elementary School District
  • Katherine Orrell, fourth grade general education teacher, Carmel Creek Elementary School
  • Marilyn Goldstein, resource specialist teacher, Carmel Creek Elementary School
  • Barbara Hochart (also spelled Hochard), speech and language therapist, Solana Beach Elementary School District
  • Ms. Redman, adapted physical education teacher, Solana Beach Elementary School District
  • Megan Prentice, occupational therapist, Solana Beach Elementary School District
  • Gayle Paterson, school counselor, Carmel Creek Elementary School
  • Mary Bembow, occupational therapy specialist (assessor and handwriting therapist hired by District)
  • Jean Benson, assistive technology specialist, Solana Beach Elementary School District
  • Mary Kawar, independent occupational therapist (evaluation submitted by parents)
  • Dr. Eastman, pediatrician; witness for Student
  • Sara Frampton, psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Ms. Chamberland, teacher, City School (nonpublic school)
  • Deborah G. DeLauro, parents' attorney during 1997 IEP process
  • City School, nonpublic school (unilateral placement)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1160-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Non Public School Placement CDS Code: 37-68387 District: Solana Beach Elementary Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability

Case Details This matter was heard on January 20 and 21, 1998, February 9, 1998, and March 5, 1998, before Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer of the California Special Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Solana Beach, California.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Andrea Leavitt. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were his PARENTS. Respondent Solana Beach Elementary School District (District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present on behalf of the District was Christine Watts, director of Pupil Personnel Services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the matter was continued to allow for submission of written closing briefs. The record was closed on March 18, 1998, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate educational program and placement for the 1997- 98 school year?

2. If it is determined that the District did not off STUDENT an appropriate program, was the City School an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year?

3. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of tuition at City School for the 1997-98 school year?

4. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of private speech pathology services?

5. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of transportation to and from the City School during the 1997-98 school year?

PROCEDURAL ISSUES

In its closing brief the District objected to the use of the Declarations of physicians submitted by Petitioner and admitted into evidence by the Hearing Officer on the ground that those Declarations were hearsay. In response, Petitioner moved to strike a number of exhibits submitted by the District on the grounds that they were also hearsay.

Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations Section 3082(b) provides in part:

The hearings conducted pursuant to this section shall not be conducted according to the technical rules of evidence and those related to witnesses. Any relevant evidence shall be admitted if it is the sort of evidence on which responsible persons are accustomed to rely in the conduct of serious affairs, regardless of the existence of any common law or statutory rule which might make improper the admissions of such evidence over objection in civil actions. Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence but shall not be sufficient in itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in civil actions.

This section provides that hearsay is admissible. Therefore, it would be inappropriate to exclude evidence merely because it would constitute hearsay under rules of evidence that are applicable in civil actions. Therefore, Petitioner's motion to strike hearsay evidence provided by the District is denied.

The District did not ask to strike Petitioner's Declarations, but merely contended that the Declarations cannot be relied upon in making findings of fact. The District is also mistaken in its interpretation of CCR Section 3082. Hearsay may be used in findings of fact if it supplements or explains other nonhearsay evidence. Therefore, the use of the Declarations will depend upon whether they supplement or explain other nonhearsay evidence. The use of such evidence will be discussed below in relation to specific issues.

FINDINGS OF FACT

STUDENT is an 11-year old boy who has received special education services from the District since he was in preschool. He has a specific learning disability in the area of written language and has a diagnosis of attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). He also has a developmental coordination disorder and sensorimotor dyspraxia, with disorder of speech production. He has a congenital arachnoid cyst in the left temporal lobe. It was not clear from the evidence whether STUDENT's learning disabilities were cause by the cyst, but his pediatrician, Dr. Eastman, testified that his cyst is a serious aggravator of his ADHD. Symptoms of his diagnosed disorders include tactile defensiveness, significant fine motor problems, an abnormal gait, a speech impairment, and a variety of nervous habits including picking at his skin, pulling his hair, kicking his legs, fidgeting with objects and hand rubbing. During his time in District programs, he has received special assistance from resource specialists, speech and language services, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education.

An IEP meeting was held on February 27, 1996 to review his triennial assessments and formulate his program for the next 12 months. He was found to be above grade level in decoding and reading comprehension. His math skills were strong. While it was concluded that STUDENT's skills in spelling and writing were improving, it was noted that he needed further improvement. STUDENT's receptive and expressive language skills were within the average to high range. Areas of need included fluency as he tells stories. He demonstrated some false starts and reformulations, his intonation pattens had improved, but he frequently repeated the last word, syllable or sound in a sentence and he frequently substituted "w" for "l".

STUDENT was significantly below average in motor proficiency for his age level. Areas of difficulty included balance, bilateral coordination, flexibility, object movement skills of striking, throwing, and rolling and hand strength. The occupational therapy consultant concluded that STUDENT's general visual-perceptual skills were grossly within the average range, with specific deficits noted in form constancy (non-motor), and in visual-motor integration skills, eye-hand coordination and visual-motor speed. He had symptoms of distractibility, including posture shifts, self-stimulations of rubbing elbows, eyes, head and fidgeting. He withdrew from non-self-initiated touch contact, unless it was firm, predictable, and demanding of his participation and then he was tolerant.

In the area of self-help skills and prevocational/vocational, it was concluded that STUDENT was motivated to do well and enjoyed math and science activities. He needed reminders to stay on task (at times) and to complete written assignments. He needed additional time for test taking and additional support in writing sentences, paragraphs and essays. In the area of social-emotional- behavioral STUDENT demonstrated age appropriate emotional skills. Social skills were improving, but were impacted by attentional concerns. His classroom behavior was age appropriate.

Goals and objectives were established at the February 1996 meeting in the areas of expressive language, articulation, motor skills, fitness skills, handwriting, fine motor skills, dexterity, crossing midline, and written language. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT should continue to receive special education services in the form of resource specialist services for sixty minutes per day for four day per week, speech and language services two times per week for sixty minutes, adaptive physical educations two times per week for 60 minutes, and occupational therapy services of sixty minutes four times per month. He was to participate in regular education 72% of the time. STUDENT's parents approved his IEP.

In the fall of 1996, STUDENT entered Ms. Katherine Orrell's fourth grad class at Carmel Creek Elementary School. STUDENT continued to receive the special education services described in his IEP of February 27, 1996. STUDENT's resource specialist teacher provided services both in STUDENT's classroom and in a pull-out small-group setting. She worked with STUDENT on his language arts and social studies, which were the subjects that Ms. Orrell was teaching when STUDENT was out of the class. STUDENT received speech therapy from Barbara Hochart two times per week in a small-group setting, and adaptive P.E. from Ms. Redman during the lunch recess to help improve his playground skills. STUDENT also received occupational therapy from Ms. Prentice four times per month.

At some time in early November, an incident occurred in the cafeteria at lunch time in which some students threw grapes at STUDENT. One of the students who threw grapes at STUDENT was disciplined by being given detention. On November 1, 1996, the IEP team met at the request of STUDENT's parents, who were concerned about STUDENT's interaction with his peers. They provided a written statement concerning STUDENT'S being teased by other students and asked the other members of the IEP team to take actions to ensure that such teasing stopped. The IEP team agreed that Ms. Orrell would speak to STUDENT one-on-one about appropriate social skills. The parents were to reinforce those skills at home. The team decided that they would set up an abilities-disabilities sensitivity session for STUDENT's class and that the school counselor would observe STUDENT. On November 26, 1996, Ms. Marilyn Goldstein, STUDENT's Resource Specialist, wrote to STUDENT's parents that a number of activities and interventions would be undertaken: STUDENT would participate in a small social skills group with the school counselor, Gayle Paterson. Ms. Paterson would schedule a Circle of Friends session for STUDENT's class, activities in the classroom would be designed to build STUDENT's self esteem, and meetings would be scheduled with other school personnel to ensure that positive peer relationships were promoted and appropriate behavior consequences would occur when peers did not meet school expectations.

On March 27, 1997, the IEP team met to review STUDENT's progress and the appropriateness of his goals and objectives. STUDENT's parents were concerned that his difficulties with spontaneous expressive language were affecting his social interaction. It was determined that the adaptive technology specialist would review STUDENT's needs and that Mary Bembow, an occupational therapy specialist, would perform an assessment of STUDENT. District representatives expressed concern that STUDENT should do more of his homework on his own. It was also recommended that strategies be developed to modify the written requirements in class and for homework assignments. Adaptive physical education goals were reviewed. A new goal in handwriting was added to STUDENT's IEP with respect to his ability to write in cursive. It was agreed that RSP services would be increased to 90 minutes per day, four days per week, thereby reducing his time in regular class to 66-70% of the day. His occupational therapy services were eliminated pending the assessment of Mary Bembow. It was agreed that the next IEP meeting would be held on April 22, 1997, at which time the IEP team would review the amount of RSP needed and review the assessments performed by the technology specialist and Mary Bembow. In addition, the team would review the Test of Written Language (TOWL) results and the other academic assessments to be performed by STUDENT's resource specialist, Ms. Goldstein. It was decided that, after a review of that information, the IEP team would formulate goals and objectives for the coming year. STUDENT's parents approved the IEP of March 27, 1997.

The IEP team met again on April 22, 1997. The team reviewed the assessment by Jean Benson, the technology specialist. She recommended that STUDENT be given aan AlphaSmart Pro laptop word processor for use in his classroom on a trail basis for one month. This recommendation was included in the IEP. The OT assessment of Mary Bembow described STUDENT as "very tight," with limited use of the left side of his body. She recommended a number of specific approaches to use with STUDENT and recommended that he undergo a functional vision examination to assess the eye-hand pattern. STUDENT's parents submitted an independent evaluation by occupational therapist Mary Kawar. It was agreed that the APE teacher, Ms. Redman, would meet further with Mary Bembow to determine further delineation of objectives. The team was to coordinate services in the motor area. The team agreed that if further goals and objectives were needed in this area, an addendum to the IEP agreement would be prepared.

The resource specialist, Ms. Goldstein, reported on the results of the TOWL-3 test and the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement. She concluded that there was still a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of written language. STUDENT's parents reported on a recent neurological exam, which did not reveal anything new about STUDENT's condition. They also expressed continuing concern about STUDENT's peer relationships. District representatives expressed concern over STUDENT's "repetitive type" movements. They reported that he "fidgets a lot by picking at himself, hand movements, etc." The IEP notes indicate that the team felt that the recommended strategies and OT might "reduce stress which will in turn reduce the fidgeting."

Revised goals and objectives were prepared which included new goals in the area of pragmatics and social skills. The IEP provided for continued placement in the resource specialist program, with RSP services four times per week. It also included provision of speech and language services two times per week at sixty minutes per session; adaptive P.E. twice a week for 60 minutes; continuation of occupational therapy services; counseling services once per week for 30 minutes; and consultation of the technology consultant two times per year for 60 minutes. The IEP provided for intensive occupational therapy during the summer of 1997. STUDENT was to be mainstreamed for 66% of the time.

STUDENT's parents requested that a developmental vision assessment be performed before the end of the school year and that the District pay for a summer school program at the City School. The

District staff recommended a number of alternative summer placements within the District. Agreement was not reached concerning a summer school placement, but STUDENT's parents signed the IEP.

On May 28, 1997, the IEP team reconvened to work on goals and objectives in the motor areas. Four new goals relating to motor skills were approved. The amount of time in regular class was recomputed to 62% of the day. Discussions concerning STUDENT's placement during the summer were inconclusive, with STUDENT's parent requesting a program at the City School and the District favoring a program in the District. The team agreed to use a cue and reward system to decrease STUDENT's nose picking.

On June 4, 1997, District Pupil Personnel Services Director Christine Watts wrote to STUDENT's parents' attorney, Deborah G. DeLauro, that the District would fund the summer school program for STUDENT at the City School. The letter stated that the agreement was based on the understanding that it was for the summer only and that STUDENT's parents would supply transportation. Ms. Watt stated that she believed the District had an appropriate program but was agreeing to fund the summer placement "in the interests of working with the family."

STUDENT attended a six-week summer session at the City School. After the summer session, in August 1997, the District provided STUDENT with special instruction in handwriting from Mary Bembow. STUDENT's APE teacher, Ms. Redman, volunteered to drive STUDENT from his home to Ms. Bembow's home for the instruction. Ms. Redman also received instruction from Ms. Bembow during August in order to be in a position to continue the handwriting therapy during the 1997098 school year.

On September 3, 1997, a telephone IEP meeting was conducted. STUDENT's parents and attorney participated by telephone, along with staff from the City School. The IEP team reviewed the results of a vision evaluation. The District agreed to provide ten sessions of vision therapy. The team also heard a report from Mary Bembow regarding her therapy sessions. The IEP team set the amount of occupational therapy services at one hour per week until April 1998. Personnel of the City School reviewed STUDENT's classroom performance during the summer. STUDENT's parents requested that the District fund STUDENT's attendance at City School for the 1997-98 school year. The District contended that it had an appropriate placement for STUDENT in District schools.

On September 15, 1997, the Special Education Hearing Office received a request for hearing from STUDENT's attorney.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate program and placement for the 1997-98 school year?

Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) as amended in 1997, children with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) with special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. section 1401 (8) (A- D) & 1401 (25). A FAPE must be provided in conformity with the child's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. section 1401 (8) (D).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

In order to determine whether STUDENT was offered a free appropriate program and placement for the 1997-98 school year, it is necessary to address three issues. Was the proposed program designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs? Was the proposed program designed to provide educational benefit? Did the program and placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?

A. Was the District's proposed program designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs?

STUDENT has a number of areas of concern that are caused by his disability. He has a significant deficit in the area of written language. His IEP contains a goal to improve his written language, with six short-term objectives. The IEP provides for assistance from the resource specialist four times per week in this area. During the 1996-97 year, the resource specialist worked with STUDENT both in small groups and in his regular class. It was anticipated that such an approach would be used during the 1997-98 year. His IEP also provides that STUDENT have a computer to assist him in his regular class. In addition, the IEP provides that STUDENT's regular class teacher would also be responsible for assisting STUDENT in the area of written language, and that an educational technology consultant would review STUDENT's needs twice a year.

STUDENT has needs in the area of oral language, specifically with respect to fluency and articulation. The IEP establishes annual goals in the areas of fluency, articulation and pragmatics, with a number of short-term objectives. The IEP provides for the services of a speech and language therapist to work with STUDENT on these goals. These services are to be provided two times per week, with each session lasting sixty minutes.

STUDENT has difficulty with social skills. The IEP provides a goal and two short-term objectives in the area of social skills, and a goal and objectives in self-esteem and social emotional development. These goals are the responsibility of the school counselor, the classroom teacher, STUDENT and his parents. The IEP provides for the services of the counselor once a week for 30 minutes.

STUDENT has significant problems with motor skills. The IEP establishes goals in the area of fine motor skills with an emphasis on the motor skills necessary for handwriting. Those responsible for helping STUDENT achieve these goals and objectives includes the APE teacher, the occupational therapist, and the classroom teacher. The IEP provides for the services of the APE teacher two times per week for 60 minutes per session. The IEP provides for concentrated effort by occupational therapist Mary Bembow to address handwriting during August 1997. During the regular school year, occupational therapist services were to be provided for one hour per week. To assist STUDENT's fine motor skill problems, the IEP has provided for ten sessions of vision therapy.

The psychologist's reports from both the District's psychologist and the psychologist retained by STUDENT's parents recommend small-group instruction in STUDENT's areas of need. The District's proposed program provides for small-group instruction by the resources specialist, speech and language therapist, occupational therapist, and APE teacher.

Based on the above, it is concluded that STUDENT's unique and individual educational needs were appropriately addessed in the April 22, 1997 IEP, as supplemented by the IEP team on May 28, 1997 and September 3, 1997.

STUDENT's attorney argues that the District's proposed program and placement did not address STUDENT's unique needs for a number of reasons and that STUDENT needed a more restrictive placement than the RSP program at Carmel Creek.

Twenty United States Code Section 1412 (a) (5) (A) provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private instructions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

STUDENT's attorney argued that placement of STUDENT in an RSP program, with the majority of his time spent in a regular class on a large campus, was not appropriate because, in the past, such a placement led to anxiety that caused STUDENT to engage in self-mutilation which, in turn, endangered his physical health. By self-mutilation, STUDENT's attorney was referring to STUDENT's nervous habit of picking at his skin. The extent and cause of this behavior was not clear from the record.

STUDENT's pediatrician, Dr. Eastman, testified that she treated STUDENT on a number of occasions during the 1996-97 school year for staphylococcal infections which were a result of STUDENT's picking at himself, causing sores. Dr. Eastman attributes the skin picking to STUDENT's anxiety caused by an inappropriate school program during the 1996-97 school year. However, Dr. Eastman admitted that she had not talked to anyone about the possible cause except STUDENT's mother. She appears to have concluded that STUDENT's anxiety was caused by his placement at Carmel Creek School because she observed a change in STUDENT when she saw him on August 21, 1997, after he had left Carmel Creek. Dr. Eastman testified that STUDENT's anger and frustration had subsided and his skin had healed. She attributed the changes to his being at City School during the summer session rather than at Carmel Creek. However, Dr. Eastman saw STUDENT during August when he was attending neither City School nor Carmel Creek. She also admitted that it was STUDENT's mother who attributed the change in STUDENT to the change in school placement.

Whether STUDENT's nervous habits ended when he was placed at the City School is also in doubt. The APE teacher, Ms. Redman, observed that picking behavior in August, after the end of summer session at the City School, and at about the same time that Dr. Eastman saw STUDENT in her office. Ms. Chamberland, a teach at City School, testified that the picking behavior has subsided since STUDENT began attending City School, but admitted that he had recently started the nervous habit of hand rubbing.

The seriousness of STUDENT's skin picking while at Carmel Creek is also in dispute. STUDENT's teacher at Carmel Creek, Ms. Orrell, did observe STUDENT picking at his skin at times, but did not feel it was serious and saw it as one of his many nervous habits. The RSP teacher, Ms. Goldstein, testified that STUDENT would stop picking himself when told to and she did not see it as a serious problem when she was with STUDENT. Megan Prentice testified that she observed sores from picking at himself after he returned from Christmas vacation in early 1997. She said that the picking got worse, subsided for a while, and then reappeared later in the Spring.

It is concluded that STUDENT suffers from a number of nervous habits which include picking at his skin, rubbing his hands, pulling his hair, licking his lips and moving his feet. While it is true that school can cause anxiety which can trigger nervous habits, it has not been established that these habits were caused primarily by his program at Carmel Creek. STUDENT's IEP includes a cue and reward system to decrease his skin picking behavior. It is concluded that STUDENT's placement in a regular class at Carmel Creek with resource specialist services is not inappropriate due to STUDENT's various nervous habits, including picking at his skin.

STUDENT's attorney also argues that placement of STUDENT at Carmel Creek would be inappropriate because STUDENT is subject to intolerable teasing by other students in that setting. Again, the evidence does not support the conclusion that STUDENT has been subjected to such teasing. The only incident of teasing that has been established was the one in which some student three grapes at STUDENT while he was in the cafeteria. It was not clear that this incident related to STUDENT's disability. The District took action to punish one of the students responsible for the grape incident. The District also took action to counsel STUDENT and sensitize STUDENT's class to the inappropriateness of such conduct.

None of STUDENT's teachers observed STUDENT being teased. The only evidence of teasing presented by STUDENT's attorney was hearsay, which would not have been admissible over objection in a civil action. It consisted of affidavits or letters which were not only hearsay, but were conclusionary, and did not provide specific instances of teasing. Pursuant to California Code of Regulations Section 3082 (b), such hearsay evidence is not sufficient to support a finding.

While STUDENT's teachers, including his teacher at the City School, admitted that all children STUDENT's age are subject to some teasing, it is concluded that STUDENT was not subjected to an unreasonable amount of teasing at his Carmel Creek placement. The District included goals and objectives in STUDENT's IEP to address the parent's concerns about STUDENT's social- emotional status. A counselor was to provide services on a weekly basis. The District demonstrated the ability and willingness to deal with any possible future incidents of teasing.

STUDENT's attorney also contended that the Carmel Creek placement with its large class and school size would be inappropriate in light of STUDENT's tactile defensiveness and distractibility.

STUDENT's attorney called psychologist Sara Frampton as a witness. She testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT could not function in a classroom with 28 students and could not function on a large school campus because of his distractibility and his tactile defensiveness. While Ms. Frampton did observe STUDENT in his first grade class in 1994, she had no further contact with him until December 1997. She did not observe STUDENT in Ms. Orrell's class at Carmel Creek.

STUDENT's teachers at Carmel Creek, including Ms. Orrell, his classroom teacher, Ms. Goldstein, his resource specialist, and Ms. Redman, his APE teacher, all testified that STUDENT did have some tactile defensiveness that caused him to want his own space. He did not like people touching him. However, his teachers testified that his tactile defensiveness was not a big problem. The teachers accommodated this problem by giving him his own space, while working with him to accustom him to more physical interaction with both teachers and other students.

The evidence established that STUDENT was somewhat distractible. He was on medication that helped in this area, and Ms. Orrell testified that STUDENT was able to attend to his work. He sat near her so that she could help him stay on task. Ms. Goldstein, STUDENT's RSP teacher, testified that, at times, STUDENT would stare off and would need to be redirected to his work. Ms. Prentice, STUDENT's occupational therapist, stated that STUDENT was more fidgety and distractible than normal, but not a whole lot more. While the evidence does suggest that STUDENT has problems in the area of tactile defensiveness and distractibility, those problems were not so severe that they could not be accommodated in his placement in the resource specialist program at Carmel Creek.

For the reasons stated above, it is concluded that the District's proposed program and placement for STUDENT were designed to meet his unique and individual needs in the least restrictive environment.

B. Was the District's proposed program designed to provide STUDENT educational benefit?

The District and the parents agreed to the goals and objectives and the related services that were included in the IEP that was formulated during the spring and summer of 1997. The primary difference of opinion concerned the appropriate place to carry out the provisions of the IEP.

STUDENT's parents contend that the program would not provide educational benefit to STUDENT if it was carried out in a regular class with resource specialist services at Carmel Creek School. They asserted that a similar program had been in place during the 1996-97 school year and that appropriate progress was not achieved. Therefore, it is appropriate to review STUDENT's performance during the 1996-97 school year to help evaluate whether the school's proposed program for the 1997- 98 school year would result in educational benefit.

Progress can be measured in a number of ways. Reference to standardized test scores, grades, progress on goals and objectives, and teacher observations can all be used to determine progress.

STUDENT's most serious deficit is in the area of written language. His resource specialist Ms. Goldstein administered the written language sections of the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement Revised in 1995, 1996, 1997. Some of the results seem to show a pattern, while others seem anomalous. STUDENT's scores on the dictation test put him at the fourteenth percentile of his age group in 195, the twenty third percentile in 1996 and the twenty eighth percentile in 1997. These scores seem to reflect a pattern of improvement over the two-year period. STUDENT's scores on the writing sample are more difficult to interpret. He scored in the tenth percentile of his age group in 1995, the seventy-seventh percentile in 1996 and the thirty-fifth percentile in 1997. His scores on this test are even more difficult to interpret in light of the fact that he was administered the same test by a different administrator in January 1998, at which time he achieved a score which put him at the sixty-sixth percentile. When comparing his core in 1995 with those in 1997, it could be concluded that he demonstrated improvement. If one compares his 1996 score with his 1997 score, it could be concluded that there was a regression. The 1998 score adds to the confusion.

Progress may not have been readily inferred from the scores given on the writing samples, but progress is demonstrated when one compares the number of questions he was able to answer in each year. In 1996, STUDENT was not able to put down any response to questions 16-20 in the writing sample portion of the test. In 197, he provided answers to each of those questions and received points for each answer.

Psychologist Sara Frampton's testimony concerning STUDENT's past testing was of a general nature. She said that the testing had been late and not well administered. After her appearance at the hearing, STUDENT's attorney submitted a written analysis by Ms. Frampton that is strongly critical of the testing done by Ms. Goldstein. Ms. Frampton accuses Ms. Goldstein of giving too high a grade on some answers and too low a grade on others. She concludes that all of the testing by Ms. Goldstein is unreliable and should not be used in determining STUDENT's level of achievement. Ms. Frampton then compares her testing results in 1998 to the past tests administered by Ms. Goldstein and concludes that the results demonstrate how much the City School has benefited STUDENT. If Ms. Goldstein's testing is so unreliable that it cannot be used to judge STUDENT's achievement, it is logical to assume that is would also be an inappropriate basis of comparison.

Ms. Frampton did not appear in the hearing after submitting her written attack on Ms. Goldstein. The Hearing Officer offered to continue the hearing and allow Ms. Frampton and Ms. Goldstein to appear at the same time to discuss their differing views of the testing, but the parents' attorney declined. Ms. Goldstein, however, did appear at the hearing, and she explained that the evaluation of the writing samples is somewhat subjective and that, when examiners differ on a score, the test instructions provide that the scores should be averaged. She also explained that had the averaging been done between her scoring and Ms. Frampton's, the scores would have not be dramatically different from Ms. Goldstein's original scores. Ms. Goldstein also testified that she has been an RSP teacher for eight years and a teacher for over 25 years. She has administered the Woodcock Johnson Tests twelve times a year for the past eight years.

Ms. Frampton's written attack on Ms. Goldstein was extreme, bordering on unprofessional. Ms. Goldstein's testimony was measured and convincing. However, the test results on the writing samples are still difficult to interpret. Therefore, it is appropriate to consider other measures of progress.

A review of STUDENT's goals and objectives for the 1996-97 school year in the area of written expression shows that he had not met the goals and objectives by April 1997; however, the performance level outcomes indicate that growth has occurred, even though the objective has not been met. For instance, with respect to the objective for STUDENT to apply spelling strategies to improve spelling to an accuracy rate of 80%, the performance level outcome states that "objective not met. STUDENT has shown growth in spelling but continues to need support in developing spelling strategies." In relation to a number of other written expression objectives, the performance level outcome states: "continue this objective to maintain growth and development." It is concluded that STUDENT was making progress toward meeting the goals and objectives in the area of written expression, but was not progressing at the rate anticipated by the IEP at the time the objectives were formulated.

Grades are another indicator of progress. During the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT received all A's B's and C's. His grades in the area of written expression were his lowest grades (C-), but he was still receiving passing grades in that subject.

Teacher observations are also an important factor in determining progress. Ms. Orrell testified that STUDENT was making progress, although in some areas the progress was not as much as she would have liked. Ms. Goldstein also testified that STUDENT made good progress in the area of written language during the 1996-97 school year.

The testing done in the area of speech and language during 1995 and 1996 demonstrated a significant improvement. There appeared to be no standardized testing done in 1997; therefore, it is not possible to compare test results for that year. The speech and language therapist, Barbara Hochard, testified that STUDENT made good progress during the 1996-97 year. A review of the goals and objectives for the 1996-97 year show that he had made significant progress. He met his goal relating to intonation and fluency and achieved two of the three objectives in the area of fluency. While he did not achieve the objectives under expressive language, he made good progress toward that goal.

With respect to adaptive physical education, STUDENT appeared to be making good progress during 1996-97. STUDENT's APE teacher Ms Redman testified that he was making great headway. A review of the goals and objectives for the 1996-97 school year demonstrate that he achieved many of the objectives and made progress toward achieving others.

While STUDENT appeared to make progress in some areas addressed by the occupational therapist, there was little progress in handwriting. The report by STUDENT's occupational therapist, Megan Prentice states that STUDENT has no difficulty with rotational movements and has made excellent progress in midline crossing. Ms. Prentice testified that she was having such difficulty helping him improve his writing that during an IEP meeting in the Spring of 1997 she recommended discontinuing occupational therapy. The IEP team disagreed with this recommendation and decided that occupational therapy would continue. The team agreed to hire a nationally known occupational therapist, Mary Bembow, to perform an assessment and provide direct therapy to STUDENT during the month of August 1997. It was also agreed that STUDENT's APE teacher, Ms. Redman, would receive training by Ms. Bembow, which would allow her to continue the therapy during the 1997-98 year.

Although there were some areas of concern where STUDENT did not show the rate of progress that the IEP team had hoped for, it is concluded that STUDENT did make educational progress during the 1996- 97 year and that in the one area of most concern, handwriting, the IEP team developed an appropriate plan of action to provide remediation.

C. Did the program and placement conform to the student's IEP?

In STUDENT's case, the District did not have an opportunity to provide STUDENT's program for the 1997-98 school year. STUDENT's parents unilaterally removed him from the District's schools and placed him at the nonpublic City School. There is no evidence to support a conclusion that the District was unwilling or unable to provide the program set out in the IEP.

Based upon the discussion above, it is concluded that the District did offer an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year.

2. Was the City School an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year?

The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year. Therefore, it is not necessary to determine whether the City School was an appropriate placement.

3. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of tuition at City School during 1996-97 school year?

The District need not reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of tuition at the City School because, as discussed above, the District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement within the District for the 1996-97 school year.

4. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of private speech pathology services?

The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District offered an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year. That program included speech and language services twice a week for sixty minutes as provided in the IEP of April 22, 1997, which was signed by STUDENT's parents. Therefore, the District is not required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of private speech pathology services.

5. Should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of transportation of STUDENT to the City School during the 1996-97 school year?

As stated above, the District offered an appropriate program for STUDENT for his 1996-97 school year, and is, therefore, not required to reimburse the parents for their cost of placement of STUDENT at the City School, including the cost of transportation.

ORDER

All of the Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each part has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on all issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505 (I).

Dated: April 17, 1998 _________________________________ Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes