California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 15, 2005

Student v. New Haven Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1161-05 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

New Haven Unified's offer of a nonpublic school placement provided a FAPE in the least restrictive environment; all student claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated. Footnotes note that two earlier due process cases settled without hearing, in January 2004 and November 2004.

Summary

A parent filed for her 7-year-old son. He was eligible for special education under the category then called mental retardation. He had serious delays in language, attention and behavior, and his history at school included frequent hitting, kicking and biting. The District had placed him at Spectrum Center, a nonpublic school. The parent removed him in September 2004 after an incident in which staff used a mat to contain him. After that, he had only a private tutor. The parent wanted him in a District special day class, as she understood an independent assessor, Dr. Rochelle Wolk, had recommended. The Hearing Officer found that the District's Spectrum offer met the student's needs. It included goals, a behavior plan built from a functional analysis assessment, a one-to-one aide, a language-rich class and twice-weekly speech-language therapy. Spectrum's failure to send the parent some incident reports did not change that result. The nonpublic school was the least restrictive environment because the District had already tried special day classes with two adults, a behaviorist and a shortened day, and the student still did not succeed. The District did not fail to provide speech-language services or prior written notice, because the parent had declined services the District kept offering. Reports that the student had improved came only from outside school and did not show a significant change in his needs. All requested relief, including $1,905 in reimbursement, was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO decided whether a nonpublic school can be the least restrictive environment. Here, the district had documented failed special day class placements that used extensive supports. The decision also shows that a district that keeps offering services a parent declines has not failed to implement the IEP. And progress seen only at home did not require a new placement offer.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the New Haven Unified School District offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE in the LRE from November 15, 2004, to June 8, 2005? (Offer in place on November 15, 2004: Spectrum NPS with speech-language therapy, BIP, one-to-one aide, transportation)

    The Spectrum offer, with its goals, BIP, language-rich class, aide and twice-weekly speech-language therapy, met the student's unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1 (LRE). Whether the nonpublic school placement at Spectrum, rather than a District special day class, was the least restrictive environment

    The District had tried District SDCs with two adults, a behaviorist, modified schedules and a BIP, and the student was still not successful because of severe aggression, so the NPS was the LRE.

  3. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1 (implementation of speech-language). Whether the District failed to provide speech-language services required by the June 8, 2004 IEP and October 18, 2004 addendum

    The District kept offering speech-language services and stood ready to provide them; the parent declined all District services after removing the student, so no implementation failure occurred.

  4. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1 (prior written notice). Whether the District procedurally denied FAPE by failing to give prior written notice of reasons it would no longer provide speech-language services

    Because the District never proposed to change or refused to provide speech-language services, it did not have to give prior written notice.

  5. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1 (post-assessment change). Whether, after Dr. Wolk's January 2005 assessment, a significant change in the student's needs obligated the District to revise its offer and place him in a District SDC

    Under Adams v. Oregon, the evidence showed no significant change in the student's needs. Reports of improvement came only from outside school, and Dr. Wolk did not testify. The Spectrum offer stayed appropriate and was still the LRE.

  6. Issue 2. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to remedies (a) through (i): District SDC placement per Dr. Wolk; individual speech-language therapy; one-to-one transition aide; ESY in District SDC with aide; compensatory speech-language therapy; compensatory one-to-one academic instruction; transition counseling; $1,425 reimbursement for tutoring; $480 reimbursement for child care

    Because the District offered and provided a FAPE in the LRE, the student was not entitled to any of the requested remedies.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrman v. East Hanover; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Alamo Heights v. State Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • Karen R. Saucedo, director of special services, New Haven Unified School District
  • Sherler Harris, private tutor, Private
  • Scottie Smith, educational advocate, witness for Student
  • Patricia Jane Weiss, Ph.D., neuropsychologist in private practice, expert witness for Student
  • Rochelle B. Wolk, Ph.D., pediatric clinical psychologist and neuropsychologist, independent assessor (did not testify)
  • Julie Robinson, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, behaviorist, Method Managements (Method Management Consultants), nonpublic agency
  • Vivian David, PsyD., clinical director, Stepping Stones Center for Autistic Spectrum Disorders, nonpublic agency
  • Elizabeth Flowers, speech-language pathologist, Spectrum Center for Educational and Behavioral Development (NPS)
  • Stephanie Martin, program director, Spectrum Center (NPS)
  • Katie Morrison, senior clinician / former education coordinator; conducted FAA and BIP, Spectrum Center (NPS)
  • Thora Cahill-Solis, Ph.D., school psychologist, New Haven Unified School District
  • Cynthia Zimmerman, preschool teacher, New Haven Unified School District
  • Pauline Bettencourt, special day class teacher, New Haven Unified School District
  • Danielle Cruz, special day class teacher (HELLP program, Alvarado Elementary), New Haven Unified School District
  • Susan (Sue) Robertson, program specialist, case carrier, New Haven Unified School District
  • Beatriz Kim, occupational therapist (OTR/L), assessor
  • Shunnae A. Lewis, speech-language pathologist, assessor, Department of Social Services, Disability Evaluation Division
  • Brittney Davis, private child care provider
  • Spectrum Center for Educational and Behavioral Development, certified nonpublic school
  • Diagnostic Center, Northern California, state assessment center
  • Children's Learning Center, nonpublic school discussed as possible placement
  • Regional Center of the East Bay, regional center evaluator
  • East Bay Agency for Children Therapeutic Nursery School, prior preschool provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Union City, California, on May 31, and June 1, 2, 3, and 7, 2005. (Footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Inga Sanders of ADAMS ESQ. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were attorney Kimberly Thomas-Rapp, also of ADAMS ESQ, and PARENT, his parent. Respondent New Haven Unified School District was represented by attorney Dora Dome of Miller Brown Dannis. Also present on behalf of the District was Karen R. Saucedo, director of special services.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: PARENT; Sherler Harris, STUDENT’s tutor; Scottie Smith; educational advocate; and Patricia Jane Weiss, Ph.D., neuropsychologist in private practice. The District called the following witnesses: Julie Robinson, clinical psychologist, Method Managements, a certified nonpublic agency (NPA); Vivian David, PsyD., clinical director, Stepping Stones; employees of Spectrum Center for Educational and Behavioral Development (Spectrum), a certified nonpublic school (NPS), including Elizabeth Flowers, speech and language pathologist; Stephanie Martin, program director; and Katie Morrison, senior clinician; and District employees Thora Cahill-Solis, Ph.D., school psychologist; Cynthia Zimmerman, preschool teacher; Pauline Bettencourt, special day class (SDC) teacher; Danielle, Cruz, SDC teacher; and Susan Robertson, program specialist.

ISSUES

(1) Did the New Haven Unified School District offer and provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from November 15, 2004, to June 8, 2005? (Footnote 2)

(2) If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to the following remedies:

(a) placement in a District SDC pursuant to recommendations by Rochelle Wolk, Ph.D.; (b) individual speech and language therapy two times a week for 30 minutes each session; (c) a one-to-one behavioral aide to assist with transitioning STUDENT from home to placement in an SDC; (d) extended school year services (ESY) in a District SDC with a one-to-one aide; (e) compensatory individual speech and language therapy one time a week for 45 minutes from the present through June 2006; (f) compensatory one-to-one instruction by a credentialed teacher in all academic areas for two hours each week from the present through June 2006; (g) counseling by a school psychologist to assist with transitioning from home to placement in an SDC for 45 minutes each week from the present through January 2006; (h) reimbursement in the amount of $1,425 for private educational tutoring by Mr. Harris from January 2005 to the present; and (i) reimbursement in the amount of $480 for child care and related services by Brittney Davis?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a seven-year-old student residing within the boundaries of the New Haven Unified School District. STUDENT qualifies for special education under the eligibility category of mental retardation. His cognitive skills are estimated to fall within the mild to moderate range of mental retardation. STUDENT exhibits significant deficits in language, social skills, attention, and behavior. At school, STUDENT has exhibited aggressive behavior that includes hitting, kicking, biting, scratching, and slapping individuals working with him. STUDENT does not currently attend school. In September 2004, PARENT removed him from his then-current placement--Spectrum, a certified nonpublic school (NPS)-- because of a dispute regarding the appropriateness of that placement. PARENT provides a private tutor, Mr. Harris, for STUDENT. Mr. Harris works with STUDENT for approximately ten hours each week.

STUDENT attended the Emeryville Child Development Center when he was two years old. He then attended the East Bay Agency for Children Therapeutic Nursery School from approximately September 2001 to December 2001. By report of staff at the Therapeutic Nursery School, STUDENT exhibited severe expressive and receptive language delays and behavior control problems. He began receiving speech and language therapy and behavior management services. In July 2002, the Regional Center of the East Bay evaluated STUDENT and determined that he met the diagnostic criteria for a Pervasive Developmental Disorder-Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS).

STUDENT’s family moved to Union City and, in September 2002, STUDENT entered Alvarado Elementary School within the District. He was placed in a special day class (SDC) preschool program for children with autism and/or language delays (Highly-Intensive Early Learning and Language or HELLP Program). However, because of STUDENT’s severe behavioral and academic challenges, the District members of the IEP team recommended changing STUDENT’s placement to Spectrum, a nonpublic school serving children with behavioral difficulties. PARENT observed Spectrum. However, because she did not consent to STUDENT’s placement at Spectrum, the IEP team then agreed that STUDENT would receive an intensive home instruction program with behavior support services. In April, the District contracted with Stepping Stones Center for Autistic Spectrum Disorders to provide behavioral intervention services to STUDENT in his home. Stepping Stones provided approximately twenty hours per week of one-to-one discrete trial teaching and three hours of program supervision and consultation. The services emphasized development of STUDENT’s cognitive, social, adaptive, and behavior skills. Sometime in June 2003, PARENT withdrew her consent to the Stepping Stones home program. Apparently, PARENT mistrusted some Stepping Stones staff after a report was filed with Child Protective Services. Following several unsuccessful attempts to convene an IEP meeting to discuss services for STUDENT, the team met in August 2003. The District continued to recommend that STUDENT return to Spectrum. PARENT requested that STUDENT attend Alvarado for three days a week and a home-based program for the remaining two days a week. Because no agreement was reached regarding STUDENT’s placement, the District requested a special education due process hearing in October 2003. This case resolved in January 2004 without the need for a hearing.

In January 2004, the Diagnostic Center, Northern California, assessed STUDENT pursuant to the agreement reached by the parties. One day of the assessment took place at his home and a second day of testing occurred at the Diagnostic Center. The report from the assessment notes that STUDENT was much more interactive and engaged at home than he was at the Diagnostic Center. For example, at the Diagnostic Center, STUDENT was able to attend only for brief periods and was highly distracted, whereas at home, he engaged in some activities with the assessors. The assessors found that STUDENT’s language and communication skills were impaired, both receptively and expressively. The report states that STUDENT was using one to four-word utterances that were not easily understood because of articulation errors. The Diagnostic Center report states that STUDENT’s behavior, attention span, and language caused him to appear more similar to a child of two to three years of age than to a child of nearly six years old. The Diagnostic Center assessors did not find STUDENT to exhibit characteristics of a child falling within the autism spectrum. Rather, assessment results placed him in the category of mental retardation. The Diagnostic Center report describes the components of an appropriate educational environment for STUDENT. Those components include a program to teach STUDENT basic school behaviors; a gradual, planned progression to return him to a classroom setting; a consistent routine; a highly structured environment; use of positive behavior intervention strategies; and language and communication intervention. The report also makes specific recommendations for staff that would be working individually with STUDENT. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 9.)

At an IEP meeting on February 3, 2004, the IEP team agreed to transition STUDENT from the home-based program to a school program. Initially, STUDENT was to attend school on a modified schedule consisting of 105 minutes daily with the services of a behavioral aide and a one-to-one instructional aide. The goal was to gradually increase the length of STUDENT’s school day. On March 2, 2004, STUDENT returned to Alvarado Elementary in the HELLP SDC. The class generally serves children with autism in Kindergarten through the third grade. In addition to the regular classroom staff, STUDENT received the support of an aide and a behaviorist. The District contracted with Method Management Consultants to develop a program to systematically reintroduce STUDENT to a public school classroom. STUDENT’s schedule included the following: ten minutes of fine-motor activity at a table with the other students; twenty minutes of gross-motor activities; circle time with the other students; table-top academic tasks for five minutes; free-choice time to play with the toys; and snack with the other students.

An occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT was completed on March 22, 2004, by Beatriz Kim, registered/licensed occupational therapist (OTR/L). The District convened an IEP meeting on March 23, 2004, to discuss the results of Ms. Kim’s assessment and to review STUDENT’s placement. The team agreed with Ms. Kim’s recommendation that STUDENT did not require occupational therapy and adopted new goals and objectives. Finally, PARENT consented to a functional analysis assessment.

On April 6, 2004, the IEP team met to review STUDENT’s progress. The team agreed to change STUDENT’s special education eligibility to mental retardation. Because of STUDENT’s ongoing behavioral difficulties at Alvarado, the District members of the IEP team recommended placing STUDENT in a new Spectrum satellite program located at Bernard White Middle School in Union City. The IEP notes that STUDENT was engaging in 30 or more episodes of aggression daily. PARENT consented to the change of placement. The team also agreed to refer STUDENT for a speech and language assessment.

In April 2004, STUDENT began attending Spectrum Monday through Friday for two and one-half hours daily. Elizabeth Flowers, J.S., CCC-SLP, completed a speech and language assessment. Her report dated June 7, 2004, recommended that STUDENT continue to receive speech and language therapy for two sessions per week for thirty minutes each to increase his mean length of utterance (MLU), vocabulary, articulation, and language processing. In May and June 2004, Katie Morrison, Spectrum education coordinator, undertook a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of STUDENT and developed a positive behavior intervention plan (BIP) based on information gathered from informal and formal observations and parent and teacher interviews. The goal of the plan was to decrease STUDENT’s aggressive behavior and tantrums and increase appropriate alternative behaviors. The plan identified the following targeted behaviors: (1) aggression including STUDENT’s throwing objects at students and staff, hitting students and staff, pressing his mouth and teeth against staff’s skin with enough force to cause redness, making physical contact with staff using the top of his head or forehead, and holding objects in his hand and hitting students and staff with the objects with enough force to cause redness and bruising, (2) property destruction including STUDENT’s climbing and standing on tables, desks, chairs, and other furniture, and pushing over tables and chairs, (3) bolting including STUDENT’s exiting the classroom without supervision and running away from supervision in the community, and (4) out of seat behavior including STUDENT’s running in the classroom. The BIP included antecedent interventions, replacement behaviors, reinforcement strategies, consequence-based strategies, and emergency procedures. The emergency procedures were to be employed when other strategies failed and STUDENT placed himself or others in danger. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 17.)

On June 8, 2004, the IEP team met to review STUDENT’s placement at Spectrum. The IEP calls for STUDENT’s continued placement at Spectrum through June 8, 2005, for five hours daily from 9:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., and for the services of speech and language therapy two times weekly for 30 minutes each session. The team adopted new goals and objectives and the BIP described above. Goals included following a schedule and learning to wait, participating in group activities, counting to 100, identifying letters and sounds, tying his shoes, writing his name, improving articulation, answering questions, increasing length of utterances, and increasing vocabulary. The IEP also indicates that STUDENT was eligible for extended school year services.

On September 27, 2004, PARENT removed STUDENT from Spectrum in response to an incident at the school. On the day in question, PARENT arrived to pick up STUDENT and found staff had contained him in a corner of the classroom behind a mat. STUDENT was naked. According to Spectrum staff involved in the incident, STUDENT had removed his clothes and thrown them over the mat. Shortly after STUDENT’s removal from Spectrum, a due process hearing request was filed on behalf of STUDENT. (Footnote 3) The District convened an IEP meeting on October 18, 2004. PARENT did not agree with the District’s recommendation that STUDENT return to Spectrum. The District’s offer also included a one-to-one aide and continued speech and language therapy. PARENT indicated she did not believe Spectrum was able to appropriately address STUDENT’s behavior. She also stated that Spectrum had not called her or sent home incident reports related to STUDENT’s behavioral incidents. PARENT requested additional assessments and that STUDENT be returned to a public school SDC. No agreement was reached at that time regarding STUDENT’s placement. However, there was agreement that the District would fund a private assessment and that the parties would visit several nonpublic schools that could be considered by the IEP team as possible placement options for STUDENT.

As the result of an agreement between the parties, Rochelle B. Wolk, Ph.D., pediatric clinical psychologist and neuropsychologist, undertook an assessment of STUDENT over five sessions between November 2004 and January 2005. (Footnote 4) Dr. Wolk met with PARENT and the District to discuss her findings and recommendations contained in her report dated January 23, 2005. Dr. Wolk described STUDENT’s attention span as “extremely variable.” She noted that STUDENT rarely sustained focus on materials or activities she had selected. However, when given an opportunity to select the activity himself, STUDENT would engage in simple activities. Dr. Wolk found that STUDENT presented with impaired social, emotional, language, and cognitive skills. Dr. Wolk found STUDENT’s motor skills age appropriate. Dr. Wolk’s report makes specific recommendations regarding STUDENT’s educational program. Included in her recommendations are that STUDENT be provided social and language interactions with developmentally appropriate peers; be placed in a developmentally appropriate school setting such as an SDC with limited class size and sufficient trained professionals, including a one-to-one aide at the outset; be provided with individual and very small-group instruction; be gradually transitioned to the school setting with the aide; be provided year round instruction; and be provided individual speech and language therapy that includes pairing sign language with spoken language. Other recommendations include the use of multimodal input and behavior management strategies. Dr. Wolk additionally recommended that there be a location where STUDENT could “cool off.” (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 21.)

On May 6, 2005, Ms. Sanders filed a due process hearing request on behalf of STUDENT.

The District convened an IEP meeting on May 16, 2005. The District continued to offer to place STUDENT in Spectrum. The IEP notes that other potential nonpublic schools either were unacceptable to PARENT or would not accept STUDENT as a student. The District also offered “home” instruction at the District’s office pending placement in Spectrum with weekly speech and language therapy for 30 minutes. The rationale behind this offer was to generate current information regarding STUDENT to allow the IEP team to write goals and objectives, and to transition him to a school routine, since STUDENT had not been in an educational environment since September 2004. PARENT requested that the District provide a program consistent with the recommendations of Dr. Wolk in an SDC on a District elementary school campus. In a letter dated May 25, 2005, the District clarified that its offer at Spectrum is five days per week from 9:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. and includes two weekly sessions of speech and language therapy, a one-to-one aide, and intensive behavior support. The letter further clarifies that the “home” instruction would be provided for one hour daily from May 16 to June 8, 2005.

The parties were unable to reach agreement regarding STUDENT’s placement and the matter proceeded to hearing.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner STUDENT contends that the Respondent New Haven Unified School District’s offer in place on November 15, 2005—to attend the Spectrum Center, a certified nonpublic school (NPS) located at Bernard White Middle School, with the services of transportation, a behavioral intervention plan, and speech and language services—was not designed to meet his needs and did not offer him a placement in the least restrictive environment. In particular, Petitioner raised concerns related to addressing his speech and language and behavioral needs.

Petitioner additionally asserts that following his removal from Spectrum, he has made significant progress in the area of behavior and recently has been prescribed medication to assist with inattention. For these reasons, Petitioner contends that the District had an obligation to make a subsequent offer of placement that is consistent with the recommendations made by Dr. Wolk in the report of her assessment dated January 23, 2005. Petitioner asserts that an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment is a special day class on a District elementary school with supplemental services that include a transition plan and speech and language therapy. Petitioner also asserts that the District substantively denied him a FAPE by failing to provide speech and language services from November 15, 2005, to the present pursuant to his IEP dated June 8, 2004. Petitioner contends that the District procedurally denied him a FAPE by failing to provide prior written notice to his parent of the reasons it no longer would provide him with speech and language services after November 15, 2005.

The District contends that placement at Spectrum with speech and language therapy and behavioral support services offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. The District asserts that prior attempts to place STUDENT in a District SDC have failed due to his aggressive and violent behavior. The District contends that at all times at issue it has made speech and language services (as well as placement at Spectrum) available to STUDENT pursuant to IEPs dated June 8, 2004, October 18 2004, and May 16, 2005. However, PARENT has declined all services from the District. Thus, the District asserts that because it has neither proposed to change STUDENT’s speech and language services nor declined to provide the services to STUDENT, the District was not responsible for providing PARENT with prior written notice.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the New Haven Unified School District offer and provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from November 15, 2004, to June 8, 2005?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (Footnote 5) 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3001(2).

A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both substantive and procedural issues. Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is that the parent must be allowed to meaningfully participate in the development of the IEP. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). The Court in Rowley determined that the IEP must be designed to provide educational benefit to the students and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. However, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. However, flaws that seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process or that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student result in the denial of FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

Additionally, special education law requires, as set forth below, that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE).

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

20 U.S.C. § 1412; See also Cal. Educ. Code § 56342(b).

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program (1) must have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) must have been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) must have comported with his IEP. Finally, the District must have offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

THE DISTRICT’S OFFER OF SUBSTANTIVE FAPE AS OF NOVEMBER 15, 2005

The Hearing Officer must first determine STUDENT’s unique needs as of November 15, 2004, prior to addressing the appropriateness of the District’s offer of placement and services in place on that date. (Footnote 6)

STUDENT’s Needs

The evidence establishes that STUDENT is mild to moderately mentally retarded. An assessment completed by the Diagnostic Center in January 2004, found that STUDENT was functioning between two to three years below his chronological age. Stephanie Martin, program director at Spectrum, testified that while attending Spectrum in the fall of 2004, STUDENT exhibited significant academic, social, language, and behavioral deficits. (Footnote 7) The Diagnostic Center’s assessment, the testimony of Ms. Martin, and the consistent testimony of the witnesses who have worked with STUDENT in an educational environment establish that STUDENT excelled at gross-motor skills but exhibited significant deficits in the areas of speech, language, social skills, attention, and behavior. He also exhibited deficits in academic areas. PARENT concurs that STUDENT experiences difficulty in these areas but disputes the extent of STUDENT’s social and behavioral difficulties. Each area of deficit and the resulting needs are discussed more fully below.

Turning first to STUDENT’s speech and language skills, PARENT testified that in the fall of 2004, STUDENT exhibited speech and language problems at home. Elizabeth Flowers provided specific information regarding STUDENT’s deficits and needs in the areas of speech and language. Ms. Flowers holds a certificate of clinical competence as a speech and language pathologist (CCC-SLP), and is employed by Spectrum. From May 2004 through September 2004, Ms. Flowers assessed STUDENT and provided him with speech and language services. (Footnote 8) Ms. Flowers testified that STUDENT had a severe articulation disorder that made his speech unintelligible approximately 35 percent of the time. Ms. Flowers observed that STUDENT also had difficulty following directions, answering “yes/no” and “wh” questions, and understanding some concepts. She testified that STUDENT spoke in one- to three-word sentences unless prompted to use longer sentences. Ms. Flowers also testified that STUDENT exhibited reduced social language skills. For example, she did not observe STUDENT initiate conversations with peers or teachers. However, she did observe him respond to greetings from peers and teachers. In summary, Ms. Flowers testified that STUDENT had a language disorder in social language and a severe articulation disorder for which he required speech and language therapy. Ms. Flowers recommended that STUDENT receive two sessions per week of speech and language therapy of 30 minutes duration each. She recommended individual therapy to focus on STUDENT’s improving his articulation skills, sounds, and some language concepts. She recommended a group session and placement in a class in which the development of language and communication skills were emphasized throughout the school day to allow STUDENT to generalize skills that he would be learning in the individual sessions and to develop social language skills.

Ms. Flowers testified that the conclusions of a subsequent speech and language assessment conducted by Shunnae A. Lewis, M.S., CCC-SLP, at the request of the Department of Social Services, Disability Evaluation Division, are consistent with her findings and recommendations. (See report dated October 27, 2004; Respondent’s Exhibit 73)

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Flowers’ testimony is persuasive as to STUDENT’s speech and language needs. She assessed STUDENT relatively close to the time at issue and provided his speech and language therapy immediately prior to PARENT’ removing STUDENT from Spectrum in September 2004. Thus, Ms. Flowers has first-hand knowledge of STUDENT’s speech and language skills at the period in dispute. Ms. Flowers holds appropriate specialized credentials to both assess and provide speech and language therapy. Furthermore, Ms. Flowers’ findings are supported by the subsequent assessment by Ms. Lewis, who also is a certified speech and language therapist. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that because STUDENT had a severe articulation disorder and a social language disorder, he required both individual and group speech and language therapy language sessions, and a class that emphasized development of language and communication skills.

The evidence establishes that in the fall of 2004, STUDENT was highly distractible. PARENT acknowledged STUDENT’s attentional difficulties. (Footnote 9) STUDENT’s teachers, including Ms. Cahill-Solis and Ms. Bettencourt, and Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT exhibited limited attention and required highly reinforcing and engaging activities to capture his interest.

Regarding STUDENT’s behavior, PARENT testified that STUDENT behaved appropriately at home. She also testified that STUDENT was able to get along with children outside of school. PARENT denied having received much of the information from the District regarding his behavioral problems and incidents involving aggression at school. She also testified that she was “not aware of STUDENT’s having exhibited severe aggressive behavior in prior placements before entering the District.” However, PARENT did recall reports of STUDENT’s crying and running away while attending Alvarado. PARENT testified that the description of STUDENT’s behavior in the positive behavior plan drafted by Spectrum is “exaggerated.”

All of the District’s witnesses testified that the greatest area of concern for STUDENT in the fall of 2004 was his aggressive behavior at school. The witnesses uniformly testified that STUDENT’s aggressive behavior has persisted since preschool in spite of significant interventions that have included providing one-to-one aides, placing him in a class with a low student-to-teacher ratio, implementing positive BIPs, providing a highly structured educational environment, giving frequent rewards to STUDENT, shortening STUDENT’s school day, and developing a schedule that includes highly rewarding activities interspersed with breaks and physical activities.

Cynthia Zimmer, STUDENT’s preschool teacher in the fall of 2002, testified that STUDENT engaged in inappropriate behaviors that included kicking, hitting, biting, and scratching. Thora Chahill-Solis testified that STUDENT exhibited similar behavior during the 2002-2003 school year. Vivian David, PsyD., clinical director of Stepping Stones for Autistic Spectrum Disorder, Inc., testified that STUDENT’s behaviors during his home-based program included screaming, whining, slapping, kicking, biting, and throwing objects at the therapists. Stepping Stones provided STUDENT’s home-based program from May to June of 2003. Dr. David is the clinical director of Stepping Stones. Although Dr. David does not personally know STUDENT, she directed his program and supervised the therapists implementing the program. She testified that her information regarding STUDENT came directly from the therapists working with him. Pauline Bettencourt, STUDENT’s teacher for a portion of 2003, testified that STUDENT’s behaviors in her class included hitting, head butting, biting, scratching, and climbing over the tables.

Danielle Cruz, STUDENT’s SDC teacher from March 2004 until he was removed from her class and placed in Spectrum, similarly testified that STUDENT engaged in aggressive behaviors that included kicking, biting, hitting, and screaming. She testified that these behaviors occurred very frequently. Julie Robinson, Ph.D., testified that STUDENT exhibited challenging behaviors that included physical aggression, running away from staff, hitting, kicking, head butting, biting, and pinching. In Dr. Robinson’s opinion, STUDENT’s behavior problems have been the greatest barriers to his success in school. Dr. Robinson is a licensed clinical psychologist and is employed by Method Managements, a private nonpublic agency. She worked directly with STUDENT while he attended Alvarado

Katie Morrison testified that during the period STUDENT attended Spectrum, she observed STUDENT engage in aggressive behavior that included kicking, hitting of staff and students, destroying property, and exiting class without permission. Ms. Morrison testified that the primary function of each of STUDENT’s behaviors was to gain access to a preferred activity. Ms. Morrison testified that the high frequency, intensity, and duration of STUDENT’s behaviors required significant staff intervention. Ms. Morrison currently is Spectrum’s senior clinician. During the period STUDENT attended Spectrum, Ms. Morrison served as the education coordinator. She completed STUDENT’s FAA and BIP. (See Respondent’s Exhibits 56 and 59.)

There is some evidence to support PARENT’ testimony that STUDENT’s behavior at home was not as severe as it has been in the various educational environments. Sherler Harris, STUDENT’s tutor since February 2005, testified that STUDENT has not behaved aggressively toward him. Scottie Smith, educational advocate, also testified that during a recent visit to her office, STUDENT was cooperative with her and she did not feel threatened by him. (See also Diagnostic Center Report, Petitioner’s Exhibit 9, page 2.) However, the testimony of Mr. Harris and Ms. Smith was based on recent observations of STUDENT. Neither knew STUDENT in the fall of 2004. Therefore, their testimony carries no weight regarding STUDENT’s needs at the initial time period in dispute. Additionally, PARENT declined to acknowledge multiple reports from various sources regarding the severity of STUDENT’s behavior in the educational environment. However, this does not overcome the consistent testimony of all of the witnesses who have worked with or observed STUDENT in a public or private educational environment regarding the seriousness of STUDENT’s inappropriate and aggressive behavior at school.

Therefore, because of their expertise and observations of STUDENT in various educational environments, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of the teachers, behaviorists, and psychologists from the District, Spectrum, and several nonpublic agencies establishes that, since preschool, STUDENT has exhibited aggressive behaviors that have interfered with his ability to access his education. Those behaviors in the fall of 2004 included physical aggression, running away from staff, and hitting, kicking, head butting, and biting of both staff and students.

As to STUDENT’s needs arising from his aggressive behavior and inattention, the report from the Diagnostic Center’s assessment of STUDENT in January 2004 states “developing interventions to teach STUDENT basic school behaviors is the first step in helping him begin to participate in a school setting. Basic school behaviors include, for example, sitting quietly, having quiet hands, attempting an assigned task, completing a task and following simple directions.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 9.) To address STUDENT’s behaviors in the classroom, the Diagnostic Center report states that STUDENT required a consistent routine and a highly structured environment. The Diagnostic Center report recommends a routine that has STUDENT engaging in preferred activities followed by breaks throughout his school day. The report also recommends certain positive behavioral intervention strategies that included interpreting STUDENT’s behavior as communicative, beginning to teach STUDENT specific behaviors he needs to engage in, and consistently and frequently reinforcing STUDENT for positive behavior. (Respondent’s Exhibit 45.) Dr. Robinson, Ms. Cruz, Spectrum employees, and the other witnesses who have worked with STUDENT concurred with the recommendations of the Diagnostic Center. Ms. Cruz specifically recommended frequently providing STUDENT with rewards for appropriate behavior. All concurred that STUDENT required a positive BIP that addressed preventing target behaviors, teaching alternative behaviors, and properly responding to target behaviors with reinforcers. They also were in agreement that the plan needed to be implemented consistently. Because of the experience of the District’s witnesses working with STUDENT specifically and with other children with behavioral problems, the fact that their testimony was consistent with the recommendations of the Diagnostic Center, and because there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony persuasive.

Finally, there was general consensus among the witnesses that STUDENT required specialized instruction to address his academic deficits and that the instruction must take into consideration his cognitive, language, attention, and behavior skills. There also is no dispute that STUDENT required one-to-one support.

In summary, in November 15, 2004, STUDENT’s needs included the following: individual and group speech and language therapy, language and communication infused throughout the school day, specialized instruction delivered individually or with a very small number of other students, a highly structured environment, a consistent routine that included preferred activities followed by breaks, and a positive behavior intervention plan that included teaching specific behaviors and consistent and frequent reinforcement for positive behavior.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs

To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the Hearing Officer must first focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). Additionally, in evaluating the appropriateness of a district’s offer, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has concluded that the actions of the district cannot be “judged exclusively in hindsight . . . and that an IEP must take into account what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993).

The IEP in place on November 15, 2004, is dated June 8, 2004. There also is an addendum to the IEP dated October 18, 2004. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 18 and Respondent’s Exhibit 64.) The IEP includes goals and objectives in the areas of academics, self-help, prevocation, speech and language, and behavior. STUDENT’s IEP also includes a BIP to address aggressive behavior, bolting from the class, and out of seat behavior. The IEP and addendum call for STUDENT to attend Spectrum daily from 9:00 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. and to receive the services of transportation to and from school and two sessions weekly of speech and language. The duration of each speech and language session was 30 minutes and to be delivered individually and in a group. The IEP addendum included a one-to-one aide.

Turning first to the adequacy of the goals and objectives, a review of the IEP reveals that it contains speech and language goals that are related to producing certain sounds, following prepositional concepts given a verbal prompt, using four-word utterances to make requests, answering yes/no questions independently, and stating his name, address, and phone number. In the area of behavior, goals and objectives call for STUDENT to follow his schedule and complete tasks, participate in structured group activities, and follow the command of “wait.” Finally, academic areas that are addressed include writing his name, counting, sorting pictures by categories, identifying letters, and saying the sounds of certain letters. Other goals and objectives address tying his shoes, going to a store and making a purchase, safely crossing the street, and developing prevocational skills.

Ms. Morrison testified generally that the goals and objectives were appropriate to address STUDENT’s educational needs. Ms. Morrison worked with STUDENT while he attended Spectrum and, therefore, has direct knowledge of STUDENT’s educational needs in the fall of 2004. No one disputed her testimony related to the appropriateness of the goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony persuasive and concludes that goals and objectives were designed to address STUDENT’s areas of identified needs including speech and language, academics, behavior.

Regarding STUDENT’s speech and language needs, Ms. Flowers testified that the IEP reflects her recommendations. She testified that the recommendations were derived from the results of her assessment and were appropriate at the time they were made. Ms. Flowers had recommended goals, objectives, and therapy to improve STUDENT’s articulation, language, social language, and mean length of utterance. Ms. Flowers testified that part of her work at Spectrum included consulting with the teachers regarding students on her caseloads. Ms. Flowers also described STUDENT’s class at Spectrum as “language enriched.” Ms. Flowers stated that Spectrum staff is trained to implement the goals when she is not there and “seek out opportunities for the students to use and expand language.” For example, when the class goes into the community, the staff works with the students to make requests.

Ms. Flowers assessed and worked with STUDENT from May until he was withdrawn from Spectrum in September 2004. Ms. Flower’s recommendations were supported by Ms. Lewis’s assessment in October 24. There was no persuasive evidence to contradict Ms. Flowers’ testimony. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Flowers’ testimony persuasive and concludes that the District’s offer of therapy and a language-enriched class was designed to address STUDENT’s speech and language needs.

PARENT testified regarding the ability of Spectrum to address STUDENT’s behavioral needs. PARENT testified that Spectrum was not appropriate for STUDENT because he imitated the inappropriate behaviors of other students. She testified that she observed other students hitting, jumping, spitting, and running in class. PARENT also testified that she observed students being “harassed and abused” at Spectrum. In particular, PARENT testified that on September 24, 2004, when she went to Spectrum to pick up STUDENT, she found him being contained behind a blue exercise mat by staff. His clothes were folded up on his desk and STUDENT was in a fetal position in the corner. (Footnote 10) He was crying. PARENT described him as “mentally distraught.” PARENT testified that she observed STUDENT at least one other time being restrained behind the mat. Additionally, PARENT testified that STUDENT did not want to get on the bus in the morning to go to Spectrum. PARENT also expressed concern that she did not receive all incident reports from Spectrum regarding STUDENT’s behavior.

Ms. Martin testified on behalf of the District regarding the program offered at the Bernard White Spectrum location. Ms. Morrison provided similar information. Their testimony establishes the following. Spectrum serves children with varying diagnosis including autism, developmental delays, and Down’s Syndrome. There are three classes on the campus. The class sizes range from 3 to 10 students with the ratio of students to staff from two-to-one to three-to-one. Spectrum staff includes an education coordinator, speech and language therapist, teachers, aides, an adaptive physical education specialist, and an occupational therapist. A functional analysis assessment (FAA) is conducted for each student that enters Spectrum from which a behavioral intervention program (BIP) is developed. In teaching the children, the staff follows principles of applied behavioral analysis. The staff is trained in behavioral intervention techniques and also receives training regarding the implementation of each individual student’s BIP. The staff is required to go through Pro-ACT training so that they are familiar with techniques to respond to students’ inappropriate behaviors by using de-escalation techniques, implementing the emergency procedures in students’ BIPs, and responding physically, if necessary.

STUDENT’s class had four students ranging in age from 6 to 10 years. The classroom teacher assisted STUDENT, who also had a one-to-one aide. To address STUDENT’s behavior, Ms. Morrison undertook a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and developed a behavioral intervention plan (BIP). Ms. Morrison testified that a primary goal at Spectrum was to teach STUDENT behaviors that would allow him to access his education by expressing his wants and needs. For example, Spectrum classroom staff and the speech pathologist worked on teaching STUDENT to say, “I want” when offered a choice of activities.

Ms. Morrison and Ms. Martin testified that the BIP was developed from the FAA, which they testified properly identified STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 16.) The goal of the plan was to decrease STUDENT’s aggressive behavior and increase appropriate alternative behaviors. A review of the BIP reveals that it addressed the specific behaviors that STUDENT had engaged in while attending the District’s SDC and Spectrum. The targeted behaviors addressed by the BIP included STUDENT’s throwing objects at students and staff, hitting students and staff, pressing his mouth against staff’s skin, making physical contact with his head, and hitting staff and students with objects. The BIP also addressed STUDENT’s climbing and standing on classroom furniture and exiting the classroom without supervision. The BIP called for providing a picture schedule of the day’s activities, engaging STUDENT in a sensory activity, offering choices of activities and reinforcers, providing STUDENT with specific one-step directions, providing warning prompts for the time left for preferred activities, and holding STUDENT’s hand in the community. The BIP identified replacement behaviors and reinforcement strategies. The BIP also includes specific things to do if a targeted behavior occurred. Finally, the BIP includes emergency procedures to be implemented if STUDENT became a danger to himself or to others. Ms. Morrison testified that STUDENT’s BIP called for use of environmental containment rather than restraint to isolate STUDENT in an area when his behavior was out of control. Two staff members were to block STUDENT’s physical and visual access to the rest of the room with a soft mat. Before STUDENT could be released from behind the mat, he had to do some type of a compliance drill to ensure that he was calm, such as putting on his socks or counting to ten.

Ms. Morrison testified that the BIP, including the emergency procedures, had been developed, discussed with, and approved by the IEP team, including PARENT. Ms. Morrison testified that when PARENT expressed concern about use of restraint with STUDENT, the use of a mat to contain STUDENT in an area when he engaged in unsafe behavior was suggested as an alternative. The IEP team, including PARENT, then agreed to the use of the mat and incorporated the procedures for its use into STUDENT’s BIP. The testimony of Ms. Morrison and Ms. Martin was persuasive as to appropriateness of the BIP. Their testimony establishes that the BIP was appropriately designed to replace STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors. The Hearing Officer relies on the testimony of Ms. Morrison and Ms. Martin because they are trained and experienced behaviorists. Ms. Morrison, in particular, spent multiple hours observing and working with STUDENT.

In response to PARENT’ concern that she did not receive all of the incident reports from Spectrum, Ms. Morrison acknowledged that initially there was some confusion about whether staff was required to prepare an incident report when the staff used the mat to contain STUDENT. Ms. Morrison testified, for example, that staff members were aware that an incident report was required whenever a student was restrained. However, initially, the staff did not understand that a report also was required when employing physical containment, such as with the mat. Ms. Martin testified similarly regarding the incident reports. Ms. Martin testified that another reason that not all of the incident reports were provided to PARENT was related to the “hostility anticipated” from PARENT toward the staff when the reports were sent home. Ms. Martin explained that PARENT had yelled at and hung up the telephone on staff. Ms. Martin testified regarding PARENT’ concern that STUDENT was naked behind the mat on September 27, 2004, seemingly because the staff had undressed him. Ms. Martin stated that STUDENT had taken his clothes and thrown them over the mat. She also testified that a police report filed by PARENT, as well as an internal investigation by Spectrum staff from another Spectrum location, exonerated Spectrum staff of any wrong-doing. Ms. Martin acknowledged that the effectiveness of the mat to control STUDENT’s aggressive behavior had been raised and required further consideration as an appropriate technique. However, before possible changes to the emergency procedures could be discussed, PARENT withdrew STUDENT from Spectrum.

The testimony of Ms. Morrison and Ms. Martin establishes that an incident report must be completed whenever there is use of either physical restraint or environmental containment, and on other specific occasions. Their testimony confirmed that Spectrum did not send all required reports to PARENT. To this limited extent, Spectrum did not follow proper procedures. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to provide PARENT several reports does not override the testimony of Ms. Morrison and Ms. Martin establishing that Spectrum was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual behavioral needs. Moreover, the evidence establishes that following the incident on September 27, 2004, Spectrum investigated the incident, PARENT’ concerns, and made recommendations for some changes. (See Respondent’s Exhibit 71.)

Finally, as to providing an appropriate educational environment, both Ms. Martin and Ms. Morrison testified that Spectrum offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT by providing him with a structured classroom, a one-to-one aide, specialized instruction, a consistent schedule, a low student-to-teacher ratio with opportunities for individual attention, access to preferred activities once he completed a required task, and a positive behavioral program to address targeted behaviors.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer in place on November 15, 2004, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs to address speech, language, social, attentional, behavioral, and educational deficits.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s poor language skills and behavior have provided the greatest challenges to STUDENT’s achieving success in school. Ms. Martin testified that consistent implementation of behavioral, educational, and language programs would “set the stage” for STUDENT to improve his behavior. It has been concluded above that the goals, objectives, program, placement, and services offered by the District in November 2004, addressed these areas with the ultimate goal of providing STUDENT the skills that will allow him to be successful in school. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer in place on November 15, 2005, was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Additionally, there is evidence that STUDENT made progress while attending Spectrum. In Ms. Martin’s opinion, STUDENT did benefit from his attendance at Spectrum. In support of her opinion, Ms. Martin provided charts of STUDENT’s progress on IEP goals. Ms. Morrison similarly testified that STUDENT was making progress on the academic skills he was working on at Spectrum. (See Respondent’s Exhibits 62 and 66.)

Comported with STUDENT’s IEP

STUDENT’s annual IEP dated June 8, 2004, and subsequent addendum to the IEP dated October 18, 2004, call for two sessions weekly of speech and language services. There is no dispute that the District did not provide STUDENT with speech and language services during period at issue. The District contends that it has not provided STUDENT with speech and language because PARENT declined all of the services offered by the District after she removed STUDENT from Spectrum in September 2004.

The evidence establishes that PARENT withdrew STUDENT from the Spectrum, declined services from the District, and requested a due process hearing to resolve the dispute. The District continued to reiterate in subsequent IEPs that it was continuing to offer speech and language. There was no evidence that PARENT ever accepted these offers. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered services and was ready to provide services in conformity with STUDENT’s IEPs.

Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)

As set forth above, the District is required to educate STUDENT with children who are not disabled to the maximum extent appropriate, and can remove him from the regular education environment only when the “nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.” 20 U.S.C. § 1412; See also Cal. Educ. Code § 56342(b).

STUDENT’s IEP in place on November 15, 2004, offered placement in Spectrum with 99 percent of his school day in the special education environment. It has been concluded that Spectrum offered STUDENT a FAPE. Neither party contends that STUDENT should have been placed in a classroom with general education peers. Rather, the crux of the dispute is whether an NPS offered STUDENT a placement in the least restrictive environment. STUDENT contends that it did not and that the least restrictive placement for him was a District SDC.

PARENT testified that she does not believe that STUDENT required placement in a nonpublic school. She testified that the least restrictive environment for STUDENT was a District SDC. PARENT testified that it is her understanding that Dr. Wolk recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class (SDC).

Ms. Smith testified that the recommendations of the Diagnostic Center and Dr. Wolk are consistent with placement in a District SDC. Ms. Smith testified that an SDC is a self-contained class with a smaller number of students on a public school setting. According to Ms. Smith, the difference between an SDC and an NPS is that because the SDC is on a public school campus, it offers opportunities for the SDC students to interact with typically developing students, whereas an NPS offers little or no opportunity for the students to interact with typically developing students. Ms. Smith further stated that an NPS placement could have resulted in STUDENT’s mimicking children with more serious behaviors. According to Ms. Smith, the District must prove that it provided STUDENT with an SDC placement with supplemental services prior to placing him in the more restrictive placement of an NPS.

The witnesses testifying on behalf of the District uniformly expressed their opinion that Spectrum not only was an appropriate placement for STUDENT but that it also offered him a placement in the least restrictive environment. The District’s witnesses also testified that multiple services and strategies were implemented prior to recommending that STUDENT be placed in an NPS.

Dr. Robinson testified that the District implemented the recommendations of the Diagnostic Center in the District’s SDC including providing STUDENT with a structured environment, a picture schedule, a low ratio of students-to-teachers, behavior interventions, and ongoing language instruction. Dr. Robinson testified that STUDENT required the close presence of two staff at all times while attending the District’s SDC and, even then, would attempt to hit and kick staff or students. Dr. Robinson testified that because STUDENT required a shortened day and two staff accompanying him at all times, the SDC actually was highly restrictive for him. Additionally, Dr. Robinson testified that because STUDENT’s behavior remained variable—he engaged in six incidents on a good day and up to 40 on the worst day—and because STUDENT’s behavior required his removal from class fifty to eighty-nine percent of the school day, an SDC did not offer STUDENT the least restrictive placement.

Ms. Cruz, STUDENT’s SDC teacher in the spring of 2004, testified that STUDENT also had not been successful in her class despite implementing multiple behavior interventions in her class. Ms. Cruz testified that STUDENT continued to frequently engage in extreme behaviors including kicking, biting, hitting, and screaming. Ms. Cruz testified that supplementary services provided to STUDENT in her class included having two adults with him at all times, one of which was a trained behaviorist. Additionally, Ms. Cruz testified that she tailored STUDENT’s schedule thereby allowing him to participate in activities he liked for short intervals so that he could be rewarded for any successes he had. STUDENT’s schedule also allowed for frequent breaks from required tasks. Ms. Cruz testified that an additional classroom was available specifically for STUDENT when he needed a break. There he could engage in sensory activities recommended by the occupational therapist to reduce his inattentiveness. For example, STUDENT could roll on a large occupational therapy ball and wrap in a blanket. Ms. Cruz testified that in her work in an SDC with children with behavioral difficulties, she has not experienced another student with as severe behavioral problems as STUDENT’s.

Ms. Bettencourt, STUDENT’s SDC teacher for a portion of 2003, testified similarly. In her opinion an NPS placement for STUDENT was warranted because STUDENT was not successful in her class even after the implementation of the BIP and increased staff to support STUDENT in the SDC.

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Robinson, Ms. Cruz, Ms. Bettencourt, and Dr. David to be persuasive that STUDENT was unsuccessful in an SDC environment. Dr. Robinson, Ms. Cruz, and Ms. Bettencourt worked with STUDENT in an SDC in the pubic school environment and, therefore, are familiar with his needs.

Additionally, the testimony discussed above establishes that the District implemented numerous supplementary aides and services prior to recommending that STUDENT attend Spectrum. For example, immediately prior to the offer of Spectrum, STUDENT had been attending HELLP. STUDENT had come to the HELLP SDC from a home program. The District modified STUDENT’s class schedule and provided him with the support of two aides—one a behaviorist—to allow him to succeed when transitioning from home to a school program. STUDENT’s schedule was developed according to the recommendations of the Diagnostic Center. His school day was highly structured and consistent. He participated in preferred activities followed by breaks that included physical activity. A “break” room was available next to the classroom. The staff provided STUDENT with positive reinforcement for positive behavior. An occupational therapist consulted with the staff working with STUDENT and trained them to deliver an appropriate sensory diet to help STUDENT maintain a calm, alert state. The evidence establishes that the District also had provided supplementary aides and services in earlier years, also without success.

As to whether an NPS constituted the least restrictive environment, the testimony of Dr. Robinson, Ms. Cruz, Ms. Bettencourt was extremely consistent that an NPS, not an SDC, offered STUDENT the least restrictive environment. All of the District’s witnesses have significant experience working with children with behavioral problems. On the other hand, none of Petitioner’s witnesses have worked with STUDENT in an educational environment. Moreover, because Dr. Wolk’s report was not available until January 2005, the recommendations of Dr. Wolk cannot be considered regarding the District’s offer in place in November 2004 because she had neither undertaken her assessment nor had she written her report.

Additionally, Vivian David, PsyD., testified that in July 2003, she had recommended that STUDENT be placed in an NPS to allow him to participate in a consistent and structured program to help him develop appropriate behaviors and developmentally appropriate skills. Dr. David recommended an NPS because it would offer STUDENT an established routine and trained staff to implement STUDENT’s goals. (See Respondent’s Exhibit 34.) She testified that her recommendation was based on input from the therapists who worked directly with STUDENT. Although Dr. David did not work directly with STUDENT, she is familiar with him and based her testimony on information from staff that she supervised and who had been working directly with STUDENT.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of placement in place in November 2004 was appropriate and also was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.

PROCEDURAL FAPE

As stated above, procedural errors on the part of the District that seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process or that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student may result in the denial of FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992). One of the procedural rights afforded to parents of students with disabilities is written prior notice when the district proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3)(A) and (B).

Petitioner contends that the District procedurally denied him a FAPE by failing to provide prior written notice to his parent of the reasons it no longer would provide him with speech and language services after November 15, 2005.

The District contends that at all times at issue it has made speech and language services (as well as placement at Spectrum) available to STUDENT pursuant to IEPs dated June 8, 2004, October 18 2004, and May 16, 2005. However, PARENT has declined all services from the District. Thus, the District asserts that because it has neither proposed to change STUDENT’s speech and language services nor has declined to provide the services to STUDENT, the District was not responsible for providing PARENT with prior written notice.

It has been determined that the District neither proposed to change, changed, or improperly failed to provide STUDENT’s speech and language. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to provide prior written notice to PARENT regarding the provision of speech and language services.

SUBSTANTIVE FAPE FOLLOWING DR. WOLK’S ASSESSMENT

Although the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has endorsed the “snapshot” rule, which requires looking at what was and what was not, objectively reasonable when the IEP was drafted, the “snapshot” rule does not eliminate a school district’s obligation to revise a student’s educational program if there is a significant change to the student or if it becomes apparent over the course of the school year that the student is not receiving some educational benefit. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999).

Here, Petitioner contends that because his behavior has improved and with the prescription for medication to improve his attention, the District had an obligation to place him in a District SDC. The District asserts that STUDENT’s behavior has not changed to the extent that he now can benefit from placement in an SDC. Prior to determining whether the District’s offer of Spectrum with the services of speech and language therapy, a BIP, and an aide remains appropriate, the Hearing Officer first must determine whether there was a significant change to STUDENT’s deficits and/or needs. The Hearing Officer must then determine if there was a change, whether the District was obligated to convene an IEP meeting and to consider offering STUDENT placement in a District SDC. Because there were no assessments or other evidence presented regarding the alleged change to STUDENT’s needs prior to Dr. Wolk’s report of her assessment to the District in January 2005, the next period under consideration begins after Dr. Wolk’s assessment.

PARENT testified that STUDENT has matured since he was last in school. For example, PARENT testified that STUDENT used to cry when he could not explain what he wanted. However, now STUDENT looks her in the eye and talks to her. He also listens more than he used to. PARENT testified that STUDENT does not exhibit behavior problems at home. She stated that STUDENT likes to play with other children and described him as “well-rounded” socially. PARENT also testified that although STUDENT is not presently taking any medication, she has obtained a prescription to initiate the use of Ritalin to improve his concentration and focus. Dr. Weiss testified that Ritalin is the brand name for methyl penidate hydrochloride, which calms children with ADD and ADHD. PARENT testified that STUDENT requires a placement that is consistent with Dr. Wolk’s recommendations.

Ms. Smith testified that although STUDENT is seven years old, he functions more like a three to four year old. Ms. Smith reported that while in her office about one week prior to the hearing, STUDENT was able to be on task for five to seven minutes, follow one-step instructions, and engage with her in reading a story and playing with a ball on the floor. Ms. Smith testified that STUDENT did not exhibit aggressive or violent behavior. STUDENT spent approximately one hour with Ms. Smith.

Mr. Harris testified that in the past four months, STUDENT has become easier to understand and has increased his vocabulary by at least 50 words. Mr. Harris testified that STUDENT continues to have a short attention span but that it has improved since he began working with him in February 2005. Regarding STUDENT’s behavior, Mr. Harris testified that STUDENT can be agitated at times but he has not been aggressive or violent with him or with other children.

Dr. Weis testified in support of Petitioner’s assertion that STUDENT’s behavior could have changed. Dr. Weis testified that theoretically, the behavior of a child could improve as the child becomes “more cognitively aware.” According to Dr. Weiss, children after the age of six years are better able to control their behavior. As to boys, Dr. Weis testified that typically at age seven, children gain more cognitive control. Dr. Weiss also testified that medication and STUDENT’s acquiring more language could reduce his frustration and, thereby, result in improved behavior.

As to Dr. Weis’s theory that STUDENT’s behavior could have matured, the Hearing Officer notes initially that Dr. Weis has not met STUDENT and, therefore, provided little relevant evidence as to STUDENT and whether, in fact, his behavior had improved. Moreover, because STUDENT is developmentally delayed, he functions below his cognitive age level. In fact, testing by Dr. Wolk found that STUDENT continues to function two to three years below age expectations. Therefore, the fact that STUDENT turned seven years old does not mean that he has achieved the same level of maturity as a typically developing seven year old.

Dr. Wolk’s report also does not support the assertion that STUDENT’s needs have changed in any other areas. In her report, Dr. Wolk states that STUDENT presents with poor problem solving skills and significant impairment in language development and substantial limitations in many of the skills associated with executive functioning. The report goes on to discuss STUDENT’s intense social and emotional difficulties. Finally, Dr. Wolk’s report states “his outbursts of aggressive behavior, sometimes described as out-of-control, sometimes as a danger, indicate that he doesn’t have the emotional, language or cognitive resources to handle the expectations of his child care and school placements.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 21, page 8.)

Finally, although Mr. Harris testified that STUDENT has increased his vocabulary since February 2005, he did not dispute the need for STUDENT to increase speech and language skills. Neither his testimony nor the testimony of any other witnesses establishes that STUDENT’s speech and language needs have significantly changed.

In summary, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s areas of deficits have not changed and the services and placement that STUDENT requires to address his deficits also have changed.

Sue Robertson, District program specialist, testified regarding her understanding of Dr. Wolk’s recommendation for STUDENT’s placement. Ms. Robertson has been a program specialist with the District for the past 19 years. She is STUDENT’s case carrier. Ms. Robertson first met STUDENT when he was four years old, has observed him in each of his placements, and has participated in recent IEP meetings for STUDENT. Ms. Robertson attended the meeting with Dr. Wolk. Ms. Robertson testified that Dr. Wolk did not make a specific placement recommendation. However, Ms. Robertson acknowledged that Dr. Wolk’s report refers to an SDC placement. However, Ms. Robertson testified that during discussions regarding Dr. Wolk’s placement recommendations, Dr. Wolk discussed the appropriateness of an NPS placement. For example, Dr. Wolk specifically recommended the Children’s Learning Center, an NPS. Ms. Robertson recalled Dr. Wolk stating that she “could picture STUDENT attending school in that [Children’s Learning Center] environment.”

Because Dr. Wolk did not testify, there is no persuasive evidence regarding whether her placement recommendation was limited to a public SDC. Moreover, the evidence above established that the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Although there was some testimony of STUDENT’s improved behavior at home, increased vocabulary, and promises that STUDENT would take medication prescribed to reduce his inattentiveness, the Hearing Officer has concluded that STUDENT’s behavior and academic needs have not changed significantly or to the extent that warrants finding the District’s continued offer of Spectrum inappropriate. Moreover, the only observations of improved behavior have been in environments other than a school environment.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s ongoing offer of placement at Spectrum with the services of speech and language, a BIP, a one-to-one instructional assistant, and transportation remained appropriate and also constituted the least restrictive placement for STUDENT.

The District and Spectrum remained ready to implement STUDENT’s IEP, including speech and language. (See Respondent’s Exhibits 72 and 75.) Additionally, Petitioner’s allegation that the District failed to provide speech and language services according to STUDENT’s IEPs fails for the same reasons discussed earlier.

PROCEDURAL FAPE

Petitioner made the same allegations regarding the District’s obligation to provide prior written notice related to speech and language services for STUDENT. For the same reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural error because it was not required to provide the parent prior written notice related to speech and language services.

SUMMARY

It has been determined above that the District’s offer of Spectrum and services (1) was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for specialized instruction, individual and small-group instruction, a highly structured environment, a consistent routine, individual and group speech and language therapy, language infused in the school day, and a positive behavioral intervention plan, (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and (3) comported with his IEP. (Footnote 11) Therefore, it was concluded that the District offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE from November 15, 2004, to June 8, 2005. Additionally, because of STUDENT’s significant behavioral difficulties in an educational environment, as well as his delayed language and attentional deficits, it also was determined that the District’s offer of placement at Spectrum constituted the least restrictive environment in which to educate STUDENT.

ISSUE No. 2: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to the following remedies:

a. placement in a District SDC pursuant to recommendations by Rochelle Wolk, Ph.D.; b. individual speech and language therapy two times a week for 30 minutes each session; c. a one-to-one behavioral aide to assist with transitioning STUDENT from home to placement in an SDC; d. extended school year services (ESY) in a District SDC with a one-to-one aide; e. compensatory individual speech and language therapy one time a week for 45 minutes from the present through June 2006; f. compensatory one-to-one instruction by a credentialed teacher in all academic areas for two hours each week from the present through June 2006; g. counseling by a school psychologist to assist with transitioning from home to placement in an SDC for 45 minutes each week from the present through January 2006; h. reimbursement in the amount of $1,425 for private educational tutoring by Mr. Harris from January 2005 to the present; and i. reimbursement in the amount of $480 for child care and related services by Brittney Davis?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dis., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). However, parents are not required to have procured the exact proper placement under the IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Ind. Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 79 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The parents may receive reimbursement so long as their placement met the student’s unique needs and provides the student with educational benefit. Id.

Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement and compensatory education remedies for the District’s denial of a FAPE. It has been determined above that the District offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. Accordingly, he is not entitled to relief.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

(1) Did the New Haven Unified School District offer and provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) from November 15, 2004, to June 8, 2005?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

(2) If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to the following remedies:

a. placement in a District SDC pursuant to recommendations by Rochelle Wolk, Ph.D.; b. individual speech and language therapy two times a week for 30 minutes each session; c. a one-to-one behavioral aide to assist with transitioning STUDENT from home to placement in an SDC; d. extended school year services (ESY) in a District SDC with a one-to-one aide; e. compensatory individual speech and language therapy one time a week for 45 minutes from the present through June 2006; f. compensatory one-to-one instruction by a credentialed teacher in all academic areas for two hours each week from the present through June 2006; g. counseling by a school psychologist to assist with transitioning from home to placement in an SDC for 45 minutes each week from the present through January 2006; h. reimbursement in the amount of $1,425 for private educational tutoring by Mr. Harris from January 2005 to the present; and i. reimbursement in the amount of $480 for child care and related services by Brittney Davis?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: September 15, 2005

Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 For various reasons, the hearing convened for partial days on May 31, and June 1, 2, and 7, 2005.

2Petitioner initially identified the period in dispute as November 15, 2004, to the “present.” November 15, 2004, reflects the date on which the parties reached a settlement in a prior due process hearing. As to the end date for the period at issue, because STUDENT’s last annual IEP dated June 8, 2004, and addendums thereto, extend only to June 8, 2005, the period addressed in the first issue has been limited to November 15, 2004, to June 8, 2005. It also is noted that Petitioner’s request made on the fourth day of the hearing to expand the period to include unresolved issues arising from the annual IEP for the 2005-2006 school year was denied as untimely. The IEP was drafted during the course of the hearing, after the issues had been discussed, and well into the taking of testimony.

3 The parties resolved this case in November 2004 without the need for a hearing. 4 Apparently, the parties also agreed to visit other potential placements that would be appropriate for STUDENT.

5 Because the events that are the subject of this dispute occurred prior to the July 1, 2005 effective date of the reauthorized IDEA, the Hearing Officer applies the law that was in effect at that time.

6 In a separate section below, the Hearing Officer will address whether there was a significant change to STUDENT’s unique needs after November 15, 2004, that obligated the District to modify its offer of placement and/or services.

7 Ms. Martin served as the assistant director during STUDENT’s tenure at Spectrum.

8 The assessment report is dated June 7, 2004, and may be found in Petitioner’s Exhibit 16.

9 Numerous people involved in STUDENT’s education have suggested to PARENT that she inquire about medication to address STUDENT’s high level of energy and inattentiveness. PARENT indicated that in the past she was hesitant to consider medication for STUDENT but that she now has a prescription from STUDENT’s pediatrician for Ritalin and is willing to have STUDENT take the Ritalin to help him focus at school.

10 Spectrum staff testified that STUDENT had removed his clothes while behind the mat and threw them over the mat.

11 The sole deficiency identified, which has been remedied, was Spectrum’s failure to send all incident reports to PARENT.