California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 22, 1996

Student v. Santa Ana Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1162-95 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Santa Ana Unified's offered special day classes in Tustin and Orange held appropriate for preschooler; reimbursement claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A mother filed for due process against Santa Ana Unified on behalf of her four-year-old son. He was eligible for special education based on mild to moderate mental retardation and Sturge-Weber Syndrome, a rare brain disorder. He attended a preschool special day class at the District's Mitchell School and received speech-language therapy and adaptive physical education. The mother believed he was regressing because his classmates were lower functioning and many spoke Spanish. She withdrew him, enrolled him at Hugs 'n' Tugs, a private preschool, and paid for a private speech-language evaluation by Cheryl Cates. The District offered special day classes in Tustin Unified or Orange Unified, or Head Start at Mitchell with special day class support.

Applying Rowley, Hearing Officer Mark Paxson found that the student needed a small, structured setting with instruction in English, peers with good language skills, speech-language therapy, and adaptive physical education. The evidence did not show that all of his classmates had to be fluent English speakers without disabilities. The Tustin and Orange classes met his needs, matched his IEP, and were likely to benefit him, given his progress at Mitchell. Head Start was not appropriate because it was not a small, structured setting. Because the District had made an appropriate offer, the Hearing Officer did not decide the private-placement and added-therapy issues. He denied reimbursement for the evaluation because no evidence showed the District's assessment was flawed. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 10 days to enroll the student in one of the two classes.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley to a dispute over a preschooler's language peers. A parent's preference for English-only, nondisabled classmates was not enough without evidence of need. It also shows that a newer independent evaluation with higher scores did not, by itself, prove the district's earlier assessment was inappropriate or require reimbursement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Does the Santa Ana Unified School District have an appropriate public placement either within the District or within an adjacent school district? (Includes whether the student's unique needs require an environment with fluent English-speaking, nondisabled peers.)

    The special day classes offered in Tustin Unified and Orange Unified met the student's unique needs, conformed to his IEP, and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. The Head Start option was not appropriate, but the District prevailed because the two SDC offers were appropriate.

  2. Issue 2. If the District has not offered an appropriate placement, is Hugs 'n' Tugs an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 1995-96 extended school year?

    Not reached because the District offered an appropriate placement.

  3. Issue 3. If the District has not offered an appropriate placement, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with Hugs 'n' Tugs beginning on February 22, 1996?

    Not reached because the District offered an appropriate placement.

  4. Issue 4. Does STUDENT require speech and language services three times per week at the nonpublic preschool in order to benefit from his special education?

    Not reached because the District offered an appropriate placement.

  5. Issue 5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the private speech and language evaluation conducted by Cheryl Cates?

    Reimbursement was denied because no evidence showed the District's 1994 assessment was inappropriate. Higher scores almost two years later were expected and did not show the earlier assessment was flawed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP team meeting within 10 days of receipt of the decision to enroll the student in one of the two special day classes (Tustin Unified or Orange Unified) covered by the decision, then take the steps needed to enroll him in the placement the IEP team selects.
  • Petitioner's claims for relief, including reimbursement for the $225 private speech-language evaluation and for the private preschool, were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56505

People named in the decision

  • Lucinda Hundley, Director of special education, Santa Ana Unified School District
  • Louise Sobieski, Special day class teacher, Mitchell School, Santa Ana Unified
  • Carole Chambers, Private speech-language assessor, Providence Speech and Hearing Center
  • Providence Speech and Hearing Center, Private speech-language evaluation provider
  • Cheryl Cates, Private pediatric speech-language pathologist; independent evaluator and witness for Student
  • Georgia Prentice, Student's pediatric neurologist (letter in evidence)
  • Barry Behrstock, Student's pediatrician
  • Ray Vaca, Sunday School teacher; witness for Student, Calvary Chapel of Costa Mesa
  • Hugs 'n' Tugs, Private preschool (parent placement), Costa Mesa
  • Ellen Johnston, Principal; witness for District, Mitchell School, Santa Ana Unified
  • Jeanne Ruiz, Speech-language specialist; witness for District, Santa Ana Unified School District (Taft Elementary School)
  • Gail Booth, Program specialist; witness for District, Santa Ana Unified School District
  • Sheila Levy, Special education coordinator; witness for District, Santa Ana Unified School District
  • Sue Watkins, Special day class teacher serving Head Start classes; witness for District, Mitchell School, Santa Ana Unified
  • Jessie Cabrera, Educational consultant representing Student
  • G. Robert Roice, Educational consultant representing District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, in Santa Ana, California, on March 28 and 29, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by Jessie Cabrera, educational consultant. Also present on Petitioner's behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Santa Ana Unified School District (District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present on the District's behalf was Lucinda Hundley, director of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1) Does the Santa Ana Unified School District have an appropriate public placement either within the District or within an adjacent school district?(Footnote 2)

2) If the District has not offered an appropriate placement, is Hugs 'n' Tugs an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 1995-96 extended school year?

3) If the District has not offered an appropriate placement, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with Hugs 'n' Tugs beginning on February 22, 1996?

4) Does STUDENT require speech and language services three times per week at the nonpublic preschool in order to benefit from his special education?

5) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the private speech and language evaluation conducted by Cheryl Cates?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a preschool student whose fifth birthday is in May 1996. STUDENT was assessed for special education services by the District in June 1994. At the time, STUDENT was three years and one month old. The conclusions of the assessment team were that STUDENT's cognitive level was in the 12- to 18-month range and his communication skills were below the 12 month level. The assessment team also determined that STUDENT's adaptive behavior skills were in the 12- to 22-month range and his motor skills were in the 24- to 26-month range.

On June 20, 1994, an individualized education program (IEP) team meeting was held, and the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services based on mild to moderate mental retardation and Sturge-Weber Syndrome -- a rare brain disorder caused by vascular malformation which can affect a child's cognitive level and speech and language levels, and can cause seizures. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a preschool special day class and that he receive adaptive physical education (APE) and consultative speech and language services.

Shortly thereafter, STUDENT was enrolled at Mitchell School in a noncategorical special day class taught by Louise Sobieski. In addition, STUDENT received APE one to two times per week for 20-30 minutes each and consultative speech and language services. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in the areas of readiness skills, ability to follow directions and rules, fine motor skills, semantics, pragmatics, oral/motor phonology, toileting and dressing skills, social interaction skills, and gross motor skills.

During the IEP meeting of June 20, 1994, STUDENT's mother, MOTHER, expressed concerns about the amount of speech and language services STUDENT would receive and also about the amount of Spanish spoken in the class. As a result of her concerns, MOTHER agreed to the IEP only for summer school and requested that another IEP meeting be held prior to the start of the 1994-95 school year.

On July 27, 1994, an IEP meeting was held at MOTHER' request to discuss STUDENT's progress. MOTHER expressed concern regarding Spanish instruction in the class. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive services with instruction in English. Additionally, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT begin receiving direct speech and language services 3-4 times per week in individual and group settings. The IEP team agreed to review the placement by June 1995, at MOTHER' request. The minutes of the IEP meeting indicate that STUDENT's teacher believed STUDENT was making excellent progress. STUDENT was attempting language use and was comfortable with the teachers, aides and peers. The teacher indicated that STUDENT was beginning to use gestures and language functionally. The IEP team also discussed MOTHER' concerns about the District's results and attributed the low scores to the fact that STUDENT had not been expected to follow structured tasks prior to the assessment, which may have adversely affected his performance.

On August 3, 1994, a private speech and language evaluation of STUDENT was conducted by Providence Speech and Hearing Center. The conclusions of the Providence assessment were that STUDENT had delays in receptive and expressive language and an articulation disorder. The assessor, Carole Chambers, recommended continued placement in a clinical preschool with future enrollment in individual speech and language therapy as a possibility. In the area of language skills, the scores of the Providence assessment were based almost entirely on parental report. STUDENT's scores were the following:

Interaction-Attachment: 9-18 months Pragmatics: 9-15 months Gesture: 12-24 months Play: 9-24 months Language comprehension: 6-24 months Language expression: 6 - 24 months Speech sound production: mildly delayed(Footnote 3)

On August 19, 1994, an IEP meeting was conducted. The IEP team recommended continued placement in the special day class with the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT's June 1994 IEP. The IEP team also recommended sixty minutes of speech and language therapy per week, to be broken into five minute individual sessions and 10-15 minute small group sessions three to four times per week. The IEP team agreed to continue adaptive physical education services.

On June 16, 1995, another IEP meeting was conducted. The IEP team discussed Head Start but determined that Head Start would not be appropriate. The IEP team again recommended placement in a special day class because STUDENT's disability required a small, structured setting with peers with similar learning needs. The IEP team also recommended daily transportation, and speech and language services and APE of the same type and quantity as STUDENT received during the 1994-95 school year. The IEP team developed new goals and objectives in the areas of readiness skills, awareness of safety issues, attention, fine motor skills, personal care, social interaction, gross motor skills, and communication skills. MOTHER agreed with the terms of the IEP pending an evaluation of the APE goals and objectives.

On October 20, 1995, the IEP team again convened. The meeting was requested by MOTHER because of her concerns regarding regression in STUDENT's language. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT's current program should be continued but that his individual time with the speech therapist should be increased.

On November 1, 1995, MOTHER sent a letter to the District requesting an alternative placement because of regression in STUDENT's speech and social skills. MOTHER noted that STUDENT had made "exceptional speech gains over the summer when in the presence of appropriate models." Petitioner's Exhibit 12. MOTHER believed the regression was due to STUDENT's being placed in a class with relatively low functioning children in Fall 1995.

STUDENT's IEP team convened again on November 16, 1995, to discuss MOTHER' request for an alternative placement in a less restrictive environment with appropriate models. STUDENT's teacher reviewed the progress that STUDENT had made and noted that he had made progress in class participation, following directions, maturity, and sharing. The IEP team also reviewed STUDENT's APE progress and noted several areas which he was working on, including cooperative play and collaborating gross motor skills and language. In the area of speech, the IEP team noted growth that STUDENT had made since May in answering direct questions, increasing sentence length, and decreasing his drooling. The IEP team noted that MOTHER had seen "great growth in expressive and receptive language."

During the IEP meeting, MOTHER noted several regressions, including inappropriate noises, inappropriate social behavior, and refusal to use language to communicate. MOTHER noted that she saw improvement in STUDENT's behavior when he was away from school. In response to MOTHER' concerns, the District offered SmartTalk, a speech and language program for children with mild speech and language problems. SmartTalk provides children with 1 1/2 hours of group speech and language per week with two speech and language specialists and one instructional aide in a setting that is similar to a preschool class. The District offered to enroll STUDENT in SmartTalk in combination with his current special day class. MOTHER declined the SmartTalk program because she did not believe the special day class was appropriate.

Following the IEP meeting of November 16, 1995, MOTHER filed her request for a due process hearing. At the beginning of January 1996, MOTHER withdrew STUDENT from Mitchell School because She felt he had progressed significantly during vacation and did not want him to return to school and regress.

On January 9, 1996, STUDENT's pediatric neurologist, Dr. Georgia Prentice, prepared a letter detailing her impressions and recommendations for STUDENT. Dr. Prentice stated that STUDENT "is at the present time developing speech, and it is coming along beautifully." Dr. Prentice was also under the impression that STUDENT was in class where other class members do not speak English and that in such a situation STUDENT would have "little chance for any language development on a peer-to-peer level." Dr. Prentice recommended that STUDENT be placed in a classroom situation that would maximize his language development. Petitioner's Exhibit 9.

On February 15, 1996, the District's special education director, Lucinda Hundley, offered in writing special day class placements in either Orange Unified School District (Orange) or Tustin Unified School District (Tustin). These placements were rejected by MOTHER, and the District proposed a placement in the Head Start program at Mitchell School with special day class assistance.(Footnote 4) Alternatively, the District proposed that MOTHER pay for a nonpublic school placement for STUDENT and that the District provide speech and language services and APE at the nonpublic school. These offers were made in writing on March 4, 1996.

In March 1996, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT at Hugs 'n' Tugs, a nonpublic preschool in Costa Mesa. On March 7, 1996, MOTHER obtained an independent speech and language evaluation of STUDENT from Cheryl Cates, a pediatric speech pathologist. Ms. Cates administered several standardized tests and observed STUDENT at Hugs 'n' Tugs. In receptive language, Ms. Cates administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R) and the Test of Auditory Comprehension of Language-Revised (TACL-R). The results of these tests were:

PPVT-R: age equivalent of 2 years, 10 months TACL-R total score: age equivalent of 32-33 months Word Classes and Relations subtest: 34-36 months Grammatical Morphemes subtest: 28-30 months Elaborated Sentences subtest: 27-29 months

In expressive language, Ms. Cates administered the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT) and the Structured Photographic Expressive Language Test-Preschool (SPELT-P). The results of these tests were:

EOWPVT: age equivalent of 3 years, 8 months.

SPELT-P: No results. STUDENT was unable to respond correctly to any of the 50 test items.

Ms. Cates concluded that STUDENT has a moderate to severe expressive language delay and recommended that he receive speech and language therapy three times per week. Ms. Cates also stated in her report that she did not believe her receptive language scores to be an accurate measure of STUDENT's ability. Ms. Cates recommended that his receptive language skills would be better assessed in an ongoing therapeutic environment in an informal setting. Ms. Cates was concerned about an apparent breakdown in visual scanning and visual distractions and recommended a visual examination. Ms. Cates also recommended that STUDENT have peer models with age-appropriate language and that his classroom be an English-only setting.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT was diagnosed with Sturge-Weber Syndrome by his pediatrician, Barry Behrstock, when STUDENT was five months of age. MOTHER testified that Sturge-Weber is a rare brain disorder that can affect a child's cognitive level, speech and language level, and cause seizures. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has a speech and language impairment and mild seizure disorder, but that his cognitive ability has not been adversely affected. In addition, MOTHER testified that STUDENT's seizure disorder is controlled by medication.

MOTHER testified that she disagrees with the conclusion in the District's June 1994 assessment that STUDENT is mildly mentally retarded. MOTHER testified that none of STUDENT's doctors has ever diagnosed him as mentally retarded. After STUDENT was placed at Mitchell School, MOTHER visited the classroom. MOTHER testified that she observed some children with severe disabilities, such as Down's Syndrome and severe retardation. MOTHER also testified that the instruction was in English but that the instructional aides would interpret the instructions into Spanish. MOTHER testified that she did not see very many English-speaking models for STUDENT in the classroom. MOTHER testified that STUDENT learned some Spanish words -- sit-down, look, and table -- during the 1994-95 school year, but that he no longer uses any Spanish words. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did well during the summer school program.

MOTHER testified that she obtained a private speech and language assessment because she felt that the District's assessment was inaccurate. Specifically, MOTHER was concerned with the District's conclusion that STUDENT was mentally retarded. MOTHER testified that the private assessment did not refer to mental retardation and that the private assessment of STUDENT's speech and language skills produced higher results than the District's assessment.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT made limited progress at Mitchell School during the 1994-95 school year. In June 1995, MOTHER requested another IEP meeting because she was concerned with STUDENT's progress. MOTHER testified that she told the IEP team that STUDENT had made progress in a lot of areas but that he was still lagging behind in speech and language.

MOTHER testified that she approved of the District's proposed placement in the Irvine Unified School District because the students were English-speaking, had mild disabilities, and the class was in a typical pre-school setting. Regarding the Tustin Unified School District and Orange Unified School District placements, MOTHER believed they were inappropriate because there was a lack of English-speaking models, the students were severely disabled, and the classes were not in a typical preschool environment. MOTHER testified that she did not visit either program but based her opinion on information provided by Gail Booth. Regarding the Head Start program, MOTHER testified that she observed the afternoon Head Start class at Mitchell and did not like the program because none of the students was English-speaking.

In March 1996, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT at Hugs 'n' Tugs, a private preschool program. STUDENT attends Hugs 'n' Tugs three days a week from 8:30 a.m. until noon. MOTHER testified that Hugs 'n' Tugs is appropriate because the students are predominantly English-speaking, there is a lot of social interaction and language, and the classes are small. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's class has twelve students with two teachers. She stated that some of the students are bilingual and one is mildly autistic. The rest are nondisabled. MOTHER testified that the cost for Hugs 'n' Tugs is $45 per week and there was a $35 registration fee.

MOTHER testified that she obtained a private speech and language assessment from Cheryl Cates in March 1996 because the District's assessment results were low. MOTHER testified that the cost of the assessment was $225.

MOTHER testified that while STUDENT was home during the Christmas break in December 1995, he began speaking more fluently and using more structured sentences. MOTHER testified that STUDENT needs a placement with fluent English-speaking peers to enhance his speech and language development. MOTHER testified that none of the District's proposed placements provides such an environment and that Hugs 'n' Tugs provides STUDENT with a typical preschool setting, and developmental activities with English-speaking, nondisabled peers.

Cheryl Cates is a private speech pathologist hired by Petitioner to conduct a speech and language assessment in March 1996. Included in her assessment was a ninety-minute observation of STUDENT at Hugs 'n' Tugs. While at Hugs 'n' Tugs, Ms. Cates observed story time in STUDENT's class. Ms. Cates testified that STUDENT appeared to listen to the story, but did not look at the teacher or at the book when pictures were shown to the class. Ms. Cates also tried to administer two tests to STUDENT while at Hugs 'n' Tugs but was unsuccessful because STUDENT did not respond when the tests got too difficult. Ms. Cates testified that all communication at Hugs 'n' Tugs was in English.

During the ninety-minute observation, Ms. Cates observed only one verbal interaction by STUDENT, when he said "no" to another child. Ms. Cates attributed STUDENT's lack of social interaction to a "silent period." Ms. Cates described the "silent period" as a period of time when an individual who is learning a language observes the language before being able to use it.

Ms. Cates testified that her assessment showed that STUDENT has a significant expressive language delay, has deficits in pragmatics (nonverbal aspects of communication), and does not initiate eye contact. She stated that her assessment did not reveal any evidence of mental retardation. Ms. Cates also testified that, while students who are cognitively delayed usually test consistently from area to area, STUDENT's results varied significantly.

Ms. Cates testified that STUDENT needs communicative, interactive peer models who speak English. She said that children first choose peers as their models, followed by individuals with the same language background, parents, and teachers. Ms. Cates testified that STUDENT needs an "English only setting," which she described as instruction in English and peers who are predominantly English-speaking. She stated that it would not be detrimental to STUDENT's language development for some of the children around STUDENT to speak Spanish.

Regarding STUDENT's speech and language therapy needs, Ms. Cates testified that his therapy should consist of two components: one or two sessions per week in a clinical setting and one session per week in a preschool setting to help facilitate interaction with other children.

Finally, Ms. Cates compared her assessment results with those from the District and Providence in June and August 1994. Ms. Cates testified that STUDENT showed about one- to one-and-a-half years of growth in receptive language. Ms. Cates testified that STUDENT showed almost two years of growth in expressive language. However, Ms. Cates testified that his growth could be attributed to an improvement in STUDENT's test-taking ability, not just an improvement in speech and language skills. Ms. Cates also attributed some of the growth to the fact that in June 1994 STUDENT was unable to take standardized tests, and in March 1996 he was old enough to participate in more detailed testing.

Ray Vaca was STUDENT's Sunday School teacher from May 1995 through February 1996 at the Calvary Chapel of Costa Mesa. Mr. Vaca testified that he had approximately twenty-five four-year-old children in his class and that the children participated in singing, arts and crafts, bible memorization, and storytelling activities. The class lasts for seventy-five minutes, and English is spoken in the class.

Mr. Vaca testified that STUDENT did not participate very much when he first enrolled in the class but that he began to participate and communicate verbally more as the class progressed. According to Mr. Vaca, STUDENT's overall performance in the class was about a year behind that of the other kids. Mr. Vaca testified that STUDENT was not disruptive and seemed well-disciplined for a child his age.

District's Witnesses

Ellen Johnston is the principal at the Mitchell School. Mitchell is a child development center operated by the District for children from 18 months of age to five years old. The program includes three Head Start classes, each of which has a separate program in the morning and afternoon.

Ms. Johnston observed the classes at Tustin Unified School District and Orange Unified School District that have been proposed by the District. Ms. Johnston testified both classes are non-categorical special day classes with students who have a range of disabilities. Ms. Johnston testified that English is the predominant language in the Orange program, but there is some Spanish. The instruction is in English. Regarding Tustin, Ms. Johnston testified that the class is a total English program. Ms. Johnston testified that either program could meet STUDENT's needs.

Regarding the Head Start program, Ms. Johnston was present when MOTHER observed the afternoon program. Ms. Johnston testified that MOTHER observed at the beginning of the class when the students were checking in. By the time MOTHER had left only six of the seventeen students had checked in. Ms. Johnston testified that the class instruction is in English and that there are a total of seventeen students, two are English-speaking, three are bilingual, and the rest have emerging English skills. The morning Head Start program is similar to the afternoon program but has five students whose primary language is English. Both Head Start programs have three students with disabilities. Ms. Johnston testified that STUDENT's needs could be met in either Head Start program.

Ms. Johnston testified that the Tustin and Orange programs are still available for STUDENT. In addition, there is a opening in the morning Head Start program, but the District is usually given only five days to fill an opening. At the time of the hearing, the afternoon Head Start program did not have an opening. Ms. Johnston testified that if STUDENT enrolled in the Head Start program, he would also be able to participate in the SmartTalk program. In addition, STUDENT would be able to receive speech and language therapy and adaptive physical therapy. Finally, if STUDENT were enrolled in the Head Start program, he would have the services of a special day class teacher available to him in the Head Start classroom.

Ms. Johnston testified that she would prefer a special day class placement for STUDENT because of the skill level of the teachers. Of the two proposed special day classes, Ms. Johnston prefers the Tustin class because of the language models and skills in the class and the teacher's experience with language development.

Jeanne Ruiz is a speech and language specialist for the District who has provided speech and language therapy for STUDENT at Taft Elementary School since January 18, 1996. The therapy includes one individual session per week and two group sessions per week. The group sessions are with either one or two other children.

Ms. Ruiz testified that a four-year, ten-month-old child should be regularly using 6-7 word sentences and regularly interacting with the therapist and his or her peers. Ms. Ruiz testified that STUDENT occasionally uses 4-5 word sentences, but does not interact verbally with other children except to say "hi." Ms. Ruiz also testified that it sometimes takes an extra effort to get a response from STUDENT.

Ms. Ruiz testified that STUDENT has made significant progress since January 1996. As an example, Ms. Ruiz testified that she has worked with STUDENT on "pronoun + is + verb -ing" sentences. In January 1996 STUDENT could not say any such sentences spontaneously. On March 25, 1996, STUDENT used such sentences correctly to describe 15 out of 16 picture cards.

Ms. Ruiz testified that exposure to another language spoken by other students would not be a detriment to STUDENT because the language is in "sheltered English." Ms. Ruiz described sheltered English as repetition and shortened instructions. Ms. Ruiz testified that sheltered English is similar to what she does in speech and language therapy. Ms. Ruiz testified that the most important factor is what language the instruction is in because students focus so much on what the teacher is doing and saying. In addition, Ms. Ruiz testified that students tend to interact with others who speak their language. If STUDENT were placed in a program in which several students spoke another language, it would not be a detriment to his speech and language development. Ms. Ruiz testified that preschool children need appropriate models to enhance their speech and language development. Ms. Ruiz testified that a student's critical language models are his or her parents, followed by peers and siblings.

Gail Booth is a program specialist for the District. Ms. Booth was involved in STUDENT's initial IEP and placement but was not involved again until she was recently asked to help find a placement for STUDENT. Ms. Booth has not observed STUDENT. Her recommendations for placement are based on her review of STUDENT's IEPs.

Ms. Booth testified that the Tustin program is four days per week. The class has two teachers and two aides for fourteen students who have a range of disabilities. Ms. Booth testified that two of the students are nonverbal, two are Hispanic, and the rest are English-speaking. Two of the students are autistic, one has Down's Syndrome, and the rest have specific learning disabilities or speech and language impairments. Ms. Booth testified that the teacher told her that STUDENT's goals and objectives are consistent with the type of work she does on a daily basis. Mainstreaming opportunities at Tustin are primarily reverse mainstreaming, when regular education children come into the special day class for thirty minutes twice per week.

Regarding the Orange program, Ms. Booth testified that there is one teacher and one aide for thirteen children. One child has traumatic brain injury syndrome and the rest have specific learning disabilities or speech and language impairments. One or two of the children are nonverbal and several are bilingual. The teacher told Ms. Booth that she could meet STUDENT's goals and objectives. Ms. Booth testified that speech and language services and adaptive physical education could be provided at Tustin and at Orange.

Ms. Booth testified that both the Tustin and Orange classes would be appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Booth testified that STUDENT's abilities and the work he was doing are similar to those of the students in both programs.

Sheila Levy is the special education coordinator for the District. Ms. Levy has worked in the speech and language area for over twenty years and has a master's degree in speech and language therapy. Ms. Levy testified that as long as instruction is in a child's primary language, the presence of a second language does not have a negative impact on language development. Ms. Levy testified that children are able to filter out what they do not understand, so the other language would be filtered out as gibberish. Ms. Levy based her opinion on her experience in speech and language and her review of the relevant literature. Ms. Levy pointed to STUDENT's language growth while at Mitchell as evidence that the presence of Spanish in the classroom was not detrimental to his language development.Ms. Levy has observed STUDENT periodically since he enrolled in the District. These observations have included classroom observations in July and October 1994, and speech and language therapy observations in Fall 1994 and January and March 1996. Ms. Levy testified that STUDENT has made some gains since 1994. However, during the March 1996 observation, STUDENT was very distractible and was not relating to his environment. Ms. Levy testified that STUDENT responded with 2-4 word utterances and only responded appropriately about 20-25 percent of the time.

Ms. Levy testified that STUDENT's lack of interaction is not typical of a child who only has a speech and language impairment. Ms. Levy also testified that STUDENT's short attention span, parallel play, and frequent need for redirection are also not typical of a child who only has a speech and language impairment. Ms. Levy testified that children who only have a speech and language impairment interact with other children and with their environment, show more curiosity and a longer attention span, and try to explain their needs to parents and teachers. Ms. Levy did not observe these behaviors in STUDENT.

Regarding the various programs offered by the District, Ms. Levy testified that the Tustin class utilizes a "learning center" approach with learning centers devoted to gross motor skills, fine motor skills, visual sequential memory, verbal input, and computer skills. In addition, the adults in the classroom are strategically located to provide 1-to-1 or 2-to-1 language stimulation. Ms. Levy testified that she did not hear any language other than English in the Tustin classroom and that a majority of the students were verbal.

Ms. Levy testified that she observed the Orange classroom for 60 minutes and during that time heard four words of Spanish spoken by the children. The instruction was in English and the class had a very structured schedule of activities, including circle time, math, social studies, and language activities. Ms. Levy testified that all of the students in the Orange class were very verbal. Ms. Levy testified that both the Tustin and Orange programs would be appropriate for STUDENT.

Ms. Levy testified that STUDENT has made good progress but that he needs a small structured setting with staff trained in language development. In addition, STUDENT needs to be instructed at his level and have good models in his classroom. Finally, Ms. Levy testified that STUDENT needs manipulatives and activities aimed at exploring his environment, because he is not exploring his environment on his own.

Sue Watkins is the special day class teacher who works with special education students in the Head Start classes at Mitchell. Ms. Watkins testified that there are three Head Start classes at Mitchell in the morning and three in the afternoon. Ms. Watkins has two instructional aides who assist her. Either Ms. Watkins or one of her aides is in each of the classes at all times working with the special education students. Ms. Watkins testified that there are some Spanish-speaking students but that the primary language of instruction is English, and there are English-speaking students in every class.

Ms. Watkins testified that many of STUDENT's goals and objectives cover areas that she and the Head Start instructors work on with the students. Ms. Watkins testified that Head Start is a very structured program and that the children know what their responsibilities are. Ms. Watkins testified that there are always three adults in each class -- one Head Start teacher, one Head Start instructional aide, and one special day class teacher or instructional aide. Parent volunteers also participate in the classes on a regular basis.

Ms. Watkins testified that the Head Start program with special day class support could meet STUDENT's social, emotional, intellectual, and language development needs. Ms. Watkins also testified that speech and language services and adaptive physical education are available at Mitchell.

DISCUSSION

1) Does the Santa Ana Unified School District have an appropriate public placement either within the District or within an adjacent school District?

State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. (California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 USC 1400 et seq.) Pursuant to 20 USC § 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions."

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. (458 U.S. 175, 200)

Taken together, the IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide three factors for analyzing whether a District's placement is appropriate. Those three factors are as follows:

1. whether the placement is designed to meet the student's unique needs; 2. whether the placement conforms to the student's IEP; and 3. whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to the student.

The first factor -- whether the District has proposed a placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs -- requires an analysis of what STUDENT's unique needs are. All witnesses were in general agreement that STUDENT needs a program that emphasizes language development. In addition, the witnesses were in agreement that STUDENT needs appropriate role models to enhance his language development.

While Petitioner contends that he needs English-only, nondisabled peers for his language development, there was no testimony from the speech and language therapists and District witnesses to support that contention. Petitioner's own speech and language therapist, Cheryl Cates, testified that STUDENT needs an "English-only" setting. However, when she described what she meant by an English-only setting, she stated that the instruction should be in English and that the children in the class should speak predominantly in English. All of the District's witnesses testified that, while STUDENT does need appropriate English-speaking peer role models, the presence of a few non-English-speaking peers would not be a detriment to his language development.

In addition, no witnesses, other than MOTHER, testified that STUDENT needs to be solely in an environment with nondisabled peers in order to enhance his language development and benefit from his education. While the witnesses were in agreement that STUDENT needs some verbal role models in his class, no one testified that STUDENT needs to be in a program consisting entirely of nondisabled peers. Finally, the testimony of the District's witnesses regarding the nature of STUDENT's disability establishes that he needs a small, structured educational setting.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unique needs include a small, structured educational program that offers him an opportunity to enhance his language development through speech and language therapy, an English-instruction setting, and peers with appropriate language skills. In addition, STUDENT needs adaptive physical education and work on the goals and objectives listed in his IEP. There was insufficient evidence presented to support a finding that STUDENT's education must take place in an environment in which all of the students are fluent users of the English language and are nondisabled.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the two special day classes in Tustin and Orange offered by the District are designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. While each program consists of a range of students, some of whom speak Spanish instead of English, the testimony of the District's witnesses establishes that each program has some students who are verbal and who are appropriate language role models for STUDENT. In addition, while some instruction is translated into Spanish for the nonEnglish-speaking students, the sole means of instructing the students who speak English is in the English language. The District has offered speech and language services and APE at both of the proposed placements.

Regarding the Head Start program, the Hearing Officer finds that it is not designed to meet STUDENT's educational needs. As stated above, the testimony of the District's witnesses established that STUDENT needs his education to take place in a small, structured setting. The Head Start program, as described in Ms. Watkins' testimony, does not offer a small, structured educational setting that STUDENT requires and, therefore, is not designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. Furthermore, Ms. Johnston's testimony establishes that there are very few appropriate language models for STUDENT in the Head Start program.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placements in the Tustin Unified School District and the Orange Unified School District are designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the IEP developed by the District on June 16, 1995, is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs. The IEP calls for STUDENT's education to take place in a small, structured setting and for STUDENT to receive APE and speech and language services. In addition, the IEP establishes numerous goals and objectives in the areas of readiness skills, safety issues, attention, fine and gross motor skills, personal care, social interaction skills, and communication skills. The focus in these areas called for in the IEP is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs.

Regarding whether the proposed placements conform to STUDENT's IEP, his IEP dated June 16, 1995, calls for placement in a special day class with speech and language services and APE. The IEP further states that STUDENT's "primary handicapping condition requires small, structured setting with peers with similar learning needs." The District has proposed two different types of placement: special day classes at Tustin and at Orange, or a Head Start program at Mitchell. The District could provide both speech and language and APE at either special day class placement. Both of these classes conform with the placement parameters established by STUDENT's IEP.

The District also will be able to provide speech and language services and APE in the Head Start program. The problem with the Head Start placement is that it is not in a special day class or in a "small, structured setting." As a result, the Head Start placement does not conform with STUDENT's IEP.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the proposed placements in the Tustin and Orange school districts conform to STUDENT's IEP. The placement in the Head Start program does not conform to STUDENT's IEP.

Finally, it is necessary to determine whether the District's proposed placements are designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. It is not an easy task to predict whether a prospective placement in which the child has not yet participated in will provide educational benefit. However, certain facts in the present case indicate that STUDENT has reasonable likelihood of achieving educational benefit from the two special day classes proposed by the District. Most important is the fact that STUDENT has progressed while in the special day class at Mitchell, a class that is similar to those proposed in Tustin and Orange. In the year and a half that STUDENT was in the class at Mitchell, progress reports prepared by his teacher show that he was progressing. The speech and language assessment test scores from Ms. Cates, the private speech pathologist who testified on behalf of Petitioner, show improvement in all areas over the test scores from the two assessments conducted during the Summer 1994.

Dr. Prentice, STUDENT's pediatric neurologist, is also of the opinion that STUDENT's language development is progressing. Dr. Prentice expressed this opinion in a letter dated January 9, 1996, a time at which STUDENT's progress could only be attributed to his participation in the program at Mitchell. The Hearing Officer notes that MOTHER testified that during Fall 1995 STUDENT made progress when he was at home and regressed when he returned to school. However, there was no evidence that STUDENT was home for an extended period of time during Fall 1995. In addition, the evidence presented by the District that STUDENT progressed in his educational program was persuasive.

Based on STUDENT's progress at Mitchell, a similarly designed program, such as those offered in Tustin and Orange with the inclusion of speech and language therapy and APE, is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit from his education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the special day classes proposed by the District are designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds pursuant to the IDEA and the Rowley standard that the placements proposed by the District at Tustin Unified School District and Orange Unified School District are appropriate placements for STUDENT.

2) If the District has not offered an appropriate placement, is Hugs 'n' Tugs an appropriate placement for the remainder of the 1995-96 extended school year?

3) If the District has not offered an appropriate placement, is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with Hugs 'n' Tugs beginning on February 22, 1996?

4) Does STUDENT require speech and language services three times per week at the nonpublic preschool in order to benefit from his special education?

Based on the decision reached in Issue #1, the Hearing Officer does not reach issues #2, #3, and #4.

5) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the private speech and language evaluation conducted by Cheryl Cates?

Education Code § 56329(b) provides that parents have the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists ... if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency.

However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500) to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.

Education Code § 56320 provides a detailed list of the criteria to be met when a school conducts an assessment of a student's educational needs. Furthermore, Education Code § 56381 provides that a reassessment of a student must be conducted at least every three years, although a reassessment may be conducted earlier if the student's teacher or parent requests one.

Petitioner requests reimbursement for the independent speech and language assessment conducted by Cheryl Cates in March 1996. Petitioner's grounds for obtaining the assessment from Ms. Cates were that the District's results in the Summer 1994 were too low and Petitioner's mother did not agree with the District that STUDENT is mildly retarded. The District contends that its assessment was appropriate, that there was no testimony indicating that the assessment was not appropriate, and that Ms. Cates' assessment merely provided updated information.

The Hearing Officer finds that there are no grounds presented to warrant reimbursing Petitioner for the independent assessment. No evidence was presented to challenge the appropriateness of the District's assessment. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that the District's assessment took place almost two years prior to the independent assessment. With that in mind, higher scores are too be expected and do not, on their own, indicate that the District's assessment was inappropriate. The Hearing Officer also notes that, while Petitioner's objection with the District's assessment related to cognitive abilities, the independent assessment deals specifically with speech and language abilities and makes no mention of STUDENT's cognitive abilities.

Based on the foregoing, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for the speech and language assessment conducted by Cheryl Cates is denied.

ORDER

1) Santa Ana Unified School District is ordered to convene an IEP team meeting within 10 days of receipt of this decision to enroll STUDENT in one of the two special day classes covered by this decision. The District will then take the necessary steps to enroll STUDENT in the placement selected by the IEP team.

2) Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: April 22, 1996 _____________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1. The District has offered three different placements: a special day class in the Tustin Unified School District, a special day class in the Orange Unified School District, and the Head Start program at Mitchell School. Each of these placements will be addressed by this decision. In addition, incorporated in this inquiry will be the issue originally identified as Petitioner's issue #1: whether Petitioner's unique needs include an educational environment with fluent English-speaking, nondisabled peers

2. The District has offered three different placements: a special day class in the Tustin Unified School District, a special day class in the Orange Unified School District, and the Head Start program at Mitchell School. Each of these placements will be addressed by this decision. In addition, incorporated in this inquiry will be the issue originally identified as Petitioner's issue #1: whether Petitioner's unique needs include an educational environment with fluent English-speaking, nondisabled peers.

3. The Hearing Officer notes that these ranges are based on the basal score and ceiling score provided by the assessor. According to the assessment, basal scores indicate the level at which all items were passed, and ceiling scores indicate the level at which all items were failed.

4. During the hearing, Petitioner stipulated that the District could implement STUDENT's goals and objectives in the Head Start program. Petitioner continued to assert, however, that Head Start is not appropriate because of the number of non-English speaking students in the program.