California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 27, 1996

Student v. Newark Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 1169-95, SN 1170-95 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel

Newark Unified failed to show a 10-year-old needed a nonpublic school; special day class ordered, consultative-only OT upheld.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated in the decision. Earlier history: the cases were taken off calendar after an Interim Mediation Agreement in December 1995 and put back on calendar at the District's request on May 24, 1996. In December 1995 the District also sought injunctive relief in Alameda County Superior Court (Case No. H-187701-2); the decision does not state the outcome.

Summary

Both the parent and Newark Unified School District filed for hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The student is 10 years old and has cerebral palsy, a cortical vision impairment, and developmental delays. In fall 1995 he attended a special day class at Bunker Elementary School. He had frequent behavior problems there, including screaming, bolting, and aggression toward adults, and he was suspended. He had been on home instruction since December 1995. The District wanted to place him at a nonpublic school, either Spectrum Center or Morgan Center. The parent wanted him phased back into a public special day class with behavior supports.

Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel found that the District had not proved the student was too disruptive for a special day class. The District never adequately carried out his Hughes Bill behavior plan. Staff disagreed about which interventions to use, and the District ended its behavior consultant's work after only a few weeks. It did not follow the emergency-restraint rules. It also refused the parent's request for a different teacher after the teacher said she was afraid of him. The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days to place him in a special day class other than that teacher's. The order also required a full-time one-to-one aide, a behavior plan, and gradual integration with home instruction at first. The Hearing Officer declined to name the parent's preferred class or to require the District to hire the parent's behavior specialist. The District won on occupational therapy (OT): consultative-only OT was found appropriate.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to move a student with behavior problems to a nonpublic school. The district had to prove it first carried out a Hughes Bill behavior plan properly. Poor implementation, staff confusion, and a broken teacher relationship weakened the district's claim that the student was too disruptive for a public special day class.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. What is the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year?

    The District did not prove the student was too disruptive for a public special day class, because it did not adequately implement his Hughes Bill behavior plan. The Hearing Officer ordered a special day class other than Mrs. Connelley's but declined to name the parent's proposed class or require the District to hire the parent's behavior specialist.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Should occupational therapy (OT) be provided to STUDENT on a direct and consultative basis, or only on a consultative basis?

    Based on the unrebutted testimony of the only occupational therapist who testified, consultation-only OT was reasonably designed to meet the student's fine motor needs.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of receipt of the decision, the District must hold an IEP meeting to develop the 1996-97 program in line with the order.
  • Placement ordered. Placement in a special day class other than Mrs. Connelley's class, to be chosen by the IEP team (Mrs. DeLeon's class may be chosen if appropriate).
  • Order to provide or change services. Full-time 1:1 aide and a Hughes Bill Behavior Intervention Plan. The District selects qualified staff to serve as aide and to oversee the plan, and may but need not choose Dr. Marone.
  • Order to provide or change services. Gradual integration into the special day class, with time in class increased as the IEP team decides. During the early stages, services such as home instruction by a District teacher and/or the 1:1 aide working with the student at home and in the community on behavior.
  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District shall provide occupational therapy on a consultative basis only.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H.; Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Board of Education v. Rowley; Honig v. Doe; Students of California School for the Blind v. Honig; Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; 34 C.F.R. §300.552 Note; Education Code §56520-56524 (Hughes Bill); 5 CCR §§3001, 3052

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Russ Riley, program specialist; District representative and witness, Newark Unified School District
  • Maritas Igloria, behavior specialist/behavioral consultant, witness for Student, Spectrum Center
  • George Loftis, case manager, witness for Student, Regional Center of the East Bay
  • Dr. Richard Couch, behavior specialist, expert witness for Student; former director of Spectrum's Pleasant Hill school
  • Katie Schwartz (also spelled Schwarz), home teacher, witness for Student
  • Dr. David Gilbertson, psychologist, witness for Student
  • Dr. Frank Marone, psychologist and behavior specialist, expert witness for Student; conducted behavioral assessment
  • Dr. Robert Bradfield, behavioral consultant who prepared the functional analysis and BIP; District witness, Spectrum Center
  • Austin Lambe, coordinator/school director, District witness, Spectrum Center
  • Terry Connelley, special day class teacher, Bunker Elementary School, Newark Unified School District
  • Margaret (Peg) Bledsoe, occupational therapist, District witness, Pediatric Building Blocks
  • Mary Allin, school psychologist; Behavioral Intervention Case Manager, Newark Unified School District
  • Leslie Wilder, physical therapist, District witness, Pediatric Building Blocks
  • Louise Emerson, program director, District witness, Morgan Center
  • Andrea Fletcher-Gill, home teacher, District witness, Newark Unified School District
  • Kenneth Stang, principal, Bunker Elementary School, Newark Unified School District
  • Shirla Vigara, 1:1 aide (1994-95)
  • Dr. Leslie Koelsch, special education director, Newark Unified School District
  • Mrs. Andrade, second grade special day class teacher, Fremont Unified School District
  • Jeff Garrett, 1:1 aide (fall 1995), Newark Unified School District
  • Mickey Woodrow, therapist (called both physical therapist and occupational therapist in the decision); associate of Ms. Bledsoe, Pediatric Building Blocks
  • Dustin Miller, aide who recorded behavior data, Newark Unified School District
  • Mrs. DeLeon, special day class teacher (placement proposed by Student), Snow Elementary School, Newark Unified School District
  • Spectrum Center, nonpublic agency and nonpublic school proposed by District
  • Morgan Center, nonpublic school proposed by District
  • Pediatric Building Blocks, private OT/PT provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Newark, California, on June 13, 14, 19 and 20, and July 22, and August 20, 21, 27 and 29, 1996. (Footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT (footnote 2) was represented by attorneys Larisa Cummings and Sarah Clarke. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was his mother, PARENT.

Respondent Newark Unified School District (NUSD or the District) was represented by attorney Bridget Flanagan. Also present on behalf of the District was Dr. Russ Riley, program specialist.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: PARENT; Maritas Igloria, behavior specialist, Spectrum Center; George Loftis, case manager, Regional Center of the East Bay; Dr. Richard Couch, behavior specialist; Katie Schwartz, home teacher; Dr. David Gilbertson, psychologist; and Dr. Frank Marone, behavior specialist.

The District called the following witnesses: Dr. Riley; Dr.

Robert Bradfield, consultant, Spectrum Center; Austin Lambe, coordinator, Spectrum Center; Terry Connelley, special day class teacher, Bunker Elementary School; Margaret Bledsoe, occupational therapist, Pediatric Building Blocks; Mary Allin, District psychologist; Leslie Wilder, physical therapist, Pediatric Building Blocks; Louise Emerson, program director, Morgan Center; Andrea Fletcher-Gill, home teacher; and Kenneth Stang, principal, Bunker Elementary School.

Oral, documentary, and video evidence was received. (Footnote 3) At the request of the parties, the record was left open until September 17, 1996 for the receipt of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. What is the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year?

2. Should occupational therapy (OT) be provided to STUDENT on a direct and consultative basis, or only on a consultative basis?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

1. Placement

STUDENT last attended school in December, 1995. Since that time, he has received home instruction, pursuant to the agreement of his parents and the District, pending resolution of their continuing dispute as to where he should be educated.

The District asserts that the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT is in a nonpublic school that specializes in educating disabled students with behavior problems -- specifically, either Spectrum Center or Morgan Center. The District asserts that, despite the best efforts of District staff, STUDENT's behavior has proven to be unmanageable and unduly disruptive in a public special day class.

Petitioner asserts that the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT is in a public special day class. Petitioner asserts that, while STUDENT has previously exhibited severe behavior difficulties in such a setting, this was attributable in large part to the District's inappropriate behavior management plan. Petitioner asserts that STUDENT should continue to receive some home instruction while he is gradually re-integrated into a public special day class with appropriate behavioral supports.

2. Occupational therapy

The District asserts that STUDENT's muscle tone, strength and hand functioning have stabilized, and that direct OT service can no longer improve them. The District asserts that STUDENT should receive OT by way of consultation from the occupational therapist to the teacher or classroom aide. The therapist would provide advice as to STUDENT practicing fine motor skills in the course of ordinary classroom activities.

Petitioner asserts that STUDENT has always received both direct and consultative occupational therapy (OT) service to address fine motor skill deficits. Petitioner asserts that STUDENT should continue to receive both direct and consultative OT.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

A. Introduction

STUDENT is ten years old and lives with his family in Newark, within the Newark Unified School District (NUSD or the District). STUDENT suffered brain damage at birth. He has cerebral palsy with left side weakness, cortical vision impairment (CVI) (footnote 4), and developmental delays. His strengths include verbal skills and working on the computer. The parties agree that STUDENT's educational needs include low staff-to-student ratio, a highly structured environment, minimal distractions, staff trained in behavior management, and curriculum modifications that address STUDENT's visual and behavioral needs.

B. Chronological summary prior to fall 1995

Since preschool, STUDENT has attended special day classes (SDCs) for disabled students that are located on public school campuses also attended by nondisabled students. (Footnote 5) From preschool through kindergarten, STUDENT attended SDCs for students with orthopedic disabilities in the neighboring Fremont Unified School District (FUSD), pursuant to an interdistrict transfer. In first and second grade, he attended an SDC for students with learning disabilities in the FUSD. While STUDENT had behavior problems prior to second grade, these became more significant that year (1994-95).

By mid-October 1994, STUDENT had been suspended three times for disruptive behavior, including profanity, throwing and/or overturning objects and/or furniture, threatening to hurt staff, and urinating. In mid-October, the District hired a one-to one aide, Shirla Vigara, to assist STUDENT in class, and implemented an informal behavior management plan to address "profanity" and "physicalness". (footnote 6) This arrangement was relatively effective, and STUDENT received no more suspensions for about five months, until March, 1995. On March 29, 1995, the District's special education director, Dr. Leslie Koelsch, wrote to PARENT that STUDENT has made considerable progress in behavioral areas this year . . . the interventions have been successful . . .

the behaviors that the team targeted have been reduced and basically eliminated . . . these behaviors have remained in remission and are not interfering with learning activities. (R 21)

On an IEP document dated April 5, 1995, STUDENT's second grade teacher, Mrs. Andrade, wrote:

STUDENT has made very adequate growth this school year in all areas. A behavior intervention plan has helped turn around his negative behaviors . . . STUDENT's behavior has improved greatly due to the intervention plan where he is encouraged and has better learned how to refocus and redirect his negative behaviors . . . [he] has made great strides in socializing with his peers. (R 25)

In March and April, 1995, however -- contemporaneous with these positive comments -- STUDENT received three suspensions for such behavior as profanity, throwing objects, spitting at and hitting his aide, and urinating. During this time, the District contracted with Dr. Robert Bradfield, a behavioral consultant with Spectrum Center, to conduct a formal behavioral analysis of STUDENT pursuant to the Hughes Bill. (Footnote 7) For the remainder of the school year, PARENT spent time in the classroom and had some success in helping to keep STUDENT's behavior under control. (The parties agree that PARENT is a valuable source of suggestions regarding how to address STUDENT's behavioral problems.)

Upon observing STUDENT in Mrs. Andrade's class during the spring of 1995, Dr. Bradfield identified STUDENT's target misbehaviors as (1) aggressive behaviors, such as hitting, kicking, spitting on staff and students when upset; (2) tipping over desks, destroying property, and knocking things off walls and desks, (3) screaming, (4) oppositional behavior when requested to complete academic or physical activities, (5) bolting and leaving the area when upset, and (6) "roaring" like a lion on the playground. (R 22) He observed that other students were not scared of STUDENT, but that his behavior could cause the class activity to be interrupted. The functions of the target misbehaviors were identified as (1) to get something (attention, a preferred activity), (2) to avoid, escape, or stop something, or (3) to provide himself with sensory stimulation. Antecedents of the target behaviors included direct demands to perform academic tasks, transitions between activities, and fatigue.

Dr. Bradfield noted that STUDENT attempts to negotiate nearly every task assigned to him. His typical response to an assignment is to want to do less than assigned or to do it in a different way than assigned. He also often announces or warns that he is about to engage in a misbehavior; sometimes he follows through, and sometimes he does not.

Dr. Bradfield prepared a proposed Behavior Intervention Plan (BIP) to address STUDENT's behavior. The BIP recommended a number of adjustments to classroom variables to prevent occurrence of the target misbehaviors: (1) a highly structured setting with a clearly defined and predictable schedule, (2) reducing the amount of time STUDENT is pulled out of class to receive related services, (3) providing a quiet room or area for STUDENT and his aide when necessary, (4) giving STUDENT "helper" opportunities, (5) modifying instructional materials to accommodate STUDENT's special needs in the areas of fine motor skills and vision, (6) providing at least three positive feedbacks for every one negative feedback, (7)

limiting academic activities to fifteen minutes, and (8) five-minute break periods after recess and lunch. The BIP also suggested a number of alternative or coping behaviors to replace the target misbehaviors. (R 22)

The IEP team met several times in May and June 1995 to discuss the proposed BIP. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be placed for the 1995-96 school year in Mrs. Connelley's special day class for learning disabled students at Bunker Elementary School within the Newark Unified School District. At PARENT's request, it was agreed that Dr. Bradfield would be replaced by a different behavioral specialist. It was also agreed that certain changes to the BIP would have to be made in the fall, since the BIP had been prepared with Mrs. Andrade's class in mind, not Mrs. Connelley's. That summer, the District assigned Jeff Garrett as STUDENT's one-to-one aide for the fall, and District school psychologist Mary Allin as the Behavioral Intervention Case Manager (BICM).

C. Fall 1995 -- Mrs. Connelley's class

In September, STUDENT entered Mrs. Connelley's class. There were nine students, ages nine and ten. (STUDENT was then nine years old.) All of the other students had learning disabilities, some had serious emotional disturbance, and many had behavioral problems. A number of things about this placement were new for STUDENT, who has difficulty with changes: (1) a new teacher, after two years with Mrs. Andrade, (2) a new one-to-one aide, (3) a new school, (4) attending school in the Newark District for the first time, and (5) being served by a formal BIP for the first time.

On the first day of school, September 5, STUDENT engaged in the following misbehavior: bolting, roaring, screaming, and throwing and overturning objects and furniture. He also screamed to Mrs. Connelley: "I'm going to kill you!," "I'm going to take a gun and blow your head off!," "I'm going to blow out your guts!," and "I hate you!" All of this had a devastating impact on Mrs. Connelley. She had never been threatened by a student before. She stated that it got her "adrenaline going", and described the day as "very intense." At the hearing, she acknowledged that her relationship with STUDENT never recovered. She was not able to establish a positive rapport with him. The first time she tried to use positive feedback, as called for by Dr. Bradfield's BIP, STUDENT's misbehavior escalated -- therefore, after that, she did not provide him with positive feedback. Mrs. Connelley stated that she did not have much patience with STUDENT. She consulted her teachers' union representative about the situation, and, based on that person's advice, began keeping an extensive daily log recording STUDENT's misbehavior. (R 38)

No behavioral specialist from Spectrum was involved in STUDENT's program at the start of the school year, when things got off to a rocky start. The evidence showed that on at least one occasion during the first few days of school the aide, Mr. Garrett, resorted to an "emergency" physical restraint of STUDENT. (Footnote 8) However, the District did not notify the parent, prepare a written report, or refer the matter to the IEP team to determine if the BIP should be modified. Between September 11 and 20, STUDENT was absent from school, due to surgery. In late September, once STUDENT had returned, Spectrum behavioral consultant Maritas Igloria entered the case. Ms. Igloria made some recommendations for interventions, such as having STUDENT hold up a card to request a break. Upon observing staff attempting to implement the BIP, Ms. Igloria had a number of concerns. First, she noted that staff members were having great difficulty in locating an appropriate quiet space for STUDENT to calm down, as required by the BIP.

Second, and more significantly, she noted that there was no agreement among staff as to which interventions should be used consistently. She believed that, until there was such agreement, it was impossible to determine if any particular intervention was working.

At a meeting on October 9, District staff, Ms. Igloria, and PARENT discussed what was working, what was not, and what changes might be made. No final conclusions were reached, and Ms. Igloria believed there remained substantial additional work for her to do on the case. However, shortly after the meeting -- and after just several weeks of involvement in STUDENT's case -- Ms. Igloria's services were terminated by the District. PARENT testified that the District's special education director told her this occurred because the BIP was not working and the District did not believe any further service from Ms. Igloria would be valuable. This testimony went unrebutted.

At the October 9 meeting, PARENT told Mrs. Connelley that STUDENT believed Mrs. Connelley did not like him. Mrs. Connelley replied, "I am afraid of him." At that point, PARENT requested another public SDC placement. District program specialist Dr. Russ Riley did not offer another SDC, but rather suggested that STUDENT attend either the California School for the Blind or Morgan Center. He stated that he would not recommend Spectrum Center's nonpublic school because, based on his personal observation there several years earlier, he had a negative opinion of Spectrum.

Ms. Allin, the BICM, testified that, during this time, numerous proposals and discussions regarding changing the BIP were made, and it became very confusing to staff as to which BIP was in fact being implemented. The evidence showed that STUDENT's one-to-one aide, Mr. Garrett, was calm and patient with STUDENT and attempted to be positive with him. However, there was also unrebutted testimony that Mr. Garrett had never implemented a BIP before, did not limit STUDENT's academic activities to fifteen minutes (as called for in the BIP to prevent fatigue), (footnote 9)had great difficulty re-directing STUDENT and giving him choices, and perhaps too often resorted to physical restraint, and that STUDENT's behavior was usually better when Mr. Garrett was absent. On October 19, Ms. Woodrow, STUDENT's physical therapist, reported to the principal, Mr. Stang, that she had been pushed to the floor and injured when she attempted to stop STUDENT from leaving the room. (R 24, 69) (Ms. Woodrow did not testify at the hearing, and there were no other eyewitnesses to the incident.) That day Mr. Stang suspended STUDENT for five days, and wrote an interoffice memo to the District superintendent stating that he had told PARENT he would "take whatever action was necessary in removing STUDENT from this school." (R 69)

On the day STUDENT returned to school, October 26, he was suspended for five more days by Mrs. Connelley for, among other things, verbally threatening her. At an IEP meeting on November 1, while STUDENT was still on suspension, the District formally proposed that STUDENT attend a nonpublic school. PARENT disagreed. It was then agreed that STUDENT would attend Mrs. Connelley's class in the mornings only, because much of his misbehavior tended to occur later in the school day when he was tired. The parties agreed that Ms. Allin, the BICM, would take more data and report to the IEP team at a meeting on November 21.

At the November 21 IEP meeting, Ms. Allin concluded that the BIP was not working, despite the best efforts of staff. She believed one problem was that of physical setting. She noted that, because the Bunker Elementary School campus was not fenced, staff had to chase STUDENT when he ran. They could not ignore the bolting, thereby "rewarding" the behavior by providing him with the adult attention and chase which he craved, sought out and enjoyed. She believed STUDENT would be better served at a fenced school. (R 25) At the hearing, she testified that the District could not satisfactorily implement the BIP at Bunker Elementary because it had to focus on this safety factor.

In December, the District filed a request for injunctive relief in Alameda County Superior Court, (footnote 10) to prohibit STUDENT from attending class, and PARENT removed STUDENT from school. The parties agreed that, as a temporary measure, STUDENT would receive home teaching from District staff for two hours per day. He has remained on home teaching since then.

D. Review of Fall 1995

The evidence of STUDENT's misbehavior in Mrs. Connelley's class during the fall of 1995, as detailed in her narrative log, is extensive. The frequency of occurrence of STUDENT's target misbehaviors from September through mid-November 1995 (as compiled by Ms. Allin based on the narrative log kept by Mrs. Connelley), is shown below. For the month of November, the numbers in parentheses represent any data separately recorded by an aide, Dustin Miller, that is different from that recorded by Mrs. Connelley. (R 76)

A = Oppositional (yelling, arguing, growling)

B = Screaming, profanities C = Roaring, barking D = Bolting E = Tipping desk F = Threatening, throwing materials away G = Aggressive (kick, spit, throwing things)

Sept. A B C D E F G

5 1 1 1 1 0 1 3 6 1 1 0 1 0 0 2 7 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 8 2 2 0 1 0 1 2 (Student absence because of surgery)

21 2 1 0 1 0 1 5 22 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 25 3 0 2 1 0 1 1 26 2 1 2 0 0 2 6 27 3 1 1 1 0 3 3 28 5 1 1 0 0 0 1 29 1 1 1 0 1 0 0

Oct. A B C D E F G

2 7 3 2 1 0 0 6 3 1 0 1 0 0 2 1 4 3 1 1 1 0 0 1 5 3 2 1 0 0 1 2 6 3 1 2 0 0 0 4 9 3 2 2 1 0 1 5 10 2 0 1 2 0 0 0 (Teacher absence because of conference)

16 2 3 2 0 0 0 5 17 3 0 1 0 0 2 2 18 3 1 0 2 0 2 1 19 2 2 0 0 0 0 4

Oct. A B C D E F G (Student suspended)

26 4 1 0 0 0 1 0 (Student suspended)

Nov. A B C D E F G

2 2 0 0 0 0 1 0 3 5(3) 0 0(2) 0 0 1 0 6 0(1) 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 4(3) 1(5) 0(5) 1(2) 0 0 0(8)

8 3(5) 1(2) 1(0) 2(3) 0 0 0(6)

9 4(7) 0(3) 0(3) 1(4) 0 2(2) 1(5)

13 6(7) 0 0 0(1) 0 3(0) 1(2)

14 4(5) 1(3) 1(2) 2(3) 0 1(0) 1(7)

15 -(3) -(8) -(0) -(4) -(0) -(0) -(9)

The total frequency of occurrence, and average occurrence per day, for the thirty-two school days of attendance covered by this data, is as follows (numbers in parentheses incorporate any data separately recorded by the aide):

Target behavior Total Avg. per day

A Oppositional 87 (95) 2.7 (3.0)

B Screaming 30 (47) 0.9 (1.5)

C Roaring 23 (33) 0.7 (1.0)

D Bolting 20 (31) 0.6 (1.0)

E Tipping desk 1 (1) 0.0 (0.0)

F Threatening 26 (22) 0.8 (0.7)

G Aggressive 58 (92) 1.8 (1.9)

The Hearing Officer does not intend to minimize the nature or extent of the misbehavior by merely summarizing it herein and providing illustrative examples. However, there is no dispute that the target behaviors occurred with some frequency. (Petitioner, for its part, identified, without contradiction, numerous instances when STUDENT was "on task" and behaving appropriately in class.)

The parties do have some disagreement as to the severity of STUDENT's misbehavior. One of Petitioner's expert witnesses, behavior specialist Dr. Richard Couch, described the behavior as primarily "annoying,", while the District's Dr. Riley expressed concern that certain of STUDENT's behaviors could potentially injure others.

The evidence showed that none of STUDENT's misbehavior was ever directed at another child -- rather, all of it was directed at adults. He never hit, injured, threatened, spit at, yelled at or threw anything at another student. He never injured himself. No adult testified that he or she was injured by STUDENT, although a written report states that occupational therapist Ms. Woodrow was hurt on one occasion trying to restrain STUDENT.

There is no question, however, that STUDENT's behavior at times caused disruption to the teacher and the other students in his class. Mrs. Connelley stated that STUDENT made her "crazy." On certain occasions she was so upset that she chose to evacuate the class until STUDENT calmed down. Ms. Allin, the BICM, testified that she instructed STUDENT's one-to-one aide, Mr.

Garrett, as to the great importance of being positive and never letting his emotions show on his face, in his voice, or in his body language. Mrs. Connelley acknowledged, however, that she herself was unable to do this. At times, the students saw the look on their teacher's face and became upset. PARENT testified, without contradiction, that Mrs. Connelley made certain negative comments about STUDENT's behavior in the presence of other students.

Students told Mrs. Connelley that they were concerned about her well-being and afraid of STUDENT. On certain occasions, some students were crying, hiding under their desks, and/or covering their ears, causing great interference with their ability to concentrate on academics. (Footnote 11) Ms. Allin testified that all of the students in the class were attempting to improve their behavior, and they were angry that a different set of rules seemed to apply to STUDENT, who was the only student with a BIP.

E. January 1996 to the present -- home teaching

1. Andrea Fletcher-Gill (January-April 1996)

Ms. Fletcher-Gill testified that she had a good relationship with STUDENT. She was not afraid of him, although it was very difficult work for her. STUDENT liked to ask questions and tell stories. He constantly tried to negotiate the task at hand. He had a short attention span, and was often off-task.

At times, STUDENT would become oppositional and not want to do the assigned task. He did all of the following: wrote on his clothes, broke pencils, tried to tip over his desk and chair, and made "little lion and train noises." No more than thirty minutes of each two hour session was productive.

Ms. Fletcher-Gill does not feel that Mrs. DeLeon's SDC class at Snow Elementary School -- proposed by Petitioner for 1996-97 -- would be appropriate for STUDENT. During the 1995-96 school year, none of the students in that class had behaviors like STUDENT's. The class is located in a large, open room with no space for him to calm down and get quiet.

2. Katie Schwarz (June-August 1996)

Ms. Schwarz testified that she developed a good relationship and rapport with STUDENT, and was not afraid of him. He responded well to a daily routine with a written schedule and a lot of structure, although he often attempted to negotiate the activities or their order. He liked working on his journal and the computer, and enjoyed hands-on activities, such as handling math manipulatives. He had a good vocabulary and was able to carry on a conversation and make his point. He demonstrated good academic potential, some higher order thinking, and a good sense of humor.

On the other hand, STUDENT was easily distracted by the slightest noise, and often attempted to engage in conversations about topics not related to the task at hand. He engaged in all of the following activities rather than engage in academic tasks: grit his teeth, growl, yell, describe violent parts of the movie "Lion King," attempt to swallow a metal bolt, throw a boot, knock over a chair, bite a chair, unplug a lamp and put the cord in his mouth, grab a scissors and cut off some of his hair, and threaten to throw things, and bite or spit. At times he would announce his refusal to do any more work, sprawl out on the floor, flail his arms and legs, pretend to snore, or laugh. No more than thirty minutes out of each two hour session resulted in productive work. Ms. Schwarz testified that, in her experience, this was slightly below average for a typical SDC student.

Ms. Schwarz believes STUDENT needs a quiet school environment with few distractions, and that, presently, two hours is the maximum amount of time he should spend on academics each day. She believes his behavior would be distracting to other students in an SDC, and that he would have to be removed from class frequently in order to calm down and get under control. She stated that the stimulation in an SDC could be distracting to him, or it could make him curious and want to participate.

E. Proposed placements for the 1996-97 school year

The District proposed that STUDENT be educated at either of two nonpublic schools, Spectrum Center or Morgan Center.

Petitioner proposed that STUDENT attend Mrs. DeLeon's special day class at Snow Elementary School and that the District hire behavior specialist Dr. Frank Marone to implement STUDENT's BIP there. Each of these placement proposals is discussed in detail below.

1. Spectrum Center

Spectrum Center is a nonpublic, state-certified school exclusively serving special education students. Spectrum is located in San Lorenzo, which is approximately a twenty-to twenty-five-minute drive from Newark. The campus is fenced and has one locked gate and one gate with a complex latch.

All Spectrum students have a diagnosis of developmental disability, which includes such conditions as autism and mental retardation. The typical student has relatively low cognitive functioning and multiple impairments. Many of the students have limited language, and some are nonverbal. All of the students have, as their primary school difficulty, very significant behavior problems, including causing injury to people and damage to property.

At Spectrum, there are six to nine students in a class. The class that ten-year-old STUDENT would most likely attend includes students aged seven through eleven. All Spectrum staff are trained in behavior modification and crisis management and have experience with aggressive students. Classroom staff include a credentialed special education teacher, an assistant teacher, and a number of aides, such that the ratio of staff to students is typically either one-to-one or, at most, two-to-one. Other on-site staff include behavior specialists and speech therapists. Occupational therapists, physical therapists, and orientation and mobility trainers for visually impaired students visit the school as needed.

Spectrum uses positive behavior intervention plans -- similar to the one Spectrum consultant Dr. Bradfield prepared for STUDENT -- for all of its students. BIPs are continually revised as warranted to meet the students' needs. When Spectrum students exhibit disruptive behaviors in class, staff may use various interventions, including having the student sit away from the group and observe, moving the student into the courtyard, and moving the student to a separate area of campus. During the period of removal from the group, the student is accompanied by a one-to-one aide. Once he demonstrates that he is under control, the student is encouraged to return to class. Students who have a tendency to bolt from the classroom are accompanied by one-to-one aides at all times.

Spectrum has had some success transitioning its students back to SDCs located in public schools. In such cases, the Spectrum student spends a gradually increasing portion of his school day in public school until he is ready to leave Spectrum. Some students who are placed at Spectrum, however, spend the remainder of their school careers there.

Several witnesses expressed an opinion as to the appropriateness of Spectrum Center for STUDENT. Austin Lambe, the school director, testified that Spectrum has some advantages over public school for a student with significant behavior problems. Spectrum is better able to control the environment than is a public school. Spectrum can control other students' responses to negative behavior, whereas a public school setting may reinforce negative behavior. Spectrum has a better-trained staff, lower staff-to-student ratio, and higher level of safety than a public school. According to Mr. Lambe, Spectrum gives an out-of-control student a chance to fix the problem and experience some success, rather than continuing to experience failure in public school. On the other hand, Mr. Lambe acknowledged that a disadvantage of Spectrum is that the students are poor behavior role models for each other.

Dr. Richard Couch, former director of Spectrum's Pleasant Hill school, testified that he would be concerned about STUDENT's safety at Spectrum. He stated that there are many assaultive students there who often require the use of prone containment, and that STUDENT is not assaultive. George Loftis, the Regional Center of the East Bay case manager, testified that the typical Spectrum student is autistic and severely mentally retarded and, unlike STUDENT, extremely aggressive toward other students. Dr. David Gilbertson stated that he believes the typical Spectrum student is lower functioning and has more significant behavior problems than

STUDENT.

2. Morgan Center

Morgan Center is a nonpublic, state-certified school exclusively serving special education students. Morgan Center is located in Los Altos, approximately a twenty-five minute drive from Newark. The campus is partially fenced. The main playground is not fenced, but there is no street nearby.

All Morgan students have a diagnosis of developmental disability, including autism, mental retardation, brain injury or other neurological dysfunction. All of the students have, as their primary school difficulty, very significant behavior problems. The typical student has learning difficulties. Some have physical impairments, and some are nonverbal.

At Morgan, there are there are seven to nine students in a class. Each class has two credentialed teachers and as many one-to-one aides as are necessary. Morgan uses general guidelines of positive behavior intervention with all of its students, but does not specifically implement a Hughes Bill BIP for any student.

While it is possible for Morgan students to be integrated for a portion of the day into a public school, generally, students who are placed at Morgan Center stay there for the remainder of their school careers.

Several witnesses expressed an opinion as to the appropriateness of Morgan Center for STUDENT. Louise Emerson, Morgan's director, testified that, in her opinion, Morgan could implement STUDENT's IEP. Mr. Loftis, the Regional Center case manager, testified that while Morgan is an appropriate setting for some students, he does not believe the District has yet done all it reasonably can to maintain STUDENT in a public SDC.

3. Mrs. DeLeon's special day class at Snow Elementary School

Details of Petitioner's plan for educating STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year remained somewhat elusive throughout the hearing. Petitioner proposed that STUDENT be gradually integrated into Mrs. DeLeon's special day class for learning disabled students at Snow Elementary School in the Newark Unified School District, with a one-to-one aide and appropriate behavioral supports.

Petitioner did not call Mrs. DeLeon as a witness, and provided few details about her class. (Footnote 12) According to the District, the class will consist of second and third grade students this year. (STUDENT is now of fifth grade age.) Petitioner proposes, generally, that the gradual integration process, and the behavioral supports, be based on the recommendations of psychologist and behavior specialist Dr. Frank Marone. Dr. Marone, who testified at the hearing, performed a behavioral assessment of STUDENT in March 1996. (Pet. Exh. F6).

In Dr. Marone's plan, the first step would be for Dr. Marone to personally hire and train a one-to-one aide to work with STUDENT. That process could take approximately sixty days. Dr. Marone did not have specific plans as to what education STUDENT would receive during that waiting period. (Upon questioning by the Hearing Officer, counsel for Petitioner stated that it would be appropriate for STUDENT to continue to receive two hours of home instruction during this time.) Once the aide was in place, he/she would work with STUDENT at home and in the community regarding improving behavior. Then, STUDENT would attend Mrs. DeLeon's class for a portion of each school day, with his aide. STUDENT would receive a great deal of positive feedback from his aide for any demonstration of appropriate behavior. He would remain in class only for that amount of time that he could tolerate before his behavior deteriorated. As the school year progressed, the amount of time that STUDENT would spend in Mrs. DeLeon's class would increase as appropriate.

Dr. Marone's written report acknowledged that, initially, "some fairly outrageous and energetic behavior may occur . . . at the school site." (Pet. Exh. F6, p. 30.) He stated that he would seek to push the classroom teacher to tolerate as much disruption as possible without calling for the removal of STUDENT. Dr. Marone stated that while removal may at times be necessary, it is not behaviorally effective because it may reinforce the escape function that a misbehavior serves for STUDENT. He stated that one possible response to STUDENT's disruptive behavior could be to have the other students walk around the school for a few minutes until STUDENT calmed down.

F. Evidence regarding occupational therapy

STUDENT has fine motor skill deficits because of cerebral palsy. During the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT began receiving educational OT from the District to increase his right hand strength and to increase use of his (weaker) left hand for academic tasks. Therapy was provided in class by Margaret (Peg) Bledsoe of Pediatric Building Blocks. That year STUDENT met some of his OT goals. In a report dated April 1994, Ms. Bledsoe concluded that she would be unable to change STUDENT's low muscle tone, spasticity, hand functioning, or tactile processing, and that vision problems also affected his ability to perform fine motor skills. She recommended that direct OT service be discontinued, and that OT be provided on a consultative basis to the teacher only. PARENT disagreed, so OT continued on a direct basis during the 1994-95 school year.

In the spring of 1995, Ms. Bledsoe's associate, Mickey Woodrow, noted that STUDENT had again met some of his OT goals. Late that spring, Ms. Woodrow recommended changing from direct to consultative service. She agreed with Ms. Bledsoe that STUDENT's progress had stabilized in a number of areas. PARENT again disagreed, so OT continued on a direct basis with Ms. Woodrow for 1995-96. During the fall of 1995, Ms. Woodrow also provided consultative OT to the classroom teacher, Mrs. Connelley. When Ms. Woodrow tried to work with STUDENT in class, he had behavior problems, so they changed to a "pullout" service model.

During the spring of 1996, by which time STUDENT was receiving instruction at home, Ms. Bledsoe worked with STUDENT on using both sides of his body, scanning the environment for objects, visual-perception games, and exercises. In June 1996, Ms. Bledsoe again recommended that OT be provided by way of consultation to the classroom teacher. More specifically, she stated that this could involve advising the teacher and/or STUDENT's aide on how to practice his fine motor skills in the course of ordinary classroom activities. (R 55) At the hearing, she testified that she believes his muscle tone, hand functioning and strength have stabilized, and that direct OT service cannot impact his cerebral palsy and neurologic problems. Therefore, she testified, he no longer needs direct OT, but rather simply needs to practice fine motor skills in the course of everyday, functional, classroom situations.

DISCUSSION

A. Summary of applicable law

1. FAPE and Least Restrictive Environment

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); §1401(a)(18). Special education means specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. It may include instruction in a classroom, in the home, and/or in other settings. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16). Related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(17).

Placement decisions must be made on an individual basis. 34 C.F.R. §300.552, Note. Accordingly, school districts must make available a continuum of placements to meet the needs of disabled students. 34 C.F.R. §300.551. The range of placements in the continuum may include regular classes, special classes, special schools, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions. Id. In order to receive a FAPE, a student must be educated in the least restrictive appropriate environment (LRE). 34 C.F.R. §300.550. IDEA states that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities [should be] educated with children who are not disabled, and . . . special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment [shall] occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services (footnote 13) cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); see, e.g., Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1403 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994) (hereafter "Rachel H.")(noting that this provision reflects Congress' preference for mainstreaming).

In this case, the parties agree that placement in regular education classes is not appropriate for STUDENT. The dispute involves whether he should attend a public special day class on a campus also attended by nondisabled students or a more restrictive nonpublic school that serves only disabled students. The District has the burden to show that a nonpublic school represents the least restrictive appropriate environment for STUDENT. Cf. Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. 874 at 880 (E.D.Cal. 1992), aff'd sub. nom. Rachel H., supra.

2. The effect of a student's disruptiveness on placement decisions

The federal regulations do not specifically address when a disabled child's disruptiveness in a special day class is such that he must be educated in a nonpublic school. On the other hand, the regulations, the U.S. Department of Education's Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), and the Ninth Circuit have all provided some specific guidance as to when a disabled child's behavior may rule out placement in regular classes and require that the student be educated in either a special day class or an even more restrictive placement. The Hearing Officer finds that this guidance is equally applicable to the present situation, and therefore summarizes it below. The regulations state:

[W]here a [disabled child] is so disruptive in a regular classroom that the education of other students is significantly impaired, the needs of the [disabled] child cannot be met in that environment. Therefore regular placement would not be appropriate to his or her needs.

34 C.F.R. §300.552, Note.

The Ninth Circuit, in developing its four-factor test used for determining the appropriate amount of mainstreaming, drew one factor from the Note in the regulations regarding disruptiveness. More specifically, the Ninth Circuit considers, among other factors, any negative effect a disabled student's presence has on the regular education teacher and other students. Rachel H., supra at 1404.

OSEP has stated in a policy letter that a school district must ensure, before determining that a child is too disruptive to be educated in regular classes, that consideration has been given to the full range of supplementary aids and services that could be provided to the student in the regular education environment to accommodate his unique needs. 21 IDELR 1152, 1155 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 48. The Ninth Circuit has adopted this position. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396, 1401 n.7 (9th Cir. 1994).

3. Behavioral Intervention Plans

An example of a supplementary aid or service which may ensure a disabled student's participation in the least restrictive environment is a positive behavioral intervention plan, or BIP. In California, BIPs are covered by the so-called Hughes Bill.

Education Code §56520-56524; Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Sections 3001, 3052. Because a FAPE must meet not only federal, but also state standards, (footnote 14) a FAPE in California must comply with the Hughes Bill where applicable.

Behavioral interventions must be utilized "to assure the pupil's placement in the least restrictive environment." Education Code §56523(b)(2)(D); Title 5 CCR Section 3001(d).

The regulations implementing the Hughes Bill provide that if a child is exhibiting serious behavior problems that significantly interfere with implementation of his IEP, the District should conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of his behavior for the purpose of developing a BIP. Title 5 CCR Section 3001(f), 3052(b). The FAA must include systematic observation and analysis of the occurrence of targeted inappropriate behaviors, the immediate antecedent events associated with each display of the targeted behaviors, and the consequences following the display of the behavior to determine the function the behavior serves for the student. Section 3052(b)(1)(A-C). When the FAA is completed, a written report is prepared that includes a proposed BIP. Section 3052(b)(2).

The BIP is approved by the IEP team and becomes part of the IEP. Section 3052(c); Section 3001(f). (footnote 15) BIP requirements include: an objective and measurable description of the targeted maladaptive behaviors and replacement positive behaviors; a detailed description of the behavioral interventions to be used and the circumstances for their use; specific schedules for recording the frequency of the use of the interventions and the frequency of the targeted and replacement behaviors, including specific criteria for discontinuing the use of the intervention for lack of effectiveness or replacing it with an identified and specified alternative; and specific dates for periodic review by the IEP team of the efficacy of the program. Section 3001(f)(2,4,5,8).

The term "behavioral interventions" is defined as the systematic implementation of procedures that result in lasting positive changes in the individual's behavior. Section 3001(d). Interventions are to be used to replace specific maladaptive behaviors with alternative acceptable behaviors. Section 3052(a)(2). (Witnesses agreed that a purpose of the Hughes Bill is to teach the student a better way to get what he wants -- that is, replace a maladaptive behavior with a more socially acceptable behavior that serves the same function for the student.)

Examples of positive behavioral interventions include (1)

altering the identified antecedent event to prevent the occurrence of the behavior, (2) teaching alternative behaviors that produce the same consequences as the inappropriate behavior, (3) teaching adaptive behaviors, and (4) manipulating the consequences for the display of the targeted inappropriate behaviors and alternative, acceptable behaviors so that it is the alternative behaviors that more effectively produce desired outcomes. Section 3052(d)(1-4).

The regulations implementing the Hughes Bill provide further guidance as to implementation of the BIP. When the targeted behavior occurs, it should be met only with positive responses, such as redirection. Section 3052(e). The effectiveness of the plan must be periodically reviewed. Where necessary, the IEP team shall propose changes to the BIP. Section 3052(f).

Emergency interventions may be used to control unpredictable, spontaneous behavior which poses a clear and present danger of serious physical harm to the individual or others or serious property damage and which cannot be immediately prevented by a response less restrictive than the temporary application of a technique used to contain the behavior. Section 3052(i). When emergency interventions are used, the parent must be notified and a written report must be prepared. Section 3052(i)(1). If it involves a situation where BIP interventions have not proven effective, the matter should be referred to the IEP team to determine if the BIP should be modified. Section 3052(i)(8).

B. Did the District provide STUDENT with adequate behavioral supports to ensure his successful participation in Mrs. Connelley's class?

There is no question that, at times during the fall of 1995, STUDENT's behavior had a negative effect on his SDC teacher and fellow students and impaired their ability to focus on academic tasks. The evidence of his misbehavior in that class is, of course, substantial. Were this misbehavior to have coexisted with satisfactory implementation of a BIP, the Hearing Officer would likely conclude that STUDENT must be educated in a more restrictive setting than an SDC. However, the occurrence of the misbehavior is only the beginning and not the end of the analysis here regarding appropriate placement. The District has the burden to show that it provided STUDENT with satisfactory behavioral support services to ensure his successful participation in Mrs. Connelley's class. See See OSEP Policy Letter, Clyde K., supra. As noted above, a purpose of the Hughes Bill is to ensure that the student is educated in the LRE. Education Code §56523(b)(2)(D); Title 5 CCR Section 3001(d). Prior to the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT has always been educated successfully in special day classes located on campuses also attended by nondisabled students in the Fremont Unified School District. In the spring of 1995, FUSD and NUSD staff made positive comments about STUDENT's academic and behavioral progress in Mrs. Andrade's second grade class. (R 21, 25) On the other hand, he also received several suspensions that spring. As of June 1995, the District agreed that the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year, beginning in September 1995 would be in a public SDC with a BIP -- and, for the first time, in the Newark Unified School District.

Things did not get off to a good start. The BIP had been prepared in the spring of 1995 when STUDENT was attending Mrs. Andrade's class at a different school. Thus, the BIP was not prepared with Mrs. Connelley's class in mind, and staff struggled to adapt it to the new setting -- for example, in attempting to locate a quiet place for STUDENT to calm down. No behavior specialist from Spectrum Center, which prepared the BIP, was brought in until late September, by which time a great deal had already occurred. Although there was evidence that on at least one occasion during the first few days of school the aide, Mr. Garrett, resorted to an "emergency" physical restraint intervention, the parent was not notified, no written report was prepared, and the matter was not referred to the IEP team to determine if the BIP should be modified. See Title 5 CCR Section 3052(i).

On the first day of school, Mrs. Connelley was so affected by STUDENT's verbal threat to her that, thereafter, she was unable to develop a positive relationship with him. She was afraid of him -- an emotion no other person testified to having -- and was unable to provide him with the positive feedback called for in the BIP. She let the students see and hear her negative reaction to STUDENT. Upon consulting her union representative, she began keeping a detailed log of misbehavior, independent of and separate from any specific data collection required by the Hughes Bill.

No criticism of Mrs. Connelley is intended here. However, it seems clear that the District should have immediately considered transferring STUDENT to an SDC with another teacher. Mrs.

Connelley was afraid of STUDENT. No other teacher who has worked with STUDENT testified that he/she was afraid of STUDENT, and several testified that they developed a good rapport and relationship with him. It seems clear that STUDENT sensed, immediately and correctly, that Mrs. Connelley would have preferred that he were not in the class. Therefore, another teacher should have been tried. (This is exactly what PARENT requested, but the District rejected, when Mrs. Connelley told her she was afraid of

STUDENT.)

Next, the District's behavioral consultant, Ms. Igloria, who started several weeks late, observed that there was significant confusion among District staff as to which interventions should be used. She concluded that there was no way to determine if an intervention was working, as required by the regulations, until such agreement was reached. Title 5 CCR Section 3001(f). Ms. Igloria's testimony went unrebutted by any other testimony, establishing that the District did not "systematically" implement interventions as required by the Hughes Bill. Title 5 CCR Section 3001(d).

The District person who spent the most time with STUDENT, and thus had the most hands-on responsibility for implementing the BIP, Mr. Garrett, did not testify. Although there was testimony that Mr. Garrett was calm and patient with STUDENT, there was also unrebutted testimony that he had never implemented a BIP before, did not limit academic activities to fifteen minutes (as called for in the BIP to prevent fatigue), had great difficulty re-directing STUDENT and giving him choices, perhaps too often resorted to physical restraints, and that STUDENT's behavior was usually better when Mr. Garrett was absent. Based on the evidence presented, it cannot be concluded that Mr. Garrett implemented the BIP in a satisfactory manner.

By early October 1995, after only one month of attendance in Mrs. Connelley's class (his first experience in a District school), after only several weeks of service from Ms. Igloria, and despite Ms. Igloria's belief that District staff still had not reached agreement on how to implement the BIP, the District was proposing to educate STUDENT in a nonpublic school that exclusively serves special education students -- a position from which it has not wavered since. The District terminated the services of Ms.

Igloria, despite the fact that she believed that much work remained for her to do, on the grounds that the BIP was not working. By October 19, the principal, Mr. Stang, had pledged to "take whatever action was necessary in removing STUDENT from school." Under the circumstances, it cannot be concluded that the District's subsequent attempts to implement the BIP were made in harmony with a BIP's legislative purpose -- to maintain the student in the least restrictive environment. The evidence demonstrated that the District did not adequately implement STUDENT's BIP, and that, while the District recorded extensive data regarding misbehavior, it was less diligent in determining antecedents and recording replacement behaviors.

Based on STUDENT's experience in Mrs. Connelley's class in the fall of 1995, the District has not sustained its burden of proving that STUDENT is too disruptive to be educated in a public SDC. To make such a conclusion, one would have to find that the District sufficiently implemented his BIP so as to assure his presence in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer finds, however, that the District's attempts to implement STUDENT's BIP were inadequate as a matter of law.

C. What is the appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year?

The Hearing Officer has concluded above that the District has not satisfied its burden to show that STUDENT cannot be successfully educated, and would be too disruptive, in an SDC if provided with appropriate behavioral supports. (Footnote 16)

Therefore, a nonpublic school is not the least restrictive environment for STUDENT, and the Hearing Officer does not reach the issue of whether Spectrum or Morgan is appropriate.

Even assuming that STUDENT required a nonpublic school, the Hearing Officer would have serious concerns about the appropriateness of Spectrum and Morgan for him. The typical student at both schools is less verbal, lower functioning and more aggressive than STUDENT and presents a poor behavior role model. While STUDENT has a goal of reintegrating into a public SDC as soon as possible, it appears that the majority of students sent to Spectrum or Morgan never return to public school. Presumably these are some of the factors which led the District's Dr. Riley to advise PARENT, in October 1995, that he did not believe Spectrum would be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. While it is possible that a nonpublic school may be necessary for STUDENT at some point in the future, the District has not yet taken sufficient steps to maintain him in a public SDC, and therefore, as Mr.

Loftis, the Regional Center case manager, testified, "[W]e're not there yet."

The Hearing Officer now examines the appropriateness of Petitioner's placement proposal. Petitioner presented little detail regarding Mrs. DeLeon's special day class at Snow Elementary School, other than the fact that it is a public SDC for learning disabled students. The District, for its part, noted that the class will be attended by second and third grade students this year, and that STUDENT is now of fifth grade age. Neither party suggested that STUDENT attend any other SDC besides Mrs. DeLeon's class. Because the evidence showed that a number of classroom variables are necessary to ensure a successful SDC placement for STUDENT, and because the evidence regarding Mrs. DeLeon's class was insufficient to demonstrate whether or not it is an appropriate placement, Petitioner's request that the Hearing Officer identify Mrs. DeLeon's class as the appropriate SDC placement is denied. The matter is referred back to the IEP team to identify the appropriate special day class for STUDENT. For the reasons described above regarding the dynamic between Mrs. Connelley and STUDENT, the IEP team shall not select Mrs. Connelley's class. (Footnote 17)

Petitioner also proposed that STUDENT be assisted by a full-time, one-to-one aide and that he be served by a BIP. These services are in fact already contained in STUDENT's IEP, and the Hearing Officer finds that they remain appropriate. Additionally, Petitioner proposed that (1) STUDENT be gradually integrated into an SDC, increasing the amount of time he spends in class as appropriate, and (2) that in the initial stages of the gradual integration process, STUDENT could receive home instruction from a District teacher and his aide could work with him at home and in the community on behavior issues. With respect to these two proposals, the Hearing Officer notes that the parties agree that it would be inappropriate for STUDENT to begin full-time attendance in a new special day class immediately. The Hearing Officer finds that these two proposals are appropriate methods of transitioning STUDENT back into a special day class.

Finally, Petitioner proposes that the District retain the services of Dr. Marone to oversee implementation of STUDENT's BIP and to hire and train STUDENT's aide. The Hearing Officer has some concerns about Dr. Marone's plan, including the effect on STUDENT of a 60-day waiting period in hiring and training an aide. Also, while Dr. Marone made a number of appropriate recommendations, including providing frequent positive feedback for appropriate behavior and ignoring certain misbehavior, the Hearing Officer has concerns about the effect of other aspects of Dr. Marone's plan on other students. More specifically, the Hearing Officer questions the appropriateness of encouraging the teacher to tolerate "maximum" disruption, or having STUDENT's classmates walk around the school when he is disruptive in class.(footnote 18) In any event, under the circumstances the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not demonstrated that the District must hire Dr. Marone in order to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. The District is entitled to select the qualified personnel who will serve as STUDENT's aide and oversee implementation of his BIP. The District may, but is not required to, select Dr. Marone and/or an aide of his choosing.

D. Occupational therapy

As noted above, related services are those required to assist a disabled student to benefit from his or her special education program. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(17). Related services include occupational therapy (O.T.). 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(17); Education Code §56363(b)(6). Occupational therapy includes:

(i) Improving, developing or restoring functions impaired or lost through illness, injury or deprivation;

(ii) Improving ability to perform tasks for independent functioning when functions are impaired or lost; and (iii) Preventing, through early intervention, initial or further impairment or loss of function.

34 C.F.R. 300.16(b)(5).

Typically, the District's choice of methodology to be used in educating a disabled student is entitled to deference, so long as the methodology chosen is reasonably designed to confer educational benefit on the child. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 207-208 (1982). (footnote 19) The evidence showed that STUDENT has received direct and consultative O.T. designed to improve his fine motor skill for several years. It appears he has gained some benefit from the service. The parties agree that STUDENT should continue to receive consultative O.T. to assist the classroom teacher and STUDENT's one-to-one aide in helping him practice daily, functional fine motor tasks in the classroom.

On the other hand, Ms. Bledsoe, STUDENT's O.T. provider and the only occupational therapist to testify in the case, has concluded that direct service no longer has any effect on STUDENT's muscle tone, strength, spasticity, hand functioning, or tactile processing, which have stabilized. She testified persuasively that STUDENT's O.T. needs can be met by way of consultation. Petitioner presented no contrary evidence. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposal to provide O.T. on a purely consultative basis is reasonably designed to meet STUDENT's needs in this area.

ORDER

Within fifteen (15) days of receipt of this Decision, the District shall conduct an IEP meeting for the purpose of developing STUDENT's program for the 1996-97 school year in accordance with the following:

(1) The appropriate placement for STUDENT is in a special day class other than Mrs. Connelley's class.

(2) STUDENT shall be supported in class by a full-time, one-to-one aide, and shall be served by a Behavior Intervention Plan pursuant to the Hughes Bill.

(3) The District shall select qualified personnel to serve as STUDENT's aide and to oversee implementation of his BIP.

(4) STUDENT shall be gradually integrated into his special day class, increasing the amount of time that he spends in class as appropriate, as determined by the IEP team.

(5) During the initial stages of the gradual integration process, the IEP team shall provide STUDENT with such services as home instruction by a District teacher and/or having STUDENT's assigned one-to-one aide work with him at home and in the community on behavior issues.

(6) The District shall provide occupational therapy to STUDENT on a consultative basis.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

Issue #1: What is the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year?

Petitioner STUDENT substantially prevailed on this issue to the extent that it was determined that he should attend a special day class.

Issue #2: Should occupational therapy be provided to STUDENT on a direct and consultative basis, or only on a consultative basis?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated: September 27, 1996 ______________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes

1. On November 29, 1995, the Hearing Office received requests from both parties for a due process hearing. The parents' case was assigned case number SN 1169-95, and the District's case was assigned case number SN 1170-95. The cases were set for hearing on January 2-3, 1996. On December 21, 1995, the parties advised the Hearing Office that they had reached an Interim Mediation Agreement, and mutually requested to take the matter off calendar. On May 24, 1996 the Hearing Office received the District's request to place the matters back on the hearing calendar. 2. The cases were consolidated by agreement of the parties. Although STUDENT is the Petitioner in SN 1169-95 and the District is the Petitioner in SN 1170-95, for ease of reference STUDENT will be referred to as Petitioner throughout this Decision. 3. Petitioner's exhibits are designated by the letter "P" followed by the letters A through W. Respondent's exhibits are designated by the letter "R" followed by the numbers 1 through 76. The following exhibits were withdrawn by mutual agreement of the parties: Petitioner's D1 through D7, and Respondent's 29, 30, 31, 39, 40, 41, 44, 47 (mediation agreement only), 49 and 50.

4. CVI is defined as follows: the eye receives the correct image, but, because of brain damage, the brain has difficulty organizing the information received. 5. Special day classes serve those students, who, because of the nature and severity of their disabilities, are unable to participate in the regular school program for a majority of the school day. Education Code §56364.

6. The parties agree that this was not a formal Behavior Intervention Plan, or BIP, as contemplated by California's so-called Hughes Bill, Education Code §56520-56524 and its implementing regulations, Title 5 California Code of Regulations Sections 3001, 3052. 7. Spectrum Center is a nonpublic agency that consults with public schools regarding behavioral interventions. Spectrum also operates nonpublic schools for disabled children with serious behavior problems.

8. The District defines an emergency intervention as a physical restraint lasting more than one minute. 9. Mrs. Connelley testified that she did not attempt to limit STUDENT to fifteen minutes of activity at a time, as called for in the BIP, and did not know if Mr. Garrett did this. Mr. Garrett did not testify. 10. Case No. H-187701-2.

11. No parent ever complained about STUDENT's presence in the class. One parent told Mrs. Connelley her child was having nightmares, but that child had experienced a "scary incident" a few months earlier requiring psychotherapy. 12. PARENT visited Mrs. DeLeon's class in the spring of 1995, when investigating possible placements for the 1995-96 school year, but, at that time, preferred Mrs. Connelley's class.

13. The term "supplementary aids and services" is synonymous with "modifications," and describes what is done to the regular education program to ensure a disabled student's satisfactory participation in that program. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 48. Common examples of supplementary aids and services include a one-to-one aide, curriculum adaptations, and assistive technology. 14. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18); see also Students of California School for the Blind v. Honig, 736 F.2d 538, 545 (9th Cir. 1985), vacated on other grounds, 471 U.S. 148 (1984).

15. Federal law does not require that a behavior management plan become part of the IEP. See 23 IDELR 1072 (OSEP 1995). However, federal special education law establishes only minimum requirements, and states can require more. See Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 736 F.2d 773, 784-85, aff's sub nom. Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985). 16. Further, the evidence did not demonstrate that STUDENT presently requires a fenced setting. Certainly a disabled student's right to a FAPE includes the right to physical safety in the school setting. Students of California School for the Blind v. Honig, 736 F.2d 538, 545-546 (9th Cir. 1984). However, the evidence did not show that attendance in an SDC with appropriate behavioral supports should place STUDENT in physical danger. While he at times ran from the classroom, the evidence showed that he had no intention of actually escaping, and never did so. Typically he would announce his intention to run and then wait for adult attention. He ran slowly and was easily caught, and clearly delighted in the chase itself, often laughing as he ran. There was no evidence that he was ever injured. The evidence suggested that an effectively-implemented BIP could reduce or eliminate STUDENT's desire to leave the classroom. 17. The IEP team may, of course, select Mrs. DeLeon's class, if appropriate. 18. This Decision does not suggest that STUDENT should be permitted to unreasonably disrupt his special day class. Ideally, STUDENT's BIP should be implemented so as to prevent the occurrence of target misbehaviors, to control them when they do occur, and to replace them with more appropriate behaviors. Nothing in this Decision suggests that the District cannot use its normal disciplinary procedures, including temporary removal from class, when appropriate. Should certain very serious behavioral concerns arise, of course, the District could have other potential options, including suspension and/or seeking injunctive relief from a court. Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305, 325-326, 328 (1984).

19. Lachman v. Illinois State Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290, 296 (7th Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 925 (1988); Bonnie Ann F. v. Calallen Independent School District, 835 F.Supp. 340, 347 (S.D.Tex. 1993), aff'd, 22 IDELR 615 (5th Cir. 1995), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ___ (1995); Peterson v. Hastings Public Schools, 31 F.3d 705, 707-708 (8th Cir. 1994); Brougham v. Town of Yarmouth, 823 F.Supp. 9, 15-16 (D. Me. 1993); Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District, 797 F.Supp. 753, 760-761 (D. Ariz. 1992), aff'd, 22 F.3d 228 (9th Cir. 1994).