California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 11, 1997

Student v. Irvine Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1170-96 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain

Irvine Unified prevails: student with diagnosed ADD not eligible as learning disabled; Winston School tuition reimbursement denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Parents of a 16-year-old Irvine High School student filed for due process after the student's IEP team found him not eligible for special education in October 1996. He had diagnoses of attention deficit disorder (ADD) and dyslexia from private doctors, and his grades had become uneven. After the IEP meeting, the parents placed him at the Winston School, a nonpublic school in Del Mar. They sought reimbursement and future tuition, arguing he qualified as having a specific learning disability.

Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain applied the three-part test of Education Code section 56337. She found a severe ability-achievement discrepancy only in math calculation, based on recent Woodcock-Johnson testing. She found no discrepancy in math reasoning or written expression. However, the student did not show that a basic psychological processing disorder caused the gap. The private ADD diagnoses carried little weight because they were conclusory and the doctors' qualifications were not shown. The parents' expert, Dr. Douglas Harrington, had never met or assessed the student. District assessors Dr. Mark Bockstahler, Claudia Walter, and Maria Cross, along with his teachers, credibly described him as attentive and focused. The student also failed to show that regular education supports could not correct the discrepancy. The district had already offered a planner, progress reports, priority scheduling, and supervised study. Because he was not eligible, the Hearing Officer denied all tuition claims.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied California's three-part specific learning disability test. A test-score discrepancy alone was not enough. A medical ADD diagnosis did not establish a processing disorder. Firsthand observations by assessors and teachers outweighed a records-only expert. Tuition reimbursement failed once the student was found not eligible.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Does STUDENT qualify for special education services under the IDEA because he suffers from a specific learning disability?

    A severe discrepancy existed only in math calculation, but it was not caused by a basic psychological processing disorder, and regular education could correct it, so the student was not eligible as having a specific learning disability.

  2. Issue 2. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for tuition incurred at Winston School and provide STUDENT future tuition?

    Because the student was not eligible for special education, he was not entitled to past reimbursement or future funding for Winston School tuition.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Education Code section 56337; Education Code section 56339(a); 5 C.C.R. section 3030(j)(4); 34 C.F.R. section 300.7; U.S. Department of Education Policy Letter of September 16, 1991 (ADD)

People named in the decision

  • Alan Kaufman, District director of special education, Irvine Unified School District
  • Lane Cole, paralegal/advocate for Student; witness, Student's counsel's office
  • Dr. Douglas Harrington, expert witness for Student (psychologist), Private
  • Dr. Mark Bockstahler, school psychologist; assessor, Irvine Unified School District
  • Claudia Walter, resource specialist program teacher; academic assessor, Irvine Unified School District
  • Maria Cross, speech and language pathologist; assessor, Irvine Unified School District
  • Stan Steele, music teacher, Irvine High School
  • Robert Cunard, English teacher, Irvine High School
  • Michael Teague, assistant principal, Irvine High School
  • Fran Antenore, assistant principal, Irvine High School
  • Dr. Michael Aufdemberg, private pediatrician (ADD diagnosis), Private
  • Dr. Cristiana Motet-Grigoras, private psychiatrist (ADD diagnosis), Private
  • Dr. Donald Smith, private psychologist/counselor, Private
  • Dr. Glen Mowbray, private counselor, Private
  • Linda Gothard, private academic tutor, Private
  • Winston School, nonpublic school (unilateral placement), Del Mar, California

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on December 3, 4, and 16, 1996, before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Officer, McGeorge School of Law, in Irvine, California.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Herbert H.

Williams and paralegal Lane Cole. Present on behalf of Petitioner were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER.

Respondents Irvine Unified School District (District) was represented by attorneys Bridget Flanagan and Ivette Pena of Breon, O'Donnell, Miller, Brown and Dannis. Present on behalf of the District was Alan Kaufman, District director of special education.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of the Petitioner: FATHER, MOTHER , Lane Cole, and Dr. Douglas Harrington, psychologist.

On behalf of the District, the following witnesses testified:

STUDENT'S former music teacher, Stan Steele; STUDENT'S former English teacher, Robert Cunard; Michael Teague, Irvine High School assistant principal; Dr. Mark Bockstahler, school psychologist; Claudia Walter, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher; and Maria Cross, speech and language pathologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received on December 3, 4, and 16, 1996. The matter was submitted for decision and the record was closed on January 10, 1997.

ISSUES

1. Does STUDENT qualify for special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA)

because he suffers from a specific learning disability?

2. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for tuition incurred at Winston School and provide STUDENT future tuition?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Sixteen-year-old STUDENT attended District schools until 1996, when he enrolled in eleventh-grade classes at the Winston School in Del Mar, California. STUDENT has never qualified for special education services.

STUDENT began kindergarten at Santiago Hills Elementary and repeated the first grade because he began experiencing frustration resulting from having trouble learning to read. (Petitioner's Exhibit "Pet. Ex." H.)

While STUDENT was in the first or second grade, his pediatrician, Dr. Michael Aufdemberg, determined that STUDENT suffered from a "moderate level" of attention deficit disorder (ADD) and dyslexia. Dr. Aufdemberg urged medication to control the symptoms of ADD, but, because his parents did not feel that medication was necessary, STUDENT did not begin taking medication until he entered the seventh grade. (Pet. Ex. H.)

When STUDENT was in the third grade, his parents transferred him to El Camino Real Elementary because they were dissatisfied with Santiago Hills' response to STUDENT'S academic and emotional difficulties. STUDENT completed elementary school at El Camino Real and with the help of Linda Gothard, a private academic tutor, earned "A's," "B's," and "C's." Ms. Gothard tutored STUDENT from June 1989 until June 1992, but has not tutored or seen STUDENT since 1992. (Pet. Ex. O.) While STUDENT was still in elementary school, he also began receiving psychological counselling for stress from Dr. Donald Smith.

In July 1992, a couple of months before STUDENT entered the seventh grade at Sierra Vista Middle School, two of STUDENT'S cousins moved in with the family because their parents had been killed in separate automobile accidents. The cousins' introduction into the household caused a strain on the FAMILY family.

(Respondent's Exhibit 12, "Resp. Ex." 12.)

Since the seventh grade, STUDENT has been taking Cylert, a medication designed to control the symptoms of ADD. (Resp. Ex. 12.) For the most part, STUDENT was successful academically at Sierra Vista. For example, he earned all "A's" and "B's" during the first semester of the eighth grade. But when Sierra Vista shortened its daily class periods and increased their number, STUDENT'S grades began to decline.

STUDENT entered Irvine High School (IHS) in September 1994.

STUDENT'S grades did not improve, so his father requested that the school assess him. The assessment did not occur because the school psychologist, who is no longer with the District, did not facilitate the assessment process. (Pet. Ex. H.)

STUDENT passed all of his ninth-grade classes, with grades ranging from a "D" in health to "A's" in water polo and string orchestra. (Resp. Ex. 7.) In December 1994, STUDENT began seeing Dr. Cristiana Motet-Grigoras, a psychiatrist. STUDENT saw Dr. Motet-Grigoras for approximately fourteen months, and during that time, she confirmed the previous diagnosis of ADD and dyslexia. (Pet. Ex. F and Q.)

STUDENT'S teachers did not report that attentional problems affected his educational performance in January 1995 or September 1996. His global science, music, and English teachers remarked that he was doing well, but a couple of other teachers commented that he failed to submit assignments. (Resp. Ex. 1 and 14.)

In September 1995, when STUDENT was beginning his tenth-grade year, his former girlfriend accused him of sexual harassment. The District disciplined STUDENT and warned him that he might be expelled. That same month, FATHER, his advocate, Lane Cole, and a different school psychologist completed an assessment plan. (Resp. Ex. 9.)

A few weeks after the accusation, STUDENT received a dismal progress report with unsatisfactory grades. In October 1995, shortly after STUDENT received the progress report, his parents learned that he had secretly purchased a car with money that he earned from a summer job and an additional four thousand dollars that he had stolen from his parents. After his mother confronted STUDENT about buying and driving the car, he ran away to Salinas, California. STUDENT remained in Salinas for about four days. The police apprehended STUDENT, impounded the car, and sent him home on a bus. (Resp. Ex. 12.)

STUDENT'S grades were erratic during the 1995-96 school year. For example, STUDENT earned an "F" in global science, a "B" in European civilizations and "A's" in keyboarding and string orchestra. (Resp. Ex. 7.)

Dr. Mark Bockstahler his psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT on October 8, 1996, and a couple of days later, STUDENT'S IEP team convened to discuss the assessment and STUDENT'S eligibility for special education services. The team determined that STUDENT did not meet special education eligibility criteria and denied his request for services. FATHER disagreed with the team's conclusion, removed STUDENT from IHS, and enrolled him at the Winston School, a nonpublic school, shortly after the IEP meeting.

STUDENT currently attends the Winston School five days a week. He lives with his older brother in Del Mar during the week and returns to his parents' Irvine home on the weekends. The PARENTS now seek prospective payment of and retroactive reimbursement for tuition and expenses related to STUDENT'S attendance at the Winston School.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

Petitioner's witnesses

FATHER

FATHER recalled that when STUDENT was in either the first or second grade, he observed that STUDENT was not reading well, was transposing numbers, could not manage time, and had difficulty completing tasks. Dr. Aufdemberg, the family pediatrician, informed FATHER that STUDENT suffered from a "moderate level" of ADD and dyslexia, and suggested medication.(FOOTNOTE 1) The PARENTS decided to forego medication and instead approached the District for assistance. According to FATHER, it offered none.

For this reason, when STUDENT was in the third grade, STUDENT'S parents transferred him to El Camino Real Elementary School, which provided him with assistance for his academic difficulties. The PARENTS also hired Linda Gothard, a private tutor, who assisted STUDENT several times a week for about five years and noticed that STUDENT frequently failed to complete the correct assignments on the correct day. Ms. Gothard diagnosed this tendency as a "far point copying problem."

Since the seventh grade, STUDENT has been taking Cylert, which, according to FATHER, enables STUDENT to focus. Without Cylert, STUDENT would be distracted by any kind of noise or visual stimulus, but with Cylert, STUDENT can attend to tasks.

In September 1994, when STUDENT enrolled in the ninth grade at IHS, his grades declined markedly. FATHER requested an assessment of STUDENT, but recalled that the school psychologist gave him a blank assessment form and asked "What do you want me to do?"

FATHER did not complete the form because he felt that he did not understand his rights. STUDENT was not assessed and remained in the regular education program.

In FATHER' opinion, STUDENT excels in playing the viola, especially when he practices. FATHER described STUDENT as a "good kid who has not gotten into trouble," but he lacks academic excellence. To remedy this problem, STUDENT'S parents requested monitored study halls for him.

In January 1995, STUDENT began seeing Cristiana Motet-Grigoras because he was experiencing stress. The doctor treated STUDENT for about fourteen months, discontinuing treatment when the PARENTS family could no longer afford the visits. FATHER noted that in 1995, Dr. Motet-Grigoras confirmed the previous diagnosis of ADD and dyslexia. (Pet. Ex. F.)

FATHER reported that STUDENT'S actions in the fall of 1995 were "greatly out of character for STUDENT" as he had never been a discipline problem before. FATHER was surprised that STUDENT secretly purchased the car with both stolen and earned money and drove the car without permission, a license, or insurance. When FATHER asked STUDENT why he stole the money and bought the car, he replied, "I don't know."

The PARENTS again requested an assessment in May 1996. (Pet.

Ex. H.) The District completed the assessment in October 1996, and STUDENT'S IEP team met to discuss whether STUDENT qualified for special education. FATHER stated that the IEP team informed him that STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criteria for special education. FATHER disagreed with the IEP team's conclusion both at the meeting and on the IEP. Shortly after the IEP meeting, FATHER enrolled STUDENT at the Winston School.

After discontinuing treatment with Dr. Motet-Grigoras in January 1996, STUDENT saw another counsellor, Dr. Glen Mowbray, from February until May 1996. (Pet. Ex. P.) Treatment with Dr. Mowbray stopped because the FAMILY family could no longer afford it. At present, STUDENT is not seeing a therapist. FATHER noted that STUDENT currently suffers from a depressive disorder brought about by his failure to perform at the level expected of him and frustration at his inability to keep up with his school work.

MOTHER

The testimony of STUDENT'S mother, MOTHER , is similar to that of FATHER. However, MOTHER supplied additional detail regarding certain instances. For example, MOTHER stated that STUDENT transferred from Santiago Hills to El Camino because he was experiencing both academic and severe emotional difficulties.

MOTHER added that STUDENT did well at El Camino and received psychological counselling from Dr. Smith.

MOTHER also stated that when STUDENT'S cousins joined the family in 1992, they were very needy and their introduction into the household strained the family. MOTHER reported that both children have adjusted to their new environment. Although MOTHER does not attribute STUDENT'S academic problems to the deaths of his aunt and uncle or the needs of his cousins, MOTHER acknowledges that STUDENT'S grades began to "slide" in the seventh grade, after his cousins arrived.

As a ninth-grader at IHS, STUDENT earned "C's" and "D's" in his academic courses. MOTHER stated that STUDENT "lost" six weeks of school during that year because he did not take Cylert, the medication prescribed for ADD. In response to MOTHERS' request for assistance, IHS removed STUDENT from college-prep classes, but made no other alterations to his program. MOTHER maintains that District staff consistently refused to assist STUDENT, repeatedly stating that IHS had no program for STUDENT.

In February 1996, STUDENT began receiving counselling from Dr. Mowbray. According to MOTHER, Dr. Mowbray reported that STUDENT was suffering from a great deal of stress and he needed to develop better coping skills. One counsellor suggested that if the cousins left the PARENTS home, STUDENT'S stress might decrease.

Dr. Douglas Harrington

Dr. Harrington earned a doctorate in education and is also a licensed psychologist, educational psychologist, and marriage family and child psychologist.

Dr. Harrington has neither met nor assessed STUDENT, nor has he met with STUDENT'S teachers. Dr. Harrington based his testimony on his review of STUDENT'S records and a "brief" conversation with STUDENT'S parents. For example, Dr. Harrington testified that he reviewed Dr. Motet-Grigoras' ADD diagnosis, and Dr. Mark Bockstahler's October 1996 assessment and its accompanying protocols.

According to Dr. Harrington, STUDENT is "not achieving to his ability level in written language" and qualifies for special education because he suffers from a specific learning disability. To explain how STUDENT satisfied the specific learning disability criteria, Dr. Harrington pointed out that STUDENT demonstrated 22.5 point discrepancies between ability and achievement in two of the seven academic areas listed in Education Code section

56337.(FOOTNOTE 2)

According to Dr. Harrington, a comparison of STUDENT'S full scale IQ score of 129 on the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Revised (WAIS-R)(FOOTNOTE 3) to his scores of 98 and 89 on the broad written language and basic writing skills Woodcock-Johnson subtests indicates 31- and 40-point discrepancies between ability and achievement in the academic area of written expression.

Dr. Harrington conceded that STUDENT'S score of 127 on the written expression section of the Woodcock-Johnson fails to establish a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in this academic area. (Resp. Ex. 13.) Still, Dr. Harrington maintained that notwithstanding STUDENT'S score of 127 on written expression, his scores on the broad written language and basic writing skills subtests reveal severe discrepancies in the academic area of written expression.

Additionally, STUDENT'S scores of 101 and 105 on the mathematics calculation and basic mathematics skills subtests led Dr. Harrington to conclude that there are 22- and 24-point discrepancies between STUDENT'S ability and achievement in the academic area of mathematics calculation. Overall, Dr. Harrington counted 15 test and subtest scores that indicate a significant discrepancy between STUDENT'S ability and achievement. (Resp. Ex.

13.)(FOOTNOTE 4)

Dr. Harrington acknowledged that STUDENT'S low score in the area of mathematics calculation could have been the result of any of the following factors: attention problems, anxiety, or lack of familiarity with the mathematics calculations tested. Dr.

Harrington was not aware of any environmental or other factors that might have affected STUDENT'S performance.

In addition to a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in two academic areas, Dr. Harrington also identified an auditory processing disorder based on STUDENT'S score of 92 on the auditory processing portion of the Woodcock-Johnson. Dr.

Harrington reached this conclusion by subtracting STUDENT'S auditory processing score of 92 from the full scale IQ score of 129.

According to Dr. Harrington, on the Woodcock-Johnson, low scores on the following tests might indicate an auditory processing disorder: short-term memory, memory for sentences, memory for words, auditory processing, sound blending, sound patterns, word opposites, and sentence imitation.

Dr. Harrington also stated that he considered STUDENT'S spelling, proofing, and punctuation errors in reaching the conclusion that STUDENT suffers from an auditory processing disorder. For example, when STUDENT writes, he misspells about every twelfth word. In Dr. Harrington's opinion, STUDENT'S problems with spelling, proofing, and punctuation might be remedied in a regular education program.

Although Dr. Harrington met Dr. Smith, he has not met Dr.

Motet-Grigoras or Dr. Aufdemberg, the other doctors who actually assessed STUDENT. Dr. Harrington also testified that he did not know what information or tests provided the bases for either doctor's ADD diagnosis. Nevertheless, Dr. Harrington stated that he accepts the ADD diagnoses of Dr. Motet-Grigoras and Dr.

Aufdemberg.

When asked about symptoms of ADD, Dr. Harrington stated that if a student suffers from the disorder, he would expect that the student would be disorganized, unable to complete work in a timely manner, and prone to err carelessly. Dr. Harrington allowed that a student's lack of motivation, fatigue, distraction, or visual processing disorder could also account for these behaviors. Based on the diagnoses of ADD, Dr. Harrington also concluded that STUDENT has a disorder in the basic psychological process of attention.

Respondent's Witnesses

Dr. Mark Bockstahler (FOOTNOTE 5)

Mark Bockstahler, District psychologist, met both STUDENT and MOTHER during an August 1996 meeting to plan the coming year's class schedule. At the request of PARENTS, Dr. Bockstahler assessed STUDENT in September 1996. As a part of the assessment process, Dr. Bockstahler and STUDENT had three lunch-time meetings. During these meetings, Dr. Bockstahler and STUDENT discussed "why he was having difficulty." According to Dr. Bockstahler, their discussion topics ranged from the presence of his cousins in his home, the sexual harassment accusation, his friendships, the incident with the car, and his desire to get his driver's license.

While talking to STUDENT, Dr. Bockstahler learned that he was interested in cars, sailing, scuba diving, his part-time job, and scouting. Dr. Bockstahler described STUDENT as attentive, alert, and focused. STUDENT had no trouble keeping his appointments and always arrived on time.

At the time of the assessment, Dr. Bockstahler was aware that STUDENT had received an ADD diagnosis, but did not know whether he had taken any medication to control the symptoms of ADD on the days of the assessment. Although all tests probe for attentional deficits, Dr. Bockstahler stated that he did not administer any specific tests to confirm or challenge the ADD diagnosis. Dr. Bockstahler asserted that he has experience evaluating students with ADD.

For Dr. Bockstahler's portion of the assessment, he administered instruments including the WAIS-R and Achenbach Youth Self-Report (YSR). (Resp. Ex. 16.) According to Dr. Bockstahler, during the assessment process, STUDENT gave his best effort. Dr. Bockstahler observed that typically, students with auditory processing disorders need to have instructions repeated. STUDENT was attentive, gave prompt responses, and did not ask to have directions repeated, even on the "complex" WAIS-R.

On the WAIS-R, STUDENT'S full scale IQ score was 129 (FOOTNOTE 6), his performance IQ score was 133, and his verbal IQ score was 120. Dr. Bockstahler maintained that STUDENT'S test results were valid. In Dr. Bockstahler's opinion, the WAIS-R addresses attention, auditory processing, visual and sensory motor skills, visual processing, and expression.

The YSR is generally considered a valid measure, but Dr.

Bockstahler acknowledged that some researchers have raised issues about its reliability. Dr. Bockstahler described it as a rating scale that gives a student an opportunity to report on his weaknesses and competencies. Because the YSR is a self-report, its accuracy depends on the reporter's judgment and self-knowledge. Dr. Bockstahler noted that teens tend to report with intense emotion, so a student's feelings on a given day can taint the results of the YSR.

Dr. Bockstahler found that STUDENT'S YSR responses indicate that his strengths are his "participation in activities and his social interests." As for weaknesses, on the YSR, STUDENT revealed that he was anxious/depressed. STUDENT'S anxious/depressed characteristics included loneliness, fear of doing badly, nervousness, self-consciousness, guilt, and sadness. STUDENT'S responses also revealed somatic complaints such as tiredness, aches, and nausea.

To describe problems he had with school, STUDENT wrote,

The work load. I have no problem with learning. But I don't see the need to answer questions on paper that you've just answered out loud.

When Dr. Bockstahler questioned STUDENT about this response, STUDENT replied that he did not like doing the "mundane" tasks and "boring stuff" that teachers asked him to do. STUDENT reported that he liked learning and could do well on tests but that he "did not like the boring part of school."

In Dr. Bockstahler's opinion, STUDENT is not eligible for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability. To establish eligibility, Dr. Bockstahler emphasized that he would rely on the results of more than one test or subtest score and found support for his position in Code of California Regulations 3030 (j)(4).

To measure discrepancies between STUDENT'S ability and achievement, Dr. Bockstahler would compare his full scale IQ score of 129 (FOOTNOTE 7) from the WAIS-R to his scores on achievement tests. Dr. Bockstahler agreed that STUDENT'S mathematics calculation score of 101 appears to indicate a severe -- 28 point -- discrepancy between ability and achievement. Dr. Bockstahler found no other areas in which STUDENT'S scores indicated a discrepancy between ability and achievement.

Notwithstanding his mathematics calculation score, Dr.

Bockstahler does not find a severe discrepancy between STUDENT'S ability and achievement in this area. To reach this conclusion, Dr. Bockstahler converted STUDENT'S 1995 Comprehensive Test of Basic Skills (CTBS) mathematics computation score which placed him in the 81st percentile to a standard score of at least 112.

(FOOTNOTE 8) (Pet. Ex. N and Resp. Ex. 21.) Subtraction of STUDENT'S converted CTBS mathematics computation score from his full scale IQ score of 129 will not indicate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement. Dr. Bockstahler testified that the CTBS has been validated for a range of purposes including determining achievement in the area of mathematics calculation and special education assessments.

Dr. Bockstahler included STUDENT'S CTBS scores in his analysis because he sought as much data as possible to enable him to decide on STUDENT'S eligibility for special education. Dr. Bockstahler stated that he considers CTBS scores particularly when, like STUDENT'S, they are consistent over time. Dr. Bockstahler estimated that in both the fourth- and the ninth-grade CTBS administrations, STUDENT frequently scored within the 90th percentile. In concluding that STUDENTdid not exhibit a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of mathematics calculation, Dr. Bockstahler also considered that STUDENT passed algebra 1A and 1B the previous year, that he had not taken a mathematics class in over a year when he took the Woodcock-Johnson, and that he was not able to use a calculator on the test.

If a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement were established, Dr. Bockstahler stated that the school psychologist and the speech and language therapist would then try to determine whether a processing disorder accounts for the disparity. However, Dr. Bockstahler noted that neither he nor other researchers have been able to link a processing deficit to a low score on an achievement test.

Dr. Bockstahler offered, however, that other factors unrelated to psychological processing disorders may cause a discrepancy between ability and achievement. These factors include: lack of motivation or interest in subject area, romantic concerns, peer relations, family problems, grief issues, personality style, or preferences for non-academic pursuits. Dr. Bockstahler also stated that over time, a student's failure to complete schoolwork could cause a discrepancy between ability and achievement.

While Dr. Bockstahler acknowledged that STUDENT has received diagnoses of ADD, he does not agree that STUDENT suffers from ADD or a psychological processing disorder in the area of attention. Dr. Bockstahler testified that during the assessment, STUDENT exhibited no behavior that was consistent with an ADD diagnosis. Dr. Bockstahler also testified that a diagnosis of ADD does not necessarily mean that the student has a psychological processing disorder in the area of attention. Furthermore, STUDENT'S score of 92 on the Woodcock-Johnson auditory processing test does not indicate a psychological processing disorder.

To determine whether a student has a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes, Dr. Bockstahler would inquire whether he or she is "significantly below average in a particular sensory processing area such as attention or auditory processing." Dr. Bockstahler stated that the student's subtest scores on appropriate instruments would have to be "significantly below average." The scores would have to be corroborated with such information as behavior samples and observations from teachers.

Dr. Bockstahler defines a psychological disorder in the area of attention as the inability to sustain effort in attention to benefit from instruction. According to Dr. Bockstahler, the WAIS-R provides information about a student's ability to attend. For example, the digit span, arithmetic, comprehension, picture arrangement, picture completion, block design, object assembly, and digit symbol subtests call for short term memory and ability to concentrate and attend. STUDENT scored above average on all of the above subtests except object assembly, where he scored within the 50th percentile. From these scores, Dr. Bockstahler inferred that STUDENT'S "short term auditory memory, attention span, and ability to concentrate" are "significant strengths compared to the norming group." (Resp. Ex. 16.)

Dr. Bockstahler finds that STUDENT scored in the average range in the area of auditory processing and does not suffer from an auditory processing disorder. Dr. Bockstahler defined auditory processing as the ability to take in information auditorially and then manipulate and make sense of it. According to Dr.

Bockstahler, auditory processing is closely linked to attention, and the digit span and arithmetic subtests measure auditory processing ability.

Based on the District's assessment, Dr. Bockstahler disagrees with Dr. Motet-Grigoras' conclusion that STUDENT suffers from disorders in reading, written expression, or rote memory and Dr. Harrington's conclusion that he suffers from a disorder in the area of attention. To reach this conclusion, Dr. Bockstahler relied on STUDENT'S Woodcock-Johnson scores and his 95th percentile score on the freedom from distractibility index.

Dr. Bockstahler also takes issue with Dr. Motet-Grigoras' assertion that STUDENT requires untimed tests. Dr. Bockstahler pointed out that on the CTBS STUDENT was offered, but did not accept the opportunity to take untimed tests.

In sum, Dr. Bockstahler maintains that STUDENT is not eligible for special education. Dr. Bockstahler speculated that the personal difficulties that beset STUDENT last year -- i.e., the sexual harassment accusation, stealing, truancy, and running away -- caused his poor academic performance. Dr. Bockstahler also offered that STUDENT'S nonacademic interests -- i.e., scouting, girls, cars, and friends -- may have distracted him from school work. In Dr. Bockstahler's view, STUDENT'S weak study skills also prevent his achievement from matching his ability.

To enable STUDENT to succeed in school, Dr. Bockstahler recommends adjustments in the regular program that include preferential class scheduling, individual academic monitoring, guidance counselling in areas such as stress management, and enrollment in a homework lab to help STUDENT with academic organization.

Maria Cross

For over ten years, the District has employed Maria Cross as a speech and language pathologist. Ms. Cross estimated that since she began working at IHS, ten percent of her students have suffered from ADD.

In September or October 1996, Ms. Cross assessed STUDENT in four session of approximately one hour each. (Resp. Ex. 15.) The sessions took place in a classroom at IHS. Ms. Cross commented that STUDENT was a pleasure to assess -- he was motivated, attentive, focused, and able to follow directions. At one point during the assessment, Ms. Cross had difficulty concentrating because the room "got a little noisy." STUDENT, however, stated that the noise "did not bother him" and he continued with the assessment. In Ms. Cross' opinion, STUDENT'S responses were not impulsive and she considered the assessment results valid.

To conduct STUDENT'S assessment, Ms. Cross administered the Woodcock-Johnson test of cognitive ability, Fullerton language test for adolescents, the subtest of the Detroit test of learning aptitude, and she reviewed data from colleagues. During the assessment, Ms. Cross specifically evaluated STUDENT'S articulation, voice, fluency, and language.

The results of the Woodcock-Johnson provided Ms. Cross with an "overall look" at his auditory memory, visual processing, picture vocabulary, and analysis and synthesis. As a result of STUDENT'S performance, Ms. Cross concluded that STUDENT excelled in the area of auditory memory. In fact, "he was superior on that test." He also achieved "high average results" in the areas of memory for sentences, matching, and analysis and synthesis. STUDENT fell within the average range in the areas of picture vocabulary and visual closure. On the incomplete words subtest, STUDENT scored within the 15th percentile. This score prompted Ms. Cross to administer the supplemental tests of sound blending and sound patterns. STUDENT'S cluster score of 92 placed him within the average range in the area of auditory processing.

To determine whether a student meets language eligibility criteria for special education, Ms. Cross inquires if the student's performance is one and one-half standard deviations below the mean or within the seventh percentile for his or her chronological or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in one or more the following areas: pragmatics, morphology, semantics, or syntax. Based on STUDENT'S performance on the Woodcock-Johnson, Ms. Cross concluded that auditory memory is a strength.

Ms. Cross administered the Fullerton test for adolescents to determine whether STUDENT has a language disorder. This test considers language, usage, and vocabulary. STUDENT scored either within one standard deviation of or above the mean on all Fullerton subtests. Ms. Cross explained that the auditory synthesis and oral commands subtests evaluate auditory processing. Ms. Cross concluded that STUDENT'S receptive and expressive language skills are either easily within or above the average ranges.

The Detroit test of learning aptitude measures acquisition of vocabulary. Ms. Cross administered the word opposites and sentence imitation subtests. From STUDENT'S results, Ms. Cross determined that his grammar, usage, and vocabulary skills were within the average range.

To evaluate STUDENT'S spontaneous writing, Ms. Cross administered the Test of Written Language. Ms. Cross observed that STUDENT'S thoughts were logical and sequential. STUDENT'S writings contained a theme, and were expressed in paragraphs that often contained introductions, complex sentences, and transitions. In short, Ms. Cross found that "STUDENT is a good writer."

Ms. Cross explained that if she were testing a student with an auditory processing disorder, he or she would have difficulty following directions and would be confused and unsure about what the assessor sought. In contrast, STUDENT was focused and attentive. To Ms. Cross, STUDENT did not demonstrate any of the characteristics of a student with an auditory processing disorder. Ms. Cross asserted that the oral commands, auditory synthesis, and syllabification subtests of the Test of Written Language probe a student's auditory processing ability. STUDENT scored in the superior and average ranges on these subtests.

Ms. Cross maintained that STUDENT'S score on the Woodcock-Johnson visual matching subtest did not indicate that STUDENT suffered from a visual processing impairment or disorders in any of the other basic psychological processes, such as attention. In sum, Ms. Cross asserted that STUDENT does not qualify for special education based on a speech and language impairment.

Claudia Walter

Resource Specialist Program (RSP) teacher Claudia Walter first met STUDENT when he was in the eighth grade. STUDENT had been randomly assigned to Ms. Walter's advisement group which was designed to help a group of 25 to 30 junior high school students transition to and succeed in high school. All freshmen students are assigned to advisement groups which meet 4 times each week for 10 minutes. Ms. Walter reported that STUDENT was cooperative and usually gave moderate to complete attention during advisement period. Ms. Walter did not teach or observe STUDENT on a daily basis in academic classes.

Ms. Walter helped STUDENT plan his ninth-grade schedule and register for classes. STUDENT was on a college prep track and enrolled in English, beginning Spanish, algebra, social science, marching band, stringed orchestra, and water polo. Usually students have 6 periods, but STUDENT elected to have 7. Ms. Walter estimated that STUDENT was sometimes on campus from 7:00 a.m. until 5:00 p.m. In Ms. Walter's opinion, this was a "heavy commitment for a freshman." Ms. Walter does not recall that STUDENT'S eighth-grade teachers expressed any reservations about his ability to handle this schedule.

Ms. Walter identified Respondent's Exhibit 14 as anecdotal reports that she requested from STUDENT'S teachers after he received a ninth-grade report card. MOTHER was concerned about STUDENT'S grades and informed Ms. Walter of STUDENT'S ADD diagnoses. In response to this information and MOTHER'S concerns, Ms. Walter gave STUDENT a day planner and calendar, suggested that STUDENT receive weekly progress reports from his teachers, and offered priority registration for the spring semester. (Resp. Ex. 1.) Ms. Walter considered these suggestions appropriate because of STUDENT'S demanding schedule and, had it been appropriate, would have offered similar suggestions to other members of her regular education advisement group. According to Ms. Walter, these modifications were not created solely for special education students.

Ms Walter administered the CTBS to STUDENT and his advisement group in February 1995. Before STUDENT sat for the CTBS, Ms.

Walter informed MOTHER that more time or a quieter place to take the CTBS was available to STUDENT. STUDENT did not request any modifications on the CTBS. Ms. Walter characterized STUDENT'S performance on the CTBS as "outstanding." STUDENT'S scores ranged from the 81st percentile in reading vocabulary and mathematics computation to the 98th percentile in language mechanics. (Resp. Ex. 3.) According to Ms. Walter, in the ninth grade, STUDENT also passed all of the high school proficiency tests required for IHS graduation.

Because STUDENT earned passing grades in the last semester of the ninth grade, Ms. Walter recalled that she did not recommend that he attend summer school. Ms. Walter helped STUDENT to register for the tenth grade.

Ms. Walter was aware of some of the stresses in STUDENT'S life in the fall of 1995, specifically the sexual harassment accusation and STUDENT'S purchase of the car. Ms. Walter recalled that STUDENT said that he found it difficult to complete homework at home because "things were extremely chaotic, and it was difficult to find a quiet space to work." At about this time, MOTHER and STUDENT met with IHS assistant principal Fran Antenore to discuss STUDENT'S grades. MOTHER confirmed STUDENT'S description of his chaotic home situation.

In the first semester of the tenth grade, STUDENT had to withdraw from intermediate Spanish and geometry because he had not kept up during the first quarter. By the end of the first semester of the tenth grade, STUDENT had earned little credit. STUDENT earned more credit in the second semester of the tenth grade, and his European civilizations teacher commented to Ms. Walter that STUDENT was interested and excelled in this class. STUDENT'S ceramics teacher remarked to Ms. Walter that his work was good but that STUDENT was "not motivated" to produce. In the fall of STUDENT'S eleventh-grade year, he registered for four college prep classes: global science, string orchestra, history, and creative drama.

Ms. Walter began conducting her assessment of STUDENT on September 24, 1996. Ms. Walter's portion of the assessment included administration of the academic portions of the Woodcock-Johnson. Ms. Walter administered four testing sessions over a two-week period. At times they were alone in the resource room; at times small groups were also present. According to Ms. Walter, during the forty-five to ninety-minute assessment sessions, STUDENT'S attention was "excellent." He did not have trouble focusing, nor did he appear distracted. STUDENT did not ask Ms. Walter to repeat or clarify instructions. In fact, he sometimes anticipated questions. In short, STUDENT put forth his best effort and "was a pleasure to test."

Ms. Walter did not notice that STUDENT had any time management problems. For example, STUDENT did not miss any sessions, was never late, and did not need to be reminded of times or dates of the assessment sessions. Ms. Walter recalled that there was at least one and sometimes two to three days between sessions and sometimes a weekend intervened between sessions.

According to Ms. Walter, auditory processing is the ability to understand and act on information received auditorily. Ms. Walter explained that if a student suffers from an auditory processing disorder, he or she might not remember the correct sequence of information or become confused by directions. While assessing STUDENT, Ms. Walter did not observe any of the behaviors that she associates with an auditory processing disorder. Ms. Walter recalled that STUDENT'S answers were clear, concise, and thoughtful. STUDENT worked through the tests quickly and confidently, not exhibiting any confusion. STUDENT'S behavior did not indicate to Ms. Walter that he had problems with either auditory processing or attention.

Only the Woodcock-Johnson mathematics calculation subtest appeared to frustrate STUDENT. Ms. Walter testified that STUDENT made no errors in basic mathematics calculations until he reached question 34. Analyzing STUDENT'S mathematics calculation errors, Ms. Walter stated that STUDENT understood the concept but gave an incorrect answer on question 36, failed to invert the fraction on question 38, did not attempt question 39, and missed some of the remaining questions. While working through this subtest STUDENT said, "I wish I had a calculator" and "I haven't been in a mathematics class in over a year."

Ms. Walter stated that because STUDENT had not been enrolled in a mathematics class for a year, he may have erred because he was unfamiliar with the concepts being tested. When STUDENT took the CTBS, he was enrolled in a mathematics class and, therefore, did mathematical calculations on a daily basis.

Ms. Walter maintained that if STUDENT'S converted score of 112 on the mathematics computation section of the CTBS were considered, STUDENT would not demonstrate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of mathematics calculation. Even assuming that STUDENT'S score on the mathematics calculation section of the Woodcock-Johnson revealed a significant discrepancy, Ms. Walter could not attribute that discrepancy to an auditory or other processing disorder.

Ms. Walter also considered whether STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of written expression and concluded that he did an "outstanding" job on this test. Ms. Walter explained that the basic writing skill tests explores a student's ability to take dictation, spell, punctuate, capitalize, and edit. Ms. Walter stated that STUDENT'S score of 89 on basic writing is inconsistent with his 98th percentile score on the CTBS. To analyze these disparate scores, Ms. Walter considers the content, length, and measurement of both tests to "find a reasonable middle ground in terms of expectation." Ms. Walter stated that she would also consider speech and language test results. If two tests yielded similar results, Ms. Walter stated that she would not give a much weight to the inconsistent test.

Ms. Walter stated that STUDENT'S score of 92 on the auditory processing section of the Woodcock-Johnson does not indicate a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement, because subtraction of 92 from a mean of 100 does not result in a 22.5 point difference.

Stan Steele

In the ninth and tenth grades, STUDENT played the viola in Stan Steele's fourth-period music class. Mr. Steele recalled that STUDENT'S ability placed him fourth or fifth among the ten viola players in the string orchestra. In addition to time spent in class, members of the orchestra also participated in four to six evening rehearsals, four concerts, and a college festival. To ensure passing grades, Mr. Steele estimated that members of the orchestra would have to practice about thirty minutes each night.

Mr. Steele testified that STUDENT consistently earned "A's"

and was an interested, enthusiastic participant in the orchestra. Mr. Steele did not observe that STUDENT had difficulty focusing on or attending to his class work. According to Mr. Steele, STUDENT needed no more instruction than other students. STUDENT seemed to have good peer relationships, and Mr. Steele believed that he and STUDENT had a "good working relationship."

Robert Cunard

From February through June 1996, STUDENT was enrolled in Robert Cunard's tenth-grade English class. Mr. Cunard described his college-preparatory class as "literature based," because it emphasized the study of plays, short stories, poems, and novels. Mr. Cunard based students' grades on their performances on essays, journals, tests, and extra credit assignments.

STUDENT earned a "C-" in Mr. Cunard's class. (FOOTNOTE 9) Mr. Cunard attributes this grade to STUDENT'S "uneven performance." Although STUDENT sometimes failed to turn in assignments, his "analysis of literature was good and reading comprehension was fine." For example, Mr. Cunard remarked that STUDENT read Catcher in the Rye "twice as fast as expected" and participated enthusiastically in related class discussions. Similarly, STUDENT'S essay on the novel was "cogent and on the mark." On this essay, Mr. Cunard noted that STUDENT performed better than most of his classmates.

On other assignments, however, STUDENT'S performances did not match his classmates'. Mr. Cunard remembered that STUDENT did not read Cold Sassy Tree, a novel assigned to the class. For this reason, STUDENT earned either no credit or poor grades on assignments related to this novel. (Resp. Ex. 6.) Mr. Cunard opined that STUDENT did not read Cold Sassy Tree because unlike The Catcher in the Rye, he did not find it interesting or personally relevant.

Mr. Cunard stated that STUDENT seemed to understand his lessons and assignments, as he did not ask for help more frequently than other students. Mr. Cunard commented that STUDENT was able to handle coursework intellectually and thought that it was STUDENT'S lack of interest and motivation, rather than a learning disability that sometimes prevented him from reading and submitting assignments.

STUDENT'S failure to turn in assignments prompted Mr. Cunard to speak with him about the consequences of not completing his work. Despite this conversation, Mr. Cunard stated that he and STUDENT continued to get along and, afterwards, STUDENT completed assignments more regularly.

When asked about how the District might alter STUDENT'S education program to help him succeed, Mr. Cunard offered that STUDENT would be motivated to read more contemporary, high-interest novels. Thirty-minute homework and teacher-directed classwork assignments would, in Mr. Cunard's opinion, suit STUDENT'S learning style.

Michael Teague

The son of IHS assistant principal Michael Teague was STUDENT'S water polo teammate. For this reason, Mr. Teague often observed STUDENT at water polo practices and meets during his ninth- and tenth-grade years. Mr. Teague also observed STUDENT at performances of the stringed orchestra.

Of STUDENT'S performance in meets, Mr. Teague remarked that, like his own son, STUDENT was not a standout, but did well enough. Mr. Teague did not notice that the coach had to explain strategies in more detail or with more frequency for STUDENT. Mr. Teague noted that STUDENT was "as focused as anyone else" on the team.

DISCUSSION

1. Does STUDENT qualify for special education services under the IDEA because he suffers from a specific learning disability?

By itself, a diagnosis of ADD is insufficient to qualify a student for special education services. (34 Code of Federal Regulations [C.F.R] section 300.7; United States Department of Education Policy Letter of September 16, 1991, 18 IDLER 118;

Education Code section 56339 (a)). Education Code section 56339 (a) states:

A pupil whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria specified in subdivision (f) or (i) of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations or Section 56337 and subdivision (j) of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations for the federal Individuals with Disabilities Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 and following) categories of "other health impairments,"

"serious emotional disturbance," or "specific learning disabilities," is entitled to special education and related services.

According to this section, to qualify for special education and related services, a student affected by a suspected or diagnosed ADD must establish that he suffers from other health impairments, a serious emotional disturbance, or specific learning disabilities. Because Petitioner limited his argument, the Hearing Officer will determine whether STUDENT qualifies for special education because he suffers from specific learning disabilities.

California Education Code section 56337 (FOOTNOTE 10) states that to qualify for special education services on the basis of specific learning disability, a student must meet the following three requirements:

(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following areas: (1) Oral expression; (2) Listening comprehension; (3)

Written expression; (4) Basic reading skills;

(5) Reading comprehension; (6) Mathematics calculation; (7) Mathematics reasoning.

(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.

(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

An IEP team decides whether a severe discrepancy exists between a student's ability and achievement.

The decision as to whether a severe discrepancy exists shall be made by the individualized education program team, including assessment personnel in accordance with Section 56341 (d), which takes into account all relevant material which is available on the student. No single score or product of scores, test or procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for the decisions of the individualized education program team as to the pupil's eligibility for special education.(5 C.C.R. section 3030(j)(4).) The IEP team may establish the existence of a severe discrepancy through a formula using standardized tests (5 C.C.R. section 3030(j)(4)(A)), by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid (5 C.C.R. section 3030(j)(4)(B)), or by the team's own determination (5 C.C.R. section 3030(j)(4)(C)).

Neither party argued that the standardized tests used to assess STUDENT would not be a valid way to assess STUDENT'S ability or achievement. Therefore, for purposes of establishing a severe discrepancy pursuant to 5 C.C.R. section 3030(j)(4)(A), STUDENT'S standardized achievement test scores may be compared with his ability scores as measured by the WAIS-R. Simply stated, a severe discrepancy exists when the difference between ability and achievement scores results in a 1.5 standard deviation or a 22.5 discrepancy and such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations, and work samples, as appropriate.

(5 C.C.R. section 3030(j)(4)(A).)

STUDENT obtained the following scores of intellectual ability on Dr. Bockstahler's 1996 administration of the WAIS-R: verbal IQ 120, performance IQ 133, full scale IQ 129. (Resp. Ex. 16.)

A severe discrepancy is obtained by subtracting STUDENT'S achievement scores in the area of mathematics calculation from STUDENT'S full scale IQ score. For example, subtraction of STUDENT'S standard score of 101 on the mathematics calculation section of the Woodcock-Johnson from his full scale IQ score of 129 results in a discrepancy of 28. This discrepancy is greater than 22.5 points and, therefore, may be sufficient to establish a severe discrepancy. (Resp. Ex. 13.)

Because the Hearing Officer cannot rely on one set of test scores alone to determine eligibility for special education, other "relevant material" is also considered. The District did not argue that the results of the Woodcock-Johnson were invalid. Instead, it presented evidence that STUDENT scored at the 80th percentile in mathematics computation on the February 1995 administration of the CTBS. (Resp. Ex. 3.) Dr. Bockstahler testified persuasively that STUDENT'S percentile score converted to a scaled score of 112, which, when subtracted from his full scale IQ of 129 score, does not reveal a severe discrepancy.

Ms. Walter stated that perhaps STUDENT'S score on the Woodcock-Johnson reflects that he was not familiar with the concepts tested because had not been enrolled in a mathematics class for over a year when he took the test. This information, and evidence that STUDENT passed both semesters of algebra, apparently convinced the District that STUDENT does not suffer from a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of mathematics calculation.

The Hearing Officer finds that the more recent Woodcock-Johnson testing is more likely to provide an accurate indicator of STUDENT'S abilities than the CTBS that was administered over a year ago. Therefore, based on STUDENT'S most recent testing, the Hearing Officer finds that he exhibits a present discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of mathematics calculation. However, the Hearing Officer may not base a finding of eligibility for special education on a "single score or product of scores, test or procedure." For this reason, the Hearing Officer will later determine whether the discrepancy is caused by a psychological processing disorder.

Petitioner also maintains that STUDENT exhibits severe discrepancies between ability and achievement in the academic areas of mathematics reasoning and written expression. STUDENT'S test scores do not support this argument. On the mathematics reasoning subtest, STUDENT scored 110. Subtraction of 110 from his IQ score of 129 does not result in a 22.5 point discrepancy. Similarly, subtraction of STUDENT'S written expression subtest score of 127 from his IQ score of 129 does not reveal a severe discrepancy in this academic area.

Disregarding STUDENT'S written expression subtest score, Petitioner contends that his ability in this academic area should be measured by his scores on individual Woodcock-Johnson subtests. STUDENT'S scores are as follows: spelling, 90; proofing, 99;

punctuation & capitalization, 96; dictation, 82; and broad written language 98. Petitioner's argument lacks the support of both his own witness and legal authority.

Even while testifying that STUDENT'S ability and achievement in the academic ares of written expression are severely discrepant, Dr. Harrington conceded that there is only a two-point difference between STUDENT'S IQ score of 129 and his written expression test score of 127. Furthermore, when explaining which subtests fit within the academic area of written expression, Dr. Harrington did not list spelling, proofing, punctuation and capitalization, and dictation as components of that academic area. In fact, during cross examination, Dr. Harrington admitted that he was "not certain what the definition in the law is of written expression." Finally, Petitioner cites no legal authority in support of the argument that severely discrepant scores on the spelling, proofing, punctuation and capitalization, dictation, and broad written language subtests indicate a severe discrepancy in the academic area of written expression. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not exhibit severe discrepancies in the academic areas of either mathematics reasoning or written expression. (FOOTNOTE 11)

Having found a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the area of mathematics calculation, the Hearing Officer must now determine whether the discrepancy is caused by a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and not the result of result of an economic, cultural, or environmental disadvantage.

The record reflects that both Dr. Motet-Grigoras and Dr.

Aufdemberg diagnosed STUDENT with ADD, but neither diagnosis states that he suffers from a disorder in the psychological process of attention. (Pet. Ex. F, Q, and R.) However, relying upon the two ADD diagnoses, Dr. Harrington testified that STUDENT has an auditory processing disorder. Petitioner's argument on this issue is unpersuasive.

First, Petitioner presented no evidence which would enable the Hearing Officer to conclude that either Dr. Motet-Grigoras or Dr. Aufdemberg is qualified to diagnose ADD. For example, neither doctor testified as to her or his professional qualifications and Petitioner did not introduce either doctor's curriculum vitae or other indicators of his or her professional competence into evidence. Without documentation of actual qualifications, the Hearing Officer can give but little weight to purported expert opinions.

Second, standing alone, diagnoses of ADD are insufficient to establish conclusively that a student suffers from the disorder. Dr. Motet-Grigoras' report of November 20, 1996 states,

[STUDENT] was evaluated with thorough questionnaires and rating forms, histories of symptoms collected from the parents and patient, and a medical status evaluation.

[STUDENT] met DSM IV Criteria for Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder by meeting all of the Inattention and Impulsivity Criteria.

This conclusory report has little probative value because, unlike the reports prepared by the District, it fails to list precisely which instruments Dr. Motet-Grigoras used, whether those instruments are valid measures of ADD, what scores STUDENT achieved, and the rationale for the doctor's finding. Lacking this information, the Hearing Officer is left with a largely unsupported conclusion.

Third, neither Dr. Motet-Grigoras' report nor Dr. Aufdemberg's letter rules out the possibility that STUDENT'S discrepancy between ability and achievement in mathematics calculation was caused by other factors such as a stressful environment. While Dr. Aufdemberg's letter does not even mention other factors, Dr. Motet-Grigoras' report acknowledges that "the family was under severe stress from a variety of factors." (Pet. Ex. Q.)

Fourth, Dr. Harrington's assertion that STUDENT suffers from ADD is unpersuasive. As previously noted, Dr. Harrington has neither met or assessed STUDENT. Dr. Harrington has not consulted with the doctors who diagnosed STUDENT and does not know what instruments or other information they relied on for their diagnoses. For all the reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not established that STUDENT suffers from ADD.

However, even if STUDENT suffers from ADD, it does not necessarily follow that a processing disorder in the area of attention caused the severe discrepancy between ability and achievement on the WAIS-R and the Woodcock-Johnson. The District presented both testimony and documentary evidence that contradicts the Petitioner's argument that he has a processing disorder in the area of attention. For example, Dr. Bockstahler, Ms. Walter, and Ms. Cross each credibly testified that STUDENT was attentive and focused during the 1995 CTBS testing and the 1996 assessment sessions, even those that lasted over an hour. In fact, Ms. Cross testified that, at times, STUDENT'S concentration seemed better than her own.

Additionally, none of STUDENT'S ninth- or tenth-grade teachers reported that STUDENT gave less than moderate attention during class. (Resp. Ex. 1 and 14.) Mr. Cunard, STUDENT'S tenth-grade English teacher, testified that when motivated, STUDENT was an engaged and enthusiastic class participant who was able to perform better than his classmates. (Resp. Ex. 4.) STUDENT'S string orchestra instructor, Mr. Steele, also commented that STUDENT had no difficulty focusing during class and did not require additional or repeated instructions.

Finally, Dr. Harrington's assertion that STUDENT suffers from a processing disorder in the area of attention is unpersuasive for the reasons discussed previously. Therefore, even with Dr.

Harrington's testimony, the diagnoses are also insufficient to support a finding that STUDENT suffers from a processing disorder in the area of attention.

Dr. Harrington also stated that STUDENT suffers from a psychological processing disorder in the area of auditory processing. Dr. Harrington so concluded because STUDENT scored 92 on the auditory processing subtest of the Woodcock-Johnson. This score, when subtracted from STUDENT'S full scale IQ score of 129, results in a difference of 37 points. (Resp. Ex. 13.)

Ms. Cross's credible testimony is directly at odds with Dr.

Harrington's conclusion. In the Speech and Language evaluation, Ms. Cross writes,

STUDENT'S performance on the Sound Blending test fell into the average range while performance on Sound Pattern fell into the average range. STUDENT'S overall Auditory Processing score fell in the average range at the 30th percentile.

(Resp. Ex. 15.) Additionally, Ms. Cross, who actually observed STUDENT as she administered portions of the Woodcock-Johnson, stated that he did not exhibit any of the characteristics of a student with an auditory processing disorder. Instead, STUDENT was able to follow directions and did not demonstrate confusion or uncertainty. The testimony of Mr. Steele and Mr. Cunard, STUDENT'S classroom teachers, confirms Ms. Cross's observations. Both teachers reported that STUDENT was generally an attentive and engaged student who did not require extra instruction.

Dr. Bockstahler emphasized that a conclusion that a student suffers from a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes cannot be based on one test but must be corroborated by such information as behavior samples and teacher observations.

The Hearing Officer notes that no relevant legal authority contains a formula for determining whether a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes exists. To make a finding, the evidence must be weighed. On this issue, the District's evidence is entitled to more weight because it is based on valid testing and corroborating evidence such as firsthand observations. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not suffer from a disorder in one of the basic psychological processes and is not eligible for special education and related services.

Even if Petitioner had met the burden of establishing that STUDENT has a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement that was caused by a psychological processing disorder, Petitioner has failed to establish that the discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

In the first place, the record does not establish that STUDENT requires modifications to the regular instructional program to receive educational benefit. STUDENT'S transcripts reveal that with the exception of a failing grade in Global Science, he was achieving passing semester grades in regular education classes at IHS. As of June 1996, STUDENT'S overall grade point average was 2.30. (Resp. Ex. 7.)

Moreover, not one of STUDENT'S teachers testified that STUDENT required special education services to benefit from his academic program. In fact, Mr. Cunard stated that when interested in the topic, STUDENT could produce superior work in his college-preparatory literature class. STUDENT response to the YSR question regarding problems in school suggests that STUDENT'S lack of motivation, not lack of ability, prevents him from academic success. STUDENT remarked,

I have no problem with learning. But I don't see the need to answer questions on paper that you've just answered out loud.

(Resp. Ex. 17.) STUDENT'S consistent "A" grades in string orchestra and "B" grade in European civilizations support the conclusion that STUDENT'S interest in the class determines whether he will succeed.

Furthermore, not one of STUDENT teachers reported that attentional problems hindered his academic achievement. Indeed, each of STUDENT'S teacher reports from January 1995 and September 1996 indicate that he gave complete to moderate attention in class and demonstrated appropriate behavior. (Resp. Ex. 1 and 14.)

In any event, the District has offered many of the educational modifications advanced by Petitioner's documentary evidence. For instance, Dr. Motet-Grigoras suggested "untimed testing, conditions of low distractibility, special computer programs that aid the educationally disabled, and a supervised homework setting." (Pet. Ex. Q.) However, Ms. Walter testified that STUDENT declined the District's offer of untimed CTBS testing and performed exceptionally well under timed-test conditions. Neither Ms. Cross nor any of STUDENT'S teachers stated that STUDENT required conditions of low distractibility. The District offered STUDENT, as part of its regular education program, a supervised educational setting and priority scheduling. (Resp. Ex. 1.) The record contains no evidence that the suggested regular education modifications will not correct STUDENT'S discrepancy between ability and achievement.

2. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for tuition incurred at Winston School and provide STUDENT future tuition?

Having found that STUDENT does not qualify for special education and related services, he is not entitled to any remedies. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not order the District to reimburse STUDENT for tuition or expenses related to his enrollment at the Winston School.

ORDER

All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondents prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(i).

Dated: February 11, 1997 Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. According to FATHER, Dr. Donald Smith, a psychologist, later echoed Dr. Aufdemberg's diagnoses of ADD and dyslexia. (Pet. Ex. R.)

2. The seven academic areas are (1) Oral expression, (2) Listening comprehension, (3) Written expression, (4) Basic reading skills, (5) Reading comprehension, (6) Mathematics calculation, and (7) Mathematics reasoning.

3. Dr. Bockstahler used the WAIS-R rather than the WISC-3 because STUDENT is over seventeen years of age.

4. Dr. Harrington noted that Cylert, if taken on the day of the test, may have improved STUDENT's scores.

5. Dr. Bockstahler was first called by Petitioner.

6. Dr. Bockstahler placed STUDENT's full scale IQ score in the upper end of the superior range, his verbal IQ score in the superior range, and his performance IQ score in the very superior range. 7. On the WAIS-R, STUDENTS verbal IQ score was 120, performance IQ score was 133, and full scale IQ was 129. Dr. Bockstahler pointed out that the 13-point difference between STUDENT'S verbal and performance IQ scores was unusual, but according to the WAIS-R protocol, a disparity of fewer than 15 points is not significant.

8. The CTBS measures a student's achievement against that of his or her peers. Dr. Bockstahler uses CTBS scores to screen students for possible special education eligibility. According to Dr. Bockstahler, STUDENT's scores do not suggest that he has a learning problem that a regular education program could not address.

9. During the hearing, Mr. Cunard realized that he erred in calculating the classes' grades. Had he properly calculated, STUDENT would have earned a "D."

10. See also 34 C.F.R. section 300.8(b)(10).

11. Dr. Motet-Grigoras stated that a "history of prior testing" indicated a "disorder of written expression." (Pet. Ex. Q.) Because Dr. Motet-Grigoras' statement lacks support within the record, it is entitled to little weight.