California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 27, 1997

Student v. Ventura Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1172-96 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain

Ventura Unified must add a neurological assessment to its plan; requests for chosen UCLA specialists and other testing denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

An 18-year-old student filed for a hearing against Ventura Unified School District. He was eligible for resource specialist services based on a specific learning disability. His triennial review had stalled because the parties could not agree on testing. The District's January 1996 plan covered academics, social-emotional status, psycho-motor and intellectual development, and occupational therapy. The mother's consent was limited to her own conditions. She wanted named UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute specialists to do neurological, neuro-ophthalmological, epilepsy-related and neuropsychological evaluations. After the student had seizures in May 1996, the family pressed for these evaluations.

Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain found that the District's plan met the Education Code's form and consent rules. The plan was not deficient when written, because the seizures happened later. The seizures, along with an educational therapist's attention testing that suggested neurological and vision problems, now made a neurological assessment appropriate. The Hearing Officer denied a neuro-ophthalmological exam because the vision records did not show a current impairment. She also denied a neuropsychological exam. A general letter from a doctor who had never met the student was not enough, and the claimed "executive function disorder" was not proven. The District, not the parent, chooses qualified assessors. A publicly funded independent evaluation was premature because the District had not yet assessed. The District was ordered to add the neurological assessment and complete it within 30 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO decided whether a parent's requested evaluations were "areas related to the suspected disability." A new medical event, such as seizures, could require adding an assessment. Letters from specialists who had not examined the student carried little weight. The district kept the right to choose qualified assessors. A parent's request for a publicly funded IEE came only after the district had assessed.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue I. s the District's proposed assessment plan appropriate?

    The January 31, 1996 assessment plan met Education Code section 56321's form, language, and consent requirements.

  2. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue II.A. Does the District's proposed assessment plan assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability? A. Should STUDENT receive a neurological assessment?

    The plan was not wrong when written, but the seizures that occurred later and an educational therapist's findings now require a neurological assessment of how the seizures and the suspected vision disorder affect his education.

  3. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue II.B. Should STUDENT receive a neuro-ophthalmological assessment?

    Vision records did not show a current impairment or a need for further testing, and the advocate's hearsay testimony got little weight, so no neuro-ophthalmological assessment was ordered.

  4. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue II.C. Should STUDENT receive a neuropsychological examination?

    A general letter from a neuropsychologist who never met the student did not prove a need for neuropsychological testing, and the evidence did not establish an executive function disorder.

  5. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue III. May Petitioner determine who will conduct the assessment?

    Under Education Code section 56322 the District picks qualified assessors. A publicly funded IEE claim was premature because the parent had not yet allowed the District to assess.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to assess. District must modify its proposed assessment plan to include a neurological assessment addressing the extent to which the student's seizures and suspected vision disorder affect his education, and must assess under the modified plan within thirty days of receiving the order. All other requests for relief denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493 (9th Cir. 1996); Education Code section 56320; Education Code section 56321; Education Code section 56322; Education Code section 56324; Education Code section 56329(b); 20 U.S.C. section 1401(a)(17); 5 C.C.R. section 3082

People named in the decision

  • Riccardo Nargie, director of pupil services, Ventura Unified School District
  • Dr. Paul Safran, school psychologist, Ventura Unified School District
  • Debbie Armstrong, RSP teacher, Buena High School
  • Barbara Harvey, RSP teacher, Buena High School
  • Maureen Byrne, RSP teacher, Buena High School
  • Mr. Wilson, math teacher, Buena High School
  • Dr. Karen L. Schiltz, clinical neuropsychologist, expert witness for District, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • Suzanne Gorenfeld, non-attorney advocate and witness for Student
  • Sandra Rappe, licensed clinical social worker, witness for Student, Ventura County Mental Health
  • Linda Rovai, counselor for students with disabilities, witness for Student, Ventura Community College
  • Kandis Follin, educational therapist who administered the T.O.V.A., witness for Student
  • Dr. Paul Satz, clinical neuropsychologist who recommended neuropsychological evaluation by letter, UCLA
  • Dr. Eric Saslow, child neurologist requested by Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • Dr. Donald Shields, child neurologist requested by Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • Dr. Joseph Demer, neuro-ophthalmologist requested by Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • Dr. Peter Engle, epileptologist neurologist requested by Student, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • Dr. Ju-Sung Wu, student's treating neurologist
  • Dr. Mark Bozek (also spelled Bocek), vision examiner
  • Dr. Philip Malinas, Mental Health physician, Ventura County Mental Health
  • Dr. John Viesselman, Mental Health physician, Ventura County Mental Health
  • Dr. Murphy, assistive technology reviewer requested by parent, California State University, Northridge
  • Dr. Dalton, examining doctor
  • Dr. Siegel, doctor consulted by advocate, UCLA

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1172-96 Case Year: 1996 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Assessment Designated Instructionand Services CDS Code: 56-72652 District: Ventura Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability

Case Details The case came before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Ventura, California on December 17 and 18, 1996, and January 23, 1997.

Petitioner was represented by attorney David R. Ellison of Ellison, Hinkle, and Bayer, and nonattorney advocate, Suzanne Gorenfeld.

Respondent was represented by attorney Donald F. Austin, general counsel for the Ventura Unified School District (the District). Riccardo Nargie, the District's director of pupil services, also appeared on behalf of the District.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner: Suzanne Gorenfeld; STUDENT's MOTHER; Sandra Rappe, licensed clinical social worker; Linda Rovai, Ventura Community College counselor; and Kandis Follin, educational therapist.

Respondent called the following witnesses to testify on its behalf: Riccardo Nargie; Dr. Paul Safran, school psychologist; Debbie Armstrong, RSP teacher; and Dr. Karen Schiltz, clinical neuropsychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received on December 17 and 18, 1996, and January 23, 1997. Testimony was received by telephone conference on January 28, 1997. Closing arguments were received and this matter was submitted for decision on February 6, 1997.

ISSUES

I. Is the District's proposed assessment plan appropriate?

II. Does the District's proposed assessment plan assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability?

III. May Petitioner determine who will conduct the assessment?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Eighteen-year-old STUDENT and his MOTHER, live within the District. In 1985, the District assessed STUDENT's eligibility for special education. The assessment revealed that STUDENT had "superior intelligence" (Footnote #1) but that "he was not achieving to his potential" in reading, mathematics, or visual-motor skills. As a result of that assessment, the District placed STUDENT in the Resource Specialist Program (RSP). (Respondent's Exhibit "Resp. Ex." 2, at p. 2.)

An addendum to STUDENT's Individualized Education Program (IEP) reveals that he began receiving "visually impaired itinerant services as a designated instructional service" in 1987. (Resp. Ex. 2, at p. 2.) In October 1988, STUDENT began receiving "support" from the school counsellor two to three times each month. (Resp. Ex. 7, at p. 2.)

MOTHER had STUDENT assessed at the University of California at Los Angeles' (UCLA) Neuropsychiatric Institute (NPI) in February 1988 "to determine whether he had any psychoeducational processing difficulties." The assessment team again concluded that STUDENT's intelligence fell within the superior range. However, the team also found that STUDENT "was experiencing problems with graphomotor output due to deficits in visual memory, motor memory, and fine motor coordination." Five months after this assessment, the District determined that STUDENT was no longer eligible for "Visually Impaired Services" because "STUDENT's visual impairments µhave mostly been resolved over the of 1 year visual therapy'" and withdrew him from the program. (Resp. Ex. 7, at p. 2 and Ex. 31.) STUDENT has not sought readmittance to this program.

In 1991, STUDENT began receiving psychological therapy from Ventura County Mental Health (Mental Health). The therapy, which included both counselling sessions and the prescription of medication, aimed at reducing STUDENT's depression and increasing his self-esteem. (Petitioner's Exhibit, "Pet. Ex." D1-79.) STUDENT continued receiving therapy from Mental Health staff until 1996.

STUDENT entered Buena High School (BHS) as a ninth-grader in September of 1993. STUDENT's IEP called for a regular education program that included placement in an advanced placement English course (Footnote #2), with one class period of RSP support. The District also provided STUDENT with a laptop computer to enable him to write more easily. (Reps. Ex. 6, Pet. Ex. F160.)

STUDENT attended BHS until 1995, but became increasingly dissatisfied with the school's curriculum and staff. While STUDENT attended BHS, he concurrently enrolled in classes at the Regional Occupational Program (ROP) and Ventura Community College (VCC). By September 1996, STUDENT was no longer enrolled at BHS and was receiving his academic instruction at ROP and VCC. (Resp. Ex. 19.)

The last IEP with which all members of the IEP team concurred was developed in May 1995. This IEP continued STUDENT's placement in RSP. (Resp. Ex. 17.) Although STUDENT's mother did not sign subsequent IEPs, they indicate that the District still considers him eligible for RSP on the basis of a specific learning disability. (Resp. Ex. 18, 19, and 25.)

The current case centers around Petitioner's request for an assessment. By letter dated January 9, 1996, MOTHER confirmed that she would attend STUDENT's upcoming Individual Transition Plan (ITP) meeting and proposed that the participants discuss "assessment as a basis of vocational, transitional, and academic planning." (Pet. Ex. Q102.) Nine days later, Ms. Gorenfeld requested the names of tests valid for the assessment of Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD), Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), executive processing deficits, sensory motor integration disabilities, STUDENT's visual processing deficits, vocational testing, and social perception deficit. (Pet. Ex. Q98.)

By letters dated January 20 and 23, 1996, MOTHER renewed and clarified the requests for assessment. Through her advocate, Ms. Gorenfeld, MOTHER specifically requested that the District promptly arrange for and fund "individuals of our own choosing" to assess, among other things, whether STUDENT needs occupational therapy services, can drive a car safely, or suffers from ADD or executive processing deficits. MOTHER also requested a "developmental vision assessment," which would provide information regarding STUDENT's visual processing and "a review of the totality of the assessment for the adaptation of assistive technology by Dr. Murphy, Ph.D., CSUN." (Pet. Ex. Q84 and 89.)

By letter dated January 31, 1996, the District responded to MOTHER's requests. While expressing doubt and confusion about the necessity and utility of some of the requested assessments, Riccardo Nargie, director of pupil services, stated that he would arrange for a District psychologist to evaluate whether STUDENT needs occupational therapy or has ADD or "any processing deficits." Mr. Nargie stated that MOTHER's request for information regarding STUDENT's visual processing "can be addressed in the psychoeducational report" and that the District would arrange for "the test results to be reviewed in light of adaptations of assistive technology." Mr. Nargie declined to arrange for an evaluation of whether STUDENT could safely drive a car, but suggested that MOTHER approach the Department of Rehabilitation for such an assessment. (Pet. Ex. Q81.)

Mr. Nargie's reply of January 31, 1996, contained an assessment plan which indicated that, as appropriate, either the District psychologist or special education teacher would assess STUDENT in the areas of: pre-academic/academic achievement, social/emotional behavior, psycho-motor development, and intellectual development. (Resp. Ex. 21.)

MOTHER sent Mr. Nargie two more letters in March 1996. The letters responded to Mr. Nargie's confusion about her request by detailing precisely who would conduct which assessment. For example, MOTHER requested that "a medical doctor with licensed specialization in neurology" conduct a neurological examination of STUDENT. From this and other examinations, MOTHER expected to obtain understandable descrioptions of STUDENT's disability, and how it impairs learning and can be remediated. (Pet. Ex. Q78 and 75.)

Mr. Nargie's written reply of March 19, 1996 reminded MOTHER that the District "stands ready, willing, and able to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability," but could not proceed unless she signed and returned the assessment plan dated January 31, 1996. (Pet. Ex. Q73.)

On April 12, 1996, MOTHER wrote to Mental Health to inquire about its decision not to "arrange for the MediCal (Medicaid) funding of disability assessments for STUDENT." (Pet. Ex. Q69.)

By two separate letters date April 20, 1996, MOTHER renewed her request for a "neurological assessment by a board-certified neurologist . . . as well as the other assessment requested" and asked that the District pay her $200.00 as reimbursement for the Test of Variable Attention (TOVA) that Kandis Follin conducted. (Pet. Ex. Q68 and 70.) The District responded to these requests by referring to its letter of March 19, 1996. (Pet. Ex. Q63.)

MOTHER signed and returned the District's assessment plan on May 24, 1996. However, MOTHER qualified her consent to the District's proposed assessment as follows:

1. Permission is given to the District to employ the services of individuals qualified, and assessment instruments validated, to assess STUDENT in the following areas of identified and suspected disability impairing his educational performance:

(1) Differential Diagnosis between ocular, muscular, and neurological impairment and etiology of impairment:

(1) impaired perception of 3-dimensional figures and visual tracking (2) slow response to visual stimuli impairing attention (3) visual impairment assessed in a visual analysis (developmental vision exam) (4) executive processing (function) deficits affecting response to visual stimuli (5) all areas of executive processing (function) deficits such as set shifting, sequencing, temporal planning, problem solving and follow through, working memory, as a neurological disability separate from ADD (6) affect [sic.] of prescribed medications on learning disabilities and all area of neurological impairment affecting learning performance (7) neurological cause of sleep disregulation, gross organizational deficits; (8) ability to be a safe driver.

The letter expressly denied the District permission to conduct assessments that it had conducted previously because, in MOTHER's view, conducting the same assessments again would not address STUDENT's disabilities. MOTHER also stated that the District staff was not qualified to conduct the assessments. The letter concluded by giving permission to "qualified individuals' to conduct the specified assessments at the following locations: Ventura College, California State University, Northridge, or the offices of a licensed occupational therapist, neurologist, or doctor of optometry. (Pet. Ex. R2.)

On May 30, 1996, STUDENT suffered three seizures. (Pet. Ex C8-13.) During the seizures, which the emergency room physician characterized as a "grand mal," STUDENT did not lose consciousness. As a result of the seizures, Dr. Ju-Sung Wu, STUDENT's neurologist, placed him on Dilantin. (Pet. Ex. C3.) On June 25, 1996, Dr. Wu examined STUDENT and noted that STUDENT was "doing well: and recommended that STUDENT continue taking Dilantin and return in one month. (Pet. Ex. R18.)

By letter dated June 6, 1996, Mr. Nargie acknowledged receipt of MOTHER's qualified consent to the assessment plan and asked permission to conduct the assessment of STUDENT without the conditions set forth in the letter of May 24, 1996. Hoping to secure the requested assessments, MOTHER corresponded with the California Department of Education, State Department of Mental Health, and various doctors.

The record reflects that MOTHER refused to consent to the assessments proposed by the District in January 1996, and the District refused to conduct the assessments as proposed by MOTHER in May 1996. (Footnote #3) Therefore, on October 28, 1996, MOTHER requested this due process hearing. (Pet. Ex. Q1.)

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner's Position

Petitioner requests that the District fund and arrange for:

an objective, effective assessment in all areas of disability, and one that is not tainted by the District's influence nor affected by the District's attitude.

(Pet. closing argument.)

Additionally, Petitioner has identified the members of the UCLA NPI whom he wishes to conduct the assessments. Specifically, Petitioner requested that either Dr. Eric Saslow or Dr. Donald Shields assess STUDENT to determine if an "undetected kind of seizure disorder" afflicts him. Petitioner also asked for an ocular motility examination from Dr. Joseph Demer, a neuropsychological examination from Dr. Paul Satz, and an assessment from Dr. Peter Engle which would, among other things, "determine the nature of [STUDENT's] seizure disorder." (Petitioner's Exhibit A1, at p. 2.)

Petitioner's closing argument contains another more detailed description of the requested assessments. (Attachment B, to Pet. closing argument at pp. 14-16.)

District's Position

The District maintains that Petitioner has failed to demonstrate (1) that he cannot benefit from special education without the requested testing, (2) that he requires the specific tests requested, and (3) that the practitioners whom he identified must conduct the testing. In short, the District contends that Petitioner is not entitled to the requested testing as a "related service" under 20 U.S.C. 1401 (a) (17).

SUMMARY OF WITNESS TESTIMONY and EVIDENCE

Petitioner's Witnesses

Suzanne Gorenfeld

Advocate Suzanne Gorenfeld's son, FRIEND, and STUDENT have been friends since 1988. As the friendship between STUDENT and FRIEND developed, Ms. Gorenfeld frequently visited STUDENT and MOTHER at their home. In addition to the social relationship, Ms. Gorenfeld provides "moral support" and advocacy to MOTHER regarding STUDENT's education. Ms. Gorenfeld estimates that she has attended all of STUDENT's IEPs since 1988. Ms. Gorenfeld has also tutored STUDENT in math.

Ms. Gorenfeld has earned a bachelor of arts degree, a secondary teaching credential and a home tutoring authorization, but lacks either medical or special education degrees and certificates. Ms. Gorenfeld testified that she taught in a parochial school for approximately one year and has occasionally taught for the District. Ms. Gorenfeld testified that she has home schooled her son FRIEND since 1993, who, like STUDENT, is gifted but suffers from processing deficits.

Ms. Gorenfeld stated that she suffers from ADD that she cannot medicate.

According to Ms. Gorenfeld, when STUDENT attended Balboa Middle School in 1991 and 1992, he "did reasonably" well, sometimes earning "B's." Ms. Gorenfeld attributes some of STUDENT's success in middle school to the intervention and support of his RSP teacher.

Ms. Gorenfeld noted that, in 1992, Mental Health expanded STUDENT's therapy to include both counselling sessions (which occurred from two to four times each month) and medication. Doctors Philip Malinas and John Viesselman from Mental Health prescribed and monitored a variety of medications to address STUDENT's depression, such as Imipramine, from December 28, 1992, through April 25, 1994; Prozac from April 25, 1994, through May 11, 1995; and Wellbutrin from May 17, 1995, through July 1995. (Footnote #4) (Pet. Ex. D 10-11.) Ms. Gorenfeld reckoned that STUDENT's educational performance began to decline when he began taking the prescribed medications. For example, after STUDENT began taking Wellbutrin, he was placed on academic probation.

Ms. Gorenfeld recalled that at the end of STUDENT's eighth-grade year, his ninth-grade honors English teacher gave the class a list of required reading to be completed before school began in September 1993. STUDENT did not complete the reading. In short, STUDENT "misspent his time" that summer.

When STUDENT entered BHS in 1993, Ms. Gorenfeld again noticed a deterioration in STUDENT's academic performance. For example, Ms. Gorenfeld observed that STUDENT had trouble waking up on time, arriving at school on time, being organized for the school day, taking notes, transporting books and other materials to and from school, and completing and submitting assignments. Ms. Gorenfeld stated that STUDENT was trying hard to perform and became increasingly frustrated in his ability to do so.

In Ms. Gorenfeld's opinion, STUDENT's inability to organize himself, complete tasks, devise and execute plans, and properly allocate time and resources are symptoms of "executive function disorder (EFD)." Ms. Gorenfeld stated that she first learned of EFD from a manual by Dr. Russell Barkley.

(Pet. Ex. T1-30.) She next saw the term EFD used in a report from an Arkansas children's hospital, and again in a clinical neuropsychology internet web page by Dr. Osmon. (Pet. Ex. S147-152 and S82.)

Ms. Gorenfeld maintains that STUDENT has repeatedly demonstrated symptoms of EFD, which she also described as the "inability to carry through to completion tasks that are assigned", the "inability to allocate time to task," the inability to collect himself and anticipate what he might need for the remainder of the day. Ms. Gorenfeld recalled a recent incident when STUDENT left home for the day without his prescription for Dilantin, his anti-seizure medication. In another incident, Ms. Gorenfeld telephoned STUDENT because he was late to a math tutoring appointment with her. When Ms. Gorenfeld's telephone call awakened STUDENT, he seemed confused and disoriented.

According to Ms. Gorenfeld, MOTHER has attempted to address the symptoms of EFD, such as STUDENT's inability to get up in the morning. Ms. Gorenfeld reported that STUDENT stays up past midnight writing poetry. To help STUDENT rise on time, MOTHER placed an alarm clock in his room. However, STUDENT was so confused when the alarm awakened him that without knowing what he was doing, he got up and turned the alarm off.

In Ms. Gorenfeld's opinion, MOTHER tries to assist STUDENT, but her ten-hour work days limit her ability to monitor STUDENT's behavior and school work. For instance, MOTHER cannot supervise STUDENT as he completes his homework or takes his medication. Ms. Gorenfeld offered that STUDENT tries to overcome the symptoms of EFD, and his inability to do so frustrates him.

In addition to coping with EFD, Ms. Gorenfeld noted that STUDENT encountered conflicts with BHS faculty. Ms. Gorenfeld alleged that during the ninth grade, STUDENT had a disagreement with his RSP teacher, which caused him emotional upset. (Pet. Ex. Q69.) Ms. Gorenfeld recalled that MOTHER asked STUDENT's tenth-grade RSP teacher, Barbara Harvey, to conduct an assessment to determine why STUDENT performed so poorly in math. MOTHER found Ms. Harvey's response unsatisfactory. (Pet. Ex. R36.) Moreover, Ms. Gorenfeld contended that STUDENT's college-prepatory algebra teacher refused to modify her curriculum to address his disabilities and that members of his IEP team suggested that STUDENT simply was not putting forth enough effort.

Ms. Gorenfeld contended that STUDENT has repeatedly requested but has not received an EFD assessment from the District.

Dissatisfied with STUDENT's program and performance at BHS, Ms. Gorenfeld testified that STUDENT and MOTHER decided that he should start to attend classes at VCC. Sometimes STUDENT would travel to and from VCC twice a week. Ms. Gorenfeld estimated that approximately one mile seperated the two campuses. STUDENT gradually dropped BHS classes and added VCC classes until he was receiving no instruction from BHS.

While STUDENT attended BHS and VCC he also received counselling from Sandra Rappe at Mental Health, and took a class at Regional Occupational Program (ROP). Ms. Gorenfeld testified that STUDENT was very tired because he had to take the bus to these three separate sites. Ms. Gorenfeld also stated that STUDENT missed school because his counselling appointments were scheduled during school hours.

According to Ms. Gorenfeld, during the time that STUDENT was commuting among these sites, STUDENT told her that the District was trying to "break his back" because it would not excuse the absences occasioned by his need to travel to these locations. Ms. Gorenfeld acknowledged, however, that time spent in transit does not explain all of STUDENT's absences from school.

According to Ms. Gorenfeld, she and STUDENT have also discussed his vision. Ms. Gorenfeld maintained that she asked the District for an assessment of STUDENT's visual search abilities, but was told that the assessment plan of January 31, 1996 "would stand as written."

Ms. Gorenfeld testified that her most recent conversation with STUDENT about his vison occurred at 7:30 a.m. on December 18, 1996, during which STUDENT made statements such as:

My "left eye is horribly dominant within my brain."

"It is like this, if you are in a movie theater and two-thirds of the screen is cut off, and the one-third is the other eye."

"There is a slight blind area where it snaps from one visual field to another."

"Sometimes I will sit there for some time, fixating between two images, and will close my right eye so I don't have to deal with one field of vision to focus in on the left-dominant eye."

In addition to speaking to STUDENT about his vision, since February 1996, Ms. Gorenfeld has also communicated with over thirty doctors, therapists, and researchers either in person or by telephone, e-mail or facsimile transmissions. (Footnote #5) (Pet. Ex. AA at pp. 1-2) During some of these communications, Ms. Gorenfeld requested and received information about possible diagnoses and treatments. Ms. Gorenfeld testified that Dr. Siegel of UCLA offered that STUDENT may be visually "fixating," while Dr. Demer suggested that STUDENT's anticonvulsant medication would adversely "affect visual search and pursuit." (Footnote #6) (See, e.g., Pet. Ex. Q 10-14, S17-22.)

However, Ms. Gorenfeld acknowledged that few of the individuals whom she contacted either reviewed STUDENT's medical records, observed or examined him. According to Ms. Gorenfeld, only Drs. Bocek (Footnote #7), Dalton (Footnote #8), Hooper, Kong, Locayo, Mastrovito, Viesselmen, and Wu personally examined or treated STUDENT; Ms Follin and Ms. Rovai tested and counselled STUDENT; and Dr. Satz (an "expert in visual neglect") received STUDENT's medical records. (Footnote #9) Ms. Gorenfeld stated that during her conversations with Dr. Satz, he did not name specific tests for STUDENT; instead, he described areas of educational impairments to have assessed and named the doctors with whom he works. Dr. Satz explained to Ms. Gorenfeld what areas each doctor would assess. (Pet. Ex. A1-2)

Ms. Gorenfeld asserted she has also requested that either the District or Mental Health test STUDENT to determine whether he suffers from ADD, ADHD, or other types of "attentional impairments that were purely neurological and had to do with visual impairment search or pursuit." Since that request, however, Ms. Gorenfeld has observed that STUDENT is not fidgety, so she is no longer requesting ADHD assessment. Ms. Gorenfeld contended that Petitioner has not substantially altered his request for testing since January 1996.

MOTHER

STUDENT's mother, MOTHER, stated that STUDENT "has always had organizational problems." Nevertheless, STUDENT was generally enthusiastic about school and able to learn. In MOTHER's opinion, STUDENT does not consider himself handicapped, but acknowledges that he has disabilities in the areas of writing, seeing, organization, and motor coordination.

MOTHER asserted that STUDENT's academic performance slumped when he enrolled in high school. MOTHER attributes STUDENT's slump to the attitudes of the BHS staff. Comparing STUDENT's experiences at BHS and Balboa Middle School, MOTHER noted that his middle school teachers tried to accommodate his disabilities, whereas the BHS teachers were adversarial toward STUDENT.

MOTHER said that, as a result, STUDENT's ninth-grade year was a "disaster." Specifically, STUDENT's advanced placement English instructor failed to accommodate STUDENT's disabilities by reducing and breaking down assignments into small segments. MOTHER also stated that although the District provided STUDENT with a laptop computer, he still had trouble "doing the writing" required for English class. MOTHER estimated that STUDENT completed about half of the class's required reading. Because STUDENT did not succeed in advanced placement English, he petitioned to drop the class.

MOTHER also testified that STUDENT did not receive a free appropriate education from BHS. In MOTHER's opinion, STUDENT found the BHS curriculum uninteresting and the teachers uncooperative. For example, MOTHER asserted that STUDENT's RSP teacher, school psychologist, and counsellor each had to write notes to his classroom teacher before that teacher would move him from the rear to the front of the class.

MOTHER stated that she attempted to help STUDENT with his homework. For example, she would ask STUDENT if he had completed his assignment, and if he had not, she would offer assistance. When MOTHER could not assist, she suggested that he speak with his teacher. MOTHER also tried to help him organize his medications and books.

According to MOTHER, about two years ago, STUDENT became so unhappy with the program and staff at BHS that he became anxious and refused to attend. After leaving BHS, STUDENT took a computer graphics class at ROP. MOTHER stated that STUDENT was determined to complete the class because he had an interest in it and considers computer graphics a possible career path. STUDENT earned a good grade at ROP and also earned a commendation for attendance.

STUDENT is currently enrolled at VCC. MOTHER pointed out that STUDENT's schoolwork at VCC is better than it was at BHS. According to MOTHER, STUDENT now understands that he needs to receive academic support and spend more time on his assignments. Yet, since the change of medication, MOTHER has noticed that his schoolwork has deteriorated. MOTHER asserted she is concerned about STUDENT's health and therefore permits him to carry a light academic load at VCC. STUDENT's current program consists of a weight lifting and two history classes. STUDENT dropped an art class because he felt unable to complete the "small detailed drawings" that the class required.

Since enrolling at VCC, STUDENT has become more comfortable relating to more mature friends and has broadened his "fields of interest." STUDENT's current attendance is, in MOTHER's opinion, probably better than it was at BHS, but not as good as it was at ROP.

MOTHER stated that STUDENT still enjoys writing poetry and composes poems once or twice a month. STUDENT also enjoys drawing "detailed swords or figures" with pen and ink, and painting detail on approximately two-inch sculptures. STUDENT spends some of his free time talking on the internet, or reading science fiction and classical literature, such as Shakespeare.

MOTHER wants STUDENT to undergo the requested testing to determine his educational abilities. MOTHER is unsure that STUDENT can perform educationally, even when the subject interests him. MOTHER also hopes that the results of the tests will reveal why STUDENT is disorganized, why he fails to follow through on tasks, why he is having seizure disorders, and what is causing executive processing deficits. MOTHER stated that the tests should be performed by doctors because the District staff lacks the expertise.

According to MOTHER, the District has repeatedly refused to assess STUDENT in the areas that she has identified. MOTHER stated that she requested a visual assessment because STUDENT was not succeeding in mathematics. Instead of conducting the testing as requested, the District attributed STUDENT's lack of academic success to his ADD or lack of responsibility.

MOTHER recalled that she was shocked and confused when, in May 1996, STUDENT had convulsions and had to be taken to the emergency room. In MOTHER's opinion, STUDENT's current anticonvulsive medication causes him to speak more rapidly and have trouble focusing, (Footnote #10) but no assessment has ever been conducted to determine whether or to what extent the anti-convulsive medication affects STUDENT's learning disabilities. MOTHER has noticed that since the convulsions, STUDENT's academic performance and ability to concentrate have declined. MOTHER does not know if STUDENT's vision has suffered a similar decline; he has not complained about his vison.

Linda Rovai

Ventura College employs Linda Rovai as a counselor for students with disabilities. Ms. Rovai stated that she lacks expertise in visual or neurological disabilities, or epilepsy. Ms. Rovai estimates that she began helping STUDENT plan his classes in 1991. Typically, Ms. Rovai would meet with STUDENT once or twice a semester and has maintained contact with him, MOTHER, and Ms. Gorenfeld.

Ms. Rovai has reviewed STUDENT's psychological reports and received updates on his condition from Ms. Gorenfeld. Ms. Rovai observed that STUDENT has had a difficult time completing classes and maintaining a satisfactory grade point average while at VCC. Nevertheless, STUDENT appears to feel more comfortable at VCC than he did at BHS.

In Ms. Rovai's opinion, STUDENT needs "someone who will take charge of his case" and coordinate efforts on his behalf. Ms. Rovai also stated that changes in STUDENT's medication have adversely affected his ability to perform.

For example, STUDENT has complained to Ms. Rovai that he is sleepy and has trouble arriving at class on time. STUDENT attributed his drowsiness to his the effects of his medication, not on keeping late hours.

According to Ms. Rovai, STUDENT's academic performance at VCC has been weak; he has earned "F's," "D's" and has withdrawn from classes. On the other hand, Ms. Rovai pointed out that STUDENT registers every semester.

Kandis Follin

Kandis Follin testified that she has earned a master's degree in special education, holds an RSP credential, and is certified to conduct neurofeedback. Ms. Follin is not licensed to either diagnose medical conditions or prescribe medications.

Pursuant to a request from Ms. Gorenfeld, Ms. Follin administered the Test of Variability of Attention (T.O.V.A.) to STUDENT in her office in March and April 1996. STUDENT and Ms. Follin had not met before she administered the TOVA. Ms. Follin described the TOVA as a "validated and reliable" standardized neuropsychological test, developed to screen and diagnose "the treatment of neurologically-based attention deficits, and in the monitoring of the treatment of attentional deficits in children and adults." (Pet. Ex. R22.)

Ms. Follin testified that she typically administers the T.O.V.A in two sessions. During the first administration the subject is unmedicated and during the second, the subject is instructed to take his or her regularly prescribed medication. In this case, STUDENT was unmedicated during the first administration of the T.O.V.A., but had taken Wellbutrin before being retested.

According to Ms. Follin, STUDENT "shows signs of depression" but depression did not affect his performance on the T.O.V.A.

Based on STUDENT's performance on the T.O.V.A., Ms. Follin concluded that STUDENT has an "attention disorder" and may have a "neurological disorder that should be looked at." Ms. Follin also suspected that STUDENT has a "developmental vision disorder" and recommended a "neurological assessment." (See also, Pet. Ex. R9.) However, Ms. Follin pointed out that the literature accompanying the T.O.V.A. cautions against basing a diagnosis on the results of one test.

Sandra Rappe

Mental Health has employed licensed clinical social worker Sandra Rappe as a psychiatric social worker since approximately 1990. Ms. Rappe began counselling STUDENT for depression in 1991, and last saw him during a regular therapy session in September 1996. Ms. Rappe estimated that she has counselled STUDENT at least one hundred and fifty times.

In the course of therapy that STUDENT received from Mental Health, Dr. Phillip Malinas and Ms. Rappe diagnosed STUDENT's major depressive disorder. (Pet. Ex. D18.) However, Ms. Rappe did not diagnose learning disabilities; instead, she relied on STUDENT's mother and school records for such diagnoses. Ms. Rappe knows that Mental Health administered a diagnostic interview which resulted in STUDENT's ADD diagnosis. Ms. Rappe does not know if Mental Health administered any other assessments.

Ms. Rappe reported that STUDENT frequently canceled or did not show up for his Mental Health appointments, especially when he was depressed. (Pet. Ex. D76.) Ms. Rappe also observed that other Mental Health staff noted that STUDENT was "reluctant to go to school in the a.m." (Pet. Ex. D43.) Ms. Rappe stated that STUDENT's habit of staying up late into the night accounted for his reluctance to attend school in the morning.

Ms. Rappe testified that during the counselling session of June 15, 1995, she observed that STUDENT "has been poorly motivated to make any changes relating to school even though he has been less depressed and more actively involved in computer networking as a social outlet." (Pet. Ex. D18.)

During the counselling session of June 10, 1996, Ms. Rappe and STUDENT discussed his participation in ROP. STUDENT reported that he enjoyed his ROP class and attended regularly because "they would not keep him in the program if he went beyond a certain number of absences." (Pet. Ex. D48.)

During their last therapy session, STUDENT briefly spoke of his plans for the future. According to Ms. Rappe, STUDENT also stated that he was in "one of his dark periods," and felt that "his friends were letting him down." STUDENT also expressed frustration about the way that his life was going, especially his "inability to attract girls." Both MOTHER and STUDENT let Ms. Rappe know that his seizure disorder prevented him from taking his medication for depression. (Pet. Ex. D48.) STUDENT also told Ms. Rappe that his disability was interfering with his ability to draw what he saw.

Ms. Rappe testified that STUDENT "very seldom" expressed anxiety or frustration about his academic performance. Instead, STUDENT's primary concerns and complaints involved his social activities.

Ms. Rappe stated that she would recommend a structured educational program which would help STUDENT follow through with assignments.

Respondent's Witnesses

Riccardo Nargie

District director of pupil services Riccardo Nargie has also worked as an educational and school psychologist. Mr. Nargie first met STUDENT when STUDENT was in the fourth grade.

According to Mr. Nargie, STUDENT has not had his 1996 triennial review because the District and Petitioner cannot agree upon what type of assessment to conduct. In January 1996, the District created an assessment plan and asked permission to assess STUDENT pursuant to that plan. By letter dated March 19, 1996, the District restated its position regarding what type of assessment it would provide.

Mr. Nargie recalled that MOTHER denied the District permission to conduct its assessment as proposed. Instead, in May 1996, MOTHER proposed a different assessment plan and consented to the implementation of her plan. Mr. Nargie maintained that the District denied some but not all of MOTHER's proposed assessment plan.

Mr. Nargie asserted that the District's proposed assessment plan addressed some of the eight areas of concern that MOTHER raised in her qualified consent for assessment. The areas that would not be addressed by the proposed District assessment are: "visual impairment assessed in a visual analysis (developmental vision exam) including but not limited to binocularity deficiency," and "neurological cause of sleep disregulation, gross organizational deficits." The District would not assess STUDENT in these areas because it considers the requested assessments to be medical, not educational.

The District's assessment would also not cover "executive processing (function) deficits affecting response to visual stimuli" and "all areas of executive processing (function) deficits such as set shifting, sequencing, temporal planning, problem solving and follow through, working memory, as a neurological disability separate from ADD" because Mr. Nargie did not understand precisely what the Petitioner was requesting. Finally, the District does not consider tests to determine STUDENT's "ability to be a safe driver" within the realm of a triennial assessment.

Mr. Nargie expressed frustration about what he considered the vagueness of Petitioner's request for assessment. Mr. Nargie further stated that poor communication between MOTHER and the District prevented the District from understanding Petitioner's request. Mr. Nargie said that if the parties could have discussed what Petitioner sought, maybe the District could have found tests that would address Petitioner's concerns.

Nevertheless, in Mr. Nargie's opinion, the District's proposed assessment would have assessed STUDENT in some of the areas that Petitioner identified as problematic. Mr. Nargie testified that the sections of the District's proposed assessment dealing with psycho-motor and intellectual development would address Petitioner's concerns regarding STUDENT's impaired perception of three- dimensional figures and visual tracking.

Moreover, Mr. Nargie acknowledged that if MOTHER would have consented to the District's proposed assessment, the results might have revealed additional visual disabilities. Mr. Nargie stated that as a part of the assessment process, STUDENT would have had an opportunity to describe his health history and current afflictions such as "blind spots" and "floaters." If additional disabilities were discovered, the District would have tried to develop accommodations to address them.

Mr. Nargie also stated that Petitioner's original request for assessment differed from the qualified consent for assessment that he received in May 1996.

Mr. Nargie also considers the District's assessment plan of January 1996 adequate because it covers all of the areas that the District routinely checks during triennial assessments, i.e., pre- academic/academic achievement, social/emotional behavior, psycho-motor development, and intellectual development. (Resp. Ex. 21, at p. 1.) Mr. Nargie testified that by comparing current results with past results, the District could determine whether STUDENT's performances have deteriorated or whether he had started to suffer from a different disability.

Mr. Nargie maintained that the District employs qualified staff and that members of the staff would conduct all of the proposed assessments except the occupational therapy assessment. Mr. Nargie understood, but disagreed with, MOTHER's assertion that previously conducted assessments did not need to be repeated.

Ms. Gorenfeld informed Mr. Nargie that STUDENT had developed a seizure disorder, but this information did not lead Mr. Nargie to conclude that the seizure disorder affected STUDENT's previously diagnosed disabilities. Mr. Nargie has neither reviewed STUDENT's medical records nor discussed this conclusion with a doctor. Mr. Nargie is not familiar with Dr. Satz's program at

UCLA.

Mr. Nargie testified that he briefly read Dr. Paul Satz's letter of December 4, 1996, in which the doctor recommended that STUDENT undergo a "neuropsychological evaluation." (Pet. Ex. 1, at p.1.) However, in Mr. Nargie's opinion, the District does not need the results of neurological, neuro- opthalmological, or neuropsychological evaluations to develop an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. Mr. Nargie contended that STUDENT can receive an appropriate education in the RSP at BHS without receiving the testing he requests. In Mr. Nargie's opinion, if STUDENT had remained at BHS, he could have succeeded academically because he would have matured and also developed self-advocacy skills.

Mr. Nargie also offered that the District successfully educates studenst with seizure disorders, and that it does not need neuropsychological assessments to develop IEPs that provide appropriate educational programs for them. Mr. Nargie estimated that the District serves "hundreds" of students with ADD and/or visual processing problems.

Mr. Nargie stated that he is not familiar with the term "executive function disorder" and, at any rate, it is not a diagnosis that is accepted or recognized by educational psychologists. To Mr. Nargie, use of the term executive function disorder may provide "a convenient label which can be abused as the excuse" for a behavior. Mr. Narggie stated that he knew that STUDENT had bilateral amblyopia, extropia, but did not know that he also had astigmatism and hyperopia.

Dr. Paul Safran

The District has employed school psychologist Paul Safran for the past twenty-five years. Dr. Safran earned both a bachelor's and master's degree in psychology and doctorate in counselling psychology. Dr. Safran stated that he updates his knowledge by reading journals and attending seminars regularly.

Dr. Safran first met STUDENT when he conducted STUDENT's psychoeducational case study in October 1993. (Resp. Ex. 7.) From October 1993 to June 1994, Dr. Safran saw STUDENT informally "from time to time" at BHS. Dr. Safran conducted STUDENT's psychoeducational case study for his triennial review to reestablish his eligibility for special education and determine whether any other processing disorders had beset STUDENT.

When Dr. Safran conducted STUDENT's psychoeducational case study, he discovered that STUDENT my no longer qualify for special education, because he no longer exhibited a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement. Dr Safran explained that STUDENT's test scores from 1993 revealed a twenty-one point discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement. (Footnote #11) (Resp. Ex. 7, at. p.13.) STUDENT's test results from 1993, no longer indicated that his intellectual ability and academic achievement were severely discrepant. Nevertheless, based on STUDENT's educational history, Dr. Safran "gave him the benefit of the doubt" and recommended that he continue to receive special education services.

Dr. Safran also assessed STUDENT to determine whether he suffered from a processing disorder. STUDENT's results on the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test indicated to Dr. Safran that STUDENT suffered from a visual processing disorder that made it difficult to "understand ideas when he writes down his thoughts on paper." Dr. Safran did not discover other processing disorders.

In his case study, Dr. Safran also noted that a team from the UCLA NPI examined STUDENT and determined "that he was experiencing problems in graphomotor output due to deficits in visual memory, motor memory, and fine motor coordination." (Resp. Ex. 7, at p. 2.)

Dr. Safran stated that RSP support would be the "most beneficial" accommodation for STUDENT. Dr. Safran also recommended the "reauditorization process" in which a student takes notes (or has someone else take them), reads the notes over to himself, and then talks about the notes to himself. Dr. Safran explained that this process, especially the final step, reinforces the lesson for the student. Dr. Safran stated that use of a keyboard can assist with the reauditorization process, particularly with a student like STUDENT, who has graphomotor output problems.

Upon completion STUDENT's of psychoeducational case study, Dr. Safran concluded that STUDENT would be appropriately placed in a resource room at either BHS or Ventura High School. Dr. Safran noted that VCC also has an RSP-like program. Dr. Safran stated that Debbie Armstrong, Maureen Byrne, and Barbara Harvey are all excellent RSP teachers.

Dr. Safran also suggested that STUDENT's RSP teachers speak with his regular education teachers about implementing the following accommodations: allowing additional time to take tests, requiring completion of fewer test questions, and writing down deadlines for submission of assignments.

In Dr. Safran's opinion, the testing that Petitioner has requested will not provide STUDENT with a more appropriate special education program. Dr. Safran stated that he recently discussed the merits of neuropsychological testing with a psychiatrist from the UCLA NPI. During that conversation, which concerned another student, the doctor told Dr. Safran that neuropsychological testing would reveal "what part of the brain might be affected but in terms of doing something about it, we really couldn't do very much more than what we're doing right now." From this observation, Dr. Safran concluded that testing would not provide the District with additional information about how to design a more appropriate educational program for STUDENT. Furthermore, in Dr. Safran's opinion, STUDENT does not require either neurological or neuropsychological testing to benefit from special education.

Dr. Safran asserted that the terms "executive processing disorder," "executive functioning disorder," and "executive function dysfunction" are not accepted terms within the educational psychological community. If these terms were accepted, Dr. Safran stated that he would be familiar with them. According to Dr. Safran, none of these terms appears in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV.

Dr. Safran opined that a behavior modification program might help STUDENT master his chronic disorganization. Such a program would first identify the behavior that STUDENT wants to change. For example, if STUDENT were trying to turn in homework on time, he might use a calendar book or write notes to himself to remind himself of his upcoming tasks. STUDENT would then do parts of the assignment instead of rushing to complete it at once. Once STUDENT completed a portion of the assignment, STUDENT would reinforce his appropriate behavior and plan the next step.

The parent's role in this program might included reminding the child to write down tasks; but Dr. Safran cautioned that the parent should not organize for the student "because the student needs to learn how to do that for himself." The RSP teacher's role would include devising and implementing the program.

Dr. Safran asserted that a behavior modification program could work for STUDENT because STUDENT is motivated and has succeeded in other areas. Even if STUDENT were depressed, behavior modification could still be appropriate for STUDENT. In fact, Dr. Safran stated that success on other areas might relieve some of STUDENT's depression.

In May 1994, Dr. Safran became aware that STUDENT was unhappy at BHS. According to Dr. Safran, STUDENT told DR. Safran that "he had difficulty getting along with other kids" and disliked his classes. In response to these complaints, Dr. Safran convened meetings with STUDENT's teachers to develop a "detailed plan" for STUDENT, based on Dr. Safran's testing results. (Resp. Ex. 7 at pp. 9-12) Sometimes MOTHER and Ms. Gorenfeld attended these meetings.

Dr. Safran recalled that STUDENT found mathematics particularly difficult. In Dr. Safran's opinion, STUDENT's visual processing deficits could be responsible for his difficulty with mathematics.

Although Dr. Safran's report states that STUDENT suffers from "bilateral refractive amblyopia, and anisometrophic hyperopia astigmatism," Dr. Safran conceded that he could not define these terms and is unaware of how to modify the curriculum of a child who has these conditions. Dr. Safran also acknowledged that if unaccommodated, a disorder that prevents academic success could lead to frustration, anxiety, and depression.

Dr. Safran added, however, that even if an expert were to describe the above conditions precisely, there are still a limited number of educational accommodations that a teacher can provide. Dr. Safran is unfamiliar with "assistive technology" that might help a student to overcome visual processing deficits.

Dr. Safran has not read STUDENT's recent medical reports. Dr. Safran was not aware that STUDENT experienced seizures and could not say whether STUDENT's seizures would aggravate his processing disorder. Similarly, Dr. Safran was not aware of the effect of either blind spots or ocular motility problems on STUDENT's vision.

Because Dr. Safran lacks evidence to the contrary, he still assumes that STUDENT has areas of deficit. (footnote #12) Dr. Safran stated that he helped the members of STUDENT's IEP team develop his educational program.

Debbie Armstrong

According to BHS RSP teacher Debbie Armstrong, the goal of the RSP is to "wean" students away from special accommodations, monitor their work, and teach them how to advocate for themselves.

Ms. Armstrong first met STUDENT in September 1993, when he entered the resource room as a freshman. Ms. Armstrong recalled that during most of the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT recieved one period of RSP each morning, but that for the reminder of the day he was enrolled in BHS' regular education program. The ten to fifteen other children who were also enrolled in STUDENT's RSP class were supervised by one RSP teacher one paraeducator.

Ms. Armstrong reported that STUDENT suffered from ADD, dysgraphia, visual and physical organizational problems, and visual processing deficits.

However, Ms. Armstrong stated that STUDENT had a "great intellect," strong vocabulary, good sense of humor and boundless curiosity. According to Ms. Armstrong, STUDENT's regular education teachers were confident that he was intellectually able to succeed in their classes. Ms. Armstrong noted when STUDENT enjoyed a subject, he was successful in it.

Ms. Armstrong counted his lack of discipline and organization as STUDENT's major weaknesses. For example, STUDENT frequently failed to keep appointments, follow through with suggested accommodations, and turn in his homework. Ms. Armstrong recalled that STUDENT reported spending his evenings using his computer, listening to music, and writing poetry, rather than doing his homework. STUDENT also complained to Ms. Armstrong that "he had a very difficult time sleeping" but that when sleep was possible for STUDENT, he sometimes slept for days. Ms. Armstrong testified that STUDENT sometimes returned from absences stating that he missed school because he "slept all day yesterday."

Ms. Armstrong stated that when STUDENT entered BHS as a ninth-grader, he was on the college preparatory track. STUDENT gained admittance into the honors English class and also enrolled in a college preparatory algebra class. Ms. Armstrong remembered that STUDENT was very capable of meeting the demands of BHS' college preparatory classes, but that his poor work habits prevented him from succeeding in them. Ms. Armstrong asserted that STUDENT failed to complete the summer reading required for honors English and neglected to complete algebra assignments, despite the accommodations made for him.

According to Ms. Armstrong, District staff attempted to accommodate STUDENT's disabilities in various manners. Ms. Armstrong stated that through BHS RSP, STUDENT received many accommodations for his various learning disabilities. Ms. Armstrong recalled that STUDENT received a hand-tailored educational program that included some college preparatory and some general education classes, differential testing of his academic proficiency, after-school tutoring, copies of textbooks for home use, instructions on effective self-advocacy, and alternate assignments that permitted him to demonstrate his grasp of a concept without completing as much work as his peers.

Ms. Armstrong described accommodations specifically targeted at addressing particular disabilities. For example, to help him with his disorganization, he received weekly academic progress reports, direct instruction in visual mapping and sequencing, and daily monitoring of his assignment calendar. Ms. Armstrong also asked that STUDENT's mother or a family friend monitor his homework to ensure that he completed and submitted it. Ms. Armstrong testified that MOTHER stated her demanding work schedule and learning disability prevented her from providing adequate in-home academic monitoring to STUDENT.

To address STUDENT's slow writing speed, dysgraphia, and visual processing problems, BHS provided student note-takers in several academic classes; supplied a laptop computer, software, and specialized training to enable him to take notes and compose written assignments; and extended time to complete assignments. Concern about STUDENT's distractibility led BHS to offer STUDENT the option of taking tests in the resource room and to have assignments read aloud to him.

Ms. Armstrong stated that to devise these accommodations, she relied on information from STUDENT, MOTHER, STUDENT's cumulative file, her own observations and experience, and STUDENT's psychological report. (footnote #13) Ms. Armstrong admitted that some of the accommodations, namely the extensions of time to complete assignments, were detrimental to STUDENT because they permitted him to procrastinate.

Ms. Armstrong testified that although she has taught students with disabilities that were similar to STUDENT's, none of the students has ever received as many accommodations as STUDENT. Ms. Armstrong concluded that STUDENT did not succeed in the educational program offered at BHS because "he didn't do his part." For example, STUDENT did not attend school frequently enough, "put in the extra time" required to succeed in the challenging classes that he selected, attend tutoring, or complete his assignments.

According to Ms. Armstrong, STUDENT did not perform well in algebra. STUDENT did not impress Ms. Armstrong as being motivated to perform well in this class STUDENT expressed only "normal frustration" at his lack of success in algebra, and, in Ms. Armstrong's opinion, "grades did not seem to matter to him." Moreover, although STUDENT and his mother often talked about going to a four-year college, in Ms. Armstrong's view, he was not "motivated to do what it takes to get there."

Ms. Armstrong wished that STUDENT were still enrolled in her class because she "enjoyed him thoroughly" and believes that he should have succeeded. Ms. Armstrong has had only incidental contact with STUDENT since the end of the 1994-95 school year. Ms. Armstrong has not read any of STUDENT's recent medical reports and was unaware that he had seizures.

Barbara Harvey

STUDENT was enrolled in Barbara Harvey's morning RSP class during the first semester of his sophomore year. Ms. Harvey and two aides provided instruction for the three to eight other students who were enrolled in this class. Ms. Harvey recalled that STUDENT's poor organization and attendance contributed to his lack of academic success.

For example, Ms. Harvey reported that during the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT missed 294 class periods, which totalled approximately 41 of 182 school days, or 8 school weeks. During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT was absent from 275 class periods. According to Ms. Harvey, when questioned about his absences, STUDENT replied that he missed the bus or overslept. STUDENT told Ms. Harvey that he frequently retired for bed between 1:00 and 2:00 a.m. Ms. Harvey commented that she did not believe STUDENT missed class because he was unhappy at school because he usually showed up at school later in the day. Ms. Harvey also recalled that staff from ROP called Ms. Byrne about STUDENT's sporadic attendance.

In Ms. Harvey's opinion, the accommodations that BHS developed for STUDENT "worked fairly well" in RSP. Ms. Harvey recognized that MOTHER was concerned about STUDENT's academic progress; however, the lack of "follow through at home" prevented STUDENT from being successful. According to Ms. Harvey, STUDENT would have succeeded in his educational program had he used the accommodations developed in RSP throughout the school day. (Pet. Ex. B121.)

Ms. Harvey also stated that if STUDENT did not enjoy a project, he would not complete it. For this reason, STUDENT seldom completed his math, English, and history homework. (footnote #14) Ms. Harvey stated that STUDENT "ran into a roadblock in algebra" because he did not complete assignments, despite having the option of using his notes on tests, having extended time to complete assignments, and receiving a computer software program designed to help him with algebra.

On the other hand, when STUDENT enjoyed a topic, he was prolific. Ms. Harvey stated that STUDENT composed pages of poetry and "creative" prose. STUDENT also enjoyed drawing and, on occasion, showed Ms. Harvey his art work. Ms. Harvey remembered that STUDENT drew slowly when he was enjoying himself.

Ms. Harvey testified that she learned of STUDENT's "visual perception problems" from reading the reports contained within his cumulative file. Ms. Harvey does not recall whether she and Dr. Safran specifically discussed STUDENT's visual problems noted in Dr. Safran's psychological report. Ms. Harvey did not completely understand the description of STUDENT's visual disability in Dr. Safran's report. (Resp. Ex. 7, at pp. 3 and 4.)

Ms. Harvey observed that STUDENT "had a difficult time" with hand-eye coordination and that writing was a laborious process for him. Ms. Harvey did not notice that STUDENT bumped into objects, had dificulty with depth perception, or relied on one eye more than the other.

Ms. Harvey concluded her professional relationship with STUDENT at the end of the 1993-94 school year, but saw him in 1996. Ms. Harvey lacks knowledge of STUDENT's current medical condition.

Maureen Byrne

RSP teacher Maureen Byrne has a learning handicapped credential and is currently working toward her master's degree in special education.

Ms. Byrne first met STUDENT in September 1993, when he entered the resource room as a freshman at BHS. STUDENT remained in BHS's resource room for the next four semesters.

Ms. Byrne acknowledged that the transition from the eighth to the ninth grade can be difficult and described how the RSP teachers try to prepare entering ninth-graders for high school. For example, the RSP teachers inform their students that failed classes must be repeated, check their students' assignment calendars, require that students use binders, monitor the students' progress in their other classes, and have "parent in-services" to explain what BHS will expect of their children. The RSP teachers also tell parents what occurs in the resource room and acquaint parents and students with the different instructional tracks that BHS offers. Overall, Ms. Byrne's goal is to help her students develop study and organizational skills.

Ms. Byrne recalled that BHS allowed STUDENT to enter it's ninth-grade advanced placement English class and also allowed him to withdraw from the class without academic penalty. Ms. Byrne stated that the regular education teachers at BHS are not adverse to accommodating special education students.

To determine how to serve her RSP students, Ms. Byrne stated that she relies on both observation and testing. For example, although STUDENT's last psychological report did not state that he had visual processing deficits, she observed that he had those deficits and addressed them in his educational program. When someone other than Ms. Byrne conducts the testing, she reviews the test results contained withing the students cumulative file.

In the second semester of STUDENT's sophomore year, he enrolled as one of the fourteen students in Ms. Byrne's RSP class. This class also included one or two instructional aides. Ms. Byrne remembered that STUDENT had a high I.Q., ADD, visual processing, and fine motor disabilities. By the spring semester of 1995, STUDENT was attending BHS two days each week and VCC three days each week. During this time, STUDENT was to spend two weekly class periods in Ms. Byrne's RSP class.

Ms. Byrne stated that the District allowed STUDENT to attend VCC because "his parent thought that his educational needs would be better served there." However, Ms. Byrne testified that she and the other RSP teachers considered BHS a better placement both socially and academically. At BHS, the then-college-bound STUDENT was enrolled in college preparatory classes with his peers. When STUDENT enrolled at VCC, however, he selected learning disabled classes that were below the level of classes that he had already taken and passed. Furthermore, when STUDENT was enrolled at BHS, Ms. Byrne could offer him support daily, but when he attended VCC, she saw him only once or twice a week.

STUDENT told Ms. Byrne that he liked the VCC campus, but he did not mention to her that he had problems at BHS. Ms. Byrne knew, however, that both mathematics and English composition were arduous and frustrating tasks for STUDENT. However, according to Ms. Byrne, students usually experience frustration and STUDENT's level of frustration did not seem "abnormally high." To reduce STUDENT's frustration, Ms. Byrne stated that she would discuss its causes and remedies with him.

When STUDENT was enrolled in Ms. Byrne's class, she concluded that he needed someone to monitor his assignments to ensure that they were completed and submitted on time. Ms. Byrne also concluded STUDENT was not devoting enough time to studying at home. Ms. Byrne reached this conclusion because "his work wasn't getting done" and "his binder wasn't organized."

Ms. Byrne asserted that STUDENT's academic performance did not improve significantly when he was in RSP at BHS. In Ms. Byrne's opinion, he would have progressed if he had attended school more frequently and received more academic support at home. For instance, if STUDENT had attended scheduled RSP class on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday afternoons Ms. Byrne would have been able to check STUDENT's daily assignment calendar and plan how to complete his assignments. Ms. Byrne commented that this process is "tedious" but usually effective. But, STUDENT's poor attendance deprived Ms. Byrne of the opportunity to assist him adequately. Ms. Byrne is not aware whether STUDENT received similar assistance at VCC.

Ms. Byrne testified that STUDENT's attendance problems followed him to his ROP class; she once received a telephone call from an ROP teacher inquiring about his erratic attendance.

Ms. Byrne noted that she read the psychological reports in STUDENT's cumulative file, but relies on her own observation rather than testing to devise a program because two students may have similar disabilities but different skills. Ms. Byrne has never relied on the results of neuro- opthalmological testing to determine appropriate accommodations for her students. Ms. Byrne stated that she was not familiar with the visual conditions described in Dr. Safran's report. (Resp. Ex. 7, at pp. 3-4.)

Ms. Byrne testified that she has not heard the term "executive processing disorder."

Ms. Byrne knew that STUDENT had suffered seizures in May 1996, but has not reviewed his medical records. In her capacity as an RSP teacher, Ms. Byrne has not worked with children with seizure disorders.

Dr. Karen L. Schiltz

Dr. Karen L. Schlitz is both a clinical neuropsychologist and a licensed psychologist. (Resp. Ex. 30) At present, Dr. Schlitz also supervises post-doctoral fellows at UCLA NPI, teaches three clinical tracks, and conducts research in neuropsychology.

Dr. Schlitz has neither met not assessed STUDENT. To prepare to testify at this proceeding, Dr. Schlitz reviewed most of the documents that the District moved into evidence.

Dr. Schlitz has either worked or is acquainted with the doctors from the UCLA NPI who Petitioner has selected to conduct the assessments that he currently requests. (Footnote #15) Dr. Schlitz's familiarity with the selected doctors enabled her to speculate about what procedures they might employ if asked to assess STUDENT.

For example, Dr. Schlitz stated that child neurologists Eric Saslow and Donald Shields would likely examine STUDENT, confer with his parents to obtain background information and presenting concerns, conduct a mental status examination, devise a treatment plan to eliminate medical variables, and perhaps order specific tests such as an EEG, MRI, or vision, hearing, and neuropsychological testing. These doctors might also discuss their results with a multidisciplinary team from the

UCLA NPI.

In Dr. Schlitz' opinion, Dr. Joseph Demer, a neuro-ophthalmologist from the UCLA NPI, would probably perform medical tests to gather information about STUDENT's vision. If Dr. Demer were to discover a problem he would likely recommend equipment that would "facilitate the use of vision for school, home or works purposes."

Dr. Schlitz has worked with neuropsychologist Paul Satz and considers him an "excellent" doctor and agrees with his letter of December 4, 1996. Dr. Schlitz estimated that depending on the battery of tests administered, Dr. Satz' testing and records review might cost as little as $1,600.00 or as much as $4,000.00.

According to Dr. Schlitz, Dr. Peter Engle would probably perform neurological examination, assess the patient's success with medication, consult with the patient's psychiatrist, and work with a multidisciplinary team to determine the appropriate treatment. Dr. Schlitz noted that the tests ordered would vary according to the patient's presenting conditions. Dr. Schlitz could not estimate the cost of treatment with Dr. Engle, but noted that he is conservative and would only order teting that was "absolutely medically necessary."

Dr. Schlitz' repeatedly expressed the opinion that the doctors at UCLA NPI will only order medically necessary tests because insurance companies will not reimburse for educationally necessary tests. Dr. Schlitz considers the testing requested by Petitioner medical in nature.

However, Dr. Schlitz questioned whether, given that STUDENT is now an adult, the testing outlined by Petitioner is still appropriate for him. Dr. Schlitz also listed the tests that she typically includes when she conducts a neuropsychological assessment.

To treat patients who, like STUDENT, are depressed, Dr. Schlitz asserted that physicians typically prescribe medication, such as Wellbutrin. Patients taking Wellbutrin must take this medication consistently and should be monitored because Wellbutrin has potentially serious side effects, for example, anxiety, insomnia, and seizures. In Dr. Schlitz' opinion, if Wellbutrin were to cause a patient to experience negative side effects, the physician would likely prescribe a different medication and monitor the patient. Dr. Schlitz warned, however, that a patient should not stop taking Wellbutrin unless advised to do so by a doctor.

Dr. Schlitz added that STUDENT should seek medical treatment for his "longstanding depression." But, Dr. Schlitz could not predict whether medical intervention of STUDENT's depression would translate into educational goals.

When asked about the tests that Petitioner requested, Dr. Schlitz stated that the attending physician decides which tests are appropriate. (Pet. Ex. A2 and Resp. Ex. 31.) Dr. Schlitz could not say with "reasonable scientific probability" that the requested battery of tests is required to enable STUDENT to benefit from special education. Furthermore, Dr. Schlitz could not say with reasonable scientific probability that the results of the requested testing would benefit STUDENT educationally. Dr. Schlitz is also unsure that conducting the extensive battery of tests "would change anything" in STUDENT's educational program.

When Dr. Schlitz works with special education students, she may "make gross recommendations such as small class, more time to complete work, and grippers on pencils." However, the members of the child's IEP team determine what specific accommodations are appropriate. Dr. Schlitz stated that "we punt our report to the [IEP] team in a school and they determine the accommodations." Dr. Schlitz noted, however, that the infromation gleaned from testing may not necessarily translate into educational accommodations that assist the child. Therefore, in Dr. Schlitz' opinion, a District may be able to devise apprpriate educational accommodations without conducting the requested assessments.

DISCUSSION

I. Is the District's proposed assessment appropriate? (Footnote #16)

According to Education Code section 56321 (b) and (c) ,

The proposed assessment plan given to the parents shall meet all the following requirements:

(1) Be in language easily understood by members of the general public. (2) Be provided in the primary language of the parent or other mode of communication used by the parent, unless to do so is clearly not feasible.

(3) Explain the types of assessments to be conducted.

(4) State that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parent.

(c) No assessment shall be conducted unless the written consent of the parents is obtained prior to the assessment except pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 56506. The parent shall have at least 15 days from receipt of the proposed assessment plan to arrive at a decision. Assessment may begin immediately uopn receipt of consent.

For the following reasons, the District's proposed assessment plan of January 31, 1996, appears to satisfy the requirements of this section. Petitioner's qualified consent of may 24, 1996, did not express concerns about the language of the document and it is written in MOTHER's primary language. Moreover, the sections outlining the specific areas to be assessed list the specific testing instruments that the District may use. The proposed assessment plan indicates that it "may result in a recommendation for special education placement and services," and it expressly states that "the assessment cannot begin until a copy of this form has been signed and returned." (Resp. Ex. 21, at p. 1.)

II Does the District's proposed assessment plan assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability?

A. Should STUDENT receive a neurological assessment?

Because the District proposed to conduct a psychological assessment of STUDENT, the District assessment must also comply with Education Code section 56324 (a) . This section mandates that, Any psychological assessment of pupils shall be made in accordance with Section 56320 and shall be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed.

The District's proposed assessment plan indicates that a psychologist would conduct the psychological assessments described in the District's plan and either a psychologist or special education teacher would conduct the academic assessments. Those areas to be assessed are as follows: pre-academic/academic achievement, social/emotional behavior, psycho-motor development, intellectual development, and occupational therapy. (Resp. Ex. 21, at p. 1.) At issue here is whether the District's plan complies with subsection (f), which requires the District to assess the pupil in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help orientation, and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status.

The District's proposed assessment plan fails to address all of the "areas related to the suspected disability" that Petitioner identified. (Pet. Ex. Al, at p. 2.) First, the District's proposed assessment plan excludes neurological testing by Dr. Eric Saslow or Dr. Donald Sheilds that, according to Ms. Gorenfeld, would determine whether STUDENT has an undetected kind of seizure disorder impairing visual, executive processing, and other cognition, other cortical/motor processes; visual attention.

Second, the District's proposed assessment plan does not provide an examination by Joseph Demer, a neruo-ophthalologist who Ms. Gorenfeld maintains would focus on "ocular motility" and "visual search." (Pet. Ex. Al, at p. 2. )

Third, the District's proposed assessment plan also lacks an assessment from a Dr. Joseph Satz, who, according to Ms. Gorenfeld, is a neuropsychologist with behavioral expertise in pinpointing the exact kind of visual processing deficits, including visual attention and the related cluster of developmental disorders, including executive processing in adolescent neurology; visual attention his emphasis, to pinpoint behaviorally the intellectual level and abilities of the brain; to determine the areas in which STUDENT can be habilitated.

Finally, the District also declined to offer STUDENT an assessment from Dr. Peter Engle, who Ms. Gorenfeld identified as an epileptological neurologist. According to Petitioner, this testing would determine the nature of the seizure disorders, their functional sites, and discover the relationship between STUDENT's responses to medications, seizures, visual attention, and his global deterioration.

In short, Petitioner requested four different types of assessments from a specific neurologist, neuro-ophthalmologist, neuropsychologist, and epileptological neurologist from the UCLA NPI which would probe STUDENT's suspected visual and neurological disabilities.

The District's failure to propose to assess STUDENT in all areas that Petitioner contends are related to his suspected disability does not necessarily render the District's plan inadequate under Education Code section 56320 (f) . To determine adequacy, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the areas that Petitioner identified are in fact "areas related to the suspected disability."

At the hearing, MOTHER testified that STUDENT experienced seizures in late May 1996. Medical records and other documents in evidence corroborate MOTHER's testimony about STUDENT's seizures. (Pet. Ex. C8-13.) Moreover, the District did not dispute that STUDENT experienced seizures. Instead, Mr. Nargie concluded that STUDENT's seizures did not affect his previously diagnosed disabilities. However, Mr. Nargie acknowledged that he reached this conclusion without reviewing STUDENT's medical records or discussing his conclusion with a doctor.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not err by excluding an assessment addressing STUDENT's seizures from the proposed assessment plan dated January 31, 1996, because when the District created the plan, STUDENT had yet experienced seizures. But the recent emergence of a suspected seizure disorder indicates that a neurological assessment may be appropriate.

The testimony of Ms. Follin also indicates that STUDENT may have a disability that warrants neurological testing. Ms. Follin testified that after administering the T.O.V.A. to STUDENT, she suspected that he has both neurological and "developmental vision disorders" that should be explored through neurological testing. (See also Pet. Ex. R9.) Therefore, to assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability, the District's proposed assessment plan should now include a neurological assessment that addresses the extent to which his seizures and suspected "developmental vision disorders" affect his education.

B. Should STUDENT receive a neuro- ophthalmological assessment?

In addition to an neurological assessment, Petitioner also seeks a neuro-ophthalmological assessment from Dr. Joseph Demer.

To support this request, Petitioner relied on both testimony and documents. An "eye report for children with visual problems" establishes that, in 1987, Dr. Mark Bozek diagnosed STUDENT with the following "vision impairments" : bi-lateral refractive amblyopia and anisometrophic hyperopia astigmatism. (Pet. Ex, S37.) But less than one year later, Dr. Bozek informed the District that "STUDENT's visual impairments have mostly been resolved over the course of 1 year of visual therapy.'" (Resp. Ex. 31. ) Furthermore, in a letter dated March 3, 1990, Dr. Bozek wrote that STUDENT's "eye health is normal and his evaluation is otherwise unremarkable." (Resp. Ex. 27, at p. 4.) The Hearing Officer was unable to determine from Dr. Bozeks' subsequent records whether STUDENT's visual impairments have returned or if new impairments have emerged.

For example, the Hearing Officer was unable to determine from Dr. Bozek's "analytical record" dated January 8, 1996 whether STUDENT still has the impairments listed in the 1987 report. While Dr. Bozek's report contains the words "ocular motility 3/5 to 4/5, Bilateral Amblyopia Refractive, alt. Exotrope Intermittent Seizures," the report does not explain the significance of these words to STUDENT's vision or recommend further visual assessment. (Pet. Ex. Z2.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot base a recommendation for a neuro-ophthalmological assessment on Dr. Bozek's report.

While Ms. Gorenfeld's hearsay testimony on these topics may be accurate, Petitioner did not establish that Ms. Gorenfeld possesses the special knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education which would enable her to offer reliable testimony on these matters. Furthermore, much of Ms. Gorenfeld's testimony is uncorroborated hearsay that cannot, by itself, support that finding that Petitioner seeks. (5 C.C.R. section 3082.) For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Gorenfeld's testimony on STUDENT's medical conditions is entitled to little evidentiary weight. Without persuasive evidence establishing that STUDENT needs the requested neuro-ophthalmological assessment, the Hearing Officer cannot order such an assessment.

C. Should STUDENT receive a neuropsychological examination?

In support of Petitioner's request for neuropsychological testing from Dr. Paul Satz, Petitioner provided a letter from Dr. Satz, dated December 4, 1996. (Pet. Ex. A1.) In its entirety, the letter states:

I, Dr. Paul Satz, a clinical neuropsychologist with the UCLA Mental Health Group, strongly recommend the neuropsychological evaluation for this child who has multiple learning disabilities, complicated by a diagnosis of epilepsy. This eighteen year old boy requires consistent monitoring of his cognitive-behavioral status in order to provide psycho-educational intervention and enhanced treatment modalities to assist him in his special education requirements and social adaption skills. In addition, I strongly feel that the consequences of his primary diagnosis of epilepsy which have implications on his medical problems should be evaluated from a multi-disciplinary team approach, in order to address these problems and stabilize his medications which present a distinctive impact upon his cognitive-behavioral strategies.

At the outset, it is important to note that Dr. Satz has neither met nor assessed STUDENT. Moreover, nothing in this letter indicates that Dr. Satz spoke to any of STUDENT's teachers or physicians, or reviewed his educational or medical records. The Hearing Officer understands, that to write this letter, Dr. Satz relied on information about STUDENT provided by Ms. Gorenfeld through a telephone conversation, and at some point, received STUDENT's medical records. (footnote #17) Because Petitioner has not established that Dr. Satz has any direct knowledge of STUDENT, his history or current condition, the opinions that Dr. Satz expresses in this letter are entitled to comparatively little evidentiary weight.

Moreover, the letter lacks a clear statement of what evaluation Dr. Satz actually recommends, or what area related to STUDENT's suspected disability this recommended assessment would address. Although Dr. Schlitz, testified that she agreed with Dr. Satz's recommendation for a neurological assessment, Dr. Schlitz also did not explain what area related to the suspecyed disability this assessment would explore. In short, Dr. Satz's letter is too general to support a recommendation that STUDENT undergo a neuropsychological assessment.

As Ms. Gorenfeld testified, she emphasized that the requested neuropsychological assessment would determine the existence and effect of STUDENT's alleged executive function disorder on his education. But the Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner's evidence was insufficient to either document the existence of this disorder or establish that it is an area related to his suspected disability that requires a neuropsychological assessment.

Therefore, because the weight of Petitioner's evidence is insufficient to support his request for a neuropsychological assessment from the UCLA NPI, the request is denied.

II May Petitioner determine who will conduct the assessment?

Having found that STUDENT is entitled to a neurological assessment, the inquiry now turns to who selects the assessors. Petitioner strongly urges that neurologists at the UCLA NPI conduct the testing. However, Education Code section 56322 allows the District to select the individuals who will conduct assessments. In its entirety, this section states: The assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.

Petitioner's evidence does not establish that District personnel are not competent to conduct the assessment that STUDENT requires. On the contrary, Mr. Nargie's uncontradicted testimony establishes that the District staff and contractors are qualified to assess students. (footnote #18) Without evidence establishing that the District does not have or cannot employ qualified assessors, the District is entitled to chose from among qualified individuals, including staff at UCLA NPI, to conduct the assessment.

However, if MOTHER permits the District to assess STUDENT and is dissatisfied with the District's assessment, she may then decide to have STUDENT undergo an independent educational assessment and seek reimbursement for that evaluation from the District.

According to Education Code section 56329 (b) , a parent is entitled to receive at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists,..., if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the public education agency.

A parent's right to an independent educational assessment is subject only to the District's right to request a due process hearing to establish that its assessment was approporiate. The case the Petitioner cites, Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1499-1500 (9th Cir. 1996), illustrates this situation. In that case, the parent disagreed with the evaluation that the District conducted and then sought an independent educational evaluation at public expense. The parents prevailed because the "District was unable to establish the appropriateness of its evaluation."

Unlike the parents in Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., MOTHER has not yet permitted the District to assess STUDENT. Therefore, under the statutory and decisional authority cited above, it is premature for Petitioner to assert that he is entitled to an independent educational evaluation at public expense.

ORDER

1. The District is ordered to modify its proposed assessment plan to include a neurological assessment of STUDENT that addresses the extent to which his seizures and suspected vision disorder affect his education.

2. The District is ordered to asses STUDENT pursuant to its modified assessment plan within thirty days of receiving this order.

3. All of the Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

I. Is the District's proposed assessment plan appropriate?

The District prevailed on this issue.

II Does the District's proposed assessment plan assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability?

The District substantially prevailed on this issue.

II May Petitioner determine who will conduct the assessment?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505 (i).

Dated: March 27, 1997-Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer.

Footnotes 1. STUDENT's full scale I.Q. as measure on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised was 131. (Resp. Ex. 7, at p. 2.) 2. STUDENT withdrew from this course within months of enrollment. (Resp. Ex. 8.) 3. STUDENT's triennial review was due in September 1996. The record does not establish that it was conducted. 4. Ms. Gorenfeld testified that when STUDENT was taking Wellbutrin, his behavior changed; he became hostile, rude, angry, and frustratetd. Ms. Gorenfeld also asserted that Wellbutrin caused STUDENT adverse side effects such as dependence on one eye. Ms. Gorenfeld recalled that STUDENT himself decided to stop taking Wellbutrin in July 1996. 5. Ms. Gorenfeld also stated that she has spent many hours in research pertaining to STUDENT's disabilities. 6. According to Ms. Gorenfeld, STUDENT now takes Phenobarbital. Ms. Gorenfeld has been informed that this and oher medications can cause amblyopia, confusion, visual blurring, and fine and gross motor problems. 7. Dr. Mark Bocek conducted STUDENT's most recent visual examiniation in January 1996. (Pet. Ex. Z1- 14) According to Ms. Gorenfeld, Dr. Bocek said that STUDENT had ocular motility problems. Ms. Gorenfeld described "ocular motility" as the way the eyes move. 8. Ms. Gorenfeld testified that Dr. Dalton noticed that STUDENT read words, but struggled with spatial tasks such as mathematics because he sometimes missed the signs for addition or subtraction. Ms. Gorenfeld also stated that Dr. Dalton recommended that a developmental/perceptual optometrist examine STUDENT. (Pet. Ex. s. 41-43.) 9. Ms. Gorenfeld stated that she did not contact any of the doctors to testify at this hearing. 10. STUDENT discontinued a previous anti-convulsive medication because it affected his memory. 11. The Hearing Officer notes that California Code of Regulations section 3030 states that a twenty-two and one-half point discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement may indicate that a child suffers from a specific learning disability 12. Dr. Safran stated that the final page of his report should have indicated that STUDENT had a visual processing disorder. 13. Ms. Armstrong stated that she read Dr. Safran's psychological report of October 1993. However, Ms. Armstrong did not understand all of the medical terms contained within the report. (Resp. Ex. 7, at pp. 3-4) 14. Ms. Harvey acknowledged that STUDENT succeeded in his math A class because his teacher, Mr. Wilson, required him to do only half of the problems. However, in Ms. Harvey's opinion, doing but half of the math A problems only partially prepared STUDENT for the demands of algebra. (Resp. Ex. 29.) 15. See Pet. Ex. A2 and Resp. Ex. 31. 16. Both the Petitioner and the Respondent agree that the assessments that STUDENT is requesting are "related services," defined as transportation, and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services (including speech pathology and audiology, psychological services, physical and occupational therapy, recreation, including therapeutic recreation, social work services, counseling services, including rehabilitation counseling, and medical services, except that such medical services shall be for diagnostic and evaluation purposes only) as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education... 20 U.S.C. section 1401 (a) (17). However, under California law, the adequacy of such assessments is determined by Education Code sections 56320 through 56329. 17. The Hearing Officer is concerned that one of the premises on which Dr. Satz relied has not been established during this proceeding. Although Dr. Satz's letter refers to a "diagnosis of epilepsy," Petitioner's voluminous record appears to lack this diagnosis. This apparent inconsistency, to a small extent, blunts the force of this letter. 18. In his closing argument, Petitioner also argues that the hostile and adversarial relationship of the District and the Petitioner is inimicable to any concept that the District could or should accomplish the assessment with its own in-house personnel. While the Hearing Officer recognizes that this and every other case that must be resolved by a due process hearing is, to some extent, adversarial, no evidence establishes that the relationship between the parties will compromise the assessment process.