California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 3, 2001
Student v. Pasadena Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1174-00 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Pasadena Unified offered FAPE in its resource program; parent denied reimbursement for Frostig School tuition and speech therapy.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A parent whose 12-year-old daughter had always attended private schools asked Pasadena Unified School District to assess her in February 2000. At a May 15, 2000 IEP meeting, the district found her eligible for special education based on a specific learning disability in written language, linked to visual-processing delays. It offered two periods a day of resource specialist program (RSP) support at Field Elementary for the last six weeks of sixth grade. The offer also included keyboarding help, accommodations, and a transition plan. The district said she would move to Wilson Middle School in the fall. The parent kept the student at Frostig School and sought reimbursement for tuition and weekly speech therapy.
Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard ruled for the district on every issue. She found that the student's small size, health history, and social immaturity did not prevent her from attending a larger public campus. The district still had to accommodate her asthma, immune disorder, and nutrition needs. Reading was a relative strength for her. She did not need speech therapy to benefit from instruction, because her language needs could be met in class and through the RSP goals. The district gave no written prior notice of the move to Wilson. That did not deny FAPE, because the parent understood the offer and toured Wilson twice. The Hearing Officer did not decide whether Frostig was appropriate and denied reimbursement.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a privately placed student who was newly found eligible. The district had to make a full placement offer, and the parent did not have to enroll the student to request a hearing. It also treats speech-language eligibility criteria as a guide only. The real question was whether speech was needed as a related service.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year at the IEP meeting of May 15, 2000?
RSP placement at Field Elementary with accommodations and a transition plan met the student's unique needs; her size, health history and immaturity did not require a small campus, reading was not an area of need, and speech-language services were not necessary for her to benefit from instruction.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
The May 2000 IEP's one-year goals and stated matriculation to Wilson Middle School's RSP program were an offer of FAPE for 2000-2001; the lack of written prior notice of the change to middle school did not deny FAPE because the parent understood the offer and toured Wilson twice.
- Not reachedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. If STUDENT was not offered a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, was Frostig School an appropriate placement for that year?
Because the District offered FAPE, the Hearing Officer found it unnecessary to decide whether Frostig was appropriate (prevailing-party section lists Respondent as prevailing).
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of tuition at Frostig School and for speech therapy services since the IEP meeting of May 15, 2000?
Because the District offered FAPE for both school years, no reimbursement for tuition or other services since May 15, 2000 was owed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Mill Valley Elementary School Dist. v. Eastin
People named in the decision
- Judy Halpern-O'Neal, program specialist, Pasadena Unified School District
- Nita Ferjo, independent educational psychologist, expert witness for Student, Independent
- Maria Austin, paralegal for Student's counsel, Newman, Aaronson & Vanaman
- Bennett Ross, executive director, Frostig Center
- Heather Chatem, private school teacher, Frostig School
- Ann Vradenberg, private speech-language pathologist, Frostig School
- Tineke Scholten, private speech therapist (assessor), Frostig School
- Stephanie Mishlove, private school teacher, Frostig School
- Terece Bell, private clinical psychologist (assessor), Private practice
- Cheryl Marie Portillo, principal, Field Elementary School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Rich Boccia, principal, Wilson Middle School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Anne Oyama, resource specialist (assessor), Field Elementary School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Nicole Billick, resource specialist, Wilson Middle School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Neezer Cynthia McNab, physical education teacher, Wilson Middle School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Elsa Toledo, school psychologist, Pasadena Unified School District
- Joan Madden, school nurse, Field Elementary School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Susan MacLaughlin, school nurse, Wilson Middle School, Pasadena Unified School District
- Gloria Giraldo, speech pathologist, Pasadena Unified School District
- Shiela Wolford, occupational therapist consultant, Pasadena Unified School District
- Frostig School / Frostig Center, private school (certified nonpublic agency) where student was parentally placed
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Pasadena, California, on December 5 and 6, 2000, February 6 and 7, March 22 and 23, and April 16, 2001.
Petitioner (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jodi Ossen Bynder from the law firm of Newman, Aaronson & Vanaman. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother. Respondent Pasadena Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bobbie F. Albanese from the law firm of Lozano Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf was program specialist Judy Halpern-O’Neal.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Judy Halpern-O’Neal; independent educational psychologist Nita Ferjo; Newman, Aaronson & Vanaman paralegal Maria Austin; Frostig Center executive director Bennett Ross; Frostig teacher Heather Chatem; and Frostig speech pathologist Ann Vradenberg.
Respondent called the following witnesses: District principals Cheryl Marie Portillo (Field Elementary School) and Rich Boccia (Wilson Middle School); District teachers Anne Oyama (Field resource specialist), Nicole Billick (Wilson resource specialist), and Neezer Cynthia McNab (Wilson physical education); school psychologist Elsa Toledo; school nurses Joan Madden (Field) and Susan MacLaughlin (Wilson); speech pathologist Gloria Giraldo; and occupational therapist consultant Shiela Wolford.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. On May 29, 2001, the parties’ closing briefs were received by the Hearing Officer. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year at the individualized education program (IEP) meeting of May 15, 2000?
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year?
3. If STUDENT was not offered a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, was Frostig School an appropriate placement for that year?
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the cost of tuition at Frostig School and for speech therapy services since the IEP meeting of May 15, 2000?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT contends that she requires placement in a highly structured, language-based program on a small campus, as well as weekly speech and language services. In Petitioner’s view, such a placement is necessary to address the unique needs arising from her specific learning disability as well as from her small size, low stamina, anxiety in large new places and difficulty in advocating for herself. STUDENT contends that the Frostig School, which she attended throughout the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school year, was and is the appropriate placement to address her unique needs. Petitioner asserts that the District’s May 15, 2000 offer of placement in the resource specialist program at Field Elementary School for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year did not address her unique needs and inappropriately required her to change schools for the last six weeks of school.(Footnote 2) In addition, STUDENT argues that the District failed to offer her any placement for the 2000-2001 school year and that this failure constitutes a denial of FAPE as a matter of law. Finally, STUDENT argues that she is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition at the Frostig School, for the costs of one hour per week of speech therapy services, and for the costs of parent-provided transportation to and from Frostig from May 15, 2000, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year.
The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE at the IEP team meeting of May 15, 2000, and that this offer extended through the 2000-2001 school year. It prepared goals and objectives for a one-year period, offered STUDENT placement in the resource program at Field Elementary School, and made it clear that STUDENT would matriculate to Wilson Middle School in the fall of 2000 if she enrolled in public school. The District asserts that STUDENT’s Mother never demonstrated her intention to enroll STUDENT in a public school and thereby make STUDENT available to receive a FAPE. In consequence, it contends that STUDENT is a student who has been unilaterally placed in private school by her mother and that District payment for private school tuition is the only service sought by the Petitioner. The District contends that STUDENT does not require placement at Frostig School in order to receive a FAPE, that it is not the least restrictive environment, and that, consequently, STUDENT’s Mother is not entitled to reimbursement for any educational or related services costs.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a twelve-year old seventh-grade student who resides within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District. She has never attended public school. From the first through the fifth grades, STUDENT attended small, private Montessori schools. She is currently completing the seventh grade at Frostig School.
In June of 1999, STUDENT’s Mother had STUDENT evaluated by clinical psychologist Dr. Terece Bell to determine whether she had a learning disorder and to better understand her learning skills and style. STUDENT’s test results on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children –3rd Edition (WISC-III) revealed her to be functioning overall in the low average range of intelligence, with a full scale intelligence quotient (IQ) of 84. STUDENT’s strength was in verbal language skills, with a verbal IQ of 91. STUDENT’s skills were weaker in nonverbal problem-solving and visual information processing, as indicated in her performance IQ of 80. Dr. Bell reported that STUDENT had a pervasive weakness in visual perception and a significant weakness in visual organization. According to Dr. Bell, STUDENT’s weaknesses in seeing visual-spatial relationships, interpreting visual cues, and recognizing visual patterns show up in STUDENT’s math and writing, and would likely impede her academic progress in the future. Dr. Bell indicated that, intellectually, STUDENT is strongest in verbal expression and rote memory, and weakest in visual organization. Academically, STUDENT’s achievement was at the mid-fourth-grade level, or one year below grade level. Her reading skills were stronger than her math skills. Dr. Bell determined that STUDENT’s weakest area was in expressive writing, which was at the late second- to early third-grade level. Particular difficulty was noted in spelling and writing mechanics.
Dr. Bell concluded that “while STUDENT cannot be diagnosed with a ‘traditional’ specific learning disorder, it is clear that her deficit in visual processing indicates the presence of a nonverbal learning disorder” (emphasis original), which seriously limits her in areas requiring visual organization, manipulation of visual-spatial information, and interpretation of visual details. Dr. Bell recommended that STUDENT receive educational therapy to address her visual processing deficits in a school that could specifically address her special education needs. In addition, Dr. Bell recommended that STUDENT repeat the fifth grade.
In the fall of 1999, STUDENT’s Mother enrolled her as a private student in the sixth grade at Frostig School, a certified nonpublic agency designed to serve students with specific learning disabilities, for the 1999-2000 academic year. In September 1999, STUDENT’s Frostig teacher administered the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA). STUDENT received a standard score (SS) of 75 in math, 87 in reading, and 84 in spelling with a composite score of 78. In October 1999, Frostig School developed an “IEP Cycle” for STUDENT, a document prepared for all students who are not placed at Frostig by a school district with an existing IEP. STUDENT’s “IEP Cycle” described her approximate functional grade ranges as from the beginning to the middle of the fourth grade in both reading comprehension and math computation and as at the beginning fourth grade in word recognition. Frostig wrote goals and objectives for STUDENT’s school year in the areas of reading, written expression, written mechanics, mathematics, vocational/transitional and social-emotional. In March 2000, following an assessment by Frostig speech therapist Tineke Scholten, Ph.D., STUDENT began receiving individual language and speech services sixty minutes a week from speech therapist Ann Vradenberg.
On February 11, 2000, STUDENT’s Mother wrote to the District to request that it conduct a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT to determine her eligibility for special education and related services.
On March 2, 2000, the District prepared an assessment plan for STUDENT, which was signed by STUDENT’s Mother. STUDENT was thereafter assessed by school psychologist Elsa Toledo, speech pathologist Gloria Giraldo, Field resource specialist Anne Oyama, Field nurse Joan Madden, and occupational therapist Shiela Wolfred.(Footnote 3)
On March 22, 2000, District speech pathologist Gloria Giraldo administered the following tests to STUDENT: the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test- Revised (EOWPVT-3), and the Test of Expressive Vocabulary and Semantics (the WORD-R Test). On these tests, STUDENT received one low score of 74 on the “association” sub-test of the Word-R. This score was -1.73 standard deviations from the mean. Ms. Giraldo reviewed STUDENT’s scores on the Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT), the Test of Word Finding (TWF), and the Formulated Sentences, Recalling Sentences, and the Sentence Assembly subtests of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamental (CELF-3) administered to her one month earlier by Dr. Scholten, and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R) administered to her in June 1999 by Dr. Bell. Ms. Giraldo took a speech language sample from STUDENT’s responses to questions and answers and to picture stimulation. She also reviewed the written language sample of STUDENT that had been obtained by Dr. Scholten. In addition, Ms. Giraldo reviewed previous reports prepared on STUDENT, including Dr. Bell’s evaluation. From this assessment, Ms. Giraldo concluded that STUDENT demonstrated average vocabulary, receptive and expressive language skills, that her speech was functional, and that her voice was within normal limits. Ms. Giraldo did not recommend language treatment for STUDENT because her expressive and receptive language was commensurate with her cognitive level and because she did not meet the statutory requirements for speech services. She recommended that language stimulation be addressed by the regular and special education teacher and the family through the school’s language arts curriculum.
On March 27 and 28, 2000, Ms. Oyama assessed STUDENT in two 90-minute sessions. She administered the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Basic Skills- Revised (CIBS-R) to STUDENT, which placed her at the 6.1 grade equivalent (GE) in word recognition (standard score/ SS=94), at a 6.0 GE in word analysis (SS=94), at the 3.3 GE in reading vocabulary comprehension (SS=83), and at a 4.8 GE (SS=93) in reading comprehension of passages. STUDENT’s basic reading composite was a SS of 97 and her reading comprehension composite was a SS of 89. In math, STUDENT placed at the 5.3 GE in computational skills and at the 4.9 GE in problem solving, with a composite math SS of 88. In written expression, STUDENT placed at the 3.0 GE in spelling and at the 5.5 GE in sentence writing. Her lowest standard score of 75 was in the written expression composite.
Ms. Oyama also administered subtests of the Test of Written Language (Form B) (TOWL-3) to STUDENT . This test assesses a student’s writing ability, in both spontaneous and contrived formats, to use standards for punctuation, capitalization and spelling; to use syntactic, semantic, and morphologic elements of language; and to express thoughts, opinions, and ideas in a mature and creative way. STUDENT tested in the average range on vocabulary (SS=9; 37%), logical sentences (SS=10; 50%), sentence combining (SS=9, 37%), and contextual language (37%); in the low average range in spelling (SS=8; 25%) and contextual conventions (SS=8; 25%); and in the below average range in style (SS=7; 16%). Composite scores were generated from these scores. STUDENT’s overall writing and her contrived writing were determined to be in the low average range (25%), and her spontaneous writing (ability to spontaneously compose an essay) was in the average range (27%). From these assessments, Ms. Oyama concluded that many of STUDENT’s academic skills, with the exception of sentence writing, appeared to be at about the fourth-grade level, which was similar to the level at which STUDENT presented herself. Ms. Oyama found that STUDENT’s written language skills seemed to be the weakest and that she could benefit from resource specialist program (RSP) services in the area of written language.
On April 13, 2000, occupational therapist Shiela Wolford assessed STUDENT to determine if she required any OT support in her educational program. She observed STUDENT at Frostig, interviewed Frostig staff and STUDENT’s Mother, and administered the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration-4th (VMI) and the Motor-Free Visual Perceptual Test-R to STUDENT for the assessment. STUDENT tested borderline in visual perception on the M-F VPTR (SS=85) and below average in visual-motor skills by the VMI (SS=77). Ms. Wolford concluded that STUDENT’s skills were above the level needed for handwriting and reading. Ms. Wolford observed STUDENT to have an immature gait with a waddle, but also observed her to have excellent endurance and a variety of excellent movements on the field during group games. STUDENT’s Frostig physical education teacher, who was also Frostig’s adaptive physical education specialist, did not recommend that STUDENT receive adaptive physical education. As a result of her assessment, Ms. Wolford indicated that STUDENT demonstrated no need for occupational therapy services.
In April 2000, District school psychologist Elsa Toledo conducted a psycho-educational evaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Toledo met with STUDENT on four occasions that varied in length from forty to ninety minutes. She administered a battery of tests, reviewed STUDENT’s school records and past evaluations, conducted parent and teacher interviews, and interviewed and observed STUDENT at Frostig. Ms. Toledo also consulted with District staff, including other school psychologists and resource specialist Oyama.
To assess STUDENT’s emotional status, Ms. Toledo asked STUDENT’s Mother to complete the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist (ACBC) (parent form). This checklist is a behavior rating form that takes scores on individual items and clusters them to help identify general patterns of behavior. STUDENT’s Mother’s responses to the ACBC indicated that STUDENT is about average in getting along with other children. Under academic or problems in school, STUDENT’s Mother indicated that STUDENT’s “small size has been a problem because she has been physically hurt and not readily accepted by others her age.” Ms. Toledo found no clinically significant behavioral concerns based upon STUDENT’s Mother’s rating. Ms. Toledo also requested Stephanie Mishlove, STUDENT’s teacher at Frostig, to complete the Achenbach Teacher’s Report Form (ATRF). Ms. Mishlove indicated that STUDENT always completed both her class work and her homework. In discussing STUDENT’s academic performance, Ms. Mishlove indicated that STUDENT has test anxiety. Ms. Toledo concluded from this rating scale that “STUDENT’s profile indicates there are no behaviors of concern at this time. She is most concerned with STUDENT’s ability to verbalize her wants and needs. It takes a long time for STUDENT to verbalize her wants and needs.” From these responses to the Achenback checklists, Ms. Toledo concluded that STUDENT did not demonstrate any clinically-significant behavioral or emotional concerns.
During their interview, STUDENT’s Mother expressed her concern to Ms. Toledo that public school would not be in STUDENT’s best interest, due to her size. She also expressed concern regarding whether STUDENT would obtain proper nutrition because of her need to eat slowly. No other health concerns were raised. STUDENT’s Mother did not discuss with her that STUDENT was overwhelmed by large places.
To assess STUDENT’s cognitive performance, Ms. Toledo administered the Southern California Ordinal Scales of Development-Cognition (SCOSD-C) and the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (KBIT). STUDENT’s performance on the KBIT placed her cognitive skills in the lower end of the average range (SS=92+/-8). On the SCOSD-C, STUDENT demonstrated solid skills in the concrete operations stages (ages 7-11) and scattered skills in the formal operations stage (11+ years). The results of these tests were consistent with Dr. Bell’s testing on the WISC-3.
To test STUDENT’s processing skills, Ms. Toledo administered the Bender Gestalt, the Test of Visual Perceptual Skills- Revised (TVPS-R), and the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R). STUDENT’s visual discrimination skills on the TVPS-R were in the average range (SS=109), but her visual sequential memory skills were significantly below expected age level (SS=55). The Bender Gestalt indicated significant delay in visual-motor skills. Educationally, this meant that it would be difficult for STUDENT to copy information off a board at the same pace as other students. These results were consistent with Dr. Bell’s report of a three-year delay on the Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI SS= 84) and of a four-year delay on the Motor-Free Visual Perception Test-R (SS=64). Ms. Toledo concluded that STUDENT’s visual-sequential memory skills and her visual-motor integration skills are significantly delayed. STUDENT’s auditory processing skills were age-appropriate.
To assess STUDENT’s academic achievement, Ms. Toledo administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). These results indicated that STUDENT’s “reading skills, math skills and written language skills are in the below average range, while her language skills are in the solid average range.” STUDENT’s basic reading on the WIAT was SS=78, her reading comprehension was SS=76, with a total reading composite of 74. STUDENT’s WIAT standard scores in reading were lower than those on previous independent assessments in this area as well as on the RST’s contemporaneous assessment in the Brigance.
Ms. Toledo concluded that STUDENT displayed a significant discrepancy between her intellectual ability and her academic achievement in written language, due to her visual processing delays, and eligibility was recommended on this basis. There was not a significant discrepancy in either reading or in math. Ms. Toledo recommended that STUDENT be provided information using a multi-sensory approach emphasizing auditory, visual and tactile approaches, that tactile manipulation be particularly encouraged during the problem-solving process and that, after general directions have been given to the class, modified (short and clear) instructions be given to STUDENT .
On April 27, 2000, an initial individual educational plan (IEP) meeting was held to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. STUDENT’s Mother, accompanied by paralegal Maria Austin, was present at the meeting, as was Frostig teacher Stephanie Mishlove. Ms. Mishlove provided the team with a report on STUDENT’s placement and progress at Frostig. District team members included representatives from Field Elementary School (Field), STUDENT’s home school. Assessment reports were presented by the school nurse, the speech therapist and the occupational therapist. There was not sufficient time to review the report of the school psychologist and the IEP meeting was continued. IEP meeting notes of this date indicated that STUDENT’s Mother was to meet with Ms. Halpern-O’Neal to arrange to visit the Wilson Middle School resource program.
On May 15, 2000, the IEP team reconvened. After reviewing the report of the school psychologist, the IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education based upon a specific learning disability. A significant discrepancy was exhibited between STUDENT’s ability and her achievement in written language and was determined to be the result of her visual-processing delays. Ms. Oyama prepared and presented pre-drafted, typed goals and objectives, which were discussed and modified.
STUDENT was offered placement in the resource specialist program (RSP) for her language arts and math classes at Field Elementary for the remainder of her sixth-grade year, 1999-2000. Because the math classes were ability-grouped, RSP would be provided for two periods a day, with a focus on written language and study skills. No designated instruction and services (DIS) were offered. The IEP meeting notes, however, indicate that the IEP team agreed to provide STUDENT with two session a week, for a total of forty minutes, to support her keyboarding skills. The team also indicated that, once STUDENT entered public school, she would “benefit from a[n assistive] technology assessment to determine additional needs than what is being provided on the accommodations page.” A draft transition plan to support STUDENT’s return to public school was presented and incorporated into the IEP. The IEP noted that “there was some discussion about [STUDENT’s] retention [in the sixth grade], but no resolution or decision from mother. The IEP was not promoting retention.”(Footnote 4) The District team members advised STUDENT’s Mother that Wilson Middle School would be STUDENT’s home school for the 2000-2001 school year when she entered the seventh grade.
STUDENT’s Mother told the IEP team that she did not believe it was in STUDENT’s best interest to begin public school to complete the 1999-2000 school year and that she was looking for a placement for STUDENT in the fall. On STUDENT’s Mother’s behalf, Ms. Austin wrote on the IEP that she did not agree with the proposed program “as I believe it is inappropriate and insufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs. This is notice STUDENT will remain at Frostig. I will seek reimbursement for STUDENT’s program at Frostig.” The District team members advised STUDENT’s Mother that, if she chose not to enroll STUDENT in public school for the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT would be considered a student unilaterally placed in a private school. The services and program offered in the IEP would not be provided and an individual service plan (ISP) would be written for STUDENT by June 2000.
On May 18, 2000, Ms. Halpern-O’Neal wrote to STUDENT’s Mother confirming the IEP team’s offer of “two periods of direct resource support within a resource classroom and resource support as needed in regular classes...[during which] STUDENT will receive services to support written language development, study skills, completion of homework/projects, in addition to keyboarding instruction.” A detailed list of accommodations as well as a transition plan was provided. Ms. Halpern-O’Neal indicated that once STUDENT was enrolled, the issue of whether the resource support would be push-in or pull-out “may change to support experience success in regular class.” She indicated that STUDENT’s academic skills in reading and math can be supported in the regular sixth grade class and “are within the range of skills demonstrated by her classmates.” Field provides the John Hopkin’s University “Success for All Reading Program,” which is used in conjunction with the Houghton-Mifflin literature series. “Thus, to support reading, STUDENT is provided 90 minutes of daily multi-sensory literature/reading instruction grouped by ability.” Ms. Halpern-O’Neal reiterated that because STUDENT’s Mother had elected to keep STUDENT in a private school to complete the 1999-2000 school year, she had no individual right to special education services and that an ISP would be developed prior to June 20, 2000.
On June 26, 2000, Petitioner filed a request for a due process.
On August 28, 2000, counsel for the District wrote to Petitioner’s counsel and advised her to direct STUDENT’s Mother to register STUDENT for enrollment in the District for the 2000-2001 school year, which commenced on September 11, 2000. “[O]nce STUDENT has been registered for school and has evidenced an intention to enroll in District programs, [the] District shall develop an appropriate IEP for the 2000-2001 school year.” The District asserted that because STUDENT was parentally-placed in a private school, the request for due process was inappropriate. The District again asserted that an ISP would be immediately developed for STUDENT .
On August 30, 2000, STUDENT’s Mother hand-delivered a letter to Ms. Halpern-O’Neal, which stated that “at no time have I ever told anyone from the District that I did not intend to enroll... STUDENT ...in a public school program if offered an appropriate program in that setting.” STUDENT’s Mother further advised that she did not believe that the District had offered STUDENT an appropriate program for the 2000-2001 school year. As a result, STUDENT’s Mother indicated that she had “no choice but to place STUDENT at the Frostig Center...effective September 22, 2000" and to seek reimbursement for the cost of this placement.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student . 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). Designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of possible related services are psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, health and nursing services, and language and speech development and remediation services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363 (b) (1987).
The goal of the IDEA is to provide a FAPE for all children with disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 (d)(1). Toward that end, local educational agencies (LEAs), such as the District, are required to establish procedures to ensure that all children with disabilities in need of special education and related services who reside within the jurisdiction of the LEA, including children with disabilities attending private schools, are identified, located, and evaluated. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3)(A). A private school child with a disability has no individual right to receive the special education and related services that the child would receive if enrolled in a public school, however. 34 C.F.R. § 300.454. A LEA is not required to pay for the cost of education, including special education and related services, of a child with a disability at a private school if the district makes a free, appropriate public education available to the child and the parent of the child elects to place the child in the private school. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56174. Disagreements between a parent and a district regarding whether FAPE has been offered to child are subject to due process proceedings. 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(b). It is not necessary for a privately placed student who is determined to be eligible for special education following a requested assessment to actually enroll in a program which the parents believe to be inappropriate in order to invoke the due process provisions of the IDEA. As noted in the Comments to the IDEA Regulations, hearing officers and courts retain their authority, as recognized in School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985) and Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993), to award “appropriate relief” if a public agency has failed to provide FAPE, including reimbursement and compensatory services under Section 615(1)(2)(B)(iii) “in instances in which the child has not yet received special education and related services. This authority is independent of their authority under section 612(a)(10)(C)(ii) to award reimbursement for private placements of children who previously were receiving special education and related services from a public agency.”
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the STUDENT with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student . Id. at 201.
In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307. If the district has offered a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if their preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit to the student than the district’s program. Id.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U. S.C. § 1412 (a) (5) (A); Education Code § 56031.
In an administrative due process proceeding, the District has the burden of demonstrating that it has complied with the IDEA by providing a FAPE to the student. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F. 3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994); Seattle School District, No. 1 v. B.S., et al., 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir. 1996); Norton v. Orinda Union School District, 92 IDELR 1069 (9th Cir. 1999). For the District to meet its burden of proof that it offered a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, its placement offer must have been designed to meet student’s unique needs and have been reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit. Because STUDENT never actually enrolled in the program offered, it is unnecessary to determine whether she actually received educational benefit or whether the services provided actually comported with her IEP.
I. DID THE DISTRICT OFFER STUDENT A FAPE FOR THE 1999-2000
SCHOOL YEAR AT THE IEP MEETING OF MAY 15, 2000?
Intent to Enroll STUDENT in Public School
When a privately placed student expresses an interest in returning to the public school by requesting an assessment for special education and related services, the District has a duty to timely assess the student , to convene an IEP meeting and to make an appropriate placement offer. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56171, 56174, Enterprise Elementary School District , SN 1416-99 (1999), Student v. Gold Trail Union School District and El Dorado County Office of Education (2000) SN 370-00). If the student is determined to be eligible for special education, the District has an obligation to make an immediate offer of placement. Mill Valley Elementary School District v. Eastin , No. C 98-03812 CW (ND Cal. 1999), 32 IDELR 140).
STUDENT’s Mother formally requested an assessment of STUDENT in February 2000. Her intent to enroll STUDENT in a public school program in the spring of 2000 is relevant to whether the District had a duty to make a formal offer of placement to a privately placed STUDENT . The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s Mother expressed her intention to enroll STUDENT in an appropriate public placement in the Spring of 2000 by requesting and consenting to a full assessment of STUDENT, and by participating in two IEP meetings. The District does not dispute that it had a duty to make a formal offer of placement to Petitioner and, in fact, did so. The Hearing Officer must determine whether the program offered to STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year constituted a FAPE.
A. STUDENT’s Unique Needs
Under the IDEA, the services and placement necessary for each child with a disability to receive FAPE “must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.300 (a). To determine whether the District’s program, placement and services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is first necessary to determine what those needs were during the 1999-2000 school year. It is undisputed that STUDENT has a specific learning disability with a significant discrepancy between her ability and her achievement in written language due to her visual-processing delays, and that she has unique needs in the area of mathematics. It was also undisputed that she requires a multi-sensory educational intervention.
As discussed below, the parties dispute whether STUDENT has unique physical and emotional needs that require her to remain on a small campus, whether STUDENT has unique needs in the area of reading, and whether she has unique language disorder needs that require speech and language services.
1. Does STUDENT Have Unique Needs That Require Her to Remain on a Small Campus?
The evidence established that STUDENT’s Mother has historically selected private educational environments for STUDENT. From the first through the fifth grade, STUDENT attended small Montessori schools. During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT attended sixth grade in a class of 12 students at Frostig, which its director Dr. Ross testified has a total of 100 students. STUDENT’s school experience has consequently been limited to private schools on small campuses within the confines of which she has attended classes with very small teacher- student ratios.
The parties dispute whether STUDENT has unique medical and emotional needs which would preclude her from attending a large public school campus. Petitioner argues that she has and continues to have physical and emotional conditions which impact her ability to feel safe in and negotiate her way around large new spaces and her ability to understand and express herself with her peers. In Respondent’s view, STUDENT has significantly overcome any such limitations which may previously have existed. It asserts that, while STUDENT may be shy or quiet, this is not uncommon for any student of her age and her needs can be accommodated on a larger public school campus.
STUDENT’s Mother testified that, as an infant, STUDENT was affected by significant physical problems.(Footnote 5) STUDENT experienced intrauterine growth retardation, weighed 3 pounds 14 ounces at birth, was described as a “failure to thrive” infant and was hospitalized at various times during her first year of life. STUDENT developed congestive heart failure due to a ventricular septal defect and patent ductus arteriosis, which was repaired by open heart surgery when she was ten months of age. STUDENT developed an IGA immune deficiency, which affected her ears, throat and stomach and lessened her stamina. By approximately two years of age, STUDENT was described as medically stable; however, eating remained an issue. STUDENT had a history of hypersensitive gag reflex which was treated with eating therapy. She had a history of mild asthma and frequent ear infections. STUDENT’s Mother testified that, when STUDENT was 2.5 years old, she developed severe panic reactions after the family was involved in a tornado while living in Tennessee. For four years after this incident, STUDENT’s Mother worked with a child psychologist who advised her that STUDENT was more emotionally vulnerable than other children due to her medical problems.
The evidence established that, throughout her life, STUDENT has been small for her chronological age and was generally at the fifth percentile in height and weight compared to her peers. Her pediatrician determined that STUDENT’s small stature was related to her genetics, rather than due to any health problems. STUDENT has been characterized as a “tiny little girl” by educational psychologist Dr. Ferjo and as “Thumbelina” by STUDENT’s Mother. Various witnesses testified that, due to her petite size, STUDENT appears to be two to three years younger than her peers. Currently, at age 12, STUDENT is 4 feet 7 inches tall and weighs 73 to 75 pounds, which places her at the fifth percentile in height and the tenth percentile in weight. STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT is still affected by these conditions. She testified that, as a result of her IGA, STUDENT frequently became sick in the fall of 2000. Despite this, STUDENT was only absent from school six times because STUDENT’s Mother gave her six-hour cough medicine so she could attend school. STUDENT required antibiotics before she was cured. Currently, STUDENT has rapid choke reflex (RCR), which may cause her to vomit everything. STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT has not had RCR while at Frostig because she eats her food very carefully and slowly to avoid embarrassing herself at school. STUDENT’s Mother testified that, on several recent occasions, she has had to make dinner for STUDENT three times a night for her retain her food. STUDENT still has mild asthma and reactive airway disease. She experienced an asthma episode from running on a dusty track at Frostig. The doctor told STUDENT’s Mother that STUDENT was allergic to dust and grass.
STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT continues to have panic attacks periodically from weather and loud noises (sounds of trains, sirens and television). STUDENT worries about things, which causes a rash on her arms and her body to feel tense. Her anxiety is also manifested in test anxiety due to her visual processing disorder. STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT has not had any panic attacks while attending Frostig. She last had a panic attack in her mother’s presence before Thanksgiving 2000, because of her fear of using a potholder with something in the oven. STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT “is blown away by large spaces,” for example, by large cafeterias, large lobbies or groups of people. She also testified, however, that she takes STUDENT to the ballet and to movie theaters, and that STUDENT likes to shop at the mall. According to STUDENT’s Mother, STUDENT is not currently under the care of either a psychologist or a psychiatrist and she is not on any medications.
As part of the District’s March 2000 health assessment, Field school nurse Joan Madden reviewed STUDENT’s medical records, interviewed STUDENT’s Mother, and had STUDENT’s Mother complete a health and developmental history form. The only pattern of behavior marked by STUDENT’s Mother on the history forms as applicable to STUDENT was that she is sensitive to criticisms. Madden testified that STUDENT has no current cardiac problems. At her most recent heart check up in December of 1999, STUDENT’s pediatric cardiologist concluded that STUDENT has done well since 1994 and currently “requires no restrictions from the cardiovascular point of view.” According to Ms. Madden, there was no information to indicate that STUDENT’s stamina would be affected by cardiac problems that would prevent her from pursuing normal activities. There was also nothing to indicate that STUDENT’s mild asthmatic condition would prohibit her from moving around the Field campus. Ms. Madden testified that IGA immune deficiency is a specific type of deficiency that makes STUDENT slightly more susceptible to infections, but that no information was contained in the records or provided by STUDENT’s Mother to indicate it was at a critical level. In summary, Ms. Madden testified that there was no indication that STUDENT could not be safe at school because of a medical condition. Furthermore, a health plan would be prepared for any District STUDENT with a health issue to notify and train teachers about the issue, and to advise about any medications required for asthma. Notification would also be provided to the parents if there were any communicable diseases on campus which would call for precautions.
The evidence clearly established that STUDENT is and has been engaged in many vigorous extracurricular physical activities. Throughout STUDENT’s life, STUDENT’s Mother has been extremely pro-active in seeking out assistance for her. Based upon the recommendations of various professionals, STUDENT’s Mother has enrolled STUDENT in ballet, swimming, and self-defense classes. STUDENT attends ballet class twice a week for an hour and 45 minutes and attends a weekly 40-minute self-defense class. STUDENT is a Class C swimmer who participates in one-hour workouts in a 33.3 yard pool several times a week and four times a week in the summer. She also participates in weekend swim meets where she swims freestyle in 50 to 100 yard races, occasionally “placing” in the race. STUDENT also roller blades and does so without any balance difficulties. STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT “thrives on physical activity.” Ms. Madden testified that the “slight difficulty” she noted with STUDENT’s balance would not affect her ability to move about a school campus, particularly given STUDENT’s participation in numerous physical activities which require coordination.
District’s occupational therapy consultant Shiela Wolford testified that, as part of her assessment, she observed STUDENT at a physical education class at Frostig, which took place at a park across from the school. The class was involved in two “tag” or “flag” games on a open grass and dirt field measuring approximately 30 yards by 30 yards. For the 30 minutes of her observation, STUDENT fully participated in both games. STUDENT ran, dodged obstacles, tagged other team members and was not tagged by peers. She demonstrated no perceptual problems to interfere with her ability to move in this large space. Ms. Wolford testified that she had no reservations about STUDENT’s ability to move around campus, after she is initially shown around.
The conclusion of Ms. Wolford and Ms. Madden that STUDENT did not have any physical limitations that would prevent her from being placed on a larger campus is consistent with the observations of Heather Chatem, STUDENT’s teacher at Frostig. She testified that, although STUDENT may eat a little slower, she had not observed any physical limitations with her and did not recall any significant concerns raised by her physical education teacher. In addition, although STUDENT initially had problems organizing herself at Frostig (i.e., using lockers and changing classes), she now helps other students in those areas.
Independent education psychologist Dr. Ferjo characterized STUDENT as a student who has low stamina, fatigues easily, and has “had extensive medical intervention and continues to be considered ‘delicate.’” Dr. Ferjo testified that a large campus would, in her opinion, be very difficult for STUDENT due to her size and stamina problems. Because Dr. Ferjo’s opinion was not based upon current medical information, the Hearing Officer gives it little weight.
In addition, the evidence indicated that STUDENT is immature in both her physical appearance and in her social development. In her assessment, Dr. Bell indicated that children with nonverbal learning disorders such as STUDENT “are often immature in interpreting nonverbal communication (e.g., body language or subtle facial expressions). This can be distressing, and can lead to immature social competence.” She indicated that this may be one reason why STUDENT gets along better with younger children and adults than her peers and may also explain why she goes along with the “baby role.” Dr. Bell indicated that it would be “understandable that transitions and new situations would be a little anxiety-producing for her–especially if she can’t ‘read’ visual cues as well as other children her age.”
STUDENT’s Mother testified that STUDENT is happier playing with younger children. Heather Chatem testified that STUDENT associates primarily with girls her own age or younger. At age 12, she is still interested in “beany babies,” which both RST Ms. Oyama and Dr. Ferjo agreed was unusual for her age. By contrast, when school psychologist Ms. Toledo observed STUDENT and her mother interact, she had a sense that STUDENT’s Mother was overprotective. In Ms. Toledo’s opinion, STUDENT has good social skills and was able to talk about issues and activities. Although she was occasionally giggly, she did not behave like a nine-year-old. STUDENT appeared “very teenage-like” in her need to be given “space” from her mother. Other witnesses testified that there is a wide range of maturity levels at this age.
Various witnesses also testified that STUDENT will talk in a funny way, use a “singsong voice” and not be taken seriously. This singsong voice was noticed once each by several witnesses during their contact with STUDENT, and appeared to occur when STUDENT was anxious (Dr. Ferjo) or did not know something (Ms. Oyama). Ms. Toledo testified that STUDENT used this voice toward the end of a session when she was becoming tired or bored. Ms. Chatem testified that she has not heard STUDENT use a childish tone of voice and has not heard the singsong voice very often. She believed that STUDENT used this voice playfully with her close friends.
Dr. Ferjo testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT presents as a child who is generally immature, both socially and emotionally, but who has no behavior or organic problems. Her opinion is consistent with Ms. Toledo’s conclusion that STUDENT had no clinically-significant emotional problems based upon the Achenbach parent and teacher rating scales.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has unique health needs in the areas of asthma, IGA immune disorder and nutrition which the District must accommodate. The Hearing Officer also concludes that none of the conditions outlined above, including STUDENT’s small size and immaturity, constitutes a unique physical or emotional need that would prohibit her attendance at an appropriate special education program on a larger school campus.
2. Does STUDENT have a unique need in the area of reading?
Educational psychologist Dr. Ferjo testified that reading is an area of concern for STUDENT. Dr. Ferjo conducted a brief consultation with STUDENT and did not administer any tests to STUDENT in the area of reading or reading comprehension.(Footnote 6) From her review of STUDENT’s educational records, Dr. Ferjo determined that STUDENT can decode but cannot abstract so that her degree of understanding of what she reads is a concern. Heather Chatem testified that STUDENT’s area of need in reading is in “inferential comprehension,” which affects content classes such as social studies or history where there is less of a story line to make the inferences strong. Ms. Chatem testified that, as a result, STUDENT does best with multi-sensory “pre-teaching,” which means familiarizing her with the vocabulary which will appear in a lesson before she is given the lesson.
STUDENT’s standardized scores in the area of reading and reading comprehension indicate that reading is a relative strength for her. In June 1999, Dr. Bell administered the Woodcock Johnson Revised Tests of Achievement (WJ- R) to STUDENT. STUDENT achieved a standard score of 95 in broad reading, based upon her scores on letter-word identification (SS=92), passage comprehension (SS=99) and word attack (phonics) (SS= 95). In September 1999, STUDENT achieved a standard score of 87 in reading on the KTEA administered at Frostig. In April 2000, STUDENT achieved a standard score of 97 on the basic reading composite of the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Basic Skills-Revised (CIBS-R) administered by district resource specialist Ann Oyama. Her standard score on the CIBS-R on the reading comprehension composite was 89, based upon her score in reading vocabulary comprehension (SS=83) and comprehension of passages (SS=93). STUDENT’s reading scores on the WIAT administered to her by Ms. Toledo were lower. STUDENT’s basic reading on the WIAT was SS=78, her reading comprehension was SS=76, with a total reading composite of 74. Ms. Toledo testified that, based on STUDENT’s reading scores on the Brigance, as well as her strong reading scores on Dr. Bell’s Woodcock-Johnson, there was no concern about her reading. These higher scores were in the average range and were commensurate with STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. She also testified that, to determine a significant discrepancy, multiple achievement tools are more reliable than one test. In addition, District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s reading skills fell within the range of reading skills of students in the regular sixth grade class. Ms. Mishlove also agreed that reading was STUDENT’s strength.
The District’s conclusion that STUDENT’s reading skills were a relative strength for her was consistent with Dr. Bell’s overall assessment. Dr. Bell noted that STUDENT’s “reading skills are generally at the level of her overall verbal abilities, as assessed by the Verbal IQ [91]. Her word decoding is limited by weak phonics, but she appears to understand what she reads.” She concluded that STUDENT’s achievement in reading was consistent with her verbal IQ.
From the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not have a unique need in the area of reading.
3. Does STUDENT have unique needs that require speech and language services?
STUDENT asserts that she has unique needs that require the provision of speech and language therapy as a related service. STUDENT does not contend that she is eligible for special education services based upon a language or speech disorder but argues that such services should have been provided to her as a related service.
Ms. Chatem testified that STUDENT has a difficult time expressing herself when there is conflict. While she is able to mediate conflicts between her friends, STUDENT has difficulty advocating for herself. STUDENT has more problems expressing herself with boys than girls and misinterprets their behavior more often. According to Ms. Chatem, STUDENT misperceives age-appropriate sarcasm. As a result, STUDENT will use a low tone of voice, or, when overly frustrated, act out by pinching a classmate or stomping on a classmate’s foot. Ms. Chatem also testified that STUDENT is sometimes sarcastic to other students and that this is typical teenage behavior. In Ms. Chatem’s opinion, STUDENT’s verbalization of her frustration is ineffective, because she does not put enough emphasis either in her tone of voice or her choice of words. The result is that STUDENT is communicating, but not communicating her actual intent.
Ann Vradenberg testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT has “plot formation problems” that made it difficult for her to interpret what was said, to transition from topic to topic, to understand why someone was talking to her. STUDENT was also unable to judge sarcasm or to interpret multiple meanings in slang. Ms. Vradenberg recommended that STUDENT be evaluated to determine whether speech and language services were warranted.
In February, 2000, Frostig speech therapist Tineke Scholten, Ph.D., assessed STUDENT by administering several standardized tests to her, including the Formulated Sentences, Recalling Sentences, and the Sentence Assembly subtests of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamental (CELF-3). Based upon these test results, Dr. Scholten concluded that STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills showed a “moderate delay, with special difficulty with tasks that require her to consciously manipulate language.” STUDENT was also noted to have limited narrative skills, which “are likely to impact her social interactions as well as her academic performance.” Speech and language therapy, with an emphasis on “the development of a variety of narrative strategies,” was recommended to boost STUDENT’s language skills. No specific amount of services was recommended. As previously indicated, on March 1, 2000, STUDENT began receiving speech services from Ms. Vradenberg on an individual basis for sixty minutes a week.
Pursuant to Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(c)(4), a pupil has an expressive or receptive language disorder when she scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean on two standardized tests or on one standardized tests and displays an inappropriate or inadequate usage of expressive or receptive language as measured by a language sample of a minimum of fifty utterances. Ms. Vradenberg testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT qualified for speech and language services under California’s regulations based upon her cumulative expressive language score on the CELF-III administered by Dr. Scholten and based on her syntax and semantics as determined from the language sample. Ms. Giraldo disagreedThe Hearing Officer notes that the debate among the experts at the hearing focused on whether STUDENT was eligible under the regulations.(Footnote 7) Petitioner did not contend that she was eligible and failed to establish that she was eligible. While the regulation defining special education eligibility based upon a speech and language disorder can be a useful guide in determining a STUDENT’s need for speech and language therapy as a related service, it is not determinative. The appropriate analysis is whether the STUDENT has a unique need which makes the provision of speech and language services necessary for the STUDENT to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b).
It is clear that STUDENT has some unique language needs. From the weight of the evidence, however, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not require speech and language services in order to benefit from her instructional program. First, many of the language concerns raised by STUDENT relate to her pragmatic skills with her peers. STUDENT’s Frostig IEP Cycle clearly indicated that her “voice, articulation, fluency and pragmatic skills were observed to be functioning within functional limits.” Second, Ms. Giraldo’s opinion that STUDENT did not require speech services was supported by the findings of several other examiners. In June 1999, Dr. Bell characterized STUDENT’s verbal skills as “generally in the average to low average range overall” with average expressive vocabulary. School psychologist Elsa Toledo characterized STUDENT’s language skills to be in the “solid average range” based upon her performance on the WIAT, with a standard score of 114 (mean=100) on the oral expression subtest and a total language composite standard score of 103. Dr. Scholten determined that there was no significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills from her comparison of the June 1999 receptive PVVT-R and the EVT which she administered.(Footnote 8) Third, the evidence persuasively established that STUDENT’s needs could be addressed in the language arts curriculum in the regular education program, in her written expression goals and by the two hours a day of services offered her through the RSP program. STUDENT had two speech and language goals at Frostig. The first was to be able to independently create multi-paragraph informative narratives that contain essential elements such as adequate details, transitional phrases and conclusions. STUDENT was able to accomplish this goal with moderate assistance. The elements of this first goal are encompassed within STUDENT’s written expression goal, that requires her to compose a three-paragraph writing that includes a clear purpose with a beginning, a middle and an end, and that uses descriptive words. Her second Frostig goal was to be able to independently interpret ambiguous language and interpret and use common forms of figurative language. The baseline for this goal indicated that STUDENT was able to use context cues and to interpret figurative language fifty percent of the time. Ms. Oyama, Ms. Billick and Ms. Giraldo testified that the use of figurative language, idioms, and slang is addressed as necessary in the classroom.
For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that speech and language services are not necessary for STUDENT to benefit from her instructional program.
B. Was the Placement at Field Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Her with Some Educational Benefit?
As previously indicated, the District offered STUDENT placement in the resource specialist program (RSP) at Field Elementary School for two periods a day, with a focus on written language and study skills. In addition, as indicated in the IEP summary notes, the IEP team also agreed to provide STUDENT forty minutes, in two weekly session, of assistance in keyboarding skills. Accommodations were itemized on the IEP and reiterated along with Ms. Halpern-O’Neal’s letter summarizing the offer. A draft transition plan to support STUDENT’s return to public school was presented and incorporated into the IEP.
The evidence established that STUDENT’s unique needs were addressed by the District’s offer in the IEP of May 15, 2000, through its goals and objectives, its modifications and accommodations, and its transition plan.
Field’s campus, resource specialist program and regular education classes were described in the testimony of its principal, Ms. Portillo, and by resource specialist teacher, Ms. Oyama. During the 1999-2000 school year, the total population at Field, from pre-school through sixth grade, was approximately 600. Field is a mid-size campus that, according to Ms. Portillo, is easily accessible to and safe for students, including physically disabled and small students. Field has two sixth grade classes and one combined fifth-sixth grade class. In May 2000, the two regular education sixth grade classes each had thirty students. There were two computers in each of these classes and there was also a computer lab. A multi-sensory approach is a mandated part of the curriculum. The regular education classes employ multi-modal instruction, with a “see it, hear it, do it” approach that includes visual presentation, lectures, hands-on work, and graphic organizers. Students often work together in cooperative learning groups. On a weekly basis, regular education teachers report to the RSP staff on current projects and class work, relevant vocabulary for that work and any concerns the teacher has for the student. This information is used for pre-teaching assignments to RSP students before the assignments are presented in the regular education class.
STUDENT’s IEP contained goals that were written for the one-year period from May 2000 to May 2001. A review of these goals indicates that they were appropriately drafted based upon current assessment data and input from Frostig to address her areas of need. In the area of written mechanics, a goal was designed to increase her ability to spell dictated words, to independently edit her written work for spelling errors using a Franklin speller, and to edit and correct a paragraph at her reading level for spelling, capitalization and punctuation errors. These goals were drafted using STUDENT’s assessment results from the Brigance, the TOWL-3 and from information from Frostig. In the area of written expression, a goal was prepared for STUDENT to compose a three-paragraph composition including a clear purpose, topic and supporting sentences, and descriptive words with appropriate writing mechanics. This goal was modified at the IEP based upon input from the team to include strategies like COPS, semantic mapping programs and computer/ultrakey use and to require that the final product be on the computer. STUDENT’s Mother testified that, in her opinion, these goals were not high enough because she expected that STUDENT could complete them by the end of the 1999-2000 school year. However, the evidence indicated that they were based upon current testing data, systematically focused on significant deficits and could be modified if achieved during the year.
STUDENT’s goals in mathematics were also appropriate. Based upon appropriate testing and current present levels of performance, three math goals were prepared in division, in converting and solving problems involving making change and in solving two- to three- step math word problems. STUDENT’s Mother testified that she believed that the math word problem goal for STUDENT was appropriate.
The evidence established that these goals could be addressed through the RSP program. Ms. Oyama testified that, during the 1999-2000 school year, she had twenty-two RSP students on her caseload, three of whom were in the sixth grade. The RSP program, either Ms. Oyama or her aide, was in the regular education classes two to four times a week. RSP services would be provided on a pull-out basis or on a collaborative basis in the regular education class. The method of delivering RSP services would be determined by the child’s needs, the parent’s desires, and the class requirements. For sixth-graders, Ms. Oyama testified that her preference is to provide RSP services in the regular education classes so that the RSP students become more familiar with the core curriculum as they prepare to transition to middle school. Pull-out services are provided according to grade or skill level. Pre-teaching is generally done on a pull-out basis for 45 to 50 minutes several times a week during study skills class. There is one computer in the RSP class that has the “Inspirations” writing program. The RSP room also has an Alpha Smarts, which she has found to be beneficial even for students with severe visual processing disorders.
As previously discussed, because STUDENT never enrolled at Field, it is not possible to determine whether she actually received educational benefit from this placement. Because the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and because the weight of the evidence established that the program could be implemented by the resource specialist staff, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
Petitioner argues that the placement at Field was not appropriate because it required STUDENT to transfer to a new program with only six weeks of the 1999-2000 school year remaining.
District witnesses testified that it was not uncommon for students to enroll in school during the last six weeks of school. To facilitate the transition of students into the school later in the year, a transition plan is generally provided. The IEP team prepared a transition plan for STUDENT’s IEP that had three essential components. First, pre-enrollment and pre-attendance activities were offered to familiarize STUDENT with the placement and her new daily schedule (i.e., STUDENT’s Mother could observe the offered RSP and the regular classes; she and STUDENT would meet school staff including the principal, dean, school counselors and special education staff to tour the campus; and a written daily schedule that would include lunch, recess, beginning and end of the day would be provided to her by the special education teacher). Second, mechanisms were provided to ensure educational consistency between Frostig and Field (i.e., Frostig would be asked to provide (1) a list of materials, text books, including the sections of texts taught, technology, and teaching techniques used so that the District could provide complementing materials, and (2) a sample of the actual daily planner and homework recorder STUDENT used). Third, mechanisms and support systems were offered to ensure STUDENT’s successful integration into the new placement (i.e., the school psychologist would collaborate with school personnel, including STUDENT’s special education teachers, to create a support network for her; a peer buddy, including daily lunch peer buddies, and peers in clubs, would be provided to support STUDENT’s adjustment and to help her make new friends; and, during lunch and recess, regular and special education school staff would be available to provide STUDENT with additional help).
The Hearing Officer acknowledges that entry into a new school late in the year is a difficult experience for any student. The Hearing Officer has previously found that STUDENT does not have any unique emotional needs which would prohibit her from attending an appropriate special education program on a larger school campus. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed transition plan is appropriately designed to provide STUDENT with support and to address the social and academic issues which she may experience as a student entering a new environment at this point in the school year.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide her with an educational benefit for the1999-2000 school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.
II. DID THE DISTRICT OFFER STUDENT A FAPE FOR
THE 2000-2001 SCHOOL YEAR?
Procedural Appropriateness(Footnote 9)
Petitioner asserts that, as a matter of law, the District did not provide her a FAPE because it failed to make any placement offer for the 2000-2001. Respondent contends that it was not required to convene a new IEP meeting for STUDENT because the May 15, 2000 IEP prepared goals and objectives for a one-year period and because matriculation to Wilson Middle School (Wilson) was clearly identified in the IEP.
“The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child.” Union School District v. Smith 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994). Such a change occurs when a child matriculates from an elementary to a middle school. The requirements of Union are not technical and should be rigorously enforced, however, a procedural violation does not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE unless it has resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
The evidence clearly established that MOTHER understood that the offer for the 2000-2001 school year was for placement in the RSP program at Wilson. The IEP notes indicated that Wilson would be STUDENT’s home school for the next school year. In addition, MOTHER’s actions in requesting to visit Wilson and in actually visiting Wilson on two separate occasions indicate that she was aware of the need to seriously consider it as a placement for STUDENT. Under these facts, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to satisfy the written prior notice requirement of the IDEA did not rise to the level of a procedural violation that constitutes a denial of FAPE.
A. STUDENT’s Unique Needs
As previously discussed, STUDENT’s unique needs arise out of her specific learning disability in the area of written language based upon her visual-processing delays. She also has unique needs in the area of mathematics. She requires a multi-sensory educational intervention. In addition, STUDENT has unique health needs in the areas of asthma, IGA immune disorder, and nutrition which the District must accommodate.
B. Was the Placement at Wilson Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Her with Some Educational Benefit?
Both MOTHER and Dr. Ferjo testified about their observation of the Wilson campus and their opinions that it was an inappropriate placement for STUDENT .
After the May 15, 2000 IEP, MOTHER arranged for and took an approximately two and a half tour of the Wilson campus with Ms. Halpern-O’Neal. During this tour, MOTHER testified that she was told there are 1,470 students on the campus. She observed the entire student body out in the yard for nutrition, buying and eating snacks. She did not recall seeing many school staff on the yard. MOTHER observed that the Wilson students were very big compared to STUDENT . Some of the students appeared to be as big as adults, sophisticated and “quite street wise.” Although she saw two boys of STUDENT’s height, they each weighed approximately thirty pounds more than she did. In MOTHER’s opinion, Wilson did not seem appropriate for STUDENT. MOTHER felt STUDENT would not make any academic progress because she would spend all her resources on just trying to get around and deal with social issues. She believed that it would be physically difficult for STUDENT to manage the Wilson campus.
In late November 2000, Dr. Ferjo toured the Wilson campus with MOTHER and Wilson’s principal, Mr. Boccia. In addition to her concerns about the size of the campus and STUDENT’s small stature, Dr. Ferjo expressed concern that several of the classes she observed were quite large. In one class, there were close to sixty students. Mr. Boccia advised her that, due to a teacher’s illness and the unavailability of a substitute, the two classes were combined that day. Dr. Ferjo also walked through and briefly observed (5 minutes) a computer class in which all students but one were playing computer games. Dr. Ferjo testified that she did not know if this was during a free time. Due to the physical size of the campus, the large number of students per class and the inappropriateness of the special day class for STUDENT, Dr. Ferjo concluded in her written report of this observation that STUDENT would have great difficulty in succeeding at Wilson. At the hearing, Dr. Ferjo testified that, because STUDENT was a “quiet, good little girl,” she was concerned about whether STUDENT would be able to receive the help she needed. In Dr. Ferjo’s opinion, it would be ideal, but not practical or likely, for the regular education teachers to implement the modifications contained in STUDENT’s IEP; i.e., to emphasize critical information or repeat instructions for her, to alter the format of assignments or to engage her in pre-writing strategies. Dr. Ferjo conceded, however, that these modifications could be implemented if a resource teacher was available to STUDENT on a regular basis.
The evidence established that the District’s placement offer for STUDENT to matriculate to Wilson for the 2000-2001 school year addressed her unique needs through its goals and objectives, its modifications and accommodations, and its transition plan.
According to its principal, Mr. Boccia, Wilson is an “International Baccalaureate (IB) School” that emphasizes academic excellence as well as community service, health, social education and experiential learning to promote student performance. Wilson received a $900,000 grant from the federal government to establish the IB program, which first began in 1999-2000. That same year, Wilson was rated the second most improved school in Los Angeles County on academic performance (API) and the sixteenth best middle school in California. The IB curriculum is coordinated with California’s curriculum content standards and requires that all teachers use multi-sensory teaching strategies: written, verbal, auditory, kinesthetic activities, including use of manipulatives.
As outlined in the testimony of Mr. Boccia and resource specialist teacher Nicole Billick, Wilson serves approximately 1,470 students from the sixth through the eighth grade. Due to its size, each grade level is divided into teams of 135 to 140 students with four core teachers. Students are then clustered into smaller groups which rotate together among the core teachers using a “block schedule.”(Footnote 10) This schedule allows more time in academics, provides less opportunity for students to be consistently tired in the same core subject each day, and reduces the amount of movement between classes. Because the students consistently rotate together, the block schedule also facilitates the formation of friendships. Seventh grade students are clustered with teams of teachers in language arts, social studies, science and math. For all classes except language arts and math, there are approximately 30 to 35 students. There are 20 students each in language arts and math class.
The majority of the seventh grade classes, as well as the resource classes and the computer labs, are located on the second floor of the main administration building. Several seventh grade classes are located in bungalows near the canteen/snack area, approximately fifty yards away. Because students are attending the same classes within their particular block, students typically walk to classes together.
As previously discussed, STUDENT’s IEP contained goals that were written for the one-year period from May 2000 to May 2001. Ms. Billick testified that there is a thirty-day review of all RSP students enrolled at Wilson to determine if the goals and objectives and the placement are appropriate for the STUDENT. If necessary, new goals would be written. The Hearing Officer concludes that these goals appropriately addressed STUDENT’s unique needs and could be modified if necessary within a reasonable time after her enrollment in the placement.
The evidence established that STUDENT’s goals could be implemented within the RSP program at Wilson. Ms. Billick testified that there are three resource specialist teachers at Wilson who work in the regular education classes with RSP students. During the 2000-2001 school year, Ms. Billick had twelve to fifteen seventh grade students on her caseload. Ms. Billick provides direct resource services in the regular education classes and she has an RSP assistant who only does push-in support in these classes. The type of RSP services provided in the regular education classes varies and includes preplanning with the teacher, collaborating on lesson plans, facilitating teaching, working with individual students, and working in small groups. Ms. Billick testified that “cooperative learning” by breaking larger classes into groups of four to five STUDENT s is used frequently in all classes. For students with nonverbal learning disorders related to visual processing, Ms. Billick uses auditory reinforcement to enhance comprehension, pre-teaching and re-teaching of materials as needed by particular students. The RSP classes have computers with the “Inspirations” pre-writing skills program.
Ms. Billick testified that she would be able to implement STUDENT’s IEP goals either by direct services in the classroom or by pull-out for remediation and extra assistance. She testified that many of the skills which are contained in STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives are also typical of the seventh grade curriculum in the regular education classes (i.e., written mechanics, written expression, and math word problems). This was also true of many of STUDENT’s 2000-2001 Frostig IEP Cycle goals. In her experience, it is not unusual to work with a student who is spelling at the fourth-grade level in the seventh grade. According to Ms. Billick, STUDENT’s functional grade ranges, as determined from her 2000-2001 Frostig IEP Cycle, are within the functional grade ranges of seventh grade Wilson RSP students.
The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Billick has had extensive experience in working with children who may need social skills development. She testified that she worked as a “friendship coordinator” for nine years at a summer camp in which she was responsible for including children with special needs and training participants to integrate, accommodate, and work as a group. At Wilson, for RSP students who are shy, Ms. Billick testified that she uses smaller group format and/or works with individual students to practice speaking confidence, to discuss conversation starters and to role-play conversations and situations students wish to try out. She has also used the peer buddy system to assist in the development of social skills and friendships with new students. As previously discussed, the transition plan outlined in the IEP would also provide STUDENT with social support.
STUDENT never enrolled at Wilson and it is therefore not possible to determine whether she actually received educational benefit from this placement. Most of the concerns raised about the appropriateness of this placement, however, were related to STUDENT’s size and medical history that were determined not to be an impediment to an otherwise-appropriate placement. Dr. Ferjo conceded that the placement could be effective with consistent support from the resource program. As a result, the Hearing Officer gives less weight to her opinion that the regular education classes at Wilson would likely not be modified to address STUDENT’s needs. Because the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and because the weight of the evidence established that the program could be implemented by the resource specialist staff, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement at Wilson was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
From the weight of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide her with an educational benefit for the 2000-2001 school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
III. DID STUDENT REQUIRE PLACEMENT AT FROSTIG SCHOOL FOR THE 2000-2001 SCHOOL YEAR IN ORDER TO RECEIVE A FAPE?
As discussed by its executive director, Dr. Bennett, Frostig emphasizes courses to enhance a student’s self-esteem by providing “affective education” classes and other enrichment activities based upon its research into factors which create successful, functioning learning disabled adults.(Footnote 11) As previously indicated, however, if a district has offered a FAPE, it is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if their preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit to the student than the program offered by the District. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307.
Because the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, it is not necessary to address this issue.
IV. IS PETITIONER ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FOR THE COST OF TUITION AT FROSTIG SCHOOL AND FOR SPEECH THERAPY SERVICES SINCE THE IEP MEETING OF MAY 15, 2000?
As discussed above, Respondent offered Petitioner a FAPE for both the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year and for the 2000-2001 school year. Consequently, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition or other services since May 15, 2000.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. On the first issue, the Respondent prevailed.
2. On the second issue, the Respondent prevailed.
3. On the third issue, the Respondent prevailed.
4. On the fourth issue, the Respondent prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: July 3, 2001 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
1.The issues listed here differ in wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis, and to reflect the discussion regarding the issues for hearing that was held on the first day of hearing between the parties and the Hearing Officer. 2.STUDENT initially asserted there were only four weeks of school remaining in the school year at the time of the offer. The parties later stipulated that the last day of 1999-2000 school was June 22, 2000, six weeks after the placement offer. 3. STUDENT had been assessed on multiple occasions less than a year before the District assessment; i.e., by Dr. Bell in June 1999, by Frostig in September 1999, and by Dr. Scholten in February 2001. Ms.Toledo, Ms. Oyama and Ms. Giraldo each testified that, as a consequence, they were not able to use test instruments that they would typically have administered to a STUDENT on an initial assessment. 4.There was conflicting testimony about who raised the issue of STUDENT’s potential retention in the sixth grade. The significance of this issue is that, if retained, STUDENT would have had another year at the smaller Field campus. If not, pursuant to the District’s offer, she would have been required to transition twice within a short period, first for six weeks at Field, and then to Wilson Middle school. STUDENT’s Mother’s testimony that she had no intention of retaining STUDENT is consistent with her two prior decisions not to retain STUDENT when it was recommended. Because she did not, in fact, retain STUDENT, it is not necessary to address this issue. 5.The PARENTS adopted STUDENT at birth.
6.Dr. Ferjo prepared a report on STUDENT entitled “Psychoeducational Assessment,” that was admitted as Petitioner’s Exhibit 19. Dr. Ferjo testified that this was not an assessment, however, but a cursory consultation. 7.It was undisputed that STUDENT’s standard deviation on the CELF-3 was -1.46 and that this low cumulative score was the result of her low score on the sentence assembly subtest. Ms. Giraldo and Ms. Vradenberg disagreed about whether the -1.46 standard deviation on the CELF-3 should be “rounded up” to a -1.5 standard deviation from the mean. Ms. Vradenberg testified that she would need to see, but would not necessarily use, the CELF-3 manual to determine whether or not to “round up” the standard deviation to -1.5. In her opinion, a -1.46 could be used either way and could be rounded up if the STUDENT appears to qualify. By contrast, Ms. Giraldo testified that the CELF-3 manual requires the standard deviations be computed to the hundredth place and does not permit “rounding up.” Where there was a borderline score such as in this case, she could make the STUDENT eligible based on an analysis of all the tests; however, even if she determine to make the STUDENT eligible, she would not round up the score because she is required to follow the manual’s protocol. In Ms. Giraldo’s opinion, STUDENT’s CELF-3 score was skewed by her poor visual processing skills that must be used to complete the sentence assembly subtest. 8.The Hearing Officer gives less weight to Ms. Vradenberg’s May 2000 report in which she made a “projection” without formal testing, that there was a discrepancy between STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills. Her opinion is contradicted by Dr. Scholten’s report and testing three months earlier. 9.Petitioner also argues that a procedural violation occurred as a result of the District’s failure to offer her an individualized service plan (ISP) as required for privately-placed STUDENT s pursuant to 34 C.F.R. § 300.452(b). Ms. Halpern-O’Neal testified that it is the District’s policy to prepare an ISP for all students with disabilities in the District who it determines are privately placed and that this is done after the IEP meeting. As indicated above, this policy was repeated to STUDENT’s Mother on numerous occasions after she declined to enroll STUDENT in the Spring of 2000, and it is undisputed that the District did not develop an ISP for STUDENT . However, special education due process procedures are inapplicable to complaints that a LEA “failed to meet the requirements of 300.452-300.462, including the provision of services indicated on a child’s service plan.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.457. Pursuant to C.F.R. § 300.452(b), this also includes the development of a service plan for such child. 10.Mr. Boccia described this schedule as a “block on a flip flop” to indicate that the schedule reverses every week. On week one, students would attend periods one, three and five on Monday and Wednesday. On Tuesday and Thursday, they would attend periods two, four and six. On Friday, they would attend all classes. The following week, students attend period five, three and one on Mondays and Wednesdays and periods six, four and two on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Friday’s schedule does not change. 11.On the last day of hearing, Respondent objected to the admissibility of Petitioner’s proposed Exhibit 22, a research article published by the Frostig Center entitled “Patterns of Change and Predictors of Success in Individuals With Learning Disabilities: Results from a Twenty-Year Longitudinal Study,” based upon Petitioner’s failure to timely offer it. Respondent was offered an opportunity to brief whether it had suffered any prejudice by the delay but did not do so. Petitioner’s Exhibit 22 is admitted.
