California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 15, 2003
Student v. Newark Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1177-03 · Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour
Newark Unified offered a FAPE to a 3-year-old with autism through a preschool SDC with in-class discrete trial training; parents' claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None. Footnote 3: on the second day of hearing, the parties resolved an issue about the 2002-2003 extended school year. Footnote 11: the student's stay put motion received October 10, 2003 was not ruled on because the decision issued.
Summary
Newark Unified School District and the parents of a three-year-old with autism both filed for due process. The cases were consolidated. The question was whether the District's May 2003 IEP offered a FAPE for 2003-2004. The child had been receiving 30 hours a week of home-based discrete trial training (DTT) from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). The parents wanted a 40-hour home program to continue until he was "ready" for school. The District offered a six-week move to a 25-hour preschool special day class (SDC) at Whiteford Preschool. Teacher Jennifer Burkholder and her aides would provide DTT. The offer also included time in a second SDC for socialization, five hours a week of in-home DTT, District speech and occupational therapy, and parent training. Hearing Officer Maxine R. Benmour found no procedural violations. The written offer was clear under Union v. Smith, and the parents took a full part in the meetings. The District changed the transition plan in response to their concerns. It had no duty to let the parents observe the class or to meet in August. Replacing Spectrum Center with District behaviorist Eric Burkholder as DTT supervisor did not change the offer. On substance, the goals matched the assessments. A special day class needs no readiness skills. The child could now handle transitions, and his behaviors had decreased. The staff were qualified, and the placement was the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 10 days to start the transition within 15 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rowley standard when a family preferred an intensive home ABA program over a district preschool. It weighed expert testimony that readiness skills are needed for general education but not for a special day class. It also held that substituting a qualified supervisor for a named agency did not require a new IEP meeting.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Did the District make a clear written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year?
The 70-page IEP named the school, teachers, classrooms, hours, schedule, supervisor and therapy minutes. The parents understood the offer and rejected it in writing, so Union's requirements were met.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did the District improperly fail to consider the input of STUDENT's parents in his IEP?
The parents, their advocate and CARD staff took an active part in the meetings, and the District changed its offer in response. There was no infringement of participation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3. Did the District improperly present a predetermined transition plan?
The District lengthened the transition period from four to six weeks and added a home-based component after hearing the parents' concerns, so the plan was not predetermined.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4. Did the District refuse to allow STUDENT's parents to observe the proposed placement?
Parents have a right to notice of the proposed placement but no legal right to observe it. The mother had also already observed the classroom during the prior year.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 5. Did the District improperly fail to schedule an IEP meeting in August 2003 despite the parents' request that it do so?
The 30-day timeline excludes July and August. The parents suffered no prejudice because the student kept receiving CARD services and the District agreed to a September meeting.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 6. Did the District improperly propose a change in the supervision of STUDENT's proposed DTT program in a letter dated August 8, 2003?
Replacing Spectrum Center with the District behaviorist (a former Spectrum Center employee) who would provide similar services did not change the offer and did not require an IEP meeting.
- Not reachedImplementation
Issue 7. Did the District offer STUDENT a program that is impossible to implement as written?
The Hearing Officer did not need to decide this issue after finding the substitution of supervisor was proper.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue a. Was the District's proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique individual needs? (goals and objectives, transition plan, Ms. Burkholder's classroom, DTT supervision, speech and language and OT services)
The goals tracked the assessments. The student could generalize skills, handle transitions, and attend an SDC despite residual behaviors. The teacher and behaviorist were qualified, and District therapists could take over services.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue b. Was the District's proposed placement reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
The SDC program with DTT, socialization, speech and OT services, plus goals in every area of need, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue c. Did the District's proposed placement comport with STUDENT's IEP?
It was undisputed that the District was willing to provide the placement and services in the May 2003 IEP.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue d. Did the District's proposed placement provide STUDENT education in the LRE?
The preschool placement offered peer interaction and group activities that the home program did not. The Rachel H. test was inapplicable because no regular class was proposed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting within 10 calendar days of the decision to change the dates of the transition plan so that the student begins his transition to school within 15 calendar days of the decision. All of the student's claims for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Honig v. Doe; Polk v. Central Susquehanna; Sacramento City USD v. Rachel H. (held inapplicable)
People named in the decision
- Leslie Koelsch, director of special education, Newark Unified School District
- Jennifer Burkholder, preschool special day class teacher, Newark Unified School District, Whiteford Preschool
- Kristina Sica, preschool special day class teacher, Newark Unified School District
- Jason Lee, speech and language therapist, Newark Unified School District
- JoAnn Perlewitz, lead preschool special day class teacher and assessor, Newark Unified School District
- Gina Wilburn, occupational therapist, Newark Unified School District
- Eric Burkholder, behaviorist (proposed DTT supervisor), Newark Unified School District
- Wilfred Lawrence Williams, expert witness for District; associate professor of psychology, University of Nevada at Reno
- Peter Bernstein, school psychologist, Newark Unified School District
- Claudia Riley, adaptive physical education teacher, Newark Unified School District
- Russ Riley, program specialist, Newark Unified School District
- Chad Graff, attorney for District at IEP meeting, Newark Unified School District
- Mila Amerine-Dickens, expert witness for Student; executive director, Central Valley Autism Project
- Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director, witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Henry Schlinger, clinical psychologist, ABA expert witness for Student
- Neha Sheth, private occupational therapist, Center for Speech, Language and Occupational Therapy (CSLOT)
- Jayne Fong, private speech and language therapist, Center for Speech, Language and Occupational Therapy (CSLOT)
- Vivian Chapman, clinic supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Jennifer Close, clinic supervisor/assessor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Rubalena Noguera, clinic supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Stephanie Martin, supervisor, nonpublic agency, Spectrum Center
- Hitomi Westfall, occupational therapy assessor
- Mary Heyward, psychologist (autism diagnostic assessment)
- Franco Carroll, service coordinator, Regional Center of the East Bay
- Jeffie Gellerman, advocate for Student at IEP meetings
- Shawn Olsen-Brown, attorney for District (first day of hearing), Miller Brown & Dannis
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Newark, California, on August 19, 21-22, 26-29, and September 9-10, 2003.
Petitioner and Cross-Respondent Newark Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget A. Flanagan of the law firm Miller Brown & Dannis. (Footnote 1) Also present on the District’s behalf was Leslie Koelsch, District director of special education. Respondent and Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Roberta S. Savage of the law firm Varma & Clancy. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were his parents, FATHER and MOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Jennifer Burkholder, District preschool special day class teacher; Kristina Sica, District preschool special day class teacher; Jason Lee, District speech and language therapist; JoAnn Perlewitz, District lead preschool special day class teacher; Gina Wilburn, District occupational therapist; Eric Burkholder, District behaviorist; Wilfred Lawrence Williams, associate professor of psychology at the University of Nevada at Reno; and Leslie Koelsch, District director of special education.
STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Mila Amerine-Dickens, executive director of the Central Valley Autism Project; Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders; Henry Schlinger, clinical psychologist; Neha Sheth, private occupational therapist; Jayne Fong, private speech and language therapist; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; and Vivian Chapman, clinic supervisor of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders. (Footnote 2) Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the District’s brief on September 19, 2003, and the Student’s brief on September 22, 2003, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 school year at individualized education program meetings held on May 13 and May 22, 2003? (Footnote 3)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a three-year-old child who is eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. He lives within the boundaries of the District with his parents and older sister.
When STUDENT was approximately eighteen months of age, his mother became concerned that he was no longer developing appropriately. He began flapping his hands when excited, wandered as though in his own world, did not play with his sister or other children, had frequent tantrums, and was not developing language skills. As a result, STUDENT’s pediatrician referred STUDENT for a speech and language evaluation at Children’s Hospital in Oakland. In July 2002, the Speech and Language Center at Children’s Hospital diagnosed STUDENT with significant deficits in expressive and receptive language development, and noted concerns regarding STUDENT’s social interactions and developmental play skills. The assessor recommended that STUDENT’s parents contact the Regional Center of the East Bay (RCEB) and that STUDENT receive individual speech and language services.
In August 2002, when STUDENT was two years and three months old, RCEB convened an individual family service program (IFSP) meeting and found STUDENT eligible for RCEB services because of his speech and language, social, and developmental deficits. The IFSP team also decided to provide STUDENT with speech and language services and to conduct further assessments in the areas of audiology, psychology, and occupational therapy (OT). STUDENT thereafter began to receive one-hour weekly sessions of speech and language therapy at the Center for Speech, Language and Occupational Therapy (CSLOT).
In September 2002, following the IFSP meeting, occupational therapist Hitomi Westfall performed an assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Westfall found that STUDENT functioned in the at-risk range in the areas of visual processing and vestibular processing and required a great deal of tactile and proprioceptive stimulation. Ms. Westfall also concluded that STUDENT had difficulty with adaptive motor responses, was at risk in the visual processing area, had some sensory processing dysfunction, and had difficulty sustaining task attention. She recommended weekly OT services.
After Ms. Westfall’s assessment, Franco Carroll, STUDENT’s service coordinator at RCEB, contacted the District regarding the possibility of District-provided services for STUDENT because RCEB had been unable to locate OT services for him. As a result, on October 11, 2002, the District convened an IFSP meeting, which included District personnel, RCEB personnel, and STUDENT’s parents. The IFSP team agreed to further assess STUDENT in the areas of health and adaptive development. The team also agreed to place STUDENT in a District preschool special day class (SDC) classroom for observation and assessment purposes. In addition, the team developed goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of expressive and receptive communication. Following the meeting, STUDENT began to attend the District’s Whiteford Preschool in Jennifer Burkholder’s SDC class for one hour per day for two days per week.
On November 4, 2002, Peter Bernstein, District school psychologist, assessed STUDENT and found him to function at low levels in communication, daily living skills, and socialization. According to Mr. Bernstein, STUDENT’s greatest area of weakness was in expressive language. Mr. Bernstein also found STUDENT to have a low probability of autism at that time.
At the same time, the District performed a variety of other assessments of STUDENT. Jason Lee, District speech and language therapist, performed an assessment in which he noted that STUDENT used gestures with very few vocalizations as his primary mode of communication. Claudia Riley, District adaptive physical education teacher, assessed STUDENT’s gross motor skills and concluded that he functioned within the normal range. In addition, Gina Wilburn, District occupational therapist, observed STUDENT and found him to demonstrate good motor planning skills and adequate fine motor skills.
With regard to his preacademic skills, Joanne Perlewitz, District special education preschool teacher, found STUDENT to be at the one-year level in language skills and to have a severe delay in oral language skills. In addition, Ms. Burkholder assessed STUDENT in the areas of communication, preacademic, perceptual/motor, emotional/social, and self-help while he was in her SDC class. She observed that STUDENT had some difficulty engaging in teacher-directed table top activities, had tantrums, bit people on occasion, did not respond consistently when his name was called, did not imitate others, used few words in the classroom, could not ride a bike or kick a ball, and generally played alone while next to other children.
On November 5, 2002, following these assessments, the IFSP team met again and agreed to provide STUDENT with one hour per week of OT at school, twice weekly speech and language therapy at school, and continued placement in Ms. Burkholder’s SDC classroom for one and one-half hours per day for four days per week. The team also agreed that RCEB would fund an additional psychological assessment to evaluate further whether STUDENT was a child with autism. In addition, the team developed goals and objectives for STUDENT in the areas of sensory motor, communication, imitation, fine motor, gross motor, preacademic, social skills, and self-help. Thereafter, STUDENT attended Ms. Burkholder’s SDC class at Whiteford Preschool, received the agreed-upon speech and language and OT services from the District, and continued to receive one hour per week of speech and language therapy at CSLOT.
After the IFSP meeting, on November 25, 2002, psychologist Dr. Mary Heyward administered the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule to STUDENT. She described him as demonstrating significant developmental delays in language and social-emotional functioning, and exhibiting frequent, brief stereotypical mannerisms associated with autism. She thus concluded that STUDENT met the diagnostic criteria for autistic disorder.
In January 2003, while STUDENT continued to attend Ms. Burkholder’s SDC class, STUDENT’s mother contacted the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) to determine if STUDENT might be eligible for their services. On January 14, 2003, Jennifer Close and Vivian Chapman, CARD clinic supervisors, assessed STUDENT and described him as having significant delays in the areas of socialization and language development. They also noted that STUDENT engaged in some repetitive and maladaptive patterns of behavior, such as hand flapping, hugging soft objects, spinning, repeatedly completing the same puzzle, having tantrums, and biting. Ms. Close and Ms. Chapman concluded that STUDENT was eligible for CARD services.
STUDENT’s IFSP team met again on February 10, 2003. At this meeting, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District terminate services for STUDENT because they had decided to enroll him in a one-on-one, home-based discrete trial training (DTT) program with CARD. In addition, the parents informed the District that STUDENT would continue to receive private speech and language services through CSLOT. RCEB had agreed to fund both the DTT and speech and language services. At the conclusion of the meeting, the team agreed to meet again on April 7, 2003, one month prior to STUDENT’s third birthday, to discuss STUDENT’s transition from his private services to District services.
Thereafter, on February 14, 2003, STUDENT began a fifteen-hour-per-week, one-on-one, home-based DTT program with CARD. Approximately one month later, CARD increased STUDENT’s hours from fifteen to thirty per week. At the time it increased his hours, CARD noted that STUDENT demonstrated major progress in the areas of communication through the use of a picture exchange communication system (PECS), verbal imitation, matching of labels and colors, block imitation, compliance, and independent play skills. CARD also noted that STUDENT continued to be significantly delayed in expressive and receptive labels, socialization, cooperative play, and self-help skills.
On April 7, 2003, the IFSP team met as agreed and decided to conduct further OT and speech and language assessments of STUDENT, to obtain copies of reports from CSLOT and CARD, and to convene an individualized education program (IEP) meeting on May 1, 2003.
On May 6, 2003, STUDENT turned three years of age. On May 13, 2003, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s placement and programming for the 2003-2004 school year. (Footnote 4) Those in attendance were STUDENT’s parents; GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT’s grandmother; Jeffie Gellerman, STUDENT’s advocate; Mr. Carroll; Dr. Koelsch; Ms. Burkholder; Ms. Perlewitz; Russ Riley, District program specialist; Ms. Wilburn; Mr. Lee; Mr. Bernstein; Ms. Chapman; Rubalena Noguera, CARD clinic supervisor; and Stephanie Martin, Spectrum Center supervisor. At the outset of the meeting, the team decided that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services on the basis of his diagnosis of autism in November 2002.
The team then discussed assessments, present levels of performance, and goals and objectives proposed by CARD in the areas of fine motor, communication, readiness, general knowledge, self-help, sensory motor, and social skills. At the end of the discussion, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District continue STUDENT in his home-based DTT program with CARD, at a thirty- to forty-hour-per-week level, until such time as the IEP team determined that he was ready to transition to a school-based setting. The District disagreed that STUDENT required this level of service and proposed a twenty-five-hour-per-week school-based program with DTT services provided by the classroom teacher and DTT supervision provided by Spectrum Center. In addition, the District proposed two thirty-minute sessions per week of speech and language and up to two hours per month of OT consultation. The District also proposed a four-week transition plan from home to school for all services. Because of the length of the meeting, the team agreed to meet again on May 22, 2003, to further discuss the issue of placement for the upcoming school year.
Following the IEP meeting on May 13, 2003, STUDENT’s parents submitted a written objection to the District’s proposed offer. The parents disagreed with the proposed twenty-five hours of DTT services for STUDENT but agreed to accept the District’s offer “as a temporary measure to prevent the complete disruption of STUDENT’s program.” In addition, they disagreed with the District’s proposed transition plan and with the use of Spectrum Center rather than CARD for supervision of STUDENT’s DTT program. In addition, the parents reiterated their belief that STUDENT requires a forty-hour-per-week, home-based, one-on-one DTT program; speech and language services of two times per week for thirty to forty minutes per session with CSLOT; OT services of one time per week of forty-five minutes per session; OT consultation with CSLOT, as needed; and autism and PECS training for the parents.
On May 22, 2003, the parties met again to finalize the IEP and to further discuss the District’s offer of placement. The same individuals attended the meeting, with the exception of the absences of GRANDMOTHER and Ms. Perlewitz. In addition, Chad Graff, an attorney for the District, and Kristina Sica, District preschool SDC teacher, attended the meeting. In response to the parents’ written objections, the District proposed a modification of its offer for the 2003-2004 school year to the following: a six-week transition period from the home-based to the school-based program, a twenty-five-hour-per-week District preschool program, primary placement in Ms. Burkholder’s preschool SDC classroom, DTT services provided by Ms. Burkholder, forty-five minutes per day in Ms. Sica’s preschool SDC classroom for socialization skills, five hours per week of an in-home District DTT tutor, two thirty-minute per week sessions of speech and language therapy in school, two thirty-minute sessions of OT per week in school, speech and language and OT consultation, and parent training on autism and PECS. (Footnote 5) The District also proposed Spectrum Center rather than CARD as the nonpublic agency to supervise STUDENT’s DTT program. At the meeting, the District representatives presented STUDENT’s parents with sample classroom schedules for Ms. Burkholder’s and Ms. Sica’s classes for the 2002-2003 school year. The District also proposed that an IEP meeting be held on October 10, 2003, to assess STUDENT’s progress at the end of the transition period, or earlier “if there is a concern during the transition period that STUDENT cannot tolerate the additional hours at school.”
On May 28, 2003, the parents submitted additional written objections to the District’s offer. They did not agree that STUDENT was ready to transition to school, and requested that an IEP meeting take place on or about August 27, 2003, to review STUDENT’s progress and current levels of functioning at that time. They also did not agree with the use of Spectrum Center rather than CARD to supervise STUDENT’s DTT program. The parents reiterated their request for a forty-hour per week, home-based, one-on-one DTT program; their agreement to transition to a school-based program “at such future date that the IEP team agrees STUDENT is ready and has developed and successfully demonstrates the necessary pre-requisite skills to benefit in a classroom setting”; and their request that speech and language and OT services continue with CSLOT rather than the District until the next IEP meeting.
On June 6, 2003, the District requested a due process hearing because it believed that the program it proposed for STUDENT in May 2003 offered him a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment. On July 24, 2003, STUDENT also requested a due process hearing because of his disagreement that the District had offered him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT disagrees that a transition plan, placement in Ms. Burkholder’s classroom, provision of twenty hours of DTT services at school, District-provided speech and language and OT services, and District-provided supervision of his DTT program provide him with a FAPE. (Footnote 6) On July 25, 2003, the Hearing Office consolidated both matters for hearing.
On August 8, 2003, Dr. Koelsch sent a letter to the parents stating that she was providing some additional information regarding the proposed program for STUDENT at Whiteford Preschool. The letter reviewed STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Burkholder’s class, where he would receive DTT services, his placement in Ms. Sica’s class for socialization opportunities, and the proposed transition plan from STUDENT’s current home program to the preschool program. The letter also stated that the District had learned that Spectrum Center was no longer going to provide in-school supervision services to school districts. Therefore, Dr. Koelsch proposed that Eric Burkholder, the District’s recently hired behaviorist, provide these services instead of Spectrum Center. Dr. Koelsch also proposed twenty hours of consultation services between Mr. Burkholder and CARD.
The hearing in this matter commenced on August 19, 2003. At the conclusion of the hearing on September 10, 2003, STUDENT was continuing to receive thirty hours per week of one-on-one, home-based DTT services from CARD pending the outcome of due process proceedings. (Footnote 7)
CONTENTIONS
STUDENT contends that the District’s offer in his IEP of May 2003 did not provide him with a FAPE because of several procedural violations. In particular, he contends that the District failed to make a clear written offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year and that it did not appropriately develop an IEP for him. In addition, he raises several concerns with regard to the substantive nature of the proposed offer. The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and that it committed no procedural violations.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2003-2004 school year at individualized education program meetings held on May 13 and May 22, 2003?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16 (1988) 853 F.2d 171, 173. The IEP, which is the “centerpiece of the [IDEA’s] education delivery system for disabled children,” consists of a detailed written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each child with a disability. 20 U.S. C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345; Honig v. Doe (1988) 484 U.S. 305. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, special education and related services, and program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to meet the child’s needs resulting from his or her disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and be educated and participate with nondisabled children to the maximum extent possible. Id.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56031, 56345.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S. (9th Cir. 1996) 82 F.3d 1493, 1500. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist. (2nd Cir. 1997) 142 F.3d 119, 130.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm. (1st Cir. 1990) 910 F.2d 983, 994.
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a child has been provided a FAPE in the LRE is generally twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps were followed and whether the proposed placement was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.
PROCEDURAL SAFEGUARDS
1. Did the District make a clear written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year?
A procedural violation that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 cert den., 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). As the Ninth Circuit stated in Union, “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced rigorously.”
The Union court further explained that a formal, written offer alerts the parents “to the need to consider seriously” whether the particular placement is appropriate under the IDEA, would allow the parents to decide whether to oppose the placement or to “accept it with the supplement of additional education services,” and would help the district to better prepare to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. Id. at 1526.
Furthermore, California law defines an educational placement as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs.” 5 California Code of Regulations § 3042.
STUDENT argues that the District’s proposed offer of placement in his IEP of May 2003 violated his procedural rights because it was not a clear, written offer of placement in accordance with the requirements of Union and Rowley. According to STUDENT, the District’s offer was improper because it allegedly lacked specific details regarding the classroom in which he would be placed and because the offer was allegedly subject to change during the school year. However, a review of the evidence reveals that the District proposed a clear, written offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year, and that the parents understood and rejected the proposed placement.
Documentary Evidence
As indicated previously, the District convened IEP meetings on May 13 and May 22, 2003, to discuss STUDENT’s proposed program for the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT’s parents, STUDENT’s advocate, STUDENT’s service coordinator at RCEB, District representatives, and representatives from CARD and Spectrum Center attended both meetings. During the course of these meetings and subsequent to the meetings, the District prepared a seventy-page IEP document.
In addition to background information regarding STUDENT and his parents, the IEP document contains STUDENT’s present levels of performance, twenty-three goals and objectives for STUDENT, an IEP team summary, an eligibility summary, copies of seven assessment reports, a compliance checklist, and thirteen pages of supplemental information. Included within the supplemental information are agendas for both meetings, a description of the parents’ request for the services that they desire for STUDENT, a brief description of STUDENT’s home program provided by CARD, the District’s proposed transition plan for STUDENT from his home-based to a school-based program, and the District’s proposed placement and schedule for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year.
With regard to the District’s proposed placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year, the IEP contains a document entitled, “Placement and Services 5/13/03 and 5/13/04.” This document states, “The district recommends placement at Whiteford Preschool.” The document then discusses the District’s proposed six-week transition plan for the upcoming school year of a shift from a thirty-hour per week home-based program to a twenty-five hour per week school-based program.
The placement and services document also states that STUDENT will receive supervision hours of his home-based program from CARD for nine hours per month during the six-week transition period. Thereafter, he will receive supervision of his school-based program from Spectrum Center, with the number of hours to be decided at an upcoming IEP meeting. With regard to speech and language and OT services, the document provides that STUDENT will receive two thirty-minute per week sessions of each from District staff beginning at the commencement of the school year. The District also agreed to provide consultation services with these providers and parent training on autism and PECS.
With respect to STUDENT’s schedule for the 2003-2004 school year, a separate District document attached to the IEP proposes the following: (1) STUDENT will begin preschool on August 27, 2003 (2) STUDENT will receive twenty-five hours of home-based DTT and five hours of school-based DTT until September 5, 2003 (3) STUDENT will receive twenty hours of home-based DTT and twelve and one-half hours of school-based DTT until September 19, 2003 (4) STUDENT will receive fifteen hours of home-based DTT and twenty hours of school-based DTT until October 3, 2003 (5) STUDENT will have snack for one-half hour per day in Ms. Sica’s classroom beginning on September 22, 2003 (6) STUDENT will receive ten hours of home-based DTT and twenty-five hours of school-based DTT until October 10, 2003 (7) STUDENT will be in Ms. Sica’s classroom for circle time for fifteen minutes per day, for snack for fifteen minutes per day, and for gross motor for fifteen minutes per day beginning on October 6, 2003 and (8) STUDENT will receive five hours per week of home-based DTT from District staff and twenty-five hours of school-based DTT after October 10, 2003, for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year.
According to the undisputed testimony, Dr. Koelsch typed both the proposed offer of placement and the proposed schedule after the meeting and thereafter sent a copy of the complete IEP packet to the parents. There is no dispute that the parents received the complete packet.
Audiotape Evidence
In addition to the written documents, a review of the audiotapes from the IEP meetings confirms the clarity of the District’s proposal. The tapes disclose that at the meeting on May 13, 2003, Dr. Koelsch informed STUDENT’s parents and advocate that the District was recommending a twenty-five-hour-per-week program at school and a transition plan from the home-based program to a school-based program that would decrease the number of hours at home and increase the number of hours at school. At the meeting, Dr. Koelsch also explained to the parents and advocate that STUDENT would be placed in a preschool SDC classroom. Following a lengthy discussion of the District’s proposal, Dr. Koelsch suggested that the parents take time to review the offer prior to the follow-up IEP meeting scheduled for May 22, 2003.
The tapes further reveal that at the meeting on May 22, 2003, the parties continued to discuss the District’s offer. STUDENT’s advocate informed the District that twenty-five hours of DTT was not intensive enough for STUDENT, and that the parents wanted to continue with private speech and language services. In response to the parents’ concerns, Dr. Koelsch agreed to increase the District’s offer from twenty-five to thirty hours per week, adding a five-hour per week in-home component, and a six-week transition period instead of a four-week period.
During the meeting on May 22, 2003, Dr. Koelsch further informed the parents that Ms. Burkholder would provide STUDENT with DTT services in her SDC classroom and that Ms. Sica would provide STUDENT with socialization opportunities in her SDC classroom. Ms. Burkholder and Ms. Sica then each described her respective classroom and gave the parents a copy of a sample schedule for the 2002-2003 school year. At the end of the meeting, Ms. Gellerman informed the District representatives that the parents could not agree to the District’s proposed transition plan because they did not believe that STUDENT was ready to attend school.
Witness Testimony
Finally, the testimony of witnesses at the hearing further corroborates the specifics of the District’s proposed offer at the IEP meetings. MOTHER testified that during the IEP meetings, she understood that the District offered Ms. Burkholder’s class, and that, at the second meeting, the District changed its offer to a six-week transition plan and to a thirty-hour per week program, including a five-hour home component. She also testified that the parties discussed the fact that Ms. Burkholder would provide DTT services, and that STUDENT would be in Ms. Sica’s class for socialization purposes. Ms. Burkholder, Ms. Wilburn, and Ms. Chapman all corroborated this testimony regarding the District’s offer.
Parents’ Written Response
Following the meetings, the parents submitted a written “Parent Addendum To The IEP Document Drafted By District.” In this document, the parents demonstrated their understanding of the District’s proposed offer in that they stated that they did not agree with the District’s proposal of twenty-five hours per week, the transition plan, or supervision by Spectrum Center. With regard to speech and language services, the parents stated that they desired to continue with CSLOT.
Findings
The IEP documents, testimony, and tapes of the meetings demonstrate that STUDENT’s parents understood that, for the 2003-2004 school year, the District was offering STUDENT a six-week transition plan from his home-based to a school-based program, a twenty-five hour per week District preschool program, primary placement in Ms. Burkholder’s preschool SDC classroom, DTT services provided by Ms. Burkholder, forty-five minutes per day in Ms. Sica’s preschool SDC classroom for socialization skills, five hours per week of an in-home District DTT tutor, supervision of the DTT program by Spectrum Center, two thirty-minute per week sessions each of speech and language therapy and OT in school, speech and language and OT consultation, and parent training on autism and PECS.
STUDENT’s argument that the District’s offer was improper because it lacked specific details regarding his program and was subject to change during the school year is not supported by the evidence. As indicated above, the offer explicitly includes the number of hours of home and school programming, the names of the teachers, the location of the classrooms, a proposed daily schedule, the supervisor of his program, and the amount of time in speech and language and OT.
The overwhelming evidence indicates that the District’s offer described the school, the classroom, the personnel, and the type of services that it would provide to STUDENT. The fact that it did not describe the detailed manner in which Ms. Burkholder would perform DTT drills does not render the offer invalid as such detail is not required by Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3042. In fact, MOTHER testified that she understood at the second IEP meeting that Ms. Burkholder would provide DTT services using ABA methodology. In addition, the fact that the program was “subject to change” at a future IEP meeting does not render it unclear at the time of the proposal. At the time of the proposal, the offer fully described the placement so that STUDENT’s parents could seriously consider whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA, and whether to oppose the placement or to “accept it with the supplement of additional education services.” In addition, the offer was sufficiently detailed so that the District was able to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. Union, 15 F.3d 1519 at 1526.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District met the Union court’s requirement that a formal written offer of placement be communicated to the parents. The District formally offered STUDENT a placement and put its proposed placement in writing, as required by Union. As is evident from discussions at the IEP meetings, the parents fully understood what the District was offering STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. Moreover, the parents confirmed their understanding of the offer by lodging a written dissent following the meetings. In summary, the District’s proposed offer did not cause STUDENT to lose educational opportunity and did not seriously infringe on the parents’ right to participate in the IEP process. Therefore, the District did not commit any procedural violations as a result of its proposed offer.
2. Did the District improperly fail to consider the input of STUDENT’s parents in his IEP?
California Education Code section 56342.5 provides that districts shall ensure that, “the parent of each individual with exceptional needs is a member of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of the individual with exceptional needs.” In addition, early education programs for children with exceptional needs between the ages of three and five must include active parental involvement. Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.
STUDENT argues that the District failed to consider his parents’ input at the IEP meetings held in May 2003. According to STUDENT, although his parents attended both meetings with an advocate, and expressed their concerns at the meetings, the District failed to consider those concerns because it filed for due process hearing after the meetings rather than reconvening an IEP meeting in August 2003, prior to the commencement of the 2003-2004 school year.
It is undisputed that both of STUDENT’s parents attended both IEP meetings in May 2003; attended the meetings with an advocate, STUDENT’s RCEB service coordinator, and two CARD supervisors; and submitted a written dissent to the District’s proposed placement. It is also undisputed that, after the first meeting, the District modified its offer to provide a five-hour-per-week home-based program and a six-week rather than a four-week transition plan.
A review of the audiotapes from the IEP meetings reveals that Ms. Gellerman, STUDENT’s advocate, asked many questions of District participants, made numerous comments throughout both meetings, informed the District that the parents would not accept fewer than thirty hours and that they did not believe that STUDENT was ready for school at that time, questioned the qualifications of the teachers to whom STUDENT would be assigned, and expressed her opinion that students in Ms. Burkholder’s class were not appropriate peers for STUDENT. In addition, Ms. Chapman, STUDENT’s CARD supervisor, discussed STUDENT’s CARD program and explained her recommendation that STUDENT needed forty hours of DTT services and that he was not yet ready for school. Dr. Koelsch confirmed the parents’ input at the meetings, stating that Ms. Gellerman “did most of the talking” for the parents.
The evidence in this matter reveals that the parents were members of the IEP team and active participants in all program and placement discussions regarding STUDENT. In fact, when the IEP team reconvened on May 22, 2003, the District had agreed to increase the time of the transition plan and to add a five-hour home-based DTT program as a result of the parents’ expressed concerns. The evidence thus indicates that STUDENT’s parents were active participants in all program and placement discussions.
In sum, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the parents’ participation in the IEP process was not infringed upon nor did the actions of the District result in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations on this basis.
3. Did the District improperly present a predetermined transition plan?
The law imposes on school districts an obligation to ensure that parents of a child with a disability are members of any group that makes decisions about the educational placement of their child, but allows school district personnel to engage in preparatory activities to develop a proposal that will be discussed at later IEP meetings. 34 C.F.R. § 300.501(c)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.510(b)(2).
STUDENT contends that, although the District has the right to develop a proposal prior to an IEP meeting, in this case it went beyond that right by refusing to modify or adjust the transition plan despite input from his parents. STUDENT argues that the District’s “overall goal” was to remove him from his CARD program and for that reason, did not consider the parents’ input regarding the transition plan.
As discussed above, the District did not deny STUDENT’s parents the right to participate in the IEP meetings. Their participation included extensive comments and questioning from STUDENT’s advocate, extensive discussion of his CARD program by Ms. Chapman, and their written dissent following the meetings. The Hearing Officer is also persuaded by the undisputed evidence that the District modified its offer to extend the length of the transition period and to offer a home-based program in response to the parents’ concerns. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District did consider the parents’ input regarding STUDENT’s transition plan. The fact that the parents disagreed with the District’s proposed transition plan, and believed that STUDENT was not yet ready for school, does not indicate that the District did not consider their concerns.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the parents’ participation in the IEP process was not infringed upon nor did the actions of the District result in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations by presenting a predetermined transition plan.
4. Did the District refuse to allow STUDENT’s parents to observe the proposed placement?
STUDENT also argues that the District denied his parents’ right to be actively involved in the development of his program by allegedly refusing to allow them to observe its proposed placement. However, he cites no authority for his contention that his parents have a right to observe a proposed placement. As discussed previously, his parents have the right to proper notice of the District’s proposed placement but no legal right to actually observe the placement. Union, 15 F.3d 1519 at 1526.
In any event, the Hearing Officer notes that it is undisputed that MOTHER observed Ms. Burkholder’s classroom during the 2002-2003 school year when STUDENT was in her class. The undisputed evidence reveals that during the time that STUDENT attended Ms. Burkholder’s class from November 2002 until February 2003, MOTHER took him to school almost everyday and stayed with him most of the time. During this time, MOTHER had the opportunity to observe Ms. Burkholder’s classroom.
The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District’s alleged refusal to allow STUDENT’s parents to observe the proposed placement did not seriously infringe upon the rights of his parents nor did it result in the loss of educational opportunity to him. Therefore, this alleged refusal did not amount to a procedural violation.
5. Did the District improperly fail to schedule an IEP meeting in August 2003 despite the parents’ request that it do so?
An IEP team shall meet whenever a parent or teacher requests a meeting to develop, review, or revise an IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(c). In addition, a meeting of an IEP team requested by a parent to review an IEP shall be held within thirty days of the parent’s written request, not counting days in July and August. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5.
STUDENT argues that, during the IEP meetings in May, the District improperly scheduled an IEP meeting to review his transition plan for October 10, 2003. Instead, according to STUDENT, the District should have scheduled the meeting for August 2003 pursuant to the parents’ request that it do so.
A review of the IEP from May 2003 reveals that the District’s written proposed placement and services for STUDENT states that an IEP meeting will be held on October 10, 2003, at the end of the transition period. The document also provides, “Any IEP team member may call for an IEP meeting if there is a concern during the transition period that STUDENT cannot tolerate the additional hours at school.” In addition, the parents’ written dissent declares, “The parents do not agree to the transition as outlined by the District to take place commencing 8/27/03 and instead request now that an IEP meeting be scheduled on or around that date to review STUDENT’s progress and current levels of functioning in the program.”
Dr. Koelsch testified that she did not convene an IEP meeting in August because no legal mandate requires this and because staff are not available in August. Both she and MOTHER also testified that the District indicated that it would schedule an IEP meeting for September, but that meeting had not yet been scheduled because the District was awaiting information from the parents regarding the availability of Ms. Chapman, who recently suffered the death of her father.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to schedule an IEP meeting for August 2003 did not infringe upon the rights of STUDENT’s parents nor did it result in the loss of educational opportunity to him. As indicated above, the District has no legal obligation to schedule IEP meetings during July and August. Moreover, since both parties filed for due process, and STUDENT continues to receive CARD services, the parents suffered no prejudice as a result of not having a meeting with the IEP team during August. Moreover, it is undisputed that the District agreed to schedule a meeting for September instead of October.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the parents’ participation in the IEP process was not seriously infringed upon nor did the actions of the District result in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District’s failure to schedule an IEP meeting during August 2003 did not amount to a procedural violation.
6. Did the District improperly propose a change in the supervision of STUDENT’s proposed DTT program in a letter dated August 8, 2003?
The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when an educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child and the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Furthermore, under California Education Code section 56340, a school district is required to convene and conduct meetings for the purpose of developing, reviewing, and revising IEPs of each individual with exceptional needs. No authority permits a school district to develop, review, or revise a child’s IEP without the benefit of an IEP team meeting.
The undisputed evidence reveals that the District sent STUDENT’s parents a letter dated August 8, 2003, which provides “some additional information regarding the proposed program for STUDENT at Whiteford Preschool and includes some additional components to the IEP offer.” The three-page letter from Dr. Koelsch summarizes the offer made at the IEP meetings and notifies the parents that Spectrum Center, the supervision agency that was to provide in-school DTT supervision for STUDENT, is no longer able to provide these services. Dr. Koelsch instead proposes that Eric Burkholder, its newly hired behaviorist, provide the supervision services that were to be provided by Spectrum Center.
STUDENT contends that the letter from Dr. Koelsch is an improper revision of his IEP because it “was written without input by STUDENT’s parents or any District staff,” and because it “introduces a new service and service provider to STUDENT’s team without an IEP meeting.” The Hearing Officer must thus decide whether or not the District has improperly proposed a revision to STUDENT’s IEP without convening an IEP meeting.
The IEP of May 2003 states that in-school supervision of STUDENT’s DTT program during the transition period is to be provided by Spectrum Center. The document further states that in-school supervision after the transition period is “TBD [to be decided] at IEP meeting. Spectrum assumes responsibility.”
A review of the audiotapes from the IEP meeting of May 22, 2003, reveals that Stephanie Martin from Spectrum Center described the typical supervision program that her agency provides for children with autism. She explained that in a typical start-up program, the supervisor observes the child in different environments, considers reports from pertinent people in the child’s life, obtains documents from other agencies for baseline information, develops a program based upon the child’s current needs and skill levels, identifies the appropriate methodology to be used, supervises the program, and meets with the team to determine the future of ongoing supervision. She also described Spectrum Center as a behavioral organization that utilizes ABA methodology as well as other behavioral techniques.
In addition, Mr. Burkholder testified at the hearing regarding his background and the supervision program that he would provide for STUDENT. (Footnote 8) He stated that he has a master’s degree in behavioral analysis and is currently a Ph.D. candidate in behavioral analysis at the University of Nevada at Reno. He described his experience supervising DTT programs and other ABA programs, as well as his experience in working with adults and children with autism and other developmental disabilities. He also described his supervisory role with STUDENT as an internal consultant who would work with CARD regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance, work with STUDENT on needed skills in a variety of settings, train and provide oversight to staff working with STUDENT, ensure a smooth and consistent transition from STUDENT’s home program to the new school program, engage in frequent data reviews, and observe STUDENT’s behavior during the process.
In comparing the descriptions of Ms. Martin and Mr. Burkholder, the Hearing Officer finds that the substitution of Mr. Burkholder for Spectrum Center does not constitute a revision of STUDENT’s IEP requiring the District to convene an IEP meeting. Initially, the evidence reveals that the District proposed Spectrum Center as the entity that would provide supervision services, but did not name an individual person from that organization who would actually provide the services. Secondly, the Hearing Officer notes that Mr. Burkholder formerly worked at Spectrum Center as an assistant director, a senior clinician, and an educational coordinator. Finally, Ms. Martin and Mr. Burkholder described similar activities that each would undertake in order to provide DTT supervision to STUDENT. Each described observations of STUDENT, developing a program based upon STUDENT’s present levels of performance and needed skills, providing ongoing supervision to team members, working with STUDENT in a variety of environments, and reviewing information from other agencies. Moreover, both are familiar with ABA methodology and other behavior strategies for working with children with autism.
As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer found that in May 2003, the District made a specific offer to the parents of DTT supervision for STUDENT during the transition period and during the 2003-2004 school year. The evidence also establishes that the District did not specify an individual to provide the supervision, Mr. Burkholder previously worked for the agency proposed by the District at the IEP meetings, and both individuals indicated that they would provide similar supervision services to STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposal to substitute Mr. Burkholder for Spectrum Center did not constitute a change in its offer regarding supervision of STUDENT’s DTT program. The Hearing Officer thus finds that the District’s letter of August 8, 2003, did not amount to a procedural violation that resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or that seriously infringed upon his parents’ right to participate in the IEP process.
7. Did the District offer STUDENT a program that is impossible to implement as written?
STUDENT contends that the District is unable to implement the program it offered in his IEP in May 2003, because Spectrum Center is no longer available to perform the proposed supervision services. However, in light of the Hearing Officer’s finding that the District appropriately substituted Eric Burkholder for Spectrum Center as supervisor of his DTT program, there is no need to make a finding regarding this issue.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with the procedural safeguards of the IDEA and State law and committed no procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.
SUBSTANTIVE REQUIREMENTS
As discussed above, in addition to the procedural requirements of the IDEA and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a substantive FAPE that is reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit. However, a school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 198-200. To determine whether the District substantively offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist. (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1314. If the District’s proposed program would have addressed STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comported with his IEP, and provided for education in the least restrictive environment, then the District offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314.
Therefore, when taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s Rowley decision require that an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet the unique needs of the student, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, (3) conform to the student’s IEP, and (4) provide for education in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188.
a. Was the District’s proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique individual needs?
What Are STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
As stated above, the Hearing Officer must initially determine if the District’s offer in May 2003 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2003-2004 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must first determine what STUDENT’s unique needs are. The parties do not dispute that STUDENT has autism. They also do not dispute that STUDENT’s general areas of deficits are in the areas of communication, socialization, general knowledge/readiness, self-help, sensory motor, and fine motor. There is also no dispute that STUDENT requires special instruction in order to address his unique needs. The only dispute relates to the type of instruction that he requires.
Therefore, on the basis of the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has unique needs in the areas of communication, socialization, general knowledge/readiness, self-help, sensory motor, and fine motor.
Is the District’s Proposed Placement Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
It must next be determined if the District’s proposed placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas identified above. STUDENT contends that the proposed placement was not designed to meet his unique needs because the District did not develop goals and objectives based upon his assessments, he is not yet ready to transition to school as he has not learned to generalize the skills needed for a preschool setting, he has not learned to transition well from one activity to another, and he has a number of aberrant behaviors that need to be extinguished before he can be successful in a preschool classroom. STUDENT also contends that, even if a preschool placement is appropriate for him, Ms. Burkholder’s classroom is not appropriate as she is not qualified to provide him with DTT services. In addition, he argues that District-provided supervision of his DTT program is not appropriate. He further asserts that the District’s proposed placement is not designed to meet his unique needs in the areas of speech and language and OT services because he is not able to transition from his privately provided speech and language and OT services to District providers. The Hearing Officer will address each of STUDENT’s contentions below.
Goals and Objectives
As discussed above, an IEP is a written statement developed in an IEP meeting that must include, among other items, measurable annual goals and objectives related to meeting the student’s needs that result from his or her disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2).
In this case, STUDENT disputes the appropriateness of the goals and objectives developed by his IEP team. According to STUDENT, since the District utilized the goals and objectives developed by CARD, rather than developing its own goals and objectives prior to the IEP meetings, the goals and objectives are improper and not in accordance with his assessments. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must review the goals and objectives and the assessments to determine if the goals and objectives relate to STUDENT’s needs as identified in the various assessments.
A review of STUDENT’s IEP from May 2003 reveals that the IEP team developed twenty-three goals for STUDENT in the areas of general knowledge/readiness, self-help, sensory motor, fine motor, communication, and social skills.
In the area of general knowledge/readiness skills, the eight goals developed for STUDENT include matching thirty objects and pictures, independently transitioning from one activity to another, following one-step directions, building a block structure, identifying colors, receptively identifying body parts, making eye contact, and increasing time on task. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals and objectives sufficiently cover STUDENT’s needs as identified in the Children’s Hospital assessment in which STUDENT exhibited deficits in developmental play, a limited attention span, reduced eye contact, and limited ability to follow directions; Dr. Heyward’s assessment in which STUDENT exhibited repetitive and stereotyped behaviors and was unable to sustain participation during structured activities; Ms. Perlewitz’s assessment in which STUDENT scored below age level in body parts, colors, quantitative concepts, directional concepts, verbal directions, and block tower building; Ms. Burkholder’s assessment that STUDENT had difficulty sitting for teacher-directed activities and had tantrums during certain activities; the CARD assessment that identified STUDENT as having difficulty with transitions; and Ms. Westfall’s OT assessment in which STUDENT exhibited difficulty sustaining attention to task
In the area of self-help skills, the two goals developed for STUDENT include independently feeding himself and independently dressing himself. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals and objectives sufficiently cover STUDENT’s needs as identified in Dr. Bernstein’s assessment that STUDENT scored moderately low in daily living skills and adaptive behavior; Ms. Perlewitz’s assessment that STUDENT exhibited deficits in undressing, dressing, unfastening, toileting, and bathing; and CARD’s assessment that STUDENT had delayed self-help skills in the areas of toileting, dressing, and eating.
In the area of sensory motor skills, the two goals developed for STUDENT include engaging in imposed sensory motor movement to increase postural stability and endurance, and using a variety of tactile mediums. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals and objectives sufficiently cover STUDENT’s needs as identified in Ms. Westfall’s OT assessment that STUDENT required a great deal of tactile and proprioceptive stimulation, required periodic rest breaks as a result of low endurance and reduced postural stability, and had some sensory processing dysfunction; and Ms. Wilburn’s OT assessment in which STUDENT exhibited sensory processing difficulties that affected his tactile systems and sensory dysfunction, primarily within the proprioceptive and vestibular systems.
In the area of fine motor skills, the four goals developed for STUDENT include imitation of drawing with a crayon, using a tripod grasp to hold a pencil or crayon when coloring or writing, copying or writing four upper case letters, and coloring inside simple shapes. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals and objectives sufficiently cover STUDENT’s needs as identified in Ms. Burkholder’s assessment in which STUDENT exhibited difficulties with cutting paper and coloring; and Ms. Perlewitz’s assessment in which STUDENT scored below age level in prehandwriting and cutting with scissors.
In the area of communication skills, the three goals developed for STUDENT include spontaneously requesting thirty-five preferred items, identifying twenty objects correctly, and producing ten simple/functional words with or without visual support. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals and objectives sufficiently cover STUDENT’s needs as identified in the Children’s Hospital assessment that found STUDENT to demonstrate significant delays in all areas of communication; Dr. Heyward’s assessment in which STUDENT exhibited deficits in the area of communication; Dr. Bernstein’s assessment in which STUDENT scored moderately low in the areas of receptive and written communication and low in the area of expressive communication; Ms. Perlewitz’s assessment that STUDENT exhibited his greatest deficits in the areas of prespeech receptive language, prespeech gestures, prespeech vocalization, and general speech and language development; Mr. Lee’s speech and language assessment that found STUDENT to have significantly delayed expressive and receptive language skills; Ms. Burkholder’s assessment that STUDENT did not respond consistently when his name was called, did not imitate vocalizations, and used few words in the classroom; and the CARD assessment that found STUDENT to demonstrate significantly delayed expressive and receptive language skills.
In the area of social skills, the four goals developed for STUDENT include setting up ten play activities, waving and using a verbal approximation of “hi” and “bye,” engaging in turn-taking activities, and imitating three-step actions in various settings. The Hearing Officer finds that these goals and objectives sufficiently cover STUDENT’s needs as identified in Dr. Heyward’s assessment that diagnosed STUDENT with autism in part on the basis of STUDENT’s deficits in reciprocal social interaction; Dr. Bernstein’s finding that one of STUDENT’s greatest areas of weakness was in socialization skills; Ms. Perlewitz’s assessment that STUDENT exhibited deficits in general social and emotional development and play skills and behaviors; the CARD assessment that found STUDENT to exhibit maladaptive behaviors and limited social interactions; and Ms. Burkholder’s assessment that STUDENT generally played alone.
Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that IEP team developed goals and objectives that are appropriate for STUDENT and address his needs as identified in his assessment reports. In sum, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above evidence that the proposed goals and objectives are designed to meet his unique needs.
Transition Plan
1. Ability to Generalize Skills
STUDENT contends that, although he has learned a number of skills in his DTT sessions at home with his CARD therapist, he is not yet ready to transition to a preschool because he has not yet learned to generalize these skills to a preschool setting. However, a review of the evidence does not support his contention.
Ms. Chapman, STUDENT’s CARD supervisor, testified that she has observed STUDENT for a total of twenty to twenty-five hours and has attended twenty-four hours of clinic meetings involving STUDENT. She testified that STUDENT has been doing well in his controlled environment, but that he continues to require work at home until he can generalize the skills that he has learned to multiple environments. Ms. Chapman further testified that STUDENT will not be ready to transition to a preschool classroom until he learns compliance, follows one- and two-step directions, maintains attention, transitions between activities, and learns to generalize skills. However, Ms. Chapman acknowledged that these prerequisite skills apply to transitions to regular education classrooms, as a child in special education requires no prerequisite skills.
Dr. Henry Schlinger, an ABA specialist hired by STUDENT’s parents to observe STUDENT and review his program, testified that he reviewed STUDENT’s exhibit file, spoke with STUDENT’s parents on numerous occasions, spoke with STUDENT’s CARD supervisor, and observed STUDENT in two sessions with his CARD therapists at his home. Similarly to Ms. Chapman, Dr. Schlinger testified that STUDENT will not be ready to transition to a preschool classroom until he demonstrates skills that would allow him to generalize from his home-based program to a school environment. However, Dr. Schlinger acknowledged that he based this opinion upon a study in which children transitioned from intensive programs into regular education programs and not into special education programs.
In addition, STUDENT’s parents hired Mila Amerine-Dickens, director of the Central Valley Autism Project, to observe STUDENT and review his program. Ms. Amerine-Dickens testified that she observed STUDENT in his home program for one and one-half hours on the morning of her testimony. In her opinion, a child is ready for a regular education classroom when he or she can answer simple questions, is toilet trained, has simple play skills, and attends to the teacher. However, with regard to special education classrooms, she conceded that a child may attend school although he or she is nonverbal and may require a different program from a child in regular education.
In contrast to STUDENT’s witnesses, Ms. Burkholder, Mr. Burkholder, and Ms. Perlewitz all testified that a child does not need any prerequisite skills to attend a preschool SDC class. According to Ms. Perlewitz and Mr. Burkholder, SDC preschool teachers instruct the children in everything that they need to learn, including basic skills such as toilet training, attending, and sitting. By contrast, they testified that in regular education classrooms, children need to begin school with certain skills because teachers do not have the time to teach these readiness skills. In addition, Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director of CARD, testified that a child placed in a classroom with an aide requires fewer readiness skills because of the assistance of the aide.
On the basis of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the testimony of Ms. Chapman, Dr. Schlinger, Ms. Amerine-Dickens, and Dr. Granpeesheh regarding prerequisite, generalization skills needed for preschool does not contradict the testimony of the District witnesses. All witnesses agree that STUDENT’s ability to generalize from his home program to a school program requires different skills depending upon whether the transitioning school program is in regular education or special education. In light of the fact that the District’s offer of placement is for an SDC classroom rather than a regular education classroom, and that STUDENT will be assisted by classroom aides, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed transition plan is designed to meet his unique needs in the area of generalization of skills to a preschool program.
2. Ability to Transition From One Activity to Another
STUDENT further contends that the District’s proposed transition plan is not designed to meet his unique needs because he has not yet developed the ability to transition from one activity to another and is thus not ready to attend school. However, a review of the evidence reveals that STUDENT has in fact learned to transition between activities.
Ms. Chapman testified that for the first two months of his DTT therapy STUDENT was “very clingy” to his mother in the therapy room and had difficulty transitioning from his mother to the therapy chair and from activity to activity. However, despite “lots of resistance,” STUDENT has learned to fade from his mother and to become more independent. STUDENT currently comes to the therapy chair on his own and waits for his therapist to join him.
In addition, both Ms. Amerine-Dickens and Dr. Schlinger testified that in their observations of STUDENT, he had learned to transition well. According to Ms. Amerine-Dickens, although STUDENT sometimes required repetition or a tap on the arm, he transitioned well between activities. Dr. Schlinger described STUDENT’s transition from table time to frequent breaks as excellent. According to Dr. Schlinger, when STUDENT had to move from one session to a second session, he moaned and refused a little but then was fine. He described STUDENT as similar to a nondisabled three-year-old child with regard to his ability to transition.
STUDENT’s speech and language and OT therapists also testified regarding STUDENT’s ability to transition. Neha Sheth, STUDENT’s occupational therapist at CSLOT, testified that she has been STUDENT’s therapist since June of this year. Ms. Sheth testified that transitions are difficult for STUDENT, especially the transition from his mother to her. However, she also stated that she believes that STUDENT could successfully transition to a District therapist, particularly one such as Ms. Wilburn who had previously worked with STUDENT for four months. In addition, Mr. Lee, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist for four months at Whiteford Preschool, testified that STUDENT had no problems transitioning from the classroom to his speech and language sessions.
Jane Fong, STUDENT’s CSLOT speech and language therapist, also testified that STUDENT transitioned to her from a previous therapist at CSLOT in early June 2003 with only one co-therapy session to ease the transition. She described STUDENT as able to transition to her as his new therapist, but that he had difficulty transitioning from speech and language to OT after the therapists changed his schedule. However, this problem resolved itself when STUDENT adjusted to the new schedule after only a few sessions. Ms. Fong recommended that, with an observation period of one or two sessions, STUDENT would be able to transition to a new therapist with no difficulty.
Furthermore, District occupational therapist Ms. Wilburn worked with STUDENT from November 2002 until February 2003, and described him as having no problems with transitions from OT to speech and language sessions and from his classroom to OT sessions. Ms. Wilburn also suggested at least two co-treatment sessions so that STUDENT would feel comfortable during a transition between therapists.
With regard to his ability to transition, MOTHER testified that STUDENT always whined when he had to go from the parking lot to the school building when he attended Whiteford Preschool. She further testified that he currently has difficulty transitioning from home to CSLOT, and that it took STUDENT almost the entire summer to become used to his CSLOT therapists. She also stated that he still whines some before CARD sessions but not very often. Moreover, she agreed with Ms. Sheth that STUDENT could transition from CSLOT therapists to District therapists if offered co-treatment sessions to ease the transition.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has made great strides in his ability to transition since the time that he began DTT sessions with CARD. Although he may have had difficulties when he attended Whiteford Preschool and when he started with his CSLOT therapists, the overwhelming testimony from the witnesses who have either worked with him or observed him establishes that he is currently able to transition between activities and between service providers very well. Therefore, the District’s proposed transition plan is designed to address his unique needs in the area of transitioning between activities and between service providers.
3. Aberrant Behaviors
Finally, STUDENT contends that the District’s proposed transition plan is not designed to meet his unique needs because he cannot transition to preschool until he extinguishes aberrant behaviors, such as having tantrums, biting, flopping on the floor, hand flapping, and vomiting. However, the evidence in this area also does not support STUDENT’s contention.
Ms. Chapman testified that STUDENT’s tantrums had decreased from thirty minutes or more per session when she first began to work with him to currently thirty seconds per session. His most recent tantrum was a one-minute tantrum during a six-hour day. She further testified that STUDENT continues to exhibit hand flapping when he gets excited, a behavior that is difficult to extinguish because it is self-stimulatory. However, she described STUDENT as much improved in the area of self-stimulatory behavior. Although STUDENT’s mother told her that STUDENT bites his sister, she testified that she never observed him biting someone.
Dr. Schlinger corroborated the testimony of Ms. Chapman in that he observed no tantrums, no biting, no flopping on the floor, no vomiting, a little bit of hand flapping, and no other behaviors during his observation of STUDENT. Dr. Schlinger also testified that hand flapping is not an easy behavior to extinguish.
Ms. Sheth testified that STUDENT has cried and had tantrums during her sessions with him. However, during tantrums, she observed that he made sure that she was watching during a tantrum. She attributed his tantrums to the fact that her sessions with him were in the afternoon and that he was tired from his busy schedule. She also testified that this happened only two or three times during the time that she worked with STUDENT. On the other hand, Mr. Lee did not observe any aberrant behaviors during his sessions with STUDENT. He described STUDENT as very attentive, sitting in a chair, enjoying the sessions, and being interested in the activities.
Ms. Fong testified that, when she first began to work with STUDENT, he cried and threw himself on the floor during sessions. In spite of this behavior, his crying behavior had stopped a couple of weeks before the time of her testimony. He now responds positively when she tells him to stop crying and to sit on a chair.
Ms. Wilburn also testified that STUDENT’s aberrant behaviors with her included dropping to the ground, pretending to be asleep on the floor, and flapping his hands. She was able to diminish his dropping to the ground and pretending to be asleep behaviors by starting her session with a preferred activity. However, when she observed STUDENT at home during a DTT session, STUDENT had a tantrum during which he hit his head and feet on the floor for a couple of minutes and also flapped his hands for a few seconds during either stressful situations or free time.
MOTHER similarly described her son as having a lot of tantrums in October 2002, banging his head often, throwing himself against beds and pillows, and vomiting occasionally. When he became angry, he used to grab a group of books and throw them on the floor but no longer does this. Currently, he flaps his hands when he watches television and gets excited. According to his mother, he still has tantrums at home when he does not get what he wants but has improved greatly in his behaviors since he began the CARD program.
On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has made a great deal of improvement in his aberrant behaviors since the time that he began DTT sessions with CARD. Although he has engaged in inappropriate behaviors, the overwhelming testimony from everyone who has either worked with him or observed him is that his behaviors have decreased significantly so that he currently has very few behaviors, such as occasional brief tantrums and some hand flapping, which is hard to extinguish. Moreover, on the basis of the finding above that STUDENT does not need the same prerequisite skills for an SDC classroom as he does for regular education, these occasional behaviors would not preclude his attendance in a preschool classroom. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed transition plan is designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of extinguishing his behaviors.
Ms. Burkholder’s Classroom
STUDENT contends that the District’s proposed placement in Ms. Burkholder’s preschool SDC class is not appropriate to address his educational needs because Ms. Burkholder does not have the ability to develop and implement an intensive program for him, and because she is unable to appropriately collect and record data regarding his DTT program.
Ms. Burkholder testified that she has a B.A. degree from the University of Nevada at Reno with a major in psychology and an emphasis on ABA methodology. She has an emergency teaching credential and is currently enrolled in a dual teaching internship and an M.A. program in early childhood education at California State University, San Francisco. (Footnote 9) She testified that she completed a class in ABA methodology and a field experience in a center-based program for children with autism. She has also taken a six-week training seminar in DTT techniques and autism, observing and working with two children with autism. In addition, she has implemented and developed a DTT program for adults with profound disabilities.
Ms. Burkholder further testified that she is currently in her second year as a preschool SDC teacher at Whiteford Preschool. Prior to her two years with the District, she taught for one year at Hayward Unified School District in a class with thirteen children with disabilities, half of whom were on the autism spectrum. During that year, she developed DTT programs for the children with autism. She testified that during the 2002-2003 school year, she had one student in her class of six children at Whiteford Preschool for whom she provided a DTT program.
With regard to Ms. Burkholder’s ability to provide a DTT program for STUDENT, Dr. Koelsch testified that she is very pleased with Ms. Burkholder’s ability to work with children and with her knowledge of DTT techniques. In addition, Dr. Wilfred Williams, associate professor in the department of psychology at the University of Nevada at Reno, testified that he has known Ms. Burkholder since approximately 1997, taught her in several undergraduate psychology classes, and worked with her on research projects. Dr. Williams testified that he has great confidence in Ms. Burkholder’s ability to make the right decisions in designing DTT programs.
On the basis of the undisputed evidence regarding Ms. Burkholder’s background and knowledge, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Ms. Burkholder has the ability to develop and implement a DTT program for STUDENT. She has sufficient background in ABA and DTT programs and experience in working with children and adults in implementing such programs. However, STUDENT also argues that, despite Ms. Burkholder’s background, his placement in her classroom from November 2002 until February 2003 demonstrated that she is unable to provide an appropriate program for him for the 2003-2004 school year. He contends that he made no progress in her classroom during that time, and that she did not provide an appropriate DTT program for him.
Ms. Burkholder testified regarding the time that STUDENT spent in her classroom last year. Initially, the IFSP team placed STUDENT in her classroom so that she could observe and assess his skills and deficits. He then attended her class for one to two hours every other day for approximately three weeks. During this time, he was becoming accustomed to the classroom, and there was no structure involved. After the IFSP meeting on November 5, 2003, the team placed STUDENT in her classroom for one and one-half hours per day for four days per week. In addition, STUDENT did not spend all of his one and one-half hours per day in her classroom because he also received speech and language and OT therapy, and participated in circle time, snack time, and a weekly music program conducted by Ms. Perlewitz. Ms. Burkholder also testified that STUDENT had irregular attendance due to illness and a family vacation that affected his progress in the program.
Ms. Burkholder further testified that during the approximately four months that STUDENT was in her classroom, she spent some time with him on DTT drills, primarily on compliance skills, gross motor skills, eye contact, and learning to sit for more than fifteen seconds at one time. She testified that she chose these four DTT programs from a CARD list of programs, as well as using The Me Book by Dr. Ivar Lovaas and Teaching Children with Autism by Catherine Maurice, books that suggest sequences for DTT drills. She also completed daily written checklists of STUDENT’s DTT trials.
Ms. Burkholder also testified that STUDENT’s placement in her classroom during the current school year will be completely different from last year’s placement. She testified that her class currently has two students with speech and language disabilities and two aides. If STUDENT comes into the class, she will have a third aide. According to Ms. Burkholder, both of the other boys, ages three and four, are verbal, have no behavior problems, and are social and play with each other. In her opinion, these children would be good role models for STUDENT. She testified that she would be able to implement STUDENT’s current goals and objectives in a DTT format in this classroom.
Ms. Burkholder also testified regarding her proposed DTT program for STUDENT. She indicated that she would personally provide ten hours per week of DTT to STUDENT, while her aides would provide the remaining ten hours per week on a rotating basis so that STUDENT would learn to generalize skills across different tutors. Both Ms. Burkholder and Dr. Koelsch testified that the aides in Ms. Burkholder’s classroom have received training in DTT, two through CARD and the other through another agency. Ms. Burkholder stated that she would be responsible for supervising, evaluating, and training her classroom aides and would ensure that they receive any additional training that they need.
Initially, according to Ms. Burkholder, she will consult with CARD, will perform an assessment of STUDENT if necessary, and will look at his current data from CARD. She will then develop a program based upon STUDENT’s current CARD program and the books that she previously used. Ms. Burkholder also testified that she observed STUDENT in his home program with a CARD therapist in May 2003, and described her observation of CARD’s DTT program with STUDENT as “nothing unique” and a “typical program” that she could implement. With regard to data collection, Ms. Burkholder testified that she has forms that are similar to CARD’s forms and that she would use those to record data during STUDENT’s DTT drills.
In addition, District behaviorist Eric Burkholder testified that he has observed Ms. Burkholder’s classroom, and stated that the physical environment is conducive to conducting DTT drills. He also testified that he believed that the other students in the class would not disrupt the classroom, and that STUDENT’s goals and objectives could be met in this classroom. He also testified that he was familiar with The Me Book and Catherine Maurice’s book and believed the drills in those books to be based upon the individual needs of the child. He believes that these books are appropriate as reference and for staff training.
STUDENT’s witnesses disputed Ms. Burkholder’s testimony that she appropriately provided DTT services to STUDENT last year. Ms. Amerine-Dickens testified that Ms. Burkholder’s approach to DTT during this time was not appropriate for STUDENT. According to her testimony, the mere use of drills from The Me Book is not appropriate because the book is outdated and was written by Dr. Lovaas years ago as a basic how-to manual of his program. She also described the Catherine Maurice book as a “watered down” program containing second-hand knowledge. Dr. Granpeesheh also testified that The Me Book contains only thirty programs while the CARD program contains four hundred programs in its language curriculum alone. In addition, she believes that the Catherine Maurice book contains a limited curriculum.
Furthermore, Dr. Schlinger testified that it is difficult to make sense of Ms. Burkholder’s data during her time with STUDENT because they are not very detailed and do not indicate the observations and measurements used. Dr. Granpeesheh also testified that she reviewed Ms. Burkholder’s data collection and found the data to be of “poor quality” and “lacking in clarity” because the data were merely an incomplete checklist.
The undisputed evidence regarding Ms. Burkholder’s skills reveals that she has an educational and employment background that includes knowledge of ABA methodology, knowledge of the needs of children with autism, and experience in developing and implementing DTT programs for children with autism. Moreover, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that Ms. Burkholder’s experience with STUDENT during the four months that he was in her class last year indicates an inability to develop and implement a DTT program for him during the current school year. At the time that STUDENT was placed with Ms. Burkholder, he had not yet been diagnosed with autism, he was becoming adjusted to school, the IFSP team had not decided that he needed a DTT program, he attended school inconsistently, and he spent time in many other activities during the one and one-half hours per day that he was at school.
With regard to the type of drills that Ms. Burkholder used last year, she testified credibly that she would develop a program for STUDENT based upon his current CARD program in addition to the books that she previously used. She testified that she would not rely exclusively upon these sources that other witnesses believe to be outdated and inappropriate. She also testified credibly that STUDENT’s current program would not be the same as his one and one-half hour per day program because a twenty-five hour per week DTT program is not the same program as a six-hour per week program that included many activities in addition to DTT drills.
Finally, with respect to Ms. Burkholder’s data collection, she testified credibly that she would collect data that are similar to CARD’s data. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the evidence that a twenty-five hour per week DTT program for STUDENT is not the same as the six-hour per week program for last year. Moreover, the Hearing Officer gives more weight to Ms. Burkholder’s testimony regarding her comparison of last year’s program with the proposed program for the 2003-2004 school year as she is the only person who has actually worked in the classroom with STUDENT. None of STUDENT’s expert witnesses observed last year’s classrooms, and they based their opinions only on a review of documents and their observations of STUDENT’s current CARD program.
Therefore, on the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s proposed placement in Ms. Burkholder’s class in which she would provide ten hours per week of DTT services, supervise three aides who would provide an additional ten hours per week of DTT services, provide appropriate role models for STUDENT, and document his DTT drills is designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
DTT Supervision
STUDENT contends that he should continue with his current DTT program with CARD supervision because of the progress that he has made in his CARD program. The District contends that the use of Eric Burkholder, its newly hired behaviorist, to supervise STUDENT’s DTT program is designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
As discussed above, Mr. Burkholder has a master’s degree in behavioral analysis and is currently a Ph.D. candidate in behavioral analysis at the University of Nevada at Reno. He has experience supervising DTT programs and other ABA programs, as well as in working with adults and children with autism and other developmental disabilities. With regard to his supervisory role with STUDENT, he would work with CARD regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance, work with STUDENT on needed skills in a variety of settings, train and provide oversight to staff working with STUDENT, ensure a smooth and consistent transition from STUDENT’s home program to the new school program, engage in frequent data reviews, and observe STUDENT’s behavior during the process
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the undisputed evidence regarding Mr. Burkholder’s knowledge of and experience with DTT programs and children with autism. The fact that STUDENT’s parents prefer the CARD program to the District’s program does not indicate that the District’s proposed program is not appropriate so long as it is designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. See Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., supra, 811 F.2d at 1314. STUDENT has presented no credible evidence to dispute Mr. Burkholder’s qualifications to supervise STUDENT’s DTT program. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District’s offer of Mr. Burkholder as the supervisor of STUDENT’s DTT program is designed to address his unique needs. Speech and Language and Occupational Therapy Services
STUDENT contends that the District’s offer of District-provided speech and language and OT therapy is not designed to meet his unique needs because he cannot transition from his private service providers to District providers. However, as the Hearing Officer concluded above, STUDENT is able to transition from his home program to a school program. Therefore, the District’s proposed transition plan from private speech and language and OT services to District speech and language and OT services is designed to address his unique needs in the areas of speech and language and OT services.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed offer of a six-week transition period from STUDENT’s home-based to school-based program, a twenty-five hour per week District preschool program, primary placement in Ms. Burkholder’s preschool SDC classroom, DTT services provided by Ms. Burkholder, forty-five minutes per day in Ms. Sica’s preschool SDC classroom for socialization skills, five hours per week of an in-home District DTT tutor, District DTT supervision, two thirty-minute per week sessions of speech and language therapy in school, two thirty-minute-per-week sessions of OT in school, speech and language and OT consultation, and parent training on autism and PECS was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the 2003-2004 school year.
b. Was the District’s proposed placement reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?
Secondly, the Hearing Officer must determine if the District’s proposed placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. As discussed previously, the Hearing Officer concluded that the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of communication, socialization, general knowledge/readiness, self-help, sensory motor, and fine motor by providing him with educational services in a preschool SDC classroom with DTT services, socialization training, speech and language services, and OT services. The IEP team also drafted goals and objectives in the areas of readiness, general knowledge, self-help, sensory motor, fine motor, communication, and social that would address STUDENT’s areas of identified need. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
c. Did the District’s proposed placement comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no dispute that the District was willing to provide the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives specified in the IEP of May 2003. d. Did the District’s proposed placement provide STUDENT education in the LRE?
As discussed above, the final element of a FAPE is that the student must be educated in the “least restrictive environment.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.550 et seq; Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The District argues that its proposed placement provides STUDENT education in the LRE because it affords him opportunities that he does not have in his home program to interact with peers and to participate in classroom activities, such as circle time, gross motor play, and music, with other students. STUDENT does not dispute that he will have these opportunities within the District’s proposed placement. (Footnote 10)
Therefore, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by the undisputed evidence that the District’s proposed placement provides STUDENT education in the LRE because it provides STUDENT with the ability to interact with peers and to participate in classroom activities with other students.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed offer in its IEP of May 2003 was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, conforms to STUDENT’s IEP, and provides education in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.
ORDER (Footnote 11)
1. All of STUDENT’s claims for relief are denied.
2. The District shall convene an IEP meeting within ten (10) calendar days of the date of this Decision to modify the dates of STUDENT’s transition plan so that STUDENT begins his transition to school within fifteen (15) calendar days of the date of this Decision.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the sole issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: October 15, 2003 ___________________________________ Maxine R. Benmour, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
The District was also represented on the first day of hearing by attorney Shawn Olsen-Brown of the law firm Miller Brown & Dannis.
2 Dr. Williams and Dr. Granpeesheh testified by telephone.
3 On August 21, 2003, the second day of hearing, the parties informed the Hearing Officer that they had resolved an issue regarding the District’s alleged failure to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 extended school year. 4 The parties agreed to change the meeting date from May 1, 2003, to May 13, 2003, at the request of STUDENT’s mother.
5 The District’s offer also included a thirty-hour per week in-home program with CARD, speech and language and OT with CSLOT, and six hours per month of CARD supervision for the 2002-2003 extended school year. However, as indicated previously, the parties resolved an issue related to the 2002-2003 extended school year at the beginning of the hearing. Therefore, this part of the District’s proposed offer is not at issue in this proceeding.
6 STUDENT does not dispute the proposed placement in Ms. Sica’s classroom or the District’s offer of a five-hour per week home-based DTT program. The parties also agree that his parents need training in autism and PECS. The IEP of May 2003 indicates that the District’s offer included general information on autism, PECS training, and “additional parent training opportunities to be discussed at the October IEP meeting.”
7 Witnesses at the hearing disputed the length of time that RCEB had agreed to continue funding STUDENT’s home-based program. However, the Hearing Officer denied the District’s request to continue the hearing so that a representative from RCEB could testify regarding its continued funding. The Hearing Officer found that any ongoing funding by RCEB is irrelevant to the District’s obligation to provide STUDENT with a FAPE after the age of three. See California Education Code section 56440.
8 Although Mr. Burkholder is Ms. Burkholder’s husband, he testified credibly that he would not be directly responsible for supervision of his wife. STUDENT has raised no issue alleging that the District’s offer to use a husband and wife as service providers has denied him a FAPE.
9 Dr. Koelsch testified that the State allows districts to hire teachers with emergency credentials so long as they are in an internship program and working on a regular credential.
10 The parties argue that the four-factor test of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H. (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, 1404, cert. den., 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994) applies to this case. However, the Ninth Circuit in that case dealt with a proposed placement of a child with a disability in a regular education classroom. In this case, the District is not proposing to place STUDENT in a regular education classroom. Thus, the factors of the Rachel H. case are not applicable here.
11 In light of the issuance of this Decision, there is no need to rule on STUDENT’s motion for stay put that the Hearing Office received on October 10, 2003.
