California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 15, 1997
Old Adobe Union Elementary School District et al. v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1188-95 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Old Adobe Union and Sonoma County SELPA must reimburse home behavioral program, preschool and speech therapy for preschooler with autism.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that the parents' earlier hearing request (SN 548-95, filed June 12, 1995) was taken off calendar on June 22, 1995 for mediation, and that SN 1188-95 was taken off calendar on November 9, 1995 before the hearing. No remand, court order, vacatur or correction is noted.
Summary
Old Adobe Union Elementary School District and the Sonoma County SELPA filed this hearing request in November 1995. The parents had filed their own request earlier, but it was taken off calendar so the parties could try mediation. The hearing covered the parents' claims about the preschool programs offered to their son, a young child with autism, for 1994-95 through 1996-97. He attended a SELPA special day class (SDC) from September 1994 to April 1995. His parents then started an intensive one-to-one home behavioral program, later run by Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA), along with private preschool and an aide.
The Hearing Officer found the SELPA's 1994 initial assessment appropriate. The child would not take formal tests, so observation and parent-report measures were proper. All three IEP offers, however, denied FAPE. The 1994-95 goals were vague and missed his language, social and behavior needs. Speech help was only 20 minutes of consultation a week, and the offer included no mainstreaming. The 1995-96 SDC and Head Start offer used a child-led curriculum that was not adapted for him and had no individual speech therapy. For the 1996-97 transitional kindergarten offer, the LEAs gave no specific evidence of how it would meet his needs. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to the parents' autism experts. She ordered reimbursement, subject to proof, for BIA services, Gan Israel Preschool costs, private speech therapy and a UCLA parent-training workshop. She denied reimbursement for two other preschools and three independent assessments.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed competing expert testimony on early autism programs under Rowley. It found that a generic preschool SDC model, not adapted to one child, denied FAPE. It also shows reimbursement denied on equitable grounds for a second private preschool attended at the same time as an appropriate one.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Did the District and SELPA appropriately assess STUDENT prior to the IEP team meeting on June 1, 1994?
The initial assessment complied with Ed. Code 56320 and 56324; observation, parent interview and the Alpern Boll were proper alternatives because the child would not take formal tests.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 school year?
Vague goals that missed language, social, behavior and family-involvement needs, 20 minutes a week of speech consultation, a short four-day program and no mainstreaming denied FAPE under Rowley.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. At the May 1995 IEP meetings, did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year?
The SDC plus Head Start offer used a child-led curriculum not adapted for a young child with autism, had no behavior goals and no individual speech therapy, and offered peers above his developmental level; the child needed an intensive one-to-one home program.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate services and placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year?
There was no specific evidence of how the La Fiesta transitional kindergarten would meet his needs or provide the promised mainstreaming, and the teacher did not testify; the offer was not appropriate.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the BIA program including the costs of a behavioral intervention specialist, the costs of one-to-one behavioral tutors, materials, and supplies from June 1, 1995, to the present?
BIA's individualized program was appropriate and effective; reimbursement was ordered subject to proof, up to 30 hours a week for 1995-96 and 15 hours a week for 1996-97.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Petaluma Valley Day Preschool?
There was almost no evidence about this preschool, and the parents did not take part in the June 1994 IEP and declined SELPA services until fall 1994, so the equities weighed against reimbursement.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Happy Day Presbyterian Preschool, including transportation and the services of a shadow aide, from September 1995 to the present?
Happy Day's large size (up to 50 children) and older peers did not meet his needs, and he was also enrolled at the same time in an appropriate preschool, so reimbursement was denied.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 8. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Gan Israel Preschool, including tuition and the costs of a one-to-one shadow aide during the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?
Gan Israel's small class of three-year-olds offered developmentally appropriate peers; tuition, a one-to-one aide and transportation were reimbursable under Burlington and Carter, subject to proof.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 9a. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments conducted by the Pervasive Developmental Disabilities (PDD) Clinic at Stanford in 1994?
The SELPA's assessment was appropriate and no reassessment was warranted or requested, so the Stanford assessment was not reimbursable.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 9b. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments conducted by Elaine Stevick, speech and language therapist?
Denied for the same reasons as the Stanford assessment.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 9c. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments conducted by Dr. Bryna Siegel in 1995?
Denied for the same reasons as the Stanford assessment.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 10. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent speech and language services provided by Elaine Stevick beginning in May 1994?
He needed individual speech therapy, which the LEAs never offered; reimbursement was ordered subject to proof, but the order covers only sessions after his fall 1994 SDC enrollment, not from May 1994.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 11. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a behavioral intervention workshop and parent training provided by UCLA in April 1995?
The Groen workshop and training were an integral part of the appropriate BIA program, so the parents' share was reimbursable, subject to proof.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving the parents' proof, reimburse their share of the workshop provided by Annette Groen (the order says April 1994; the workshop took place April 7-10, 1995).
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse BIA services of up to 30 hours per week through the extended school year for 1995-1996 and up to 15 hours per week through the extended school year for 1996-1997. This includes supervision, biweekly meetings, materials, and a one-to-one aide for play dates and for attendance at Gan Israel Preschool.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse tuition and transportation to Gan Israel Preschool.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse speech and language sessions with Elaine Stevick provided after the student enrolled in the SELPA SDC for the 1994-1995 school year.
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Sacramento City School Board v. Holland; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Betty G. Beavers, principal of SELPA preschool programs; LEA witness, Sonoma County SELPA
- John Namkung, SELPA director of special education, Sonoma County SELPA
- Rhandee Lipp, private speech-language pathologist (assessor)
- Elaine M. Stevick, private speech-language pathologist; provider and witness for Student
- Michael Alessandri, assessor at Stanford PDD Clinic; expert witness for Student, Stanford University; later University of Miami Center for Autism and Related Disorders
- Linda Lotspeich, physician assessor, Stanford PDD Clinic, Stanford University Medical Center
- Melissa Caboara, SELPA preschool special day class teacher, Sonoma County SELPA (Pengrove School)
- Hilary Stubblefield, program director, nonpublic agency; witness for Student, Behavioral Intervention Associates
- Jim Partington, behavioral specialist recommended by Dr. Lotspeich
- Diane Swenson, SELPA assessor (psychologist), Sonoma County SELPA
- Annette Groen, UCLA doctoral candidate; behavioral intervention workshop and parent training provider, UCLA
- Ivar Lovaas, researcher whose behavioral intervention model was discussed, UCLA
- Bryna Siegel, independent assessor; expert witness for Student, UCSF Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute PDD Clinic
- Dr. Elliot, independent assessor, UCSF
- Lorraine Haas, head teacher, private preschool, Happy Day Preschool
- Thomas J. Zembal, student's pediatrician
- Sarah W. Field, occupational therapist (OTR) assessor and provider for SELPA
- Debbie Gayaldo, SELPA adapted physical education teacher, Sonoma County SELPA
- Deborah Porter, SELPA school psychologist, Sonoma County SELPA
- Darrell Henke, SELPA speech-language pathologist, Sonoma County SELPA
- Barbara Hutchinson, SELPA speech-language pathologist, Sonoma County SELPA
- Tristram Smith, clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student, Washington State University
- Shelley Davis, behaviorist; witness for Student, Language Education Assistance for Preschool (LEAP)
- Tracie Vickers, case manager, nonpublic agency, Behavioral Intervention Associates
- Jody Neeson, school psychologist; BIA tutor and shadow aide, Behavioral Intervention Associates; formerly counselor at Pengrove
- Susan Malin, case management leader for initial assessment; speech-language pathologist, Piner-Olivet and Mark West School Districts
- Kathy Bregder, SELPA program specialist and school psychologist, Sonoma County SELPA
- Judy Adams, SELPA nurse, Sonoma County SELPA
- Sue Nieuwenhuijs, teacher who drafted initial IEP goals, Sonoma County SELPA
- Debbie Blanton, manager of disability and mental health services, Sonoma County People for Economic Opportunity Head Start
- Diane Ashton, former SELPA preschool director; expert witness for LEAs, Twin Hills Union School District
- Linda Patterson, SELPA preschool assistant principal, Sonoma County SELPA
- Carolyn Coyman, District director of special education and bilingual education, Old Adobe Union Elementary School District
- Billye Raye Lipscomb, District superintendent, Old Adobe Union Elementary School District
- Behavioral Intervention Associates, nonpublic agency (intensive behavioral intervention)
- North Bay Regional Center, regional center
- Happy Day Presbyterian Preschool, private preschool
- Gan Israel Preschool, private preschool
- Petaluma Valley Day Preschool, private preschool
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Petaluma, California, on December 10-13, 1996, January 28-31, and March 24-27, 1997. STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents. Old Adobe Union Elementary School District (District) and Sonoma County SELPA were represented at the hearing by attorney Lawrence M. Schoenke. Also present on behalf of the District SELPA was Betty G. Beavers, principal of SELPA preschool programs. John Namkung, SELPA director of special education, was present intermittently throughout the hearing.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments and rebuttal arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did the District and SELPA appropriately assess STUDENT prior to the individualized educational program (IEP) team meeting on June 1, 1994?
(2) Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 school year?
(3) At the May 1995 IEP meetings, did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school?
(4) Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate services and placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year?
(5) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the BIA program including the costs of a behavioral intervention specialist, the costs of one-to-one behavioral tutors, materials, and supplies from June 1, 1995, to the present?
(6) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Petaluma Valley Day Preschool?
(7) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Happy Day Presbyterian Preschool, including transportation and the services of a shadow aide, from September 1995 to the present?
(8) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Gan Israel Preschool, including tuition and the costs of a one-to-one shadow aide during the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?
(9) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments conducted by:
(a) the Pervasive Developmental Disabilities (PDD) Clinic at Stanford in 1994;
(b) Elaine Stevick, speech and language therapist;
(c) Dr. Bryna Siegel in 1995?
(10) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent speech and language services provided by Elaine Stevick beginning in May 1994?
(11) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a behavioral intervention workshop and parent training provided by the University of California (UCLA) in April 1995?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a six-year-old student with autism. He will enter kindergarten during the 1997-1998 school year. Since April 1995, STUDENT’s parents have provided him with one-to-one intensive behavioral intervention services. Since June 1995, the services have been provided through Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA). STUDENT also attends private preschool programs at Happy Day and Gan Israel preschools.
On April 8, 1994, one month before STUDENT’s third birthday, Rhandee Lipp, a speech and language pathologist in private practice, assessed STUDENT. She was not able to complete formal testing with him; however, she expressed concern regarding STUDENT’s “jargoning” and the fact that he repetitively used five “rotely-learned” sentences. Ms. Lipp referred STUDENT to a developmental pediatrician and to the SELPA for a possible special education placement. She also recommended twice weekly speech and language sessions of one hour each. (LEAs’ Exhibit 1)(Footnote 1) In May 1994, North Bay Regional Center assessed STUDENT and determined that he was eligible for their services based on a developmental quotient of 66. (LEAs’ Exhibit 2) Elaine M. Stevick, a speech and language therapist in private practice, also attempted to assess STUDENT; however, he would not participate in formal testing. Thereafter, STUDENT began receiving twice weekly one-hour sessions of private speech and language therapy from Ms. Stevick.
On May 10, 1994, MOTHER consented to the SELPA’s plan to assess STUDENT. (LEAs’ Exhibit 3) The assessment on May 10, 1994, included health and developmental histories completed by MOTHER, which were reviewed by a school nurse. STUDENT’s mother also completed the Alpern Boll Developmental Profile II. A psychologist and a speech and language specialist from the SELPA’s preschool transdisciplinary team observed STUDENT at his home because he would not participate in formal testing. The assessment team concluded that STUDENT was functioning at the early two-year-old level. At the time of testing, STUDENT was two years and 11 months old. The assessment team identified STUDENT’s instructional needs in the areas of “communication (interactive communication skills, expressive vocabulary, syntax), social skills, school behaviors (compliance to direction, group participation, following simple classroom rules/routines, peer interaction), willingness to attempt fine-motor/table/preacademic tasks, attention to task and task completion, preacademic/cognitive skills (imitation, matching, sorting, followed by size/number/color concepts), self help skills (toilet training, self dressing, utensil usage), gross motor skills (jumping, balance, catching, pedaling).” (LEAs’ Exhibit 8)
On June 4, 1994, the IEP team determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria for special education. His initial IEP called for 180 minutes per week of instruction over four days each week, speech consultation/collaboration for 20 minutes per week, daily transportation, and extended school year services (ESY). Goals and objectives addressed improvement of cognitive, self-help, receptive and expressive language, and motor planning skills. Additional goals were to increase task attendance and group participation. (STUDENT’s Exhibit C) STUDENT's parents did not participate in the IEP and declined services from the District for the summer of 1994. According to MOTHER, she did not participate in the IEP because the Stanford assessment was pending, she understood the IEP to be a “formality,” and the placement offered by the District was at some distance from the PARENT’s home.
On July 12, 1994, Michael Alessandri, M.D., and Linda Lotspeich, M.D., of the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at Stanford University Medical Center, assessed STUDENT. The assessors concluded that STUDENT had a pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS) based on STUDENT's meeting 5 of 12 diagnostic criteria set forth in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-Fourth Edition (DSM-IV). They also recommended that STUDENT attend a special education preschool program for students with communication disorders on two or three days a week to help develop eye contact and attending and sitting skills, and that he also attend a regular preschool program to help develop more appropriate social skills. Additional recommendations were to include goals and objectives in STUDENT’s IEP to improve expressive language and cognitive skills and that STUDENT be provided speech and language and occupational therapies. The report also states the following:
It is advised that tasks and task materials be carefully structured and organized for STUDENT. . . . Parents and teachers are advised to be as consistent as possible in their interactions with STUDENT, to follow through on commands, and to reinforce consistently and systematically all appropriate behavior. Self stimulatory behaviors involving tactile and visual stimuli should be redirected, and STUDENT should be encouraged to perform all skills that are clearly in his repertoire.
(STUDENT’s Exhibit E)
In September 1994, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him in a SELPA SDC taught by Melissa Caboara at Pengrove School. The number of students in the class ranged from 7 to 12. A speech and language therapist, adaptive physical education teacher (APE), and an occupational therapist collaboratively worked with the teacher to provide activities for the students within the classroom.
On October 10, 1994, the SELPA conducted an occupational therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT and recommended weekly OT using a collaborative model whereby the speech therapist consults and collaborates with the preschool teacher to provide services. At an IEP meeting on October 19, 1994, the services of OT and adapted physical education (APE) were added to STUDENT's IEP and his then-current functional levels were updated. The SELPA speech and language therapist and Ms. Stevick consulted regarding speech and language goals, which were added to the IEP as were OT goals. The IEP team members, including the parent, agreed with the recommended goals and services. (STUDENT’s Exhibit F) About the time of winter break, the PARENTS became especially concerned about what appeared to them to be a regression of STUDENT’s behavior and an increase in self-stimulatory behavior. Ms. Stevick noted similar concerns in February 1995. (STUDENT’s Exhibit X)
MOTHER consulted Dr. Lotspeich regarding STUDENT’s increased perceverative and self-stimulative behaviors, including watching television in the reflection in the glass of a photograph, laying his head on the table to look at trains he had lined up on the table, loudly humming, and running away in public places. In a letter dated February 6, 1995, Dr. Lotspeich recommended an intensive behavior modification program for STUDENT. She specifically suggested that services be provided either by Hilary Stubblefield or Jim Partington or by anyone else with expertise in developing behavioral modification programs for children with PDD/autism. (STUDENT’s Exhibit I)
On April 3, 1995, Diane Swenson assessed STUDENT on behalf of the SELPA following MOTHER’s request for further evaluation of STUDENT's functional levels. Ms. Swenson stated that STUDENT was able to sit for over one-half hour for testing, whereas he would not participate in the assessment in the spring of 1994. Ms. Swenson described STUDENT's overall test scores as "low" with "peaks in visual-spatial reasoning which might indicate higher potential." On the Leiter International Performance Scale, STUDENT obtained an IQ score of 64. STUDENT was only able to complete two subtests of the Stanford-Binet. On the vocabulary subtest he obtained a standard score of 78, and on the sentence memory subtest he obtained a standard score of 76. Ms. Swenson made the following additional statements regarding STUDENT:
His loss of 'set' during the tasks and his inability to look for and correct his errors are both remediable. He also needs help in expanding his repertoire of question-answer formats and direction-taking. Since STUDENT does not do well under pressure it would be best to teach him these skills in a natural setting where other children would be doing the same things.
STUDENT is a sweet child who is trying hard to please the adults in his life. Since input-output connections are difficult for him, STUDENT is working much harder than other children. This needs to be considered when setting up a program for him. It will be important for him to have time to play and to rest so he can integrate what he is learning. It will also be important to set expectations that he can meet.
(STUDENT’s Exhibit K)
In a speech and language progress report dated April 7, 1995, Ms. Stevick reported that STUDENT had become more aware of and "attached" to people in his environment. She recommended that STUDENT continue to receive "communication centered therapy" to expand his functional communication skills. Ms. Stevick also stated that
STUDENT has made steady progress in achieving goals set for him and is beginning to point to objects on request, follow directions more consistently, comment, affirm, negate, use sentences of four to five words in length at times, ask questions, declare his feelings ('this is fun'), engage people with the use of language ('let's go play'), and is moving beyond noun labeling to verbs and adjectives.
(STUDENT’s Exhibit N)
The PARENTS withdrew STUDENT from Ms. Caboara’s class on April 13, 1995, so that STUDENT could participate in an intensive one-to-one home-based behavioral intervention program. On April 7 - 10, 1995, Annette Groen, a June 1995 doctoral candidate a UCLA, conducted a workshop with the PARENTS and another family. Ms. Groen had worked at UCLA with Dr. Ivar Lovaas, a psychologist who is well known for developing and researching the effectiveness of intensive behavioral intervention programs for students with autism. The purpose of the workshop was to "evaluate two children, develop IEPs for them, and to train tutors [hired by the families to work with their children]." (STUDENT’s Exhibit J) Ms. Groen's programming recommendations are set forth in STUDENT’s Exhibit O. STUDENT began the one-to-one program with the tutors trained by Ms. Groen.
On May 2, 1995, STUDENT was assessed at the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic, Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF). The report is signed by Bryna Siegel, Ph.D. Using DSM-IV criteria, the assessors concluded that STUDENT met diagnostic criteria for an autistic disorder based on delays in the following: use of nonverbal behaviors such as eye-to-eye gaze, facial expression, and gestures to regulate social interaction; peer relationships; and communication. The Clinic also found that STUDENT exhibited idiosyncratic language (jargoning) and restricted, repetitive, and stereotypical behavior, interest or activity, and lacked spontaneous social imitation and make believe play. Based on the report of STUDENT's PARENTS that STUDENT was making progress in his intensive behavioral program, the Clinic recommended that he continue with the program. It was also recommended that in approximately six months STUDENT attend with an aide a "small, not too-highly structure preschool." The report also stated that "children like STUDENT benefit from 6 to 12 months on an intensive full-time program, and thereafter, full-time preschool plus about 2 hours of 1:1 time in the afternoon (for another 6-12 months).” (STUDENT’s Exhibit R)
On May 18, 1995, and June 26, 1995, the IEP team convened for an annual review of STUDENT’s IEP and placement. (STUDENT’s Exhibit V) The IEP includes goals and objectives to improve self-help, fine-motor, pre-academic readiness, social/emotional play, receptive and expressive language, balance and eye-hand coordination skills. The IEP calls for placement in a preschool SDC and Head Start Preschool.(Footnote 2) It is unclear from the IEP document the recommended level of services from Head Start. The box indicating the extent of inclusion in a regular program is marked “recesses/break periods,” and “inclusion in Head Start program” is handwritten nearby. The IEP calls for the following services: twice weekly speech and language therapy for 20 minutes each session; weekly OT classroom collaboration for 30 minutes each session; weekly APE for 15 minutes each session; ESY of 180 minutes per week; and transportation between home and school. The parents did not sign the IEP. On approximately June 11, 1995, BIA began providing STUDENT’s behavioral program. STUDENT worked with two BIA tutors approximately 33 hours per week.
On June 12, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from attorney Kathryn E. Dobel on behalf of STUDENT regarding the appropriateness of his placement. (SN 548-95) On June 22, 1995, the parties agreed to take SN 548-95 off calendar to allow them to participate in mediation. In the fall of 1995, STUDENT’s one-to-one services with BIA were reduced to 21 hours per week and he began attending the four-year-old class at Happy Day Preschool with a BIA tutor. Happy Day had up to 50 students with three to four adults. On October 24, 1995, STUDENT was reassessed at UCSF by Drs. Siegel and Elliot. They recommended that STUDENT be placed for three days per week in a preschool class with three-year-old students, which they believed would be more developmentally appropriate for him than the class he had been attending with four-year-old students. They also recommended placing STUDENT two days per week in a special education classroom for students with communication disorders, one-to-one tutoring through BIA emphasizing development of language and social skills, “play dates,” and continued work on generalizing tutored play sequences to new settings. Based on two “video clips,” the assessors made the following comments pertaining to the appropriateness of Ms. Caboara’s class for STUDENT. “Although the classroom appeared to be very warm and full of interesting activities, a ‘child led’ program is not appropriate for an autistic child like STUDENT. STUDENT needs to be in a more structured learning environment. He would benefit from a classroom that emphasizes work on his communicative delays and that offers programmed facilitation of peer interaction.” (STUDENT’s Exhibit AA) Following the UCSF assessment, the PARENTS enrolled STUDENT in a preschool class at Gan Israel, which he attended with the assistance of a BIA tutor. Gan Israel has approximately nine students who are three years old.
On November 3, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request for hearing from attorney Lawrence M. Schoenke on behalf of the District and SELPA regarding STUDENT's placement for the 1995-1996 school year. (SN 1188-95) On November 9, 1995, the parties agreed to take SN 1188-95 off calendar.
In a progress report dated December 29, 1995, Ms. Stevick noted that STUDENT had increased his “ability to be vigilant, attend to tasks, participate in testing, and developing emerging age-appropriate language behaviors.” She also stated that since “STUDENT’s involvement in his intensive behavioral program, his overall attention and social interactive behaviors have increased dramatically, resulting in more normalized pragmatic and linguistic behaviors.” (STUDENT’s Exhibit BB) In a letter dated January 2, 1996, Lorraine Haas, head teacher at Happy Day, described STUDENT's functioning after four months of participation in the preschool program. She indicated that STUDENT was participating in large motor group activities with his peers and seldomly exhibited self-stimulatory behavior. She also stated that STUDENT "moves around the classroom both by choice and with the encouragement of teachers." She also stated, however, that STUDENT needs to have simple, direct questions asked of him or he has difficulty understanding what is being asked of him. She noted occasional jargoning when frustrated, or "if 'carpet time' runs too long and his attention is no longer focused on a specific activity." Ms. Haas described STUDENT's social skills as "awkward" but noted that he is able to join a group of children working on a specific project. (STUDENT’s Exhibit H)
In a letter dated March 14, 1996, Thomas J. Zembal, M.D., STUDENT’s pediatrician, stated that STUDENT had made great improvement because of his BIA therapy and recommended that he continue to participate in the program. Dr. Zembal also stated that “before therapy, he would come into my office and wander aimlessly around and find it very difficult to make it through a very basic exam. He is now able to follow instructions and communicate some of his needs to me. He can now socialize and maintain some focus and eye contact which he could never do before.” (STUDENT’s Exhibit FF)
On March 18, 1996, Sarah Field, OTR (registered occupational therapist), and Debbie Gayaldo, APE specialist, assessed STUDENT on behalf of the SELPA. The assessors noted that STUDENT needed multiple cues to complete most items and encouragement to stay on task. His speech was mixed with jargon, single words, and simple phrases. He showed some humor and eye contact was good when responding to a request. The assessors concluded that STUDENT‘s fine- and gross-motor skills were delayed. They recommended weekly OT and APE that included direct services in small groups, consultation to staff, and development of curriculum ideas. (STUDENT’s Exhibit GG) On March 24, 1996, Deborah Porter, school psychologist, assessed STUDENT to determine his current level of functioning. The assessment included administration of the Southern California Ordinal Scales of Development, which provides information on the child’s general developmental level, and observations of STUDENT at his home and preschool. STUDENT’s mother also completed the Burk’s Behavior Rating Scale, the Childhood Autism Rating Scale, and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale. STUDENT demonstrated cognitive skills up to the four-year-old level with relative strengths in performance tasks requiring visual and manipulative skills. He exhibited weaknesses in expressive and receptive communication and limited ability to interpret and appropriately respond to “his world.” STUDENT’s daily living skills were at the two-year-seventh-month level. STUDENT demonstrated emerging skills at the 42- to 47-month level in social and play skills. Ms. Porter made the following recommendations regarding STUDENT’s placement:
STUDENT would benefit from a highly structured and supportive educational placement with a small student to teacher ratio. Clearly STUDENT continues to have needs in the areas of communication, socialization, fine motor skills, problem-solving responsible behavior and emotional expression. STUDENT’s mother and aide report that he is beginning to make good pre-academic progress in pre-math, pre-reading, and pre-writing skills. He would benefit from a placement which allows him to continue to develop in these areas.
(STUDENT’s Exhibit HH)
On March 21 and April 1, 1996, Darrell Henke, speech and language pathologist, assessed STUDENT with input from Barbara Hutchinson. They found that STUDENT’s language had improved; however, he continued to exhibit receptive and expressive language deficits, particularly in group settings. (LEAs’ Exhibit 51) The IEP team convened in April and May 1996 to draft goals and objectives and determine STUDENT’s placement for the 1996-1997 school year. SELPA and District representatives recommended that STUDENT attend Ms. Caboara’s class for the remainder of the 1995-1996 school year. Since Ms. Caboara would not be teaching during the ESY, STUDENT’s placement would be different during the summer. The placement proposed for the fall of 1996 was a transitional kindergarten class at La Fiesta School with up to 1200 minutes per week (20 hours) for an instructional assistant, OT collaboration and consultation to home 60 minutes per week, APE collaboration for 60 minutes per week, speech and language service and consultation 20 minutes for two sessions each week, and consultation to home and/or private school setting by a special education teacher. The parents agreed with the goals and objectives. They did not agree to the proposed placement.
During the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT continued to receive one-to-one services from BIA, participated in play dates facilitated by BIA, and attended preschool one day per week at Happy Day in the company of a BIA tutor.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
Witnesses for STUDENT
STUDENT’s mother, testified that STUDENT met expected developmental milestones during his first two years of life. He attended the Marin Day School infant/toddler program, where he did well and there were no contrary comments from school staff. MOTHER testified that when STUDENT was about two and one-half-years-old, he lost interest in things and his speech worsened. Thereafter, MOTHER took STUDENT for a number of assessments. MOTHER testified that she did not attend the first SELPA IEP for STUDENT because the Stanford assessment was pending and she understood that it was not necessary for her to be at the IEP because it was an “administrative formality,” should STUDENT attend school in a SELPA program. MOTHER testified that the SELPA offered to place STUDENT in a program in Sonoma for the summer 1994; however, she did not enroll STUDENT in the program because she did not think that it “made any sense” to send STUDENT to a school located out of town. MOTHER testified that none of her recommendations for occupational therapy, sensory integration, or potty training were incorporated into STUDENT’s IEP when it was revised in October 1994.
MOTHER testified that she attended STUDENT’s first day of school in Ms. Caboara’s class and is familiar with the class because she participated in class field trips and drove STUDENT to school daily. MOTHER testified that Ms. Caboara’s classroom at that time was dark and dreary and did not have bathrooms. There was a gate at the door to keep STUDENT in the classroom and the aides held STUDENT in a fashion that would not allow him to escape their hold. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was not learning in the class and Ms. Caboara’s only response was to reassure MOTHER that the class was appropriate for STUDENT. MOTHER testified that Ms. Caboara did not make any home visits although she understood that the teacher was required to do so. MOTHER testified that when she spoke with Ms. Caboara and Ms. Beavers about STUDENT’s need for an intensive behavioral intervention program, they reacted negatively. MOTHER testified that the SELPA’s concerns about the use of aversives with STUDENT because the individual program is based on early Lovaas techniques is totally unfounded. BIA does not employ aversives with the children to whom it provides services and no one has every used an aversive with STUDENT.
In response to testimony by SELPA personnel that the reason for the deterioration of STUDENT’s behavior in January 1995 was illness, MOTHER testified that STUDENT did have Giardia at the beginning of December 1994; however, tests showed he was clear of the parasite as of December 15, 1994. MOTHER testified that at the IEP meeting in May 1995, the SELPA’s expectations for STUDENT were very low and they did not include in his IEP goals and objectives she had drafted. MOTHER testified that based on her observation of the Wright Place, which was proposed for STUDENT during the summer 1995, she concluded that it would not have been an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it was located 30 minutes from their home, none of the children living in their neighborhood attended school there, the children did not offer an appropriate peer group, and there were no opportunities to mainstream. MOTHER testified that when she observed Ms. Caboara’s class during the spring of 1995, it was “chaotic and disorganized.” One student was crying outside of the classroom and the occupational therapist was in the classroom working with some students on a scooter activity. Regarding the proposal that STUDENT attend Head Start in the fall 1995, MOTHER testified that she believed it would be futile to apply to Head Start since STUDENT’s application had been rejected once before.
MOTHER testified that she requested that STUDENT be placed in a full inclusion class in April 1996. The SELPA responded by offering to place STUDENT in the transitional kindergarten at La Fiesta. MOTHER testified regarding her observation of that class in the fall of 1996. There were 15 students in the class. None of the activities during center activities were academic and all appeared to be more like the curriculum for preschool. MOTHER testified that the students were “milling” around and were very noisy. The class did not have any good language or behavioral models. The class also did not include any of STUDENT’s peers from the neighborhood and there were no opportunities to mainstream with nondisabled peers. MOTHER testified that the teacher of the class told her that none of her students are integrated with regular education students. MOTHER concluded that, for these reasons, the class would not be appropriate for STUDENT. She also testified that the first time she was aware that the services of a one-to-one aide were being offered for the 1996-1997 school year was during Ms. Patterson’s testimony at the hearing. MOTHER testified that neither the SELPA nor the District has ever offered STUDENT behavioral services. They also have not offered to make any changes to the SDC to meet STUDENT’s needs or to provide strategies to the parents to work with STUDENT at home. MOTHER testified that Happy Day is an appropriate placement for STUDENT because of the regularity of its regular routine, which provides STUDENT with continuity. Happy Day also involves the students in a lot of gross-motor activities. The teachers also plan strategies to help STUDENT participate in activities. MOTHER testified that she considers especially important the fact that STUDENT’s play dates and neighborhood peers attend Happy Day with him.
STUDENT’s father testified that he initially was impressed with Ms. Caboara’s class and was optimistic about the potential for STUDENT to make progress in her class; however, he became concerned when, over winter break, STUDENT’s behavior regressed. He was less compliant, unpredictably ran into the street, and lacked connectedness to family members. FATHER testified that he was unable to get any feedback from the school regarding STUDENT. On the other hand, BIA makes him aware of what happens each day and he participates in weekly meetings regarding STUDENT. FATHER testified that STUDENT’s behavior has improved since he began working with BIA. He is now able to go places with STUDENT and to do things with him. STUDENT’s relationships with his siblings has also changed and STUDENT engages in activities with them.
Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., is assistant adjunct professor and director of the PDD and autism clinic, Langley-Porter Institute, University of California, San Francisco (UCSF). Dr. Siegel focuses her research on the early identification and intervention of children with autism. She has assessed approximately 2,000 children. In 1983, Dr. Siegel was employed at the autism clinic, Stanford University, and, in 1993, moved to UCSF. Dr. Siegel testified that early intervention for children with autism is extremely important because, during the first six years of a child’s life, it is easier to “mold the child neurologically.” Dr. Siegel testified that children with autism engage in a high degree of perceverative behaviors, are not engaged with or driven to explore their environment, and have low levels of curiosity. When a child with autism is in close proximity to something, the child tends to play with the item over and over and in the same way. Dr. Siegel testified that an appropriate educational program for a child with autism is designed to “interfere” with the child’s routine behavior and to make learning its own reward. Because of their lack of interest in their environment, young children with autism have fewer experiences and their base of knowledge is limited. This lack of knowledge will have a cumulative effect unless the child is involved in an intensive program that “force feeds” new information to the child. Dr. Siegel testified that a child-centered curriculum where the child is expected to explore materials on their own will not be effective for a child with autism who, by definition of the disability, does not have an interest in his or her environment. Dr. Siegel testified that children with autism also lack imitative skills, which is the primary way in which young children learn. Because of the lack of imitative skills, young children with autism do not benefit from group-based instruction until they are specifically taught to imitate. Dr. Siegel testified that young children with autism also do not respond to social rewards the same way as other children and social praise is ineffective unless it is paired with something that is rewarding to the specific child.
Dr. Siegel testified that her research has shown that children with autism participating in intensive, home-based treatment programs make significantly greater progress than children with the same developmental levels, diagnosis, and chronological age participating in 10 hour per week group-based instructional programs. Dr. Siegel defined “intensive” as 25 to 35 hours per week of individual treatment. Dr. Siegel also concluded that children with autism benefit from intervention that has a low student-to-staff ratio, that promotes adaptive behaviors, language development, and socialization, and that provides behavioral interventions. Dr. Siegel testified that young children with autism have difficulty generalizing so a successful program must include opportunities for the student to practice skills in different contexts. Dr. Siegel testified that it is also important for the child’s parents to be trained how to facilitate the child’s education in different environments. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT’s assessment at UCSF in May 1995 included administering of the Merrill-Palmer Scale of Mental Tests (M-P), a measure of intelligence, and standardized play sessions with STUDENT to evaluate his social skills, reciprocal interactions, observations of others, and spontaneous exploration of the environment. Dr. Siegel described STUDENT as falling in the “high outcome” group for children with autism because of his higher cognitive functioning and less severe autistic symptoms than other children with autism. Dr. Siegel testified that the first time she saw STUDENT, he appeared more like a child with delayed development because of his “fairly good” language and social skills. At four years of age, STUDENT was one year below expectations for nonverbal skills and two years below for verbal skills. Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT participate in an intensive behavioral program for approximately 30 hours per week with an aide and which has developmentally appropriate peers to help him develop social and language skills. Dr. Siegel testified that when she reassessed STUDENT in October 1995, he had met or exceeded all expectations. He was showing improved play, social relatedness, and language. Dr. Siegel testified that STUDENT made one year’s growth during the period between the Stanford assessment and the first UCSF assessment, whereas he made nearly two year’s growth in the less than one year between assessments by UCSF. Dr. Siegel concluded that STUDENT’s rate of growth accelerated after the commencement of the intensive behavioral intervention program. Dr. Siegel noted also that STUDENT has shown growth across all areas of development, whereas many children she sees develop isolated skills.
In October 1995, Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT continue with BIA and that his individual program be decreased and his group program increase. She recommended that STUDENT be integrated with three-year-old children. Dr. Siegel testified that the strength of BIA is developing the child’s social skills and recommended that STUDENT continue with play dates. Dr. Siegel testified that, based on her observations of Ms. Caboara’s SDC, she concluded that the program offered by the SELPA was not appropriate for STUDENT because it was a child-led program dependent on the child’s exploration of objects and materials. The program also lacked a behavioral intervention component. Dr. Siegel observed that all the children engaged in similar activities regardless of their needs. For example, all students were engaged by the occupational therapist in a scooter activity although many of the students did not appear to require remediation of gross-motor skills. During circle time, some of the students sang songs while others appeared “clueless.” These observations coupled with the heterogeneous grouping of children in the class led Dr. Siegel to conclude that students in the class were included in classroom activities notwithstanding their individual needs. Dr. Siegel testified that the classroom aides were “guarding” the children rather than working individually with them or facilitating interactions among them. Dr. Siegel also described the class as “chaotic” and “unfocused.” Dr. Siegel did not recommend the SDC for STUDENT at any time of the time periods at issue.
Dr. Siegel also observed the transitional kindergarten at La Fiesta. She did not express any specific concerns about the program; however, she testified that the peer group would not be appropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Siegel also testified that since STUDENT has made “nice” progress in the BIA program, he should not change programs at this time. For the 1996-1997 school year, Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT receive approximately 10 to 15 hours per week of individual instruction through BIA, that he participate in play dates, and that he attend preschool with a shadow aide.
On rebuttal, Dr. Siegel testified that she used the M-P to assess STUDENT because it evaluates various aspects of non-verbal intelligence, which is especially important for children with autism who may have delayed language. Dr. Siegel agreed with the SELPA that the norms are outdated and that scores tend to be a little higher than on other measures of intelligence. She also stated that the M-P is not a good measure of a student’s language skills. Dr. Siegel testified that there is not much of a practice effect on the M-P because a majority of the test involves motor activities. Dr. Siegel testified that the progress shown by STUDENT indicates that his intervention program is successful and may be directly attributed to the interventions provided by the parents. Dr. Siegel expressed her opinion that STUDENT would not have made as much progress had he remained in the SDC because there is very little direct instruction provided in the class and the instructional methodologies that are employed are not appropriate for children with autism. Dr. Siegel also noted that a lot of class time was spent trying to control the behavior of several children and to engage them in OT activities. Dr. Siegel testified that Ms. Caboara employs some aspects of a picture communication system; however, the program is not carried out with individual children. Dr. Siegel testified that her recommendations would not have been different if STUDENT’s diagnosis was PDD rather than autism.
Michael Alessandri, Ph.D., director of the Center for Autism and Related Disorders, University of Miami, assessed STUDENT while he was employed at Stanford. Dr. Alessandri testified that at that time STUDENT was assessed, there was some debate among the assessors whether STUDENT was autistic or PDD. Dr. Alessandri testified that STUDENT’s behaviors changed after the assessment and that further assessment was warranted. Dr. Alessandri also testified that he would have recommended an individualized behavioral program following STUDENT’s assessment; however, at the time, he did not have the authority to unilaterally make such a recommendation. Dr. Alessandri testified that he has worked with BIA and he believes it to be an “absolutely” appropriate program for STUDENT. BIA has all of the necessary components to build STUDENT’s foundational skills. BIA provides a behavioral foundation, uses a developmentally-based curriculum, keeps data, and stresses social language and communication. Once STUDENT has a strong foundation, BIA provides support through play dates and participation in a preschool program to allow STUDENT to learn to apply skills he has learned in a broader environment. Dr. Allesandri testified that STUDENT is a candidate for regular education with support and to place him in an SDC would be a step backward.
Tristram Smith, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, currently is on the faculty at Washington State University. Dr. Smith previously worked with Dr. Lovaas at the Young Autism Program at UCLA. Dr. Smith has been involved with studies involving treatment of young children with autism, including follow-up and duplicating of Dr. Lovaas’ studies. Dr. Smith testified that the research shows that students involved in an intensive treatment program that consists of one-to-one instruction for 30 to 40 hours per week for two to three years using the UCLA treatment model made gains of 15 to 20 points on measures of ability and language. Children receiving less intense services in a public school regular education classroom lost 5 to 10 points on average. Dr. Smith testified that 5 of the 16 children who participated in Dr. Lovaas’ original study who had received intensive services now meet the definition of “normal functioning.” Their IQ scores fell above 85 and they were functioning in a regular class without an IEP. Dr. Smith concluded professional literature contains good evidence that the behavioral approach works, whereas there is very little research on the effects of students educated in public school and the results of the limited research are negative. Dr. Smith testified that the only scientifically validated program is one-to-one instruction in a program of at least 20 hours per week. Dr. Smith testified that the results hold true for students diagnosed as PDD as well. Dr. Smith testified that the closest replication of Dr. Lovaas’ treatment studies have been done by Dr. Siegel and a Dr. Anderson of the May Center. Dr. Siegel’s study found that the average IQ of students in the home-based program after 19 months was 90, whereas the average IQ students in public school SDCs was 62. Six of the students in Dr. Anderson’s study participating in an intensive program showed average increases in their IQS of 20 points. Dr. Smith testified that changes have been made to the approach used by Dr. Lovaas since publishing the Me Book in 1980. Dr. Smith testified that aversives are not used at all and there are more advanced programs.
Dr. Smith met and worked with STUDENT for about three hours on February 21 1997. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT was playing creatively and interacting with other kids. He spoke in 5 to 10 word sentences, sustained conversations on a variety of topics, and made his wants clear to adults. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT is “moving away” from autistic behaviors. As to the appropriateness of STUDENT’s IEPs, Dr. Smith expressed concern about the role of the parent, which research has shown is very important, and the group-based instruction provided in Ms. Caboara’s class. Dr. Smith testified that the approach employed by Ms. Caboara is contrary to the results of studies of children with autism and the research regarding the type of programs that have been found to benefit children with autism. Dr. Smith testified that her class did not offer sufficient one-to-one instruction and, given STUDENT’s language deficits, 40 minutes per week of speech and language therapy was insufficient. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT did not appear to understand what was going on in the video tapes of the preschool. He concluded that there is no clear evidence that STUDENT gained skills while attending the SDC. Based on test scores and observations of the skills STUDENT has acquired while participating in BIA, Dr. Smith concluded that STUDENT has made progress. Dr. Smith testified that STUDENT’s growth cannot be attributed to maturation because children with autism do not learn the same as typically developing children.
Regarding the issues for hearing raised by the PARENTS, Dr. Smith testified that the SELPA’s evaluation was not appropriate because it did not include measures of cognitive skills, adaptive functioning, or language. As to STUDENT’s initial IEP, Dr. Smith testified that the goals and objectives are vague and STUDENT may have been able to do some of them prior to entering school. As to STUDENT’s IEP for the 1995-1996 school year, Dr. Smith testified that the IEP lacks goals and objectives to reduce STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors. Regarding the services STUDENT required (Issues 2 and 5), Dr. Smith testified that all of the components set forth by the parents are appropriate; however, he would not have recommended that STUDENT participate in a preschool program at the initial period of the one-to-one program.. Dr. Smith recommended that STUDENT continue the one-to-one program for 10 to 15 hours per week for another 12 to 18 months. He also recommended that STUDENT participate in school for 15 hours per week, engage in community outings for 5 hours per week, and have play dates to work on peer interactions for 5 to 10 hours per week.
Shelley Davis, J.D., has worked for the last three years as a behavioralist for the Language Education Assistance for Preschool program (LEAP). LEAP provides home, school, and community-based services for children with autism. Ms. Davis provides services for several school districts in Santa Clara County. At the request of STUDENT’s parents, Ms. Davis observed Ms. Caboara’s class in April 1995. She also met on one occasion with STUDENT and observed a video tape of him. Ms. Davis testified that the SDC staff appeared competent and caring; however, the class was structured as a regular mainstream preschool and was not appropriate for STUDENT. Ms. Davis testified that STUDENT did not “tune into” group instruction and that the only time he was not self-stimulating was when he was being restrained by the staff. Ms. Davis testified that the one-to-one program was necessary for STUDENT to benefit from instruction. Ms. Davis would not recommend that STUDENT return to an SDC, given his success in a regular preschool. She testified that the next logical step is for STUDENT to participate in a regular kindergarten class with support.
Hillary Stubblefield is the program director of BIA, a non-profit, state-certified non-public agency (NPA), that provides a behaviorally-based program to children with autism from age two and one-half-years-old to six years. Ms. Stubblefield studied under Dr. Lovaas at UCLA and has set up approximately 70 behavioral intervention programs. BIA currently has 32 clients. Approximately 15 of the clients are funded by a school district. The goal of BIA is to reinforce the student’s appropriate behaviors and to extinguish inappropriate behaviors. The BIA program is intensive (approximately six hours per day) and employs a four-step discrete-trial format. The instructor provides a stimulus, instructs the student, and gives the student an opportunity to respond. The student then receives a consequence, which may be social praise, specific feedback, a tangible reward, or an activity. Ms. Stubblefield testified that the purpose of the program provided by BIA is to maximize learning opportunities for the student. BIA simplifies the input of information to the student by breaking the world into small parts and by providing stimuli to the student. The program is individualized by using items rewarding to the student so that his/her interest is engaged. The program also is designed to build on the student’s strengths. Ms. Stubblefield testified that BIA emphasizes teaching through play. Ms. Stubblefield testified that the parents play an important role in the success of the BIA program. Parents provide opportunities for the student to practice skills he or she is learning in the sessions. Parents also can participate in the sessions, gather materials, maintain data, attend team meetings, report on their observations, develop goals, and provide individual instruction. The student’s case manager reviews notes made by the instructor two times a week and Ms. Stubblefield reviews the notes every other month to determine whether the program requires modifications. She also writes progress reports with the case manager every six months. Ms. Stubblefield testified that she also observes the student’s school at the beginning of the school year, in the middle, and in the spring. The students and their programs are re-evaluated every three to six months. If the student is not demonstrating some spontaneous imitation, speaking at least 10 words, and is not engaging in some play, a three-month transition plan would be developed after which it would be determined whether to continue with the program. On cross-examination, Ms. Stubblefield testified that none of the instructors employed by BIA have teaching credentials.
Ms. Stubblefield met STUDENT in May 1995. She testified that she easily engaged STUDENT while he was playing with a train. He had a lot of affect, smiled, and exchanged gazes with her. Ms. Stubblefield observed that STUDENT exhibited some communicative intent and receptive language skills, was able to follow minimal directions, and imitated concrete play. Ms. Stubblefield also reviewed STUDENT’s educational records, spoke with Dr. Siegel, and observed a video of his second and third birthday parties. Ms. Stubblefield testified that based on this information she designed STUDENT’s individual program to expand his ability to integrate with his peers, to imitate and engage in abstract play, and to improve expressive language skills, including labeling and vocal imitation. Ms. Stubblefield testified that in May 1995, the only appropriate program for STUDENT was an individual behavioral program, particularly because STUDENT was “losing ground fast.” Ms. Stubblefield testified that STUDENT’s neighborhood offers an “ideal setting” for an individual program emphasizing socialization because the street is enclosed and is “swarming” with three and four year old children, many of whom also attend Happy Day preschool. Ms. Stubblefield stated that the neighborhood setting is important because when STUDENT was ready to generalize skills he learned in the one-to-one program, there were peers available for play dates. Ms. Stubblefield testified that after six months of intensive services from BIA, STUDENT’s linguistic and communicative skills improved and his play became more symbolic. STUDENT began speaking in full sentences and engaging in role play. Ms. Stubblefield testified that STUDENT initially had difficulty demonstrating the behaviors he had learned during individual sessions in environments other than his home. Ms. Stubblefield testified that STUDENT’s program addressed extinguishing self-stimulatory behaviors including chinning, giggling, teeth-grinding, and jargoning.
Ms. Stubblefield stated that STUDENT has required an aide to help him stay focused during the preschool program and continues to require a year-round program so that he will not regress and lose the behaviors he has learned. Although she has not observed the class personally, Ms. Stubblefield testified that the transition class would not be an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1996-1997 school year. The class provides cognitive tasks geared toward kindergarten attendance, whereas STUDENT needs play-based activities. Ms. Stubblefield testified that it is critical for STUDENT to remain in an environment that fosters social growth.
Tracie Vickers is a case manager with BIA. She trains the tutors and parents, writes program reports, observes the students at school, and coordinates team meetings. Ms. Vickers first met STUDENT in May 1995. She testified that STUDENT climbed on the sofa and briefly interacted with Ms. Stubblefield. Ms. Vickers observed STUDENT “chinning” and making a low humming sound. Ms. Vickers testified that during the first three months of the program she observed STUDENT three to six hours per week. She testified that STUDENT responded very well to the program. For example, STUDENT initially protested during the circle time; however, at the end of three months, STUDENT was able to participate in a play date at least one time per week. Ms. Vickers testified that during her observations of STUDENT this year at Happy Day, STUDENT has engaged in more interactions on his own and requires less direct interaction from the tutor.
Ms. Vickers testified that the current emphasis of STUDENT’s program is developing his social and language skills. STUDENT participates in play dates to foster his social skills. Ms. Vickers testified that STUDENT has shown an interest in letters and has begun working on a reading program. STUDENT is learning to generalize at circle time, during play activities, and on play dates. Ms. Vickers described the ways in which each of STUDENT’s goals and objectives are addressed by his BIA program. Ms. Vickers testified that STUDENT should remain in his current class at Happy Day, which provides opportunities for STUDENT to interact with some of the peers who will also be in his kindergarten class. Ms. Vickers also testified that Happy Day’s curriculum is developmentally appropriate for STUDENT and his abilities fall within the range of the other students.
Ms. Vickers observed the La Fiesta transitional kindergarten class to determine whether it would offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1996-1997 school year. She concluded that it would not. There were 15 students in the class. Only one student was a female. The class was arranged around activity centers. There was a sand tray, a table with clay, and a computer. Ms. Vickers testified that she observed few interactions between the aides and the students. She testified that four of the boys in the class behaved aggressively and the teacher spent her time “policing” them rather than teaching. Ms. Vickers testified that the students have not been integrated with a kindergarten class. Some students are “paired” with first-grade students. Ms. Vickers testified that this would not be an appropriate pairing for STUDENT..
Jody Neeson is a school psychologist and has been one of STUDENT’s BIA tutors since June 1995. Ms. Neeson served as the counselor at Pengrove and regularly observed STUDENT in Ms. Caboara’s class during the 1994-1995 school year. Ms. Neeson described Ms. Caboara’s class as “dark, loud, and not aesthetically pleasing.” She stated that the students engaged in self-directed activities and spent a lot of time running around the classroom. Ms. Neeson testified that STUDENT was not using language to communicate and engaged in a lot of self-stimulatory behavior. STUDENT did not attend during circle or activity times and the teacher’s aide restrained him from getting up. The aide did not direct STUDENT to engage in activities. On some occasions, Ms. Neeson observed STUDENT rolling around on the floor. Ms. Neeson testified that she observed Ms. Caboara’s class recently. She described the class as “brighter” and “a little nicer” than her prior classroom. Ms. Neeson testified that Ms. Caboara was using sign language, which is not appropriate for STUDENT because he needs to improve his language skills. Ms. Neeson again observed aides reaching around students to get their attention rather than establishing eye contact with them.
Ms. Neeson testified that she has observed tremendous growth in STUDENT since he began the BIA program. Ms. Neeson stated that when she initially met STUDENT, he avoided people, was noncompliant, screeched, ran away, had no eye contact, spoke one or two words to get what he wanted, and had little or no relationship with his peers. Ms. Neeson testified that STUDENT now is more connected to his family and seeks out his peers. He takes more responsibility for his behavior, reaches out to his neighborhood playmates, spends less time by himself, is more tolerant of others, and has improved eye contact. Ms. Neeson testified that she taught STUDENT to ride a tricycle. Ms. Neeson attributed STUDENT’s progress to the BIA program and the support he receives from his family. She testified that the BIA program is consistent, supportive, understanding of STUDENT and his needs, committed to STUDENT and his family, and offers a systematic approach to teaching language. Ms. Neeson has served as STUDENT’s shadow aide at Happy Day. She testified that STUDENT initially needed a lot of prompting. This year he is more connected to the staff and students. He know the school routine and is easily redirected. Ms. Neeson testified that Happy Day has a stable staff and is one of the best preschools in the area.
Ms. Neeson testified that STUDENT would not have made the same progress if he had remained in the SELPA preschool class. No one was teaching STUDENT at the preschool class in a manner that would allow him to learn. There also were no attempts to build his use of language or to extinguish his self-stimulatory behavior. Ms. Neeson testified that it would not be beneficial for STUDENT to make changes to his program.
Elaine M. Stevick is an independent licensed speech and language pathologist. She first evaluated STUDENT and began providing him speech and language services in the spring of 1994. She was unable to administer formal test instruments and was concerned with STUDENT’s failure to engage with his mother. Ms. Stevick testified that she spent a lot of time with STUDENT’s parents so that they could support STUDENT’s therapy at home and worked with STUDENT by playing and engaging in conversation with him. Ms. Stevick testified that STUDENT’s language skills began to develop and he started labeling things and using language for functional purposes. Ms. Stevick testified from September 1994 to December 1994, that STUDENT’s behavior and skills strangely began to decline. He became more withdrawn and began to grind his teeth very loudly, to rub toys on himself, to butt his head repeatedly on her side, and to rub his head while sitting in the corner of the room. Ms. Stevick testified that unless STUDENT was completely involved in an activity, he would engage in self-stimulatory behaviors.
Ms. Stevick testified that when she observed Ms. Caboara’s class in September 1994, she did not have concerns about the appropriateness of the class for STUDENT. She knew a number of other students in the class and understood that Ms. Caboara used a communication-centered approach to teaching. Ms. Stevick testified, however, that when STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated and exhibited more autistic-like characteristics, she recommended a behaviorally-oriented program and referred the PARENTS to the Regional Center for services. Ms. Stevick initially expressed concern about STUDENT’s participating in a Lovaas-type behavioral program; however, after observing the BIA program, she concluded that the program was working for STUDENT. Ms. Stevick testified that she noticed gradual improvement in STUDENT’s ability to comply, to focus, and to attend. He also “recaptured” some of his prior communicative skills. Ms. Stevick described STUDENT’s growth in the fall of 1995 as “astounding.”
Ms. Stevick testified that from May 1995 to May 1996, STUDENT met a majority of his speech and language goals. STUDENT’s skills were emerging toward meeting another five. Ms. Stevick evaluated STUDENT in November 1996. Ms. Stevick testified that STUDENT was able to label things. She did not observe STUDENT use jargon or perceverate and his answers were not robotic. In November 1996, Ms. Stevick observed STUDENT at Happy Day. She testified that when she entered, STUDENT said from six feet away, “Hi, Elaine.” Ms. Stevick testified that during prior observations, STUDENT had paid little attention to anyone entering or leaving the classroom. Ms. Stevick observed that one of STUDENT’s play dates sought him out at circle time to sit with him. STUDENT was not chinning, humming, or jargoning during her observation. Ms. Stevick testified that language samples taken by BIA demonstrate that STUDENT’s conversations include a variety of responses and consist of more than mere labeling of items.
Ms. Stevick testified that in December 1996, STUDENT demonstrated improving eye contact. He was able to make contact from a longer distance away, for an extended period of time, and for a purpose. STUDENT’s play skills also improved. He was able to play gross-motor games, to play independent with toys, to invite other children to play, to engage in dramatic play, and to take turns. Ms. Stevick testified that STUDENT’s chinning, jargoning, and giggling had decreased and she did not observe any humming or teeth-grinding. Ms. Stevick testified that STUDENT was using six-word sentences with intelligibility and was able to respond to a topic such as,”tell me about....” Ms. Stevick testified that STUDENT sometimes needed to be prompted to use a louder voice and to attend during circle time. Ms. Stevick concluded that STUDENT has made steady, measurable, and positive improvement and has met the majority of his goals. Ms. Stevick attributed STUDENT’s growth to the BIA program and stated that she does not believe that STUDENT would have made similar progress in the SELPA preschool program because it is not sufficiently “intense” to meet his needs. She stated that the SDC employed a “general developmental approach,” whereas STUDENT required a program with specific instruction to develop his vocabulary, articulation skills, and language concepts. She also expressed concern that, because the SDC children had a variety of needs, there was insufficient time to address all their individual needs. Ms. Stevick testified that a collaborative model for delivering speech and language would not provide STUDENT sufficient individual attention, given the difficulty he experienced when working one-to-one with her. She testified that the essential components of BIA’s program that meets STUDENT’s needs is its distinct and well-defined approach to task analysis, the use of motivators, and the consistent involvement of STUDENT’s family. Ms. Stevick recommended that STUDENT continue to receive one-to-one instruction from BIA and attend the same preschool programs for social interactions. She stated that STUDENT is benefitting from the interactions with his regular education peers.
Witnesses for the SELPA and District
Susan Malin holds learning handicapped, administrative, and speech and language therapist credentials and is currently employed as the special education director for the Piner-Olivet and Mark West School Districts. Ms. Malin served as the case management case leader for STUDENT’s initial assessment. Ms. Malin testified that she informed the PARENTS of the assessment process and provided them with a copy of the parents’ rights, which also is on the back of the assessment plan. Ms. Malin testified that at STUDENT’s assessment, she informed the parents of the different programs available within the county. She testified that the results of the assessment were not reviewed with the PARENTS because they were not present at the IEPs. Malin testified that she served as the teacher at the IEP meeting. The teacher who drafted the goals and objectives was not present. Ms. Malin testified that STUDENT’s IEP calls for speech and language consultation and does not necessarily exclude provision of one-to-one services. Ms. Malin testified that it was unnecessary to explain to the PARENTS that private speech and language services STUDENT was receiving from Ms. Stevick could be included as a service in STUDENT’s IEP even if he were not enrolled in a District or SELPA program because SELPA’s preschool program proposed for STUDENT already included speech and language consultation services. Ms. Malin testified that STUDENT’s IEP does not indicate a specific classroom because class placement is an administrative decision. Ms. Malin also testified that the PARENTS indicated that they did not want to place STUDENT in a program during the summer of 1994. It was her understanding that another IEP meeting would be convened prior to STUDENT’s enrolling in the program.
Kathy Bregder, SELPA program specialist, holds standard and administrative credentials and is a licensed school psychologist. Ms. Bregder has assessed over 2,000 students, including 200 students with autism. Ms. Bregder testified that it is the general practice of the SELPA to assess preschool children at their homes because they tend to do better in familiar surroundings. Ms. Bregder testified that STUDENT was noncompliant and would not participate in formal assessment measures. For this reason, the SELPA’s assessment consisted of observations and information from the parents. Ms. Bregder testified that she asked the parents a lot of questions about STUDENT’s behavior. Neither informed her that STUDENT had poor eye contact and lacked social skills. It was her observation that STUDENT made good eye contact during the assessment. Ms. Bregder testified that observations by the assessment team provided information from which to develop goals and objectives. Ms. Bregder testified that she was not present at the IEP; however, Diane Ashton was present in her place. On April 5, 1995, Ms. Bregder observed STUDENT in the SDC. (See District Exhibit 22) Following the observation, Ms. Bregder concluded that the SDC was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. She described the classroom as “bright, happy, fun, exciting, and interesting.” Ms. Bregder did not recommended a one-to-one intrusive program for STUDENT because he was making “expected” gains in the SDC and also because one-to-one intervention is a more restrictive placement that the SDC.
Ms. Bregder expressed concern that Dr. Siegel primarily drew conclusions regarding STUDENT from one source, STUDENT’s parents. She also expressed concern that Dr. Siegel made educational recommendations without first-hand knowledge of the SELPA program. Ms. Bregder testified that Dr. Siegel relied on a report from Shelly Davis and neither visited the SDC herself nor obtained information from STUDENT’s classroom teacher. Ms. Bregder testified that Dr. Siegel’s conclusion following her reassessment that STUDENT’s cognitive skills increased by 20 months was faulty. Ms. Bregder testified that the M-P measures skills at which an autistic child excels. Ms. Bregder also attributed STUDENT’s higher scores to his improved ability to comply, general maturation, and to the practice effect of STUDENT’s taking the same test for a second time within a brief period of time..
Judy Adams, SELPA nurse, was part of the preschool assessment team that conducted the initial assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Adams testified that she gathered information from MOTHER on the telephone. She did not make a home visit because there were no concerns regarding STUDENT’s health. Ms. Adams testified that information regarding STUDENT’s current levels of functioning were not included in STUDENT’s IEP because the assessment reports were gone over with STUDENT’s parents and then become part of the IEP. Ms. Adams testified that Sue Nieuwenhuijs drafted the goals and objectives on STUDENT’s initial IEP. She did not recall that any particular SDC preschool class had been recommended for STUDENT.
Melissa Caboara, SELPA preschool SDC teacher, holds regular and special education teaching credentials. About 10 of the 50 to 60 preschool students she has taught were diagnosed with autism or pervasive developmental delays. STUDENT was in Ms. Caboara’s class from September 1994 to April 1995. There were seven students at the beginning of the school year and there were twelve students in April 1995. Ms. Caboara was assisted by one full-time aide all year. Another was added in January 1995. Ms. Caboara described her class as a “heterogenous” group of students. Most of the students were learning or communicatively handicapped with fairly high cognitive abilities. Ms. Caboara testified that there were appropriate peers in the class for social interaction with STUDENT. Ms. Caboara testified that the SDC at Pengrove had quiet, play, rug, and housekeeping areas. There were cubbies for the students’ backpacks and lunches and a table in the middle of the room for snack time and activities. Ms. Caboara testified that she posted the class schedule in the classroom so that parents and students would know what to expect. Ms. Caboara testified that she employed portions of the Hi Scope curriculum during circle time, used the Bonderman speech and language program, and provided activities to develop typical preschool skills including shapes, colors, articles of clothing, and vehicles. The Bonderman program is designed to introduce sounds to the students and to teach them to incorporate them into daily activities. For example, at circle time Ms. Caboara would show the students pictures that include the sounds. The students would then practice the sounds at recess, art would incorporate activities involving the sounds, and snacks were also related to the sounds. Ms. Caboara testified that she provided a structured environment that allowed opportunities for the students to participate in a number of activities and to use a variety of materials. Ms. Caboara balanced free choice activities and teacher selected activities, and provided individual, large- and small-group instruction. Ms. Caboara testified that to meet students’ needs, she would individualize each activity. For example, when making a collage, she would stress colors with one student while using the same activity to develop the pincer grip of another student. Ms. Caboara testified that Ms. Field, the OT, was in the class at least one hour per week and Ms. Henke, the speech and language therapist, was there at least two times a week for one and one-half to two hours.
Ms. Caboara testified that STUDENT and his mother “appeared”on the first day of school in September 1994. Since she was not anticipating that STUDENT would be in her class, she had not read his IEP. Ms. Caboara testified that she did not get a chance to read STUDENT’s IEP until the end of the first week of school. Ms. Caboara testified that the goals and objectives STUDENT entered her class with were appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs and that she was able to address all of the goals and objectives in her classroom. Ms. Caboara testified that while in her class, STUDENT had good days and bad days. He was ill for a period in January 1995; however, she did not recall that he experienced a “crash” in December. Ms. Caboara testified that Tuesdays and Thursdays were difficult for STUDENT because he arrived late from speech and language sessions. Ms. Caboara testified that she spoke regularly with the PARENTS when they picked up STUDENT from school. She did not make a home visit until STUDENT had been withdrawn from her class because she saw the parents frequently and sent notes home daily.
Ms. Caboara testified that to meet STUDENT’s behavioral needs she used redirection and physical prompting interspersed with breaks, positive reinforcement for appropriate behavior, and setting of clear boundaries. She testified that hand-over-hand assistance was also used, as necessary, and that a child gate was set up to keep STUDENT in the classroom when the door was open. Ms. Caboara testified that students sat in the laps of teachers and aides; however, students were not restrained. Ms. Caboara defined restraint as “holding down a student for a significant period of time.” Ms. Caboara testified that to get STUDENT to respond, she would first make a verbal request, take STUDENT by the hand, and then wait. She stated that STUDENT would get tired at circle time so a teacher would hold him or he could sit on a nearby sofa. Ms. Caboara testified that in September and October, STUDENT would need to be physically redirected to nearly every activity. By March 1995, STUDENT was able to participate on his own more frequently. Ms. Caboara testified that STUDENT engaged in self-stimulatory activity several times a day. He would press his hand and other items to his chin, self-talk, and hum. Ms. Caboara testified that she would redirect STUDENT if his self-stimulatory behavior was interfering with his participation in the classroom. Ms. Caboara testified that she encouraged interactions between children by stepping in when one child initiated play and the other did not respond. She also planned games and activities involving several children, encouraged interactions with other children, and reinforced spontaneous interactions. Ms. Caboara testified that at the beginning of the school year, STUDENT was unable to sit by himself or participate in a whole song at circle time, whereas in the spring he could. Ms Caboara testified that in September, STUDENT did not spontaneously interact with peers. By April, STUDENT was able to follow the leader and also to initiate his own playground activities, such as chase.
To encourage STUDENT’s development of language, Ms. Caboara used materials designed to stimulate his production of language, modeled appropriate language, narrated what STUDENT was doing, repeated what he said with embellishment, used total communication throughout the day, and encouraged and reinforced all spontaneous speech. For example, if STUDENT said “fish,” Ms. Caboara said,”Oh, look, the fish are swimming.” Ms. Caboara testified that she addressed STUDENT’s language goals and objectives throughout the daily schedule. For example, to encourage him to follow a two-part direction, she would tell STUDENT at the end of an activity to “put away toys and come to circle.” At snack time, she would tell STUDENT to “put cup in bucket and napkin in garbage.” Ms. Caboara testified that STUDENT initially required her to physically prompt him through the sequence. She would also ask STUDENT, “What are you doing?” and then would describe what he was doing. To address STUDENT’s goal to improve cognition, she would reinforce anything STUDENT did or said spontaneously. To address STUDENT’s goal regarding motor planning, Ms. Caboara would sing songs at circle time that used simple motor movements and would repeat APE activities in class. To address self-help skills, Ms. Caboara provided regularly scheduled opportunities to reinforce positive skills. For example, if STUDENT used the toilet, she would sing and express her excitement. To get STUDENT to participate in “messy play,” Ms. Caboara would encourage STUDENT to participate in activities using shaving cream, soap, foam, and finger paints. To address STUDENT’s goal regarding scissors, Ms. Caboara always had scissors available and incorporated activities using tongs to select items to sort. Tricycles were available at recess and Ms. Caboara encouraged STUDENT to ride them. Ms. Caboara testified that initially, an adult would have to push STUDENT. To address STUDENT’s goal regarding attending to task, Ms. Caboara would attempt to get him to stay in the circle with minimal assistance from an adult. Ms. Caboara testified that she kept track of STUDENT’s progress through observations, conversations with staff and specialists, notes of events, work samples, and conversations with STUDENT’s parents. Ms. Caboara testified that she did not record data on each teaching trial because it would have interfered with her ability to be an effective teacher.
Ms. Caboara testified that she reported at the IEP meeting in May 1995 that STUDENT had made progress while in her class. She stated that in September, STUDENT did not use the bathroom and did not put his coat and other items away. In May he would urinate in the bathroom and independently put away his belongings. STUDENT’s willingness to participate in fine-motor activities also increased. In gross-motor areas, STUDENT learned to ride a tricycle independently. In speech and language, STUDENT showed improvement in his ability to use phrases in appropriate contexts. In academics, STUDENT showed improvement in his ability to identify body parts and colors and to participate in academic tasks. STUDENT continued to need to work on social and play skills. He also needed to be less resistant to following adult direction and to improve toileting and completing tasks. Ms. Caboara testified that the goals and objectives developed at the May 1995 IEP meeting could have been addressed in an SDC with Head Start providing appropriate support for social interactions with typically developing peers. Ms. Caboara testified that a one-to-one aide was not necessary for STUDENT to successfully participate in the SDC or Head Start. Ms. Caboara testified that the home program provided by the parents was not appropriate for STUDENT. It also was not the least restrictive environment for him. Ms. Caboara testified that at home, STUDENT was not learning in a natural context and she expected STUDENT would have difficulty transferring skills learned in the isolated home environment to other environments.
Ms. Caboara testified regarding her observation of Happy Day. Ms. Caboara expressed concern regarding the size of the classroom and the number of students. She stated that there were 50 children at the school. Ms. Caboara observed little adult facilitation to encourage STUDENT to participate in activities. During free play, STUDENT “flitted” from one activity to another. She observed that STUDENT used little language and infrequently interacted with peers or adults. Ms. Caboara testified that STUDENT’s aide interacted briefly with him and then stepped back from him. Ms. Caboara testified that STUDENT engaged in the same types of self-stimulatory behaviors he engaged in while in her class. She observed him press items to his chin twelve times. Ms. Caboara also observed Gan Israel. Ms. Caboara testified that, compared to Happy Day, the student-to-teacher ratio at Gan was low and STUDENT interacted more with students and adults, participated in more activities, and used more language. Ms. Caboara observed STUDENT at home. Her concerns regarding the home program were that it was too adult directed and that STUDENT had little opportunity to make choices. Ms. Caboara observed the following changes in STUDENT since she last saw him in May 1995: at Happy Day, he was less focused and engaged in a new self-stimulating activity-spinning; at Gan Israel, he required a comparable amount of prompting to participate in messy activities and he showed some growth in play skills; and, at home, his language and ability to identify shapes improved. On cross-examination, Ms. Caboara testified that STUDENT requires OT, APE, and speech and language services wherever he attends school.
Debbie Blanton is the manager of disability and mental health services components for the Sonoma County People for Economic Opportunity Head Start. Ms. Blanton testified that Head Start is a child development program for children from low income families and children with special needs. Head Start serves children who turn three years old by December 2nd of the school year. The upper age limit for eligibility is five years old, so long as the child is not eligible for kindergarten. Ms. Blanton testified that Head Start has an interagency agreement whereby Head Start and SELPA SDC staff team teach three classes. These sites are in Healdsburg, Windsor, and at Grace Reese School. In Petaluma, the SELPA SDC and the Head Start preschool program are located on the same site; however, the teachers do not team teach. During the 1995-1996 school year, two head start classes were located at McKinley. Ms. Blanton testified that Head Start offers an effective model for students with disabilities and provides opportunities to acquire language and social skills. Each Head Start class has approximately 20 students. Fifteen of the students have typically developing skills. Head Start follows the Hi Scope curriculum, which is a child-centered, child-directed curriculum whereby students flow through the classroom and participate in open-ended activities set up by the teachers. Ms. Blanton testified that Head Start centers are licensed and teachers must possess child development center certificates or permits. Some of the teachers hold regular teaching credentials. Head Start teachers receive ongoing training and annually participate in training with SELPA staff. Head Start staff are also required to observe students who also attend a SDC.
Ms. Blanton testified that the Head Start class located at McKinley during the 1995-1996 school year was three and one-half hours long. The class had one teacher and an assistant. Additional staff included a language resource assistant to help students whose primary language is not English, a family outreach worker, and a site assistant to help with meals. Ms. Blanton has not been present at any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings. She “hypothesized” that STUDENT would have attended the SDC in the morning until noon and then would go to the afternoon Head Start class. Ms. Blanton testified that STUDENT’s needs appeared to be similar to other students attending Head Start. Ms. Blanton testified that over the past seven years, Head Start has served three students with autism. She did not recall speaking with MOTHER and did not know what MOTHER may have been told about the availability of a space for STUDENT in the Head Start program.
Darrell Henke, SELPA speech and language therapist, has assessed and provided services to approximately 1,000 students. Over 40 of the students have been diagnosed with autism or pervasive developmental disabilities. Ms. Henke testified that she provided STUDENT’s speech and language services in the classroom because that is the natural environment for school where he needs to practice his communication skills. She testified that when STUDENT entered the SDC in September 1994, he played by himself, had limited eye contact with children and adults, used little spontaneous language, did not socially engage with children or adults, engaged in stereotypical play with objects, and used a lot of jargon. Ms. Henke worked with STUDENT on following directions and expanding his language. For example, she would shadow STUDENT and describe the actions he was going through. Ms. Henke testified that the Bonderman program was used with STUDENT to help him increase his attention to task, taking turns, following directions, and participating in group activities. Ms. Henke testified that Ms. Caboara would sit behind STUDENT to prompt him. Ms. Henke testified that after the winter break, STUDENT independently participated in lessons and his skills improved. Ms. Henke testified that her assessment of STUDENT in March 1995 showed that he had made gains in pointing to pictures, answering some “wh” questions, and answering some “yes/no” questions. Ms. Henke testified that STUDENT was inflexible in his behavior and resisted when things were not done in the manner he was accustomed. Ms. Henke described STUDENT’s language as “unsequenced and unpredictable.” Ms. Henke did not think it was appropriate to tell STUDENT to “use a quiet voice” when STUDENT began to jargon. Ms. Henke testified that STUDENT continued to exhibit deficits in maintaining eye contact, grammatical structures, paying attention to verbal requests, and flexibility in play. Ms. Henke testified that Ms. Stevick’s scores do not indicate that STUDENT has made significant progress. Ms. Henke expressed concern that Ms. Stevick had re-administered tests she had used one month earlier. Ms. Henke testified that she occasionally made home visits during the 1994-1995 school year; however, she did not make a home visit to STUDENT’s home.
Ms. Henke testified that STUDENT’s parents were actively involved with developing goals and objectives at the May 1995 IEP meeting. She stated that the goals and objectives and placement proposed at the May 1995 meeting were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Henke testified that STUDENT had been making progress in the SDC and that the Head Start program would provide him an opportunity to interact with his normally developing peers to practice social and language skills. Ms. Henke testified that the students in Ms. Caboara’s class during the 1995-1996 school year had language skills that were both above and below STUDENT’s. Ms. Henke testified that Ms. Caboara’s class continued to offer a program that would provide STUDENT with the consistency, follow through, and support that he required to allow him to make educational progress. Ms. Henke testified that STUDENT would not require a one-to-one aide if her were in Ms. Caboara’s class.
Ms. Henke testified that for the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT requires placement in a small classroom with 15 or fewer students. The class should include students with higher language, social, and play skills than STUDENT so that he will learn to model their behavior. The class also should have strong language component. Ms. Henke testified that the transitional kindergarten offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Ms. Henke testified that a home program has been uncalled for because STUDENT had begun to make social contact, imitate play with his peers, and follow directions in Ms. Caboara’s class. Ms. Henke also expressed concern that the language taught in the home program is rote and limited in application. Ms. Henke testified regarding her observation of STUDENT at Gan Israel. STUDENT sat in a circle on the floor with the other student in the class. STUDENT’s attention fluctuated and sometimes he sang the songs. Ms. Henke testified that the teacher did a good job of cuing STUDENT to respond. STUDENT’s only interaction with the other students was to chase them through some cubes. Ms. Henke observed that when the class became unpredictable or stressful, STUDENT hit himself on the chin. Ms. Henke testified that at Gan Israel, STUDENT was pretty much on his own, whereas in Ms. Caboara’s class, he was engaged with other children.
Sarah W. Field, OTR, is in private practice. She assessed STUDENT for the SELPA in the fall 1994. Ms. Field administered as many portions of the Peabody measures of fine and gross motor skills as could. She also spoke with Ms. Caboara and FATHER. She recalled writing an addendum to STUDENT’s initial IEP but did not recall attending an IEP meeting. Ms. Field testified that she provided weekly OT in Ms. Caboara’s class. A small group of students would rotate through activities she had set up. Following the sessions, the teacher would replicate the activities with the students. Ms. Field described Ms. Caboara’s class as “organized.” Ms. Field testified that STUDENT came to class late, which was difficult for him; however, he was willing to participate in activities with her and spoke in sentences. Ms. Henke testified that the SDC and Head Start offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1995 school year. She recommended that STUDENT continue with OT in whichever educational setting he is placed.
Debbie Gayaldo, SELPA adapted physical education teacher, has assessed approximately 1,000 students to determine whether they are eligible for APE and has provided services to 700-800 students. Over the past three years, Ms. Gayaldo has worked with 50 to 60 students with the diagnosis of autism of pervasive developmental delay. Ms. Gayaldo currently provides APE to 52 preschool students with gross-motor delays of approximately one to one and one-half years. Ms. Gayaldo testified that occupational therapy, APE, and speech and language services are provided in preschool SDCs using a collaborative model rather than by pulling students out of class to provide individual services. Ms. Gayaldo rotates students through several stations where she has set up gross-motor and sensory-motor activities. Ms. Gayaldo served STUDENT while he was in Ms. Caboara’s class following an assessment by Sarah Field on October 10, 1994. Ms. Gayaldo had not attended the IEP at which APE goals and objectives were developed. Ms. Gayaldo testified that after STUDENT was placed on her APE case load, he continued to participate in the group stations; however, she worked with him for a longer period of time to address APE goals and objectives. She also collaborated daily with the teacher and provided in-service training to the classroom staff. Ms. Gayaldo provided services in Ms. Caboara’s class for a total of 15 minutes per week. Ms. Gayaldo testified that in April 1995, STUDENT’s gross-motor skills had improved and he was able to follow directions with fewer prompts. Ms. Gayaldo testified that she did not provide any services to STUDENT after he left Ms. Caboara’s class. Ms. Gayaldo testified that she did not reassess STUDENT prior to the May 1995 IEP; however, she provided an update of his present levels of performance. She developed goals and objectives with input from MOTHER. Ms. Gayaldo testified that the SDC and Head Start placement proposed for the 1995-1996 school year was appropriate for STUDENT. In the SDC, STUDENT would receive appropriate sensory programming and in Head Start, he would have opportunities to develop social and play skills. Ms. Gayaldo assessed STUDENT in May 1996. She testified that STUDENT continued to require APE due to delays in gross-motor and motor planning skills. Ms. Gayaldo testified that goals and objectives were developed in consultation with MOTHER and could be implemented in the transition kindergarten. Ms. Gayaldo testified that she works with the students in small groups using pre-kindergarten games to develop gross-motor skills.
Ms. Beavers testified that Ms. Caboara’s SDC offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 and 1995-1996 school years because Ms. Caboara has the requisite background and skills to meet STUDENT’s needs. Her class is structured and there are opportunities to mainstream with other students either in Head Start class or a regular kindergarten class. Ms. Beavers testified that at the IEP meeting in the spring of 1995, she provided the parents with a copy of parental rights, reviewed goals and objectives from the June and October 1994 IEPs, talked about STUDENT’s then-current levels of functioning, and gathered information from the parents. Ms. Beavers testified that when the IEP team reconvened in May 1995, the team reached consensus on the goals and objectives. Ms. Beavers testified that she provided the parents with a copy of their rights. Ms. Beavers testified that at all times STUDENT has required a school placement. She weighed Dr. Siegel’s recommendations against the recommendations of the educational staff and Stanford. Ms. Beavers concluded that Dr. Siegel had limited experience with STUDENT, whereas school staff had worked with STUDENT and observed him in an educational setting. Ms. Beavers testified that the parents did not request additional support services and stated that BIA was “complete within itself.” Ms. Beavers testified that the transition kindergarten, which was proposed as an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year, is an SDC that serves as a link from the preschool SDC to a regular education program. Ms. Beavers testified that the transition kindergarten at La Fiesta has 15 children. The students range in their abilities and generally are in the process of transitioning to kindergarten classes in their home districts. Ms. Beavers testified that STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behavior could be addressed within the classroom environment.
Ms. Beavers testified that she was concerned about STUDENT’s participation in a Lovaas program because of its limited focus on behavior. Ms. Beavers stated that many students with autism have successfully gone from a preschool SDC to a regular education kindergarten without participating in an individual behavioral program. Ms. Beavers testified that she currently has contact with two former students with autism who are employed in the community and live in the community with roommates. Ms. Beavers expressed concern about the number of students at Happy Day and stated that when a class is large, it is difficult for the student to receive individual attention. Ms. Beavers testified that preschool is a step from home to a regular school program and should be personalized and intimate. Ms. Beavers testified also that best early childhood educational practices dictate that groups of preschool students remain small. Because of the number of students at Happy Day, circle time is directed by the teacher and students participate only when called upon. In Ms. Beavers’ experience, children with autism do not generalize well and should be taught in the environment in which the student will have opportunities to use the skills. For example, Ms. Beavers does not believe that STUDENT can learn circle skills at Happy Day and then implement what he has learned in another environment. Ms. Beavers testified that STUDENT is being taught in two extreme environments. On the one hand, he is at home with two aides who focus their attention on him and structure his environment. At Happy Day, STUDENT is one of 50 students in a much less structured environment. Ms. Beavers conceded that STUDENT has been successful to some extent in his BIA program and that he shows improved language skills. Ms. Beavers testified that there is no reason to believe that he would not have made the same or better gains in the SELPA’s program.
Diane Ashton, Ph.D., is currently the director of special education for the Twin Hills Union School District, which is a consortium of 11 school districts. She also is on the faculty at California State University Sonoma and is an educational consultant in private practice. Dr. Ashton previously served as the SELPA preschool director and as a school psychologist in Sonoma. Dr. Ashton has assessed 500-600 children with autism and has designed programs for over 100. Dr. Ashton testified that autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder in which incoming sensory information is distorted, unreliable, and does not have the same meaning or relevance as it does to a typical person. Dr. Ashton testified that there are many different approaches to teaching children with autism. Dr. Ashton testified that Temple Grandon, an adult with autism, states that the essential program components for a student with autism are: a set structure with consistency and predictability; a behavioral management program with clear expectations; a developmentally appropriate curriculum; strong communication program; and a curriculum to teach social skills. Dr. Ashton also referred to a study conducted at Rutgers University that found children with autism progressed in an integrated setting with nondisabled and disabled peers that included a strong communication program. Dr. Ashton testified that the strong communication program is an essential component of a successful program for a child with autism. Dr. Ashton expressed concern regarding Dr. Siegel’s assessment. She testified that it appears Dr. Siegel relied on the work of a resident. Dr. Ashton also stated that the same test should not be have been readministered after only a few months because the outcomes will not be reliable. The second administration may result in higher scores because of the practice effect.
Dr. Ashton testified that STUDENT’s IEPs for the 1994-1995, 1995-1996, and 1996-1997 school years are appropriate. The goals and objectives are comprehensive and cover developmentally appropriate areas, preacademic readiness, social, emotional, and play skills. The IEPs offer speech and language therapy and OT services to enhance STUDENT’s gross-motor skills. Dr. Ashton noted that the IEPs did not designate the amount of time that STUDENT would spend with regular education peers. It also would be important for STUDENT’s teacher to conduct home visits and to communicate daily with the parents so that they can support the school program at home. Dr. Ashton also took issue with the statement that the SELPA preschool is “child led.” She stated that there is a daily schedule and routine and the students’ behaviors are managed by the teacher. Dr. Ashton testified regarding her observation of the transition kindergarten. There were 10 students in the class. The students’ language skills ranged from non-verbal to speaking in sentences. Dr. Ashton observed that the students were talking and interacting with each other and the staff engaged in appropriate language interactions with the students, particularly during snack time. Dr. Ashton did not observe any acting out behavior or tantrumming by the students. The daily schedule, including the times for activities, was posted on the chalkboard, the classroom was arranged by areas, and there were three work tables at which the students were grouped. Dr. Ashton testified that it is appropriate to group students with different disabilities when they have similar needs. Dr. Ashton testified that the transition kindergarten offers an appropriate program for STUDENT with the addition of a one-to-one aide and a transition plan for moving him to a regular education program. Dr. Ashton testified that she would not recommend a home-based program in lieu of the SDC; however, she was willing to consider it as a supplement to the SDC.
Deborah Porter, SELPA school psychologist, testified that the IEP developed for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 was designed to address his strengths and needs. STUDENT’s needs included weaknesses in expressive and receptive language and inappropriate behaviors. Ms. Porter, who had worked with Ms. Caboara in another school district and was assigned to her class during the 1995-1996 school year, testified that Ms. Caboara’s class is structured and that she addresses each student’s needs within developmentally appropriate activities and materials. She directs the students through opportunities in the classroom and has clear expectations and consequences for the students.
Based on her assessment of STUDENT in March 1996, Ms. Porter testified that two-thirds of STUDENT’s skills fall in the two- to four-year-old level. He has some emerging skills in the four- to seven-year-old level. Ms. Porter criticized Dr. Siegel’s assessment because she did not include measures of autism, adaptive skills, or cognitive strengths and weaknesses. Ms. Porter testified that the M-P used by Dr. Siegel was normed in the 1930s. The tasks do not increase in complexity and the student is asked to do the same tasks each time the test is administered. High scores are obtained by the student completing the task at a faster rate. Additionally, because of the effect of retesting on the same instrument, Dr. Siegel’s scores should not be used to substantiate that STUDENT’s cognitive skills increased while he was in the BIA program. Ms. Porter testified that Dr. Siegel’s second assessment of STUDENT’s skills falls above the otherwise consistent progression shown on all other measures of STUDENT’s skills. Dr. Siegel did not follow her own advice to talk to everyone involved with STUDENT. Ms. Porter also testified that Dr. Siegel’s report of STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors increasing cannot be relied upon because she did not consult with school personnel who did not, in fact, observe an increase in self-stimulatory behavior.
Ms. Porter testified that the program provided by BIA is not appropriate for STUDENT because it is based on flawed research. According to Ms. Porter, Dr. Lovaas’ research is faulty because it did not have a control group for purposes of comparing the results of the subjects receiving treatment with those who did not; the subjects were not randomly assigned to a treatment group; subjects were not selected by any discrete measure of autism; there were no predictable pre- and post-test measures; and the subjects was exclusionary because only higher functioning individuals were included. Ms. Porter expressed similar concerns regarding Dr. Siegel’s recent study because she may have placed students in a certain groups based on their language skills. According to Ms. Porter, Dr. Siegel has said that she diagnoses some students with autism rather than PDD because it is easier for them to get services with a diagnosis of autism. Ms. Porter also criticized Dr. Smith’s article because he misportrays the TEEACH program. She also questioned Dr. Smith’s objectivity because he has written articles with Dr. Lovaas and casts him in a “glowing light.”
Regarding her observation of STUDENT’s BIA program, Ms. Porter testified that she was “struck” by how artificial the environment was and how dependent STUDENT was on adult intervention. She testified that STUDENT did not require the support of two adults. Ms. Porter additionally expressed concern that, because it is difficult for children with autism to generalize from one environment to another, it is unlikely that STUDENT will be able to use skills he has learned with BIA in other environments. Ms. Porter testified that the home program is unnecessarily restrictive, given that STUDENT was successful in the preschool environment. Ms. Porter testified regarding her observations of STUDENT at Happy Day. She stated that STUDENT tried to attend and comply with directions from the teacher; however, verbal cues were insufficient and he needed to rely on visual and contextual cues. During her observation, STUDENT’s spontaneous verbal utterances were limited. She testified that STUDENT appeared motivated to participate; however, he did not interact with other children during play and he did not appear to have any friends.
Ms. Porter testified that at the IEP meeting to plan for the 1996-1997 school year, the team reviewed the results of the assessment and information from BIA, and then worked collaboratively to draft goals and objectives. Ms. Porter testified that STUDENT should be placed with a small number of other students where his social and communication skills can be developed. Ms. Porter testified that all of the goals and objectives can be implemented in the transitional kindergarten and the services will provide the support STUDENT needs. Ms. Porter testified that the class is structured and offers a developmentally appropriate curriculum.
Linda Patterson, SELPA preschool assistant principal, testified regarding STUDENT’s IEPs. She concurred with the testimony of other witnesses regarding what took place at the meetings. Ms. Patterson added that STUDENT’s IEP for the 1994-1995 school year does not include behavioral goals and objectives because no one raised behavior as a concern. Ms. Patterson testified that the IEP does not indicate that STUDENT would be mainstreamed with regular education students because SDC students are generally first taught the skills they will need to successfully mainstream before actually being mainstreamed. Ms. Patterson testified that she frequently observed Ms. Caboara’s class during the 1994-1995 and 1995-1996 school years because Ms. Caboara was a new teacher in the SELPA and part of Ms. Patterson’s responsibilities as vice principal was to evaluate new teachers. Ms. Patterson testified that Ms. Caboara is an excellent teacher. She has a solid understanding of early childhood education and does a good job adapting the curriculum to individual students’ needs. Ms. Caboara also is organized and her classroom is structured. Ms. Patterson testified that the Hi Scope curriculum employed by Ms. Caboara is balanced between child- and adult-led activities. The teacher provides structured learning activities centered around the child’s interests and may lead or facilitate the activities. Ms. Patterson testified that she never observed staff inappropriately restraining STUDENT. Ms. Patterson testified that there was not a written behavioral intervention plan while STUDENT was in Ms. Caboara’s class; however, the staff employed behavioral strategies including ignoring, redirecting, physically and verbally prompting, and positive reinforcing for appropriate behavior. Ms. Patterson was not aware of any language samples of other data collected pertaining to STUDENT’s progress toward meeting goals and objectives while in Ms. Caboara’s class.
Ms. Patterson concurred with the testimony of other witnesses that the SDC, the SDC and Head Start combination, and the transition kindergarten offered appropriate placements for STUDENT. Ms. Patterson testified that the transition class has 15 students, a teacher, and two assistants. The class is four hours per day and focuses on pre-academic, social, and communication skills. The teacher uses positive reinforcement and structures motivation and developmentally appropriate activities. Ms. Patterson testified that 60% to 75% of the students successfully move to kindergarten classes in their home school districts and do not require additional special education services. Ms. Patterson concurred with other SELPA and District witnesses that the BIA program was unnecessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. Ms. Patterson testified that Happy Day has too many children for STUDENT and that he did not receive sufficient support from his assistant or from the Happy Day staff. Ms. Patterson found that Gan Israel was more appropriate for STUDENT because it has a small number of students and a low student-to-teacher ratio. Ms. Patterson testified that STUDENT appeared more comfortable, relaxed, and interested in the materials. STUDENT’s aide interacted with him and facilitated play activities and transitions.
Ms. Patterson testified that Ms. Stevick’s assessment of STUDENT does not support her conclusion that STUDENT made “significant” progress. Ms. Patterson testified that STUDENT showed growth only in his ability to label objects. Ms. Patterson testified that she could not tell much about STUDENT’s use of language from the language samples provided by the parents. During her observation of STUDENT at a play date, he used from one-word to seven-word utterances. His average utterance was from three to four words. Ms. Patterson commented on the videos provided by the parents. She stated the segment of a group activity in Ms. Caboara’s class does not include the aide gradually moving STUDENT to the floor and pulling away from him when he began to put his chin on her. Ms. Patterson testified that STUDENT “looked real appropriate” during the letter activity at the table. Ms. Patterson testified that the physical education segment omits STUDENT ultimately participating in the activity.
Ms. Patterson testified that the program provided by BIA is artificial. She did not find appropriate several techniques employed by the tutors, including putting food in STUDENT’s mouth as a reward and rubbing their hands across his face. Ms. Patterson testified that STUDENT’s incessant laughing, jargoning, and making funny noises are indicative of stress. Ms. Patterson does not believe that STUDENT’s chinning is self-stimulatory. She stated that putting objects to his chin is how STUDENT explores his environment. She also stated that it is not interfering with his education because he is able to pay attention ad participate in activities.
Carolyn Coyman, District director of special education and bilingual education, has been present at least one IEP meeting for STUDENT. Ms. Coyman testified that STUDENT’s application to the COE full inclusion program was denied. Ms. Coyman testified that she “philosophically” disagrees with the request to fund a program such as BIA for one child when there are programs available in the District to meet his needs. Ms. Coyman expressed the opinion that the transitional kindergarten is an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year.
Billye Raye Lipscomb, District superintendent, testified that Happy Day generally has a good reputation and that students coming to the District from Happy Day, as well as from a number of other preschools, are well prepared to enter kindergarten. Ms. Lipscomb testified that kindergarten classes in the District are limited to 30 students per classroom.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT prior to the individualized educational program (IEP) team meeting on June 1, 1994?
In order for the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Assessment and testing materials must also not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.
Subsection 56320(e) states that “No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs.” Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b).
The initial assessment of STUDENT, which is contained in LEAs’ Exhibits 6-8, was conducted by Judy Adams, nurse, Susan Malin, speech and language pathologist, and Kathy Bregder, school psychologist. The assessment team reported that formal testing was not completed with STUDENT because he would not participate in “adult-directed table activities.” For this reason, the SELPA’s assessment of STUDENT consisted of MOTHER’s completion of the Alpern Boll Developmental Profile II, a review of the available records regarding STUDENT, and observations of STUDENT at his home by the assessment team. The school nurse also had MOTHER complete health and developmental questionnaires and spoke with MOTHER on the telephone. The assessment report references a speech and language assessment completed by independent speech and language therapist Ms. Lipp. Ms. Lipp’s scores were also based on information obtained from MOTHER because STUDENT “did not respond directly to any of the tasks on the Preschol Language Scale-3.” (LEAs’ Exhibit 8, p. 2 and 3)
The testimony of Ms. Malin, Ms. Bregder, and Ms. Adams, and LEAs’ Exhibits 6-8 establishes the following. As to whether the SELPA’s assessment of STUDENT addressed all areas of suspected disability, STUDENT’s communication, motor skills, self-help skills, cognitive functioning, and some social skills were evaluated utilizing the Alpern Boll and by observation. Further information regarding STUDENT’s speech and language skills from Ms. Lipp was available and considered by the assessment team, and health and developmental information was obtained from the parent. No additional areas of suspected disability were identified. The assessment consisted of observation, information from the parent, and a measure of development. Therefore, the assessment did not rely on only one procedure for determining an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. As to the validity of the Alpern Boll, there was no credible evidence that the Alpern Boll is an invalid measure to obtain information pertaining to STUDENT’s development, given his lack of cooperation in formal testing. There also was no evidence that the testing, assessment materials, or procedures utilized by the SELPA were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. The assessment was attempted in English, which is STUDENT’s primary language. The assessors included appropriately credentialed school psychologist, nurse, and speech and language pathologist. Their testimony establishes that they have received training in the assessment of young children with varying disabilities and cultural and ethnic backgrounds. The evidence also establishes that, through course work and other training, the assessors have some familiarity with the diagnoses given to STUDENT--autism, pervasive developmental disabilities, and speech and language deficits.
The SELPA’s initial assessment was supplemented in October 1994 by an OT assessment. Sarah Field, a registered occupational therapist, conducted the assessment. She observed STUDENT with his father and attempted to administer the Peabody Developmental Motor Scale. Ms. Field reported that the test was not administered in a standardized manner because of STUDENT’s unwillingness to complete some tasks. Ms. Field also stated that the results could be used to “reflect a range of his skills.” Ms. Field’s qualifications allow her to conduct an OT assessment and she testified that she is familiar with the disabilities of P.D. and autism. There is no evidence that her assessment was in any way discriminatory or that it was administered in a language other than English..
The only substantial issue raised on behalf of STUDENT is whether the SELPA’s assessment was based on “mere report and conjecture,” as asserted in “PARENT’s Closing Brief.” The sole instrument utilized by the SELPA in its initial assessment of STUDENT, the Alpern Boll, is a screening device that elicits information from the parent regarding the child’s development in a number of areas; however, the SELPA did not rely entirely on the Alpern Boll. Additional information was obtained from the report of a private assessor, observations of STUDENT in his home environment, and through a supplemental OT assessment. Moreover, Education Code §56441.11(e), which addresses the assessment of children between the ages of three years and five years, states that when standardized tests are considered invalid, “alternative means, for example, scales, instruments, observations, and interviews shall be used as specified in the assessment plan.” The SELPA’s assessment plan, which was signed by MOTHER, provides for observation, interview, and alternative means of assessment. (LEAs’ Exhibit 5) Given STUDENT’s lack of cooperation in formal testing attempted by the SELPA, as well as by independent assessors, Ms. Lipp and Ms. Stevick, the use of nonstandardized and alternative means to assess STUDENT was appropriate under the circumstances. Based on the above information, the Hearing Officer concludes that the SELPA’s assessment complied with the requirements of Education Code §§ 56320 and 56324(a)(b) and, therefore, was appropriate.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 school year?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term "related services" includes transportation and other services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17).(Footnote 3) California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
STUDENT’s representative contends that the IEP goals and objectives, services, and placement offered by the SELPA and District at the IEP meeting for the 1994-1995 school year were “generic” in nature and based on an already available collaborative model rather than on STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and did not provide him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE). STUDENT’s representative also contends that the following were necessary components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 school year: (a) a 30 to 40 hour per week one-to-one in-home behavioral intervention program supervised by Behavioral Intervention Associates (BIA) or, prior to BIA, by an appropriate nonpublic agency behavioral specialist; (b) participation in a mainstream preschool program for 12 hours per week with a shadow aide from BIA; (c) six hours per month of behavioral intervention provided by BIA; (d) one hour biweekly treatment team meetings with all staff; and (e) materials and supplies as necessary to implement the behavioral intervention program. The SELPA and District contend that the goals, objectives, services, and placement in Ms. Caboara’s SDC were appropriate and met STUDENT’s needs during the 1994-1995 school year.
In order to determine what services STUDENT required during the 1994-1995 school year, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT’s needs at the beginning of the 1994-1995 school year were identified in reports from a speech and language assessment by Ms. Lipp (STUDENT’s Exhibit A), the SELPA’s assessment (LEAs’ Exhibit 8), the Stanford assessment (STUDENT’s Exhibit E), and the SELPA OT assessment. Ms. Lipp identified language and communication deficits and recommended individual speech and language therapy twice weekly in hourly sessions. The SELPA assessment team identified the following areas of need:
communication (interactive communication skills, expressive vocabulary, syntax), social skills/”school behaviors” (compliance to direction, group participation, following simple classroom rules/routines, peer interaction), willingness to attempt fine-motor/table/preacademic tasks, attention to task and task completion, preacademic/cognitive skills (imitation, matching, sorting, followed by size/number/color concepts), self-help (toilet training, self dressing, utensil usage), and gross motor skills (jumping, balance, catching, pedaling).
(LEAs’ Exhibit 8)
The SELPA assessment also described STUDENT’s avoidance behaviors and general unwillingness to engage in activities. The SELPA assessment report is the only report describing STUDENT’s eye contact as “good.”
The assessment at the Stanford Clinic in July 1994 found that STUDENT exhibited significant developmental delays across all areas of function with “a high degree of noncompliance which interferes with his performance of skills. . . .” The report identified deficits in eye contact, attending, social and cognitive skills, and expressive language. Recommendations included adding goals to STUDENT’s IEP for improving expressive language and specific cognitive skills; continuing with speech and language therapy twice per week; working closely with STUDENT’s parents to ensure consistency; carefully structuring and organizing tasks and task materials; consistently and systematically reinforcing all appropriate behavior; and redirecting tactile and visual self-stimulatory behavior. (STUDENT’s Exhibit F and testimony of Dr. Allesandri.) A second SELPA assessment recommended OT consultation to address deficits in motor skills development.
To summarize, the reports of the assessments, the testimony of the SELPA assessors, as well as the testimony of Ms. Stevick and MOTHER, establish that STUDENT’s primary needs at the beginning of the 1994 -1995 school year were in the areas of language, behavior, attending, communication, cognitive, motor, and social skills. There also was general consensus that STUDENT required instruction to develop age-appropriate cognitive and self-help skills and that, to meet his needs, he required a consistent and systematic program that involved the parents and school closely working together. There is no dispute that OT services were called for to address motor deficits.
The first requirement of an appropriate placement is that it must be designed to meet the students’ unique and individual needs. Additionally, the student’s IEP must include, among other things, the following: present levels of the student’s educational performance; annual goals and short-term instructional objectives; specific special education instruction and related services required by the student; the extent to which the student will participate in regular education; the projected date for initiation and duration of special education programs and services; and objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, at least annually, whether objectives are achieved. Education Code § 56345(a). Goals describe what a student can reasonably be expected to accomplish within a year’s time and objectives are measurable, intermediate steps toward meeting the goals. 34 C.F.R. 300.346, Appendix C, Questions 37, 38, and 39.
The goals and objectives included on STUDENT’s IEP dated June 9, 1994, were developed by a teacher who neither assessed STUDENT nor attended the IEP meeting. Each goal is very general and simply calls for STUDENT to “improve” in a given area. There are four goals on the June IEP and each goal has one objective. For example, one goal is to “improve cognitive and motor planning.” The sole objective related to that goal states, “given a variety of desirable manipulatives and teacher model during work and small group time, STUDENT uses his work materials appropriately 1 of 2 opportunities daily over one month.” Another goal is to “increase task attendance and group participation.” The related objective states, “given a structured, teacher directed activity, STUDENT attends to and interacts appropriately with the group 15 minutes independently 4 of 5 days over one month.” No one explained at the hearing how these objectives would meet STUDENT’s needs or how they would provide intermediary steps toward the goals. The SELPA and District assert that the IEP was a “good initial” IEP and that, when STUDENT actually entered a SELPA class, the IEP would be revised. The SELPA and the District also noted that the parents did not attend the initial IEP meeting and that it was unclear at the time the IEP was developed whether STUDENT would attend school in the fall. STUDENT did enroll in the SELPA SDC in September 1994, and additional assessment information was available from the Stanford assessment and from the SELPA’s OT assessment; however, when the IEP team reconvened in October 1994 with the parents present, only minimal revisions to the IEP were made. The only changes made to the initial IEP were to add three OT goals without any accompanying objectives, collaborative APE and OT services, and a goal and two objectives related to developing STUDENT’s expressive language skills. (STUDENT’s Exhibits C and G)
Moreover, taken together, the initial IEP developed in June 1994 and the addendum developed in October 1994 do not include goals and objectives that are consistent with the recommendations of either the SELPA’s or Stanford’s assessments. None of the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT’s IEP address the following deficits identified by SELPA assessors: interactive communication skills, expressive vocabulary, syntax, social skills, peer interaction, and preacademic/cognitive skills. None of the goals and objectives address the following identified by Stanford assessors: deficits in specific cognitive skills, the need for close collaboration between school and STUDENT’s parents, the need for a systematic and consistent program, and redirection of self-stimulatory behavior. None of the goals or objectives address STUDENT’s noncompliant behavior. The goals and objectives address only one area of STUDENT’s deficits in self-help skills, toileting. The goal calls for STUDENT to toilet himself given a verbal prompt and minimal physical assistance. The goal does not identify the verbal prompt and there are no provisions in the IEP for STUDENT’s parents to work with the school so that consistent prompts and procedures are utilized at both home and school. Stanford assessors, Ms. Lipp, and Ms. Stevick recommended that STUDENT’s significant language and communication needs be met through individual speech and language therapy. Ms. Lipp recommended that STUDENT receive individual therapy twice weekly with sessions of one hour each. Ms. Stevick concurred with the recommendation and provided STUDENT with independent speech and language therapy. STUDENT’s IEP for the 1994-1995 school year provided only for speech and language consultation/collaboration for a total of 20 minutes per week. The only goal on the IEP developed in June 1994 in the area of receptive language has to do with following directions. In October 1994, an additional goal was added to STUDENT’s IEP to increase his expressive language skills. The specific speech and language program utilized in the SDC was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Caboara and the SELPA speech and language pathologist testified that STUDENT participated in the Bonderman speech and language program while in the SDC. They testified that the program was helpful in teaching STUDENT to attend and to participate in an activity; however, no one testified that the Bonderman program was designed to address STUDENT’s significant speech and language deficits. Therefore, the evidence establishes that the program provided to STUDENT during the 1994-1995 school year did not address his speech and language needs.
Stanford assessors also recommended close collaboration between the home and school so that STUDENT’s program would be consistent in both environments and would be supported at home. Both Dr. Siegel and Dr. Smith identified family involvement as one of the factors in a successful program for students with autism. No one contradicted the importance of family in the education of preschool children, and California Education Code sections pertaining to the education of preschool-aged children support and encourage family involvement. (See Education Code §§ 56441 and 56441.3) Section 56441.2 provides that “an early education program for individuals with exceptional needs...shall include specially designed services to meet the unique needs of preschool children and their families. (Emphasis added.) There are no provisions in STUDENT’s IEP to address family involvement, and the SELPA and District did not provide any specific services designed to meet STUDENT’s need for family involvement. SELPA witnesses testified that the SELPA offers regularly scheduled parent training on a number of topics and that home visits are made as a part of the preschool program; however, no one from the SELPA made visits to the PARENT’s home before they removed STUDENT from the SDC. Training was available to all parents of children in SELPA programs and, as such, was not necessarily designed to meet the needs of STUDENT and his family. Samples of the written communications between the school and home (STUDENT’s Exhibit S) and the testimony of Ms. Caboara and the PARENTS establishes that a majority of the sheets sent home were the same as those sent home to every other student in the class and do not specifically address STUDENT or his needs.
Ms. Caboara’s SDC was “non-categorical” and served students with a number of different diagnosis, including learning disabilities. The curriculum employed in the class was developmental in nature; however it was not specifically designed for students with communication needs. Speech and language needs were met through the collaborative approach whereby the speech and language pathologist was present in the class for only one hour to one and one-half hour each week. The evidence established that STUDENT required an intense program. The SDC met on four days a week rather than five and, as a three-year-old student, STUDENT attended for only three hours on those four days. Given the nature of STUDENT’s disability and the need for an intense program, the level of services and the duration of the program were insufficient to meet his needs or to provide him with educational benefit.
Stanford recommended that STUDENT also attend a regular preschool program two to three days a week to develop social skills with his regular education peers. Both federal and state special education law promote maximum interaction of children with disabilities with their nondisabled peers. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(5)(B); California Education Code § 56001(g). See also Sacramento City School Board v. Holland (9th Cir., 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, cert denied, (1994) 114 S.Ct. 2679. The comment to 34 C.F.R. § 300.552 addresses whether public educational agencies are required to include preschool-age children with disabilities with nondisabled peers. It states that least restrictive requirements “apply to all preschool children with disabilities who are entitled to receive a FAPE.” The comment also states that public agencies not operating preschool programs are not required to develop such programs; however, they are required to locate and provide suitable alternative placements. Dr. Siegel, as well as SELPA witnesses, testified that children with autism have difficulty generalizing and need opportunities to practice social and other skills in the environments in which the skills will be used. The SELPA assessors made no recommendations regarding mainstreaming, nor does STUDENT’s IEP provide for opportunities to participate in educational experiences with his regular education peers. Dr. Siegel testified that she would not have recommended that STUDENT enter a preschool program until approximately six months after initiation of the one-to-one program; however, Dr. Siegel was not involved in assessing STUDENT until May 1995. Therefore, based primarily on the recommendations resulting from the Stanford assessment, which were supported by the testimony of Dr. Allesandri at the hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required opportunities to participate in an educational setting with his regular education peers to meet his need to develop appropriate social skills and to develop speech and language skills. Neither STUDENT’s IEP nor the supplement address mainstreaming in any way, nor did testimony of Ms. Caboara establish that mainstreaming occurred in her SDC during the 1994-1995 school year. At the hearing, several witnesses for the SELPA attributed the lack of any mainstreaming provisions for STUDENT to a generalized perception that preschool students need to be taught the skills that they will require for regular school placement in the SDC before mainstreaming with their regular education peers. The Hearing Officer finds that the lack of opportunities for STUDENT to participate in an educational program with his regular education peers does not comply with the requirements of an appropriate IEP and also did not meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
The evidence establishes that the IEP developed for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 school year failed to address his unique and individual needs and also was deficient in that it did not include all of the required components of an IEP as set forth in Education Code § 56345. The services and placement offered by the SELPA and District were also not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, particularly in the area of developing his significantly deficient speech and language and social skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that for the 1994-1995 school year, the SELPA and the District failed to offer an IEP and placement that satisfied the requirements of an appropriate placement under Rowley and federal and State special education law.
ISSUE NO. 3: At the May 1995 IEP meetings, did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year?
STUDENT’s representative contends that the IEP goals and objectives, services, and placement offered by the SELPA and District for the 1995-1996 school year were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and did not provide him with an appropriate education. STUDENT’s representative also contends that the following were necessary components of an appropriate placement: (a) a 30 to 40 hour per week one-to-one in-home behavioral intervention program supervised by Behavioral Intervention Associates BIA; (b) participation in a mainstream preschool program for 12 hours per week with a shadow aide from BIA; (c) six hours per month of behavioral intervention provided by BIA; (d) one hour biweekly treatment team meetings with all staff; and (e) materials and supplies as necessary to the implement the behavioral intervention program. The SELPA and District contend that the goals, objectives, and services included in STUDENT’s IEP drafted May 18 and 26, 1995, were designed to meet his unique and individual needs. They also contend that Ms. Caboara’s SDC with concurrent enrollment in the Head Start Preschool Program for socialization offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year.
In planning for the 1995-1996 school year, the IEP team had available the assessment by UCSF, an assessment by Ms. Swenson, SELPA psychologist, and reports from Ms. Stevick and Ms. Caboara. Ms. Swenson’s report describes STUDENT’s ability to focus during testing for one-half hour as an “improvement.” The evidence establishes that there were two adults present during the assessment and that they provided STUDENT with a number of positive reinforcers. Ms. Swenson reported that STUDENT’s needs included learning to correct errors, expanding his “repertoire of question-answer formats and taking directions. Ms. Caboara reported growth in self-help areas. In the spring, he would urinate in the restroom at school and would hang up his coat; however, he still needed improvement in toileting skills. She also reported improved motor skills and pre-academic skills of identifying body parts and colors. School reports and the testimony of witnesses establish that STUDENT continued to have significant deficits in language and, according to reports by Ms. Stevick, as well as SELPA speech and language pathologists, STUDENT’s language skills ranged from the two-year-old level to the two-year and ten-month-old level. Additional deficits were identified in attention, compliant behavior, social, play, and pre-academic skills. STUDENT also engaged in jargoning, humming, teeth-grinding, and self-stimulatory behavior, including putting items to his chin.
STUDENT’s IEP includes nine goals to improve self-help, fine-motor, pre-academic/readiness skills, social/emotional-play, receptive and expressive language, balance and locomotor, and eye-hand/ coordination skills. There are nine pages of specific objectives related to each of the goals. Self-help objectives address dressing, washing and drying hands, and giving his first and last name when asked. Fine-motor objectives address cutting, tracing, imitating shapes, puzzles, building with blocks, and using playdough. Pre-academic objectives address counting, identifying shapes, sorting, following verbal directions, and working independently. Objectives related to social and emotional goals address playing games with peers and attending to a story. Language objectives are related to developing eye contact, indicating “yes” and “no,” expressing spontaneously, responding verbally, answering questions, and labeling emotions. Motor objectives address standing, hopping, walking, throwing, catching, and kicking. (STUDENT’s Exhibit V) The parents participated in drafting the IEP goals and objectives, which are detailed and designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs; however, there are no goals and objectives to reduce STUDENT’s self-stimulatory and noncompliant behavior.
Dr. Ashton, who testified on behalf of the SELPA and District, concluded that a strong communication program is an essential component of a successful program for children with autism. STUDENT’s then-current levels of language and communication skills also indicate the need for speech and language services. The evidence is not persuasive that Ms. Caboara’s class had a strong communication program. The communication program is provided through collaboration between Ms. Caboara and a speech and language therapist who appears in the class to work with the children for fewer than two hours per week. The speech and language pathologist provides a program for the students that emphasizes articulation rather than language. The only additional services offered to STUDENT to meet his language and communication needs was twice weekly group therapy of 20 minutes per session. Ms. Stevick, who at the time had worked individually with STUDENT for over one year, testified that STUDENT experienced difficulty attending even in one-to-one therapy. As stated above, the SELPA utilized two adults when attempting to assess STUDENT. Moreover, it was determined above that, for the prior school year, STUDENT required individual therapy. There is no credible testimony that his needs changed.
If any change occurred, it is that STUDENT’s autistic-like behaviors had increased during the of the 1994-1995 school year. Ms. Stevick and STUDENT’s parents described STUDENT’s increased resistance to adult interaction and direction and self-stimulatory behavior. STUDENT’s parents also described instances of STUDENT’s running away, lacking connectedness with family members, and of STUDENT’s watching television in the reflection of the glass of a picture. (See also STUDENT’s Exhibit X) SELPA witnesses also testified that there were changes in STUDENT’d behavior; however, they attributed the changes to his being ill. There was some confusion on the part of STUDENT’s teacher about when STUDENT was actually ill. Statements from STUDENT’s physician and the testimony of MOTHER establish that STUDENT’s illness was ameliorated by December 14, 1994, well before the period of difficulty recalled by SELPA staff. Moreover, it is unlikely that the behaviors described by the parents and Ms. Stevick were solely attributable to diarrhea STUDENT had associated with Giardia. Moreover, the fact that UCSF determined in May 1995 that STUDENT met DSM-IV criteria for autism supports the testimony that STUDENT was, in fact, exhibiting more autistic-like behaviors. When STUDENT was assessed in July 1994 by Stanford, he did not exhibit sufficient characteristics to meet DSM-IV criteria for autism, whereas in May 1994 he did. (Testimony of Dr. Siegel; STUDENT’s Exhibit 4)
Following its assessment of STUDENT in May 1995, UCSF recommended that STUDENT participate in a 30-hour-per-week intensive one-to-one behavioral intervention program. (Testimony of Dr. Siegel and STUDENT’s Exhibit Q) Dr. Siegel testified that because children with autism lack interest in the environment, lack imitative skills, do not benefit from group instruction, and do not respond to social rewards in the same way as other children, the only proven educational program that allows children with autism to learn is an intensive one-to-one in-home behavioral intervention program of between 25 to 30 hours per week. Dr. Siegel also recommended that STUDENT participate two days per week in a class for students with communication disorders and three days per week in a regular preschool class to develop social skills. (See STUDENT’s Exhibit AA) Dr. Siegel’s recommendations and testimony were based on her review of professional literature and her own studies of children with autism, as well as her familiarity with STUDENT and information regarding BIA and the SELPA’s SDC. Dr. Smith’s testimony was similar to Dr. Siegel’s testimony regarding the effectiveness of intense one-to-one, behavioral programs for children with autism. Dr. Smith’s testimony was based his independent review of professional literature, his studies of children with autism, and his work with Dr. Lovaas while affiliated with UCLA. Shelly Davis, who provides services to schools and individuals with autism, observed Ms. Caboara’s SDC in April 1995, drew the conclusion that Ms. Caboara’s class was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs because the program was child-led. She also testified that STUDENT was not benefitting from group instruction and recommended a one-to-one intensive behavioral intervention program. (See also STUDENT’s Exhibit P) Dr. Lotspeich had also written a letter indicating that STUDENT required a one-to-one intensive behavioral intervention program. (STUDENT’s Exhibit I) Ms. Neeson observed STUDENT in Ms. Caboara’s class while serving as the school psychologist and testified that STUDENT was not benefitting from the class. She observed him engaging in self-stimulatory behavior and not attending or interested in activities.
A principal concern expressed by witnesses appearing on behalf of STUDENT was regarding the appropriateness of the “child-led” curriculum utilized in Ms. Caboara’s class. Ms. Caboara testified that her class was balanced between child-led and adult-led activities; however, observations by Ms. Davis and Dr. Siegel and the videotapes submitted by both parties establish that, throughout the course of the day, students selected activities in which to participate from an array of activities and materials set out by the teacher. Moreover, Ms. Blanton from Head Start described the Hi Scope curriculum, which is employed by Head Start as well as by Ms. Caboara, as a “child-centered and child-directed curriculum whereby students flow through the classroom and participate in open-ended activities set up by the teachers.” A second concern expressed about the appropriateness of Ms. Caboara’s class for STUDENT was the lack of opportunities for him to receive one-to-one instruction. (Testimony of Dr. Siegel and Ms. Davis) APE, OT, speech and language, circle time, and pre-academic projects in Ms. Caboara’s class were all group activities and the opportunities for one-to-one instruction were limited.
The Hearing Officer is aware that all of the witnesses who testified have some experience and training regarding young children with autism and it is not unexpected that the SELPA and District witnesses, who are all currently or have been employed by either the SELPA or District, would view their philosophy and approach to teaching young children with autism in a more favorable light than the philosophy and approach of others who address the needs of young children with autism. On the other hand, the witnesses called on behalf of STUDENT are affiliated with a variety of highly respected institutions, including the University of California, San Francisco, Stanford, and UCLA, and have a great deal of experience and expertise in the field of autism. They also have met, assessed, and/or worked with STUDENT. Dr. Siegel has worked at both Stanford and UCSF assessing children with autism and PDD. She has been involved in studies regarding the efficacy of educational programs. Dr. Smith, formerly of UCLA and currently on the faculty at Washington State University, has similar credentials and has been following the persons involved in Lovaas studies and doing his own research. Dr. Allesandri, formerly of Stanford and currently at the University of Miami, has likewise assessed and made recommendations for a great many persons with autism and PDD. He continues to do so in his new employment. Ms. Davis provides independent behavioral intervention services to students with autism, as well as contracting with school districts, and is not affiliated with BIA or any of the educational institutions. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the testimony of Dr. Siegel, Dr. Smith, Dr. Allesandri, and Ms. Davis, and relies on their expertise, as well as their familiarity with STUDENT and the SDC, in reaching the conclusion that STUDENT requires an intensive, one-to-one home-based program to meet his needs and to allow him to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer notes also that the California Education Code provides for preschool students to be educated in a variety of environments, including their homes. Education Code § 56440-56441.4.
This dispute is not regarding Ms. Caboara’s abilities as a teacher or the appropriateness of her class for other students. The issue in this case is whether the placement offered for STUDENT was appropriate. The evidence establishes that the SDC, the collaborative services provided in it, and the curriculum utilized in the class are based on a model that has not been modified to meet STUDENT’s needs as a young child with autism. The program offered in the SDC and in concert with Head Start offers the same program to students with a variety of disabilities using the same model and for the same number of hours each school day. Both the SDC and Head Start employ the Hi Scope curriculum, which is not appropriate at this point for STUDENT, and the program does not sufficiently emphasize communication and language or provide for STUDENT to receive individual speech and language therapy. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. STUDENT required opportunities to integrate with nondisabled peers during the 1995-1996 school year. The District and SELPA offered concurrent placement in Head Start, which serves children up to five years or older. UCSF recommended that STUDENT be placed with developmentally similar peers to allow him to engage in successful play and social interactions with them. At the time of the UCSF recommendation, STUDENT was functioning at the three-year-old level in some areas and at the two-year-old level in others. Therefore, the Head Start students would not have been an appropriate developmental level for STUDENT at the time it was proposed for him. For all of the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC and Head Start programs were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, and, therefore, did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year.
ISSUE NO. 4: Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate services and placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year?
STUDENT’s representatives asserted that the following were necessary to address his unique and individual needs and to provide him with an appropriate education during the 1996-1997 school year: (a) at least 15 hours per week of one-to-one in home behavioral intervention program supervised by BIA, including a structured peer play component; (b) participation in a mainstream preschool program for 15 hours per week with a shadow aide from BIA; (c) six hours per month of behavioral intervention provided by BIA; and (d) one hour biweekly treatment team meetings with all staff. The SELPA and District proposed to place STUDENT in the transitional kindergarten class with a one-to-one aide for up to 1,200 minutes per week, 40 minutes per week of direct speech and language therapy plus consultation, one hour each per week of OT collaboration plus consultation to home, and one hour per week consultation from special education teachers and staff to the preschool teacher and home. STUDENT’s general areas of need and the appropriateness of STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives for the 1996-1997 school year are not in dispute. (STUDENT’s Exhibit RR) The IEP includes goals to address preacademic/cognitive, social/emotional, behavioral, language, self-help, and motor skills.
Turning to whether the placement proposed by the District and SELPA for the 1996-1997 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, a report by SELPA speech and language pathologists Ms. Henke and Ms. Hutchinson in March and April 1996, indicated that STUDENT continued to have “significant, receptive and expressive language deficits and differences which interfere with communication, especially in group settings such as school.” (STUDENT’s Exhibit JJ) The assessors also noted that STUDENT’s language was much better when situations were “structured and simplified.” Deborah Porter, school psychologist, who assessed STUDENT in March 1996, concluded that, “STUDENT would benefit from a highly structured and supportive educational placement with a small student to teacher ratio.” (LEAs’ Exhibit 49)
The teacher from the transitional kindergarten class did not testify. Information regarding the class was gleaned from testimony regarding observations of the class by MOTHER, Dr. Siegel, Ms. Stubblefield, Ms. Vickers, Ms. Henke, Ms. Beavers, and Dr. Ashton. There are 15 students in the class and their language skills range from nonverbal to speaking in sentences. The classroom has activity centers. There are no opportunities to mainstream; however, some students are “paired with” students in the first grade. The class serves as a link from a preschool SDC to a regular education program. Ms. Porter described the class as “structured” and offering a developmentally appropriate curriculum.
District and SELPA witnesses testified that the transitional kindergarten was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Ms. Henke testified that the class meets STUDENT’s needs for a class with 15 or fewer students who have high language, social and play skills and also has a “strong language component.” All of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT concluded that the transitional kindergarten class at La Fiesta was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT. MOTHER, Dr. Siegel, and Ms. Vickers of BIA expressed concern whether the other students would provide STUDENT appropriate language and behavior models. They all described the students as having behavioral problems. Ms. Stubblefield of BIA testified that STUDENT needs to continue attending a “play-based” school, whereas the emphasis of the transitional kindergarten is on teaching the students cognitive tasks they will require for successful kindergarten attendance.
The evidence establishes that STUDENT has made progress during his participation in BIA. No one testified that STUDENT’s needs have changed or that he does not continue to require the services of BIA. As a matter of fact, SELPA assessors described his ongoing need for a structured educational program that emphasizes communication and provides opportunities for STUDENT to mainstream with nondisabled peers and Dr. Ashton, the SELPA’s witness, testified that she would consider the BIA program as a supplement to a class placement. The placement offered by the SELPA and DISTRICT increased the amount of speech and language therapy available to STUDENT while in the transitional kindergarten class; however, even SELPA speech and language assessors indicated that STUDENT experienced a great deal of difficulty when in a group setting. Moreover, most of the testimony regarding the transitional kindergarten was of a general nature. No one testified how STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives would be implemented, what curriculum is employed in the class, the special education needs of the students, the extent, if any, of parental involvement, or regarding the education and experience of the staff. There was no persuasive testimony that the class emphasizes communication. The cover sheet of STUDENT’s IEP indicates that he would spend 25% of his time in a mainstreamed environment; however, the evidence establishes that none of the students in the La Fiesta transitional kindergarten class were mainstreamed at the times of the numerous observations by both parties and no further information was available regarding the way in which the mainstreaming called for by STUDENT’s IEP would be met. As previously noted, the teacher of the class did not testify. Moreover, the recommendations of the experts in autism have changed only in the amount of time STUDENT requires for an individual program from those that were discussed more thoroughly in the issue above. Dr. Siegel and other professionals working with STUDENT recommended that STUDENT continue with the program he currently is receiving, BIA and private preschool. Dr. Siegel and Dr. Smith recommended that STUDENT continue with BIA for 10 to 15 hours per week, that he participate in play dates. Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT attend preschool with a shadow aide. The shadow aide would be in close proximity to STUDENT should he require assistance or redirection. Therefore, based on their expertise in educating young children with autism and the lack of specific evidence regarding the class and how it would meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs or provide him with educational benefit, the Hearing Officer determines that the transitional kindergarten does not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
ISSUE NO. 5: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the BIA program including the costs of a behavioral intervention specialist, the costs one-to-one behavioral tutors, and materials and supplies from June 1, 1995, to the present?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the placement they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parent was appropriate. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Moreover, parents need not procure the best possible private placement or services in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.
It was determined above that the SELPA and District did not provide an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995, 1995-1996, and 1996-1997 school years. The testimony of the many experts testifying on behalf of STUDENT established that he required an intense one-to-one behavioral intervention program to meet his needs and to allow him to benefit from his placement.
The evidence establishes that BIA is a state-certified nonpublic agency (NPA) and provides intensive individualized behavioral intervention programs to young children with autism. The testimony of Ms. Stubblefield and others establishes that the BIA program is designed around STUDENT’s individual strengths and needs and emphasizes teaching through play and parent involvement. BIA constantly monitors STUDENT’s progress and redesigns the program to meet his needs. The program designed for STUDENT addresses his ability to integrate with peers and to improve language and attending skills, while learning developmentally appropriate preacademic skills. BIA also coordinates play dates so that STUDENT is able to practice the play and socialization skills that he has been taught, and provides aides to facilitate STUDENT’s preschool attendance. The BIA program has been effective and no one disputes that STUDENT has made progress. The evidence establishes that his language and communication skills improved, as did his social and attending skills. As discussed more thoroughly above in Issue No. 3, Dr. Siegel, Dr. Allesandri, Ms. Davis, and Dr. Smith testified persuasively that BIA has met STUDENT’s needs and has offered an appropriate educational and social skills program for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT’s BIA program, in conjunction with individual speech and language therapy provided by Ms. Stevick, and participation in a preschool program with his one-to-one aide, has provided an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
As to the appropriate number of hours of one-to-one intervention STUDENT has required weekly, effective programs have been described by the experts and in the studies of students with autism, as being a minimum of 20 to 25 hours per week. Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT’s program initially be 30 hours per week. This was also her recommendation for STUDENT. Dr. Smith concurred. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony persuasive as to the number of hours of BIA intervention STUDENT required during the 1995-1996 school year. For the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT’s hours with BIA were reduced, which was consistent with the recommendations of Dr. Siegel that STUDENT receive 10 to 15 hours of intensive one-to-one services.
The PARENTS incurred expenses in providing for STUDENT’s BIA program, which has been determined was appropriate for STUDENT. The PARENTS testified regarding some of the costs, which are also set forth in STUDENT’s Exhibit DDD. The testimony establishes that these costs were related to implementing STUDENT’s goals and objectives and, therefore, subject to proof, are reimbursable under Burlington.
ISSUE NO. 6: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Petaluma Valley Day Preschool?
Under Burlington, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for private preschool expenditures when the educational agency has failed to provide an appropriate placement. There was little, if any, evidence presented at the hearing regarding Petaluma Valley Day Preschool. STUDENT’s representative also did not put forth any argument in the closing written brief regarding the services provided at or the appropriateness of the Petaluma Valley Day Preschool. Given the dearth of information regarding the school and STUDENT’s attendance there, and based on the parents failing to participate in drafting the IEP in June 1994, as well as declining to enroll STUDENT in the SELPA preschool program until the fall of 1994, the Hearing Officer concludes that the equities weigh in favor of denying reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attendance at Petaluma Valley Day Preschool.
ISSUE NO. 7 Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at the Happy Day Preschool, including transportation and the services of a shadow aide, from September 1995 to the present?
STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attendance at Happy Day. Under Burlington, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for a preschool placement when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parent was appropriate. Reimbursement may be ordered as a remedy even if the private school does not have state NPS certification. Florence County School District Four v. Carter (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361, 365-366. In reaching this decision, the Court concluded that it would be inconsistent with the IDEA to deny reimbursement to parents when the local educational agency had failed to provide an appropriate placement because the parents had selected an otherwise appropriate placement that was “simply” lacking state certification.
Dr. Siegel observed STUDENT at Happy Day and did not, at the time, find that it offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT. District and SELPA witnesses testified similarly. The primary concern was related to the number of students in the class, which could be as many as 50. Another concern expressed by Dr. Siegel and others was that the students were at a higher developmental level than STUDENT. The primary reason for placing STUDENT in a regular preschool was to provide him with opportunities to develop social and play skills with developmentally appropriate peers, which it does not appear that Happy Day offered. Ms. Beavers testified regarding the “best practices” for preschool education. Her testimony was persuasive that, because preschool serves as the transition from home to a school environment, it should be small, personalized, and intimate. The Hearing Officer notes also that, for preschool-age children identified as severely disabled, the maximum ratio of children-to-adults is five-to-one. Education Code § 56441.5. The testimony of Dr. Siegel and witnesses for the SELPA and District establishes that Happy Day did not appropriately meet STUDENT’s needs nor does it conform to some of the best practices for educating preschool-age children. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Happy Day did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
In determining whether reimbursement is warranted for STUDENT’s attending Happy Day, the Hearing Officer looks also to the fact that STUDENT’s parents enrolled him simultaneously in another preschool program that met Dr. Siegel’s recommendations and apparently offered him appropriate opportunities to develop social skills with developmentally appropriate peers. (See Issue No. 8, below) Given that STUDENT was participating in an appropriate preschool for which the parents also seek reimbursement, the Hearing Officer finds that under Burlington, the equities weigh in favor of denying reimbursement for STUDENT’s attending Happy Day..
ISSUE NO. 8: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Gan Israel Preschool, including tuition and the costs of a one-to-one shadow aide during the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years?
It has been determined above that an appropriate placement for STUDENT included participation with regular education peers to develop appropriate social and play skills. Dr. Siegel recommended that STUDENT participate in a preschool program with three-year-old children because their developmental levels would be close to STUDENT’s developmental level. The observations of a number of witnesses for both parties establishes that Gan Israel included children with appropriate developmental and age levels for STUDENT. There also was a small number of students in the class. The evidence establishes that Gan Israel offered an appropriate placement to implement STUDENT’s social and play goals and objectives. Because it was determined above that the District did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT that included opportunities to interact with age-appropriate regular education peers, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s parents were justified in their providing a private placement for STUDENT. Therefore, the equities weigh in favor of reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s placement at Gan Israel.
In addition to the cost of tuition, the PARENTS request reimbursement for the cost of round-trip transportation they provided for STUDENT while he attended preschool. Transportation is included in the list of DIS. California Education Code § 56363(a). Because of his disability and young age, STUDENT required transportation to and from school. Moreover, the IEP provides for transportation as a service. It was determined above that STUDENT’s parents were justified in seeking the private placement and that transportation was included in the costs they incurred as a result of that placement.
Dr. Siegel and BIA also recommended that STUDENT be accompanied to the preschool by an aide. It was concluded above that STUDENT had deficits in attending and following adult direction and the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers in both the SELPA and private preschool programs establishes that STUDENT required the assistance of an aide to facilitate participation in group activities and to focus him to task. In the absence of an aide, the evidence suggests that STUDENT would benefit minimally, if at all, from group instruction. The testimony of BIA personnel and MOTHER also established that STUDENT did not possess skills to interact with his peers and needed the aide to facilitate social interactions. Therefore, to allow STUDENT to benefit from placement in a regular preschool and to facilitate his learning appropriate social skills with his regular education peers, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT required a one-to-one aide to accompany him to Gan Israel.
Based on all of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that pursuant to Burlington and Carter, and subject to proof, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of tuition, the services of a one-to-one aide, and transportation they provided for STUDENT on the days he attended Gan Israel.
ISSUE NO. 9: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments?
(a) The assessment by the Pervasive Developmental Disabilities (PDD) Clinic at Stanford in 1994.
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student. When the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent also has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. Education Code § 56329(b). It was determined in Issue No. 1 that the SELPA conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in May 1994. A reassessment of a student must occur every three years or more frequently, if “conditions warrant, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new individualized education program is developed. Education Code § 56381. There was no evidence that further assessment of STUDENT was warranted following the SELPA’s assessment and Stanford assessment in July 1994, nor was a request for further assessment made at that time by either STUDENT’s parent or his preschool teacher. STUDENT was not attending school in the District at that time because the parents had elected to place him elsewhere. Therefore, because the SELPA’s assessment was appropriate and no additional assessment by the SELPA was warranted at that time, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the assessment by the P.D. Clinic at Stanford in July 1994.
(b) Assessments by Elaine Stevick, speech and language therapist.
For the same reasons set forth above in Issue No. 8 (b), the request for reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Elaine Stevick in 1994 is denied.
(c) Assessments by Dr. Bryna Siegel in 1995.
For the same reasons set forth above in Issue No. 8 (b), the request for reimbursement for the assessments conducted by Bryna Siegel in 1995 is denied.
ISSUE NO. 10: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent speech and language services provided by Elaine Stevick beginning in May 1994?
It was determined above in Issues No. 2, 3, and 4 that STUDENT required individual speech and language therapy. It was also determined above that the SELPA and District did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT and have never offered him appropriate, individual speech and language services. Ms. Stevick is a qualified speech and language therapist. STUDENT has demonstrated improved speech and language skills while receiving therapy from Ms. Stevick. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement, subject to proof, for their costs of therapy provided by Ms. Stevick.
ISSUE NO. 11: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a behavioral intervention workshop and parent training provided by UCLA in April 1995?
It was determined above that the SELPA and District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate placement during the 1994-1995 school year. The parents, in their attempt to find an appropriate placement obtained the services of Annette Groen from UCLA to consult, devise a preliminary program for STUDENT, and to provide training in implementation of the program to STUDENT’s family and the tutors hired by the PARENT’s to implement the individualized program. (Testimony of MOTHER and STUDENT’s Exhibits J and O) Ms. Groen has been employed with Dr. Lovaas at UCLA and her training provided the basis for the program that was ultimately supervised by BIA. Because it was an integral part to the BIA program, the Hearing Officer concludes that, subject to proof, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for their share of the costs of the workshop and training.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did the District and SELPA appropriately assess STUDENT prior to the IEP team meeting on June 1, 1994? The District and SELPA prevailed on this issue.
(2) Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1994-1995 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(3) At the IEP meetings in May 1995, did the District and SELPA propose appropriate goals and objectives, services, and placement for STUDENT for the 1995-1996 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(4) Did the District and SELPA propose appropriate services and placement for STUDENT for the 1996-1997 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(5) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the BIA program including the costs of a behavioral intervention specialist, the costs of one-to-one behavioral tutors, materials, and supplies from June 1, 1995, to the present? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(6) Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT’s attendance at Petaluma Valley Preschool? The District and SELPA prevailed on this issue.
(7) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Happy Day Presbyterian Preschool, including transportation and the services of a shadow aide, from September 1995 to the present? The District and SELPA prevailed on this issue.
(8) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of STUDENT's attendance at Gan Israel Preschool, including tuition and the costs of a one-to-one shadow aide, during the 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 school years? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(9) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments? The District and SELPA prevailed on this issue.
(10) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent speech and language services provided by Elaine Stevick beginning in May 1994? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
(11) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a behavioral intervention workshop and parent training provided by UCLA in April 1995? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
ORDER
(1) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof from the PARENTS, the District and SELPA shall reimburse them for expenses they incurred for:
(a) their portion of the workshop provided by Ms. Groen in April 1994; (b) up to 30 hours per week of BIA services through the extended school year for the 1995-1996 school year, and up to 15 hours per week through the extended school year for the 1996-1997 school year, including the costs of supervision, biweekly meetings, materials, and the costs of a one-to-one aide to facilitate play dates and STUDENT’s participating at Gan Israel Preschool; (c) tuition and transportation to Gan Israel; and (d) speech and language sessions provided by Ms. Stevick following STUDENT’s enrollment in the SELPA SDC for the 1994-1995 school year.
(2) All other requests for relief are denied.
DATED: September 15, 1997 _______________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Evidence submitted by the District and SELPA is designed as “LEAs’ Exhibits.” “LEA” stands for “local educational agency,” which includes local and county school districts and SELPAs(special education local plan areas). Footnote 2: A second “Student Information” sheet states that the proposed placement was for 240 minutes divided over four days per week. (STUDENT’s Exhibit V1) Footnote 3: In 1997, amendments to the IDEA were enacted; however, this case arose and was heard prior to the amendments becoming effective. Therefore, in this case, the Hearing Officer relies on the law in effect at the time the dispute arose and the hearing was convened
