California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 14, 2003
Student v. El Rancho Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 119-02, SN-119-02 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
El Rancho Unified's special day class offer upheld, but Hearing Officer orders AT reassessment, PEP-R testing, and DTT goals.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. Before witnesses testified, the parties settled the original prehearing-order issues on a Diagnostic Center referral, an adapted physical education assessment, and production of records, and those issues were dismissed.
Summary
A 10-year-old student with autism, represented by his mother, filed for due process against El Rancho Unified School District. He had attended Tobinworld (Brill School of Autism), a nonpublic school, since 1998. By 2003 everyone agreed he needed a new placement, and the District offered a special day class (SDC) at Birney Elementary taught by Jay Arroyo. The mother asked for several assessments and challenged the District's offer for 2003-2004.
The Hearing Officer found that discrete trial training (DTT) would help the student, but his IEP had no present levels or goals for using it. He ordered an expert to observe the student in the new class and draft DTT goals. Because the new classroom would change the student's setting, he ordered an assistive technology (AT) reassessment after the move. He also ordered the Psychoeducational Profile-Revised (PEP-R) test within 30 days. He denied a new speech assessment on the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS). He also denied a functional analysis assessment, finding the existing behavior support plan likely to work. The District may use Gallagher Pediatric Therapy for the agreed occupational and physical therapy assessments, despite the mother's objection.
The Birney SDC had four adults for ten students and used structured ABA methods. The Hearing Officer held that it offered FAPE without a one-to-one aide. The parent-training claim was moot because the District had already offered training. The IEP team must meet within 45 days of the new placement to revisit tutoring and home computer access.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled parent requests for reassessment under the Education Code as then numbered. A request alone was not enough without changed conditions. Here, a move to a new classroom, combined with severe communication needs, justified an AT reassessment. The decision also shows a district keeping its qualified assessor over a parent's objection.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1A. Must the District provide STUDENT with a discrete trial training (DTT) assessment?
No further assessment was needed to show DTT would help, but the IEP lacked present levels and goals for ABA/DTT, so an expert must observe the student in the new class and draft them.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1B. Must the District provide a speech, language, and/or communication reassessment to determine whether the picture exchange communication system (PECS) is an appropriate system of communication for STUDENT?
Conditions did not warrant reassessment and no substantial change in circumstances was shown; the 2002 District assessments recommending PECS were undisputedly appropriate.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1C. Must the District provide an assistive technology (AT) reassessment?
The move to a new placement changes the student's customary environment and warrants a formal AT reassessment after the placement begins, to be written into the IEP.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 1D. Must the District provide a neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 assessment by Dr. Shirley Lanyi?
A full neuropsychological reassessment was not required, but the PEP-R must be given within 30 days to set a baseline for the new placement.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1E. Must the District provide a functional analysis assessment (FAA)?
The behavior support plan in the proposed IEP, used in a more structured placement, was likely to be effective, so neither an FAA nor a BIP under the state regulations was required.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1F. Must the District provide occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) assessments by an entity other than Gallagher Pediatric Therapy?
Gallagher has qualified therapists and proper equipment; events from 1999 did not show bias, so the District may use Gallagher for the agreed assessments.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2A. Has the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer appropriate classroom placement?
The Birney special day class gave enough structure, behavior support, visual cues and suitable academics; a one-to-one aide was not needed and would be more restrictive.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B. Has the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer individualized tutoring in reading, writing, and math?
The need for tutoring was not shown, but the IEP team must revisit tutoring within 45 days after the new placement begins; the Hearing Officer stated that neither party prevailed.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2C. Has the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer training to STUDENT's parent as a related service to help implement STUDENT's IEP?
Moot, because the proposed IEP already provides individual parent training.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2D. Has the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school?
The student will use computers at school; the IEP team must reconsider home computer access within 45 days after the new placement begins; the Hearing Officer stated that neither party prevailed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. The PEP-R (Psychoeducational Profile-Revised) must be given to the student within 30 calendar days of the decision.
- The District may have Gallagher Pediatric Therapy perform the agreed-upon OT and PT assessments; the parent must make the student available.
- Order to assess. The IEP team must designate a school psychologist or other qualified expert to begin observing the student within the first two weeks of the Birney placement and to draft present levels and goals and objectives for implementing ABA/DTT, for the IEP team to consider.
- Order to assess. The District must submit an AT reassessment plan for the parent's approval; the reassessment must begin after the student starts at Birney and be completed within 45 calendar days after the placement starts.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 45 calendar days after the student starts the Birney SDC, and as often as needed afterward, the IEP team must meet to: consider the PEP-R data; amend the 2003-2004 IEP with present levels and goals for ABA/DTT; use the AT reassessment to specify AT services, goals, devices and software; and reconsider home computer access and individual tutoring in reading, writing and math.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range Sch. Dist.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3001, 3052, 3065
People named in the decision
- Darin Barber, attorney for District, El Rancho Unified School District
- Barbara Moore-Brown, director of special and alternative education, El Rancho Unified School District
- Vanesa Farfan, regional center assistant supervisor (present for Student), Eastern Los Angeles Regional Center
- Francis Jurado, regional center service coordinator (present for Student), Eastern Los Angeles Regional Center
- Mary Hasokawa, regional center education specialist (present for Student), Eastern Los Angeles Regional Center
- Laura Ruesga, program specialist, witness for Student, Fiesta Educativa (nonpublic agency)
- John Wakeham, program specialist, witness for Student, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP)
- Manju Mohan, special education classroom teacher, witness for Student, Tobinworld / Brill School of Autism
- Jared Pickett, classroom aide, witness for Student, Tobinworld / Brill School of Autism
- Gail Slott, speech-language pathologist serving student, witness for Student, Tobinworld
- Connie Miller, program coordinator, witness for Student, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP)
- Mary Kay Gallagher, pediatric occupational therapist and CEO, witness for District, Gallagher Pediatric Therapy (nonpublic agency)
- Lisa Aniversario, speech-language pathologist and assistive technology specialist; AT assessor, El Rancho Unified School District
- Jennifer Shubin, speech-language pathologist; speech-language assessor, El Rancho Unified School District
- Jay Arroyo, special day class teacher at proposed placement, Birney Elementary School, El Rancho Unified School District
- Shirley J. Lanyi, Ph.D., neuropsychologist; jointly selected assessor (September 2002)
- Tobinworld (Brill School of Autism), nonpublic school placement
- Gallagher Pediatric Therapy, nonpublic agency; OT/PT assessor
- Southern California Diagnostic Center, agreed assessment provider, California Department of Education
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on September 30 and October 1 and 2, 2003, in Whittier, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf at various times throughout the hearing were Vanesa Farfan, Eastern Los Angeles Regional Center (Regional Center) assistant supervisor; Francis Jurado, Regional Center service coordinator; and Mary Hasokawa, Regional Center education specialist. Respondent El Rancho Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Darin Barber. Also present on the District’s behalf was Barbara Moore-Brown, District director of special and alternative education.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Laura Ruesga, program specialist at Fiesta Educativa, a nonpublic agency (NPA); John Wakeham, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP) program specialist; Manju Mohan, special education teacher at Tobinworld, an NPA; MOTHER; Jared Pickett, classroom aide at Tobinworld; Gail Slott, speech and language pathologist; and Connie Miller, WACSEP program coordinator. The District called the following witnesses: Mary Kay Gallagher, pediatric occupational therapist and chief executive officer of Gallagher Pediatric Therapy (Gallagher), an NPA; Lisa Aniversario, District speech and language pathologist and District assistive technology (AT) specialist; Jennifer Shubin, District speech and language pathologist; Jay Arroyo, District special day class (SDC) teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until the Hearing Officer’s receipt of closing briefs on October 16, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue 1: Must the District provide STUDENT with the following:
A. Discrete trial training (DTT) assessment;
B. Speech, language, and/or communication reassessment to determine whether the picture exchange communication system (PECS) is an appropriate system of communication for STUDENT;
C. Assistive technology (AT) reassessment;
D. Neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 assessment by Dr. Shirley Lanyi;
E. Functional analysis assessment (FAA);
F. Occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) assessments by an entity other than Gallagher Pediatric Therapy?
Issue 2: Has the District denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer:
A. Appropriate classroom placement;
B. Individualized tutoring in reading, writing, and math;
C. Training to STUDENT’s parent as a related service to help implement STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP);
D. Access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school? (Footnote 1) BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], is a 10-year-old student eligible for special education as a child with autism. The District has provided STUDENT with his special education program from 1996 through the present. His classroom placement has been at the Brill School of Autism, also known as “Tobinworld,” an NPA, from 1998 through the present. He received occupational therapy (OT) services until 1999, and speech and language services are continuing.
In January 2002, STUDENT filed the current request for due process hearing. (Footnote 2) Upon application by the parties, the Hearing Office designated the case to “off-calendar” status in February 2002. Several months thereafter, the parties selected Shirley J. Lanyi, Ph.D., to perform a neuropsychological assessment. Dr. Lanyi evaluated STUDENT in September 2002 and issued a comprehensive report. District personnel performed assistive technology (AT) and speech and language assessments in November and December 2002.
STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP) team met on May 30, 2003, and reviewed the above assessments. The team also received oral progress reports and input from Tobinworld staff. On the basis of that information, the team agreed that STUDENT’s continued placement in the school for autism at Tobinworld would not be appropriate for the 2003-2004 school year. The team agreed that details of a new program, including placement and services, would be developed during the summer of 2003 and considered at the next IEP meeting.
At the next IEP meeting, held on September 24, 2003, the District presented its program offer for the 2003-2004 school year. The program offer includes an offer for placement in a special day class (SDC) at Birney Elementary School (Birney), a District school. STUDENT’s mother has rejected the District’s offer. Pending resolution of the due process hearing, STUDENT has remained at Tobinworld. (Footnote 3)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT’s contentions in this case involve assessment, placement, and services. Regarding assessment, STUDENT asserts that a discrete trial training (DTT) assessment is required for determining whether and to what extent he could benefit from DTT. He seeks a speech and language reassessment for the purpose of supporting his position that use of the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) in his program would be inappropriate. He asserts that an updated assistive technology (AT) assessment is required for determining whether he can benefit from AT and, if so, the type of AT that would be appropriate. He seeks a neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Lanyi. He asserts that a functional analysis assessment (FAA) must be performed and then used in the formulation of a behavioral intervention plan. Finally, although the parties agree that OT and PT assessments shall be performed, STUDENT objects to the District’s selection of Gallagher Pediatric Therapy (Gallagher) to perform OT and PT assessments.
Regarding the placement and services offered by the District for the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT asserts that the District’s proposed placement in the special day class (SDC) at Birney Elementary School (Birney) is inappropriate because behavioral support and supervision in the SDC would be inadequate to meet his needs. More specifically, he asserts that the behavioral support and supervision in the proposed SDC is inadequate because the SDC is inconsistent with the TEACCH model recommended in Dr. Lanyi’s report, the SDC has insufficient visual cues within the classroom, and the program fails to provide for a one-to-one aide. He also asserts that the proposed placement in the SDC at Birney is inappropriate because the level of academic instruction in the SDC is too academically advanced for him. He also objects to the District’s failure to offer individual tutoring in reading, writing, and math, and he further asserts that his mother should be trained to assist him at home in the areas of academics and behavior. Finally, he asserts that computer access and appropriate software should be available both at school and at home.
The District denies all of STUDENT’s contentions regarding assessment, placement, and services. The District asserts that the September 24, 2003 IEP proposed by the District constitutes an offer of free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1: Must the District provide STUDENT with the following: (A) DTT assessment; (B) speech, language, and/or communication reassessment to determine whether PECS is an appropriate system of communication for STUDENT; (C) AT reassessment; (D) neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 assessment by Dr. Shirley Lanyi; (E) FAA; (F) OT and PT assessments by an entity other than Gallagher Pediatric Therapy?
************* A. DTT assessment.
Legal requirements for special education assessments are set forth by statute and regulation. In general, “before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an assessment of the pupil’s educational needs shall be conducted . . .” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Reassessment of a pupil, based upon procedures specified in § 56320, “shall be conducted at least once every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. A pupil must be “assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
Assessments and the ongoing receipt of information about the pupil are used in the development of the pupil’s individualized education program (IEP). An IEP is a written statement determined in a meeting by the pupil’s IEP team. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a). Necessary components of an appropriate IEP include, among other items, reference to the pupil’s applicable present levels of performance. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(1). The present levels of performance are used to draft measurable annual goals and short term objectives related to meeting the educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). The pupil’s program, including “the specific special educational instruction and related services” to be provided to the pupil to enable the pupil to, among other matters, advance toward attaining the annual goals, is then formulated by the IEP team and written into the IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). The IEP team must meet at least annually to review the pupil’s progress and make revisions to the IEP as necessary. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.
In the present case, STUDENT asserts that he requires a discrete trial training (DTT) assessment. The purpose of the assessment would be to determine whether STUDENT could benefit from DTT as a method for learning how to perform certain tasks and, if so, to what degree. The District asserts that STUDENT presented no evidence to show what a DTT assessment would involve and, in any event, all areas of suspected disability will be assessed in the agreed-upon assessment to be performed at the Southern California Diagnostic Center (Diagnostic Center). (Footnote 4)
Testimony by District SDC teacher Jay Arroyo and the content of Dr. Lanyi’s September 2002 report showed that DTT is a component of a broader strategy known as applied behavior analysis (ABA). In her report, Dr. Lanyi recommended that STUDENT receive “direct instruction, in an ABA format” for “a good part of his day.” During the course of the hearing the parties repeatedly stated their general concurrence with the recommendations in Dr. Lanyi’s report. Her recommendation for ABA was consistent with testimony by Mr. Arroyo and by STUDENT’s Tobinworld classroom teacher, Manju Mahon, indicating that ABA/DTT would be beneficial in STUDENT’s program. On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that further assessment for determining whether STUDENT would likely benefit from DTT is unnecessary. The remaining question, as phrased by MOTHER, is whether additional assessment is required for ascertaining the degree to which STUDENT would likely benefit from DTT. More properly, the question is whether additional assessment is required for enabling appropriate implementation of DTT in STUDENT’s program.
Mr. Arroyo testified that he is the classroom teacher of the proposed SDC at Birney. He testified that he has received training in ABA/DTT. He stated that when implementing ABA/DTT in his classroom, including DTT drills, he collects extensive data to determine why a behavior is occurring and to address the behavior. For example, he (a) identifies the antecedent, such as a teacher stating to a student that it is time for the student to write, (b) observes the behavior, such as running away or crying, (c) determines how to make the antecedent, i.e. writing, a positive experience for the student, such as by offering alternatives of using the computer to perform the writing task or having the student orally state something instead of writing it, and (d) determines what works for the student as an alternative task or effective reward. All of the above, as described by Mr. Arroyo, is dependent upon the effective collection of data during the school day. He described the above process as “DTT,” but also stated that it could properly be characterized as part of an ABA format for teaching.
Although data collected in the manner described by Mr. Arroyo would serve to show STUDENT’s responses to ABA/DTT, the evidence demonstrated a lack of data and planning to enable appropriate implementation of ABA/DTT in STUDENT’s program. STUDENT’s IEP does not identify present levels of performance and goals and objectives for the specific areas to be addressed by ABA/DTT, such as particular elements of STUDENT’s behavior. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order that the IEP team designate a school psychologist or some other qualified expert to observe STUDENT within the first two weeks of the commencement of his new classroom placement and draft present levels of performance and goals and objectives for presentation to the IEP team. STUDENT’s IEP must then be modified to include present levels of performance and goals and objectives specific to implementing ABA/DTT in STUDENT’s program.
B. Speech, language, and/or communication reassessment to determine whether PECS is an appropriate system of communication for STUDENT.
On the basis of information considered at the May 30 and September 24, 2003 IEP meetings, including assessments by Lisa Aniversario and Jennifer Shubin performed in November and December 2002, the District recommends the use of the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) in STUDENT’s program for the current school year. MOTHER is opposed to the use of PECS in STUDENT’s program. She asserts that STUDENT is able to express his needs and wants using oral communication and, therefore, use of PECS as a mode of communication is unnecessary and would discourage STUDENT from using oral language. MOTHER does not dispute whether the assessments by Ms. Aniversario and Ms. Shubin meet the criteria for appropriate assessments set forth in Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. However, she disagrees with the recommendations set forth in those assessments concerning PECS, and she seeks reassessment to confirm the inappropriateness of using PECS in STUDENT’s program.
Thus, the question to be addressed is whether reassessment applicable to the use of PECS is required either because conditions warrant such reassessment or because STUDENT’s parent “requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. A common sense reading of § 56381 shows that a substantial change in circumstances must be demonstrated before a parent can compel a district to perform reassessment whenever reassessment is requested in conjunction with a request for development of a new IEP. Otherwise, a parent could compel reassessments on a daily basis in an effort to obtain the one assessment that supports the parent’s views.
A review of the evidence shows that Dr. Lanyi mentioned in her September 2002 report that PECS might not be age appropriate for STUDENT, but she recommended an “augmentative communication evaluation” to examine whether certain devices could facilitate STUDENT’s ability to communicate. Such an evaluation was performed by Ms. Aniversario, District AT specialist and speech and language pathologist, in November and December 2002. PECS was one of the communication aids that Ms. Aniversario recommended for STUDENT when she concluded her AT assessment. Ms. Shubin, District speech and language pathologist, further addressed the subject of PECS in her December 2002 speech and language assessment, and she also recommended PECS for STUDENT. Ms. Aniversario and Ms. Shubin concluded that STUDENT could benefit from PECS as a method for adding structure to his school day, for facilitating non-verbal communication, and for increasing his oral communication skills. (Footnote 5) Moreover, their opinions were consistent with testimony from Gayle Slott. Ms. Slott is the speech and language pathologist currently rendering speech and language services to STUDENT at Tobinworld. She testified that she has extensive training in PECS, that PECS is appropriate for STUDENT, and that she uses PECS or visual aides similar to PECS in STUDENT’s program.
Ms. Mohan, STUDENT’s classroom teacher at Tobinworld, was the primary witness having a negative opinion concerning the suitability of PECS for STUDENT’s program. Ms. Mohan was more familiar with STUDENT than were any of the other witnesses except MOTHER. However, as confirmed by her own testimony, Ms. Mohan is not a speech and language pathologist, is not an AT specialist, is unfamiliar with the structure of SDCs in general, and has no knowledge concerning the use of PECS except in its most basic forms.
The above evidence shows that, within the meaning of Cal. Educ. Code § 56381, conditions do not warrant reassessment for determining the appropriateness of PECS in STUDENT’s program, including use PECS in the proposed placement in the SDC at Birney. Similarly, no substantial change of circumstances has been demonstrated with respect to the question of whether PECS is appropriate for use in STUDENT’s program, and reassessment therefore is not required in conjunction with the parent’s request for development of a new IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that reassessment to determine the appropriateness of using PECS in STUDENT’s program is not required.
C. AT reassessment.
“Assistive technology service” is defined as “any service that directly assists an individual with exceptional needs in the selection or use of an assistive technology device that is educationally necessary.” The term includes, among other elements, evaluation of the needs of the pupil, including a “functional evaluation” of the pupil in the pupil’s “customary environment.” Cal. Code Regs. tit 5, § 3065(b).
STUDENT asserts that he requires an updated AT assessment for determining whether he can benefit from AT and, if so, to further determine the type of AT that would be appropriate. Ms. Aniversario commenced an AT assessment of STUDENT in November and completed in it December 2002. She concluded that STUDENT can benefit from AT, and she made specific AT recommendations. Her competence and qualifications to perform the assessment and the appropriateness of the methods used in her assessment are undisputed. The District asserts that the November/December 2002 AT assessment negates the need for AT reassessment at the present time. Thus, the question to be addressed is whether AT reassessment is required either because conditions warrant such reassessment or because a substantial change in circumstances has occurred in conjunction with the parent’s request for development of a new IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381.
As recognized in the reports and testimony of Ms. Aniversario and Ms. Shubin, communication is a profound area of deficit for STUDENT and, generally, for children with autism. Ms. Aniversario’s December 2002 report and her testimony confirmed that AT services involving the use of computers and appropriate software will likely have some effectiveness in addressing STUDENT’s severe communication deficits. STUDENT’s present ability to benefit from AT services is not disputed. Thus, reassessment to determine whether STUDENT can benefit from AT is not required.
With regard to the matter of reassessment for determining the type of AT services that would be appropriate, the recommendations in Ms. Aniversario’s December 2002 AT report are to consider using PECS, using a picture schedule to assist STUDENT in structuring his school day, using “social stories” to assist STUDENT in a systematic way to use language in social situations, and using computer software within the classroom setting to enhance STUDENT’s academic program and reinforce learning instead of using the computer primarily as part of a reinforcement and reward system. Ms. Aniversario testified that STUDENT does not currently need AT reassessment to determine the appropriateness of the above recommendations. She testified that her November/December 2002 AT assessment was performed in conjunction with ongoing and current efforts by the IEP team to formulate a new IEP for STUDENT. Through those efforts, Ms. Aniversario became aware of new information about STUDENT presented at the May and September 2003 IEP meetings. She testified that the new information has not caused her to believe that a new AT assessment is required, and she believes that the above-stated recommendations are still valid. Her opinions are partially based upon her belief that she will be the person assigned to provide AT and speech and language services in STUDENT’s proposed placement at Birney, and she will recommend or provide adjustments as necessary in STUDENT’s AT services when she observes STUDENT in her capacity as his service provider.
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that Ms. Aniversario’s somewhat informal plan for making adjustments to STUDENT’s AT services after commencement of his new placement is consistent with the Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a) requirements of a written IEP, as referenced above. The commencement of STUDENT’s new classroom placement outside of Tobinworld will constitute a change in STUDENT’s “customary environment.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3065(b). The appropriateness of the AT recommendations made in Ms. Aniversario’s report will then be influenced by the characteristics of STUDENT’s new placement, such as classroom structure, academic curriculum, and peer interaction, and also by STUDENT’s performance in the new placement. Thus, although many or all of the recommendations in Ms. Aniversario’s December 2002 report may remain applicable, the new placement in this particular case will constitute a change in conditions/circumstances warranting AT reassessment. (Footnote 6) AT reassessment before STUDENT commences his new placement would be premature, but provision must be made for a formal reassessment of STUDENT’s AT-related needs and services by an AT specialist within a reasonable time after STUDENT has commenced the new placement. The AT reassessment information must then be used by STUDENT’s IEP team to specify STUDENT’s AT services in his IEP, including appropriate goals and objectives a description of the devices and software to be used. (Footnote 7)
D. Neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 assessment by Dr. Shirley Lanyi.
There is no dispute that the neuropsychological assessment performed by Dr. Lanyi in September 2002 met the criteria for an appropriate assessment as set forth in Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. However, STUDENT asserts that he requires a neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Lanyi. The District asserts that a neuropsychological reassessment is not warranted. Thus, the question to be addressed is whether neuropsychological reassessment is required either because conditions warrant such reassessment or because a substantial change in circumstances has occurred in conjunction with the parent’s request for development of a new IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381.
The Hearing Officer initially notes that Dr. Lanyi’s report contained a recommendation for a six-month re-evaluation of STUDENT’s progress and program at Tobinworld. With the parties having agreed that STUDENT now requires a different placement, Dr. Lanyi’s recommendation for re-evaluation of STUDENT’s progress and program at Tobinworld is now chiefly a moot point. Dr. Lanyi’s report also recommended that the PEP-R be re-administered one year from September 2002 to determine STUDENT’s level of progress and the appropriateness of STUDENT’s program for the 2002-2003 school year. The appropriateness of STUDENT’s program for the 2002-2003 school year is not at issue in this case and is similarly a moot point. Furthermore, Dr. Lanyi’s September 2002 report has already been obtained and used specifically in conjunction with MOTHER’s ongoing request for formulation of a new IEP. Thus, a neuropsychological reassessment is not required in conjunction with the parent’s request for development of a new IEP.
However, the Hearing Officer finds that current conditions do warrant reassessment, at least to the extent that administering the PEP-R to determine STUDENT’s current levels of performance would provide important information to the IEP team. (Footnote 8) This is particularly fitting because STUDENT has severe deficits in multiple areas, and the shortage of annual IEPs during STUDENT’s five-year placement at Tobinworld causes the Hearing Officer to regard the information concerning STUDENT’s progress toward former IEP goals and objectives as unreliable. Thus, a current determination of STUDENT’s present levels of performance on the PEP-R would be invaluable to the IEP team as a baseline to measure progress in STUDENT’s new placement, especially as the timing of the PEP-R will likely coincide with the commencement of the new placement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order that the PEP-R be administered within 30 days from the date of this Decision. (Footnote 9)
E. FAA.to meet STUDENT’s unique needs related to visual cues and aids.
With respect to the matter of a one-to-one aide, the evidence in this case confirmed that having a one-to-one aide would tend to isolate STUDENT in certain situations by creating a barrier between STUDENT and his peers. Under the principles of least restrictive environment, cited above, such barriers will only be imposed if having a one-to-one aide is consistent with the statutory mandate for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 22) Mr. Arroyo’s testimony showed that ABA and DTT are used in his classroom in a manner and a frequency that would allow STUDENT to have appropriate amounts of social interaction with children in the classroom and also with typical peers at lunch, recess, and assemblies. Given the relatively manageable frequency and nature of STUDENT’s adverse behaviors, the importance of STUDENT’s needs related to development of social skills, the high adult-to-student ratio in the classroom, the high levels of structure in the classroom, and the description by Mr. Arroyo of how his SDC students are monitored by SDC staff outside of the classroom, the Hearing Officer finds no basis at present for subjecting STUDENT to the restrictiveness of having a one-to-one aide assigned specifically to him. (Footnote 23)
Accordingly, on the basis of all the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the level of behavioral support and supervision in the District’s proposed program and placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
Level of academic instruction. Mr. Arroyo testified persuasively that the level of academic instruction in his SDC would be appropriate for STUDENT. He was informed regarding STUDENT’s current academic levels. As the classroom teacher, he is obviously the person most familiar with the academic structure of the proposed SDC at Birney. He emphasized that the academic levels of students in his class vary widely and the curriculum is modified to their individual level, whether higher or lower. He also emphasized that the level of behavior support in his class enables him to keep the students sufficiently on task for making academic progress. No contrary evidence was offered. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the academic level of instruction at the proposed SDC is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
B. Individualized tutoring in reading, writing, and math.
STUDENT asserts that in addition to the services listed in the District’s offer, he requires tutoring in reading, writing, and math. The District asserts that, in STUDENT’s case, tutoring is not required for meeting STUDENT’s unique educational needs or for meeting the FAPE standard of educational benefit.
Mr. Arroyo’s description of the SDC, including the emphasis on academics and the level of adult support in the classroom, has persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT would receive substantial academic support in the new classroom placement and, consequently, the need for further services in the form of academic tutoring to provide educational benefit has not been demonstrated. However, because STUDENT, now approaching age 11, has academic skills roughly equivalent to kindergarten level and will be starting a completely new classroom placement with an emphasis on academics, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team must revisit the matter of individual tutoring in reading, writing, and math after STUDENT’s academic performance and progress in his new program can be evaluated.
C. Training to STUDENT’s parent as a related service to help implement STUDENT’s IEP.
STUDENT asserts that to meet his unique educational needs, his mother should be trained to assist him at home in the areas of academics and behavior. Such training for MOTHER was recommended in Dr. Lanyi’s report. The September 24, 2003 proposed IEP states that “when the primary placement is determined the professional support staff will provide individual parent training to support the cooperative implementation of the goals and objectives in the home.” (Footnote 24) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has already agreed to provide parent training. The Petitioner’s contentions regarding parent training are therefore moot.
D. Access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school.
Ms. Aniversario recommended the use of computer software within the classroom portion of STUDENT’s program. She made no recommendation for using a computer at home. Mr. Arroyo’s testimony confirmed that computers are utilized in the proposed SDC and STUDENT would have access to computers during the school day at the appropriate learning centers. Having considered STUDENT’s severe academic deficits and the fact that STUDENT will be commencing a new program, including a new classroom placement emphasizing academics, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s performance in the new program, including performance related to academics and computer skills, must be observed before one can determine whether STUDENT needs access to a computer at home in order to receive an appropriate program. The IEP team must revisit the matter of home computer access after STUDENT’s performance in his new program, including his performance in academics and computer skills, can be evaluated. (Footnote 25)
Summary and findings in Issue 2.
Except with respect to the items listed below concerning tutoring and home computer access, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer set forth in the September 24, 2003 proposed IEP is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and is therefore an offer of FAPE. STUDENT is a child with severe deficits arising from autism. He is now 10 years old, and the available years for providing him with educational benefit are diminishing. He will be commencing a completely new classroom placement for the 2003-2004 school year, and information concerning his performance in his new placement will have to be obtained and considered by the IEP team within the early stages of that placement. Consequently, the Hearing Officer will order the IEP team to revisit the matter of individual tutoring in reading, writing, and math after STUDENT’s academic performance and progress in his new program can be evaluated. For the reasons stated above, the IEP team must similarly revisit the matter of home computer access. To allow appropriate consideration of the AT reassessment and updated PEP-R data, as ordered herein, the matters of individual tutoring and home computer access shall be reconsidered by the IEP team within 45 days after STUDENT has commenced his new program in the SDC at Birney.
ORDERS
1. The PEP-R shall be administered to STUDENT within calendar 30 days from the date of this Decision.
2. The District is entitled to have Gallagher Pediatric Therapy perform the agreed-upon OT and PT assessments. STUDENT’s parent shall cooperate to make STUDENT available for the assessments.
3. The IEP team shall designate a school psychologist or some other qualified expert to observe STUDENT, and the observations shall commence within the first two weeks after of the start of STUDENT’s new classroom placement at Birney. On the basis of those observations and other available data, that designated expert shall draft present levels of performance and goals and objectives specific to implementing ABA/DTT in STUDENT’s program and present the same for the IEP team’s consideration at the meetings ordered below.
4. The District shall submit an AT reassessment plan for MOTHER’s approval. The plan shall provide for the AT reassessment to commence after STUDENT starts his new placement at Birney and be completed within 45 calendar days after the start of the new placement. The purpose of the AT reassessment will be to enable STUDENT’s IEP team to specify STUDENT’s AT services in his IEP, including appropriate goals and objectives a description of the devices and software to be used.
5. Within 45 calendar days after the commencement of STUDENT’s new program in the designated SDC at Birney Elementary School, and as often as is necessary thereafter, the IEP team shall meet to accomplishing the following:
(A) Consider the new PEP-R data obtained as ordered above and use that data, as appropriate, to modify STUDENT’s present levels of performance and goals and objectives.
(B) Amend STUDENT’s IEP for the 2003-2004 school year to specify present levels of performance and goals and objectives specific to the implementation of ABA and DTT in STUDENT’s program.
(C) Consider the results of the AT reassessment ordered above and, as necessary, modify STUDENT’s IEP to specify STUDENT’s AT services, including appropriate goals and objectives and a description of the devices and software to be used.
(D) Reconsider the matter of home computer access in accordance with STUDENT’s performance in his new program, including his performance in academics and computer skills.
(E) Reconsider the matter of individual tutoring in reading, writing, and math in accordance with STUDENT’s academic performance and progress in the new program.
6. All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue 1: Must the District provide STUDENT with the following:
A. Discrete trial training (DTT) assessment. STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
B. Speech, language, and/or communication reassessment to determine whether the picture exchange communication system (PECS) is an appropriate system of communication for STUDENT. The District prevailed on this issue.
C. Assistive technology (AT) reassessment. STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
D. Neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 assessment by Dr. Shirley Lanyi. STUDENT prevailed on this issue to the extent that the PEP-R must be administered within 30 days from the date of this Decision.
E. Functional analysis assessment (FAA). The District prevailed on this issue.
F. Occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) assessments by an entity other than Gallagher Pediatric Therapy? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: Has the District denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer:
A. Appropriate classroom placement. The District prevailed on this issue.
B. Individualized tutoring in reading, writing, and math. Neither party prevailed on this issue.
C. Training to STUDENT’s parent as a related service to help implement STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP). This issue was determined to be moot.
D. Access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school? Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 14, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
STUDENT asserts that he requires a functional analysis assessment (FAA). He further asserts that the FAA should be used in the formulation of a behavioral intervention plan (BIP). The District denies that an FAA is necessary.
Federal and State law specify that behavior plans, formulated on the basis of assessment information, are to be included in a pupil’s IEP when necessary for meeting the pupil’s behavior-related needs arising from his or her disability. Federal law makes general references to “positive behavioral interventions,” “functional behavioral assessment,” and “behavioral intervention plan[s].” See 20 U.S.C. §§ 1414(d)(3)(B)(i) and 1415(k)(1)(B). State regulations set forth, for use in certain situations, the mandatory and relatively detailed elements of a “behavioral intervention plan” (BIP) formulated from a particular type of assessment known as a “functional analysis assessment” (FAA). (Footnote 10) BIPs, as defined by State law, are developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP. (Footnote 11) The term “serious behavior problems” is defined as “the individual’s behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(aa). State law also specifies that FAA’s, used in formulating BIPs as stated above, are mandatory if the IEP team finds that “instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP have been ineffective.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3052(b) and (c).
In the present case, the key element applicable from the above law is whether “instructional/behavioral approaches” in STUDENT’s IEP are effective, thereby negating the need for an FAA and a BIP.
Jared Pickett, a classroom aide in Ms. Mohan’s class at Tobinworld, testified that he has worked with STUDENT for two years. The classroom currently has a teacher, three aides, and nine students. The students’ ages are from 7 to 11 years. As described by Mr. Pickett, STUDENT’s behaviors have included head butting, spitting, hitting, being out of his seat, desiring to use the computer off task, fascination with female genitalia, taking off his shoes and clothing, deliberate regurgitation of food, urination and defecation in his pants, running away, and fascination with breaking glass. He testified that STUDENT responds to verbal prompts and although he does not believe that STUDENT requires a one-to-one aide, the adults in charge of STUDENT need to be vigilant. He testified that STUDENT’s behavior has improved in the past two years, although not dramatically. He testified that STUDENT is compliant during about 75-80 percent of the school day and has tantrums about once per week.
Ms. Mojan, STUDENT’s classroom teacher at Tobinworld from November 2002 through the present, testified that during the first week she had STUDENT in her class, he would “yell” during about 80 percent of the day. Since that time, according to Ms. Mojan, STUDENT’s behavior has improved significantly. She testified that STUDENT “tries his best” at academic tasks and his behavior is now approaching 100 percent compliance. She stated that tantrums are now rare, occurring about once per week, and can include STUDENT’s hitting himself on the nose, causing the nose to bleed. Ms. Mohan testified that STUDENT does not have a designated one-to-one aide and he responds well to her and to her staff of three aides.
The Hearing Officer notes that when Dr. Lanyi conducted her neuropsychological evaluation of STUDENT in September 2002, she had specifically been asked to address STUDENT’s behavior-related needs. Her recommendations regarding behavior emphasized the need for structure in the classroom. In her report, she stated that STUDENT needs a strategy of improving behavior through prevention rather than through reactive strategies. She indicated that much of STUDENT’s behavior at that time arose from his high level of stress and anxiety, most likely exacerbated by a lack of structure and routine in his environment. She recommended a “structured teaching model” as being calming for STUDENT and, by its nature, being likely to reduce inappropriate behaviors in the classroom and elsewhere. (Footnote 12) At the hearing, both parties expressed their agreement concerning Dr. Lanyi’s conclusions and recommendations.
The IEP proposed by the District for the 2003-2004 school year includes a written “behavior support plan.” Several witnesses testified that the plan was devised by Tobinworld, and the witnesses indicated that the plan was reflective of behavioral interventions that Tobinworld has used for STUDENT. The plan was not intended to be as specific as a BIP under the State law definition, and it was not formulated from an FAA. However, consistent with both State and federal law, the plan utilizes a positive behavioral intervention approach by identifying the adverse behaviors, identifying the purpose that STUDENT intends for the behaviors to serve, and identifying positive alternative behaviors and positive reinforcement strategies.
In summary, the evidence confirmed that STUDENT’s behaviors can be problematic. However, with Tobinworld’s use of a positive behavioral intervention approach, STUDENT’s behavioral compliance in the classroom environment has improved over the past year, even within a classroom placement that the parties now recognize as needing significant revision. Those approaches were written into a behavior support plan and that plan is part of the proposed IEP for the 2003-2004 school year. The plan would be used in conjunction with a new and appropriate classroom placement having, in accordance with Dr. Lanyi’s recommendations, a higher level of structure in comparison to what STUDENT received at Tobinworld. Thus, the weight of the evidence shows that such “instructional/behavioral approaches” for STUDENT, specified in an appropriate IEP with a written behavior support plan, will likely be effective in addressing STUDENT’s behaviors, thereby negating the need for the more detailed approach of an FAA and BIP as defined in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3001(aa) and 3052(b). (Footnote 13) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that neither an FAA nor a BIP formulated from an FAA are required at the present time.
F. OT and PT assessments by an entity other than Gallagher Pediatric Therapy.
The parties agree that OT and PT assessments shall be performed. They dispute whether the District’s selection of Gallagher Pediatric Therapy (Gallagher) to perform the assessments is appropriate. STUDENT’s objection to having Gallagher perform the assessments arises from events that occurred when STUDENT’s therapy at Gallagher was terminated in or about April 1999. On April 13, 1999, Gallagher issued a report entitled “Occupational Therapy Discharge Summary.” The report states that Gallagher had been providing OT to STUDENT on a continuous basis since July 1995. The report states that commencing in March 1996, the District funded the OT as part of STUDENT’s special education services. It describes STUDENT’s progress on goals and objectives set forth in the February 5, 1998 IEP and states that although STUDENT had made progress on his OT goals and objectives, the progress had “not carried over to the classroom setting.” The report refers to comments by the classroom teacher, who reportedly stated that STUDENT was continuing to have difficulty organizing his behavior at school, “often runs around the room,” and “has difficulty sitting still for activities without a one-on-one situation.” Immediately thereafter, the report concludes by stating, “Therefore, at this time, it is recommended that [STUDENT] be discharged from occupational therapy services.” STUDENT’s mother testified that she was subsequently told by Gallagher that funding had been terminated by the District and she was to stop bringing STUDENT to Gallagher for therapy. The evidence was unclear concerning whether a decision to terminate OT services had actually been made by the IEP team. (Footnote 14)
On the basis of the above, STUDENT’s mother asserts that Gallagher’s April 1999 recommendation to terminate services was inappropriate and, consequently, Gallagher cannot be trusted to perform an appropriate assessment at the present time. She also asserts that Gallagher lacks the appropriate equipment to evaluate and/or provide therapy to a child as physically large as STUDENT. The District asserts that Gallagher is properly qualified to conduct the proposed assessments and STUDENT’s remedy would be to demand independent assessments if his mother disagreed with Gallagher’s findings or recommendations. (Footnote 15)
Mary Kay Gallagher testified that she is the chief executive officer of Gallagher Pediatric Therapy, employing 62 occupational therapists. She testified that Gallagher has the requisite expertise to conduct OT and PT assessments of STUDENT, that Gallagher has extensive experience assessing children with autism, and that there are no applicable weight restrictions. She stated that clinic-based assessment could be done if necessary, but she also explained that an ultimate goal of clinic-based therapy is to enable a student to generalize skills learned in the clinic setting so those skills can be used in the classroom setting. Thus, she suggested that STUDENT should first be evaluated in school because improving his performance in an educational setting is potentially the primary objective of therapy services. The Hearing Officer asked Ms. Gallagher to explain why her company’s April 1999 report recommended termination of STUDENT’s OT services when the same report indicated that STUDENT still may have had OT-related needs. Ms. Gallagher replied that she did not write the report and was not familiar with the circumstances surrounding termination of STUDENT’s services at that time.
After considering MOTHER’s experience with Gallagher arising from the April 1999 report, the Hearing Officer understands why MOTHER objects to entrusting Gallagher with responsibility for assessing STUDENT and making recommendations to the IEP team. However, the appropriateness or inappropriateness of Gallagher’s April 1999 recommendation to terminate OT services for a child manifesting significant needs related to OT, if that in fact is what occurred, is not at issue in the present case. Similarly not at issue is the District’s wisdom in insisting that Gallagher perform the new assessments when the District knows that Gallagher has poor credibility with MOTHER and she is likely to view the assessments with skepticism. Instead, the current dispute before the Hearing Officer is whether Gallagher, at present, is qualified under Cal. Educ. Code section 56320 to perform the assessments. The testimony of Ms. Gallagher supported the District’s assertion that Gallagher currently has numerous therapists who are appropriately qualified to conduct the assessments, and that Gallagher has the necessary equipment to perform the assessments. There was no effective evidence presented to the contrary. Further, although the events related above from April 1999 are troubling, the evidence from events occurring more than 4 years ago is not sufficient to support a finding that Gallagher currently should be precluded from performing the assessment, either on the basis of bias toward the District or some form of prejudice toward STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to have Gallagher perform the OT and PT assessments.
Summary of findings in Issue 1.
With regard to STUDENT’s request for DTT assessment, the Hearing Officer has determined that the IEP team must designate a school psychologist or some other qualified expert to observe STUDENT within the first two weeks of the commencement of his new classroom placement and draft present levels of performance and goals and objectives for presentation to the IEP team. STUDENT’s IEP must then be modified to include present levels of performance and goals and objectives specific to implementing ABA/DTT in STUDENT’s program.
Provision must be made for a reassessment of STUDENT’s AT-related needs and services by an AT specialist within a reasonable time after STUDENT has commenced the new placement. The AT reassessment information must then be used by STUDENT’s IEP team to specify STUDENT’s AT services in his IEP, including appropriate goals and objectives and a description of the devices and software to be used. To coincide with the timing of other orders to be made in this Decision, the Hearing Officer will order that the AT reassessment must commence after STUDENT begins his new placement, and the AT reassessment must be completed within 45 days after STUDENT begins his new placement.
Neuropsychological reassessment is not required at the present time, except that the PEP-R shall be administered within 30 days from the date of this Decision. Reassessment to determine the appropriateness of using PECS in STUDENT’s program is not required. Neither an FAA nor a BIP formulated from an FAA is required at the present time. The District is entitled to have Gallagher perform the agreed-upon OT and PT assessments.
Issue 2: Has the District denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer: (A) appropriate classroom placement; (B) individualized tutoring in reading, writing, and math; (C) training to STUDENT’s parent as a related service to help implement STUDENT’s IEP; (D) access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school?
************
A. Appropriate classroom placement.
Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. In accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 207-208.
To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. (Footnote 16)
The elements of FAPE applicable to STUDENT’s contentions in Issue 2 are whether the District’s offer for the 2003-3004 school year is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. More specifically, STUDENT objects to the District’s proposed SDC classroom placement at Birney on the grounds that behavioral supervision and support in the SDC would be inadequate to meet STUDENT’s needs and a one-to-one aide is required. STUDENT also asserts that the SDC is inappropriate because the level of academic instruction in the SDC would be too advanced for him. STUDENT further asserts that the District’s offer is deficient with regard to tutoring, parent training, and computer access. (Footnote 17)
Before examining the above-stated contentions, the Hearing Officer will first review and identify STUDENT’s unique educational needs. For purposes of convenience, all of STUDENT’s unique educational needs and the elements of the District’s offer that may be applicable to the analysis of subparts (A) through (D) of Issue 2 will be identified immediately below. The Hearing Officer will then proceed through each subpart of Issue 2 and determine, within the context of STUDENT’s contentions, whether the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
I. STUDENT’s unique educational needs.
The parties agree that the chief areas of deficit arising from STUDENT’s disability include behavior, academics, speech and language, social skills, and self-help skills. Dr. Lanyi’s September 2002 report lists what Dr. Lanyi considered to be STUDENT’s educational needs arising from those deficits. Her opinions regarding STUDENT’s unique educational needs were substantially consistent with the testimony of witnesses from the District and from Tobinworld, including John Wakeham, Ms. Shubin, Ms. Aniversario, Ms. Mohan, Mr. Pickett, and Ms. Slott. Those needs are summarized below. (Footnote 18)
First, because of his behavior-related deficits, STUDENT needs a high level of structure in the classroom setting. More specifically, the classroom must have a high adult-to-student ratio. The school day must be structured in terms of the classroom activities to be performed and the predictability of the schedule for those activities. The daily schedule should be consistent and should be presented visually and orally. The witnesses and Dr. Lanyi’s report confirm that such structure would tend to reduce STUDENT’s stress levels and thereby improve STUDENT’s behavior.
Next, behavior must be addressed by preventive instead of reactive strategies. Mr. Wakeham, a WACSEP program specialist, testified that an appropriate program must provide behavior intervention by anticipating STUDENT’s behavior instead of reacting to it. (Footnote 19) He stated that to implement such a program, the staff must utilize frequent cues and prompting. Mr. Wakeham emphasized the importance of a written behavior plan and the importance of advance preparations so supports are in place before STUDENT first “steps through the door” to the District’s proposed placement in the SDC at Birney. In addition to acknowledging the importance of structure and predictability as preventive behavior strategies, Dr. Lanyi’s report stated that the combination of structure and an ABA format should increase STUDENT’s attending skills and thereby increase his ability to learn new tasks. Dr. Lanyi recommended that STUDENT receive significant daily amounts of direct teaching in a structured ABA format designed to teach him to imitate appropriately, follow adult directions, and interact appropriately with adults and peers in social situations.
There is no dispute that STUDENT has needs in reading, math, and speech and language. Ms. Mohan testified that she considers STUDENT’s academic skills to be roughly equivalent to kindergarten level. STUDENT reportedly can identify some numbers and recite them in proper sequence, although Ms. Mohan testified that STUDENT does not understand math concepts such as one plus one. There is no dispute that STUDENT needs speech and language services. Assessment indicates that STUDENT’s receptive language skills are equivalent to about the 2.5-year age level, and expressive language skills are equivalent to about the 1.5- to-2.0-year age level.
Witnesses were in agreement that services to address STUDENT’s behavioral, academic, and speech and language needs require balancing with STUDENT’s social-skill needs. Ms. Mohan testified that STUDENT would benefit from ABA methodologies but DTT would have to be incorporated into his program in a manner that allows for his social interaction with the children in his classroom. Mr. Wakeham testified that whether STUDENT required the restrictive services of a one-to-one aide would be dependent upon the level of structure and adult-to-student ratio in the classroom. He believes that STUDENT’s IEP should provide for ABA support, including some individual support during “key learning times,” but that group instruction is also important for STUDENT. Regarding outdoor activities, Ms. Mohan testified that STUDENT should have someone watching him at least from a distance but he does not necessarily need a full-time one-to-one aide. She stated that he does not tend to run away from his group when outdoors and he responds if called while wandering off.
Finally, with regard to training, the parties agree that STUDENT’s classroom teacher and service providers must be trained in the basic strategies needed to work with children with autism. Dr. Lanyi further recommended that for STUDENT to “optimally benefit” from his educational program, it was important for his mother to be have some knowledge of the different methodologies and strategies used in the program, thereby allowing his mother to “work in tandem with school personnel and reinforce learning for STUDENT at home.”
II. The District’s offer.
The IEP proposed by the District at the September 24, 2003 IEP meeting sets forth the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year. The District has offered a five-days-per-week placement in the SDC at Birney, known to be taught by Mr. Arroyo. Speech and language therapy would be provided to STUDENT in the SDC in three thirty-minute group sessions per week. STUDENT’s educational needs were listed as “reading, behavior, math, written language, communication.” Goals and objectives were stated for written language, math, reading, attention to task, and recognizing high-frequency sight words. Communication goals and objectives, to be implemented by the special education teacher and the speech and language therapist, included formulating sentences of greater complexity, increasing social conversations, responding to “wh” questions, and increasing vocabulary.
The District’s proposed program includes a behavior support plan prepared by Tobinworld. The plan formulated by Tobinworld is not a “BIP.” As stated earlier in this Decision, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT presently does not require a BIP formulated from an FAA, as those terms are defined in State law. The first page of the proposed plan briefly lists some of STUDENT’s tantrum behaviors, what generally occurs before and after the behaviors, purposes served by the behaviors, replacement behaviors, reinforcement strategies, and modifications and support for use in the classroom. Recommendations for communication, monitoring, and “one-to-one assistance when possible” appear on the second page of the behavior support plan, along with some goals and objectives for following a visual schedule.
Mr. Arroyo, the teacher of the proposed SDC at Birney, testified concerning his qualifications and the nature of his class. He has training in autism, ABA, DTT, PECS, and crisis prevention intervention (CPI). He has been the SDC teacher for the past five years. The SDC has ten students, ranging in age from 9 to 12 years, plus the teacher and three adult aides. According to data confirmed by Mr. Arroyo, academic achievement test scores show that the students in his class have been successful at making meaningful progress. The classroom schedule involves having the children split into groups of two and having them rotate to different learning centers at 15- to-20-minute intervals. The learning centers for language arts include a reading center utilizing “Reading Mastery” and “Language Master,” a spelling center using both paper and a computer, and a speech and language listening center where the children are expected to “relax” and listen to tapes of their choice. Learning centers for math include centers devoted to language-based math strategies, number writing, taped instruction, and math workbooks. The students are monitored by the classroom aides during daily mainstreaming with typical peers for lunch and recess. Schedule adjustments are made as needed for pull-out services, school assemblies, and English language development. Ms. Aniversario provides speech and language services in the SDC four days per week from 9:30 to 10:30 a.m.
According to Mr. Arroyo, the academic curriculum in the proposed SDC is generally at the first- and second-grade level, but adjustments are made in accordance with each student’s individual skill level. Mr. Arroyo testified that although his class emphasizes academics, students with behavior problems have demonstrated improved behaviors in class and have made academic progress. Mr. Arroyo testified that he uses ABA/DTT strategies and collects large amounts of data on each student. He also utilizes “social stories,” and his aides are trained in DTT and probably in CPI. He testified that although the students know the class schedule, he also places visual cues on the board.
III. Discussion.
Subpart (A) of Issue 2 pertains to STUDENT’s assertions that behavioral supervision and support in the District’s proposed SDC at Birney would be inadequate to meet STUDENT’s needs. More specifically, STUDENT asserts that behavioral support and supervision in the proposed SDC are inadequate because the SDC is inconsistent with the TEACCH model recommended in Dr. Lanyi’s report, the SDC has insufficient visual cues within the classroom, and the program fails to provide for a one-to-one aide. (Footnote 20)
Dr. Lanyi’s report describes an appropriate classroom placement as being one that emphasizes structure, including the use of schedules, picture and word communication, work stations, and preventive behavior strategies. (Footnote 21) The report states that such a classroom is derived from the TEACCH model. Neither the District nor Mr. Arroyo labeled the proposed SDC as being a TEACCH model. However, Dr. Lanyi’s report does not suggest that only a classroom specifically labeled as a TEACCH model could provide the requisite structure for meeting STUDENT’s needs. STUDENT’s needs will be addressed by the features of the classroom placement, not by the label ascribed to the classroom.
Mr. Arroyo’s testimony showed that the classroom environment of the proposed SDC is quite similar to Dr. Lanyi’s description of a TEACCH model. More importantly, the evidence showed that the nature and levels of structure and behavioral support in the proposed SDC were consistent with STUDENT’s above-identified needs related to behavior and social skills. Specifically, the testimony of Mr. Arroyo, Ms. Aniversario, and Ms. Shubin established that the expected SDC classroom teacher, classroom aides/assistants, and the speech and language and AT service providers all have appropriate training and experience in the basic strategies needed to work with children with autism. The Hearing Officer was persuaded that the learning center format utilized in the classroom, the consistent and predictable daily schedule, the use of preventive ABA strategies with emphasis on collection and use of data, the ratio of four trained adults to ten students, and the frequent use of cues and prompts would all combine to produce a high level of structure in the classroom. The Hearing Officer was also persuaded that the visual aids described by Mr. Arroyo, in conjunction with recommendations by Ms. Aniversario and Ms. Shubin for using PECS as a component of speech and language therapy and AT, were all designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs related to visual cues and aids.
With respect to the matter of a one-to-one aide, the evidence in this case confirmed that having a one-to-one aide would tend to isolate STUDENT in certain situations by creating a barrier between STUDENT and his peers. Under the principles of least restrictive environment, cited above, such barriers will only be imposed if having a one-to-one aide is consistent with the statutory mandate for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 22) Mr. Arroyo’s testimony showed that ABA and DTT are used in his classroom in a manner and a frequency that would allow STUDENT to have appropriate amounts of social interaction with children in the classroom and also with typical peers at lunch, recess, and assemblies. Given the relatively manageable frequency and nature of STUDENT’s adverse behaviors, the importance of STUDENT’s needs related to development of social skills, the high adult-to-student ratio in the classroom, the high levels of structure in the classroom, and the description by Mr. Arroyo of how his SDC students are monitored by SDC staff outside of the classroom, the Hearing Officer finds no basis at present for subjecting STUDENT to the restrictiveness of having a one-to-one aide assigned specifically to him. (Footnote 23)
Accordingly, on the basis of all the evidence discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the level of behavioral support and supervision in the District’s proposed program and placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior-related needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
Level of academic instruction. Mr. Arroyo testified persuasively that the level of academic instruction in his SDC would be appropriate for STUDENT. He was informed regarding STUDENT’s current academic levels. As the classroom teacher, he is obviously the person most familiar with the academic structure of the proposed SDC at Birney. He emphasized that the academic levels of students in his class vary widely and the curriculum is modified to their individual level, whether higher or lower. He also emphasized that the level of behavior support in his class enables him to keep the students sufficiently on task for making academic progress. No contrary evidence was offered. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the academic level of instruction at the proposed SDC is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.
B. Individualized tutoring in reading, writing, and math.
STUDENT asserts that in addition to the services listed in the District’s offer, he requires tutoring in reading, writing, and math. The District asserts that, in STUDENT’s case, tutoring is not required for meeting STUDENT’s unique educational needs or for meeting the FAPE standard of educational benefit.
Mr. Arroyo’s description of the SDC, including the emphasis on academics and the level of adult support in the classroom, has persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT would receive substantial academic support in the new classroom placement and, consequently, the need for further services in the form of academic tutoring to provide educational benefit has not been demonstrated. However, because STUDENT, now approaching age 11, has academic skills roughly equivalent to kindergarten level and will be starting a completely new classroom placement with an emphasis on academics, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team must revisit the matter of individual tutoring in reading, writing, and math after STUDENT’s academic performance and progress in his new program can be evaluated.
C. Training to STUDENT’s parent as a related service to help implement STUDENT’s IEP.
STUDENT asserts that to meet his unique educational needs, his mother should be trained to assist him at home in the areas of academics and behavior. Such training for MOTHER was recommended in Dr. Lanyi’s report. The September 24, 2003 proposed IEP states that “when the primary placement is determined the professional support staff will provide individual parent training to support the cooperative implementation of the goals and objectives in the home.” (Footnote 24) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has already agreed to provide parent training. The Petitioner’s contentions regarding parent training are therefore moot.
D. Access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school.
Ms. Aniversario recommended the use of computer software within the classroom portion of STUDENT’s program. She made no recommendation for using a computer at home. Mr. Arroyo’s testimony confirmed that computers are utilized in the proposed SDC and STUDENT would have access to computers during the school day at the appropriate learning centers. Having considered STUDENT’s severe academic deficits and the fact that STUDENT will be commencing a new program, including a new classroom placement emphasizing academics, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s performance in the new program, including performance related to academics and computer skills, must be observed before one can determine whether STUDENT needs access to a computer at home in order to receive an appropriate program. The IEP team must revisit the matter of home computer access after STUDENT’s performance in his new program, including his performance in academics and computer skills, can be evaluated. (Footnote 25)
Summary and findings in Issue 2.
Except with respect to the items listed below concerning tutoring and home computer access, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer set forth in the September 24, 2003 proposed IEP is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and is therefore an offer of FAPE. STUDENT is a child with severe deficits arising from autism. He is now 10 years old, and the available years for providing him with educational benefit are diminishing. He will be commencing a completely new classroom placement for the 2003-2004 school year, and information concerning his performance in his new placement will have to be obtained and considered by the IEP team within the early stages of that placement. Consequently, the Hearing Officer will order the IEP team to revisit the matter of individual tutoring in reading, writing, and math after STUDENT’s academic performance and progress in his new program can be evaluated. For the reasons stated above, the IEP team must similarly revisit the matter of home computer access. To allow appropriate consideration of the AT reassessment and updated PEP-R data, as ordered herein, the matters of individual tutoring and home computer access shall be reconsidered by the IEP team within 45 days after STUDENT has commenced his new program in the SDC at Birney.
ORDERS
1. The PEP-R shall be administered to STUDENT within calendar 30 days from the date of this Decision.
2. The District is entitled to have Gallagher Pediatric Therapy perform the agreed-upon OT and PT assessments. STUDENT’s parent shall cooperate to make STUDENT available for the assessments.
3. The IEP team shall designate a school psychologist or some other qualified expert to observe STUDENT, and the observations shall commence within the first two weeks after of the start of STUDENT’s new classroom placement at Birney. On the basis of those observations and other available data, that designated expert shall draft present levels of performance and goals and objectives specific to implementing ABA/DTT in STUDENT’s program and present the same for the IEP team’s consideration at the meetings ordered below.
4. The District shall submit an AT reassessment plan for MOTHER’s approval. The plan shall provide for the AT reassessment to commence after STUDENT starts his new placement at Birney and be completed within 45 calendar days after the start of the new placement. The purpose of the AT reassessment will be to enable STUDENT’s IEP team to specify STUDENT’s AT services in his IEP, including appropriate goals and objectives a description of the devices and software to be used.
5. Within 45 calendar days after the commencement of STUDENT’s new program in the designated SDC at Birney Elementary School, and as often as is necessary thereafter, the IEP team shall meet to accomplishing the following:
(A) Consider the new PEP-R data obtained as ordered above and use that data, as appropriate, to modify STUDENT’s present levels of performance and goals and objectives.
(B) Amend STUDENT’s IEP for the 2003-2004 school year to specify present levels of performance and goals and objectives specific to the implementation of ABA and DTT in STUDENT’s program.
(C) Consider the results of the AT reassessment ordered above and, as necessary, modify STUDENT’s IEP to specify STUDENT’s AT services, including appropriate goals and objectives and a description of the devices and software to be used.
(D) Reconsider the matter of home computer access in accordance with STUDENT’s performance in his new program, including his performance in academics and computer skills.
(E) Reconsider the matter of individual tutoring in reading, writing, and math in accordance with STUDENT’s academic performance and progress in the new program.
6. All other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue 1: Must the District provide STUDENT with the following:
A. Discrete trial training (DTT) assessment. STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
B. Speech, language, and/or communication reassessment to determine whether the picture exchange communication system (PECS) is an appropriate system of communication for STUDENT. The District prevailed on this issue.
C. Assistive technology (AT) reassessment. STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
D. Neuropsychological reassessment as an update to the September 2002 assessment by Dr. Shirley Lanyi. STUDENT prevailed on this issue to the extent that the PEP-R must be administered within 30 days from the date of this Decision.
E. Functional analysis assessment (FAA). The District prevailed on this issue.
F. Occupational therapy (OT) and physical therapy (PT) assessments by an entity other than Gallagher Pediatric Therapy? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: Has the District denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2003-2004 school year by failing to offer:
A. Appropriate classroom placement. The District prevailed on this issue.
B. Individualized tutoring in reading, writing, and math. Neither party prevailed on this issue.
C. Training to STUDENT’s parent as a related service to help implement STUDENT’s individualized education program (IEP). This issue was determined to be moot.
D. Access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school? Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 14, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The above issues were derived from the September 2, 2003 Prehearing Conference Order (PHCO) and the parties’ discussions with the Hearing Officer on the first day of hearing. For purposes of analysis in this Decision, the above statement of issues contains some modifications in wording compared to the wording of the issues in the PCHO. However, with some minor exceptions, as explained hereafter, the issues stated above are substantively the same as the issues stated in the PHCO. Prior to the calling of witnesses, the parties engaged in settlement discussions outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. The parties reported that they had resolved the issues previously identified as Issues 1, 4, and 11 in the PHCO. Those issues involved a request for referral to the Southern California Diagnostic Center, a request for adapted physical education assessment, and a request for production of school records. Accordingly, those issues were dismissed. The parties’ settlement discussions also resulted in substantive changes to what had been listed as Issues 2 and 3 in the PHCO, and those substantive changes have been incorporated into the portion of Issue 1 above concerning OT and PT assessments. Moreover, in discussions with the Hearing Officer prior to the calling of witnesses, the parties agreed that the appropriateness of the District’s offer made at the September 24, 2003 IEP meeting would be addressed at the hearing. That latter agreement resulted in substantive changes to what had been listed as Issue 10 in the PHCO, and that modified issue now appears as Issue 2 above .
2. The issues as written in the January 2002 due process hearing request are stated too generically to permit a meaningful comparison to the issues actually presented for hearing on September 30, 2003.
3. Until recently, IEP meetings have been infrequent for STUDENT. The record in this hearing referenced IEPs in February 1998, January 2000 with a February 2000 addendum, May 2003, and September 2003. Throughout the hearing, MOTHER made references to STUDENT’s allegedly being “warehoused” by the District at Tobinworld without appropriate services. However, none of the events concerning prior school years remained at issue when the hearing commenced. Instead, the issues presented for hearing concern only the current school year.
4. During settlement discussions on the first day of hearing, the parties agreed to have the Diagnostic Center assess STUDENT at the earliest available date. The Hearing Officer considers the District’s position on DTT assessment to be disingenuous. The District conveys the impression that it does not know what a DTT assessment would be, yet at the same time attempts to reassure STUDENT and the Hearing Officer that the Diagnositic Center will perform something equivalent to a DTT assessment.
5. Undisputed evidence showed that Ms. Aniverario and Ms. Shubin were qualified to conduct the assessments. Their assessments included interviews, observations of STUDENT on multiple occasions in various educational settings, and, in Ms. Shubin’s assessment, formal testing. Furthermore, Ms. Aniversario and Ms. Shubin received updated information on STUDENT presented by Tobinworld staff at the May 30 and September 24, 2003 IEP meetings.
6. This finding should not be construed as meaning that a new placement should always be followed by an AT reassessment. Among other special factors in this particular case, such as STUDENT’s severe communication deficits, Ms. Aniversario’s report is nearly one year old and the District’s proposed SDC placement at Birney had not even been contemplated at the time Ms. Aniversario conducted the November/December 2002 AT assessment and made the recommendations in her December 2002 report.
7. STUDENT also asserts that if an AT reassessment determines he can benefit from AT, he should be given access to pertinent software and a computer both at home and at school. STUDENT’s assertions regarding use of a computer at home and at school will be addressed in Issue 2 below.
8. Dr. Lanyi’s report states that the PEP-R (Psychoeducational Profile Revised) is particularly suited to provide information on patterns of learning and behavior in students with autism. The report states that although the PEP-R is most appropriately used with children between the ages of 6 months and 7 years or students who are functioning at or below the first-grade level in one or more skill areas, data available to Dr. Lanyi indicated to her that the PEP-R was still the most appropriate tool for assessing STUDENT’s skills.
9. Given the parties’ expressed approval of Dr. Lanyi’s prior report, the parties may consider Dr. Lanyi to be an appropriate person to administer the PEP-R.
10. The specific and required elements of a behavior intervention plan (BIP), as referenced under State law, are distinct from the general references to behavior intervention plans in federal law.
11. BIPs are described in Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(d), (e), and (f). BIPS are intended to provide for systematic implementation of procedures designed to result in lasting positive changes in the individual’s behavior. The plan must include an objective and measurable description of the targeted maladaptive behaviors and replacement positive behaviors; the individual’s goals and objectives specific to the behavioral intervention plan; a detailed description of the behavioral interventions to be used and the circumstances for their use; specific schedules for recording the frequency of the use of the interventions and the frequency of the targeted behaviors, including specific criteria for discontinuing the use of the intervention for lack of effectiveness or replacing it with an identified and specified alternative; criteria by which the procedure will be faded; interventions which will be used in the home, residential facility, work site, or other noneducational settings; and specific dates for review by the IEP team.
12. Dr. Lanyi’s report contained no recommendation for an FAA.
13. The Hearing Officer has found that instructional/behavioral approaches implemented in an appropriate IEP, including an appropriate classroom placement, will likely be effective in addressing STUDENT’s adverse behaviors. Elsewhere in this Decision, the Hearing Officer will address the separate question of whether the proposed classroom placement in the SDC at Birney is appropriate.
14. The District presented no evidence that the IEP team had made such a determination, although the Hearing Officer also notes that this subject was not at issue in the case.
15. A parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, if the district’s assessment, through a due process hearing, is determined to be appropriate, the parent is not entitled to have the independent assessment at public expense. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
16. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484. No such procedural violations were at issue in the present case.
17. This Decision addresses specific FAPE contentions raised by the Petitioner during the hearing. Some of those contentions were elaborated upon by the Petitioner in his closing brief. Many of those expanded contentions made by the Petitioner in his closing brief are addressed in the portion of this Decision below that identifies STUDENT’s unique educational needs. Objections regarding the lack of OT/PT services in the District’s offer were raised for the first time in the Petitioner’s closing brief. The Hearing Officer makes no findings regarding OT/PT services except to note that the matter of OT/PT services will have to be reconsidered by the IEP team after completion of the assessment by Gallagher Pediatric Therapy.
18. Dr. Lanyi’s report states that it was written to address a series of questions by the parties regarding a “most appropriate” program for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs. Although “most appropriate” is higher than the standard required for FAPE, unique educational needs for purposes of FAPE are readily identifiable in the report.
19. John Wakeham testified that he has been a program specialist at WACSEP for 31 years. He testified that he attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings in May and September 2003. He is familiar STUDENT’s educational records and the various evaluations presented at the IEP meetings.
20. The Petitioner’s assertions regarding visual cues were inconsistent with his objection to using PECS.
21. This description appears on page 14 of Dr. Lanyi’s report. The report also identifies TEAACH as being a classroom model “based on the Division TEACCH project from North Carolina.”
22. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
23. Evidence regarding the need for a one-to-one aide was not persuasive. Laura Ruesga, a program specialist at Fiesta Educativa, an NPA, testified that she has known STUDENT for the past five years, observing him during the times that MOTHER attends special education seminars at Fiesta Educativa. She testified that on the basis of her observations of STUDENT and the difficulties that her staff has with him, she believes that STUDENT needs a high degree of structure, including one-to-one attention. However, Ms. Ruesga testified that she has never observed STUDENT in an educational setting and she has no experience teaching students with special needs, either in SDCs or in other educational settings.
24. That portion of the proposed IEP also references Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. The section states that designated instruction and services may include parent counseling and training.
25 In Issue 1 above, the Hearing Officer similarly ordered that after STUDENT’s new placement has commenced, an AT reassessment must be performed and the information from that reassessment will be used by STUDENT’s IEP team to specify STUDENT’s AT services in his IEP, including appropriate goals and objectives and a description of the devices and software to be used. Lisa Aniversario would be an appropriate person to perform the AT reassessment.
