California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 23, 2002
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1192-01 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy
Hearing Officer finds student lived within Los Angeles Unified's boundaries since 1999, rejecting the District's residency defense to a compensatory education claim.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The hearing on the student's underlying FAPE and compensatory education claims was continued to September 10 and 11, 2002. The case had earlier been taken off calendar on June 5, 2001 and was put back on calendar at the student's request on July 3, 2002.
Summary
A 12-year-old student with a specific learning disability filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. He sought compensatory education for an alleged denial of FAPE from March 1999 forward. The District raised an affirmative defense. It argued that the student never lived within its boundaries, so it could not owe compensatory services even if it had failed to provide FAPE. At the student's request, the case was bifurcated, and the Hearing Officer heard the residency question first in a one-day hearing on July 25, 2002.
The Hearing Officer looked at three time periods. For March to summer 1999, the District's own enrollment form showed that staff had checked address verification, a utility bill, and immunization records. That supported the Carson address the mother gave. For summer 1999 to April 2002, the mother admitted she kept giving the District an outdated address so her sons could stay at Ambler Elementary. However, the grandmother and great-grandmother credibly testified that the family lived in the great-grandmother's Los Angeles home, which was also inside the District. The District's attendance counselor had no personal knowledge of where the family lived. The Hearing Officer gave no weight to hearsay from an unidentified agency operator who said the family lived in Compton. For April 2002 onward, gas bills supported the family's move to a new Carson address. The Hearing Officer found that the student was a District resident for the entire period. The FAPE claims were set for hearing in September 2002.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's non-residency defense to a compensatory education claim. The Hearing Officer weighed the district's own enrollment verification and testimony from relatives with firsthand knowledge against investigator hearsay. A parent's misstatement of which in-district address the family used did not establish that the family lived outside the district.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 1. Was STUDENT a resident of the District between March 1999 and the present?
A preponderance of the evidence showed the student lived within District boundaries throughout March 1999 to the present (first in Carson, then at his great-grandmother's Los Angeles home, then at a new Carson address from April 2002), so the District's non-residency defense failed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Interim finding only: the student was a resident of the District during the relevant periods. The hearing on the underlying FAPE and compensatory education claims was continued to September 10–11, 2002.
People named in the decision
- Verle English, pupil services and attendance counselor; District witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Patricia Wilson, administrator, District due process unit; District representative and witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on July 25, 2002, in Los Angeles, California.
Petitioner-STUDENT was represented by attorney Joel Aaronson. STUDENT’s mother, his grandmother, and his great-grandmother were also present on his behalf. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District was represented by attorney Julie Mullane. Patricia Wilson, an administrator for the District’s due process unit, was also present on behalf of Respondent.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
The Hearing Office originally received a request for hearing from STUDENT on June 4, 2001. In his request, STUDENT contended that the District had failed to provide him with a FAPE between March 1999 and the present. In his request for hearing and statement of the issues, STUDENT requested compensatory education as a remedy for his claim. Thereafter, at the request of the parties the Hearing Office removed the matter from calendar on June 5, 2001. On July 3, 2002, Petitioner requested the matter be placed back on calendar. Hearing dates were set for July 25 and 26, 2002. On July 12, 2002, Petitioner filed a motion to bifurcate the hearing. In his motion, STUDENT stated that the District had taken the position that he was not a resident of the District. STUDENT requested that the Hearing Office decide the issue of residency prior to hearing the underlying substantive dispute. On July 15, 2002, the District filed an opposition to Petitioner’s motion to bifurcate. The motion was addressed at a telephonic prehearing conference held on July 17, 2002. At the prehearing conference the parties agreed to have the issue of residency heard on July 25 and to continue the hearing on the underlying matter pending resolution of the residency issue.
On July 25, 2002, the hearing convened. At that time the Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. In support of its position on the residency issue, the District called Verle English, a District pupil service and attendance counselor for the District, and Ms. Patricia Wilson, an administrator with the District’s due process unit. STUDENT’s mother, his grandmother, and his great-grandmother testified on his behalf. At the conclusion of the hearing on the residency issue, the parties agreed to continue the hearing to address STUDENT’s underlying substantive claims to September 10 and 11, 2002. The Hearing Officer informed the parties that a written order regarding residency would be issued prior to those dates.
ISSUE
1. Was STUDENT a resident of the District between March 1999 and the present?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 12-year-old boy who lives with his mother and his two younger brothers. He is eligible for special education services because of a specific learning disability. STUDENT completed the sixth grade in June 2002, and is expected to start the seventh grade in the fall of 2002. He has attended public schools in the Los Angeles Unified School District continuously since March 1999.
STUDENT initially attended the third grade during the 1998-1999 school year at the Miracle Bible School, a non-public school. At that time, school records indicate that STUDENT was living on ADDRESS 1 in Compton, California, 90220. Compton is not within the District’s attendance boundaries. In March 1999, STUDENT’s mother enrolled him at Ambler Elementary School in the Los Angeles Unified School District. At that time, STUDENT’s mother filled out the District’s enrollment forms. She indicated on the form that her address was on ADDRESS 2 in Carson, California. The address is within the District’s enrollment boundaries. The District’s enrollment records noted that STUDENT already had an IEP at the time he entered the District, but that the IEP was not complete. STUDENT then completed his third grade year at Ambler. School records also noted that an initial IEP meeting was held for STUDENT on May 24, 1999.
STUDENT completed his third grade year at Ambler, and then he attended that school for his entire fourth and fifth grade school years–the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years respectively. During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended the sixth grade at the District’s Curtis Middle School. Various other IEP meetings were held for STUDENT over the three-plus years he attended school in the Los Angeles Unified School District between March 1999 and the present.
An IEP meeting has not yet been held regarding the 2002-2003 school year, and no decision has been made regarding STUDENT’s school of attendance or his special education program for the coming school year.
POSITION OF THE PARTIES
The District, by way of asserting an affirmative defense to STUDENT’s claim that the District denied him a FAPE between March 1999 and the present, contends that STUDENT was not a resident of the District during that period of time. The District takes the position that even if the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE, it cannot be required to provide him with compensatory education services if he was not a legal resident of the District.
In that regard, the District asserts that STUDENT falsely led school staff to believe that he lived on ADDRESS 2 in Carson, which is within the District’s enrollment boundaries, between March 1999 and April 2002. The District claims that for at least an unspecified portion of the time in question, STUDENT actually lived on ADDRESS 3 in Compton, which is not located within the District’s attendance boundaries. Additionally, the District contends that STUDENT did not and does not live on ADDRESS 4 in Carson, an address that is within the STUDENT does not now, and has not since March 1999 lived within the District’s attendance boundaries. Thus, the District argues, it cannot be required to provide STUDENT with compensatory education services even if it did not provide him with a FAPE.
STUDENT responds that he has lived within the District’s attendance area since March 1999. He contends that he lived on ADDRESS 4 in Carson between March 1999 and the summer of 1999. STUDENT asserts that in the summer of 1999 he moved with his mother and brothers to his grandmother’s house at ADDRESS 5 in Los Angeles, an address also within the District’s attendance area. STUDENT claims to have remained at this address until he moved with his mother and brothers to ADDRESS 4 in Carson, where he claims to have lived since.
ANALYSIS
Verle English, a District pupil service and attendance counselor, testified on behalf of the District. Ms. English testified that in approximately December 2001 or January 2002, she was requested by a District staff person–whose name she could not recall–to investigate whether STUDENT actually resided within the District’s attendance area. Ms. English said that in early 2002 in the course of her investigation she personally went to the address listed for STUDENT on the District’s attendance records–ADDRESS 2 in Carson. She relayed that she knocked on the door at that residence and a woman in her late 20's answered the door with a baby in her arms. Ms. English recalled that the woman told her that the residence was some sort of facility like a group home or foster home. The woman told Ms. English that she had worked at the home for seven years and she did not know STUDENT or STUDENT’s mother. Ms. English did not obtain the identity of the woman she was talking to, nor did she follow up and contact any other persons connected with the ownership or operation of the home.
Ms. English further testified that over a three-week period of time in early 2002–but prior to April–she placed several telephone calls to STUDENT’s mother. Ms. English said that she and STUDENT’s mother exchanged a number of phone messages, perhaps five or six, and that they also spoke to each other on the telephone on at least one occasion. Ms. English stated that her live conversation with STUDENT’s mother occurred after she had personally visited the address on ADDRESS 2. In that call, Ms. English testified that STUDENT’s mother initially claimed to live at the ADDRESS 2 address and then admitted that she had lied–that in fact she did not live at that address. Ms. English said that STUDENT’s mother did not say that she had never lived at the ADDRESS 2 address. Ms. English went on to say that STUDENT’s mother said that she was in the process of getting “another place” in Carson. Ms. English said that she asked STUDENT’s mother to provide a utility bill or some other proof of residency. According to Ms. English, STUDENT’s mother replied that she would and she asked Ms. English to give her some time. Ms. English said that STUDENT’s mother said something about temporarily living with her mother or a relative and that she was making arrangements to move. Ms. English testified that she did not ask STUDENT’s mother where she was living or where she had been living.
Ms. English testified that in the course of her investigation she checked on two other addresses: ADDRESS 4 in Carson and ADDRESS 3 in Compton. However, Ms. English could not articulate what information led her to investigate these addresses. At ADDRESS 4, Ms. English said that the house was empty at the time of her visit and it appeared as if was in the process of being remodeled. Ms. English recalled that she met a woman in front of the house who was talking on a cell phone. The woman told Ms. English that STUDENT’s mother lived in the house with her. Ms. English said that she told the person on the telephone to have STUDENT’s mother bring in proof of residency. Ms. English added that neighbors on ADDRESS 4 did not want to get involved, but she did not elaborate on what investigative steps were taken in this regard. Ms. English also described her experience in investigating the address on ADDRESS 3 in Compton. She said she drove to the address and observed a two-story house with sheets covering the windows. Ms. English said that she did not approach the house or attempt to contact the occupants. She explained that she was concerned because she felt that STUDENT’s mother had expressed hostility in the voice messages she had left. Ms. English did say that she asked a neighbor if STUDENT lived in the house on ADDRESS 3, and the neighbor said no.
Ms. English testified that she personally believed that STUDENT and his mother in fact lived in the house on ADDRESS 3 in Compton. She based her belief on information that she received from a switchboard operator at a non-District agency. Ms. English said she could not identify either the person or agency for legal confidentiality reasons. Ms. English said she did not know the source of the agency’s information, the reliability of the source, the date the information was provided to the agency, or the agency’s policies and practices for confirming and updating information.
Ms. Patricia Wilson, an administrator with the District’s due process unit, testified that she was the District’s administrator most familiar with STUDENT’s special education file. In that regard she had attended past IEP meetings and attended a mediation in STUDENT’s case in August 2001. Ms. Wilson testified that three addresses were listed on the face page of STUDENT’s May 2001 IEP document: ADDRESS 2, a P.O. Box in Compton, and ADDRESS 3. The ADDRESS 3 address was listed as a “mailing address.” She stated that at the mediation STUDENT’s mother provided only the ADDRESS 2 address, which was also the only address listed in STUDENT’s cumulative file. Ms. Wilson said that she wondered why STUDENT’s address and mailing address on the May 2001 IEP were different. She also stated that the issue of residency was not raised at the mediation. Moreover, over the course of the months that followed, Ms. Wilson testified that she did not raise the issue of residency when she discussed STUDENT’s assessments or assessment plans with his representative.
STUDENT’s mother testified on behalf of her son STUDENT. She said that she moved from ADDRESS 1 in Compton to ADDRESS 2 in Compton in March 1999 to escape an unsafe situation. STUDENT’s mother stated that ADDRESS 2 provided her with a temporary place to live when she left ADDRESS 1 and that she had only brought clothes with her when she moved in. She explained that her friend, who lived at the house and operated a foster home and day care center there, gave her a place to stay when she needed to move from ADDRESS 1. STUDENT’s mother said that when she moved into ADDRESS 2 she enrolled STUDENT at Ambler Elementary School, the District’s neighborhood school for that address. She emphasized that the house at ADDRESS 2 was a temporary measure when she left ADDRESS 1, and she moved again in the summer of 1999–this time to STUDENT’s great grandmother’s house on ADDRESS 5, in the City of Los Angeles.
STUDENT’s mother described how when she was young she had lived with her grandmother, who is STUDENT’s great-grandmother, and that she herself had grown up in the house on ADDRESS 5. STUDENT’s mother said that she had attended school within the District when she lived on ADDRESS 5. STUDENT’s mother stated that her grandmother’s house was large and when she moved there in the summer of 1999 with her three boys, each of them had their own bedroom. STUDENT’s mother said that she did not update the District as to her new address. She explained that she used the ADDRESS 2 address on the 2001 IEPs because she did not want to move the boys from Ambler. STUDENT’s mother expounded that STUDENT and his younger brother had established themselves at Ambler and they had cultivated friendships there. She added that she did not want to move STUDENT and his brother from Ambler to a different neighborhood school near ADDRESS 5. STUDENT’s mother testified that she lived with her grandmother on ADDRESS 5 until April 2002.
STUDENT’s mother provided a somewhat different account of her telephone message exchanges and conversation with Ms. English. STUDENT’s mother recalled that she received several telephone messages from Ms. English, and although she promptly returned the calls and left Ms. English messages the same day, Ms. English did not call her back for several days at a time. STUDENT’s mother stated that she had even called Ms. English’s supervisor when she didn’t get a return call from her. STUDENT’s mother adamantly denied admitting to Ms. English in their live telephone conversation that she “lied,” but she said that she did tell Ms. English that she in fact did not live at the ADDRESS 2 address anymore.
STUDENT’s mother admitted that she had written the ADDRESS 2 address, the P.O. box number, and the ADDRESS 3 mailing address on the May 2001 IEP document, and that she provided the ADDRESS 2 address at the August 2001 mediation. STUDENT’s mother said that except for determining which neighborhood school her boys would attend, she did not think it mattered whether she used the ADDRESS 2 or the ADDRESS 5 address since both were within the District’s boundaries. STUDENT’s mother stated that she has never lived at the ADDRESS 3 address, but she said that a friend, who she said is also an ex-boyfriend, does live there. She admitted to having visited him there, but denied that she or STUDENT ever lived with the man at that address. STUDENT’s mother said that sometimes she had problems getting mail forwarded from ADDRESS 2 and she occasionally used her friend’s house on ADDRESS 3 as a mailing address. She also said that she borrowed his fax machine at times. STUDENT’s mother testified that at one point her ex-boyfriend could not obtain gas services on ADDRESS 3in his own name so she “helped him out” by letting him put his gas service under her name for a period of time.
STUDENT’s mother said that she moved from her grandmother house on ADDRESS 5 to ADDRESS 4 in April 2002. STUDENT’s mother stated that she established the utilities at ADDRESS 4 under her name, and that she requested a copy of the utility bill to provide the District. She explained that the first bill was for one day–April 4 to April 5–because she obtained service one day before the billing cut-off date. When the District requested another utility bill in June 2002, she provided the utility bill for ADDRESS 4 for the period of time between May 6 and June 6, 2002.
STUDENT’s great-grandmother, STUDENT’s great grandmother, testified that she had lived on ADDRESS 5 in Los Angles for many years and that MOTHER had grown up in her house. She explained that she had run a foster care home at her house for a number of years in the past, but that she discontinued her business in 1997. STUDENT’S great-grandmother testified that STUDENT’s mother moved into her house with her three boys in the summer of 1999. She said that there was plenty of room in her house for each of them to have their own room. STUDENT’s great-grandmother stated STUDENT’s mother and the boys remained in her house until they moved to ADDRESS 4 in April 2002. STUDENT’s great-grandmother said that STUDENT’s mother and the boys moved after STUDENT’s birthday, which she recalled they celebrated on a Saturday during the week of April 13.
STUDENT’S grandmother testified that in 1999 STUDENT’s mother moved to Carson from ADDRESS 1 due to “challenges.” She recalled that STUDENT’s mother moved with the boys to STUDENT’s great-grandmother’s house that summer–the summer of 1999. STUDENT’S grandmother said that STUDENT’s mother moved to the house on ADDRESS 4 in Carson a few months ago. She said that she has visited her there and that the house is a single facility residential home near Avalon.
Although STUDENT has attended school in the District continuously since March 1999, the District contests the fact that he was ever a resident of the District for any of that time. Thus, the Hearing Officer will determine whether the evidence supports the District’s contention.
The first period of time at issue is from March 1999 to the summer of 1999. The District contends that STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT never lived on ADDRESS 2. The only evidence presented by the District to show that STUDENT did not live on ADDRESS 2 between March 1999 and the end of the 1998-1999 school year is the testimony of Ms. English regarding her conversation with an unidentified woman at that location. Although the woman Ms. English talked with said that she had worked at the home on ADDRESS 2 for seven years and did not know STUDENT’s mother or STUDENT, the woman providing the information was never identified. But according to the unidentified woman, the house on ADDRESS 2 was a group or foster home. No one asked the woman how many people had come and gone from the home between March 1999 and the spring of 2002, or whether it was possible that the FAMILY had stayed there for a few months three years earlier and that she just did not recall their names.
In contrast, the District’s own enrollment documents indicate that STUDENT’s mother provided adequate proof of residency. The March 1999 enrollment document includes a section for “address verification” in a portion of the form designated for “office use only.” In this section, there were three boxes were labeled “address verification form,” “utility bill,” and “immunization.” Each of these boxes on the form was checked. The area of the form designated for “office uses only” was also signed by a District employee. Moreover, the handwriting in this portion of the form is clearly in different handwriting from that portion of the form filled in and signed by STUDENT’s mother. Thus, from the enrollment document submitted by the District, the Hearing Officer can only infer that STUDENT’s mother had provided the District with satisfactory evidence of her residency at ADDRESS 2 in March 1999. In addition to the information on the District’s own enrollment form, Ms. Aiken testified that STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT had moved to Carson from Compton before moving in with STUDENT’s great-grandmother in the summer of 1999.
Clearly STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT had to be living somewhere during this period of time. The District’s enrollment form and STUDENT’s grandmother’s testimony identify ADDRESS 2 as that location. The District, however, did not present any evidence that during this time STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT were living some other location outside of the District. Thus, the preponderance of the evidence indicates that STUDENT resided on ADDRESS 2 when his mother enrolled him at Ambler Elementary School in March 1999.
The next period of time in question is from the summer of 1999 to April 2002. The District contends that STUDENT did not live in the District during this period of time. The District contends that STUDENT in fact lived on ADDRESS 3 in Compton. The District argues that STUDENT lived on ADDRESS 3 because (1) he did not live on ADDRESS 2 as his mother claimed; (2) his mother misled the District about living at ADDRESS 2 after the summer of 1999; (3) in May of 2001 STUDENT’s mother identified the ADDRESS 3 address as a mailing address; (4) STUDENT’s mother placed the gas bill at the ADDRESS 3 address for an unspecified period of time: (5) and an unidentified switchboard operator at an undisclosed non-District agency told Ms. English that STUDENT’s mother lived at the ADDRESS 3 address.
Although STUDENT’s mother concedes the first four points raised by the District, she provided explanations for each of them. She testified that she did not want the District to know that she had moved to ADDRESS 5 because she did not want to transfer her children from Ambler to another District school. Although it was inappropriate for STUDENT’s mother to mislead the District as to when she left ADDRESS 2, it is just as reasonable to infer that she deceived the District to cover the fact that she had moved to ADDRESS 5 as to ADDRESS 3. Under either scenario, STUDENT’s mother did not reveal her real address to the District because she wanted STUDENT to attend Ambler and Curtis. STUDENT’s mother also explained that she had a relationship with the person at the ADDRESS 3 address, which is why she put the gas bill under her name for some period of time and used it, at least on one occasion, as a mailing address.
Both STUDENT’s grandmother and STUDENT’s great-grandmother credibly testified that STUDENT’s mother and her sons, including STUDENT, lived with STUDENT’s great-grandmother on ADDRESS 5 in Los Angeles. And both of these witnesses had personal knowledge as to where STUDENT’s mother and STUDENT were living. In contrast, Ms. English testified that she did not have any personal knowledge that STUDENT or STUDENT’s mother resided on ADDRESS 3 in Compton. Furthermore, the hearsay statement made by an unidentified switchboard operator at an undisclosed non-District agency was accompanied by so little information relating to its validity that it has no evidentiary value whatsoever. Therefore, the preponderance of the evidence indicates that STUDENT and his mother lived with STUDENT’s great-grandmother on ADDRESS 5 during this period of time.
The final period of time in question is from April 2002 to the present. The District questions whether STUDENT ever moved to the house on ADDRESS 4 in April 2002 for two reasons: First, when Ms. English visited the residence in early 2002, the house was being remodeled. Second, STUDENT’s great-grandmother testified that STUDENT celebrated his birthday on a Saturday during the week of his birthday, which was April 13, while he still lived at her house, and yet the gas bill for the ADDRESS 4 address indicates service began on April 4.
As to the first point. Ms. English testified that she spoke with STUDENT’s mother after she had visited the ADDRESS 4 house and STUDENT’s mother told her that she was making arrangements to move back to Carson, not that she already lived there. Ms. English did not assert that she visited the ADDRESS 4 address after STUDENT’s mother claimed to move there. Regarding the second point, neither party established which Saturday in April STUDENT celebrated his birthday–i.e., the Saturday that precede or followed his birthday. More importantly, STUDENT’s mother did not claim to move in and occupy the house the same day the gas service began. Indeed, Ms. English testified that when she visited the house on ADDRESS 4 it was being remodeled. Regardless of whether or not the ADDRESS 4 house was ready for occupancy on April 4, the date the gas service began does necessarily determine when the STUDENT’s family actually moved into the residence. People frequently adjust move-in dates based upon their work schedule, the availability of people to help with the move, or whether the house is ready for occupancy. Some people, particularly if they are not required to immediately vacate their current residence, will move property over the course of several days. The fact that a gas bill in STUDENT’s mother’s name is dated April 4 while she does not claim to move into the house until several days later, does not prove she never moved there. In fact, when the District asked for an additional utility bill to prove she lived at the ADDRESS 4 house, STUDENT’s mother produced a June 2002 gas bill under her name.
In contrast, the District has not provided any evidence that STUDENT does not live on ADDRESS 4 or that he lives at a residence other than ADDRESS 4. Therefore, the preponderance of the evidence indicates that STUDENT and his mother moved to the ADDRESS 4 address in April 2002 and have lived there at least through June.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that a preponderance of the evidence presented at hearing establishes that STUDENT was a resident of the District during the relevant periods of time in this case.
Date: August 23, 2002 Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. STUDENT did not reside within the District. Although Ms. English believed that STUDENT was living at ADDRESS 3during this period of time, she did not attempt to confirm this fact. Ms. English drove to the ADDRESS 3residence, but she did not talk to anyone at the residence. (Although Ms. English was in the best position to determine whether it was safe for her to attempt to personally contact the resident of the ADDRESS 3address, it is reasonable to assume that she could have received support from the District’s police department or the local Compton police.) Ms. English was in an excellent position to garner information as to who lived at the ADDRESS 3 address and what, if any, was their relationship to STUDENT and STUDENT’s mother. In contrast, the only information Ms. English learned during her visit to ADDRESS 3was from a neighbor who said she did not know STUDENT. Interestingly enough, Ms. English did not ask the neighbor if she knew who did live in the house, or whether she had seen any children living or visiting the residence. Such information–particularly if the residents at ADDRESS 3had been uncooperative–could have been very valuable in determining whether STUDENT lived at that address. The District, however, was not able to provide any information as to whether STUDENT actually lived at that address. Additionally, when STUDENT’s mother admitted to Ms. English that she did not live at ADDRESS 2 any longer, Ms. English did not specifically ask STUDENT’s mother where she was or had been living or ask for an immediate home visit. Ms. English would at least have been in a position to ask neighbors whether they had seen STUDENT or his brothers at the house. Conversely if STUDENT’s mother had been unwillingly to reveal her address when confronted by Ms. English on the telephone in early 2002, a much stronger inference would have arisen that
