California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 4, 1997
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1200-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
Los Angeles Unified's Frances Blend placement upheld; reimbursement and compensatory education denied, and reassessment including assistive technology ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision.
Summary
The parents of a nine-year-old boy filed for a hearing against Los Angeles Unified School District. He was eligible for special education due to multiple handicaps, including blindness and mental retardation (now called intellectual disability). In September 1995 the parents removed him from Frances Blend School, a District school for blind and visually impaired students, and taught him at home with hired tutors. They wanted a full inclusion placement, reimbursement, compensatory education, and independent assessors.
Hearing Officer Mark Paxson found the 1994-95 placement and the September 1995 offer appropriate. Both IEPs had technical defects: the 1994 IEP did not list needed materials and equipment, and the 1995 IEP did not state time in regular education. Neither defect caused educational loss. Applying the Holland test, the Hearing Officer found the student would have gained little academic or social benefit from full inclusion in 1995-96. For 1996-97, the District proposed full inclusion but could not prove it appropriate without current information about the student. The parents prevailed on that issue. Reimbursement and compensatory education were denied because the parents refused to attend IEP meetings or consent to assessment, and offered no evidence the home program helped him. The District may choose its own assessors. It was ordered to develop an assessment plan within 15 days that includes assistive technology and is given in the student's primary language, followed by an IEP meeting for 1997-98.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO put the burden of proof on whichever party sought to change the status quo. It also shows how SEHO applied the Holland factors to a full inclusion request. Finally, it shows how parents' refusal to attend IEP meetings or consent to assessment, plus no evidence that the home program helped, weighed against reimbursement and compensatory education.
Issues and holdings
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP content
Issue 1a. Was Student's IEP developed on June 20, 1994, appropriate?
The IEP did not list the specialized materials and equipment Education Code § 56345(a)(7) requires for a low-incidence disability. The Hearing Officer found no evidence this caused any educational loss.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1b. Was Student's placement for the 1994-95 school year appropriate?
The Frances Blend placement met the student's unique needs, substantially conformed to the IEP, and provided educational benefit under Rowley. Claims about the teacher's credential, group speech therapy, part-day placement in a lower-functioning class, and bus ride length were not proven.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP content
Issue 2a. Was Student's IEP developed on September 22 and 28, 1995, appropriate?
The IEP's failure to state how much time the student would spend in regular education was a technical violation that caused no educational loss. The teacher who attended was appropriate, and the goals, evaluation criteria, and mental retardation eligibility were not shown to be inappropriate.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2b. Was the placement proposed by the District for Student for the 1995-96 school year appropriate?
Applying Holland, the Hearing Officer found the student would get little academic or nonacademic benefit from full inclusion, so Frances Blend was appropriate. The alleged procedural violations (psychologist's attendance, draft goals, a late-arriving therapist's signature) caused no loss of educational opportunity or parent participation.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Was the placement proposed by the District for Student for the 1996-97 school year appropriate?
The District proposed changing to a full inclusion placement, so it bore the burden of proof. Without current information about the student, it could not show that placement was appropriate. The Hearing Officer added that this was largely not the District's fault and does not mean the placement was inappropriate.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 4. Does Los Angeles Unified School District have the right to conduct a triennial reassessment of Student?
Under Education Code § 56322, the District may choose its own qualified assessors. Assessments must comply with 5 CCR § 3023 on the student's primary language (Farsi). The District must develop an assessment plan within 15 days.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. Is the least restrictive placement for Student a full inclusion placement?
Both parties now proposed full inclusion, so there was no dispute and the issue was not reached.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. Does Student require assistive technology materials described in Petitioner's evidence packet?
Without current information about the student, the parents did not prove the specific materials were needed. An assistive technology assessment must be part of the reassessment.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for educational aides hired by his parents from October 1995 through August 1996 and October 1996 through December 1996; Mother's time spent home schooling Student; and special materials provided by Student's parents?
Reimbursement was denied. The 1995-96 placement was appropriate, the parents refused to cooperate with IEP meetings and assessment, and there was no evidence the home services provided educational benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 8. Is Student entitled to compensatory education?
Compensatory education was denied. The only failure proven was in 1996-97, and the student could have been placed in full inclusion by November 1996 if the parents had cooperated.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to assess. Within 15 days of the decision, the District must develop an assessment plan that complies with all relevant federal and state special education requirements and includes an assistive technology assessment. Under 5 CCR § 3023, the assessment must be given in the student's primary language (Farsi) by competent personnel or with an interpreter.
- Parents must make the student reasonably available for the District to conduct the assessment.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. After the assessment is complete, and within the timelines for assessments and IEP meetings, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Holland; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Burger v. Murray County School Dist.; Vander Malle v. Ambach; Dubois v. Connecticut State Board of Education; Rettig v. Kent City School Dist.; Education Code § 56345; Education Code § 56322; 5 CCR § 3023
People named in the decision
- Shirley Brown, District representative at hearing; coordinator of student services for special education, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Gloria Lopez, Administrative coordinator / administrator, special education division; witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Vicki McKendall, Observer at hearing
- Dr. June Downing, Expert witness for Student; assistant professor of special education, California State University, Northridge
- Dr. Joy Efron, Principal; witness, Frances Blend School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Sharon Jarrett, Witness called by Petitioner (role not stated)
- Hisashi Matsutani, Assistant principal; witness, Frances Blend School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Cynthia Thompson, Principal, home and hospital instruction; witness, Carlson Home and Hospital School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Gail Anderson, Witness called by Petitioner (role not stated)
- Tina Saunders, Witness (role not stated)
- Steven Mark, Administrative coordinator; witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Janice Milgrim, Witness called by Petitioner (role not stated)
- Linda Michel, Witness (role not stated)
- Pat Grayson-de Jong, Witness called by Petitioner (role not stated)
- Roberta Eban, Witness (role not stated)
- Keith Lord, Principal; witness, Melvin Avenue Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Jo Ann Grofsky, Fourth grade general education teacher; District witness, Topeka Drive Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Karen Berry, District witness (role not stated)
- Jane Lim, District witness (role not stated)
- Carolyn Claverie-Gunther, District witness (role not stated)
- Carla Galias, Speech-language therapist (1994-95); District witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Debra Russell, Early childhood home-visit teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Leili Sadeghi, Psychological assessor (1993), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Valerie Wallace, Psychological assessor (1993), Los Angeles Unified School District
- Peggy Tutor, Special day class teacher, credentialed for visually impaired students (fall 1994), Frances Blend School
- Beth Milstein-Wahba, Special day class teacher with orientation and mobility credential (spring 1995), Frances Blend School
- Virginia Kennedy, Complaint investigator, California Department of Education
- Blind Children's Center, Nonpublic school attended from ages two to five
- Child Development Center, CSU Northridge, Kindergarten placement, 1993-94
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Reseda, California, on January 21 and 22, March 7 and 8, and May 28, 29, and 30, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his parents FATHER and MOTHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented by Shirley Brown, coordinator of student services for special education. Also present on the District’s behalf was Gloria Lopez, administrator for the special education division. Also present as an observer on the last day of hearing was Vicki McKendall.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Dr. June Downing, Dr. Joy Efron, Dr. Sharon Jarrett, Hisashi Matsutani, Cynthia Thompson, Gail Anderson, Gloria Lopez, Tina Saunders, Steven Mark, Dr. Janice Milgrim, Linda Michel, Pat Grayson-de Jong, Roberta Eban, Keith Lord, and MOTHER.
Respondent called the following witnesses: Jo Ann Grofsky, Gloria Lopez, Karen Berry, Jane Lim, Carolyn Claverie-Gunther, and Carla Galias.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing arguments. Closing arguments were received on July 2, 1997. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) (a) Was STUDENT’s IEP developed on June 20, 1994, appropriate? (b) Was STUDENT’s placement for the 1994-95 school year appropriate?
(2) (a) Was STUDENT’s IEP developed on September 22 and 28, 1995, appropriate? (b) Was the placement proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year appropriate?
(3) Was the placement proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year appropriate?
(4) Does Los Angeles Unified School have the right to conduct a triennial reassessment of STUDENT?
(5) Is the least restrictive placement for STUDENT a full inclusion placement?
(6) Does STUDENT require assistive technology materials described in Petitioner’s evidence packet?
(7) Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for educational aides hired by his parents from October 1995 through August 1996 and October 1996 through December 1996; MOTHER’s time spent home schooling STUDENT; and special materials provided by STUDENT’s parents?
(8) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Prior to the hearing, Petitioner had identified, in addition to the issues stated above, an issue relating to reimbursement for a nonpublic school placement made by his parents. However, at the outset of the hearing, MOTHER indicated that she would not disclose the name of the school for which she was requesting reimbursement. The Hearing Officer advised her that without specific information regarding the school, it would be impossible to award reimbursement for costs associated with the school. In response, MOTHER decided to withdraw her request for reimbursement for the nonpublic school placement. The Hearing Officer also notes that MOTHER, the only witness with knowledge of STUDENT’s education since September 1995, refused to provide any significant evidence regarding that education, STUDENT’s present functional levels, or the kind of progress he has made since September 1995.
At the beginning of the hearing, it became apparent that much of Petitioner’s case would be based on contentions that the District has engaged in unethical, discriminatory, and biased conduct toward STUDENT which has resulted in a denial of a free appropriate public education for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer advised Petitioner that, while issues relating to procedural violations may impact a final determination regarding the appropriateness of the District’s placement, a special education due process hearing is not an appropriate forum for determining whether the District has discriminated against STUDENT or acted in any unethical manner, outside of those procedures contained in special education law. Claims of discrimination or bias may be raised under other statutes not under the jurisdiction of the Special Education Hearing Office. However, the IDEA does not address issues of discrimination or bias.
Contrary to the Hearing Officer’s suggestion, Petitioner presented a case which was based primarily on his contentions of unethical conduct, discrimination, and bias. Much of Petitioner’s contentions rest on the idea that the District discriminated against STUDENT because they did not provide him with a full inclusion setting when requested to do so by his parents. Most of the witnesses called by Petitioner were District administrators who had little, if anything, to do with the actual education of STUDENT while he was in District programs. Instead, the District administrators were involved in conversations and meetings with STUDENT’s parents in which Mr. or MOTHER were continuing to request a full inclusion placement for STUDENT. While the testimony regarding these conversations and meetings establish that the District continued to propose placement for STUDENT in Frances Blend School, a segregated site for visually impaired students, the evidence presented by Petitioner did not establish that the District engaged in any discriminatory, unethical, or biased conduct. Because issues of discrimination, bias, and unethical conduct are not covered by the IDEA, the testimony relating to Petitioner’s contentions of discrimination, bias, and unethical conduct will not be summarized in this decision.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT will be ten years old in September 1997. STUDENT was born in Iran and came to the United States shortly after his birth. He has been in this country ever since. Throughout his life, STUDENT has been exposed to both English and Farsi. STUDENT is eligible for special education due to multiple handicaps, including blindness and mental retardation. STUDENT has not been enrolled in any District educational programs since September 1995, when his parents withdrew him from the Frances Blend School because of concerns over his placement. Frances Blend is a segregated school operated by the District specifically for blind and visually impaired students. Since that time, STUDENT has received home schooling and was also placed for a time by his parents in a private school.
Prior to STUDENT’s third birthday, he was placed in a District program for early childhood development. The program consisted of weekly visits from a teacher, Debra Russell, who worked with STUDENT and his mother. In addition, STUDENT enrolled in the Blind Children’s Center (BCC), a nonpublic school. STUDENT started attending BCC when he was two years old and continued there until he was five. In 1991, STUDENT attended Frances Blend School for approximately one month while his teacher at BCC was on maternity leave.
When STUDENT turned five years old, he was no longer eligible for the BCC program; therefore, his parents started looking for a public school program. An IEP meeting was held in May 1992 at which placement at Frances Blend or Lokrantz Elementary School was proposed. The IEP team also agreed to conduct an assessment, and STUDENT’s parents agreed to an interim placement at Lokrantz pending completion of the assessment.
In March and April 1993, Leili Sadeghi and Valerie Wallace completed a psychological assessment of STUDENT for the District.(Footnote 1) The assessors summarized their findings as follows:
He is compliant and generally waits for others to interact with him as compared to his exploring and interacting with his environment. Currently he is exhibiting fluctuating skills levels that range from solid performance in the 2-3 year range with splinters in the 4 year range. Previous test results are indicating that although STUDENT exhibited skill levels closer to his chronological age at a younger age, the gap between his chronological age and his level of ability are continuing to widen. His strongest level of functioning is in the area of gross motor skills, with his ability to use language as his weakest area. He does exhibit some self stimulatory behaviors which indicate that he is uncomfortable with the input of sensory stimuli found in his natural environment.
For the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT attended kindergarten at the Child Development Center at CSU, Northridge, pursuant to an IEP developed on August 7, 1993. The IEP notes that the team approved the placement at the Child Development Center because STUDENT’s parents rejected a full inclusion placement in a public school. Following the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT enrolled at Frances Blend pursuant to an IEP developed in June 1994. Pursuant to the IEP, STUDENT was to receive orientation and mobility services once per week for 30 minutes and speech and language services once per week for 30 minutes. The IEP team adopted goals and objectives in orientation and mobility, speech and language, and adapted physical education.
Frances Blend serves visually impaired students in the preschool through sixth grades and is located next door to a regular education elementary school. STUDENT was placed in a class for high-functioning, multiple-handicapped students. The class consisted of approximately six students, a teacher, Peggy Tutor, and an aide. Ms. Tutor was credentialed to work with visually impaired students. However, Ms. Tutor left the class midway through the year and was replaced by Beth Milstein-Wahba, who possessed an orientation and mobility credential and a waiver to teach visually impaired students. STUDENT also received speech and language services, orientation and mobility services, and adapted physical education.
At some point during the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT was placed in a class with lower functioning students for 30 minutes per day. When STUDENT’s mother found out, she requested that he be placed in a class with older, more verbal students. On April 18, 1995, the District complied with her request. During the school year, STUDENT’s parents also expressed concerns to District personnel regarding the pre-braille skills work being done and the availability of tactile materials in STUDENT’s class. In response, Joy Efron, principal of Frances Blend, met with STUDENT’s teacher to ensure that his IEP was being followed.
STUDENT’s report card issued at the end of the 1994-95 school year shows that he was receiving “satisfactory” or “good” marks in all areas of achievement, and “satisfactory” or “excellent” marks in all areas of effort. In his “work habits and cooperation,” STUDENT received “satisfactory” marks in all areas except for “works independently” and “completes tasks,” in which he received “unsatisfactory” marks. The teacher’s comment, prepared by Ms. Milstein-Wahba, for the end of the year stated that “STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language has improved; and he is more cooperative and following directions. He is working on completion of tasks. His gross motor skills are great!”
In July 1995, MOTHER contacted the West Valley Unit of the District to indicate that she was concerned that Frances Blend was not following STUDENT’s IEP, that the transportation to Frances Blend was too long, and that she wanted STUDENT placed at a school closer to home. Between July and September 1995, MOTHER discussed the transportation with several District administrators. The result of these conversations was that at the end of September 1995, Ms. Efron was able to change STUDENT’s bus route
On September 22, 1995, STUDENT’s IEP team convened to discuss his placement. STUDENT’s parents requested a full inclusion placement at Topeka Drive Elementary School. Their request was based on the transportation issue (Topeka is approximately one mile from STUDENT’s home) and STUDENT’s parents’ desire to see him educated in a less restrictive environment. The IEP team was unable to reach an agreement regarding placement and the team reconvened on September 28, 1995.(Footnote 2) The IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a result of multiple handicaps, including blindness and mental retardation.(Footnote 3) STUDENT’s parents attended the meeting on September 28, 1995. However, because of dissatisfaction over the discussion, they left the meeting before the IEP team discussed placement options. The placement options discussed after STUDENT’s parents left included a multihandicapped class at a school for visually impaired students or at another special school with itinerant services provided by the VH program; full inclusion at a regular education school with a VH resource room; a preschool VH special day class at a regular education school; full inclusion at STUDENT’s home school; a class for trainably mentally retarded students with VH itinerant services; a nonpublic school; or the California School for the Blind. The IEP team recommended continued placement at Frances Blend “due to concerns about delays in development and blindness.” The team also recommended an inclusion assessment and a comprehensive assessment to be completed at the California School for the Blind. Neither assessment was ever done because STUDENT’s parents did not consent. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in the areas of academic/concept development, language, pre-braille reading, listening, math, social skills, and pre-vocational skills.
STUDENT’s parents withdrew him from school at the end of September 1995, and he has not returned to the District since September 28, 1995. STUDENT never went to school on the new bus route developed by Ms. Efron. Beginning in October 1995, STUDENT’s parents have hired tutors to work with STUDENT and also sent him to a nonpublic school for a half day for social interaction.(Footnote 4) STUDENT’s mother has also provided STUDENT with a significant amount of instruction since October 1995. The home tutoring STUDENT receives is based on a curriculum and goals developed by his mother.
On May 7, 1996, CynthiaThompson, principal of Carlson Home and Hospital School, sent a memo to Steve Mark, administrative coordinator for the District. According to this memo, Carlson had received a request for home teaching for STUDENT on November 16, 1995. Carlson staff then contacted at least six teachers, all of whom turned down the home teaching assignment. On December 1, 1995, a teacher accepted the assignment. However, STUDENT’s mother rejected the teacher because she did not have a VH credential. The memo further states that “[a]dministrators from Blend School assisted in trying to find us a suitable teacher for this MH/VH child, but with no success. Principals from all the Valley special education centers were asked to inquire at their schools if anyone would be interested. There were no responses.” On June 6, 1996, Ms. Efron sent a memo to Ms. Thompson indicating that she had a VH credentialed teacher willing to provide home instruction to STUDENT.
On June 26, 1996, Virginia Kennedy, complaint investigator for the California Department of Education, completed a compliance investigation regarding STUDENT and the District. Ms. Kennedy found that the District was in compliance with regard to the credentials of STUDENT’s teachers during the 1994-95 school year; the District was in compliance with regard to including present levels of functioning on STUDENT’s IEP dated September 22, 1995; and the District was in compliance with respect to ensuring that the appropriate teacher attended the IEP meeting held on September 28, 1995. The District was out of compliance with regard to the attendance of a school psychologist at the IEP meeting held on September 28, 1995 (the notice of the IEP meeting did not indicate that the school psychologist would be attending); the District was out of compliance with regard to providing records to Petitioner within five days of his request; and the District was out of compliance when it moved STUDENT to another classroom for a portion of the day during the 1994-95 school year without convening an IEP meeting or notifying STUDENT’s parents.
On November 6, 1996, Gloria Lopez, administrative coordinator for the District, sent a letter to Petitioner memorializing several conversations she had with STUDENT’s mother. According to the letter, on November 3, 1996, Ms. Lopez offered immediate placement at Frances Blend or placement, following an IEP meeting, at Topeka Drive Elementary School with a one-to-one aide. STUDENT’s mother rejected Ms. Lopez’ request to schedule an IEP meeting; therefore, STUDENT was not placed at Topeka Drive. On November 8, 1996, Petitioner submitted a request for a due process hearing to address issues relating to placement.
After the first two days of hearing, the District and STUDENT’s parents began working on developing an interim placement for STUDENT pending the completion of these proceedings. An IEP meeting was held on February 25, 1997, which was not attended by STUDENT’s parents. The IEP team developed an IEP calling for an interim placement in a full inclusion setting so that an assessment of STUDENT’s educational needs could be completed. The IEP team continued to find STUDENT eligible for special education due to blindness and mental retardation. Because STUDENT had not been in any District program since September 1995, and the IEP team did not have any updated information regarding STUDENT’s functioning, the IEP team copied the present levels of functioning and goals and objectives from the IEPs developed in September 1995.
MOTHER did visit Melvin Avenue School several times and she met with the principal, Keith Lord, to discuss enrolling STUDENT at Melvin. District staff gave approval for STUDENT to enroll at Melvin. As a result, MOTHER and STUDENT visited the regular education class in which he would enroll. Mr. Lord and MOTHER also interviewed and selected an individual to work as an aide for STUDENT in the class. The aide, however, had to go through the District’s testing and hiring process before starting her assignment with STUDENT. By the conclusion of the hearing, the aide had not yet been formally hired. Therefore, STUDENT had not started his interim placement at Melvin.
During the February 1997 IEP, the IEP team also developed an assessment plan. STUDENT’s parents have not signed the assessment plan and will not do so until they know who will actually do the assessment.
Petitioner requested this hearing to address the issues of placement for the 1994-95, 1995-96, and 1996-97 school year. Petitioner also identified issues relating to IEPs, assessment, reimbursement, and compensatory education. Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s placement for 1994-95 was not appropriate because his IEP was not followed, appropriate materials were not provided, his speech and language services were not appropriate, and he was taught by a teacher who was not credentialed to work with visually impaired students. Regarding the 1995-96 school year, Petitioner contends that the IEPs developed in September 1995 were not appropriate and that STUDENT required a full inclusion placement instead of the placement at Frances Blend offered by the District. Petitioner also contends that STUDENT continued to require a full inclusion placement for the 1996-97 school year. Finally, Petitioner contends that, while STUDENT needs to be reassessed, the District should not be allowed to conduct the assessment, and requests that independent assessors be used for the reassessment. Petitioner requests reimbursement for costs associated with home tutors and MOTHER’s time spent teaching STUDENT at home since October 1995, and compensatory education.
The District contends that the placements provided for STUDENT have been designed to meet his needs, have or would have provided him with educational benefit, and, therefore, were appropriate. The District further contends that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement and that the District has the right to conduct the reassessment of STUDENT.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
This case is unusual in that much of the evidence which was presented by Petitioner related to issues of discrimination and bias which are not issues addressed by the IDEA. There was very little evidence presented by either party regarding STUDENT’s placement during the 1994-95 and 1995-96 school years. There was also very little evidence presented regarding the educational services provided for STUDENT by his parents. Because of the lack of evidence, the question of which party bears the burden of proof on the issues identified for hearing is significant.
There is no provision in special education law which specifically address the question of burden of proof. Furthermore, courts have adopted different standards for determining which party in a due process hearing bears the burden of proof.(Footnote 5) The Hearing Office has previously adopted the standard identified by some courts which requires that the party seeking to change the status quo bears the burden of proof at a special education due process hearing. Burger v. Murray County School District, 612 F.Supp. 434 (N.D. Ga. 1984). The issue before the court in Murray was whether the student
[M]ust establish that the [District’s] proposed IEP and change of placement are inappropriate or whether the School District has the burden of proving their propriety. (Ibid.)
The court concluded that “the party advocating the move should bear the burden of proving its propriety.” Therefore, because Petitioner proposed the change in placement for the 1994-95 and 1995-96 school years, Petitioner bears the burden of proof regarding issues relating to those school years. Regarding the 1996-97 school year, the District changed its proposed placement and, therefore, bears the burden of proof to establish the appropriateness of its proposed change.
(1) (a) Was STUDENT IEP developed on June 20, 1994, appropriate?
Petitioner contends that the IEP developed on June 20, 1994, was not appropriate because it did not include the materials STUDENT needed to benefit from his education. District personnel testified that they do not list every material or piece of equipment that a child may need on his or her IEP. Instead, decisions regarding materials and equipment are left to the teacher to determine. This practice of the District is not in compliance with Education Code § 56345(a)(7), which requires that for a student with a low-incidence disability, such as blindness, his or her IEP must include the specialized services, materials, and equipment the child needs. STUDENT’s IEP dated June 20, 1994, includes no description of the materials or equipment that STUDENT needed for his education.
Petitioner presented evidence regarding assistive technology that STUDENT may need, and which Petitioner contends should have been included in his IEP and provided to him in school. See Petitioner’s Evidence, pp. C-309 to C-352. Ms. Efron, the principal of Frances Blend School testified that many of the materials listed in Petitioner’s evidence were beyond STUDENT’s ability during the 1994-95 school year and that many of the materials were available in all of the classrooms, including STUDENT’s, at Frances Blend. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not established that the District’s failure to develop STUDENT’s IEP in compliance with § 56345(a)(7) resulted in any loss of education to STUDENT or deprived him of an education designed to meet his unique needs. There was no evidence presented that STUDENT was not provided with necessary materials, nor was there evidence presented regarding which specific materials STUDENT needed which should have been included on his IEP.
(b) Was STUDENT placement for the 1994-95 school year appropriate?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s IEP. “Special education” is defined as “specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child.” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).(Footnote 6)
In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. Instead, the Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the [IDEA] consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit” to the student. Rowley, supra, at p. 200.
To determine whether the District has provided a free appropriate public education, the following questions must be answered:
(1) Did the District’s placement meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
(2) Did the District’s placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
(3) Did the District’s placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
(1) Did the District’s placement meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
Joy Efron, the principal of Frances Blend School, testified that, due to STUDENT’s significant developmental delays and blindness, STUDENT required very intensive services requiring constant intervention. According to Ms. Efron, STUDENT’s lack of progress is more attributable to his cognitive and processing deficits, including a short attention and a lack of ability to relate or interact with others, than to his blindness. Ms. Efron stated that she never actually heard STUDENT speak. Ms. Efron testified that STUDENT needed a small educational setting with specific hands-on instruction with a teacher who is trained to work with STUDENT’s type of disabilities. Hisashi Matsutani, the assistant principal at Frances Blend, testified that STUDENT needs direct instruction and very specific help because he will not learn incidentally. Mr. Matsutani also testified that before STUDENT could be included in a regular education classroom, he would need to be able to read at grade level, and improve his socialization skills and mobility skills. District witnesses testified that STUDENT has significant needs requiring intensive services in the areas of orientation and mobility, and speech and language. Carla Galias, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist during the 1994-95 school year, testified that she provided group therapy to STUDENT once per week. Ms. Galias testified that although STUDENT made some progress in responding to commands and staying in his chair, he never responded to her in English. Ms. Galias considers STUDENT to be a nonverbal child. Ms. Galias’ opinion was that STUDENT did not use any language, either English or Farsi. Dr. June Downing, an assistant professor in CSU, Northridge’s special education department, testified that STUDENT’s areas of need are communication and social skills.
STUDENT’s IEP dated June 20, 1994, provides additional information regarding STUDENT’s needs. At that time, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a class “that utilizes manipulatives, movement, hands-on, learning experiences with real objects. Small class size. Typical language models. Opportunities for modeling, saying, talking with and learning with peers who are motivated to express and communicate verbally. Opportunity to receive one on one adult assistance for certain activities. Class with clear cut routine. Use of compensatory strategies for instruction.” A year prior to the IEP, the District’s assessors made several recommendations, including that STUDENT should have appropriate language models; STUDENT’s use of language should be encouraged, along with the use of his hands and fine motor skills to explore his environment; and STUDENT should participate in a small play group.
The evidence establishes that during the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT was a child with significant educational needs to address his blindness and developmental delays. Included in those needs were a small, structured classroom with a small group of students; language work, including appropriate language models in his classroom; orientation and mobility work; hands-on instruction; and social skills work. STUDENT’s placement at Frances Blend provided him with speech and language services, orientation and mobility services, and adapted physical education, services directed at addressing STUDENT’s needs.
Petitioner makes several contentions that STUDENT’s placement during the 1994-95 school year did not meet his unique needs. First, Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s unique needs were not met when Ms. Milstein-Wahba, a teacher who was not VH credentialed, took over his class. However, Petitioner did not present any specific evidence as to how Ms. Milstein-Wahba failed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in her class. Although Ms. Milstein-Wahba was not VH credentialed, she did possess an orientation and mobility credential. Additionally, Education Code § 56061 allows for substitute teachers to teach for periods in excess of 40 days in certain circumstances. Based on the lack of specific evidence regarding Ms. Milstein-Wahba’s instruction, the Hearing Officer finds that the mere fact that she was not VH credentialed does not mean that STUDENT’s unique needs were not met while Ms. Milstein-Wahba was the teacher. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not established that Ms. Milstein-Wahba did not meet STUDENT’s needs while she was his teacher.
Second, Petitioner contends that the speech and language services provided to STUDENT were insufficient to meet his needs. According to the IEP dated June 20, 1994, STUDENT was to receive one session of speech and language services per week for 30 minutes. The IEP does not indicate whether these services were to be provided individually or in a group. Carla Galias, the speech and language therapist, testified that she provided her services to STUDENT in a group setting. While Petitioner contends that these services were insufficient and that STUDENT required one-to-one speech and language services, no expert testimony was presented to support this contention. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that STUDENT required speech and language services different from those provided during the 1994-95 school year.
Based on the evidence that the District placed STUDENT in a small class geared to the needs of visually handicapped students and provided related services in the areas of speech and language, orientation and mobility, and adapted physical education, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement for STUDENT for the 1994-95 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. (2) Did the District’s placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
STUDENT’s IEP developed on June 20, 1994, called for STUDENT to receive his education in a special day class in a special school, specifically at Frances Blend School. STUDENT was also to receive speech and language services once a week for 30 minutes, orientation and mobility services once a week for 30 minutes, and adapted physical education once a week for 30 minutes.
Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s placement did not conform to his IEP because STUDENT was placed in another class with lower functioning children for 30-60 minutes per day for several months during the 1994-95 school year. Petitioner contends that this did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP because the IEP includes a recommendation that he be placed in a class with “typical language models, opportunities for modeling, playing, talking with and learning with peers who are motivated to express and communicate verbally.”
For several reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement in the other class for several months for 30-60 minutes per day did not result in a placement that did not conform to his IEP. First, the specific placement called for in STUDENT’s IEP was a special day class at a special school. The evidence establishes that the other class was also a special day class. Second, the specific placement called for in the IEP does not indicate that STUDENT was to be placed in a special day class with higher functioning students. There is no indication on the IEP that the recommendation of the IEP team was intended to be a formal requirement of STUDENT’s placement. Instead, the IEP requires only that STUDENT be placed in a special day class. Third, there is no indication that the recommendation of the IEP team was not followed. The recommendation does not indicate that STUDENT’s entire education should have taken place with the typically developing language models. Although STUDENT was removed from his regular class for a portion of the day, the evidence establishes that a significant amount of STUDENT’s educational day took place in the special day class with higher functioning students in compliance with STUDENT’s IEP and the recommendations made by the IEP team.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement for the 1994-95 school year substantially conformed to his IEP developed on June 20, 1994.
(3) Did the District’s placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
It is important to note that Rowley does not require the District to maximize STUDENT’s educational potential. Rather, the Court in Rowley set a standard requiring the District to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The evidence establishes that STUDENT obtained educational benefit during the 1994-95 school year.(Footnote 7) STUDENT’s progress report from the end of the school year establish that he received satisfactory, good, or excellent marks in all areas except for “works independently” and “completes tasks.”
Furthermore, the teacher comments on the progress report also indicate that STUDENT was making progress. STUDENT’s teacher for the first quarter, Peggy Tutor, commented that “STUDENT is making progress in his preoccupational tasks. He is adjusting to the class and beginning to enjoy his peers. His daily living skills are very good.” Similarly, STUDENT’s teacher for the second and third quarters, Ms. Milstein-Wahba, commented that STUDENT was “working well with preoccupational activities, but needs assistance in completion of tasks” at the end of the second quarter; and by the end of the school year, “STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language has improved; and he is more cooperative and following directions. He is working on completion of tasks. His gross motor skills are great!”
Ms. Galias testified that STUDENT had made progress in her speech and language sessions with him. According to Ms. Galias, STUDENT had shown progress in his responses to commands, and his ability to sit and attend for longer periods of time. According to the IEP developed in September 1995, STUDENT had met three of his four motor goals. The same IEP includes a progress report from STUDENT’s orientation and mobility instructor who stated that
STUDENT has become aware of textures changes at feet level (bumpy tile) and the presence of walkway edges (rubber mat) while traveling on daily routes within school. STUDENT has used the WALK-ALONE, a push device similar to a push cane. After several months of practice, STUDENT was able to push the WALK-ALONE on his own with correct posture along the hallways following voice prompts from in front of him. STUDENT has also been introduced to the long cane and demonstrates some understanding of the cane as a bumper and a probe. He is now able to hold the cane with a modified correct grip, on both sides, more than 75% of the time, with occasional physical prompting and minimal verbal prompting. STUDENT can use the cane while trailing with his hand along the hallways.
Based on the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the STUDENT’s placement for the 1994-95 school year provided him with educational benefit, substantially conformed to his IEP, and met his unique needs. Therefore, STUDENT’s placement for the 1994-95 school year was appropriate pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley.
(2) (a) Was STUDENT IEP developed on September 22 and 28, 1995, appropriate?
Petitioner raises several contentions regarding the inappropriateness of STUDENT’s IEPs developed in September 1995. First, Petitioner contends that the wrong classroom teacher attended the IEP. Education Code § 56341(b)(2) provides that an IEP team must include the student’s present teacher. However § 56341(b)(2) provides for several exceptions in cases where the student does not currently have a teacher or where the present teacher is not available. In such circumstances, the teacher attending the IEP meeting should be either the teacher with the most recent and complete knowledge of the pupil who has also observed the student’s educational performance, the regular classroom teacher referring the pupil, or a special education teacher qualified to teach a student of his or her age.
Peggy Tutor, STUDENT’s teacher from fall 1994, attended the IEP meetings held in September 1995, instead of STUDENT’s teacher from spring 1995 or his summer school teacher. Ms. Efron testified that Ms. Milstein-Wahba, STUDENT’s teacher from spring 1995, was no longer employed by the District and was, therefore, not available for the IEP meeting. Ms. Efron also indicated that Ms. Tutor was the individual most qualified to discuss STUDENT’s educational needs and that she had a report from STUDENT’s summer school teacher regarding STUDENT’s progress during summer school. Based on the testimony of Ms. Efron, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Tutor was an appropriate teacher to participate in the development of STUDENT’s IEP in September 1995.
Second, Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s IEPs developed in September 1995 were inappropriate because they did not indicate the extent to which STUDENT would be able to participate in regular educational programs. Special education law requires that a student’s IEP include the amount of time the student will be able to participate in regular education. Education Code § 56345(a)(4). The IEP dated September 28, 1995, which states that it is a continuation of the IEP developed on September 22, 1995, indicates that STUDENT was to be educated in a special school and does not indicate that he would participate in any regular education programs. Ms. Efron testified that, while mainstreaming opportunities are available for students at Frances Blend, STUDENT was not a student who participated in those opportunities because of his significant needs. The only participation in mainstreaming activities that STUDENT had was during special events. While the evidence is not clear, it appears that STUDENT’s IEP team determined that STUDENT’s placement should not include any time in regular educational programs. If it was the IEP team’s intent that STUDENT would not participate in regular education programs except for special events, § 56345(a)(4) requires that his IEP indicate that. While STUDENT’s IEP failed to indicate how much time he would participate in regular education, the failure to do so is a technical violation of the law. There was no showing that the District’s failure to indicate on STUDENT’s IEP the amount of time he would participate in regular education resulted in any educational loss or deficiency in his program.
Third, Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s IEP did not include appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining whether he was meeting his goals and objectives. Education Code § 56345(a)(6) provides that IEPs must include “appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether the short-term instructional objectives are being achieved. The IEPs listed the evaluation criteria and ending date for each goal and objective listed on his IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEPs complied with § 56345(a)(6).
Fourth, Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s IEP did not include linguistically appropriate goals, objectives, programs and services. Education Code § 56345(b)(4) provides that IEPs shall include linguistically appropriate goals, objectives, programs, and services for individuals whose primary language is other than English. Although none of the goals and objectives listed on STUDENT’s IEPs specifically address the fact that his primary language is Farsi, Petitioner provided no evidence regarding what his goals should have been or specifically how the goals that were developed did not meet his needs. The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s parents signed an IEP for STUDENT in June 1994 which contained goals very similar to those contained in the IEPs developed in September 1995. The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that the goals and objectives were inappropriate pursuant to § 56345(b)(4).
Fifth, Petitioner contends that the IEPs developed in September 1995 inappropriately identify one of STUDENT’s eligibility criteria as mental retardation. The Hearing Officer notes that mental retardation was first used as an eligibility category for STUDENT in May 1992 in an IEP signed by STUDENT’s mother. According to the IEP, the eligibility was based on developmental delays identified by the Regional Center. These delays were also identified in the District’s own assessment conducted in March and April 1993, although the District’s assessors did not actually use the words “mental retardation” or “developmental delays.” Considering the evidence of developmental delays from the Regional Center, the District’s assessment, and the testimony of Ms. Efron and other District witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that eligibility based, in part, on mental retardation was not inappropriate under the circumstances.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that STUDENT’s IEPs developed in September 1995 were inappropriate.
(b) Was the placement proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year appropriate?
The placement proposed by the District for the 1995-96 school year was identical to that provided to STUDENT during the prior school year. In addition, there was no evidence presented that STUDENT’s needs had changed since the prior year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner did not establish that the District’s placement for 1995-96 was inappropriate pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley. However, by the beginning of the 1995-96 school year, Petitioner had requested a full inclusion placement. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has developed a four-part test to determine the least restrictive environment when a school district proposes a more restrictive placement than that requested by a student’s parents. Holland v. Sacramento City Unified School District, (1994) 20 IDELR 812. The factors developed by the Holland court include academic benefit, nonacademic benefit, effect on the teacher and children in the regular class, and cost.
Academic Benefit
Ms. Efron testified that STUDENT had very intensive needs that required constant intervention that could not occur in a regular education environment and that his level of functioning was significantly lower than that of his regular education peers. Ms. Efron testified that she rejected full inclusion for STUDENT because of his developmental level, lack of ability to relate to other children, and need for a small setting with hands-on instruction on an ongoing basis. Mr. Matsutani testified that he would not recommend full inclusion for STUDENT because he requires very specific instruction and will not learn incidentally. Mr. Matsutani also testified that, at a minimum, to be able to benefit from a full inclusion program, STUDENT would have to be able to read at the third grade level, have appropriate social skills to be able to assert himself and fit in with the other students, have sufficient mobility skills to maneuver around the regular education site, and have communication skills. According to Mr. Matsutani, STUDENT does not have any of these skills. Ms. Galias testified that for STUDENT to benefit from full inclusion, he needs attending skills and language skills which he does not yet have. The testimony of Ms. Efron, Mr. Matsutani, and Ms. Galias establishes that STUDENT has such significant delays that instruction in a regular education class would provide him with little, if any, academic benefit and that he would be doing completely different work from that done by his same-age peers in a regular education class. The Hearing Officer also notes that JoAnn Grofsky, the fourth grade teacher at Topeka Drive Elementary School, testified that, while she could implement STUDENT’s goals and objectives in her class, most of the goals listed on STUDENT’s IEP were far below the level of work she does with her fourth grade students.
While Dr. Downing testified that STUDENT should be placed in a full inclusion program and that he would receive benefit from such a placement, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Downing has never assessed STUDENT, never observed him in an educational setting, never spoken with STUDENT’s teachers regarding STUDENT’s performance, and based her opinion on meeting with STUDENT for a short time in fall 1996. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Downing’s opinion is unpersuasive when compared to the testimony of District employees who have worked with and observed STUDENT in an educational setting.
Based on the testimony of the District employees, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT would have experienced little, if any, educational benefit if he had been placed in a full inclusion setting during the 1995-96 school year.
Nonacademic Benefit
Ms. Efron testified that STUDENT would not receive nonacademic benefit from a full inclusion placement because he does not relate to or interact with other children. According to Ms. Efron, STUDENT usually sat passively and uninterested during lessons without interacting with his peers or teachers. Ms. Efron testified that STUDENT needs to improve his social skills before he can benefit from the peer interaction in a full inclusion placement. Ms. Galias testified that she considered STUDENT to be nonverbal and that she never saw him use language to communicate with others.
Again, while Dr. Downing testified that STUDENT would benefit socially from a full inclusion placement, her testimony was not based on any assessment, observation, or discussion of STUDENT with his teachers. The testimony of Ms. Efron and Ms. Galias, along with the documentary evidence, establishes that STUDENT’s combination of disabilities were such that he did not interact sufficiently with peers to receive significant nonacademic benefit from a full inclusion placement.
Effect on students and teachers in the regular education class
There was no testimony presented that STUDENT’s presence would have an adverse effect on the students and teachers in a regular education class. MOTHER and Keith Lord, principal of Melvin Avenue, both testified that STUDENT’s recent visits to the classroom provided positive experiences for the other students in the class. Based on the lack of any evidence that STUDENT’s presence would have an adverse effect on the other students and teachers in a regular education class and the testimony of MOTHER and Mr. Lord, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s presence in a regular education class could have a positive effect on the students and teachers.
Cost
No evidence was presented regarding this factor.
Based on the fact that STUDENT would experience little, if any, academic and nonacademic benefits from a full inclusion placement and that STUDENT was receiving a significant amount of services and benefit from his placement at Frances Blend, the Hearing Officer finds that the factors identified by the Holland court weigh in favor of finding that STUDENT’s appropriate placement was at Frances Blend rather than in a full inclusion placement.
Finally, while Rowley and Holland provide for tests to determine the substantive appropriateness of the District’s placement, Rowley also provides for a procedural inquiry into the District’s placement. The Rowley Court stated that “[w]hen the elaborate and highly specific procedural safeguards embodied in § 1415 are contrasted with the general and somewhat imprecise substantive admonitions contained in the Act, we think that the importance Congress attached to these procedural safeguards cannot be gainsaid.” Thus, the Court held that, in addition to the substantive requirements of an appropriate placement, a school district must also comply with the procedural requirements of the IDEA and failure to do so may render an otherwise appropriate placement inappropriate.
Subsequent to the Rowley decision, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a decision interpreting the procedural requirements established by Rowley. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 18 IDELR 1019 (1992). The W.G. Court held that procedural violations which result in a loss of educational opportunity or which seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process result in a denial of an appropriate education.
Petitioner raises several contentions that the District violated the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Petitioner contends that a psychologist attended the September 1995 IEPs without prior notice to STUDENT’s parents, that goals were developed prior to those IEP meetings without the participation of STUDENT’s parents, and that a speech and language therapist signed the IEP dated September 28, 1995, although she did not attend the meeting.
The Hearing Officer finds that none of these alleged violations have resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or infringed upon his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. With regard to the presence of the psychologist at the IEP meetings, there was no showing as to how this had any adverse impact on STUDENT’s education or his parents’ opportunity to participate. Instead, the evidence establishes that a psychologist was necessary for the IEP team to develop an appropriate IEP.
The Hearing Officer notes that there is nothing in special education law which specifically addresses the issue of whether goals can be developed prior to an IEP meeting. However, at least one interpretation of the IEP process allows for teachers and other members of the IEP team to develop draft goals prior to the IEP meeting for discussion purposes. See 34 CFR, Part 300, Appendix C. The testimony of the witnesses and a review of the actual IEPs developed in September 1995, establish that several individuals who had worked with STUDENT during the 1994-95 school year, and were in the best position to discuss his progress and needs, were unable to attend the IEP meetings. As a result, they summarized their observations of STUDENT from the prior school year. Under such circumstances, it is entirely reasonable that those individuals may have also developed draft goals and objectives for consideration of the IEP team. The Hearing Officer also finds that Petitioner has not provided any evidence that the goals prepared prior to the meetings were presented to STUDENT’s parents as final goals. There is also no evidence that STUDENT’s opportunity to benefit from his education or STUDENT’s parents’ ability to participate in the IEP process were adversely impacted in any way by the prior development of draft goals and objectives.
Finally, regarding the speech and language therapist’s signature, Ms. Galias testified that she arrived late to the meeting on September 28, 1995, because she was working with some students when the meeting started. When she arrived, STUDENT’s parents had already left the meeting. Ms. Galias’ testimony was confirmed by other individuals who participated in the meeting. There is no evidence that the District failed to comply with any procedural requirement by having Ms. Galias sign the IEP.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to establish that the District committed any procedural violations during the 1995-96 school year which resulted in a denial of an appropriate education to STUDENT.
Underlying Petitioner’s contentions regarding the inappropriateness of the District’s placement for both the 1994-95 and 1995-96 school years is Petitioner’s contention that the transportation provided for STUDENT was inappropriate. MOTHER testified that the bus ride for STUDENT was two hours one way each day. STUDENT had to get up early in the morning to catch the bus and did not arrive home until 5:00 or 6:00 p.m. MOTHER also stated that the bus that STUDENT rode on was not air conditioned and did not have bathroom facilities. As a result, STUDENT frequently arrived home hot, tired, and thirsty. According to MOTHER, the District’s transportation policy requires that no child’s bus ride be longer than 90 minutes. Ms. Efron testified that, when MOTHER complained to her about the transportation, she checked with the transportation department and was told that the bus ride for STUDENT was not longer than 90 minutes. In addition, Ms. Efron testified that in September 1995, she took several steps to shorten STUDENT’s bus ride. However, STUDENT because did not return to Frances Blend he was never able to take the shorter bus ride.
Education Code § 56221(a) provides that educational agencies providing special education must adopt policies addressing several services, including transportation. Subparagraph (5) provides that the transportation policy should describe “how special education transportation is coordinated with regular home-to-school transportation. The policy shall set forth criteria for meeting the transportation needs of special education pupils.” While Petitioner contends that STUDENT’s bus ride violated the transportation policy adopted by the District, Petitioner did not provide significant evidence regarding the length of the bus ride or the specifics of the District’s policy. The actual policy was not submitted into evidence and no District employees were called who could testify regarding the specifics of that policy. Additionally, while MOTHER testified that the bus ride was two hours, Ms. Efron testified that the bus ride was 90 minutes or less.
The Hearing Officer also notes that there is no evidence that the bus ride interfered with STUDENT’s ability to benefit from or participate in his education. There was no evidence that the length of the bus ride forced STUDENT to arrive at school late or leave school early in order to accommodate the bus schedule. Based on the lack of evidence presented regarding the District’s transportation policy, the length of the bus ride, and any effect the bus ride had on STUDENT’s education, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not established that the transportation provided for STUDENT during the 1994-95 school year and proposed for STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year resulted in an inappropriate education.
(3) Was the placement proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year appropriate?
Several factors make it difficult to determine what an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year would be. First, STUDENT had been out of the District for almost one year by the beginning of the school year. Therefore, District personnel who testified had little information about STUDENT’s skills, functional levels, and educational needs in September 1996. Second, the last District assessment of STUDENT occurred in April 1993. By September 1996, STUDENT’s triennial reassessment was approximately five months overdue, and, as of the date of this decision, the District had yet to receive consent from STUDENT’s parents for an assessment. There also have been no independent assessments completed recently. The result is that there was no updated assessment information regarding STUDENT’s educational needs and disabilities in September 1996. Third, MOTHER was the only witness who could provide information regarding how STUDENT has done since September 1995. MOTHER refused to provide any significant information regarding the private school she enrolled STUDENT in, the home teaching she provided for STUDENT, the qualifications of the tutors she hired, the benefits STUDENT received through the home teaching, or any progress STUDENT has made since September 1995.
However, the evidence did establish that the following occurred. At the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, the District continued to propose placement at Frances Blend School. The details of that placement were never described, nor was there ever an IEP meeting to formalize that placement. Based on the previous IEPs and the testimony of the witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement the District continued to propose was identical to the placement provided to STUDENT in 1994-95 and proposed for STUDENT in 1995-96. Such a placement was appropriate for those two school years and there is no evidence that changes were proposed that would have rendered it inappropriate for the 1996-97 school year.
In November 1996, Gloria Lopez, administrative coordinator for the District, proposed in writing that STUDENT be placed in a full inclusion setting at Topeka Drive Elementary School with a one-to-one aide. Ms. Lopez conditioned such a placement on convening a meeting to develop an IEP for STUDENT’s transition to Topeka Drive. MOTHER refused to accept the placement, insisting that the placement take place before scheduling the IEP meeting. STUDENT was not placed at Topeka Drive. On February 25, 1997, an IEP team was convened to discuss an interim placement for STUDENT pending the completion of these proceedings. STUDENT’s parents did not attend. The IEP team recommended an interim placement in a full inclusion setting to allow time for an assessment to be completed. STUDENT’s parents did not sign the IEP or the assessment plan, and objected to the placement being only for the purpose of conducting an assessment. Following the February 1997 IEP meeting, MOTHER visited Melvin Avenue Elementary School and decide to enroll STUDENT there. The District approved enrolling STUDENT at Melvin Avenue.
MOTHER and Dr. Downing testified that STUDENT required a full inclusion placement in order to benefit from his education. Dr. Downing testified that STUDENT would benefit from exposure to nondisabled peers who could provide him with language and social skills models. The District’s witnesses, including Ms. Efron, Mr. Matsutani, Tina Saunders, Carla Galias, Linda Michel, and Roberta Eban, each testified that STUDENT required much more intensive services than could be provided in a regular education environment and pointed to the combination of STUDENT’s blindness, developmental delays, and communication delays as the reason why STUDENT’s needs could not be met in a full inclusion setting.
Petitioner contends that the District failed to comply with special education law in developing an interim placement pending completion of these proceedings. Petitioner cites 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, No. 35 (hereinafter referred to as No. 35) to support his position. No. 35 is an interpretation of 34 C.F.R. § 300.345, which details how school districts are to ensure parent participation in IEP meetings. No. 35 specifically deals with the question of what school districts are to do if the parents and school district are unable to reach an agreement at an IEP meeting. No. 35 suggests that the parents and school district should adopt an “interim course of action” to be followed until the disagreement is resolved. The parties can also implement any agreed upon portions of the student’s IEP. No. 35 also suggests that if the parties are unable to reach agreement on any interim measure, the child’s last agreed upon IEP would remain in effect. The Hearing Officer notes that No. 35 is an interpretation of § 300.345 and is not binding on the Special Education Hearing Office.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s conduct since November 1996 was not unreasonable under the circumstances. The Hearing Officer notes that as of November 6, 1996, the District was willing to provide a full inclusion placement for STUDENT pending the development of an IEP placing STUDENT in such a setting. A final placement for a student eligible for special education cannot be made without an IEP in place. Petitioner contends that he requested an interim placement pursuant to the IEP dated June 1994. However, considering that that IEP called for placement in a special day class on a segregated site and was almost two and a half years old, it could not be used for the purposes of placing STUDENT in a full inclusion setting. Such a placement would require different services, different goals and objectives, and a different placement designation from that contained in the IEP dated June 1994.
The Hearing Officer also notes that the ability of the District and Petitioner to develop an interim placement is dependent upon the cooperation of both parties. In the present case, Petitioner has consistently refused to cooperate. In November 1996, Petitioner refused to participate in an IEP meeting as requested by Ms. Lopez. Again, in February 1997, although Petitioner had requested the development of an interim placement pending the completion of these proceedings, Petitioner failed to attend the IEP meeting and did not consent to the IEP or the assessment plan developed at that IEP meeting.
Based on the lack of current information regarding STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the there is insufficient evidence to determine whether a full inclusion setting was appropriate for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year. Based on the fact that the District proposed a change in placement for STUDENT from a placement that was appropriate, the District had the burden of showing that the proposed change was appropriate. Although the District acted reasonably in proposing a full inclusion placement in November 1996 and attempting to develop an interim placement in February 1997, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to establish that its proposed change in placement was appropriate.(Footnote 8)
(4) Does Los Angeles Unified School have the right to conduct a triennial reassessment of STUDENT?
Both parties agree that STUDENT needs to be assessed. Petitioner contends that the District has engaged in discriminatory and unethical conduct which should prevent the District from conducting the assessment. Petitioner proposes that the assessment be conducted by independent assessors under the direction of Dr. Downing.
As already noted, there was no evidence presented to suggest that the District has engaged in any discriminatory or unethical conduct. Education Code § 56322 provides that assessments be “conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.” (emphasis added) Several Courts of Appeal have held that school districts have the right to determine who will conduct assessments of children with disabilities. See Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 1981-1982 EHLR 553:589 (2d Cir. 1982); Dubois v. Connecticut State Board of Education, 727 F.2d 44, 1983-84 EHLR 555:398 (2d Cir. 1984); Rettig v. Kent City School District, 720 F.2d 463, 1983-84 EHLR 555:222 (6th Cir. 1983).
Based on the language of § 56322 and the decisions cited above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has the right to select an assessor of its choice to conduct an assessment of STUDENT. The selected assessor and the assessment must meet the assessment requirements contained in the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and state special education law. The Hearing Officer notes that Respondent is entitled to an independent assessment and may, under very narrow circumstances set forth under Education Code § 56329(b), seek reimbursement for that assessment.
The Hearing Officer also notes that several witnesses, including Dr. Downing and Mr. Matsutani, testified that any speech and language assessment of STUDENT should be conducted by an individual knowledgeable in Farsi. The regulations adopted by the state Department of Education provide that “assessments shall be administered by qualified personnel who are competent in both the oral or sign language skills and written skills of the individual’s primary language or mode of communication and have a knowledge and understanding of the cultural and ethnic background of the pupil. If it clearly is not feasible to do so, an interpreter must be used.” California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3023. Any assessment developed and conducted by the District shall comply with § 3023. The District is ordered to develop an assessment plan which complies with special education law within 15 days of the date of this decision.(Footnote 9) STUDENT’s parents shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the District to conduct the assessment.
(5) Is the least restrictive placement for STUDENT a full inclusion placement?
The Hearing Officer notes that both parties are now proposing a full inclusion placement for STUDENT. There appears, therefore, to be no dispute regarding STUDENT’s current educational placement and the Hearing Officer does not reach this issue.
(6) Does STUDENT require assistive technology materials described in Petitioner’s evidence packet?
Dr. Downing testified that STUDENT should have access to the materials listed in Petitioner’s Evidence Packet, pp. C-309 to C-352. Ms. Efron testified that many of the materials listed were above STUDENT’s level. Other District witnesses testified that they would want to conduct an assistive technology assessment of STUDENT before recommending materials for his use.
Because Petitioner is requesting that materials be provided that are not indicated on STUDENT’s IEP, Petitioner has the burden of proof in establishing that those materials are necessary. Based on the lack of current information regarding STUDENT, and the testimony of the witnesses regarding the need for an assistive technology assessment, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not established the specific materials needed. STUDENT’s IEP shall address STUDENT’s need for materials by including an assistive technology assessment in the reassessment.
(7) Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for educational aides hired by his parents from October 1995 through August 1996 and October 1996 through December 1996; MOTHER’s time spent home schooling STUDENT; and special materials provided by STUDENT’s parents?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the placement or services they have obtained for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parent was appropriate. In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359. Furthermore, when a parent places a student in a private school, reimbursement may be ordered even though the private school does not satisfy state certification standards. Florence County School District v. Carter, (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361.
In the present case, the District provided appropriate placements for STUDENT for the 1994-95 and 1995-96 school year. Petitioner is requesting reimbursement for educational expenses incurred since October 1995, when STUDENT was removed from the District. Those expenses include tutors hired by STUDENT’s parents, MOTHER’s time working with STUDENT,(Footnote 10) and specialized materials purchased for STUDENT by his parents. Because the District provided an appropriate placement during the 1995-96 school year, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for services provided during that school year. The evidence is unclear as to whether the District’s proposed full inclusion placement for the 1996-97 school year would have been appropriate for STUDENT. However, the evidence does establish that the District’s proposed placement was similar to the placement requested by Petitioner.
The evidence also establishes that since the District proposed a full inclusion placement, STUDENT’s parents have not cooperated with the development of an IEP guiding the placement. STUDENT’s parents left early from the IEP held on September 28, 1995, and refused to sign it. They also have refused to participate in any IEP meeting during the 1996-97 school year, have not signed any IEPs developed during the 1996-97 school year, and have continued to refuse to consent to a reassessment, which is now almost one and a half years late. In weighing the equities to determine whether Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement, this lack of cooperation weighs against reimbursement. If STUDENT’s parents had cooperated by participating in an IEP meeting, STUDENT could have been placed in a full inclusion setting as they requested as early as November 1996.
Furthermore, while services provided by parents when a school district fails to provide an appropriate placement do not have to meet the three factor test of the IDEA and Rowley, such services must at least be shown to have provided benefit to the child to warrant reimbursement by the school district. In the present case, there was no evidence presented regarding any progress STUDENT has made since October 1995 or educational benefit he has received as a result of the services provided by his parents. There was also very little evidence offered regarding the specific nature of the services provided by STUDENT’s parents. The question, then, is whether the District should be required to reimburse Petitioner for educational services provided by unspecified tutors, based on an unspecified curriculum, using unspecified materials, and which produced unspecified results. Based on the lack of evidence presented regarding the services provided by STUDENT’s parents, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has not established that services provided by STUDENT’s parents met his needs or provided him with educational benefit.
Based on STUDENT’s parents’ failure to cooperate in the development of IEPs and assessments, and the lack of evidence presented regarding the services provided to STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the services and materials provided by his parents from October 1995 to the present. (8) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
Similar to reimbursement, courts have held that parents may be entitled to compensatory education for a school district’s failure to provide an appropriate education. Parents of Student W. V. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489. Petitioner in his closing brief did not indicate if there was specific compensatory education he was requesting. The only time period that it was established that the District did not provide an appropriate placement was during the 1996-97 school year. The Hearing Officer notes, however that the District had offered a full inclusion placement, similar to that requested by STUDENT’s parents, in November 1996. It is only because of STUDENT’s parents’ refusal to cooperate that STUDENT was not placed in that full inclusion placement as early as November 1996. As with the issue of reimbursement, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents’ refusal to cooperate with the District as outlined above warrants a denial of compensatory education.
ORDER
(1) Los Angeles Unified School District shall develop an assessment plan for STUDENT within 15 days of the date this decision. The assessment shall be conducted in compliance with all relevant federal and state special education requirements, and shall include an assistive technology assessment.
(2) STUDENT parents shall make him reasonably available for the District to conduct the assessment.
(3) In compliance with the timelines relating to assessments and IEP meetings, Los Angeles Unified School District shall convene an IEP meeting following completion of the assessment to develop an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) (a) Was STUDENT IEP developed on June 20, 1994, appropriate? (b) Was STUDENT placement for the 1994-95 school year appropriate?
Los Angeles Unified School District substantially prevailed on this issue.
(2) (a) Was STUDENT IEP developed on September 22 and 28, 1995, appropriate? (b) Was the placement proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year appropriate?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(3) Was the placement proposed by the District for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year appropriate?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(4) Does Los Angeles Unified School have the right to conduct a triennial reassessment of STUDENT?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(5) Is the least restrictive placement for STUDENT a full inclusion placement?
Neither party prevailed on this issue.
(6) Does STUDENT require assistive technology materials described in Petitioner’s evidence packet?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(7) Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for educational aides hired by his parents from October 1995 through August 1996 and October 1996 through December 1996; MOTHER’s time spent home schooling STUDENT; and special materials provided by STUDENT’s parents?
The District prevailed on this issue.
(8) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(I).
DATED: September 4, 1997 ______________________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1.The District has not conducted an assessment of STUDENT’s educational needs since April 1993. 2. The teacher who attended both of the September 1995 IEPs was Peggy Tutor, STUDENT’s teacher from fall 1994. Ms. Milstein-Wahba, who taught STUDENT during spring 1995, and STUDENT’s summer school teacher were not available for the IEP meeting. 3.STUDENT was originally found eligible for special education due to blindness and mental retardation in 1992. However, the IEPs developed between 1992 and September 1995 only listed blindness as the eligibility criteria 4.As already noted, Petitioner refused to provide any significant information regarding STUDENT’s nonpublic school placement. 5.See Special Education Law and Litigation Treatise, Weber, Mark, LRP Publications (1992). “On the issue of appropriateness of the district’s proposed program and placement, some courts have placed both burdens on the school system as the plans’ proponent. A greater number of courts have placed the burdens on the parent as the person challenging the district’s plans. Still others have placed the burdens on whichever party is proposing a change from the status quo.” [citations omitted] Weber, § 20.11. 6.The Hearing Officer notes the IDEA was recently amended. See H.R. 5, Individuals with Disabilities Education Act Amendments of 1997. However, because the placements at issue in Issue #1 occurred prior to the amendments, those placements will be analyzed under the IDEA as it was written prior to the amendments. The Hearing Officer also notes that there do not appear to be any changes contained in the amendments which would impact the issues raised regarding the District’s placements during the past three years. 7.The Hearing Officer notes that this case presents a difficult situation in determining whether STUDENT made educational progress. The only witness to testify who worked with STUDENT during the 1994-95 school year was Ms. Galias, the speech and language therapist. None of STUDENT’s classroom teachers testified. Therefore, there is relatively little testimony regarding STUDENT’s progress during the 1994-95 school year. 8.The Hearing Officer notes that the District’s failure to establish the appropriateness of the full inclusion placement is not necessarily the fault of the District since STUDENT’s parents have not made him available for assessment and the only individual who testified who is familiar with STUDENT’s education since September 1995 was STUDENT’s mother, who refused to provide any updated information regarding STUDENT. The Hearing Officer also notes that the finding that the District did not establish the appropriateness of its proposed placement does not necessarily mean that the placement was inappropriate. 9.Petitioner objected that the assessment plan developed by the District in February 1997 did not include information regarding the individuals who would conduct the different assessments called for in that plan. The Hearing Officer notes that there is no provision in special education law which includes such a requirement. 10. MOTHER testified that she worked with STUDENT eight hours per day for much of the time since October 1995.
