California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 9, 2001
Student v. Fremont Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1205-00, SN-1205-00 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski
Fremont Union High School District's algebra placements and offers provided FAPE; parents denied reimbursement for private educational therapy.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated.
Summary
The parents of a 16-year-old eleventh grader at Lynbrook High School filed for due process against Fremont Union High School District. The student was eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability in written expression and math calculation, based on an auditory processing disorder. He also had characteristics of Asperger's syndrome. The parents challenged only his algebra placement. They argued that he learns best visually and concretely, so he needed one-on-one educational therapy with Jean Dresden. They asked to be reimbursed for her services.
The Hearing Officer applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard and ruled for the District on all four issues. For fall 1999, William Mansfield's general education Algebra I class met the student's needs. The class had 15 to 18 students and a very experienced teacher who used visual methods. A tutorial class with an instructional assistant was also available, though the student rarely used it. He passed the class with a D, and his math achievement scores stayed average to above average.
For summer 2000, the District offered a math prep class with an instructional assistant, plus one hour a week of tutoring with Dresden. That offer was appropriate. For 2000-2001, the District offered a team-taught Algebra I class with a general education teacher and a resource specialist, plus weekly Dresden tutoring. That offer gave the student FAPE in the least restrictive environment. Tutoring with no classroom instruction, as the parents wanted, was the most restrictive option. Because the District offered FAPE, the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a dispute limited to a single subject. A passing grade and steady achievement scores counted as "some educational benefit," even after grades declined. The Hearing Officer gave weight to the fact that the parents' experts never observed the classroom. Tutoring with no classroom instruction was treated as more restrictive than a supported general education class.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment from September 1999 through January 2000? (limited to the algebra class placement)
The general education Algebra I class, with its small size, an experienced teacher using visual methods, and an available tutorial class with an instructional assistant, met the student's needs. It gave him some educational benefit in the LRE.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the extended school year (ESY), summer 2000?
The offer of a summer math prep class with an instructional assistant, plus one hour a week of funded tutoring with the parents' educational therapist, was an appropriate offer in the LRE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the period September 2000 to June 2001?
The team-taught Algebra I class (general education teacher plus resource specialist, roughly 10–11 students per teacher) and one weekly funded tutoring session offered FAPE in the LRE. The parents' tutoring-only option was the most restrictive.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the services provided by educational therapist Jean Dresden, M.S., which the parents funded?
Because the District provided and offered FAPE for every period at issue, the parents could not be reimbursed for the private educational therapy.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District
People named in the decision
- Jean Dresden, educational therapist in private practice (parent-funded tutor); witness for Student, Private practice
- Sarah DeCarlo, private tutor; witness for Student, Private
- Diane F. Kosters, Ph.D., clinical psychologist who assessed Student; expert witness for Student, Private
- Deborah Bloom, educational consultant; witness for Student, Private
- William C. Mansfield, retired general education Algebra I teacher, Lynbrook High School
- Lorraine Cho, general education algebra teacher (team-taught class), Lynbrook High School
- Eric Stietzel, mathematics teacher; proposed summer course instructor, Foothill College
- Phillip M. Wagner, resource specialist (team-taught algebra co-teacher), Lynbrook High School
- Cathi Serpa, program specialist, SELPA II
- Michelle Garcia Winner, speech and language pathologist; summer program provider and District consultant; witness for District, Private / District consultant
- Nancy McDonnel, resource specialist and special education department chair; tutorial class teacher, Lynbrook High School
- Anne Hammond, resource specialist; tutorial teacher, Lynbrook High School
- Trudy Gross, program specialist; case manager, Fremont Union High School District
- Polly Bove, Director of Educational Services, Fremont Union High School District
- Bonnie Waxenbaum, instructional assistant (tutorial class), Lynbrook High School
- Andrew Sample, case manager, Lynbrook High School
- Janet Rulifson, contacted for math program support, Children's Health Council
- Ken Edwards, math teacher contacted for after-school program, Monte Vista High School
- Children's Health Council, private assessment agency
- Amen Clinic, private diagnostic clinic
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Sunnyvale, California, on September 26, November 14, 15, 16, and 17, and December 12 and 13, 2000.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his father, attorney FATHER. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Fremont Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Laurie E. Reynolds from the law firm Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District’s behalf was Polly Bove, Director of Educational Services for the District.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Jean Dresden, an educational therapist in private practice; Sarah DeCarlo, tutor for Petitioner; Diane F. Kosters, Ph.D., psychologist who assessed Petitioner; Deborah Bloom, educational consultant; William C. Mansfield, retired Lynbrook High School mathematics teacher; Lorraine Cho, algebra teacher at Lynbrook High School; Eric Stietzel, mathematics teacher at Foothill College; Phillip M. Wagner, resource specialist at Lynbrook High School; and Cathi Serpa, program specialist for SELPA II.
The following witnesses were called by Respondent District to testify; Michelle Garcia Winner, speech and language pathologist; Nancy McDonnel, resource specialist and special education department chair for Lynbrook High School; and Anne Hammond, resource specialist for Lynbrook High School.
Both parties called the following witnesses to testify: Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER; Trudy Gross, Program Specialist for the District; and Polly Bove, director of educational services for the District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Following receipt of written closing arguments from both parties, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment from September 1999 through January 2000?(Footnote 1)
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the extended school year (ESY), summer 2000?
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the period September 2000 to June 2001?
4. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the services provided by educational therapist Jean Dresden, M.S., which the parents funded(Footnote 2):
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old eleventh grade student at Lynbrook High School (Lynbrook) within the Fremont Unified School District (District). STUDENT’s eligibility for special education is based upon the District’s determination that STUDENT has a specific learning disability (SLD) in the areas of written expression and mathematics calculation due to a disorder in auditory processing. On January 26, 1999, STUDENT was found eligible for special education by the District. STUDENT had not previously been found eligible for special education services.
STUDENT attended private schools in his early years for the first grade through the first semester of the sixth grade. STUDENT was assessed at the Children’s Health Council during the summer following the third grade and apparently was found to have an auditory processing deficit. STUDENT received the following scores in math on the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT): 70th, 72nd, and 68th percentile, for the fourth, fifth, and sixth grades, respectively. STUDENT also received math scores on the Stanford Diagnostic Math Test in the 90th, 84th, and 99th percentiles for the fourth, fifth, and sixth grades, respectively. (Dist. Exh. 44 and Testimony of Trudy Gross)
STUDENT transferred to the West Valley Elementary School in the Cupertino Union School District (Cupertino) for the second semester of the sixth grade, where he received an A- and C in math for report periods 3 and 4, respectively. STUDENT attended a regular math class at Cupertino Junior High School for the seventh grade and earned B, B, and C- math grades, with a satisfactory grade for effort in each trimester. In March 1997, STUDENT received a 73rd percentile score, in the average to high average range nationally, on the Math Advance Skills test and the Math Total test for the Iowa Tests of Basic Skills. (Dist. Exh. 46 and Testimony of Trudy Gross)
STUDENT attended Cupertino for the eighth grade and earned the following math grades for each trimester: C, D+, and C. STUDENT’s parents retained Sarah DeCarlo as a private tutor for STUDENT, mostly for math, twice a week. Ms. DeCarlo’s overall impression of STUDENT was that he was a normal and active young teen, very intelligent and likeable, who experienced difficulties in math. In a “To Whom It May Concern” letter dated November 13, 1998, Ms. DeCarlo noted that “on many occasions I observed STUDENT’s memory lapse. I would go over a mathematical concept in which he would successfully complete and master, and then, two days later, he would approach this problem as if he had seen it for the first time. He also had a lot of difficulty with the order of operations and adding and subtracting positive and negative numbers (i.e., -10-(-12)).” However, Ms. DeCarlo also noticed STUDENT’s “incredible ability to compute multiple and difficult equations in his head and figure out the answer quickly and accurately.” STUDENT was enrolled in the highest algebra class at Cupertino, but then transferred to the regular math class during the third trimester. (Pet. Exh. SS and Testimony of Ms. DeCarlo) In March 1998, STUDENT scored at the 69th percentile in math on the Stanford Achievement Test, Ninth Series (SAT-9), and placed in the average or above average range in each subsection of the math portion of the SAT-9. (Dist. Exh. 47 and Testimony of Trudy Gross)
For the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT enrolled at Homestead High School as a freshman in regular education and regular math. STUDENT attended school for approximately one month, but was arrested for some serious behavioral offenses and placed with juvenile hall. STUDENT was home-schooled until he enrolled at the District’s Lynbrook High School (Lynbrook).
During the fall 1998, STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, contacted Polly Bove, the District’s director of education services, for assistance in placing STUDENT, who was then currently at home under 24-hour supervision for his legal problems. Ms. Bove agreed to provide assistance and arranged for an assessment through Cathi Serpa, program specialist for SELPA II. Ms. Bove testified that since STUDENT was at home and the family was under a lot of stress, District officials felt very strongly that they wanted to serve STUDENT.
STUDENT was assessed by the District in December 1998, and Ms. Bove testified that although STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy between aptitude and achievement in math, there was some discrepancy in math, and more in writing, and, although knowing “it was a stretch,” the IEP team decided that STUDENT was a student with a specific learning disability, even though STUDENT had been performing at grade level.
At an IEP meeting held on December 11, 1998, STUDENT was placed in the therapeutic special day class (TSDC) at Lynbrook. (Testimony of Cathi Serpa) The IEP document indicates as follows: “STUDENT will have direct supervision at all times while attending a self-contained class and being on a public school campus. He will have specialized instruction in writing and math. A school-based therapy program will address social emotional. STUDENT will continue on home teaching until a behavioral/supervision intervention plan is established in a public school setting as described above.” STUDENT’s parents signed the IEP document on 12/11/98 and consented to the following: “I consent to home teaching, the development of a supervision behavioral plan, and a referral to 3632.” STUDENT’s parents acknowledged receiving a copy of the parental rights and indicated that they understood their rights. Under Goals and Objectives, STUDENT’s math goal was to increase numeric computation. The short-term objectives or benchmarks were to complete grade-level work regarding working with real numbers, and with solving equations, problems and polynomials in Algebra I. (Pet. Exh. CC) On January 26, 1999, STUDENT was found eligible due to a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of written expression and numerical operations. (Pet. Exh. Z)
According to MOTHER, STUDENT began attending the TSDC in late February or early March 2000. STUDENT studied math in the TSDC and received an A. (Dist. Exh. 46)
Meanwhile, STUDENT’s parents had STUDENT assessed by Diane Kosters, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist, on March 15 and 30, 1999. Ms. Kosters concluded in her report that STUDENT has an “Asperger’s-like condition [which] not only makes it difficult to generalize a math concept from one problem to another, it also makes it difficult to generalize in terms of social rules. He needs to be taught, situation by situation. Thus he needs a lot of feedback.” (Pet. Exh. SSSSS) During the spring of 1999, STUDENT was also diagnosed with Asperger’s at the Amen Clinic, and a copy of the Amen report, together with Dr. Kosters’ report, was provided by STUDENT’s parents to the IEP team that met on June 3, 1999. (Testimony of MOTHER)
On April 12, 1999, the IEP team met and agreed to continue STUDENT in the TSDC and on the current safety plan, increasing STUDENT’s school day to a full school day. STUDENT was found ineligible for Speech and Language services. (Pet. Exh. BB)
On June 3, 1999, the IEP team met again and agreed to continue STUDENT in the TSDC and agreed to mainstream STUDENT for world history and biology, supervised by a therapeutic staff member. The June 3, 1999, IEP document states as follows: “STUDENT’s schedule of mainstream classes (teachers) will be chosen keeping in mind his particular needs and learning style in view of the diagnosis of Asperger Syndrome. Personnel experienced with Asperger Syndrome will consult with mainstream teachers and school staff. Staff experienced with Asperger Syndrome will establish specific goals for STUDENT at home and school for the 1999-2000 school year. This staff will meet with the family prior to the 1999-2000 school year to establish goals. Trudy Gross will be STUDENT’s case manager. The IEP team will reconvene prior to the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to establish a new IEP.” The District also agreed to pay for a summer program held by Michelle Garcia Winner titled “Thinking It Through.” (Pet. Exh. BB) The program was designed to teach skills related to social/pragmatics and problem solving. Ms. Winner was experienced in program development and the treatment of children and adults with Asperger’s and Non Verbal Learning Disability (NVLD).
The District funded Ms. Winner’s five-day program to benefit STUDENT and to obtain training for a District employee (program specialist Trudy Gross). The District also wanted to evaluate Ms. Winner’s suitability for acting as a consultant to the District. Ms. Winner testified that STUDENT was easily the highest functioning person in the camp and distanced himself from the other students. STUDENT sent a thank you letter for a successful camp to the District. (Dist. Exh. 22)
Prior to the start of the 1999-2000 school year, the District and MOTHER attempted to located individuals with an understanding of Asperger’s Syndrome who might address STUDENT’s math needs. At the request of MOTHER, Trudy Gross contacted Janet Rulifson of the Children’s Health Council for support to develop a math program for STUDENT, but Ms. Rulifson told Trudy Gross that Asperger’s was not her area of expertise and, in turn, asked Ms. Gross for support. Trudy also called two other persons to find a private tutor. Trudy testified that she was trying to find out what type of program to offer for math, and the two people she contacted offered approaches similar to what the District offered. By then, the 1999-2000 school year had begun. MOTHER testified that Trudy had also contacted Ken Edwards, a math teacher who taught at Monte Vista High School and who taught a “New Start” program for students with math difficulties, but Mr. Edwards was unavailable to teach the after-school program due to a scheduling conflict.
On September 14, 1999, and IEP meeting was held, and the IEP team continued STUDENT’s math placement in the TSDC. (Pet. Exh. CC)
Trudy Gross and MOTHER then verbally agreed, three weeks into the 1999-2000 school year, to place STUDENT in a regular classroom for Algebra I taught by Mr. William Mansfield. Trudy Gross testified that mainstream Algebra class was the most appropriate one that was available for STUDENT and that Michelle Garcia Winner agreed with the placement. MOTHER testified that Andrew Sample, STUDENT’s case manager, had told her that STUDENT was misplaced in the TSDC for math and should go into mainstream math. MOTHER cited concerns about STUDENT not having had a math program for over one year. MOTHER further testified that on the very day she spoke with Trudy Gross about placing STUDENT in the Algebra I class, Mr. Mansfield was speaking at a “Back to School Night” at Lynbrook. MOTHER stated that she attended the program and spoke with Mr. Mansfield, who referred to the small class size, and then she told Mr. Mansfield that he would be getting a new student (STUDENT). MOTHER testified that she regarded the placement as an interim one and that she would continue to search for an appropriate math placement.
STUDENT started Mr. Mansfield’s algebra class with no modifications or accommodations, although STUDENT attended class with a one-to-one proctor aide for behavioral and security reasons. The aide served no academic function.
MOTHER testified that in October 1999, she attended as Asperger’s conference given by Eric Stietzel, and Mr. Stietzel gave MOTHER the name of an educational therapist, Jean Dresden. MOTHER did not recall when she first contacted Ms. Dresden.
On October 20, 1999, the IEP team met to address concerns over STUDENT’s struggling in some of his mainstream classes. The team decided to add a tutorial class for STUDENT taught by Nancy McDonnel, a resource specialist and supported by instructional assistant Bonnie Waxenbaum. Trudy Gross and Nancy McDonnel both credibly testified that STUDENT’s parents did not express any concerns about STUDENT’s performance in the algebra class at the IEP meeting.
STUDENT performed well at the beginning of Algebra I and earned a C for the first six-week grade period, even though he did not start Algebra I until three weeks after the class had begun. However, during the second six-week period, STUDENT began to experience difficulty with algebra, and received a grade of 59, with final three test scores of 34%, 40% and 59%. (Pet. Exh.C) In a teacher report for an IEP meeting, Mr. Mansfield noted that “STUDENT has not always been doing his homework.” (Dist. Exh. 20) In a feedback report dated December 6, 1999, Mr. Mansfield stated the following: “STUDENT struggles to do better in algebra. He does his homework daily, but without a strong connection between what he is doing on one problem and the next one.....STUDENT’s mind goes blank when he is asked a question (by me) in class. He has decent number skills when he relaxes, but he is easily confused if there are steps involved moving from the problem to a solution. He does not bounce back well. A harsh word from me lasts a long time. He is not well organized. He has trouble getting his material out, but he does pay attention to what I’m doing and volunteers answers during class discussion.” (Pet. Exh. C)
On November 4, 1999, STUDENT and MOTHER met with Jean Dresden, M.S., for an introductory meeting. MOTHER engaged Ms. Dresden to provide math tutoring services for STUDENT. Ms. Dresden is credentialed and has taught math for about six years at the secondary level. At the time of the hearing, Ms. Dresden worked part-time for the San Jose School District as a resource technology teacher. However, Ms. Dresden was not certified by the State of California as a non-public agency to provide educational services. Ms. Dresden had received a certificate from UC Santa Cruz in educational therapy, after completing 45 course credit hours and fifteen hundred hours of supervised educational therapy services. According to Ms. Dresden, educational therapists are not licensed or tested by the State of California. Ms. Dresden considers herself to be an expert in teaching, but not in math. (Testimony of Ms. Dresden)
STUDENT’s one-on-one tutoring with Jean Dresden began on November 9, 1999, with one-hour sessions, twice weekly, and continued to January 20, 2000, at the end of the first semester.
STUDENT had begun struggling in his Algebra I class in early December 1999, according to the testimony of Nancy McDonnel. The parties differ over the reason for this. Mr. Mansfield reported that STUDENT was not completing his homework in class, and Mr. Mansfield testified that STUDENT told him that he had a tutor and didn’t need to do his assignments in class. The District contends that Ms. Dresden’s tutoring may have confused STUDENT and may have reduced his level of commitment to Mr. Mansfield’s Algebra I course. STUDENT’s parents contend that the algebraic concepts were becoming more difficult for STUDENT, and in view of his “visual and concrete” learning style, STUDENT could not learn the more conceptual word problems of algebra without Ms. Dresden’s one-on-one tutoring. According to MOTHER, at this time, the tutor worked with STUDENT on his homework but did not follow the Algebra I textbook, and tutored STUDENT on pre-algebra concepts.
The parties met for STUDENT’s annual overall IEP review meeting on December 7, 1999. The report on STUDENT’s math scores on the WRAT, administered in December 1999, indicate a raw score of 41 and a standard score of 102, for a percentile of 55, placing STUDENT in the above average range for math achievement. (Testimony of Trudy Gross) Ms. Dresden’s written report dated December 2, 1999 was discussed. (Pet. Exh. A) Mrs. Dresden notes within her report that she was “impressed with STUDENT’s overall study skills and organization,” further observing that “STUDENT had learned large amounts of information, but had achieved mastery in few areas. His preferred learning style is visual and concrete.” Ms. Dresden summarized her findings by stating that STUDENT’s “current enrollment in a traditional one-year Algebra I course, supported by two hours per week of educational therapy and parent tutoring, are not likely to be sufficient for STUDENT to demonstrate proficiency.”
Members of STUDENT’s IEP team met on January 14, 2000, to discuss topics set forth on an agenda prepared by the District. (Pet. Exhs. DD and EE) The IEP team met again on January 19 and 28, 2000. (Pet. Exhs. FF and GG)
It was at this time that “the IEP team, “ according to MOTHER, decided that STUDENT would not return to Mr. Mansfield’s Algebra I class. According to the testimony of MOTHER she and STUDENT were too stressed to continue with the Algebra I class. Also, STUDENT wanted to play baseball in the spring, and that would conflict with his scheduled tutoring with Jean Dresden. STUDENT did not take the second semester of algebra (Algebra II) in Mr. Mansfield’s class, and STUDENT did not continue tutoring with Jean Dresden. According to the testimony of Nancy McDonnel, the decision was made not by the IEP team, but by STUDENT’s parents. Ms. McDonnel credibly testified that the IEP team explored several options in January 2000, including STUDENT’s returning to Mr. Mansfield’s class for the second semester, and that STUDENT’s parents decided that STUDENT would take computer repair for the second semester and not Algebra I. Mr. Mansfield testified that STUDENT should have continued with Algebra I into the second semester, and even if he had failed the course, STUDENT would have received a benefit, since a repeat of the course in the 2000-2001 school year would have made it easier for STUDENT to succeed in algebra on the second attempt. Mr. Mansfield stated that in his experience, many students, after re-taking algebra, did very well and sometimes received an A grade.
IEP team members met with Jean Dresden on February 3, 2000, to discuss her math teaching techniques. Subsequently, the District attempted to contract with Jean Dresden to teach STUDENT, other students, and staff members of the District, during the extended school year (ESY) for the summer 2000, but Ms. Dresden subsequently declined, stating in a letter that she could not give up her private tutoring.
An IEP meeting was then held on March 22, 2000. The IEP document indicates a grade of D for Algebra I and notes that “STUDENT has added a computer repair class at the semester. Math needs are to be addressed as a part of this IEP.” Under goals and objectives at page 10, STUDENT’s annual measurable goal for algebra was “to increase awareness of the rationale for the study of algebra and its usefulness in everyday life by June 2000.” This goal “enables student to be involved and progress in general education.” The following short-term objectives or benchmarks are indicated: “By June 2000, STUDENT will view videos, as homework, that demonstrate the importance of math in our lives as measured by completion of an evaluation/questionnaire after viewing to be kept in a math binder. By June 15, 2000, STUDENT will participate in no less that 4 job shadowing experiences chosen for their strong math component as measured by written observations to be kept in his math binder.” Extensive accommodations were made a part of the IEP at pages 14 and 15, including provisions for extra time for test taking and allowing quiet areas for testing. The IEP team also agreed to an ESY for STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. AA)
In a letter addendum prepared by STUDENT’s parents dated March 24, 2000, the parents requested, inter alia, that the IEP team set a math goal leading towards algebra proficiency and that the District collaborate with Jean Dresden to implement recommendations contained within her report dated December 2, 1999. (Pet. Exh. AA) Ms. McDonnel testified that STUDENT did not need a math proficiency goal since he did not have a math deficit.
On April 13, 2000, Polly Bove responded by letter to STUDENT’s parents’ request for an algebra placement for STUDENT which incorporated the teaching techniques of Jean Dresden. Ms. Bove indicated that Ms. Dresden had decided not to collaborate with the District in the “original instruction and teacher training plan,” but that the District was pursuing using Eric Stietzel, a math teacher at Foothill College, to provide a summer option. (Pet. Exh. K)
On April 14, 2000, the IEP team met again, and Phillip M. Wagner, a resource specialist at Lynbrook High School, described the team-taught Algebra I class that the District was offering STUDENT beginning in the fall 2000.
According to Eric Stietzel, a mathematics teacher at Foothill College since 1970, Trudy Gross of the District called him in April 2000 with an offer for Mr. Stietzel to teach a summer math course at Lynbrook to a small group of students with SLD and for teacher training. Mr. Stietzel stated that they met and discussed the course. However, Mr. Stietzel was unable to teach the course because of a hand injury. (Testimony of Eric Stietzel)
The IEP team met again on May 30, 2000, to “update goals on Form B and to plan courses for next year.” The IEP document indicates as follows: “All other services remain from IEP dated 3/22/00.” The IEP team met again on June 5, 2000, “to update goals for this year and to develop new goals....Another meeting will be held to finish goal update.” The IEP document indicates as follows: “Other services to remain as before on IEP 3/22 and addendum 5/30/00.” (Pet. Exh. AA)
STUDENT’s parents then sent a letter to Ms. Bove dated June 19, 2000, “to provide [Mrs. Bove] with additional information before STUDENT commenced his math program with Jean Dresden during the summer 2000. The parents provided as an enclosure a three-page document that contained a verbatim recital of State of California standards for math goals and objectives for completion of Algebra I. (Dist. Exh. 3)
Polly Bove replied by letter dated June 23, 2000, informing STUDENT’s parents that the IEP team needed to meet, either on June 28 or 29, 2000, to conclude the review of updates for goals and objectives from STUDENT’s March 22, 2000 IEP. Ms. Bove set forth the District’s offer for the summer program to begin on June 26, 2000, which is summarized as follows: a math prep course specifically designed to prepare students for Algebra I, with an instructional assistant to ensure supervision and curriculum support, and funding for one hour per week of tutoring with Jean Dresden while STUDENT in enrolled in the math prep course. A detailed description of the course was attached to the letter. (Dist. Exh. 2)
STUDENT’s parents decided not to enroll STUDENT in the math prep course, and instead, STUDENT resumed his tutoring relationship with Jean Dresden twice weekly in hour-long sessions, commencing on July 5, 2000, the same day STUDENT’s parents filed a request for a due process hearing. STUDENT’s math tutoring with Jean Dresden continued throughout the summer and fall and is continuing to date. The IEP team did not meet again until after the summer break.
By letter dated August 22, 2000, Polly Bove informed STUDENT’s parents of the District’s offer of placement for STUDENT in the team-taught Algebra I class for the 2000-2001 school year: “Although we have investigated other options including San Jose City College and several educational therapists, we believe that based on STUDENT’s assessment data including the WIAT, WRAT and SAT 9 as well as teacher reports, this is the best option for STUDENT to be successful in Algebra I.” The letter contained a notice of the August 29, 2000 IEP meeting, an agenda, a copy of Parent Rights and Procedural Safeguards for Special Education, updates of the goals and objectives from the June 5, 2000 IEP, and proposed revisions to the IEP. (Pet. Exh. KK)
At the IEP meeting held on August 29, 2000, the school-based IEP team recommended the team-taught Algebra I course for the 2000-2001 school year. The IEP document, signed by Polly Bove and Anne Hammond but not signed by STUDENT’s parents, also indicates that the District offered to fund STUDENT’s tutoring with Jean Dresden for one session per week. STUDENT’s parents did not accept the District’s offer and declined to enroll STUDENT in the Algebra I program. (Dist. Exh. 48)
To date, STUDENT has continued to meet with Jean Dresden for educational therapy and has not enrolled in a Lynbrook algebra class.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment from September 1999 through January 2000?
In accordance with the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” is one which provides special education and related services to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian that meets the State educational standards and conforms to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).
To determine whether the District provided or offered STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District’s placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program reflects STUDENT’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District has offered or provided a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in a greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. While the school district is required under Rowley to provide a child with a disability with a meaningful access to education, it does not require the district to guarantee success. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2nd Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. The Court stated that districts are only required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, at 207-08. However, a de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d cir. 1998).
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for STUDENT must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate educational placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comport with his IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Hearing Officer will now analyze the application of these requirements in regard to whether the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment in the area of algebra placement from September 1999 to January 2000, and whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment in the area of algebra placement for the summer 2000 and for the school year September 2000 to June 2001.
From September 1999 through January 2000 (1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs
To determine whether the math program the District provided to STUDENT was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the first step is to identify his needs. The parties are in agreement that STUDENT’s goal is to attend college and that successful completion of an algebra class is important for STUDENT to gain college admission. Neither party contends that STUDENT is incapable of learning algebra. Standardized assessments conducted of STUDENT in December 1998 and December 1999 place STUDENT in the average to above average range in math ability and achievement. STUDENT’s history of math instruction referred to in the factual background indicates that STUDENT has previously done well in regular math without any accommodations.
The parties agree that STUDENT’s preferred learning style emphasizes the visual and concrete over auditory and conceptual and that STUDENT has some Asperger’s characteristics: a difficulty with seeing the big picture (gestalt), and generalizing a math concepts from one problem to another. (Testimony of Sarah DeCarlo, Ms. Kosters, and Mr. Mansfield) The parties disagree over the extent of STUDENT’s Asperger’s Syndrome, and yet Ms. Kosters agrees that the diagnosis is “not a perfect fit, in that kids generally are attracted to him for friendship, and he is quite athletic.” (Pet. Exh. SSS)
The parties acknowledge STUDENT’s deficit in central auditory processing, but the parties also acknowledge that STUDENT has good number skills and strength in visual learning. (Testimony of Ms. Dresden and Mr. Mansfield)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s math placement for STUDENT during the fall 1999 contained the following characteristics: A regular algebra course taught during the first period of the day by a math teacher with forty-one years of experience(Footnote 3), within a small class of fifteen to eighteen students. The class included time for homework during class, and time for one-on-one assistance from a math teacher prior to and after class. The class was taught from a textbook and with the following visual and concrete techniques: The teacher and students used the blackboard for illustrations of problems. STUDENT was given additional support in October 1999 when the District added a tutorial class, supervised by the director of special education and supplemented by an instructional assistant who was available for individual tutoring.
With respect to the District’s math placement, the Petitioner contended throughout the due process hearing that STUDENT’s unique needs were not met in Mr. Mansfield’s class, and that STUDENT’s preferred visual and concrete learning style necessitated one-on-one private tutoring with Jean Dresden, who employed techniques that addressed STUDENT’s learning style and unique needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs were met within Mr. Mansfield’s Algebra I course in the fall 1999 for the following reasons. STUDENT needed a college preparatory algebra course taught by an experienced math teacher. The Algebra I course was a college preparatory algebra course and Mr. Mansfield had forty-one years of experience teaching math to students with a wide variety of aptitudes, skill levels, and learning styles. STUDENT needed a small class to help him stay on task and to reinforce new math concepts and their applications. (Testimony of Ms. Kosters) Mr. Mansfield’s class size of “fifteen or eighteen” students was small enough to provide STUDENT with needed individual attention and encouraged classroom participation.(Footnote 4) In fact, STUDENT did participate in classroom discussions, even though he sometimes volunteered incorrect answers. (Testimony of Mr. Mansfield) STUDENT also needed assistance with his math homework when he encountered algebraic problems, such as word problems, that were not sufficiently addressed in the classroom, given STUDENT’s learning style.The Hearing Officer also finds that the tutorial class added by the District after the October 20, 1999 IEP meeting, and prior to the point when STUDENT’s math performance began to slip (in early December, according to the testimony of Nancy McDonnell), met STUDENT’s need for assistance with his math homework. The tutorial class for special education students served as a study hall and was supervised by the director of special education and resource specialist, Nancy McDonnel, who had access to notes and scheduling for each student. Furthermore, the tutorial class allowed STUDENT time to complete homework assignments and ask for assistance. The tutorial also provided an instructional assistant, Bonnie Waxenbaum, who has a master’s degree in special education and was well-qualified to serve as an instructional assistant. Ms. Waxenbaum was available for students every day, upon request, both inside and outside the algebra classroom. Ms. Waxenbaum saw very few students, just one student every day and a second student frequently. (Testimony of Nancy McDonnel) Tutorial assistance was therefore available to STUDENT when STUDENT needed help with algebra problems or homework. Ms. McDonnel stated that Ms. Waxenbaum was available to work with students on exactly what they were working on in the classroom. Ms. McDonnel credibly testified that every time she tried to get STUDENT to use Ms. Waxenbaum’s help, STUDENT’s usual reply was that he was doing his math homework at home. Occasionally, Ms. Waxenbaum would sit next to STUDENT and have him demonstrate to her that he could do the math homework. (Testimony of Nancy McDonnel and Trudy Gross) The fact that STUDENT did not use the assistance offered by Mr. Mansfield, Ms. McDonnel and Ms.Waxenbaum does not detract from the placement provided by the District.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the visual and concrete teaching techniques employed by Mr. Mansfield, the use of a blackboard by the teacher and students during the class, was designed to meet STUDENT’s need for visual illustration of algebraic concepts. On those occasions when the techniques used by Mr. Mansfield were not sufficient to convey instruction to STUDENT, given STUDENT’s preferred visual and concrete learning style, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Mansfield’s offer of assistance before and after class for students who were having difficulty with homework or with the course material addressed, together with the assistance available from Ms. McDonnel and Ms. Waxenbaum, was sufficient to address STUDENT’s need for additional assistance.
STUDENT’s participation in an algebra class within a group setting also addressed a social need for STUDENT, particularly in light of STUDENT’s behavioral issues, and provided STUDENT with an opportunity to learn algebra concepts with peers in an interactive and concrete manner. Mr. Mansfield testified that his students were seated in small groups so that they could work together to help one another. Student teams also went to the blackboard to work on problems together. While students worked together on algebra problems, Mr. Mansfield circulated through the classroom to provide assistance.
Petitioner’s parents and witnesses called by Petitioner, particularly Jean Dresden and Diane Kosters, attempted to show that STUDENT could not learn algebra without employing methods used by Jean Dresden, which she said responded directly to STUDENT’s preferred learning style of visual and concrete. However, neither Ms. Kosters nor Ms. Dresden ever observed STUDENT perform in a classroom. Neither Ms. Kosters nor Ms. Dresden ever contacted STUDENT’s teachers. Neither individual ever spoke with the other. Ms. Kosters is not a teacher and does not have a credential. Ms. Dresden did not conduct formal assessments of STUDENT at any time while tutoring STUDENT in order to provide verification and support for the services she was rendering. Nor did Ms. Dresden, who is not certified as a nonpublic agency, substantiate the reliability of the tutoring methods she used with STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents contended that his declining grades for the second six-week grading period meant that STUDENT could not succeed in Mr. Mansfield’s class as formatted, and yet Ms. Dresden testified that a student who receives a poor grade can still receive an educational benefit. Ms. Dresden also testified in person that it would take STUDENT two years to complete algebra through her tutoring, but when she testified six weeks later by telephone, she recanted with a reasonable explanation and stated that she expected STUDENT to complete algebra through her tutoring within one year, by June 2001. (Testimony of Ms. Kosters and Ms. Dresden)
Polly Bove stated that she has thirteen years of experience in teaching math to students at all levels, including special education, and found Ms. Dresden’s use of cut paper and paper cups for tutoring STUDENT on equations to be confusing. Ms. Bove credibly testified that algebra is an important gateway course to other mathematics courses and that STUDENT needs to be able to learn from a variety of teaching modalities (auditory as well as visual and concrete) to experience the full class in preparation for college. She also testified that STUDENT’s visual learning style is not his disability and is not unusual.
The Hearing Officer also finds that even if Mr. Mansfield did not know that STUDENT had Asperger’s characteristics, such an omission by the District did not lead to a denial of FAPE. The credible evidence shows that the placement, including the class, the techniques, Mr. Mansfield’s wealth of teaching experience, and STUDENT’s opportunities for assistance both inside and outside the classroom, was an appropriate one designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.(Footnote 5) For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Mr. Mansfield’s Algebra I class was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
(2) Be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did achieve some educational benefit from the Algebra I placement as taught by Mr. Mansfield. STUDENT received a C grade for the first six weeks, and then received test scores of 34%, 40%, and 59%, at about the same time that STUDENT had begun tutoring with Ms. Dresden. Notwithstanding these declining scores, which led to a course grade of D for Algebra I, STUDENT had impressive overall study skills and organization and had learned large amounts of information even though he had achieved mastery in few areas, according to Ms. Dresden’s report dated December 2, 1999. Furthermore, STUDENT performed in the high average range for math achievement on the WRAT administered in December 1999, when STUDENT was well into Mr. Mansfield’s class, and at the time when STUDENT’s algebra class performance had started to slip in early December. Rowley requires that the placement be reasonably calculated for the student to receive meaningful educational benefit, not mastery or proficiency of the subject matter as the Petitioner, and Ms. Dresden, apparently believe. Resource specialist Nancy McDonnel testified persuasively that STUDENT achieved the following educational benefits from Mr. Mansfield’s algebra class: he earned credit in Algebra I with a passing grade; he increased his knowledge of Algebra I; and he had a chance to be educated in math with his nondisabled peers in a cooperative learning situation which he seemed to enjoy.
The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT had only been a member of Mr. Mansfield’s Algebra class for approximately five weeks before the student’s parents contacted Ms. Dresden without contacting the District or Mr. Mansfield. It is unclear whether STUDENT had lost his commitment to the Algebra I course and had stopped studying Algebra I once he began tutoring with Ms. Dresden. For example, Mr. Mansfield testified that when he asked STUDENT why he was no longer doing his homework in class, STUDENT replied that he was doing his homework with his tutor. Mr. Mansfield stated that STUDENT’s algebra test scores had begun to drop at that time. At some point, Ms. Dresden decided not to assist STUDENT in the algebra course, and at that point Ms. Dresden relied on her own techniques and tutored STUDENT on pre-algebra concepts. The exposure to different teaching methods, one from his algebra teacher and one from his tutor, each covering different material, may have led to confusion for STUDENT. And yet, STUDENT still managed to score in the average to above average range for math on the WRAT administered in December 1999, and the scores were such that STUDENT no longer had a significant math deficit for SLD. (Testimony of Trudy Gross) For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
(3) Comport with STUDENT’s IEP
The parties did not dispute this issue. However, the last agreed-upon placement, as expressed within the IEP addendum for the IEP meeting held on September 14, 1999, provided for math placement in the TSDC. The Hearing Officer finds that the District attempted, in good faith, to find individuals with math teaching experience for students with Asperger’s Syndrome, but the District was unsuccessful. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District and the parent’s mother verbally agreed to the placement in Mr. Mansfield’s Algebra class, a placement the Hearing Officer finds to have been an appropriate one for STUDENT’s unique needs.(Footnote 6)
(4) Be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE)
Certainly, a traditional Algebra I class taken with nondisabled peers without a resource aide in the classroom is the least restrictive environment. The fact that STUDENT had a one-to-one aide for behavioral and security reasons in Mr. Mansfield’s class does not diminish the nature of the placement provided by the District.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the period September 1999 through January 2000.
ISSUE NO. 2: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the Extended School Year (ESY) Summer 2000?
(1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs
The previous discussion concerning STUDENT’s unique needs is applicable to the summer program offered by the District. The Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a summer math program that met STUDENT’s needs--adequate preparation for the team-taught Algebra I class that the District had offered in the spring 2000 for the 2000-2001 school year. The program was set forth in detail in an attachment to the June 23, 2000 letter of Polly Bove to STUDENT’s parents. The program was designed to address STUDENT’s need for individualized attention in a small class setting with an opportunity to work with peers who were also experiencing difficulties in math. The math prep class was specifically designed to prepare the student for the fall Algebra I class. The District also offered STUDENT an instructional assistant “to ensure supervision and curriculum support.” Finally, the District offered to fund, for one hour per week, Jean Dresden’s tutoring program during STUDENT’s summer program. Petitioner contended that Jean Dresden’s one-on-one tutoring was the appropriate summer placement for STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the summer math program offered by the District was specifically designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
(2) Be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit
The previous discussion concerning the educational benefit provided by Mr. Mansfield’s class is applicable to the summer math program offered by the District. The program takes into account STUDENT’s unique needs, and even includes express provisions for an instructional assistant and funding, once per week, of Jean Dresden’s tutoring. In contrast, STUDENT’s parents insisted upon one-on-one tutoring with Jean Dresden twice per week without any classroom instruction with nondisabled peers. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of the math prep class was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
(3) Comport with STUDENT’s IEP
The parties did not dispute this issue. The IEP did not set forth a summer program, but merely indicated that the student qualified for ESY.
(4) Be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE)
The District’s offer of a math prep class was the least restrictive environment. The District attempted to accommodate the parents’ wishes and provide the student with some outside tutorial assistance. The Hearing Officer finds that the math prep summer program was the least restrictive environment.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the ESY summer 2000.
ISSUE NO. 3: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the period September 2000 to June 2001?
(1) Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs
The previous discussion concerning STUDENT’s unique needs is applicable to the algebra placement offer made by the District for the 2000-2001 school year. The District offered STUDENT a team-taught Algebra I placement class of approximately twenty-two students to be taught by Lorraine Cho, a credentialed regular education algebra teacher, and Phillip M. Wagner, a resource specialist at Lynbrook High School, reducing the teacher student ratio from approximately 20 to 1 (Mr. Mansfield’s class) to 10 or 11 to one. In addition, the District offered to fund, for one session per week, STUDENT’s ongoing tutoring with Jean Dresden. Moreover, STUDENT was also enrolled in a tutorial class to assist with all aspects of his educational program, including math.
Ms. Lorraine Cho and Mr. Phillip Wagner testified credibly concerning the characteristics of the team-taught Algebra I class offered by the District as STUDENT’s math placement for 2000-2001.
Ms. Cho, a credentialed math teacher, credibly described how she team-taught math with Mr. Wagner: She gave organized assignment sheets for students to keep track of where they are supposed to be, and provided note packets for every chapter so that the students had an organized set of notes. Ms. Cho also used an overhead so that the students could follow her as she gave illustrations for each type of problem. She then would gauge student feedback to determine if they understood or if there was further need for class discussion. If questions arose, she would give additional examples or different approaches. She allowed extra time for tests and quizzes as needed, and she would accommodate students who needed more time on homework or a shortened assignment. Ms. Cho also gave out mini-books, another form of notes in an organized way to cover main concepts. Students could then exercise creativity and decorate in their individual way. The mini-books were a quick reference tool that Ms. Cho allowed students to use for doing homework and for tests and quizzes. Accordingly, a student didn’t need to memorize concepts. Math games in groups were a way to give the students practice and helped the students get to know one another and to work together. The students were also given individual whiteboards, so that a student could be brave about trying to solve a problem, and the effort could then be erased. Ms. Cho also used pre-reading posters, held up for the students for about fifteen seconds, to help the students remember, in the form of a game. Students also were given a class set of books. Ms. Cho used playing cards to demonstrate concepts such as probability. Ms. Cho made sure students understood math vocabulary. Ms. Cho used silly putty to represent a variable in a math problem, which could then be formed to represent different shapes or lengths.
Resource Specialist Phillip W. Wagner testified that he had a Master’s degree from Stanford in the intern program, a Master’s degree in counseling from Santa Clara University and had taught at Lynbrook for thirty-five years. Mr. Wagner credibly described his role in the team-taught algebra class: He began the class with warm up questions to find out from the students which homework problems gave them trouble. He would review the problems and make sure they understood. Lorraine Cho would teach the new material. Mr. Wagner stated that having two teachers in the class was like having two parents; each teacher complemented the other and provided the students with different points of view. The team-taught course was composed of students with a variety of skill levels and needs, and the team addressed the course in three styles: visual (most of the students have this style), auditory, and hands on. At the hearing, Mr. Wagner demonstrated one way he teaches balancing and equations to students visually and concretely: by standing on a chair and shifting his weight and eliciting responses from the students. Mr. Wagner uses positive encouragement, and avoids calling a student to the board who does not understand. He also uses students’ names in problems and tells students, in attempting to help them to focus more, that if they catch him making any mistakes he will buy donuts for the kids. Students receive partial credit demonstrating the steps they take to solve problems on tests, quizzes and work in the classroom, even if they have gotten the wrong answer. Mr. Wagner indicated that he is available during the first and seventh periods if a student needs additional help, and that students also receive help in their resource class and tutorial.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s team-taught algebra placement offer for the 2000-2001 school year is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the following ways: The low student-teacher ratio of 10 or 11 to one ensures adequate and prompt individual attention to STUDENT during class that is supplemented by tutorial assistance outside of class. The visual and concrete supports used by Ms. Cho and Mr. Wagner within the team-taught algebra class presentations, together with the District’s offer to fund STUDENT’s ongoing tutoring with Jean Dresden for one session per week, address STUDENT’s preferred learning style. The Hearing Officer also finds that Ms. Cho and Mr. Wagner possessed a level of experience, training, and knowledge to meet STUDENT’s unique algebra needs.
In contrast, Ms. Kosters testified that she had never observed the team-taught Algebra class proposed by the District for the 2000-01 school year, was unaware of any testing of STUDENT performed by the District since April 1999, and had not seen STUDENT for over one year and a half. Ms. Kosters did not recommend that STUDENT take algebra outside of the regular classroom. Ms. Kosters testified that she had not attended any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings and that she did not have enough information to state whether STUDENT could learn algebra in the team-taught Algebra I class proposed by the District for the 2000-2001 school year, and that she did not know the characteristics of the class.
Anne Hammond, a Lynbrook resource specialist with a Master’s degree in special education and a credential in mild moderate disability, testified that she spent 2-1/2 hours discussing STUDENT’s Asperger’s characteristics with Michelle Garcia Winner, with whom the District contracted to provide specific instructions to District staff members regarding STUDENT’s visual learning style. Ms. Hammond stated that Ms. Winner gave information on the creation of web maps for students to put down ideas to connect visually, and to create outlines for long-term projects in a planner. Ms. Hammond testified that she was STUDENT’s seventh-period tutorial teacher during the second semester 1999. She described STUDENT as extremely social then, and noticed a growth in STUDENT’s maturity during the tutorial class she taught in school year 2000-2001. Ms. Hammond stated that STUDENT did not want any help in 1999, but sought help in the 2000-2001 school year, mostly in English and history, but also in math. Ms. Hamm described STUDENT as an extremely social student who liked to interact in class and who had learned to empathize, and had even apologized to her. Ms. Hammond stated that she had assisted STUDENT with some math word problems this year and that STUDENT understood her explanations that she presented in the same manner she would for any student.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement in algebra for the 2000-2001 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
(2) Be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit
The District’s offer at the August 29, 2000 IEP meeting effectively reduces the teacher-to-student ratio from 20 to 1 (which the Hearing Officer has already determined was adequate for STUDENT’s unique needs) to 10 or 11 to one. The chances of STUDENT’s success are increased thereby and the overall placement offer is calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. The District’s offer to fund, for one session per week, STUDENT’s tutoring with Jean Dresden addresses the parents’ concern that STUDENT’s visual and concrete learning style be supported in a one-to-one tutorial setting. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
(3) Comport with STUDENT’s IEP
The parties did not raise this issue. The District’s offer incorporates by reference the March 22, 2000 IEP, which details accommodations for STUDENT in terms of a quiet place to perform testing, as well as additional time to complete the testing.
(4) Be provided in the least restrictive environment (LRE)
The District’s offer provides for STUDENT’s attendance in a class room with nondisabled peers with a resource specialist who is able to assist STUDENT during the class if STUDENT develops difficulties with a problem or an algebra concept. The team-taught Algebra I program is certainly the LRE for STUDENT at this time. The insistence by STUDENT’s parents on a one-to-one tutorial with Jean Dresden without any classroom attendance represents the most restrictive environment, and deprives the student of the important educational benefits of association and interaction with peers in a group setting reasonably calculated to learn algebra.
For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the period September 2000 to June 2001.
ISSUE NO. 4: Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the services provided by educational therapist Jean Dresden, M.S., which the parents funded?
In light of the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment in the area of algebra placement for the period September 1999 through January 2000, and that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment in the area of algebra placement for the period ESY summer 2000 through the school year 2000-2001, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
On the first issue, the District prevailed.
On the second issue, the District prevailed.
On the third issue, the District prevailed.
On the fourth issue, the District prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).
DATED: February 9, 2000 _________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: The sole concern raised by Petitioner’s parents was the appropriateness of the algebra class placement provided by the District for the relevant periods, and not the overall placement or services received. Initially, the Petitioner raised a Family Education Rights and Privacy Act of 1974 (FERPA) issue and made a request for expenses and attorney’s fees, but the FERPA issue and the requests for expenses and fees are outside the scope of the Hearing Office’s jurisdiction. Petitioner did not develop at the hearing an issue stated initially concerning the District’s alleged failure to provide complete copies of Petitioner’s school records. Footnote 2: The District contends that since Jean Dresden is not certified to act as a nonpublic agency, the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to order prospective placement with Jean Dresden. In light of the decision that follows, there is no need to address this contention. Footnote 3: Mr. Mansfield testified that he has a master’s degree in math education and had taught at the high school level for forty-one years. He also testified that he used a variety of teaching methods: visual, auditory explanation, “a lot of” one-on-one tutoring during the class period, Socratic questioning (to make sure there is understanding), bonus quizzes, and more extensive tests over chapters to establish performance levels Footnote 4: Mr. Mansfield testified that the algebra class size was reduced from thirty or more students in prior years to fifteen or eighteen students in 1999. The Hearing Officer finds that this change, which benefitted all math students and STUDENT, is additional evidence of the District’s reasonable expectation that STUDENT could succeed in the regular algebra program at Lynbrook. Footnote 5: Mr. Mansfield testified that he was told that STUDENT was a special education student, but Mr. Mansfield did not review STUDENT’s IEP. Ms. McDonnel testified that she gave Mr. Mansfield Asperger’s information provided by MOTHER prior to STUDENT’s entry into the class. The June 3, 1999 document provides that all mainstream teachers be informed of STUDENT’s Asperger’s condition. Footnote 6: The fact that STUDENT’s mother felt that Mr. Mansfield’s class was an interim placement, and that the District believed that Mr. Mansfield’s class was “the” placement is not relevant to the Hearing Officer’s analysis. The relevant consideration is the nature of the algebra placement provided by the District and whether the placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and met other FAPE requirements
