California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 18, 1998

Student v. Newark Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1208-98 · Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare

Newark Unified's learning handicapped class is appropriate for student with cerebral palsy; IEP team must add safety, cleaning, and training plans.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of an eight-year-old girl with athetoid cerebral palsy and spastic quadriplegia requested a hearing. Newark Unified had proposed moving her from Linda Bowman's class for orthopedically handicapped students at Patterson Elementary, in the Fremont Unified School District, to Patricia Wright's special day class for learning handicapped students at Kennedy Elementary in Newark. In 1998 the Mission Valley SELPA stopped running classes, so each district became responsible for its own resident students. The Hearing Officer refused to add the SELPA as a party. He ruled that Fremont had no duty to educate a student who lived outside its boundaries. He also ruled that a denied interdistrict transfer must be appealed to the county board of education, not the Special Education Hearing Office. Fremont stayed in the case only to preserve stay put and was dismissed by the decision.

On the one issue heard, the Hearing Officer found the Newark class appropriate and in the least restrictive environment. The same therapists and services would continue. Ms. Wright was highly qualified and trained in the student's physical care. Ramps, mats, a changing table and classroom changes would meet her physical needs, and her mainstreaming would match her current program. However, he found gaps in emergency planning, daily cleaning of the room and mat, and training for her general education teachers. He ordered a transition of at least two weeks and an IEP meeting within two weeks to add plans for those gaps and update her goals.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a SELPA restructuring that ended classes shared across districts. It held that denials of interdistrict transfers go to the county board, not to a special education hearing. It also judged the proposed class by whether it would meet the student's needs with planned changes, not by whether it copied her current class.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedResponsible agency

    Issue Procedural. Fremont's motion to be dismissed as a party and Petitioner's motion to add the Mission Valley SELPA as a party, based on Petitioner's claim that she was entitled to stay in a Fremont class and had been improperly denied an interdistrict transfer

    After the SELPA plan was amended, neither Fremont nor the SELPA owed the non-resident student an education. Interdistrict transfer denials must be appealed to the county board of education, not SEHO. The motion to add the SELPA was denied, and Fremont stayed in the case only to preserve stay put and was dismissed by the decision.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Is Ms. Wright's learning handicapped class at Kennedy Elementary School in the Newark Unified School District an appropriate placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment for the remainder of the 1998-99 school year?

    The placement was designed to provide educational benefit, conformed to the IEP, met the LRE requirement, and generally met the student's unique needs. The Hearing Officer ordered limited IEP additions covering emergency plans, cleaning, and training of general education teachers.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. Ms. Wright's learning handicapped class at Kennedy Elementary School is an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for the remainder of the 1998-99 school year.
  • Transition from Ms. Bowman's class to Ms. Wright's class shall occur over a period of at least two weeks.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within two weeks of the decision, the IEP team shall meet and develop plans to (a) address emergencies involving the student, including when the school nurse is not available; (b) ensure appropriate cleaning of Ms. Wright's room and the student's mat; and (c) train the student's general education teachers. The plans are to be added to the IEP, and goals and objectives revised to reflect her recent progress.
  • Staff training. As part of the IEP plans, train the student's general education teachers in proper means to ensure her safety and comfort and in methods that address her learning strengths and weaknesses.
  • Fremont Unified School District dismissed as a party.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Clovis Unified School District v. California Office of Administrative Hearings; Education Code § 46600; Education Code § 46601; Education Code §§ 56195-56195.9

People named in the decision

  • Linda G. Bowman, special education teacher (orthopedically handicapped class); witness for Student, Patterson Elementary School, Fremont Unified School District
  • Patricia Wright, special education teacher (proposed learning handicapped special day class); witness for District, Kennedy Elementary School, Newark Unified School District
  • Leslie A. Koelsch, director of special education; witness for District, Newark Unified School District
  • Russ Riley, program specialist, Newark Unified School District
  • Amy Roman, augmentative communication and technology specialist; witness for District, ACTS (certified nonpublic agency)
  • Amy Wilman, augmentative communication provider (named once; possibly the same person as Amy Roman), ACTS
  • Carol Viegelmann, principal; witness for District, Kennedy Elementary School, Newark Unified School District
  • Claudia Riley, adaptive physical education (APE) specialist; witness for District, Newark Unified School District
  • Linda Marie Anderson, school nurse, Kennedy Elementary School, Newark Unified School District
  • Ann Padover, consultant representing District, Newark Unified School District
  • Bridget A. Flanagan, attorney for Fremont Unified and Mission Valley SELPA, Miller, Brown & Dannis
  • ACTS, nonpublic agency providing augmentative communication services
  • California Children's Services (CCS), occupational and physical therapy provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Edwin Villmoare, Chief Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Newark, California, on November 17 and 18, 1998.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Maureen L. Fox. Also present on STUDENT’S behalf were her parents, FATHER and MOTHER OF STUDENT . Respondent Newark Unified School District was represented by consultant Ann Padover. Also present on Newark’s behalf was Dr. Leslie A. Koelsch, director of special education, and Russ Riley, program specialist. Respondent Fremont Unified School District was represented by attorney Bridget A. Flanagan of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Ms. Flanagan also appeared on behalf of the Mission Valley SELPA to address Petitioner’s motion to add the Mission Valley SELPA as a party. (See the discussion under Procedural Matters, below.)

The following witnesses testified for Petitioner: FATHER OF STUDENT, and Linda G. Bowman, special education teacher at Patterson Elementary School in the Fremont Unified School District.

The following witnesses testified for Respondent Newark Unified School District: Amy Roman, augmentative communication and technology specialist; Carol Viegelmann, principal of Kennedy Elementary School; Claudia Riley, adaptive physical education (APE) specialist; Patricia Wright, special education teacher; and Leslie E. Koelsch.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for the submission of written closing briefs. Only Respondent Newark Unified School District submitted a brief. The record was then closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the outset of the proceeding, the Hearing Officer was called upon to address two pending motions: (1) Fremont’s motion to be dismissed as a party, and (2) Petitioner’s motion to add the Mission Valley SELPA as a party. (Footnote 1) The dispute underlying the two motions involved Petitioner’s claim that, although a resident of the Newark District, she was entitled to continue her education in Ms. Bowman’s class for the orthopedically handicapped located on the campus of the Patterson Elementary School in the Fremont District.

Pursuant to Education Code §§ 56195-56195.9, each school district is required to participate in a state-approved local special education plan and a structure or entity to implement the plan. This structure or entity is commonly referred to as a Special Education Local Plan Area or SELPA. Usually, a SELPA is created and operated by a consortium of contiguous school districts although, in some instances, county offices of education or individual school districts serve as SELPAs. SELPAs must perform a number of specific duties enumerated by statute. These mandatory duties do not include the provision of direct special education to individual students within the SELPA. SELPAs may provide such services but are not required to do so. Education Code §§ 56195.5 and 56195.7. SELPAs that do provide direct special education may designate a particular class in one school district as a SELPA class, making that class available to eligible students from all districts within the SELPA. When a SELPA plan includes provisions for direct special education, nothing in the law prohibits the school districts operating the SELPA from rescinding these provisions. In the absence of a SELPA agreement providing for direct services, a student from one district may attend a class in another district, but only pursuant to an interdistrict transfer. Education Code § 46600.

During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT attended Ms. Bowman’s class for the orthopedically handicapped in the Fremont District. This class was operated by the Mission Valley SELPA, which serves, inter alia, both the Newark and the Fremont Districts. In the spring of 1998, the SELPA was restructured by its member districts. As part of this restructuring, the SELPA no longer operated classes as of the beginning of the 1998-99 school year. Instead, each school district within the Mission Valley SELPA now has full responsibility for the education of all special education students residing within its boundaries. Fremont Exhibit 1.

In the spring of 1998, under the new SELPA plan, Fremont proposed to return STUDENT to Newark for the 1998-99 school year, and Newark proposed to place STUDENT in Ms. Patricia Wright’s class at its Kennedy Elementary School. The return of STUDENT to Newark was temporarily blocked by the filing of this case and the requirements of stay put. Education Code § 56505(b). In the meantime, STUDENT’S parents requested an interdistrict transfer to allow her to stay in Ms. Bowman’s class for the 1998-99 school year. Newark denied the transfer.

In its motion, Fremont correctly argued that, absent an obligation such as the one it had previously assumed pursuant to the rescinded provisions of the now amended SELPA plan, it has no duty to educate a student such as STUDENT, who resides outside of its boundaries. Education Code § 48200. The SELPA correctly argued that the amended SELPA plan relieved it of any future obligation to educate STUDENT. Education Code §§ 56195.5 and 56195.7. Fremont and the SELPA correctly pointed out that Petitioner has made no claim against either for inappropriate past educational services that might give rise to retroactive relief under Education Code § 56501(a).

Petitioner argued that even if Fremont has no obligation to educate STUDENT pursuant to the newly amended SELPA plan, Newark, and possibly Fremont, had improperly denied STUDENT an interdistrict transfer. However, interdistrict transfers are largely a matter of discretion and require the consent of both districts involved. Education Code § 46600. In any case, a challenge to the denial of an interdistrict transfer must be directed to the appropriate County Board of Education pursuant to Education Code § 46601. Review of a denial of an interdistrict transfer is not a special education matter, and it is not within the jurisdiction of the Special Education Hearing Office. Education Code § 56501(a).

Accordingly, at the outset of the proceeding, the Hearing Officer concluded that Petitioner had stated no claim for relief against either the Fremont District or the SELPA that the Special Education Hearing Office could adjudicate. The Hearing Officer, therefore, denied the motion to add the SELPA as a party. However, because the Fremont District had agreed to serve as the stay put placement pursuant to Education Code § 56505(d), the Hearing Officer retained the Fremont District as a party for the limited purpose of preserving stay put. The Hearing Officer determined that jurisdiction over Fremont would end with the issuance of this decision. At that time, Fremont would be dismissed as a party. Petitioner’s education would then become the sole responsibility of the Newark District and any placement ordered by the decision would become the new stay put placement. Clovis Unified School District v. California Office of Administrative Hearings, 903 F.2nd 635 (9th Cir. 1990).

ISSUE

Is Ms. Wrights’ learning handicapped class at Kennedy Elementary School in the Newark Unified School District an appropriate placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment for the remainder of the 1998-99 school year? (Footnote 2)

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

The parties agree that STUDENT’S IEP, including all related services specified in the IEP, is appropriate, except that certain goals and objectives require updating to reflect STUDENT’S recent rapid progress. The parties agree that STUDENT will continue to receive in the placement proposed by Newark the same occupational and physical therapy services from California Children’s Services (CCS) that she currently receives, and that the providers of those services will be the same individuals. Further, the parties agree that STUDENT will receive the same augmentative communication services from Ms. Amy Wilman of ACTS that she currently receives and the same type and frequency of APE and speech and language services that she is currently receiving.

The core of the dispute involves Ms. Wright’s class at Kennedy Elementary School. Petitioner argues that Ms. Wrights’s class will not meet her physical needs, that the composition of Ms. Wright’s class and Ms. Wright’s teaching techniques will not adequately address STUDENT’S learning difficulties, and that the proposed placement is too restrictive. The District argues that the proposed placement will meet all of STUDENT’S physical needs, will address her learning difficulties with more individualization and greater teacher expertise than she is currently receiving, and is not restrictive because it will provide STUDENT with a full range of appropriate mainstream and reverse mainstream activities.

FACTS

The significant facts in this case are not in dispute.

STUDENT is an eight-year-old girl who resides with her parents within the Newark Unified School District. STUDENT is eligible for special education as the result of athetoid cerebral palsy and spastic quadriplegia. STUDENT also has visual/perceptual learning difficulties which have caused delays in academic achievement.

Under the prior SELPA plan, for school years 1995-96 and 1996-97, STUDENT attended a special day class for the physically handicapped located at the Millard School in the Fremont District. For the 1997-98 school year, the IEP team assigned STUDENT to Ms. Bowman’s class. For the 1998-99 school year, in accord with the new SELPA plan, the IEP team proposed to return STUDENT to Newark, her district of residence, and to place her in the third grade in the special day class for the learning handicapped of Ms. Patricia Wright, located at Kennedy Elementary School in the Newark District. As noted above, STUDENT is currently attending Ms. Bowman’s class for the orthopedically handicapped with inclusion in a regular education second grade reading class at the Patterson Elementary School in the Fremont District pursuant to a stay put order.

STUDENT’S educational needs are numerous and substantial. STUDENT has extremely limited motor control. During most of the school day, STUDENT sits in her wheel chair or in a favorite red bolster chair or lies on a rug on the floor of the classroom. She needs materials on the class walls posted low so that she can see them. STUDENT is working on the ability to stand at a specially designed table. She can manage to stand at this table for only a few minutes at a time. She periodically needs to have her muscles stretched. Her athetoid cerebral palsy produces sudden, unpredictable involuntary movements that require her to be carefully repositioned. STUDENT is almost entirely dependent on adult assistance for toileting. In the now relatively rare instance when she has a bowel or bladder accident, a changing table with a clean set of clothes must be readily available in a nearby bathroom.

STUDENT is not able to move her wheel chair, and has not acquired the skills to operate a mechanized one. STUDENT is entirely dependent on others to move her within the classroom, and about the school. She is currently moved by adults and by "wheel chair pushers" -- carefully selected and trained nondisabled peers.

STUDENT is unable to express herself orally. However, she produces spontaneous unintelligible utterances which appear to represent specific words. For the last several years, she has used a "delta talker," an augmentative communication device that allows her to select from a menu of words the talker then articulates for her. STUDENT is now learning to use a "dyna box," a similar but more sophisticated augmentative communication device. Given her communication challenges, STUDENT needs extra time to express herself, especially when a question is directed to the class generally.

STUDENT faces a number of other specific challenges. While she does not require a tube for feeding, she must struggle to chew and swallow, and must be carefully monitored while eating. She needs a relatively warm environment to avoid painful muscle contractions. Her visual/perceptual problems require that she be taught primarily through auditory modalities with supplemental visual reinforcement. She needs visual enhancements, such as large lettering with extra space between words. She also needs tactile or sensory experiences involving touch and taste.

Despite her serious disabilities, STUDENT has great strengths. She is intensely social and has the ability to form friendships with disabled and nondisabled children and adults alike. She is determined to communicate and is a motivated student. She possesses a good sense of humor, an excellent memory, and above-average cognitive and receptive language skills.

In her current placement in Ms. Bowman’s class, STUDENT is able to mix with her nondisabled peers for reading, recess, science and computer labs, lunch, physical education, and school-wide events such as assemblies and parties.

Newark’s proposed placement, Ms. Wright’s special day class, is geared primarily for learning disabled children. One of the eight students STUDENT would join in that class has cerebral palsy and is generally confined to a wheel chair, although her cerebral palsy is less severe than STUDENT’S. None of the other children have physical disabilities. The proposed class, with STUDENT in it, would include nine students ranging from eight to twelve years old. STUDENT would be the youngest. Two of the other students read at STUDENT’S level. The classroom is not as spacious as STUDENT’S current classroom, nor is it arranged primarily to meet the needs of the severely orthopedically impaired. Most students work at standard school desks. Furniture would need to be arranged to accommodate STUDENT’S wheel chair. When Ms. Bowman visited the classroom, the temperature of the room was too cool for STUDENT because the school furnace was in need of repair. The repair has been made and the room is now sufficiently warm. A space heater is available to increase the warmth in the room if necessary.

The toilet that STUDENT would use is located just outside Ms. Wright’s classroom, and a pull-down table will be added if STUDENT attends the class. With the table down, the bathroom is a bit cramped, but there is sufficient room to maneuver to meet STUDENT’S toileting needs. The classroom is not carpeted. Ms. Wright uses a mat for the one child with cerebral palsy, and proposes to use the same or a similar mat for STUDENT. Selected events would be held on the mats so that the students who are not physically disabled can join STUDENT and the other child with cerebral palsy on the floor.

Ms. Wright’s class at the present time may have too many distracting documents on the wall for STUDENT to process. Items currently on the wall are too high for STUDENT to view effectively. Ms. Wright indicated that she will make appropriate adjustments to these materials and to their location for STUDENT.

Part of the school may not yet be wheel-chair accessible for STUDENT. However, ramps will be immediately added if STUDENT matriculates at Kennedy. STUDENT’S school day at Kennedy will last from 8:15 am to 2:15 pm, approximately one hour longer than her current placement.

STUDENT will be able to attend all class and school-wide events, including plays, assemblies, science field trips, and fine arts programs. She will also have access to computers, the school library, and science labs. A "wheel chair pusher" program for nondisabled students to assist STUDENT may be initiated at Kennedy, if appropriate.

STUDENT’S proposed teacher, Ms. Patricia Wright, holds the California Multi-subjects Credential, a California Special Services Credential for the Severely Handicapped, and a California Behavior Management Specialist Certification. She has worked as a special day class teacher, a special education program specialist, and a mentor teacher. In the past, she has worked with children with athetoid cerebral palsy and spina bifida who needed complete toileting assistance and careful handling. She has a three-year-old son who suffers from athetoid cerebral palsy. When at home, she feeds and moves her son. She has observed STUDENT in her current placement, conferred with Ms. Bowman, and recently received training from the school nurse, Ms. Linda Marie Anderson, in the care and handling of children with cerebral palsy (as have two school aides and the school principal, Ms. Carol Viegelmann). Ms. Wright describes her teaching approach as involving multiple modalities selected to reflect individual needs. She modifies her curriculum to meet the needs of the individual students. For STUDENT, Ms. Wright recognizes the need to emphasize an auditory approach while working to strengthen STUDENT’S visual/perceptual capabilities. Ms. Wright proposes to use manipulatives to improve STUDENT’S fine motor hand control, and to help her understanding of basic mathematics.

The APE teacher proposed for STUDENT, Ms. Claudia Riley, has worked with approximately twelve students with cerebral palsy during her career, and last year worked with three students with athetoid cerebral palsy. She has received training from the school nurse, Ms. Anderson, in proper techniques for lifting and moving STUDENT. She has also consulted with STUDENT’S CCS physical therapist concerning correct techniques for positioning, stretching, and lifting STUDENT. CCS will provide ongoing consultation to both Ms. Wright and Ms. Riley.

Ms. Anderson, the school nurse, has a B.A. in Nursing and a Masters of Science in Environmental and Health Education. She is a registered nurse with a Public Health Certificate and a School Nurse Service Credential. She will be available to support STUDENT’S teachers, aides, and related service providers and to provide health services.

Ms. Amy Roman, employed by ACTS, a certified nonpublic agency, currently provides STUDENT with her augmentative communication services and will continue to do so if STUDENT joins Ms. Wright’s class. Ms. Roman will work with Ms. Wright, STUDENT and the classroom aides in the use of the "dyna box." Ms. Roman has a Master of Arts in Speech and Language Pathology and a Rehabilitative Service Credential.

Newark proposes a two-week transition for STUDENT. During the two weeks, the staff at Kennedy would continue their consultations with Ms. Bowman and STUDENT’S related service providers. STUDENT would visit her new class to get acquainted and acclimated, and Kennedy would complete proposed physical accommodations for STUDENT by adding the fold-down table in the bathroom that services Ms. Wrights’s class and by adding ramps throughout the school where appropriate.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and comparable state law, students with disabilities have a right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standard of the state education agency and conforms with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). "Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term "related services" includes transportation and other services, such as occupational therapy and speech-language services, that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program."

In Board of Education of Hendrik Hudson Central Valley District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services which must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA (now IDEA 1997). The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services, or that the special education maximize the student’s potential. The Court stated that "the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 201 .

In determining whether a district has offered a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987). If the district’s program is adequate, the district has offered a free appropriate public education, even if the parents prefer another program, and even if the parents’ preferred program is better (that is, would likely result in greater educational benefit to the child than the district’s program). Id.

Special Education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). U.S. Code § 1412(a)(5)(A) provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

Thus, special education statutory law and the Rowley decision taken together establish a four part test for analyzing whether a school district’s proposed placement satisfies IDEA: (1) whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to the student; (2) whether the placement is designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (3) whether the placement conforms with the student’s IEP; and (4) whether the placement satisfies the LRE mandate.

1. Is the District’s Proposed Placement Designed to Provide Educational Benefit?

STUDENT’S IEP calls for her to receive services that will assist her to improve her communication and motor skills, and advance her academic skills and knowledge across a broad domain that includes reading, math, spelling, and general information.

Under the District’s proposal, STUDENT will continue to receive the same augmentative communication services provided by the same specialist, Ms. Roman, that she is currently receiving at Patterson. STUDENT will also continue to receive speech and language services to improve receptive and expressive language skills, including the formulation of sentences and the improvement of phonetic discriminations. STUDENT has progressed from the delta talker to the more sophisticated dyna box. Given STUDENT’S previous success and the continued use of the same augmentative communication specialist and the ongoing delivery of speech and language services, it is more likely than not that STUDENT will continue to make progress in communication.

STUDENT’S motor skills will continue to be addressed in exactly the same manner that they are currently being addressed. In the case of occupational therapy and physical therapy, STUDENT will be working with the same CCS providers. The parties have acknowledged that STUDENT is making appropriate progress in the area of motor skills at Patterson. The provision of the same related services and, in some cases the use of the same CCS providers, establishes the likelihood that she will continue to make progress with her motor skills.

Petitioner questions whether Ms. Wright’s class can confer academic benefit. Ms. Wright is an appropriately credentialed, highly-experienced teacher. She individualizes her curriculum for each of her students. STUDENT has a visual/perceptual problem that can be effectively addressed in a class for those with learning disabilities. Ms. Wright understands STUDENT’S learning modalities, including her auditory and memory strengths. Ms. Wright testified that she would teach to STUDENT’S strengths, while working on her visual/perceptual capabilities. Ms. Wright also testified that she would use tactile modalities, as recommended by Ms. Bowman. Ms. Wright will have two aides to assist her in her class. STUDENT will be mainstreamed for reading and math, as called for by her IEP. Newark plans no changes to STUDENT’S IEP, except to update certain goals and objectives. It is true that STUDENT will be the youngest student in Ms. Wright’s class. Merely being the youngest student is not necessarily a major drawback. STUDENT is a determined and motivated student who quickly establishes a friendly rapport with children and adults. Moreover, two of the students in Ms. Wright’s class read at STUDENT’S level and, therefore, STUDENT will have access to academically similar peers. The record establishes the likelihood that STUDENT will make academic progress in the placement proposed by Newark.

Given STUDENT’S prior success, Newark’s plan to adhere to STUDENT’S IEP, the replication of STUDENT’S current related services, Ms. Wright’s qualifications and plans to adjust her curriculum to STUDENT’S academic level and learning modalities, and STUDENT’S own eagerness to learn, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement is designed to confer educational benefit upon STUDENT.

2. Is the District’s Placement Designed to Address STUDENT’S Unique Needs?

Petitioner’s objections to the District’s placement concern primarily STUDENT’S safety, comfort, and self-esteem. STUDENT is now in an orthopedically handicapped class that has been carefully designed to address all such concerns within a single room. Ms. Wrights’s classroom and the activities of that class have not been designed with such a purpose in mind. However, the question is not whether Ms. Wright’s classroom replicates Ms. Bowman’s classroom. Rather, the question is whether Ms. Wright’s class, with modifications and proposed modifications, will adequately address STUDENT’S needs.

The basic characteristics of Ms. Wright’s class are as follows: The class will have three full-time instructors for a class of nine students, two of whom (including STUDENT) will have severe orthopedic impairments. The classroom is sufficiently warm for STUDENT, and the school has the capacity to augment the temperature with a space heater. Mats will be available for STUDENT and the other student with cerebral palsy to stretch out on. Selected class events will be moved to the mats to ensure that the two students with cerebral palsy do not feel isolated there. The bathroom that STUDENT will use is just outside the classroom door and will have added a fold-down table and a change of clothes for STUDENT. The location of the furniture in the classroom will be adjusted to accommodate STUDENT’S wheel chair. Ms. Wright and the other staff who will interact with STUDENT have been trained in her basic physical needs, including positioning and toileting. Ramps will be installed to guarantee STUDENT’S access to all rooms in the school that she might enter. Newark officials are exploring the possibility of bringing STUDENT’S favorite red bolster chair with her or providing her with a comparable chair. Ms. Wright has indicated that she will accommodate STUDENT’S need for material located low on the class walls, and will produce this material in enlarged print.

Ms. Wright has consulted with Ms. Bowman, and will continue to do so during the transition and as necessary thereafter. Ms. Wright indicates that she will initiate a "wheelchair pusher" program similar to Ms. Bowman’s. In the meantime, only Ms. Wright and her aides will push STUDENT’S wheel chair. The school nurse is readily available for emergencies and supplemental staff training. Ms. Viegelmann is being trained as a back up to assist with STUDENT’S physical needs. Ms. Riley, the APE teacher, has received training in the positioning, stretching and lifting of STUDENT, and will work to see that STUDENT receives appropriate APE and physical education.

The Petitioner complains specifically that the bathroom STUDENT will use is small and outside the classroom; the classroom is without windows and will be more densely occupied than STUDENT’S present classroom; Ms. Wright’s classroom does not contain a kitchen or refrigerator; Ms. Wright’s classroom does not have a specific carpeted area; and Ms. Wright’s classroom is not as "homey" as Ms. Bowman’s.

While factually accurate, none of these criticisms is fatal. The bathroom, even when the fold-down table is added, will be adequate in size. There was no showing that STUDENT needs a bathroom located within her classroom, or that the absence of windows will impair her enthusiasm or ability to learn. The size of Ms. Wright’s classroom means that Ms. Wright will have to move furniture to accommodate the use of mats, and will have to develop procedures to ensure the physical safety of STUDENT and the other child with cerebral palsy when they are on the mats. Ms. Wright indicated an awareness of these needs and her intent to fully meet them. Two refrigerators for food and snacks are located close to Ms. Wright’s classroom. The lack of a carpeted area, while less than ideal for STUDENT, should not prevent Ms. Wright from using mats effectively to achieve the results similar to those achieved in Ms. Bowman’s classroom. A less "homey," more traditional atmosphere is merely a different environment from what STUDENT is currently experiencing, not a worse one. There is no evidence to suggest that STUDENT cannot adjust to such a placement relatively quickly and happily. In short, Newark’s proposal adequately addresses STUDENT’S physical needs, including those for safety and comfort, by continuing with all of STUDENT’S related services and by modifying Ms. Wright’s classroom and the school itself appropriately.

STUDENT’S self-esteem will depend in part on curriculum adaptation, in which Ms. Wright is an expert, and on the rapidity with which STUDENT feels accepted and makes friends. The Hearing Officer was persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Wright, Ms. Riley, and Ms. Viegelmann that they genuinely look forward to working with STUDENT and will take all reasonable steps to make her feel welcome. STUDENT’S attendance at all school-wide events will add to her sense of welcome. STUDENT’S sociability and intense drive to make friends, along with her history of acquiring a wide range of diverse friends, almost ensures that she will quickly acquire new friends. The record establishes the likelihood that STUDENT’S self-esteem will be preserved in Ms. Wright’s class and can be reasonably be expected to grow. Therefore, the District’s proposal adequately addresses STUDENT’S needs in the area of self-esteem.

In terms of STUDENT’S specific academic needs, Ms. Wright will, as discussed above under Educational Benefit, modify STUDENT’S curriculum and materials to reflect her strengths and weaknesses. Ms. Wright testified persuasively that she will develop ground rules to allow STUDENT time to answer questions and participate in class discussions. Ms. Wright and her aides will work with Ms. Roman to expand STUDENT’S use of the dyna box. STUDENT will be mainstreamed into reading and math classes as called for by her IEP. Ms. Wright will develop written materials that address STUDENT’S visual/perceptual problems. The record clearly establishes that the District’s proposal adequately addresses STUDENT’S academic needs.

Several questions remain concerning STUDENT’S unique needs. It is unclear exactly how Ms. Wright and school staff will respond to an emergency such as choking over food lodged in the throat, particularly in the absence or unavailability of Ms. Anderson. Ms. Bowman testified persuasively that STUDENT’S classroom and the mat which she uses must be cleaned daily to ensure sure that STUDENT, who is highly susceptible to colds and flu, is reasonably protected. Finally, the District gave little indication how STUDENT’S regular education teachers for reading and math will learn to accommodate her need for safety and comfort, as well as her visual/perceptive difficulties. For STUDENT’S placement to fully address her needs, the District must develop plans to address these specific concerns.

Based on the above discussion, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement is designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs appropriately, except with regard to certain possible emergencies, the cleaning of Ms. Wright’s classroom and STUDENT’S mat, and the training of STUDENT’S regular education teachers.

3. Does the District’s Proposed Placement Comport with STUDENT’S IEP?

As indicated above, the Newark proposal includes all the ingredients called for in STUDENT’S IEP. Therefore, as a matter of law, the proposed placement comports with STUDENT’S IEP.

4. Does the District’s Proposed Placement Satisfy the LRE Mandate?

The LRE mandate references education with nondisabled children. In the District’s proposed placement, STUDENT will receive the regular education with nondisabled peers called for in her IEP. Moreover, she will be included in all school-wide activities and events. The District’s proposed placement is comparable in this regard to Ms. Bowman’s class. Petitioner did not identify other significant events or situations in which STUDENT should be educated with nondisabled peers. The District’s proposed placement comports with the LRE mandate.

* * *

Given the conclusion that Ms. Wright’s class at the Kennedy Elementary School generally meets the criteria for free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment, the Hearing Officer concludes that the class is an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT for the remainder of the 1998-99 school year. The Hearing Officer further concludes that the two-week transition plan proposed by the District adequately reflects STUDENT’S needs, provides adequate preparation time, and is, therefore, appropriate. However, as discussed above, the District must develop plans to address possible physical emergencies, the cleaning of Ms. Wright’s class and STUDENT’S mat, and the training of the regular education teachers from whom STUDENT will receive mainstream classes.

ORDER

1. Ms. Wright’s learning handicapped class at Kennedy Elementary School is an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for STUDENT for the remainder of the l998-99 school year.

2. STUDENT’S transition from Ms. Bowman’s class to Ms. Wright’s class shall occur over a period of at least two weeks.

3. Within two weeks of the date of this decision, the IEP team shall meet and develop plans to: (a) address emergencies that might arise involving STUDENT, including emergencies that might arise when the school nurse is not available; (b) ensure the appropriate cleaning of Ms. Wright’s room and STUDENT’S mat; and (c) train STUDENT’S regular education teachers in proper means to ensure her safety and comfort and in appropriate methodologies to accommodate and address her learning strengths and weaknesses. The IEP team shall incorporate these plans into STUDENT’S IEP. The IEP team shall also revise STUDENT’S IEP goals and objectives to reflect her recent progress.

4. The Fremont Unified School District is dismissed as a party.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided, except to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer ordered modifications to STUDENT’S IEP to address certain possible physical emergencies, the cleaning of Ms. Wrights’s classroom and STUDENT’S mat, and the means by which STUDENT’S regular education teachers in reading and math will learn to ensure her comfort and safety, and address her learning strengths and weaknesses.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: Dec. 18, 1998 Edwin Villmoare Chief Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

CASE NO. SN 1208-98 Footnotes: 1. Ordinarily, a Petitioner is free to name any Respondent, and a Respondent must then make a motion if it seeks to be dismissed. In the instant case, Petitioner formally moved to add the SELPA at the last minute. Whether this matter is viewed as a motion to add the SELPA, or as the addition of the SELPA followed by a motion to dismiss the SELPA, the result reached is the same. 2. Once the two motions had been ruled on, only this issue remained to be adjudicated.