California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 12, 1998
Student v. Minarets Joint Union High School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1220-97 · Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson
Minarets Joint Union High School District, as the parents' district of residence, is responsible for a deaf student's education; Sierra and San Ramon dismissed.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The FAPE issues, including CSDF's proposed discharge, were split off and left pending. The case continues as STUDENT v. Minarets Joint Union High School District and the California School for the Deaf, Fremont (SN 1220-97). Before this decision, on January 29, 1998, the Hearing Office denied a request by San Ramon and Sierra to stop the California Department of Education from holding an IEP meeting to move the student to a nonpublic school.
Summary
A 17-year-old student was eligible for special education as deaf and seriously emotionally disturbed. She filed for due process after the California School for the Deaf, Fremont (CSDF) moved to discharge her. Minarets Joint Union High School District filed its own case, and the Hearing Officer combined the two. The student stayed at CSDF under stay put, and the Hearing Officer first decided which school district was responsible for her education in 1997-98. Her parents live within Minarets. During the week she lived in a certified foster home run by a relative near CSDF, inside San Ramon Valley Unified.
Minarets argued that its 1995 Master Service Agreement with Sierra Unified made Sierra responsible, because the agreement let Minarets students attend Sierra High School. The Hearing Officer disagreed. The agreement only guaranteed Minarets students a place at Sierra High, and this student had never attended school in Sierra. Sierra's earlier claim of responsibility did not bind it, because Minarets showed no harm from relying on that claim. Minarets also argued that a state hospital stay and the foster home placement moved responsibility to San Ramon. The Hearing Officer found the hospital stay was an evaluation, not a permanent placement. County Mental Health had arranged the foster home under the student's IEP as part of her educational placement. Minarets, as the district of residence, was ordered to serve as her LEA, and Sierra and San Ramon were dismissed.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the parent-residence rule under Education Code § 48200 and Government Code § 7579.1. A blanket interdistrict attendance agreement did not shift special education responsibility. A foster home arranged by county mental health under the IEP did not make the foster home's district responsible.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedResponsible agency
Issue I. Which local educational agency (LEA) is responsible for providing STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year -- Minarets, Sierra, or San Ramon?
Minarets, as the parents' district of residence, is the responsible LEA. The Minarets-Sierra Master Service Agreement only guaranteed attendance at Sierra High School, and Sierra was not estopped because Minarets showed no detrimental reliance. The evaluative state hospital stay and the foster home arranged by Mental Health under the IEP did not shift responsibility to San Ramon under Gov. Code § 7579.1(b).
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Minarets shall assume the responsibilities of the local educational agency in providing the student's education for the 1997-98 school year, consistent with federal and state special education law.
- Sierra Unified and San Ramon Valley Unified are dismissed as parties. The remainder of the case continues as STUDENT v. Minarets Joint Union High School District and the California School for the Deaf, Fremont, SN 1220-97.
Key authorities
California Government Code § 7579.1(b); California Education Code § 56155; California Education Code § 48200; California Education Code § 59020; California Civil Code §§ 1636, 1638, 1647; Valdez v. Federal Mut. Ins. Co. (1969) 272 Cal.App.2d 223; Amarawansa v. Superior Court (1996) 49 Cal.App.4th 1251
People named in the decision
- Dr. Philip O. Pendley, superintendent; witness, Minarets Joint Union High School District
- Bryan Martin, attorney observer, Stroup & de Goede
- Dr. Don Witzansky, superintendent; witness, Sierra Unified School District
- Barbara Thomas, SELPA director; witness, Fresno County Special Education Local Plan Area
- Camille Giometti-May, program manager; witness, Madera County Office of Education
- Robert G. Hansen, former superintendent of Minarets' predecessor district; witness, Minarets (former)
- Lissa Vasquez, school psychologist; witness, Sierra Unified School District
- Pat Mazman, county mental health case manager; witness, Madera County Mental Health
- Malisa Cochran, SELPA program specialist; witness, Contra Costa County SELPA
- Joyce Eckrem, school representative (did not attend), California School for the Deaf, Fremont
- Families First, agency that assisted with foster home certification
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
The issue regarding the responsible local educational agency in this matter was heard before Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in North Fork, California, on November 14, 1997, and in Madera, California, on December 8, 1997.
STUDENT was represented at the hearing by her mother, Ms. PARENT.
Minarets Joint Union High School District (hereafter Minarets) was represented at the hearing by attorney Raymond W. Dunne, of the law firm of Stroup & de Goede. Attorney Bryan Martin was present on November 14, 1997, as an observer from the same law firm. Also present on Minaret's behalf was Dr. Philip O. Pendley, Minarets superintendent.
Sierra Unified School District (hereafter Sierra) was represented at the hearing by attorney Thomas Riggs, of the law firm of Lozano Smith Smith Woliver & Behrens. Also present on Sierra's behalf were Dr. Don Witzansky, Sierra superintendent, and Barbara Thomas, director of the Fresno County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA).
San Ramon Valley Unified School District (hereafter San Ramon) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lenore Silverman, also of the law firm of Lozano Smith Smith Woliver & Behrens.
No representative for the California School for the Deaf, Fremont (hereafter CSDF), appeared at the hearing.
Minarets called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Pendley and Camille Giometti-May, Madera County Office of Education program manager.
Sierra called the following witnesses to testify: Robert G. Hansen, former Minarets superintendent (by telephone); Ms. Thomas; Lissa Vasquez, Sierra school psychologist; and Dr. Witzansky.
San Ramon called the following witnesses to testify: Pat Mazman, Madera County Mental Health case manager; and Malisa Cochran, Contra Costa County SELPA program specialist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. On January 15, 1998, the Hearing Office received the closing arguments, the record was closed, and the issue regarding the responsible local educational agency was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On October 1, 1997, the California Special Education Hearing Office (hereafter Hearing Office) received a request for a due process hearing from Ms. PARENT on behalf of her daughter, STUDENT, regarding (1) whether CSDF's proposal to discharge her from that school was a violation of her right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and (2) which school district is the local educational agency (LEA) responsible for providing her a FAPE. On October 17, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from attorney Raymond W. Dunne on behalf of Minarets regarding the issue of the responsible LEA. By written order dated October 28, 1997, the Hearing Office consolidated the two matters and ordered the parties to maintain STUDENT's placement at the CSDF. The Hearing Office scheduled the consolidated matter for hearing on November 13 and 14, 1997. By minute order dated November 5, 1997, the Hearing Office bifurcated the issue of the responsible LEA from the FAPE issues and scheduled it to be heard first as a threshold issue. Subsequently, the parties agreed to have the issue of the responsible LEA heard on November 14, 1997. The parties were unable to complete the questioning of their witnesses that day due to delays associated with weather and the failure of CSDF to appear at the hearing. One more day was scheduled for presenting testimony on December 8, 1997, and the matter concluded thereafter.
At the beginning of the hearing, no one from CSDF was present. Several of the parties present indicated that they understood that CSDF representative Joyce Eckrem would be attending the hearing. The Hearing Officer contacted the Hearing Office and learned that Ms. Eckrem had called to say that she would not be attending the hearing. Because two differing reports of Ms. Eckrem's intentions were presented, the Hearing Officer called Ms. Eckrem at the telephone number she left with the Hearing Office to clarify the situation on the record. Ms. Eckrem stated that she would not be attending the hearing. Therefore, finding that CSDF had been provided sufficient notice of the hearing and intended not to be represented at the hearing, the Hearing Officer went forward with the proceedings.
Before documentary evidence was admitted or testimony was presented, San Ramon moved to be dismissed as a party. The Hearing Officer denied the motion because a ruling could not be made on that motion without ruling on the ultimate issue for this hearing, which required evidence to be presented in order to resolve factual and legal disputes.
Before testimony was presented, Sierra presented to the Hearing Officer a document entitled "STIPULATION," which contains eleven separate stipulations of fact and law agreed to by Sierra, San Ramon, and Minarets, as well as a chronology of the events surrounding STUDENT's education and the dispute in this matter.
Additionally, on January 28, 1998, after the hearing was concluded and before the Decision was rendered, the Hearing Office received a request from attorney Lenore Silverman on behalf of both San Ramon and Sierra to enjoin the California Department of Education (hereafter CDE) from convening an individualized educational program (IEP) meeting for STUDENT. Ms. Silverman indicated that San Ramon and Sierra had just been notified that the CDE was taking over as the educational agency for STUDENT and that it would be convening an IEP meeting at 11:00 a.m. on January 29, 1998, in order to change STUDENT's placement from the CSDF to a nonpublic school. According to Sierra and San Ramon, the CDE was attempting to convene an IEP meeting without allowing the participation of either Minarets, Sierra, or San Ramon. In a written order faxed to the parties before the time scheduled for the meeting on January 29, 1998, the Hearing Office denied the request to enjoin the CDE from convening the IEP meeting, in part because the moving parties provided no authority for granting such an order.
Although STUDENT may raise issues in the remainder of this case regarding whether she has been provided a FAPE by the CDE and/or the school district found herein as the LEA responsible for her education, this Decision is the final administrative ruling on the issue presented below.
ISSUE
I. Which local educational agency (LEA) is responsible for providing STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year -- Minarets, Sierra, or San Ramon?
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old young woman who is eligible for special education services because she is deaf and seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). STUDENT's parents reside in North Fork, California, within Minarets. STUDENT has attended the State's school for deaf students in Fremont, CSDF, off and on since 1987. STUDENT has had problems with her behavior which have caused CSDF to ask her to leave that school, although as of the last day of hearing, she was attending classes there pursuant to a stay put order by the Hearing Office. While attending CSDF during 1993, STUDENT's behavior became disruptive, and that school discharged her. She was taken to Napa State Hospital and evaluated. STUDENT stayed longer at Napa (several months) than was originally envisioned, at least partly because of the difficulty finding an appropriate place for her to live. Various agencies in Northern California worked together to have STUDENT's half-sister (who lives near CSDF) certified to operate a foster home for her, in order to allow STUDENT to continue to attend classes at CSDF. STUDENT has stayed at her half-sister's "foster home" since its certification. The foster home is located in Danville, within San Ramon. STUDENT comes home to North Fork on weekends to see her parents. CSDF allowed her to resume classes until August 1997, when further behavioral problems prompted CSDF to again discharge her. After due process hearings and a stay put order were requested, the Hearing Office ordered the parties to maintain STUDENT's placement at CSDF pending these proceedings.
While STUDENT is at CSDF, the state of California (as the state educational agency, operating the CSDF) pays for her educational costs directly. (California Education Code § 59020.) However, if STUDENT does not attend CSDF (or another state-operated school), the local educational agency responsible for her education must provide her with a FAPE. It is this placement and funding disagreement which has prompted the current case. All three school districts deny responsibility for STUDENT's education on various grounds.
In the background of this matter are several boundary changes involving Minarets and Sierra. In 1992, school districts in the area in and around North Fork were changed. As part of a reorganization effective July 1, 1992, Minarets and Sierra were created, but Minarets students lost the high school they had been attending, Sierra High School. The high school became part of Sierra Unified School District, and no other regular high school existed within Minarets. Initially, Sierra informally allowed Minarets students to attend Sierra High School. In 1995, Minarets and Sierra decided to create a written agreement that outlined each district's responsibilities regarding the right of Minarets students to attend Sierra High School. Part of the agreement provided for a "blanket interdistrict transfer" that allowed Minarets students to attend Sierra High School without having to separately apply for an interdistrict transfer. Another part of the agreement provided for a certain amount of money to be transferred from Minarets to Sierra to compensate for the additional burden on Sierra resulting from Minarets students attending Sierra High School. No specific provision regarding special education students was included in the agreement.
The parties dispute which of the local educational agencies that are parties to this matter is responsible for providing a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year. Specifically, the parties dispute the effect on the issue of the responsible LEA of (1) the agreement between Minarets and Sierra resulting from the school district reorganization and Sierra's actions following that agreement and (2) the certification of STUDENT's half-sister as a foster home operator.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Which local educational agency (LEA) is responsible for providing STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year -- Minarets, Sierra, or San Ramon?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA(Footnote 1)) and state law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) State and local educational agencies are responsible for providing a FAPE to a child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(6).) "Local educational agencies" include public boards of education or other public authorities legally constituted within a state with administrative control and direction over public elementary or secondary schools, including public school districts. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(4) and (15); California Code of Regulations § 4600(j).) With some exceptions, a child of school age must attend the school district in which that child's parent or legal guardian resides. (California Education Code § 48200.) Therefore, the residency of the parent with whom the student lives typically determines the residency of the student for purposes of school district responsibility.
STUDENT's parents reside in North Fork, in Madera County, California, within Minarets, and before attending CSDF, STUDENT lived with her parents. No party disputes that fact. Therefore, absent other controlling factors, Minarets is the LEA responsible for providing a FAPE for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer will now turn to factors which Minarets contends affect that responsibility.
Minarets puts forth two alternative arguments for the proposition that it is not responsible for STUDENT's education: one, that the agreement between Minarets and Sierra and/or Sierra's actions following the agreement shift the responsibility for STUDENT's education to Sierra; and two, that the circumstances surrounding the certification of STUDENT's half-sister as a foster home operator shift the responsibility for STUDENT's education to San Ramon. The Hearing Officer will go into greater detail concerning these arguments below.
The Minarets-Sierra Agreement
Minarets contends that because Sierra agreed to accept Minarets students at Sierra High School (and to receive money from Minarets), the responsibility for STUDENT's education shifted to Sierra because STUDENT is a Minarets student. Sierra contends that although it agreed to provide a high school to Minarets students because they no longer had such a facility after the reorganization, it has no obligation to provide any services to Minarets students who do not actually attend that high school, including STUDENT.
A contract must be interpreted to give effect to the parties' mutual intentions as they existed at the time they contracted, as far as those intentions are ascertainable. (California Civil Code § 1636.) The language of a contract governs its interpretation, if that language is clear and explicit and does not involve an absurdity. (California Civil Code § 1638.) A contract may be explained by referring to the circumstances under which it was made. (California Civil Code § 1647.) A court must determine what the parties meant by the words they used, but, unless it is feasible to determine that meaning from the instrument alone, the court must turn to extrinsic evidence and the circumstances for assistance. (Valdez v. Federal Mut. Ins. Co., 272 Cal. App. 2d 223, 77 Cal. Rptr. 411 (1969, 1st Dist.).) Therefore, the Hearing Officer will first consider the actual language of the Master Service Agreement and, unless the meaning is clear and explicit, will then consider evidence regarding the parties' mutual intentions and the circumstances surrounding the making of the agreement.
The "Preamble" to the Master Service Agreement states as follows:
Based upon the expectations that Sierra Joint Union High School District [Minarets' predecessor] students would continue to attend Sierra High School and based upon the actions of each of the Parties establishing an interdistrict attendance agreement, the Sierra Unified School District [Sierra] is currently accepting the resident students of the Sierra Joint Union High School District.
(Sierra Exh. 1, at p. 3.(Footnote 2))
The Master Service Agreement then states as follows:
Any growth in the Sierra Joint Union High School District [Minarets] student population attending Sierra High, above the 1992-93 population base, adversely effects [sic] the Sierra Unified School District's revenue limit. [Emphasis added.]
. . . .
The Sierra Joint Union High School District wants to provide supplemental financial support for the period of time that the Sierra Joint Union High School District resident students continue to attend Sierra High because there is no comprehensive high school facility within the territory of the Sierra Joint Union High School District. [Emphasis added.]
(Sierra Exh. 1, at p. 7.)
Although the language of the Master Service Agreement is fairly clear in its statements that Sierra was "accepting" Minarets students at Sierra High School and that Minarets would pay amounts of money to Sierra for allowing its students to attend the high school, the language is not clear and explicit about any responsibilities toward special education students. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will now consider evidence regarding the parties' mutual intentions.
Robert G. Hansen testified regarding the circumstances surrounding the drafting of the Minarets-Sierra agreement and the intentions of the districts. Mr. Hansen is now retired, but he was the superintendent of Minarets' predecessor, S. Joint, from 1984 until the reorganization. Mr. Hansen was directly involved in the drafting of the Master Service Agreement between Minarets and Sierra. For several years following the reorganization, Mr. Hansen worked half-time with Minarets and half-time with Sierra to assist with the transition, including serving as the administrative assistant to Dr. Pendley, Minarets' new superintendent.
Mr. Hansen testified that one purpose of the Master Service Agreement was to establish the fact that Minarets students would be allowed to continue to attend Sierra High School under the blanket interdistrict attendance agreement. Another purpose of the Master Service Agreement was to protect Sierra from adverse impact on its revenue limit and basic aid status, considering the number of students Minarets was asking it to accept under the blanket interdistrict attendance agreement.
Mr. Hansen testified that under an individual interdistrict attendance agreement, the district of residence does not change by virtue of the agreement. He said that the student is simply granted permission to attend a school outside that district of residence. He said that the intent of the parties in creating the blanket interdistrict attendance agreement for Minarets students was not to change the understanding of the effect of an interdistrict attendance agreement.
Mr. Hansen also testified that if Sierra could not provide a program for certain Minarets high school students and an appropriate program for those students existed within Minarets, Sierra would have no obligation to those students. He cited the Willow Creek alternative high school program that Minarets operates in North Fork as an example of how such responsibility remained with Minarets, as the district of residence.
Witnesses called by both Minarets and Sierra indicated that some Minarets high school students (including special education students) attend or have attended high schools or programs such as Minarets' alternative high school and a home study program run by that district, instead of attending Sierra High School. (Testimony of Dr. Pendley and Mr. Hansen.) The testimony of Fresno County SELPA director Barbara Thomas also supported that contention. Ms. Thomas further stated that she was aware that Minarets had accepted responsibility for at least one of those Minarets students who do not attend Sierra High School -- a special education student who was placed in Minarets' home study program.
The Hearing Officer finds that the agreement, supplemented by the testimony, establishes that the Master Service Agreement simply provided a guarantee that Minarets students would be able to attend Sierra High School. The Hearing Officer finds that the Master Service Agreement did not provide for Sierra to be responsible for Minarets students who did not attend school within Sierra. STUDENT has never attended Sierra High School (or any school within Sierra) and there is no indication that STUDENT was denied an opportunity to attend that school. Because STUDENT is a Minarets student who has never attended Sierra High School, the Hearing Officer finds that the Master Service Agreement does not shift the responsibility for STUDENT's education to Sierra.
Minarets further contends that Sierra's actions following the reorganization and the creation of the Master Service Agreement shifted the burden to provide STUDENT's education to Sierra. Minarets asserts that because Sierra stepped in and attended IEPs for STUDENT when CSDF was threatening to discharge her, that district has assumed liability for her education and should be estopped from denying such liability. Minarets contends that Barbara Thomas, the Fresno County SELPA director, believed Sierra was responsible for STUDENT's education and that Sierra acted consistently with that belief. Sierra contends that it may not be held liable for a student's education on an estoppel argument, and that the Fresno County SELPA director was mistaken when she recommended that Sierra be responsible, because she erroneously believed at that time that STUDENT's mother resided in Fresno County, instead of Madera County, where she actually resides.
To bar a party from showing the existence of a fact, equitable estoppel requires that the moving party show that it relied to its detriment upon the past conduct of the party to be estopped. (Amarawansa v. Superior Court (Los Angeles), 49 Cal. App. 4th 1251, 1261, 57 Cal. Rptr. 2d 249 (1996).) In 1996, Sierra claimed responsibility for STUDENT's education, following the recommendations of its SELPA director, Ms. Thomas. (Min. Exh. K, at p. 6; testimony of Ms. Thomas.(Footnote 3)) Assuming equitable estoppel applies, Minarets submitted no evidence of its own detrimental reliance on Sierra's past conduct. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that there is no basis for Minarets' contention that Sierra should be estopped from denying liability for STUDENT's education.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the Master Service Agreement does not shift the responsibility of providing STUDENT's education to Sierra. The Hearing Officer also finds that Sierra's actions following the inception of the Master Service Agreement do not estop Sierra from now denying liability for STUDENT's education. Based on all the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that neither the existence of the Master Service Agreement between Minarets and Sierra nor Sierra's actions following the agreement shift the responsibility for providing STUDENT's education to Sierra.
The Foster Home Certification
Alternatively, Minarets contends that STUDENT lost her North Fork residency status because she was placed in a State hospital and, upon her release, was then placed in a licensed children's institution. Minarets contends that STUDENT was transferred to Napa State Hospital involuntarily because she was taken there pursuant to proceedings under California Welfare and Institutions Code Section 5150. Minarets further contends that when she was released and moved to her half-sister's foster home as part of her return to CSDF, she became the responsibility of San Ramon, as the district within which the foster home is located, because the home qualifies as a licensed children's institution (LCI).
San Ramon contends that although STUDENT was evaluated at Napa and stayed there longer than anticipated, she was not "transferred to" or "placed at" that state hospital and that STUDENT's placement in her half-sister's foster home was part of her educational placement at CSDF. San Ramon asserts that, therefore, the law cited by Minarets is not applicable and the circumstances surrounding her stay at Napa and the foster home certification did not shift the responsibility for STUDENT's education to San Ramon.
For children who have been admitted to and discharged from facilities such as a state hospital, an LCI, or foster home, responsibility for the provision of special education services rests with the school district in which the child's parents reside, unless the child is placed in "another" such state hospital, LCI, or foster home by a court, regional center, or public agency other than an educational agency. (California Government Code § 7579.1(b); California Education Code § 56155.) If a child is so placed, the district in which the child now resides (where the LCI or foster home is located) is responsible for the child's education. (California Government Code § 7579.1(b).) Therefore, in order for Minarets to prevail on this issue, it must establish two propositions: (1) that STUDENT was admitted to the state hospital on a permanent basis, such that she lost her residency in North Fork and gained residency at the state hospital and (2) that her subsequent move to the foster home was not part of her special education placement.
Pat Mazman, STUDENT's case manager with Madera County Mental Health (hereafter Mental Health), testified regarding the circumstances surrounding STUDENT's stay at Napa State Hospital and the certification of STUDENT's half-sister as a foster home operator. During 1993, when STUDENT's behavior became disruptive and CSDF attempted to discharge her, STUDENT was sent to Napa for a thirty-day evaluation through Mental Health. Although STUDENT was never formally admitted to Napa, she ended up staying there for several months, because CSDF would not allow her back in the dormitory and because there were difficulties in locating another placement. STUDENT qualified for a pilot program that helped children find foster homes and receive services such as a one-to-one aide at school, and CSDF agreed to allow her back in the classroom, as long as she did not live in the dormitory. However, it proved difficult to find a deaf foster family that was willing to take a deaf/SED child. Therefore, another agency, Families First, assisted STUDENT's half-sister in becoming certified as a foster home operator so that STUDENT could stay there while she attended classes at CSDF.
Ms. Mazman stated that Mental Health asked San Ramon (the nearest school district to CSDF) to hold IEP meetings for STUDENT because CSDF refused to do so. Ms. Mazman also testified that STUDENT's placement in the foster home was an AB3632 placement by Mental Health and that it was not a placement by a county or other agency. Ms. Mazman stated that STUDENT is still a resident of North Fork and that she, Ms. Mazman, never considered San Ramon the responsible LEA because STUDENT's mother was still her legal guardian. Ms. Mazman said that she, as the Mental Health representative, was acting under STUDENT's IEP as an educational agency throughout the period in question.
Minarets submitted no evidence showing that STUDENT was ever officially placed at Napa on a permanent basis, such that she lost her North Fork residency and assumed residency at that state hospital. Sierra submitted evidence showing that STUDENT was at the hospital for an evaluative stay which was extended simply because of the difficulty in finding her a place to stay while attending school. (Testimony of Ms. Mazman.) Even assuming arguendo that STUDENT was officially placed in Napa, Minarets submitted no evidence showing that STUDENT's placement in the foster home was by a court, regional center, or a public agency not acting as an educational agency. Sierra submitted evidence showing that STUDENT's placement was by Mental Health, acting upon her IEP, as part of her educational placement at CSDF. (Testimony of Ms. Mazman; S.R. Exh. 4, at p. 2.(Footnote 4)) Ms. Mazman, as STUDENT's program manager for her education, testified that Mental Health was acting as an educational agency under STUDENT's IEP at all times, including the arrangement for the foster home. Based on the evidence submitted, the Hearing Officer finds that Minarets failed to establish either proposition described above, much less both propositions. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's stay at Napa and the foster home placement did not shift the responsibility for STUDENT's education to San Ramon.
Conclusion
Based on the evidence and argument presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the Master Service Agreement, Sierra's actions following that agreement, and the circumstances surrounding the certification of STUDENT's half-sister as a foster home operator do not shift the educational responsibility from Minarets to either Sierra or San Ramon. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Minarets, as STUDENT's district of residence, is the LEA responsible for providing a free appropriate public education for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year.
ORDER
1. Minarets shall assume the responsibilities of the local educational agency in providing STUDENT's education for the 1997-98 school year, consistent with federal and state laws regarding special education.
2. Sierra and San Ramon are dismissed as parties.
3. The remainder of this case shall be entitled "STUDENT v. Minarets Joint Union High School District and the California School for the Deaf, Fremont" and shall be known by case number "SN 1220-97."
4. All of the parties' other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I. Which local educational agency (LEA) is responsible for providing STUDENT with a free appropriate public education for the 1997-98 school year -- Minarets, Sierra, or San Ramon?
Sierra and San Ramon prevailed on this issue to the extent that established that they are not responsible for providing STUDENT's education and were dismissed from this matter. STUDENT prevailed on this issue to the extent that she received what she requested in this phase of her case -- a ruling indicating which LEA is responsible for her education.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: February 12, 1998 ____________________________________ Kathleen Peterson Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES:
1. Amendments to the IDEA were signed into law on June 4, 1997.
2. "Sierra Exh." refers to Sierra's exhibit number 1, admitted into evidence.
3. "Min. Exh." refers to Minarets' exhibits, lettered A through E, and G through Q, admitted into evidence.
4. "S.R. Exh." refers to San Ramon's exhibits, numbered 1 through 14, admitted into evidence.
