California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 14, 1997
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1223-96 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain
Los Angeles Unified must reimburse a neuropsychologist's report and add his goals to the IEP; physical therapy and social skills requests denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes an earlier due process matter between the parties (cited as SN 756-96 and also as SN 976-96), which was resolved by a Memorandum of Agreement dated August 6, 1996. No remand, vacatur, or correction is noted.
Summary
The parent, helped by a non-attorney advocate, filed for an eight-year-old third grader. She was eligible for special education because of a traumatic brain injury. She attended an aphasia special day class taught by Jack Richter at Tulsa Street Elementary and joined a general education class for language arts. During the hearing, Los Angeles Unified agreed to provide one hour a week of clinic-based occupational therapy for six months, with transportation. It also agreed to pay for the Hyland Clinic's independent occupational therapy assessment. The Hearing Officer ordered those items.
The Hearing Officer found that the student did not need physical therapy to benefit from her education. The district therapist, a California Children's Services assessment, and the parent's own experts agreed that she functioned independently and safely at school. Social skills training and a cognitive intervention program were also denied. Teachers and observers saw no behavior problems at school, and defiance reported at home and in private tutoring did not prove an educational need. The district must add twelve of the fourteen goals proposed by neuropsychologist Dr. Douglas Harrington and write new versions of two goals on verbal hesitation. The district must also pay for Dr. Harrington's January 1997 report. The behavior assessment the district had agreed to provide was only a set of observations that did not meet state rules for behavior assessments. Expert witness fees were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO used Rowley's educational-benefit test to deny services aimed at behavior seen only outside school. The district had agreed to do a behavior assessment but provided only informal observations that did not meet title 5 functional analysis assessment rules. SEHO ordered the district to pay for the parent's independent assessment.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Is STUDENT entitled to physical therapy services and transportation from the District?
Student did not need physical therapy to benefit from her education. The district therapist, a CCS assessment, and the parent's own experts found she functioned independently and safely at school.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Is STUDENT entitled to the "social skills training" that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended? (including a requested cognitive intervention plan)
No educational need for social skills training or a cognitive intervention program was shown. Teachers and observers saw appropriate behavior at school, and reported defiance at home and in tutoring did not establish a need.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 3. Must STUDENT's IEP include the fourteen goals that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended in his letter of August 21, 1996?
Twelve undisputed goals had to be added to the IEP. Two goals requiring 'no hesitancy' in speech were unreasonable and had to be rewritten by the IEP team.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Douglas Harrington's report of January 17, 1997 (independent psychological assessment)?
The district's agreed behavior assessment was only an observation that did not meet the title 5 section 3052 requirements for a functional analysis assessment, and no adequate assessment was completed on time, so the parent was entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Harrington's report.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for witness fees?
The Education Code did not authorize the Hearing Officer to award expert witness fees or costs.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. District to provide one hour of occupational therapy each week from the Hyland Clinic for the next six months, as the district conceded. The IEP team will then meet to decide whether OT is still needed. If Hyland Clinic cannot provide the services, the district must immediately secure another clinic-based OT provider.
- Order to provide or change services. District to provide transportation to occupational therapy (the district offered a one-to-one aide on the bus).
- Reimbursement. District to reimburse the cost of the occupational therapy assessment that Dr. Knox of the Hyland Clinic performed on January 15, 1997, within 30 days of receiving the bill (conceded by the district).
- District to bring Dr. Harrington's proposed goals one through six and nine through fourteen to the student's next IEP team meeting and include them, with revisions if necessary, in her next IEP.
- District to develop and add to the IEP two goals addressing the student's verbal hesitation, replacing proposed goals seven and eight.
- IEE at public expense. District to reimburse the cost of Dr. Douglas Harrington's report of January 17, 1997, within 30 days of receiving his bill.
Key authorities
Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493 (9th Cir. 1996); Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396 (9th Cir. 1994); Education Code section 56363(a); Education Code section 56344; Education Code section 56329(b); Education Code section 56507; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, section 3052; 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, question 38
People named in the decision
- Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office
- William Bauman, non-attorney advocate for Student; witness
- Shirley H. Brown, District representative, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Linda Michel, coordinator of special education services, West Valley; witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Douglas Harrington, neuropsychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Dr. Susan Knox, occupational therapist; independent OT evaluator and expert witness for Student, Hyland Clinic
- Dr. Ronald Mossler, private educational therapist; witness for Student, One to One Reading Center
- Jack Richter, special day class (aphasia) teacher, Tulsa Street Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sharla Bohman, district physical therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Mitsuko Kushida, program specialist and case manager, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dolores Cannata, least restrictive environment counselor, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Diane Goldstein, program specialist; least restrictive environment behaviorist who conducted behavior observation, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Cindy Sobel, district occupational therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Linda Mann, general education third grade teacher, Tulsa Street Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Dr. Jean Ottina, neuropsychological assessor (reportedly conducting behavior assessment)
- Bobbie Sobel, district behaviorist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Hyland Clinic, private clinic-based occupational therapy provider
- California Children's Services (CCS), public agency that provided and assessed physical therapy
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Encino, California, on February 13, 14, and 17, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by her mother, MOTHER, and nonattorney advocate William Bauman.
Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (the District) was represented by Shirley H. Brown. Also present on behalf of the District was Linda Michel, coordinator of special education services for the West Valley.
The following witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner: MOTHER, Dr. Douglas Harrington, Dr. Susan Knox, Dr. Ronald Mossler, and William Bauman.
The District called the following witnesses: Jack Richter, special day class (SDC) teacher; Sharla Bohman, district physical therapist; Mitsuko Kushida, program specialist; Linda Michel; Dolores Cannata, district counselor; Diane Goldstein, program specialist and Cindy Sobel, district occupational therapist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until March 17, 1997, for the receipt of written closing arguments. On March 17, 1997, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Is STUDENT entitled to physical therapy services and transportation from the District?
2. Is STUDENT entitled to the "social skills training" that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended?(Footnote 1)
3. Must STUDENT's Individualized Education Program (IEP) include the fourteen goals that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended in his letter of August 21, 1996?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Douglas Harrington's independent psychological assessment of STUDENT?
5. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for witness fees?
ISSUES NO LONGER IN DISPUTE
Occupational therapy and transportation
At the due process hearing, the District conceded liability for the occupational therapy services recommended by Petitioner's witness, occupational therapist Dr. Susan Knox. Both at the hearing and in its closing argument, the District offered to provide one hour of occupational therapy services each week for a six-month period and, after that six-month period, to "determine [STUDENT's] continued need for occupational therapy services." The District also agreed to transport STUDENT "to the clinic based occupational therapy sessions, and [provide] a one-to-one aide to ride the bus with Petitioner to therapy."(Footnote 2)
At the due process hearing, the District emphasized its willingness "to provide clinic based occupational therapy services, [at] a nonpublic agency."(Footnote 3) Because the District has conceded liability, the Hearing Officer finds that the issues of provision of occupational therapy services and transportation are no longer in dispute and will order the District to provide the occupational therapy services and transportation that it offered at the due process hearing.(Footnote 4)
Reimbursement for independent occupational therapy assessment
In its closing argument, the District also agreed to reimburse Petitioner for the cost of the Hyland Clinic's independent occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT.(Footnote 5) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that this issue is no longer in dispute and will order the District to reimburse Petitioner for the cost of the independent occupational therapy assessment within thirty days of receiving the bill for the cost of the Hyland Clinic's occupational therapy assessment.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Eight-year-old STUDENT resides with her mother, Ms. MOTHER, within District boundaries. STUDENT is a third-grader who is currently enrolled in a special day class (SDC). STUDENT qualifies for special education because she suffered a traumatic brain injury.
When STUDENT began school in 1993, she was enrolled in the regular education program. However, in September 1994, then-six-year-old STUDENT sustained a traumatic brain injury when she was hit by a car as she was crossing a street.
STUDENT's injuries left her unable to speak and reliant upon gestures for communication, and temporarily in a wheelchair. STUDENT also experienced "problems with cognition, gait, fine motor control, and ataxia, and ongoing seizure disorder."(Footnote 6) STUDENT remained in the hospital until December 1994.(Footnote 7) Because STUDENT's injuries qualified her for special education, shortly after STUDENT's release, her Individualized Education Program (IEP) team convened its first meeting.
STUDENT has remained in an SDC since her initial placement, but she has attended several different schools. STUDENT is currently one of nine students enrolled in Jack Richter's aphasia class at Tulsa Street Elementary School. STUDENT's IEP team placed her in an SDC, and determined that she was entitled to occupational, physical and speech therapy.
Since February 1995, various organizations such as CCS and private charities have funded and provided STUDENT's physical therapy services. In September 1996, both the District and CCS assessed STUDENT's need for physical therapy and concluded that she no longer required it.(Footnote 8) STUDENT has not received physical therapy since September 1996. Petitioner now requests that the District once again provide physical therapy services and transportation to the therapy site.
Both Petitioner and the District participated in a due process hearing on August 6, 1996.(Footnote 9) The parties created a Memorandum of Agreement that, among other things, obligated the District to conduct assessments of STUDENT's need for occupational and physical therapy, and conduct behavioral and neuropsychological assessments.(Footnote 10) To comply with the Memorandum of Agreement, the District assessed STUDENT's needs for occupational and physical therapy, and produced a "behavior observation report." (Footnote 11)
In the Memorandum of Agreement, the Petitioner consented to and District agreed to conduct the requested assessments, and both parties agreed to withdraw their requests for due process hearings. However, some issues raised at the previous hearing arise in the instant case because Ms. MOTHER challenges the adequacy and timeliness of the assessments that the District conducted and the services that the District provided.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY and DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE
Petitioner's witnesses
MOTHER(Footnote 12)
Ms. MOTHER testified about the frequency and duration of STUDENT's occupational and physical therapy sessions. The Hearing Officer will not recount Ms. MOTHER's testimony as it relates to STUDENT's need for occupational therapy because the District has offered and will be ordered to provide occupational therapy services and transportation to STUDENT.
Ms. MOTHER also testified at length about her dissatisfaction with the District's conduct and services. Her testimony will be summarized only to the extent that it bears on issues disputed at this hearing.
According to Ms. MOTHER, as of December 1994, STUDENT's IEPs have indicated that she was entitled to receive physical therapy services. Beginning in April 1995, STUDENT sporadically received physical therapy from a variety of sources, including private hospitals and CCS. Ms. MOTHER stated that either she or Mr. Bauman secured and provided transportation to physical therapy sessions until October 1995.
STUDENT next received two months of physical therapy from CCS. These sessions began in February 1996 and ended in April 1996.(Footnote 13) Ms. MOTHER stated that CCS discontinued STUDENT's physical therapy four months early because the provider was not able to meet STUDENT's complex needs. From June until August 1996, CCS provided STUDENT's physical therapy.
Ms. MOTHER testified that in September 1996, CCS assessed STUDENT's progress in physical therapy and planned to monitor her. Ms. MOTHER maintained that CCS did not follow its plan because STUDENT's treating physician was so exasperated by CCS' paperwork that she refused to write a prescription for continued CCS-funded physical therapy. Ms. MOTHER contended STUDENT's IEPs continued to list physical therapy as a designated instructional service. Nevertheless, after September 1996, neither the District nor CCS provided STUDENT with physical therapy. Ms. MOTHER therefore contended that STUDENT is entitled to physical therapy from the District even when CCS is unable to provide it.
Ms. MOTHER stated that she participated in STUDENT's IEP team meeting of October 23, 1996. During that meeting, Ms. MOTHER expressed her concerns regarding STUDENT's need for physical therapy and requested that the District provide it.(Footnote 14) At that IEP team meeting, Ms. MOTHER also requested that STUDENT receive "small group counselling" and proposed that the fourteen goals that Dr. Harrington developed be included in STUDENT's IEP. Ms. MOTHER testified that an IEP team member assured her that Dr. Harrington's proposed goals would be "stapled" to STUDENT's IEP and thereby be incorporated into the document. Ms. MOTHER contends, however, that Dr. Harrington's proposed fourteen goals were never included in STUDENT's IEP.
Ms. MOTHER recounted that, during the due process hearing of August 6, 1996, the District agreed to provide cognitive rehabilitation services for STUDENT. Ms. MOTHER described these services as one-to-one therapy with a behaviorist who specializes in the treatment of children with traumatic brain injuries. Rather than providing the one-to-one therapy services that Ms. MOTHER described, the District provided STUDENT with the services of Dolores Cannata, a least restrictive environment counsellor. According to Ms. MOTHER, Ms. Cannata occasionally observes STUDENT at school and asks her questions following the observations. Ms. MOTHER stated that Ms. Cannata is not "working on any cognitive or social skills" with STUDENT.
In addition to STUDENT's need for cognitive rehabilitation services, Ms. MOTHER testified that her family requires counselling to help them cope with STUDENT's "sudden outbursts and oppositional behavior" that typically accompany traumatic brain injuries. Ms. MOTHER acknowledged that STUDENT does not display oppositional behavior at school. On the contrary, Ms. MOTHER considers STUDENT's in-school behavior "too quiet and passive" and fears that "people will take advantage of her."
Ms. MOTHER also maintains that the District reneged on its agreement to conduct a behavior assessment of STUDENT. Instead of conducting an assessment, Ms. MOTHER contends that the District simply observed STUDENT's behavior.
Dr. Douglas Harrington
At the request of Ms. MOTHER, neuropsychologist Dr. Douglas Harrington conducted a neuropsychological consultation of STUDENT in January 1996.(Footnote 15)
Dr. Harrington testified that he memorialized his counselling recommendations and proposed IEP goals in a letter dated August 21, 1996.
On January 17, 1997, Dr. Harrington observed STUDENT at her school, pursuant to Ms. MOTHER's request. Dr. Harrington began observing STUDENT during lunch. Dr. Harrington testified that STUDENT ate, talked, and later played with age-appropriate male and female peers.(Footnote 16) Dr. Harrington noted that STUDENT's "left hemiplegia gait" was "mildly noticeable" but that she "was able to keep up with [her] able bodied peers" as they walked toward Linda Mann's classroom.(Footnote 17)
Dr. Harrington commented that while in Ms. Mann's class, STUDENT listened attentively and voluntarily responded to the questions that the teacher directed to the class about twenty percent of the time. However, STUDENT responded to questions that did not require an oral response one hundred percent of the time. Dr. Harrington noted that STUDENT's oral responses were appropriate but typically preceded by a slight delay.
Next, Dr. Harrington recalled that the adapted physical education (APE) teacher and an instructional aide escorted STUDENT and four other children to the playground. STUDENT only required "moderate assist" during APE; she stumbled during some activities but did not fall. Dr. Harrington noted that STUDENT seemed frustrated when she had difficulty catching a rubber ball.
After APE, STUDENT returned to Mr. Richter's SDC and engaged in cooperative play with two female peers. Dr. Harrington reported that STUDENT went to the restroom and washed her hands without prompting. By the end of the school day, STUDENT appeared tired but retrieved her backpack and supplies without assistance. STUDENT entered the school bus under the supervision of Mr. Richter. After STUDENT left school, Dr. Harrington spoke with Mr. Richter. Mr. Richter expressed concern about STUDENT's fatigue, but stated that "he is pleased with her progress," i.e., attention span, motivation, and participation. According to Dr. Harrington, Mr. Richter did not report angry outbursts or oppositional behavior, but stated that STUDENT sometimes cries when she stumbles and falls. Mr. Richter also informed Dr. Harrington that he addresses STUDENT's social skills through classroom-based partner play activities.
Dr. Harrington stated that during the January 17, 1996 observation, STUDENT did not exhibit any "negative acting out behavior." In fact, STUDENT appeared to have "good social dialogue with peers." Of STUDENT's behavior, Dr. Harrington wrote, "She is not having any significant behavioral problems."(Footnote 18) Based on his observation, Dr. Harrington concluded that STUDENT was in an appropriate academic placement and should join a regular education mathematics class in the near future.
Nevertheless, Dr. Harrington recommended the STUDENT receive individual psychological counselling from a traumatic brain injury specialist to address STUDENT's oppositional behavior at home. Although Dr. Harrington has not observed STUDENT at home, he offered that STUDENT's reported defiant behavior may limit her academic achievement and speculated that STUDENT may become more defiant as she matures and encounters a more challenging curriculum.
Dr. Harrington also advised a cognitive intervention program that would increase STUDENT's ability to attend to and complete tasks, seek help when frustrated, and think before acting. In Dr. Harrington's opinion, a school psychologist or speech and language teacher, such as Mr. Richter, could implement such a program. In fact, Dr. Harrington expressed approval of Mr. Richter's interactive play program.
Dr. Harrington testified that the fourteen goals he proposed in his letter of August 21, 1996(Footnote 19), are still appropriate, especially as STUDENT transitions to mainstream classes. The proposed goals include improving rate of completion of assignments, self-initiating interaction with classmates, and eliminating hesitancy when speaking.
However, Dr. Harrington no longer recommends that STUDENT receive direct occupational and physical therapy services. He commented that STUDENT "appears to exhibit functional skills in her current class setting, and appears to be adequately taking care of her functional education behavior." Dr. Harrington stated "At the present time, I'm not so sure that it [occupational and physical therapy] is required." Instead, Dr. Harrington suggested that STUDENT receive both occupational and physical therapy consultations and reevaluations when her IEP team meets.
Dr. Susan Knox
Occupational therapist Dr. Susan Knox conducted an independent occupational therapy evaluation of STUDENT in January 1997. As a result, Dr. Knox recommended that STUDENT receive a one-hour session of clinic-based occupational therapy each week for a six-month period. Dr. Knox suggested that STUDENT's continuing occupational therapy needs should be reassessed after she has received those services for six months.
The Hearing Officer will not further summarize Dr. Knox's report(Footnote 20) or testimony as it relates to STUDENT's need for occupational therapy because the District has agreed to provide the occupational therapy services that Petitioner requests and will be ordered to do so pursuant to this decision.
Although Dr. Knox emphasized that she is an occupational therapist, not a physical therapist, she offered that STUDENT does not currently require physical therapy. Dr. Knox considers STUDENT "a little high [functioning] for a straight physical therapy program." Dr. Knox explained that physical therapists work with children who have more obvious deficits in strength.
Dr. Knox testified that she has not worked with STUDENT but has spent one and one-half hours observing her in her SDC and on the playground at recess. Dr. Knox's observations led her to conclude that STUDENT's strengths are her "fine motor skills, attention and cooperation." According to Dr. Knox, STUDENT did not display oppositional or diminished behavior.
However, Dr. Knox did note that STUDENT tends to hang back on the playground rather than asserting herself during play. Dr. Knox stated that she "was very impressed" with STUDENT's classroom.
Dr. Ronald Mossler
Private educational therapist(Footnote 21) Ronald Mossler works for the One to One Reading Center. Dr. Mossler testified that since July 1995, he and STUDENT have met for two thirty- to forty-five minute reading sessions each week. Dr. Mossler stated that when he met STUDENT, she was a "non-reader," but that she is now reading at approximately a second-grade reading level.
Dr. Mossler stated that he has neither observed STUDENT at school nor spoken to District staff about her.
According to Dr. Mossler, "at times [STUDENT] will be oppositional and refuse to work" during their reading sessions. Dr. Mossler testified that he can often coax STUDENT to read by offering her rewards or alternate reading materials, but that these tactics can just as often fail. In Dr. Mossler's opinion, STUDENT's oppositional behavior interferes with her ability to learn. Dr. Mossler observed that the instances of defiance have increased, and often require Dr. Mossler to devote a large portion of the reading sessions to behavioral intervention.
Dr. Mossler stated that challenging assignments trigger STUDENT's defiance and speculated that STUDENT complies at school because her assignments are not appropriately challenging. Dr. Mossler acknowledged, however, that he could not determine whether STUDENT received more difficult reading material from school or from him. At any rate, he remarked that when STUDENT faces a challenge, her behavior tends to deteriorate.
Dr. Mossler testified that he is qualified to create a behavioral intervention program for STUDENT. Dr. Mossler's program would focus on helping STUDENT remain on task, increasing the frequency and duration of reading, and decreasing defiant behavior. In Dr. Mossler's view, STUDENT's behavioral intervention program should include her family.
William Bauman
Mr. Bauman's testimony supplemented the information that Ms. MOTHER provided about the dates and durations of STUDENT's occupational and physical therapy.
Respondent's witness
Jack Richter
STUDENT has been enrolled in Jack Richter's aphasia SDC for grades one through three, since March 1996. Three instructional aides assist Mr. Richter's class of nine students. Pursuant to Mr. Richter's assignment, one of the aides accompanies STUDENT to her outside therapy sessions.
Mr. Richter testified that since enrolling in his class, STUDENT's reading skills have improved from a primer to a second-grade level. STUDENT is also at the second-grade level in her supplemental phonics program. Mr. Richter testified that STUDENT reads with him one time each week, and also reads with the aide in groups of three students. Mr. Richter stated that STUDENT's reading program also attempts to remediate her word finding and retrieval problems.
Mr. Richter stated that STUDENT is motivated, stays on task, has improved her phonics skills, and demonstrates good reading comprehension. Mr. Richter estimates that STUDENT is the second best reader in his SDC, but cautions that she is not yet ready for a mainstream reading class. While Mr. Richter remarked that STUDENT's rate of assignment completion has improved, he stated that he would like to see her work more quickly.
Mr. Richter stated that he has spoken to Ms. Mann about placing STUDENT in her class for mainstream mathematics instruction. STUDENT currently joins Ms. Mann's class for language arts in a mainstream setting. According to Mr. Richter, STUDENT participates in language arts without additional assistance, so he doubts that she would require additional assistance if placed in Ms. Mann's class for mathematics.
Mr. Richter testified that when STUDENT first joined his class, she sometimes said that she was tired and did not want to continue the task. Now, according to Mr. Richter, STUDENT seldom uses fatigue as a reason not to finish her work. Mr. Richter also stated that STUDENT is occasionally tired when she arrives at school. She has sometimes attributed her fatigue to getting up early or staying up late watching television. Mr. Richter also testified that approximately once or twice each day, STUDENT will stare blankly rather than respond to her environment. Ms. MOTHER refers to this behavior as "zoning." Mr. Richter reported that the frequency and duration of STUDENT's "zoning" has decreased.
When challenged by an assignment, STUDENT sometimes "gives up" and says that she cannot finish it. However, when Mr. Richter provides STUDENT with additional explanation and encouragement, she will continue working.
Mr. Richter has neither personally observed nor heard from other District staff that STUDENT demonstrates defiant, oppositional or inappropriate behavior. On the contrary, STUDENT works independently and when she completes a task, she begins the next one. Mr. Richter stated that STUDENT thinks before she acts and does not demonstrate "negative impulsivity." Mr. Richter also observed that STUDENT initiates conversations with both classmates and instructors, and characterized STUDENT's social interactions as "positive."
Mr. Richter recalled, however, that Ms. MOTHER reported that STUDENT sometimes defies and opposes her at home. Furthermore, Ms. MOTHER once complained about STUDENT's APE class. STUDENT's aide also commented that STUDENT did not like the APE bar climbing activities. In response, Mr. Richter asked the APE teacher to contact Ms. MOTHER. After the telephone contact, Mr. Richter heard no more complaints about APE.
On Monday morning, the members of Mr. Richter's class typically describe their weekend activities. STUDENT participates in this activity, describing for example, her Karate lessons, visits to the park or mall, and play with children in the neighborhood. Mr. Richter noted, however, that "most of the time" STUDENT reports that she spends time with Mr. Bauman.
In Mr. Richter's opinion, STUDENT is safe on campus. STUDENT has not fallen or been knocked down more than other students, and has not been seriously injured. Sharla Bohman
The District has employed licensed pediatric physical therapist Sharla Bohman for one and one-half years. Ms. Bohman testified that she holds a master's degree in physical therapy.
In September 1996, Ms. Bohman evaluated STUDENT's physical therapy needs. To conduct the evaluation, Ms. Bohman observed STUDENT at Tulsa Street School, spoke to STUDENT's teacher and instructional aide, and considered the CCS physical therapy evaluation dated June 14, 1996. Neither STUDENT's teacher nor her instructional aide expressed concerns about STUDENT's equilibrium or ability to safely negotiate the school grounds.
However, Ms. Bohman reported that STUDENT has "motor control difficulties with higher level balance activities and with rapid, alternating movements of the arms or legs."(Footnote 23) Nevertheless, Ms. Bohman stated that STUDENT functions independently in her classroom and "in all areas of gross motor skills and accessibility of her educational environment."(Footnote 24) According to Ms. Bohman, the CCS physical therapy assessment dated September 30, 1996, reached a similar conclusion.(Footnote 25)
Ms. Bohman testified that she also observed STUDENT on the playground. In Ms. Bohman's opinion, STUDENT has appropriate on- campus safety skills, in that she is not impulsive and does not engage in dangerous activities.
Ms. Bohman considered STUDENT's strength "good" based on her achievement of a score of 4 of a possible 5 on a manual muscle test. Scores on the manual muscle test range from 0 to 5: a score of 0 indicates that the subject has no movement in the muscles; 1 indicates "trace" muscle strength; 2 indicates "poor" muscle strength; 3 indicates "fair" muscle strength; 4 indicates "good" muscle strength; and 5 indicates "normal strength." Ms. Bohman explained that STUDENT's traumatic brain injury has reduced her muscle strength. For this reason, STUDENT's earned a "good" score on the manual muscle test.
Ms. Bohman pointed out that the CCS physical therapy assessment dated September 30, 1996, reached a similar conclusion regarding STUDENT's strength. The CCS report states, "Strength not formally tested but is functional for gross motor skills." Ms. Bohman also considered STUDENT's comparatively lower score on the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency (Bruininks) that CCS administered in September 1996 consistent with her score on the manual muscle test.
Ms. Bohman stated that she did not readminister the Bruininks because "readministration ... within such a short time span would give inaccurate information, due to the practice effect on test-retest reliability."(Footnote 27) Ms. Bohman explained that notwithstanding STUDENT's scores on the Bruininks, STUDENT is able to function independently in her educational program, and lacks deficits that adversely affect her ability to function at school. Ms. Bohman further testified that she relies more heavily on her own observations than on results from standardized tests.
Ms. Bohman explained that she did not test STUDENT's reflexes because STUDENT did not exhibit any "abnormal" reflexes that compromised her ability to negotiate the campus safely. Ms. Bohman used informal methods to assess STUDENT's endurance, and concluded that she was "within functional limits."(Footnote 28) Although Ms. Bohman did not time STUDENT to determine how much time she required to walk from one campus location to another, Ms. Bohman noted that she kept pace with her peers.
According to Ms. Bohman, STUDENT is able to eat, drink, and perform other "self-care activities" such as wiping her nose and mouth and disposing of her trash. Ms. Bohman did not observe and could not comment on STUDENT's bowel and bladder management skills. Nevertheless, she maintained that she conducted a thorough physical therapy assessment.
Ms. Bohman did not recommend remediation for STUDENT's balance problems because, in her opinion, STUDENT's adapted physical education class addresses her balance issues. Based on her observations, Ms. Bohman concluded that STUDENT no longer requires physical therapy to benefit from her education placement. Mitsuko Kushida
Program specialist Mitsuko Kushida began her career as an elementary school teacher. Ms. Kushida has acquired credentials in the following areas: learning disabled, speech and hearing, and resource specialist program (RSP). Ms. Kushida also has a master's degree. Ms. Kushida estimated that she has served approximately sixteen students with traumatic brain injuries. Ms. Kushida emphasized that she is not a behavior specialist.
In September 1996, the District determined that Ms. Kushida would act as STUDENT's case manager. As case manager, Ms. Kushida was expected to coordinate STUDENT's services, schedule IEP team meetings, and observe her at school. Ms. Kushida stated that she requested observations from two District behaviorists, Ms. Goldstein and Bobbie Sobel.
Ms. Kushida understands that Dr. Jean Ottina is conducting a behavior assessment of STUDENT as a part of her neuropsychological assessment called for in the Memorandum of Agreement that settled SN 756-96.
Ms. Kushida observed STUDENT's social and behavioral skills in her SDC, regular education class, and on the playground. Ms. Kushida reported that STUDENT engaged in appropriate behavior in all academic settings. For example, STUDENT participated in class activities and socialized with her peers.
Ms. Kushida estimated that since being assigned to STUDENT's case, she observed her approximately once a week in sessions that lasted from forty-five minutes to a half-day. During the sessions, Ms. Kushida occasionally worked with STUDENT individually. After the observations, Ms. Kushida sometimes spoke with Mr. Richter, Ms. Mann, and STUDENT. Neither teacher expressed concerns about STUDENT; in fact, Ms. Mann praised STUDENT's class participation. From her observation, Ms. Kushida concluded that STUDENT "does not need one-on-one" behavioral counselling.
Ms. Kushida testified that she and Mr. Richter considered each of the fourteen goals(Footnote 29) that Dr. Harrington proposed for STUDENT's IEP to determine whether the goals were appropriate and, if so, whether they had been included in STUDENT's IEP. According to Ms. Kushida, Mr. Richter stated that he addressed goals one through six and nine through fourteen in the SDC class. Ms. Kushida noted STUDENT's IEP team included goal two in her IEP of April 23, 1996 and included goal three in her IEP of October 23, 1996.
Ms. Kushida recalled that she and Mr. Richter doubted that proposed goals seven and eight were appropriate. These goals state:
(7) The student will demonstrate no hesitancy in verbal expression due to accommodation by peers and teachers for her slower rate of speech and low volume.
(8) The student will demonstrate no hesitancy in her verbal interactions due to word retrieval or work finding difficulties.
Ms. Kushida testified that she and Mr. Richter questioned whether STUDENT could reasonably be expected to "demonstrate no hesitancy," given that she had suffered a traumatic brain injury and given that uninjured students often pause to collect their thoughts before speaking. Ms. Kushida also remarked that teachers often encourage students to pause before reacting.
Linda Michel
Linda Michel, unit coordinator for special education, West Valley, participated in the creation of the Memorandum of Agreement dated August 6, 1996, SN 976-96. With respect to the appointment of Ms. Kushida as case manager, Ms. Michel testified that she was to do the following:
consult with other members of the special education unit to pull together an appropriate behavior assessment, beginning with a behavior observation and then, as necessary do behavior counselling or planning.
Ms. Michel stated that Ms. Kushida observed STUDENT and determined that additional behavioral assessment or counselling was not required.
Ms. Michel confirmed that she initialled the assessment plan that Ms. MOTHER signed on August 6, 1996.(Footnote 30) When Ms. Michel approved the assessment plan, she intended that a "behavior consultant" (specifically, a least restrictive environment behaviorist, or LREB,) would help Ms. Kushida conduct "at least a baseline observation" of STUDENT during her school day to determine what behavior the District needed to observe, and what intervention it needed to begin.
Dolores Cannata
The duties of Dolores Cannata, District least restrictive environment counsellor, include working with other health impaired students and assisting children as they transition into regular educational programs. Ms. Cannata stated that her role is to help STUDENT transition into a regular education program.
Since November 1996, Ms. Cannata has observed STUDENT during all portions of her school day. Ms. Cannata stated that she currently sees STUDENT for one hour once a week. Ms. Cannata spends half of the time observing STUDENT and half of the time talking with her.
Ms. Cannata testified that she observed STUDENT in Mr. Richter's SDC. Ms. Cannata remarked that STUDENT participated in the class's reading activity by reading aloud. In Ms. Cannata's opinion, the SDC indoor recess play "engrossed" STUDENT. Ms. Cannata characterized STUDENT's behavior in SDC as "very positive."
According to Ms. Cannata, STUDENT enjoys her mainstream language arts class. Ms. Cannata reported that when STUDENT was in this class, she "sat with the other students during story time and appropriately answered" the questions that Ms. Mann, her regular education language arts teacher, posed. Ms. Cannata also noted that STUDENT socialized with a boy from the class. When Ms. Cannata asked STUDENT whether she enjoyed her mainstream class, she replied affirmatively.
Ms. Cannata further testified that she and Ms. Mann discussed STUDENT's progress on November 20, 1996. During that conversation, Ms. Mann stated that STUDENT joins her language arts class three to four times per week from noon until approximately 2:00 p.m. Ms. Cannata remembered that Ms. Mann stated that STUDENT was doing well in her class. Ms. Cannata did not observe, and Ms. Mann did not report, that STUDENT engaged in any inappropriate or defiant behavior while in her class.
Ms. Cannata stated that STUDENT's educational program should place more emphasis on academic development. To this end, Ms. Cannata offered that STUDENT would likely benefit from placement in Ms. Mann's mainstream mathematics class.
In addition to observing STUDENT in her classes, Ms. Cannata also observed STUDENT during recess and lunch. Although STUDENT played during recess, Ms. Cannata recalled that she did not venture onto the "big yard." Instead, STUDENT remained with the girls from her class who were playing with a hula hoop or were jumping rope. STUDENT got her lunch independently and, while eating, sat and talked with her peers.
Ms. Cannata described STUDENT as a "friendly and verbal, but quiet" child who exhibits "a slight delay in [oral] response time." According to Ms. Cannata, STUDENT's language delay did not seem to interfere with her ability to interact at school. Furthermore, Ms. Cannata noted that STUDENT initiates about half of her peer interactions. Ms. Cannata remarked that STUDENT demonstrates the ability to interact in an age-appropriate manner with her regular and special education classmates.
Diane Goldstein
District program specialist Diane Goldstein holds the following credentials: elementary teaching, reading specialist, administrative, and learning handicapped. Ms. Goldstein has also earned a master's degree in education.
Ms. Goldstein has held many positions including that of a least restrictive environment behaviorist (LREB) for five years. According to Ms. Goldstein, an LREB "assists with behavior modification of students who are experiencing difficulty in the classroom." Ms. Goldstein stated that she has taken a course in behavioral management and has "thirty years of classroom training." Ms. Goldstein testified that her supervisor asked her to conduct a behavioral observation of STUDENT rather than a behavioral assessment. Ms. Goldstein stated that she did not know whether the District has conducted a behavioral assessment of STUDENT.
Pursuant to the August 6, 1996 Memorandum of Agreement, Ms. Goldstein observed STUDENT at school on September 10 and 17, and October 2, 1996. The behavioral observations lasted between thirty and seventy minutes. During the visits, Ms. Goldstein observed, for example, that STUDENT played ball with her peers and when in class, sat in the middle of the class. However, Ms. Goldstein's detailed testimony regarding her observations of STUDENT's school activities and behavior will not be summarized because it is substantially similar to Dr. Harrington's.
After Ms. Goldstein observed STUDENT as she participated in academic, physical education, and social activities, Ms. Goldstein concluded:
STUDENT was on task and participating. Her interactions with her peers and adults were appropriate in all instances.(Footnote 31)
Ms. Goldstein made no recommendations to STUDENT's IEP team regarding STUDENT's behavior.
Cindy Sobel
Occupational therapist Cindy Sobel conducted an occupational therapy evaluation of STUDENT in September 1996. However, the Hearing Officer will not summarize Cindy Sobel's report or testimony as it relates to STUDENT's need for occupational therapy because the District has agreed and will be ordered to provide the occupational therapy services that Petitioner requests.
DISCUSSION
1. Is STUDENT entitled to physical therapy services and transportation from the District?
In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, (1982), the United States Supreme Court held that the Education for the Handicapped Act,(Footnote 32) requires a district to provide disabled students a "free appropriate public education (FAPE)."
A district satisfies this requirement if it offers a disabled student "personalized instruction with sufficient support services to permit the child to benefit educationally from that instruction." Rowley, supra, at p. 203.
A district is not required to provide a service to a student merely because the services might assist him or her. The service is only required under Rowley if it is necessary to help the child benefit from educational instruction or to meet unique instructional needs.
Moreover, California law reflects the Rowley standard. Education Code section 56363(a) mandates that "designated instruction and services shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit instructionally from his or her instructional program."
In this case, neither Petitioner nor District witnesses testified that STUDENT requires physical therapy to benefit from her educational program or to meet her unique instructional needs. Physical therapist Sharla Bohman credibly testified that STUDENT exhibits "motor control difficulties" but is able to function independently and safely on campus. Ms. Bohman therefore determined that STUDENT does not require physical therapy to benefit from her special education program.(Footnote 33)
Dr. Knox and Dr. Harrington offered similar observations and conclusions regarding STUDENT's need for physical therapy services. The Hearing Officer notes that neither doctor is a physical therapist, and does not consider them experts in that area. While not entitled to as much weight as Ms. Bohman's opinion their opinions are considered nevertheless.
Dr. Knox testified that STUDENT is "a little high [functioning] for a straight physical therapy program," because physical therapists work with children who have greater deficits in strength. Dr. Harrington also did not recommend that STUDENT receive direct physical therapy services. Dr. Harrington testified that during his observation of January 17, 1997, STUDENT appeared "to exhibit functional skills in her current class setting, and appear[ed] to be adequately taking care of her functional education behavior." Rather than recommending physical therapy services, he urged periodic consultations and reassessments of STUDENT's physical therapy needs.
The physical therapy assessment conducted by CCS in September 1996 reached a similar conclusion. The evaluator concluded, among other things, that STUDENT possesses "independent functional skills in all areas of gross motor ability." The CCS assessment recommended a "physical therapy consult with periodic checks" rather than the services that Petitioner seeks.
Based on the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not require physical therapy services to benefit from her special education program.
2. Is STUDENT entitled to "social skills training" that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended?(Footnote 34)
Dr. Harrington recommended that STUDENT receive personal counselling conducted by a school psychologist or behavioral specialist on a weekly basis "in a one-to-one or small group counselling program." According to Dr. Harrington's letter of August 21, 1996,
[the aim of the counselling] would be to work on relevant issues associated with social skills development, learning to handle frustration, relaxation training, initiating/maintaining appropriate social interactions with peers and reducing behavioral outbursts as described by parents.(Footnote 35)
Pursuant to the Rowley test, the District is required to provide STUDENT with sufficient support services to permit her to benefit from her educational placement. In this case, the evidence fails to establish that STUDENT requires social skills training to benefit from her education.
Although Dr. Harrington suggested that STUDENT receive social skills training, he did not testify that her social skills interfered with her ability to succeed at school. On the contrary, after observing STUDENT at school on January 17, 1997, Dr. Harrington wrote that STUDENT "is not having any significant behavioral problems." Dr. Harrington also testified that STUDENT did not demonstrate "negative acting out behavior" and that she engaged in "good social dialogue with peers" at school.
District witnesses noted similar behavior when they observed STUDENT at school. Ms. Cannata, who has observed STUDENT on a weekly basis since November 1996, credibly testified that STUDENT interacted appropriately with her peers and did not engage in oppositional or defiant behavior. Additionally, Ms. Goldstein testified that STUDENT appropriately participated in both large and small group activities.
Moreover, Mr. Richter, who teaches STUDENT each school day, testified that she is a motivated student who stays "on task" and appropriately initiates conversations with both adults and peers. Mr. Richter testified that STUDENT is succeeding in her regular education language arts placement and predicted that she would soon be ready to join a regular education math class. Furthermore, Mr. Richter reported that STUDENT did not engage defiant, angry, or oppositional behavior at school.
On the other hand, both Ms. MOTHER and Dr. Mossler describe STUDENT's off-campus behavior quite differently. Each witness testified that STUDENT defied and opposed them when she was confronted with activities that she considered challenging or somehow unpleasant. In fact, Dr. Mossler testified that he must coax and cajole STUDENT into reading for just a few minutes.
Additionally, Mr. Richter testified that he understood that when STUDENT is away from school, she plays with Mr. Bauman more than she plays with same-age peers.
While STUDENT may be more compliant and social at school than at home, Petitioner's evidence failed to establish that STUDENT's requires social skills training to help her benefit from her special education program or meet her unique instructional needs. It is unclear whether STUDENT's defiance emerges as a challenge to her mother's discipline or as a reaction to an educationally related task. While STUDENT's defiance of Dr. Mossler is related to her education, the evidence is insufficient to establish a pattern of behavior that requires the intervention that Petitioner requests.
In fact, testimony from STUDENT's teachers establishes that she is succeeding both socially and academically in her current placement and is gradually transitioning into the regular education program.
For the above cited reasons, Petitioner's request for a social skills training program is denied. However, the Hearing Officer is not ordering Mr. Richter to suspend the interactive play activities in which STUDENT currently participates. The interactive play activities will continue until STUDENT's IEP team determines that they are no longer appropriate.
Petitioner also requested a cognitive intervention program that Dr. Harrington maintained would increase STUDENT's ability to attend to and complete tasks, seek help when frustrated, and think before acting. However, the evidence does not establish that STUDENT needs such a program to benefit from special education. Mr. Richter credibly testified that STUDENT's rate of assignment completion is increasing, that she requests assistance when appropriate, and that she does not demonstrate "negative impulsivity." Likewise, Ms. Bohman testified that STUDENT is not impulsive and refrains from dangerous activities. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to a cognitive intervention program.
3. Must STUDENT's Individualized Education Program (IEP), include the fourteen goals that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended in his letter of August 21, 1996?
Federal law defines IEP goals as statements that describe what a child with a disability can reasonably be expected to accomplish within a twelve month period in the child's special education program.(Footnote 36) Furthermore, Education Code section 56345(2), requires all IEPs to contain a student's "annual goals."
In this case, Petitioner seeks the inclusion of the fourteen IEP goals that Dr. Harrington developed. Ms. Kushida's undisputed testimony establishes that Mr. Richter currently implements twelve of the fourteen goals in STUDENT's special education program. However, Ms. Kushida's testimony also revealed that only two of the fourteen goals were contained in STUDENT's IEP. Because the parties do not dispute that twelve of the goals Dr. Harrington proposed are appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that goals one through six and nine through twelve should be included in STUDENT's IEP.
Ms. Kushida also contended that goals seven and eight were inappropriate because they required STUDENT to speak without hesitation. Ms. Kushida testified that in light of the language delay that has resulted from STUDENT's traumatic brain injury, these goals are not reasonable for her. Ms. Kushida added that encouraging a student to speak without hesitation may prevent appropriate deliberation before responding.
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Kushida's concerns are reasonable and directs STUDENT's IEP team to modify goals seven and eight. However, the Hearing Officer further finds that these goals identify areas of concern that STUDENT's IEP team should address. Therefore, the IEP team should immediately meet to develop goals that strive to reduce STUDENT's verbal hesitation but still allow her time to gather her thoughts before speaking.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Douglas Harrington's report of January 17, 1997?
Education Code section 56344 sets forth some of the timelines to which the District must adhere when must it conduct an assessment. In relevant part, this section states that an assessment must be completed within 50 calendar days of receipt of parent's written consent for assessment.(Footnote 37)
Here, the Memorandum of Agreement from SN 976-96 indicates that the District agreed to conduct an assessment of STUDENT's behavioral needs "in compliance with special education law."(Footnote 38) The assessment plan and parental consent for assessment dated August 6, 1996, secured Ms. MOTHER's permission for the District to conduct an assessment of behavior.(Footnote 39) Therefore, under the section cited above, the District had fifty calendar days from August 6, 1996, to complete its behavior assessment of STUDENT.
Ms. Goldstein testified that to comply with this agreement, she observed STUDENT on three separate occasions and completed her behavior observation on October 2, 1996. While Ms. Goldstein's behavior observation may have been conducted in a timely manner, her behavior observation does not satisfy the statutory definition of a behavior assessment or functional analysis assessment.
Title 5 of California Code of Regulations (CCR) section 3052 (b) sets forth some of the requirements for functional analysis assessments.(Footnote 40) According to subsection (b), a functional analysis assessment must be conducted by or under the supervision of a person who has documented training in behavior analysis with an emphasis on positive behavioral interventions.
Furthermore, CCR section 3052 (1) lists additional mandatory components of a functional analysis assessment. For example, a functional analysis assessment shall include:
(F) Review of records for health and medical factors which may influence behaviors (e.g. medication levels, sleep cycles, health, diet).
In this case, the District has not established that Ms. Goldstein either possessed "documented training or behavioral analysis" or conducted her observation under the supervision of a qualified person. The District also did not establish that Ms. Goldstein complied with subsections (1)(A) through (F) of section 3052. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Goldstein's behavior observation is not an adequate behavior assessment.
Moreover, the record lacks evidence establishing that the District conducted any other behavior assessment of STUDENT within fifty days of August 6, 1997. In fact, there are inconsistencies in the testimony regarding whether the District conducted a behavior assessment. In February 1997, Ms. Kushida testified that she understood that Dr. Ottina was then conducting a behavior assessment of STUDENT. However, on the same day, Ms. Michel testified that STUDENT did not require and would not receive a behavior assessment. In any event, the District did not produce a timely completed and adequate behavior assessment.
In this situation, the Education Code section 56329(b), permits a parent to request at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists,..., if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the public education agency.
A parent's right to an independent educational assessment is subject only to the District's right to request a due process hearing to establish that its assessment was appropriate. Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1499-1500 (9th Cir. 1996), illustrates this situation.
In that case, the parent disagreed with the evaluation that the District conducted and requested reimbursement for the independent educational evaluation. The parents prevailed because the "District was unable to establish the appropriateness of its evaluation." Here, the District was also unable to establish that its own assessment was adequate.
The Hearing Officer recognizes that Dr. Harrington could not fully comply with the regulations regarding functional analysis assessments because STUDENT did not exhibit the "maladaptive behavior" that the regulations contemplate. Nevertheless, Dr. Harrington's report complied sufficiently with these regulations to constitute an assessment. Therefore, under the statutory and decisional authority cited above, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Harrington's report dated January 17, 1997.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for witness fees?
Petitioner maintains that the District must reimburse her for the fees incurred from Petitioner's expert witnesses, Dr. Douglas Harrington, Dr. Sue Knox, and Dr. Ronald Mossler as a result of this due process hearing.(Footnote 41)
The Education Code does not authorize the Hearing Officer to award either party such costs or fees.(Footnote 42) Therefore, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for these costs and fees is denied.
CONCLUSION
STUDENT is still in elementary school. Barring a change in circumstances, the District will provide STUDENT with services for the next several years. Therefore, noting the contentious nature of the relationship between the parties, the Hearing Officer offers them the following observation from Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Districts, 35 F. 3d 1396 (9th Cir. 1994):
Though the doors...are always open, the slow and tedious workings of the judicial system make the courthouse a less than ideal forum in which to resolves disputes over a child's education. [This] experience offers a poignant reminder that everyone's interests are better served when parent and school officials resolve their differences through cooperation and compromise rather than litigation.
ORDER
(1) The District is ordered to provide STUDENT with one hour of occupational therapy each week from the Hyland Clinic for the next six months. At the conclusion of six months, STUDENT's IEP team will meet to determine whether she continues to need occupational therapy. If the Hyland Clinic cannot provide the services, the District will immediately secure another clinic-based occupational therapy provider for STUDENT.
(2) The District is ordered to provide STUDENT with transportation to occupational therapy.
(3) The District is ordered to reimburse STUDENT for the cost of occupational therapy assessment that Dr. Knox of the Hyland Clinic performed on January 15, 1997 within thirty days of receiving the bill.
(4)(a) The District is ordered to include Dr. Harrington's proposed goals one through six and nine through fourteen to STUDENT's next IEP team meeting and include them, with revisions if necessary, in her next
IEP.
(4)(b) The District is further ordered to develop and add to STUDENT's IEP the two goals that address STUDENT's verbal hesitation.
(5) The District is ordered to reimburse STUDENT for the cost of Dr. Douglas Harrington's report of January 17, 1997, within thirty days of receiving Dr. Harrington's bill.
(6) All of Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Is STUDENT entitled to physical therapy services and transportation from the District?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Is STUDENT entitled to "social skills training" that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended?
The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Must STUDENT's Individualized Education Program (IEP), include the fourteen goals that Dr. Douglas Harrington recommended in his letter of August 21, 1996?
Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Douglas Harrington's report of January 17, 1997?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
5. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for witness fees?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(i).
Dated: April 14, 1997 Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1:At the due process hearing and in closing argument, Petitioner also requested a "cognitive intervention plan." As Respondent did not object to this request, it will be considered. Footnote 2:Respondent's (Resp.) closing argument at p. 6.
Footnote 3:Resp. closing argument at p. 5.
Footnote 4:Petitioner's request for occupational therapy services did not specify the frequency or duration of the services. For this reason, the Hearing Officer relies on the testimony of Petitioner's witness, Dr. Susan Knox, who recommended that STUDENT receive a one-hour session of clinic-based occupational therapy each week. Footnote 5:Resp. closing argument at p. 13.
Footnote 6:Petitioner's (Pet.) Ex. D, at p. 5.
Footnote 7:Pet. Ex. H and L.
Footnote 8:Resp. Ex. 9 and 13.
Footnote 9:Case No. SN 756-96.
Footnote 10:Pet. Ex. E, Vol. I, at p. 2.
Footnote 11:Pet. Ex. E and L, vol. II.
Footnote 12:The District also called Ms. MOTHER as its witness. Footnote 13:Pet. Ex. V, Vol. I, at p. 4.
Footnote 14:Resp. Ex. 1.
Footnote 15:Pet. Ex. I 1.
Footnote 16:Pet. Ex. 1 H.
Footnote 17:STUDENT currently joins Linda Mann's regular education third grade class for language arts. Footnote 18:Pet. Ex. 1 H, at p. 1.
Footnote 19:Pet. Ex. F, vol. II, at p. 2.
Footnote 20:Pet. Ex. 1 G.
Footnote 21:Dr. Mossler is also a licensed marriage, family, and child counsellor and holds a community college teaching credential. Footnote 22:Resp. Ex. 13.
Footnote 23:Resp. Ex. 13, at p. 4.
Footnote 24:Ibid.
Footnote 25:Resp. Ex. 9, at p. 4.
Footnote 26:Resp. Ex. 9, at p. 1.
Footnote 27:Resp. Ex. 22, at p. 1.
Footnote 28:Resp. Ex. 23, at p. 1.
29:Pet. Ex. F, Vol. II, at p. 2.
30:Pet. Ex. D, Vol. I.
31:Pet. Ex. L, Vol. II, at p. 3.
32:Congress renamed this act the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). 33:Resp. Ex. 13, at p. 5.
34:The discussion of this issue centers on whether STUDENT currently needs social skills training. The Hearing Officer was not asked to rule on whether the District complied with its agreement to provide a "one-on-one behavior specialist" to address STUDENT's social skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not rule on the District's compliance with its agreement. 35:Pet. Ex. F, Vol. I, at p. 1.
36:34 C.F.R. ch.3, app. C question 38. (1996)
37:In relevant part, this section states:
An individualized education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 days, not counting days between the pupil's regular school sessions, terms or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays, from the date of receipt of parent's written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension. 38:Pet. Ex. E, Vol. I., at p. 1.
39:Pet. Ex. D, Vol. I.
40:California Code of Regulations section 3052 (b) refers to behavioral assessments as "functional analysis assessments." 41:Pet. closing argument, at p. 30.
42:Education Code section 56507 (b).
